Reviews (page 9 of 16)
The haters will hate but this is a very good album containing my favorite Kanye
“I miss the old Kanye” -Kanye Probably on my Mount Rushmore of favorite albums.
0 out of 5. The same day this album came up Kanye doubled down on his praise for Hitler and Nazis.
I seriously don't get this--nor am I interested in getting it.
no.
This is a tough one to rate. I've never been a big Kanye fan, even before his current mental health crises (as of the time writing this he's currently on Twitter literally professing his love for Hitler... you can't make this up), but I can acknowledge all he's done for both production in general and hip hop. Death of an Artist? I still didn't love the album, way too long and too many skits. There were some stand-out tracks: Jesus Walks, and All Fall Down that keep this from a single star.
Its a classic
Kanye West: 0 Stars - Is a Nazi - Has an ego complex the size of The Sears Tower - evidently doesn’t like the North Side of CHI - is just a shitty person in general - Has made some really good music. Strong strong singles on this album. Shame that he is trash.
Great melodies. Good story and lyrics. But I can't fully enjoy it due to Kanye's latest behaviour. Guess I can't fully separate the art from the artist. Thereflre the max score I'm willing to give this is an 8. Fuck Kanye.
One of the best album of music history!
This would be three stars, I could never get down with Kanye the way others could. But he’s a Nazi so fuck him, one star.
Odio a west
we eating good today, two 5/5 albums in a row
Hard no from me, horrible little man with or without the mental health issues I am sure he is a good musician but needs help and as all narcissists and bullies, just ignore him, hopefully he will go away
Amuugy faszos
1) Hiphop is typically not a genre I like 2) but I can appreciate there were some interesting moments, both musically and lyrically 3) but for the most part, the messages or tens of the lyrics aren't especially compelling to me 4) and finally, going back to point 1: hiphop ain't my thing. Quite a few songs I slipped out of a little past halfway because the setting was getting boring.
Bangers and fun, I like his newer stuff better.
nazi
Well damn. Didn't think Kanye's debut would slap like this. Baller beats all the way through. On the weaker tracks, Kanye's Flow, the beats and the occasional feature carry you through. The strong tracks are instantly recognizable classics. The album is dripping with innovation and delivers good story telling, all "without using knives or guns". Only criticism: could have been condensed a bit more. 4.5/5
I miss the old Kanye... When he made charmful beats. Also, this album could be a little shorter
I’ve been waiting for this one. I’ve read some of the reviews of this album, and it’s kind of funny (?) to me. Almost all the reviews from 2020 and 2021 praise the album and the artist, while those from 2022 and beyond seem less supportive of him (wonder why?). I’m not saying he doesn’t deserve the criticism—or even a boycott, for that matter—because he probably does. But it’s interesting, and kind of sad, to see the shift in perspective regarding one of this century's most innovative and influential artists. His first release comes from a time long before he managed to make the whole world turn against him, and I am at least trying to separate his older art from the person he’s become today. But I’m not by any means saying that everyone else should try, cause goddamn he makes it difficult.
Boycotting this artist
Nous voilà en 2004. Une année un peu bâtarde, musicalement parlant. Le grand frisson du début du siècle s'est un peu calmé, le rock garage new-yorkais commence déjà à tourner en rond et le hip-hop, eh bien, le hip-hop est en pleine crise de bling. Ça brille, ça rutile, ça parle de flingues, de putes et de grosses bagnoles sur des prods de plus en plus lisses. Une caricature de ce que le genre avait pu être. Et puis, le livre "1001 Albums" me force à me pencher sur le cas Kanye West. Kanye, à l'époque, ce n'était pas encore le demi-dieu mégalomane, le mari de star de la télé-réalité, le gourou de la mode ou le candidat à la présidence. Non. En 2004, Kanye West, c'était avant tout LE producteur. Le petit génie de l'ombre chez Roc-A-Fella, le type qui avait offert à Jay-Z des beats en or massif pour son Blueprint. Un orfèvre du sample, un type qui savait faire sonner la soul des années 70 comme personne. Tout le monde attendait son passage derrière le micro avec une curiosité mêlée de scepticisme. Un bon producteur fait rarement un bon rappeur. C'est une règle quasi immuable dans ce business. Et puis The College Dropout est arrivé. Et là, pendant une bonne moitié de disque, j'ai dû ravaler mon cynisme. Il faut le dire, le crier, le graver dans le marbre : la première partie de cet album est une putain de claque. Une claque monumentale. Kanye, ce petit con arrogant, a réussi un tour de force. Il a pris le hip-hop à contre-pied. Pendant que les autres se la jouaient caïds de cour de récré, lui, il est arrivé avec ses doutes, ses angoisses de mec qui a lâché la fac, ses frustrations de vendeur chez Gap, ses questionnements sur la religion et le matérialisme. Le mec ne rappe pas sur le fait de vendre de la coke, mais sur sa peur de ne pas percer, sur la pression familiale, sur le racisme ordinaire. Il parle de Jésus, de sa mère, de ses complexes. Putain, enfin un peu de chair, un peu d'âme ! Et la production... Ah, la production ! C'est là que le génie éclate au grand jour. C'est riche, c'est chaud, c'est inventif. Les samples de Chaka Khan, de Lauryn Hill, de Curtis Mayfield, les choeurs gospel qui te soulèvent l'âme, cette façon de triturer des vieilles pépites soul pour en faire des hymnes modernes... C'est du grand art. On sent le mec qui a passé des heures à fouiller dans les bacs, le genre de client que j'aurais adoré et détesté à la fois. Le genre de type qui te fait découvrir des merveilles tout en te faisant sentir que t'es à la ramasse. Des morceaux comme "Jesus Walks", "All Falls Down" ou "Through the Wire" (enregistré la mâchoire bandée après un accident, la légende était en marche) sont des monuments. C'est intelligent, c'est drôle, c'est touchant, ça groove. Ça te réconcilie avec le rap mainstream. On se dit que le genre a encore des choses à dire, qu'il peut être subversif et populaire en même temps. On se dit que ce disque a amplement sa place dans ce foutu bouquin. On est aux anges. On se dit qu'on tient le chef-d'oeuvre. Et puis... Et puis vient la deuxième moitié. Le soufflé qui retombe. Brutalement. Je ne sais pas ce qui s'est passé dans la tête du bonhomme, mais à partir du onzième morceau, la machine se grippe. Le marathonien qui était en tête de la course s'écroule à quelques kilomètres de l'arrivée. C'est long, mais alors qu'est-ce que c'est long... Les morceaux s'étirent sans raison, les interludes et les skits, au début amusants, deviennent d'une lourdeur insupportable. On a l'impression qu'il a voulu absolument tout mettre, qu'il a été incapable de faire le tri. C'est le drame de l'artiste qui est aussi son propre producteur : personne pour lui dire "Mec, là, tu te touches un peu la nouille, on coupe". Le flow de Kanye, qui n'a jamais été son point fort, montre ses limites. Les idées de production, si brillantes au début, semblent se répéter, s'essouffler. On passe d'un festin de roi à une fin de banquet où on ronge des os en espérant y trouver un peu de saveur. C'est flagrant. On commence à regarder sa montre. On se fait chier, soyons honnêtes. L'album dure plus d'une heure, et il aurait dû, il aurait fallu, qu'il s'arrête à 40 minutes. Il serait alors passé du statut de "très bon album inégal" à celui de "classique absolu". C'est toute la frustration de ce disque. Un chef-d'oeuvre amputé. Un sprint de génie qui se termine en footing poussif. C'est l'histoire d'un type qui a tellement de choses à dire qu'il finit par ne plus rien dire du tout, noyé dans sa propre logorrhée. C'est peut-être ça, le "syndrome du premier album" pour un producteur qui devient artiste. L'envie de prouver tellement de choses qu'on en oublie l'essentiel : la concision. Au final, que reste-t-il ? Le souvenir impérissable d'une première moitié stratosphérique. Et le goût amer d'une fin qui gâche la fête. C'est pour cette raison que je ne peux pas lui mettre plus. C'est un grand disque malade, un génie qui n'a pas su quand s'arrêter. Une promesse incroyable, mais tenue à moitié. Allez, un 3/4, et c'est bien payé pour m'avoir fait bailler pendant près de trente minutes.
