Music by Madonna

Music

Madonna

2.7
Rating
22940
Votes
1
12%
2
32%
3
35%
4
16%
5
5%
Distribution

Reviews (page 6 of 8)

Strong and refreshing 4.1

2000 was a weird year. Everything sounds so synthesized and it really didn't age well

## In-Depth Review of *Music* (2000) by Madonna Madonna's *Music*, released in 2000, marks a significant chapter in her career, showcasing her ability to reinvent herself while maintaining her status as the "Queen of Pop." This album blends various musical styles, explores diverse themes, and reflects her artistic evolution. Below is a comprehensive analysis of the album focusing on its lyrics, music, production, themes, influence, and a summary of its pros and cons. ### Lyrics The lyrical content of *Music* reflects a duality that runs throughout the album: celebration and introspection. The title track, "Music," serves as an anthem for unity and joy, emphasizing music's power to bring people together. Lines like "Music makes the bourgeoisie and the rebel" highlight the social implications of music as a unifying force across different classes and backgrounds[2]. Other tracks delve into personal and emotional territories. For instance: - **"What It Feels Like for a Girl"** explores themes of female identity and societal expectations. The lyrics convey a sense of vulnerability and empowerment, capturing the complexities of womanhood. - **"Gone"** presents a more introspective view, reflecting on loss and longing. The poignant lyrics evoke feelings of heartache and resignation. Madonna's ability to juxtapose light-hearted themes with deeper emotional currents is evident throughout the album. While some songs celebrate the exuberance of life, others reflect on personal struggles and societal observations. ### Music Musically, *Music* is an eclectic mix that combines elements of electro-funk, pop, and folk influences. The production features a blend of organic instruments and electronic sounds, showcasing Madonna's willingness to experiment with new textures. - **"Music"** itself is driven by a catchy electro-pop beat that incorporates elements reminiscent of disco and funk. The use of synthesizers creates a vibrant soundscape that invites listeners to dance. - **"Impressive Instant"** features vocoder effects alongside Madonna's unadorned vocals, creating a contrast that enhances the song's energetic feel. The track embodies a futuristic sound while retaining pop sensibilities. - **"I Deserve It"** introduces acoustic guitar elements that provide warmth against the backdrop of electronic production. This song exemplifies Madonna's ability to integrate different musical styles seamlessly. Overall, the album's sound is characterized by its upbeat tempo and innovative production techniques that keep it fresh and engaging. ### Production The production of *Music* was primarily handled by Madonna herself alongside Mirwais Ahmadzaï, who played a crucial role in shaping the album's sound. Their collaboration resulted in an experimental yet accessible sonic palette. - The use of electronic elements is prominent throughout the album, with tracks like "Nobody's Perfect" featuring glitchy sounds that create an immersive listening experience. - Madonna's decision to incorporate live instruments alongside electronic beats adds depth to the overall production. Songs like "Paradise (Not for Me)" showcase lush string arrangements that contrast with more synthetic tracks. - The production quality is polished yet retains an underground vibe, reflecting Madonna's ability to balance mainstream appeal with artistic integrity. ### Themes Thematically, *Music* navigates through various concepts: - **Unity Through Music:** The title track encapsulates this theme perfectly, celebrating the power of music as a universal language that transcends barriers. - **Female Empowerment:** Tracks like "What It Feels Like for a Girl" challenge societal norms surrounding femininity and gender roles, making statements about women's experiences in contemporary society. - **Introspection:** Songs such as "Gone" delve into personal reflections on relationships and emotional struggles, showcasing Madonna's vulnerability alongside her strength. These themes contribute to the album's overall narrative arc, creating a cohesive listening experience that resonates with listeners on multiple levels. ### Influence *Music* was influential not only for its sound but also for its cultural impact. It re-established Madonna as a relevant artist in the new millennium after some criticism in the late 1990s. The album’s exploration of dance music culture resonated with audiences during a time when electronic music was gaining mainstream popularity. - The title track became an anthem for club culture and was embraced by LGBTQ+ communities for its inclusive message[3]. - Madonna’s ability to blend different genres influenced many contemporary artists who sought to merge pop with electronic sounds. - The album also marked a return to form for Madonna in terms of chart performance; it produced several hits that dominated airwaves globally. ### Pros and Cons #### Pros - **Innovative Sound:** *Music* showcases Madonna's willingness to experiment with new sounds while maintaining her pop roots. - **Cohesive Themes:** The thematic exploration of unity, empowerment, and introspection creates a rich listening experience. - **Cultural Relevance:** The album resonated with contemporary audiences and influenced future artists in the pop and electronic genres. - **Catchy Hooks:** Memorable choruses make many tracks instantly recognizable and enjoyable. #### Cons - **Lyrical Depth:** While some lyrics are impactful, others may feel less substantial or repetitive compared to her earlier works. - **Production Choices:** Some critics argue that certain tracks rely too heavily on electronic effects at the expense of lyrical substance[5]. - **Mixed Reception:** Although many celebrated its innovation, some fans preferred her earlier albums’ more straightforward pop sound. ### Conclusion Madonna's *Music* stands as a testament to her enduring legacy as an artist capable of evolving while staying true to her roots. Its blend of catchy melodies, innovative production techniques, and thoughtful lyrics make it a significant entry in her discography. While it has its drawbacks—particularly regarding lyrical depth—the overall impact of *Music* is undeniable. It reflects not only Madonna’s artistic vision but also her ability to connect with audiences through universal themes that resonate across generations.

Some really interesting production here but the album I remembered this being is better than the album it is, it's completely lost it's way by the end.

Couple good pop songs but most songs are just hot garbage.

OHHH, I GET IT NOW! Madonna is like the pop superstar version of David Bowie, what with all the reinventing and \"shape-shifting\" and songwriting ability... nevermind, this bit sucks. Mostly cringey, the song \"Amazing\" is ok, but even that just goes on too long. Madonna does not sound like she's having fun - which is the first rule for this kind of music. Some interesting production here and there. Why MUST I hear this before I die? Probably would not have been worse off without it. But hey, I made it through.

Ray of Light was her masterpiece. This one is pretty good too.

A couple of songs on here that I wouldn't mind hearing on the dance floor, but for the most part this just seems like Madonna trying to cash in on a musical trend. Not very inspired and not worth a second listen. 2.5 stars

Eigentlich nicht so meine Musik, aber das Album ist ganz gut.

Madonna's discography really is a musical roller coaster. Her previous album two years prior to this was 'Ray of Light', which felt like a spa friendly, buddhist inspired record that could have been conceived during some journey about finding oneself in Nepal. This record gives me the feeling that she is back in the bar, ready to shot Jack Daniels and throw dart with the boys. This was an incredibly strange record with a wide array of different musical styles. Both 'Music' and 'Don't Tell Me' feels very 90s and are both Madonna classics. They both sound vastly different though, so it's strange to find them on the same record. They're both by far the best songs of the record though. Some mentions must be made of 'Nobody's Perfect', where Madonna discovered auto tune, which is quite a terrible song actually. 'American Pie' is quite a decent cover I guess, but just weird to find it on this record. Musically it stands out quite a bit from the rest. The rest of the songs were not that noteworthy. Overall I think this record was too sprawling and incoherent for my taste when combined with the fact that the songs weren't that good.

Holy auto-tune batman, what a mess! There is some compression effect on all vocals which sounds horrible. That in combine with overuse of bad auto-tune ("Nobody's perfect") made this a pretty bad album. Even the hits like "Music" were quite dissapointing. Also why was the cover of "American Pie" popular? It is pretty bad. It gets a star for trying something different and for the best song on the album "Don't tell me" with its country riff which is pretty decent.

surprisingly good

Interesting but a bit too electronic for me.

Unbearable autotune experiment

Not nearly as good as i remember it. American pie cover is awful , ‘Music’ is incredible . everything in between these two tracks is middling . 2 overall , but 5 for the Music .

This album is so far from Madonna's best work! I'm genuinely surprised Music made the cut. Yes, the title track is an absolute bop to this day, but too many songs were lackluster. The end of the album improved some, at least. The middle of the album was forced, and the lyrics were uninteresting. Madonna relied too heavily on electronica and unnecessary autotune. She has such a beautiful voice, which she reveals in the "American Pie" cover, but why wasn't that voice actually showcased in the actual album and only in an extra track for the international version?! I admire when an artist changes their sound but only when it's done well. And this album just wasn't even in the quality. Considering I know Madonna can do so much better, Music was a disappointment after the first song finished.

