Reviews (page 6 of 16)
Nope.
10
I like the art but not the artist
No
good and fun, -1 for Kanye
Pretty good, runs a little too long, a few too many fillers for me
even outside of being made by an unmedicated racist dweebazoid, this fucking blows. autotuned and uninteresting and way too long and whiny. dork shit by a dork, who'da thunk'd it
Shit. I mean, I was definitely biased coming in as a life-long Swiftie, and I will definitely say that that conditioned my listening experience. I absolutely despise him as a person, for many reasons, but you simply cannot deny his musical talent. I hate it when people say that, but in some cases, it is true. My favorites on first listen were Slow Jamz and Last Call (crazy last track btw, what do you mean this is 12 minutes long and he's simply talking for like half of it? Still enjoyed it though). I wouldn't say it is a life-changing album for me, but I did enjoy listening to it once. Probably will never listen to it again based on principle, but it was quite decent (could probably even say good)
Not bad not great,
basic and boring
Too bad I can never just listen to this album again. It’s fantastic.
Naravno, mnogi odmah daju kečeve. I ja to radim iz svojih principa, cionistima je kec iste sekunde. Ali Kanye je "samo" mentalni bolesnik. Imamo doslovne pedofile u top 20 albuma. Tu nismo dosljedni, kolektivno. Inače, ovo je jedina vrsta hip hopa koju skoro volim. Nije predosadno uprkos tome što traje predugo. Podnošljivo je sve. Edit: jedinica iz principa
Takes me back. Loved this album when it came out. Still holds up even though Ye is a d-bag.
I decided to put everything I think I know about Kanye West to the back of my mind to give this record a fair go but I really bloody hated it within the first three seconds. Once I got past that horrible narration, or whatever it is, and the music started, yeah, okay... it's not terrible. The music and the tunes were okay - the melodies are there and that's something I think is usually missing from hip-hop/rap records. It hasn't relieved me of my general disconnection with the genre but I didn't stamp on my laptop which is what I thought would happen. In fact, I listened to the whole thing and didn't hate it. Trust me, that's high praise. I didn't listen too closely to the lyrics - I suspect if I did, my rating would be adjusted downwards but I know I will never listen to this again, so let's move on.
I tried, I really did (twice), but this left me just... bored. I'll accept it's not a style of music that I know much about but this doesn't make me want to know any more...
As brilliant as I've known Kanye West to be, he's always been so obnoxious that I've avoided listening to his solo records. My opinion of Kanye West as a person hasn't changed after listening to The College Dropout, but I have to admit that this record is dope. Unsurprisingly, the best part of the album is the production. The music is incredible on virtually every track. The creativity and passion shown on this record are impressive enough that Kanye's massive ego is almost understandable, even if the record makes it no more palatable. On "Jesus Walks," he explicitly complains about how it's unacceptable to rap about spirituality and that his goal is to make people dance in clubs to his song about his spiritual journey. He composed the song with the complaint to achieve this goal, and he was successful. Everyone knows the story behind "Through the Wire," in which he uses his temporary disability (a broken jaw, wired shut) as texture in a song about the terrible car accident that caused it. That's the kind of unbridled energy and unstoppable motivation that can cause artists to create some of their best work, or fly too close to the sun and burn out. Add to that the fact that this record was only the beginning of an intense period of musical brilliance from Kanye West, and it's hard not to be seduced into the mythos that he believes about himself. Luckily for us, there are some serious flaws in The College Dropout as well. First, at an hour and fifteen minutes, it is far too long. Not only that, but it is obvious to me that the entire "School Spirit" and "Workout" sections could have been easily cut, making the album brilliant and tight instead of brilliant and sprawling. If it were tighter, I'd be more inclined to throw it on often in the future. As it is, though, I'll be happy to listen to any songs on this record, but I don't really want to listen to the whole thing. Four stars.
I wish Kanye wasn’t the mess he is
162/1001 Kanye West - The College Dropout Heard before? ✅ Revisit? ❎ No.
Not for me 1/5
nazi pos
I’m sure it probably deserves a place here but fuck Kanye and everything he has said. Not listening to this, no streaming revenue for this cunt.
*sigh* He sucks ass, but I have to say this album was pretty fun with all the skits. Althought the repetition of the lyrics 'Eat yo' salad skip dessert' is a HARD no from me. No diet culture on my watch! I'm also all for not everyone /needing/ to go to college, but uh, I don't think this strongly of an anti-adademic message is what the world needs right now... Tip if you don't want to give him streams: listen to lyric videos on youtube or sth.
Yes I know its Kanye. Some of the lyrics were so dumb they were funny but I vibed with the music, as I usually do with hip-hop. Good listen, saved a decent amount of songs to my playlist so a solid 4.
Can't stand the guy but this album has so many bangers. 3/5
A classic, one of the best albums around. It can't surpass other albums, though. And of course, it's another legendary album that people will remember (if you disregard his bad behavior).
Nope won't listen. No revenue for Kanye
Kanye's spiralling mental health decline over the last 20+ years has been quite the spectacle. It's a remarkable study into the fragility and madness that power and success gives a person. Kanye was arguably one of the best hip hop producers ever, and this album is a perfect case for it. His rapping also showed that he could offer some interesting critiques that a lot of hip-hop at this time wasn't willing to offer. As always, skits are shit and don't offer a lot, but the top tracks offer so much. It feels painful to give a 5 to a certified dickhead in 2025 but in 2004 at least, he wasn't a complete one.
3.5 ish
All falls down us good, but the album is pretty meh. Possible 3.5 on a good day
ugh sorry this was great but no
Loved this when it came out, and still love it now. Narrative, witty lyrics, samples, guest appearances, all excellent. Just hard to separate it from the artist now
Honestly, as youngin, this was amazing. Kanye where have you gone
I'm not a rap fan, so this listen was completely outside my usual "algorithm" (which, of course, is the primary reason I'm doing this 1001 Album challenge in the first place). That said, I was impressed with the production. This album SOUNDS great. Learning more about Kanye's production background, I shouldn't be surprised. The rhythm tracks are funky, and soulful. To be honest, those backing tracks are what kept me listening. As for the subject matter, "Jesus Walks" was the standout. I was shocked at the level of introspection. Great cut. On the whole, the album had a sense of humor but was a little too long.
this one was very fun
Fuck Kanye West/10
Not gonna listen to this d-bag
My second Kanye West album, and again, surprised. I find it nice that Kanye could make such diverse music,full of R&B and soul mixed with his rap lines, the melodies are great and catchy, and I hate to praise Kanye West. Funny how he tells the story on how he ended up on Jay-Zs record label...bet he ised a lot Kanye as well . I would give itba 4, but itbis Kanye so, it is 3/5
More interesting than the previous Kanye album I reviewed, but his narcissism is just too off-putting for me.
It gets a 6/10. Look, prior to him revealing himself as a Nazi-sympathizer and a bigot, the man made some decent music. And usually, I'm pretty good at separating the art from the artist. But I can't give this dude any more streams. He's a royal piece of human garbage. FWIW - "My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy" is a masterpiece. I'm sad that I can't listen to it anymore.
I briefly listened to the album and realised that I don't like this music, especially of this genre, enough to give this racist individual even a penny in royalties. Kanye West is blocked on my streaming account. 1/5
No thanks
Kanye Not
I’m not so sure how essential this is. The artist even less so.
Old Kanye was so special.
Two out of three have been rap. I don’t like rap. I gave them a chance but has not changed my opinion.
NO NO NO NO WAIT WAIT WAIT WAIT
Hadn't really listened to this album before. Kanyes debut album rewards those who dive in and listen for the impressive use of samples. The lyrics are cheeky and catchy and while never seeming to go too deep, there are some great one liners. Too many skits to make this an album I'd want to listen to back to front to often. Kanye's production goes hard and he often finds a way to take it to another level. Not my favourite genre and I'm late to this 20 year old record which hampers my personal rating: 7.8/10.
