Reviews (page 7 of 16)
Simply awful
Separate the art from the artist. "You know the kids gonna act a fool when you stop the programs for after school and pay DCF's... some of em dyslexic, they favorite 50 Cent song "12 Questions"
Kanye West is one of the most successful rap artists of all time, so sure he must have some level of talent, aside from his far right politics? Well, I lasted about one and a half tracks and then looked up the rest of the lyrics online. There’s no pathos, warmth or humour to be found here - just an endless steam of mother-effin n words, bigotry, violence and sexism, with no redeeming qualities, like every other gangsta rapper from the 90s. Appalling.
Allow me to copy/paste another review I wrote for another album from the guy: The guy is a scumbag, but that's more or less all I know from him, I've lost interest/lost track with mainstream hip hop a long time ago. Is it any good? I don't particularly like his flow (there is no particular edge, it's a bit too smooth/dull to my taste), the background music is not too bad but a bit bloated. We can clearly hear that lots of efforts were put in the production, but I'm not really convinced and it's hard to claim that is pure genius. It wasn't really bad overall, but not that good either. And as the guy is despicable, I don't intend to put too much effort on this.
I'm not even trying to listen to ts
Understand why the album got the praises it did (prior to Kanya going all nazi). Interested to relisten to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy when it shows up.
This one surpassed my expectations.
Really really fantastic album. Listening to his old stuff, make's it all the more depressing to know how he turned out. Still, this is one of the greatest rap albums ever, and he gets even better later. 4.5/5
Kanye is a wanker. This album is good. Shame. Do I rate it based on how much I hate the guy, how good the album is?
4 for the album -2 for artist.
Hate the player, love the game.
Unfortunately I just can't bring myself to give him any streams/views. I've heard it's a great album, though.
If I look past the artist and just judge the art, this album is amazing.
The amount of pointless, self-righteous virtue-signaling in these reviews is just embarrassing. "I won't give Kanye a single cent of streaming revenue!!" Well, luckily for you, he would only earn about a thousandth of a cent from your listen, lol. Some fun tracks, and definitely some annoying tracks. Also the Lil Jimmy skit made me lol.
Pas mon style
So so good. Holds up as maybe some of his best. A better time for his music
Look, at this point he’s so crazy, so completely detached from reality, that it was honestly pretty easy for me to separate him from this absolute beast of an album.
Deep fucking sigh. I miss the old Kanye.
Not _quite_ as offensive as the other Kanye albums, but still pretty offensive.
Not putting more money in this clowns pockets.
Exclude the people review bombing this album and this would easily be the highest ranking album of 2004 on this site. Pity the people that can't separate the art from the man. Suggest clicking "did not listen" and save the rest of us the holier than thou BS. Bernie Mac intro kills me every time. I remember the MTV days and seeing Jesus Walks for the first time. Blew me away. Took a mental note of the artist and song so I could torrent it later. This could easily be considered Kanye's best album. So many bangers on this one. Production value is through the roof. Runs a little long though. 4.5/5. Raising to a 5.
Fuck Kanye, but his early work is top tier.
Separating the art from the artist - listening to this album felt like levitating. Sad to think what happened to this dude. Art is a hell of a drug. Man he really knew what he wanted with this one.
What an amazing album. Unbelievable that this is Kanye's debut. I love the social commentary littered throughout and how young Kanye is but how incredible he already is. I truly miss the old Kanye lol
Banger after banger, shame he’s a bellend.
The production, the originality, the humour, the quality, a classic. Two Words is one of the most underrated hip hop songs of all time. Brilliant album. What a shame this man is now dirt.
This is the first album released during my lifetime that I've had to rate for this and it's a fitting one! The College Dropout is one of those highly-regarded LPs that I've never had the chance to properly listen through – albums like this are exactly why I felt like I needed to finally commit to doing this challenge. Kanye West's debut album isn't the first I've heard from him (it's actually the eighth, including KIDS SEE GHOSTS), but I think you could make a case for it being his best. For the first seven tracks, it feels like a bona fide five star album – the beats are incredible and uplifting, the track-to-track flow is impeccable, the bars are clever and unique. There's a sense of adolescence & humility that I've never really heard from Kanye prior to this point and it makes me understand (ever so slightly more) why his day ones have stood by him through his many controversies in the decades since. The College Dropout is a great album, but it's not perfect (for me, anyway). The album has a pretty sizable dip from tracks 8-13, in which it veers into fairly generic early/mid '00s club hip-hop territory without much of the character and charisma found on the rest of the project. There are interesting moments during the dip ("The New Workout Plan" is a highlight) and I don't outright hate any of the songs in that chunk, but I probably would have enjoyed the whole album like 25% more if it went straight from "Jesus Walks" to the first "School Spirit" skit. Overall, it's a solid project and one that I feel I've truly missed out on all these years (which is ultimately what I'm looking to get out of each album on this list)! It also inspired me to finally check out Late Registration and Graduation, since [SPOILER] neither made the cut for this list. Might share some thoughts on those in my eventual reviews of MBDTF and Yeezus, assuming there's anything relevant to share. Highlights: We Don't Care, All Falls Down, Jesus Walks, The New Workout Plan, School Spirit, Two Words, Through the Wire, Family Business, Last Call
With postsecondary education tuition costs, I can't blame them.
no nazis in my wrapped. 0/5
Nayyy not for me. We Don’t Care was good.
One of the more notable features of the pop culture landscape of the last five or so years was Kanye outing himself as a Black Nazi Fuck. It's difficult separating the art from the artist at the best of times, and it proves so here because he does present a banging collection of beats, rhymes, flows and collabs that would stand up to anything you want to throw at it. Jesus Walks is iconic, as are All Falls Down, Spaceship, Get Em High, Breathe In Breathe Out, and others you can care to mention. If he wasn't a Black Nazi Fuck it would be a 5. Never mind separating the art from the artist, like most Nazis he'd be more interested in separating your head from your shoulders if he had the chance. So... fuck him. (By the way, a black guy wrote this, so away with your thoughts of casual racism)
The age old question returns: should we separate the art from the artist? I can't think of a bigger disparity between the art, and artist than I can with this album, and the album's artist. In good faith, I can't possibly give this a five-star rating because Kanye West is an apprehensible scumbag(whether he's using his alter ego "Ye", or not), but at the same time, the album is a musical masterpiece. Is this a fair compromise? Favorite Track: "Through The Wire".
people who say that kanye is not washed are in heavy denial. this is such leagues above anything he's put out in the 2020s, it's insane.
Pass.
So many great songs, great features, great verses... I wish Kanye could hear this record now, remind himself what's important. Until then, he's a nazi, and there's no getting past that.
Not the best Kanye album.
4.5/5
He should've stuck to music instead of supporting fascism
Overall, a pretty decent record with some fun songs. It’s got a few filler tracks and skits, and it would be a lot stronger without the faffing about, but it’s better than the “working through his mental health” era of Kanye that started a decade later. 3.5/5
Kanye West was Len’s cleaner for 3-4 years. He was terrible! 3.4 4/21 All Falls Down
Hip-hop beats and AC. The cure to headaches. 4/5
luchino says all falls down is not bad, indeed it's not
7/10
Wow that was such a great album. I'm very impressed. Too bad he's crazy now.
