Reviews (page 16 of 16)
I can't lie, I'm biased against Green Day. I rather like this album. But, I just can't get past all the discussions I had with people describing punk music and why Green Day, is not punk. I know, I'm shallow.
classic. easy 4. almost a 3 cause overplayed
Better than I remembered it to be. There's plenty of amazing hits while the rest of the album is rather consistently good. The quality dips a little at the end but that might be just me not enjoying too long albums which this is one of those.
Grew up listening to Green Day, needed to be a 5
It is so nice to see these nice young boys cracking the glass ceiling and assimilating with the rest of us. Have you ever been to the opera, or the theatre? Well, this record is so nice, I'd like to extend an invitation. What's that, you say? Oh, yes! We DO like money but the idea of a broadway show based on this album is absolutely preposterous. Oh, that's a hoot! Well, sure. Go ahead and try. Sure, it IS a good album, you're right, but ... Oh! Oh, YES! We hate George W. Bush too. Oh I see, yeah. Yeah, theatre audiences hate him as well. Ok, YES! You've sold me. Let's do it. Good on you, sir. This will be jolly fun...
Look, we all loved some "Dookie." It was dumb punk fun. But we're not gonna pretend that Green Day didn't go gradually downhill from there in their next several albums. There were some hits in there, but nothing that hinted that they had "American Idiot" in them. I don't think Green Day was taken very seriously before "American Idiot." They were a raucous punk band, but mainstream enough to be MTV darlings and probably the band most responsible for the unfortunate wave of pop-punk of the late 90s and early 00s. (Take a star off for that if you want.) But holy crap was "American Idiot" ambitious. And I think it's the best they've ever sounded. (Who knows, maybe I would eat my words if I went back and listened to all of "Insomniac" or "Nimrod.") They cleaned up and polished their sound, and while that may sound bad for a punk band, they pulled it off so well. Regardless of any concept in the story or lyrics, Green Day really matured sonically. The punk is still there, but the songs are varied, well-structured, with great build and rise-and-fall throughout. You may not love Billy Joe's voice - it's nasally and a bit whiny - but I think you can tell here that he is becoming a better singer. It's really a great album, start to finish. It may not be the Great American Novel of the 21st century, but it's a solid concept with good lyrics for a vaguely political punk album. And it became a musical! Are Green Day sell-outs? Or did they just perfect what they do and be accepted for it?
While I personally prefer Dookie overall (what a sentence!), American Idiot is a very strong album, with Green Day maturing into a band that matters. Billie Joe has a very unique voice, one that entirely fits the sound of the band and the POV of the song lyrics. In listening to the whole piece, it's clear that the band intended as a concept album and is no surprise that it has done well as a rock opera/musical. The stories & characters in the songs are compelling, and the music (unfortunately) tips over sometimes into musical theatre tropes. There are a few tracks that make me think the band was aiming a little too high, but it's hard to fault their ambition. I'm very interested in listening to this again, closer, to glean more from it.
Riley says 5 stars and I agree. I have a soft spot in my heart for pop punk and Green Day does it better than anyone. Jesus of Suburbia is like a microcosm of the whole album, a tiny pop punk rock opera all on its own. Even if you don’t love them, you have to appreciate the ambition here.
One of the small things I appreciate about Green Day is their ability to blend the end of one song into the beginning of the next (Jink to Haushinka anyone). Being that Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming are each 5 songs in one, they do it several times in a row. It really is an underrated skill. St. Jimmy sounds alot like their early 90s stuff: fast and hard yet accessible. Give Me Novacaine is part the old sound (chorus) and something I can’t quite put my finger on (verses). My oh my the verses sound like a dreamy 50s song. I’m in between on this album. I really like it, but I don’t love it yet. I would like to keep listening.