Ok guys, Kanye wrote an apology in the WSJ now, we can stop pretending he's not the GOAT of rap of the aughts and 2010s. A little too RnB focused on this record compared to his other records, which I'm not the biggest fan of, but it's still a fantastic album. Not giving it a 5 because it's not Graduation, and he did say all that terrible stuff, but come on. He made Graduation.
It's really not as terrible as I had expected. And even one or two songs you might be able to listen to a couple of times. But still a "one".
its not very good
Album No. 0078 on my list. "The College Dropout" is already my second Kanye West Album ("My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy") being the first one. Reviewing that first one, I tried to the best of my abilities separating the art from the artist, and I'm trying the same thing again in this review. I found "The College Dropout" to be somewhat worse than MBDTF, but it was still surprisingly okay-ish. I'm not the biggest hip hop fan, but I can't deny that I had an okay time listening to the album. I definitely see why "The College Dropout" would be featured on a list like this. I didn't enjoy all tracks and found many of the short skits and interludes rather annoying, but there are certainly some good tracks on this. I've enjoyed "All Falls Down", "Slow Jamz", and "Through The Wire" in particular. 3/5 stars.
Genuinely hated this. The autotune crap is annoying. Kanye has no business anywhere around kids, don't include them in the album. Hated every second of this despite every effort to push past my reservations about the artist and respect the art.
This album is really good. I like how it feels like an actual story. It was able to keep me interested throughout the whole hour and 16 minutes. I'm not the biggest fan of rap, but this is enjoyable.
Es ist OK
What a music producer. Just too good. Sadly Kanye himself, mainly in the last years, has become not the most loveable person... But his music is good. All Falls Down (very popular for a reason) and Through the Wire are classics. Highlight: I'll Fly Away
One Kanye is enough. This one isn’t worth rating as Kanye’s importance has been reevaluated.
Nah
I'm not a child, immature sure, but not a child. So I don't feel I'm in a position to point out the emperor has no clothes. Even then, I'm not sure it is pluralistic ignorance either, just another dose of grumpy old man syndrome? Probably. The other day the Dimery jukebox chucked out Bowie's Low, not his best but you enter a world of the artist at work, the music, the songwriting, the performance. So what exactly is this, what is it? What the fuck is this? Was that I'll Fly Away? If yes then why? What's all that talking? and to prove I listened to the whole frigging thing there's a reference to BIGGIE OF COURSE THERE IS right at the end! Fuck me this has really pissed me off, horrible, horrible experience.
Oh Kanye, you are making this really hard. And this really raises the eternal question of "the artist or the art". Can we forgive the transgressions of the artist enough to allow us to enjoy the art? I loved this record when it came out, and I still think it is one of the best hip hop albums of the past 30 years. I could sing the praises of this album, but I won't right now. I just can't stomach Kanye's persona these days. The antisemitic, pro-Nazi, pro-Trump rhetoric is just abhorrent. I can't bear it. But there have been plenty of (white) musicians who have flirted with fascism over the years (Bowie, Johnny Ramone, the Sex Pistols, Lemmy Kilmister, Siouxsie and the Banshees, Bryan Ferry, the Rolling Stones, Rammstein, etc) whose pro-Nazi stances have been ignored, forgotten or forgiven over time. I wonder if he, as a black artist, will be granted the same leniency, should he ever come to his senses? In my mind, he would need to publicly and explicitly retract many of the things he has said over the past ten years. Kanye, however, seems to double-down every time he is held to account, which makes it hard. In the meantime, I am using the "Michael Jackson standard". I can still listen to MJs records from before he turned into a drug-addled, pedophile ambition monster (Jackson Five records are still awesome), but his post-Bad material is too creepy for my taste. Similarly, I can still enjoy The College Dropout, where Kanye still seems like a reasonable human being, but would struggle to even listen to his more recent releases. If Kanye had released this record and immediately disappeared, never to be heard of again, this would be five stars for me. But his words and actions are tarnishing its value to me, and so now, the best I can do is a three. And if he keeps going, that could fall even further. I have to admit some embarrassment at liking this record. Clearly the toxicity of Kanye's public persona is polluting this work for me, and I can foresee a time when you can't play his records at all because of his abhorrent ideas and statements. I acknowledge that, for many people, that line has already been crossed.
This album is my probably my favorite Kanye album. His debut has so much creativity and interesting ideas in it, the songs really don’t miss. ‘We Don’t Care’, ‘Last Call’, and everything in between this is Kanye at his finest.
Classic
Luckily the later crazy Ye doesn't filter through to this absolute banger. So many forgotten classics, Slow Jamz etc. maybe 5 is a stretch but quality production, wordsmithing etc. love it.
I do not like Kanye as a person, but I do like some of his music. I knew All Falls Down, Jesus Walks, Slow Jamz, and Through the Wire.
Album number 200. Not one I'd hope for today. I have made a concerted effort to separate the art from the artist in this project, but this one is really tough. Kanye's untreated mental illness (yes, I'm giving the benefit of the doubt) has led to him impulsively saying and doing horrible things for quite some time now. For others with problematic behavior, there are accusations that might or might not be the truth. But in Kanye's place, he's put it all out there front and center. With all of that being said, this is mostly an excellent album. I had young children when this came out, and I rarely bought hip hop records at the time due to not wanting this to be stuff they listened to. But this album was one I had to get based on all of the hype. He came out of the gates so full of himself, but his talent was so obvious lyrically and musically. He touched on themes that were not at all popular at the time as well. This was both a good listen and one I was ashamed to play. I have no clue what rating I'm going to give it.
I can hear what all the buzz is about. This kid has a future
Solide album, artiste détestable.
Epic
Unfortunately, this is really really good. I get so many parallels between Kanye and MIA, where they're both awful, brainrotted human beings, but their music during this peiod was so singular, forward-thinking, and undeniable.
This was better than I expected a Kanye album to be - I don’t know if I’d ever listen to it again given the legacy he’s left behind but on a whole I enjoyed this a lot more than I expected to.
1000/10
not my music
bättre än 2pac men diggar nog ff inte hiphop :s
bra album, dålig kanye
I am not going to address anything about Kanye the person, just Kanye the artist and this particular album. What an absolute banger of an album! This is one I've heard before, many times. It was one of my favorites back in college, so this review is going to be tinged with considerable nostalgia. As with my review of Eminem's Marshal Mathers LP, I'm ignoring the intros/skits. They don't add anything to the albums, but they're not distracting enough to detract from it either. We Don't Care starts the album off solid, showcases Kanye's flow. All Falls Down is wonderful, the female vocals really shine. I'll Fly Away keeps it going, great sample chosen for that one. Jesus Walks brings a killer energy, great workout track. The chanting in the background just makes you want to move. Already a great album and we're only a third of the way through. Never Let Me Down is fun, nice cameo by Jay-Z, and the chorus is also well sung. The New Workout Plan was pretty funny. And then Slow Jamz hits. Oof. Kanye West, Twista, and Jamie Foxx? Sign me up now. Such an incredible song. Kanye West's flow, Twista's speed, and Jamie Foxx bringing it all together in the chorus. Bottom third of the album, and it does not let up. School Spirit has a nice beat. The "Step" part hits nicely, and the rap is smooth. Oh man, Through The Wire is next. This was the first Kanye West song I'd ever heard, and it totally had me hooked. Such a great song. The story he tells, the lyrics, the flow, everything just hits so well. And Chaka Khan's sample in the background really ties it together. Family Business is kinda funny. Last Call is a good ending. And I love how he tells the story of how he got his deal at the end, it was interesting to hear. This would definitely go on the list of my top albums of all time. So many full 5s, and nothing I would rate lower than a 4. Incredible album. Best song was really hard to pick. Top three are easily All Falls Down, Slow Jamz, and Through The Wire, with the top spot bouncing between the latter two. I'm going to give it to Slow Jamz, but Through The Wire could take the top spot any day. Best song: Slow Jamz
5 stars and a dose of nostalgia knowing we'll never hear anything like this from him again, rip
one way that i know i have always loved this album and had that love rush right back through me is the fact that the minute i started this i remembered all the lyrics to all the songs and started rapping along LMAO. WE DON'T CARE WHAT PEOPLE SAAAYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!! this song really was so important to me for so long. you know i'm an advocate for CHANGE AND EDUCATION. but this entire album was so good and had so many hits like jesus walks and new workout plan.... the list goes on. omgomgomg i forgot how much i loved breathe in breathe out too LMFAO FUCK!! amazing work! and i missed this kanye :( just grateful to be alive and sharing his voice (and beats) sigh! anyways i needed that!!!!!