Classic. Some of my favorite songs on here.
not another kanye west album :(
This album is definitely catchy and was enjoyable for its time, bringing a refreshing energy with its uplifting production. One thing I just learned from listening to this is the term “chipmunk soul”—a production style that speeds up soul samples to create a distinctively bright and energetic sound. I never knew there was an actual name for that technique, but it definitely adds to the album’s lively and feel good vibe.
Nope, did not listen, I still cannot support the work of this antisemitic fascist sympathizer.
Not just another Gangsta-Rap album. But still Gangsta-Rap...
I didn't get it. I know the hype around this one. Didn't grab me at all.
This album is such a fucking good debut, despite the rate Kanye is at right now, it is amazing where he came from and what comes after. The lyrics, vibe and production is something to praise. I don't have much else to say. 9.9/10
BEATS ARE EVIL. I've already heard most of them, but the ones which I hadn't heard surprised me at how good they are (spaceship, breathe in breathe out). Rapping is obviously good probably Kanye's best ever (unfortunately). Hooks are pretty repetitive but often good. Features are also good. Quite a lot of songs shouldn't exist and the skits are not needed at all and all pretty terrible (besides the guy with the funny voice). Overall around 8/10
Nazi
So damn amazing... from beginning to end. This holds up
90/100
A few good songs, but not much more.
My controversial Ye opinion is that his early work isn't that good. Overproduced, autotune, too many skits. But there are some diamonds in here as well.
Not going to line this madman's pockets by listening.
I automatically assumed I'd hate this. I was tempted to skip it, but I committed to listening to every album. I'm glad I did listen to it. Not that I liked it (I didn't), but I didn't absolutely hate it as I thought I would. So I'll keep listening to everything, as I've found some surprisingly good stuff here. 2 stars, though, cos I definitely didn't actually like it.
Goat album hands down
Not a Kanye fan. Too much ugliness to separate from his art.
Solid and timeless, poetic and creative. Still hate nazis tho sry not sry
Actually a good album, solid thing, but I'm not into the explicit and I don't want to have many more albums like that so I'm going to give it a 2/5, but musically its a solid 4/5
Not really an album. Couple bangers on there tho.
Authentic, smart, and listenable.
god dam a fkn masterpiece The beats, hooks, flows, samples, wordplay, and features all top tier Truly groundbreaking hip hop album And it was his debut sheesh 10/10 You could cut this album in half, keep only the deep cuts, and it’d still be one of the best things released that decade I think through the wire is a goofy song tho
This clown doesn’t deserve the credit from a single stream.
Oh how far he has fallen
Tough to rate with the usual metrics due to skit tracks. I like a lot of this but it’s not my favorite Kanye. Slow Jamz was a fun throwback. This album had some BOPS! Family Business is my fave though. I was gonna say 3 stars but we upgrade to 3.77 on vibes alone. It’s GOOD.
In a vacuum I'd probably rate this one as a 3 - that's where I put Common's Kanye-produced album Be, which to me feels like a spiritual cousin to this album - but I'm choosing to apply an artist turd penalty here. West is a still living, still active artist who sucks a whole lot and who played a nasty role in American politics for a season. Not sure where I'd draw the line on this - I didn't let the fact that Phil Spector murdered someone weigh down my rating of his Christmas album - but I think Kanye's over it. (Don't know if he's on the list, but I'd probably also punt Marilyn Manson?)
Hiphop klassieker. Pionier van de moderne hiphop productie. Af en toe nog opvallend scherpe social commentary voor iemand die tegenwoordig de draad volledig kwijt is.
Absolute classic, this is one of the best Kanye albums, and it's all cause his lyrics hasn't been tainted by the big ass ego he gets in the future. It doesn't have the amazing and grandiose production like MBDTF, but the down to earth vibe, and way more likable Kanye works wonders here. Skits are great and funny, and i don't think there is a single forgettable song on here.
First time listening to this entire album, shit fucking slaps. Not a huge fan of his later stuff, but Imo this is prime Kanye. 4/5
No. I got halfway through We Don't Care and wondered why should I spend my valuable time listening to an antisemitic, homophobic, racist, rapist POS. Also, he sings flat.
Either I am racist or hip-hop is a bad genre of music.
Kanye is a jackass. Literally could not wait for Family Bidness and Last Call and the album to be over. (Did think his line about black card being African American Express was funny, ha ha.) Something about this experience made it seem lame, I think it’s his rhymes (1,75*s)
I will preface this by saying Mr. West turned out to be a deplorable human being so I hate to like any of this (including contributing to his bottom line by streaming this for the review). He's awful but damn, he makes some fire beats. When this album came out it was different than others in the genre and a lot of the songs are really catchy and dare I say clever. He has some undeniable talent but I'm finding it hard to separate the art from the artist and I probably would have rated this higher 10+ years ago. The first half of TCD is much stronger (Slow Jamz and prior), after that it goes downhill (plus the skits are embarrassingly laughable). This sorta sums up early-Kanye into Yeezy into the sheer lunatic he is now (publicity skits included). Considering all factors, I can't go higher than a 3.05.
Yeezy got chipmunk soul? I don't think so but this album was massive when it hit and has some good tracks like "All Falls Down" and "Through the Wire." Some better lyrical play and content then I originally thought. Should have finished college though so he could learn to write better skits... so dumb. Ye has been a polarizing character through the decades and def an arrogant bastard that's over compensating for something (lying about his P.h.D.). I will say I like some of his tunes but never dug the lazy rap style much. Not the worst thing to come out of Chi-town...1.87.
It's hard not to be aware of Kanye West's relatively public and scandalous rise and fall. Despite his huge pop culture influence I hadn't heard any of his music beyond a couple of radio hits many many years ago. I had never delved into any aspect of his early career but have consistently heard from various sources that The College Dropout is a great album. I went in skeptical, but after finishing this listen I have to agree. It's a different take on rap with some pretty catchy tracks and some clever lyrics. It hits on some of the common rap tropes but mostly avoids a lot the standard gangsta rap points that never really worked for me. I had never heard a single song off of The College Dropout and was entertained from start to finish. If he was able to build off of this strong debut I can see how he quickly elevated himself to one of the biggest rappers of his era. Unfortunately Kanye has certainly had a storied history. He has done himself no favors over the past couple of years which has only served to distance himself from what may once have been a very promising musical career. At this point I think most people look at him as an off-the-rails psycho and largely ignore his music (I know I did prior to this listen). Glad I was given a reason to give this one a listen. Solid review from my end. 3.18 stars
Yeah he sucks, but I’m not gonna boycott an artist because they’re a terrible person, then half the list would be null. Plus I don’t see you guys boycotting the Christmas album made by an actual convicted murderer. Anyway now for the actual review. This is some of the best hip hop production I've heard. Insane lyricism, kinda feels like every important rapper from the early 2000s showed up in this one, some emotional moments, some super fun ones, this is one of the best rap albums I’ve ever heard to be honest. Sucks that Kanye would go into a downward spiral 20 years later. But I’m not gonna let that deter me from saying this album is excellent.
Aus dem WC fließt der Haufen in den Kanal und von da ins Klärwerk und von dort wird elles gesammelt und konzentriert und mitten im Konzentrat steck dieses Album, das für meinen Geschmack zum Himmel stinkt 💩.
good
The downfall of a great musician chapter 1
Now the, we've had a few modern artists from this genre, and much as I hate to admit it, this is one of the best. Yes he makes some social and political statements, but he's not too in your face about. The lyrics are well put together, for the most part, and it's not bad listening on the whole. But it's just not me enough to give me more than a 2. It's a shame really, as I can't but feel it deserves better. But I just can't do it.
Gave it a listen as I always do, despite a very strong preconception of what I was going to hear. This time my preconception was right. An absolute pile of steaming plop.
This is the second KW album I've listened to now. I first thought my first experience was an aberration, so much so that I enjoyed it and gave the first on a 4 star review. Maybe it isn't an aberration after all as this was better than expected. The standout track was 'Jesus Walks', I might even add it to a playlist! He may not be my thing but I can understand his appeal.
Euhm, gingen we muziek maken of zeikverhaaltjes ophangen? Dat laatste dus. Want meneertje is gezakt voor z'n examen en daarom is hij heel erg zielig. Zielig? Nee, hij is dus juist echt heel stoer! Of wat dan ook. Jeuh, wat een rolmodel. Want waarom zou je je hersens aanzetten, als je gewoon stoer heel dom kunt blijven. Dat is immers precies wat de wereld vandaag nodig heeft.