Ein großes Lob ans saubere Handwerk; super produzierte Songs; vielleicht hat man sich an den technischen Möglichkeiten so sehr ergötzt, dass man vergaß, ein paar seiner Darlings zu killen. Was zur Völlerei am Punkrock Stick noch etwas komisch hinzukommt, ist der Jeckyll/Hyde Gestus des radiotauglichen Stadion-Materials, das auf sehr schmalzige Art sellout säuselt. Chris Martin gibt mehr als 1.6
Ich wünsche Green Day per se alles Gute. Gute Jungs, Erfolg verdient, Power-/Pop-Punk ist voll ok. Fühle mich halt nur nicht so angesprochen von denen, aber muss ja auch nicht. Zu dieser Platte: super Anliegen, der Protest gegen die Bush-Regierung, die Neocons und alles was sie natürlich weiterhin falsch und nur schlimmer gemacht haben. Sie hätte noch viel viel mehr Gehör verdient gehabt als sie immerhin schon hatte, aber der Kamp geht weiter. Ich bin halt nur kein Fan von Musicals, und für Konzeptalben reicht meine Aufmerksamkeitsspanne in der Regel auch nicht wirklich. Trotzdem: irgendwie möchte ich Props dafür geben. Deshalb: auch wenn mich das musikalisch nicht so reizt, bekommen diese kalifornischen Toten Hosen die Punkte, die man für die simple Idee und Umsetzung ruhig mal geben darf. Und den guten Wunsch, dass es sich irgendwann auch auszahlt.
It is amazing what they do with 3 or 4 chords. Good record.
I liked it more than I thought I would given its genre. That being said, it doesn't adhere to past albums or the genre of "punk." The lyrics have that spirit, but the music sounds more like pop or pop rock rather than punk. Overall though, it was a decent experience. Favorite track: Jesus of Suburbia
While their earlier work is a lot more poignant and relatable, the first few tracks of American Idiot are pretty good. The thing about this point on in Green Day's discography is that they will write maybe 1-2 good songs and then phone it in for the rest of the album. That's pretty much what happens here. Most of the tracks are very vague about antiestablishment/anarchist views, but American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, and Holiday/Boulevard are some great doomer-minded anarchist songs. The rest of the album can really just be thrown directly in the trash. Wake Me Up When September Ends doesn't really feel like it belongs on this album, and I honestly thought it was on Twenty One Guns or Nimrod, but it definitely solidified that Green Day could phone in their earlier punk talents for radio bullshit. Oh my god... there's even fake clapping added to track 6. This band fell so hard. It's like Weezer, but at least Weezer has had redeemable moments in the last decade. Highlights: 1, 2, and 3.
I will always love this album despite the 2nd half being a tad weaker than the first few songs.
Liked this a lot more than I remember liking it when it came out.
\m/
Better than expected. Close 4
Some transitions on this album are simply incredible (Holiday/Boulevard of broken dreams). Themes of american society, I can't really relate with. But the music is iconic.
Perhaps I’m just rating it highly because I lived in the East Bay for so long, but this album seriously holds up after 17 years. A punk rock opera was genius then and is genius now
few bangers on it
This is not my favorite. Top tracks Holiday Wake me up when September ends
Been touring this album for 15+ years and that's alright. Good stuff.
38. Quase não se vê a merda do castelo com tanto nevoeiro. As luzes da ponte são fumo à distância. Fumo fumo. Fumo. Merda para estas subidas até aos bombeiros. Estamos tão falidos que o nosso sistema educativo nem consegue pôr umas chapas de amianto por cima das nossas cabeças. É provisório, para sempre. Nunca mais como n'As Massas. Não me caíram bem. Talvez tenha sido dos nervos quando ela me pegou na mão a brincar, ou será que não era, tinha de ser, só pode, nunca na vida ela, mas será que, nah, deves estar louco. Idiota. O álbum ficou em casa. MotA: American Idiot "Don't wanna be an American idiot"
This album is terrible.
Ok, not great
3.75
Nostalgic bliss
I've had heard the hits, but never the full album. Every song is good or a masterpiece, it's a very solid album.
love the in beat - entertained heard this song - popular relatable like it, not my style though, would listen monthly or weekly if appeared on radio :)
Rating: 10/10 Best songs: all
Still one of the best concerts I ever saw was their American Idiot tour. I also still know most of the lyrics as I listened along. Jesus of Suburbia is still a classic and forever will be.
super kickass hooky melodic pseudo punk genius
Bops start to finish. Brother's favourite/10
Its punk rock, babyyyy
Already have heard it’s a good concept album
GOOD THROWBACK
The high water mark for Green Day and possibly all pop-punk.
This album was… ok. It wasn’t my favorite but I didn’t hate it either. The only tracks I really enjoyed were the singles they’ve dropped when this album came out. It was plain and lacking a spark that I look for in music. Top tracks: American idiot, Give me Novacaine, Wake Me Up When September Ends
one of my personal favorite albums. great songs from front to back.
