The Köln Concert by Keith Jarrett

The Köln Concert

Keith Jarrett

3.38
Rating
28626
Votes
1
6%
2
15%
3
32%
4
28%
5
19%
Distribution

Reviews (page 4 of 14)

A unique album in many ways, and it’s one of the more incongruous big sellers in the world of jazz.

I really enjoy Jarrett's music, this is a great one. 5.

Piano music, progressive jazz? Good stuff if you like piano music

pqp 4 musicas em 1 hora é foda FAVS (top 3): part I, part II a, part II b menções honrosas: part II c GENTE q performance maravilhosa eu gostei bastante... nota final: 4.5/5

This got a 2 because the piano playing is impressive. But I am never going to want to sit and listen to this album start to finish. Background music at a dinner? Maybe.

사랑스러운 처연함

Cool story, out of my wheelhouse, comforting I suppose.

Best Song: Part II(c) To me, you can't really hate this but also, it's not something you put on doing 80 on a freeway or pounding beers with friends. Its use case is a rather small window unless you are a musician type that really enjoys the intricacies of Jarrett's playing. Sadly, I have the musical talent of a box turtle and the musical knowledge of a wolf spider, so for me this was just mellow piano music. It is good background music for work, cleaning, etc. but that's about it for this guy. 3/5.

De lo mejor de piano solo improvisado que he escuchado. Nunca se queda sin ideas, tiene una técnica impresionante y una forma única de expresar y crear melodías y construir sobre ellas. Te hace sentir que estás en el público viéndolo tocar. Tener en cuenta el contexto en el que sucedió le suma mucho valor como obra. Lo volvería a escuchar sin duda

I liked it. In some parts it gets a little monotonous, but overall it's good.

Cool record. This type of music is a bit outside my wheelhouse, but I enjoyed it. Love the story behind it as well. 4/5

Surprised at how much I liked this. Definitely will be revisiting this one.

An extremely good piano performance with an insane backstory. Most of the album being improvised is just even more icing. Eager to listen to this again soon.

Decent. An impressive selection of classical music that was evocative. Unfortunately, it didn't quite match the positive mood we were in so we didn't quite manage to submerse ourselves.

I really don't know what to think about this album. It's mostly runs, it's a single piano playing what is truthfully similar sounding notes on an instrument that should not be there. The story of how the concert went and hwo it came it be is incredible. But does a good story make up for what, in my opinion, is a mostly dull but well-executed piano concert that lacks most of the parts of jazz I enjoy? I honestly don't know.

One of the most incredible performances in not only piano or jazz, but all of music. It’s beautiful. And it works great for background or foreground listening! I love the story behind the piano used and how it wasn’t the right one or in tune. Yet that obstacle didn’t stop the music. Imperfection lead to perfection.

A good album, h liked Part 2 a and Part 2 c the most.

I can tell it's awesome but not in the right zone for it today. Worth a revisit

Never listened. Expectations: None - Verdict: Very Good - Apparently this is the biggest selling jazz album by a solo artist of all time, and the biggest piano album ever. Not sure how I've never even heard of it. This is very pretty at the start. It sounds extremely modern without shouting about it. I'm 6 minutes in and wow, this is absolutely stunning. I think the opening 10 or 15 minutes of Part 1 is the highlight but this is really impressive throughout.

It’s good. I wouldn’t die if I couldn’t hear it again.

This was excellent.

Boring. Only background noise

It was all improvised amazing

Pianomusic, well......ill try again with wine on the beach during sunset

Tremendous piano

Хорошая фортепьянная неназойливая музыка. Мне, как любителю потупить под инструментал или эмбиент, зашло. Насколько я понимаю, это ещё и импровизация.Немного раздражало, что в записи концерта один из микрофонов был расположен так, что были слышны периодические покашливания и восклицания рядом сидящего человека

I'm sure I won't be the first review you've read discussing the backstory to this performance. But to summarize a long story, Keith Jarrett was to perform a live concert in Köln Germany with a luxurious Grand Piano. All the Germans had to do was provide one for him and he would be set for a great concert. He was partially injured at the time and wearing a back brace, so bending over must have hurt a ton. To make things worse, somehow the wrong piano was ordered. Instead of what he had requested, they ordered a tiny, broken, piece of garbage piano that wasn't even really meant to be played by anyone. He claims that the only reason he even performed at this concert was because the piano was fixed before he arrived, but I can only imagine how pissed off he must have been. What he delivered ended up being a hell of a performance, and resulted in the best selling solo album in Jazz history, as well as the best selling piano album of all time. Which really says a lot about Jazz when you think of it, but I won't go there this time. Regardless, this album is absolutely nothing without that story. I mean, sure, it probably would have been a pretty great performance if the piano was what he requested, but he'd likely done a ton already just like it, which would have been just another boring live Jazz performance. Instead, we got this. Pure talent and an amazing sounding record that sold like hotcakes due to a hilarious situation. It was lightning in a bottle for Keith, and I'm sure he's looked back on this concert and smiled about it for years now, even if it wasn't a good situation to be in while it was happening for him. I'm not a Jazz guy. I thought this album was just ok. I can recognize the talent, it's oozing from every note. But, I would never personally return to it. Without the backstory, I would probably give it a mid 2 or a low 3. It's not my taste in music at all, but the background heavily elevated my personal enjoyment with this one. Again, you don't have to be an expert to tell how impressive this is, and I can't honestly dislike a dude playing his freaking heart out on a bad piano like this. So I'm going to give it a 3, which seems very fair for this one. Picking a favorite song from the 4 is also going to be very difficult, especially since it's just a dude playing the piano for an hour, but I'm going to go with "Part II b". Not entirely sure why. I think I picked that one because a lot of the beginning notes just resonated positively with me. This was an alright album, but a remarkable story. Carry on Mr. Jarrett.

not for me

no esta mal, pero no es algo que escucharia ni agregaria a mi playlist

Good? Look I don’t hate it..but it’s not easy to love either..I mean I’m all for piano..and the expertise really shines through..I mean this whole thing was IMPROVISED?ona broken piano?? Amazing..but still..after a while it becomes repetitive..although..if u play..close ur eyes..and really really pay attention to every note..u will enjoy it..and it is super peaceful..but man overall…it’s good..not great or amazing,.but good..

Not usually what I would listen to however the back story of how it was made was intriguing. There is no denying the talent on display here.

Piano... if the commentary is from the crowd, it's kind of annoying, but if its from Keith, then it's kind of sick. Great, just something I'll probably never listen to again.

Lovely!! Great for walks or focus music

A bit repetitive

There's nothing to say about this that hasn't been said a millions times before. Incredible piece of artistry and as good as live jazz can be

This is esentially an hour of improvisation on the piano, so of course it won't be for everyone. Since I'm a fan of both piano and improv, this was a great listen for me. However, I have to be honest, parts of this do get a bit repetitive even for improv standards and at times feel too "safe" (not enough experimentation and moments to leave you amazed). Part II b was my favorite section, but Part I was also great as a whole. I do feel that ending on a minute of applause is a bit much, even for a live album (as if anybody is going to listen through that).