This album felt kind of monumental at first, but the more I thought about it, the less strongly I felt about that. I'll explain. While girl pop icons like Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera were carving out the new girl pop paths, Madonna was doing her own thing, refusing to become a follower rather than a leader in the pop space. This album is a reflection of that: electronic dance pop, quite different from the typical girl pop of the time. So that feels like a big deal. But upon further reflection, it seems like a little less of a big deal because she actually was ALREADY doing this, starting with 1998's "Ray of Light". "Ray of Light" feels infinitely more groundbreaking sonically than "Music" does. The music in "Ray of Light" seems to pack a more meaningful punch and feels less hollow than "Music". The title track, while ridiculously catchy and never skippable, still has a certain lackluster to it, though it is pretty much the album's best offering. Anyway, I baseline enjoyed this because I'm an absolute sucker for electronic pop, but yeah, it seems to lack heart. Hoping "Ray of Light" is on this project somewhere to set right things right. A pretty flat 3.

Despite the cover art, not much country music here. It's more of the same electronic sounds from Ray of Light, with a few more surprises. We start off with a few dancefloor ready cuts before the second half goes a bit more eclectic and chilled out, which I like better. It's all quite interesting production wise, not sure if it sounds retro or futuristic. I can't decide if I like this more than Ray of Light but it's in the same conversation. Favorites: Runaway Lover, Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like for a Girl, Paradise (Not For Me).

Ik had vrij lage verwachtingen, maar dit luistert best lekker weg. Een artiest als Madonna drukt mij bij nog wel eens op de irritatieknoppen, maar deze niemendallerige dancenummers zitten best goed in elkaar en wat zou ik dan gaan zeuren. Gelukkig hoort de belachelijke en volstrekt overbodige cover American Pie niet bij het oorspronkelijke album, anders was er zeker een punt afgegaan, misschien wel meerdere.

Madonna had natuurlijk een flinke invloed op de pop-muziek. Ondanks dat ik het eerdere album niet zo interessant vond, snap ik dat deze zangeres in onze lijst thuishoort. Nu krijgen we echter een album van haar uit 2000. Met al het begrip, maar ik durf wel te stellen dat ze op dat moment echt geen trendsetter meer was, maar een trendvolger. Ze volgde ze de nieuwere elektronische muziek en keek goed hoe haar jongere collega-popzangeressen hier mee omgingen. Dit is dan ook vooral een papagaaien-album. En net als bij papagaaien begrijpt Madonna zelf eigenlijk de geluiden niet die ze voortbrengt. Het tweede nummer is het meest exemplarisch. Dat begint als een Daft Punk kloon. Muziek die draait om een kale ontwikkelende basis. In plaats daarvan wordt het overschaduwd door de totaal niet passende verdraaide stem van Madonna. Zo doet ze die basis én zichzelf tekort. De titeltrack is eigenlijk het enige nummer dat een positieve uitzondering vormt. Zilver voor American Pie. Maar dat is een uitzondering. Madonna vond zelf blijkbaar dat dit niet op het album thuishoorde. Het tapt echt uit een ander vaatje. En dat is terecht. Maar ik begrijp de platenmaatschappij wel. Ik zou het er ook graag doorgedrukt hebben. Anders was dit schijfje helemaal mondiaal door de shredder gehaald.

Wat Madonna altijd goed heeft weten te doen, is vernieuwing in haar muziek brengen. Ze was zelden de eerste die een bepaalde stijl uitbracht, maar ze was vaak wel een van de eersten uit de mainstream. Het wiel zelf uitvinden deed ze nooit denk ik, maar slim als ze is zoekt ze wel de samenwerking met andere artiesten. Dit keer met William Orbit, geen bekende naam bij het grote publiek, maar wij hebben al een plaat van hem mogen luisteren in de lijst. Fijne triphop was dat, al stond er ook tergende ambient op zijn Strange Cargo. Het resultaat is een album vol Madonnaliedjes met beats en elektronica van oa Orbit. Madonna kon al niet zingen en nu moet ze haar heil zoeken in de autotune. Het voegt maar weinig toe en zal wat mij betreft ook absoluut niet de annalen van de popmuziek halen. Dit waren de laatste stuiptrekkingen van Madonna gok ik. Al heeft ze blijkbaar hierna nog een rits albums uitgebracht die me niks zeggen. De beatjes redden het nog enigszins, maar dit album had de lijst niet hoeven halen. Zit tussen de 2 en de 3 in. De vorige keer heb ik Madonna hoog gegeven, dan zijn we nu weer een keer streng.

Unlike the music but the lyrics are absolutely cringe, just horrible

Rough album to get through. Madonna leeches off of new trends, much like exploitation film, and this is her autotuned record. The hits are solid, but the lyrics are atrocious. You just have to thank God that her version of 'American Pie' was not included in the original release.

Who is that much of a Madonna fan that you think everyone should listen to Music? It’s mental. The hits are hits for a reason but “Nobody’s Perfect” is easily one of her worst songs. Madonna is a chameleon, changing with every musical trend to blend in - no real integrity, she just wants to be relevant. Ultimately I can sorta respect that; it just doesn’t always make for a great listen.

Holy autotune. Found nothing redeeming about this album.

Pop, RnB, 2000 -> 2

I like Madonna's earlier stuff, but the electro-pop of this album doesn't do it for me. It's well produced and good for the genre, just not my kind of music. I respect her ability to evolve with the time.

Ouf, c’était pas top. Au moins elle est honnête, il y avait bel et bien de la Music sur cet album

Wow Music took me straight back to that era. I didn't know most of this album, but it encapsulates that period of music really well. 3* Highlights: music and don't tell me (because nostalgia)

Classics maar trager dan je denkt

I was just going to talk about how inane this is, mostly because of Madonna’s lyrics, but the beat to Don’t Tell Me pissed me off so badly that it went immediately on my curated ‘Worst Songs Ever’ playlist. I genuinely moved my head around in an attempt to reconnect my headphones. Fuck whoever came up with that idea. What It Feels Like For A Girl is interesting enough that it pulls this from the brink of a 1 star, but the rest of the album is so banal yet pretending to be deep that it just puts me in a bad mood

I honestly think Madonna should have recorded all of the lyrics in French. At least there would have been some mystery to the music. As it stands, this is shallow and forgettable pop.

не так бесит как в молодости (т. к. слишком перформатив), но конкретно это альбом слишком наавтотюненный, сильно не зацепил

Finally I got something that is not an agreed-upon bonafide classic! There are moments on this record that I plainly did not like. Pastiche and dated: Madonna seems to be trying to set herself apart from her younger contemporaries with a blended sound that combines trance, euro-dance and electropop with "country" or "americana". The latter elements are put in quotations because the "country" moniker is mostly worn as a cheap aesthetic and not as an actual authentic sonic foundation. Some songs have kernels of hyperpop post-ironic experimentation laden within Madonna's murky, overly-earnest songwriting that sometimes meanders into utter meaninglessness. There are adventurous moments that I am sure would have piqued my interest in the year 2000 but as a retrospective listen, the production is too hollow to keep pace with the giants of that time like the bombastic and meticulously crafted beats of the likes of Britney Spears. It is neither urgent nor mature, existing somewhere blandly in the middle.

Quite ahead of its time for 2000. Set the trend for this poppy sound. I didn’t like it

Madona's career during this century has been mostly riding the wave, with some good results like this record. I would give it 3 stars, but that American Pie rendition is a crime alright

Not today lol

Except for the hits, I don't know a lot about Madonna's music. I can imagine their earlier stuff is of higher quality than this album. Some very annoying songs on here, and then some better things when it progresses. Still mediocre in general though.

I've never been into anything Madonna does. Great dance music I guess, but not my thing :)

I know a lot of music fans (snobs) look down on pop, but I’ve never been that way. There’s no trophies for writing off an entire genre of music that’s scientifically designed to be catchy and pleasing to the ear. This album was solid. Just enjoy the damn music! 🎶“Music makes the people come together.” 🎶 — 4/5 Highlights: I Deserve It Don’t Tell Me Paradise (Not For Me)

I Deserve It is the exact style of the latter half of Madonnas career that I really like. I think the William Orbit time in her career is the most interesting time for her. It's a production style that works so well. Really good. Prefer it to Ray Of Light 4

Desperate attempt to be something she was

Correcto

I went into this album not expecting too much, but ended up really enjoying it. There are really surprising elements here. Don’t get me wrong, it is a pop album, but how was I unaware that Madonna had elements of glitchwave in an album? That definitely peaked my interest from the start. Seriously, have a proper listen to Don’t Tell Me. It’s really weird, but it’s so catchy.

