Reviews (page 11 of 16)
Listened to it sat at a tram stop and barely noticed it even though the tram was 20 minutes late.
I was never a huge Strokes fan but this album is solid and I can't separate the nostalgia feelings of that sound
Is good. Might've been a five if Last Nite hadn't been butchered on the radio for years, but alas, I can no longer listen to it objectively
Very nostalgic with a few real bangers. Surprisingly close to 5 stars.
The album was great. I started off thinking, oh wow another alt/indie/garage band, and was pleasantly surprised with how unique they sounded. The songs are punchy, memorable, and fun. Probably as good as indie alt gets for me.
The fact that this was one of the best albums of the early 2000's says a lot more about that decade for music than it does about this album!!! It was fine though, I enjoyed it enough.
A fav
Fairly repetitive, nothing stands out. Still nice to listen to
i love the punk rock vibes
What a great listen. A return to roots for rock as it is, simplistic but powerful catchy bops
i like it so far, sounds like the pixies, maybe a little bit of indie rock? the whole album reminds me of a song but i just cant figure out which one.... nvm i figured it out i dont want to talk about it the guitar parts are good its so indie helpl not bad but nothing special, just generic i guess my favorite song: none of them really stood out to me on the first listen
eh. nothing special here. never really was a fan of The Strokes.
Eddie was always right about this one.
Seminal. Love listening to the UK version w New York City Cops included.
Reminds me of Barfly circa 2002. It's a good album but it does lack variety and I can't say I'm particularly inspired to play it again.
Seeing The Strokes at a packed out gig at The Louisiana, touring this album was an amazing night. The albums not bad either
Some nice post punk or whatever the CGBB's.
When this album was released I sort of wanted not to like the new kids on the block with all the build up and hype, but this is a good album
Yeah, umm, Not bad.
Last Nite is the obvious highlight, the rest of the album is a bit samey but in a good way.
Really got into this band. Not a song I disliked although don’t think I remember truly hearing any of them before. Driving guitar, punchy, punky lyrics, worked for me.
Unique sound! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 36 intense minutes of energetic guitars and driving rhythm. 🎸🥁 Not a single weak song. Very catchy. Fun to listen to every time.🔁
Never understood the hype: the album is OK and probably their best but quite a few songs do not stick and are not so special. score in 2000: 8/10 score in 2024: 8/10
Yeah, this is it! Overwhelming, confident, and intense.
Although I really like a couple of the tracks on this album it does float around the edge of 4/5 for me. I'm still not sure which it is, and that's enough to keep it at 4. The sound of the album is great, I admire the effects used to stylise the vocals and the guitar work is deceptively simple. But the only tracks I really see myself coming back to are the bigger hits.
Not my kind of music.
I WAS SURPRISED. I have owned this album for a long time and never made it past the first or second track - to be clear, I do think the first song is a banger! I don't know why I wrote them off. But it's a good one. Full listen, lots of hooks, lots of melody.
Love the album , knew about 75% of it. 8/10
Highlights: Someday, Last Night, Alone Together, New York City Cops. In a nutshell: a band who revived garage rock in the 2000’s. The Strokes have an indescribable pull to them. They borrow from Iggy and the Stooges, Ramones, etc. There are some recycled riffs. I still prefer Franz Ferdinand but no love is lost for the band who crafted the sound first. Overall: 6/10
One of, if not the best, indie album ever. Inspired all my favourite bands and soundtracked my teenage years. Love this album more than some distant family members. Forever grateful to you, Julian Casablancas xx
Pretty good rock album
Too many of this music I‘ve listen… yes, not bad but nothing incredible… 5/10
Good stuff, one of the classics
Decent, but listening to the album a lot of it sounds very samey and seemed to blend into each other.
a quintessential indie album. i always hear people talk about how this is the best strokes album and they’ve spent their whole career trying to replicate it. maybe it’s because we’re twenty years removed from it, but this is not the best strokes album. it’s still great, and massively influential for the indie scene at the time but they have definitely put out better music over the length of their career. this is a great album worth listening to, even if i think it’s overrated.
Are The Strokes kinda overrated? Sure. Is this still a near flawless piece of aughts indie rock? Also yes. You’ve gotta respect it.
Definitely a quintessential garage rock album from the early 2000s
Even The Strokes being the #1 band of skinny boys wearing skinny pants and suits, I listened to so many better indie rock bands (like Muse) that I can't stand their washed-out/drink-for songs. "Last Nite" is a fun song; no one can deny it, but it's just fun. Or I am black and can't stand this epitome of whiteness.
Simply the best
Independent rock schön für die doko runde
Amazing debut
To quote Michael Jackson: Yes, "This is it". Some of the songs on this album are long time favorites of mine. An effortlessly cool rock album that was a standout in a remarkable musical era.
They have their hits, the album from A-Z is a bit boring though
No notes. Just good.
best album of 2001 (sorry daft punk)
It’s very good, smooth, clear, cool rock ‘n’ roll…but it’s just a little bit dull. Evan with multiple listens, nothing to complain about, quite enjoyable, and the best tracks are pretty fun, but nothing stands out as particularly memorable.
Типикал индюшка
i feel like i should love this album, but it just doesn’t hit for me ☹️ i’ve listened to it probably three or so times over the years, but i always feel like there’s something missing… Someday is a fantastic song though.
Yay
Solid
Hittibiisit kuultu aikaisemminkin, mutta en ole ikinä syventynyt levylliseen kerralla. Ja voi pojat mikä lopputulema, aivan vitun hyvä levy ja heittämällä koko tämän paskan haasteen paras yksittäinen yllärilevy. Fiilistelin koko päivän loopilla ja taidan jatkaa vielä tänäänkin. Tämä levy todella piti kuulla ennen kuolemaa ja nousee absoluuttiseen kuninkuusluokkaan.
Mukavaa rallattelua. Joskin laulajan laiska tyyli käy pidemmän päälle raskaaks. Last Niten laulun kaltaista olis pitäny olla enemmän
A very solid outing
Another insta-5. One of my favorite albums from one of my favorite bands. Just the right amount of pop-y. Top five for me are: Is This It, The Modern Age, Someday, Last Night, and Hard to Explain but there's not a single bad track on this album. You could argue that basically all of the less popular ones are underrated.