Still awesome!
Ball buster of an album! Absolutely BRILLIANT
Absolutely fantastic album that is a highlight of Green Day’s career. I love so much of this album and have for as long as I can remember.
Great piece of American music.
Pour ceux qui me demandent régulièrement des nouvelles de crisduss, il a été éjecté du groupe à quelques semaines de la fin du générateur. Sa page a été suspendue par Robert qui a envoyé ses hommes saisir les derniers meubles à son domicile. Personne ne sait où il se trouve à l'heure actuelle.
Troglodytes
Very very awesome Album!!!
I think I've heard all of Dookie (it was everywhere in '94). I own Nimrod ('97). I had heard "American Idiot", "Boulevard of Broken Dreams", and "Wake Me Up When September Ends" off of this album, but that might be it. I liked the album. I'd listen to it again.
Good shit I really like it especially Septemeber
É Green Day, não tem muito o que dizer. No limiar entre o bom e o ruim
un grand classique, rien a voir avec par exemple The Doors
Так, ну че. Альбом с двумя главными хитами Грин Дея. Плюс не раз встречал мнение, что вообще один из главных альбомов роцка нулевых, шедевр и все такое. Ну к этому вернемся ещё, давайте про хиты сначала, поскольку с ними я был знаком и до прослушивания. Wake Me Up When September Ends — эта параша мне никогда не нравилась. Да, я ещё раз оговариваюсь, что это просто не для меня делалось и не для таких как я. Но здесь я всё же хочу заметить, что это делалось вообще не для людей, интересующихся музыкой. Это просто продукт консьюмеризма, как например старбакс или ЭйчЭндЭм. В эти места ходят люди, которые не интересуются настоящим кофе или хорошей одеждой, это просто популярное место, где можно быстро и недорого затариться и забыть. Вот эта песня — такой же безликий коммерческий продукт, которую можно послушать по радио в машине, если музыка для тебя это просто фон. Я почти уверен, что даже человек, имеющий плохой (субъективно) музыкальный вкус, но при этом имеющий неподдельную страсть к музыке (бля, синонимов не завезли особо) не станет всерьез утверждать, что это хорошее произведение. Не раздражающее — да. Но безликое, аморфное и пустое. Boulevard Of Broken Dreams — по сути не сильно отличается от предыдущего, но здесь хотя бы более-менее бодрого ритма завезли, что можно реально пойти, например, по улице и подумать «ебать, иду по бульвару прям как в песне, хыы». Да, я знаю, что песня не про бульвар, мне похуй. В остальном же — наитипичнейший пост-гранж по типу, ну я не знаю, группы Никельбэк. Такого говна в нулевые было навалом, вообще деваться некуда, это возможно один из самых броских представителей. Но лучше от этого не становится. Теперь по остальному материалу. Я, признаться, был даже удивлен немного тому, что я там наслушал. Потому что помимо двух вышеуказанных хитов (и ещё нескольких унылых баллад по типу Novocain) содержимое представляет собой какое-то дичайшее бесструктурное месиво из рандомных панковых риффов (не очень-то и запоминающихся), крикливого вокала, бесконечных «хей-хей, оу-оу-о» спорадических изменений темпа (по ощущениям как минимум раза два-три в каждой песне) и прочего непотребства. Я хз, что там с лицами у тех, кто на это дрочит, но господа. Я ожидал обычного плаксивого поп-панка для баб, это он и есть по большей части (только с политическим мессажом ещё, уууу клятый буш), только куда попс-то проебали? Ну от такой музыки ждёшь, что как минимум запоминаться будет, напеваться там постоянно. А по итогу ну во время прослушиваний я ещё мог вычленить для себя, где хук, а где куплет, но сейчас вообще ничего, кроме уже слышанных ранее хитов, вспомнить не могу. Или это новый для меня по звучанию арт-альбом? Всё же сомневаюсь. По итогу что? Ну имеем довольно средний поп-панк, если честно. Жанр и так опущенный и петушиный, и Грин Дею реабилитировать его не удалось (я для себя немного надеялся). Чтобы совсем уж хейтером не слыть поставлю 5/10 — примерно так и ощущается, иногда норм, слушается, иногда прям бесить начинает, ибо все песни идут ёбаную вечность, и я зачастую вообще никакой логики в них найти не мог. Как-то так.
