Reviews (page 12 of 16)
ugh. Did not enjoy this album at all.
March 12, 2024 HL: title track, “The Modern Age”, “Someday”, “Last Nite”, “Hard to Explain” Playing catchup. Not only is today the first time I listened to (all of) the Strokes’ Is This It, it’s the first time for Room on Fire (2003) as well. As someone who leans toward 2000s indie bands, this has been a longtime blind spot. At the same time, I couldn’t see the appeal in diving deeper into their catalogue past “Last Nite” and “Reptilia”, as catchy as they were. So what to say about their debut that hasn’t been said? I don’t have any emotional connection to it, but after the 5 killer highlights I listed earlier, and my next favourites “Soma” & “New York City Cops”, there’s not really any loss of quality with the remaining 4 tracks. They built a pretty airtight ship here. And the next one might be just as catchy, if not more so! Damn, nothing to justify my playlists going sans-Strokes all this time. Somewhere between 4 and 5, but I’ll round up tonight.
ASSSSSSS ALBUM!!! Fav songs: - Is This It - The Modern Age - Barely Legal - Someday - Last Nite - Hard to Explain
Last Nite was on the version of Guitar Hero I had lol. Havent listened to this album in ages, and I think this is the only The Strokes album I've ever listened to. They feel like the American spiritual approximation of what Oasis was to the UK imo. In both cases I definitely got a lot more out of this in the mid 2000s than I do listening now, but its still enjoyable. Just on the scale from dated to timeless this is heading a bit more towards the dated side of the spectrum. I wish there was a bit more variety in the sound, and the riffs are dead simple, which I get is rooted in punk but did have me wishing for more at time. 3.5 but will round up for the strength of Someday thru Hard to Explain (these 4 do simple perfectly).
Man, that bass line in the title track gets me every time. Is this a Great Album? It is if you ask everyone I went to high school with. While there’s definitely some filler, I can’t deny that this is an excellent listen. Last Night, Someday, Hard to Explain are the singles for good reason. The album has great pacing and lasts as long as it should. Was torn between a 4 and a 5 but add on that this influenced a whole new wave of bands and it gets to the cinco.
Solid alt rock album. Happy to listen to it anytime. Definitely influencing some of my own music writing
I don’t get all of the hype around this band. This is a fine album and I thought some of the guitar parts were really, really good but that’s about it. Maybe they’ve had a lot of influence on bands who came a little later? Not good enough to make me want to hear it again.
I liked this more than I expected to. I just really hate julian casablancas. He's a dickhead and is so obnoxious. The tunes here are all solid though and are a nice fusion of pop and rock. Would do a 3.5 if I could. I just wonder why this band became so popular?
Man. It feels like it's been forever since I've gotten an album that I was actually excited to listen to. Every day for the past week or so (possibly even more) I've clicked on the next album button wondering "is this it?" Well, fortunately, "Is This It" is, in fact, it. This album is awesome. I love it. It feels like what the modern equivalent to something like The Velvet Underground would sound like in the best way possible. I think the clearest example of this is in the singing. Julian Casablancas is like if Lou Reed was a good singer. That was a joke, but I do like this singing more. The sound is just great. It's like the perfect mix of punk, alt-rock, and even pop at times. The writing is quite good as well. There's depth to this album. There really isn't a bad song. The popular ones like Last Nite are deservedly popular, but even the tracks that don't get talked about as much still stand strong. This isn't that important, but I find that both the original album cover and the replacement are quite good. I think the original fits the album better, but I do really like looking at the replacement. Although, that's not to say that the original isn't visually pleasing in a different way, if you know what I'm saying. Overall, this is easily the best album I've gotten in a while, and my second favorite album of 2001, only behind Toxicity by System of a Down. 5/5.
pleasant songs
simply iconic, enjoyed listening to british version over US this time even though it's just one track.
Nice
I remember thinking this album was too repetitive but I must have listened to it a lot because it felt nostalgic and I enjoyed it more than I thought I would
I see from a little background reading The Strokes were leaders of the early 2000's post-punk movement. This album did not do much for me. Very upbeat and guitar heavy, which is great but it just didn't keep my interest.
Didn't we all Alex. The Strokes get credited for saving rock from the Smash Mouths of this world. While I'm sure that's hyperbole, they did define what a rock band would sound like for my entire childhood. On a related side note, I'm old. 4/5.
Pretty solid. Sad they changed the album cover.
Really enjoyed this one. Can still remember when it came out and all the hype around it. The album definitely lives up to it. 4/5 Will listen again
This is quintessential 2000’s rock, it’s got all the right grooves and a message about living a life with meaning over some brilliant band chemistry. Favorite Song: Hard to Explain.
Favorite Tracks: Hard To Explain Someday Last Night
Too definitive of the early 2000s and the album was more pop-py than I remember.
4/5. Fun album. Teen me loved this album.
Typical late 90's POP....I do not call this Rock. I can do without....I did enjoy Trying your Luck!
Is This It So good when it first came out. In fact I think I might have bought it in Melbourne when I came to visit you Paul. July 2001, so the timing checks out. Think I also bought the Purple Hills single by D12 at the same time. Is this still good or is there too much nostalgia? I love that the first track played with the idea of hype and disappointment. Obviously the hype was huge, so to open with a detached sounding song that never quite builds and then just sort of finishes is great. Super bassline hanging the whole thing together. Banger after banger. No matter how derivative the songs might be or how self consciously cool they wanted to be the songs are excellent. For their particular style and template it really is fantastic. No weak tracks. 35 mins. Superb. Love the overall sound, particularly that dry drum sound and the rhythm guitars. Although Last Night is basically American Girl the rhythm guitar is Lennon-esque, not quite the triplets of All My Loving but a nice version of it. It so heavily reminds me of early 2000s and absolutely loving it but I don’t think it sounds dated, it’s still great, unlike a lot of bands albums they followed in their slipstream. Musically and aesthetically they had the same effect on rock music as Nirvana did a decade before, you can see clear a line before and after of how indie rock bands looked and sounded. My only slight reservation is that sometimes I think it’s too studied a synthesis of cool influences and is it really them, is there an artifice that I can’t quite see through? But then I think I’m overthinking it and every time I listen to it I love it. So it has to be a 5, can’t be anything else. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Liked it a lot. Good rock vibes, and overall not bad
Fantastic record. Great melodies and vocals with an upbeat tempo. Classics that I had heard before but didn’t realize was this group. Very good listen.
