Reviews (page 8 of 16)
God damnit. This is really good isn't it. For someone so eloquent and thought out in what he is saying here it is appalling to see that is such a massive tool. I imagine those who have been fans of him since this time must feel devastated. It's inventive, it's interesting, it's funny. I read the wiki and it said no one would sign him cos he wasn't doing Gangstar rap. Good. I can't be arsed with Gangstar rap. Anyway, that also made him innovative. I'm not really keen on the "chipmunk" samples, but I've heard worse examples than on this record. What a shame.
I'm not about to give a Nazi more than 1 star. Eat shit, Ye.
Nem deveria dizer isso, mas eu acho hilário os ativistas de sofá postando aqui que se negam a ouvir esse álbum. Como se o Ye fosse o único artista que tenha feito merda e está nessa lista. Pessoal estúpido. Enfim, tanto faz, cada um com sua vida. Não existe isso de separar a arte do artista. O artista é sua arte, e a arte é o seu artista. Só nao glorifique artistas, eles também são pessoas como você. Isso é óbvio mas a Internet atualmente mais se assemelha a uma creche, onde precisamos falar o óbvio de forma macia, tipo "não corte seu cabelo com as tesouras" e "não morda seu amiguinho". Enfim. Sobre o disco: Uma estréia magistral. Fica claro ouvindo esse álbum que Ye, acima de tudo, queria se provar. Ele claramente era seu maior fã e tinha uma crença absurda em seu potencial e talento. Desta forma, o trabalho final acaba estufado com um pouco de tudo, batidas infectantes, samples finíssimos, versos quentes, flows melódicos, skits cômicos, e até mesmo partes cantadas. Por um lado, no contexto do artista desesperado procurando seu Break e querendo colher imediatamente os frutos que ele andou plantando por tanto tempo e com tanto esforço (Lock yourself in a room doing 5 beats a day for 3 summers), esse bloat imenso faz sentido e é até mesmo charmoso as vezes. Mas não há como negar, os três primeiros discos do Ye são os únicos de sua discografia que eu consideraria "datados". Pra começar: Tanto esse quanto LR possuem uma duração laborosa. Muitas canções poderiam ter sido encurtadas, com participações inconsequentes que poderiam ter sido cortadas. Além disso, as faixas muitas vezes são complementadas por skits que francamente, não são engraçados, e atrapalham muito a fluidez do álbum. Dito isso, ouça All Falls Down e lembre-se imediatamente porque Ye se tornou o artista magnânimo que ele é. O talento do homem é inegável e inconfundível. As batidas aqui são todas PERFEITAS (não uso essa palavra levemente). É perceptível que ele havia guardado esses beats por muito tempo especialmente pra sua triunfante estréia. O mesmo pode ser dito dos seus versos, que possuem flows diversos, trocadilhos brilhantes e um charme interminável. Dito isso, esse disco não está nem perto de ser meu favorito do Ye por conta dos fatores mencionados, mas ao ouvi-lo é impossível ficar parado. Abaixa o punho e ouve o som. 4.5/5 The kid that made that, deserves that Maybach.
Listened to this album a lot when I was younger, and a majority of the tracks still hold up. "We Don't Care" is a strong opener, the singles are all bangers, fantastic hip hop record from the 00's. 4/5
Nice hip hop but not my kind of music.
What a debut. Here kanyes gripes are still relatable. He is still full of himself but damn this still sounds good.
Continuo não gostando, mas acho que finalmente entendi como um todo o apelo da coisa. Porém, envelheceu como um leite a carreira e pessoa.
I had never heard this album in full before so I wanted to listen from a “this album was important, but clearly the legacy has been tarnished” lens. I didn’t love it, but it did make me sad to think of this man who used to make music with purpose and how it quickly became another money making scheme for Kanye on top of him using his platform to either be an actual Nazi or to make the worst social experiment of all time. Time will tell? 3.25 star album. One star man.
There’s a lot of ideas here, and what works really works. The singles are incredible. The main drawback is that it is overindulgent in ways that I frankly find annoying (it ends with a nearly 13 minute account of how he got a record deal).
Didn’t like it.
Repeat listen
Jesus fucking Christ, it’s another Kanye West album. You know, when you become a hotpot of controversy, it becomes a Herculean effort to separate art from the artist. It’s even harder when you don’t really give a shit about hip-hop or rap to begin with. So, to be honest, I just want to move on and get this over with. This album was only fine, but much like My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, I went in and out not understanding what in the fuck people see in Kanye to make them say “he’s a terrible human being that makes great music”. Because to me, he’s a terrible human being that makes okay music. The only reason I won’t completely rip this album is, and this might be weird, is because… some of the music behind the rapping is really good. Like if someone took out all of Kanye and like, keep some of the instrumental parts with the higher pitch stuff, this would be actually great. Especially on Through the Wire. As is, outside of a few fleeting moments, I largely didn’t care. It’s got all the rap album trappings: being over an hour, songs that come off as annoying and “comedic” skits. Ok, actually, Graduation Day is pretty funny. That “What in the fuck was that” lives rent free in my head. But the diploma skits overstayed their welcome. We get it, Kanye, diplomas are worthless, I didn’t need like three skits pounding that info into my skull. And dear god, the fuck even is Last Call? You seriously end your album with a 12-minute song that’s mostly just you talking? I didn’t this I would yes an album to death, but… here I am. Look, I just want to move on from this. I have like 800+ albums to go and the less I have to deal with Kanye West the better. Outside of all his bullshit, this was just ok, but I’m confidant in saying that I’ll never get Kanye West. Both in terms of his music and person. And frankly, I just don’t care. Favorite track: Slow Jamz Other hits: Through the Wire, The New Workout Plan, All Falls Down, Family Business
kanye was a real talent wasn't he
Truly a shame this guy went Hitler mode cause this is music
The combination of nostalgia mixed with his undeniable artistic genius made this a 5/5 for me.
Old Kanye
Despite my previously mentioned dislike for Kanye West, and while not as good as MBDTF, this was another strong effort. I'll separate the art from the artist again and give him credit for his talent. The album was full of overall good production and composition, solid rap efforts, and interesting topics that didn't feel like pandering for the most part. The quantity of artists and musical additions to the album almost make West blend in and disappear into the mix at times, which maybe helps him stay toned down. It makes sense that he worked as a producer for years with these tracks, as they sound well constructed and thought out. Much like his other albums, more is really more for him, and it works. He also uses his singing voice infrequently on this one, which I appreciate since I find it generally weak. Aside from the music, the album imagery is fitting; the way I understand it, West dropped out of college to pursue the music career, but wasn't widely accepted in the rap world given his background. He didn't fit the more urban-focused packaging that dominated the hip hop scene at the time. So there he sits, the would-be "dancing bear". A mascot meant to enthusiastically depict school spirit. But instead of dancing, he is sadly alone, having isolated himself from the suburbanites by leaving college while still being rejected by the group he wanted to be a part of. The ornate surrounding literally frames this isolation as the art itself making up/driving the album. It's one of the better uses of album art I've seen come up through here. While there is a lot to like here, it just didn't stand out to me as "great" even it it was very good. Comparing it to MBDTF, I thought this was the weaker of the two. Overall: 3.75/5
Fantastic samples, great flows. Classic Kanye.
For a hip-hop/rap album, it's actually pretty good. However, it's least enjoyable listening to it knowing Kanye goes on to be a Nazi.
Beats
One of my fave albums ever, hate how Kanye is now.
It’s a masterpiece start to finish. Really hard not to give this one a 5, it’s Kanye at his very best. Iconic samples, beats and vocals.
Didn't finish it. Don't want to give much time to this man.
I hate to say that I enjoyed this a bit (but at least it's from before he went off the rails). A few great samples and generally enjoyable listening 3
9/10 we need to put Kanye in perma debt to ensure he stops making shit music and doing shit for attention
Know this album well. It's excellent start to finish. Hard to listen to him now knowing his feelings on Nazis. He committed career suicide and it has tarnished his legacy
⭐️⭐️ 1001 ALBUMS- # 52 This album is a dropout alright, it sucks! Well, not really, but Kanye is detestable 🙄. I will never understand the overuse of the ‘ni#%a’ lingo in hip hop, which I could kinda sorta look past to the backdrop of impressive beats, however with Kanye his ego is too larger than life echoing across this bloated tracklist. His debut album, while breaking ground still contained typical rap tropes that just turn me off from the genre. The skits between tracks, racist sexist lyrics and self righteous take on the topical themes of religion, socioeconomic issues, personal insecurity and anxiety feel less like satire and more about attention starved preaching. 🎧 Classic Track: All Falls Down 🎧 Deep Cut Gem: We Don’t Care 🚫 Skip Track: All the skit interludes The College Dropout may have help change the face of hip-hop with its soul-sampling production and themes of insecurity, education, and religion, however Kanye’s polarizing approach to his self image, politics and personal life overshadow his art. 🖼️ Album Artwork: At least he’s masking himself 🐻 I understand my take may not be a popular one, however I firmly stand behind my assertions here; good music soured by poor character.