Not bad, I've heard the hits from this album but never the whole thing. It's pretty good, the non hit songs are more of the same kind of pop music but it isn't tiring and has a catchy beat. Not sure I would go out of my way to listen to this again but it is not bad at all. If I happened upon it I wouldn't be upset.

Not really a Madonna fan, sorry

The glitch-country-of “don’t tell me” is pretty good. And the warm wave of electronica of “what it feels like for a girl” is nice. “Gone” is another good one. Madonna herself doesn’t exactly shine on this album, but I kinda like the production.

The two big singles from this are good songs, but they also belie how fantastically weird the album around them is. The rest of what's here sound like Madonna was listening to a lot of Air, but also sort of presages hyperpop and the wider crossover of French House? Like Homework was already out, and "Around the World" had had a little impact, but this album came out two months before "One More Time". It's not a *great* album, but it is a fascinating one, and a great example of Madonna's ability to anticipate trends, even in the middle portion of her career.

ok here's the thing. I'm going to be the biggest Madonna defender in this group. I know. Sometimes you just have to resign yourself to your fate. And yet I remain fascinated by Madonna's midcareer albums all the same. Here we have the lingering influences of trip hop Madonna loved in the late 90s with the rising influence of French house on European club music in the early aughts combined with an odd, uh, country? musical sensibility Madonna never explored before or since at a time when no other major pop star was doing that (I think? It's honestly hard to tell because eve calling this "country-inspired" seems deeply wrong in a way I can't articulate but in a way I'm going to continue doing), just before all of these influences cascaded into Madonna making her easily worst album three years later. I don't expect everyone to like this, sure. But I still find it fascinating years later. The fact that it has all-time great pop tracks like the title song and "Don't Tell Me" doesn't hurt, either.

so euro-dance. it's got a distinct 2000 electronic big beat pop sound. At the time it was cool and different from the Britney Spears et al pop sounds, but today it feels a little dated. Nobody's perfect is perfectly awful. Album was probably a bit ahead of its time, at the time but retrospectively doesn't hold up.

I realised that I already knew a lot of songs off this album. I also realised that I hate the ones I didn't know as much as I hate the ones I did.

ależ słabe 1+

Not really a fan but there is enough here for 3 stars or C as a rating.

There was nothing fun about this album. Why would anyone call this "Music"?

Has some nice hits but also so many anoying parts..

This wasn't great. Modern Madonna... Just shitty electro pop music, drum machines, and her moaning. Not for me. Favourite songs: Music, Don't Tell Me, Amazing Least favourite songs: I Deserve It, Nobody's Perfect, Paradise (Not For Me) 2/5

So derivitive. As someone who does kind of enjoy 80s Madonna, this is a huge falloff

bissi trash, bissi gut

I'd give it a 0 if I coule

i KNOW i can’t be the only one who has seriously been vibing to some music lately… i enjoyed listening to this!! it always feels a little weird to, like, sit down and listen to a dancey pop album like this; nevertheless i did like it. yeah it’s cheesy but it’s cute!!! yay!!!

that was cute and fun. it sounds a bit dated to me though. it had a lot of leftover stylings of her 90s music but with some of the sort of early 2000s techno flourishes on it which made it really sound like a time capsule of that era in a way that i think did not age super well. i think that's typical of pop and it doesn't make it bad music, it just doesn't sound fresh in the way that some of her (even older) music still does. fav tracks: Runaway Lover, Gone, Impressive Instant

Great! I knew every song. I've listened to this album hundreds of times. It's timeless. ❤️

The bad cover of American Pie is on "Music." This is one of quite a few terrible covers of 60's/70's songs that were pushed on the public in the late 90's and early 2000's (looking at you, Sheryl Crow). If we need three Madonna albums then this would not have been my choice for the third. It doesn't really break ground, as she seemed to tell her producers "Cher Me" and then they did. Not to say it's bad, as Madonna does a great job of altering her voice and sound to fit what she wants to be. Madonna has always been a sort of chameleon, being able to fit her sound into the latest trends and "Music" is no exception. The song Music is really great and one can see how these tracks would fit well in the early-2000's club atmosphere. The middle is the best part of the album, which isn't something you would traditionally expect, especially on an album with only 10 tracks. Not sure this one belongs in the book, as I do not know what it brings by the 2000 that hasn't already been presented.

Ooh she is an under-appreciated diva.

No. 268/1001 Music 3/5 Impressive Instant 2/5 Runaway Lover 3/5 I Deserve It 3/5 Amazing 3/5 Nobody's Perfect 3/5 Don't Tell Me 3/5 What It Feels Like For A Girl 4/5 Paradise 2/5 Gone 4/5 American Pie 4/5 Average: 3,09 I get what she tried to do with this album. Just didn't click for me.

What it feels like for a girl wasn't half bad!

this album is pretty meh. 'Music', the opening track, is the most fun track here. Everything else was pretty forgettable. To me, this album sounds pretty over-produced. its electronic - but it sounds almost like it tried to be risky and wasn't I don't think I would have this in rotation again.

There were a couple of songs that I kinda liked (Don’t Tell Me, What It Feels Like for a Girl, Gone), but overall this album was pretty boring and unremarkable. If it wasn’t by Madonna, there’s no way it would be on the list. I hate the adaptation of American Pie. So much.

It’s like if daft punk had a baby and then Shania Twain had a baby and then by some miracle those two babies met and [at the appropriate legal age] fucked, that would be this album. Unfortunately, that genetic amalgamation is no good. But you know what is good, madonnas song die another day from the movie die another day. I feel like no one ever talks about that song but it was a banger. And it was cool like usually during a bond credits opening it’s just like random stuff going on but in this like the scene keeps going and it’s bond being tortured with silhouetted women on fire all around him. Pretty cool. Maybe people were just focused on that scene where bond parasails down that massive wave with the roof of that weird ice speed racer and a parachute. Like who the hell green lit that idea. So bad. But freakin Halle berry. Wow. What a run she had. So hot. And that orange bikini. Goodness. But ya this album sucked.

Boomer music

There were a couple decent songs but otherwise this was a slog. Don’t see much influence besides it being Madonna. At least we’re knocking out some of the latter albums in her career.

Oof... this album really is a product of it's time. It's so stuck in time that I wouldn't even say it's a 00's album. It's specifically the year 2000. When people say they don't like Madonna, this is the era they're referring to. I've always heard that Madonna is the only artist to release a chart-topping record every decade since her start. I'm now realizing she only accomplished this by pandering to the audience of the time. She just chases whatever the trend is. The only song I kinda liked was "Don't Tell Me", but even that feels like a rip-off of Green Day's "Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)". Specifically the guitar cutting in and out.

I'm, conflicted on this one. It would have been genuinely groundbreaking at the time, inspiring ultimately better artists (Goldfrapp), but it also popularised the shit trend of autotune

Rating: 7/10 Very good album overall. The production was definitely the standout, blending pop with electronic and country. Pretty experimental and sounds like this album had a large influence on other 2000s pop artists. Most of this aged pretty well (besides the horrendous autotune) and is mostly pretty catchy as well. Favorite songs: Music, I Deserve It, Don't Tell Me, What It Feels Like for a Girl, Paradise (Not for Me), Gone. Worst song: Nobody's Perfect.

At first I was bowled over by how ridiculously Y2K-sounding this album was. Like, the sort of "techno," as pop listeners called every electronic music genre at the time, along with futuristic production effects that I remember being really wowed by at that time, is all over this thing. If I'd listened to it closer to release I would probably rate it higher, but encountering it for the first time in 2024 does it few favors. It sounds extremely dated. Some songs really won me over though, especially in the last half, like "What It Feels Like For a Girl" and the moody and cinematic "Paradise (Not For Me)." Still, I probably won't revisit it unless I'm showing it to my wife to see her reaction.

It was just alright, not one of her better albums

Did not care for that at all.

A few good songs and a few unlistenable songs. Overall not for me

This album wouldn't exist without Cher's Believe. With that said, there are some truly fun songs on here if you don't take it too seriously. Afterall, "it's the millennium."