Not my cup of tea, but it wasn't bad.

Beautiful piano improvisations. It was grey and cloudy in my city today. The weather called for rain, but so far, nothing. Otherwise, it's still warm enough to leave the windows open, so I do. There is no breeze as I wash the dishes and sweep the floors, as Keith Jarrett's piano twinkles and flutters. His playing is powerful in the way that electronic drones or ambient music is powerful; though it sits just beneath the surface of your attention, it simmers and boils there, both demanding one's attention while simultaneously inviting you to allow your mind to wander. I fold laundry and put it away. The piano drives my in my mundane, albeit comforting tasks as ritual. I leave the house and ride my bike through town, the spacious piano making my meanderings feel dreamlike and surreal. Still no rain. It is powerful work.

Great music for doing taxes to. Thanks, Keith!

Definitely my favorite Keith Jarrett album and quite possibly my favorite jazz album. Fascinating story of this concert, how the grand piano promised never showed up and how he had to play this out of tune damaged piano instead. He hates this album, the rest of us love it.

muy buen álbum, pero una horita sin voces se me hace pesado. soy un ignorante

Well this is just stunning piano improvisation. Perfect concentration music for working

Objectively, a nice piano improv concert. Subjectively, I’m not into it and I zoned out halfway into the first track.

Easy listening good for working

This was relaxing. I could see myself listening to this for background music when I'm painting.

I dont liek doing imstrumental things for reviews, so this album is a bit harder, but its very good, like i assume most of the albums on the 1001 before you die list will be. with the songs were split up so i could pick sections i like, but whatever. 10/10 easily.

hermoso, al principio me parecia muy piano clasico, pero despues entendi el jazz y me encanto, quiero que sea el soundstack de mi vida.

Pretty but elevator music

Good but not really my thing

album #20 in the name of billy joel - sing us a song piano man!! love the story behind this but i'm afraid i am not the target audience lol. ꩜ album rating: ★ ★ ☆ ☆ ☆ ꩜ number of albums left to review: 1,069 ꩜ number of albums from the list that i agree with being on the list: 9 ꩜ albums from the list that I would consider on my list: 3 ꩜ albums from the list I won't include on my list: 14

Despite being an avid jazz listener and knowing the reputation of this piece I’d always avoided listening to it as I’m wary of solo piano albums. They can get a bit monotonous and go on a bit. But I have to admit I can see why it’s lauded so much. It’s a beautiful album with a floating quality and huge amounts of space. Not exactly jazz but not classical either. Excellent stuff. 4.5

I appreciated the music. It was beautiful, emotive, impressive. It moved and flowed and took you on the same journey as everyone in attendance at the concert. Keith Jarrett’s groans in the background I did not appreciate. Get a room Keith. 3.5/5.0 Best Song: Part II c

Really beautiful music, but its not for me, its too classical and too sort of long winded for me to really get behind. Plus i think he cums his jeans about 4 times in the hour long set.

I liked learning about this more than actually listening to it. I can appreciate the idea of a fully improvisational concert. And it seems like people really love the clanging and banging, I cat say I felt the same.

It’s alright I guess, if you really really really want to hear the piano. It was like the music from a Charlie Brown cartoon but a bit more somber and serious…like if Charlie Brown was waiting on a cancer diagnosis or going through a messy divorce.

Definitely wasn't jazzed (😉) when I saw the 66 minute runtime, but I really liked this, even with the baby grand piano and NOT the Bosendorfer 290 Imperial. The upbeat stuff was more enjoyable, but overall it was a decent listen. Might scope out more of this dude's work. Was wondering who was making all that racket during the good parts...[from his Wikipedia page]: "Jarrett frequently emits loud vocalizations, sometimes characterized as moaning, during his playing. Jarrett is also physically active while playing jazz and improvised solo performances, but the vocalizations are generally absent whenever he plays classical repertoire"

Normally classical/jazz piano doesn’t hold my attention as a solo instrument. But this is something else. Jarrett’s approach grabbed my attention; the pacing, the timing, the particular feeling he infuses in the notes makes it stand out. I just know - without expertise - that I’m listening to a master. It’s not suitable to classify this as classical or jazz; it is something new and distinctive. It was only after I listened all the way through that I learned that Jarrett had improvised this entire concert with a substandard piano, with a sore back, with an empty stomach… well, the greatest speak for themselves. True brilliance.

Fascinating piece of work with a fascinating history. Leans more into classical music than into jazz, but that doesn't mean it's less great.

canciones de 30 min que solo tienen piano, no lo escuche completo pero no me interesa mucho

Not even being clearly technically impressive, and having a fun story behind it, can change the fact that it’s still a whole hour of improvised piano.

It took just one listen to this album. This man is a genius.

really nice pianoman

beautiful piece of music. I do see the vision. The closer was a pretty encapsulation of the whole show. I may not listen to this for fun, but I will throw my roses to keith.

It sure was piano (dnf)

I've a lot of time for this. Much like Vince Guaraldi Trio, Oscar Peterson or Esbjörn Svensson Trio these well played, composed and delivered pieces drift beautifully along with real creativity and passion. I'd never heard of Keith Jarrett, but I'm sold on the idea he is right at the top of his genre. Lovely stuff.

inesperado, la mejor parte ll c. me gusta mucho la idea de que se deja llevar: compone las canciones en el mismo concierto

I get the skill involved to do this considering the story behind the album and concert, and there are some beautiful parts of this, but I drifted off at some points. Still pretty good though.

Keith is a phenomenal pianist. I'd never heard of him before, but I was hooked for the whole performance. The fact that it's improve is incredible.

Surprisingly I listened to the entire thing. Not my thing. Banging the same chord over and over? Yeah, no. I don’t know how to review things tactfully without saying this album was trash. I can appreciate the musical ascent, but it was torture to listen to.

An hour of solo piano? I'm in. This is compelling enough for being about an hour of long form improvisation, but even more so for moving so smoothly over that period. The pieces don't feel boring (to me at least) or stagnant, even boiled down to one instrument for 25-30 minutes at a time. Hard to give a top track, but it's definitely a 4*

Absolutely breathtaking. I’d never heard of this before. Exactly what you dream of for this project.

- The humming/vocalising is very distracting when it appears. - Other than that, very impressive, especially reading the history of this performance and how much was improvised.

Hard grade super talented but not for me

Wow! Didn't know anything about this going in, but hard to say it's anything but great!

This is an alright album. it's what you'd suspect from a classical album. I wouldn't really say that this is an album "you must listen to before you die" but it's good.