Even het boek erbij. Volgens mijn 2006 editie meldt Kan West dat als hij met een beatje eronder de oude soul naar het nieuwe millenium brengt, het net is alsof God dat doet. De man was blijkbaar toen de weg al goed kwijt... Dat zijn wel meer goede artiesten. Dus laten we maar eens luisteren. Het verrast me. Het latere album dat we kregen voelde zo afgeraffeld. Maar dat is nu helemaal niet. Misschien het voordeel van een debut plaat. Alle energie en creativiteit zit dan nog in een artiest. Leve de debutjes! Dit plaatje wordt gekenmerkt door rustige rap. Niet zwoel, maar vooral ongeforceerd. Zonder naar de teksten te luisteren voelt het daardoor 'echt'. Binnen die stijl wordt aardig afgewisseld. En dan luister het plaatje makkelijk weg. Je mist wel een mooie uitschieter of iets onderscheidends. Waardoor het maar een hele krappe 4 wordt.
Ik moet altijd even moed en zin verzamelen bij een hiphopalbum en dan met name als ze weer dik over het uur heen gaan. Dat is soms best een opgave, al heb ik ze ook meer dan eens met een 4 beloond. Ik hoor dingen waar ik me aan stoor: veel te veel skits. Gebruik van autotune (het blijft redelijk binnen de perken gelukkig). Maar ik hoor ook goede dingen. Prima flowende rap, swingende deuntjes en beatjes. Goede samenwerkingen met andere artiesten. Als je dan toch samenwerkt, zorg dan dat het wat toevoegt. Dat doet Ye wel. Zoals gewoonlijk luister ik niet naar de teksten, maar volgens mij gaat het over normalere zaken. Over logischere onderwerpen. Dat hij tegenwoordig wat op hol geslagen is, nemen we voor dit debuutalbum voor lief. Ik kan hier prima naar luisteren. Ik ken er geen hitje van helaas, maar ik wil de 3,5 best wel weer afronden naar een 4. Ben benieuwd of er ooit nog een hiphopplaat een 5 gaat scoren bij mij.
Podrán decir lo que quieran de Kanye West, pero carajo, el tipo sabe como hacer música.
Another elaborate hip hop album, deftly produced, complex and clever lyrics, which probably deserves a second listen, but which I think I may appreciate and admire, but which I don't think I'll ever really love or connect to emotionally, although the run of tracks from New Workout Plan onwards are fun and I like them, but the final Last Call is just way too long and I can't imagine listening to Kanye's rambling memories for fun again.
Class. Forgot how good this sounds
It’s hard to believe that this album is so divisive. I guess some people have trouble separating the man from the music. Is Kanye a narcissistic, mentally ill douche? Without a doubt. Is The College Dropout the most influential rap album of the aughts? I believe so. Like it or not, Kanye changed the production game and made it okay for rappers to be a bit nerdy. 4.5/5
I tried but no thanks. Not for me.
it’s such a shame that it’s more or less impossible to talk about kanye without the shadow of his mental breakdown hovering over everything because he truly was so spectacularly talented. his music sounds so ELEMENTAL, like it’s impossible to imagine a world in which it didn’t already exist. i am ultimately pro-education but i think that the skits still kinda hit honestly lol. his lyrics are just so clever and funny!!!! ugh!!!!!!!! loses a half star cos “last call” is too long…i GET it but it should have been split up into two tracks imo. fav tracks: jesus walks; never let me down; get em high; school spirit; two words
aaaaaaaaaaaaAAAAAAHHHH!!! Well it’s very good. And it makes me kinda sad because it’s too bad that he’s taken the trajectory that he has because he really was a pioneer with such an identifiable impact on music as foreshadowed by this record. I maintain that if something tragic and shocking had happened like ~8 years ago to him and caused him to d*e he would’ve been immortalized as a misunderstood, cutting edge genius. I think he still will, but obviously his legacy has gotten pretty complicated especially considering the lyrical themes earlier in his career. I think besides the later skits skewing a bit too “we live in a society” for me, the messaging on the album is so well executed. His egotism is balanced out by a thoughtfulness about his surroundings that on paper sound contradictory of each other, but end up creating a complicated and compelling narrator, which kept me engaged in the lyrics basically the whole time. This is the first time I think I’ve actually listened to this all the way through despite recognizing several songs and lyrics, so it was great to see how it all comes together. The music itself is so interesting on this too, and he really did have to be kind of a crazy genius to think of combining ideas the way he did on some of these songs. “Jesus Walks” in particular has so much going on with the various choral parts, and even songs like “Slow Jamz” whose foundation is a more classic soul sound, has a twist because of the production and then is topped with iconic but ridiculous lyrics like the Michael Jackson line. Despite his impact of having mainstreamed hip hop / hip hop influences into pop music, a lot of this still sounds pretty unlike anything else I’ve heard. There’s so much variety and complexity on here, and despite its length, it never lags and kept me on my toes. It was genuinely very exciting to listen to. *Fav tracks: Jesus Walks, All Falls Down, Never Let Me Down, Through the Wire*
F@&$ this S%#/! Would like to vote Zero stars.
I enjoyed this album a lot first time around - but given he is such a massive bellend now I will not be listening this time round.
The College Dropout The man is mentally ill, I’ve seen him eat a plastic pie It’s kind of hard to think back to before he was a bit Nazi and before his megalomaniacal narcissistic personality emerged when he made great pop-rap like this album. It is a bit long, and like many hip hop albums the skits are completely pointless, but it is a great pop album, full of great hooks and samples and it sounds excellent. You can tell it’s from the mid 2000s but it has a nice round fullness to the sound, there are no sharp edges to it, or much rhythmic harshness, and the pitched up soul samples and gospel inflections give a nice bit of warmth, adding to the overall accessible feel. Lyrically it’s also really accessible, ranging across religion, race, working at the Gap, fame etc and mixing bravado with introspection and a degree of self awareness that is pointedly different to what came along later. Jesus Walks and Through the Wire are bangers but there are great tracks strewn across it; We Don’t Care, Spaceship, Never Let Me Down, Get Em High, School Spirit, The New Workout Plan and Two Words are all great, diverse tracks. Dickheadedness not withstanding this is a great listen; catchy, melodic, amusing and great sounding. Solid 4. 🐻🐻🐻🐻 Playlist submission: Jesus Walks
I've listened to this a few times and I'm not sure how good it is. He is a tragic figure really, and I know his view have been less than wholesome but, benefit of the doubt, he'd forgotten to take his meds. He did help move rap on from the ostensible inexorable bling movement, and probably paved the way for the likes of Kendrick Lamar. For that, and for some good tunes in here it's a three.
Needs more guitar solos
This is a good album, 3/5. I'm not a huge fan of Kanye West generally, but he does have some nice tracks. Of the 21 tracks on this album, four (4) are on my "liked" songs list.
perfect 10/10
Es difícil hablar de Kanye West en big 2025 por lo de que está, bueno, loco. Sin embargo, nunca me ha costado separar arte de artista, aunque sea altamente personal como en este caso. Hace bastante tiempo, cuando en el mismo 1001 Albums Generator me salió MBDTF de Kanye West me volví instantáneamente en un fan del hip hop. Y, en consecuencia, me puse a oír el resto de la discografía de Kanye. Titular tu álbum debut como "The College Dropout" en una época donde la cultura de ser un gangsta en el rap estaba en su apogeo ya es una declaración de intenciones clarísima. Que tu primera canción sea sobre vender drogas debido a no encontrar salida y no porque es la cosa "gangsta" de hacer es otra declaración más. Y con ese inicio, tenemos más de una hora de canciones increíbles sobre hacer lo que tu quieras y no lo que la sociedad vea correcto para ti (vender drogas por ahí, graduarte...), donde lo mejor de la música de Kanye destaca especialmente: su producción, usando ese estilo de samples de canciones de soul antiguas para crear un estilo totalmente nuevo, donde el ritmo suele ser más importante que lo que se dice en la canción. Y es que, a diferencia de en su discografía posterior, aquí Kanye es una persona humilde, autoconsciente y con los pies pegados al suelo. En mi canción favorita de este álbum, Family Business, Kanye habla sobre una reunión familiar donde recuerdan a los que no están, momentos de la infancia y hablan sobre sus vidas, todo desde una perspectiva nostálgica y muy bonita. Y es que The College Dropout se siente reconfortante, se siente totalmente fresco pese a tener más de 20 años, y se siente como algo que nunca más vas a volver a tener (al menos con Kanye, eso seguro lol). En resumen, uno de mis álbumes favoritos y que es totalmente recomendable para meterte en la música de Kanye y el Hiphop en general. Olvida que es nazi, eso sí. TOP 5 Canciones: 1. Family Business 2. Through the Wire 3. We Don't Care 4. Jesus Walks 5. New Workout Plan 5/5
3.5 What's with all the fucking skits? Kanye is very talented, shame he's such a shitty person.
Unfortunately, I encountered Kanye's reputation before his music, and I find it incredibly difficult to separate the art from the artist.