I know the album is good when I open it up and all but 3 of the songs are already in my liked songs.
Sometimes white bread - properly baked, without a load of additives - is what hits the spot rather than all the sourdoughs and rye in the world. And sometimes a bunch of lads playing catchy indie guitar tracks...they didn't take over the world, but they did make one great album and Is This It? It is.
Already 1000000/10 i fucking love this album and have probably listened to this more than any album ever in my life so.....
Is This It tiene que ser uno de los trabajos más importante en lo que al Indie Rock se trata. Una verdadera piedra angular para el género. Hoy en día no es difícil reconocer su sonido en muchas bandas de los 2000' y ello no es coincidencia, puesto que su influencia es discutida hasta el día de hoy. Este LP cuenta con una composición que no brilla por su complejidad, pero que gracias a la gran voz de Casablancas y la armónica ejecución del resto de la banda te mantiene atrapado en todo momento. Mi único pero sería que no se trata especialmente de uno de mis géneros favoritos, por lo cual realmente no disfrute al máximo esta experiencia y hasta me hizo considerar que algunas canciones suenan muy parecidas unas a otras. A grandes rasgos, un álbum genial. FAVTRAXS: Is This It / Someday / Alone, Together / Last Nite / Hard To Explain / New York City Cops LEASTFAV: Soma
Everything about this is great. I've had it on rotation for over 2 decades. It's a perfect record.
Very overrated band, this album has a lot of what sounds like pretty much the same song repeated. Whenever it sounds like they might shake things up even a little bit it quickly devolves back into their basic work yet again. Pair that with the horrendous filter over the singer's voice and the repetition within each song and you have the perfect recipe for a 1 star album.
Alright. Pretty meh besides like 2 songs
It's okay. Good music but it doesn't catch me. Most likely because I've heard songs like it already. Maybe those songs were influenced by this album but I heard those first.
Não é o meu tipo
A unique sound that had a massive impact on the next decades of music(a lot of which fails to improve on the strokes first album). The release complications with 9/11 are another interesting anecdote that pins this album to a place and time. It’s nostalgic for me personally but trying to be objective, I think it’s an impactful album worth its inclusion in the list. 4/5
These guys KNOW how to throw an album together. Excellent
I mean, it’s the Strokes, what else can I say? If you’re a fan of indie rock then it’s hard to make a case for why this album shouldn’t be at least a 4/5
Bad.
Punchy and full of attitude
Is it just me or did every song sound eerily similar?
I liked it, but in a “middle of the road” sorta way. Nothing stood out and blew me away, considering its indie cred status. The original UK album cover, too risqué for us pearl-clutching Americans, was absolute genius.
Very good and enjoyable
Fotonico
Great album
Always liked the Hits from this record…and now I know which came 1st, the Killers or the Strokes? Easy to remember now, a stroke can kill you. I like this album, if I was younger when this came out I’d be a hardcore fan. Is this it? Could’ve been.
Cool
what a great consistent sound and vision. The album has gotten better over time, I initially was not in love with its overt pop sound but it has such an simple approach with excellent guitar work I came around and now find it amazing in its beauty.
Boring indie that sounds like every sitcom intro. Can see how it was influntial, but not necessarily in a good way.
This record is calculated ennui and curated New York guitar rock sounds bound together by more hooks and artful feints than I gave it credit for when it arrived, dismissing it as cynical homage. It is, but cynicism comes with regret and romanticism, and I swear they cornered the market that year in wistful chord changes and references to looking back - even their most riotous song calls to “Last Night”. 24 years after 1977’s “no future” comes “is this it?” and almost the same stretch later - Christ - I find myself closer to the latter than the former. Accidentally elegiac?
Oh boy - fueled by UK press hype more intense even than for Oasis, tantalizingly described as the second coming of Television, I fired up the ol'Kazaa (hooray!) and ripped this, listened to it once, and sadly agreed with its title. Has not improved with age, wtf are those vocals and that "bass guitar"? If you can't play, at least try to play something interesting! Fucking trust fund posers. Side note - at that point had anyone in the UK press even heard Television?!
The Strokes are a fun band and this album has a few great songs of the 2000s.
Didn't care for the singers voice.
First album, thought that a lot of it was very familiar like I've heard it before but I most definitely have not. I really liked Someday, Last Nite, NYC Cops, and Take It or Leave It(at least the take it or leave it parts). I don't know if I should really put more but yeah, this was definitely an early 2000's indie(?) album.
Standard good rock.
3.5-3.75 not a big strokes guy but i would say objectively good music and the heavy hitters in this album are awesome
Excellent album. 4 stars
The bass part coming in on the first track carries this whole album at least an extra 1.5 stars.
Another band I was familiar with but didn't know their name.
I finally listened to the naked hip album... and kept wonder Is This It?
It's a decent album. The two of the better known songs "Someday" and "Last Nite" are the best imo 3.5/4
Excellent
Definitely enjoyed it. Catchy songs.
Like this album. Nice guitar sound
Todos los temas tienen una vibra especial, el bajo es super atrapante, y el disco siempre me alegra. Discazo.
A solid presentation letter. 7/10
This album came out my senior year of high school when I was also working in a major chain record store, so I heard a ton of it and it really takes me to a specific time and place. The album holds up pretty well, aside from the decision to put the same distortion on the vocals on every single track. It serves a purpose on some songs, but on others it just has the effect of making the entire album very same sounding.
Obra prima. Memorável do início ao fim.
1 full listen (+ some casual repeats of a couple of songs). Sounds mostly fluffy to me. Like if The Killers’ Hot Fuss (which I assume was inspired by this/the band) was robbed of its infectous energy. Not sure if the distorted vocals are a feature or a fault but they don’t exactly help its case, in any case. Some decent songs (The Modern Age, Barely Legal) but overall just so monotone—lyrically, vocally, sonically.
The Strokes were the coolest band - there's a reason Alex Turner himself wanted to be one of them. Is This It is so consistent, there's no filler here and it's hard to pick the best track. So I won't, and will just say it's all great
Listened Before? N Surprisingly good. I believe this album contributed to some of the lo fi trend of the early 2000s. Last Nite is a bit overplayed, but I enjoyed the record overall, and it doesn't drag on forever so I may revisit it. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: Hard to Explain
Slays. One of those records that you wish would keep going and going when it ends. The quintessential indie rock album. Not a weak track to be found. Lots of nostalgia but quality as well.