I can appreciate that this is an impressive feat, with the piano having distinct character and key leitmotifs. However, it's just too long and the piano is never played gently, which just isn't my preference. Not to mention the parts are up to 25 minutes long. It's just too long to listen to. I didn't like it, but I can appreciate that is a key piano album

What the hell!? This is PHENOMINAL...my first 5-star rating!

At first I was intimidated that it'll just be boring but the live recording is amazing. The guy is in flow state.

He’s a bit percussive but i have just come out of an operation and feel drowsy. A diffetent mood might hit diffetently. The runs ate like beautifully timed drum rolls, incredible really. But the slammed notes crash into my ears too harshly ATM. Listening the next day its not quite as sharp in the ears but he is pretty heavy handed. Its at once soft and tender but heavy as well. He’d do well writing certain types of metal. Full props for a solo album with a solo instrument. Its a lot to carry and he does, but i prefer other pianist, even Monk funnily who is also very percussive (but im fascinated by Mink’s almost mathamatical calculation like approach, he’s working it out in real time Nd doing it in the edge of his ability). So i looked it up and the Koln redera to the piano. Seems he turned up and improvised for a couple of hours on an instrument that linely needed a heavy hand, perhaps didnt allow as much subtle touch. I havent finished this and should revisit. Got halfway. Its great in bits. Would be a good album to chop up selected bits into tracks, cut away the rest which get a bit repetitive.

I don't know if this good or not but it bores me too much to care. 2 stars or D.

Wow, this was great. Such a great pianist I had never even heard of.

Dios cómo le vas a meter 24 mins de piano jajja la inculta. Inicio etereo, una parte en el medio tambn y al final el ritmo cool. La segunda empezó sonando a Disney, creo que a Monsters INC. La segund parte de esa está cool. El man siempre empieza muy sólido pero como es tan largo después ya no (?

Sve pet, ali ne mogu ovo slušati u komadu. Smatram isto da ne zaslužuje baš mjesto na listi, nezz. Od sve klasične glazbe i sličnih glazbenika, ovo je vjerojatno zadnje čega bih se sjetila staviti na listu. 1/5, 1/10

Opening bars sound good. As a jazz-hater, dunno how this is gonna go. Bring on the pain I guess. Update: I have not hated this as much as I thought I would. I'm kinda into the crowd enjoying it too

Dude from Allentown, PA shreds on the wrong piano for an hour in Koln.

Beautiful, interesting, and a nice listen. Something I never would’ve picked up. Classical meets jazz piano. And I admit I liked it. The man is incredibly talented. I love the passion with which he plays too. The audible “Ahhh…” and “”ohhh…” in some of the pieces almost songs like he is making love to the piano and orgasming as he plays. You can literally hear his pleasure. And the fact that this is live and improvised (I believe) makes it even more remarkable. Great listen.

Este es uno de los mejores discos de la historia. Yo no lo creía No he visto una demostración de talento musical tan grande en mi vida.

Vet omdat het een complexe wirwar is van tonen waar je in kan verdwalen, soms mooi en soms schuurt het.

“Regard your limitations as secret strengths. Or as constraints that you can make use of.” Brian Eno said that, talking about how embracing restrictions can fuel the creative process. Well Keith Jarrett had plenty of those constraints on the night of this performance. Because of a mix-up, he ended up playing on a sub-par piano. But instead of it having a negative impact on the performance, Jarrett had to get creative to produce the sounds he wanted from an instrument that was inflicting a lot of restrictions on his playing. The rhythmic patterns he develops with his left-hand, that are such a big part of these pieces, are apparently as a result of trying to get this piano to sound halfway decent. This is a very different listening experience to the other jazz albums on the list so far. It’s a lot more subdued and easy to listen to than some of the more experimental records, but far more interesting than some of the big band jazz standards on the list. You need a little background and context to fully appreciate it. Jarrett is improvising for a full hour non-stop, composing complex pieces right in front of an audience. That’s pretty damn impressive. You can hear him, in real-time, stumble across an idea, develop it and build on it, before it dissolves and makes way for another idea. It’s musical exploration at its purest. Hearing his vocal stimming when he leans fully into a musical direction adds to the energy of it all, and makes it feel even more real. The pieces fall away to quiet moments, before building back up to more intense, energetic movements. There’s something properly hypnotic about it all. It’s over an hour of just one guy messing about on a piano with no plan, but it never lost my attention once. A fine example of the musical creative process happening in real-time, and of an artist fully using limitations as their secret weapon.

Impressive! Was it all improvised? Or do he compose it?

People that enjoy this also enjoy the smell of their farts

Smá töff, sko. Fann tilfinninguna alveg í gegn. Samt bara þrjár stjörnur, að hluta til vegna lengda laganna.

Didn't know if I'd like a solo piano album, but I enjoyed it, especially after reading the backstory behind the concert.

Wow this was improv piano playing? Very impressive.

Did not do it for me. The piano itself sounds off to me in this. The music is nice sometimes, but most of the time feels pretty stock. It’s like royalty free background music.

great background / dinner music.

There's so much to say about this recording. The full history and background. Im sure there's plenty in others reviews describing all the bits and pieces of the wrong piano, Jarrett's back pains, his attempt earlier on this tour, and have the tour was financed. There's a recent screen play surrounding this almost mythological concert called "Köln 75". The build up towards this concert from the perspective of 17 yo girl who acts like a promoter for jazz in Germany. As well, one of my strong recommendations is to at least abit try to read up on the evolvement of jazz until this point. How it's gone from big band swing, to be pop, to free jazz, to this... full on improvisation.

Nice stuff 4

Very expensive dinner music vibes, it's fine but pretty boring Stand-outs - Köln, January 24, 1975, Part II b

Not that great.

God do I love the piano, I need to start practicing it again

I forget how beautiful piano music can be. Lovely album!

I liked the music. Very chill and relaxing

The story behind this is pretty crazy. The improvisation on it's own is very well done, but knowing it is done on a subpar piano, with back pain, little sleep and little food makes it even more impressive. I agree this is an album that solidly belongs on this list and even if you won't listen to it again, you should at least listen to it once.

4/5 The fact that this is entirely improvised makes it so much more impressive. It was a nice hour of just piano music, but it's not something I would really listen to again. Still though, gotta give credit where it's due.

veoma veoma dobar džez klavir! svakih pet minuta se oglasi neki glas u pozadini koji uglavnom usklikne u znak zadovoljstva hahahha

not my type of music

Long, so long

plinky plonky

Just a man, his piano, and one hell of a song. Solid 5 Stars.

It’s obviously a 10. It’s just beautiful. I’m not really sure what else to say. To put together a performance like that on a piano that’s different from what he originally wanted to play on, and to craft something so lovely out of a flaw, persevering forward to make something that might be universally described as art… man. It’s just a remarkable piano performance that will evoke anything in anyone, and the wide variety of pictures it can paint feels as endless as the sky itself. Just go listen to it. It’s incredible. A masterpiece, even. It’s a 10.

