Millions Now Living Will Never Die by Tortoise

Millions Now Living Will Never Die

Tortoise

2.89
Rating
23646
Votes
1
11%
2
25%
3
33%
4
23%
5
7%
Distribution

Reviews (page 6 of 9)

I liked this album quite a lot. It's very indicative of what would come after, and what this would inspire.

100% genuine dialogue from the studio during this album: “Dan, we’ve only come up with 14 minutes of music! How are we going to fill an entire full length album?” “No need to worry, John. Let’s just repeat what little we have over and over until it’s long enough” “But won’t that make it boring and repetitive?” “Not if we just tweak small elements every now and then” “Couldn’t that still render the album dull and repetitious?” “Perhaps we could make little changes here and there” “Doesn’t that risk our music being tedious and monotonous?” “…”

I suppose it was fairly pleasant to listen to, if not a bit boring. I couldn’t even tell that first song was 20mins long it all sounded so similar. Simpsons: No

I didn't dislike it. Some parts I quite liked and overall wanted to enjoy it more, but it was just a bit boring. Maybe OK as background music.

This was utter shit!!!!! A song over 20 minutes long that didn't do anything. A totally instrumental album and just boring music. This album is a stain on the credibility of this list. Whoever put the list together must be related to one of these geezers. Because nobody likes this. The peak position in the charts for this was 115th. Just to put that into perspective.The smurfs also released an album in 1996 called ‘the smurfs go pop’ and that peaked at number 2 and had 29 weeks in the top 40. Yet it doesn't appear on this list. If I recorded the noise I make from the toilet on a loop for 45 minutes I reckon it would make a better album. 

I didn’t hate it, it was nice while I was doing a jigsaw. Maybe not what Mr Tortoise was aiming for but I’ll add it to my jigsaw rotation

This feels like the direct predecesor to Explosions in the Sky and I love it so much. Pitch perfect.

Atmospheric, ambient and melancholic. A nice album for background music.

Thoughts before listening: Cool, abstract indie rock instrumentals. I went through a phase where I was really into Tortoise, but its been a long time since I have listened to these guys. Review: So this album starts out with Djed which is one of Tortoise and the genre of post-rock's most celebrated songs. Its okay. There are definitely some interesting parts, but as a whole I find it to be too long and abstract to be one of my favorites. I do however enjoy quite a bit of this album. Its certainly a journey and takes some patience to make it through, but I find it quite rewarding. There are very interesting textures and styles being incorporated throughout, especially with the shorter songs. 3-stars

This is not Tortoise, but Torture. 20 minutes song that is not good even as elevator music? The rest is just OK, sometimes, but nothing more. 1/10

Engaging in parts, intricate instrumentation, experimental but lacks consistent replay value; a sound that might resonate more with evolving taste over time.

Välgjort men är nt för intresserad i instrumentella album som inte är jazz

I’m sure at the right venue with the right drugs this would be great.

Seems like quality jams, but I was waiting for it to end most of the time.

Some Explosions in the Sky vibes at times which I liked but overall it was just alright

It's a difficult listen, but rewarding in some ways. The odd instrumental lineup (I think they have like 2 bassists and 3 drummers) takes some getting used to, and the fact that almost none of the tracks have any sort of normal musical arrangement is likewise strange. The 20+ min opener is more like 5-10 short semi-musical interludes connected by rhythmic noise. A few tracks have some genuinely interesting grooves in them, and I appreciate the constantly changing odd time signatures. Not something I would probably listen to again, but intriguing.

A meandering slog of nothing (affectionately) This is what Mike Oldfield would make if he were a computer science major with vague left-wing revolutionary philosophies in the late '90s

Enjoyed it enough.

Okay background instrumental music 2.5

Ikkje så verst, men revolusjonerte ikkje livet mitt heller

Very interesting production. Definitely could hear and appreciated how it influenced post-rock. Could be kinda boring at times, but there's a lot here to enjoy.

Very experimental album. Yes, I remember the band with what felt like 20 drummers. But I was expecting a bit more sonic power. Unfortunately, it doesn't seem to be my cup of tea.

I was excited to check out something by an artist I’d never heard of. Unfortunately this album sounds like it was made by people who never played music before and were just given a bunch of instruments to try out. Atrocious bass playing, random noodly guitar, percussion glitches that they couldn’t even be bothered to make in time, sound effects that sound like children just mashing on toy keyboards, arrangements that go nowhere forever and then just suddenly and unmusically change to something else entirely. Just terrible all around.

honestly rocks. what i'd want to hear in a glass museum

Strange post rock album that lacks some heft

Muy conceptual

Prog rock for the post-rock generation. I can dig it. Not the best thing I've ever heard, but I like it.

They are very talented, but I am not a huge fan of the music.

Beautifully cinematic yet tight ambient-ish album.

never heard of these before but love this. I have started to delve into the back catalogue to see what else is in there .

Seriously wtf. 1.33

As a fan of Post Rock, this just sounds so good. The whole thing sounds beautiful, but it almost sounds a lot more grown up that postrock of the late 00s. There is great use of different sounds, different tempos and the production sounds so good. Although the album never really goes all out or heavy, at times you can feel this underplayed feeling of aggression, but its controlled and just bubbles under. This is a 4 to me, I could see it growing from there, i like it, and i could imagine listening to it for fun. A really good album, moody in all the right ways

It took me a while to decide how many stars, but at the end of the day this allowed me to discover TNT, Djed is a great track, Tortoise are my new favorite band and I think all of this deserves a 5

organs at beginning of Along the Banks of Rivers reminds me of something I can't put my finger on. It's okay, like more boring Godspeed you black emperor

Favourite tracks: glass museum; djed

Not my thing. Wasn’t annoying, but I definitely won’t be listening again. Production was very good and so was the writing and arrangements. 2/5

October 15, 2024 Post-rock is one of those subgenres that, on paper, looks boring & dreadful. But my experiences with Sigur Ros, Godspeed! & now Tortoise prove otherwise. I listened to Echoes and Shine On You Crazy Diamond literally this week, so I reallly shouldn’t complain about the length of “Djed”. Though I wasn’t prepared for all 20 minutes (I should state I knew nothing about this album before today) it IS an impressive feat in moody atmosphere, sometimes more IDM than alt-rock (Radiohead is that you?) I also really enjoyed the final track, “Along the Banks of Rivers”, for it’s noir-ishness, and “The Taut and the Tame”, despite its proggy noodling. 4/5

Loved the first song on the album, unfortunately it really just dragged on from there

Interesting, but for a different time in life.