Да это же лучший жанр, поп-панк! Стоит, вероятно, немного пояснить за отношение к коллективу. Узнал где-то в период своего роцкерского становления на A-One. Вероятно, сразу после клипа на Бульвар поставил ярлык недорока для школьниц и боле шанса даже не давал. Ещё негатив подкрепился тем, что именно Green Day стали единственной "современной" (на тот момент) группой, удостоившейся собственной игры с пластиковыми гитарами. То есть встали рядом с Metallica, The Beatles, AC/DC, Aerosmith и Van Halen, отчего я немного негодовал. Посему в ближайшем окружении хейтил. Спустя годы выкупил прикол панка так какового, да и поп-панка в частности. Енто позволяэ как-то иначе взглянуть на творчество коллектива. На самом деле альбом сделал мои выходные, грубо говоря. Возможно, тут можно говорить о явлении, когда кто-то испытывает ностальгию по тому, чего в жизни и не было. Тупа веет яркой молодостью. Издали думал, что альбом является где-то первым-третьим с основания группы, мол в начале запилили, хайпанули, а потом паразитируют на начальных успехах. Но, сука, альбом то седьмой и запилен через 18 лет после основания! Уже подобное вызываэ увожение. Аналогия навскидку проводится разве что с пристовским Паникулёром. Чё там по трекам... На самом деле, прослушивание на 4-5-е выкупаешь, что все хорошие. Хотел сказать, что к концу явно просаживается, но то, что опосля Whatsername - цэ, оказывается, бонус-треки. Не, реально, как-то всё в единое концептуальное полотно выстраивается с сопоставимой степенью качёвости, из которого вырывать что-то отдельное и не хочется особо. Разве что 3 "главных" трека: есессна, заглавный, Бульвар и Сентябрь. Заглавный ранее казался недостаточно цепляющим, чтобы быть цепляющим при своей лаконичности. Но ныне, особенно в рамках альбома, звучит вполне достойно. К Бульвару сохранился немного школьный негатив, наименее живой трек на альбоме. Звучание веет словом "коммерческий". Ну типа а вдруг так вышло просто? Написался трек, как и остальные, но там продюссеры подсуетились, давайте ща стерильности наведём, сотни нефти подымем. Ну типа а чё бы и нет. Возможно, один из тех треков, по котором публика знакомится с исполнителем, а, прошарившись, не особо и ценит. Но трек в целом всё же хороший. Сентябрь, возможно, даже и не слышал ранее. Разве что фрагменты где-нить, да и то не точно. И прям чёт сразу пропёрся. Этот рек всё же достаточно цепляющий, чтобы быть интересным при лаконичности. При этом он не такой уж и лаконичный, там вон инструменты разные всякие, переходы. Ну типа попс, да. Но попс то мы тут не хейтим сам по себе. В целом, возможно, лучший новый для себя альбом в рамках 1001. Синтез идей прошлых декад, причём тех, что мне самому заходят. Тут слышу Битлов, там - Квинов немного, тут - Дэвид Боуи, там - глэм-митол 80-ых. И при этом как бы не завершает ход эволюции, а служит её звеном. Так, хук из Letterbomb я будто слышу в angelic milk - Rebel Black. Короче, отличный альбом. Отличный альбом, оставлю на плеере.
I went into this fully expecting for it to not have aged well. I was wrong. This album still bangs.
Classic!
Sorry, just not my cup of tea!
I'm too old for this, and so are they. Singles are fine, but the rest is filler. Teen punk rock for people who think the Matrix is 'deep'.
Though this album marked a bad turning point for this band, the album as a whole was better than I remembered. Could be nostalgia talking, but I thought it ages well.
This is how a band does a sound change and comes out on top for it. Excellent pop rock fun.
fuck me, this was so much worse than i expected. the singles aren't even the worst bit and they're fucking awful. i have no understanding of how this steaming pile of shite was so popular.
Ok guys. I’ve decided our next album is going to be a concept album! Oh wow that’s great Billy Joe. What’s the concept? A punk rock.....wait for it....OPERA! Amazing! Does that mean you’re gonna write punk songs again? Hahahaha of course not Tré Cool don’t be très dumb. No it means I’m going to base all of the songs around a few different characters. Do you think you’re capable of writing like that? Oh yeah definitely. See there’s this one character called St. Jimmy so I just call the song ‘St. Jimmy’ and write lines lines like “St. Jimmy that’s my name and don’t wear it out” Ok but that sounds awful Billy Joe. It is Tré Cool. It is.