Virtuoso piano. I did not enjoy the "songwriting".

Wasn't expecting to love this album, but I do. Maybe it's the right sound for a Friday morning, but I'm all. Reading about the concert is even more fascinating.

Exceptionally good. Had no idea what I was going to be listening to. Blown away.

Ja, alltså han är ju duktig. Tyckte generellt om de lugnare partierna mer än ompa-bompa-delarna. Lausanne är bättre.

I mean good piano playing and the added "fun fact" that it's improvised adds to the experience. But probably nothing I'll revisit.

Impressive and certainly relaxing. Harmless at worst. Virtuous masterwork at best. Ultimately, I only enjoy listening to it so much and can't say that I "like" it, so it feels wrong giving it higher than a 3 - the other albums so far that have been outside of my comfort zone and favorite genres still managed to "move" me for example, while this and say Hendrix are just... Impressive, so impressive, but ultimately don't make me either enjoy myself or feel anything.

now this is something totally different barely started and I already feel woefully underqualified to rate this feels neoclassical in a way, like a modern building with Corinthian pillars i could do without the random man-noises starting around the 7 minute mark, but such is the nature of the live album as if I didn't want to get a piano before this :c i might not be musically literate enough but what part of this is jazz apart from the improvisation? goes to show how against preset genres in music I am kinda lost me in part 2, and I feel this needs to be enjoyed live/on vinyl/focused (neither of which I did), but overall you can still sense the virtuosity given the context that this was entirely improv and the troubles they had recording it

I just recently listened to this album actually and enjoyed it, so a great piece to start a day with. While piano solos aren't my preferred form of music this was very beautiful. It is a live concert, just a man and a piano. The concert is an hour long and all improvised, don't think the music was even written/charted until like 25 years later or something. Which brings up the most fantastic part of this piece, the story surrounding it. A great read if you want to be fully immersed in the concert.

I know how amazing it is that it was all improvised, but I still can't help but feel I'm in an elevator.

Instrumental, bom, 7,0

Storytelling without words in a magnificent form. Holy shit this is amazing. And the immortalisation of moments of awe from the audience, gasps and exclamations of delight as the playing effortlessly eases from season to season in a narrative that feels like it's unfolding completely organically.

This was an hour and change of an immensely talented man getting so much out of a battered out of tune piano. The story of how this live performance came to be is remarkable and I was weary that it might overshadow the music found on here, but I was pleasantly surprised with how much I enjoyed this. Basically a tired and worn out Keith Jarrett turned up to a Cologne concert hall and was furious that they only had this rehearsal piano that was in dire need of a repair and tune-up for him to play on during that night's performance. He reluctantly agrees to perform and makes the most with what he's been given. He avoids the weak bass notes, uses the broken pedals as makeshift percussion and improvises music that feels so full despite it just coming from one man and a piano. He does these weird vocal tics that could have been left out, as he just sounds like he's grunting over his beautiful piano playing. Aside from that, this was a lovely time.

A staple of my parents generation. Somewhere between Vince Guaraldi and George Winston.

I hated this so much. Incessant pounding in the first three pieces. Enough to drive one one insane. I'm sure he's a very accomplished musician but I'm not a fan of piano music and I really don't get why anyone would want to listen to this.

Middle seat on a morning flight after a bad night of sleep--I was ideally positioned to appreciate this. Still not really my jam, but I admire the effort.

Meandering and sometimes furious piano music. Not sure what else I can say. It was alright.

хороший, буду слушать!

part II A was my favorite

It's impressive, but not something I'd seek out

I was ok to long tho!

A great display of musicianship, way more captivating that I thought an hour of solo piano could be. His mastery of dynamics and ability to take the same phrase and then pivot to a different direction is awesome

Second non-vocal album. So many emotions can be heard in a piano. Got bored after song 1 tho,

This is loved by a select few people. And I am not one of them.

Great piano album for me, falls just short of 5 but still very good. Glad I discovered this album.

This put me in mind of music by an artist named George Winston that my parents use to listen to. I believe this style of music is rather pejoratively called New Age Jazz. Apparently there’s nothing new about it. The wiki talks gleefully about the “8 minute vamp in D major” or the “12 minute vamp in G and A”, and I think, “my god how boring!” And I wasn’t wrong. This isn’t a terrible album to have on in the background of a pleasant dinner party but it’s not music to pay attention to.

Some guy that plays piano very well noodles around on a piano for over an hour, and when he’s done, the whole audience is so relieved that they applaud and cheer for like 5 minutes.

Transcendent improvised piano mastery. Man BECOMES instrument here. This is one of those rare tomes that exists in the liminal space between the seen and the unseen, the known and the unknown, the real and the surreal. Keith Jarrett was a vessel for brilliance and human perfection with all of its glorious triumphs and blemishes.

favorite song: N/A vibe: unlike anything else. beautifully musical rating: 94/100

Not for me

Beautiful.

Pure poetry

Heard this album a few years back and the story of how it came to be. Really enjoyed it. He’s a real “piano man”!

I loved it! It got me through a very stressful hour of work 5/5

Je n'aime pas le piano...

The piano was interesting and fun. However, each song too closely followed the same path and I began to lose interest pretty quickly. Nice stuff, not for me.

Fascinating, but long. Whenever I hear improvised music, I think "this could have really used some writing and refining."

Not something I’d seek out, but serious talent on display

One of my favourite live albums ever. The story behind this shambles of a concert and how it came together better than anyone could have imagined just adds to the stunning playing on display here. I love Jarrett’s total immersion in his performances and this is probably his best.

relaxing and nice

Very expressive, inventive.

Who doesn't love some chill piano music?

Great background music. I wish it wasn't live though, only because I don't want the jarring audience applause when I am listening to fine piano work.

I thought this album was beautiful and quite emotional at times. Then I read the background and found out it was entirely improvised in far from ideal circumstances. Incredible! I will be listening to more of his music. Oh, and the album cover is great too.

fantastic.

Tento album som si naslepo kúpil svojho času v DDR. Okamžite som si ho zamiloval. Pre mňa je to 5+

Kann man gut laufen lassen, aber wo jetzt die Genialität ist, weiß ich nicht. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

bischen hochgestochen, aber sehr gut hörbar, wahrscheinlich einfach nicht mein Geschmack

Loved it. 5 stars. Honestly though I'd give it 4.5 because of the occasional vocal exclamations that you could faintly hear in the background throughout the album. I don't begrudge him getting excited and exclaiming while playing but I kept thinking it was someone shouting at me and then I'd realize it was from the album. So a little distracting. Otherwise fantastic.

As a 10-year student of the keys myself, I can definitely appreciate the performance. Honestly not sure if it belongs on the list but I don’t regret the listen

This album was great and just the change up I needed in this challenge. Beautiful tunes and incredible improv

OK, die man kan piano spelen... maar je kunt ook teveel piano spelen... het verhaal achter het concert was boeiender dan het concert zelf

The Köln Concert. Not bad.

