Reviews (page 7 of 8)
Blandly fine? Finely bland? The American Pie cover is a shocker.
Besides a few standout tracks, this was an entirely forgettable experience, and I was expecting so much more from this.
Overrated
3.8 - actually liked this a lot more than beyond light.
The singles are unreal from this album - Music and Dont Tell Me especially are both still bangers in their different ways. I definitely don't like or love all tracks on the album, bit of a mix bag but interesting all the same - prefer the slower ones like I Deserve It and What It Feels Like For A Girl rather than dance tracks.
Nobody's Perfect is one of the worst tracks I've heard on the 1001 so far. Why is Madonna's outfit and all the branding for this album giving off Americana country vibes, and yet the album is autotune electro-pop. The second half has a few highlights, but still this really is one of the most baffling inclusions in the list for me. Fave Tracks: Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like For A Girl 1.9/5
Some catchy songs but ultimately a pretty unsophisticated venture into electronic pop.
I had Ray of Light recently and think all my comments apply about this one. If you took her name off of it, no one would care about this. Unreal how well this awful music sold. Rating: 1.8
Pretty good
Over production and uninteresting attempts at hooks make this blah to me. But I still liked a few moments.
First miss from a Madonna album on the list for me, and it’s a *big* miss. The other ones I heard from her were kind of taking the musical waters of their era and doing them really big and really well, but unfortunately this particular era was real real bad waters
No way near as good as her other album from the era that is on this list. Bit too bland.
The musical equivalent of the Steve Buscemi 'how do you do, fellow kids' meme.
Il y a des concepts intéressants et des risques pris sur cet album. Les 2e et 3e pièces ont des beats electro bien faits. Le reste de l'album par contre essaye de faire beaucoup trop de choses en même temps et plus souvent qu'autrement, ça se plante en pleine face. Les autotunes sont souvent abusés, les mélanges country et electro sont douteux. La reprise d'American Pie est inexcusable. J'admire le risque de cet album et je suis sûr que ça a influencé du monde, mais cet album a en même temps rien inventé et a très mal vieilli. 4/10
This whole album reeks of desperation. It feels like a frantic - and ultimately futile - attempt to remain relevant. Lame production, shallow songwriting, and tired performances left me feeling kinda sad for Madonna, honestly. Like the star high school quarterback trying to relive his glory days, Madonna just... wasn't relevant to the music scene by 2000 and she's doubly irrelevant these days.
Not too shabby.
Man did I really not enjoy this. Never been a big fan of Madonna but christ I found this one to be pretty uninteresting, over produced and bland. Fav songs: - Music
I like Madonna but this album wasn't very good.
is it 1001 albums you must hear before you die, or 1001 albums that make you want to die?
Not for me
Whoa. I had no idea. The production has me floored
Such a mixed bag. Some of these feel like Madonna is ahead of the curve (“What It Feels Like for a Girl”, "Gone") and some of these feel like she’s chasing trends instead of setting them (“I Deserve It”, "Paradise [Not For Me]"). Some good songs offset by some god-awful autotune. The less said about the "American Pie" cover, the better. Talk about missing the point of a song.
2.75
Hmm. Not my music
I like Madonna just fine, but this is a big letdown after the more atmospheric Ray of Light. She's still going for that mature approach but this time the songs are really disjointed from one another. Sometimes she's doing that vague acoutstic/country thing that doesn't really work, and at other times she goes back to the electronic sounds of hger previous album. What It Feels Like for a Girl is really great though.
The title song was alright, but the rest was just bad studio decisions over bad studio decisions.
Electropop with a "house" that does not age very well. Do people still listen to this album today?
2 star. Boring and mid
2 for two recognizable songs when I was younger.
We hit peak Madonna with Ray of Light.
Out of all her albums this one made the list? "I like to singy singy singy like a bird on a wingy wingy wingy"
Not her best. Ok
This album was a pretty good pop album. A few of the songs were superhits from back in the day. All around it seemed to be pretty experimental with it's glitchy sounds and futuristic uses of electronics. It didn't succeed all the time, but was pretty good nonetheless. 3.3/5 -> 3/5.
Pop at its best
She really thought she did something here. She had the gall to call this album music then release the most lukewarm pop album ever with cringe 2000s effects.
Really not for me. Too poppy and feels dated now
This is the album Madonna reinvented her image as a cowgirl... and then theres people who still give it low star..
Not the best pick of Madonna albums. Why this is on the list and the earlier work not (f.e. Like a Virgin), beats me.
THIS IS FUCKIN COOL
It has been a long while since I first heard Like a Prayer. I honestly forget Madonna exists sometime. But if you go back and look at that review, I didn’t not enjoy that album one bit. Safe to say those feelings were not a one time thing. I just don’t get it. And I could say that for a lot of albums I’ve heard over the last 191 days. But Madonna just doesn’t make sense to me. I’m going to say the same thing I said back then, because it still stands the test of time. Her music ellicits zero emotional response within me. Absolutely nothing. I feel lifeless when I listen to her music. What is the purpose of listening to music if that’s all I am able to take away from it? This is some of the most boring, bland, derivative and lackluster 2000’s pop music I’ve ever heard. What is she doing here than everybody else before her, and better at that? Even if this was considered “ahead of its time”, it would not be deserving of that title by any means. The autotune over her vocals on Nobody’s Perfect is enough to just throw the whole album out. Or the way the guitar is spliced up on Don’t Tell Me? Genuinely pissed me off a little bit. Such strange choices with the production and instruments that lack substance and stand as nothing but overly glossy and gimmicky pop trash. Keep Madonna far away from me. Rating: 3/10
Madonna is normally iconic because she was ahead of the times. This album screams of being behind the times. The main single is addictive in nature even if somewhat annoying. A big miss from the normally reliable Madonna.
Pretty glad when that one ended. It sounded to me like she was fulling a contractual obligation.
I played this during my morning commute and now I am SO HYPED for writing INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL for SOFTWARE
Pretty cool!!
Hits are good but this is such a mediocre Madonna album, don’t know why it’s on the list as there are many more iconic albums.
I really hated this.
I generally like Madonna, and have a soft spot for her earlier stuff. This didn't do much for me.
Music is an iconic song. The rest of this album kind of sucks.
La reina del pop. Un 4.