For me, perfectly formed
When I was a teenager listening to The Jesus and Marychain and The Primitives my mum used to shake her head at me and say, "that just sounds like the 60s. Why do young people want to listen to that? Why not listen to something original". But they were my 60s sounding stuff. I didn't want to just listen to old stuff. When this album came out I realised I was now just a little bit more like my mum. But if you're 10+ years younger than me maybe this was/is exciting.
A very youthful sounding LP; that is, the sort of record you could imagine as part of the soundtrack to an American slice of life drama/comedy. Evokes thoughts of quickly smoked cigarettes, wind-swept hair and late night drives in dodgy cars. That said, the sound does stay rather samey; if it were a little more adventurous with its tones, this LP could score a bit higher.
a perfect album if ever there was one.. the bassline to is this it alone makes this a five star-er
Listened to this none stop when it came out (and before, thanks SoulSeek!). Every single track is a banger.
I really liked this. Been meaning to listen to some of their stuff.
2001 Genre: Indie rock, garage rock revival, post-punk revival Standouts: Last Nite, Someday, Soma, Hard to Explain
These guys always sounded to me like they had listened to other bands and kind of tried to recreate the sound. All style no substance.
Lots of songs that I enjoyed, although it was monotonous in places. I wish I heard this when it was released! I would def listen again.
I had not listened to The Strokes before and I was surprised that I rally enjoyed their style. Great album.
Great album, own it already
Never heard this all the way through before and idk how, it’s perfect. “After the September 11 attacks, the American compact disc release was delayed from September 25 to October 9 and had its track list amended, with the song "New York City Cops" being removed and replaced.” Lol
i love the strokes ‼️‼️‼️ wtf is the touch of a woman 🤨 5/5
Классика, которую я, судя по всему, не могу воспринимать в контексте всей вышедшей позже музыки: говорят, чтобы понять влияние и популярность дебютного(!) альбома Касабланкаса (фамилия потрясная) и компании, нужно было жить в лимбе одинакового ню-метала и криков Фреда Дёрста, как всем теперь кажется, вечность. Если поставить вопрос таким образом (а именно что лучше, вечный Линкин Парк [со всем уважением к их музыке] и ню-метал или вечный Строукс и инди-рок), то это явно лучший альбом из всех мне предложенных до сих пор: если бы не эта революция, я бы скорее всего слушал EDM, Майли Сайрус и латин поп-хиты с радио (как будто в этом есть что-то плохое). У этого альбома супер-странное происходит с обложкой. Конечно же международная гораздо лучше, чем американская. Революционный ли это альбом? Нет. Это даже не лучший альбом группы более, имо (ибо почти 20 лет спустя вышел The New Abnormal). Лучшая-лучшая песня группы вышла два года спустя (см. Reptilia). И, собственно, только за это (как будто освобождения от ню-метал-ства было мало) этот альбом можно любить. А тут еще и неплохие песни. Лучшая песня - Trying Your Luck.
One of the great indie rock albums. Songs lack variety but they're great songs.
Definitely pretty high energy rocking out, grungy
Uma bosta
4+
Yea, it was fun
A fun pop album reminding me of the vibe when I first hear block party. Loved the tone of the drums and the overblown vocals. Overall not my favorite listen but haven’t come across any bad songs.
11/11 songs saved
Last Nite got me into this Band. All the other songs made me stay
Nicht meine Richtung
First Listen: It feels like one continuous song throughout the whole album which can be a great thing. Easy flow, but to me there was not a single memorable song within the whole album. I can’t say that I had a favorite one or that I disliked any of them. I might want to go back and listen to this album again… Second Listen: Sick guitar solo from track 2 “The Modern Age!” Nice discordant ending. Frequent abrupt track endings. I fell asleep halfway through second listen…
Sounds like any other indie rock album nowadays, even though it has a vibe
Serious bangers on their. I feel like The Strokes gained too much of their style from their lo-fi mic sound they use on every single song though.
Fuck yeah.
I like it, i feel like i will definitely be listening to it again. Trying your luck so far is my favorite one.
Definitely has a throwback sound to it. Good guitar play but the vocals are not my cup of tea with the "vintage mono" filter on his voice. I've given it a few listens but it never quite hold my attention or makes me want to dig further. 3/5 for being sonically interesting.
I like this album, familiar with a few songs. The Strokes are indie before indie was big. Will listen to this again.
Really liked this band a lot. Great instruments and voice of lead singer. I am willing to give them a listen on some other albums.
I was shocked because I didn’t think it was going to be that good!!!
I really liked this album. I had heard a couple songs by The Strokes before but never really listened to them much. This was pretty solid, not enough to get them a 5 since quite a few of their songs kinda sound the same and there isn't much variety in terms of what their frontman does vocally or really overall with their sound. However lyrically I felt there was enough variation and combined with the different feels to each song, I felt there was enough variety to keep one interested for the entire album so this gets a 4. Kinda reminds me of Cage the Elephant.
not a fan of the album cover, but was very pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed the album. vocals, music-enjoyed all of it
Legitimately perfect rock album. Boomer comment of I remember back in my day when “New York City Cops” was on it instead of “When It Started.”
A lot better than I expected! Cool guitar riffs and an expressive vokal performance, but a bit too monotonous.