Muy denso y emocional

I hate rating albums like this. Yeah he's very talented, but it's boring af to me.

Yea. Good piano or whatever.

Very talented player but I didn’t particularly enjoy it.

Absolutely incredible. Like a jazz improvisation on studio ghibli themes. Mesmerising and joyous. Absolutely blown away by this album

Last.fm tells me I have listened to Keith Jarrett before, but apparently it hadn't won me over enough for me to listen to more than a few tracks. I think that all changes today, because this was phenomenal. Probably one of my favourite discoveries from this project so far.

Amazing music. I’ve listened to this thousands of times and still love it.

-chill music -nothing crazy -good background noise

Very easy listening and hits some cool motifs

It’s a hour on piano improvisation so that’s cool. Maybe I’m not classy enough to totally get this album but to me it’s just another full piano album. After a bit it’s hard to focus on it and it ends up as background music.

A masterpiece

Just not my cup of tea unfortunately. Very calming though.

Okay, it's not so bad for one dude sitting at a piano for an hour. He sustains some interesting shit, I guess.

If I wanted to hear an hour of uninterrupted piano I'd just sit in my brother's living room.

I'm always curious why certain albums get popular within the public consciousness. The Koln Concert was the best-selling solo jazz album in history, not that I know who the other contenders for that title are, other than it would have to be another piano player, right? Can't imagine solo drums charting very well. But this was a relatively big thing for jazz in the mid-70s and I'm mostly curious how that happened. The circumstances were hardly ideal. The wrong piano was provided, a rehearsal piano that had to be tuned for several hours to make it even playable and it apparently sounded like crap at the highest and lowest registers and the pedals didn't work. Jarrett himself wasn't feeling great, nursing a back injury. Also, the concert was at 11:30 at night. Who starts a concert that late? The seventies were a weird time. Jarrett's a great pianist and one capable of making this car crash of a baby grand sound great, although the problems with the piano do explain why he mostly confines himself to the middle register. But achievements aside, the question is whether or not it's an engaging listen or just serviceable background music, and the answer, I'm happy to say, is definitely the former. Jarrett isn't content to just sit back playing pretty melodies, instead vamping over set chords throughout and doing interesting things with them. This is proper jazz music, not instrumental pop, not easy listening. It is not instrumental music to accompany you while you're studying. I should know, I tried to do other things while listening and kept getting drawn back into the music. And to be clear, that's a good thing! This also isn't some Cecil Taylor level of atonality that might put you off. Jarrett is rhythmic and soulful in his playing, creating interesting textures throughout. That he did it under such trying circumstances is a credit to his skill and adaptability, but you won't have to care about that. What matters is that it's a great listen.

Wonderful piano, cool story, I'd be pissed too

Extremely impressive when you know the story behind it, overall just very very good.

Nice work. Not something I’ll likely listen to again, but pretty good piano work.

This one is great. 4 stars

quite but boring

His composed sections are beautiful. Last song is great. His noodling is sparse and masturbatory. It's like SIMs building music but worse.

Before: Hhmm, wasn't expecting this one. My mom had this album back in the late 70's and I listened to it many times. I have not listed to it since then. During: Some incredible playing for sure but it's not the kind of thing I usually listen to. At some points I'm wondering, how may many hands does that dude have? After : I didn't know about the back story until I started reading the reviews. I get it now why so much of this sounded like improv. I'm giving it a 4. Sure, it deserves a 5 but it's not something I really enjoy listening to that much.

No me copó tanto. Buena idea, no gustó tanto

Piano melodies

I don't think I really enjoyed this album, but it's nothing to do with the pianist himself. I just don't think I really enjoy music that's just one instrument. There was a bit of a jazzy tone to the music, but not enough to really make me like it.

Nice background music for studying or doing work. Really solid album.

Didn’t know this one before I started and needed a few goes to get my head around it (and am still probably some way off completing the task). Beautiful rhythms and movements, it’s hard to fathom it’s a spontaneous performance.

This is tough to rate. Its a well-crafted piece of music with a fascinating backstory that makes it even more impressive. That said, an hour long solo piano performance is a tough sell. On personal enjoyment I'd give it a 3 but I'll give it an extra point for circumstances under which it was created.

A pleasant album that's joyful in the mid-section (and I assume technically excellent, though I'm no expert), but hasn't got any truely outstanding features. Would put on at work to concentrate.

Reading about this concert helped a lot. I had a similar experience (though I'm not Keith Jarrett) when I travelled overseas for a show and they presented me with a keyboard that was literally a toy. 4 octaves, plastic, no pedals. I completely freaked out and didn't want to play. Had to rework my whole set and it was terrifying. Hearing this concert in it's mastery and knowing that it was an incredibly stressful case of improvisation.. it's IMPRESSIVE

Pleasant as background music.

muy relajante, interesante

Classical piano but with a twist. So energic, nuanced and exciting.

This may betray my lack of ball knowledge regarding solo piano compositions and albums, but this didn't resonate with me a whole lot. Jarrett is obviously a master of his craft as a pianist, and it is impressive this was essentially just a freeform vamped performance, but it gives elevator music. Hey, at least it was a nice soothing listen while I worked.

Woah this comes from the source!!! Those bottom keys!!!!!

Good but not my thing

Hearing the backstory of this album is cool, but nothing else about it is. I personally know several pianists and, as far as I, someone with only basic piano training, can tell, this isn't that special. I'm sure more experienced pianists would find this amazing, but I found it boring.

I like the story and idea more than the actual album. I'll be sure to put this on next time I have a mundane task to do. It's great piano playing for sure.

It's hard to have live concerts on as albums but will allow it because this list isn't the 1001 "Best" albums, it's 1001 diverse musical offerings that will expand your horizons. It's neat to hear 1 person, 1 instrument, 1 album. Not my exact jam but enjoyed the playing and creativity. Takes a lot to go play for an hour straight by yourself, I'd imagine.

A piano solo? I enjoyed this, Keith has some talent. Every song had good energy and rythem to keep me interested. Those fingers be dancing on those keys. Strange song names.

This was a very good piano improve album. I enjoyed this alot. It's kind of something you need to sit and meditate with a bit, but it's very worthwhile if you do. Nice.

It's a mood.

I enjoyed it as background music.

Quite special

Finally an album in this project that is not pop, rock or rap. I wish the creators of the list were more adventourous. .

Excellent. Learned that this was entirely improvised. Impressive display of talent.

1: Part II b 2: Part II a 3: Part II c

It was ok - but only as background music

No thanks

This was very nice overall, just not anything that really is exciting or stood out to me. But for people who enjoy this type of music I can see why it would be special.

