It's A Shame About Ray by The Lemonheads

It's A Shame About Ray

The Lemonheads

3.12
Rating
24445
Votes
1
4%
2
20%
3
44%
4
24%
5
8%
Distribution

Album Summary

It's a Shame About Ray is the fifth album by American alternative rock band the Lemonheads, released on June 2, 1992. The album was produced by the Robb Brothers. At the time of principal recording, the band consisted of Evan Dando (lead vocals, guitar), Juliana Hatfield (bass, backing vocals) and David Ryan (drums). Though not originally on the album, the band's cover of Simon & Garfunkel's "Mrs. Robinson" was added to the album in later pressings after it had become a major worldwide radio hit, and it features a later lineup of the band with Nic Dalton on bass.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

This is a brief little jangle pop album. It's fine but nothing special; I'm not sure why it's here on this list. While listening, I learned Juliana Hatfield was a member. Spurred me to go listen to her album I'd long forgotten about, "Become What You Are", which came out the year before this. That was a better album than this one. So I guess this wasn't all for naught.

really vibed

Jangle pop and power pop in grunge clothing. After frontman and only fixed member Evan Dando toiled in the hardcore and punk rock scene for the four albums preceding this record, they soften their sound for the band's breakthrough outing. I'd argue that there is nothing groundbreaking about this record as music wouldn't be much different if this was deleted from history, but I'm a big Lemonheads fan so I welcome an excuse to listen it. Dando has a handsome voice and it is a pleasure to hear him rip through these breezy alt rock tracks. I'll break my own rule of only reviewing the original release as their Simon & Garfunkel cover of "Mrs. Robinson" is one of the band's most known songs. Their cover updates the song for the nineties and while Paul Simon might have disliked it, I've always enjoyed it.

This was one of those very pleasant surprises. Hadn't really heard of this band at all and this album was pretty awesome! Great new find.

Jag gillade dem live, när det begav sig (80-tal) men de satte inte något kvardröjande avtryck. Den här plattan har jag aldrig hört. Den växer nog på en. Kompetent ärrad och spelad alt rock, fina gitarrer, bra låtar. Men det saknas något som sticker ut, en X-factor. En fyra

if the most popular song on your album is a cover, you're not that good.

This album did not really capture me when it came out, and pretty much the same now. It is ok, with A few good songs but nothing amazing that makes me want to listen to it again. Title track was the standout song. "a ship without a rudder is like a ship without a rudder".....deep dude. 3 Stars

Som legalzinho, mas nada muito chamativo. Mas curti a versão deles de Mr Robinson. Gostei mais de ouvir as tracks Demo deles, ver a música mais crua.

Man, I feel sorry for anyone who had grow up on this stuff because this is utter no-effort slacker nonsense. Anyone who has taken a week's worth of guitar lessons could crank out these boring, hook-free numbers which, to add insult to injury, are topped off by lazy singing that carries no emotional weight whatsoever.

Alternatieve, maar iets te welluidende jarennegentigmuziek, met hier en daar een hint van grunge. Het hangt er wat tussenin en is allemaal net niks. Het leukste nummer is de Simon & Garfunkel-cover, maar dat is de later toegevoegde bonustrack, dus die telt niet. En doorrrrjjjj.

Dit valt volgens wiki onder alternative rock. Ik noemde al eerder dat de term 'rock' betekenisloos is geworden. Kijken we even naar die andere term: 'alternative'. Wat zegt wiki daarover? Het had 'mainstream success' in de jaren '90. Heel alternatief hoor... Lekker met zijn allen volhouden dat je anders bent... Maar inderdaad in de jaren '90 hoorde je dit geluid de hele dag door op de radio. Verondersteld dat je daarnaar luisterde. Want de continue stroom van dit toen moderne alternatieve geluid was voor mij juist een reden om die radio niet aan te zetten. Genoeg vergelijkingsmateriaal dus. Ook in deze lijst. Hoe verhoudt dit album zich dan daartoe? Het is relatief clean. Dat luistert ten opzichte van de rest wel makkelijk. Maar de andere kant van die medaille is, dat er nauwelijks iets prikkelt. Het is dan ook niet gek dat alleen Mrs. Robinson boven is komen te drijven. Dat heeft net wat meer energie, spelende coupletjes en een daarmee balans brengend pakkend refreintje. Niet mijn smaak, maar wel wat kleur.

