Reviews (page 8 of 8)
This album cover really sets you up for a whole different experience than what it gives you lol
Great album apart from the crime that is her American Pie cover. And the awful cover.
Yes it was.
no false advertising here: it's definitely music by madonna
Didn’t know she was so dance music
Big singles small impression.
very well done. Not my type though
This was pretty good. Some familiar tracks, really liked the cover of American Pie.
Unmemorable, unremarkable. Undeserving of a place in this list.
This is shit, probably the most egregious of the list’s over compensating by adding recent albums in case they become classics
Not her best, but pretty good. 3 stars.
Mmmdonna, hittibiisit ollut aina ihan kuunneltavia ja muuten en niin välitä. En muista oliko tämä vai Ray of light kun tyyli muuttu meikäläisen makuun huonompaan suuntaan? Oli miten oli niin kultaisella 90-luvulla hänen nudet kiinnosti enemmän kuin musa, nykyään ei kumpikaan...
Pari hyvää biisiä, kuitenkin suurimmalta osin latistuu
I liked Madges early stuff, it was catchy and fun, but this Musoc album is a far cry from the likes of her True Blue album. Yes there's a couple of commercial radio known tracks on this album, but as a whole it lacks very much substance of tracks worth listening to... I just found it very boring, and just another album churned out to top up her coffers.
Not her best but I did love this when it was realised
One or two OK songs, but in general the album sounds a bit gimmicky
There is a fitting pop superstar arrogance to just naming a release "Music". Madonna signing about what music does to the "bourgeoisie" is the icing on the cake. Obviously with the sort of team behind something like this, there are catchy pop earworms aplenty. I think this list has leaned too heavily into this artist's later catalog; its all pretty forgettable.
Meh
"Music" is fine. The rest of the album didn't do much for me. As noted previously, anything post-Vogue just doesn't hit the sweet spot for me.
This is my least favorite Madonna album, but I do love Impressive Instant. The rest sounds dated & bland compared to her other work. It's honestly disappointing to see this one & not Confessions on a Dance Floor - that one has an ABBA sample for christ's sake! I will always love/hate Madonna, and she'll always be The Queen of Pop, but this album is a general dud.
Best lekker eens een keer zo’n album te luisteren
Aantal nummers vond ik aardig, maar de rest is allemaal vergane glorie. Ik heb overigens echt een hekel aan haar arrogantie, maar dat heb ik verder niet doorberekend in mijn oordeel.
Mjah, nooit echt een grote Madonna fan geweest.
Madonna die wanhopige probeert om relevant te blijven. De albums die ze voor deze maakte kan ik tot op zekere hoogte best waarderen, maar dit is gewoon treurig. En het wordt hierna alleen maar treuriger en treuriger. Vooral niet toe willen geven Madonna, dat je inmiddels een ouwe valse kraai bent! Lekker doorgaan, mallerd dat je d'r bent!
Ik had hier vroeger zo’n gekopieerd cd’tje van, maar hoe nu pas hoe erg het eigenlijk is.
Heard it before?: No Enjoy it?: Not really, this transition/phase of music for her isn’t something very appealing to me Favourite song: Track 1 - Music
Very good electronica that I hadn’t heard before.
Not my kind of music.
This is the second Madonna album I got here on the 1001 list, and even being so crucial for music history, they chose her worst albums to be on the list. Since I'm not a huge fan of her, it always looks like any standard pop song without much to say. It's not objectively bad, but besides the 1st song, it's a good album to be used as background music for those who like pop.
The early 2000s is the all time worst era for popular music, discuss? This album would support the case for the above proposition. 1998's dancy 'Ray of Light' was varied, interesting and decent overall. This takes the dance direction and strips out anything interesting or innovative and replaces it with generic, by-numbers turn-of-the-millenium dance-pop. Mid-paced, repetitive, overproduced, vocoder-heavy, and bland. It sounds incredibly dated and is the sort of thing you would have heard at a rubbish nightclub whilst drinking a blue WKD or Smirnoff Ice. Rating: 1.5/5 Playlist track: Don't Tell Me Date listened: 31/07/23
This was just fine, the title track was great, but not many others were particularly memorable. Production is a bit dated at this point.
A couple of songs I knew but were ok at best, I wouldn't run into a burning building to save it is all i'm saying. I'll just just shake my head while I see it in my newsfeed and think "Tragic".