Never really got into this one. Sure, songs like Someday and Last Nite are solid. But the rest sound so generic -- like golden-age Interpol without the gothic sadness and great breakdowns, or jangle-rock like the Wedding Present without the bittersweet lyrics and vocal delivery, or wall of stacked guitar riffs. This is bare bones and there's not enough meat to bite into
Good! Great guitar and vocals. Interesting lyrics too
One that I know very well but in my opinion, bettered by its successors. I didn’t quite get the hype at the time; it sounded a bit mechanical, the vocals are all distorted and I sort of felt the songs all sound too samey. It’s still one I listen to quite often though and was hugely significant at the time, which fortunately I was there to see.
Strokes in it.
A frequent flyer on the radio station I listened to in high school - pretty formative for expanding my music taste
Very good album, reminds me of Veronica Mars and middle school which is fun
Great album with some nice classics!
This album was pretty good, and i would recommend it to others.
If I was more depressed and like spoken word, would like it more but its fine
I have listened to this many many times in the past so didn’t listen to it on the day. Good stuff 4/5
Excellent!
Sucks
I liked it, it was new to me
I wasn’t sure at first if I liked this or not, but I eventually warmed up to it and it clicked for me in the second half. This album is amazing. The lyrics paired with the distorted vocals are fun. The instrumentals, while samey, are very energetic and fun to listen to. The distorted percussion on some tracks sounds great as well. Good production as well. All around good
Amazing album
Ever come across an album that you feel bad about not having listened to during its prime? This is one of those for me. I know The Strokes and grew up hearing them on the radio, and even have some of their newer stuff on regular rotation. But for whatever reason I never gave this record a fair shake. Wrong decision, because this is fantastic! Carefree indie rock that's so representative of the early 2000s. The instrumentals are simple, the melodies are easy, and the vocals are never anything complicated. Sonically, it's not actually anything that's particularly exciting. The sound and its simplicity are very much evocative of my childhood, though. Music has many qualities, but nostalgia is an easy way to my heart. Standouts are The Modern Age and Someday.
4.0
Yes it is.
Easy 4 stars if for no reason than Last Nite.
Not really it for me. Different Strokes for different folks, I guess.
This is one of my favorite albums of all time. Notable tracks include is this it?, the modern age, someday, last nite, hard to explain, trying your luck. Great band.
I’ve heard of the Strokes but couldn’t name a single song of theirs. Turns out I knew “Last Nite”… but that’s it. And all the rest are the same. I’d rather just listen to The Buzzcocks.
Not for me, sound the same.
It's fine
Familiar with this record in full already but not as much as their other albums. I actually really enjoy their newest record probably the most so going all the way back to their first was a welcomed experience. The songs on this album remind me of a lot of sports video games I used to play when I was younger, like NHL, NFL, all had early Strokes stuff on em. Either way, I could listen to this many times over.
Okay, this has that peppy fun feel and to me is more of something I would listen to then yesterdays
obviously seems to be regarded as a seminal rock record, but to me it feels a bit uninteresting. there are some incredible lyrics and eardrilling melodies that worm their way into your brain (“Someday” and “Hard to Explain” being particular standouts), but as a whole Is This It doesn’t seem to completely earn the regard it’s been afforded.
Boring. Not a single song on there that I really liked minus Last Nite and I like that better by Weird Al
I drank some beers with Julian Casablancas once. Strange dude. 5/5
It's a stunner
Excellent! 4.5
The best strokes album
Strokin' it I was not. Spent the whole album waiting for last night. The songs M All sound the same.
Great album
One of Colins favorites
I don't get it. Mediocre riffs, average vocals, run-of-the-mill lyrics. Painfully mid. Sole highlight is them kinda clowning on the NYPD.
An alright listen, but nothing quite outstanding to me. Decent middle of the pack
I can see how they probably had fun writing and playing this but I find it a bit grating tonally.
I liked it better than I thought I would. Catchy, bouncy, and infinitely listenable.
Undeniable. We pirated this music, burned MP3s, traded music on MegaUpload and distributed it widely. All of us music nerds know rock and roll and indy music was on life support and the wider music world was stuck listening to bands like Korn, Linkin Park, System of a Down and Green Day before this broke. This was exciting. Some of us hated it immediately because it was successful, it wasn't indy enough, but the wider world appreciated the change and that sparked more unique NYC bands to be recognized. This music created a world that us 90's kids dreamed of, but weren't ready for and instead tried to look the other way. (Buddyhead, I'm talking to you) But it's undeniable. Like time, it ages, you age and the world keeps spinning and hindsight is 20/20. Today, this is easily available on Spotify and everything else is discoverable (even AI generated tracks ;). But I think the era that Is This It bloomed, was last physical movement in music, or indy music if you can call it that. Hopefully, you are able to be a paying member of your favorite music streaming service. Hopefully you still go out to see bands and hopefully are still part of the community. Hopefully you visit the merch bar, buy a t-shirt or vinyl and support the music you listen to. And, hopefully, you've discovered that if you pay for Spotify, you're entitled to 14 hours of audiobooks and have discovered Meet Me In the Bathroom, the book by Lizzie Goodman which can provide a much better interpretation of this era than I can... but if you haven't you can always stream the movie. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgHN-YE7IPI
I wasn't a huge Strokes fan. I always kind of got the impression that Julian Casablancas was pretentious and full of himself. I have no idea if that impression was at all justified, I just thought he gave off a bit of a vibe in what little I saw of him early in The Strokes’ career. Not to make his head even bigger, but I think The Strokes may have saved rock music. The Strokes broke through with “Is This It” in 2001 (the same year as The White Stripes “White Blood Cells” at a time when mainstream rock was in a downward spiral. The post-grunge years had left a void that was being quickly filled by edgier and edgier nu-metal and rap rock, and it looked like a bleak future dominated by the likes of Limp Bizkits, Korns, Slipknots, Papa Roaches, and Stainds. But along came The Strokes and The White Stripes, and the influence they had over the next 10 years of rock music can’t be understated. I wasn’t a huge Strokes fan, but listening to “Is This It” I could hear their fingerprints on the next decade-plus of rock music. The garage rock elements gave space to the less flashy and commercial White Stripes, Black Keys, and Black Rebel Motorcycle Club. The jangly danceable guitars paved the way for Franz Ferdinand, Walk the Moon, Fun/Bleachers, and many more. The in-your-face old-school rocker stardom inspired The Libertines, Kings of Leon, and The Killers. I wasn’t a huge Strokes fan. But I knew this whole album. I didn’t follow them afterwards, but “Is This It” is undeniably catchy, pulsating, and well-crafted from start to finish. I’m not quite sure I can get behind “Barely Legal,” even when written by a 20-year-old, but every other song completely captures me and transports me back to the early 2000s, when in the midst of 9/11, Total Request Live, the Bush presidency, boy bands and Nickelback, The Strokes lit the way for rock bands in the 21st century. I’m sorry I thought you were all-ego, Casablancas - you and Albert Hammond, Jr. deserve all the accolades you received. It sounds hyperbolic, but I’m serious. Emerging rock artists may never again reach the commercial heights they did in the 90s, but great music abounds.