You can literally just hear however many millions they spent on this. The production is incredible, and it hides some of the cracks on the weaker tracks. "Music" is just so perfectly arranged, "Don't Tell Me" is, I think, my favorite Madonna song, and the cover of "American Pie" is just hilariously weird and doing its own thing, such a brilliant little oddity.
la reprise qui cloture l’album c’est pour m’achever
Her previous album Ray of Light was fine but this one just wasn't. I made it through the whole thing so there's that.
Alright pop
Madonna blends country and pop well on some of the tracks. Others are standard Madonna pop.
After three opening cuts – which are silly and synthetic, completely disposable club music – there is much to like here. Her voice is/was still in good shape at this point but one woulda like more room for the beats/beds to live and breathe. Perhaps the production was a big deal. The stop-start effect on "Don't Tell Me" is silly. This song also sounds like she's channeling Sublime -- how the mighty have fallen. And poor Joe Henry; his version of this cut -- his own -- is about 1,000 times cooler, though hopefully the royalties from his sister-in-law have cheered him up. The more organic the songs – that is the least plastic and clubby – the better (see "I Deserve It, ' "Gone"). One assumes "Nobody's Perfect" was a relatively early adoption of Autotune (again, who cares?) which doesn't sound any better today and the weird effects (a theremin with sinus congestion?). Best moment of the whole record is the vibe/bed toward the beginning of "What It Feels" but rest of song doesn't remotely do it justice (so maybe h/t to producer on that one). Overall, it's hard to resist the conclusion that this is a trend-chasing exercise by a celebrity desperate to stay relevant. But at least's polished, well-made and often pleasurable.
Her final epic album
I went into this only knowing the song "Music" - I really enjoyed this album apart from the last song which is a truly unnecessary cover of "American Pie". The rest of the songs are experimental electronic pop gems that range from club bangers like "Impressive Instant" and "Runaway Lover" to slow jams like "Paradise (Not For Me)" and country samplers like "Don't Tell Me", "Amazing" mixes house beats with surfed out guitar.
GTA 3 Head Radio/Lips 103 ass album - just not as good
I enjoyed this album - to songs, the mood the production. Didn't really listen to it at the time, but appreciate it now.
Why
Overall it's a really good album.
This album immiedieteely hooked me with it's techno/trance-esque production and fun, anthem-like lyrics. Runaway Lover especially was just a blast. Starting with I Deserve It, the album took an odd turn into this country inspired pop territory. I wasn't a fan, save for the percussion being wicked tight and reminded me of trap beats. After a short dip into generic pop land, we're back into this odd, spacey auto tune slow jam with Nobody's Perfect. This album is at it's best when it's less Sheryl Crow and more Bjork. Also, probably the best version of American Pie I can think of.
A more mellow Madonna.
Begon niet heel sterk, daarna echt een paar leuke nummers maar bij american pie gingen m'n nekharen recht overeind staan. Ik denk dat Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens en J.P. Richardson zich omdraaien in hun graf
Ik was hiervan aan t genieten. Vond het veel nicer dan ik dacht dat ik het zou vinden, het klonk goed, heel nice geproduceerd etc. Toen kwam american pie
don't think I'll revisit but really not as bad as I expected after really hating "Ray of Light"
Excelent album. Cant believe i never listened more of it
It's not her best, and in some ways a bit indulgent. Her French is worse than mine. We didn't need to spend three minutes on Paradise (which should be paradis).
The first few tracks and interesting with a curious electronic vibe, but I like the later tracks that a little bit more mellow and moody. It definitely feels like a mature pop record, though there is nothing catchy enough to warrant repeat listens.
Not for me. Wasn’t a fan of, really, any of the choices made on this album. I don’t think they’re really working. Wasn’t difficult to get through, although I won’t be giving it another spin again if I can help it. 2/5
The Queen of Pop shows she’s quite comfortable on the throne, even if her status was starting to slip by the turn of the millennium. The lyrics are a bit clunky, but the beats remain danceable and her confidence shines through. (Side note: Don’t Tell Me was cowritten by Madonna’s brother-in-law Joe Henry, who has a highly underrated music career of his own—including his own take on Don’t Tell Me on his 2001 album Scar, though there it’s called Stop. Extremely recommended!)
Mmm
Not bad. I can appreciate that she evolved her sound but I guess I like her earlier albums better.
I’m a little surprised that this Madonna album is on the list. There are 4 or 5 true classics from her and this one doesn’t measure up to them. That being said, this is still a very good album, and possibly great if you take off the more embarrassing moments, like the “Beautiful Stranger” retread of “Amazing”, and the career low point of “Nobody’s Perfect”, which became the template for her next album, the still awful “American Life”. This is also the point where she became obsessed with autotune bullshit, which completely ruins vocals 9 times out of 10 to my ears. It doesn’t sound futuristic anymore. It’s a lazy studio trick (that many use to mask the fact that they can’t actually sing, except Madonna has proven that she really can sing so it’s pointless) showcasing a lack of ideas and pointing out that she is no longer driving ahead of the curve, but following others. I’m a super Madonna fan from everything she put out between her 1983 self titled debut album and 1994’s “Bedtime Stories”. Pure magical brilliance. I can more than tolerate 1998’s “Ray of Light”, and this record. Beyond this, it becomes a wasteland of overestimating relevance with a few moments of being good but never truly great again.
This is around the time I stopped listening to Madonna as much because her early aughts evolution was a bit jarring to me at the time (though I LOVED Ray of Light). I know the hits from this album, but I really enjoyed it as a full listen. Amazing is a great song I wasn’t familiar with. She really layers a lot of funky and interesting beats and sound effects throughout these songs. It’s a bit more forgettable than her 80s catalog, but still a good Madonna time. Queen’s gonna queen.
Most of my opinions of Madonna stem from my early exposure to her role in "A League of Their Own" This album, while not my favorite, earns a solid three
Not my cup of tea. Kind of the worst of 2000 with no memorable melodies, lacking any infectious hooks, grating drum machines, and a feeling of smugness that is not deserved. Compare Madonna for instance with St Vincent who can actually write and perform emotive music.
Baby making music. But where are the hits, Madge?
somes songs sounded really awkward but others weren't half bad. truly the second half is better than the first. Felt like a fake dance album.