J’adore Kanye.
Back in the days when Kanye was any good, and not an anti-Semitic POS. Couple of good songs in there.
I get the protest of Kanye West (Ye) now, but this was an important record for Hip Hop and had much beats. I fucked with the first few albums but don't go back to them. Fuck Ye
This album fucks
The Good: Saving money, by dropping out… The Bad: Maybe some more higher education could’ve helped the man? The Ugly: Stupidity of people not recognizing serious mental health issues… Here comes my skipping record: I don’t like rap. However, this album was actually “easy listening” for me. It was musical, it has structure, just easy listening. Now, if they could stop with the damn sketches, maybe I can start taking certain hip hop albums more serious. 3*
While I liked the album, I have a hard time understanding why this would be on here as one that must be listened to
great hip hop album with lots of variety, melodic vocals and a cozy mid 2000's vibe
quite good! like the story behind the songs and how it joins together
I hate how much I loved this.
What a bummer it is to revisit this knowing what Kanye turned into. I've been wondering if I could stomach listening to his stuff anymore, because I haven't in years. There's still plenty to like on here, skits and filler aside. There just isn't anything to like about Kanye personally anymore.
Kanye again...stupid sick man. This album might frustrate me more than the last one. He is soooo good at rap and making it so smooth and effortless. He has such good poignant lyrics and mixes in so many pieces that flawlessly go together. His narcism shows but in a way he is really that good at making music. This one did get a little long after a while and seemed a little all over the place at the end. But my gosh he is a bad person and seems to go against so many things he is singing about
TIL he recorded Through the Wire while his jaw was wired shut after a car accident. Wut. How did I not know this. He's one that's REALLY hard to separate the art from the artist, but this is a good album, except for The New Workout Plan. That song is gross. Overall though, I'd give this more accolades if he wasn't awful. I was a big fan of several of these songs back in the day.
Please god, show him the way, because the devil has broken him down.
Fascist scum. Refuse to play it.
Yes good melody
Hoping the algorithm had set a precedent with Brian Wilson and Ozzy, I eagerly raced over to Wikipedia to read about Kanye's untimely demise... Alas... Having never before heard anything on this album, I was concerned I might enjoy it and be conflicted. Thankfully, that didn't materialize. I can confidently say that both the art and the artist have been given far more attention than they deserve. Let's be honest. Even if you like this, you can't deny that a 76-minute album with trite skits and a presumptuous, self-important outro could be objectively described as anything but tedious.
Great album. Kanye might be a musical genius, but also a giant piece of shit. I would like to grade this solely on the musical content, and for the most part I will. I have to knock it slightly for how I felt the ick the entire time I listened to this.
Fuck Kanye. I don't care about his music anymore. He's a horrible person and I refuse to listen to his music anymore
Not much to get excited about here honestly
Not my cup of tea.
Another classic.
Trash tier
I hope he gets the help he needs but until then, fascists get a zero if I could.
This isn’t my genre, but I kinda get how people would like Kanye’s earlier stuff after this listen
Superb. Excellent. Masterful. Memorable. One of the best hip hop albums of all time by one of the GOATs.
A lot of mixed feelings because ye is now a Nazi, and I’m usually a fan of death of the artist but it’s hard when the person is alive and still doing what they’re doing. In saying that, objectively this is a very good album, very well produced with great features and songs, the main thing that drags it down are the skits which I’m not the biggest fan of on rap albums
Its hard to pinpoint the true apex of rap, because it seems like its been on apex mountain for the last 30 years. But this moment in rap is so good and so visceral. Just the fact that this record features: Jay-Z, Talib Kweli, COMMON, Jamie Foxx, Ludacris and Mos Def??? That's like getting The Highwaymen all together to make a couple songs. I love the production on this one. I love the rhymes and lyrics. I love the way that Ye weaves the music and lyrics throughout the album. It all flows so well together in terms of themes and sound. This era of Kanye is so good. It kind of has a pop punk element to it, where its rough around the edges but still pretty easy to groove to. Its such a shame that Ye went the way he did. He really did create some incredible records.
I'm not gonna listen to Kanye
Como me jode que sea un nazi, pero bueno no he escuchado casi nada de este disco a si que imaginare que estoy en el pasado y este hombre sigue cuerdo, tampoco me parece un discazo de temazos, pero en general esta bien.
I just can't believe the same dude who made these songs is now a Hitler praising edgelord. God, what a waste. What the hell happened, Kanye?
WHAT TF HAPPENED KANYE?
Excellent
Songs were good, don't care about skits
A cunt and absolutely horrible person but good beats
Could be the greatest rapper ever but just sounds like an album full of ramblings. Not for me this one.
His politics and views aside, this is perhaps one of the biggest piles of crap I have ever heard. It was painful to finish. A resounding 0 stars if I could
I'd never heard a Kanye album before, and now isn't the time to start really! That said, I still listened. What a damn shame. Some excellent tracks.
This is not my favorite Kanye album, its also not perfect (breathe in breathe out is not as great as many others and the skits get tiring on multiple listens), but it's still an amazing time. Incredible production, innovative bars and tracks. This album paved the way for so many new rappers that wanted to tell different stories. Honestly most kanye albums should be on this list due to influence alone, but im Happy that at least this one made it
nope. Don't get it. Can't see what's so interesting about him at all. In fact a couple of the tracks are WTF?
Nope.
Kanye’s off the fucking rails but college dropout was an incredibly solid first album. What a way to drop and establish yourself as a rapper.
Not his best album. Couple bangers, but uneven. Talent is there. Too bad he’s now nuts
Ye is an out of touch, likely literally insane, Nazi and he sucks. Let's get that out of the way up top. At this point in his career though, he was just an unsuccessful narcissist who finally broke big and what a hell of a break it was. I missed this when it dropped, but his next album Graduation, is what finally made me understand hip hop. While that particular project aged poorly, this one holds up and then some. Last Call overstays but it's the only weak track. Everything else is just so fun and well produced. How can you hate on "She got a black friend, look like Michael Jackson. She got a white friend, look like Michael Jackson."? Is that line dumb as hell, yes. But is it also fun, yes. I don't stream Ye anymore even though I love his music. Glad I had the excuse with this project and sad that he's ruined himself.
Muy buen disco, no había escuchado ninguno tan antiguo de Kanye.
I needed an excuse to listen to this album because it's not my favorite Kanye album and I rarely revisit it, especially because of how long it is. I was excited that this was the album of the day giving me the excuse I needed. But relistening to the album my experience was aligned with my expectations, and I feel justified I am hesitant to listen to this without an excuse. After spending time as a producer hidden behind the curtain, Kanye's ego forced it's way out in a debut album that solidified him as one of the greatest rap producers of all time, and kicked off his career as the rapper unafraid to write the corniest lyrics of all time. College Dropout is a sneak peek into everything Kanye will do in the future: an album that drags on, music where I get bored and irritated wanting it to end, songs with stand out production, songs with surprising instrumentals and excellent production that I never noticied before when listening closely, Kanye showing his genius in good ability to know who to collaborate with to make a song really stand out, Kanye lyrics being annoying, Kanye lyrics being clever, Kanye lyrics being funny. However, I'm at my happiest when the album is finally done and I can move on to something else. Rating 4 stars because 3 is an injustice to Kanye's production.