Honestly surprised by how much I enjoyed this. The production was minimal yet polished. The combination of acoustic guitar, house style beats, and pop vocals made for a fun listen. 3.5 / 5

Not very good— some of the beats are actually terrible. The beat in the title track, at the end, is used in an Edward the Confessor song from Sleeping Dogs. That later song is much better. A lot of it sounds like Ratchet and Clank background music.

Did not enjoy this. A couple songs were okay I guess but more than a couple were just straight bad. Production was… creative, but often not enjoyable. I really don’t that this was an album that I needed to hear before I die.

Madonna has some legendary songs. None of the songs in this album are among them.

Als damals Music damals auf dem Markt kam, war ich sehr enttäuscht. Es fällt deutlich ab im Vergleich zu "Ray of Light". Heute bin ich immer noch der Meinung, dass es zu den schwächeren Alben gehört, muss aber feststellen, dass es mir jetzt viel besser gefällt. "Music" und "American Pie" ist immer noch grauenhaft, aber ansonsten ist es sehr gut anzuhören. "I deserve" " Can't Tell you" Weltklasse.

I mean, it's alright

Madonna's extraordinary collaboration with Scottish legend, Hamish the DJ. I've not listened to this album for over twenty years. I remember it being a surprising continuation of the redemption of Madonna after her slippage of the mid 90s. Music is actually a corking track - the bass is thumping and pumping and it leads nicely to Impressive Instant, which is a track that had completely exited my memory until it kicked off with an absolutely wicked four-on-the-floor beat that invigorates me in ways I might even be ashamed of it wasn't so damn good. Clearly Madonna had taken notice of Boris wosshischops' mixing for Moloko's Sing It Back because it's almost the same level of good. Runaway Lover suffers a bit for being too "out there" - it can't support the tempo it sets itself and feels five years too late, missing Prodigy and Kosheen doing this what it tries to, but nowhere near as well. The vocals sound disconnected and that's a shame. We then come onto a bit of a "Can you try and make me sound a bit like Dido?" sort of track in I deserve it, and I'm tempted to skip. In fact, at over four minutes it IS a skip, because it does everything it needs to within about 50 seconds. Amazing, put onto this album in the year 2000, has incredible resonance in late 2024 with "Hagmaxxing" being the word du jour. Madonna was doing it back in the day, Gen Z. Nobody's Perfect is an abomination of vocoding and it gets a skip straight into the "Madonna being a bastard hybrid of Green Day and Cheryl Crow" that is Don't Tell Me, and that almost gets a skip too. It doesn't, but only because I quite like that start/stop thing it does. It's also (weirdly) the most "Madonna-voice" track in the whole recording. And I quite like that. She has actually got a good voice, and it's nice to hear it almost unfettered here. The whole rest of this album can do one, though. Do I know what it feels like for a girl? No, surprisingly. As other commentors here have said, that cover version of American Pie is a pickled turd. Rating this album for the first 2 tracks, it'd get a comfortable 5. It doesn't hold its energy well enough to be more than a 3.

Really not that memorable to me

Strange, poppy music

Fine, dated feeling.

Not for me

Turns out I don't like early 2000s pop style Madonna, who'd have guessed?

I associate this sound with grubby clubs (and not the good kind of grubby)

What a fuckin mess this album is. It’s like they took every shitty trend in pop music in the year 2000, randomly mixed them together and puked out 11 songs hoping a couple of them hit. I guess it’s interesting that an aging pop star/sex symbol tried to revive her career in such an obviously contrived and desperate way…and it actually worked. I mean the album is called “music” and had Madonna in a cowboy hat on the cover for fucks sake and ends with a horrible cover of American Pie. Wait, maybe this is satire and I’m just getting it as I write this. If that’s the case it’s a masterpiece, if it’s a genuine attempt to make good music it’s terrible (though I kind of like Don’t tell me).

1.9 I think I liked the production of this album as whole even if was very busy. If you took of the Maddona name it might rate a half point higher. Impressive Instant was the standout for me, I will listen to that again, everything else there is no chance. The crap songs are crap

apart from the few already known songs, I didn't enjoy it

Madge kicked off her third music decade with a fantastic album. She always found a way. Several stand out songs to me: Music, Don’t Tell Me, and What it Feels Like For a Girl. And…..NOBODY should remake American Pie. Seems an odd choice for this album anyway. It’s a club/disco/electronic album and I’m here for it.

The first couple of songs were slightly interesting in how they were built. Lyrics all kind of throw-away and obviously the whole album is aimed at danceability. But then track six came along and just stomped on everything downgrading the overall status. Madonna can be a competent and creative artist but this as all the hallmarks of having no driving reason to be other than for cash from the market.

Reasonable range of styles

I like Madonna. The Immaculate Collection album is one of my favorite things ever. But whether this album was done by her or somebody else it slides into annoying bad rather than regular bad and it makes my skin crawl in places. Plus her cover of “American Pie” is egregious. 1.5/5

Fun and enjoyable, pop done right

Boring, typical pop. Nothing that has to be heard here.

When one thinks of Madonna albums, one easily thinks of any of her first five; Madonna; Like a Virgin; True Blue; Like a Prayer; and Erotica. those albums are trailblazers and ones that are truly mandatory listens. Music and its one hit that felt like Madonna was reinventing herself… again are okay but not an example of a good portion of her output. 3/5

Utter rubbish from a "has been." Just because an 80s/90s sexual pop star puts out an album (or, album after hackneyed album), doesn't make it good, or even listenable. Gee whiz, artists should be held to a higher standard. These are the albums that make me absolutely abhor corporate record label horsesh*t.

This album was bizarre. Not in a good way. I have never listened to Madonna before, and I’m gonna assume this was the outlier. Product of its time, certainly should not be made now. I liked glimpses of the production, like how some of the chopped instrumentals or samples were, but a lot of it is grating. Some of it feels brilliant and avant-garde. Some of it feels like trash. Can’t pinpoint how it made me feel. Standouts: Music, Runaway Lover, Don’t Tell Me, and Gone.

Listened to this with my husband, on our way up north for a little weekend vacation. I mostly liked it but it did sound pretty dated. I forgot all about the other non-“Music” singles on this.

Pop. Wow I really didn’t like this album. It felt like there were a bunch of do things tried, but all of them were terrible. The whispering, the sudden stops, the auto tune, the cover. There were a couple of okay songs here, but not one I’d recommend.

Didn't I already have this? No wait, that was Ray of Light. Pretty sure we don't need both on this list. This album has some real clunkers and few real triumphs, though I do really like Don't Tell Me for reasons I can't really put my finger on.

Not one of Madonna's finest albums, mediocre at best.

Better than I thought it would be

Better than expected. Some great production flourishes and more interesting subject matters. Sadly it also contains one of the most dogshit cover versions in human history, of American Pie. Impressive as I couldn't think of a way to make that mawkish turd worse myself!

Music is not a good album despite its pretentious ideas to the contrary. For starters it's a weird collection of styles that don't work together, all copycats of late 90s stuff Madonna clearly thought she could use to reinvent herself. Some very generic pop, some piss poor efforts at introducing trance/europop sounds, some embarrassing country-adjacent bits and wtf was she doing with autotune? None of it is cohesive, it's lyrically empty (What It Feels Like For A Girl is *bad*), a couple of songs are passable (Music and Amazing) so it's not downright bad, but the cover of American Pie should have her in The Hague. A low 2 because it didn't disgust me enough to turn it off early and give it a 1.

I find it amusing that "music" is in inverted commas on the album cover - someone at the record label must've had the same opinion of this as me. This is properly bad, no idea why it's made the list when she's made some decent pop in her career. Feels like a midlife crisis album, desperately trying to stay relevant and just getting everything one beat wrong. Like a dad going on his first night on the pull after the divorce, or David Cameron at a football match. 1/5.