One of the greatest rap/hip hop albums of all time.
Goes downhill after Jesus Walks
God this was such a way for white middle schoolers and black middle schoolers to bond. The mark of a new era in hip hop. That's not meant to diminish this album. Once I first heard when my dad played it for me.
Fuck this asshole, not listening. 0 Stars
1. intro - 1 2. care - 1.5 3. day - 0 4. douun - 1.5 5. fly - 0 6. zpace - 1.5 7. jezuz - 2 8. never - 1 9. high - 1.5 10. plan - 0 11. neuu - 1 12. jamz - 1.5 13. breathe - 1 14. zchool - 0 15. zpirit - 1.5 16. zchool - 0 17. zkit - 0 18. tuuo - 1.5 19. uuire - 2 20. family - 1.5 21. call - 1.5
I think I'd give this 3.5 stars. It's a lot better than yeezus and I liked the general flow of the album.
gas
Pretty good. Social commentary on the lack of value of a college education flipped into rapping about drugs, clubs, guns, and money. Hilariously in poor taste for old Kanye. Sure you can make money, but did you know that bipolar disorder can be onset? Youda learn that in school boy. Anyway, I used to praise old kanye. But Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy was far better than this. But the second side including last call are bulletproof. Good albo.
Great album. Got into it a few years back after watching Jeen-Yuhs.
Lol the day after Kid A, this shit? Kanye was always an odd fit. Great producer - so, either purchaser or creator of samples, beats, entire songs - with a few tricks that caught a moment with Jay Z. And also a producer who wanted to be an MC. The DJ who wanted to rap. The drummer or lead guitarist who wanted to be the frontman. And he simply fucking could not rap. Not awkward as say, me, a white guy with some rhythm, but just...as rappers and their critics became consumed with the art of the flow, here stumbles in a guy who literally had his jaw rebuilt. Which he made integral to his whole appeal as this album came together! But he had jokes and a fake it til you make it bravado that was annoying, but not disqualifying. Dropout was fun in parts, a bit overbearing and clumsy elsewhere (this would only increase), but mostly seemed perfunctory. I did it Jay! I made my record! What now? Where will my story go next? To what amazing heights will I soar? And oh how I will crash.
Will not listen to the music of a Nazi.
Kanye in 2025. Ooof! This one is spawning much internal dialogue about “art vs. artist.” There's an argument to be made for separating the two, but when the art is (partially) about race and racism, I don't think I can/should discount the outspoken racism of present-day Kanye. The production is fantastic, and though I think Kanye isn't the most proficient rapper, he can write a good line, and call in great featured artists. 20 years ago, this would be a 5. In 2025, a 4 feels like I'm giving him more grace than he deserves. I hope K gets the help with his mental health that he desperately needs, and does something to make up for the harm he's been doing to himself and his audience of late. "Through the Wire" is perfect, and I hope Chaka made a few million off it.
Det føles ganske teit at mine første moralske kvaler i forbindelse med det her prosjektet dukke opp med Kanye West, bare tenk på kor mange moralske kvaler man burde ha med majoriteten av (mannlige) artister opp gjennom alle tiår med albumlytting. Men det e jo vanskelig når noen man vet va toneangivanes for enogtyve år siden etterhvert har blitt et moralsk forkvakla menneske man nu ikke egentlig har lyst til å støtte, sjøl bare med de få milliøran han eventuelt måtte tjene på min ene gjennomlytting av albumet. Men æ hørte på det, og sjøl om æ ikke har hørt mye nok på rap til å kunne plukke ut de fremragende kvalitetene det her e i besittelse av, så skjønne æ at det e bra. Æ bare kommer aldri til å høre på det igjen fordi æ ikke vil støtte et menneske som e moralsk forkvakla og i aktiv drift.
This is even better than I remember. I really liked the song “Spaceship”. Oh man, Jay-Z is on this in “Never Let Me Down”.
This one isn't too bad, but it's a little one-note with the overuse of those sped up soul samples, often referred to as Chipmunk Soul. West is famously a sloppy MC but that doesn't really distract from the songs, which despite being somewhat serious in nature, at the end of the day are meant as Pop music. Obviously, West went on to produce much better albums, and also much, much worse ones. Key tracks: Jesus Walks The New Workout Plan Through the Wire (Looking at the reviews, seems like I'm the only one separating the art from the artist, which is sad.)
האלבום הכי טוב בהיסטוריה
Grande canie guest
Classic Kanye. You can hate him but don't tell me these songs aren't bangers!
Almost a perfect album
3 - surprisingly listenable
good album
Sounds like ass
The first album i will skip and not listen to. Fuck nazis.
Changed hip-hop forever. Changed music forever. Changed culture forever. Not a single skip, even the skits are apropriately placed and not drawn out. Perfect record. First 10 on this list
Fyre
The second star is for 'I'll Fly Away' and the cool production.
I miss the old Kanye. 😢 After watching the Kanye documentary a few years ago, I developed a newfound appreciation for this debut. The amount of stick he got from the hiphop community before his breakthrough was ridiculous. No one took him seriously for not being tough like rappers were expected to be at the time. Despite not even being one of his best 3 albums for me, this album is still full of classics. The middle of the album is a little bit bloated, and some of the absolute standouts for me come towards the end of the album, with Through The Wire, Two Words, Family Business, and Last Call giving this album a legendary close. Jesus Walks is the ultimate standout though - it’s a fascinating description of being intent on being a righteous person but working in an industry where that is not rewarded in any way. The production is groundbreaking and immaculate throughout, with this album introducing the chipmunk-style production to the world (sped-up soul samples). I’m not sure what’s crazier: the fact that Kanye followed this up by 3 even better albums back-to-back (Late Registration, Graduation, 808s and Heartbreak), or the fact that these days he has completely descended into madness and is now a despicable human being. No longer a fan, but I still appreciate this great stuff from over 20 years ago(?!)
I’m very conflicted. Kanye is a horrendous person. But this album is undeniably great. Wordplay, production, beats, everything is top notch. Marking it down a star for obvious reasons and because it goes on slightly too long.
5 stars for the music 1 star for the man
3,5
he did as much as anyone could do it’s not his fault this entire musical genre is the most vile trash
Looking back at this historically, there's no doubt that it had a big impact on hip hop, lyrically as well from the production side which was always something West got lots of praise for (albeit being aided by tons of talented people - also other producers). Impact shouldn't also have only a positive connotation - there is something like a negative impact we often forget when we talk about music. West's debut album has both: Great, deeper lyrics and wonderful sample productions but also annoying high-pitched soul samples and hooks sang by guys who can't sing as well as odd mixing here and there. The album has too many unnecessary skits but also some tracks that are not very interesting ("Through The Wire"). "Breathe In, Breathe Out", "Get Em High" or "Jesus Walks" are bangers though. All in all, I'd rather give this 3.5 but I tend to 3 now that I'm in doubt. There's just too much forgettable stuff and, as I wrote, trends that shouldn't have happend.
Dammit. This album is a reminder of the better world we used to live in, and subsequently a reminder of how things are awful now. Why'd you have to go off the deep end, Kanye? This album is a damn near perfect hip hop masterpiece. Even with how things turned out 20 years later, it still is a standout work of art. Dammit.
I wont be playing this. No interest in it, or him.
I listened, I didn't understand and I very much didn't like. Awful.
"I call her caddy the way she drag my golf balls in the club" has to be one of his greatest bars. Arguably his greatest album with his greatest production imo 10/10 timeless classic
Honestly I hate that it's good. I get why people cite this album in specific in conversations about Kanye. The music and style are great, but there's a purposeful ego and anti-intellectualism that put me off of some of this. But at the end of the day, fuck this Nazi asshole
Does not live up to the hype but a good hip hop album
Meh, 2 stars.
Unfortunately this is a five star album I will never listen to again
Listened to this a lot back when it came out. It just doesn't have the same kick/appeal anymore now that we know that Kanye is fully off the rails.
Don't like kanye
Listen in order
Great album that gave me a llot of nostalgia but unfortunately gone completely off him with recent behaviour.
I’m not into rap/hip hop, I’m also most certainly not a fan of Kanye West - I do not support his Nazi rhetoric/comments. However ignoring West as a person, and giving this album a fair shot — I was pleasantly surprised, the songs were all pretty decent and the humor sprinkled in was great. I didn’t love it as I usually don’t love rap/hip hop but it was certainly better than expected, and I would say it was good and I enjoyed it.