Didn't really care for it
2.5
The production is top notch here. Slicker than snot on ice. But "experimental"? Really? Does this get credit for blazing trails just because it was Madonna and it wasn't cool to do anything but fawn all over her at the time? Honestly, the producer is the star here, not Madonna. Any middling performer could have released this album and it would have been just as good, but not nearly as highly praised. Boring. Repetitive. Hard to tolerate after the first few tracks. I'll give it a two because a one would be disrespectful of an artist that deserves more than that just for finding a way to stay relevant for as long as she did ... or maybe has.
She's the queen of pop. A lot of this electropop is well ahead of it's time.
Not for me, but it's clearly well produced and designed to get you moving. 3 The wikipedia article for this album is *sprawling*. This lady has some fans.
im not sick of it, but i forgot what an early adopter of autotune she is.
Really
Loved it
Expected Madonna on this list as she is renowned, but not this album. Way too much bad autotune and the worst American pie cover ever.
Я думаю это был просто разрыв в 2000, некоторые песни просто крышесносные Но общий вайб альбома на 4, чувствуется, что экспериментальненько
эй мистер диджей.. бля, это так старо оказывается... кавер на american pie такой себе, но отчасти понимаю в рамках контекста альбома алкоальбом: маргарита в клубе ночном (3+)
хз мне лайк э прэйер в разы лучше вкатил, тут эти звуковые эффекты даж лишними кажутся
Second half of the album improves a lot. Was not expecting this from Madonna
This is like so boring.
No, it’s not.
More mediocrity from the Queen of it.
I know it sounds a bit bad but I'd like to know how much of this she really had a hand in? Maybe the lyrics? Yeah I can see that, but I don't think she produced it REALLY did she? I genuinely like Ray of Light and can hear Orbit in this as well. Whilst I applaud her intentions to push boundaries and put herself on the line this is at the end of the day just dancey Pop.
I certainly haven't listened to everything Madonna, but I think this might be my favorite now. The pop plus some folk/country at points. This kind a felt fresh in some ways, and certainly did back then as I loved Music and Don't Tell Me. Listening to this album for the first time, there were many other tracks I liked too like Nobody's Perfect, What It Feels Like For a Girl, and Gone.
Had a few good laughs listening to this. It's late-era Madonna, the older pop star trying to keep up with the youngin's. In the era of Britney Spears and whoever else, Madonna puts out this. The production ranges from really cool and interesting to just silly, and that's sort of the album as a whole. I skipped a few songs on here, which is never a good sign, but I also found myself enjoying even more. And "Don't Tell Me" is one I've certainly heard before. I can't really give this more than three stars in good faith because it's goofy and has skips, but I'm not as mad at the inclusion that I worried I would be. Thankfully it's not the only Madonna on the list. Favorite tracks: Music (funny), I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me, Paradise (Not For Me), Gone. Album art: The cherry on top, and what had me worried most of all. The album is called "Music," which is dumb enough on its own, but it's a picture of rancher Madonna? This isn't even a country album, I can only remember one song that arguably veers into country-ish instrumentals, why's she doing all this? I hope she was having a laugh here because I certainly am. 3/5
First time listening to Madonna, I can understand why she is such an icon. Not my taste especially because of her voice, it's not that phenomenal. "Don't tell me "is such an annoying song.
Exceptional!
I would never have sought this out but I super dug it! It’s a terrific compilation of pop and electronic. Madonna keeping it fun and relevant through a strong career arc.
Much better than I expected it to be, but not amazing either. I definitely underestimated Madonna. 7/10 Top 3: 1. Paradise (Not for Me) 2. Gone 3. Impressive Instant
Fashion show runway music, highly produced, voice autotuned like a robot, but classic.
Ordinary Madonna Pop. Nice, but with sone exceptions boring
This album is absolute garbage. A complete waste of my time to listen too. Demoralizingly terrible music quality, atrociously uninspiring lyrics, disgusting use of digital music editing technology. How on earth did this album qualify in the top 1000? Absurd.
Definitely gave me high school vibes
I've always liked Madonna. Soft spot for this one. Newly wed, we had the cassete in the car an the cd at home. Love the rhythm (and sound) of the bass in Amazing. Not on this album, the single Beautiful Stranger came out similar time - great pop track.
The title track is one of those pop songs that I don't actually mind listening to if it comes on the radio or whatever - even if it does sound a bit like S Club 7. "Parp Parp! ...Parp!" Great! I don't need a whole album of it though. That's not to say it's all exactly the same. It's quite a tuneful album. But it's got that weird, slightly-dated, half-electronic 2000s sound. And by the time it got to the awful cover of "American Pie" I was literally counting down the seconds for it to end. I'm giving this two stars because it has one song on it that I sort-of don't mind.
'Music' tanta roba. In generale non mi dispiace lo stile disco-pop di questo album, anzi! Svolta un po' country, comunque piacevole su 'i deserved'. Con anche 'American Pie' diventa un ottimo ascolto.
Ehhh discazo realmente, es la primera vez que escucho a Madonna más a fondo.
Skipped thru some songs. Didn't like this album at all.
What is this album doing in this list?! "Madonna" and "Like A Virgin" are 5 star. "True Blue" is 4.5 and "Like a Prayer" is 4 star. "Frozen" is 4 star, just like "Confessions on a Dance Floor". All other Madonna albums are 3 star at most. Out of these remaining albums, Music is one of the best. It is perhaps a bit more consistent than Frozen, but Frozen contains four absolute 5-star singles, and Music contains none: a couple 4 star, a couple 2 star, rest is 3 star. my vote in 2000: 6/10 my vote in 2024: 6/10
This one left me stone cold.
Not a bad album, but why pick this one for the 1001 list?
Does not start to my taste, very 2000 style which i am not a huge fan of especially in pop 2/5
The first listen made it hard to listen to again but I perservered and it's not a complete trainwreck. This quote from the wikipedia article also makes me curious "...she intended to embark on a tour. However, her record company encouraged her to return to the studio and record new music before going on the road." Anyway I like Music for the boogie-woogie.
Oof - first play through I was leaning towards a 2, but maybe I was just in a mood that day - the second play through it isn't striking me as being quite as objectionable. It definitely feels like Madonna is trying to play catch up with Björk or something, right? A couple of the tracks feel like sub standard Daft Punk or Air knock offs. Fave tracks - "Gone" maybe? "Don't Tell Me" is the least objectionable of the singles...