I remember this album cutting through the noise that was rock radio in early 2000s and being so refreshing.
Another wonderful discovery through the 1001. I’ve heard of The Strokes and Last Night or course, but I had never gone out of my way to listen to their music. And I’m glad I did. I’m in love with the lo-fi-ness of this album. The basement recording with minimal sound processing and imperfections included sounds enticingly gritty. The vocals sound like they were recorded from the output of a $50 amp. I don’t feel like there is a single track that is a drop off from the rest. I’ll be coming back to this album for sure.
Obv amazing
Lived it. Every song is good.
Heel goed
Great album, have a pandora station off these guys and already knew most of them.
instant classic
Loved
Perfectly listenable to but a bit repetitive maybe. For me it's a good job it’s a short album. The guitars are solid enough, although I might want a bit more funk in the baseline perhaps. The vocals seem a bit lost in the guitar which isn't my preference. Glad I listened to it though, and reading about it the album's clearly influential. It had already occurred to me that it's similar to early Arctic Monkeys, so the influence it had on that sort of sound is a good enough reason for it to be on this list. It just lacks the wit and style to go with it. It's all fine. I enjoyed it enough but I doubt I'll listen to it again, certainly not regularly. A solid 3.5 though.
Ruppig, der Song „Take it or leave it“ erinnert an Nirvana
Love this album. Saw this tour in concert. I even bought this version of the album from Amazon UK. It's still good. I remembered it pretty closely to what I thought. I like the way the songs kinda "roll along" - jangly guitar and quick beat.
Quality stuff. ‘Classic’ vibes in terms of my musical experience!
I really enjoyed this one a lot too. My favorite part of this is seeing all the newer artists I like that were so heavily influenced by these artists. I heard so much of Jet in here, and I love that Jet was obviously so heavily influenced by The Strokes.
Awesome
Listening to this after work with my windows down made me feel like the main character. The strokes are good but I didn’t love all their songs. It kind of gives me “Nirvana” vibes like “they’re just not like other artists” or it’s cool to like them. I do like them though! Last Nite is such a classic.
SAME AS IT EVER WAS
Un disco que no suena a 2001, sino que es mucho más atemporal. Esto es lo que hace que un disco sea bueno de verdad.
5- Stars (13/15)
One of my favorite albums of all time
very good
The album that changed my life. Would give 500 stars if I could.
Fantastic album
absolute heater
Is this it: heard this before, love the nostalgic feel. has a really interesting vibe, feels like home some of the songs kinda blend together, but a few rly stick out Someday: heard this before, very cool Alone together: very cool ideas mixing the different guitar parts in the first verse. Simplistic but really powerful sums up like a lot of songs on the album but this express it very well. part where it gets fast is really great, love how it adds to the chorus when it transitions into that. Solo is really cool, love the stroked guitar work in general. Last nite: Very cool, vocals are really nice, pair well with the guitar. Nice vibe Over all 3.5, wish there was more variety between some songs. Very mellow and simple songwriting can be super powerful and this is a rly cool example.
good album but damn it gets repetitive at times. overall like the sound though so it's a 3/5
Hmm, vad kan detta vara? Bra grejer
• Har annat omslag i USA för detta är för explicit • Det patenterade Strokes bôset Betyg: 5/5
Svinbra album. Vem kunde tro att jag skulle tycka om The Strokes. Många bra låtar som man inte lyssnar på så ofta om man inte lyssnar hela albumet. New York city cops var lite weird
I couldn't move the left side of my body after listening to this album, but it was catchy and had a feel good beat the kids are sure to love.
I adored this album and what the band could have been, but they fell short. It’s an overproduced album by a group of entitled rich kids led by a control freak who is ruled by substance abuse. Is This It was what we needed to jumpstart the change in radio at the end of a decade of dad rock. Its a shame Julian wasn’t held accountable 25 years ago (or ever). This album influenced a lot of experimental garage pop bands on the scene to up their game, that is the contribution of The Strokes.
Thumbs up.
Added 4 songs to my liked songs. They have their own sound, broken mic singing. Bass pops out. Bobblehead 01 Collage alternative pop for sure.
this band got me into "indie" back in the day lol
Mäßiger Post Punk.
Mix is a bit shit, but the bass lines are super. I once saw them at the isle of white festival. The lead singer was off his tits, but kept shouting out "isle of whitey" which was the main highlight
Decent.
Solid rock album. Better than their later stuff.
Man, I fucking love The Strokes. This debut album is by no means "The New Abnormal" but it clearly shone a light about the kind of band they were set to become.