Fun to revisit after many years
Rap, R&B, 2004 -> 1
I refuse to listen to Kanye West.
This one marginally holds up better than his others in the list so far. Mostly because he hadn’t gotten to bold yet. His flow is still kind of corny and his production hasn’t reached its apex yet. Again too bad he has destroyed his legacy.
Well for those who were shocked by Ye turning heel and saying he’s Jesus - this debut lays that all out there already. Look the beats and rhymes are great. The skits a fucking dumb. Kanye is a turd.
Viel zu lang. Aber ich muss ehrlich sagen, dass es viel besser war, als ich erwartet habe. Ich fage mich, wieso es Chipmunk Rap genannt wird. 2 1/2.
It's good. Wildly overrated, but good.
What a waste. He’s so witty, but even here there’s a lot to disagree with
I stopped listening to this blud for the last year and more. Haven't heard his debut I suppose and I can't rate this one that highly right now. 3 or 4 stars.
I appreciate that with The College Dropout, Kanye West created a space for hip-hop to rap about higher education, materialism, Jesus, etc. My favorite tracks are Spaceship, Get Em High and School Spirit. Once I removed the skits from the playlist, I liked the album a lot better.
this album sent me on a little research excursion regarding "chipmunk soul," as while wikipedia cited kanye west as popularizing the sound, it said nothing about who did it ""first"" or how, exactly, it came to be. maybe i'm not ""hip with it"" but pitched up singing seems enduring and, at times, ubiquitous. like, they're still doing edits to kordhell's music, aren't they??? that hasn't totally fallen out of style yet, right???? regardless, i was delighted to learn in my cursory research that it was a specific group of producers in the early aughts (which does include mr. kanye) who were experimenting, remixing, and taking advantage of any affordance the technology could offer. as rsonist says in the red bull music academy article on the origins of chipmunk soul "we all started using our voices as instruments. a lot of the times, i started using the voice simply because i couldn't get it out. but when i started putting it together, something dope happened... when you chop it up and piece it back together, you realize that the voice is actually an intricate part of what you do." funnily enough, i had kid a (2001) yesterday and that album's mythology goes along a similar trajectory where, as an antidote to writer's block, thom yorke took after electronic music and experimented with synthesizers to modulate his voice as an instrument. i also can't help but think about vocaloids, which, while initially released in 2004, would spin off into something so much bigger. learned here, too, that michael stipe of R.E.M. was cited as being impressed by vocaloids in a 2003 nyt article but was worried about the long-term implications with this incredibly prescient quote "i would hate to think that 250 years from now altria would use the michael stipe voice to sell organic soy to a mars landing ... it's intriguing in 2003. i'm not sure about 2303." i don't really have a thesis here aside from: i just think hip-hop is neat. the more i learn about hip-hop producers the more i understand how foundational their craft was for most any kind of music i like these days. oh, i was rating an album, wasn't i ??? uh... lukewarm four stars because, i'll hand it to kanye this is a phenomenal debut with phenomenal production but as much as i enjoyed the this album's tone it started to drag on for me. liked this more than my beautiful dark twisted fantasy for sure!! highlights - we don't care, spaceship, jesus walks, never let me down, the new workout plan, school spirit, through the wire
This album is phenomenal. So many good features. So many “wait, I know that voice” experiences. So much good conscience hip hop. Kanye before he was ultra self aggrandizing.
Better than I remember. Mostly good time. 4/ 5
Separating the art from the artist … this is really good. It’s powerful songwriting that has the magic of sounding like what it is about.
Jeez, this is just so well produced and still slaps hard. It could lean more toward a 5 in this system, but a strong 4.5.
-1 from 3 for being Nazi. Starts strong but meanders and loses impact.
4/5
A timeless classic that is a pure reflection of the aspirational spirit.
Fairly average rapper and producer markets himself as a genius and gets away with it, despite heavily relying on ghostwriters and ghost producers to do much of the work for him. It should have been enough to market himself as a charismatic performer and not have to pretend to be a visionary auteur. It's not a bad album, so I shouldn't let the Milli Vanilli of it all bother me. Actually, that's unfair on Milli; they never claimed to be making "great art." Maybe the problem is that Kanye is all show, all persona, and his persona pissed me off long before I knew he was a neo-Nazi. The genius myth simply isn't entertaining. I mostly listened to hip-hop up to 2004, but around the time this came out I just wasn't hearing anything that excited me any more. I quite liked the singles from this, but no more than I liked The Game. It's like being told Lady Gaga was a wildly inventive maverick chameleon circa The Fame; one can't just claim it without backing it up. It's not that the emperor is naked, but that he's wearing the same jeans, t-shirt and trainers as the guy next to him. Oh yeah, and once again IT'S TOO LONG. He could have cut nearly half an hour from this and it would have been a much better album.
Artist 0/5 album 5/5
Eva : à l'ancieeeenne bravo pour la prod et le rap... Chapeau !
Pretty iconic album. Not my favourite Kanye album, but as his breakout it has a unique spot in his discography
5 sterne
Hafði ekki hlustað áður en hún kom mér ánægjulega á óvart og ég fór loks að skilja hvers vegna hann hafði þann status sem hann hafði. Mjög flott margt, fjölbreytt, góð nýting á eldri stefum &c.. College skittin eru samt bara efni í eina hlustun.
Helt ok, men inte min grej
Didn't want to listen to this because of Kanye's, make that Ye's, politics and behavior. But f that. This album is damn good. His talent is undeniable. Rich, profound lyrics and genres including from rap, hip hop, and soul on one album. Tremendous vocal collabs. This is a winner.
Nice, bare ein sang igjen Sangen: nesten 13 min
*sigh* This guy. This is not my kinda guy. I'll give the album the appropriate rating since it's genuinely brilliant. But I can't with this dude. Only thing I'll say: Ye get your life together you fucking psychopath.
7 / 10
Liker mye her. Litt mye skits. Siste "låta" er 12 minutter skit.. Why.
The ensuing 20+ years have not all been kind, but there's no denying Kanye was in his bag on this one.
If this has been a bit shorter it would be a 4. I enjoyed it overall despite some of the songs being a little trashy.
Wish it was a tad shorter but it also is not his best
I'm sorry, but I just don't get the appeal of this album. It's fine, the beats are cool I guess, some of the lyrics are inventive and interesting. That's about it. Like most rap albums, it's waaaaaaaay too long. Why do rappers feel the need to include skits? Most of them suck and just interrupt the flow of the album and drag it out. I feel like a lot of rappers underachieve. They have the skills and the talent to do something great and instead they just rap about themselves and money and their dick and chicks and drugs. Sure, they throw in the obligatory 2-3 songs about family and some sad story and everyone goes aww see they care about their family/friends/literally anyone that isn't them. A couple songs on an album over an hour long doesn't make up for all that self-centeredness. The 12:41 song at the end didn't endear this album to me either. Also this fool is straight up a Nazi so I can't give this a good rating.
rating him solely on this album-i don't care at all for the language or demeaning treatment of women, but he does communicate his point of view. sounds are all over the place & not in a good way. way, way too long.
I know he'd only get 0.0001p per stream, but I'm not going to make this amoeba-brained Nazi moron even 0.0001p richer by playing his album online. I don't care how "classic" this album is, Kanye can do one.