There’s a bop or two on here, but it’s inconsistent in theme
One or two notable songs (as in, I recall them being a big deal on the radio, not that I actually enjoyed them) but overall nothing special with this album.
Boooooooo
Really nice pop album. Showcases Madonna's evolution into modern pop while still having her signature melodic voice and upset songs.
Madge had a bit of a damp squib with this one. A couple of good tracts but most of it feels like it has no soul and the less said about her cover of American Pie the better. She’s made far far better albums than this one.
This was just not a good album. It was derivative before she released it.
"Music" is the eighth studio album by American singer Madonna. In reponse to the pop chart dominance of acts such as Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera, Madonna collaborated with Mirwais Ahmadzi and William Orbit to go in a more experimental direction. The album incorporates elements of house, funk, country and folk into the overall dance-pop and electronica styles. It worked as the album hit #1 in 15 countries including the US and UK. There are overall themes of partying and love differing from her previous album "Ray of Light" which was more introspective. Critically, the album had mostly positive reviews. The self-titled song "Music" opens up with a vocoder. It then kicks in with a funky beat and synth. The beat continues with strange synth sounds. She just wants to dance with her baby. "impressive Instant" takes the dance music to the club level. A deeper bass and beat. Synth space sounds. More use of the vocoder...almost stepping into Daft Punk territory. A love at first sight song. Slow synth keys begin "Amazing." The music kicks in. A echoing, reverbing guitar and prominent bass. Electronic beats. Great, haunting guitar breaks reminding me of David Bowie. My favorite song on the album. An acoustic guitar starts and stops and starts begins "Don't Tell Me." Country meets electronica here. An electric drum backbeat. Strings are added. She urges her lover to stop controlling her. Why not venture into the ambient and that is what she does in "What It Feels Like to be a Girl." An ambient synth melody and underlying electronic beats. The ambience builds. She condemns male chauvinism and urges men to imagine themselves as a girl. This is a very, very good album. Not one song really fits into any one category. There's funk mixed with club dance, both rock and country with electronica and even the ballads have dance/electronica elements. A very high production level as one would expect. I didn't hear one song not worth a listen. A strong recommendation.
Went a bit OTT on the autotune!
The first half of the album is overproduced. I get the feeling the music producer thought he was smarter than the industry, ahead of the game. Lots of strange sound effects and laser beam noises, lots of electronic vocal changes. None of it seems to mesh well, or make a cohesive song. This album feels like it’s trying to do electronica but it’s been done by many others, far better. Madonna, you are above being autotuned. The second half of the album suffers from being melodramatic and boring. I really like the track “Don’t tell me”, but I found the rest pretty forgettable.
not bad
It would be actually good without the auto tunes
meh
4.0 - I always felt this record dwelled in “Ray of Light”‘s shadow, the more “serious” of the two projects. I’ve changed my mind. “ROL” finds Madonna clinging desperately to relevance with her late-to-the-party rave anthems mixed with yoga-inflected wisdom, offering incantations to a “zephyr in the sky.” Yawn. This record, on the other hand, shows a quirkier Madonna stripped of these pretensions, ready to hang. Sonically, “Music” has aged far better. I like the glitchy, hyperpoppy elements that remind me of “100 gecs.” As is often the case with Madonna, you still get some schlocky philosophizing on clichés and truisms (e.g., “nobody’s perfect”) but she balances that with a pre-#MeToo ballad about the female struggle that resonates (“What It Feels Like For A Girl”). My only real gripe is that the record ends on a melancholy note and I would’ve loved more of side A’s frenetic energy to send this off.
Maybe this was ahead of its time with the clubby electronica pop, but wow can this album be annoying. The lyrics are completely mindless, the production is so overdone, and that autotune on Nobody’s Perfect almost made me hurl. There are a few decent moments, like the title track, the jittery acoustic Don’t Tell Me, and the feminist anthem What It Feels Like for a Girl, but otherwise this album is completely avoidable.
The early 2000s auto tune trend was rough
Some of these songs though, too much auto tune for me
3 songs at 4/5 stars, the rest 1/2... I dunno about the maths on that, but it's another mixed bag Madonna album that's for sure.
I guess I do not like to boogie-woogie
decent album, seemed samey for the genre.
J'aime bien Madonna, mais pas mes chansons préférées ! Mes préférées: Music et Paradise (Not for me) j'ai bien aimé sa voix et le rythme pour celles ci
Definitely good! I liked the first song "music" and all the instrumentals on the other songs. Good voice and lyrics 3.7
A quick listen. While Madonna is a talented artist, I don't particularly care for her style of music.
I don't think I've heard any of these songs before. Typical of Madonna, it shows an artist who is always willing to try new things, experiment, and create. Although it's outside the scope of music I typically focus on, it's quite good. She always is. (Side Note: it's awful to see the way people talk about her. I know I should let it roll off me, but it's easy to see how the negative things people say would never be brought up if she were a man. She's as tough and brave as they come.)
5/10 не мое
Listened to this in a foul mood and it put me in a worse mood. If it weren’t bad enough, it finishes with a godawful cover of American Pie. Where’s the 80’s Madonna!?
She certainly didn't waste any time capitalizing on Cher's comeback now, did she? A reminder that Madonna chases more trends than Kiss ever did. The cover of "American Pie" borders on abysmal. Also: No one is buying Midge in that cowboy hat.
2000, vuosien vuosi.. milleniumin vaihtovuosi ... uudet teknologiat autotunet sun muut löydetty.. käyteätään tässä täydessä vauhdissa.. varmaan luuli että joku futuurinen saundi heh... JA OIKEASSA OLI.. MAHTAVAA ROBO TEKNOLOGIA LAULAU... hulluja pliippejä ja plööppejä, tieto kone polkkaa.. mutta mikäs tuo american pie coveri, ei hitannut tällä kertaa paradise (not for me)
Disappointed this was not Madonna's country album like the cover suggests. Mercifully the North American version leaves out the laughably bad version of American Pie---I played the single and it made me lol.