I rarely listen to College Drop Out, and I have to observations reflecting on this album as the origin of his later works: 1) The production value has been strong since day 1. Without context, you'd think that the success of this album was driven by the producer collabs with the top artists of the day (Jay-Z, Mos Def, Jamie Foxx). But in context, you know that he got those collabs because they respected his talent so much. 2) The hard-to-look-away guilty pleasure characterized by Kanye's blend of wittiness and griminess on his overtly sexual songs that make up like half of Yeezus are marginally evolved versions of songs like New Workout Plan. Transitioning from recalls to his mom's involvement in the civil rights movement to calls for women using sex to strengthen their core to making a joke about michael jackson's skin color and landing on a sex -> rapping speed to introduce Twista is maybe the best representation of Ye as a polarizing figure. Some highlights here but ultimately too long and too cringe, 3.5 rounded up
I wrote a whole thing for this, but I didn't post it and I don't feel like rewriting it. The short is I've always been fascinated by religious themes in Kanye's music, the skits are actually good, and this has some killer tracks. Within the universe of Kanye's work, this is maybe 4 stars, but by broader standards, I think that's a 5. It's a little long, and I can get a little touchy about how much he's anti-education here (granted, I get a lot of what he's after, but this is my world...), but I'm broadly on board.
In retrospect, we all probably should have seen the line "The prettiest people do the ugliest things" as Kanye foreshadowing the turns he's taken in the past decade. This album though is fantastic, a near masterpiece that reminds me of why Kanye rose to fame and was EVERYWHERE in pop and rap in the mid-and late-00s. He was a great rapper who knew what he was doing with a unique and interesting sonic brand.
Kanye spends an entire 12 minute track at the end of this album talking about how he’s more than a producer and how hard he worked to prove he was a rapper and not just a huge talented beat maker. The entire rest of this album is proof that he absolutely was not ready for an album. Cause his beats are great, but god his bars stink to holy hell.
Too bad he is a nazi because this album is great.
Truly great
Absolute certified masterpiece without a single miss, and anyone who says otherwise is just trying to rewrite history. This was the beginning of one of the best five record runs in music history: College Dropout, Late Registration, Graduation, 808s and Heartbreak, and My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. It's a shame that Kanye then immediately decided to take his millions of dollars and retire to live happily ever after with his beautiful wife and children, and disappeared from the public eye permanently to never be heard from again. Really a shame, but at least he left as a well-respected musician with an entirely uncontroversial legacy. Am I right? AMIRITE?!
Fuck kanye West, die slow Nazi motherfucker. Not listening to his bullshit. 0/5 Instead, I listened to The Fame Monster (2009) by Lady Gaga. This should have been on the list anyway, so let's dance on Kanye's grave, baby. Essentially a deluxe edition of The Fame with an EP attached, there are an insane amount of hits: Just Dance, LoveGame, Paparazzi, Poker Face, Bad Romance, Alejandro, Dance in the Dark, Telephone. What more do you need from a debut?! There are a few superfluous tracks towards the end of The Fame that could have been cut that are holding it back from being perfect, but that's the only minor note I have. I love this album, I love Lady Gaga, and cannot wait to see her next weekend at MSG. 4.5/5
own
Musically 5 As a human though -5
"we wasn't supposed to make it past 25 Jokes on you we still alive" classic. enough said.
Again would have been 4.4 if he Kurt cobained it but alas no. Why did 00s rap albums love having a bunch of skits in. Also last call is just a bit of a ramble. Guess this was the warning signs of his rants later on. Specific rating - 0.0 Fav song- all falls down Least fav- last call
Will not listen x
Great beats, funny lyrics
Separating the art from the artist on this one.
I remember buying this when it came out. Lots of reviews said is was revolutionary, a masterpiece. I didn't get it then and I still don't get it now. The College Dropout is a bland, self indulgent album, finishing with a twelve minute track that is just Kanye talking about how he got signed (he had to assemble his own Ikea bed - the horror!). I didn't absolutely hate it, and I'm not going to dock marks for his increasingly bizarre behaviour, but this album is a two star album at best.
Graduating to new music, nice to hear some early to peak Kanye beats back when he wasn’t as crazy.
4/5 bangers!
bored
lot of variety in soundscape and the type of songs Favorite track: slow jamz other picks: all falls down, spaceship, jesus walks, through the wire
i miss the old kanye
Listening to this album I decided I was going to separate the art from the artist. I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the album. Honestly, he was hungry for success, desperate for a win. The beats were pretty diverse, which is such a breath of fresh air in the day and age. I also enjoyed how vulnerable he was at times. That was my biggest surprise of all. Before this album all I knew was the ego and the insane public displays. I understand a bit more how that came to be now
pas mal mais je dirais pas un classique
Ça me coûte de le dire mais c’est un super album Musiques cools, vraie structure d’album C’est très très bon
West is an antisemitic, homophobic, racist, misogynist. So 0⭐️ for the person. But back when this came out, it was my jam! I listened to it on repeat. So sad that I can’t enjoy what this music once was. 4⭐️ for the music (if you can separate it from the artist). On balance, I will give this 2⭐️ and no listens.
Great album - with some very cutting and still relevant social commentary. 3 starts because some songs were meh but overall great hooks, lyrics and super creative.
Pas forcement mon style
Good start to the Kanye story. I prefer the next 4 albums as he really got into his stride IMO. But this one is decent, glimpses of what's to come, both his positive genius and also his insecurity and issues.
Nope
Great rap album, I wish Kanye didn’t go insane
A man that would reach the apex brought down by society and his own undoing.
Nice listening to Kanye's earlier music. More rappy and happier than I'm used to hearing him. Some songs hints at what's to come, genre wise. Not bad at all.
Some quality beats and funny lines, but I don't feel the quality is consistent through out the album which is a fair downside when the album is well over an hour long. I don't find the skits enjoyable either. When it's good though, the beats are fantastic to listen to, the production is great and Kanye's flow is fantastic.
Not listening out of principal
Not listening to this shit.
Good music yes. Crappy and despicable human being, even more so.
If I'm being purely objective, this is an absolutely phenomenal album, although it always makes me sad to revisit Kanye after everything that's happened over the last 5-10 years. That said, this album is a masterpiece and is still so so easy to listen to, even after so many of this album's contemporaries sound incredibly dated. The only thing about this album that's aged poorly are the skits (which every rapper decided to do in every album for 2003-2007 for some horrible reason) and the guy singing them. Other than that, this album is incredible, especially considering that this is his FIRST ALBUM. Insane.
Kayne West can suck a bag of dicks, I'm not wasting my time listening to anything from him. I would have given zero stars if I could.
Mixed emotions.
Musical Yenius
-Not my fav Kanye album (Late Registration) or his best (MBDTF) but is it his most cohesive? I think it's definitely in the running since the pitched-up soul samples and themes of consumerism, the struggle of African Americans and trying to find meaning in the modern world throughout -Not a lot of skips! But defeintely a few (the skips yes but also a few tracks) -Man that Twista verse on Slow Jamz still takes off like a fuckin rocket, huh?