Han mestre virkelige at dosere sine virkemiddeler. Det var ikke kedeligt, der var masser jeg har hørt før. Jeg vender dog aldrig tilbage igen.
Endelig et alternativ til gangsta rappen. Kaney er langt mere intelligent og har en mere nuanceret beskrivelse af “den sorte mands” kamp. Lidt ironisk at kalde Kaney intelligent når man ser ham i dag. Albummet bliver desværre ca. 30 min for langt.
very good Kanye is nasty tho
Still relevant. It did contain too much talking theough the music for my tastes, but overall really nice
Gammal Kanye er dritfett! Digger det her
Ok-ish. Not my style. ★★
Trying to listen to Kanye objectively is kind of hard as this album is still a stone cold classic to me and landed at such a pivotal time in my life I can’t help but still love it. Listening to how passionate he was about his craft on this album is painful knowing where he’s at now. Some of Kanye’s best production work can be found on this album, it still hits incredibly hard. Once again, could do without so many skits but otherwise there’s not a dropped beat on this whole thing. It’s no surprise that since he became a huge piece of shit his music has also become some of the worst stuff I’ve ever heard. I don’t recognise the 50 year old edgelord racist prick he is now, but I lament the loss of this young and hungry 27 year old.
the beginning of a very good streak
I went in to this one trying not to think about the current state of Kanye. I'd heard so many times about what a game-changing album this was when it was released. I was surprised by how it just felt like another standard hip-hop album of the era. Typical raps about being a drug dealer, and being the greatest rapper, etc. Those horrible unfunny skits between songs. I'll admit there was a time when I started to enjoy a song, "Spaceship", but then I noticed I hadn't heard Kanye in a while. Seems I can appreciate his guests far more than I care for him.
Ugh
I don't really know this album. And it's hard to tell how I feel about his work before he went full Howard Hughes, but this is just not a 3.
0 stars for Kanye the person
Yeezy sucks as a human, no doubt. But, this album is great. 5/5
Not as good as I remembered. The use of backing vocals, and the very Kanye power transitions from verses to choruses were great. But overall, just not as good as some of his other stuff. Several songs are pretty boring, and I have a love/hate relationship with skits in music albums. This album overdoes the skits. Get Em High and Family Business were bright spots and hint at the genius we get in Graduation and 808s.
Kanye west is good at music
I don't know how to rate this. Makes me sad despite being good.
idk, man, it's an awkward listen in 2025. Still really good, though. I'm giving it a rating sort of deliberately ignoring that it's now straight up nazi music, but honestly I generally can't force myself to listen to it these days.
It's still a great album, but listening to it is hard considering who Kanye has become. Here he's a relatable, if messy, 20 something angry at the system and trying to find his way into adulthood. His talent is undeniable and he is both confident and totally clueless. I wish I could just enjoy this as the great, influential, tone setting album is was in the early '00s. The cover is also great, a 4/5.
It’s real separating the art from the artist territory. Because Kanye West is a terrible person, but this is a great album.
As a non-Hip-Hop listener, "The College Dropout" was a challenging 2/5 listening experience. The album's bloated length and packed track list were immediate turn-offs; frankly, I'm ready to permanently retire the Hip-Hop skit. While I found the music sonically rich, well-produced, and competently arranged, the repetitive nature of the beats became a significant hurdle. My greatest barrier, however, was the unengaging and dull lead vocal performances, which not even the strength of the choruses or guest artists could successfully camouflage. My patience ran out around "Slow Jamz," but I persevered on, and I'm glad I did, as that led me to "Two Words," easily the strongest track on the album. It's a genuine commentary on the album's structure when the pleasant attention-grabber, eighteen tracks deep, is a simple drum fill. Let's finish on a positive note; I really liked the album artwork, it's a striking image that's instantly eye-catching. 1 "Intro (Skit)" (2/5) 2 "We Don't Care" (3/5) 3 "Graduation Day" (2/5) 4 "All Falls Down" (featuring Syleena Johnson) (2/5) 5 "I'll Fly Away" (3/5) 6 "Spaceship" (featuring GLC and Consequence) (3/5) 7 "Jesus Walks" (4/5) 8 "Never Let Me Down" (featuring Jay-Z and J. Ivy) (2/5) 9 "Get Em High" (featuring Talib Kweli and Common) (3/5) 10 "Workout Plan (Skit)" (2/5) 11 "The New Workout Plan" (3/5) 12 "Slow Jamz" (Twista featuring Kanye West and Jamie Foxx) (2/5) 13 "Breathe In Breathe Out" (featuring Ludacris) (2/5) 14 "School Spirit (Skit 1)" (2/5) 15 "School Spirit" (3/5) 16 "School Spirit (Skit 2)" (2/5) 17 "Lil Jimmy (Skit)" (2/5) 18 "Two Words" (featuring Mos Def, Freeway and The Boys Choir of Harlem) (4/5) 19 "Through the Wire" (2/5) 20 "Family Business" (2/5) 21 "Last Call" (2/5) Total - 52 Average - 2.48 148/1001 78/148 albums reviewed were new to me.
Crazy man raps
nope. 1/5.
Fuck Kanye and all fascist enablers.
One of the most influential hip hop albums of the 00s. Probably his best imo
Not wasting my time with this.
ye boycott - skipping this one, though high school me used it as an entry point into rap/hip-hop
honestly came into this with an expectation to dislike it given who kanye is now, and previous experience with his music - unfortunately it was very good haha
Never liked the person but appreciate the artist.
Immediately after this album, Kanye quickly became the braggadocio that everyone knew him as before he fell from grace down to an incel-leading nazi. His recent edgy middle-school level behavior is plenty reason to avoid him and his work, but here he was a struggling artist pleading for equal recognition to his bosses like Jay-Z. Nearly every song on this album is about a very real sort of struggle, whether it be money, family, faith, or being on the brink of death. The only time he’s ever really been relatable, even if his discography all the way to KSG was great. I’ll need to find the time to play this on CD because I can’t give this any streams because I’m not funding the next Nazi Super Bowl ad. Steal this record, it’s absolutely his best.
I only have the basic knowledge of this, but even I aim aware that Mr West has well issue and is a tad controversial. Musically he definitely knows what he is doing, but still his world view is kind of omnipresent in 2025. Would honestly have probably have liked the record after my 1 listen musically, but no desire to be a Kanye fan due to said controversy so after hearing won’t be exploring, which as said musically is a shame but there it is. Musically higher score but bellend score 2 Star.
It's a great album. 5/5
Crazy how 20 years ago he dropped one of the best debuts of all time and now…
i dislike this man but this album is 10/10
4.4/5
Great album. Even the skits aren’t too bad.
Can't stand him, and this is absolutely my least favourite genre of music so I'm negatively biased but I know it has some merit even if I don't appreciate it
Listened to half . Couldn’t stand anymore
did not listen! fuck him!
better than i expected
This was a really interesting album. As much as I hate him, Kanye is so IN his music it's wild. Never seen an artist interject themselves in an album before. Overall, I liked it. It didn't seem to drag too much despite it's 80 minute runtime. I liked "Be" by Common more though.
Not really my thing but All Falls Down and especially Through The Wire are decent tunes. Appreciate this was a landmark album but just not my cup of tea.
This was the most challenging album on the list so far. This album is objectively really good, however Kanye in recent years is an admitted nazi. In an attempt to separate the art from the artist. 4/5
Kanye West is a horrible human being, but there is a lot of humour and some truth in this album, and it did break out hip/hop to a lot of people.
Nope
I've always hated skits in rap albums, and these really bring it down. The tracks themselves are very good. Too bad Kanye is also a massive POS.
Kanye is a POS
Early 2000s hip hop was it's own thing. Personally not a fan of the skit type tracks on the album and the only memorable song was Through the Wire which I distinctly remember hearing this as a kid either on radio or in a store
The overall sound of this was better than I expected, for hip hop, but the longer it went on the more it felt like it would never end, and he still seems to be a Nazi controversy stirring pillock, so not going above 2.5.