Pretty solid album from Kanye. Standout tracks: We Don't Care All Falls Down Get 'Em High Through the Wire Family Business
Okay
I once again hate how good of an album this is for how bad of a person Kanye is. Ugh. The beats here are great and the mix of styles is soooo impressive. The production here is amazing. I normally hate skits too, but these were good. The School Spirit / Lil Jimmy Skits were pretty funny. I can't believe this a debut album. Pretty impressive. "Last Call" was such an ehhh way to end an album tho. Actual Rating is a 4.5. Perfect Songs: "We Don't Care" , "All Falls Down" , "Never Let Me Down" , "The New Workout Plan" , and "Through The Wire" Liked Songs: "Slow Jamz" , "Get Em High" , "I'll Fly Away" , "Spaceship" , and "Jesus Walks"
liked songs: Here we go again. We Don't Care was a hard listen. Surprisingly, Kanye's rapping and singing was fine. The kid's choir, however, may qualify as cruel and unusual punishment. All Falls Down was fine. It's very 2004. Spaceship had a neat bassline, but why the plastic garbage can sound effect? I have many thoughts on Jesus Walks, but they all boil down to Kanye's ego. Never Let Me Down was decent. Get Em High sucks. The New Workout Plan was a funny track. Interesting string arrangement. Slow Jamz was the most musically interesting track so far. Breathe In Breathe Out... Ludacris' part made me want to "peace ouuuuuuuutt..." School Spirit (+ skits): Kanye, why do you hate education so much? Two Words and Through the Wire were fine. The samples on Family Business made me irrationally angry because they were so annoying and so far up in the mix. Which is a shame, because the guest vocals/arrangement were actually good. Last Call... Kanye, my dude, this could've been an email Again, I think the only real credit I can give here is for some very talented people that worked on the album (John Legend, Miri Ben-Ari, a lot of others). 1.5
Listening to this album in 2025 feels like listening to an album from a deceased artist. I don’t know when or how or why Kanye became who is today but I’m able to separate the art from the artist enough to acknowledge the greatness of this album. It was fresh and original and exciting when it came out and remains a testament to the depth of Kanye‘s talent.
I actually found myself kind of enjoying this album. I like it a lot better than Yeezus. I enjoyed All Falls Down, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, and Never Let Me Down. Kanye really does make some very interesting music. It's not 100% my thing but I can appreciate it. It's a shame he's such an awful person.
His peak I fear
Most of vocals were clear and often humorous. Decent chill beats.
Didn't want to like this because, you know, but I actually really did think some of these songs were really good.
Ok, not great
this has some good deep cuts here but considering how good some of his discography is this is kind of mid tier (defs not near the bottom, man has probably had the biggest and most unending fall from grace i have ever seen)
Perhaps ironically, one of the most intelligent albums ever made is titled The College Dropout.
Ah, Kanye again, the real struggle of separating the art from the artist. I couldn't do it for Yeezus because by then he'd already gone into ubercunt mode, but I suppose The College Dropout is him at the start of a journey where that didn't seem likely. I actually bought Late Registration but never owned or really listened to this, it's alright, has some strong moments in All Falls Down, Never Let Me Down (especially, it's great) and Two Words, but the rest is a little overblown in style, content and length. Those three tracks probably squeeze it to a 3/5 though, they're really good, but it probably says something else that they're all made better by collabs.
This was the first rap album that I owned I think? Haven't listened to it for ages, but it still holds up pretty well; there's definitely a few tracks that aren't great but the singles are really strong. I don't like skits at the best of times really, and there are too many on this album, but Kanye does them a lot better than most (particularly the School Spirit ones). Solid 4/5.
Way more my music taste. "Never Let Me Down" is such a good song. I love this song. The album is very cool. It was not my introduction to Kanye, but it is really good. I love this album. Laughed so hard at all School Spirit parts. Especially "School Spirit Skit 2". That's my life :D Also I like "Family Business". And the album cover is cool with this sad looking bear. Even if not every song is perfect, in my opinion, there are some diamonds in it that make it absolutely perfect.
Surprisingly enjoyed this, but it's far too long.
Should really be a 5/5 but I hate skit interludes and there's like seven interludes on this record
Just rated the previous album and had some thoughts about having done this for a year now and oh fuck off.
Great album. Antisemite though
Album #8 - Ye: 0/5 This album is really nostalgic for me, and shows that Ye really had the ability to be great. Too bad he turned out to be an absolute garbage human. Ye is a Nazi-loving, Hitler-praising antisemitic. He is a misogynist, a MAGA bro, and an idiot.
One of the greatest rap albums of all time, probably the best rap producer of all time. Makes me feel sad about his fall off, but that doesn't change how incredible this album is. Even the skits are good. Iconic album that set the tone for a generation
I try really hard, but every time I try to listen to Kanye's music I can't stop thinking about what a horrible person he is. That aside, this was actually not that bad. It shows that this was early Kanye before he went complete bonkers, so this feels much more humble than his later works somehow. The album didn't start out that strong for me. I don't think I really get Kanye that well, or modern rap for that matter (if you can call 2004 modern). It turned at 'Slow Jamz', followed by 'Breathe In Breathe Out' which I think had a really cool riff. The whole school skit section with 'School Spirit' in the middle was actually pretty well done. Usually skits don't add much value but here Kanye portrayed some self-distance. The three last songs were good as well, with 'Through The Wire' being a classic. In summary I think this will have to get a weak 4 to me. It seems very widely praised, and I can understand why to some extent, but it just doesn't sit THAT well with me.
I wasn't really in to rap-music in my teens. I had a Jimmie Hendrick's t-shirt and long hair. Still, the one rap-album I did own was "The College Dropout". I listened to this album a lot! I even remember having a PE-class where we had lead the warmup and me and my friend chose "The new Workout Plan" to do our warm-up class to! After listening to this, I still think this is a good album. There are a few iconic hits like "The new workout plan", "Jesus Walks" and "Through the Wire". The lyrics run from poignant e.g "All Falls Down" which may be my favourite song on the album (together with "Never let me down") to just stupid ("Get em High"). As always the samples are great and the guest raps are great to. I think this is a classic album and really defined a lot of the 00s hip-hop. Although i may be biased as this was all the rap i knew for quite a few years. I think this deserves a 5.
It's truly tragic what the cult of celebrity, unmedicated mental illness, and who knows what else has turned Kanye West into. Listening to this I can't help but think that 2004 Kanye would absolutely hate 2025 Ye. Yeezus has been my go to Kanye album in recent years, but this was a fantastic listen today. I found that despite not listening to many of these songs since I was a teen I still knew almost all of the words, particularly to faves like "Spaceships". His production remains unimpeachable. He'd been making hits for bigger acts for years and saving and tweaking these beats for his own debut and it shows, these aren't just beats they are entire songs built off of his prodigious drum programming and distinctive sampling style. Lyrically, this is definitely his funniest and most coherent album. At the time these sort of self conscious, introspective bars were far from mainstream. Also, there are so many clever and hilarious quotable lines. The outro in "Last Call" describing the challenges he experienced trying to get this album released is a great historical snapshot of the culture at the time, and prophetically lays out how influential this album would come to be.
Unexpectedly loved this. Not a huge hip-hop listener (mostly just lack of knowledge more than anything). I lived in Chicago when Chance the Rapper’s “Coloring Book” came out in 2016, and the album felt like it was everywhere. I knew Kanye was a key collaborator, but it was even cooler to listen to this album and here the original ideas that came to later influence Chance—the melodic qualities, chipmunk-y sound, etc. Listening brought me back home to Chicago.
Shitty person, but classic album.