Kanye, you mad genius. ✅✅✅ All Falls Down ✅✅✅✅ Spaceship ✅✅✅ Jesus Walks ✅✅✅✅ The New Workout Plan ✅✅✅ Last Call
This album is so nostalgic for me, but also still feels so current - like it could have come out today and had the same impact. I've revisited this album many times and stopped once Kanye became so undeniably problematic and scary. Relistening to it yesterday brought back all of the joy and fun I had with this album - it's like one big R&B, hip hop party with everyone coming in and out and doing their thing (I will always love a Jamie Foxx appearance). This is a 4.5 for me, but I'm giving it a 4 only because I think 'Graduation' is tighter and better....but this is still a stunner.
I thought Kanye sucked before it was cool
Ugh i can't (never liked this album)
Unfortunately incredible
sense memories of college activated. tougher and tougher to rank these Kanye records in lieu of recent events but in all subjective objectivity- this still throws down.
boycotting nazis
Not for me
o kurde belek to był dobry album fav track- roses/touch the sky
I remember when this album debuted, mostly thanks to Slow Jamz and Through the Wire. It sounded so unique compared to other hip-hop albums and still does. Kayne before Kayne Kayne'd. 3.5 stars
Wasn’t a huge fan when it was released. Have always enjoyed “Through the Wire” & “ All Falls Down”. What we know now about Kayne it’s hard for me to separate his personality from his art… I would say 3.5
The skits on this need more appreciation they're fucking hilarious 4*
I'm not going to downvote this JUST because Kanye is a piece of shit (though it's hard to not let it influence my listen). Everybody already knows that. I'm downvoting this because it's just musical gibberish. The production has nothing unique or special that draws me in. The lyrics mostly sound like unrelated nonsense crammed together to force a rhyme. No idea why this guy was ever considered a "genius".
Sometimes people are the worst can do good things. This album is good. He absolutely sucks as a human, hes utter scum and I dont listen to him for pleasure now, not one bit. Never let me Down is the highlight. Family Business is good. The singles are great. Too many skits, too long I cant stress this enough; fuck kanye. 4/5
I’m assuming the title is autobiographical which makes a lot of sense given his uneducated views… stay in school kids!
The album is better than the rating. Much better. But I can’t separate the art from the artist when he’s still actively destroying his legacy and hurting people.
I'm not the biggest Kanye fan, I'd never heard this album all the way through and some of these songs are a part of my childhood memories, so it's nice to put context to them. I've always thought Kanye was a better producer than rapper, and even though he shows some impressive rap stunts, I don't find it redeemable in general. I'm picky. I don't find the album has maintained a futuristic style, though it does have its own sound and it stands out as iconic. I do feel nostalgia, I do feel 00's retro. I would not put this on my regular rotation, but the production work is something I can't deny (if not occasionally overproduced), and would be happy to give it a listen if anybody suggests playing the record.
Sigh. Had to find a random upload of this album on YouTube to avoid giving this guy any money, since I've never actually sat through one of his albums. Pretty clear he's always been full of himself, because this album is way too long. Anyway, I've never been super interested in him, but he's got some zingers in the lyrics, and he's incredibly influential, so a very conflicted 3* from me.
A surprisingly deep glimpse into Kanye to come. The left field gospel is all there, all the desperate measures to appeal to the current hip-hop mainstream is there. The shocking thing is how great of an ALBUM this is. It builds interests, and gets better as it goes along. Even the weaker songs provide something different, something interesting, and it all moves things along. Yes, Kanye is a lunatic now. In a lot of ways, he was a lunatic. But damn, he's a creative force in this era. 4 stars only because it's a bit pandering, and I know what's coming.
Nazi rappers, fuck off!
Ganske så chill, mer religiøst enn jeg kunne huske
Felt like a lot of filler.
First time I have listened to one of his albums. It’s okay, probably won’t listen to it again
First and foremost FUCK Kanye West!! Now excluding his punk ass, this album is one of the best in hip hop history. It set off a whole new generation of rap and it stands on its own as far as uniqueness goes. The man behind it may have strayed far away from this version of himself but at least he left us with this classic. Kanye gets a 1 but College Dropout can never be below a 5, we’d be lying to ourselves.
It’s hard to revisit this one without all the baggage, but damn… The College Dropout is hands down one of the greatest debut albums of all time. ‘Jesus Walks’ alone is a revelation — bold, spiritual, revolutionary. And then there’s ‘All Falls Down’, ‘Through The Wire’, ‘Spaceship’ — classics, front to back. The songs are there, the features are there, his ego’s already there, but it’s fuelled by hunger — not yet warped by fame or delusion. There’s humility in the delivery, even when he’s flexing. It’s self-aware, soulful, and sonically rich. Whatever came later, this album still stands. A stand-up classic that changed hip hop, and I hope Ye listens a bit closer to this stuff again.
Y'know, not my favorite Kanye album. As is the case with most of his albums, I do enjoy the humor and the beats.
I hate the guy, but this album is fucking good
Trash.
This takes me back. Couldn't let my kids listen to it (yet), but I do like it.
Aivan liikaa aikaa taas annettu Kanyelle. Pidän kyllä taustoista. Uhoa on toistaiseksi sopivasti tässä. Mutta nääh.
Maybe I don’t have the context as to why this is seen as so groundbreaking but it did nothing for me.
Nope
unfortunately need to admit this is good as days need mfs to stop acting like not going to college is a personality trait though
I went into this album honestly expecting something awful. The other music of Kanye that I’d heard sounded like the auditory equivalent of having somebody urinate straight into my ears, so naturally I wasn’t filled with hope for the album. Kanye’s personality also makes him a pretty unlikeable person too, which adds to this low expectation. However, as much as I may have wanted to dislike it, I couldn’t help but to really enjoy this. The music is pretty great, mixing hip hop with lots of old soul music. The lyrics were actually really good for the most part. I wanted to hate this. I actually quite love it. It’s just too long to give a perfect score.
Groundbreaking album. Solidified him as a superstar producer, but introduced the works to his unique flow and, somewhat ironically at this point, his down to earth lyrics that connected with young adults of all races and sexes. As a college dropout in 2004 this one resonated with me and is a bit of a time capsule piece for me.
3.5.
Surprised again. I've never listened to Kanye before this list, and now I get to enjoy another album of his. Can't argue the dude has talent, and it shows through again on this. Amazing beats, entertaining storytelling. Just a solid album.
This album makes you think about the trials and tribulations of inner city life in Chicago and in America. Iconic debut b4 the crazy came out! Collaborating with hip hop’s greatest rappers. Several hits songs in one album. Skits are Crazy, stupid, and hilarious!
Back when Kanye just made fun music
I can't give a literal Nazi anything other than one star. If he wasn't so repugnant, I'd give this a 3. It's fine, it's nothing amazing.