After years of post grunge and pop punk shyte this album was refreshing. The Atrokes got tired real quick but I’ll always think of this album fondly.
Great album
Simple, enjoyable, great
It's not that great.
My Personal Favorite album from The Strokes. It doesn't have a ton of variation, but The Strokes are some of the best at their particular sound, so they don't really need to vary a ton. Songwriting is on point, just a really enjoyable album.
Good album - don't like the cover though!
What a vibe. Had the Strokes on my radar for a while, but never had the excuse to indulge. 'The Modern Age' and of course: 'Someday' are particular favourites from this album.
It's a fine alternative album, although I think the blown out, distorted vocals are super overdone. I knew it was really hyped up coming in, so the album title is basically how I felt after listening
It's a 3 bordering to a 4 for me. I think it needs time to settle with me before I say I might like it.
Decent alt rock
Eh, all Strokes songs sound so similar. Not my thing.
4.5
It's funny I know Julian Casablancas more by his work in The Voidz than The Strokes. The latter is a somewhat poppier and less daring version of the former. Still great though, there's something je ne sais quoi about his work... Best UK indie album to come out of America
I'm over here storkin' it... and by it I mean. Well, my peanits.
Pretty solid early '00s rock and roll record, considering it was made by a bunch of NYC trust funders.
Solid rock album. Someday and Last Nite are the sure standouts. I remember Last Nite being in my repertoire of printed guitar tabs, it takes me back to my teen years to hear this again.
I get why the British love this. Sounds like their rock. I find it underwhelming and bland. Been 30 minutes of the same vocals and backing to me
That was nothing next please.
I was interested to hear this again to judge if the love for it was pr hype and nostalgia or if it's actually a quality record. I got three runs through and I think it's a little from column a and a little from column b. I think they were very well timed for the zeitgeist, well packaged and undoubtedly cool. But it is quite derivative and has the flavour of posh boys cosplaying as rebels. But on the plus side, there are some excellent tracks on this. The whole album hangs together well and by the third run through I was singing/dancing along. In conclusion this is pop music for people too cool for pop music but it's well done.
They have a very distinct style and thankfully it didn’t get too tired by the end. My favorite was “Last Nite.”
It was fine. Nothing really stood out to me.
Such an important album from my youth. All time classic.
Day 3 of listening to album of the 1001 everyday. It’s really interesting to listen to a bands first album and hear the beginning of what would begin. While it is short it makes up for it for having just so many great songs back to back. I think the lyrical is depth is there however it’s not as prevalent compared to the vocals and music. It’s a great album with its main stand out be the lead singer amazing vocals. Every song has so much raw emotions. However I do feel the lyrics get overshadowed by the great sound. I don’t think that’s a bad thing, I just know the lyrics could be such a bigger focus and makes me to want to listen to more of the strokes. Overall the legacy of the album far outweighs many other albums and it’s great to see a album inspired by The Velvet Underground (which has a huge legacy for inspiring others) end up inspiring others as well.
You want to talk about influential albums? The Downward Spiral definitely changed the industrial metal game for many people. But Is This It in so many ways represents what modern indie rock music has become. Believe it or not, The Strokes do actually make good music. But I was sort of opposed to them for a long time. The album’s reputation is inescapable, and it’s widely regarded as one of the greatest debuts of all time. Personally, I could never get past the first song. I just wasn’t into it. But I’m glad I gave it the chance it deserves. It’s definitely an important album. The band claimed they took a lot of influence from Lou Reed and The Velvet Underground. In a lot of ways, the two groups parallel each other. It is said that everyone who bought that Velvet Underground debut record went home and started a band. I have a feeling the same is very true for this record. I bet you can hear fragments of this in every indie album released in the 21st century post-2001. I mean just look at Car Seat Headrest as an example. The band also claims they took no influence from Television, as they hadn’t even heard them until after this record was released. I find that really hard to believe, but if it’s true, it makes this all the more impressive. That’s basically the equivalent of Talking Heads trying to make a song that sounded as close to Joy Division as possible without ever having heard their music, and creating The Overload. Pretty damn close in both cases. I think where my problems lied initially was with Julian. I’ve never been a fan of vocals that sound like they’ve been recorded through a dollar store microphone. Julian himself is a great singer, don’t get me wrong. But that purposefully lo-fi feeling took some getting used to. It may not even be on purpose either. But once I finally dove deeper and actually heard what this record had to offer, I understand where everyone’s love came from. This is a collection of some of the most undeniably catchy and well written garage rock of all time. And it’s funny to see how far and above this stands with critics over other artists of the same garage rock revival era, like The White Stripes and Arctic Monkeys. The former of which I have equally as much respect for as The Strokes. Rating: 9/10
2 good songs but doesn't grab me as a whole
The schtick of the distorted vocals is a distraction from... nothing else of interest. This is blandness
An undeniable nostalgia 5 for me. It's July 2001, I am weeks away from turning 18 and finishing High School. The Strokes fly into Australia to support You Am I. The album hasn't even dropped yet, but that's basically their setlist in order. News spreads from other states of what awaits us. Four glorious nights in a row at the Newtown Theatre in Sydney quickly become legend, culminating an early album drop months before anywhere else in the world. Something momentous has occurred. We're finally free of our post-grunge and nu-metal shackles. I'd like to think the album holds up without nostalgia goggles, but I honestly can't tell. These 35 odd minutes sounded huge back then, and it always will to me. If not, a bonus point for the iconic non-American artwork perchance?
Seriously?! Good grief!
Wish I enjoyed this sort of music more. It's good, I know it's good, but it hasn't won me over just yet.
Basically the album of my generation. A true classic.
Fine, good tracks, but samey, might grow on me
Still a top 5 album for me
Cute
sexy bass 2000 jugend klassiker
It was good, but I didn’t like the singer guys voice at all.
It’s impossible for me to listen to this without nostalgia. Love this from top to bottom. Not a bad song on the album. Love the grungy fuzziness of it. I know detractors say that it’s derivative. Maybe it is. But I still love it! 5/5
En mi opinión, este es el mejor álbum de rock de los 2000's, y el que inició el revival del garage rock, dando incluso el puntapié inicial al indie sleaze con otros contemporáneos neoyorquinos como Yeah Yeah Yeahs. Sorprendente performance, composición sencilla, pistas pegajosas y una duración de media hora casi sublime. Sumamente recomendable.