There are two kinds of people. Kanye, and Kanye’s other personality.
he was excellent before he went crazy
Jesus Walks
This is a good hip hop record. I know it’s a pretty commonly expressed sentiment, but I really do miss the old Kanye. My biggest complaint about this record is its inconsistency. There’s some really top tier singles, a few good songs, and the rest of it feels a lot like filler. As far as the singles go, “Jesus Walks” is clearly the best track on the record, but I personally feel it still pales in comparison to some of Kanye’s later singles. It’s really well produced for a debut record, and you can tell Kanye had a very unique approach and vision when it comes to actually making music. Not my favourite Kanye album, but certainly nowhere near the worst music he’s made. 3/5
This is a really great, classic album. Kanye is a fantastic producer whose sound is so recognizable and had such a massive imprint on the sound of hip hop in the 2000s. His rhymes are clever, creative, humorous, thought-provoking and personal. At a time when most rappers where putting out songs to inflate their ego and image as thugs and ladies’ men, Kanye is on some real shit here. And the soul!!! This is a rather long album and I’m sad to say I think it suffers for it. Some tracks fall flat for me, sound pretty dated, and just bloat the album - namely “Never Let Me Down”, “Get ‘Em High” and “Breathe In Breathe Out”. One could also argue the number of skits and interludes is too damn high. None of the skits on their own are particularly bad or tedious, but they also serve to bog down an album that’s chock full of excellent songs. There is, of course, the nearly-13-minute “Last Call”, as well; I really enjoy hearing Kanye tell his story of producer turned solo artist. But again, it’s just… so long. I really want this to be a 5 ⭐️ album and with a stronger editorial hand it absolutely would be. Unfortunately, there are a handful of skips on it that prevent me from giving it full marks. But it really is an excellent album. 8.5/10
Top 3 kanye
NGL I was bopping out about the first third of this album because it's kinda fun and the beats are good, if overdone at times as is typical of Kanye. But then you keep listening and it's just dumb, vaguely offensive, Jesusy drivel. There was one creative line in Family Business: African American Express It's also cheesy and like so dumb you have to know you're being dumb several times, which I didn't know was also true of his old stuff. Also cool how Work out for me by J Cole sampled this
Want to hate it. I really can't. Damn it, it's actually really good.
Not a Kanye fan
not for me
Kanye West used to be my favorite artist of all time. I once listened to his entire discography at the time on a road trip in 2016. I defended him when he was just an egomaniac comparing himself to God. Then, the Alex Jones interview happened. That was the breaking point for me and many others. This is the first Kanye album I’ve listened to since that interview. I’ve seen so many 1-star reviews for this solely because of what he did and not because of the content of this record. While that is valid, you would have to give 1’s to A LOT of people on this list (David Bowie, Koffi Olomide, John Lennon, Elvis, Morrissey, etc.). The reason Kanye is such an easy target for this is because we all saw it happen. There’s no speculation on what was said. I still find it tough to rate this low because of that. This album is a look into the Kanye that once was: a hungry producer / rapper hoping to make a name for himself by working nonstop for years, waiting for his shot. Once he got signed, he did not let that shot go to waste. Every song on here plays into the theme of betting on yourself, not letting others determine your path for you. The production is immaculate, Kanye peaked as a lyricist here, and the skits add even more life into an already lively album. Kanye sucks. This doesn’t. Don’t punish the art for its artist.
This album is an hour and 16 minutes of pure copium about dropping out of college. Glad it worked out for him though.
Ok, memes aside - this stuff is pretty dope. Młody Kanye, zanim mu odjebało, wiedział, co robi. To są dobre bity i bardzo zgrabne teksty. Dużo dowcipu, gierek słownych, to jest po prostu dobra płyta. That being said - jestem wyedukowanym białasem, a Kanyemu odjebało i został jakąś dziwną karytaturą nazisty, także nie jestem w stanie patrzeć bezstronnie na album, który do przesady gloryfikuje robienie szmalu jako jedyną wartość w życiu i nie tylko krytykuje system edukacyjny w Stanach (do czego ma absolutnie pełne prawo, bo to jest chory shit, teraz jeszcze bardziej, niż w czasach albumu), ale podważa sens edukacji w ogóle (aż dziwne, że jeszcze nie wszedł w komitywę z Trumpem). W tym sensie ten album jest toksyczny.i destrukcyjny, co nie jest obojętne. No i druga sprawa, że o ile nie utwór nie jest o tym, że edukacja jest bez sensu, to jest o przedmiotowym ruchaniu, co też nie jest dla mnie cool. Muzyka i flow tego albumu są naprawdę mocne. Ale jest on koszmarnie niekonstruktywny i destrukcyjny w swoim wyrazie. Ale oceniając muzycznie i konstrukcyjnie zasługuje na cztery imo. Nawet jeśli nie mam zamiaru go więcej słuchać, ani polecać.
Finally something I know and I listened to when it came out. Now with new perspective (20 years!) I see it in new light, better light. Maybe I know more about music, maybe I am older and those lyrics hit differently. All in all I love it and I think it is important part of rap history.
What a tremendous bore.
I miss the old Kanye
Blind album. I'm here to rate the music regardless of the person. This album had some okay tracks and it flowed well, and the skits were creative. I liked Dark Twisted Fantasy more though and I thought a lot of people liked this more from what they told me. Oh well. Meh.
this was a tough listen, to be honest. and… still don’t like kanye.
Fuck Kanye
Kanye... oh Kanye. What the fuck happened? Kanye West used to be cool. Then he started getting egotistical, but his music was still good, so there wasn't a huge problem. Now? Not only has he gone even more crazy with the Hitler shit from the past few years, but his music isn't even good anymore! But you know what? I don't care. Well, okay, I do. However, while it's important to discuss Kanye's issues, I'm not going to be one of those people who just gives all of his albums 1 star without even listening to the music. I have to focus on the quality and impact of the actual album that is The College Dropout. Fortunately, this is his debut album, so none of the issues that I've mentioned even really matter. I'm saying all this stuff like I'm an expert, but this is effectively my first time ever really listening to Kanye West's music. So, how do I feel about The College Dropout? It's great. While I obviously do not love Kanye West as a person, I do love his debut album. Admittedly, this album isn't perfect. However, my only major issue is the length, especially regarding the final track "Last Call." Everything else is great though. Kanye's rapping isn't revolutionary or anything, but it gets the job done quite well. I enjoy it. The writing is pretty good. I haven't listened to his other albums, but I do know that other Kanye albums have some lyrical issues. The College Dropout's writing is very solid. There's funny moments that are actually entertaining and haven't aged poorly. This album has aged remarkably well overall, and the writing demonstrates this well. The subject matter for these songs wasn't as common for hip-hop in 2004 as it is now. You have songs on here about things like religion (Jesus Walks), self-consciousness (All Falls Down) and, of course, school (School Spirit). The variety in songs is just incredible. The concept here is interesting. The production is incredible and ahead of its time. The features are all great. The skits add value to the meaning of the songs and the album as a whole. Ultimately, I can understand why someone would struggle to separate the art from the artist in cases like this. I know I have before. However, I think we have to look at the bigger picture pertaining to the impact of The College Dropout itself. This album not only kick-started the career of (for better or worse) one of the most influential rappers of the 21st century, but it also showed the world that hip-hop was more than edgy gangster music. Of course, other albums did that before, but the influence of The College Dropout is hard to understate. The album's also really good. While Kanye West as a person would probably get a 2/5, I think I have to give The College Dropout a 5/5. The impact and quality are just too hard to ignore.
Listened before. Good but long. Meh on the skits
Not an album I will listen to again. Horrid lyrics and boring beats. It’s also very hard to give any of your time to such a bigot and moron. All falls down and the new workout plan are great songs but the rest of the album seems lazy. Favourite song: all falls down Least favourite: the school spirit tracks are all awful Album artwork: freaky
This is an iconic album for so many reasons, but it’s bloated with skits and multiple skips. Despite the skits and skips, there’s too many great tracks on the top half of this record to not give it a decent rating. Tempted to go 5 stars, but the back half really waters it down in my opinion.
Makes me want to have dropped out of college!
If you can separate the art from the artist this is the best hip hop album of its decade.
There is a lot of good stuff here, and I lot of stuff not so much. I like the gospel influences, not a fan of the 'chipmunk soul'. An impressive list of collabs. If I had heard this when it came out I might have rated it higher. Probably more relevance than I am giving it credit for.