Damn, I miss old Kanye. This album dropped in my early twenties, right around the time when I realized that mainstream hip hop isn’t all bullshit, and was vibing on Jay-Z after seeing him perform with the Roots on MTV Unplugged. Kanye was hitting his stride in a big way after contributing to Jigga’s best album, The Blueprint, with his signature sped-up soul sound. I have this clear memory of coming home to our house in Greeley and being handed a joint and the GameCube controller because Alan and Zakis were trying to ace a hard-mode Grand Prix on Mario Kart, and needed me for Rainbow Road. The soundtrack was College Dropout, an album equivalent of this shiny candy kaleidoscope featuring (to bite the cover of Piñata) everyone in the rap game worth fucking with. This album isn’t perfect, but it’s damn near. Kanye is not the best rapper, but his goofy bars and delivery are endearing. Listening to this on vinyl is the optimal experience, because the dumb skits are not included, and the last two corny songs are on Side 4. Sides 1-3 are all killer no filler non-stop hit after hit. It unbelievable that all of this pure gold is on one record. It all seems effortless, and a great example of someone who has just been waiting to get a record deal so they could show the world what they’ve been working on and honing their whole life so far. My intellectual brain knows that “My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy” is Kanye’s masterpiece, his should be Pulitzer Prize winner. But the other side of my brain, the one that feels that rush of dopamine when that perfect sunny day vibe hits just right, knows that this is the zenith. Donda West was still alive, Kanye survived a near fatal car crash, and he’s just so happy to be alive and making this music.
Funny follow up after Be, this is an undisputed classic
This had some good instrumentals and I can see why people liked Kanye a lot before. There was some catchy moments but again I'd never listen to this willingly.
I would have thought this inventive and fresh when I was in 4th grade, but now it seems repetitive and uninspired (regardless of how much I’m expected to gush over it).
Brilliant production and lyrics but….its Kanye. Can he Nazi why someone wouldn’t like his music? It’s hard to separate the art and the artist sometimes.
I'm pretty sure I actually liked this a lot when I first heard it, but I'm not going to bother listening to it again to see if that's still the case. Rating it as close to my hip hop average as possible so the fact that Kanye is an actual Nazi doesn't hurt the entire genre too much in my ratings.
*The world's largest sigh* Well I can't say I didn't know this one was coming. Just thinking about rating this album is giving me a headache. Kanye is, and will always be, one of the most important people in the history of hip-hop. From his production to his themes to what he raps about, no one was doing it like him and it completely changed the artistic direction of a whole genre, and honestly popular Western music as a whole. But yeah you don't need me to be the one to tell you he's a complete piece of shit, on a level few have touched in modern times. He's the ultimate test of separating the art from the artist. Even writing this review right now my mind is split between a 1 star and 5 star review. Fuck. Talking just music for a second this is my favorite Kanye album. Sure the skits are dated and there are the typical Kanye-isms in the lyrics but as an atheist, goddamn if "Jesus Walks" isn't one of the best songs of all time. Not to mention "Through the Wire", "Spaceship" and "All Falls Down". Call it a cop out but I'm going to split the middle on this. 10/10 for the music 1/10 for the dude. 5/10 Edit: I've had a few hours to think about it. I also looked ahead since I guessed there would be other Kanye albums on the list, and I was right. Since they didn't put Gradation (the other near perfect album from him) on the list, but put on the overrated MBDTF and meh Yeezus I think I'm going to give this one a good score. Pleanty of people on this list has done terrible, possibly worse things. IDK don't hate me. 9/10
Bueno, movido y da sensación de estar en NY
👎👎👎
Kanye West is like reggaeton but in English. I want this to end. What the fuck was with that salad song? It disgusts me to think someone thought to put this on the list. Some tracks at least had critiques of the education system but were trying to be cool (“Two Words”), but the whole time I felt like I was sifting through shit to see if I could come up with something nice to say.
Ikke ulidelig å høre på, men fryktelig overrated.
I wish he was a musical dropout.
Some great tracks, some blah. Recognize that he influenced hip hop. Doesn't mean all the tracks are good. Removing a star b/c he's a bad person.
Although its very bloated and you do really have to separate the art from the artist here, I enjoyed quite a lot.
This is *the* early 2000s hip-hop album.
Before the Nazism
God conscious rap. Det er jo Kanye West og det er hans debut album og det er virkelig godt. Det har sådan en Old School hip hop over sig og det er tydeligt at høre hvad han synger. Kan godt lide teksterne og flowet.
If there's an artist I wanna think about less, it's probably Kanye with his endless horrible shenanigans but despite that this is the album I got and well... I didn't hate it, I didn't love it either, it was a good album in all the ways you'd expect a rap album from the mid 00s to be, except that the skits are actually kinda funny and not just useless to the album. I guess if anything part of why I didn't like it more is that most songs just kinda went in one ear out the other, the production is cool but it didn't stand out to me like hip hop most often does, and I don't think it's negative feelings about Kanye making it difficult to like, but I guess I don't find Kanye's style of production here all that appealing (but ig we'll see about other albums) As a whole, good album but not one I care for much
3 1/2 I can’t stand Kanye but this is a good album.
Yah you’re not getting my attention when you praise hitler and nazis. Especially when that is becoming a bigger problem everyday. Even if this music was good (which it’s not, it’s mediocre at best) this album and all of his music is now an echo chamber for hate and ignorance to grow. There shouldn’t even be a “well he’s a terrible person, BUT….” Like but what? He’s a mentally ill narcissist with too much money and exposure. Only bummed I couldn’t give negative stars.
nope
Insert throat clear about Kanye qua Kanye blah blah blah this slaps idc
A few enjoyable songs, but I really don't want to touch this one. Any merit that this album gained in 2004 has been overshadowed by his later reprehensible behaviour, so is it worth even talking about the album? How can you possibly critique an early '10's painting by Hitler? Same deal here. F--- Nazis, and especially those self-proclaimed Nazis. The less said, the better.
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die: 4/1001 Extremely real and relatable over a decade later. To get the full experience '1001 Albums to Hear Before You Die' lays out, I'm putting myself in the mindset of when the album was released rather than thinking about it in the context of today. With that in mind, this is the album that led to the Kanye of the 2000s, gave him the fame we all came to know him for, and there's no denying he was deserving of it then. I thoroughly enjoyed this more than I thought I would. A bit long (ending on a 12-minute track is certainly a statement, though) There are many songs here that I could come back to, and some I could've lived without. But overall, the beats are catchy, the songs are real, and the lyrics are deep. It's fun and serious at the same time. There are memorable verses that I was awaiting even after a first listen. Its highs are some of the best of rap, its lows are completely forgettable though they don't diminish the album much overall. It's a strong showcase for an artist clobbering his way to the scene. 'We Don't Care' is the precipitate for who Kanye was at this time, and it was the perfect opening track for this album. It's an introduction to him and the thematic elements this album is shaped around. The album may be titled 'The College Dropout,' but Kanye schooled the industry with this release. Podium: 1. All Falls Down 2. We Don't Care 3. Slow Jamz Honorable Mention(s): 'The Wire' -- While not a podium song for me personally, it's an important track for the album overall, and as I understand it, part of the reason for Kanye pursuing this album in general. The story behind The Wire is too powerful not to acknowledge in a review. It's a solid album, great even, with a decent amount of hits. Though there are skippable parts, the message here is equal parts meaningful and catchy, and it sticks to the theme outlined in the title. It's worthy of being on this list and demonstrates the new beginning of one of the most significant and controversial artists to enter (and change) the genre. For these reasons, I give The College Dropout by Kanye West 4/5 stars P.S. 'But the people highest up got the lowest self-esteem, the prettiest people do the ugliest things' in 'All Falls Down' is just so on the nose for current Kanye)
10/10 the goat
This is objectively good it’s just not my style
Cuando kayne west era bueno (dijo nadie nunca)
I miss the old Kanye Beats are fire, flow is sick, lyrics are very good. Not a 5 because it has a 13 minute final song of just talking
Типичный рэп новой волны, когда он перестал быть слушабельным, когда он плотно слился с РнБ и попсой, как в музыкальном, так и в текстовом плане. Это не ужас нынешних дней, но и слушать ради удовольствия здесь нечего.