Fire
really good and a classic. Kanye really cooked on this one
i didn't want this racist schizo motherfucker making any money from my streaming of his albums (i have him blocked on spotify for this very reason) but i also wanted to try rating this and giving it a fair shot. with a little workaround (thanks free mp3 sites ❤️) i managed to give it a spin man what a fucking waste of time. i've heard hip-hop fans praise this album up and down as his best work for years... is the best work in the room with us?? i don't get the hype at all pros: production was okay, that tends to be his strength. i consider the sampling kinda lazy by today's standards, but i suppose this was acceptable for the early 2000s. cons: everything else. he's rapped better in other albums in his discography. too many skit tracks. too long of a run-time. this was one of the few instances where i couldn't stand to sit through multiple tracks without skipping i think my final score is very generous. his performance here, while not impressive in my opinion, was just good enough to not be considered the worst thing i've listened to
This album is one ive already heard its really good. It also has some of my favorite Kanye songs, like All falls down, jesus wallks, get em high, slow jamz, and through the wire.
An impressive debut, and one of the best and most artistically satisfying hip-hop albums of all time - bringing great production, clever if sometimes juvenile lyrics, tasty samples and solid R&B hooks. Hip-hop isn't my thing, but this record is a shoe-in for top ten in the genre. It's too bad that Kanye is such an asshole.
kanye, 1, brandi, 5, her voice is an instrument, not only an album you should listen to before you die, but also one of the best albums maybe ever, pretty life changing, college dropout is okay
BOOOOOO 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎🗑️🗑️🗑️🗑️🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅
Kanye as a human: 0/5 This album: 3/5
Hate Kanye, but I love the album
Great music, tragic he passed in 2020
i really do miss the old kanye
Tål inte karln. Man skulle egentligen göra murbruk av honom. Blött murbruk. Han kommer dock undan med denna platta. Det är inte asdåligt. Bara lite dåligt.
Absolutely not listening to this guy.
I can’t bring myself to give him more than 1 star.
production is incredible. a remarkable album. shame about a piece of shit kanye is, and looking at the evidence the guy left about some of his toxic attitudes (see: the next workout plan). one for a category I expect to see a lot of out of this list, "incredible album by someone who is a real piece of shit"
no
Kanye had (has?) so much talent. This album just makes me sad for all the things we've lost. Also forgot that I know 90% of the words, and that it ushered in a whole new sound for music.
Fuck nazis
So many just flat out badass songs. Amazing production. Couple that fall flat for me so can't give it a perfect but I still love this album.
Whew, lot of feelings about this. It’s impossible to separate what Kanye has become from the Kanye that was, the record is hugely influential and pleasant to listen to the for the most part, some of the lyrics are deeply troubling and one cannot stop thinking about what is to come.
i’m so cheesed that kanye crashed out bc this album has some bangers and i do see his overarching theme here, BUT minus stars for being a raging nazi and minus stars for being terrible towards women, though i do have to give him 1 extra star because of the aforementioned bangers and the fact that this album went triple platinum in my car when i first got my license, sorry :/
The first half was great but then it got really really misogynistic
I am separating art from artist in my rating cause he’s a nazi and if I didn’t it would be a 1. I can appreciate how it was groundbreaking but it still isn’t as much my thing
so torn because I used to really like this but upon relistening it is... rather misogynistic. I used to see this album as 'before he went crazy' but I fear it was there all along
He’s a chatty man, sunnier demeanour than of late. Almost justifies its length with a sweet shop of sound, but misses the delirium of his later stuff.
Went into this with an open mind but, christ, this is terrible. Bland smug irritating juvenalia. Consumerist trash composed by a tedious dickhead, the aural equivalent of his ex-wife [EDIT: MBDTF and Yeezus, man - stick with 'im!]
The top two reviews actually made me cringe… Ik we’re at a point where this man is either just a straight up cock or needs serious help but he made great music and I hope people don’t forget that. As of typing this he’s the 28th most streamed artist in the world on Spotify and while I don’t think popularity is a factor in quality at shows he’s got something very right. Boycott vultures, bully, ww3 (whenever that comes out) honestly I think there little point beyond kids see ghosts. But this MBDTF and graduation (which should be on this list) are amazing. On this I love all falls down and Jesus walks a ton and always have. Spaceship is great too! Slow Jamz is super catchy. It just lacks bad songs… too many interludes I admit though it’s too long so 4/5
I see why people like him (or liked him) the beats were cool, his style was unique with lots of story telling. The lyrical content is a bit questionable at times still, but that tends to be the case with rap music. Will probably never listen to again, but I see how Kanye inspired so many other artists at the time and got as popular as he did.
don't wanna give a nazi sexist pig my time.
Some of Kanye's best songs ever. A few too many skits and I can't stand Breathe In Breathe Out. 9/10
I miss the old Kanye
As good as with i first heard it. this album is such a treat the whole way through
and of all the time i could get this album it had to be just as i'm into kanye (also for the record as he dropped cousins, man if i could review that). had this review come a year earlier it would be many stars lower but here we are. and it's his first album too. TRACK BY TRACK 1 WE DON'T CARE. it's incredible how catchy this song is, just so uplifting despite the lyrics, which is entirely the point. such a great opener and no i'm not reviewing the skits. rare kanye lyrical W. 10/10 2 ALL FALLS DOWN. it might be slightly starting to click, it's a great song. who cares if its overrated, also this hits different after having heard the lauryn hill performance it samples. 9/10 3 SPACESHIP. gorgeous song. literally as i am writing this a funeral is being planned so this is hard to both write and listen to, such an emotional beat and lyrics. sorry if these are cut short, i love this album and this really should be the perfect time to write it since i've been listening to it so much lately. 10/10 4 JESUS WALKS. a very cool song about... jesus? still it's a very cool song and a very cool beat, that's pretty much all to it to me. 8/10 5 NEVER LET ME DOWN. this is probably one of the most 2000s sounding songs i can think of. the rapping is great but it's an alright song. 7/10 6 GET EM HIGH. it is a very cool beat but kanye does absolutely nothing with it. actually the only memorable part of this song is the beat and kanye saying "gotta catch the beat, yeah, catch the beat". 7/10 7 THE NEW WORKOUT PLAN. the hardest a song has ever harded. the video is great too and it honestly upsets me that this kanye is gone. this song is so self aware and touches on subjects of the objectification of women and self images that the modern kanye is the complete and utter opposite of. still it's a crazily catchy and hard song. 9/10 8 SLOW JAMZ. such a chill and pretty song, a great sample and absolutely insane rapping from twista who kind of makes the song. 9/10 9 BREATHE IN BREATHE OUT. breathe in breathe out. uhh breathe in and breathe out. pull your sleeves out and breathe in and maybe breathe out. pull your breathe out and your sleeves breathe out. that's all i can ever remember. this song is pretty annoying. 6/10 10 SCHOOL SPIRIT. alpha step. omega step. kappa step. sigma step. yo!!! anyway cool song. 7/10 11 TWO WORDS. man this still floors me. what an incredible and hard ass song. crazy hard beat and amazing performance especially from mos def. not much else to say just incredible. 10/10 12 THROUGH THE WIRE. fuck. this is by far the most emotional kanye song, the guy is so genuine, likeable and its already just a great song. amazing sample, so catchy and so many quotable lines. also he doesn't even sound like himself (obviously because his jaw was wired shut, was that because of the cousins incident?). just incredible. this is my favourite version of kanye. 10/10 13 FAMILY BUSINESS. we lost this guy. this last four track run is stunning. bring this kanye back, kill the clone. 10/10 14 LAST CALL. la la la la. la la la la la la la. what a closer. this is just stunning man. the playful brother of mortal man. and no it's not just a cool beat with a long ass interview over it afterwards. it's one of his best songs with a genuinely interesting anecdote afterward that stops me everytime i reach for the skip button. 10/10 such an endlessly fun and giving album, it just makes you sad that this is the same guy that just dropped WW3 and has CUCK on the way (to me in the future, did that shit ever come out? did he change the name again?). one of his best and most consistent, which is so impressive for an album of its length. 9/10
Super Dope
"Never Let Me Down" is a real standout. I'd never listened to anything but the singles before.
Interesting one. Not nearly as good as MBDTF from earlier, and truly thought the first 1/3 to 1/2 was just there/bad, but back half beats were pretty stellar. I'd listen to the back half again, it vibed, but still tough to work around
Really not my thing!!!
Kenye si meriterebbe 5 stelle a prescindere. L'album ha alcune mine, ma nel complesso è quel rap che non mi piace. Si salva sulle 3 stelle nonostante tutto ma non penso che lo recupererò mai.
Never listened to any Kanye before so the only track I had heard before was All Falls Down. I liked the clear delivery (I realise I sound ancient but it isn't my genre!), orchestration and guest artists. Mostly thoughtful lyrics and concept.
After having some initial reservations about listening to this due to the KW's objectionable political statements of late, i decided that he seems to have lost the plot after 2017/18. And seeings as this album was way before then it would be wortb listening to. I found it mostly enjoyable and really liked Spaceship in particular.
3 - decent
Fajniutkie. Buja. Nostalgicznie
Two Kanye albums in one week that’s tough! We have had this CD in our collection since it came out and I think this only the second time it’s been played, what does that tell you? I think my partner bought it because she liked the one song which pretty much is still the case.