Could not finish this one

I remember this being the album where Madonna completely lost me. It just felt like she was trying to keep up with where popular music was going, but it didn't feel like there was much if any of her in the music. Actually sitting down to listen to the album didn't really change my opinion about that. It's fine, but I also can't justify this album making this list. Ray of Light I could understand, but this album feels far too pedestrian to be one of the 1001 albums I should listen to before my execution 3/5

4 yeah this was some pretty solid madonna, 3.5 but i’ll round up

Pre-listening thoughts: listen as bizarre of a pick as this may be I am SO relieved to get Madonna after the onslaught of 90s grunge and indie rock. It’s something different. Post/during listening thoughts: interested why they picked this Madonna album tbh. Like I feel like they should’ve picked True Blue no? But whatever. It’s a weird fusion of genres and has a veryyyy turn of the century electronic feel to it. It’s a little all over the place - maybe this is her Red before Red lol. Upon second listen it’s so camp y’all just don’t get it. Y’all will hate me for saying this but none of yall would be having a BRAT summer if not for this album. This is kinda fire lowkey maybe I should listen to more Madonna 7/10 DID I NEED TO HEAR THIS BEFORE I DIE: nah but there’s some good stuff for pop girlies here Fav tracks: Music, Runaway Lover, I Deserve It, Amazing, Gone Least fav tracks: none tbh

There was a time, 10-15 years before, "Music" when Madonna was a relevant artist. Sometimes controversial, kinda edgy and her songs, videos and persona kept her in the headlines and the charts, because she was an artist that walked the thin line of celebrity, performer and what we would call today, an influencer. I didn't care for her music, actually I couldn't stand her, but I recognize and respect her talent and show(woman)ship. Fast forward to 2000, with the release of "Music", it questions her relevancy. First of all, the music is horrible, the songs are forgettable, on the cover she wears a cowboy hat and glitzy western shirt, the techno-pop beats are repetitious and boring and covering an iconic song, American Pie is unnecessary and embarrassing. Trying to keep up with the times musically has been what I think of Madonna for over the past 20 years and the ride has been amazing bland from someone that constantly seeks our attention. "Music" was almost unlistenable and when the auto-tune kicked in I wanted to turn it off, but clearly I'm a masochist. Essential?...uh NO, garbage...YES!

Not as off-putting as the Yoga-core that Madonna trafficked in on Ray Of Light, “Music”takes its cues from the downtempo and trip-hop of its time. I’m not saying Madonna made an Air record, but…actually, I kind of am saying that, especially now that I hear her singing in French on “Paradise (Not For Me)”.

Not as good as older Madonna

I had visited this album at least one time before to look for something beyond the one radio hit. Revisiting it now, all these years later, presented me with the same profound disappointment at what was hopefully the low water mark of Madonna's career. Paradise is the one exception. It hit me last time and it hit me now. Unlike the rest of the album, it seems to convey a feeling. And there are lyrics as well as instrumentation. For such a great artist who has been so important to Gen X listeners for decades, this one is tough. A single point of light in that one song, depressing as the song is.

Sad and pathetic. Not sure what is worse, fading into the background while music moves forward, or publicly flailing in an effort to emulate a world you used to own but has now surpassed you.

It’s true, music does make the people come together. And I guess sometimes it unites the bourgeois and the rebels. But more often it just lets the bourgeois cosplay as rebels. Just because some rich kids go out to the club and dance with the riff raff to the music of one of the wealthiest artists of all time doesn’t mean they’re gonna wake up from their hangover the next day and try to change the world. It’s all performative and temporary.

Overall Madonna has been maybe the biggest disappointment of any artist on this list. Making a name for herself as a maverick, the song on this album "What it feels like for a girl" just feels empty of any of that rebel spirit. This journey has taught me that I like about one album's worth of Madonna's songs across her whole career. Too band none of those songs are on this album.

This album demonstrates the true power of music industry. Despite containing auto tuned, vapid, genre-less shit, its sound was all over the place and even garnered several Grammy nominations. Critics “loved” it. I don’t buy it for a second. They know who butters their bread. Madonna! If you shone a light on this album it would not cast a shadow because there is no substance.

yeah not for me.

Singlarna är det väl inga fel på men resten är ju blä.

Yeah, I think only like 80's/early 90's Madonna. A couple of good songs; but a bold, stupid title for a mediocre album.

Hate American pie and the title track, but the rest of it is okay.

Much like her face these days, too much filler

Doesn’t belong in the list. Ray of Light would have been a better choice as It was adventurous and more of a radical step for her than “Music” was.

Not her best. her latest reinvention...

Previously rated: Ray Of Light (3/5) *********************** After the first half, I was leaning towards a 4/5. Really solid dance music with some throwback 80s effects. Then the awful auto-tune in Nobody's Perfect and the annoying sound cutting out on the next track Don't Tell Me, I have to take a point off. I'd still rather listen to any of her first four albums.

Never listened all the way through and this is, actually, a banger? Couple of missteps (American pie - why?) but overall it’s a cracker!

Not heard any of this before. It surprised me how different it was to what I'm used to from her. Despite being intriguing the experimental sounds don't pay off on every track. I do like how each track sounds so distinct to the previous one. There were some decent tracks but I think I'd need to listen again to fully get the album. Highlights: Impressive Instant Runaway Lover

An interesting album, I've never heard these Madonna songs before. I liked Music, Amazing, What It Feels Like For a Girl and her version of American Pie.

Madonna 3/3 (after LaP and RoL) HL: “Amazing”, “What It Feels Like For a Girl”, title track Can’t love it, can’t hate it. Exists in a blind spot I have in late 90’s/early aughts pop. Orbit’s work on the track “Amazing” makes me think I underrated his work on Ray of Light. It does anticipate 2000s dance-pop trends as some critics have suggested, but to me they’re all the ones that make me look back and think “what a tacky era of music” But to illustrate my biases, I put on Robyn’s Body Talk (2010) on for the first time the other day, and I don’t think that aged the best either. Would definitely choose that over Madonna’s eighth album on a list of this caliber, though

Bleh. Cept for music

Pretty catchy

So much great music by Madonna, why this album and not one of her first releases?

Gotta agree with Curtis on this one - so many better Madonna albums

Horrible experiencia.

Nunca he sido el más fan de Madonna. No está mal, pero seguro tiene varios mejores. De esos que no entiendo bien que hacen en la lista.

Mixed reaction to this one. I wasn’t looking forward to it when it popped up. However the first bunch of songs I thought were quite good. Unfortunately by the time I hit Nobody’s Perfect the electronically manipulated voice had worn me down and it lost me from that point forward.

The American Pie cover sucks, but there’s some great songs.

Incredibly boring. This only got a pass to be on the list because it's Madonna. Had this been some no-name (probably with a first AND a last name, loser) musician it wouldn't have even been considered.

I know it should be for me, but I just couldn’t get myself into it. A little too bizarre.

Strange overlay between acoustic guitar and techno. Didn’t know where this album was trying to go. And what’s with the cowboy themed cover art

Experimental weird album. The production is crazy. Sounds like they listened to daft punks homework and a bunch of 90s techno. The sings is strange. Madonna is strange. I was interested by this album and could see it being influential but I don’t think it would be accurate to say I liked this album. Bizarre stuff

2 maybe 3 songs that I enjoyed. I did not like the American Pie cover. What was she thinking

Seems like a real throwaway album to me. I really hated the first 4 songs but then it seemed to get a bit more musical. The production is weird because on a lot of songs all the instruments are just part of the rhythm. There's very little instrument carrying the melody or harmony; just thump thump. Many tunes almost sound like house music, probably proto house which is what make this album a little important? And the autotune gets old quickly.

Bunch of random 90s cliches thrown together

Forgettable

I don't think any of Madonna's are really thought of as classic albums she's a singles artist. But THIS is the one I need to hear before I die? Well I tried, it almost turns into a half credible dance album but then comes the god awful electronic country nonsense, a total re-run of 'Beautiful Stranger' and a cover of 'American Pie', to top it all it's got the auto-tune gimmick on it too. Sheesh. OK, 'Don't tell me' is a corker. Fair play. It's only right to have some Madge on this list, but this is a bloody odd choice.

Apparently, this is the last Madonna I'll encounter in this list. Crazy that I didn't have to hear any stuff from her dance-pop era. Instead, I mostly got her wonky attempts at electronic music at least a decade after her prime. What a disappointment.

As much as I dislike electronica, pop and dance music, I have to say this album is very good. Madonna reinventing herself after years of domination and fussioning a ton of different generes to make this experimental album which turned out to be better than ever expected. Dont love any specific song but after listening to it in order without interruptions I can say its a top Madonna album and probably top of that genere. This rates high because of the context of Madonna having to bring something new and different to the table and she brought it. The slow songs kill the vibe mood for me but still those are decent songs.

Not her best, but she reinvents herself each album. The autotune song had to go, though.