Legendarisch album.
the exception to the rule that all garage rock revival bands are shite, One of the only critical darlings that are actually good.
wish this had been as edgy and cool as the album cover made it seem
pretty good overall and nice to see a more modern album on this list, but most of these songs were pretty average garage rock. oddly, i liked the middle of the album and didn't really care for the beginning or the end. the strokes have some good tracks and someday is easily my favorite of this album. the sexy album cover also seems out of place and unnecessary? or maybe I'm just saying that because it's taking up most of the screen on my work computer. the alternate/US cover is way cooler imo. also i keep thinking julian casablancas and the strokes are british for some reason but i promise i didn't factor this into my rating. favorites: someday, alone together, last nite, hard to explain
Wow ... phenomenal, epitome of indie rock. Songs are so catchy and are excellently written and mixed
I think of the Strokes as the last in a long line of bands to have "saved Rock and Roll"; the last guitar-based band to have enormous success by reimagining the sound of two guitars, a bass, drums and vocals, while keeping the raw energy of youth as the guiding principal. I dislike the megaphone effects on the vocals and I still love this album.
they have their signature sound, and it's already in full throttle in their debut album. it's a perfect music for a bar
Well it's been a long time since I listen to this album and I feel I enjoyed it more when it came out. It's fun rock album that leans heavy in the Lou Reed Velvet Underground sound which get's closer to ripping off than inspiring. Still a good listen, 3.5 for me but a +.5 for nostalgia.
Still a super album. Does the vocal effect get to be a bit much? Maybe, but I like it. I love when a band has a unique enough sound that it really grabs your attention and makes you want to listen. And the true tast is if you want to listen again. And again. This record definitely passes that test for me.
I like this record. It's hard separating the massive hype surrounding the Strokes when this came out. I wish their follow ups were anywhere near as good.
First time I heard this album all the way through. I really like some of the stuff that sounds like Lou Reed, so that's good. Overall very enjoyable and I'll listen to it again.
A rock band of a classic take, from a more modern band
I was pleased to be able to give this a good listen as it's a highly rated album that hadn't done it for me. Having listened I can see what the fuss is about. It is very good, but it still doesn't do enough for me to push it to a four.
I had always heard of this album, but never got around to listening to it. Pretty much got what I expected based on reviews I had seen. Great riffs and drumming and good singing, but ultimately nothing out of the ordinary for a 2000's alternative album. Just solid front to back.
Not it
I can hear the new decade in this record! Super innovative. Awesome guitar and bass playing, with an insanely tight band. It would lose points for being a bit repetitive but I respect it so much artistically I think I can round up.
love it
I did recognize one track. Other than that this is a new experience. Very energetic. I can see myself listening to this when I want to be a lot of energy in the music I am listening to.
Awesome! I bought this when it first came out, but had forgotten how great it is. Classic!
Outstanding from beginning to end. Really enjoyed every song.
2/5. Really a mellow album compared to the Reptilia Strokes that I grew up with. Not my favorite, but still a few good moments.
fav songs; the modern age, (alone, together) and trying your luck overall a good album but i thought i would like it more than i did in the end. so imma go with a 3/5 and see if other albums by the strokes make me *pause* *Edit* after +200 Albums later i didnt had any The Strokes Album... It grew on me too (4.0/5.0)
always one of the best
Good sounds. My kind of music. Great guitar riffs. However, I would have liked to hear more variety and creativity between the songs. It feels like they found their sound and stuck with it rather than try out new stuff. Overall, a solid album for the genre and there are a few great songs that I'll add to my regular playlist.
Banger
Includes one of my favorite songs of all time but it doesn’t hold up on a full listen
The strokes are such an iconic sound for this era. Outside of my highlights though, didn't love the rest of the album. Highlights: modern age, last nite, someday (LOVE this song), hard to explain
Lots of hits.
Another one I knew some of already. Very "cool" New York sound throughout. Nothing beats Last Nite though
I only knew the song, Reptilia, by The Strokes - so this was a great way to get into a new band. This is a really strong album where pretty much every song is good to great. Most of the songs are played with high energy and passion. There is a degree of "sameness" to many songs, but they are played with gusto that makes me not mind after awhile. My favorite tracks: The Modern Age, Barely Legal, Last Nite, Take It Or Leave It, and Alone Together (my favorite song on the album).
Seems very much of it's time. Very one note.
I wonder how many of the mix CDs I’ve ever made include “Last Nite” (hint: it’s a lot). I liked them 20+ years ago and think the album still holds up today.
Pretty good stuff. Reading about how it was recorded was interesting. I remember them on SNL. Somewhat remind me of The Jam, who didn’t get US recognition like this group did. Good job, lads
Is This It, is, in my opinion, where The Strokes peaked. IMO this album is the epitome of 00s rock and defined their sound for the next decade, until they transformed into their current, more pop-y form. Someday and Last Nite are two of the most important rock tracks of the 00s and I love them. Easy 5/5 for me.
First track is 99% ASMR. Thats about all I got for this album, not much to talk about. Its artistic for sure.
Not really my thing.
Also very nostalgic for me. I am learning that my dad has great taste in music. I really dig this!
Very good
"Is This It" is an apt title for one of the most overrated albums of recent memory.
Indie awakenings. Primavera sound disappointments. In my forever playlist.
Very familiar with this one. Love The Strokes. Easy 5 star.
Goed album om de afwas op te doen
Very solid album
Dare I say a 5? I grew up with Someday from mlb2k8, the other famous song is of course famous, but the rest was pretty new. While it all had a similar tone, it was varied enough to not bore me and make me wanna listen more. This may be in rotation
Classic.
The Brits sure as hell know how to make hits. An album perfect for a summer roadtrip
First time hearing these guys. I like it
Good early 2000's indie rock. Definitely worth another listen.