Yo, Kanye, I'm really happy for your shit career, but Beyoncé and Taylor kick your lame ass.
Can't deny it's a great album, but can't rate appropriately with who he's become
Such an amazing album. The guy sucks ass but this is one of the best rap albums front to back.
Don't support nazis. Kanye does not deserve to be on anyone's "must hear" list.
Solid beginning up and down
This album is almost perfect! The songs are great front to back and have a good variety of sound. The skits are funny. I like the storytelling throughout the album on songs like through the wire and last call.
This was huge for me in college. It has held up, while Kanye himself has…not…
I just could not do it. His baggage is just too much for me and I can't get past that.
When I was younger in the late 2000s, I thought Kanye West was one of the greatest musicians ever, and while it wasn’t my favorite, I argued that The College Dropout was the best proof of this argument. I don’t think I need to re-write critical obsessive analysis of The College Dropout and explain why it was seen as groundbreaking. We all know why, if we’re here. But as a 15 year old smoking a one hitter in her Dad’s car before her after-school coffee shop job, The College Dropout felt revelatory, like sound as I had never heard it before. No Graduation, obviously, which was new and my gateway into Kanye obsession, but damn close. But now, nearly 2 decades after I first heard The College Dropout, I feel less enthusiastic. I’ve tried to revisit this album nearly 20 times since pausing this project for personal life reasons, assuming it should be an obvious, if nostalgic, 5-star review. I’ve told myself to pretend that the Kanye of the last decade is a different person, has no impact on this vital record. I know every note of this record like the back of my hand; I should be enjoying it without issue. But I just couldn’t. Sometimes, you grow out of an album. Also, sometimes, bad people make great art, but the seeds of what makes them a bad person– the holier-than-thou ego, the religiosity, the isolationism/judgement of other communities, the self-obsession, the anti-intellectualism, the obsession with riches at the cost of everything else– can still be found in that great art, at least in a seedling form. The harder I stared at The College Dropout, the more obvious it became that Kanye West has always been the same Kanye West…it was just a lot more buttoned-up back then. I found myself getting an ick the more I thought about the lyrics and themes here. I mean, sure, I might be a trans lapsed Catholic, so maybe I’m not the target audience, but there was a time when I at least appreciated this, even as a nerdy white “boy.” Plus, eventually, all groundbreaking music becomes dull and passé. I still think the production on here is great, but given the runtime, once you figure out the schtick, the whole album starts to feel stylistically dull. It’s also a long album, with a lot of songs that were only ever good, even upon release, but the highs were so high, you forgave the mid. Now, the highs are lower but the mid is the same, making it a more even yet still exhausting sit-through. I may also be looking at this in the rearview, since Late Registration is basically a 2.0 version of this and really wears the style thin; I’m sure anyone hearing this for the first time would still be blown away, but if not, it’s definitely become a bit more boring than timeless. And last, but not least, I think sometimes, when you know every note of an album from your youth but may have not continued to carry that album with you into new chapters in your life for whatever reason (and we all know why with Kanye), a revisit isn’t a homecoming, but more a redundant, passive, obligatory revisit, as if you’re having a drink with a high school friend you no longer have much in common with and frankly will never talk to again. For me, all of these elements combined together to create a difficult listen, and one I can’t really assess without also checking my baggage in the loading dock. The College Dropout is still an essential album, especially on a list like this, and it is still largely a great album. If this is your first time hearing this, you really are about to experience something so cold, but even then, it won’t be as revelatory as it was in the mid-2000s, that’s for sure. I found when I just had this on in the background while I was running errands or working, I was more inclined to bop along with it, passively engaging with the nostalgic memorized grooves and words, but if I gave it an attentive listen, I wanted to turn it off. Some songs still work for me because they’re just great or pure camp: “New Workout Plan,” “We Don’t Care,” “Family Business,” “Slow Jamz,” and “Through the Wire” are all amazing, and I can stomach them because they’re songs I have continued to listened to, detached from the Kanye West of it all. But on the whole, the flaws stand out, and the future flaws stand out even more. In short? It’s no Graduation, but it’s still important, but not as important as it felt back then.
I didn't like it at all but this not my cup of tea music genre 's wise
Top to bottom great album. Don't like them man behind the music, but that's a different issue.
same vibe as good kid, mAAd city
I miss this Kanye. What a killer debut album.
All the bullshit aside, this is a pretty great album.
Good on every metric.
No
Great album. Questionable person nowadays. (41 known/87 new)
setting aside kanye's politics and awful behavior (which you shouldn't), this album just isn't very good. frequent dated and unfunny jokes, bloated runtime, proto-Hamilton delivery, take your pick, this is just annoying to listen to.
Chulo pero largo
Unfortunately soooo goood??? To paraphrase Glee-- He may be difficult, but boy can he rap hahah (4 because of the artist, 5 if it was someone else)
no comment 8/10
Been a while since I listened to this in full - Kanye used to be genuinely funny and brilliant and such a tonic to the Bling Era of rap. Such a shame listening knowing how it’s all ended.
Found an old mp3 copy of this so I didn’t have to fuck up my algorithm with a listen.