What a masterpiece. I was questioning whether I was going to even like this, but over the course of the 20 minute opener it slowly started winning me over, and throughout the album won me over more and more, and when the final track starts it was settled. Love the marimba incorporation as well

Not my thing..

Melodious.

from the beginning of track one, i felt like i was going to be in for a miserable time. over the course of the first track, this really turned around on me. no longer did i feel like someone was cleaning out my ears, but more was intrigued about the cool soundscape that was being crafted here. usually ambient music is not really my jam, but this one grew on me a bit. i don't know if i would go out of my way to listen to it again, but i did find what was created here to be interesting and calming, in a way. i appreciate this album in the context of this list because it is decently different from a lot of what is on the list - instrumental and not totally cookie cutter, yet very listenable.

Great for sleep deprivation!

It went by so fast, I didn't even notice

terrible

I really hated the first like four minutes of this album, then it gradually became more intriguing. However I’ve never been of fan of music that just really contains different “sounds.” I definitely wavered with this album because at points it was pretty sounding then others it was just honestly aggravating noises. I’m just not a fan of this type of music, but I can see why others may be.

First impression - this is a great headphone album. I'm not entirely sure about the song delineation/s here. Djed is 20 minutes but it's not 1 "song" or even really a good pastiche like those old 20 minute prog rock classics (e.g. suppers ready, 2112). When we get to the next track tho I'm really digging it - I love the vibraphone on "Glass Museum" - giving a bit of a fusion-Zappa vibe. Overall - this is hard or impossible to categorize. This is a "great to work to" album - no vocals to distract, not even any jarring instrumental breaks but at the same time it doesn't lapse into boredom (much). I think the 20 minute "Djed" is a bit of a downer; should either have been the last track or subdivided into 2 or 3 shorter cuts. This one feels especially weird reducing it to a number/score because similar rankings I'm sure I'll listen to more, but for what this is...it's pretty excellent, and might be a zen go-to album for me. 7/10 4 stars

Alternativ rock, ren instrumental, ambient, gode glimt, men for mærkeligt

Completely new to me, but I love it. I'll be listening again. Maybe right now, in fact.

Post-rock, huh? Definitely new for me. I didn’t love this but it wasn’t terrible to listen to. Light 3.

Yet another completely unneeded inclusion on this list. Innocuous, but purely background music. The best thing about this record is that it's short.

Honestly pretty vibey. Not sure I could listen to this without it being in the background, but I didn't mind it at all.

Was pleasantly surprised how much I ended up liking this. Very fun music to just chill and vibe to. It is somehow chill with a little bit of an edge/darkness to it.

This was really interesting. It's very meditative, something good for laying peacefully in a dark, quiet room. I love when Djed starts glitching out around 14 minutes in. I thought the aliens were intercepting for a hot sec.

3.5☆/5 09.24.2024

3 stars but extra star for uniqueness

Post rock

Really enjoyed this one. I used to listen to ambient music a lot when studying (and still do for working). The likes of American Analog Set, Röyksopp, Goddamn Electric Bill etc. got me through more all-night essay writing than I care to remember.

Was okay. Could listen to while getting some work done. 3/5

Pretty cool

For an album comprised of nothing but sound and no words, it sure does hold a lot. It is truly instrumentally dense and full of key moments. There were energizing moments, soothing moments, and wtf is happening moments. No part of it was boring. I don’t tend to listen to albums like these but I am glad I listened to this one.

Great- five star

I'm going up to 3 on this one even though it doesn't appeal to me as an album. I checked out the group and live and there is definitely an appeal there.

This suffered from the syndrome where music that I like, which came later, was clearly influenced by this band/album, but it makes the album seem derivative rather than inventive. Fortunately this is the kind of music I generally enjoy and I'll take an instrumental album any day of the week. 3.5

The problem with this and so much post rock is that it’s an entire album that sounds like an intro for a song that never starts

Genuinely, what was the point of this album? This was so boring.

this is like, perfect background music for me. i already kinda forget what it sounded like. 3.5

I vibed. It's not like super interesting, but was pretty good background noise

I accidentally autoplayed twenty minutes of another Tortoise album so I'd say it felt samey

Hm, irgendwie abseitige Klangfummelei. Hat mich zuerst an Kraftwerk erinnert. Aber ich muss zugeben, ich habe das Album 2x angehört und ja, hat mich dann doch angesprochen. Unerwartete 3*

Interesting album, but not exactly my cup of tea. Would not return to this album or group.

Interesting

Cool relaxed sound. Liked Glass Museum and Along the Banks of Rivers, but most importantly got interested in the band. Ima listen to more of their stuff, might be a hidden gem

I didnt outright /like/ it but I appreciate it. for once it wasn't the same and I enjoyed the process of listening to it

#335. Decent enough, kinda background musicky. I didn't really like the first song all that much, and unfortunately that's about half of the fucking thing. I did think the rest of it was pretty good though. 3/5: decent Song added to playlist: Glass Museum I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link

I tried but just couldn’t get there. 2

Instrumental post rock that screams "ignore me and write emails." I love it.

Conocía el anterior. Éste me ha aburrido un poco.

Who? Apparently it's Post-Rock/Jazz-Fusion which immediately puts me off, but I gave it a chance. First track, "Djed", is just under 21 minutes long, but reminded me of early Kraftwerk. The second track, "Glass Museum", reminded me of Gentle Giant. Overall, I quite liked it, but I wouldn't buy it.

Millions Now Living Will Never Die is the second studio album by Tortoise, originally released in 1996. Man, I really like this band. I was first put onto them from their album "TNT" which would come out after this one. I really with TNT was included on this list because I feel it is a much better representation of their sound than this one. Nonetheless, I still really enjoyed this record. It's much more ambient/electronic-focused than their other works. The latter half of the record really shows what their sound would become. I prefer those jazzy songs, but the electronic stuff is cool too. Pretty trippy moments on here. The whole record is pretty much a jam session. For those who like weird jammy stuff, you'll love it. For those who don't, sorry.