Un álbum prácticamente perfecto. No lo escuchaba desde hace más de 10 años y lo he disfrutado más de lo que creía. Las melodías vocales son perfectas, el ritmo prácticamente no decae, es una historia desesperada; no hay héroes, no hay cambio. El cambio es la quimera. "Letterbomb", el punto álgido.
A fun romp through the world of punk pop. Second half is a bit of a slog.
Never paid this much attention on release because the title track grinded at me so much but actually it’s a really well put together album with some great pop songs - did two listens and it tails a little so downgraded to a very solid three stars
Excellent and nostalgic album
The last good album by Green Day. Love some songs, dread others.
Almost a 4. One of my favorite bands of my teenage years, but unfortunately I pretty much grown from them. There are some great songs, but on the other hand there are quite generic and very long, repetetive numbers, which drag this album down.
The worst green day The fall of green day
Very very solid album. I listened to American Idiot a lot on our old computer with ITunes, and that song still slaps. I love the singles that I've got saved, but the whole rock opera trope drags on a bit with some of the longer songs, so I dropped this to a 4. A high 4, nonetheless Already Saved: American Idiot, Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me up When September Ends Saved After Listening: Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel
Saved Prior: American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams*, Wake Me up When September Ends Off Rip: Holiday*, Are We the Waiting / St. Jimmy, Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel Cutting Edge: None *: I prefer the songs split up, so I had them saved off a greatest hits compilation at different times Overall Notes: I can't believe this album is as good as it is. IDK if I really follow the plot of the punk rock opera, but these songs all bop despite their hefty running times for punk songs.
3.5 very good.
I find this music quite uninspiring.
4/5 well that was unexpected. Kudos to them!
I think Green Day has been growing on me over the years. This has at least 2 songs that I like, so I'm sure it's a 3. Does it have enough to be a 4??? Nope. Okay overall, but nothing that grabs me enough to take it to the next level.
.
Production: 5/20 Songwriting: 2/20 Innovation: 2/20 Bangers: 0/20 Emotional response: 2/20 =11 Just did a sick
Car journeys with dad
Damn did they capture some kind of zeitgeist. Last two songs fall flat, as in absolutely zero curvature. Really the album's a downward slope from the peak/ridge of Jesus of Suburbia
I’m not a huge Green Day fan, but if I had to choose a favorite album of theirs it would probably not be American Idiot. A few familiar tunes, but overall not great not terrible.
Good old Green Day. Wasn't a fan back then, not a huge fan now.
Ergh. Nah, not having this. Only interested in Nimrod and Dookie.
A punk rock opera concept album? Johnny Rotten would be rolling in his grave, if he were dead. Shame he's not dead really, rather than selling his soul on I'm A Celebrity and butter adverts.
The Band should be self titled from this album because its definitely a snapshot of the American Idiot's thoughts for me. That's because I didn't grow up listening to Greenday. Indeed, I had only heard two songs on this album before. The songs I did hear I was heavily pressured or forced to listen to despite my unswervibg lack of care for this music. The people who did it - They are the American Idiots. White suburban angst shapes the American Idiot. The American Idiot only fucks like he's gonna die afterwards. The American Idiot thinks the beastie boys are 'awesome.' The American Idiot envisions his alleged dream girl in short skirt and a loooooooooooooooooong jacket. Oh the American woman wants a 'girl' alright. He also wants chips and dips for dinner; a daughter that's almost a tomboy; a local guitar center; The point is. I know the American Idiot, and in a lot of ways, the Idiot knows me too. In a lot of ways, I am the idiot, but in some crucial ways, not serious person should be him (he is necessarily male, let's be clear about that). Well I thought the album was alright. I can almost see why its so beloved. Although, it isn't that far off from music that people have so quickly forgotten (except the American Idiots of course). Its a definite 3/5, but more accurately 6/10 (as in, it is four steps from a tops, rather than two. Fight me.
Bloated
Thought it was purile and shite when it came out and was “pleased” to be proved right. Horrendous listening experience and I curse myself for not having enough self respect to have turned it off.