LAAAAAAAAAST NIIIIIIIIIIIIIGHT, SHEEEEEEEEE SAIDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD OH BABY I FEEEEEEL SO DOWNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN Is This It: 4.5 The Modern Age: 4 Soma: 3.5 Barely Legal: 4 Someday: 5 Alone, Together: 4.5 Last Nite: 5 Hard to Explain: 5 When It Started: 4 Trying Your Luck: 4.5 Take It Or Leave It: 5
Haven't really listened to this since it came out when I was in high school. It's good blues, rock but very derivative of what comes before it.
No. 94/1001 Is This It 3/5 The Modern Age 3/5 Soma 4/5 Barely Legal 3/5 Someday 4/5 Alone, Together 3/5 Last Nite 3/5 Hard To Explain 3/5 New York City Cops 4/5 Trying Your Luck 3/5 Take It Or Leave It 3/5 Average: 3,27 Didn't like the distorted voice. Aside from that a fun rock album.
Highs: Is this it?, Last Nite, Take it or Leave it Lows: basically everything else
Good shit but gotta be in the mood for it
Cooler version of the music I listened to in high school.
This was definitely what rock music was like between 2000 and 1990, from the vocals and the array of music on the album with only one song becoming a staple. It had a few songs I could go without hearing them again, but that doesnt make the conviction the artist had any less real!
This band is weird. I tend to enjoy their songs, but at the same time all of their songs sound like they were ripped off from more popular songs. Setting that aside, I find the singer's voice oddly compelling. They sound pretty good as a band. This album was hailed as a revitalization of rock when it came out, yet it ultimately ended up being more of a last hurrah. Regardless, this album has aged a lot better than much of the rock being made in the early 2000s. The production being excellent probably has something to do with that 4/5
Not too bad
Is This It is the perfect album. The Strokes came along in the early 2000’s and helped pave a new road away from all the weirdness that arose in the late 90’s. They didn’t over complicate it, they made a perfect album with jangly guitars, clean drums and Casablancas with his seemingly effortless delivery singing about sex, youth and drugs with wit. Everything about this band was cool, the album art is iconic, the band logo was awesome, they were here to save rock and they did. This is the most defining album of my high school experience and unlike other favourites from my teenage years, aged beautifully. This remains my favourite album of all time, I will be singing along to this til I die. 10 stars
5 star cover art. 3 star music.
I loved punk rock in the 80’s but this I found the lyrics boring as well as the music itself
Interesting that you've not received my comments or voting...I have done so on my phone? I gave this album 5 stars! or higher if I could. It was awesome. Great lyrics and musicality was spot on...I Loved it, was surprised as i had heard some of the songs from before, but had not remembered the name of the band!!
Never heard of them before…
Better than I expected, some familiar songs
Probably The Strokes best album, and for good reason. It contains most of the hits they are known for, and the rest of it is also really good - though it took me a bit longer to appreciate perhaps. I think they do a great job of sounding modern, but also manage to rub off some older indie band vibes like The Smiths. I can't swear exactly on how much The Strokes have influenced other bands, but if Alex Turner from the immensely successful Arctic Monkeys sings "I just wanted to be one of The Strokes", I have a vague idea.
This was such a fun listen! Released in the beginning of the garage rock revival it really was the start of 00s rock sound. I was a bit too young yet to be swept away by it (i was 10) so it is not with too much nostalgia I listen to this. I still think this album holds up really well. The lo-fi mixing might feel a bit dated but the riffs and catchiness of the songs are still there. "Someday" and especially "Last Nite" are decade defining songs but I really enjoyed the rest of the album as well. It can hold it's own through all its tracks and does not outstay its welcome. A few duds (looking at you "New York City Cops") and that I held some similar records in higher regards prevents from getting this a 5.
favourite song: alone, together so difficult to pick a favourite here. one of the best albums of its era. a masterpiece of an album thats good enough that i can forgive the band for (mostly) being private school rich kids.
Hell yeah. Favorite band in high school and the highwater mark of the post-punk revival in the early aughts. Tons of brilliant stuff, even if their constant need to be hip (and drunk) was off-putting even as a teen. It's hard to remember, but this was one hell of a band up until their third LP when things started to fall apart. Essential.
Minimalistisch
Adequate 2 or 3 good tracks. Rest is blah.
Someday and Last Nite are good, the others are all varying degrees of ok
Before listening i felt as though i wouldnt like it though i did it was very fun to listen to would most likely listen to again i really liked his voice and the guitar in songs is very good too overall 5/5
Not something I would have picked to listen to on my own, but some of the songs were enjoyable.
This is one of the greatest albums ever written. I just wish that New York City cops was on the default version of the album
Strokes interessant, aber viele langweilige lieder
I've learned, this is a kind of garage rock. It sounds a little bit flat to me. This will not be one of my favorite albums.
Is This It 3.5/5 The Modern Age 4.5/5 cool solo Soma 4/5 Barely Legal 4/5 Someday 4.5/10 Alone, Together 4/5 cool solo Last Nite 5/5 Banger Hard To Explain 4/5 When It Started 4/5 Interesting solo Trying Your Luck 4.5/5 Take It Or Leave It 4/5
https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-qyzG0d9vJbE/UBe_j1-CZ4I/AAAAAAAAAwU/FYStjagCi0c/s1600/Bowl+Skate2.gif
I have not heard this album before and I only know of The Strokes by name. I was a bit apprehensive about listening as I thought their genre would be too left field for my taste but I was pleasantly surprised. I found myself liking all of their songs in some way. A few songs I would like to mention are: Barely Legal, Soma, and Alone, Together (which I really like the instrumental from). I would say my least favourite song on the album is the title track, Is This It. The songs are very short in length with primarily vocals and only a few guitar solos (which were good). I will definitely listen to this album again; I just have to find a playlist to put it in.
Is this it? Yes it is. Indie rock perfection. It's like Marquee Moon for the 2000s. Short and to the point, fun, catchy, iconic. *Heard before (a lot)
This be the mood.