Pretty good and free-flowing and mostly fun, this is pretty easy to like now, when Madonna's cynical and continual reaching after relevance far in the rearview. The clubbier cuts that open the record are totally forgettable and mindless (as is anything with auto-tune) but much of the rest works well and has some emotion in it, seemingly. "I Deserve It, ' "Gone" and "Nobody's Perfect" and especially "What It Feels for a Girl" (maybe the best song) almost sound sincere. "Paradise" is also cool. Production mostly holds up, too. Like one said, pretty decent overall, but a grudging 4 (mainly for middle-effort with only a moderately sized amount of cringe).

Not my kind of dance music but she gets props for being an innovator and an icon.

Soo goodd

I got really scared when I saw this album cover because I thought it was just gonna be Madonna doing country badly. After listening to this album I wish it was just that.

🎧I liked Runaway Lover and I Don’t Deserve It even though both drag on a bit too long. Otherwise this album is a stinker. Madonna is, of course, capable of so much better.

7/24/24. Admittedly, this is my first time giving Madonna a true shot. I have to say I liked this one, went in without expectations. Pretty clean and enjoyable pop record, just can't decide if this should be a 3 or a 4. My true rating is a 3.5.

Lots of influences expressed well, with good sound variety. The album starts out really dance-y and shifts to a more trip hop oriented sound in the latter half, with more straightforward pop senses sprinkled in. This transition is a bit awkward, and overall, the cohesion of this album isn't strong. Nevertheless, I enjoyed it and could see myself coming back to it.

Hope there is more Madonna on the list if this is essential. Some bangers though

Favorites Amazing Nobody’s perfect What it feels be like for a girl

The one where Madonna, in a desperate attempt to remain relevant, shamelessly apes anything remotely good about 90's electronic music. It's not even all bad, but so many egregious duds here. Yikes.

"I deserve it" and "amazing" were the best tracks for me, the rest was a bit bland/boring, wasn't what I was expecting from madonna.

Much less worse than anticipated. Holy shit is that American Pie cover the absolute worst thing I've heard in a long time.

The only thing I can say about this is that I listened to this out of the 1,001 albums before I die. That’s about all I can say. Prefer her earlier stuff.

So dance pop is totally not my thing. I hate the overproduction of this album. I hate the terrible autotune that's on most (all?) songs. There is more to making music than synthesized beats, phased shitty drum sounds, and autotuned vocals. That's like the worst kind of album I can imagine. I do like some of the stuff that Madonna did in the 80s and maybe early 90s but this is pretty unbearable. I was close to giving this album an extra star because I rather enjoyed Gone but then American Pie followed. WTF? I have always hated the original version of that song and this has to be some kind of joke. Like how many people heard this before the album was released and none of them thought to say "You know, Madonna, this really is not something to which you should subject the world"? 1/5

It's tough to listen to a Madonna album knowing that there was a time when she'd put out an album where you'd have a good 3 or 4 songs that pulled you right in. There's nothing even bad here, I don't think. It just doesn't have that pull. It's like seeing someone's thumb slip off the pulse of the audience.

A slightly hunched, crabbit Madonna stares us down from the album cover. There is something uncanny about her visage, which is just as well; for half this album she sounds like a glitching android. The other half, well, it's Madonna - she sings with the same expression as most hostages give in proof-of-life videos. That's not to say that there isn't any interest in 'Music'. In fact, as a studio confection there's plenty to enjoy, Madonna and her producers throwing the entire box of tricks at almost every tune going. Just as well, because beneath the bells and whistles are some rather cookie cutter melodies and uninspired song craft. However, I'm almost missing the point here - 'Music' very much is a collection of gaudy sounds and aural gewgaws - it's tinsel all the way down, boys.

I’ve always discounted this album as auto-tune early-2000s bad dance music. After listening to it properly I still don’t like this Madonna like I do 80s Madonna, but it kind of works together and she hadn’t changed as much as I thought. It’s weird they auto-tune her sometimes when she can clearly sing. Probably needs another listen, sadly I don’t have time. I have discovered it has a French producer so another example of French EDM seeming to be not my thing. Fave Track: I Deserve It Rating: 3

Das Nachfolgealbum von "Ray of Light" ist im Vergleich zu steril, zu perfekt produziert, irgendwie ohne Seele. Allein schon die Coverversion "American pie" kommt gar nicht an das Original heran und ist seelenlos. Dennoch spricht der Mut von Madonna, einen Stilwechsel vorzunehmen, für sie. Countrymusik ist in dieser Form auch für das jüngere Publikum gut erreichbar

I can see how some people might enjoy the album.

muito sad girl, mas extremamente coeso

3/5. These are some solid electronic pop songs. I do hear the genre bending, and I think it works for a lot of the faster songs but when it slows down, it's hard to really follow and enjoy for some of them. There is even some influence from Alt Rock, R&B, country that I can hear. It's unique and enjoyable but I don't think it's perfect. It might go up in rating on more listens, which I do want to do, but don't think I super enjoyed it save for some songs. Best Song: Music, What It Feels Like For A Girl, Paradise (Not For Me)

There was one song that didn't make me want to rip my headphones off.

This is all a bit low key but not in a bad way. Just more emphasis on her pure vocals I feel like. Really chill and enjoyable listen! 4.5

Vallan kuunneltava levy. Onneksi American Pie on viimeisenä, erinomainen nostatus loppuun. Aika metallinen soundi, se on Madonnalla läpi uran läsnä vaikka muuten monipuolinen onkin.

Avaus on helpon tuntuinen mutta pirun tehokas: yksi kuuntelu ei riitä. Jos viehättyisin enemmän aikakauden elektronisesta tarkkuudesta, kuuntelisin loputkin uudelleen. Toimiva LP.

Must be the first Madonna album I’ve ever listened too

it’s a mess but a decent one

I do not like Madonna and I never have, and I can’t say I particularly enjoyed this either. However, the influence on the next decade of pop music, for better or worse, cannot be denied here. It’s definitely a relic of its time and has not aged well. The American Pie cover is something that I had memory holed, and damn, it’s really bad.

Don’t have to much to day about this one! A fine listen

Coolt men lite långtråkigt

Madonna never had a great voice and her 80s pop wasn’t great, but is classic 80s. The newer stuff is much worse. Could not get through 4 songs

Madonna’s hit or miss for me. She has some great albums and great music, but this one is just so… boring. Not at all like her great synthpop from the 80s, or dancy trip hop Ray of Light released just before this album, or the later disco-esque Confessions on a Dance Floor. Music is just so much lamer than what she's capable of.

First Madonna album I've listened to. It was fine.

I remember a time - it must have been the mid 80s to mid 90s - when a new Madonna album was a sensation. But that ship had sailed by 2000, when this album came out, and apart from American Pie (which is a cover) and maybe Music, it only contains pop tracks that about betray the time when they were produced. 2/5

The music is so overproduced and loaded up with auto-tune and voice effects that it really could have been sung by anyone at all. In addition, it's enough to listen to the first 30 seconds of any of the tracks and you'll have heard the entire song. The entire endeavor is devoid of any personality. Sure, for Madonna this may be consider re-inventing things. But it's just a switch from manufactured-to-death 80's pop to manufactured-to-death 00's pop. I was prepared to give this 2 stars as most of it is inoffensive background muzak. But then the atrocious American Pie cover hit me like a personal insult.

Pop music. Over produced. Some people love it. This is the first time I’ve ever purposefully listened to Madonna. It sounded exactly how I thought it would.

In which Madonna attempts to simultaneously ride Brittney Spears' and Shania Twain's waves

Has a few highlights but a fairly boring and derivative 2000s pop album. Not close to her best work and notas bad as her worst.

This wasn't bad.

The second album in Madonna's maturity phase. We've got some millennium pop optimism going on but it has actually aged better than some of the other albums from this era. A few solid songs make this a good collection.

There are a few duds on this. It's mostly really good though.

This album made quite a comeback for me... It started out pretty bad but really enjoyed the mid to back end of the record. I still prefer the earlier Madonna album, Like a Prayer, but pleasantly surprised.

One the one hand, this project has given me an excuse to engage with Madonna's career; on the other, I'm now well versed enough in Madonna to rank this album as quite inessential.

Oh dear, very cringy. Giving off big “cool auntie” energy - “hey kids, I’m 42 but I still make dance music and take mandy”. The odd bit of good song writing (mostly Don’t Tell Me) just about saves this from the one star club.

