American Idiot by Green Day

American Idiot

Green Day

3.77
Rating
31357
Votes
1
4%
2
9%
3
24%
4
34%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 14 of 16)

Iconic pop-punk. I love a good concept album and the big, sweeping centerpiece tracks on here really anchor all the shorter, punchier hits that you know and love.

American Idiot been one of my favorite albums since I first heard it in middle school over 15 years ago. It's cohesive, consistent, self-referential, emotional, and just brilliant. I love every song. This might be my personal favorite entry on the list so far.

Kyllä ovat kovan levyn tehneet, kunnianhimoisen mm., kun on sidottu biisit yhteen niin tauottomuuksilla kuin sanoituksilla. Ei ole niin naiivi kuin odotin. Mutta liian siloiteltu, liian stadion kuulostaakseen ns. aidolta, mitä levy jää kaipaamaan.

Taitavia biisintekijöitä; karmaisevia esteetikkoja. Ei (aina) niin epäpunkkia, kuin kaikki haluaisimme uskoa, mutta haluaa itse kuulostaa siltä, kuin olisi. Eikö ole jännä kuvio?

Track ratings: 1. American Idiot - [8/10] 2. Jesus of Suburbia - [9/10] 3. Holiday - [8/10] 4. Boulevard of Broken Dreams - [7/10] 5. Are We the Waiting - [7/10] 6. St. Jimmy - [6/10] 7. Give Me Novacaine - [7/10] 8. She's a Rebel - [7/10] 9. Extraordinary Girl - [6/10] 10. Letterbomb - [7/10] 11. Wake Me Up When September Ends - [6/10] 12. Homecoming - [7/10] 13. Whatsername - [7/10] I haven't listened to this album front to back in years. Very strong first half, but I kind of lose interest as the album progresses. There isn't any song I actively dislike, but Wake Me Up... just annoys me at this point due to the years of hearing it ambiently so much. 4/5

Yeah, this album is very well known and much loved by me already.

strong ablum

Great start

how dare you send me from Dookie to this shit 1/5

This one has a lot more nostalgia than Dookie for me. I do think it is the better album, too. Love how the songs leak into one another. It’s got a little bit of rock opera going on. Much more varied in sound, even if some of the ballads are a little cheesy

Good stuff

SO GIVE ME NOVACAINEEEEEEEEEEEE

I love this album so my review is going to be a teeeeeensy bit biased. I hope teenagers for generations will continue to find this one because it captures so many feelings I had at that age so perfectly - informed but powerless, surrounded but lonely, angry at nothing and longing for something better. Its play/singability lend it well to passionate and sloppy jam sessions. I think I'd enjoy it but wouldn't connect with it nearly as deeply if it came out now. 4/5 stars.

- American Idiot: Banger, don't really love the f-slur but it's a product of its time. - Jesus of Suburbia: The GOAT, each part is so fun to sing and they're all so different but all fire. - Holiday: Another banger, very 2004-pilled politically but it's kinda based. - Boulevard of Broken Dreams: I defy anyone to not sing along to the chorus. - Are We the Waiting: Great one to sing along to, prepares me for the upcoming uptempo jam. - St. Jimmy: Has there ever been a "1,2,3,4!" that went harder? - Give Me Novacaine: I'm not normally an emo guy but I feel this song, maybe due to nostalgia but we ball. - She's a Rebel: Not an extreme banger but but fun to sing and pretty catchy melody. - Extraordinary Girl: Pretty interesting musically but I feel like it's not as fun to sing along to and this album really lends itself to singing along. - Letterbomb: I really like this song but I honestly never listen to it because I have to listen to Extraordinary Girl and the weird mean nursery rhyme thing. - Wake Me up When September Ends: I still like this song but I think I've heard it too many times. I used to love it but now I feel it's kinda just a nothing song like it shouldn't even be around in the area. - Homecoming: Another banger, I think I'm still taking JoS over this but it's close. - Whatsername: Nice little ditty to close out the album, not my favorite but it's nice.

A rock opera chock full of classic punk rock tunes and worthy of a place on the list, will come back again for some nostalgia.

incredibly nostalgic simplistic pop punk. the sound of my childhood playing Tony Hawk games on the DS, except I was too young to truly notice all the punk themes. 3.75/5

Great songwriting and extremely catchy tunes. Definitely need to be in the mood to listen to the high energy delivery and at times anxiety inducing vibes.

I found it very interesting how different songs were recorded as one track, forcing you to listen to certain songs back to back

I think the hit rate on this is pretty damn good. It's fairly consistent across the board too. Really upbeat, nice catchy songs. I always thought of Green Day as super quick, pop-punky songs, but there's plenty of longer ones on here too that still work well.

Oh man, I remember really liking this album as a kid. My sister had the CD in a little blue case, and we listened to it all the time. Most of the songs on this album are bops too. What is strange is that this version of the album has some tracks merged together into one ex: Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams. This is a solid 4/5 I just have too much nostalgia for the album. I'm glad this still holds up for the most part aside from their use of the f slur in one track

it was pretty nice! i couldn’t rlly tell if it was repetitive or just consistent but i think i could definitely tell the differences between most songs. i’ve never listened to greenday so this was very different. overall, pretty alright :)

catchy but no great shit

Not my personal favorite, but it does take me back.

-didn’t write a BL, retroactively reviewed on 24/08/23, generated on 7/08/23- AL: I like Green Day, this album was an anthem throughout my childhood. Nowadays when I’m older and can look at it under a more mature eye I can see that it maybe wasn’t the political statement I might’ve thought it was when I was 10. This Bush era political album sort of has points and ideas that reflect disdain for the wars in the Middle East that were going on but I think it kind of distracts a lot from the other stuff that’s going on. While it’s still a perfectly solid album I would argue it has not aged super well, still a fun listen and very catch pop punk but not much more than that these days in my eyes. FT: “Jesus of suburbia”, “Give me Novocaine”, “Wake me up when September ends” 3/5

i was really not looking forward to this. i do not like green day and i told myself i would never listen to an album of theirs. it's not as bad as i thought it would be, but jesus fucking christ its so corny. im 18 and i feel like im too old for this album. best track is whatsername 6/10

THE VIDEO CLIPS AREN'T BAD FOR THE THEME THE ALBUM TELLS, BUT I ISN'T SOMETHING THAT YOU LOOK AND "WOW HOW COOL" NOOOO otherwise, the songs are good, actually. Some of them have cool transitions like "Holiday" with Boulevard one. There are also the counterparts wich show how the songs can get different with a simple change, like "Give me Novacaine" with "She's a Rebel". EXTRAORDINARY GIRL BEST SONG

The first album I ever bought as a young teenager. Masterpiece. All the singles are awesome. Boulevard of broken dreams was on the radio every single day and I don't think I got sick of it. St. Jimmy is underrated, great punk tune.

Heard before: 'American Idiot', 'Boulevard of Broken Dreams', 'Wake Me Up When September Ends'. I can't really understand him between the loud instruments and his accent, except on songs I already know. Isn't this pop-punk? Maybe not, according to this website. I love love love 'WMUWSE' but it could not save this thing. 'American Idiot' and 'WMUWSE' are absolute bangers. I also think if I had got this on a different day I would have loved it, given that I quite enjoy pop-punk. However, today I was not feeling it and I doubt I'll listen again. It was on the side of meh that's closer to bad. Thus, I'm giving it a 3 and a 5/10. I was going to give it 4 after hearing 'WMUWSE' again but after the album limped on for 13 more minutes I think the original rating was good.

european heare...Europe has fallen behind America and the gap is growing. ei ollakaan niin idiootteja nyt vai häh... 20 years fly by incredible lyric (foreshadowing...its now 20 years from the album..) konflikti, sisäinen konflikti sisälläni velloo. paskimmat biisitt ehkäpä koskaan mutta hyvä albumi silti.. jesus of suburbia...

I guess what appeals to me most about this album, other than the catchy-as-hell pop punk, is the rock opera feel of the whole thing. This is the story of Jimmy, a suburban kid from Jesusland trying to make his way in a world of rock n roll and politics, trying to live in a divided America where everyone is drawing lines in the sand.