Awful
Not much to say about this. Radio friendly generic chart rap. A lot of work went into it and he obviously has skills but it was too preppy and toothless for me at the time and it is much the same now only with a side of mental health emergency, neo-nazism and woman hatred. Later, when Kanye was getting into weird and experimental stuff he had a few top notch production ideas but this record has zero edge. Long, lame and boring. Life is too short for stuff that goes in one ear and out of the other.
Never heard a Kanye album in full so when people say they miss the old Kanye, I get it now. Like REALLY get it now. Great beats, great samples, great album. Enjoyed it all the way through and I thought the skits were hilarious.
Unfortunately still incredible. Even most of the skits work. The first half of the album is perfect and the second half is more a product of its time than it is flawed.
Oh Kanye, Kanye, Kanye, what can I do with you... liked some of the production, but way too long
Once upon a time, Kanye was the fresh, new face in hip-hop. I actually enjoyed "All Falls Down" and "Slow Jams". I would've rated this album a 3. Now, Kanye is a Nazi. Fuck Kanye West.
Kanye to bardzo chory człowiek z obrzydliwymi poglądami. Ale obiecałam sobie za każdym razem oddzielać płytę od twórcy. A ta płyta jest dobra! Zabawna, z pomysłem, dobrymi featami i no taką zabawą z samplami i bitem, że ociera się to o geniusz. 7.5/10
-listening to this the day Ye hops on Twitter to reveal he used to suck his cousin’s dick… this man is uhh the gift that keeps on giving -I had heard this album once before in high school but I appreciate it much more now. truly genius and definitely helped to shape the sound of modern hip hop. maybe a bit long but in this case it’s allowed to be -RIP to the version of Kanye West that made this -Favorites are All Falls Down, Jesus Walks, The New Workout Plan, and Slow Jamz
A classic
Great album ofc but hard not to think about how terrible KW is while listening
Kanye has a reputation for being unapologetically himself and it definitely shines through in this album. The album highlights Kanye’s progression to fame and denounces traditional ways to making money like going to school (almost too much). This album was funny and hard and told a good story.
Young Ye - het sehr Spass gmacht es ganzes Album vom Kanye durezlose - au en Künstler woni immer nur vom Noah, Basil, Soma etc. ghör, aber selber immer biz berüehrigsängst gha han. Defür das Album vo vorne bis hinde und obe bis unde berüehrt, gstreichlet und kräbbelet. Viellichts wird sogar bald eis vo sine neue Albe duregstreichlet. Vier Streicheleinheite am rechte Ohrläpli
ai caramber, serste kanye album isch dropped - und zwar hemmer da en klassische fall vom "pink polo kanye" churzi gschichts stund ich würd sege mer chan am ye sini albe ih 4 kategorie ihteile sini early classic era wommer da mal "pink polo" kanye era nenned (bis zu 808 & heartbreak) pre kim era wo bis zu "watch the throne" gange isch the golden era (wells mini fav isch) – da ischer scho chli is crazy abgrutscht aber nanig ganz -> "yeezus" bis "kids see ghosts" und denn alles danach isch "spiral into batshit crazy" isch minnere meinig nah progressiv beschissener worde, paar gueti sache aber mostly meh stuff aber ezt zu dem schmucke ding: ich lose nöd so viel pink polo ye wellsmer zu classic und au ab und zue chli langwilig isch es hett natürlich scho paar bangers druf aber allgemein ischmers denn doch zu zahm und zwenig experimentell, was minnere meinig ja am ye sis gröschte talent isch (abgseh devo sich unbeliebt zmach weller eifach en batshit crazy nazi isch) bin froh gsi hanismer doch mal ih ganzer längi gönnt und ich hans gfühl es paar vo sine spätere crazyness züg schinet doch chli dure und au textlich hetts es paar element wonner gern mal wider ufgrift dur sini albene dure alles ih allem chani da aber keis 4ri inedrücke leider, aber für 3.5 pink polos sötts den scho lange I miss the old Kanye, straight from the Go Kanye Chop up the soul Kanye, set on his goals Kanye I hate the new Kanye, the bad mood Kanye The always rude Kanye, spaz in the news Kanye I miss the sweet Kanye, chop up the beats Kanye I gotta say, at that time I'd like to meet Kanye See, I invented Kanye, it wasn't any Kanyes And now I look and look around and there's so many Kanyes I used to love Kanye, I used to love Kanye I even had the pink polo, I thought I was Kanye What if Kanye made a song about Kanye Called "I Miss the Old Kanye"? Man, that'd be so Kanye That's all it was, Kanye, we still love Kanye And I love you like Kanye loves Kanye
ufff – here we go vor monate hani de ye us offesichtliche gründ leider komplett us minere rotation müesse striche... & au wenn‘s mer ih sim fall schwer fallt das ganze düütlich als schwarz & wiss ahzgseh isch es halt doch es unverhandelbars no go trotzdem isch das album – und das obwohl‘s es nur knapp ih mini kanye top 5 schafft – en integrale bestandteil ih minere musigloskarriere gsi rein musikalisch gseh sind through the wire, family business & jesus walks unbestritteni hymne wo mich dur schöni & schwierigi ziite begleitet hend also es fallt mer schwer aber muess es 5i gäh. gueti besserig ye, ich bezwifles zwar aber ich wünsche dir dass du din weg zrug findsch... aber trotzdem fuck you
I bought this at the time and like most people, could immediately tell that Kanye was destined for big things. The production and lyrics are great and it comes back with great tunes again and again. I was excited to see what he'd do next and I thought he was genuinely funny and clever. Now, if ever there's an appropriate time to dock a star for being a genuine binbag of a human, this is the one. It's hard to identify the extent to which his clear mental health issues have contributed to Kanye's artistic and personal decline but you can't just casually become a nazi sympathiser and dangerously narcissistic megalomaniac without having some serious character flaws to begin with. There are plenty of narcissists in this world and particularly in this industry, but when you combine that with these levels of wealth and influence it becomes truly dangerous. I'm sure there will be further Kanye albums to come in the list but the closing number of this one in particular struck me as an accurate representation of his career generally. For the first couple of minutes there's a great track building, but then we end up with ten minutes of Kanye rambling on about himself in a seemingly unscripted history of the man and the artist, while the beat sort of chunters along in the background, long since forgotten behind the self-obsession. I just want it be over. Please shut up, dude. You had our attention and were earning our respect but you should've stopped a long time ago.
No Kanye because he a moron
Credit where credit's due. This was a great debut and has held up reasonably well, unlike the man himself.
Read some of the reviews of this reviewing the person who created it. I'm sorry but that's not what this project is concerned with. Judge the album. It's a decent album. Not really my type of thing. It's definitely well produced but it's just not for me. Stand out song - Jesus walks and Slow jams (the quick rap on this is incredible). - 3
Some nice beats, but overall not my vibes and I did not finish. Would not relisten and would switch away if possible.
Solid hip hop album.
Incredible album from before Kanye lost his mind. Can't deny the genius of this album even though I can't support the man behind it today. So sad to see how he is today. Man needs some help.
Perfection. One of Kanye's best, everything about is nailed perfectly.
Musicalmente excelente, lamentablemente por gusto personal disfruto más los samples qué a Kanye rapeando arriba.
OMG fucking Kanye. He certainly has a confident sense of himself and what he's trying to achieve. Plenty of people see hits artistic intent and emerging genius. Not me. I like my hip hop less chipmonky. Still better than Morrissey. Two stars.
Not really my bag.
i dont like hip-hop
2 good songs, the rest were bad
don't like all the interludes, but the songs themselves are pretty good
A CLASSIC!
YESSSSSSS YESSSS YES EY UDHEB Dude I fucking love this album 5/5 ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I refuse to support nazis
Nazi scum can fuck off
PERFECT.
Cracked called it: https://www.cracked.com/blog/what-if-kanye-west-is-retarded In addition to being a nut job and a terrible person, is Kanye overrated as an artist? This has good samples and some good guest verses, but this, by and large, isn’t great rap. WAY overdoes it on the autotune. Also, “Last Call” is such a stupid song. As an aside, fuck Kanye and fuck Nazi trash.
Fantastic album - enough said.
A lot better than I expected, to be honest. Not a big fan of the language, but the music part was surprisingly decent.
sorry sorry sorry sorry
Tried to listen but couldn’t.
Oh, goodie. A genre I don't enjoy, and an artist who's an absolute muppet of a person and a waste of space. Listened to a bit of it and am glad I can go ahead and not listen to it with extreme prejudice, not having to bother with separating the art and the artist.
3.5
No comment
Nothing overly groundbreaking here but it’s better than ‘Yeezus’ and ‘My Beautiful Twisted Dark Fantasy’ which are also in the 1001 albums book. Big name guest rappers help to elevate this to better than average. And I will admit that there are some cool samples and beats on this as well. However, at the end of the day Kanye just isn’t that great a rapper and he doesn’t really have anything all that interesting or important to say.