A protest rock opera that protests... something? I understand the thrust of songs like "American Idiot" and "Holiday", but "Jesus of Suburbia" seems like a protest song without a cause and more of the album resembles the latter than the former. An album that claims to protest the state of America, but magically omits any mention of race or gender or class is probably not a very effective protest album. The protagonist (the aforementioned Jesus of Suburbia) just comes off as an edgy kid with no political consciousness. At the very least, it sounds a lot better than The Offspring.
One of the legendary Rock Opera's of our time. Right up there with Pink Floyd's The Wall.
Not for me
The first album we have gotten that I have listened to all the way through before this project. The way they pair two songs for the middle four tracks(plus Jesus and Homecoming both have 5 subtracks in them) is a cool concept and helps underline the bands desire to put out something they enjoyed creatively rather than something that would necessarily do well commercially - luckily this did both. I mean Punk Rock Opera? Nostalgia+Strong Songs+Creativity= 5 stars
I don't know if I ever listened to this album, but I know every song. Iconic
Great album. Career defining. Good guitars, beats, melodies!, sensicle lyrics.
This hasn't aged well but it still takes me back to chugging too many drinks at house parties and jumping off of the roofs of various neighbours
"No one ever died for my Sins in hell As far as I can tell At least the ones that I got away with" (Jesus of Suburbia) "Cigarettes and ramen and a little bag of dope I am the son of a bitch and Edgar Allan Poe Raised in the city under a halo of lights The product of war and fear that we've been victimized I'm the patron saint of the denial With an angel face and a taste for suicidal" (St. Jimmy) A Green Day sí le permito hacer canciones de más de cinco minutos.
Nostalgia
Fuck off Billie
Wow this album unlocked childhood memories I forgot existed. Was a little nervous that it wouldn't be as good as I remembered, but oh my god am I so glad I was wrong. That rocked hard as hell, its got a political message that still rings true today, was a total risk by a band way outside of their comfort zone thematically, and still was an incredible success. We've had a lot of concept albums lately and I haven't been the biggest fan, but yo this is how its done right. Also, who else was a 5th grader who didn't really know anything about politics but didn't like George Bush just because of Green Day? Any ways, this group just earned its pop-punk merit badge because its 5s across the board for Green Day!
8
Not surprised that this ended up on the list. Jam-packed with hits, somehow polished and pop while maintaining the raw edge.
Américan idio, Jesús suburbio y boulevard broken dreamS
Dogshit.
“American Idiot” by Green Day (2004) Not familiar with this album or this group. Punk political opera - intriguing. Good music, shallow politics. But the music is good enough to persuade the listener to overlook the political naivety. These gentlemen would have been well advised to read a few lines of Zbigniew Brzezinski on the Iraq War before writing this opera. They still would have been wrong, but at least they would have sounded intelligent. Or are they affecting intentional unintelligence? Are they just joshing? Anyway the music is very entertaining. Head banging punk rage, with a unifying operatic theme. Plenty of creative innovations. Some real gems here. “A steady diet of soda pop and Ritalin” is a great line. Conceptually this album follows the line of “Tommy” by The Who, without being overly derivative. “Dearly Beloved” is truly good music. Integrating acoustic guitar in this genre is a stroke of genius. And the glockenspiel! Ya-ya. But check out this quatrain: Oh, therapy, can you please fill the void? Am I retarded or am I just overjoyed? Nobody's perfect and I stand accused For lack of a better word, and that's my best excuse One could step back and reflect on that for awhile. Very good drum work. Bass contributes much counterpoint. Vocals appropriate for the genre. Billie Joe Armstrong can really sing. Extraordinary musical range for punk (admittedly, my experience with punk is limited), reminiscent of what The Beatles did for rock ‘n roll on “Sgt. Pepper” and “Abbey Road”. I enjoyed this one. 4/5
YEESSSSSSSSS
These lyrics are burned into my memory forever. Cool guitar riffs and connected story. Some songs drag on for a bit.
Würde ich gerne mögen, ist mir leider immer noch zu flach
Sophomoric attempts
A pop-punk album that hasn't aged well and sounds trite/over-produced. 'Jesus of Suburbia' is the least hackneyed, due to the meter changes. 4/10, used to like this.
Idiotisk highschool-punk MED allsang-tendenser. OMG.
Very clean album. A bit too clean and predictable, I like a bit of fuzz. Some good songs to listen to on their own, but BJ’s voice and guitar gets a bit grinding listening to a whole album.