Pop. Folk
This is like the who’s on first of album names. What an absurd title and even more absurd is some of the songs in this album. The first song is at least pretty catchy. Everything else is just what I imagine a producer saying we need more songs people can relate to with bad lyrics and auto tune sounds. That’s this album summed up. 3.9/10
This was a shit album. I remember when this album came out and it was bad then. Not sure why Madonna thought to go auto tune, maybe it is because she knew she couldn't sing. Also the American Pie cover was awful.
Really reaaally solid
I’m very surprised how much I enjoyed this one. Mostly on the production side the songs are really pretty groundbreaking for 2000 with glitchy synths and a lot of vocal effects that make it a pretty fun listen. 7/10
Madonna has been making danceable hits for 40 years. “Music” and “Don’t Tell Me” took me straight back to middle school—Probably haven’t heard those songs for 20 years. Loved the club/house tracks on this album but everything else wasn’t too compelling. Three stars.
Ive never listened to Madonna before. This was an interesting mix of 90's pop that was moving into a more modern style. Overall it was pretty forgettable except for Paradise (not for me). This song would never be popular but the synths, robot voice, and whispering really hit an accord with me. As an experimental song I think it slaps and it was the only song I listened to twice. overall its a 2 star for me
Mehdonna effort to stay rlevant.
I guess this is okay? I think I'd be less negative on this if it wasn't by an artist that was a legitimate superstar in my time. I wonder if my opinion is affected by the fact that this is the first Madonna album released after MTV went full garbage reality TV. I mean there might not be a recording artist of her stature more associated with the music video. I know my opinion is affected by Don't Tell Me making me think there was something wrong with my bluetooth headphones and that terrible American Pie cover. Can a cover be ballsy and lazy at the same time? It sure can.
¿En serio esto uno de los 1001 mejores discos?
Classic Madge
Not a big Pop fan of this era, can see the influence. Not for me.
Ooof. Rough listen.
I've not been a fan of most Madonna LPs served up through this project, but at least they had a more cohesive organizing principle than whatever this mess is. Spastic autotune, random Americana covers, twee radio pop interspersed with (questionably executed) dips into other culture's musical themes. Whoever produced this clearly didn't know how to say no to a single coke-addled request from this pop idol, and the end result is just a bizarre mishmash of musical ideas that feels like the auditory equivalent of a home for abandoned children. Gets one extra star for the sheer balls it took to actually release this to the public and the fact it made me question my sanity.
Full of bops but nosedives at the end into a very unnecessary cover of American Pie.
The songs all sound the same, and none of it was interesting at all. 1/5
Sounded alright, I suppose I am glad to have given Madonna a listen but not my style
Serieux wtf. C’est over produit. Sans saveur.mon dieu et le cover the american pie. C’est juste un crime… 1
DNF, absolute garbage, so disappointed in Madonna for this.
Mishmash time. She’s best with the dancier stuff but the autotuning is awful. The lyric-driven folk tracks are weak.
Meh
Gay
Hey, I found this CD for two euros in a secondhand shop! The title track, "'Don't Tell Me" and that cover of Don McLean's 'American Pie" are famous Madonna songs, aren't they? Is the album "essential" though? Nope. When I brought that CD home, my partner looked at me as if I was a hoarder. And she LIKES Madonna, generally speaking. To put it in a nutshell, Louise Ciccone just hired trendy producers at the time (Mirwais, plus William Orbit, also used for *Ray Of Light*), recorded songs following the trends those producers were experts of, and just thought doing this was enough to make her relevant again. The problem is that for three or four memorable songs in the record, there are twice or three times as many deep cuts failing to leave an imprint on the listener. All style, not much substance. Besides, some of the "trends" inspiring the production of this album have not aged that well. "French Touch" can be nice, as dated as it is. Yet three or four earworms are not enough to transcend the whole shebang. Especially when a lot of synthetic arrangements are streamlined to a fault, and when the vocal performance often feels quite bland and impersonal. Madonna could infuse a lot of her personality within her eighties hits. Where had it gone in 2000? So I'll keep humming the singles, and forget about the rest. About Madonna's presence in list of "essential" albums such as this one, there's been indeed a couple of previous LPs by her where producers helped her make far more memorable songs overall--*including* the deep cuts. *Like A Prayer* is one of them. The more introspective *Ray Of Light* might be one of them as well. But everything else is secondary, in spite of the legendary singles. 2/5 for the purposes of said list. Which translates to a 7/10 grade for more general purposes, mostly thanks to the three famous songs in it. Number of albums left to review: 352 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 295 Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 155 Albums from the list I won't include in mine (many others are more essential to me): 207 (including this one)
Good
Another one I wanted to like but didn't hit for me. Too much synth maybe?
First cut is great. Some other catchy tunes including a nice cover of American Pie.
Not my favorite Madonna album, but it's still m*f*ing Madonna.
Not a fan of this Madonna. Give me 80's Like a Virgin and 90's Vogue.
done
Not as groundbreaking as other might say just because they remember few songs from MTV.
Wouldn't really listen to this much
Cringe at times, visionary at others. The deep exploration of the early 2000s pop textures makes this read more like hyperpop than pop.
Ah the autotune era. Has this always been Madonna's thing? Interesting to hear more and feel/experience Madonna's branding of herself as an innocent, sexy girl. 'Music' is a great song, the rest of the album wasn't much for me.
Never listened to entire album. Enjoyed it. But it's MADONNA . . . . .
I have long been on the record as “not a fan” of Madonna. But this was really great, probably the best album I have heard from her. Madonna is in excellent voice and she gives 100 percent to her performances. She always does. The key to this album’s success though is as much in the production of Mirwais Ahmadzaï and William Orbitwhich, which is wonderful. This is just great fun, with a mix of instant club classics and some nice straightforward pop as well. I love all the quirky, blippy little touches, the unusual chord progressions, the strategic uses of vocal tuning and guitar. They lean into the artifice and experimentalism of electronica, but with great warmth and nuance. Fabulous work, a classic of its era. Fave Songs: Music, Gone, Paradise (Not for Me), Impressive Instant, Runaway Lover, Don't Tell Me
Ali G innit. my memory must be fucked but wasn't madges version of american pie fucking huge when it was released? it's absolutely horrific. as is most of this album.
Presumably fucking shit
Niet direct mijn meug, maar ik kan het wel nog appreciëren
The first song is not bad, but the rest of the songs are not necessarily better.
I appreciate the creative attempt, but it was uneven overall.