There are a couple of OK songs on this. I'd forgotten how horrible that version of American Pie was.
This just wasn't great. Felt like the music (no pun intended) was all over the place and nothing was particularly catchy. On a separate note, garbage album art. 4/10.
I'm really unsure about this bc I fucking hated it: the music has aged as well as milk from the year 2000 and the high level of autotune hurts my ears. I don't understand why she would tarnish her career with smth so bad. The cover makes me sick and the ending cover of American Pie is enough to drive anyone to insanity.
2.5
Good but also has some weak moments. What It Feels Like For A Girl is my favourite.
1 2 3 hmmmmm "Paradise (Not for Me) is kinda nice. The whole thing is dated though. Not the future like some reviews say. And calling an album "Music" is the same as calling it "Untitled" and thats just the laziest and most boring thing you can do. "Gone" is great too Don't know how you fuck up "American Pie" though 2
This album incorporates disco, trance, electro-pop, and country/folk elements. Though the use of these elements is not new, the fact that they’re all present in a pop album by a blockbuster artist is really fascinating. The album does sound really dated due to the effects it uses and its production style, but I did really enjoy it as it gave me a new perspective of an artist who is known for her earlier groundbreaking pop work. Madonna is clearly interested in musical growth and even if it doesn’t always land, I appreciate her trying to expand her horizons.
I didn't like this. But, it was risky and bold, so I respect it. I think primarily I just can't stand the way Madonna sings.
Pretty good, but honestly nothing really brings me back to it.
God no. Madonna is just awful.
Better than expected but still felt a little forgettable
I vaguely recall when this album came out, and it was being heralded as a marked turn in Madonna's career. Listening some 22 years later, it doesn't really have much sense of being groundbreaking, indeed some of the content seems quite dated (see 'Feels Like For A Girl'). Still, there are a few decent tracks, including the titular 'Music' which I recall featured none other than Ali G in the accompanying video
Very dance oriented, almost EDM-ey but not much base
Just not a dance music kind of person I guess
1.5./5. Bad, I thought Madonna was supposed to be good.
This was fine and I liked it but Madonna is the pop dance goddess and this wasn’t her.
Painful
This is not in the latest issues of the book anymore. Probably because it's not different enough from Ray of Light. It's not the worst album on the list by far, so that can't be the reason. It's alright. Not a record I would pick myself. Favorite song: What it feels like for a girl
Some lame lyrics and sparks of cool production. Overrated.
Good follow up to Ray of Light with some harder house and some indie songs. Awful version of American Pie with unnecessary nursery music.
I was planning not to like this which probably isn’t the right way to approach the 1001 offerings. Let’s say it was better than my low expectations and I found myself grooving a bit at the beginning. Still, there was nothing original here. I was excited for the cover of American Pie but it was underwhelming.
Back in the day my co-judge and I danced to the title track at Club Med, where it was on high rotation. Madonna made a smart move two years earlier, by teaming up with William Orbit for a fresh club sound and here she adds another producer to the mix with good results, though outside of "Music" the up-tempo tracks aren't as strong. Not often you'll find a multi platinum pop album with such adventurous (for its time) production. As far as transformations go, Madonna's not in the same school as David Bowie or Miles Davis but she's up there. In this version I find the Cowboy image is a bit confusing, considering the overall sound.
I wanted to like this but I found it formulaic and quite boring actually. A two is being generous
Funny how Mirwais made 2 albums this year and this was the worse one.
horrid lyrics on some tracks
Starts off well, but boy does it fall away after that.
I didn’t mind this. A couple of good tracks and a reasonable listen. I’m not familiar with all her albums but I quite liked this point in her career. 3*
Bits of this album veered dangerously close to a 1. But in the end I'm going to show some mercy and go for a 2. Don't push me to listen to it again though.
I danced to this when I was three and four years old. I love Madonna.
Half decent album by the ultimate singles Queen. Won't be adding to the rotation though
Some enjoyable moments and crystal clear production certainly keeps Madonna relevant but Music struggles to match up to the title track and is, overall, a little stodgy.