Fascinante 1 hr y 6 min de pura improvisación con Piano? Eso es una locura Además de que el concierto casi no ocurre por múltiples razones La historia detrás del concierto ya por si sola es muy buena. Ya cuando entramos en materia musical, se percibe como Keith está en un proceso de adaptación con el piano defectuoso y viejo que tenía a su disposición, como buscaba domarlo, y cuando se llega a la parte II B, minuto 14 se percibe la paz y la victoria de todo lo que se había hecho hasta el momento El álbum me dió mucho que pensar y mucha admiración hacia el artista Repetible totalmente

Very relaxing, but also lively. Reminded me a lot of Mannheim Steamroller's "Fresh Aire" albums.

"Bro, I'll just make it up as I go" is no way to make an album. It's truly uninspiring music. He is a talented piano player but it's so repetitive. No thank you.

lijep klavir bam bam itd. neki dijelovi baš dobri

Clearly talented but not a very engaging listen

Absolutely beautiful, especially so with the context of Jarrett playing this at the request of a young fan, on a broken down, shoddy piano which was the only equipment avalible.

Halfway through the first track I knew this was an album I’d return to again and again.

Very good

Nice album. Peaceful.

I get that the story is cool and I’m sure that someone who likes this music would appreciate it more but it just wasn’t for me.

I was completely unaware of this, fascinating backstory, interesting and pleasant listen.

It was a good listen

Spectacular! I went down the rabbit hole learning about Jarrett and his incredible improvising skills.

Very impressive for live improvisation. Wow. This is softer than jazz...in a good way.

Great for in the car during rush hour.

That all of this the fullness of this album is just one guy improving on a crappy, practice piano is nuts.

I recognize the talent here and don’t necessarily dislike it, however this is definitely a “it’s not you, it’s me” album

The background story to this and the resulting performance is astounding really. This is an artist, story and album I'd no clue about until today. Amazing.

This was a pretty fun listen, could definitely see myself putting this on in the background during a dinner party or just working on something. I know absolutely nothing about Jazz piano but this dude sounds pretty damn good. My favourite part is the odd time when you hear some random dude go “oh yeah!” from the crowd, presumably when Keith does something extra nasty on the keys.

4.4 What has two thumbs and is going to smoke a joint, lie on their living room floor and blast this next time I have an afternoon to myself? This guy!

Jeg er mere til helt klassisk musik, men spændende koncept med komplet impro. Det er et vellykket album.

Probably not as interesting as it would have been live, this is a nice record of awesome jazzy piano pieces. The songs are extremely long, so it is pretty patience testing. Overall, I enjoyed it, but had a hard time getting fully engaged with it. The incredible applause at the end of the album is indeed pretty narcissistic, but leads me to believe that there’s something we all missed out on.

Impressive? Yes Enjoyable? No Albums like this are so hard for me to rate. There's no question that Keith Jarrett is a talented musician, but it was largely background music for me (and annoying at times, to be honest). I suspect I would give 5 stars if I saw this live, but it just doesn't hold up as a recording for me.

I usually need strong lyrics to stay engaged with a song, so despite how beautiful this sounded, I found myself getting a little bored.

ABSOLUTELY GOATED SHIT LET'S GO KEITH‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️ if you don't like the jarrettnoises you are missing the point i fearrrr this man loves tunes so much he's moaning to the music get used to it 👏👏👏

Phenomenal. Dude was cooking with gas

Its apparently 100% improvised on an apparenly subpar piano....whilst this makes it more impressive, it doesnt make it more attractive to me either. Sorry super talented guy, tis a 2 star from me despite the fact Im pretty sure I heard you c*m several times during the performance.

Sublime, what an experience. Mid 4s.

Nice piano music but just feels a bit long and like background music

Well now... this one struck a chord in me. I've heard it once before and I don't recall being moved by it back then, but upon listening more actively this time, it evoked a lovely sense of familiarity and homeliness. The ebb, flow, comforting major tonality and general structure of Part 1 reminded me a bit of John Butler's Ocean - one of my all-time favourite tracks - which set me up for a pleasing listening session throughout the rest of the album. That's not to mention the story behind the recording - to hear it almost never came to fruition! This is definitely at the top of my shelf when it comes to instrumental music. Magnificent stuff.

Väldigt välkommet med lite jazz! Det känns som att det varit allt för mycket rock på sistone. Har inte lyssnat på detta album på flera år, men visste att det låg i listan så det är ett av de albumen som jag har lite väntat lite på. Fantastisk konsert! Så otroligt uttrycksfullt. Älskar alla hans små stön och utrop. Man verkligen känner hur inne i musiken han är. Part II c, eller Memories of tomorrow som den också heter, spelade vi ett gäng gånger när jag pluggade. Gillar den skarpt.

Skön palettrensare. Väldigt duktigt, men också lite långtråkigt efter ett tag.

Blir impad när jag läser att det är improviserat. Hör av det är mycket känsla bakom och det är behagligt att lyssna på. Andra spåret kändes kanske lite för repetitivt. Bra musik att ha i bakgrunden när man läser men kommer förmodligen inte lyssna på det igen. Stark 3a.

Vilken king, att med de förutsättningarna gå upp och leverera det där. Som sen ba blir bäst säljande solojazz- och pianoalbumet genom tiderna.

Att detta är totalt improviserat har alltid övergått mitt förstånd. Bara vetskapen att det här sker i stunden där och då tillför så satans mycket till upplevelsen. Och att han dessutom spelar på ett kasst övningspiano som han hatar gör det ännu bättre. Dynamiken och de lediga övergångarna mellan stämningslägen och genrer är fan sjuk. Kommer aldrig sluta avundas de som fattar ett instrument på ett så här djuplodande sätt, som att det är en del av deras egen kropp. Man kan börja tro på Gud för mindre. Allt är otroligt. Svänget varvat med det finstämda och vackra och så hans röst som hela tiden fångas upp av micken, ena stunden sjungandes och andra stunden småstönande. 5a!!

Kliver upp och stumt improviserar. Extremt äkta av maestro. Det vackraste är ju nästan ljuden han själv gör av sin egen känslighet. Omöjligt att blunda för skickligheten men det blir eeeen aning bjäring efter 26 minuter på två ackord, oavsett hur sjuk Keith är. Precis som med Kind of Blue lär ju dock poängen vara vad han gör med dom.

Stäm mig

First listen

Nice instrumental for work or reading but doesn't baaang

Did not expect to like this. But I honestly really did. It’s beautiful!

A joy to listen!

Vastly different from everything else I've seen on here so far. Just beautifully done.

This is FANTASTIC. How I had gone the last 50 years without hearing this is a mystery. About 4 minutes in I started looking for a copy of this on vinyl. THIS is what should be on a list like this.

A true testament to the creative process trudging through adversity.

Stevo won’t be happy. Somewhere between a 2 and a 3, but rounded up because I can’t justify giving it the same score as The Shamen.