I loved Kanye's first solo release. It soundtracked my junior year of high school and inspired me to pick-up music production. After listening to it for the first time in a long while, it's easy to poke holes in it's classic status. Musically, it's hard to diminish the monumental impact his production style had on hip-hop. In an era when super-producers like Dr. Dre, Timbaland, and The Neptunes were carving out new sonic landscapes for popular music, Kanye leaned into sample-heavy production styles popularized in the mid-90s that were falling quickly out of fashion, replaced by production that relied less on samples and more on traditional musicianship. His nascent, brimming talent for production is the album's strongest quality — not only did he have great, unconventional taste in samples, but from the onset he was a prolific collaborator, an aspect of his music that only grew in scale with subsequent releases. The same goes for his braggadocios, corny lyrics, stacked features list, and plentiful skits. He covers topics like materialism, religion, slavery, and personal struggles to attain success and fame with a sly smirk, always ready to deploy a tacky metaphor or pretentious posture, a tendency that unfortunately entrenched itself with successive albums. A highlight lyrically is the HBC through-line embedded within the plentiful skits. Kanye highlighted an aspect of black culture for the mainstream that many non-blacks were unaware of, and executed it in a way that amusingly knit-together the dropout theme. And the features only cemented his elevated-status as hip-hop's most enigmatic, dynamic producer: he effortlessly acquired excellent verses from a who's-who of both underground and mainstream rap. Before Kanye it seemed impossible to imagine Jay-Z and Common on the same album, titans of their respective above-and-below ground domains respectively. Kanye also effectively launched John Legend's widely-successful career. This album is still fun to listen to, and not because of it's nostalgic importance to me. The joyous tone is felt throughout, his sped-up soul samples and playful bars are infectious, and you're rooting for the self-proclaimed underdog he was then. While Kanye covers deeper concepts, his ultimate goal then was to make you smile and nod your head, and because fame had not-yet corrupted and inflated his ego he actually wanted people to respect and like him, and he made sure you knew of his genuine intentions to earn that acceptance. From that point on though, Kanye obsessed over and widely-expressed how he felt his greatness was not fully recognized, and that viewpoint calcified and soured year after year, eventually leading to his rapid decline in the mid 2010s. The end result of such unchecked pride and power is a delusional, unshakeable belief in one's supremacy, and Kanye thought — and still thinks — Kanye reigns supreme. As he would say on a subsequent album, "no one man should have all that power". Ultimately Kanye succeeded at what he strove to do with College Dropout: he took the template of classic mid-to-late 90s hip-hop records and retuned it for a wider pop audience. He succeeded wildly, and he nurtured his initial fame and success, planting seeds that ultimately would grow too large for his roots to bare, unearthing and toppling his eventual greatness. "The Old Kanye" oft-discussed by himself and his day-one fans alike never existed in full. The Kanye West we know today was always there just beneath the surface, a significant slice of his personality pie — but he revealed that true self in measured, sporadic ways. His fame turned to infamy too quickly, and I can't help but wonder what kind of Kanye we'd have today if he had the wherewithal and communal support to address his demons and take control over his mental health earlier in his life. Another truly great, generational artist who grappled with fame and fortune and ultimately lost, forfeiting his legacy for one painful headline after another. The eroded, polarized state of his fanbase is as bipolar as his diagnosis: you either worship or disdain him, all nuance stripped away by his extreme declarations and actions. As someone who shares a bipolar diagnosis with him, I'm all to familiar with the symptoms and tendencies at play here, and I truly hope he does the immense work necessary to earn the trust and respect his creative legacy undoubtedly deserves.
0/5 person but pretty good album.
Did not expect to vibe to this as much as I did given that I only know this man from memes, meltdowns, and South Park. Shout-out to the school spirit skits. My degrees will SURELY keep me warm when I'm dead!
Fun album!
Definitely not my genre of choice, and the guy is a massive prick but some of it I quite enjoyed other parts I didn’t. Will probably never listen to it again just because of him and what he says and does.
I means its college dropout 4.5 stars and i rmbr listening to this in highschool for the first time he changed my broke ass life
Kanye is a POS, but you can’t deny that he made incredible music
Pretty consistent but doesn't hit the same highs that would be reached on Late Registration, may drag a bit late but picks up a little by the end, overall a hopeful debut for perhaps the greatest artist in hip-hop Sucks what's happened to his life and the person he's become, the soul he once had will remain immortalized
Based purely on the music this album is an absolute banger. So many great songs on it, the only thing I don't love is the skits and general length - could have been a lot tighter IMO. Kanye did an amazing job with both the production and the rapping on this, I think the work as a whole came out really special due to him having complete creative control of the vision. Not many artists can do both so well. Unrelated to the album content: I've been a fan of Kanye's music for a long time but it is getting more embarrassing to be a fan given how far off the deep end he has gone. It was easier to write off egotistical and brash sound bites, but the recent move towards hate speech made me listen to this one with the windows up and seek streaming on sources that would not contribute to his bottom line. 10/10
We're going to have to do some separating the artist from the art to review this one. This is one of the best albums ever, and I don't think it would be an overstatement to say that it changed hip-hop. This era of Kanye is stacked with hilarious and often touching emotional lyrics, delivered on top of incredible soul beats. The story of this era of Kanye's life is crazy. This man had everything he did during the production of this album recorded by Coodie because he was THAT sure he was going to be famous. "We Don't Care" immediately introduces you to the fullness of who Kanye is at this point. The production is lively and loud, there's a kid's chorus singing in the background, and the bars are amazing. 'We wasn't supposed to make it past twenty-five'. "Graduation Day" is a funny skit that turns into some sweet production. You think the skits over and then the beat and autotuned vocals come in. "All Falls Down" is a legendary song. A lot of the lyrics are about a personal (and black-american) self consciousness that is covered up by materialism. He revisits that idea a lot in the next ten years, but he never becomes less materialistic. Even in the 'New Slaves' era, the man was selling $400 egyptian cotton t-shirts. "Spaceship" is the first song that I don't love. It's a great song but not quite my taste. The samples are nice though. "Jesus Walks" is one of his most famous songs ever. He wanted to write a song that would bring jesus into the club, and he sure as hell did it. The documentary, if I'm recalling correctly, has scenes of him making assistants of music executives listen to this song. They do not look impressed. "Never Let me Down" has great lyrics but is less captivating than the other songs heard so far. This is an 'OK' song on this record and might be a highlight on many other artists'. "Get Em High" really highlights his versality in beat-making. This song is pretty different from the others that came so far. "The New Workout Plan" has maybe not kept up with the times with regards to body image, but it is a funny song. The beat change into the 'daft punk' style section is sweet. I don't really like "Slow Jamz" personally, not quite my speed. "Breathe In Breathe Out" is another miss for me. This stretch from "Slow Jamz" to "Two Words" is the most missable part of the album for me, but I'm sure other people love it. Mos Def goes hard on "Two Words". "Through The Wire" is my second favorite song on the album. The story behind this song is wild. The beat is incredible. "Family Business" is my favorite song. The beat is so pleasant. This song I think paints the starkest contrast between who Kanye was in 2004 and who he is today. It genuinely makes me sad to listen to it. "Last Call" is fun and endearing. 10/10
Kanye’s best album
If you're conflicted about listening to this antisemitic, misogynistic piece of poop, this album is off the list now, so you don't have to! Give it a swerve, deprive this Hitler fan boy of his royalties! ***** 0 ⭐ *****
Another great album from a time before Kanye went insane. Very honest, reflective. Tongue in cheek humour. Overall a great hip hop record but it had too many skits that didn't have to be there.
I just don’t get it
this was good, i fuck with it
This album, along with Late Registration and Graduation got me into hip hop and listening to music in general. A great introduction to the genre. Some of Kanye's best rapping, and all the samples with the chipmunk soul production is so good. Last Call is long but worth listening to. I will say some of the skits are kind of corny, and tracks 13 through 17 are a weak spot on the album for me. Obviously Kanye is off his rocker now but listening to the college dropout trilogy makes his current persona feel all the more disappointing and frustrating.
7/10 - Kanye music is good but Kanye person is bad
Really is a shame he completely lost it. Would give it a five if it weren’t Kanye
Feeding me this the day he beat the sex trafficking charges? Hard no.
Fuck Kanye, Fuck Nazis, and Fuck anyone who supports any of this fascist shit that's going on right now.
I have a hard time separating the Kanye of today from the Kanye of the past. While I have enjoyed some of his music, I have very much felt he was always on the overrated ride. 3.5/5
first 4 kanye albums among the best of all time - what happened?