Btw, are we all getting a kick outta the listener who keeps plagiarizing - usually just wholesale stealing - reviews from all music.com?
Decent album. It didn't hit for me when it was originally released and a refreshed listen didn't change my opinion.
Alles schnell - durchaus gut, aber sehr einheitlich
Enjoyed their sound but don’t think I could distinguish the Strokes from a dozen other bands
Julian Casablancas is said to have wanted Is This It to sound like a pair of favourite jeans, worn but familiar and comfortable. Whoever engineered this record did such a good job with that brief that Is This It really does feel as if it’s been around forever. Ground Zero for Rock in the new millennium, The Strokes feel like something new, a turning point away from the bloated and incoherent mess Alternative had become since Grunge fizzled out, a move towards an unkempt urban hipster cool image, that’s been so successful as marketing that it’s still what I imagine cool young people listen to in downtown Manhattan apartments over 20 years later. What I feel is often undervalued is how interesting it is as music. It all slots together in a very intricate way, with parts stopping and starting, the guitars playing off each other, the metronomic drums giving a tribal motorik performance that is weirdly danceable. I can slip this album on like a favourite pair of jeans at any time of day, at any point in the year and it fits. As a piece of art it is flawless, as a social document it is fascinating, and as an instruction manual in cool it is still functional. I love this album
Pleased to report that this thing holds up remarkably well. There's an argument to be made that not only was (is) it worth all the hype, but also the greatest garage rock album ever. Sometimes it sounds like a more polished version of The Ramones. Oddly enough, the only track that doesn't grab me is the opening song. The freaking title track, a stiff that leads off an amazing album. For all the press and hype this thing got upon release, you'd think someone would have suggested a better sequencing of the songs. Bonus points for the dude who wrote and recorded "It Never Rains In Southern California" having a son who brought thunder to The Strokes.
Great album, im a semi fan of the strokes, but i would give this album a 3/5
Great early aughts rock before metal/hard rock took hold. Recommended!
Enjoyable first listen. 8/10
A brilliant album, in part genre defining of east coast indie rock of the early 2000s. The Modern Age is a perfect song.
One of my favorite albums ever. Julian Casablancas will forever be one of my favorite musicians. Only second perfect 5.0 album for me 175 albums in. I fell in love with the new abnormal which has lead me on the path to seeking out new music which in turn lead me to this website. Only fair to give this one a 5.0 just for that. Julian’s other band the Voidz is awesome too if anyone has read this far but doubt they’re represented on this list. Rating: 5.0
uhhh w indie album very good julian casablancas sounds like hes singing into a bread box 👍
Good rock n roll
Solid. Never heard this album and I enjoyed it a lot. There is a lot of swagger in the singers voice. It's probably the best part of the album. I'll listen to this again.
This is the perfect album. I love every song. Each moment I could recognise from the tiniest of clips because the sound they’ve created is so distinctive and stylised. Always a joy to listen to and it’s never not in rotation for me.
Solid album with some recognisable tunes.
Oh Maya says I'm lacking in depth I will do my best You say you want to stand by my side Darling your head's not right Ah see, alone we stand together we fall apart Yeah I think I'll be alright I'm working so I won't have to try so hard Tables, they turn sometimes Oh someday No I ain't wasting no more time And now my fears they come to me in threes So I Sometimes Say fate my friend you say the strangest things I find sometimes This album is pretty great. 5/5
Nicht mein Geschmack
Rumpelig, auf Dauer bissi anstrengend
good stuff gotta give it another listen
Meh.
9/10. Consistently high quality throughout, and ends before the sameyness of the songs becomes oppressive.
Man I love The Strokes. 9/10
Every song sounds the sa-(gets pummeled by rocks) Most songs sound the same, but it's a really good sound that I enjoy, so it's fine. This isn't my favorite Strokes album though - I think both "The New Abnormal" and "Room on Fire" have a tighter sound.. But I can't really hate on the quintessential indie rock album of the early 2000s.
A hyped album that was good. Overloved by the British music media but it does everything right. Songs, production, stripped back playing. Strong
I haven´t listening this album in a while. It was joy to my ears
I remember buying this and listening to it a pretty fair amount when it was first released. I enjoyed it back then and I enjoy it now. Back in 2001 I saw them perform in Lawrence, Kansas, shortly after this was released. It was a disappointing show. The singer was pretty drunk or something, and was sloppy enough to where other people in the band were visibly frustrated with them.
I should have some cynical take on this album, and I can say that of the new Rock revival bands The Strokes are not my favorite (that would be TV On the Radio) but this is an undeniable classic full of great throwback tunes. I will say I’m very happy the version I heard doesn’t have this cover.
I remember the hype when this came out and I remember liking this, but not being blown away. I hadn’t listened in maybe 20 years. It’s good, but all sounds the same to me and Julian refuses to do anything interesting vocally.
Liked it alot in high school but didn't really grab me past the initial nostalgia on this relisten. I'll average out the 5 stars high school Eric would give this with the 3 stars 40 year old Eric gives this...4 stars
Catchy songs, nice voice. I liked it 4/5 Favorites: Someday, Last Nite
It was pretty good throughout,don’t understand the complete critical love bust last nite is a banger.
Whiney. Sounds like it was recorded in a bathroom.
מעפן
Очень сильно напоминает инди-рок 10-ых, но удивлён тому, когда он был выпущен. К сожалению, кроме одной композиции, альбом совсем не зацепил.
I was very late to the party when it came to The Strokes. I dismissed them as overhyped rich kids making standard rock music. Probably not bad but I didn't have the time to bother. When I finally got around to listening to this, I could see what I had been missing. The album is so much better than I'd expected. It's not often that a band manages to balance on the fine line between mainstream radio-friendly rock and unpolished underground indie. But the Strokes managed and the album still holds up well. Easy 5 stars.
Not bad but not particularly remarkable overall. Last Nite bumps it up to a 4 for me though.