Never heard a Kanye album before. Don't even know if I've heard a single. Track 1: Okay. Track 2: Man. Banger track. Capitalism is a failure state. Exploiting it is a means for true success. There's intelligence within the system, and there's intelligence to break the system. It all boils down to getting paid. And any intelligence knows who has the money, and how they got that money. Track 3: Good interlude track. The Dean(?) is a bit overly play-acted for me, but the autotuned section was nice. Track 4: Great track. Consumerism. Just chipping away. Track 5: Sang this song at church many a time. A whatever rendition. Just messing with harmonic layers. Kind of puzzled why it's here. Perhaps it's an intro to the next track? Track 6: Favorite track so far. Have you played the video game What Remains Of Edith Finch? This song expresses the theme of my favorite story from that game. Track 7: Holy shit! Banger! Nice Happy Gilmore reference. Glad the intro and interlude tracks went away. Just give me the songs. Track 8: Pretty good. Music good. Not feeling Jay-Z's contributions. Masturbatory. Plus, tonally different than the other two's verses. Praising family, praising helping others. His is just about how great he is. No thanks. Represents that dark side of capitalism and ego. Track 9: Not into this style of track. Slam poetry with a repetitive beat. I'll take another song, please. Track 10: Okay. Track 11: Great song. What a production! Track 12: Nice song. Good vibes. Good story. A good stoey about wanting good vibes. More into the choruses and bridges than the verses. Track 13: More of that bullshit ice rap. Not my thing. Track 14: Ugh. And not in the intended way. Cheesy. Track 15: Okay track. I'm starting to get a bit bored. Album is feeling long. Production is on point, but the writing is feeling a bit uneven. It's starting to feel like a good chef who made too many dishes, and half of them are a great meal. Track 16: Meh. Did he say doctrine instead of doctorate? Intentional. These skits sound like they were supposed to be funny and clever. Track 17: I don't know how to phonetically type out the sigh I just made. Kanye, stop trying to recreate old Adam Sandler cds and stick to songs. These skits are really messing with the average. Track 18: Another slam poetry song, two words at a time. As I get older, I'm more drawn to ambient or lyric-less music. Mostly because I don't give a shit what people have to say as much. People talk too much for how little they are actually saying. A lot of whatever words. Would rather listen to music. Track 19: Yay, a song. Pretty good. Track 20: Decent track. Feels like I should have liked it more. Track 21: Okay. Weird. Almost feels like an audio commentary track on a dvd. But instead of being optional, it's the final song. Alright. Cool story... Overall: The actual songs are really good. The interludes and skits are bad. The slam poetry tracks aren't memorable. 2/5. Only 6 out of 21 tracks playlisted.
Good album, definitely ahead of its time. Multiple songs that stand up to today.
Classic
Sometimes I forget how different 2004 really was (I was 5 to be fair...) but this album just has different sounds from anything since. That said Cordae's The Crossroads feels is a spiritual successor to this with multiple samples from TCD and a Ye feature. This is an easy 5 for me. The impact this had on rap is still felt to this day. Without Ye, everything looks different. The skits don't feel like a waste of time. Without being crass or violent, Kanye still nails the braggadocio and competitive energy of rap. If you'd like to see the behind the scenes of this album check out Jeen-Yuhs on Netflix. Fantastic footage of Kanye getting signed and developing this album. Favorite Songs: Jesus Walks, Slow Jamz, & Family Matters
It’s so good
Luckily, I'm able to separate my mind between: Kanye (the person) - Horrible person. Kanye (the musician) - Meh. Using this this album as a touchstone - It's OK. Deliberately flashy rap, full of debut album theatrics, but overall, I found nothing that I actually enjoyed. Once it finished, there was no temptation to press "Repeat."
Super!
Isegist oli täitsa ok
I wasn't really enjoying it this much initially but eventually got into it. I definitely prefer his later, more maximalist records, and the soul-esque vibe this album has is also not my thing, but the atmosphere was still very pleasant. It's on the longer side, but the songs were pretty consistently enjoyable, so it didn't feel long. I understand what this skits/interludes were supposed to do to the story, but I didn't like them regardless. It felt like they were distracting me from the actual song, and incorporating them into the music (some of them are) would've been better. Although I had some problems with this album, from the artistic standpoint, it's a wonderfully executed project that fully deserves its classic status. Definitely not my type of music, and I didn't get deep into was going on here lyrically since I don't really enjoy listening to vocals, but I fully understand why some people would consider this a masterpiece.
Not his best work 6/10
Love Kanye
You would have to pay me a lot of money to listen to this
Vidunderligt album !!! Fortæller meget om hans tidlige dage og en skam han ikke laver lignende musik længere men hold da op det er godt og anderledes men anderledes på en god måde. Rap var ikke sådan her på det tidspunkt men damn det er godt. Det er meget mere muntret end hvad rap var i de tidlige 00’ere. 9/10
Nah I'm not listening to this
This album is my personal believe why there should be a zero button….
My third and, I think, my final Kanye album and for me this is the best of the three. The other two I gave 4 stars cause there was a few songs I wasn’t fussed on but I enjoyed this right the way through. It’s a shame he’s a few peas short of a pod these days cause this version of Kanye is brilliant. Top Track - All Falls Down
I hate Kanye west but he makes good music
i ain’t really gotta say much Top 3 Family Business Two Words Never let me down 10 🐐
One of the best debut albums of all time, from the greatest hip hop artist of all time The crossroads of two eras of hip hop the production is so incredible hard to overstate Listening to this album feels like eating a bowl of delicious chicken noodle soup. Top 3 songs 1 Family Business 2 Two words 3 Last Call H.M (freakster) we don't care Pure 10/10
2025-10-15: I am not used to this type of music and I have some bias against it. I enjoyed the second half better, perhaps because of the content or because I turned the volume down (it was getting late). I wasn't attentive to the lyrics, so if that's part of the appeal, I was missing out on it. I feel the cadence that rapping adds to music to be limited, but probably this is true of other kinds of music that I am more keen about. 2025-10-16: I have half skipped through the album on a subpar setting. Today I have found some of the groove and fun I felt on the latter tracks on the first ones. I still feel that rapping isn't something that I will have time stomaching and that will drag down this kind of music for extended/focused listening. However the fun/delight for which I have upped the score in previous albums is somewhere in there, so I won't rate it as a meh this time.
Fun record, I enjoyed the listen. No sure how much i could revisit since it felt a bit long but really glad I was exposed to it.
Removed Album #17 (List: https://pastebin.com/cSThNiK9) Yup, this album was scrubbed from future editions of the book. A big surprise, since I know that this album and the also-removed Good Kid m.A.A.d City are big deals within the hip-hop community. This is my first-ever Kanye album. I listened to a snippet of The Life of Pablo a few years back, though I don't remember a single thing about that album and I didn't even finish it, so that one doesn't count. I'm not expecting to like this album, though I've heard Kanye be described as an entry-level pick for hip-hop, so who's to know? An hour sixteen. Fuck my FUCKING life, dude. Why? Why do these hip-hop albums always have to be so fuuuuuucking long? Anyways, there's some merit in this one. The instrumentals are impressive. There's a varied catalogue of instruments, genres and vocals that are sampled on here, though throw out just about everything I said as I didn't like this one all that much. To a hip-hop fan I'm sure there's a lot they can sink their teeth into, but I'm just not a part of that crowd. The already limited appeal of this album is hurt greatly by how repetitious and padded the songs, and I also can't help but view the hip-hop song structure on this album as greatly limited and unremarkable. Kanye is well-suited to this genre of music and has an accessible vocal style, though it didn't stop me from feeling bored out of my mind while listening to this. "We Don't Care" is an alright opener. I like the weightless instrumental and how the lighter parts intercept with a punchier, more traditional hip-hop sound. The programming of "Jesus Walks" didn't work on me. We live in different times, what can I say? "Breathe In, Breathe Out" was the point where my eyes finally glazed over and I lost whatever investment I had in this album. Such a boring, lethargic tune. Why was this album removed? Beats me, though I know that the editors of this book do a hack rush-job whenever they're assembling the new editions, so I think it's just a simple case of this album being replaced with a more acclaimed successor album. Granted, Kanye has two not-yet-removed albums on the list, so it's anyone's guess. Book time. "...one of 2004's most-anticipated and well-received albums". A lot of collaborators. I know this one's a big deal, so I don't need more confirmation than this. I cosign this inclusion and will graciously save it from the ex-inductee moniker.