Alternative rock. No real good songs.
Awesome album, back-to-front!
This one brought me back to the post 9/11 world. In college being concerned about wars and terrorism - all while the radio was playing butt rock and new metal. Along comes these greasy hipsters from New York to bring rock-n-roll back and suddenly life made a bit of sense again. Listening now the album feels pretty derivative - but it’s easy to forget that it ushered in a new sound and banished Limp Bizkit, Korn and Staind into the dust bin of history.
one of my favorites. And definitely makes me nostalgic for my early 20s
A solid rock album epitomizing the 2000’s
05/12/2024 D̶a̶t̶ ̶a̶s̶s̶ I've only heard their top hits, but after hearing the album, I'm genuinely disappointment at how "hyped-up" The Strokes are. Don't get me wrong, "Is This It" has got some good Brit pop. Some songs are warm and catchy, and "Last Nite" is especially awesome. My complaint though is that majority of "Is This It," excluding the 'famous' songs, follow the same arrangements. The album ends up being monotonous with little diversity.
I remember when everyone in the LES was buzzing about this band. Never got the hype. Honestly, I think you have to be young to be impressed with this. There’s nothing new here. Feels on par with Lenny Kravitz, in terms of authenticity. They listened to their parents’ records and tried to imitate. But this is just pop music. Anyone who says the word “punk” needs to be slapped in the mouth.
classic
The highs were as high as I remember, but I didn't really like the album front-to-back.
Kerri
I don't think I've actually listened to this front to back in a while. What really needs to be said about it? It's a total classic, fire from front to back, truly an era-defining piece of music. I gotta catch these boys live again now that I'm in New York. Will I ever be able to identify each deep cut by name though? Remains to be seen haha, they still blend together for me. I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing though.
Incredible album, there isn't a miss on here. 10/10
First time listening to this album in full. I enjoyed it!
This album was my first introduction to my favorite band, The Strokes. For that sentimental value alone it could easily be called my favorite album of all time. But in addition to that, the album earns it. The tracklist remains so cohesive throughout. One of my favorite signature elements of The Strokes is their use of a rhythm guitar and a lead guitar. The two just dance around, I love switching my focus between them. There's often some funky bass too, really a showcase. The drums consistently focus the energy exactly right. Julian's voice sounds so young, it makes me emotional. I cannot overstate the impact of this album on my life. Some songs transport me directly to specific moments in my life. Julian's voice on every song is directly rooted into my soul. I love the grit on the mic, the little riffs he does, the shifts in rhythm from the rest of the band, every song has so much layered within it despite being a 5 person group of all classic instruments. Factoring in that this was the bands first album is really a testament to their talent, they developed a unique sound that many attribute to the revitalization of rock n roll in the early 2000s. I'm so happy that everyone has gotten the chance to listen to the most important album in my life 💛 thank you
A true perfect album. No notes. Easiest 5 of my life. Fav Songs: Literally all of them
Thank you Kerri for the fun facts about this album! 5/5
Like a few songs but listening all at once was too much of the same thing over and over
I mean, its fine? The music just seems super basic, and the distortion filter on the vocals just wasn’t right, it was getting repetitive over the album. IDK I didn’t really “feel” anything while listening to this album.
Good, liked it in the past like it now
Extremely pleasantly surprised, it’s an all around great album
The Strokes esta bien fucking en bomba, solo había escuchado The New Abnormal y Angels y me parecían una banda solida, pero Is This It me parece de alguna forma legendario. Muy buenas canciones y creo que el run the Barely Legal, Someday, Alone, Together, Last Nite y Hard to Explain es sumamente increíble. Muy buen rock. Its a low Ten or a very high 9, no me decido aún. 9.5/10.
This is one of my absolute favorite albums. Front to back just essential indie rock. It’s gritty and heavy with some nice themes and tones throughout. This us definitely a must listen for anyone who enjoys rock.
This is a fine debut album, like a modern garage band with occasional hints of The Velvet Underground. I'd say that on the downside, that the songs all seem fairly similar, with none that stand out to me. But that said, I played this three times and really enjoyed it.
Best song: Last Nite Vibe: high energy loneliness themes: listless frustrated yearning
Not bad
Love the sound on this one.
Never listened to this - great rock. Accessible and real tunes. A treat!
2.5 accent kills be me
Raw. Unfiltered. Great.
I was so excited when this one popped up (although it's not the cover art I'm used to). Every single song on this album is on one or more of my Spotify playlists. The production is crisp, the performances are tight, not a moment out of place on the whole album. As an amateur guitarist, my favorite thing about this album is the way they use the two guitars playing separate but interlocking lines to add complexity to simplistic song structures.
One of THE classic 2000s indie rock albums. Its reputation precedes it and for good reason. A strong start with some of their most iconic work right out the gate.
Primera vez que escucho esta banda y realmente me gustó mucho vale completamente la pena y tiene piezas muy buenas🤌🏽
The dominant record of that time. How did they dig this up.
Ok rock, just not my thing
Good listen. 3/5
It finally clicked.
The Strokes were maybe the drunkest band I have ever seen live. Still totally brought it. I love this album. Great sound, real rama lama attitude, good songs and downtown lyrics. I'd give this a 5 star for "New York City Cops" alone.
Great all around album, loved it
Pretty good album with some catchy tunes. It just doesn't stand out so much from similar bands at the time.
Yes beautiful surprise, I kinda of knew the Struts with "Last Nite", but the entire album is even better than expected for that reason it's a 5/5. From now on this album is part of my rock folder.
Hooky pop rock but I don’t like the lyrics
Satisfying and compact
They defined an entire generation of indie punk rock. This album has some truly catchy riffs and the ambition is monumental. I think the hits really hit and some of the rest is just filler, but groundbreaking nonetheless.
Fine. 3-stars.
It's good but not anywhere near as good as people say. It feels like it's always about to go into another gear but never quite does. High 3 seems fair?
4.5, an extremely good album. High energy and gives me a nostalgic vibe
This is it
Maravilhoso, amei!