Best rock album of the 00s

This is by far Greendays best record. People will argue dookie, but this album is nearly a masterpiece. I can't give the album a FIVE (because I didn't give ratm a 5) but it's as close to a 5 as possible. The album is somewhat frontloaded, Jesus of Suburbia possibly their best ever song. While listening through the City of the Damned bit, I thought to myself that it may be greendays best part of any song they've written. The low point of the album is She's A Rebel. That song could be on any greenday album, whereas the rest of the tracks could only be on this record. The album is held together by the two long songs, I would have preferred the album end on Homecoming. Some of the hits are overplayed to the point where its harder to evaluate how good they are. One of the other negatives of the album are the solos, I don't want some rip roaring technical fast solo, but I theres something about them that haven't aged that well, it may be the guitar effect on the solos, but it's a minor gripe. Upon listening to the album, it's easy to see how it lends itself to being a musical, its a rock opera and clearly a heavy influence on the Black Parade. I heard elements of Joshua tree. The sad part about the greatness of the album is that after it, theyve not released any albums that are even vaguely listenable. This was their peak, and everything after has lived in the shadow of this superb album VERY VERY HIGH FOUR

This album was such a good one to look back on, so good

Nothing but bangers

Sjov historie at følge med i under hele albummet Skal høres flere gange

I can see why they made this into a Broadway show

a bit boring

Heard before Saved 9/9 Top track: Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams

Don't even need to listen to know where I rate this - a solid 4.5 - just due to the 100 times I listened to this as a teenager. But I'm re-listening just to see if anything strikes me this time around... Still really enjoy this album but some of the croon-ey, mopey, singing parts just rub me the wrong way to this day. Thus the .5 point docking for me.

Having established themselves within the genre of chucklehead power punk, American Idiot was a complete surprise from Green Day. It has intelligent social commentary, much of which is sadly still true, coupled with a more sophisticated power pop (not punk). Easily the best album from Green Day and a classic of the early 2000s.

Love this album. One of my all time favourites. Instant classic.

I'm not a pop punk devotee but this album stands out.

AJ: some tracks are excellent. Couple snoozers. Cool piece of punk rock art overall. Appreciate what they were doing. Stayed fast for the most part, with much more to say. America. Idiots. Idiots as far as you can see. Jesus of Suburbia clocking in at 9+ minutes… not exactly Dookie. Quite a ride. Holiday is such a great song.

Pretty much a modern classic. 4/5 Singles: ------------------------------------------------------- "American Idiot" (US ALT #1, UK #3) "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" (#5 UK, #1 US ALT, #1 US Pop 100) "Holiday" (#11 UK, #1 US ALT and Mainstream Rock) "Wake Me Up When September Ends" (#8 UK, #2 US ALT) "Jesus of Suburbia" (#17 UK, #27 US ALT)

I was never a Green Day fan so it colors this.

Listened to this album a lot when I was younger

I mean it could be subversive if you were the most middle American person possible. I am not and so it seems more like a corporate put together mainstream bland "punk". All guitar riffs sound the same throughout. "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" is the stand out which shows it's not really punk at all but middle of the road rock.

Still great

I really like those old rock vibes and it's mighty impressive how long some songs are. But I have to admit, I have a music class trauma due Wake me up when September ends😂

4.4 13 year old me would be proud that I still remember all the lyrics to every damn song. This entire album is one of the best (if not the best) pop punk albums, every song fits with the entire theme but also stands up on its own. Fave songs: Jesus of suburbia, Homecoming, Are we the waiting, St. Jimmy

For my generation it’s kind of classic

Super strong album.

hmmmm appreciate the message but wouldnt really listen again, i think

Day 96 A heart-shaped grenade bleeding in a hand? The poetry of that cover art should be enough to bring a tear in your eye. Or maybe not, but it is for me.  I was aware of Green Day (but then again, who wasn't?) but didn't listen to American Idiot when it came out. But I have a very precise memory of that moment in time: Green Day came to Montreal and played a show in a huge open air venue; it was summer and I was broke, I didn't go to see the show, but I remember seeing the kids around the city on public transportation heading to the venue; there were thousands, millions of them and It was a beautiful spectacle to see: suddenly the city was filled with punk kids in their black clothes, each with their own version of a punk haircut, hair dyed in different colours, wearing their face piercings and make up; tattoos weren't that common yet so there weren't many of those, thank you. This is exactly the image I view whenever I listen to Green Day. This, and Billy Joe Armstrong. I love that chap, I think he's awesome cuz he looks exactly like one of those kids even if he's decades older than them. Whenever I see a picture or video with Billy Joe on it I just wish I could give him a warm hug, he really looks like this fragile, shy and sensitive teenager who gets pissed off about the injustices in the world and speaks out without becoming a pedantic asshole; the kind of teenager who asks questions and doesn't assume they have all the answers; the kind of teenager-adult who looks sort of innocent but takes no bullshit and believes in integrity. Are you reading this, Bono?  With American Idiot, Green Day took pop punk to a whole new level and gave it the substance it was lacking; many of the songs have a Phil Spector feel, or sort of. Some have written that American Idiot was Green Day's attempt at being The Who and recording Tommy; although I can see where they are coming from, they clearly need to listen closer. Rating: all the bombs pumping blood through my heart. 

Okay... Dookie, I understand, but why in the hell is this album on here? Post relevant Green Day cashing in on a popped up version of the sound that made them great on their 1994 breakout. The fact that there is not only one, but four song weighing above the 6 minute mark does not bode well. Doesn't help that I never actually have the focus to care about a rock opera; they feel like things that musicians make for their own ego rather than for the listener. All that out of my system, I do have a soft spot for American Idiot. Like I recognize it as a not very good song, but I have a certain nostalgia associated with it. Perfect song for being 13, white, and believing yourself to be edgy. Never before have I heard a GD song and said "you know, I wish this was 3x as long." Having listened now to Jesus of Suburbia I feel justified in this sentiment. It's actually not godawful, but its kind of a schizophrenic mess. Holiday is actually a solid, catchy pop song. And while it pains me to say so, so is Boulevard of Broken Dreams. Had Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb in the background, but found myself tapping along to the back half. I really did not like Wake Me up When September Ends on its own, but it is surprisingly, somehow better in the context of the album. Okay... Having just completed the album I will say that it isn't nearly as terrible as I expected it to be going in. I did not particularly enjoy it, but it is an honest and respectful entry into Green Days catalog. The songs err on the pop-punk / emo spectrum and probably have something to do with teenage love and being an outsider or something. To be honest I wasn't paying much attention to lyrics. I won't come back for another listen, but I didn't want to gouge my ears out. This is a soft 3 for me.

Klassiker.

Like relevant nå som for 20 år siden...

When this album came out, I listened and to it a bunch and I am a fan of Green Day. I think they are used ironically, but the f bombs are still shocking to hear. If I could give this half stars, I’d give it a 4.5/5 or a 9/10. So many hit songs on here and the ones in between are pretty good too.

Very much of the zeitgeist. Sounds hoary now (certainly didn't expect to recognise the slightly reworked chords of Bryn Adams' 'Summer of 69' amidst this...

One of the biggest albums I can remember as a school kid. Seemed to hit the mainstream proper big time. As a result I really can’t stand American Idiot (song) but there’s a few belters in there. Even songs I’ve heard so many times. I like all the songs but stars are getting dropped for the title song and ‘Extraordinary Girl’

I’d rather undergo nine years of medieval torture than ever listen to this shit again

American Idiot is the The Wall for millennials but with less hopelessness and even more political dissatisfaction. An anti-US, anti-consumerism and anti-capitalism monument, this record ended up defining large parts of the 00's music scene post-9/11. The album and Green Day themselves became synonymous with criticism of the Bush administration, and 'Wake Me Up When September Ends' was used in everything from protests of the Iraqi war to memorials after Hurricane Katrina. The songwriting is top notch, melodies are catchy but never boring, and the production on the guitar is otherworldly. It makes me want to bring out the eyeliner and the red tie, and I would not change a single thing about this teenage-angst ridden phenomenon.