Paul isn't happy either

Autotelic

Very accomplished playing, completely inoffensive and great for any piano enthusiast. Just not for me

This has been a lot better than what I expected. I mean, the guy can play, jesus. The fact that this is all improvised is extremely impressive, and even more so now I've read the story about how he ended up having to use a very poor piano that wasn't really fit for performance purposes. I saw the term "jazz" and expected just a bunch of noodling around being technical but not musical (apologies jazz fans if I'm wrong - I'm not well versed with jazz but this is the impression I can get). However this couldn't have been further from that. It was technically amazing but the way he blends so much emotion into it is very well done. The way he progresses each piece and often sort of dances around before continuing on. In truth this is just a lovely listen.

Bon album de piano contemporain

Très bien pour lire haha J’ai pas fini d’écouter vu la longueur des tracks, mais j’ai mis uniquement pour lire volontairement

J'adore le piano mais j'ai pas été convaincu plus que ça pour le coup, sympa mais sans plus. Au moins ça change!

wss nothing short of delighted to see this as the album of the day. best piece of improvisation OAT

I'll search for information about this iconic jazz album to provide you with a comprehensive review. Let me search for more information about the musical structure, themes, and critical reception of this album. Now I have comprehensive information about this iconic album. Let me provide you with an in-depth review. --- ## **The Köln Concert** (1975) — Keith Jarrett ### **An In-Depth Review** --- ### **Overview & Historical Context** Recorded on January 24, 1975, at the Cologne Opera House in Germany, *The Köln Concert* stands as one of the most remarkable achievements in jazz history—and arguably the best-selling solo piano album of all time, with over 4 million copies sold worldwide . What makes this recording extraordinary is not just the music itself, but the almost mythical circumstances surrounding its creation: it was entirely improvised, performed on a substandard piano, by an artist who was sleep-deprived, in pain, and initially refused to play . The concert was organized by 17-year-old Vera Brandes, Germany's youngest concert promoter at the time. Jarrett had requested a Bösendorfer 290 Imperial concert grand, but due to a delivery strike, the venue provided a much smaller Bösendorfer baby grand rehearsal piano instead—out of tune, with malfunctioning sustain pedals and a thin, bright upper register . Jarrett, who possesses perfect pitch and is notoriously particular about his instruments, initially threatened to cancel. Combined with back pain, sleep deprivation from a five-hour drive from Zurich, and food poisoning from a bad meal, the conditions were catastrophic . Yet Jarrett performed. And in doing so, he created something that transcended jazz, classical, and popular music boundaries. --- ### **The Music: Structure & Analysis** **The Performance Structure** The album consists of four continuous sections: - **Part I** (26:09): The monumental opening improvisation - **Part II a** (14:55): Transitioning from elegiac to more rhythmic territory - **Part II b** (18:14): Building intensity and complexity - **Part II c** (6:57): The composed encore (more on this below) **Musical Language** Jarrett's improvisation operates in what scholars identify as a "modal context"—harmonic progressions that don't follow classical jazz cadences like II-V-I turnarounds, but instead use "direct transition" techniques to modulate between tonal centers through common notes . This creates the album's characteristic suspended, floating quality. The opening motif—five notes that mimic the opera house bell calling the audience to their seats—demonstrates Jarrett's immediate responsiveness to his environment. From this simple cell, he develops a 26-minute journey that musicologists have analyzed as containing: - **Pentatonic scales** combined with pedal tones creating modal centers (reminiscent of Debussy's *La Cathédrale Engloutie*) - **Power chords** (root and fifth without third) providing harmonic suspension - **Contrapuntal dialogue** between short rhythmic cells in left and right hands - **Genre fluidity**: gospel rhythms, Middle Eastern trance influences, country flavors, blues, and classical romanticism all woven seamlessly The physical limitations of the piano ironically became strengths. The bright, thin upper register forced Jarrett to concentrate in the middle range, creating a more rhythmic, hypnotic approach than he might have otherwise taken . The instrument's deficiencies demanded a percussive, groove-oriented attack that gives the music its driving momentum. **The "Composed" Question** Musicologist Peter Elsdon's research reveals that while most of the concert was indeed improvised, the final piece ("Part IIc") was likely a pre-composed piece called "Memories of Tomorrow" that Jarrett had written earlier that year . This doesn't diminish the achievement—it was standard practice for Jarrett to end concerts with prepared encores—but it complicates the "pure improvisation" mythology. More importantly, Elsdon demonstrates that even "pure" improvisation isn't chaotic; Jarrett employed strategic patterns and "rescue maneuvers" when stuck, developed over weeks of touring . --- ### **Production & Sound** Produced by ECM founder **Manfred Eicher**, the recording captures the concert with remarkable intimacy despite the piano's shortcomings. Eicher later spent days in the studio working on the tape, and ironically, the album won awards for its sound quality despite the compromised instrument . The production choices were deliberate and influential: - **Minimal microphone placement** capturing both the piano and Jarrett's physical presence - **Retention of audience applause** reminding listeners they are witnessing a shared, temporal event - **Inclusion of vocalizations**—Jarrett's humming, moaning, and foot-tapping—which became controversial but essential to the document's authenticity The ECM aesthetic—clean, spacious, reverberant—perfectly suited this music. The label's 50th anniversary vinyl reissue (2025) demonstrates the recording's enduring sonic quality, with "Tubey Magical Midrange" that modern records struggle to reproduce . --- ### **Themes & Interpretation** **Presence & Imperfection** The album's central theme is **mindfulness**—being utterly present in the moment. Jarrett has described solo concerts as "the most revealing psychological self-analysis imaginable" and "like stepping onstage naked" . The Köln performance embodies this: an artist accepting limitation (the piano, his physical state) and transforming it into possibility. **The Architecture of Improvisation** Jarrett's approach treats improvisation not as randomness but as **spontaneous composition** with structural integrity. The music builds through "thematic episodes arranged in plateaux," each originating from rhythmic, melodic, or harmonic ideas that develop organically toward climaxes . This architectural approach—comparing Jarrett to Le Corbusier in his systematic yet creative method—reveals deep formal intelligence beneath the surface spontaneity . **Spirituality Without Dogma** The music radiates what producer Manfred Eicher called a "miraculous kind of quality" . Listeners consistently describe spiritual experiences—transcendence, emotional catharsis, meditative states—without any religious framework. The album functions as both "sophisticated background music" and "emotionally stimulating foreground music," serving different needs for different listeners . --- ### **Influence & Legacy** **On Jazz Piano** *The Köln Concert* fundamentally changed perceptions of solo jazz piano performance. It demonstrated that extended improvisation could sustain emotional and structural interest without ensemble interaction, existing material, or predetermined forms . Pianists like **Brad Mehldau** owe their solo recital careers to Jarrett's breakthrough . **Beyond Jazz** The album's influence extends across genres: - **New Age/Ambient**: While Jarrett disavowed the "New Age" label, the album's accessible, contemplative qualities spawned countless imitators (including George Winston), for better and worse - **Classical**: The recording introduced jazz improvisation to classical audiences through its Debussy-esque harmonies and formal coherence - **Popular Culture**: By the late 1970s and 80s, the album was ubiquitous in boutiques, wine bars, and bookshops, becoming sonic shorthand for sophisticated taste **Cultural Impact** The album made ECM Records financially independent and established the label as the premier venue for "chamber jazz" and improvised music . It proved that avant-garde-adjacent music could achieve mass commercial success without compromising artistic integrity. --- ### **Critical Reception: The Schism** The album inspires polarized reactions that reveal much about listeners' relationship to improvisation: **Acclaim** - "A certified work of genius" that "redefines jazz" - "The best-selling piano album of all time" and "landmark document" - "A lullaby for anyone who has no need for slumber" - "Proof that equipment does not matter" **Skepticism** - "A brilliant trick masquerading as jazz" - "Pleasant dinner party wallpaper" and "jazz for people who want to tell you how much they like jazz, but don't actually like jazz" - Criticism of Jarrett's vocalizations as "moaning" or "giving birth to a square baby" - The "background music" problem—some find solo piano for 66 minutes becomes ambient texture rather than engaging art --- ### **Pros & Cons** | **Pros** | **Cons** | |----------|----------| | **Unprecedented spontaneity**: 66 minutes of sustained, coherent improvisation without pre-planned material (mostly) | **Vocalizations**: Jarrett's humming and moaning distract some listeners, though others find them essential to the emotional document | | **Structural mastery**: The music maintains architectural coherence despite being created in real-time | **Accessibility vs. depth debate**: Some jazz purists find it too "middle of the road" or "vanilla" compared to more challenging free jazz | | **Emotional range**: From melancholy to ecstasy, intimacy to grandeur | **Length**: At 66 minutes of solo piano, it can become background music for inattentive listeners | | **Historical significance**: Changed the perception of solo piano in jazz and improvised music | **Mythology overshadows music**: The backstory (wrong piano, bad conditions) sometimes dominates critical discussion over the actual musical content | | **Production quality**: ECM's recording captures the concert's intimacy and acoustics beautifully | **The "New Age" association**: Spawned countless inferior imitators that diluted the album's innovations | | **Genre transcendence**: Appeals to jazz, classical, and pop audiences alike | **Part IIc is pre-composed**: The "pure improvisation" claim is slightly undermined by the prepared encore (though this is minor) | | **Inspirational narrative**: Demonstrates how limitation can breed creativity | **Physical demands**: Jarrett's subsequent health issues (chronic fatigue syndrome) may have been exacerbated by this intensity of performance | --- ### **Conclusion** *The Köln Concert* remains one of those rare artistic achievements where circumstance, limitation, and genius converged to create something unreproducible. The "wrong" piano forced Jarrett into a rhythmic, middle-register approach that became the album's signature. His physical distress may have lowered his inhibitions, allowing raw emotional expression to flow unfiltered. The late-night setting (11:30 PM start) contributed to the dreamlike, suspended quality. Is it jazz? Classical? New Age? It is none and all of these—**it is simply music**, created in the moment, captured by technology, and preserved as a document of human creative potential. Whether you find it transcendent or tedious may depend on your capacity for sustained attention and your tolerance for vulnerability in art. For those willing to listen actively, it offers a masterclass in improvisation as architecture, limitation as liberation, and presence as practice. For those seeking background ambiance, it provides that too—though perhaps at the cost of missing what makes it genuinely miraculous. **Essential listening for**: Piano students, jazz enthusiasts, meditators, lovers of spontaneous creation, and anyone who needs reminding that perfection is not a prerequisite for beauty. **Rating**: ★★★★★ (Masterpiece)