Ah yes, here comes the token "non classic rock/punk" album to sprinkle in this list. The way this list picks non classic rock/punk albums is the equivalent of someone saying "Oh yeah, I love Rock Music! Have you ever heard of Nirvana or Red Hot Chili Peppers?" The absolute most obvious, stereotypical, every-single-person-on-the-planet-likes-them-you're-not-special picks you could possibly imagine. That said, this album really was a big deal for the Hip-Hop Genre. One of the iconic ones from the Mid-2000s that still mostly holds up to this day. A few duds in the tracklist as there always was, but it still definitely is an important album for the time. Shame it's retroactively tainted by being created by an absolutely despicable cretin.
Alr, dont like kanye
Had few very good songs.
Thought this was really good to be fair (as Nazi music goes)
Not bad but I can’t stand the man
Dårlig mann men satan for et album
Not bad overall, but a full star deduction for being a Nazi and hanging with pedophiles.
Not listening out of principle I'm afraid.
One of the greatest hip hop debutes Shame who Kanye is now
Why do these hiphop albums always have to be so freaking long?!? The vinyl standard 45min would be enough of this stuff. Still it's not a bad album, i have to say. Style between songs wary enough and there are some good groove's on this, but too much is too much...
Really sleek and well done. I'm also well done after listening The Collage Dropout. No edge or anything that would speak to me. Regardless of that this was really easy listening stuff.
The only thing good about this album is the production, and even that is sometimes on the verge of tacky. It's like this is easy listening hip hop. And the bloody gospel bits, why the hell? I do not get the hype Kanye West received and still does. Was it just the right time to put out something other than gansta rap?
Sigh. I know it’s a jokey thing to say, but DAMN, I miss the old Kanye. THIS Kanye! This music is so instrumental (no pun intended) to me as a person. Those first five albums are soundtracks to teenage Brad becoming a young man. As an extremely white kid, Kanye was one of the first rappers that actually made me sit up and pay attention. He was just different at the time. Weird and nerdy and his choruses were so catchy and sing-y and I just felt seen by him in some way. This album is so big and bright and silly and musical. I really wish he had never become what he has become. It’s genuinely depressing. Still too many skits on this thing, tho.
He's a piece of shit but this album is pretty good.
not my thing
not today, Nazi
This could be a great album. Has all the makings. But the lyrics spoil it.
Already listened to this and, separating art from the artist, as a debut project, is incredible for its diversity of beats with intricate samples, as well as its lyrical content tackling various themes. Overall, a great album, 10/10.
I never like Kanye but I had never listened to this one. It’s good. Minus the strange, non-sensical lil Jimmy skit track, this is not pretty pretty pretty good. Pretty creative album. But maybe he shouldn’t have hated college so much and tried to learn something back then and he might not have ended up with a brain of mush today. 4 stars.
I have to admit this album is good.
Early Kanye album so it gets a pass for how he currently acts. Back when Kanye wasn’t completely crazy. This album is fantastic though.
Decent but not really my thing.
Thank you god bless you goodnight i came
Never heard of this guy before, but pretty good stuff.
не слушал
Not for me
Good
3-4
I used to love this album but I can’t like it anymore given what Kanye/Ye has turned into
top3: - two words - never let me down - spaceship
It's not bad, y'know
great lyrics and good sampling
My second West album. The other one, Yeezus, was worse. Still, I cannot in good conscience give this 2 stars.
Did I really have to listen to this Album again to rate it a 5/5? No. But did I have to listen to it because it is such an incredible album. The first 10 tracks are just an amazing listen with the back half still being very listenable. This album is evident of the creative genius that is Kanye West. This album is a mastery of sampling, flow, mastering, production, etc. you truly cannot have modern hip hop without this album.
- Gefällt mir tatsächlich besser als ich gedacht hätte, aber ich bin einfach kein persönlicher Fan von Kanye - Ist ein gutes Album mit Abwechslung und guten Melodien Topsong: All Falls Down
The intermezzos/skits are probably funny only once, if at all. Some parts he tries to sing himself. Better leave it to other people. Over-all it's still pretty good, but his 2 newer albums in the book are much much better. I think this can be removed from future editions. Favorite song: get em high
Dammit. Made sure to go find a version that isn't attached to him. He really has ruined his entire public image to a point where it's hard to even be excited to listen to any of this. I'll try to review it non-biased. We Don't Care - 4/5 song. Catchy chorus, it's a good message, cool. Graduation Day - 2/5 eh. All Falls Down - 5/5 banger. Can't speak to the lyrical content but this is kayne in his bag. I'll fly away - 2/5 Spaceship - 5/5 Jesus Walks - 2/5 I get it but I don't want to listen to it ever again. Never let me down - JayZ: 2/5 Kanye: 3/5 J Ivy: 2/5 Beat: 4/5 Overall: 3/5 Get em high - 5/5 beat and vocals. This is my favorite song on here. New work out plan - 2/5. Great beat but nah. slow jamz - 3/5. Another good beat but this song is not for me. Fast rap is nice. breathe in breathe out - 2/5 she grabbed my golf balls in the club school spirit - 2/5, sure this goes hard when he says your sorority but that's about it. two words - 3/5 enjoyed mos def through the wire - 3/5 I think this song is overrated just because he did it while his jaw was wired shut. I do like that you can hear it, and it's inspirational in that sense but the song isn't amazing. family business - 4/5 pretty good, I love the piano on this. Hate the it aint gay to love a man line but again, 2004. last call - 3/5 why is this 12 minutes long. a least it's enjoyable mostly It's a good story but it's so long. skits - 2/5, some funny moments but pretty bad across the board That comes out to a 3. Man, I think that the appeal of college is going down steadily, and cool on him for saying it in 2004, but a lot of the college specific stuff on this album comes across like that Jake Paul we hate teachers song. Anyways, that's my trying to be unbiased as possible listen, sorry it's so long! Popping back into to say I listened to 3 newish albums today after this. This is beating life of a show girl (2/5) but losing hard to ego death at a bachelorette party (5/5) and I love my computer (5/5)
Damn, I was not even going to listen...just write something snarky. But that's not fair, so I listened: Shit this stuff is good. Really good. I am impressed. I enjoyed this stuff, a lot. Bueno! Not the interludes, but the actual stories/songs. Good. 5 solid stars.
Where it all started for the GOAT.
05.10.25 Favourite tracks: jesus walks Rate:3/10 Not my type of music
Unfortunately mental illness goes untreated.
Better than some rap but still rap. And a little boring.
I ain’t listening to this Nazi loving piece is shit
not a moment of my life where i don't think "oh kanye, what happened, man?" this right here is his debut album. back in the day he had a lot to say and he wasn't AS schizophrenic as he was today. college dropout is about societal expectations, spiritual struggle and a memoir of sorts when it comes to his experiences. it's unmistakably early kanye, his anti-conventional way of spitting bars and defying norms paired with his practically trademarked vocal sample loop centered beats... it's pretty great. again, i just... aaaaah, kanye. kanye, what happened?
People need to learn to separate art from the artist. This record is amazing.
some good songs, but the artist itself has some bad views, 2
Yeah Kanye as a person sucks, but there was a time he didn't, and this album still bangs.
Belle constante récursive qui veut que je me tanne avant que chaque toune finisse et qui s'applique également à l'album. Chapeau. C'est quand même un clown talentueux. 2.5 étoiles
I like one song on here. I think it's School Spirit with some sampling thrown in. Apart from that? No.