This album is not good and I'm glad I'll never have to listen to it again.
Ahh yes, 2000's Madonna, brings back some memories. Overall, I enjoyed this album. I wouldn't listen to it regularly, but I can appreciate the music. Favorite Tracks: Music, Amazing, and Don't Tell Me. Awful Track: Nobodys Perfect. Shit 2000's auto tune (thanks Cher) and horribly grating noises that don't resemble good songs.
just. over produced. absolument pas grand chose de bon. et ne parlons pas du remix american pie... 4/10
Standouts: Music, Nobody's Perfect, Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like For A Girl, Others: I Deserve It, Gone 4/5
“Mom, can we get Portishead?” “We have Portishead at home.” As usual per Madonna there is a few fun dance songs that I assume countless gay men have grinded and fucked to, but there is so many bland ballads that overshadow those.
some good and proper rubbish here, I had to skip a few tracks halfway through garish autotune, bewildering production choices, offputting genre medleys there are some gem production moments in here that save it from a 1, but this is not a good album, that American pie cover alone takes off 3 stars 1.5 stars.
Buena sucesión de canciones con estilo, con el sello propio de Madonna. Voz características y temas bien construidos. Levanta el ánimo.
# 119 : Kind of ok well rounded album. There's definitely some filler though. A bit lame for a "Super star", but I liked it more then I thought I would. Fun to listen to, but nothing mind blowing. Favourite Track : Amazing Listened : 28/11/2023
Some great moments in there
La reina del pop. Un 4.
¿En serio esto uno de los 1001 mejores discos?
madonna
Good album, Madonna’s foray into pop electronica is an enjoyable listen. 3/5 mainly only because as much as I enjoyed it, I won’t listen to it regularly.
Another 2000’s era dance-pop and electronica album. Madonna here is almost 20 years into her career as a “queen of pop”, it seems a little tired, and not particularly creative. The dance beats here are incessant which I guess is the point. But they’re also very generic sounding to me, and entirely mechanical. Whatever effort is made to be original is provided by various synthesized beeps and boops and such…. and vocal effects. All of which can be interesting in small doses, but these aren’t small doses. I find it all irritating. Cher did the Auto-Tune thing 2 years earlier, and better. It also spotlights that Madonna doesn’t really have a great voice. This is probably great background music for an early 2000’s dance club…. It is very well put together, it is vert professional. But it’s not essential, or even especially interesting. Oh yeah, the bonus track cover of “American Pie” is somewhere between embarrassing and offensive. I almost docked the rating a point, but decided to let it slide as it’s not part of the official track list. But, man, that remake SUCKS. It takes some gumption to cover a massive classic and make it your own by sucking out all of the emotion/soul of it. 2/5
I've never understood Madonna's MASSIVE popularity - her melodies are generally vapid and unmemorable, the lyrics are pretty banal and above all, above all else, she is a really average undistinctive singer. OK, so admittedly the production is strong (as are the grooves) but these positives don't overcome the vast array of negatives that basically makes it naff music. Don't take my word for it though, check out your local charity shop!
Lost it, whatever it was.
Vapid pop with an unpleasant whiff of desperation. Former pop princess tries to keep up with the new kids (Britney et al) by throwing money at her latest album. Hardly headline news Ms Ciccone. Cher did it first, and Kylie was more fun. And that American Pie cover was an abomination.
Well. Let's see, shall we? It's better than Ray Of Light, agreed? I was also rather mean about Beck yesterday, so now I feel like I shouldn't go too low on albums that aren't offensively poor. I'm not enjoying listening, but it's not offensive. If I was in a cafe and this were on I'd vaguely think, "Ugh; Madonna." and make no more of it.
Yet another ex-1001 album!™ http://1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie.wikidot.com/album-artists-a-z-ex I liked the opening track for the first 30 seconds, then it was too much. Not a fun listen. Step away from the audio effect buttons! If you want to like Madonna, stick with mid-to-late 80s pop Madonna.
Started off strong with Music. Took a bit of a nosedive. Recognized Don't Tell Me as well. Also What is Feels Like for a Girl. Not my usual music taste, but not bad. Kind of fell off after the hits. The music at the start of Amazing sounded liker stick RPG.
Eh…
There were some better songs on here than other Madonna stuff we've done. The American Pie cover was atrocious. Gone was an interesting look at her actual singing ability. I Deserve It was pretty good. Overall though this music still sucks.
Better-than-respectable, and the experimentation toes a brave line, Don't Tell Me sublimating the genuinely annoying. However, the album's a seriously mixed bag, and the concept never quite comes together but always slightly binds.
Just cringy and boring. American Pie ruined forever.
Ruined by its shit production. The glitchy beats really ruin a couple of potentially decent songs
Couple of bangers but not enough
I have never listened to Madonna; and I have no desire to continue.
Not actually that bad, some funk/soul influences in there.
Rating: 7/10 Best songs: Music, Runaway lover, Want it feels like for a girl, Gone, American pie
almost 20 years since Madonna debuted, Madonna was basically replaced by autotuned AI version of herself. The only thing she is good at is keeping herself relevant in media with controversial bullshit. The only song the autotune wasn't as obvious was that cover of American Pie, but let's be honest. That song is equivalent to a war crime.
Honestly I don’t really get her hype, especially after listening to this album. I think this didn’t show any skill in her voice because of the overpowering autotune. I was really not impressed with this album at all. However compared to a lot of albums it was not terrible, so I wont give a 1.
Where her previous album "Ray of Light" worked so well this one just falls flat on its face. Surface-wise it probably seems like the logical progression but this one just seems like she/her people got all the hottest producers and newest studio/editing tricks and let them all run wild with little to no thought on song construction. Sure it *sounds* fantastic. But do any of these songs go anywhere (comparison: "Candy Perfume Girl" or "Subsitute for Love" from previous album)? Picking on the worst attempt here to be sure but "I Deserve It" is the very definition of *banal* - for someone who doesn't pay much attention to lyrics...I noticed. The bad-even-for-BonJovi lyrics combined with Madonna's rather unemotional vocals... man I don't know what else to say. Actually.... are all of her lyrics this bad? Is she 12??? The next track "Amazing" would have been a good song (and sounds like a decent outtake from her previous record) but I'm totally distracted by these lyrics holy crap. I can't look away now. As for the rest of the album - it sometimes sorta works as a club and/or party album but as for listening to it as...Music... it's not doing anything for me. At least it's relatively short. TL;DR: Lyrics taken from the back of her 7th grade Biology notebook combined with quickly-annoying modern production edits makes for a bad album. 3/10 2 (to be fair, very generous) stars.
