Some songs were a little silly, but they were all very catchy and I find myself humming them even after listening.
Lots of noise without saying anything. I just don't get it.
Plenty of fun ideas, a bit more stuck with me compared to other Beck albums.
Quirky without losing depth.
I appreciate the musicianship, but its not for me.
The instrumentation is interesting, but the singing and songwriting isn't for me.
Flows aged poorly, lyrics aged alright, production aged wonderfully.
A new favorite. Packed with aggressive vocals and interesting instrumentation. Will definitely be listening again and checking out more of their discography.
Production is excellent, flows are decent but lyrics haven't aged great.
The instrumentation was nice.
Interesting but some tracks made me sleepy.
Not usually a fan of this style, but it won't me over by the end.
No skips. Excellent album.
Kind of everything I want from a rock album.
Eh. There's other country rock I'd listen to if given the chance but this is fine.
Interesting but not my thing.
Fun album. The crowd really showed the energy.
Instrumentation is very nice but the lyrics were so bad. Just whiny revenge fantasy after whiny revenge fantasy. Then it ends with a Christian tune? It's bordering on parody.
Glad I listened, but probably won't be revisiting it much outside of Lexicon Devil.
Nice in the background and foreground. Chill enough not to be distracting the complex enough for critical listening.
Excellent first three songs. The rest are meh.
I'd like it way more if the songs were a little shorter.
Never been a Neil Young fan, but some of these where his voice isn't so warbly are pretty good.
Solid album. A few highlights.
I just can't get over the vocals.
I like this way more than I thought I would.
Be still, my millennial heart.
I'd never heard of this band, but I really liked this record.
I honestly dont know how to feel about this.
I honestly dont know how to feel about this.
It definitely peaked early, but I still enjoyed it.
Bloopy 80s cheese. I don't like it.
Easiest 5/5 I've ever given. This album is phenomenal.
Excellent energetic rock.
Kinda hard to listen to, but the instrumentation is fun.
Instrumentation was not nearly good enough to make up for the lyrics and vocals.
Greater than the sum of its parts (which is saying something for an album with Moondance and Crazy Love on it)
This is the third Dylan album I've had during this project. I couldn't stand the first two, but this one wasn't too bad.
Nothing stood out, but the album as a whole was a nice ride
Starts and ends weak, but there's a solid run of songs in the middle.
Theres a reason theyre classics
Some of the melodies feel purposefully grating. I can appreciate the skill it takes to make them but I didn't care for it much.
I feel like I would've liked this more when it first came out, but this style has been done much better by others in the years since its release.
I have never wanted to tell a lead singer to shut the fuck up more than I have listening to this album.
Continually changing and staying interesting without losing its punk edge.
Didn't leave much of an impact, but it was fine.
A truly gifted songwriter.
This album did not feel nearly as long as it was. Excellently crafted and extremely catchy.
Songs were quick and fun. I enjoyed hearing the crowd banter as well.
I just don't get Neil Young as a solo artist. Old Man is a nice song but I feel like I only really click with his music when he's part of a larger group.
Way better than I remembered.
Incredibly good listen. Aged really well.
Beats are fun but the lyrics did not age well.
The bass was doing some fun stuff but overall I didn't care for it.
I think I really really liked it, but I'll need a few more listens to know for sure
Definitely an interesting listen. Some songs sound half-finished but I kinda liked that. It felt like a glimpse into Paul McCartney songwriting process.
Very front loaded, but mostly enjoyable all throughout.
Absolutely incredible. One of my favorite live albums of all time.
Entirely forgettable except for Bob's Yer Uncle but that's memorable for the wrong reasons.
It made me want to punch a wall in the best possible way.
Great classic rock album.
Just about every song is decently catchy, but only a few were memorable. I liked it overall but I'll probably only ever return to a handful of these tracks.
Wonderful record. Infinitely listenable and grooveable.
It was fine. I appreciate the musicianship but most of it wasn't for me.
I can't believe this album flew under my radar for so long. No skips, excellent songs with enough angst, grit, catchiness, incisiveness, and energy to keep me coming back.
The heavy guitars are really well done. I enjoyed it.
A little disappointing since I know these guys are capable of much more.
It just did nothing for me. I've been to a rave and I tried imagining dancing to this there and it felt depressing. The music is kinda interestingly layered every once in a while, but the album as a whole made me bounce back and forth between feeling annoyed and apathetic.