I just kinda struggled to get excited about this one, unfortunately. Even when I was impressed, I wasn’t really interested.
zna se
The beat sampled album of all time. Kanye is godfatherbof chipmunk soul
It’s interesting to go back to this after everything he has become.
5/5. It's crazy this was the first drop from Kanye. Sure, he evolved into a concerning and dangerous person but listening to this shows great promise for a successful career and this is just a fact that his discography is excellent. This is a double album that never feels boring and has funny skits that compliment the songs. It's hard find a bad song here, even the silly ones are just good objectively. It's a balance of rap, R&B, and soul that creates a perfect experience. This is a great front to back listen and a must for this list. A nice dream to see a different man here than who he is today. Best Song: Never Let Me Down, All Falls Down, Through The Wire
“I’m not going to support this Nazi by listening to his music. I mean, I’ll listen to all the other Nazis, pedophiles, rapists, abusers, and general pieces of shit on this list, but not this particular one. Aren’t I enlightened?” - y'all stupid motherfuckers. Fuck y'all. Kanye West has gone insane as many geniuses do but this is a great album. The beats are solid, the subject matter goes beyond the stupid gangsta cliches rappers constantly spout, and it’s actually funny pretty much throughout. But enjoy being morally pure by not listening to this and maybe spin some RHCP instead.
more woman-hating pop-rap. 2* because of the Kweli collab tracks
I respect anyone who refuses to engage with Kanye’s music on moral grounds. Just like his hero Michael Jackson, the challenge of separating art from the artist is unavoidable, especially when considering the scope of his influence. The College Dropout marked his official debut as a solo artist after years of crafting hits for icons like Jay-Z, Ludacris, and Alicia Keys. This felt like a cultural reset, redefining hip-hop with its groundbreaking sound, relatable themes, and crossover appeal. Hailed as a classic debut, the album broke from mainstream hip-hop stereotypes by embracing vulnerability, humour, and middle-class experiences. With its trademark soulful samples and deeply personal storytelling, it struck a chord at the time. Tracks like "Jesus Walks" and "All Falls Down" have become timeless, cementing their place as influential and widely celebrated anthems. In retrospect, the album isn’t without flaws. The skits, amusing at the time, haven’t aged as well and feel excessive, taking up a disproportionate amount of runtime. Out of the 14 tracks remaining a few lag behind the standouts, but even these imperfections highlight Kanye’s burning ambition and potential. From the start, it was clear this was a generational talent. At its heart, The College Dropout is Kanye’s most grounded and accessible work. Its sincerity resonates even as his later albums ventured into experimental and polarizing territory. This debut laid the foundation for Kanye’s transformation into one of music’s most innovative—and controversial—figures. My relationship with Kanye is complicated. He dominated my listening habits for years, regularly appearing in my year-end top artists. And justifiably so—his decade-long run from this debut to 2013’s Yeezus was extraordinary. While I have albums I favour (and some I am ambiguous about) within his discography, his overall influence during that era is undeniable. However, his actions in recent years—from spreading dangerous conspiracies to making repeated anti-Semitic remarks—have tarnished his legacy. I'm sure he doesn't care but I haven’t revisited his music regularly in a while, reflecting my discomfort with his behaviour. Yet, hearing songs from this era instantly transports me back to a time when his music was simply a source of joy and inspiration. I would gladly return to 2004 if only to experience this Kanye again. Despite its imperfections, The College Dropout remains a landmark release—a defining statement from an artist just beginning to show the world the heights of his talent. Did/Do I own this release? On Mp3 Does this release belong on the list? For its cultural impact Would this release make my personal list? MBDTF all day every day. Will I be listening to it again? For the most part, I'm avoiding Kanye these days.
Love this album, one of my comfort albums for a long time I'd say, enjoyed dipping back into it after a long hiatus!
Listened to j Cole 2014 forest hills drive instead
Fuck Kanye. His music is mediocre at best. And as a human being he is completely atrocious.
Slow Jamz is a classic but this is objectively before he gets to his best
He's a racist asshole now, no doubt, but rating the music purely on its own merits this has to be a 5*. Kanye at his best is one of the most captivating artists in modern music and impossible to ignore. Although he became more overtly experimental in later albums, this was still extremely fresh and successful when it came out. The beats are cool and all self-produced, showing his talent as a producer and ability to create a big, epic hip-hop sound. The rapping is great, with clever wordplay and tongue-in-cheek humour throughout. Oh for the days when Kanye didn't take himself too seriously. Packed with hooks and great moments, this is a classic
It’s ok to punch nazis.
A lot going on here. Musically, this one is a banger. A ton of wicked licks and drums. Lyrically, I can't get this. Hip hop def isn't for me. From drugs and gang banging, being a general POS to women, to then spouting off about Jesus and family love. The "comedy" if that's what the whole anti-education stuff is super cringy, but aligns with his Trumpian weirdness.
Awesome
Solid rap album. It's a shame Kanye lost his mind, he's very talented.
Mix equal parts hip-hop, R&B, and gospel, throw in a ton of attitude, chill, and see if you haven’t changed the game completely. Not just groundbreaking, but still imminently listenable.
We Don't Care All Falls Down Jesus Walks Slow Jamz Through the Wire
Kanye innit
top 3 kanye, incredible debut with some of the best beats of the 2000's. shame he hates jewish people.
Better than I expected - I had only listened to one full Kanye album before and I really didn't like that. This had some great production, which makes sense, and some surprisingly good stuff from Kanye. But it definitely falls short for me. Way too long. Annoying skits. And, well, Kanye.
Ja, abwechslungsreich.
Let’s get this out of the way first: Kanye is a real asshole piece of shit but that doesn’t mean his music automatically is as well. College Dropout ranks among the best hip hop albums and just albums in general ever made. His latest output is shit but his first 5 albums or so are classics and this one, together with MBTDF is probably his best. Not a bad song on this thing.
Kanye has always been an insane, phenomenal producer. The beats and samples are crazy and timeless. Slow Jamz is one of my favorite songs on this album, it's beautiful.
5 beats a day for 3 summers, it's the quintessential album of someone who proved themselves through grind and effort. To this day, still one of his best albums and is near top marks, but it is a bit bloated with some of the skits and 12 minute outro. This is the old Kanye people miss, the Kanye before he lost his mother, before he went off the meds, before he lost Kanye and became Ye. His current abhorrent actions will continue to degrade and spoil his legacy and catalogue, but this is his most 'innocent' stage of his career like Jackson 5 was to Michael Jackson.
Phenomenal storytelling, I think the skits really add to the appeal of this album. Completely recommend listening, it is just plain fun all the way through.
Almost a 4. It felt a little long-winded, especially the last song. I didn't enjoy the skits but I don't usually in music albums, but the music was pretty great
I miss the old Kanye. Not my favorite Kanye album, but it is produced well. I found myself singing along to the chorus and singing more so than the rap lyrics. Good features, my favorite being Jamie Fox. That outro story was a little long winded.
Jesus Walks has always been a track that I've been ashamed to like. I'm now ashamed to like a lo more.
Again Kanye West is technically good but I just cannot get into his lyrical content.
Kanye keeps surprising me every time. I avoided hin cause although his producing skills are amazong and his knowledge of music is vast, I just dont like him. But music speaks louder than idiocoracy and his rants and crap. This guy is a producing machine and a musical genius. Apart from all the gospel and praying, I understand its part of who he is and his culture. Not my thing but I get hebis pouring hisbheart out in each and every single song he records.
Excellent album. Maybe sags a little in the middle but so many great tracks. Obligatory disclaimer, yeah he said some bad words but this is a music list not a people pure from wrongdoing list. I'm sure this list is peppered with people who've done worse.
Not going to lie, I went into this with the preconception that I wouldn't like it. However, I didn't hate it. I did get really bored of it about halfway though, so I can't give it more than a 2.
First 9 tracks are really really great. Then the middle kinda lost me and not a big fan of skits. However last 3 redeemed the album 3.5/5 (could be a 4)
Oh boy, where to start? Let's get it out the way. Praising Hitler is really not where it's at, any vaguely decent person knows that but we're talking about Kanye West here he's not a well man. However if we excused every unwell person for praising genocidal maniacs, we'd be in a real pickle. Music is decent enough, he's done better work I HATE skits on rap/hip hop albums.
This album came out when I was coasting through college and changed the trajectory of mainstream hip hop.