Too many skits on here, and it didn't need to be an hour and a quarter. I like this about the same as Yeezus, which is to say there were moments I liked a lot, but the whole was just too much for me.
excellent album, truly some golden days for kanye
Classic. Too bad Kanye is poo poo head now.
“Oh oh Kanye West is the best rapper oh my, Knaye is a god oh his music is amazing oh oh oh blah blah blah I’m an idiot”
Too poppy.
I miss this Ye! This is an absolute 5!
5.5/10 Highlight: Never Let Me Down
I'm not going to listen to a self professed modern Nazi, sorry.
Not quite up to MBDTF, but excellent nonetheless. 4.
The skits don't really hold up overall, pretty standard.
для любителей репа.
jó
Classic
The greatest debut album of all time. A very rare feat in modern music to be honest…how many musicians can say they wrote, produced, and recorded their first album and have it go on to be as successful as The College Dropout? Not to mention the biggest single from this album as recorded with his mouth wired shut. This is a masterpiece that changed the direction of hip-hop during a time when it was only cool to rap about money, girls, cars, drugs, and violence.
It's an interesting feeling when you see your favorite artist from your coming of age decide to start hating your people. For starters, everybody giving this album a 1 because of Kanye or Ye's antisemitism, you aren't doing anything. You aren't standing up for jews and you aren't scaring nazis with your mean words. There are lots of bad people on this list, including antisemites, and artists who's bad politics come through in the art much more than this. An album who's author became antisemitic 20 years after its creation. It actually comes off as pretty racist and xenophobic that Ye/Kanye gets dogpiled for his life outside of this album when the global community is able to separate the art from the artist with other things. This album is fantastic. It set a new standard for rap in the 2000s and every aspect of it is some of the best that was ever made up to that point. The sampling is phenomenal. The production is phenomenal. The skits... are good. Ye's rapping is some of the best it would be. The lyricism is clever and Tongue and cheek. So many great lines in this, "Named her daughter Alexis", "Said I had a Bloodclot, I said Im not Jamaican". Ye was genuinely funny on this. The features were great. Getting Jay-Z, Ludacris, etc. on a debut album shows that the industry was just waiting for this debut to drop. Everyone wanted in on this. Lastly, thematically this is a fantastic album. The themes in this album of rebellion and confusion come through across the whole thing. Ye is challenging institutions set up for white people. Going to College, working corporate and living a normal life, where he knows the urban black experience is either be a wage slave or escape through either music or drug dealing. Ye has for a long time in his music expressed themes of finding yourself incongruous with the systems of oppression that exist, whether they be racial, federal, or social. On this album you see Ye talk about being religious. The challenges he experiences trying to balance his faith with the godlessness of his contemporaries. These feelings are what the reactionary and fascistic groups prey on. Ye ultimately didn't have issues with the institutions of power, he had issues with his position within them. And when you're a genius, that is a mistake, you should be at the top. The problem isn't with the slave ship, it's that Kanye isn't' the one driving it. And when he was the one selling $90 T shirts made in sweat shops it was good. But when he stopped doing well, the yeezy bubble burst, and other companies were doing fine, the problem couldn't be with him. There must be a bigger institution that he is underneath, and that is unacceptable. That's where he became so susceptible to believe the shadow government, and the jewish control... because when you're on top but you still feel oppressed, you have to invent an oppressor. Social media, feminism, jewish label executives, Skete Davidson. This album is the introduction of KanYe West. KanYe was a hard worker, someone with things to say, someone with belief in his talent and faith in his religion. There were a lot of things along the way that challenged the man. The death of his mother. Drug addiction, mental health struggles, being constantly surrounded by yes men. His wife leaving him and taking his children. Shady and predatory business dealings exploiting his financial inexperience. Things used to be simple for Ye, and now the world is very very complex. It's nice to imagine that the world is simple and explainable. Why do bad things happen to good people, why can't a billionaire buy whatever he wants. For a man like Ye who sees the world as a very designed place, randomness is unacceptable. It's a good thing Kanye changed his name to Ye. I find it easier to see them as two different people. I still love Kanye's music. From College dropout to The Life of Pablo and ye., this music taught me to be myself, have fun, live life, be reflective. Kanye is still one of my favorite artists. Ye is a problemtatic and deeply troubled individual, a guy who rides the Coattails of that other guy, a guy who died a few years ago.
Maaaan, this is such a good album and I hate that I have to think about Kanye when I listen to it. Musically it created the baseline for rap for the next 10 years, and it was the culmination of all the production work Kanye had done for other artists for years leading up to it. The beats are so clean, the rapping is very distinctly Kanye (and the features of course), there is variety in all the beats and styles, everything is just excellent. Maybe lyrically it's a little "basic" but that's what makes it accessible. You don't have to know every term and you don't have to think too deep to hear what is ultimately a message of struggle with real life as well as expectations placed on people by their peers, society, work, etc. The biggest gripe is "Last Call" which goes a bit far up its own ass. As has been noted by pretty much everyone, Kanye is an asshole now. But man, this is great and I've had this album available well before spotify existed so I don't feel terribly bad about listening to it.
Who hurt you Kanye? You could have just made a billion dollars doing this over and over again and you needed more so you ruined your sound and your legacy.
morally choosing not to listen to this album.
Good first album, not my style (especially lyrics). Graduation is much better
I’ve been dreading this day since starting this list
Every song is better knowing that Eloïse hates it.
Sorry, this is a fantastic album. What an assured, finely crafted, charismatic, explosive debut record. What a fucking waste. Production knocks and he sounds hungry and fired-up. I’m so mad. I DO miss the old Kanye. I will crawl on my belly over broken glass as penance. Thankfully I can at least begrudge this a perfect score because it is about 15 minutes too long and some of the engineering choices haven’t aged well.
This is a really entertaining and enjoyable album...and I never thought I would say that about any rap album. It's just not a genre that I have much appreciation for as I'm more of a melody/hooks person and about as white as can be. This album surprised me, I hadn't really heard it beyond "Jesus Walks." The skits were funny, the samples were fantastic....and there's lots of melody/hooks. Still don't care for much of the toxic male bravado but that's a big part of who he is...and only got worse after this album it seems.
This changed rap. There's no denying that. Kanye came out of virtually nowhere as a producer and took from the best elements of 90s hip hop, with sweet soul samples and insanely clever mixing. So much of this sounds fresh, like it could've been released two years ago instead of two decades ago, and it was huge in taking hip hop out of the 90s-hangover, exceedingly dull malaise of the bling era. But for me, every other Kanye album through Life of Pablo is basically no-skip. This is a great debut, but the second half pales in comparison to the first. We Dont Care, All Falls Down, Spaceship, those are quintessential Kanye. But New Workout Plan is fucking lame, the attempt at R&B is pretty embarrassing on Slow Jamz, etc. There's some gems on the second half like Through the Wire, but it doesnt hold a candle to the first. Still, a pretty fantastic debut.
Nope. No way. Will NOT listen to this man.
Obviously hate the guy as a person but can’t deny how great his music was back when he wasn’t as mental. Maybe slightly longer than it needed to be whereas mbdtf felt a perfect length but it still managed to keep it interesting all the way through. As much as it feels weird to support his stuff I think I have to give this 5 stars
Oh my god, how many Kanye albums are on here. It's my 3rd Kanye album from the generator and the previous two (even his views aside) weren't good enough to deserve a spot on the list. The album itself is fine I guess? But like many rap albums: waaaay too long, I thought an hour had passed after just 30 minutes. Worth noting that Jay-Z mentions JP2 on one song? I guess that's the only reference to my country I will find on this whole albums list 2/5
I don't like all the swearing
Boycott bitch
I have a hard time separating what we know about Kanye today from his art.