Heb nog nooit goed naar Madonna geluisterd maar ik vond het wel interessant. Er zitten een aantal spacende nummers tussen. Ik vond het niet bijzonder goed maar wel verrassend
Good album
Just what I always wanted, an electro-country album from THE material girl trying to act like she rejects materialism. Despite the production team's best efforts at making a solid and interesting accompaniment to the music, Madonna manages to completely stink up the joint. This has all the worst aspects of that bland, saccharine techno that in many ways seemed to define Y2K. It's a shame, because Madonna does have good songs, but none of them are on here. I disappointed parent out of 5 😞
definitely of its time
It's certainly music. It's not great and sounds super dated. Also what a shit cover of American Pie. 1.5/5
A real mixed bag with high highs and low lows. Has aged suprisingly well for the most part, considering that its 25 years old at the time of these lines. In all the lows (nobody's perfect) drag the thing too much down for 4 stars that the highs (Don't tell me; What it feels like for a girl) would deserve.
61 of 1001 Madonna - Music Favorite Track : Music Rating : 3 / 5 (Rounded Up) It wasn't as bad as I expected. A bit toned down for Madonna. Some songs seemed more suited for a 20 year old, but who am I to judge?
3/.55 A few great songs.
Just alright, feel like this is Madonna trying to recapture old magic, just doesn’t hit
Year 2000 pop, nice to listen to but nothing mind blowing
DIgamos que se trata de musica lisa, ademas de que las letras no son nada del otro mundo, tampoco creo que haya un hit ademas de music, pero bueno que se peude esperar de la era del estancamiento del pop. Madonna se queda fuera de ideas en un album en el que hasta sus instrumentales son aburridas 3/10.
I often gripe about production. This has 5* production...total credit to that dude. Tbh its a very listenable album. Some of the lyrics are a bit hokey and there are track (nobody's perfect) with a auto tune thing that i skipped. And American Pie was an execrable cover. Almost a 4.
Really tried to like this. Just feels like way too many sounds and effects thrown together.
Sounds like it was made by a 12 year old in garage band
Some brilliant dance production on this. It's not quite ray of light for me, but it's a very good album
It's a bit zero 7/Moby in places...that turn-of-the-century ambient Ibiza chill-out vibe. It's not an album that I would choose to listen to again.
It's hard not to see the influence this album held on the next 7 years of pop music. It feels like a quintessential pop album of the 2000s because it's the first of that kind.
Madonna es trobava en un moment dolç, després de la seva recuperació artística i comercial amb 'Ray of Light'. Aquí va continuar amb la seva pròpia reinvenció com a icona rellevant en el nou mil.leni. Ho feia, de nou, juntant-se amb alguns dels grans noms del moment. Una tàctica intel.ligent que encara li serviria durant un bon grapat d'anys. El resultat és un treball interessant, inspirat, basat en les cançons, cada una d'elles tractada com una obra en si mateixa. Temes com 'Nobody's Perfect', 'Amazing' o el propi 'Music' es troben entre el millor de la seva discografia; tot ell un treball molt consistent
Top notch turn of the century production, but the songwriting, particularly the lyricism and melodies were weak for a release for an artist this big.
Madonna trying to be modern but what's lost here are any good songs. Best song is a cover of a song that's 30 years old
I always check the tracklist before listening to an album and omit the bonus tracks or international release tracks from my listen, which is how I avoided the human rights violation that is the Madonna cover of American Pie, which I'm about 60% sure is one of the direct causes of 9/11. Best track: Paradise (Not for Me)
Nice
I much prefer earlier Madonna, and American Pie is a crime. I do remember though how big this was when it came out and she was a rule breaker and pop visionary in her own way.
I liked vibing to this one. The music was sorta pop/electronic, but also soft enough that I could listen while working without getting distracted.
Meh. Bland, over produced, shiny and expensive. Not her best work. Also includes her cover of American Pie, which is so bad it is virtually a hate crime.
Typically like Madonna and this is right in the middle of her re-invention when I think she's perhaps a little too comfortable - she's at her best when working with up and coming producers and bringing outside influences to the mainstream, which I guess is being tried here mixing electronica with country. However as a listen it's not anywhere near her best "I deserve it" stand out tune. 3
Listened to front half, I'm guessing the back half isn't too different. Meh in every sense of the word. Exc3pt "Nobody's Perfect". That's straight ass. 2.5/5
Not one of her best, or one of THE best
Kind of weird use of electric sounds on some songs- but I generally liked it.