Hmm, Lemonheads, die naam komt me bekend voor. Ik zou zeggen dat ik een nummer van ze zou moeten (her)kennen. Ah, die titeltrack ken ik wel. Verder hebben ze voornamelijk gescoord met coverhitjes van anderen blijkbaar. De muziek klinkt als veel van de 90s rockerige bandjes. Er zit een lekker tempo in, de zang is ietwat lijzig, de gitaar mag af en toe rocken. In die zin voegt het niet veel toe aan deze lijst, maar zit dit uiteraard wel in het hoekje wat ik makkelijk luister. En al helemaal als je het bij een klein half uurtje houdt. Je moet het dan wel heel bont maken, wil je niet minimaal een 3 scoren. Maar laten we eerlijk zijn, het stijgt er ook niet boven uit.

A pleasant enough album with a bunch of songs that all sound nearly identical to one another. I enjoy this style of alt rock, but this is one of the last bands that I’d choose to listen to. Turn on some Gin Blossoms instead.

Inoffensive.

Love the candy, had never heard the band. Definitely has that 90's sound I love. I will listen to this again soon.

2.75 - Mostly decent. There were some odd things that took me out of it at times.

definitely getting another listen really liked this album!

I had definitely listened to this way back when, and it holds up. Nice power pop songs that should be on the soundtrack to a 90s movie. Lovely stuff.

a fine addition to my collection

Sounded like a samey fuzzy mush on first listen, with songs that ran way too short. Appreciated it much more on the second listen. The songwriting is lovely and goes down nicely. It lives and dies by that distorted 90s jangle, though. It is something you just have be in the mood for, like truffle mayo.

They figured out how to make a bunch of okay alt rock songs, and decided that was good enough

It's pretty good. Obviously Mrs Robinson is a great cover, and the title track It's a Shame About Ray is great. The other songs are good and seems like the type of album that would get better with more listens. Added to library.

...i got nothing new nor revolutionary on this album...

Nice 90s energetic rock, but nothin too special about it.

Alternativ und gut

Needed another 57 songs

I quite like it but I mean it shouldn't be on here should it

only care for mrs robinson. the rest isnt interesting and held it back

хороший роцк с добрым настроением, чистые 90-ые

Not a fan.

It was a drag. Not a fan

90s alt rock. Really good natured 90s rock. Melodious, a bit like an edgier, younger REM.

It's fine, no strong reaction other way.

Fairly inoffensive, I've heard a hundred albums like this on this list so it hasn't really left an impression

I'd never heard of them before, but something about this just hit all the right notes. Fun!

4/10 - generic 90s American rock

Good album. Catchy and direct songs (and short overall album). Pretty good power pop or jangle pop. Not a big fan of the "Mrs. Robinson" cover (it is obviously a good song, but I don't think it fits here). Some tracks I enjoyed: "Confetti", "It's a Shame About Ray", "Rudderless" (together with "Confetti", probably my favourite), or "My Drug Buddy" (I found the second half of the album was less inspired). Overall, it's in the 3,5 star range for me. It's a shame that, at least for me, the album is quite irregular and the best tracks happen to be tracks 2 to 5 in a row. For this reason, overall, i think it falls short of the 4 stars.

Classic non-offensive 90's alt rock. It's a good album with some great songs here and there.

Rockin' Stroll - Okay 2/5 Confetti - Not a fan of this one 1/5 It's A Shame About Ray - Meh 2/5 Rudderless - I like parts of this 2/5 My Drug Buddy - Drugs are bad and so is this song 1/5 The Turnpike Down - More energy and more formula 2/5 Bit Part - Eh 1/5 Alison's Starting to Happen - Losing interest is starting to happen 1/5 Hannah & Gabi - Slide guitar? 2/5 Kitchen - Claps! 1/5 Ceiling Fan in My Spoon - Nah 1/5 Frank Mills - Not feeling it 1/5 Mrs. Robinson - Best song and also not their song 3/5 Thoughts that come to mind: "I have never heard of this band and have no expectations." "They seem to enjoy having both an acoustic guitar and a distorted guitar playing the same thing." "It's not the worst thing, but pretty formulaic. I wish these songs took more chances." "I feel like a lot of songs have things I like about them, but the entire composition just fails to grab me." "Now at the point where I need to consider how much I care enough to hear all of the deluxe edition bonus tracks." "I think I'm tapping out after the Mrs. Robinson cover."