Eat shit kkk west
it's good but it's kanye u know (listened to on a random youtube channel) fav track never let me down for sure
I at least gave it a listen. He sucks as a person, and the album is a poor product of its time. He’s not a genius. He’s not a messiah. He’s just got an enormous ego. And when you push for mocking education and reinforcement of religion, you get a population full of idiots.
What to do with this album? Obviously a talented artist, albeit not really in my genre, but I respect the work. Then there’s the person who I usually try to separate out, but this is a bit of a special case. Terrible person or not it’s not an album I would likely return to, it is what it is.
Not a single bad song on this
The decline of rap
First time I ever listened to Kanye. I now understand the meaning of Chipmunk Soul/R&B/Rap. I can dig the vibe but I'm turned off by his antisemitism - not a musician for me. Bit of weird finish with the long extended stream of consciousness storytelling.
Can't listen without hearing current mental health cries.
Kanye! I just want to roll my eyes. 21 songs is way too long - my patience wore very thin. Occasionally I didn’t hate it. I quite like All Falls Down but I guess that’s because I remember not hating it 20 years ago and I like Syleena’s voice. But I’m never going to listen to this again voluntarily.
I really don’t like Kanye West. As a person. And I couldn’t name any of his songs. I almost turned this album off after about two or three songs, but I kept going, in the spirit of our endeavor. I can’t say that it is an album I needed to hear or will ever play again, but it doesn’t deserve the one star rating that I was planning to give it. If it wasn’t Kanye, I might give it a 2.5 but because it is a Kanye album I am giving it a 2
I'd like to lobby for a "Will Not Listen" button. Kanye can go fuck.
Sigh. I was wondering when this asshole would show up. I'm going off memory here because I didn't spin this. Music: 5 stars. It's fantastic, and he only got better. His output from this debut through Kids See Ghosts is incredible in terms of quality, creativity, boldness of vision, and ability to get incredible performances from his collaborators. He's one of the all-time greats. But he's also a n*zi fuck. He wasn't always that way. And yeah, he's bipolar, and I don't think he has surrounded himself with people who exacerbate his worst inclinations. But that doesn't excuse him being a n*zi fuck. I adore his music. I hope he gets the help he needs and apologizes for all of his shitty behavior so I can listen to it again.
It's got some good stuff. It's too long and Kanye is too weird. Will I listen to again: 10%
When Kanye was good and not mental.
Not my vibe what so ever.
Fuck Kanye
ITS NOT GNX
great production , but absolutely awful person who probably should have got help a long time ago . 1
Interesting lyrical content and musical stylings.
great but not his best
Bad guy, great and influential album
½☆
No thx. I deal with enough bigots in my daily life.
I was looking forward to listen to this and to catch a well-deserved break from folk music but I was disappointed. I hated all the skits and the talking. Felt like I was listening to a podcast recorded by men at times.
Hahahahahaha, you fool. I've already listened to this album!
A fairly high quality, if slightly drawn out full-length debut from Kanye West. Aside from the "classics" (Jesus Walks, All Falls Down & Through The Wire), oddly the only track I was familiar with from this record was 'The New Workout Plan', a comically bad piece of all too common 2000's misogyny. Unfortunately, that isn't the only ugly moment on this album. This doozy comes very early on during 'We Don't Care': "The drug game bulimic, it's hard to get weight// So n* money is homo, it's hard to get straight". More grizzly bottom-feeding bars are not hard to come by. 'Slow Jamz' feels like an R. Kelly offcut. Jamie Foxx introduces what is ostensibly a smooth song for the ladies. Kanye takes no time whatsoever to dismantle that image "I'ma play this Vandross, you gon' take yo' pants off" (poor Luther passed away 18 months after this hot garbage was released, he'd had enough). This isn't to say that this record is without highlights. 'Never Let Me Down' is a notable first major collaboration between West and Roc-A-Fella boss Jay-Z, despite never being released as a single. The album finishes well with 'Through the Wire' and 'Family Business' also. Aside from the occasional (perhaps frequent) juvenile lyric, this album is notable for displaying West's chops as a producer. The extensive use of sampling throughout The College Dropout keeps things interesting, even when things threaten to fizzle out during the bloated middle of the record. Top 3: 1. Never Let Me Down 2. Jesus Walks (that sample is heavenly) 3. Breathe In Breathe Out Bottom 1: Slow Jamz Overall Score: 6.4/10
Lekker man. Staan echt lekkere nummers op. Erg onder de indruk. Vind wel het stuk met die School Skits de vaart eruit halen. Is daarna ook weer moeilijk herstellen. Last Call is ook uhhhhh wat.
Als een debuutalbum is het een easy 5, maar in absolute zin is het niet perfect en zijn z'n latere albums meer deserving van een 5, dus ga ik bij deze toch voor de 4
ja fucking goed album, al is mbdtf mn favo kanye
Fantastic album from start to finish.
Some decent singles but has all the annoying traits of a hip hop album
Ich fand das Album kagge. Schon damals Reimverse die einfach nur stumpf sind, heute ja nicht besser. Hatte er bessere Alben dazwischen? Dieses hier war enttäuschend für den Hype um diese Person
Jesus Walks bestes Lied von Kanye ***** Witzige Skits The New Workout Plan crazy aber gut Through the Wire auch top
Abgesehen, dass er inzwischen ein verrückter bipolarer Antisemit ist. Kanye in den 2000ern, einfach unfassbar geiler Flow und geile selbstgemachte Beats (Ich empfehle die Doku Jeen-Yuhs) Ich kann nicht nachvollziehen, warum das nachfolge Album Graduation nicht in der 1001 Liste ist, ist kriminell. Sein bestes Album voll mit Bangern. College Dropout hab ich damals nicht gehört, aber Jesus Walks ein Song den ich viel gehört habe. Auf dem Song hat mir aber auch viel nicht gefallen, außerdem viel zu lang. Songs der Playlist hinzugefügt: Jesus Walks
Just impeccable to say the least. Amazing lyricism and rhymes, beats and production, features and performances, etc. This is definitely the most fun i’ve had with a Kanye album that i’ve heard. This album just keeps on bringing when you’re listening to it. It’s just iconic, and amazing 2000s hip hop. I really respect Kanye and his craft here, this does NOT excuse him being an idiot though. I don’t have a lot to say except that I encourage that people listen to this for themselves. It’s just a great listening experience, to say the least. Excellent hip hop record, one of the best i’ve heard so far.
75/100, good album. Some standout tracks, with some less good fillers.
Best kanye album
Never liked Kanye and don't care for this
Fuck Kanye, lol.
Dude sucks
Look, I hate who Kanye has become these days: anti-Semitic, misogynistic, Trumpian, to say the least. But before that, he was a damn musical genius. This album is a masterpiece and it's a shame that I'm never listening to this ever again because of how shitty of a person he is.
Good beats wasted on a man who thinks he’s God’s mixtape.
Not a fan
This one is better than 50's album but I'm also giving it a 3 because i need to re-adjust my scale. It is starting to seem like the author of this list and me don't have the same taste in hip hop music =(
No explanation needed
Far too much rap on here. Not my thing AT ALL. Over rated rubbish
Innovative post-boom bap beats that expertly uses soul samples. This has some of the best songs of his career on it, unfortunately it's not very consistent like his later albums are.
Hate to be that guy but listening to this today made me very nostalgic for a time I was excited to hear a new Kanye album when it dropped.
fucking kanye
Started out good, but got bloated too much by the end...
Two words is one of my favourite songs ever and this is a great album
This is one of my favorite kayne's
4.5/5. It lulls in the middle section a little bit for me, but it’s still so good. This would be the album of a lifetime for 99% of other rappers and producers. Hard to be a Kanye apologist nowadays but this is as good a a reason as any.