Very quirky interesting album. Will try to listen again

Great ambient album, left me loving the unique sequences after each listen. Favs: Glass Museum The Taut and Tame

Ok this is interesting. Probably a lot better on headphones. Really enjoy the way the sounds and melodies rise up and evolve. Gives your mind something to play with, while you’re busy doing other things. Don’t hate this. 4/5

Did that first song really need to be 20 minutes long? Really?

beautiful album. feels more like a journey than just listening to songs

Stop me if you've heard this before... I mean stop this, I keep hearing it over and over. I dug the first song, until it droned. Then noticed the next song drone. Repeat. Then while cleaning the kitchen, it set a numbing vibe. But I was not high, so it diminished. But that brief stretch gets it an extra star.

I liked this a lot. The film noir vibe was excellent, reminding me of Portishead's "To Kill a Dead Man" and the soundtrack to so many spy thrillers like The Ipcress File. Also hints of Jeff Wayne's musical version of War of the Worlds, all of which I adore.

A bad acid trip

Ambient, spacey, jam.4/5

2.9 listened 2x

It grows on you after the first 20m track.

This is basically ambient rock--layers building upon layers, like a parfait. No, an onion. Is that even a touch of modern classical I hear there? It goes from warm, round tones to razor-thin scratches. Soothing throughout.

First track is fantastic, the rest of the album can't quite hit those heights. Can see why this was mega-influential. Er...not a lot a else you can say. 3.5 really.

Great stuff

I can’t say that I really understand this music but they are obviously gifted musicians. And I try to put it in the context of the time which I think it makes it more interesting.

I liked this more than I expected I would after the first ten minutes. Glass Museum had a desolate vibe to it, I felt myself becoming entranced in it. The Survey and Djed didn't do much for me. The Taut and the Tame was alright. Dear Grandma and Grandpa felt like floating through space in outer wilds. Along the banks of the river was like good, bad and the ugly in space. Songs that take you someplace are special but there were some duds here too, overall enjoyed

Very chill, perfect for early morning work background music or late night chill mode. Some might not like it or find it boring if you want something with high energy.

Sounds like background music from the movie Primer. No vocals, just ambient sounds and instruments.

**An ok instrumental album

Soundscapes. The music became entirely background.

Nope, really not feeling this. I guess you have to be in the mood, maybe chilling with the headphones on letting it wash over you. Clearly I wasn’t

Description of the album was so mich better than the album itself. Early post rock record, paving the way for a great genre to grow? Sounds amazing. Unfortunately the songs lack a bit of substance, all form. A slightly disappointing effort.

Interesting instrumentation

I'm still learning to appreciate post rock. This was a step in the right direction for me though. Really great atmosphere on each track

Pretty decent instrumental post-rock. Nothing particularly memorable.

Great instrumental post-rock album with jazz elements. The music is quite diverse from soundscapes to rhythmic tracks. If you like this one, TNT is also a nice album of Tortoise.

WTF? I don't even know where to start... what the hell is Post-Rock? And, if that is a musical genre, what kind of genre is it? Google has only managed to confuse me more... Does "being experimental" mean that you are included in this musical journey? I thought the idea of having something that is good to listen to would be the main criteria... So, for now, having to sit through a 20+-minute intro song, which goes so far as making me wonder if my sound-system is broken around minute 14:04, really makes me dislike Tortoise. Maybe my second listening of the album will make me change my mind... Okay, second listening, and my thought has now shifted to "okay, so it's several styles of music being created by instruments that aren't standard for those styles. Still not liking it.

Ok this is interesting. Probably a lot better on headphones. Really enjoy the way the sounds and melodies rise up and evolve. Gives your mind something to play with, while you’re busy doing other things. Don’t hate this.

3.5 stars rounded up.

I’ve never heard of this album or artist before, but based on the description, I think there’s a good chance I’m going to enjoy this album. It should make a for a stark contrast to Machito’s Kenya, which I just wrapped up. Overall, this album was fine. As far as post-rock goes, it definitely wasn’t my favorite, but it was pleasant to listen to. I did like that this album had a very jazz-adjacent in terms of song structure and flow (great follow up to Kenya, actually). “Djed” was my favorite song on the album, which really surprised me, give its 20 minute-plus run time. I really enjoyed the sounds that were utilized and how the song evolved, and I liked the use of contrasting musical sounds, like when the xylophone kicked played over the low-frequency humming sound. There was a moment in “Djed” where some heavy distortion was used, and it was really jarring, but I loved the affect it had on me. “Glass Museum” was really great as well. The song started off with a bit of a shoegaze sound, before shifting to something more frantic. I liked the xylophone melody, especially when the song became more frantic in its pacing; it provided an interesting balance to the deeper guitar melody. After the third track though, the album lost some steam with me. It didn’t feel like the album was doing anything new or exciting after that point, and I was pretty bored with the last three songs. They weren’t bad, but they certainly weren’t interesting. I enjoyed the experience of branching out and listening to an artist I’d never heard of, and I think this album is objectively pretty good. However, I don’t think I’d come back to it, mostly because if I were craving a sound like this, there are other things I’d gravitate towards first.

Slow and long-winded instrumental prog. Experimental at times. Pretty cool.

Djed was wild. I really enjoyed this album. I had a Tortoise cd that I got used on a whim from goodwill back in the day. So I knew what I was getting into to a point. They did not disappoint. For how many influences they borrow from they have a unique and consistent sound. And the music is good!