I tried but I don’t like Madonna at all
Inoffensive
Impressive instant ima jako neugodan za uho ponavljajući zvuk. American pie obrada je zanimljiva
Rambling? No song felt like anything to me. Not my style and even for this style of music just nothing interesting going on here for me.
usch vad tråkigt
Noone can get away with that American Pie cover.
This is not peak Madonna, nor is it peak 2000s dance pop. Even Madonna doesn't sound very convinced of what she's singing. She famously set out to rule the world, not to bet the top singer or top composer. This is the album she made when she saw her rule evaporating.
It's just never going to be my thing honestly, but I don't hate it either. The production is cool honestly.
Madonna gets old. One decent track on a pretty boring album. 2/5
New wave pop? amazing album. I loved "i deserve it" and "Amazing". it reminded me of Bjork but with the more comercial side of Madonna.
I did my best to listen without prejudice but this album has lyrics so insipid it’s insulting. The production is excellent but Madonna just kinda ruins it. And the cover of American Pie is bad enough that I can’t even listen. Just no. Catchy songs throughout so I’ll be singing Hey Mr Deejay for the rest of the week but I ain’t happy about it.
I wish the whole album was in the same vein as the two great songs “Music” and “Don’t Tell Me”, I think that would have been awesome. Unfortunately the rest of the album is mostly low energy dance tunes mired in an autotune muck. Mostly uninteresting save for a couple of high notes.
Highlights: Music What it feels like for a girl
It had it's moments. Kinda felt like the start of a bit of "listen to me, I'm still cool. I can hang with the new girls on the scene" kinda vibe. The "futuristic" pop sounds didn't age too well. And why is she wearing a cowboy hat?
This was not an enjoyable listen. Over reliant on autotune and techno. One of my least favourite covers of all time to finish the album.
This was not good and has no place being on this list when Madonna has like 6 really good to great albums.
That a cringeworthy cover of one of the most loved songs of all time is probably one of the better songs on this debacle says it all. Madge is the poster child for the history of pop music. Take a black genre, make it palatable for a white audience, rinse and repeat. She has tried to rise above her insipidness by flashing her "edgy" image all over any willing media platform. If you need reminding just how insipid she is, the first two songs feature electronically altered vocals. They're awful but still way better than those songs that feature her natural voice. This is a truly horrid album. But not as bad as Like A Prayer. Nothing is worse than that shit.
I don't mind some Madonna music, but I don't really enjoy electronic Madonna with auto-tuning. And I definitely didn't need to hear an electronic version of American Pie today. Despite the fact that Madonna is from my hometown of Rochester, Michigan, I'm going to have to go with 2 stars for this one.
Bien.
Incredibly Crafted POP Album. Her Voice Never Sounded Better & the Production Rivals that of Steely Dan's AJA. This is BY FAR Her Best Album
I was expecting a 3 star but I got a 4 star, good basseline, good pop
Early auto tune… not my jam
Nostalgia central, reminds me of being 9 years old. Some bangers here
This all just blurred into one. Vacuous dance-pop.
Let me start by saying that I love Madonna. I have long argued that she is the only wholly innovative pop star and that all others are just derivative. But this is a bad album. The saving grace is the production, which is excellent and way ahead of its time. But Madonna herself is maybe at her worst. The whole album is essentially spoken word and my god the words that are spoken are terrible. The lyricism is downright terrible, laughably so. And no, bad lyrics don’t become good when you sing them in French. Honorable mention for What It Feels Like To Be a Girl, which is a bop.
I think this album has been dropped from later versions of this list. It shouldn't have been.
Meh, 80s hits much better.
Lazy
Madonna is tight. Crazy looking these days, but such a good artist. Weird, poppy (for its time) and good energy. Reminds me of a country Britney spears album
This album is kind of like the opposite of Transformer for me. I think Madonna is a pretty good singer. Don't get me wrong, I think Lou Reed's singing could grow on me with future listens to other Lou Reed albums as well as the Velvet Underground albums, but I wasn't a big fan of his singing. What I'm trying to say is that while I think the singing was the worst part of Transformer, I think the best part of Madonna's "Music" is her singing. Nothing else really stuck out to me that much. I didn't like the sound on a lot of the songs. I just don't think that the contrast between the techno sound and the almost folk-like sound work well together. Some of the songs dragged on for me. Did "Paradise (Not for Me)" really need to be 6 minutes? Some of the songs were good though. I think the closer, Gone, is the best song in the album. The editing just isn't my thing a lot of the time. Overall, I can see why others might like it a bit and I understand why this album is on here, but this just isn't my thing at all. low 3/5.
Too much auto tune was honestly kind of annoying. I would have preferred one of her earlier albums
It was ok but nothing grabbed my attention
Continuing the victory lap that began in earnest with Bedtime Stories, Madonna's first missive of the 21st Century deals with her continued fixation on remaining hip to the times whilst wielding personal subject manner. Although a tad less reliant on the power of healing in Ray of Light, we still hear Madge waxing philosophical on tracks such as Gone, Don't Tell Me and What It Feels Like for a Girl but she still makes room for an ode to a good time via the first three tracks. Regardless of the picture painted on the album cover, there is no dust kicked up by horses here. Favorites: Music, Runaway Lover, I Deserve It, Amazing, Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like for a Girl, Paradise (Not for Me).
Generic unimaginative pop.
Some hits and misses
Do you want to? No, not at first.... but she led with the big hitter, the "Music" did indeed start. The music production was wild, those "high whining noises" just aren't what they used to be _ears bleeding_. But, in seriousness it was very well produced. I skipped through most of the tracks; notable highlights were Music, Don't tell me & American Pie.
Actually really liked the album, apart from the aptly named "Nobody's Perfect" which is a good summation for the song itself because it's an overly autotuned piece of poop. The overall tone of the album feels like a mish mash of random directions but I don't really mind that, it provides relief from the norm of some albums to bore me to death with the same sounding songs.
