I didn't think it was possible to make 44 minutes sound like 4 hours, but this managed it. What a crock of shit.

Just my luck to get two albums by the same artist on consecutive days, although this came up second... I'm glad I listened to this before Fetch The Boltcutters, which is mostly 51 minutes of shite. There are some good tracks on here - Criminal, Sullen Girl and Never Is A Promise were good. Pale September the standout.

I've put off listening to this for a couple of months or so, because I thought I knew what my reaction to it would be. But it's worse than I expected, and if I could give it a negative score I would. This album has no redeeming features whatsoever and makes me want to inhale my own vomit.

My default setting is rock, but it's 5 in the morning and I'm delightfully drunk. Sometimes you need to listen to something stripped back like this. Great album.

Well that was a pleasant surprise. I wasn't expecting much from reading the Wiki page, but I got the much - and some more. And now I'd like someone to make the film, please.

I've promised to listen to every album all the way through, and it's difficult with some. But I'd rather cut my bollocks off with a rusty razor than listen to this shit again.

Why can't I rate albums that are really, really shit as a zero? I thought I'd got as low as I could get with Supa Dupa Fly, but this was worse. Oh well, only another 819 albums to go...

"If ever an album title was in dire need of an exclamation mark It surely had to be Frampton Comes Alive!" ("Third Track Main Camera Four Minutes" by Half Man Half Biscuit. 2000) I saw Frampton support Deep Purple in 2004, and he was just as good as you would expect. This album is an absolute belter! One of the easiest 5's I'll give.

I'll be honest. From what I read before listening, I wasn't expecting much from this album. so please don't tell my mates I liked it.

Fuck me sideways, but that was tedious - and I say that as a fan of prog rock. I was all for giving it a 1, but I almost enjoyed Along The Banks Of Rivers.

The good thing about the songs being so short is you don't have to put up with them for too long. The bad thing about the songs being so short is that they can cram even more of the bastards on there. I'm giving it a generous 2 because halfway through, like an island in the middle of a sea of dirge, I enjoyed Motor Away.

Fuck me! There's 71 minutes of my life I won't get back.

It's probably the best pop album in the world ever. But that doesn't mean that I have to like it.

Well that was a pleasant surprise.

First couple of tracks were OK, but then it all started sounding a bit repetitive. I'm giving it a 3 because Thurston Moore gets name-checked in a song by Half Man Half Biscuit (who ought to have at least one album on this list)

As soon as I see the word "jazz" a chill runs down my spine - it is, without doubt, my least favourite type of music - and that's why it's taken me 6 weeks to get round to hearing it. I enjoyed it more than I expected to (and the story behind it is incredible) , but like all jazz I do find that it drags on a bit too long. Went into it expecting to give it a 1. Came out surprised to be giving it a 3!

I ought to hate this album because (a) it's pop and (b) it's '80s. I'm still not a fan of the big hits, but Witness and I'll Kiss You are bloody good songs.

Sadly this is a much underrated album. Yeah, it's got "Sunny Afterrnoon" that everyone knows, but it's also got "Dandy", "Too Much On My mind" and "Little Miss Queen Of Darkness" which may be my favourite Kinks song.

This one's on my list of albums that everybody else should hear before they die.

I've listened to it twice and I'm still not sure whether I like it or not.

I fell asleep the first two time I tried to listen to this.

OK, I hate Mercedes Benz - there I said it. But what a fantastic voice she had. A Woman Left Lonely is the best song here.

That was more chilled out than I was expecting.

I'm mostly rock/metal fan, but I was enjoying this album until Pyramids came along and dragged on for far too long. Listening to the rest of the album seemed like a chore after that.

I thought it was a load of pretentious bollocks when it came out. Nothing's changed.

Wow! What a voice. Sweet Blindness was the highlight for me.

It's a fantastic album from start to finish.

This is definitely an album of its time It hasn't aged as well as Making Movies or Love Over Gold. I want to give it 3.5, and the 3 I've given it feels a bit mean for an album which I enjoyed so much as a teenager.

So many good songs in such a short amount of time.

It's good, but I'd rather Sound Affects was on this list.

I probably would never have listened to this album if it wasn't for this project. I'm glad I did, because it was totally unlike what I was expecting. His voice isn't the greatest and some of the songs go on a bit too long, but I'll be listening to more of his stuff now. Standout track: Desolation Row.

For the love of God, make it stop!

Possibly one of the blandest albums I've ever heard.

Ziggy Stardust was great. This is greater.

I love this album, and have done for years. This is one of those rare albums which, for me, doesn't have a bad song on it. Easy 5!