Not going to sound very original here: this is a seminal album in the post-rock genre, still nascent by 1996. A music style that's so BADLY represented in Dimery's book (no GY!BE, no Mogwai, only one Sigur Rós album...) that I'm pleased to give quite high marks to this one. The mix of influences--going from jazz and classical to rock, dub and funk--is hypnotic, the instrumentation is always interesting and often surprising, and some of the harmonies used here can send you into a meditative state that's one of a kind. As other reviewers remarked, those tracks can equally serve as background or "foreground" music, and hit all the right spots in both modes. Plus, the Steve Reich influence on the repetitive patterns of the percussive instruments (including a xylophone, I guess) give Tortoise a very distinct personality in that whole post-rock family. Which is exactly where you can separate the whiff from the chaff in that overall genre. That said, I think the Chicagoans' formula was greatly refined for their subsequent, even more ambitious double-LP *TNT*, unfortunately not mentioned by Dimery and co. So maybe I will keep that Tortoise slot for that other record of theirs in my own list. I have other important post-rock albums to include, you see... 4/5 for the purposes of this list of essential albums. 9/10 for more general purposes (5 + 4) Number of albums left to review: 132 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 375 Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 222 (including this one) Albums from the list I won't include in mine: 279 PS: speaking of Steve Reich, I have to point out that the latter is another shameful blind spot in that 1001 Albums book. A couple of pivotal albums presenting historical renditions of his key works (albums from the ECM label, obviously) should have been included in the list at no great cost. Just erase Kid Rock, Limp Bizkit, or Hanoi Rocks from everyone's memory and voilà!

I liked this more than I initially thought I would. Almost like a precursor to math rock.

Not a huge fan of nothing but bland instrumental.

Drifts through post-rock, minimalism, freeform jazz, ambient, and math rock while always maintaining impeccable vibes. Fantastic background music.

A soup of uncontained creativity. Pleasing to the mind more than the ear.

Stop. Rewind? Stop again?

Um what was that

Nothing I enjoyed

I got worried by the first track because it was *ambient* ambient. Like vaguely harmonic noises ambient. But as it introduced actual instruments and real musical sounds it got a lot better and by the end I was having fun especially since the last track was my fav.

djed, glass museum and along the banks of rivers did i like a lot. the rest odf the album (other 3 songs) did not much for me but it was a soli listen as a whole! 2.5/5.0

Fun little instrumental album

There's no reason I should like this at all. And yet I do. Immensely.

whatever

Enjoyed listening to this but was a bit similar to bands like Single Gun Theory who deserve waaaaay more attention.

This sounds like a band just compiled all the intros, outros, and interstitials they made for an album or two and turned that into its own album. It has some really cool stuff on it, but it is just herky jerky, incomplete sounding

I think that I enjoyed this at the time (yesterday) but 24 hours later, I have no recollection of what it even sounded like. That probably says it all.

Krautrock, IDM, Minimalism, and ambient blended expertly…and that’s just the first track. Millions Now Living Will Never Die is one of the best records of the 90’s.

I feel like I want to give this a positive mark but in reality it never quite made it beyond the background.

I've listened to the album TNT a number of times over the past few years and always thought that something was... missing. That is also the case on this album. I prefer instrumental music that is either: dramatic, ear catching, bombastic (Lift Your Skinny Fists, Earth 2, Fashion Week); or more subtle (Music for Airports, any Time Hecker or Phillip Glass). This middle of the road music (Tortoise, Explosions in the Sky) always feels lacking. 3/5.

Not my Kind of music

Loved it. Ehterial. 3.5

Very innovative album full of surprising things! It was a lot more listenable than I had remembered of the band. Earlier things I have run into seemed kind of dinky or not serious enough. This is one of the few albums in the project that I hope to revisit in a bit. Quite fascinating.

Tortoises are amazing creatures. We may or may not all be on the back of a tortoise, and they are the longest living land animals. I don’t think Tortoise the band is going to be particularly long living though outside of the 1001. There are several parts of “Millions Now Living Will Never Die” that would be decent foundations for some background chill lo-fi type stuff, but as a whole the album is a boring improvisational jazz rehearsal with a rock spin.

This is decent background music while walking through the woods as I did this morning. Though I enjoyed the cricket and bird noises just as much once the album was over and I took my head phones off. I think being high would add the 1-2 stars needed to make this a regular listen.

01) Djed - 7,0 02) Glass Museum - 7,0 03) A Survey - 6,0 04) The Taut and Tame - 6,5 05) Dear Grandma and Grandpa - 5,5 06) Along the Banks of Rivers - 7,0 TOTAL: 6,50 (65/100) Current ranking: 173/222 An ambient, instrumental post rock album perfect for background music while you work. "Djed" is a 21-minute long song that practically consists of five or more experimental songs glued into one. It's not unpleasant to listen to, but the length of the song irritates me. "Glass Museum" at least has some common melody that ties these parts together as well as a more appropriate length. "A Survey" is a song where you hear bass and crickets for three minutes. "The Taut and Tame" somewhere in the middle sounds like RHCP without the vocals, but only briefly. "Dear Grandma and Grandpa" is just some weird sounds, I wouldn't even call it a song. "Along the Banks of Rivers" sounds cool, light, one of the better songs on the album.

Conocía el anterior. Éste me ha aburrido un poco.

chill vibes

Less interesting now than it was then.

This is good background music. If it's all you're focusing on, it's a bore. Highlight was the minor key finale track that suited the slow tempos much better than the other cuts. Listened to: at home. Favorite tracks: Along the Banks of Rivers

I actually checked to make sure my speakers were working. When I realized they were I didn’t understand why I was made to listen to someone experimenting with Apple’s Garage Band.

It's been way too long since I listened to Tortoise. Perfect post rock noise scapes that grate and entice. This album is sloppy at times which threw me a little as I am more familiar with TNT which has laser sharp precision. I wonder if they are fans of Barry Adamson's Moss Side stories or maybe they share the same influences. Either way both Millions and that record share a muddy dirge that feels like the sound is smothering me.

cool post-rock/jazz album. really enjoyed this

Vaguely pleasant sound but then not so much other times. I don't really get the idea of post rock even if I like some of the results. Did rock end? Where's it gone?

Millions Now Living Will Never Die falls short of expectations, presenting itself as a disjointed and tedious listening experience. The album opens with a slow and uneventful start, lacking the engaging hooks or rhythms to captivate from the beginning. Throughout its duration, the tracks often meander aimlessly, giving the impression of a band warming up rather than delivering cohesive musical compositions. The extended instrumental passages, while showcasing technical proficiency, fail to sustain interest and feel indulgent. Overall, this album may disappoint listeners seeking structured and engaging music, offering little beyond its experimental aspirations. NUMBER OF BANGERS - 0 STAND OUT TRACK - None

The vibes are immaculate on this instrumental album. I really enjoyed it! 8/10 Would I listen again? Yes

Instrumental. A little navel-gazing, a little bit of a snooze. It's ok. Should it be on the list? No.