Memories of paramedic prac circa 2005, loading a patient into the back of the ambulance at the Green Day concert at Sydney Entertainment Centre. Got to see a little bit live. Those first 3 tracks have somehow aged even better than Billy Joe Armstrong. Add in ‘Wake Me Up When September Ends’ and you’ve got 1/2 of the greatest album of the 2000’s. Pity about the filler tracks which bring it way the fuck back to Earth.
It was ok. Just ok.
Perfectly captures the zeitgeist of a time I don't care to revisit...
Some good songs - classics like Holiday/Boulevard, American Idiot - but the songs in between were too long or uninteresting.
more timely than ever!
Superb.
Solid album that represents Green day maturity. I just don't get the double songs per album track.
Bastante bueno. Temas buenos.
Punk Opera about the disillusionment of growing up in suburbia? Easy 5 stars. I listened to this album so hard the summer it came out that I spent the next 3 years hating on it. Once I went back and realized I had just overplayed it for myself, it went back into a moderated heavy rotation.
stone cold classic.
I'm dating myself here, but American Idiot is the first album I ever owned. There are legitimate criticisms that can be made about it - it's firmly rooted in the Bush era and hasn't aged particularly well; it's a whiny sort of pop-punk for white kids in the 'burbs - but none of that is enough to detract from my rose-tinted nostalgia. Even today, I find the album's pure sincerity a very charming break from the 2010s ever-present air of irony.
Not my favorite Green Day album.
I like their other records more. I know this was caught up in the hysteria of a rock opera but for the NEW MILLENNIUM, but I don't think it was quite as amazing as it was made out to be.
Energetic, one of my favourite albums then I was a teenager.
Decent. A few alright singles. 5/10
I enjoyed the mashup songs. Jesus of Suburbia is good too but at 9 minutes a little long
Je me suis rendu à la chanson 2
3.5 to be honest. Liked some of the songs more than I remember, I don’t care for the “rock opera” aspects as much as I used to. I could definitely pick out theme, but narrative is a bit of a stretch. While some of the movements on a few tracks were inspired, most just felt crammed together. It would have been better to make a couple of fleshed out 3.5/4 min songs than a 7.5 min song made up of two parts. Standouts are American Idiot and Jesus of Suburbia and various parts of other songs
Can't not give it a 5
Great. Recognize lots of songs.
Wondering if this album is a storyline or not. Want to research some time to see if it is.
i definitely had a phase where i liked their early stuff - fun, melodic punky stuff. at some point, i realized they'd really only written one song (i'm in love, and she doesn't know i exist), and that kinda did me in. this album was sort of a watered-down version of all of that. melodic enough, but ultimately pretty boring. plus i've come to think billie joe's a bit of a tool
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
No comment.
I was pretty meh about this when it came out. Same 25ish years later
I definitely bought this album on the day it came out - I was 16. I was riding in the back seat of my friend's car listening to "Holiday" - we had it cranked and he was driving too fast trying to take a turn off 18th Ave - into the ditch we went! A fond memory. I get why some people don't like Green Day but they were such a big part of my formative years and I come back to their music often enough. I think this is their best album. "Jesus of Suburbia" is epic, I love that song. Rounding up to a 5.
Better than I remember. A classic
first half is a classic
Meh
Very good, perhaps overrated.
Great album, they put it all out there
Green Day y su intensidad
Not fussed on this one.
For punk, it is very thoughtful and interesting
Don't want to listen to this generic hot trash.
Wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be but still not one I’m going to come back to
A rock opera in everything but intention, this segued album is easily one of the best of the punk-pop-idiot rock that came about in the era of the Iraq war. Easily one of the best albums of the 2000's
long songs n quirky lyrics 😪💔
decent. not in the mood
Production: 5/20 Songwriting: 2/20 Innovation: 2/20 Bangers: 0/20 Emotional response: 2/20 =11 Just did a sick
Dit is toch geweldig
A couple of good tunes
Pop punks love politics. So edgy!
First encounter with Green Day was as an opener for Bad Religion, playing pretty straight ahead punk. Their transformation into more of a conventional alternative rock band was an odd one, though obviously it worked out for them. Listened to this album a lot in the day, although the lyrics increasingly strike me as pompous.
Of all the pop punk bands, I think Green Day is the only one I actually enjoy on some level. I've only heard Dookie through Nimrod before though. I've seen this album get alot of praise and I wanted to give it a 3 when I first started listening but as the album goes on I feel like it collapses under its own weight. I respect the ambition but it was a bit of a chore to get through.