God, auto tune is cringe, and the American Pie cover? Woof. Two for some okay tracks but so much better Madonna albums out there.

★★½

Siempre al día.

Not even going to try and listen to this one

Yes, discazo. Aunque igual me gusta harto Ray of Light

y’all. what are you doing. Dont Tell Me is better than Music.

MY FAVOURITE MADONNA ALBUM (and the first one that this generator has generated for me)! I was thinking of this album just earlier today! This album is an excellent exploration of electronic music, building on the experimentation of ‘Ray of Light’ (widely acclaimed as her best). Of course, it contains the monster hit ‘Music’, alongside plenty of deep cuts with important messages, such as ‘What it Feels Like for a Girl’ and ‘I Deserve It’. I’m unsure why there is so much Madonna hate on here. Perfect arrangements and fantastic vocal technique. The influence on every single pop song from the 2000s should not be underestimated. To paraphrase another review, it sounds like the quintessential 2000s album because it influenced plenty of albums from the 2000s, despite this being the third decade of her career. Unpopular opinion: Madonna’s cover of *that* song is better than the original 😘 10/10

This is an interesting one because I always knew that Madonna went through a bunch of reinventions in the 90s and 00s through pop culture osmosis but I’ve never actually listened to an example of it. This was an interesting first time because it’s wildly different from her 80s music and is just unique in general since it tries to fuse both country and electronica. Sometimes it really works (paradise) and sometimes it really doesn’t (American pie cover) but it was a surprisingly fascinating listen either way.

No he escuchado un disco de Madonna en mi vida, sus canciones en la radio y la MTv por supuesto que sí. Cero interés, conocía algunas canciones, pero no puede ser menos interesante. Lo mejor es que me han entrado ganas de escuchar American Pie. Le voy a dar 2 estrellas.

This is not a preferred genre in my rotation, but I do recognize the cultural significance of the artist, and have much respect for the way she has been able to reinvent herself and evolve continuously to maintain relevance for 40 years. All that said, this album pales in comparison to everything she did leading up to this release. The two singles merit and I can see where they achieved mainstream success. There rest is average at best IMO. 2.5/5

I thought I was gonna be like a virgin when listening to this one since I really don’t know much of her songs outside of the hits. But then around track six I heard that stupid Cher-inspired autotune vocal modulation effect and I realized I wasn’t being touched for the very first time. I liked the acoustic meets electronic element on some tracks, but outside of the two known singles it all just started to sound the same.

This just faded into the background for me. And I don’t really mean that as a good thing. I guess it was offensive to my ears but was just kinda meh

The fact that THIS Madonna album is on the list makes me think we have another 2-3 Madonna albums to go... she has never been my favorite and not sure why it was selected to represent her catalog. I did enjoy Music and Don't Tell Me, but the rest is kinda meh (especially when she leans heavily on Autotune). 2.5/5

This is the worst one so far. So dated and just a cacophony of sound. The lyrics are on par with Kirk van Houten's "Can I Borrow a Feeling?" I hated every second I had to listen to this.

Not to my taste

First time I have listened to a full Madonna's album(or maybe a second one, after Like a Virgin) and I instantly regret it. Three singles are pretty good, revoking some good memories, but the rest of the album is so terrible, I can't even think of it anymore. The auto tune songs are so bad, I actually did a double take if it's a real thing. In case of Madonna - only listen to singles from now on.

First track is gorgeous

1.5 stars. Dated songs and dodgy lyrics. One weirdly decent track (paradise).

Not her best

Perfectly good.

Some of these songs are way too long

Not her best album. The 80's techno vibe was really weak. Didn't age well

It's alright but doesn't grab me

some decent, some poorer I liked the instrumental parts more than her singing

Very techno. Second song is a no no. Third song is not much better. Fourth lookin ok? Still weird,weird album. I think I might like Nobody’s Perfect 3/10

This sounds like a mix of electropop and general acoustic pop. I don't really know why it's on the list since it isn't one of Madonna's essential albums, as far as I understand. "Paradise (Not For Me)" is a great track, though.

Appareently, the title track was released as a single, but I don't remember hearing it or anything else from this forgettable album. Interesting, but insipid, cover of Don McLean's "American Pie".

Dont Tell Me is good, and I would listen to a Madonna country album in a heartbeat, but the rest is not so much. I dont know if it was an experiment to try a bunch of different stuff but it falls fairly flat. Also she gets points for all the anger stirred up by her American Pie cover.

I mean… it’s Madonna doing euro club music. On paper that sounds like an album I wouldn’t like. “Don’t Tell Me” earns it an entire star on its own but other than that this is a hard pass for me

one banger could i write poetry to this? n

Not one of the Madonna albums I would have chosen for this list. "Don't Tell Me" and "What It Feels Like for a Girl" are great songs, but the rest of it left me a bit flat. Two and one-half stars, with the half-star being a bonus in honor of Pride Month. This half-star will be revoked in July.

Thanks to this list I've listened to enough electronic albums to know that there's nothing special about this album other than Madonna released it

Nothing on here that I want to revisit, but not bad.

Liked this a lot. Talented lady singing about her boyfriends and break ups a bit like Ray of Light but not quite as good

Ágætt stöff. Alls ekki hennar besta.

I expected this to be a lot better as I remember really liking Don’t Tell Me at the time Turns out I only liked Don’t Tell Me

Way below earlier Madonna output. 2/5

Madonna has had one of the most successful, enduring careers in modern music. Music is her eight studio album, and a significant departure from the pop singles that made her famous. This collection of tracks are closer to dance and electronica than her earlier work. This is a surprisingly good album, with memorable tracks like "Don't Tell Me."

I am not the biggest Madonna fan, but I really enjoyed this album. Ray of Light is definitely my favorite album of hers, and I like that Music sonically carries over part of that aesthetic. It does sound a bit dated here and there, but I didn't really mind that. For me, the highlights on this album are the "ballads" - such as What It Is Like For A Girl, Paradise (Not for Me), and Gone.

The title track is a fun song, very catchy. Don’t Tell Me may be the best song on the album. There is a reason these two songs were the singles over the rest of the album. The remainder veer from generic dance music, to just bland, or moderately catchy but forgettable. Overuse of autotune abounds in these tracks. What it Feels Like for a Girl is atrocious. I get what she is trying to do, but this missed the mark. America Pie should be considered a war crime; it is terrible. 2

not a big fan, in fact, i despise this album. awful title

I really expected better from such a renowned pop icon. I get that she needs to evolve and change her sound, but Jesus fucking Christ. Half of this album is just boring and repetitive, and when it's not being boring it's just weird experimentation, and not in a good way. And I feel like that album title is trying to compensate for something, because half the songs on this album don't even feel like music. They are just a random assortment of sounds that nobody asked for.

Some hits I remember and still enjoy. Pseudo-experimental sound but also feels dated and sonically trendy for 2000. Some beautiful poetry mixed in between some cheesy lyrics.

You cannot call this... monstrosity "Music." It is laughably absurd and too 'experimental' for even electronic music today.

Except for Music and Don’t Tell Me, I never heard any of the other tracks. Auto tune seemed to be the trend for this album which was disappointing.

Much respect for Madge. Seventeen years into her career and she puts out an album that shows she can still bring it to the dance floor with solid club bangers. For me, this album is below her 80s classics but just below; the strength being the production quality. A nice mid-career release showing she still had a lot in the tank.

Wow this has aged terribly. The thin drums, the autotune. Grand aspirations that fell so so flat. 1.5/5

album wasn’t bad, i’d just say it was decent, the title track was good, and there was an empowering feel in the music, overall the music didn’t blow me away but i respect madonna for her influence

Super poppy, not a huge fan of Madonna but a couple of these tracks aged well imo (better than others) 2.7

Woof this did not age well. Don't Tell Me is still cool, but Music which was the lead single is awful. Didn't love it back in 2000 and definitely like it less now. And that American Pie cover sucks, but then again, nothing could ever come close to Weird Al's version.

Pretty awful album but I still can't give it a 1. It's soulless and the single "Music" isn't good today and wasn't when it was released. This doesn't even compare to Madonna's greatest hits like Material Girl, Like a Prayer, Like a Virgin and so on. Those are timeless classics. Oh and she also completely butchers American Pie.

I really like Madonna and it was nice listening to this album again. There are some really good and clever songs on this album. It has a nice feel to it. I wish it ended a little stronger as I don't really care for the last couple of songs as much as I do the others. I will try to listen to them more and see if they grow on me.