I don’t get it. Maybe more THC would help me get it…?

What initially gave off an impression I was not digging eventually turned into a unique blend of electronic influences and post rock structure that was pretty pleasing. That said, I listened to it two days ago and couldn't hum you a single melody from it.

Hypnotic rhythms, layered instrumentation, and affecting, atmospheric ambiance make for an engaging post-rock listen whether in the background or the forefront.

5/5 AWESOME

Un muy álbum de postrock, por uno de los actos más influyentes del género. Hipnótico de principio a fin, la banda crea un LP que de principio a fin atrapa a quien lo escucha con texturas sonoras sorprendentes. Sumamente recomendable para cualquiera que quiera escuchar un buen disco de rock instrumental.

Do I like 20 minute long instrumental post-rock noise? Let me answer that in the affirmative. I do. I'd listened to Tortoise for the first time a few weeks ago because they're repeatedly referenced in Stuart from Mogwai's autobiography, and while they don't carry anything like the heft of Mogwai, you can see the connection. I think they really need to find the overdrive pedal though; so mang songs are crying out for a big GNRRR to break up the Casio keyboard demos.

Long instrumental

Dreamlike, smooth

The first thing I ever heard from Tortoise was their later collab with Will Oldham. That was a much more interesting album but this wasn't bad at all. The opening track was a bit of meandering noise that lacked a home base and went on a bit too long. However, the second track was by far and large the star of the album. All in all, it was interesting enough to hold my attention but not something I'd probably revisit again in the future.

Ganska okej ändå. Inget jag har hört förut.

Gear: DCA ÆON 2 Noire Artwork: 🐟🖼️ Mix: Feine Sahne Fischfilet mit besonders solidem Fundament Musik: Post Rock Monument Wertung: 🐟🐟🐟🐟(🐟)/5

if the first song didn’t exist, i think the album would be netter. some weird 20 minute experimental song to open the album seems quite unnecessary. the rest of the album is pretty good, though. i like “The Taut and Tame” a lot.

- noise music but decrescendos into jazzier chiller feel - a little too noise music-y at bits - would be overwhelming to have too loud, good for work though, art, introspection - good to have lyricless albums in my arsenal so i’m not wearing out my one playlist - 3/5 saving in library

Olisivat voineet tehdä enemmän sillä vallalla joka heille suotiin kun pääni sisään tätä soitatin. Kuitenkin, jos ensimmäiselle biisille nauroit, toisessa biisiss bändikkö jahtasi kintereilleäsi kun koitit paeta.. Uskon, monen kriitikon surullinen kohtalo, ja miksi 2,xx avg rating albumilla..

I mostly liked it- a few times I considered skipping ahead when things were a bit discordant but I stuck it out.

Over the past 15 years I've listened to a little Tortoise off and on (mainly TNT). Never a deep dive, but they always stand out as a band worth noting. I'm happy to sit with this album. Oh... I'm 100% into this. I'll probably spend all day listening to related Chicago indie and jazz. Stuff like The Sea and Cake, Brokeback, Isotope 217, Chicago Underground [duo, trio or whatever], plus whatever Rob Mazurek is up to nowadays

Meh. Didn't leave much of an impression. Along the banks of rivers was nice.

well that was a whole lot of nothing

Not an album that I would pick and listen throug

This might be my coolest find in this project. Djed on it's own is already a complete journey and they just keep going. It gives me that rare sense of wonder.

Big fan of tortoises, even bigger fan of songs that have words in them

The band is very aptly named because their music is slow, dry, and I want to turn them into soup

Essential, seminal post rock album, so influential on so much amazing shit, another easy 5. The club is on fire this week!

interesting initial long song followed by regulars

In total honesty, I was not looking forward to this. Ambient with no lyrics can go either way. But I ended up listening to this in the early morning before everyone else woke up. Just sat, drinking coffee listening to chilled vibes. It was the perfect setting for this. Had I listened to this while commuting to work I am not sure I would have liked it as much.

I put this on and immediately hated it, thinking it sounded like a bad YouTube ASMR video. Also, I remembered when SPIN Magazine or someone tried to make them the "next Nirvana" in the 90s, as if instrumental math-rock was going to blow up and blast from every high schoolers' car stereo in America. Then I left it on and forgot about it, only to find myself making guttural noises along with the instrumental sounds and tapping my steering wheel along with the drum beats. Okay, part of this is catchy. By the end I was totally invested. It may not have blasted from this high schooler's car stereo in the mid-90s, but it was playing at a reasonable volume in my sensible truck almost 30 years later, and I was enjoying it.

bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad bad

Tortoise is the perfect name for this band. Everything is slow and rhythmic.

Carino, la canzone da 20 minuti un po' inutile ma l'ultima molto bella

Not for me

Didn't find anythin interesting here.

Very nice instrumentals, just also very long songs (5-20 mins)

40 minutos de disco con 6 canciones y la duración de la primera canción son 20 minutos? Qué sentido tiene eso? Tenía que tener un mejor reparto de tiempos. Por lo demás suena bien, echo en falta algo de letra de vez en cuando y algo mas de caña.

Very experimental. Not really my taste. "Along the Banks of Rivers" is the best song of the album.

Nothing like any other post rock album I've heard, which is exactly what the genre should be going for at all times. Score is reflecting where it'll be in like half a year most likely.

"Post-rock" = "Dull" If this is what got the Friends of Dean Martinez together, then cool. That gets them a second star. Otherwise, it's barista music.

crunchy post rock. There is some legit cool shit on this album. The bass tone on The Taut and Tame is exemplar.

Wow. This is a fantastic album.

tremendo

My go-to album for calming my brain. Djed is perhaps my favorite song ever.

Interesting chill, and more ambient but apparently a groundbreaking "post-rock" album. Didn't love it, but didn't hate it and enjoyed it as background music.

I liked this instrumental album. Great back ground music.