It’s hard to overstate the impact American Idiot had on the music scene in the years following its release. Green Day outperformed themselves and delivered an era-defining record that gave a voice to millions of angsty teens longing to be heard under the post-9/11 Bush administration. It’s been a few years since I heard this album last but nothing seems to have aged badly. Hit after hit after hit of perfectly written punk rock songs - and an especially honorable mention to the fantastic “Letterbomb”. I remember growing into my music taste with American Idiot. I don’t think I will ever outgrow it.

Probably the weakest Green Day album. No idea why this is here and not Dookie or Nimrod.

South Harmon Institute of Technology theme song! Go SHIT heads.

I feel like Green Day has to be my favorite pop punk band for a genre I generally don't love. Lots of classics on this one with some lyrics that are more politically charged than most pop punk.

Very different than Dookie, and not as good personally, but still a great album with some nice hits. Holiday going into Boulevard of Broken Dreams is a great transisition. Something about Green Day just gets me going. Billie Joe is an awesome frontman

Highs are super high on this one but it still ain’t no Dookie. Still an enjoyable listen I just think some songs could be halved. Soundtrack to middle school

"American Idiot" is the seventh studio album by American rock band Green Day. After the master tapes of their upcoming album "Cigarettes and Valentins" got stolen, the band decided to start over and rewrite another album since they weren't really impressed with the result of the finished album. They landed on a concept album of sorts, a "punk-rock opera." The main character Jesus of Suburbia is the lower-middle class anti-hero from suburbia who decides to escape to the city. The song themes tend to go into the dissolution and dissent of a generation that came of age with 9/11 and the Iraq War. It also takes aim at giant corporations and George W. Bush. The album was a big success reaching #1 in the US and UK and winning the 2005 Grammy for Best Rock Album. The guitar right into their punk-pop rhythm opens "American Idiot." It's melodic. Great drumming by Tré Cool. Leader singer Billie Joe Armstrong going after the mass media (cable news) and their orchestrated paranoia and idiocy among the public. "Jesus of Suburbia" starts the story of our anti-hero. It's broken into five parts, each with a different melody. There's a ballad in there, a bass-heavy song and ends with the most rockin' song. Maybe, my favorite Green Day song and one that typically is at the end of their shows. Along with "American Idiot," "Holiday" is the most political of the songs on the album. The guitar chorus with the band kicking in. Armstrong with his most aggressive vocals taking aim at American conservatism and Bush and their alienation of a group of people. The guitar reverb and a slower pace highlight their US chart topper "Boulevard of Broken Dreams." Armstrong wrote this while taking a break in Manhattan and it's about feeling alone in a city. Nice vocals and lyrics. Their rock-pop anthem. "Wake Me Up When September Ends" was written in the aftermath of 9/11 and is based on Armstrong's Dad dying from cancer. More acoustic guitar but goes electric. Drums added. A guitar bridge. Somebody always still mentions to wake Billie Joe up on October 1. Bille Joe begins the closer "Whatsername" in a more deadpan voice. Catchy melody and chorus. The soft-loud-soft-loud dynamic. Melodies abound in this album. The band is tight and the music sounds great and rocks at times. Anthem after anthem. Green Day's best album in my opinion.

A pop/punk/rock band makes a concept album and it doesn't suck? I didn't see that coming.

Much better than I remember. Could this be punk rock at its peak?

Achieving successfully a pop/punk rock opera in 2004 is a master move. This album contains many important hits from the 2000s and one of Green Day's finest cut : Jesus Of Suburbia, an unexpected 8 minutes track with movements, killers riffs and awesome drum parts. On a personal level, this is one of the most important album from my teenage years. It changes everything.

+ for nostalgi

4 (3) radio hits: American Idiot (hard punk rock); Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams (did not realize that was a pair songs on one 8:13 track... 2 completely different vibes); Wake Me Up When September Ends

I know this was a big album when it came out but I’ve never been a fan. Just never sat well with me. Giving a two as there is likely something I’m missing.

I’m all for the idea of a “punk rock opera” and while it has the risk of coming across as gimmicky, they were really able to pull it off. This album started off really strong but wasn’t able to maintain that in the second half. Still a great listen. 4.5 stars

This brings me back. American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake Me up When September Ends were on constant repeat. Going back and listening to this album I would say it still holds up and is a great album but my taste has changed and this wouldn't be my first choice to play. Who knows, maybe in a few years I'll go back and listen to Green Day more.

The 2000s were kind of a wasteland for american art. Compared to previous generations, music wasnt the great communicator and rallying of a generation that it had been. This was one of the like 20 albums of the decade that was something that everyone had heard and tended towards liking it. 4/5

Didn't age well, but some slaps.

I still enjoy this album, although not to quite the same extent as when it first came out.

I was in middle school when this album came out and a bunch of people were going nuts over it. It's marginally better than fine.

Probably a 4 but I like it so a 5. I listen to a lot of the songs in this album all the time. This was the first CD I ever got to pick out myself so maybe I'm a little biased and nostalgic but I don't care. GOOD ALBUM

1. American Idiot - absolutely love this song so catchy and very upbeat, love the lyrics, the vocals and guitar interlude-10/10 (added to playlist) 2. Jesus of suburbia- love the rhythm of this song, especially in the first part of this song, vocals on point, love the switch up when the piano and acoustics come in, not too keen on the backing vocals. i love how this song has the different sections like its moving along with a scene in a theatre or film, very theatrical, love how it switches from a fast angry pace to an almost innocent instrumental, love the bass switch up too 8/10 (liked the song) 3. Holiday/boulevard of Broken dreams- (holiday)- love the guitar on this one, very good consistency, Armstrong vocals again killing it, chorus very catchy, love the lyric "another protestor has crossed the line" love the monologue type bit ( bobd) love the switch up to this song, my fav green day song, love the guitar effect throughout the song, lyrics are very relatable vocals amazing, catchy , love the piano notes after first chorus, love how the song gets heavier near the end- 10/10 (added to playlist) 4. Are we the waiting/St. Jimmy- ( awtw)- love the guitar, Armstrong vocals are strong, strong rhythm, love the echoed voices too, chorus is very catchy, love the reference to "Jesus of suburbia", however i did feel like this one did drag a tiny bit, became a bit repetitive ( st jimmy)- love how this song was more faster than the other song, this did feel very pop punk, rhythm was good, however was a bit too fast to keep up with, overall this one did drag a bit- 7/10 5. Give me novocaine/She's a rebel- (gmn)- love the acoustic on this very very nice rhythm, loved the vocals on this, guitar effects were brilliant, loved the guitar solo- (rebel)- again loved the switch up to this one, very upbeat, love the lyrics, love the references to the other songs on this album, loved the drums- 8/10 (liked the song) 6. Extraordinary girl/Letter bomb- (extrod girl)- not too keen on the drums at the start of this song, however I loved the guitar and drums had amazing consistency, loved the lyrics, again was relatable for aspects (no I'm not a prozzie), (letterbomb)- loved the little singalong at the beginning, the build up was good, however was not too fond on the little screech billie let out, I did get a bit bored of this one, found it a little bit weaker than the others-7/10 7. Wake me up when September ends- another green day classic, love Armstrong vocals, a bit of a sad turn for the album, considering the background and lyrics to the song, love the guitar picking, love the gradual build up too, it was fucking amazing, very catchy tune. - 9/10 8. Homecoming- found the start a bit boring, vocals were ok, love the instrumentals, drums and guitars were brilliant, found this one a bit boring, as i thought it did drag a bit- 5/10 9. Whatsername- nice lyrics, loved the rhythm, vocals were on point, love the guitar build up, 6/10 overall this album is truly a masterpiece, being one of my top 10 albums of all time, I have always been amazed by green days work.. the songs are very consistent and love how they all compliment on another, lyrics and theme on post 9/11, American culture and war really show you the real world in just a matter of an album. fav song: holiday/boulevard of broken dreams, least fav: homecoming overall average rating:7.8/10

Listen to Green Day mature since Dookie to this album is like seeing your drug dealer buddy who’s all grown up with a house, family and job. I’ve always liked this album. Great to be reintroduced to it again. Still love it.