Bangers!
5/10…hip hop
No.
Kayne really changed the game. Genius producer, clever rapper.
This one was a chore to get through. I had some visceral hate reactions to some of the songs when they came on. Workout Plan. I think the other was Graduation Day. I thought Gold Digger was on this album but I guess not. When I was in college I worked with this girl who would put this album on every time we worked together. I must have listened to it 50 times. I remember thinking it was kind of funny because she had dropped out of college. One time she invited me over for dinner. She was a big woman. After we ate dinner we sat on her couch and she took her shoe off and stretched it out across the couch towards me. I don't remember how I got out of that situation, but I remember the way she looked at me, with hunger in her eyes.
kids sing, kiids siiing. killer. set this party on fry. sekurrr. remember when he was a class conscious underdog making poignant statements about systemic racism and the empty promise of material wealth? touching song about wanting to transcend your circumstances. militant song about fighting the good fight. always funky, consistently balanced with humor. even if you can see his god complex poking through, at least it’s the good side of christianity he’s conflating himself with. yeah yeah jay z, hand the mic back to the exciting new young upstart. get em high. in the pocket now. not one stutter yet, what a great fuckin album. poor ray ray’s broke ass. “damn baby i can’t do it that fast but i know someone who can” haha. enta twista. party certainly on fry by this point. oh shit i forgot about this ludicrous song. sick guitar sample too. “say my name like candyman and i’ll come fix you up like the handyman.” makes it sound easy. one killer beat after another. and how FUN is this record. propulsive and swaggering. a couple whoos comin on cuz. i’ll be the smartest dead guy lol. excellent from start to finish. the skits always hit and even have a certain rhythm. family business is so earnest and innocent. 5 w/o a doubt
I remember this album being better. Production used to be so fucking good but dude lost his mind. Now we get …https://open.spotify.com/track/3uYDO9dPLTVrgfwg7EYXSf?si=hKB-OZTQS5Ww1_SxztqgeA
Can't believe how old this shit is. I liked Kanye's music, didn't love it, but I did bump it. Kanye is a crazy dick now. It will be interesting to relisten to this with my recent bias of him being a Nazi. It's a fun listen. Kanyes flow is a bit shit and lyrically hes not always interesting but he's just a really good song writer. The album The actual production is a little rough but it the album has a DIY feel and spontaneity that makes it all work. SLOW JAMZ stands out to me because it has an actual rapper on it. Anything with relieving kanye of some rapping makes the tracks infinitely more interesting. It's light hearted and fun and was played at every party I went to in college. I miss the old Kanye. Probably a light 5 downgraded to a solid 4 because Nazi.
Arguably the best debut rap album ever. Docking a star because he has since become a full blown nazi nutcase.
Kanye is a massive piece of shit. He is a product of unchecked ego and unchecked mental illness. He has too much money and too much influence. And somehow along the way he became anti-Semitic (what?). He hasn't put out a good album since 2016. I wish people would stop paying attention to him so he would stop getting the spotlight. But once upon a time, he was a really good producer and rapper. And he put out a series of albums that will always be discussed in the the greatest of all time conversation. This is the album that kicked all that off. It's amazing to me that this is his debut, but obviously a lot had been cooking under the surface for a while. I've listened to Jesus Walks more times than I can count. But I'm not overly familiar with this album as a whole. Man, it pisses me off to say but it's really good. He can rap. He can make a beat. He's got some amazing guest spots. And despite the length, I wasn't tired of it by the end. It's just got banger after banger. It's a hip-hop classic. Someday, after everything with Kanye is over, someone will write a really interesting book on how he went from this to where he is today.
Kanye is a tremendous piece of shit, what else can I say?
I’ll write this as if I don’t know how Kanye ended up years later. It’s too bad, cuz the creep can roll, man. Kanye was doing the best hip hop production in the game before he made himself a star, and this record shows what he could do when he saved all the choice beats for himself. Turns out he could also rap with the best. He’s a musician’s rapper and knows how a song works. He also wrote some fantastic rhymes about topics that no one else would touch, including (no way!) human vulnerability and wondering about his place in the world. I think this album could use some editing, it’d make a fine EP.
Gulp
# Album Name: College Dropout # Artist: Kanye West # Rating: 2/5 # Comments: Admittedly, theres a few good tracks on this album which were released. The rest of it is complete dross. And this thing goes on for a loooooonnnnggggg time. That including the crappy skits are enough to drive me mad. Coming in at 1hr and 16 mins this album is simply way too long for what it is. I was blown away by Kanye's My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy album. It was terrific. But this is nowhere near that level. I would have given this a 3 which i think is fair. But the length of the album plus the crap skits drag it down to a 2. Obviously Kanye is a pos now but im focussing on the album only. # Top Tunes: All falls down, jesus walks, workout plan, slow jamz # Would I listen to it again? No, single only.
Breakout album from one of the most controversial people of the century. Musically, there is really nothing to hate, though would point out that 'Last Call' is unreasonably long to close out the album. Disregarding this, Kanye's nostalgic production is engaging enough, and has some highlights, though these aren't high enough to write home about. Best Tracks: - Spaceship - Slow Jamz - Two Words Worst Tracks: - Last Call Rating: 5/10
Didn’t really like this when Kanye wasn’t hated.
No antisemitism please
iffy
I dislike this man. I don't particularly care for his work. Still, this is a good album. Maybe the best from him.
Great album. Miss the old Kanye West.
i thought this would be a no skip album 5/5, but honestly not every track hits definitely see how its considered a classic, but also i dont support nazis lol
Альбом, на котором Канье еще не успел в край ебануться и начать кидать насвай с фанатами Зенита 9/10
Fuck Kanye.
Lieblingstracks: I'll Fly Away und Spaceship Super Übergänge zwischen den einzelnen Songs
7.5/10. The instrumentation is great, and Kanye West can rap really well. Also, remember to separate the art from the artist.
Intro: Sooo doof und es gaht platt wieter. Hilfe, Workout plan und New Workout plan chani nüd ernscht nä. All falls down isch typisch aafangs 2000 und tönt würkli na guet.
we dont care isch e perfekts bispil vo früenem kanye. es macht sooo spass zum lose de beat isch fucking geeil es isch sozialkritik und sin flow isch easy charmant. mir hend wprklich es genie verlore. nocher zwei cooli aber nöd hammer songs. und denn halt jesus walks. scheiss isch guet. ich fang weg dem nöd ah glaube aber er het so viel liideschaft dehinder. get em high isch huere viel nöd kanye und s stresst mich mit de ziit au wenn de beat sehr cool isch. de workout plan slappt zwor aber isch glaub recht problematisch kanye. aso so women be shoppin problematisch. slow jamz isch geer nöd miis gsi ui. aso ich has kennt aber irgendwenn z vil s glich. und ich ghör eigentlich lieber de kanye. breathe in breathe out au chlii lahm. i always had a phd a pretty huge dick. school spirit skit 1 isch super. school spirit super gospelmässig. i finished school. oh you graduated? no i decided i was finished. super funny. through the wire slappt uhuere s sample isch seeeehr geil. er chans ebe. und dasers mit meeega metall i sim muul nochme umfall ufgnoh het goht chli hard. dude wär fasch gstorbe. family business cute. aber gseh langsam sochli dure hani s gfühl. wenns guet isch isch de kanye insane guet. aber het schochli e formle. alte last call goht jo e EWIGKEIT. und er redt afoch. mh. glaub e 3. well scho uuuhuere lang und d hälfti vode songs hani nur okay gfunde. die ander hälfti macht extreem spass.
HAHAHAHAHAH ICH HASSE S INTRO also we don't care und all falls down sind schomal bangers😭 space ship wird hert gecarried vom sample/vode wiibliche bgvs jesus walks au wieder sehr geil fuckkk manHO HO HO HOOO HOO HOO wett churz sege, dass ich versuech da echt nur uf d musig ihzgah und nöd uf s hütige mess vonere person wo de kanye isch muss aber zuegeh, dass ichs bis jz echt geil find get em high het wieder so es geils klavier föck ok also ich find die einzelne lieder immerno guet aber ich finds langsam echlii ahstrengend HAHAHA de ludacris okee de school spirit skit isch schona funny he die beats killet mich also rein musikalisch ischs für mich es 4i. wenn de kanye nöd de kanye wär, würdi hüfiger zu dem album zruggcho. aber han gmerkt, (ja ich han vorher öppis anders behauotet) dass ichs nöd übers herz bring es 4i z geh
I got Kanye 2 days in a row. Of all the artists to get back to back... This came out when I was in high school, and I do remember some of the songs but none of them feel iconic in the same way as other artists from that time period. I can appreciate this as a tone shift in rap, but if I didn't have that context I'm not sure I'd understand why it's here. Of course, Kanye's personal trajectory has to be put aside which many folks won't do.
Not supporting a Nazi
Not interested in anything produced by K West
I can’t bear to write a single thing about Kanye but yes, unfortunately still a great album.