Queen of Pop I prefer some of her other albums over this one though
Loved the vibe, I didn't know Madonna very well and especially didn't know she did this kind of music!
I should have been less surprised that the 5th highest selling artist of all time has decent music. Too poppy for my tastes, but did a lot with it. Interesting.
Not the worst. But certainly not good pop. Madonna is definitely over confident in her prowess
2/5 eventually no...
Electro and pop wonder
:wat:
Did not enjoy, couldn’t make it through album
Agree with Aron and Jennie. It felt very much like background music and I am also scared of Madonna
Feels very manufactured. Definitely 2000s music, feels like music for background without a lot of meaning Some catchy tunes but I dislike the use of auto tune
The production on this was quite cool, I enjoyed this more than I expected to. Dance vibes
Another album my parents always used to play me! I remember we used to listen to this on the way to swimming lessons when I was v young. Never really noticed the complexity/sophistication of the 'Music' instrumental - was pleasantly surprised and really enjoyed it. Also really liked 'What it feels like for a girl'.
I'm scared of Madonna
A solid later album from Madonna. Not the heights of the album directly preceding (Ray of Light) or Confessions after, but fun and well made. Could be sequenced better.
Madonna is catchy as always. Most of it is a bit too cheesy for my taste, but it’s still really good! My favorite of the album is Nobody’s Perfect - it sounds like a modern day down tempo electronic banger! Includes legendary song American Pie as the outro.
Next album please
I was prepared for this to be an utter trainwreck. But it wasn't, some of it was quite, ahem, 'musical.' However the less said about the horror of the American Pie cover, the better.
Drivel.
There is plenty of Madonna's music that merits being on this list, but this isn't it in my opinion. As a professional musician, she's obviously welcome to try anything she wants, but just because her name is on it doesn't mean it's worth listening to.
Music. It's indeed music. The autotune on "Nobody's Perfect" makes me want to rip my ears out, jesus christ. Madonna can sing alright, what's the need? The cover of "American Pie" wasn't as bad as they all say, but it's still probably classifiable as a warcrime in 162 countries around the world.
Don't Tell Me is okay. I prefer her earlier work to this and I'm not really a big Madonna fan to begin with.
Tää ei oi kyl must madonnan parhaita. Ajan hammas purassu aika lujaa noihin 00-soundeihin. 2/5
Ihan kivat soundit, mutta vähän liikaa huonolla maulla tehtyä kikkailua.
En jotenkin ehkä vaan tajuu tätä Madonnan nollaripoppista. Tylsät taustat, geneeriset sanat eikä mitenkään ihmeellistä muutenkaan. 2/5
This proves why Madonna ruled all pop music
Klassiker
Quite boring
m u s i c
la quiero mucho pero no me pinta tanto este género ah 7.5/10
Totally remember the time this electro producer Madonna record dropped, a certain feeling of postmodern genre clashing made everything feel cocainy euphorical before 9/11 hangover awakeing. Also humour wenn from Ali G then to Achmed „l’ll kill you“ the dead terrorist. Rrrreprezent!
American Pie ruined it for me :/
Yes, it's bland, but it's "dance music". Don't Tell Me is the highlight for me. The low point is definitely that certain cover song it ends with. I'm not even a huge fan of the original, but that cover is inexcusable.
This was good but not great, some good songs but not the absolute consistency of a great pop album.
This has aged much better than I would have guessed. At the time it just sounded like the state of pop radio, because it was the music Madonna was making. But now it sounds inventive and creative, even refreshing. Unfortunately the album takes a nose dive with the last couple songs (I especially don't think the world needed that version of American Pie, which thankfully wasn't on the original release anyway). Take those two out though, and this is a surprising gem of an album.
An artist trying to maintain relevance by chasing current musical trends and modifying their image. Not a total embarrassment, but not really a cohesive statement either. This vacillated between 3 and 2 for me, but I will go with 2 since there were several tracks I really had the urge to skip.
How high the mighty have fallen.
I really love „ray of light“, but this one is not as good as „Ray of light“. Too bad because it has some good moments and catchy melodies
Hmm. On a re-listen this feels like a bit of a curate's egg, betrayed by three different producers. Three stellar tracks in Music, What It Feels Like and closer Gone. But bits of it feel like out-takes from Ray of Light, bits of it feel like a not quite fully achieved French filter house album, and bits of it are a bit duff. Then of course one of the worst covers of all time. So can't give it more than three stars.
La génération d'avant avait des goûts de chiottes.
Un anniversaire dans une ambiance des plus obscures, l'appartement de Robert est en effet plongé dans le noir depuis plusieurs longs mois. Personne n'est venu nous ouvrir à notre arrivée, nous avons donc decidé de célébrer ces 900 albums dans la sobrieté, non sans lâcher quelques larmes au passage.
oh man the autotune on this record is atrocious. This is real bad. The only song I enjoyed was What It Feels Like For A Girl.
Obviously never heard this, the second track was quite interesting, though essentially 'Music' redux. Music was alright, as it goes. Including both this and Ray of Light seems quite the egregious move on the part of the editor. Oh shit this is the album with American Pie, the abomination. 2 nothing tracks follow, track 5 is pretty decent, could absolutely have been on Ray of Light. Sounds a lot like Beautiful Stranger. Track 6 is nothing, oh I recognise 7. Yeah that one was alright too. 8 was a single too I guess, that was fine, no more. I just read that both Amazing and Impressive Instant were a promotional single, resetting the 'worthwhile album tracks' counter back to zero. Although by that metric there are only 4 tracks not released as a single in some form, they're all completely unremarkable though. I haven't yet listened to Ray of Light but I already think that will be better and more essential than this, and including Ray of Light pt. 2 seems pointless. Really enjoyed Like a Prayer, what about some of her earlier stuff? Low 3, average, well crafted pop album. Good Christ, the American Pie cover is painful. Worse than I remember even. Loses a star. 2.
Testifying that the early 2000s were not a great period in music history
Madonna i 00’er-udgave, ikke helt vildt fedt
Forgettable, bland, generic pop shit. Not a fan of Madonna, but she has recorded better and more memorable stuff than this.
I was disappointed. Seemed like she was trying to be deep but everything came off as shallow. Plus I couldn't relate to what I expect were meant to be relatable lyrics. I saw a review saying it sounded like the future... Gosh I hope not. Sounds like the past to me.