I speed-ran the math rock subgenre in my youth, moving from American Football to Hella to Meshuggah in the span of 6 months my Junior year of high school. Along the way, the post-rock Slint-inspired stuff never caught my attention, as it was either too sparse or too quiet for my ears. I craved the extremes, and the post-rock stuff felt like Brooklyn Divorced Dad™️ music to me, music made for a calm show with no pit where you can lean against the doorframe beneath the exit sign, nursing a PBR, not concerned about how much your knees will hurt in the morning. I’m older now and work in an office, and when I occasionally loudly listen to the math rock I used to like, my colleagues will turn to me and ask if I’m doing okay, mentally, and that happens more often than I’d like, so I tend to just avoid that type of music while I work. So I now get the appeal of post-rock - it’s tame but still weird and off-kilter. And Tortoise does a good job with their weird repetitive riffs and jazz-influenced structures. It is listenable, and well-made, and maybe even important to the genre, although, again, because I wasn’t initially sold 15 years ago, I barely know what the post-rock essentials are, so never hearing about this until today is a silly critique. If you want ambient, jazzy post-rock, this album serves it up hot and ready. But I don’t really need this in my life, personally, so I’m not really sold on this either. It is very, very bland. And that has a time and place, but I’d rather have my coworkers assume I’m having a mental health crisis because I’m listening to The Dillinger Escape Plan than assume I’m old as fuck for listening to this.

Arvostan, että osataan tehdä instrumentaalilevy, joka jaksaa pitää mielenkiinnon yllä koko ajan - eikä katkea! Siis kappaleet on liitetty yhteen. Ja on sopiva pituus. Kiva äänimaailma, tuo viestinsä perille. Mutta jää tasolle ”kiva”, saatan palata vain muistuttamaan, miltä tämä ”post-rock” kuulostaa.

Mistä vetoa, että tämä on instrumentaalimusiikkia vain siksi, että soittajat ovat "cooleja" tyyppejä, jotka pelkäävät, että nolaisivat itsensä itsensä, jos yrittäisivät laulaa? Levy on sinänsä yllättävänkin kiinnostava: en välttämättä kuuntelisi uudelleen, mutta kelasin taaksepäin aina silloin, kun jokin kohta meni minulta ohi.

This is such a good headphones album - I walked my dog while listening to the opener, the 21 minute long "Djed". It was so hypnotizing that I kept my headphones in and took in the rest of the album on my couch. The combination of really driving almost punk drums, with textural guitar and bass, playful and jazzy xylophone, and electronic atmospherics made for a uniquely cool listening experience. Loved it!

I think that 18 year old me would have been all over this, probably made it a pillar of my personality for a few months. Whatever has happened in the ensuing 2 decades, I’m become now just a husk who listened to it, thought it was ok and promptly moved on.

Couldn't get into this

There is a place for minimalist music and a place for ambient music. It's not really to my taste anymore although it does relax my brain to have something like this on in the background while I'm doing something else. But if that's the reason for making an album, you might as well just create an algorithm to produce this kind of music. Western music is characterized by tension and release. there wasn't much of that here. That is perhaps by design, but there are other ways to disrupt Western music conventions. I'm not sure this band was trying to do that, although it appears they were trying to do something. What that is is unknown to me, but I hope it made them happy. They call it “post-rock” because it uses rock instruments in new ways. But honestly I’d rather listen to musicians use their instruments the way Tricot and Primus do. If you are going to break rock conventions and make a stylistic statement do it with virtuosity, not blandness.

Cold music you can't touch, that keeps its distance and does not invite in glass everywhere. there was a series of equations to solve at the source a puzzle to which the music is a solution something to look at but not enter was there a who they had in mind? made for spaces empty of community. deserted banks of dry rivers Where is life? I will not come back here.

Depressing

that was interesting. Started out a little too experimental and slow for my tastes but I especially enjoyed the last track.

Conocía el anterior. Éste me ha aburrido un poco.

Silent Post Rock.

No one can complain about my singing…

Didn’t get it

Dope band name and dope album. Didn’t know what this was going to be but happily surprised to hear some post rock, also good choice on the variety of instruments used (3.5/5)

I prefer John McEntire in The Sea and Cake.

Пошли нахуй козлы со своими 20-минутными песнями

These are exactly the kind of albums I was hoping to discover through this list

love the way Glass Museum starts

I'm not totally opposed to instrumental music but this doesn't even build to any big moments that grab you. I guess it's in the list because it's influential in the post-rock genre but I didn't need to hear it and I'm not big on post-rock anyway

Very unusual rock. Enjoyed it a decent bit. I could see this one growing on me. Rating: 3.4

Just about made it through the first few song. Albums like this should not be on a list to listen to before you die…unless you want to die of boredom.

I can see where they got the band name from with that first song Would probably rather watch a tortoise race than listen to this album again...

How on earth has this album been included in the top 1000? Dross. 1/5

Actually didn’t mind this, not my first rodeo with long ambient albums. Still don’t understand how it’s made it on this list mind you. Would still rather listen to 1 hour of this than 1 second of The Lemonheads

OK post rock with lots of bleeps and bloops and electronic effects. I reckon the first track ‘Djed’ coming in at 20+ minutes actually sucks a fair bit of momentum from the rest of the record, and I’m not sure it ever really recovers.

Forcing Alicia to listen to these on vacation. Her review: “Sounds like music from a coffee shop with a bunch of random noises mixed in”

2.4 Not everyday listening for me by any stretch of the imagination but I did find certain parts were pretty progressive and interesting

Have I heard this album before? No Highlights: Djed, Glass Museum, The Taut and Tame, Dear Grandma and Grandpa, Along the Banks of Rivers Rating: 8.4/10 The intro track Djed is a really cool, minimalist rock piece that moves through different phases and holds the attention the whole time despite its simplistic nature. The rest of the album features some post rock and ambient type tracks that I enjoyed a lot.

Started off strongly but just tapered too hard. Kinda like the first time hearing a jamband turned into an album. Not exactly revolutionary but could speak deeply to a certain group or age. Unfortunately that passed thru me decades ago. Not bad but certainly not more than 3.