I don't know about this one ... I made it through to the last song, Take it or leave it and decided I'd leave it.
Good Vibes Like the Chill but energetic rock
Me ha encantado
no wonder why the killers almost didn’t make music because of this record
Just bangers on end
works for me :)
Easy 5*. Heard this album so many times I can't actually remember when I first heard it. I love every track on this and the list of bands that I like that wouldn't have existed without this album is endless. Fav tracks: Someday, Hard to Explain, Is This It
I love the Strokes. However, this album suffers a bit from every song sounding a little bit the same, so I have to dock a point here. But overall an incredible album.
Heard it before I like it
I know there are people in my demographic who LIVE for this album. But I wasn’t mindful of, or paying attention to this group when it came out. I had my head stuck firmly in the neon hair rocking 80s instead. There’s stuff here I like for sure, but it doesn’t have the small nostalgic chokehold on me that it does for my peers. The raspy punky pleading vocals are good. The music starts to feel a bit samey the longer it goes on. But it’s a short record and there’s merit here. I enjoyed this one. Better late than never I suppose?
A top 5 album of all time for me so one that I've listened to more times than I could count. Gives you the opportunity to listen in a different way when thinking about how to review it. Some things I noticed for the first time or felt worth mentioning, in no particular order: I always assumed that Someday was my favourite tune but today I realised that it could actually be Alone, Together. That lead break is something else. Someday still being up there with best song ever recorded. So many powerfully simple lines - And now my fears, they come to me in threes; The way every track seems to open up at some point, welcomes you in then wrap you back up into it (The Modern Age as a prime example). The vocal effects maintain a sense that there's always two or three degrees seperation between him, the subject matter and me as the audience. But then at the same time it all seems deeply personal. The double outro of Hard to Explain The Pixies energy of Is This It I'd never paid any attention to the bass line on Last Nite ABH's ability to insert and assert himself on almost every track with out you even noticing. Something about this being the strongest debut album ever made next to Arctic Monkeys but also recognising how much Arctic Monkeys owe to this album. Or put another way, how much I owe to The Strokes for paving the way of many of my all time favourite bands and genres.
Well. Another album of rock and roll that is just the same song over and over, same vocal effect, same guitar tones, same beat, chords, and "melodies." I get that this is basically an album recorded live, but then make a live album. When you have the time and space available to you in a studio, just setting everything up the same way and pressing "record" seems like a waste. Is this is the most important Strokes album? I hope not, for their sake. The most interesting bits? The bass line in the verse in Is This It? is fantastic and had me hoping for more, but alas the rest of the album is just dododododadadada, eight to the bar with a few variations here and there The feedback at the beginning of New York City Cops was probably the most interesting thing on the album. Lo and behold it even had a guitar solo for a second there. So does Take It Or Leave It, but I generally consider a guitar solo something exceeding five different notes. Maybe a phrase or two. And speaking of strokes, they should have called this "The Stroke" because, with the exception of the syncopated rhythm on The Modern Age, it's all just the same driving downstroke. Am I generalizing? Yes. But I'm not going to spend a full 35 minutes trying to find tiny pieces of interesting minutae on an album of sameness. It's all white noise after a while. As they say in "Take It Or Leave It," enough is enough.
I have liked this record for a long time. I initially got into it a few years after it was released, thanks to my sister who had a copy laying around that became stapled to my discman (these were the days). To me it's music that is really evocative of a specific time and place - the early 2000 and the whole rock revival after grunge petered out into endless not so great things and after nu-metal took over (in the US) and brit pop started to fade. It seemed that at that time there was much to listen to that had this kind of grit and amateurishness that band like the Strokes, the Libertines or the White Stripes brought over. That was a breath of fresh air for the fan that I was at the time. This is not particularly original, but it works. It is, in some ways, manufactured too: there is an affected boredom and laziness to Casablancas's vocals and the whole thing seems very intentionally produced to sound somewhat sloppy. But it works. It's got a pretty great bouncy energy about it. I love the bouncy bass, the guitars are pretty sharp (as in cutting and edgy). It manages to sound quite primitive and simple while staying sophisticated. There is also a sense of looming disenchantment and melancholy that is never quite far, like in Alone, Together, or Last Nite that will become more prevalent in their later records and make them, in my view, more interesting. This record also got me back to listen to the sources of this sound, back to being fascinated by the mix of grit and artsy of 70s NY punk-rock. Come to think of it, this was kind of a bridge towards these ancestors. And it brings quite a lot of charm to this process even as you suspect how manufactured the tears in these tight fitting jeans are.
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm Dit is voor mij echt een soort prototype standaard rock. Met andere woorden, hier gebeurt weinig spannends, de muziek is ok I guess, de teksten springen er niet uit en elk nummer klinkt vrijwel hetzelfde. Is er dan niets waar ik echt blij van word bij dit album? Ohnee hoor! Het duurt namelijk maar 36 minuten in totaal! Daarnaast irriteer ik me er ook niet echt aan, maar je kan mij echt niet vertellen waar het ene nummer begint of ophoudt of dat 1 nummer echt zo bijzonder is. Weet je wat het is? Different strokes for different folks, I guess... FAVO: Last Nite
One of my favorites. Someday makes me tear up.
The Modern Age and the last two songs were surprises for me. The songs Nowadays and Last Nite are classics. Mwah, chef’s kiss. Superrrr impressive for a debut album
Rocking album
I feel like ive heard this album before on this list. I get that a lot of people like it, but it is just so... bland. Like so many rock albums, it is loud, abrasive and at times politically engaged. There's nothing unique and exciting about it. I'm not saying I hated it (and it was mercifully short), it's just that this scene completely passed me by in 2001 and I do not have the fuzzy nostalgic feelings that could make it a classic in my eyes.
reminds me of college
Solid
W sumie to dobre. Lubię taki indie rock, szczególnie w starym wykonaniu. Żywe i skoczne brzmienie 4/5
A good album. They're not my favourite band, owing to a couple of my personal dislikes around the musical style. But it's good.
One of the more influential albums of my lifetime. This one changed everything for me.
Perfect rock album.
So so
Not anything groundbreaking, but some good stuff. I particularly liked Alone, Together
One of the greatest debut albums.