Got me through some hard and good times back then and this album will always be a masterpiece to me.
Actually give it 3.5 stars. Not one of his top 3, but a good album.
Solid. About 20 minutes too long. 3/5
I can't (won't) listen to him. It's a big 0.
It's too long. Too many skits. Still, there's some excellent stuff on here. And, more than most, the vaudeville does at least seem to add to the overall arc of the thing. There's some good ideas here, exploring the tension between loading up on conspicuous consumption, vs lifelong education. Kanye doth protest too much... you can tell he wants to be a good student, a church boy, a family man. Be he also wants to push miracle whips and chase women. I rate him highest when he's not trying too hard to be hard. The best tracks are more reflective and vulnerable ones (spaceship, family business). An interesting listen for sure.
Shame he's a tool, but the album is great even if a bit stupid. Loved the School Spirit + Timmy skit
good, but maybe not as mature as my dark twisted fantasy
Classic before he went crazy
I’m upset that Kanye is actually good
A lot of people are going to trash this album and reviews due to Kanye's character, and I don't blame them. But just for a minute, I'd like to talk about the art independent of the artist in this case. College dropout was undoubtedly a game changer for rap. Kanye's unique style when it came to be making, and his creative wordplay with lyrics made him an instant success. This is significant because rap had gone through a couple different iterations by this point. If you've been listening to any rap on this album generator, you might have come across some '80s or early 90s hip hop like Public Enemy or Run DMC or you may be found yourself listening to '90s gangster rap like Biggie or Mobb Deep. Kanye took a sound more reminiscent with less mainstream hip hop like Black Star or Tribe Called Quest (both referenced on this album) and made it the most popular style of rap. If you went to college in the early 00s, Kanye was likely part of the soundtrack of your life. As far as the album itself. I don't think it's Kanye's best work, but it is indicative of his style (meaning you could listen to College Dropout and "get it"), and some of his best work, like "Jesus Walks" is on this one. But, the album is a bit too long, not just because of the skits, which I get are just a part of rap albums but they're not good here, but also because many of the songs just go on for too long and become quite repetitive. Also, I think the second half of the album is much better than the first, for whatever that's worth. Now, back to Kanye the artist. He's lost his mind for sure, and I can't think of anything he's released in the last ten years that's worth mentioning, but do we dismiss the first few albums of greatness? Well, I understand the sentiment of not giving him money via streaming, but let's say you had a ripped copy of this album somewhere, does it hold up? I'd say it does, but it's also rough to listen to knowing what we know about Kanye now. And, his massive ego and his misogyny are already present on his first album. Plus, we're not just talking about generic rap ego (like "I got more money than you" type stuff) but almost equating himself to God, which he does unabashedly and very obviously in his later work. All in all, I do think this is a great album and it's worthy of this list, but due to issues with who Kanye is as a person, I think it's a one and done for me, despite being such a huge part of my early 20s.
durva hogy egy ilyen minősített seggfej ilyen jó dolgokat tud csinálni, de ha egyszer így van :(
Standing on your anonymous internet soap box and giving this album a 1 star review does not make you better than the person who actually listens to the album. If you don't want to listen, just don't listen. This album is a masterpiece and was released by a different person than the Kanye West that you see in the news today, if you'd listened you would know that.
Fuck Kanye West's nazi ass. I used to bump this record a ton way back in the day. Some of the tracks hold up but overall the album is bloated and drags. Some of the production and mixing sound a little dated, especially a few of the features. Jay-Z's verse on Never Let Me Down sounds like it was pasted on top of the finished track; it doesn't quite sit in the mix properly. I know this is "classic" and at the time it was, but even outside of Kanye's turn to nazism this is far away from his best work.
No interest in giving him any of my streaming time or attention.
Seems this guy is a complete trainwreck. But separating the art from the artist, this album from 20+ years ago is a very solid record. Real and raw. I liked it. Based on the comments, it seems he’s jumped off the rails since this release - but nonetheless worthy of a top 1,000 album.
It's truly great - albeit with some filler - and was groundbreaking at the time, but wow is it depressing to listen to now. Loses a star because of that.
Against my better judgement, I gave this a listen. And I'm not sure I get the hype. This feels like an album people know they're supposed to like but they secretly don't care that much. The music is fine. The skits are caricatures at best. The last track is some sort of rambling autobiography that feels like a toddler telling his parents about a field trip. I'm giving this 2 stars for it's actual work and removing one more for good measure.
Fuck Kanye
It’s hard to review this album with everything this man has said and done. Even though this was all before that. I never understood the hype around him, after listening to this album it makes a little bit more sense. Just based on the music it’s very good, also for not big rap fans. Still it’s hard to listen to him. Because this is a music platform I’ll give the rating just based on the music.
32% banger
Won't be streaming. One of the few artists I can't separate from the art.
Fuck Kanye
I got Yeezus last week, so I'm going to skip over ranting about how Kanye being a nazi makes it really hard to evaluate his work. This album definitely feels a bit dated now, as a lot of early 2000s stuff does, I will also say that I prefer his more synthesize-heavy work that came after this. However, as a debut album for a rapper/producer, this is really good and deserves it's iconic position in hip-hop history. Kanye got better from here, and then he got a bit worse, and then he got a lot worse. It's best just to enjoy the music and not think about it too much 4/5
On point effort - can't love what he became but the effort on this one is solid.
Hubo un tiempo, bastante largo, en el que Kanye era el Rey Midas y todo lo que hacía era brillante. Tenía un horizonte despejado y disco tras disco construía una carrera espectacular. Este, su debut, fue el primer peldaño hacia el infinito. Mejor que Jay-Z y Kendrick Lamar??? Gran pregunta... por cierto Lauryn Hill ya estuvo antes contando cosas personales y reflexivas en clave Hip-Hop... All falls down (tercer sencillo y mejor tema del disco) a lomos de Lauryn Hill, Through the Wire (primer sencillo) en clave Gospell Hip-Hop y Chaka Khan, Jesus Walks (cuarto single) es sencillamente imponente. Slow jamz (su primer número 1) sigue reluciendo como el primer día (colaboran Twista y Jamie Foxx). School Spirit innova con ese sonido "chipmunk soul". Two Words con Mos Def, Freeway y The Boys Choir Of Harlem es una maravilla. En su debe podríamos poner temas como We Don't Care, The New Workout Plan, Breathe In Breathe Out, "amily Business o Last call, que se hace larga con sus 12 minutos (4 de canción y el resto speech innecesario). Aún así un imprescindible por méritos propios.
Horrible person getting trashier by the day. That does not change the quality of the album though. I have never listened to a complete Kanye album before, and I never understood the hype. I get it now. I still don't enjoy him as a rapper, but the beats and the production - and even some of the lyrics - are just above and beyond.
Poco he podido rascar de este álbum, incluso tratando de pasar por alto que Kanye West es un nazi. Para empezar, las letras no han resonado mucho conmigo. Entiendo que en su momento fueran revolucionarias, mostrando una vulnerabilidad que separa a este álbum del típico Gangsta Rap de la época. Pero no sé, me siguen pareciendo bastante superficiales. Los temas son pegadizos y muy animados, típicos del rap americano de la época, aunque tanto rollo R&B (con el característico y cansino "chipmunk soul" de West) no es lo mío. Más aún teniendo en cuenta que el álbum dura más de una hora. A la mitad ya estaba deseando que se acabara. En fin, merecería una estrella solo por tratarse de Kanye West, pero vamos a dejarlo en dos.
Ugh. You know you're in for a long one when the homophobic slurs start 1 minute into the first song. "Spaceship" was one of the few songs I liked.
Not really my thing, but I can appreciate it.
SEPARANDO O ARTISTA DA OBRA todo mundo sabe que o college dropout é um dos melhores já feitos, n tem nem discussão dito isso VSF KANYE triste o acidente de carro no qual ele perdeu a vida 😭
eu escutei eric clapton. e pantera. e mais 3948392 filhos da puta nazista/racista. vo ouvir todos os albuns memo e ser sincero fodas. infelizmente é um album revolucionário brutalzaço, tudo nele é top. não é meu preferido mas bom demais. kanye é maluco nazista pau no cu dele.
oh Kanye, a study in how to throw it all away. Was always gonna be a 1. I can't separate the artist from the art.
This album gets three stars for the beats. That's it.
fuck
If you're protesting this album because the artist is a nazi - I see you, understand where you're coming from, but challenge you to listen to this through once and put in effort to understand the messages and influence of this album. If it makes you feel better, you playing it once isn't getting him rich. Whatever streaming platform you're listening to it on underpays their artists anyways. If it still bothers you, put your money where your mouth is and donate to a nonprofit. Actually, if you're not making a monthly reoccurring donation to a nonprofit that benefits some sort of marginalized community, particularly a local nonprofit to you, then your protest is likely performative. This album is so damn good. Undeniably so. I have to admit, The New Workout Plan has been on my workout playlist for years. Through The Wire was literally recorded with his mouth wired shut from facial reconstructive surgery after a car accident two weeks prior to recording. And to sample a queen, Chaka Khan, is just iconic. Slow Jamz, Breathe In Breathe Out, All Falls Down, Family Business....So many great songs from this album. I would listen to this album more regularly if he weren't a nazi.