Zum Teil zu übertrieben. An ein paar Stellen etwas gefühlvoller gespielt, und es wäre perfekt gewesen.

Beeindruckend, aber nicht für über eine Stunde als Aufnahme.

The majority of this album sounds to me like boring, directionless piano noodling, like if you gave a chimp a keyboard that was incapable of playing out of key. While Jarrett is clearly a talented pianist, the few moments on this album where he appears to be playing with intention aren't worth slogging through the rest of the aimlessness for, and truthfully I'd rather listen to elevator music. This probably hits differently while doing drugs though.

Learning this was improvised on a shitty piano: sick Personal enjoyment: I dont really get anything out of piano solos. Hopefully by the end of this concert I will be more cultured

This was pleasant to listen to in the background while I was working; however, I wouldn’t put this on to intentionally listen to it. I respect it because I am not musically inclined and this was a live performance of an hour of straight piano playing, which I do find impressive. But was it anything special? No. Was it bad? Also no. Will I listen again? Unlikely! But it did what it set out to do. I could also see this hitting if you were high.

Great concert recording. Especially the first track is stunningly good. I guess i have to check out the movie Köln 75 now, that touches on the time and the young woman who organized this gig.

This album was nice and calming. As far as instrumental music I did like the way that it made me feel sorrowful and joyous at the same time. 6/10

Not my taste:/ good but after one hour of hearing only piano made my brain explode

tragica historia de fondo

This was clearly a very well performed piece of music showcasing an impressive improviser, but it’s not really my thing. The backstory of this concert is fun and makes the performance even more remarkable, but this kind of long form piano music was never going to much for me. Nice as background music.

Having never heard of Keith Jarrett, this was a really pleasant surprise, though the fact I had the Residents yesterday probably also helps, after which almost anything would seem transcendently beautiful… Joking aside, much of this album genuinely was beautiful, and I was amazed by Jarrett’s ability to improvise so brilliantly. Despite being classed as jazz, to my (albeit untrained) ear this seems overly simple; I hear lots of classical influences. This might also be an example of how knowing an album’s backstory can enhance my enjoyment of it (the Wikipedia article is a fun read). Definitely one I’ll revisit.

was not expecting an instrumental album! but it was a nice surprise

Probably one of the best instrumental albums I have ever listened to. I really enjoyed the vamping. The hoots during the song were a bonus.

A classic!! Seems like every woman I dated in college had this album—on vinyl, of course!!

POPPY! NOT MY FAVORITE BUT HAS TO BE SENTIMENTALLY A FO!

It's beautiful playing, but 1 hour of piano noodling is too much for me

Pia-pia-pia-no, piano, piano Pia-pia-pia-no, pia-piano 🎹

Sweet piano playing.

Production is good for a live performance. I like hearing some of the background noise, makes it feel like a truly live performance. However, an hour of solo piano after about 15 minutes becomes noise to me. Kieth is a phenomenal pianist, and this performance does a good job of displaying his ability as a classical musician while mixing in some of the performative Jazz Piano.

Jajajaja Sicher schön komponiert und blablabla. Aber für e album klöpp cha mir da nöd migt ere guete bewertig belohne. 2 kölsch uf das