I can never explain why this album is so impactful to me. I’ve heard it on good days and bad days and it hits hard either way. A lot of its sound just feels so iconic. The first time I heard Is This It? I was told it sounded like it was being sung to someone through an apartment buzzer. That is fitting, for whatever reason, and it strips down an otherwise bold, varied, and chaotic album. It’s absolutely one of my all time favorites.
more of a 3 at parts, but marking up in honor of Mikey
These guys might not have saved rock ‘n’ roll like the pundits thought they would but they pulled it off in my heart. Not a perfect album but a really important one for me as a teenager that cemented my love for guitar rock. Still can sing every song. Best song: Hard to Explain
Strokes at their best!
Although I am quite familiar with the band and know a few albums I had never listened to this one from the beginning to the end. And this is also a nice album with several great songs.
A pretty solid album of 2000s era guitar rock.
Ah, the Nevermind of the 21st century! Here’s one of the best and most important debuts, maybe of all time, but certainly that I’ve ever heard. The pioneers of the garage rock revival and indie scene come out swinging with nothing but bangers. And the recipe would go on to be used in nearly every successful rock record for the next 20 years.
Motherfucker, this is IT!
I tried to approach this objectively, because I can't stand people who never shut up about how great the Strokes are. A refreshingly short album. I appreciate how much the bass stands out in the mix. Tight, poppy rock music. A decade earlier, Nirvana changed the face of rock music and the Strokes did something similar for the 2000's. Definitely a beginning of an era, it's just not my style. I like my rock music a little less polished and with a bit more edge. It's not my favorite, but I can appreciate it's place in music history.
great album... but not the masterpiece everybody is talking about.
Obv, i love this record
Not only does every song sound basically the same, but it sounds like a dozen other bands at the same time. I don't know who was copying who and I don't care, it's not interesting.
A yes, a watershed rock album for our times. There are some massive hooks and riffs in here. I was skeptical going in, maybe because of all the hype around this debut album, but I warmed up to it as it progressed. The filter on the vocals gets old. Highlights: The Modern Age, Someday, Alone Together, Last Nite, Hard to Explain, Take It Or Leave It
This album is driving down pch with Leila in high school. Loved the whole thing. This is it, New York City cops, hard to explain. There’s not one song I don’t like on this album.
I loved this album when I was younger. Doesn't do it for me anymore. 2.5/5
Loved this album when i first discovered it Felt it had a great mix of rock licks and a punk style on a slower tempo I don’t find that it aged as well, but still nostalgic to hear 3,5
4.5
I love this friggin album. Every song could have been a single. What a debut! The distortion on the guitars and vocals, the driving rhythm - so good. Not sure how they mixed the drums, but to me it’s absolutely perfect. Feel good dance music. 4.8
Not into it. Seems like the distortion on the vocal is doing the heavy lifting. Probably better in context. 2.7
okay album not reat, but not bad either
Good album. Good band. I don’t really have any other notes for this. It’s just a good album, simple as that.
Kinda vibes. Not my personal taste (how does one listen to lyrics?) but I can see how this is a classic!
Meh.
I have never really listened to them, liked it!
Fun, but wouldn’t own it.
Always need generic modern rock
It was okay, I guess.
I remember where I was hearing "Last Nite" for the first time. Truly incredible album, I can't top what's already been said.
RATING SYSTEM: 1*: Horrible 2*: Bad 3*: Middle of the road 4*: Good 5*: Amazing (will round up/down songs that I feel fit between two ratings) ALBUM 2: Is This It This album was very consistent throughout. I could find absolutely nothing to dislike abt this album and there were no songs that I disliked. While I wouldn't say its one of my fav albums, I rlly enjoyed it and think it deserves my high rating. 4.5* rounded up to 5
Not for me. I get why my kids would enjoy it.
9/10 fantastic rock album so many great songs, great aesthetics too
Goated
I really liked this album
A lot of nostalgia for me in this one. Just narrowly misses a 4.
Indie garage rock. Un megahit. Me ha gustado. Un 4.
Strong lyrics, solid bass and guitar riffs. Only knock is a lot of the songs sound the same. Solid album. Will download and listen some more.
I knew so much of this album. It's a fun album with memorable riffs and poppy lyrics that is a good listen. But by the end, it all starts to blend together. However, my autoplay started playing Arctic Monkeys afterwards and I realized I wished I had listened to them instead for the hour.
This may not be life changing, but it’s catchy as hell. That said, it’s less than 40 minutes long and by the last quarter it was all starting to sound the same and I was tired of it. Can you tell I wrote this review while listening? The importance of listening all the way until the end.
Bellissimo album che il passare del tempo non scalfisce. Pixies, Velvet, Franz Ferdinand... passato e presente (del tempo) e una produzione perfetta, né troppo pop né troppo indie. A una punta di stella dalle 5*
Another one of those albums where 'Alternative' is a poor excuse for 'no variation'. I mean, why produce an album at all when you only have ideas for one song?!? *annoyed sigh* 2/5
Better than i thought, handful of + songs added. Barely any skips, only the single
Enjoyable, easy to listen to, and a couple of catchy tunes, but nothing that blows me away. 3.5 stars.
Just not feeling it, they were never in my wheel house when this stuff was new, and hasn't really grown on me since. Some catchy stuff in a few song for sure, but just not understanding the hype.
great album
Is this it this modern age soma barely legal someday last nite hard to explain take it or leave it jesus i enjoyed the whole bloody album, every track. no wonder every other rock band since has copied their sound
Solid album, a lot to enjoy here.
I used to listen to this a lot, but it doesn't seem as good as i remember as a full album. There's 4 really, really great singles and the rest is a bit forgettable.
I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Pretty basic and simple rock music, four beats to the bar, banging away most of the time. Not.something you call sophisticated but it has energy and swagger.
Normally I like the Strokes, but not feeling it this time
Komende week weinig tijd om te luisteren naar voor mij nieuwe albums. Dit album kende ik gelukkig al. Binnenkomer legt een goeie fundering waar de rest op gebouwd kan worden. Vind het gitaargebruik heel lekker en aangenaam klinken. Kan me voorstellen dat dit inspiratie is geweest voor velen bands. Doet me toch heel erg aan m'n ex denken aangezien ze groot strokes fan is. Hoogtepunt: Is this it blijft me toch wel het meeste bij.