I liked this album quite a bit. I try not to hold the character or actions of the artist against their art, but Kanye has definitely made that harder than usual, though some of that's certainly recency bias. All that said,, this album holds up quite well. It's satirical, smart, and funny, with some pretty catchy tracks to boot. 3/5 (can't help but think I'd be inclined to give it a 4 if he stopped making music and being in the public eye around 2010)
sorry 4.5
Didn't really enjoy this, but I don't think it's bad at all
This album dropped when I was 14 (this was a painful sentence to write) and I was immediately obsessed. It was (is?) one of the seminal albums of my youth. Kanye West was a breath of fresh air at a time when hardcore Gangsta Rap was dominant. As a white kid attending boarding school, I couldn't relate to 50's bacchanal of violence, drugs and more violence. But, I could relate to the themes that Kanye West tackles on 'The College Dropout.' Religion (I was raised with a complicated religious background), family (I had a complicated family) and self-consciousness (I was - and still am - a deeply self-conscious child). It holds up, 21 years later. It is, if anything, even better than it was 21 years ago. It sounds, to me, how Hip-Hop SOUNDS and it's one of the greatest albums of all-time. In general I believe that the art can be separated from the artist - this is easy to say as a theoretical exercise. But, I think it holds. As a music fan, I love this album and always will. As a music fan I respect Kanye's early genius. As a Jew...well, that's a more complicated conversation. Nevertheless, this is an easy 5 stars, always.
It's stupid how good this album is. Sucks that Kanye the person is so dogshit now.
Pretty good album, Kanye is so talented it's too bad he's insane now.
If only he had grown from this instead of becoming a Nazi.
*no music, just rap, filthy language.
This is a perfect example of needing to separate the artist from the art. The art is 5 stars. One of the best rap albums of its time. And I don’t like Kanye. At all. But this album has great tracks, a fun theme, and awesome collabs. I really enjoyed the final track, where a somewhat “humble” Kanye is new to the biz and telling his story. Even I am surprised to rate this 5 stars, but give credit where credit is due.
Ah, the days when Kanye or whatever the fuck he’s calling himself this week wasn’t bullying women, dressing head to toe in black, declaring himself a superhero one minute and a human being the next, posting anti-Semetic garbage and selling swastika T-shirts on X, doing nitrous oxide, and mentally and verbally abusing his “wife” by making her present herself as a scantily dressed mute in public. Simply put, fuck any idea of giving this SOB any more plays on social media. Despite six good albums in a row from this one to Yeezus, he isn’t worth the time and the attention anymore and I won’t even stream his better material anymore. He needs to be in a mental institution for the rest of his natural life.
No, just no
Great fuckin album by a real fuckin asshole
Fuck this nazi. I don’t care if the music this hateful solipsist made when young gives full body orgasms- I won’t listen to a fucking note of it. Wish I could give it -10000 stars.
Rating based on music and not the nazi piece of shit he became.
Hate the guy now, but objectively, a great album
Nice album, horrible guy
kayne at kanyes best
Can’t listen to this 💩
I miss the old Kanye
An absolute banger of a classic.
Not bad
I have no pleasure of listening to this.
Say what you will about the man, in fact I’ll say it: f*ck Kanye. But his music in this album is absolute bustastic. The production and the beats and variety of vibes and the skits and the 12 minute finale of just him telling his story of getting signed and stuff, like I could listen to him talk forever, it all combines to make one extremely solid hip hop album. It is really quite self evident why this man’s early work became so influential to so many who came after him and the entire future of the genre. So it really is a darn shame he went so far off the deep end.
Such a good start
An hour and 16 minutes!!! Never listened to this end to end. The skits are fun, the whole production is so cool. It's hard to like Kanye these days.
Star-Studded album with hilarious skits between songs. Come get the PHD for Free.99!
Wish this had half stars. Sick beats. Semi-positive Kanye before he went off the deep end.
Ugh.
I can admire his influence on the hip-hop genre, but this ultimately isn't something I'll come back to. Funnier than I expected.
Oh how the mighty have fallen. If only he had gotten some therapy, perhaps he wouldn't be a self proclaimed Nazi now. Anyway. This was a good album. Kind of sullied by how crap of a person he is now.
All his bs aside, it’s a pretty stunning album
wow i did nazi this coming when i first heard Kanye West over a decade ago!
A visionary, one of the best producers ever, his pen fresh but already sharp. It's a shame what has happened with him in the last couple of years.
Foi uma experiência estranha ouvir um álbum de uma figura que acho o comportamento e ideias desprezíveis. Achei o álbum mediano para ruim. E sei que provavelmente minha opinião sobre ele interferiu. QKZxHBB Hades.
Good album from a nazi.
fuck this guy
Sorry to all my Jewish friends but this is a 5
It wasn’t terrible, but it’s definitely not my favorite rap.
Fuck this guy
Bof. I kinda despise Kanye West's persona. But here I am, voting a 5 star album because this was supergood. I loved the beats, the concept and some lyrics were fun.
I Love that old Kanye
Kanye Goat West
Back when Kanye was a legit genius. Hip hop is no where near my thing, but I love this album. I’m taking two stars off because these days he is a legit psychopath
Tha shit is gud but bro is soo nazi that I gonna give 9/10
Not going to support him by listening to this
I refuse to hear a single second of an album made by human trash. Fuck Kanye West. Fuck Nazis.
This album is good. Not good enough to overcome Kanye as a person.
i miss the new old kanye, before he went stictly by ye kanye.. the black skinhead and pablo life kanye… this album aight tho
Pretty good, but really suffers with all the stupid skits. That would really hurt the re-listenability.
No thank you.
I was hoping not to like any part of this record... but I just can't dislike it. We Don't Care is a great song. All Falls Down is another great bop. Spaceship? Relatable. There's also some extra cringe stuff on here like "the new workout plan" and "breathe in, breathe out" Ending the album with a twelve minute nothing beat is certainly a choice. Listening to the lyrics here all about the disadvantage and institutional racism etc right throughout this album is kinda confronting, and it's easy to empathize with the themes of the day to day struggle of not having cash despite doing your best and working hard every day etc, but the problem is it all kinda falls flat when you realise where this guy ended up once he finally had the cash and success. Success that he couldn't have ever had without overcoming his early struggles. There's already a few signs of the impending spiral into being a nutso with Jesus Walks here, too. Kanye might have gone off the rails but goddamn could he make music.
First half was OK. Second half was pretty great, had some very well made and powerful songs.
Jesus walks best tune
Terrible. Awful. Garbage.
Years ago, after I first listened to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, I got on a brief Kanye kick. This album wasn’t on heavy rotation at that time, but revisiting it, I enjoyed it more than I remembered. There’s an innocence and playfulness to this album that feels bittersweet - maybe even outright sad - given how far its creator has fallen. It makes me nostalgic and almost in mourning of a simpler time in my own life as well; coincidentally, I first heard “Through The Wire” when I was spending a lot of time at the hospital visiting a close friend who had broken her jaw. There were lots of things going on back then, but hearing that song makes me miss that person and that time. I don’t know exactly where I come down on separating the art from the artist, and I’m sure I’m not even consistent. I still find this worth listening to, though. Favorites: Spaceship, Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down
I'm very sorry but it's very good until the last third. Never Let Me Down (bar Jay-Z) is the highlight.