I mean yeah it was music
Pretty ostentatious to name your album "music", as if to encompass all music. Also, how does one talk about this album? "Have you heard music?" "yes, of course" "no, I mean Madonna's music" "like a virgin? yes" "no, I mean her album music" "yes she puts her music on albums" "no" All jokes aside this is pretty bog standard pop music. This is probably the worst of the 3 albums by her I've come across on this list (so far?), but it's inoffensive. Except for her cover of American Pie. That shit was a war crime.
Ah it's fairly shite tbh. Music is a banger, what it feels like... is okay, there is a.l.o.t. of filler, and that American Pie cover is an abomination.
This was a nice revisit of a CD I had bought when new, but went with the other CDs into a box some time ago. It's been a while. This one really shows how Madonna has been able to successfully reinvent herself so many times. It was a sound that felt very modern at the time and which I think has held up since then. "This is the one with acoustic guitars and robot voices," is probably how I would distinguish it. I loved it, it made me move and groove today.
I had never listened to this album until today. I haven't listened to many of Madonna's albums. I guess that I am not a huge fan. I enjoyed it.
One of Madonna's most mature albums. Very entertaining, very catchy. I love it.
I liked this album back in the day, but it hadn’t stayed with me like Like A Prayer or Ray of Light. I’m glad to have revisited it, because I enjoyed the cool electronic vibe. Driving around Seattle listening to this today felt a little like I was in some kind of Tron universe. 23 years after its release this still feels like the future.
This album really surprised me. Much better than I remembered based off the radio singles.
I liked Gone, Music (mostly for nostalgic reasons) but the rest was very mid. Also the American Pie cover is sacrilege.
Thought I’d hate this but it wasn’t bad. Obviously the American Pie cover is terrible. But I don’t really like the original that much anyway.
Too electronic. Sounds rubbish. Madonna Extremely overrated this is dogshit
Her version of American Pie is one of the worst things I have ever heard. The rest of the album is hohum but fine and if it had stopped before that track it would have been unremarkable.
Madonna tried trip hop. At certain points the glitchiness feels overwrought, and at certain points they don't feel like Madonna songs, but more songs featuring Madonna. Somewhere. There are a few genuinely good tracks, but I don't think this record needs to be here. Favorite tracks: "What It Feels Like For a Girl", "Runaway Lover", "I Deserve It"
Highlights: "Music," "Don't Tell Me" It's ridiculous to justify how awkward this album is and how terribly it's aged by saying any of this was 'experimental' even by the most mainstream US pop standards. Cher's "Believe" had tested the waters for autotune two years before, and NSYNC was having a blast earlier that year running the gamut of gaudy special effects from ring modulation to step filtering to sequencers and ARP. Madonna has always been derivative, and by this time she's just in over her head, too. Do we care about lyrics? Ideas? Because she pretends to. Laughably absurd lyrical bookends to the album: singing about the bourgeoisie and how "selling out is not my thing" when she is literally Madonna. Can't you just do what every honest sellout does and send audiences glum and bitter putzing dispatches on your barbarism of reflection from the barren apex? Whatever. No good songs, but only four I skipped halfway through out of disgust.
2 star album, 0 star cover
It's ok she's trend following on this one.
No standouts. The dance songs lack energy, the slow songs are bit dull. There are much better Madonna records.
Some of the singles hold up. It just felt a little soulless.
While I'm not really a Modonna fan, I can find stuff in her early work that I can enjoy and appreciate. This one could've been made by so many different people in the late 90s/early 2000s, it was just uninspired.
The 2000 U2 album All That You Can’t Leave Behind feels like it is desperately trying to re-capture former pop-star glory with mixed results. This 2000 disc by Madonna succeeds at that same task (apart from the clunker of an American Pie cover) without the desperation. It also innovates by combining techno and country in a way that hadn’t been done before (and not super-well since).
A good pop album. There's definitely some filler though. But I like that a lot of songs have the eccentric feel of experimental electronica (especially the early tracks). The production gets a little adventurous.