Een ijzersterk debuutalbum kan je dit wel noemen. Een album dat de indie rock beweging begin jaren 00 een duikvlucht liet nemen. De albumcover is ultra iconisch, herken je uit duizenden. Ik ben niet de grootste Strokes fan, maar je kan er niet omheen dat dit album zo goed is, het heeft eigenlijk geen imperfecties. Het enige wat ik heb aan te merken is dat de vocale effecten een beetje overused worden. Het is typerend voor dit album, ja, maar ik denk dat er even knallende nummers zouden kunnen gemaakt worden zonder deze lofi/distortion achtige effecten. Het begint na de 11 nummers een klein beetje op m’n zenuwen te werken. Rating: 9/10 Highlights: Vrijwel het hele album
Misschien niet de OG cool indie kids, maar zeker die het meest tot de verbeelding spreken. The Strokes' debuutalbum is echt een iconische pilaar - en mogelijk de belangrijkste - in de fundering van de 21e-eeuwse rockwereld. Dit was misschien wel het eerste album waarbij ik rustig andere dingen in huis kon gaan doen, terwijl de plaat op de achtergrond in een andere ruimte z'n gang kon gaan, wetende dat elk nummer ondertussen wel vastgebakken zit in m'n brein - en in m'n ziel eigenlijk. Front to back, en back to front, 'Is This It' is als een aap, noot, mies voor indie rock liefhebbers. Het is meer een revival van garage-achtige genres, en de lo-fi benadering die we al terugzagen in het werk van The Velvet Underground, dan dat het echt revolutionaire trucjes tentoonstelt. Het is een gitaaralbum pur sang, en de riffjes en basslines ademen de muzikale souplesse van hun stadsgenoten Television. En niet alleen de virtuositeit op de snaren, maar ook de algehele look van The Strokes is als een reïncarnatie van hun musical peers. Maar het is geen kopie. Het gitaarwerk is ruiger, sneller en dansbaarder, en krijgt een geheel andere lading door de laid back - maar toch luidkeelse - vocalen van Julian Casablancas. De laconieke wijze waarop hij de nummers overbrengt is minstens zo sturend geweest voor de indie rock boom die volgde na dit album als dat de gitaren dat waren. De dichtheid aan pakkende rock songs op dit album is bijna unmatched. Op het eerste oog is het een verzameling aan vluggertjes, die allen hun eigen piekfijne riffs etaleren, maar ook nogal eendimensionaal zijn. Maar ondanks de geringe lengte van de songs - en de LP in het geheel - zijn er nog verrassend veel slimmigheden te vinden die het album naast enorm catchy ook gewoon heel boeiend maakt. Die intelligente songwriting is bijvoorbeeld te vinden in de verrassende tempowisselingen van 'Soma', de wijze hoe de lazy intro van 'Alone, Together' onaangekondigd transformeert in een punkerige banger, en de complexe afsluiter 'Take It Or Leave It'. Vaak zul je als kritiek op dit album lezen dat hij eentonig is, maar geen song gebruikt de zelfde opbouw, en het is soms knap lastig om het verschil tussen een couplet en een refrein te horen. Sonically, vocally en instrumentally is er weinig variatie op het album, maar de onorthodoxe structuur van de nummers en onvoorspelbare riff- en tempowisselingen zorgen dat het album niet alleen leeft op z'n catchy gitaarspel en het charisma van Julian. Op de tamelijk zwakke opener 'Is This It' en de forgettable 'Trying Your Luck' na zit er eigenlijk geen echte filler op het album, en heb ik voor het eerst echt moeite met het aanwijzen van highlights. Er staan zoveel boeiende songs op. 'The Modern Age' had wat mij betreft de opener moeten zijn. Stilistisch gezien zet hij de juiste toon, en laat de luisteraar direct weten dat het hier niet om je average garage rock band gaat. De chorus is echt classic Strokes. 'Someday' en 'Last Nite' zijn de twee songs die echt boven de rest van het album zijn uitgegroeid qua cultstatus, en zijn echt staples op elke indieparty/gitaardisco. De eerste doet me niet zoveel, maar 'Last Nite' is zelfs na honderden luisterbeurten nog steeds een gangmaker. Wel vind ik dat de populariteit van deze twee singles andere juweeltjes op het album overschaduwen, zo ook de derde single 'Hard To Explain', wat m'n absolute favoriet van het album is. Het was het eerste nummer waar ik bewust van was dat het een nummer van The Strokes was, en hij staat tot de dag van vandaag nog steeds op eenzame hoogte. Het no nonsense gitaarspel, de extreem lo-fi vocalen van Julian, de waanzinnige hook. Het klopt gewoon, ik kan moeilijk uitleggen waarom ( ;) ;) ;) ;) ). Het is ook het nummer die de stempel 'post-punk revival' het best past. 'New York City Cops' is een andere personal favorite, en is de song waar het meeste speelplezier van afspat. Plus dat het aan het einde van de rit eigenlijk altijd het nummer is dat zich nog in m'n hoofd afspeelt, en dat zegt wat gezien z'n concurrentie. Interessant verhaal ook waarom hij niet op de originele US release stond. Vaak kijk ik met een hoop jaloezie naar het exceptionele assortiment van artiesten in de 60s en de 80s, bijvoorbeeld. Als je je realiseert aan wat voor waanzinnige releases het muziekminnende volk destijds werd blootgesteld, en je dan een kijkje neemt in de toch wat gezapige alternative charts van de laatste jaren, dan krijg ik heimwee naar een tijd die ik niet heb meegemaakt. Maar albums als deze zijn een reminder dat ook onze generatie z'n Pet Sounds en Dark Side of the Moons heeft, ook al komt hij in een volledig andere verpakking. Een generation defining plaat waar we trots op mogen zijn. 9,5/10 Highlights: The Modern Age Hard To Explain New York City Cops
Is this it? Already? Had nog wel ff mogen doorgaan. Het waren 35 gelukzalige minuten... Ik ga hier niet al te veel woorden aan vuil maken. Deze plaat is precies wat ik lekker vind en waar de zeroes destijds behoefte aan hadden. Dankzij deze plaat is er nog zoveel gave indierock verschenen in de jaren 00 en 10. Daar moeten we the Strokes dankbaar voor zijn. Even dacht ik dat de echte rammers op de andere platen stonden, maar in deel 2 van het album bewijzen ze het tegendeel. Hier doen we niet moeilijk over: 10/10 Highlights Is this it Someday Last Nite Hard to Explain Take it or Leave It En shout-out naar het later geskipte New York City Cops. 9/11 denken we even weg. Dan toch gewoon één van de lekkerste tunes van de plaat.