I hope Kanye never reads this but I fucking love this album Taking off a point for the rambling tho
Hoo boy... Seperating the art from the artist is particularly hard on this one in lieu of the recent events. That being said then this is about the greatest album, not the greatest people... And in that aspect this album is really strong. I've never heard it before but found myself going back to listen to my standout tracks multiple times Standouts All Falls Down Never Let Me Down The New Workout Plan Through The Wire 4/5
Not gonna losten
sorry im sorry im sorry im sorry im sorry im sorry
From a forgotten era before we knew he was batshit crazy. Mayonnaise colored Benz, I push miracle whips. This album is undeniable.
Overall good album, golden era Kanye.
All-time classic
hey remember when kanye was a good person? i was Not born yet. anyways this album is really good
The best thing about this album is the selection of samples.
Not too shabby. Not my jam though, but I can see why this album became so big.
Soooo good, this album. Of course, Kanye's literally a crazy nazi these days, but he was a REALLY good musician, I think. Like, this album has some really complex, incredible, catchy songs. All Falls Down is so good that I used in my AP Lang argument essay (Thank you Kanye for the 5, not so much for the alt right tweets). It's clever (like most rap that I've listened to) and it has commentary and its sound is so remarkable to me. I don't listen to all that much rap, so to me at least, this seems like REALLY good rap/hip hop/whatever. REALLY good music in general. And it's funny. Laugh-out-loud funny, at times. It is serious at times and silly at others. It's just good. That being said, I mostly listen to the first half of this album even though I'm certain I've listened to it in full. I’ve been listening to this lots recently (not because of the nazi stuff, but IN SPITE of it!) In fact, this was my most listened album of the week, which is unusual because it’s some indie rock bullshit. Intro: I mean, this is just silly. His voice is so hilarious. The inflection, the pacing. Sharing candy and stuff. Funny. We Don't Care: A hilarious song. Like, FUNNY. The literal children singing about drug dealing is funny but it's also sad. There's commentary to be heard but it's also just silly. The drug game bulimic, it's hard to get weight/So []'s money is homo, it's hard to get straight" is zingy af. Also, it just sounds awesome. Catchy and calming in a certain way. Graduation Day: OH my god this is so funny. There is like NO time between "we don't care what people sa-ay!" and "What in the FUCK was that, Kanye???" Like, the contrast between that beautiful feminine voice and Kanye's ridiculous faculty character. It's FUNNY, dude. And then you get a sneaky super-good mini-song. Like, "I'm no longer confused, but don't tell anybody" is so genuinely good that I can't even dismiss this as just a silly, skippable part of the album. All Falls Down: I LOVE this song, dude. Why wouldn't I? It's so good, it's catchy, you get the beautiful voice of Syleena Johnson blending so well with Kanye's verses, which are actually pretty profound and tell realistic stories. Like, yeah, you have the bit on materialism, but then the added context of black materialism(??) is extra-interesting to listen to. I'm not black so maybe I don't get it fully but it definitely feels important. Also, Kanye's delivery is just solid. "Sophomore, three yurrs ain't picked a carrur, she like 'fuck it, I'll just stay down hurr and do hair," is sooooo good. And I watched a clip of him doing this as a slam poem, I think -- super good. Like, he was a real artist at this point. That's cool. It's funny, too. "Pass that ver-say-see!" I'll Fly Away: Quaint song. Apparently one of the most recorded gospel hymns ever and I'm sure there's some significance that is lost on me there. Spaceship: Mellow and groovy. And I get the feeling that this song was trendy at some point, I don't know. Sounds more familiar than maybe it should. A little repetitive but idc it's so good. Jesus Walks: I guess this is one of the cooler Christian songs I've heard. I mean, Christianity's cool but this is a little bitter to listen to with all his current NAZI stuff. But it does sound super good and it's sort of interesting and like... cool to hear a rapper be super god-loving? I guess it comes off as earnest and I appreciate that. Also, the "JE-SUS WALKS" is a very jarring but very interesting sound. I like it. The repetition of the n-word in the background is kind of insane but like .. good idk it's hard to comment on this song as an athiest wasian Never Let Me Down: Good. Love the mix between melodious singing and rapping in this album, it feels like he's got a whole chorus behind him and it makes the sound very grand. Sam's Club line is good. Don't get the God stuff but the "Take 'em to church" was cool. Get Em High: This is the part of the album where I kind of stop paying attention when I listen to it. This is good, like the rest of the album, but skippable. Not totally remarkable, at least to me in this moment. Workout Plan: I resent the fact that this and The New Workout Plan are named so similarly. I play the wrong one all the time. But this is a really fun skit to listen to. I love girls and I love girl talk, even if it's scripted. Cute and silly and funny. New Workout Plan: Banger banger banger. So complex with so many different parts and it's FUNNY and it's SO good. A creative idea for a song, great execution -- the thank-yous with the Alabama girl who could "date outside the family" is SO funny. "Mo'." repetition is so fun to listen to. The drum beat that comes in with the autotuned voice is SOOOO good dude. I think this is tied with All Falls Down for me. So good. Shout out to Work Out by J. Cole. Also a banger despite stealing from this song and Paula Abdul. Slow Jamz: So agree. Focus on the ladies! Smooth af and the jazzy singing is good. Light skin/dark skin MJ line is so iconic and witty and funny. Twista(?)’s verse is fast and incredible and the chorus is sweeeet. Thank you, Jamie Foxx, for writing Blame It, which has the best verse ever from T-Pain. So good! Breathe In Breathe Out: Feels, like, old school and cool and simply awesome. “Always said if I rapped, I'd say somethin' significant/But now, I'm rapping 'bout money, hoes, and rims again.” His delivery is fucking funny and it’s self-aware and good. PhD pretty huge dick. Fucking funny. Ludacris is good, too. His voice is just so… I don’t know. “Peace ouuuuuut.” It’s almost stoner. School Spirit (Skit 1): Funny. I bet I can add up all the change in your purse very fast. Funny! School Spirit: Actually super good even though I don’t recall it. POOTIE TANG MENTIONED — “Did y’all know he wrote Pootie Tang? Brilliant” God it’s actually crazy that the lunatic tweeting that Nazi racist bullshit and flaunting his naked wife at the Grammys was the same dude who made this objectively awesome music. IN-sane. I wonder what the fuck happened. School Spirit (Skit 2): It’s true. So many fucking degrees. Yeah, I’ll prob be 52 by the time I have a degree, god damn. Lil Jimmy Skit: All the regular homeless people. Funny and true! Two Words: Ok this seems serious. I might need to listen to this more, but it sounds pretty good. Through The Wire: Chiller. I could listen to this on a sunny day after school. This album sounds how the album cover looks. It’s rich and full of sound. And this song sounds like it’s sitting on the curb or a step. Family Business: Feels emotional. Almost makes me wanna cry and this is my first time actually listening to it. Probably because it’s 2 AM. Last Call: Confusing. Why is it 13 mins. But it’s funny. And I’ll listen to it lots again. This album is good. So good.
Know very little about the hiphop timeline, but this felt different than other rap albums I’ve listened to — almost felt more honest and the persona put forth was more real. Kanye gets a lot of hate nowadays for his personal life, but this album was pretty solid. Production was great, lyrically strong and I enjoyed the sampling, background choruses, etc 3.5/5
If you want to know how I feel about Kanye West as a person and how I try to separate art from artist, please go back and look at my review of "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy." The short version: Kayne is a mentally ill person who seems to be completely rejecting whatever help he could be getting and has now gone off the complete deep end into fascism and sporting swastikas. I don't support him. I don't like him. And while this will likely influence my opinions of his music, I try not to let it. Now, the album: It's fine. There's some real great tracks here (see below), but it's far too long. And "Last Call"? Are you kidding me? What is that supposed to be? If I wanted to hear Kayne talk about himself for more than ten minutes I would just find literally any clip of him talking about anything, ever. That was some self-indulgent crap if there ever was some. But man when this album hits, it hits so hard. It's a great mix of genres at times, and other times it just shows off this man's clear musical genius. The production is top notch ("Jesus Walks" in particular), and Kayne's ability to take a simple musical concept (a beat, a melody, or a lyric that he seems fond of) and build on it is on full display. Look, I don't like the guy but it's so clear that he's immensely talented. It's such a damn shame to have to witness his decline in real time. I could've done without the skits. Those were unnecessary. And, at least for me, it was mostly downhill after "Jesus Walks." That's basically half ot the album I'm saying wasn't amazing. Three stars, purely because what was good was excellent. Standout Tracks: We Don't Care, All Falls Down, I'll Fly Away, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, The New Workout Plan
Make facism uncool again
I’ve never listened to a full album by Kanye, but I'm familiar with a lot of his songs, and I usually like them. This album went a bit long for me. On a re-listen, I’d cherry-pick the songs and skip the skits.