Not the most boring album, but it definitely thinks it's more interesting than it is.
I was dancing from the first song and didn't stop until the end. Absolutely fantastic and fun record that will be going into my rotation.
It's an influential album for a reason.
Not my favorite of theirs, but still packed with excellent songs.
The song lengths make this difficult to put into casual rotation, but I did really enjoy it.
Started out meh, but the guitar work in some of the later songs won me over.
It was good. I dont remember most of the songs the next day but I enjoyed it while I listened.
I can see myself listening to this again if I'm ever in the mood.
It was good. Definitely different for early 2000s.
Not super memorable to me.
It was almost 80 minutes long and I still didn't want it to end. The catchy songs and charisma left me wanting to play it again and again.
Moments were grating, but in a way I weirdly didn't mind.
Nothing will ever touch Back in Black, but this was still pretty good.
All vibes. I didn't really care for it.
I overlooked this band for way too long.
Very gifted songwriting on display here.
Some of the instrumentals were fun, but I really didn't like the vocals or lyrics.
It made me want to walk around New York around Christmastime.
I can't really figure out why, but I just find this music annoying.
Pretty interesting stuff. I could definitely listen to this over and over again.
Overblown. Songs would be better sampled and not listened to in their entirety.
My third Dylan record on this project and by far the best. Still not really my thing though.
One of only a few albums that can justify 7+ minute songs.
I really enjoyed it. Some of it was rough, but a lot of it sounds surprisingly modern. Hard to believe its almost 20 years old.
Not the best garage rock revival album, but the sound definitely took me back to the late 90s early 2000s.
I started this project a certified Bob Dylan hater. Five albums in, I still don't like it, but I think I kinda get it. Maybe. I don't know. I enjoyed parts of this more than the other albums I've had so far.
It may be unfair to review an album in my current state, but fuck it. This is my review.
I listened to about a third of this album, then received some entirely unexpected news about a family member in the hospital. I've had a really difficult time with the news, and admittedly I'm still processing it as I write this, but I relistened to the album and it didn't make me feel better, but maybe not so upset at myself for how I'm feeling.
The vocals, while rough on the first listen, complement the lyrics exceptionally well. The push and pull of beautiful instrumentation and sometimes-subtle-sometimes-overt darker moments really hit me. I left the album feeling not so alone with my own complicated feelings.
Starts strong but tapers off pretty quickly. Also -1 for the homophobia in One Of Them.
I just really didn't care for it. The vocals were also grating to me.
Excellent musicianship, but some of the crowd banter felt off.
A chill listen and I enjoyed it, but nothing really stuck out and some songs felt overly long.
I enjoyed it quite a bit.
One of the easiest 5s I've given so far. Extremely fun to listen to and pick apart.
I've been a casual Jack White fan for a while, but this just didn't click with me.
I was meh on the album until I realized the mix made the singers "ess" sounds all squeeky/whistly. Really grated on me by the end of the record.
I did it. I listened to the whole thing. I completed the Ella Fitzger-athon. And I have some thoughts.
This album fundamentally breaks this project. Most of the 130ish albums I've had so far are somewhat analogous to movies - discrete experiences with at least some thought put into the beginning, middle, and end. Not every one is a concept album, but they at least have some kind of flow to them.
If these other albums are movies, this one is a sitcom, specifically an early sitcom with no overarching narrative. That's not to say it's worse, it just needs to be enjoyed differently.
Independently, most of these songs are pretty great. Ella Fitzgerald's voice is incredible, and the jazz accompaniments suite the songs well. If I heard one of these at a snazzy cocktail bar, I'd probably really enjoy it.
Binging all these songs together is a mistake. The cutesy lyrics and jazzy bombast can only get you so far. I was mentally done halfway through the second volume/disc, but I was less than halfway through this thing.
If you have the opportunity, maybe try listening to this over a long weekend of cleaning the house or something. I think I would have definitely liked it a lot more if I had given each volume a little more room to breathe.
Somehow better than I remember
I was lukewarm to it at first, but it kinda grew on me by the end.
Weirdly, it almost felt too peppy for grunge and too passive for punk.
This feels like a very "you had to be there" album. I was not there.
I tried to like it but just didn't.
I like jazz but never know where to start. This was a nice recommendation.
Absolutely loved this album.
Some of it was a little difficult, but I liked it overall.