Awesome start to a cool idea. Very nice production and playong.

Bass needed tuning n a couple of spots! Great vibe.

Before I die, am I supposed to listen to the 1956 album or the complete version released in 1999?

I prefer Curtis

Not really my thing, Peter Gabriel to me sounds like one long song. A few classics but the synths and snare sounds are stuck in time.

Enjoyed. Liked the lofi and tone and pace. Also the bits that sound like jesus christ superstar. Did not know PM had done an album around the Beatles breakup so this was all new to me.

I reckon I could have not listened to this before I died. It's an ok collection of Americana inspired pop rock but I don't get much of an album or artistic statement from it. Multiple songwriters? I bet they are one of those bands that hate their one big hit because they will feel they had more going on

I need a 3.5. Much more art here than the La's. Enjoyed this, good songs.

I took a while to warm to it but then I really did. Its the sort of exotic obscure stuff that impresses people at sophisticated dinner parties.

Bit rocky

Lyrics are intersting, but musically what was the fuss about? Truly meh

Nice folk

I'm old enough to appreciate Yacht Rock, so I kinda secretly wanted to like this, but this is real wallpaper. Like they were famous perfectionists apparently so why be so bland. Reeling in the years gets me nodding along with that groove and maybe lyrics that are trying to say something. But otherwise this was meh mcmehface

Dreadful morals, world view, narcissism, misogyny, sociopathy and materialism.

Sounds like dying duck callers. Thank god they found disco

Folky country. Nice.

Mor white dudes

Bloody excellent

If I’m listening to songs about murder, much prefer Nick cave. Music was great tho.

Love dolly.

Tots excellent.

Too screechy

Enjoyable but not one of the 1001 you must listen to before you die

Good

Sadly average.

Worth going to prison for.

Best album of all time. Better than wearing underpants.

The older I get, the less time I have for dumb lyrics.

Moody gravelly classic. Reminds me of my dear old boss Dave (rip)

Seven stars. More of this. Martin Denny les Baxter esquivel all those cats.

Good but felt a bit bland after a while.

isn't it good

Excellent music by penguins.

Magic.

Nice pop.

Would give 6 stars if I could

Nice folk

Reminds me how much blues influenced rock.

I andantes it darker. And got it darker.

It’s the bomb