Kanye is not my jam. Never was, never will be.
Kanye sucks, this is a good album
I didn't get on the Kanye bandwagon until Graduation (and until Life of Pablo). This is okay, but I prefer the later albums.
Kanye is a sick man. But that doesn’t change the reality that the music is the highest quality. Still I’m not taking a self-described Nazi to the desert island. The rhymes are political, creative, tight. The musical backing is great. Still the seeds of Ye’s illness are apparent. Between some if the amazing tracks, are lazy and indulgent tracks. At times, he’s riding the line between revealing the lives of his characters (eg, the kids choir — which is hella funny) and exploiting them. Looking back with 20:20, it’s clear that sometimes (eg, Slow Jamz) he’s mocking his subjects. He might not have meant that at the time — but that’s where it went. Too bad, because this Kanye is super-talented and has important things to say. It’s a 4 — would have been a 5 with some more editing discipline.
Oh boy
Luckily this is not a conflicting album for me at all. Kanye literally sucks Hitler ass, and so does this. Everything as it should be. To be continued when My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy shows up here, I might have a harder time mending my cognitive dissonance.
Ill drop out of this class too
I draw the line at listening to actual Nazis.
A seminal, timeless classic that sounds just as good today as it did in 2004. A debut record that was a legit turning point in hip hop history, which makes it a turning point in all of music history. That the author of this thing is taking this album off the next iteration of this list is a travesty.
I actually enjoyed this album a lot, even though I'm not a big fan of Kanye.
Great record but admitting you are a nazi might be a bridge too far
Fantastic record from an incredibly gifted musician that unfortunately grew into a psychopath. I understand other reviewer's contempt for Kanye, but his musical talent and creativity cannot and should not be overlooked or "canceled." This project is about the music, not the person. At the time this album came out, Hip Hop was in a transition from its golden era of the 90s. Kanye introduced some unique and very creative drum and sample programming which still resonates to this day. The soul, the passion and the ambition can all be felt. The guest features speak beautiful words of inspiration and complement the production so well - Kanye handpicked them perfectly. Even the skits are great, adding to the story of this album. This is always a classic record in my book.
I hate what Kanye has become, but unlike Eminem's lyrics I could listen to this in isolation and be okay with it (apart from.The New Workout Plan, -1). I was going to give this a 4 but I think with the lyrics to that song, a 3 feels right.
Pretty good. Some bangers. Don't need it in my collection but good to hear for sure
"I miss the old Kanye, straight from the 'Go Kanye I hate the new Kanye, the bad mood Kanye The always rude Kanye, spaz in the news Kanye" Don't even need half the brain cell kanye has remaining to understand that this album was insanely good. When were skits ever so fun to listen to? Who else did it so well to invoke deep thoughts in seemingly foolish and silly skits? 10/10
Очень хорошее звучание, но из-за длины альбома и длины треков сложно рекомендовать
крутой альбом, тем более для первого альбома ого
Kanye may be a hypocrite bigot, but damn this album is good. It was supremely popular when I was in school, but I didn't pay rap or hip hop much attention at that time. This album has awesome backing music, pretty good flow and topics, great lyrics, and is pretty funny as well. Sucks that it belongs to a piece of shit, because I want to enjoy it unabashedly. My favorite was Spaceship, but We Don't Care, Never Let Me Down, and several others were great. Gonna rate it as music, as I have other controversial artists like MJ.
Going to continue not supporting Nazis and fascists.
I was conflicted until I found a way to listen to this that wouldn't put any money in Kanye's pocket. This was my first listen and, although I have enjoyed individual works by Kanye, I hadn't experienced this as an album. It was like very little I had listened to before. I didn't expect the humour, the skits, the contrast between self-deprecation and self-aggrandizing. The rhymes are so good, the beats are amazing. I listened to every word of the 1 hour, 20 minute album and at the end I just felt sad. This album made me laugh and gasp and dance, but I felt sad for what the man is today. I don't know if Kanye in 2005 had the same opinions and beliefs that he has today and was just good at masking them, or has untreated mental illness and 20 years of fame changed him into what he is now. Since I'm rating the album and not the man, this is 5 stars. A 5 star album for me has to be something that I genuinely enjoy, but also appreciate for a unique approach, or a groundbreaking effort, or a contribution to music that deserves recognition. 5 stars doesn't require perfection but it does require innovation or creativity or generational talent. I see no reason not to recognize that here while boycotting the man in 2025.
Kanye was truly a mastermind before everything went downhill
"I miss the old Kanye, straight from the 'Go Kanye I hate the new Kanye, the bad mood Kanye The always rude Kanye, spaz in the news Kanye" Don't even need half the brain cell kanye has remaining to understand that this album was insanely good. When were skits ever so fun to listen to? Who else did it so well to invoke deep thoughts in seemingly foolish and silly skits? 10/10
too many skits, too many songs. but the highs are some of the highest of the decade.
Rated without further comment.
god i hate skits
great album but i feel it is too overrated
The skits bog it down, which is why Graduation is superior. Kanye really is the best at this though.
Прикольный альбом, не раз слушал, всей душой люблю канье, поэтому 10/10
Dude is a huge jackass but this is a great album
This album was great but Kanye is just the worst
The College Dropout feels like a perfect product of the 2000s. From the production to the lyrics and the rhythms, it’s undeniably rooted in that era. It has all the hallmarks of Kanye's early style, but when I listen to it, it doesn’t feel like it pushes the boundaries of the time. It’s an album that fits seamlessly into the landscape of the period, yet doesn’t necessarily stand out or introduce something revolutionary to the broader music scene. It captures the vibe of its time, but in terms of lasting impact or innovation, it doesn’t feel like it shifts things forward.
Fuck kanye.
fuck kanye dude needs to stay on his medsc and far away from the internet
Listening to the most misogynistic song I’ve ever heard “wow, this is troublingly classist”. I dunno, this album was a big part of my youth, not sure what the fuck I’m supposed to do with his albums now.
Fuck you Kanye
Ставлю этому сумасшедшему копчённому крепкую пять
Not listening to a nazi lover.
Very torn about this one. There is no denying he is extremely talented and really paved the way for a next generation. But he’s also a disgusting human being.
Kanye before he went crazy. But you can still see the crazy even back then… that self indulgent 12 minute last song. I only got into Kanye after dark twisted fantasy. I’d never listened to this album but I’d hear so many of the songs before. There are so many features on here too! I can appreciate it but I don’t think I’ll be going back for more listens.
Erg goed geheel, paar hele vette nummers. Jammer dat Kanye is geworden wie hij nu is, maar dit was gewoon echt goed.
A masterful piece of work. He's a terrible man mind.
Anyone selling t-shirts with swastikas on them deserves a 0.
Not for me
Shit
There’s a lot of very immature reviews of this album here. This man lost his mind when is mother died. He’s done some abhorrent stuff lately but as far as I can see a lot of people on this list has that we don’t necessarily delve in to. The album is a masterpiece. A real standout from what rap was serving up when it came out. Immaculate production and soulful lyrics, there’s not many like it.
Trots aan de kant voor Kanye, was eigenlijk best prima
Jesus...that was awful. Worse than I anticipated. It gave me an anxiety attack. I try to be objective with the genres I dislike...but I just Do. Not. Get. It.
Putting to one side that the guy needs serious help, he made some great music. Personally I prefer late registration, MBDTF and yeezus to this, but this is still great. Beautiful production, clever wordplay and I've always liked his rapping style, it sounds different to pretty much everyone else around
I refuse to listen to something Kanye has made
pretty neat. my kind of hip hop
Bittersweet listening to Kanye these days, but, man, he used to be one of the GOATs. This album in particular is one of my favorite casual listens from his discography, and, therefore, overall. Pretty much all of his albums have some sort of central theme to the sound of the album, but this one doesn't. It's all consistent, clean, straight bars from the 2000s. Love it.
non il miglior momento per parlare di kanye west 💀💀
Personality aside, can't deny Kanye is a great rapper. Solid debut, with some great songs I've never heard before.
Really catchy tunes and great lyrics - would def not have listened to this so great to hear it - cheers !
As I am not really into hip-hop and Kanye West is a certified whacko, I did not expect to be entertained by this album. However I find it quite listenable and quite musical.
8/10
GD*mnit Kanye, if this is an art project, ala Andy Kaufman, time to abandon project. If it isn't, please someone help this guy. No cOsIgN WhAtEvEr tHiS Is
Shame about all that stuff
F kanye
I miss the old Kanye
I saw Kanye in concert in 2014. It was pretty cool. It was a few days after the 10th anniversary of this album so he played a lot from this album. He also yelled about Charlamagne a lot. Weird how no one pays attention to him anymore. Anyway, fuck nazis.