Liked some parts and not others
Is negative 1,000 stars an option?
ye could never
Favourite songs, All Falls Down, Jesus Walks, Through The Wire
I know this is supposed to be like, the greatest rap album of the early 2000s, but I really just don't like it very much. High school football team pre-game music. Kanye's a talented producer and an overrated rapper with a couple of banger lines, and this album showcases that. Some really great sampling, some really impressive features, some catchy tunes, but even if the album weren't a packed 75 minutes that feels longer, it would overstay its welcome. Great achievement and great debut, but well before the end, I'm done with it. Straddling a 3 and 4, thinking of going up because it ends pretty strong but Last Call is, in my opinion, a showcase of Kanye's mediocre flow. Maybe not mediocre, but one note. Either way, it just doesn't hit me the way it hits other people.
Hemeltje lief wat is deze man afgegleden he. Maar dat is de magie van de muziekwereld. Zoals ik bij zijn vorige plaat al benoemde ben ik geen Kanye fan, maar bewonder ik hem als kunstenaar. Dit is voor velen hét Hip Pop album van de early 2000s, wat ik me best kan voorstellen. Ik vond hem wel wat te lang, en het middenstuk was me iets te speels. Z'n latere experimentele werk (zoals op 'Yeezus') weet me van begin tot eind te boeien, maar zijn College trilogie kent fases waar het me gewoon iets te cheesy - of Yeesy - is. Mja, het heeft ook wel weer de credits om soms de plank mis te slaan, met 'Jesus Walks', 'Through the Wire' en 'All Falls Down'. Een beetje grillig, niet helemaal wat ik zoek in Hip Hop, maar een onmisbaar album om de koers van het genre na de eeuwwisseling te omschrijven. 7,5/10 Highlights: Jesus Walks Through the Wire All Falls Down
Los dat deze man zich ontwikkelde als een antisemiet, wist hij in de zeroes wel hoe hij een catchy hiphop-track moest fabriceren. Zeker door zijn unieke collabs natuurlijk, want zelf is hij niet de beste rappert. Gelukkig laat hij op The College Dropout Chris Martin nog niet invliegen. Die fout zal hij later pas maken. En mocht die plaat ook in deze lijst voorkomen dan zal ik hem daar ook naar beoordelen. Op the College Dropout hoor ik de klasse van Kanye als het aankomt op het maken van sterke melodieen en beats. Iets wat hij op MBDTF had geperfectioneerd als je het mij vraagt. De plaat als geheel luistert lekker weg maar komt niet veel verder dan dat. 7/10 Highlights All Falls Down
the one artist I don't even bother to open the album - not feeling objective enough to listen today so I'm skipping
Not into this one. The message a woman needs a flat stomach to get someone to pay for her lifestyle and a man who goes to college will never have sex is lost on me.
The good outweighs the bad. At least musically.
Kan (Ye) = ABSOLUTE SCUMBAG/LOONEY/... "Art" isnt the same as the artist for me... Therefore: Very good production! Good voice Some good songs But a lot of typicall rap stuff (drugs/woman/d*ck/...) not my kinda "art"...
The production is immaculate, but to be honest the actual rapping is not my cup of tea. I had never heard this album until fairly recently, and I don't really feel like I missed anything, even though I know most of my friends who are about ten years younger worshipped this album, even if they dislike what Kanye stands for now. I still don't really get it.
I do not love The College Dropout, but I like it well enough.
That wasn't half bad. I had the displeasure of listening to a more recent album by Mr West and just turned it off. This is a good album although it's completely not my thing.
Man I miss the old Kanye…. 😔
This is the Kanye I fell in love with. Smooth delivery, clever punchlines, smart artistry. I even thought the trashing of higher education was funny before I graduated high school. This album still holds up today. The music does anyway. "Jesus Walks" is still an all-time banger. "Through the Wire" and "Workout Plan" are still hits, but even the album cuts had some true gems on them: "Two Words", "Never Let Me Down" , and "Family Business" all make you remember how good Kanye used to be. The features on this album were top notch. You could tell everyone put their best foot forward to make sure this project would be a success. Shame we didn't realize then that we probably shouldn't be taking any advice from an admitted college dropout, but who ever thought that would be a bad idea?
Perfect album
His debut album. Hip Hop. The production is slick. The skits are lame. The music is okay. The lyrics are pretty good at times. It's an okay album for me but probably not something I'll come back to.
I refuse to listen
I am going to use a private session, because f this guy. Separate the man from the music, DazRocket, be objective! Too much use of the n word for me a white man who wants the word nowhere near my vocabulary. Lots of stuff here I don't want to hear again, it's not that it sucks really, but telling s story over background music isn't something I need to hear more than once. Does that last track count as rapping? If so, I am a rapper.
Lo de siempre, sin letras no hay paraíso.
Passing on Kanye no Nazi stuff here
Disclaimer: I am judging this album based on the merits of the art and not of the human. I’m pretty familiar with Kanye West’s work, but hadn’t really taken in one of his albums as a whole. I was struck by the themes, continuity, and ingenuity. Kanye just has the gift of lyricism and an undeniable flow. The rhymes are ripe with creativity and witticism yet they are rooted in reality. The features are well done and the samples were well chosen. I really enjoyed the album. It’s too bad we lost this Kanye.
This is a debut album??? Genius.
I’ve been a fan of his since I heard this record and continue to enjoy his first 5 records to varying degrees (but honestly don’t listen much at all these days, for obvious reasons). Anyway, this is one of the all time great hip hop debuts, and there was a LOT of expectation and anticipation and haters ready to shit on this record, and he came through. I hate hate hate skits, and there’s some filler here but it’s an audacious and auspicious debut. Rob Mitchum nailed it: a flawed, overlong, hypocritical, egotistical, and altogether terrific album
Once again if I could give the Nazi 0 stars I would
One of the greatest tragedies in recent music history is that the dude capable of making this record turned into such a broken, confused, hateful person. Sucks. Anyway, this album is a monumental piece of art. Absolute game changer in hip-hop. Easy 5.
There’s a reason this guy got popular back in the day, before all the crazy shit. Some bangers on this album but good listen overall even though I disagree with those school spirit skits
Jesus Walks carries this album
So weird to have a rapper's debut album also be their more polished, non-problematic stuff.
8.6/10 FANTASTIC story telling. amazing production. catchy and influential. truly a goated album
It’s impossible for me to see this as anything other than a 5. The beats, the production, the cast. It’s all just too epic. And there isn’t a song that misses.
Shane there's no option for zero
Some of its ok but you can't escape the sheer insanity of the "artist"
Not listening to this
Pure caca
AAAAHAGHGGHHHGGG This is the absolute, ultimate art-from-the-artist question. I gave "Layla" 4 stars even if Clapton is a fascist shitbag, so, ughhhhh, here we go: It's sort of funny that I got excited when this came up because I totally gave up on Kanye, to the point where I didn't want him to get the one-trillionth of a cent for even a single stream. But I was really, really looking forward to listening to this again. Not sure what that says about me. Ok, but the music! This album was absolutely unescapable my senior year of college when it dropped. Kanye didn't invent backpack rap, or conscious rap, or Autotune, or incorporating gospel, or much of anything, but goddamn he did something incredibly fresh with it. Lyrically, musically, overall it's a fascinating moment in time. Kanye mostly does a great job walking the balance beam between his desire to an advocate and a poet while acknowledging his materialist, misogynist core. Here, he's still conflicted about it, which is what makes it great. By the time he's done he just wants to wallow in and celebrate his awfulness. Some of this aged poorly: "The New Workout Plan" (really encapsulate the misogyny that runs through all his work), "Breathe In Breath Out," the stupidly long adlib at the end, and the goddamn skits. But this album is so, so dense, and has so many bangers I almost forgot some existed (e.g., "School Spirit," "Two Words," "Spaceship"), along with some of the best songs of the aughts ("All Falls Down" "Family Business" "Jesus Walks"). A great album by a rotten, mentally ill man.
It's insane how different this is to so much of the other hip hop at the time, chipmunk soul will always have a very special place in my heart
I don't like Kanye West. However, this album featured plenty of other [more talented] artists like Ludacris, Twista, and the Boys Choir of Harlem. So it wasn't a miserable listening experience.