Nastalgic

Some parts were better than I remembered, others feel a bit tacked on. Still, this is a foundational memory album for my musical history. I’ve probably listened to this album 100 times. 3.5/5

Dude, the Johnny Test theme song!!! I'm kidding, obviously. It's funny how similar they are, though. Was not excited for this one. Don't have the nostalgia for it that a lot of people have. I also don't really like his voice. I don't really know what to feel about this. It could have been worse. I'm sure that there's some important themes in this album, but I can't really focus on them. There were parts I dare say were okay, and I didn't absolutely hate my time with it like I suspected I might, but I got pretty annoyed and tired of it by the end... I'm left feeling empty. I expected to come out of this experience angry, but there's nothing. I guess my favourite song was Give Me Novacaine/She's a Rebel. but even that song annoyed me at parts.

Pop Punk - not as bad as I expected. It's not awful

An good album for sure. Wouldn't listen outside of the singles but I did enjoy it.

Well well well, it's been a long time since I've listened to this! I remember enjoying it when it first came out, until radio got a hold of it!

Never knowingly listened to any Green Day and, having seen the name in loads of places, was quite looking forward to this. It's OK, in a bit of a generic sort of way. It reminded me of something, but for the life of me I can't remember exactly what it was. Perhaps a bit of the Saw Doctos, which is a bizarre thing for it to sound like. But then Davy Carlton was in a punk band so maybe it does sound a bit similar. It's certainly radio friendly enough and, I'm afraid, a little bit bland for me. I probably need to listen to this a few more times to get a true impression. Perhaps it's absolute genius, I don't know. It's not really punk though is it? Alt-rock, sure. College radio friendly I imagine.

Today’s album will be very easy to review! Not only because of my familiarity with it, but also because I reviewed it on my YouTube only a couple of months ago. I don’t want to be someone who spans their own stuff, so just let me know if you want a link to that. Songs I already knew: all of them Favourites: Give Me Novocaine, St Jimmy I remember the first time I heard American Idiot. My parents had a PC under the stairs and I watched the music video on YouTube. I was hooked from the beginning. I couldn’t tell you how many times I’ve listened to this album but it’s definitely a lot. It has some angstiness, but is still melodic and poppy enough to stick in your head. I wouldn’t say it’s perfect (I never really liked Holiday, and I don’t really see the point of Are We The Waiting) but it’s still a very good album overall.

oh baby. The songs I don't know are so much better than the ones I do know... I think it's because the ones I do know are just too cringe?

i feel like this is probably the best 2000s punk rock album out there, has variety interesting topics great singalong and nice riffs. its the complete package

Love it. Might be the only Green Day album I've ever bought actually, definitely a maturity to it that I wasn't expecting from them at the time. Playing is tight, and it holds a consistent theme throughout. Not a weak track IMO. 5/5

Sometimes you have to check your biases. This was not as bad as I expected it to be. Actually quite enjoyable and more so with each listen. Even the singles started not to annoy in context.

Huh, a Green Day Rock Opera, and it's much better than it ought to be! Ignoring the songs that got played to death on the radio, this is actually a very good album with some excellent songs, especially the longer medleys. Glad I heard this in the end! 3 / 5 stars.

good memories, and this kinda holds up, but most of it is only ok

Good about 4 stars

Pakko olla hyvä levy kun on niin paljon hyviä kappaleita. Mahdollisesti kuitenkin se Green Dayn paras levy

Het verbaasde me echt hoeveel nummers ik kende, niet helemaal mijn ding maar keek dit soms toch ook wel op youtube om hip te zijn rawr xd

Ik mag het eigenlijk niet zo hoog raten maar ik vind dit gewoon een top album. Green Day op hun best, en voor mij mega nostalgisch. Uit de tijd dat ik thuis kwam na de basisschool en ‘green day rsmv’ op YouTube intypte (ik was 10)

A gem through and through. The Led Zeppelin of our time.

The defining musical work of Bush-era America. Angry, snotty, melancholic, a blast.

That's me!

awful trash

Loads of classics on here, and I love the way songs blend into each other. Lots of variety and a political intent - love it.

I never gave this album a chance when it was new. I was so done with Greenday at this point. But fuck, it's good.

Excellent!

Buen disco de punk-rock con temas cañeros, ritmos acelerados y voz característica. Algún tema muy reconocido. Disco motivador y que incita a moverse

forever the best green day album

I'm not a Green Day fan, and there's not a single from this album that I have liked, but I listened to it anyway...it's not good. Overindulgent but completely uninteresting punkish rock opera with annoying vocals and songs that go on way too long. At it's best, it's okay (I don't mind Whatsername or Holiday), at it's work it's insufferable. 1.5/5

First half I was going to put a 4 which surprised me a lot. Second half was a little too inspired by Black Parade imo

I like the title track a lot. Good people, good album

Better than I remember

Green Day has spent their career disproving my hypothesis that I can totally hate them. And, while I can't totally, easily hate them...this record comes close with every overproduced, over-instrumented slow number meant to be "meaningful" from the band that brought us the album titled "Dookie" and named themselves after a big weed session. And here we are with this record. I'm not a fan of Green Day's Grease by way of the Clash mixed with their own selves from a decade ago and a dropout version of Professor Greg Graffin's course on Bad Religion. Quadrophenia this is not. And yet, I'll give it an entire star for existing at all as a signpost to punk that existed in the mainstream during some rough years for radio rock and a second star for the opening track.

I was 16 when this album came out, and a big fan of Greenday, especially Dookie, and for some reason I just hated this album. Probably that hipster thing of hating how popular greenday became with casual fans and being that guy who kept raving about their older stuff. Listening back as a more mature adult, this album is better than my 16 year old self gave it credit for. Probably deserves its place on the list, but won’t be making my frequent rotation anytime soon.

Grew up on this album! Brings back memories

Fun, iconic punk rock (pop punk? Pop rock?). More technical than I remembered, with meter changes, etc

I knew the big hits off this album, but I was surprised by the amount of depth there was across the rest. A lot more varied and complex than I would have expected.

holiday is my go to song to play on the drums

Des hits, évidemment, mais aussi des morceaux de 9 minutes un peu relou. Pas trop mon truc.

5/5. No notes.

a guilty pleasure. one complaint- shorten the songs!! a 3.2

Jodå, här finns en å annan bra låt.

Still amazing, almost 20 years later.

Honestly a banger that I’ve liked more and more since it was released.

Not a fan of Green Day, still not. The pre-genitors of whiney boy rock wanna-be punk rock bands.

Proof that the the old axiom, “no one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American people” is not only true, but that you can turn a buck (quite a few, as it turns out) calling them idiots to their face.

I’ve never seen any artist combine two songs into one. Maybe I’m just really not observant. But I really enjoy this album. Pop punk is probably one of my favorite genres of music. With the songs being combined as one kinda bores me but that’s because I have a short attention span lmao. Holiday probably is my favorite song from this album. Overall this album is great.

American Idiot is a classic punk rock/pop album. It symbolized and represented a young generation's fear for their collective future. Jesus of Suburbia is one of my favorite Green Day songs, and while American Idiot is maybe overplayed, it is still a bop. Nevertheless, it is still a pop punk album.

Great at what it is but dated

Didn’t listen, grow up album generator.

Puerile pop punk in which you can actually hear Billie Joe’s god complex. More Radio 1 than rebellion, but some catchy tunes here and there.

First half is great, second half not so much - can't stand "wake me up when September ends". It's like a bat out of hell, rock opera type affair. I enjoyed it Jesus of Suburbia is the highlight.

A more polished Green Day than earlier albums. They know their audience - this is still pop punk targeted towards tweens & teens. No hidden gems; the hits were already overplayed on radio.