I never got into Green Day, but they aren't bad per say. I can appreciate the punk opera concept and I think the album starts strong but then fizzes out, like Jon said. It's not bad, but not my thing. I did get a bit tired of it towards the end, probably won't listen to it by choice, lots of the songs were played so much on the radio, so that's my association.
Good album but not my thing personally
It's nice to see kids music making the cut, but this doesn't really do much for me as an adult.
Not their best, but I like it
Not a fan of green day.
Definitely heard this one. One of my favorites. Very cynical, and considered a sell out album by them, but, as a concept album/rock opera style, it’s great!
I have a hard time stepping back and not being judgy about this album and about Green Day. After years of feeling like they play poser punk and feeling like they were making political songs as part of a growing fad, rather than out of genuine concern for the current political climate. There's undeniably some great songwriting and the production quality is great.
Very good musicianship and a very cool approach, doing most of the songs as double feature/mashups that flow pretty seamlessly into one another. The hits are much better than some of the other tracks, but they all fit together pretty well.
It's fine, but not close to their best album (Dookie).
Some great tracks. Good album
Some classic songs but not their best album
I like Green Day energy, but all their songs sound the same.
Best moments were when it sounded like dookie but I’m partial.
LOL WHO MADE THIS LIST, TRASH
poggers
blokes
Meh.
Not a big fan. Never been huge into Green Day and pop punk in genre, all feels very samey. Highlights: Holiday, Too Much Too Soon
Naja, Green Day.
Was pretty much over Green Day when this album came out. But looking back it’s probably one of their best.
Tough. So much harder to listen to than anticipated. Just too much all the time. I also saw that E-boy was listening to Mac while I was listening to this and I really needed that antidote
Epic!
Gähn day. Generisches Punk Rock -Gedudel. Die Platte hat 2-3 Momente, sonst aber gar nix.
idiota americando da minha juventude idiota
Formulaic. Some good moments.
Absolute classic.
4.25
Used to listen to this all the time back in the emo kid days. I still know every single word.
I was never interested in this album when it came out, but I heard the singles. They're better in the context of the album. Green Day can certainly write some catchy songs.
Probably my best Green Day album as well. Loved the first one but this one is just really good.
Green Day reminds me of middle school and high school.
Wake me up when this album ends... Nah it's alright
One of my favorite albums from Green Day. I like how they evolved and this new sound. Solid album.
+
One of the albums I listen to often, very good.
Middle school favorite. A rock opera in every sense of the term.
Bekannt. Gut.
Was very excited to see this bad boy pop up. This was the album that introduced me to Green Day but I haven’t listened in forever. Very rewarding for us lyrics listeners ;) Kathleen Hanna should’ve sang Letterbomb though.
Really good album, but not really my thing
Y
meh
Piiitkän tauon jälkeen kuulosti ihan hyvälle
Been a while. A classic
One of my favorites, a great commentary and timeless rock sounds to bang your head along with.
Meh. It's fine.
Hands down the best Green Day album of all time, one of the best concept albums of all time, and one of the best albums in general. 5 stars, all killer-no filler.
Iconic album but a little loud for me.
i didn't wanna listen to this lol im just gonna give it a two
Álbum mais interessante do que eu imaginava. Destaque pra balada "Wake me up when September Ends"
Still great and fun to listen all the way through. S/o to my cousins and their Limewire plug
Already heard this one, very many times - great project; one of the best pop punk works of art there is. Relevant even today.
Dookie is there best but still a fan listen
15 y/o me gives this a 5
Look. I know the rating should be lower. But I fucking love this album. I love it. Its a no skip album for me. I remember loving it since I was four. So many great tunes. 9/10 F. T. : A tie between Holiday and Are we the Waiting. I can't choose among my children.
Nostalgia bomb. Awesome album, and the slow/fast song double features are pretty fun, I kind of forgot about that format
2004. Key Songs: American Idiot, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends
Nobody ever asked for 7, 8 and NINE minute green day songs. That being said some good individual tracks but not enough to save the whole piece.
Why on earth is the lame end of Green Day on this? This is a band that should never have tried to "grow up". 3/5.
Nope.... this type of grunge is just bad pop dressed up and sold to the disenfranchised.