I don’t think I’ve heard of Tortoise before. Could it be that they are The Turtles in disguise? A turtle lives in water. A tortoise lives on land. A turtle’s not a tortoise, it’s not hard to understand. That’s how to remember. Anyway, lets listen and find out how Tortoise sound! Songs I already knew: none Favourites: Glass Museum This reminds me a lot of Boards Of Canada and Aphex Twin. It is an ambient electronica that sits well in the back of your head while listening. I did enjoy this, but it didn’t really make as much of an impression on me as BoC or Aphex, and I’m not really sure why. Perhaps I need to stew on this one for longer. It is the kind of album where I could theoretically see myself loving it, but I’m just not quite there right now.

Usually, I say that I like rock music. It's a way to define myself, even broadly. Now, I'll start to say that I dislike post-rock. This is much more precise in defining myself.

Expected incredibly boring post rock, but this was interesting at times.

This was cool

Wow, super atmospheric music.

Another great find! Never heard of Tortoise, I hadn't even heard of "post rock", although now I know what it is, it seems many of the bands I like are post rock. This was atmospheric, jazzy, dreamy music that I enjoyed very much and would happily listen to again. High 4 stars, almost 5.

Honestly, I don't know how to rate it. Sometimes intriguing, sometimes squawks

There are days when I really enjoy long instrumental post rock tracks. It wasn't today though. It was just okay with moments of great and moments of boring noise.

First ever listen to these guys, love this album.

2nd day in a row where I get a 20 minute long opener song. This is an instrumental album which is the first in a long while. Nonetheless the music just isn't that interesting. It just kinda limps along never really being all that assertive.

In college, I went to a house show at "The Treehouse". The house had an actual living tree growing through the middle of it. That's irrelevant to this rating but objectively very cool. At the end of the night, a dude played a set that largely consisted of the automated voice from the New Jersey Turnpike Authority being played over and over on repeat with some random beeps and boops thrown in. It was hands down the worst sound I have ever listened to and I will never forget it. Now back to this album... About 16 minutes into the first song, a horrible combination or sirens and other stressful beeping started. I actually could not make it through to the end of the song because it was so terrible and it reminded me of that troubled young man who loved the New Jersey Turnpike Authority too much. The rest of the songs were not nearly as offensive but they were basically just a crappy version of Explosions in the Sky.

I liked the pacing and sounds a lot. There were some sorta dull moments, but I enjoyed it more on the second listen.

It's a weirder Explosions in the Sky with far more electronic sounds. The first song, Djed, dragged and was a little too ambient for me. Glass Museum slapped. None of the other songs really drew me in. I was bored most of the time and likely wouldn't play this again. 4/10

Blind album and artist. This was very interesting for an experimental ambient instrumental album... not my favorite for sure but was very unique. Odd and spooky and eerie.

Solid instrumental but i have no interest in a 20 minute instrumental

I have always been a big fan of this album and "TNT." Tortoise were an even bigger inspiration than I think a lot of people gave them credit for. When Radiohead put out "Kid A," my coworkers and I instantly were like, "Oh, it's Tortoise plus Aphex Twin with Radiohead's Brit rock mixed in." Just solid songs, playing, and great production for the time and how small that scene was, especially at the time.

Could not really get into

I'm liking all the Post-Rock stuff here. Some really cool songs on this album, especially in 1996.

Favourite song - Glass museum

Awesome!

Interesting. Not bad but I feel sleepy now.

I don't mind these kind of ambient, soft electronic albums. It's a very chill time for the most part, but it's never going to dazzle me.

Classé dans Rock ? Euh... Mais bon, sinon un peu étrange. J'aime bien car c'est instrumental, ça passe en travaillant.

Very well

Djed - 8/10 Glass Museum - 7.5/10 A Survey - 7/10 The Taut and Tame - 7/10 Dear Grandma and Grandpa - 7.5/10 Along the Banks of Rivers - 7/10 TOTAL - 45/60

A interesting album. No lyrics throughout the album. Definitely a bit experimental. The first song was awful and does not deserve to be called music. The second was probably my favorite. Most of the rest of the album reminded me of lofi study beats. Lots of… nature sounds used throughout the album. Not bad, but the first song kinda ruined it for me

This one was okay. It seems way ahead of its time to me, but I could be off with that estimation.

Experimental Techno-Electronica. Not into it at all. Another 1

Jammy, slow, weird. I’m down

I want to give this album a 3.5. It’s pretty solidly in the uncanny mid-good valley

Lots of meandering.

Click "play". Waiting for something interesting to happen. Around 14 minutes into the first song I thought my speakers were broken. They were not. 30 minutes into the album, did it start yet? Have I missed something? 40 minutes in. Someone is softly playing the guitar. VEEERRRYYY softly. And just like that it's over. It's over? It's over.. It was nice though.

I did really try to listen to this. Made it about 1/3 of the way through, and I don't think I really enjoyed a single part of any song I heard.

At times this album drags on like a tortoise. But there are moments where this pace of development pays off.

Instrumental. Boring. Pointless.

Good post-rock. Some of it reminds of yo la tengo slow grooves

I found this one so interesting, and I think I probably played it every day for 2 weeks before deciding how to rate it. So much going on - bass harmonics - well all the bass playing, drummer going wild, melody just wandering around aimlessly and then coming together. Loved it, will check out their other work.

Decent background music, nothing too distracting.

Good post rock album, but not one that really encapsulated me. Agree should be on the list, but don’t think I’ll be coming back to this the same way I do a mogwai or sigar Rios album.

Curveball of an LP that will require a few more listens to parse out my feelings on. Overall, though, I found myself enjoying this slower, more contemplative post-punkish rock even if the LP is a slow burn at parts. The mids-heavy distortion over glassy basslines reminded me of bands like Dismemberment Plan, but stretched out and slowed down to a contemplative pace that felt like its own thing.

Not my cup of tea

Enjoyable. moody ambient album clearly made with skill and care and an excellent example of the genre. Music to get work done by.

Didn’t hate it

Gets a 3 solely for Djed. That song was an evolution and interesting experience in post-rock. But then I need lyrics. Otherwise it's just jamming

I knew we were in for a long one when they busted out the keys and started noodling on the first song. And much like this album, I have nothing else to say

What a wild ride. Like be dropped off in the middle of the desert and having to find your way back home. Maybe that's the Tortoise of it all. I'd love to dive into the album title too, trying to figure out what they are alluding to. Especially with the fish. I know millions living now will not die is used in Jehova's Witness' per the description. Is that a metaphor? Like that those who convert won't die? It seems like it would be more powerful to title it "In one hundred years, all who are alive now will be dead" or "hero's get remembered, legends never die". Either way, cracking this open with a twenty minute song is balsy beyond belief. But that song is good, and does a better job harnessing sounds than that Report album I hated last week. The rest of the songs were good too, I really liked Taut and Tame.