Interesting rock opera I had to read along with the lyrics to get it but enjoyable nontheless

I remember everyone flipping out over this album. I feel like this album could've been half the length because they're just repeating the chorus like 6 times. What the fuck, man.

I know a lot of people think this is a great album. I think it’s good but still does hit top rated for me.

I liked this a lot more - and knew it a lot better -than I expected. Some good tunes, plenty of good melodies. Obviously the theme is a bit "American" for my interests but that's kind of the point. A good find.

Highlights: "American Idiot," "Holiday" It's easy to understand the success of this as a resolute musical comeback for a beloved pop group, with all the hooks and energy their fans could want. But I don't think anyone would have asked for this group to make something so self-serious as a narrative concept album with nine-minute medleys. You can't really call it a "rock opera" so much as a musical, a mark of the increasing convergence in emo et al between rock fans and theater kids. You could imagine Lin Manuel Miranda featuring somewhere in here. Just kidding. But not really. "Dookie" has an appeal as one of many 90s albums about being a loser, something way more grounded and honest and sympathetic than being a millionaire in the Bay making an utterly flat character with a 'Christ figure' label say "how dare you sir." What's really so frustrating is that the narrative seems to obscure the initial setup. The lyrics of "Holiday" don't even line up semantically, let alone arrive at a message, but you definitely get extremely political airs with a clear context of Bush-era jingoism for two wars in the Middle East. And this album literally has a bleeding heart as a weapon on the cover. And it says nothing at all with that. The protagonist gets a girlfriend, smokes weed, gets dumped, and commits suicide. The "letterbomb" in the album if *figurative* for a mean letter sent to an ex. Even if this is some allegory, suggested by the inept use of quasi-pseudo-Indian affect to introduce the love interest, the tail is wagging the dog, and it's not only incomprehensible but ultimately self-pitying. It's purely inward-looking, interested in the suffering and guilt of Americans. Or else that's giving it too much credit. Really a touchstone of feckless liberal resistance preening, a work of dithering, diffusive controlled opposition, a great cash cow dropped all of two months before Bush took a second term, giving no one a moment's pause over what it really had to say.

I remember this being a big departure from the "REAL" green day back in the day and listening back to it I feel as if it's trying to be inflammatory but not too much so as to not offend people for real.

Ok. I generally like the genre and 'Boulevard of broken dreams' is good, but on the whole I prefer Blink-182.

Bra men kort

Was quite something when this album came out - Green Day being political and ambitious artistically - however, it has aged and it hasn't helped that it was way overplayed. What's left is a decent album, with nods to the who, and a little brainier than Green Day's other outings, yet not as earnest and fun.

this was worse than i remember i was rly annoyed

There were some wonderful moments in the 90s, but some of the 90s make me think we shouldn't do them again. Green day sound like a leftover of that part of the 90s. I'm not sure how this style of music earned the moniker of punk, highly processed and produced it doesn't relate to original punk music, from either the UK or the US. I gritted my teeth and listended attently, I even thought some of it was OK but there's nothing here that I thought was a breakthrough, musically or culturally, just a band doing their thing for as long as someone is still listening. Not me, I'm not playing this album again.

classic punk record

Excellent

So much nostalgia. First half of this album is legendary

Genre: Punk rock Review: One of the earliest pieces of English music I ever listened to was "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" when I was in high school. Since then I must have listened to this album dozens of times, and every time with increasing admiration for the rebellious passion and energy that drove every track. Rating: A clear 10/10

De stem van Billie Joe Armstrong kan ik waarderen. Waardoor ook dit album. Sommige nummers duren wel erg lang dus dan wordt het langdradig maar komt ook deels omdat ik met momenten een ongeduldig persoon ben. Had nog nooit volledig naar dit album geluisterd en vond dat leuk om te doen.

Some great songs and some stinkers. I remember buying this album when it came out. Not a fan of the 2 song tracks. It’s no dookie.

A real banger of its day

Superb album.

Very enjoyable.

Conceptalbum van Green Day over de polariserende tijd van de administratie Bush Jr. Bevat de meeste van hun beste nummers, o.a. American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia en Wake Me up When September Ends. leukste nummer: Jesus of Suburbia De invloed van David Bowie's The Rise And Fall Of Ziggy Stardust is goed te horen en geeft het album een fantastische sound.

Good, lots of catchy moments, nice feel about the album

Is it punk? Nah. Are these complex songs with a lot of depth? Also no. Is this an 'anti-american' and political album? Nah, not really. Was this 'punk-opera' the first of its kind? Nope, been done several times before. But is it a fun, catchy and just rocking album? Sure as hell it is!

Started to lose interest in Green Day around this point, possibly their last decent album. Cliché I know, but preferred their earlier works.

First few songs were too dissonant for me. Liked some of the later songs but probably not enough to buy the album.

3.6 - While I don't love this record I can appreciate how it helped to rekindle Green Day's career. With their mall-punk blend of processed power chords and melodic hooks, they've managed to swipe broadly at American politics. Mostly it's too bombastic for my taste - the songs trail on for too long, the arena-filling slogans are too on-the-nose (e.g. "She's A Rebel") - but I do like the two big hits on here ("Boulevard of Broken Dreams", "Wake Me Up..."). "Good for them!" I consistently say to myself as I listen. With this record, I imagine Green Day managed to please their die-hard fans, and also capture legions of disaffected younger fans.

Didn't like it all. I just hate the singers voice, and the instrumentation was more boring than i thought it would be. The lyrics are bad. Some of the guitars sounded okay. But it was not an enjoyable experience, sad because I thought I would have liked it.

Reminds me of highschool, teenage angst favorite song is either wake me up when September ends or holiday. Interesting how almost all the tracks are double.

Solid from start to finish.

I had a better time with this than Dookie, but I think that's mostly from familiarity (I'll cop to kinda liking "Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams," but otherwise I've really disliked their stuff). I'm definitely in the age cohort such that this one was a big, big deal to people when it came out, so it was nostalgic to play this and realize I knew each song on here really well. But it's also interesting to pull the lists of what else was going on in rock music at the time, and 2004 had a lot going on! Like that's the year that brings us Franz Ferdinand and "Hot Fuss," Modest Mouse released "Good News," White Stripes had just put out "Elephant" the previous year... idk I know emo went strong into the aughts, but my personal big music touchpoints for that era tended to be alt-rock/indie stuff.

A solid pop punk opera.

Je déteste c'est surcôté à balle et c'est gênant comme pas possible

Admittedly, I'm not the biggest Green Day fan, and I remember finding the songs from this album pretty trite when they came out. But in the context of this album, they become part of a larger whole that ebbs and flows organically. I love the idea of a punk concept album as well.

Never been a fan of Green Day. That 90s-punk, cutesy face, faux high-energy thrash. Ripping off other bands' songs like Chicago and The Who, while trying to act "original." Then comes this concept album. And I have to admit, it's done really well. I think a few of the songs ramble a bit, like Jesus of Suburbia. Homecoming I think was the one that really went on too long. Biggest problem for me is that Billy Joe's voice, for a concept album doesn't fit. He doesn't have the kind of range needed. I think they could have used a few other singers in there to vary it up some. Ultimately, it did work as an album, and as much as I am not a fan of GD I have to respect what they achieved here.

I was really impressed by this album when it came out. Still am. To me, it's Greed Day's last great album. At the time, I would say that Green Day didn't really make bad albums. But the previous one (Warning) wasn't that well-received by audiences. To me this was proof that Green Day was good at what they did and wouldn't disappoint (later albums changed my view). They took a very different approach to what they had done previously and it worked really well. This is a very cool, unique rock opera. I thought their two multi-part songs (Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming) were excellent and those are the two that really took them outside their comfort zone. Their singles (American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, were also great fun, rocking tunes - good lyrics and good pop punk beats and tempos. They deserved to be big hits. Wake Me Up When September Ends is the one single that I grew tired of (even before it became a single). Non-singles that I was always fond of are St. Jimmy, She's a Rebel, Letterbomb, and Whatsername. Big fan of this album, a mid-2000's classic.