Right in my 90s wheelhouse.

Pretty good! Loving the riffs here. It's a shame about Ray, though.

One top comment described this as a less interesting blind melon. And I can kinda see it, it's got some more mainstream sound though and not as much jangliness in the voice. But I really really like my citrussy indie rock so this one gets a seal of approval.

This shit was longer than my life expectancy. So at least it wasn’t trash!

Long time fave

Gutes Punk Album, sehr 90s

It's A Shame About Ray: 1992. it's a good fun album, I remember their Simon and Garfunkel cover (which was added to reissues of this album), but don't know anything else by them.

Jangle pop hooks at hardcore run times.

Just not my thing.

It's a shame this wasn't really worth a listen. Favorite song: Hannah & Gabi

I was never really able to enjoy this particular type of indie rock. Just a bit too mundane and slight for my taste.

Upbeat jams, pretty good vibes.

Nostalgic 90’s alt rock. Nothing to love or hate.

I've said this several times now but this band sounds a lot like the BNL Best Song: Self Titled Rating: 7/10 Stars: 4

A hit doesn't make an album. Nor a band. Bland an irrelevant. 5/10

A band I had heard of but could never have named a song. Obviously one huge banger. This sort of light ninetees stuff isn't massively my bag but still enjoyed it.

If you're going to be a strummy, strummy band without much musical invention or skill, then you had better have an amazing singer with compelling lyrics. Evan Dando doesn't really hit either mark. A fine 90s rock album, but there are loads of those.

It's a shame about the Lemonheads

Undemanding pop led by a guy that all the cool girls loved when I was 17 - I was pretty much anti-Lemonheads on principle back then, especially when my tastes were leaning more towards Faith No More and Pantera at the time. Listening now, it’s still pretty undemanding and radio-friendly but kind of lacking in much substance or originality. It does what it does well but doesn’t leave any lasting impression.

There wasn't anything life-changing about it, but it also wasn't offensive in any way--basic 90's alternative rock, it seems.

I found this boring but 90s aficionados seem to love it.

I was expecting it to be another average 3 star album, but I liked it more than expected

It is a shame

I don't think it's particularly sophisticated examples of 90s pop rock but I enjoyed it

It was alright, nothing more.

Did Ray also go into this album and be thoroughly underwhelmed?

This band somehow passed me by back in the 90s, but it sounds like it would have fit in with a lot of what I was listening to. It makes me think a little bit of the Gin Blossoms -- occasionally more Stone Roses-y and other times more Oasis-y. Most of the time it feels a little forgettable, but I think that could be because it sounds like things I like due to nostalgia -- without me having any of the nostalgia. By the time it got to the bonus tracks I did find I was familiar with the Mrs. Robinson cover... and I actually like it a lot. I might even prefer it to the original. The only problem I have with it are a few country-tinged songs near the end of the track order I didn't enjoy. Other than that it was fine and occasionally engaging. I wish I'd heard it at the time of release -- I might feel differently about it now.

Listens: 3 Standout Tracks: Rudderless, My Drug Buddy, Bit Part, Mrs. Robinson This is some good 90s alternative rock. I figured I would know of Lemonheads or recognize at least one of their track, but I don't simply don't. It's weird. There are a ton of 90s "college rock" bands I can rattle off: Eve 6, New Radicals, Gin Blossoms, Third Eye Blind, Cake, etc. But Lemonheads somehow evaded my interest in the genre growing up. That's okay, it just means I can experience them fresh now.... 30+ years later. I really enjoyed a lot of the demo tracks on the back half of the Expanded Edition. They come off not just as demo tracks, but also stripped-down, acoustic-style, which makes the whole affair a lot more somber and frankly, way more impactful.

Meh. Not as good as I remember.

Ya el cover no me gustó, me dió indicaciones de lo mid que iba a ser este álbum solo dos temas buenos.

Meh, rock movidito fácil de escuchar, pero nada muy wow.

nice listen.

it is quite alright

Alternative rock, grunge, pop-punk, jangle pop, folk rock

This was okay but that’s about as much as I have to say on it.