Dopamine hit with every start of every song, absolutely love this album
Really good album , I had already listened to this before but was definitely happy to have a proper relisten
Quite liked it, felt like I’d heard similar stuff before though. I knew …Sometime and Last Nite which I liked. Good music, would happily put on at a party.
Liked it, didn’t love it
It's good
Good but kinda forgettable
forgot how many incredible tracks were on this record, the sounds is unmistakeable however it is a bit samey
It's fine.
Not even their best album and it’s still filled with bangers
TheStrokes's debut album presented a unique sound with the jangly guitar riffs and iconic vocals of Julian Casablancas. Each song has energy and it is a fun listen to get through.
Fantastic album, love The Strokes anyway and can listen to this album time and time again ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I think it's pedestrian yet somehow undeniable at the same time!
What a fucking awesome album! I forgot how much I like the strokes
I enjoyed this album and will be listening to it again! I have a few friends who love The Strokes but I'm not sure why I never got into them! I think I probably would have loved them more back in the early naughties, but still good now :) Strokiest Track: Alone together
3.5
I went into this one totally cold having only ever heard of the band name but not knowing the music. At just over 35 minutes this album was consistently strong throughout and didn't have an ounce of padding on it. For a debut album this was surprisingly good and I enjoyed it from front to back.
yup
90s Rock was officially over in 2001, we'd survived the few years dalliance with Nu-Metal and bands like The Strokes, The White Stripes, The Vines, and Kings of Leon were here to bring the garage band style cool back. Low production values are the order of the day here, make it sound like it's recorded in one take on a busted 4 track in some guys 3rd floor walk-up in the Lower East Side (in reality it was in a basement in the East Village, but who counting here?). Julian Casablancas is dripping in understated coolness, Albert Hammond and Nick Valensi have serious guitar duels throughout, Fabrizio Moretti brings a tribal drum feel but my MVP is Nikolai Fraiture and his driving bass, it kicks in during the title track and then I knew what I wanted to do, I wanted to play bass like that.... But I never could. Anyway, this is a classic, stone cold classic garage rock revival, biblical!
It's good, but I feel like a lot if the hype around it is of the "you had to be there" variety, because I personally don't get it.
Gefällt sehr gut von Anfang an direkt. Paar bekannte Songs helfen zwischendurch. Aber auch sonst kurzweilig
Another one I'm very familiar with. And a frankly brilliant album, for what it is. It's cohesive and driven. Some of the songs are quite fun. It was part of revival in music, so has a huge part in rock history. Do I enjoy it? Yeah. Is it a masterpiece that moves me? Not really. A great candidate for 4/5 stars.
Immediately transported me to Lansdowne St, when it was still a bit gritty.
Lyrics Pros: The lyrics are often praised for their simplicity and relatability, capturing the essence of youthful angst and urban life [1]. Clever wordplay and catchy phrases contribute to the album's memorability. Cons: Some critics argue that the lyrics lack profound depth, bordering on superficiality. Music Pros: The Strokes' musical prowess is evident in the album's tight instrumentation and Julian Casablancas' distinctive vocals. Catchy guitar riffs, dynamic drumming, and basslines create an infectious groove. Cons: Some tracks may sound sonically similar, leading to a lack of diversity in the overall musical landscape. Production Pros: Gordon Raphael's production style embraces a lo-fi aesthetic, enhancing the garage rock authenticity. The stripped-down production emphasizes the band's raw talent. Cons: The lo-fi approach might not appeal to those seeking a more polished sound. Themes Pros: "Is This It" explores themes of disillusionment, romance, and urban life, resonating with a generation navigating the challenges of early adulthood. Cons: Some argue that the thematic content lacks innovation compared to other albums of the time. Influence Pros: The album significantly influenced the garage rock revival of the early 2000s, inspiring a new wave of bands. It played a role in shaping the sound of indie rock for years to come. Cons: The immense influence may overshadow the album's individuality for some listeners. In conclusion, "Is This It" remains a landmark album that captures the zeitgeist of its era. Its strengths lie in its simplicity, energetic music, and lasting impact on the music landscape. While some criticize its lyrical depth and sonic diversity, these factors are minor compared to the album's overall significance in the evolution of rock music.
Hard to believe this is a pre-9/11 album. So fresh and undeniably fun - in retrospect has had an immeasurable influence on the scene. No faults
Good choice of instruments but nothing overly exciting.
THE premier rich kid rock album, lol.
Most of it was the same
I’ve had Last Nite stuck in my head since I saw this was the album
This slick, flawlessly mixed and produced debut from The Strokes almost makes it worth it to have to deal with The Ramones as a pop culture phenomenon.
Undoubtedly highly influential to bands that in the end turned out more exciting that The Strokes themselves. Is This It isn’t quite the bomb I remembered it as - even though it is really effective. The songwriting is tight, the instruments even tighter… I guess, when all is said and done, I just don’t really have a special thing for Casablancas.
Absolute banger. Strong album all the way through.
I remember when this album came out. It sounded pretty different to anything else that was out of the time. Re-listening to it brought back some memories. Enjoyable ones!
Hace años que escucho este album: nepotism done right. Quien pudiera ser tan cool como los Strokes y su primer album
Meh.
Nice
banger!
Very catchy! Steady rhythms, very enjoyable guitar and bass sound. My favourites are Hard to Explain and Last Nite.
If you've just listened to this album for the 1st or 2nd time, it really creeps up on you. First you think, oh this is a fun rock album, nothing too special. A couple listens later the songwriting and the performances just grip you tight and never let go. One of the best rock albums ever made for me.
Just a perfect garage rock band/album. Had this in regular rotation in the early 2000's, so this took me back.
Incredibly fun, and I really liked the drums.
A nostalgia bomb. Very solid indie/alt rock vibes all around.
A total classic, even though I didn't heard them so much
I prefer Room on Fire