Lots of good parts on it

Good album

C+ philosophy and politics meets A+ rock.

Me twenty years ago: "This album is so overrated." Me now: "I need to add all of these songs to my library."

I enjoyed the first half, but it really starts to drag

Listened to this the other week and rather enjoyed it

Clearly a band trying to outgrow one-note punk, but the only good songs on this are the one-note punk songs. And what's with the voice?

Punk grows up and becomes pop. A rocker of an album.

Heard it before?: Yes Enjoy it?: Yeah definitely, it’s one of the first albums I listened to as a child, just great rock all round and I’d rather entertaining from start to finish, just wish the tracks were separated and not conjoined? Favourite song: Track 3 - Holdiay/Boulevard Of Broken Dreams

Brilliant

Good listen and mixed playlist after

God I hate Green Day. Almost all of their famous songs either sound goofy, cheesy, or rip-off another song. You can argue that "songs sound like other songs" all the time in music, but Green Day does it so much that they constantly get called out for it, and that obnoxious voice only detracts from these iconic songs. Now, I will admit most of these rip-off songs are not on this album, but that doesn't excuse my hatred of this whiney ass band. So, let's just say I'm not going into this album with the most neutral mindset of these pop punk shit. Alright, this isn't any better. His vocals still suck, and knowing almost every song in some way just made me know right when it started I hated it. And why, oh why, is a punk album, what's know for being short and sometimes sweet, have multiple way too long songs. I realize they are usually multiple songs in one, but they are always listed as one, so they shall be punished as one. Just awful. Have no clue why pop punk is such a popular genre.

I love the whole album

The quintessential rock opera album. Exceptional.

Solid, if unspectacular. Outranked by Dookie

Would have definitely enjoyed it more during my Panic! At the Disco phase. It’s fun to listen to and I liked some of the songs, but a lot of them are way too long for no reason. BJ’s voice is a bit too overwhelming for me. Will probably listen to some songs separately, when I’m in a mood for some teenage angst.

I have mixed feelings about this album. It sounds great, and sounds like Green Day, but the concept album kind of ruins it for me. I suppose this album is, for me, like Dookie was 10 years prior to all the original Green Day fans. A big change that made them even more popular than ever, but I wasn't a huge fan of.

Ingen bias här inte

Absolute masterpiece of an album. Not as good as Dookie, but damn close. It's funny that this album was just fun pop music to me in 5th grade, but now I can appreciate it as one with genuinely poignant points about life. Favorite track: Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel

It’s not Dookie, but it’s probably, technically better. I’m too big of a fan to rate Green Day objectively, but i won’t apologize.

Very samey, sounds like a petulant bunch of adolescents. Not really enjoying over much

This has always been a start to finish listen for me. The Broadway show was amazing too. 5/5 every day.

Still slaps

Didn't even have to think about my choice for a second. Instant 5 star album! American Idiot: A great opening and titular track. A classic song that when listened to right is a wonderful protest song, and when listened to wrong becomes a beautiful form of irony. Jesus of Suburbia: While the song doesn't compare to it's inspiration in terms of sound or legacy, it is a damn good song, that even at 9 minutes and 8 seconds long doesn't drag. Holiday: If the fact that this is a protest album hadn't set in yet this track has to make it apparent. Boulevard of Broken Dreams: This track really just speaks for itself. It is one that stands on its own as its single and while I don't mind the message behind the album it is nice to have a less political song. Are We the Waiting: I think this song is super underrated just a nice melodic break in the middle of the punk. St. Jimmy: Good classic punk sound for the first half and more rock opera like at the end. Not my favorite but good. Give Me Novacaine: Also very underrated, I like melodies and I will not apologize for it. I love punk and pop punk but they could benefit from more melodic parts sometimes. She's a Rebel: Not bad just not that special of a song on this good of an album. Extraordinary Girl: This is probably the weakest song on the album, just nothing special about it. Letterbomb: I like this song a lot, but I get why it isn't as popular. Wake Me Up When September Ends: I mean it is the all time classic song. It is just such a damn good song. Though I hate the memes that get made from it and the annoying commenters that "inform" everybody what it is about even though we all already know. Homecoming: This tries to do everything that "Jesus of Suburbia" did, but it just doesn't quite do it as well. It is supposed to be the wrap up to the story and it does have a lot of resolve to it, just not as much of a hitter on its own. Whatsername: Just a nice closing song to a great album! I love Green Day I love this album! Green Day was my first ever concert and I went with my Mom. Will forever be one of my favorite memories! This album is a 5 in so many ways and just never gets old. As a concept album and as a album with great singles it excels. Polyphonic on YouTube has a great video breaking down this album.

3 stars for the drummer. -1 star for everything else being shite.

It has its moments.

Decent singles but that's it

Still a good listen. Has dated pretty rapidly. Fairly poptastic

Generous 3 saved by some good singles. Feels dated now.

Like, it’s fine. This is probably the Apex of Green Day.

I must be getting old this is catchy AF and I didn't hate it.

This brought me right back to high school days. ALL THE NOSTALGIA! So surprised I hadn't listened to the whole thing before, it would have been (and still is) right up my alley

Brings back a lot of memories. Walking to work with this on my original iPod. I like this album, although When Sept. Ends has been played to death. I'd be fine never hearing that song again. Overall, I really like this album.

Oh boy. Bush. Elementary school. If somebody asked me what life was like in 2004-2005 I would simply have them listen to this album. I remember the cynicism of that era well, despite being 9. This album was the coolest, punkest thing I could have imagined at the time. It’s been said that every teenager who heard The Velvet Underground & Nico started a band. The closest thing our generation might have to that is American Idiot. They’re not even my taste particularly but im thinking Green Day has got to be the greatest rock band of my lifetime

There’s a lot of hits on this one but imma play it down a lil cause I’m a hater and some of this shit corny. Honestly a good album and stuff

Takes me straight back to being 13. Great album that stood the test of time, classic pop-punk.

Some really good songs, lots of really mid songs. Therefore, MID

BEST GREEN DAY ALBUM

Track Ranking: 1. Jesus Of Suburbia - 9 2. American Idiot - 8 3. Wake Me Up When September Ends - 8 4. St. Jimmy - 8 5. Homecoming - 8 6. Letterbomb - 7 7. Holiday - 7 8. She's A Rebel - 7 9. Boulevard Of Broken Dreams - 7 10. Extraordinary Girl - 7 11. Give Me Novacaine - 6 12. Whatsername - 6 13. Are We The Waiting - 5

The first half of this album is by far the best part of it, the back half seems like a lot of samey filler. I don't mind political messages, but to say the politics on this album are ham-fisted is an understatement. Also, this albums mastering is a victim of the loudness wars, it was honestly fatiguing listening to this album all the way through at a normally very tolerable listening volume. This teeters between a 2 and a 3 for me, I'll be nice and give it a 3.

Never listened to before, only heard select songs "Old" comparatively Very same-samey from song to song Start of Extraordinary Girl is nice because its not punk rock and then it becomes punk rock again. tsk tsk Not an enjoyable album, cannot comment on its production quality Thought the last song was incredibly good until I realized that spotify had turned on radio mode and was playing a Gorillaz song LMAO

A pivotal moment in my having musical taste while entering highschool. Now? It’s alright. But I’ll always appreciate this album.

peak 2000s punk?

I would rate it five stars because of my teenage year's soundtrack, but I'll finally rate it with four because the album is too repetitive. Very good album and that's enough

Despite the nostalgia behind this one, I can’t get myself behind everyone’s favorite mainstream emo LP of the aughts. The highlights (‘Idiot,’ ‘Boulevard,’ ‘September’) show the band at their most creative and confrontational, but they’re ultimately dragged down by being coupled to longer, less innovative sections in the weird decision to shove two songs together into one for a cinematic purpose. The rest is just filler - I’m not expecting punk songs to use more than three chords, but the production is so sterile and lifeless that the lack of dynamic melodies/tempos/rhythms really sinks this one to two-star territory.

not as good as I expected - lack of catchy hooks, lacklustre lyrics, and an uneven focus of an overarching concept (contrary to its status as a concept album). standouts were pretty great though

Close to perfect. Clean production, iconic songwriting, sticky melodies, and a strong message. Never overstays its welcome, even on two different 9+ minute songs impressively enough. Realistically one of my top 10 albums of all time.

instant classic

Green Day has always been an anomaly. Highly polished, impeccably produced and finished, and aimed at the heart of the American wallet. But when you listen to them, all of their themes are raw, gritty, and anti-capitalist. If you like Green Day, you'll love this pop-punk opera. If you don't then you're better off listening to something else.