In 2000 I was 10 and really starting to get into music on my own. I remember being younger than this age and liking rock music on the radio, like Nirvana and classic rock, but around this time is when I started to be more aware of music. Her song "Music" I remember hearing and being a real guilty pleasure. Of course to my friends I couldn't like her because she was "pop" and young boys don't listen to pop music they listen to rock music because you don't develop that part of your brain that allows you to not care about silly social conventions like that until you are older (atleast for me until I was in my late teens / early 20's). I think there is really something special for me personally about the general time period of 1998-summer 2001, the music that came out in that time period was so vibrant and I really vividly remember moments of life happening while listening to music from then. I think specifically of these records: Linkin Park - Hybrid Theory Korn - Follow The Leader Kid Rock - Devil Without A Cause Lauryn Hill - The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill Red Hot Chili Peppers - Californication Outkast - Stankonia Eminem - Marshall Mathers / Slim Shady Those were really pivotal for me and it was a time period where I was able to more autonomously look for and listen to music on my own. I was 8 to 10 years old! I could listen to what I what when I want. And I did! I remember listening to so much music during those 2.5 years and just doing my thing and loving life- playing sports and hanging out with friends, becoming obsessed with baseball and videogames, and not really having a care in the world. That specific time kind of ended after 9/11 and I think that was the start of puberty / teenager issues / listening to music with more serious sounds and lyrical topics. I do theorize that 9/11 played some part in that transition because up until that point I didn't really have a concept for experiencing the sometimes really terrible parts of the world. I wasn't expecting the start of this review to end up about 9/11 but that's the fun of hearing records that take you to a place in your life. I wouldn't say that this album was as special as those others listed but "Music" was a single from that era. Outside of this track the album isn't that bad. I think it's short of a 4 but higher than a 3, like a 3.3 for me.
'Music' was an ok single, but there's nothing much else going for this. 'Nobody's Perfect' is very poor indeed.
Listened a while ago don't remember it
So, Madonna got together with William orbit and a few other late 90s producers and made an album where she's a cowgirl singing over house beats. OK. I mean, there's part of this I like in theory, but I just don't think Madonna can pretend to be the source of electronic underground, especially in a Stetson.
This album was everything when it came out. Listening to reminds me of good times, I’m just singing my lil heart out. Don’t tell me is soo good. I still love it and I think It’s fucking great!
I love this album. Sooo…yep.
Most of the songs on this album don’t pay off the way my brain wants them to. I like Madonna’s earliest albums, but this one was very meh for me. Maybe too electronica for my tastes.
way more musically unique than I thought it owuld be. cool time signature stuff
Weirdest country album I’ve ever heard. Haha just kidding Production was really good. Very late 90s french electronica. Madonna was the weakest part of the album; is she good or just super hot? Will have to listen to more of her lesser known work.
I’ve always been a little confused how Madonna became the icon that she is today. This album did not clear up any confusion, but I’m looking forward to hearing her earlier work
This album goes hard, definitely not what I was expecting. A little bit all over the place, but still enjoyed the listen
Cat: Some of the tracks musically are a lot of fun and maybe were trendy or groundbreaking at the time. The lyrics are mostly terrible. Madonna has a beautiful, distinct voice. AJ: Totally agree. The two singles were the two best songs. Couple random acoustic guitar songs thrown in with more random electronic noises. She sounds great, but the writing is elementary at best. 🤣
ugh, fucking really? I know Madonna has never exactly been thinking man's music, but at least her earlier stuff had fun 80s charm. This just sucks. I remember the first song, and the rest is just as awful. Basic late 90s turd beats (adding vague rock overtones at times) and dumb lyrics about the dancefloor. Fuck off, madge. 1/5.
Se cae en la segunda mitad.
6/10 more interesting than i expected, cool beats.
3/10. Wow, I really didn't care for this, but I can certainly see how it influenced 2000s music.
I'm not a big fan of cowgirl-electronica-Don McLean Madonna. 4/10
with the resources at her disposal she had to score a couple of cool tracks, but it just strikes me like gangsta rap: the expression of goals and desires that are fundamentally shallow and corrosive
I hate this. Shitty club backbeats ruin most songs for me.
Oh god, forgot about the early 2000s music, probably for good reason. The mixing is just interesting lol. Some definitely Daft Punk vibes which I'm okay with. But some of the fake instruments and voice effects are just grating. Lots of experimental more electronic stuff in the beginning, but the middle of the album slows down for more approachable, catchy, dance music. Lyrics vary, some are generic love songs. While some actually pose interesting philosophical questions. I get a lot of video games sounds from some of these songs. Some enjoyable parts, but overall 2/5 Favorite songs: Impressive Instant, I Deserve It, Amazing Least favorite songs: Music, Nobody's Perfect,
It's no Ray of Light, is it? That American Pie cover is so painful it makes the original sound great