Just one of the best debut albums ever!

Country's really not my thing, but this wasn't overly offensive.

Not someone I'd heard before, and the first 15 minutes had me thinking I might want to listen to more. After Jacksonville I was constantly looking to see how much more I had to endure before it was over.

According to the Wiki she didn't want the string and flute arrangements added to the album. Which is a shame, because they were the best part of it.

The pinnacle of space rock. I will never get tired of listening to this album.

Not something I'd choose to listen to, but it wasn't overly offensive.

Iron Man was the first Sabbath song I heard and 30+ years later it's still their best song. Does it need Planet Caravan or Rat Salad? Who cares when the rest of it's so bloody good.

If you could record the sound of tedium, it would sound like exactly like this.

That was incredible.

Fuck me, that was grim!

Not my sort of thing, but it wasn't too unpleasant.

They should've been so much bigger. What a great debut album.

I would rather hammer rusty nails into my bollocks than listen to that again.

Pleasantly surprised!

Side one is immense. Side two is even better. This is undoubtedly my favourite album from the so-called "classic" line up.

It goes without saying that he had a great voice, it's just not my sort of music.

I didn't think it was possible to make 44 minutes sound like 4 hours, but this managed it. What a crock of shit.

I'm not a fan of electronic music, so I was pleasantly surprised that I enjoyed this.

I was all set to give this album 4/5 until I heard Love, Pt 1.

I keep meaning to listen to more of their stuff. Maybe this is the kick I needed.

So many great songs in such a short space of time.

Another Brick In The Wall Pt 2 was the first Pink Floyd I heard at age 8. As a teen, I probably heard DSOTM and WYWH before I heard this album - I probably saw the film first. At 50 something, listening to it for the first time in about 20 years I'm loving it all over again. I'd give it 5/5 if Roger Waters wasn't such a knobhead.

A shame that the best track here was the last one - Chartered Flight - the rest of it was fairly grim.

Marvellous!

If I didn't work in retail, and have to hear these songs several times a night in the run up to Christmas, I may have been more generous. But probably not.

Not as tedious as I was expecting.

The only thing wrong with this album is that Freebird should be about five minutes longer.

The Tidal link sent me to an album of the same name by an outfit called The Foreign Exchange, so I listened to that as well. They were both equally shit.

One of the best debut albums ever. Not one bad song on it.

A tricky one to rate,... I loved the previous three albums, and when this came out it was a complete surprise, and took me a good few listens to get into. I had a chronological playthrough of their albums about 6 months ago and, not having heard it for a few years I appreciated it a lot more. And at least it's not Load...

I never really "got" the White Stripes, so this was a pleasant surprise.

There was one track which had a repetitive tone which sounded to me like somebody begging "Why?". I found myself agreeing with them.

I was 15 when this came out and had just discovered rock & metal, as times change it's not the sort of thing I'd choose to play any more and I don't think I'd heard it for over 20 years. It's getting a 4 for the nostalgia blast.

Well there's two hours of my life I'll never get back.

Lose about 30 minutes and you'd have a perfectly decent single album that I'd score at 4.

Not my thing, but I can see why some people would like it.

Haven't heard that for years.

Not quite sure what I was expecting with that one.

I bought this when it came out on the recommendation of a friend and I hated it. Pleasantly surprised to find myself enjoying it 30 years later - althoug it did drag on a bit.

Sorry, but I'm never going to like Jazz.

Overblown, pompous pop-rock. What's not to like?

Just because you can reinvent yourself again and again it doesn't mean that you should.

A lovely slab of garage rock.

I was intrigued at the start and bored at the end.

Possibly the best live album ever made.

I liked the first couple of tracks, but I was bored of it by the end.

Never heard heard of him before, but his Wikipedia biography was quite a read. Country's way out of my comfort zone, but the guy had a good voice.

Great voice. Great songs. Great album.

What a voice!

It's not as good as Psychocandy.

Tedium on a stick.

There are no bad Led Zeppelin albums. This is the best though.

Not even Maybe I'm Amazed can polish this absolute turd of an album.

More like Let's Get Bored.

I would've liked this more if it had been released as two separate albums. As a double album the second half dragged after the first.

First half really good. Second half bad.

I'll never be an Elvis fan, but this was OK.

Not as bad as I'd feared.

This is the perfect album to play at about 3 in the morning after a few pints, and not at 10 in the evening after listening to Motörhead. But that's my fault. It dragged on a bit too long for me.

Ride The Lightning, which was my introduction to Metallica will always be my favourite album. But this one's immense.

Dragged on a bit towards the end.