Fantastic album, superb production, great rock album

Even before listening to it, I knew it was a classic and I would most likely really dig it and I wasn't wrong. I really liked it.

Was okay, but made my ears wanna bleed when they start jamming too hard

First CD I ever bought. I still think this album is great. I remember listening to it with my Dad in his car when he—and this is music I knew he would humor but not indulge in himself, mind you—said, "Usually there's only 1 or 2 good songs on an album. But nearly every song on this album is good." I didn't know anything about albums at the time, but I agreed that almost every song on this album was indeed good. And I still believe that. In an objective sense, it's difficult to argue there's a not-catchy song on this album. Or see why the response to this album, especially among burgeoning scene kid community, was so enormous. This is an enormous, theatrical, ambitious, political and important post-9/11, pop-punk masterpiece. It's a little cringe-worthy maybe. And it hurts a little to see the trio behind Dookie stoop to this sort of sentimentalism following the prom-night success of "Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)." But the band who wrote "Basket Case" and "Welcome to Paradise" is still very present in the louder, angrier songs here. The songwriting is still very, very good. And in many ways this is a better record than anything they ever recorded. Certainly it is bigger. More influential. Perhaps, more important. Even if it is hard to swallow with all its populism. I love this record. It's a guilty pleasure for which I have a sweet tooth. I'd roll the window up if "Wake Me Up When September Ends" came on my radio while driving, but I wouldn't turn it off. "Boulevard," though, I might turn off. That's just a tad too sweet. 4/5.

We are closing out 2022, and it is time I put aside all the old, well-worn prejudices against Green Day that I harbored in high school. The sins of the fans– the many sins of some *particular* fans I knew in high school– are not the sins of the band, and they should not cloud my judgment. At this point, 50 albums in, I am like Spock, a Vulcan reviewer, evaluating albums on pure logic. So utterly removed am I from emotion. So advanced beyond the petty, petty drama from 2007. I have attained escape velocity. The baggage I once came to this record with has all but escaped my mind. I have forgotten it. I am one. With Green Day. To listen to this album is to experience a divergence... a dissonance. On one hand, here I am with all of my prejudice. On the other is a genuinely captivating record. Oozing with ambition, with confidence and vision and rock opera-ness and so many goddamn hits that it seems impossible they're all on this album. The height to which this band climbs on this album is so impossibly high, it's hard to not just gawk at how high up things are. It really feels like a capstone record for a time, and maybe for the genre altogether. The conclusion of something. I think the band should be extremely proud of the record, and they really deserve the praise they get for it. And really... really, I'm over it. I swear. Really. I'm going on two listens. We'll see about 3.

Classic!

лучший альбом в жанре который я не люблю, но здесь они смогли сделать так, чтобы понравилось даже мне. 4 абсолютно айконик песни на этом альбоме, и остальное тоже максимально достойное, и даже отчасти концептуальное Лучшие песни: Wake Me Up When September Ends, American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday, Whatsername Фактор ностальгии и моего эмо-детства сыграл не последнюю роль в выставлении оценки

solid album. 4.

One of my favourite albums of all time.

This album is not how I remember it from when it first came out. Did they really combine so many tracks? Weird. The political stuff felt a bit lightweight and simplistic when I was 14, and hasn't aged particularly well - but musically it's still really fun, varied, and got a lot going on. And I'm a sucker for a good rock opera. Can't remember how many of these they released as singles, but could easily have been American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, St Jimmy, and Wake Me Up When September Ends - although none of those songs are lifechangingly brilliant, it's rare that you get six single-worthy songs on a single album. 4/5.

A modern rock opera without the cringe, probably their best and most cohesive work. Angrily reflecting the hypocritical American rhetoric of the time. A masterpiece.

Hard to believe this is 15 years old. Great listen.

Great album! Yes it's commercially successful, no that's not automatically bad.

Klassiker, kann ich noch auswendig

This album feels like the sound of a decade to some degree. Hugely popular at the time and rightly so. It also feels like it’s aged well. 4.5/5

Mostly pretty middling to me, a couple great songs though.

Well, I've already heard this one about 300 times lmao

This album was my intro to the genre by my 7th grade history teacher. It’s a solid record that has aged so incredibly well. Shout out to Mr. Kerr!

Simple and understandable melody. Rhythm is not felt. Bit i can read the lyrics.

Interesting at times, especially with the longer song lengths. Includes some classic songs from the era. Didn't find it to be consistently great.

Good record. Skip it somewhy when was young. Should be in my collection

Well, this is a second time I have to write a review for this album, so in short - it's great. So many hits and singles, and in the context of the record they sound even better than on the radio. It's a really wild ride, and for sure a pleasurable one.

Mitähän tästä kirjoittaisi? Kiistattomasti maailman isoimpia pop punk levyjä Dookien ja Offspringin Smash:in kanssa. Se on sinällään jo ihan hienoa. Mulla on vähän ristiriitainen suhde koko GD bändiin. Tavallaan sillä on ollut kiistaton vaikutus muhun, mutta myös äärimmäiseen kaupallisuuteen menevä bändi saa jotenkin kulahtaneen oksennuksen nousemaan huulille. Samalla tavalla tällä levyllä on ollut iso merkitys siihen miten itse kirjotan musaa ja mistä ne meidän PYU:n poppijutut lopulta kumpuaa. Tavallaan tämä levy on hyvä ja hieno. Jos Queen tekis punkkii niin se kuulostais varmaan tällaselta punkkioopperalta. Näille hiteille on altistunut niin monta kertaa että ne on aika rajua kuulla läpi mutta muut biisit pelastaa. Kaipaisin levylle lisää räkää ja paskaa sen sijaan että soundi on ultrahiottua studiomenoa. Toisaalta jos tehdään poppia niin tehdään sit kunnolla — siinä tässä onnistutaan ja se tavallaan tekee tästä hyvän levyn. On ihan turhaa että mä raivoon että ”ei oo oikeeta punkkia” kun kyseessä on oikeesti hyvä pop levy. Levy on täynnä toinen toistaan isompia hittejä, mutta kyllä st.Jimmy on ehkä se terävintä poppiksen ja rokin sekotusta. Vaikee arvostella. Tavallaan haluaisin antaa 3 tai vaan 2 pistettä mutta ehkä tää korvamatoisuus ja sit tosiaan se kiistaton vaikutus oman musan tekemiseen aina sieltä 10-vuotiaan Kallen maailmasta asti hilaa pistehanat enemmän auki. Vetäkää käteen! Annan mä sen 3 pongoo 3/5

Yritin kitkeä tätä halveksineen teiniminän ja suhtautua avoimesti, mutta siis ei helvetti. Ei ei ei. Kamalia biisejä kaikki paitsi ehkä pari hittiä. Boulevard of Broken Dreams saa isot sympatiat/nostalgiat, koska oli eka biisi, jota opettelin skidinä kitaratunnilla. Mutta en voi sen perusteella antaa tähtiä.

Yläasteella taas. Oman aikansa kuva, ja edelleen toimii ihan hyvin! 3/5

Wonderful

I WALK ALONE!!!

Punk rock opera. It's such an interesting phrase, and one that fits Green Day's massive album, "American Idiot". Apparently, more than just signing with a major label and being one of the biggest "pop-punk" act of the early 2000's, they made a CONCEPT ALBUM. With tracks as long as 9 minutes, complex structure, and big guitar and production tricks. Perhaps the only common thing between Green Day's sound and punk's general sound it the political and teenage angst dimension of it. That being said, it's a more demanding listen than I expected. Some tunes and lyrics are fire, but some are too messy to follow. I might listen to it again with more focus, but as of now, I'm not in a mood for some overblown punk rock.