Nøøøj hvor har jeg hygget mig med det her album hele weekenden. Næsten alle numre kendte jeg, og resten er også virkelig gode!
Garage Rock Revival på toppen. Klart et af de bedste albums til at byde det nye årtusinde velkommen og sparke døren ind med et nyt take på en gammel lyd. Simpelt, energisk, ørehængende riffs og en forsanger der både kan lyde køligt fraværende og intenst vrissende. Så nemt kan god rock laves.
I've been slowly learning via this list that I have very limited knowledge of post 2000 music as I stuck my head in the sand at some stage pre 2k. That said my 16yo has been a huge fan of The Strokes and I've been getting into them as I hear more and more. This album is touted as the "reinvention of post-millennium guitar music" so my thanks go to The Strokes. Faves: Someday, Last Nite, and Hard To Explain.
Lot of nostalgia for this! It was definitely one of the highlights in 2001s musical landscape, and popular with my friend group. Still stands up to scrutiny, I'd say! Fave tracks - "The Modern Age", "Last Nite", "New York City Cops" - really, though, any track from this album will give me that sweet sweet reminiscence!
Yawn.
Nice
Pretty good but a bit repetitive
Favourite song - hard to explain
A provocative cover which promises so much yet the music delivers so little.
troede jeg ville være sådan helt 🙄🙄 fordi den her slags musik er ikke rigtigt mig, men synes den er rigtig god faktisk (også en smule monoton). New York City Cops er fed! Last Nite er fed og lyder ret meget som American Girl med Tom Petty!
mesterværk!
Kan stort set alle sange med tekster.. Kan godt finde på at smide hele albummet på fra ende til anden.. det må være definitionen på en 5'er..
Not my jam.
Cornerstone album of the genre, song structures and riffs are simple but mesmerizing, fun listen start to finish. Side note the riffs on 'Alone Together' bang so hard
Great singles on this album. All sounds the same!
Upbeat and fun with punk vibes. Was interesting listening with Kelly since she knew the whole album from high school. Enjoyed the album overall.
Groove rock, rythym guitar keeps the beat and the bass feels more lead/solo, I can see how it was a hit as contrast to typical rock sound
Gave it a second listen to decide of its a 3 or 4. It's a 3
Weird. When this popped up I was listening to it on vinyl. Good album. Loose production makes it sounds like it was recorded live in a garage. It’s a a brilliant debut album with catchy tracks and sun lyrics.
I have always loved the Strokes, including when Last Nite dropped, but didn't get into them until well after this. They (with Interpol/Shins/et al) seem to have kept true rock moving in the aughts while other mainstays were effing around with electronica or being dwarfed by Hip Hop/Pop. I like the feel of this album and their sound is so good and inventive--it was fun to read about their origins. I like their next album more, but probably because it's the only one I own and I WORE IT OUT!
This was interesting. Didn't love it, didn't dislike it, won't remember it next month.
I immediately got into the groove of this album and never got out of it.
They don’t jive with me. Boring vocals and voice
I liked this album. My second time through I liked it even more than the first time. I like the lofi sound, I think the guitar tracks are really interesting. I maybe could use a hair more variation in the tracks, but coming in at 35 minutes its kind of OK as is. I'm going 4 stars for now but could easily see it jumping up to 5
This is an excellent album. I am not sure why I haven't listend to this before but I will definitely listen again.
When this came out over 20 years ago, the Sous Chef where I was working told me about this band that reminded him of the Velvet Underground. He was about the age I am now and we both shared a love of music. 'This Is It' is such a New York album for me. Quick paced and loud. Every song is like a New York Conversation. All of the instruments are distinct, weaving in and out, sometimes arguing, sometimes complementing, sometimes taking turns. All atop Julian Casablancas lyrical storytelling introducing us to a cast of characters throughout. Loved it then, love it still.
This was great. I wasn't into The Strokes when they were big, but this was definitely a hit of nostalgia. I expected the tracks to be repetitive but they stood out from each other. This album felt a lot like Wolfmother because it's classic rock and roll presented in a slightly new way with a little funk on it.
Solid album, great musicians. I would have liked to have been able to understand the vocals a bit more.
Best wel priem!
I've always felt like I'm missing something when people talk about The Strokes. I find it difficult to get excited about them. I find them a bit boring lyrically and vocally. I've heard this album before, but enjoyed listening to it more closely, and a lot of the music stuck out to me more this time. I'm still not a huge fan of Julian Casablancas - even the moments when it seemed like he was trying to do something different vocally (like in Take It or Leave It) I wasn't super into it. But the songs on this album are solid. Faves: Last Nite; Hard to Explain; Alone, Together
Not my cup of tea.
Sleek and stylish and way too cool for school, but also a little self-regarding one feels, a bit too knowing but perhaps not as smart or savvy as it wants to be. Had the good sense to be poppier than punk, punkier than glam, and more fun/rolicking than VU/Reed with its predlictions toward the ponderous and pretentious. Perfomrative, yes, but will Casablancas some credit for irony and a touch of self-parody, too (which are features, not bugs, and seem to have grown more additive, if less necessary, over time). Still a pretty fun and glittery ride that holds up better than one might have guessed hearing it in real time lo, these decades ago.
Not my cup of tea.
# Playlist track - The Modern Age # Notes - Boy, this makes me feel old. This was *amazing* when it came out. And it's aging pretty well! +1 - The opening chord +1 - Cover art +1 - Hard to choose a favorite track for the playlist +1 - No bad tracks +1
I really really like this album. So glad it still sounds fresh after 20+ years. The bass line in the opening track is glorious, all from a Casablancas demo. The dry guitars and distorted vocals are iconic. Listening again there are so many high points in the album, like the solo in last nite, or the chorus in hard to explain. It is such a well crafted album. The playing is quite restrained and minimal at times, so when there’s a change in the drums or a guitar riff, or a melodic bass line comes in, it really has impact.