Here's a really cool one, never heard of this group but I seriously love the title, hard as hell. The music is really cool, I would describe it as a sort of prog-instrumental stuff, with rock textures. Wikipedia says "post-rock" and "jazz fusion," so maybe I'm not wildly off course. But it's really cool, only a handful of songs but some of them are really long and meandering. The first three songs on the album that I dug enough to favorite turned out to be, literally, the first three songs, though listening through I thought I was on five or six. I really like this style of music, it's a great journey. Right up my alley, need to get more stuff like this I haven't heard. Favorite tracks: Djed, Glass Museum, A Survey, Dear Grandma and Grandpa. Album art: Decent cover, a faint image of a school of fish swimming around, with an inset to show you the fish. It's not much to write home about, but it gets the job done I suppose. Again, nothing is gonna top the album title itself. 4/5

Halfway between Mogwai and Boards of Canada, but with its own jazz thing going on. Another one I should have been listening to at the time.

An enthralling piece of sonic doom ambience.

Lucky to be young and living in Chicago when they were doing their thing. Definitely hear the groundwork for Yankee Hotel Foxtrot here.

Shit was ass

Djed is an expansive, laid back instrumental journey that takes many forms; it is not a cohesive song so much as a collection of ideas spliced together seamlessly. The segment around 7:00 has key work and overall vibe that remind me vaguely of Vulfpeck (from what I remember of their work). This "song" has a gentle groove about it and I enjoy the way that they just keep noodling and experimenting with various additive effects while a consistent, tight drum rhythm and burbling bass keep things going in one direction. Well that is until the bottom drops out around 9:30 and the whole thing segues seamlessly (by way of electronic stutter) into a bright bell-lead segment. This carries on until about 14:00 when they start to overlay some effects that make it seem like the whole thing is falling apart at the seams. We are left in the aftermath with a minimal drum machine pop/click and static scratching, through which some euphoric synth line attempts to surface while being bombarded by sounds of an apparent alien invasion. The last 2 minutes of the song take all agression and let it melt into a blissful opium haze. Loved this ride and will absolutely go on it again soon. Glass Museum opens with a sad-boi tone that remind me a bit more of Ovlov or some Explosions in the Sky mixed with Modest Mouse. Back half opens up into a tear with lovely, unexpected bells work. This song is sick. A Survey is a nice burblin bass interlude. Doesn't really go anywhere specifically, but it is moody and nice. You hear similar themes in the bass line of The Taut and Tame. Along the Banks of Rivers has a dusty almost smokey western vibe about it to round out the album. Love the atmosphere. Super easy going with no rush to be over and done with. Just a nice slow exit. This album was pretty great all the way through. I'm surprised I haven't listened to Tortoise before. Nice to see an instrumental album on here from the modern, indie era. Even with a 20+ minute song this album doesn't stay in any one place for very long. Lots of different sounds and textures at work. I liked it a lot and will most likely be back. Strong 4.

Fine to listen to in the background of doing stuff but felt like at times I am just listening to random sounds. Various clicks and sounds fading in and out. It feels like a 90s psychedelic mostly instrumental sounds. Wouldn't be surprised if there is some Pink Floyd influence behind them. I think I enjoyed the last song the best Along the Banks of Rivers. Giving it a hard 2.5. Almost want to give it a 3.

Interesting album here that felt like a bit of a jam. Some pretty cool stuff going on in this one that could warrant a 4, but not ever really exciting enough to bring it there.

That sure was trippy. I really liked the instrumentals and all around mysterious sounds. At times it was a little too repetitive. But still a very cool album.

Honestly a baller listen. Listened in the car but had to go back and listen again on headphones to see what I missed. So much going on in these songs. The first song Djed felt like it was 3 or 4 songs wrapped in 1. A Survey gives off some Pink Floyd vibes I dig it. Djed is the standout but also really loved The Taut and Tame. The drums kicked ass on it. The last song could be in a Tarantino movie right before some shit goes down. This is an extremely high 4 for me, close to a 5.

I really enjoy this kind of rock/jazz fusion "post-rock" sound. However, this isn't my favorite Tortoise material by far. Overall a worthy listen but doubtful it would be returned to. 3.5/5

Did not do much for me

Cool and weird and trippy. Super lowkey.

Instrumental ambient album. It has to play in the background, because when you pay attention it's mildly infuriating. 2.5/5

Genre: Post-rock, Jazz fusion 1996 The most well known songs: Djed, Glass Museum (According to Ranker.com) and The Taut and the Tame was a single along with Djed. Don't know these guys or the music. Djed is a 21 minute long song. This one is a slow burn. It's not something you pick up, listen to and fall in love with immediately. I've been listening for a while now, and I'm not getting it. I can see some people getting into it after maybe a 100 listens. Who has the patients for that? I can see putting this on a playlist of songs to study to. Perfect for that. Djed just seems really long and not very interesting honestly. Glass Museum has a dreamy quality to it that makes it stand out as the 'best' on the album. A Survey has a Pink Floyd sound that never seems to take off. On a good day this is nothing more than a 3 / 5. Rating:

All instrumental, probably a little experimental at the time, decent music for doing homework.

What the crap was that?

along the banks of rivers

gonna have to revisit this one maybe, just didn't click with me!

I really liked it, however it seemed like some parts, like the keyboards in the first song, was just added on without listening to the rest of the song.

A real bop.

Es akustisches rock Album? Hmmm... Schomol schwierig. Eis vo de erste mal dasi Wikipedia ahglueget han welli denkt ha evt isch da e deeper meaning behind it... Naja irgendwie sött meh "hailed as godfathers of the American 'post-rock' movement" ih demm fall fasch meh als Warnig gseh als öppis anderes. Es tönt ja scho nid terrible aber ich gseh überhaupt nid de appeal vo dem. 2/5

Hä?? Was bini am lose?? Nahh