The Dookie/American Idiot dichotomy sums up my issues with aughts-era angst and protest; where the 90s were a relatively peaceful and prosperous time, the youth were angry, didn't know why, and were ready to aim it at everything. With the destabilization of the 00s, the warmongering and conservative-christian values sinking their teeth into a weakened US, musicians descended into a brand of toothless, commercial protest music. There was so much going on at this time, yet the most trenchant observation most of these groups could muster was "the president is pretty dumb, and by proxy so are we Americans." However, there's a whole generation of people who were in middle or high school when this album came out, and it was their first and most accessible expression of anger and dissent. But to me this sounds like a collection of zippy singalongs, peppering in midsong reminders to go hit up the festival's voter registration tent.

Technically my day one but I lost the account name to that project after that day and decided to ignore that account. But this album is a 5/5 but MCR’s the black parade is the better concept album of the 2000’s and should’ve been on the book.

Better than I expected!

This album was the soundtrack of my youth. an exhuberant, dread inducing, landmark of the bush era that says no to war, no to isolation, and a send up to the human spirit.

Nostalgic but not my favorite Green Day although I like that it’s a concept album

I was surprised by the depth of this albums tracks, I only remember the titular track as being from this album, and thought the rest were from earlier albums. Pretty surface level commentary. I think this album got turned into a musical and I can see why you could really thread a narrative of a despondent youth through the songs.

Bold and fun. A great ensemble of songs. Loud for me.

The best rock album of the 2000s and probably ever since. This album defined a generation and spawned hits that stand to this day. It recovered GD’s career while also being so commercially and critically successful, everyone knows where they were when this album was out. The production is perfect with it’s layers of electric guitar tracks and acoustic guitar foundation, the dynamics are strong, the album has movements, a storyline, it is thematic and theatric, and overall just rocks. This will always be my favourite album.

What a great album with an A side that is as good as it gets. Rest of the album falls off a little bit but the overall impression remains great

Sadly, the title track's even more relevant now than it was back then.

I was a big fan of early Green Day. This album was good, but too poppy for me.

9/10 shows its age but still really good

10/10. I don't wanna be an American Idiot, and I don't wanna put each song on its own track

It’s quite good, but it’s a lot of Green Day all at once. 8/10

This album dropped when I was a freshman in highschool, and with a lot of things from that time period I was interested in, I was expecting to cringe while relistening to this. I'm happy to report that wasn't the case, this album still holds up and was pretty ambitious for the time. While I think I prefer other rock operas, Green Day tried something new and found a format that really worked for them.

Pop Punk's last great gasp as a mainstream musical force (although it's starting to re-emerge here and there these days, with highly mixed results) and the best album Green Day managed since 1994's 'Dookie'. I still remember being in high school and walking by a group of freshmen huddled together, singing the album's title track. I could be wrong, but it's a rare thing these days for albums to elicit the sort of fandom this album prompted - it's all the radio could play for a solid year; even the 9-minute 'Jesus of Suburbia' got its moment in the sun - when was the last time anyone had patience for a 9-minute song?? Admittedly, Armstrong sort of cheated, given it's not a really a 9-minute song, but a medley of 5 shorter songs, but I'll be damned if I won't listen to that entire thing all the way through everytime I put it on. Putting aside the 5 major hits this album spawned, some of my fondest memories of this album reside in the non-radio hits - the anthemic 'Are We the Waiting?', the poignant sentiment and longing of 'Whatsername', or the band's willingness to segue from the 'concept album' focus and just have a bit of goofy fun on parts of 'Homecoming'. This album is terrific, no matter how you spin it.

Having heard this album plenty of times already, I'll pass on listening to it again... forever.

-this shit slaps -consistent across all tracks

This sounds quintessential early 2000s post punk.

A stone cold classic, the best album they ever made and one of the best of the century so far. Another band I saw live, on the tour for their album following this one, and a band who put everything into each show. Was never likely to be less than full marks, but listening again confirmed it as entirely deserving of 5 big 🌟

Hit na hit. Meezingbaar, herkenbaar, stevig (met hier en daar een kort momentje van rust) . Kortom een zeer goed album!

Très solide comme album. C’est la première fois que je l’écoute en entier. Je réalise que tous les hits qu’il y a dessus forment un tout et que c’est plus réfléchi que ce qui n’y parait en écoutant les pièces une à une.

Couldn’t get into it. It just felt very phony to me. I don’t need Billie Joe to tell me how to feel about George Bush, or anything else that actually matters. What on earth is the point of slick, serious Green Day? Don’t get me wrong, I also dislike the rest of their music. But my sense of it is that it at least has a certain integrity in being the anthem for a kind of kid who actually comes from a totally safe suburban home, but chooses to be a dirtbag because everything else is too much effort. Or maybe it’s just that one song.

I am very familiar with Green Day. They were a big part of my formative years with music. The first cassette of theirs I ever owned was Nimrod, and I loved it. After that, I went out and bought Insomniac and Dookie. American Idiot came out when I was in university, and got a lot of air play on both Much Music, as well as the university radio station. There were quite a few singles released off of this record: Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends, American Idiot, and Jesus of Suburbia. The song Holiday reminds me of the movie Accepted every time I hear it. This album is fantastic. 2 songs (Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming) are 9 minutes long each, but there are tempo changes throughout, so really each of them is like 4-5 songs. Overall, I love this band and this album. So great, I listened to it twice. Favourite songs: Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends, American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Are We the Waiting/St. Jimmy Least favourite songs: if forced to pick one, Whatsername 5/5

From albums named after shit to political agitator, hey? Naaaaah.

green day - american idiot (2004) notes - i dont even need to listen to this, i could recite the whole album from memory because of how much i listened to this album between the ages of 10 and 14 - i saw the musical and i had green day rockband for the wii - so its pretty much impossible to separate nostalgia from this album - i’m realizing relistening to the album now how much of the lyrics i didnt fully understand - this album does such a great job of flowing from one song to the next as a complete project Fav - Extraordinary girl / letterbomb - This was my favourite as a young lad and it remains least fav - give me novacaine / shes a rebel - the weakest of the 2 song pairings on this album 4.5/5

Good Punk Album

I unironically think this may be green day's best album. Banger.

Overrated, but solid. I can't fairly give this any less than a 3.

I’m not that into Green Day, their brand of punk always felt too suburban and tame. No real danger, it’s watered down for the mildly rebellious teen. But I can’t deny that this album is full of hits, it’s very easy to listen to, and it takes me back to a specific nostalgic point in my life. This album dropped when I started the 12th grade and it was HUGE at school. Everyone had it on rotation for the better part of that year. I started to really hate Wake Me Up When September Ends with all the airplay it got.

Yet another group I totally missed in their hey-day, and I’m glad this project helped introduce me more thoroughly to their music. They play so super-tight, which I know from experience is very difficult to do, and I like their mix of pop sensibility and punk and rock ethos. Their sound can get a little repetitive at times, but it’s not to the level of repetition that I’m too bothered by it. It’s a small number of people in the band so one does need to accept a certain amount of limitations. Overall, some pretty good work here.

Wow blast from the past…this one was fun to listen to as I was unpacking boxes and at my desk. Good upbeat rhythm to keep the energy going. Probably couldn’t listen to while working/reading, but great for doing mindless work.

I like this album more and more the older I get. I never really listened to it much when it came out, but I like it more now. It’s a really well put together album.

Consistently good throughout, only one or two songs that aren't absolute bangers.

10/10 would always recommend. i love Green Day, especially this album. it makes me so nostalgic. the fade of Holiday into Boulevard of Broken Dreams is just… chefs kiss.

Awesome stuff

It's solid but I think most the mass appeal was the shock that a skater punk band has thoughts to put into lyrics.

Fine for what it is, again not my kind of thing

Enjoyable, but I think they would be better live than on a recording.