This was a pleasant little surprise. All I knew about this band was their hit cover of Mrs. Robinson, and I had written them off as a one-hit wonder. Well, they are, but the rest of this album (Mrs. Robinson was only ever released on the deluxe version, so you purists will miss out) was totally decent.

2.5/5 not bad, but not a must listen.

That Mrs. Robinson cover is great.

Not really great, but the sincerity of just making music they want to make carries it to 3

It doesn't reinvent any wheels, but it's nevertheless one of the quintessential college rock records - superbly-executed, blissful guitar rock with infectious tunes with dark hints of the sad torment haunting Dando seeping through.

This is #day785 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and... here's to some '90s alternative rock on this early October Friday afternoon again. It's kind of good at what it does, but... I don't know. Is this record so essential that you must hear it before you die? Let it be a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day786.

Great folky grunge. Not sure it’s super serious music that’s taken very seriously these days, but I love this album.

🙂‍↕️😍😛😁

Yaya I’m rock punk

This is a 90s college alt rock band that feels like a warm blanket. Like everything is going to be ok and the future is bright we can make a difference and the live music scene is thriving and the world isn’t crashing down.

Overall I haven’t got a lot to say about this album - it was just a bit flat. I kept waiting for it to kick in, but sadly just found myself wanting to skip songs to get to the good bit that didn’t come. In all honesty I’m not sure I’ve been able to tell the difference between songs. I think this is a “had to be there album” and if you were coming of age in the 90s or listened during some life changing event it’s probably brilliant, but for me it just sounds like good background music for a scene in American Pie 😂 Highlights: Like the guitars overall with some nice rock melodies. Lowlights: A very average example of early 90s rock, sadly nowhere near as good as their peers. Top tunes: Mrs Robinson - shame it’s not originally theirs! Rating: 1.5

This album gave me a feeling of nostalgia despite never having listened to the album before. The only song I recognised was Mrs. Robinson. I enjoyed this album, although some of it was a wee bit samey. 3/5 - slightly above average, not much more to say!

I didn’t like it

I kind of liked it. It had a cool sound that I didn't expect on this list. But I don't remember anything particularly standing out. Not sure if it was because I was occupied whilst listening or if it was just in a more familiar genre that didn't have any great tracks

All I knew about these was that lead singer is called Evan Dando and they covered Simon & Garfunkel’s ‘Mrs Robinson’ (weirdly) Turns out they’re American which maybe explains that this totally misses being any good as an indie guitar-type album. A couple of okay tracks but basically dull. 0.8/5

Classic rock melodies made for easy listening. However, song lyrics are utterly uninspired - suffered greatly by comparison to Simon & Garfunkel with their cover of Mrs Robinson

Nah - not my favourite genre and this certainly isn’t the best of its kind. Just a bit meh for me. 1.5

Typ Green Day.

Fun no real stand outs. Had heard of their version of Mrs Robinson. Good band that might be worth a further listen

#49 / 1089 Heard before? ❌ Revisit? ❌ I've obviously heard some of the songs, but never the full album. It's quite clear why too, it's very soft pop rock from the folk side of the street, but now with added grunge. Basically, the most watered down a record company can have their fad and sell it too. I was a bit nonplussed with the name of the group, I keep mixing it up with local Finnish pop groups like Lemonator and few others and the reason is quite obvious; none of these bands ment anything to me, be it musically or culturally. But they still "sound the same in spirit", which basically means toothless and vanilla, which I tend to forget as soon as I hear it. Only few of the most replayed to death tracks stuck with me from early 90's. To me this is drivel, music made with "what would the majority like" frame of mind. Because of the folk vibes I'll drop it to fuck all 1/5

Never got into these guys, and I still understand today why that was. The music is just a bit dull and dry, not much character or energy to it and is a bit depressive on the ears. I know this crew had their fan base, but I wasn’t a part of it. This music is best left in the 90s.

Lemonheads- It’s A Shame About Ray (1992) I bought this on vinyl and it definitely didn’t have the Mrs Robinson cover on the end. I haven’t felt the urge to listen to this in 34 years , never replaced it on CD and never felt the urge to stream it. Always felt it was poppy but a bit average. Here’s ⭐️⭐️⭐️ to you Mr Dando.