I did not enjoy this at all. Some songs I absolutely hated, and there were 1 or 2 that were just ok, but overall I would not want to listen to this again.

Boring, except I liked one song alright: "Paradise (Not for Me)" sorta had some triphop vibes, and I enjoyed that. Wish it were more of that. The rest is either bad or entirely forgettable. 1.5/5

Kinda surprised that Music was picked, this really feels like M was chasing the trends instead of forming them. Additionally, William Orbit’s production doesn’t really hold up. But, this is the first Madonna era I really remember- I knew who she was and some of her older songs, but I vividly recall hearing and seeing the videos for the title track and “Don’t Tell Me” often. So there’s definitely nostalgic attachment to it, even if this isn’t her best. C

very good album showcasing Madonna's ability to stay relevant and unique.

Wasn't expecting to see Madge pop up again. I suppose this album is evocative of very specific moment in pop culture when she was still relevant and not yet completely cringeworthy. (I say this as someone who went through a HUGE Madonna phase, and did in fact see her on tour in 2004). She did do a bit of a country western aesthetic revival that influenced early aughts fashion. Music and Don't Tell Me were both hits with memorable music videos that got lots of rotation on MuchMusic and/or MTV. It's what I expected though, the hits are hits and they still slap but the rest of this album is boring filler. There isn't anything edgy or exciting here. It's basic pop drivel. I do still love the classic or canon Madonna eras (1983-2005) and respect what she's done as an artist. But everything she's done after Confessions on a Dance Floor has been embarrassing to witness. I don't want to be ageist, BUT, I do wish she'd chosen to age a bit more gracefully like Cher has and act in a way befitting an icon; a way that doesn't diminish her legacy the way all the "edgy" lingerie, grills, and face filler are doing now.

Quite a bit of musical genres in this one. Another end of college days for me. Know the album well.

"Nobody's Perfect," indeed. This felt formulaic and tired.

Good enough to just have playing in the background and ignore.

Late Madonna album. Obviously knew the songs that made the radio. In listening to it through, I was not hating until it got to the one that was all autotune. I despise autotune. For that reason, I knock it down from 3 to 2 starts.

Auto-tune garbage

Wow the opening track took me right back to that time. I like this because it’s basically an electronic album featuring Madonna. Producers deserve title credits!

A surprisingly good album and love Mirwais’ contribution. It’s very clear eyed and stark in its intention to be a good pop album, and it hits all the right marks - well balanced, not too long and with a few good modernish Madonna hits.

Following her electro-pop success of Ray of Light, we see similar creativity and excellent electronic production on this record. This one is brighter, faster, and louder. It's also more traditional of a pop album than Ray of Light, which I think serves as a weakness. It's more predictable and it seems like the music is disjoint from Madonna's singing. She also shows less personality and emotion in these songs. The first 3 tracks are a strong start and gives you an idea what this album should have been. Instead, it takes a turn from there with 3 lame tracks: a lifeless ballad, a generic dance tune, and a Cher-level autotune disaster that drags on for 5 minutes of the same line over and over. "Don't Tell Me" is the only song that fits the "cowgirl" design she was going for, with a pleasant blend of electronic, pop, and country that doesn't go too crazy. The following track is some dreamy downtempo, a bit boring and repetitive but also pleasant. "Paradise" is the most creative song and could definitely fit on Ray of Light. And finally, "Gone" is an underwhelming but fitting closer. In comparison to Ray of Light, I do feel it's less consistent and less innovative. The highs don't reach the same, and the lows are just awful. But you do still have top-of-the-notch production skill, and there is quite a bit of surprising innovation throughout.

Seems only tangentially related to Madonna. Could have been anyone singing these tracks. I think I had heard 2 of the songs on here before. It was inoffensive and forgettable but okay for what it is.

It sounds like Madonna is singing in front of the soundtrack to a Matrix film. It's forgettable, repetitive, and unusual in a bad way. I can't believe this is the artist that did "Material Girl." It's like the studio just had some background music and asked Madonna to sing exactly ten voice lines so they could auto tune it and cash out.

I laughed, I cried, I pissed myself. A placeholder album. Low-effort, I’m-it-for-the-paycheck energy I went and listened to Madvillainy upon finishing this one, just so that the day’s listening wasn’t a waste.

Listened Before? N Ehhhhh.. not sure what this is doing here especially when I haven't seen any of her earlier work on the list. Music the song is okay but the rest was meh. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Music

This is awful, the cover of American pie is possibly the worst thing I've heard. Such a surprise as the last 2 Madonna albums I got both got 5's. She can clearly sing, but why on earth she decided to (what I assume is) autotune the hell out of her voice is beyond me

Better than I remember

I never really liked her music...

¿En serio esto uno de los 1001 mejores discos?

Of all the Madonna, why is this one to make the list

Like an Oscar going to an actor who was just okay in a role but everyone now agrees was really good in something a few years ago, music critics love nothing better than pretending a late period album by a once great artist is something other than garbage. Sorry critics, I’m not falling for it. Madonna was a force of nature from ‘83 to ‘89 but this sucks.

By 2000, Madonna was not really relevant to the popular music scene. She had effectively been dethroned as pop goddess by artists like Britney Spears. She hadn't had a number one album since 1989. This album was an effort to conform to the times. It relies on heavily electronic production. Do not be deceived by the cowgirl album cover - none of this is country. Lots of electronic-based production and autotune experimentation. It certainly hasn't aged well and comes off as a desperate cash grab with almost completely meaningless lyrics in many of the songs. It seemed to have worked, though, as this album was pretty successful upon its release. What was interesting to me were some of the more R&B inspired tracks such as "Amazing" and "What it Feels Like for a Girl". I can't say this album didn't keep me interested.

It’s Madonna. Of course it is good. Quite a few memorable hits including on of my favorite Madonna songs, “Nobody’s Perfect.” 4/5

Have heard Music and Don’t tell me and the rest aren’t too far behind….

bis auf Music und American Pie solala

I guess I don't like Madonna... Favourite track: I Deserve It.

pretty bad. American Pie was the only good song. 2/5

Najbolje pjesme: 1. Don't Tell Me

Surprisingly unremarkable for Madonna

I am conflicted with Madonna. On the one hand I think she has pushed boundaries and refuses to be a quiet woman, for which she should be applauded. On the other hand, I find her a bit embarrassing. She seems a bit like one of those girls from school who keeps posting about how they can still fit in their cheerleading outfit. Her emphasis on her looks contradicts the female positive message she sends. Then there’s the music. Meaningful lyrics? Never heard of her! (Although her early work was much more intelligible). I wish Madonna would stop trying to be something and just be Madonna.

Nostalgia is a powerful drug. This was one of the car CDs of family holidays and also my feminist awakening

This was quite fun despite some very odd production in places. The songwriting wasn’t quite as strong as the previous Madonna albums on this list (Like a Prayer and Ray of Light), and I’m surprised this made it on over something like True Blue. It was a good time though, even if a bit inconsistent

nowhere near as good as Like a Prayer. don’t love the more “modern” vibe she went for here. not bad though just not good

very 2000 sounding production, sometimes veers into S-Club but a couple of solid smashes in there

3 --- Excelente calidad de grabación y producción. Salvo por los éxitos, los demás tracks son de relleno

Yes. Of course I'm a sucker for Madonna. It seems like I'm a 4-star girly on this platform. I enjoyed myself just fine with this album. Not as good as Confessions on a Dancefloor of course, but a fun listen anyways.

What it feels like for a girl er best, Don't tell me er fínt og American Pie hefur sinn sjarma þrátt fyrir ég fíli originalinn betur. Hitt er ágætur filler.

DO NOT BE FOOLED: THIS IS NOT MADONNA'S COUNTRY ALBUM. IN FACT SHE HAS NEVER DONE A COUNTRY ALBUM. Madonna's entry into the 2000's after Ray of Light was bold and brash (more like belongs in the trash!) When pop stars such as Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera, and Jessica Simpson were modeling their careers after her, Madonna was choosing to innovate and experiment with her own music. The result is a mix of house, folk, downtempo, and other diverse sound influencing her approach to electropop. The result is a mixed bag where some songs definitely work better than others. I commend Madonna for being so willing to evolve and attempting to synthesize new elements. It's just that some parts of the album come across as painfully dated, and the American Pie cover should've been dropped.