Pretty good stuff but not my preferred style
Honestly, a pretty great debut hip hop album, if also a reminder that there's not much that reveals character like success.
too bad kanye is such a terrible person. reluctant 4 stars
Started well with We don't Care, but then it had that annoying Graduation day like nails being driven into my ear. a few pretty average songs and then spaceship is ok. Don't like the R&B songs on the album (i.e. Slow Jamz). I can see why it is popular, just not my style of music. Mostly painful to the ears, Won't listen to it again
pre: not a fan of kanye as a person. Never listened to an entire album, but there are a few singles I have worn out (including Jesus Walks and School Spirit from this album). Interested to hear them in the context of an album. Super mixed feelings. Any given song, in a vacuum, was pretty damn great. I like Kanye's lyrics and vocal style, and he's an inarguably great producer. As an album, I'm not sure what I would think, but my listening was so disjointed today that I didn't really get that experience. I hate the skits, as I do for pretty much every rap/hip-hop album that incorporates it (except Enter the Wu-Tang of course). And then there's the Kanye of it all. Oof. I think this would normally be a solid 3.5 for me (between "I wouldn't mind if someone else played this" and "I would choose to put this on"). I have rounded up in the past, but I think the Kanye-ness of it plus the skits are going to make me round down. Specifically, they are genre and period appropriate, but they would be a slight deterrent to me listening to the album again. I do want to listen to the other two albums in this trio though
I did not think I had heard this album before, but I recognized more songs than I expected. I know there are many people who love this album but I find it kind of corny, especially the Jesus song. The Jay-Z feature was probably the highlight for me, beyond that it’s pretty forgettable in my eyes.
Nope - should have stayed behind the boards making beats for others.
Well, My son is really into hip-hop right now, so car rides have been filled with Kendrick Lamar, Tyler the Creator, (a little) Kanye, etc.. so I have actually listened to parts of this album more recently than I would have without his influence. We will see how this goes. Well, there are some good songs on here -- also a lot, alot of just talking and skits........but Slow Jamz is a banger. ...She said she want some Marvin Gaye some Luther Vandross......
I was in between a 3 and a 4 for this one, but I have to go with 4 here. A lot of good stuff in here, nothing that blew me away, but certainly kept me interested throughout the album.
Had high expectations and not that the album wasnt good. Just my expectations were so high and I dont feel like the whole album impressed me it was just a few songs.
Some of his best on this one including All Falls Down, Jesus Walks and Through the Wire. This album may be closer to a 3, but I'll bump it up since I enjoy the hits so much and discovered a few new tracks I liked.
The intro/outro filler was a bit forced and kitschy, nothing that hasn't been done many times before 2004 and not done better here. Lyrics were similarly non-attention grabbing. Of the 21 tracks, 3-5 were really solid. Not a great hit ratio. Breathe in Breathe out was pretty solid. Then lost it with School Spirit as the follow up. That pattern seems to repeat. The critique of college is shallow and annoying. And as far as I could glean, his proposed alternative is to deal drugs and smoke pot? If everyone is dealing, then the value of being a dealer goes down, that's just simple economics, but I guess he dropped out of that class...
Crazy hooks, wild beats and punchy lyrics
the gospel-sounding 'i'll fly away' was a nice suprise, mens voices with a piano accompianment. upbeat music is very different to what i usually listen to, but not bad tbh i don't normally like rap music, but this is a lot more melodic than i thought it would be
This should be dropped out of this listing.
I didn’t get it
Ew
meno bello di My dark beautiful fantasy, ma cosa vuoi che ti dica... prima che impazzisse era veramente un artista degno di nota. che nervoso.
L’Old Kanye pre-follia è sempre una garanzia
The College Dropout broke minds back in 2004 and still breaks them in 2024. In 2004, people said "wow, this Kanye guy is making a whole new sound and is changing the rap industry forever! I sure hope he doesn't become anti-semitic one day " and in 2024, they say "aw dangit".
Anyone hating on this album due to present day Kanye’s antics need to reexamine themselves. This is a nearly perfect album. Every beat here is incredible, Kanye’s lyricism is both hilarious and introspective. The shift in vibe comparing this to other hip hop of the time is unmatched. He had something to prove here and he did just that. His best album. Where else can you find Jay-Z calling himself the Jeff Gordon of rap?
Well, this is another obvious one. Not my favorite Kanye album, but one that I find myself coming back to a lot. Hit after hit.
Previously, when I listened to West, I figured I was missing something. It does nit satisfy like Nas, Wu, Em, NWA... So this was a chance to see what I was missing. Turns out, not much. This is not bad, but it wad not enjoyable either.
citelné kvality v žánru, citelné nekvality u osoby autora. Asi nejtěžší na hodnocení v tomto ohledu. Při hodnocení při uvážení těchto faktorů jako protiváh
I miss the old Kanye, straight from the 'Go Kanye Chop up the soul Kanye, set on his goals Kanye
Ég skil af hverju Kanye varð svona stór. Þetta eru bara hin fínustu lög þó svo að ég sé ekki mikið fyrir rapp. Mér fannst samt skemmtilegt að hlusta á textana og sketsana inn á milli sem drulla yfir menntaelítuna. Hún á það alveg skilið.
I knew how good Kanye is but I've never listen to a full album until now and I've realised how much I've been missing out. Super fun listen, maybe slightly too long but it keeps a high standard throughout. Not even his best stuff either. We Don't Care, Through The Wire and All Falls Down are proper bangers.
I'm both a psychiatric and addictions registered nurse and a Kanye West fan. I've observed Kanye's career with equal amounts of hope and dread for many years now. In nursing school we watched a clip of Kanye on Jimmy Fallon speaking honestly and thoughtfully about the reality of being bipolar. Imagine having mental illness involving delusions of grandeur, believing you're one of the most important people on earth, except that in your case, you kind of are one of those people-- and on top of that, you're surrounded by sycophants who pay their bills by cosigning every paranoid or grandiose thought in your head. In this way I feel like Kanye has never really had a chance to get mentally healthy the way he was on this album. There are flashes of what's to come on The College Dropout. Ye drops a few self-deprecating bars, then gleefully raps about how his inflated ego keeps him afloat. He also constantly references surviving that brutal car wreck which maimed him and was clearly a traumatic event for him. But overall, it's someone that younger people never had the chance to know, sadly: an optimistic, wise-cracking genius who seemed to be very aware that he was on the brink of superstardom. I loved this album so much when it came out. These days, I cherish it as an almost perfect work of art created before the artist's mental health fell to an unimaginable, possibly irretrievable low point. I used to feel joy when I listened to The College Dropout. Now I feel nothing but sadness and yearning. I know that Kanye symbolizes something different to everyone. To many he is a mouthpiece for true evil, and that is a fair way to view this man. To me he's a symbol of the colossal failure of the mental health system I'm a willing participant in. It is hard to me to square the era of Kanye we hear on The College Dropout with the man he has become today. I miss the old Kanye.
I love the old Kanye.
Hella good. It’s crazy where he came from to what he is now.
I don’t like Kanye. It’s official.
Should have stayed in college.
it's OK, but rap is not my thing
If I separate the art from the artist, this is easily a 5. In 95% of cases, I can do that (e.g. The Smiths) - but for some reason, I just can’t hear Kanye’s voice and not associate it with who he is. But, credit where credit is due - not just a great rap album, but a great pop album thrown in there alongside. I’ll give it a 4 because I can’t allow it to be on my favorite albums list. But I can’t deny it’s great.
He complains about working at the gap. Not sure why that doesn’t hit the same way when someone else complains about a job in a song.
Yeah Kanye was way better before he went totally nuts into the Trump Swamp and all that. He has some good rhymes and beats with top-notch guests like Jay-Z and Mos Def so it's not terrible
Can't listen to Kanye and give him another cent in royalties.
This is one of the most fun albums of all time. It’s absolutely Kanye’s best and you will not convince me otherwise
It's so funny/sad how Kanye's albums act as portraits of a man's rise and fall, and how money power and fame can corrupt people. The general concept of this album is great. I love the skits and find them hilarious, and I enjoy a lot of the songs. Unfortunately this album suffers significantly worse bloat than MBDTF. Every song is about 1-2 mins too long, and many tracks on the second half of the album weren't entirely necessary. That being said I generally enjoyed the album. 3/5
I’ve said it 100 times, “I miss old Kanye.” It’s sad when someone can ruin something that could’ve been pretty epic. When this came out I was so excited about the music and him, but now I can’t even listen to it.
As much as I find Kanye as one of my least favorite humans I enjoyed this album. I refuse to give him any recognition.
Intro was very profane but okay ig don't like songs that are just talking tho 5/10 We don't care still had some language but I'm gonna assume that's the whole album has that kind of language so I'm gonna not write either down anymore other than that it has good flow and it was a solid start 7/10 Graduation day was weird and I'm not a fan of songs that you can't listen to by themselves like graduation day that just give more info to the other songs on the album 5/10 All fall down had really good flow and I enjoyed listening to it the other singer was very good as well probably on eo fmy favorite so far 8.5/10 Ill fly away was the same line repeated seven times and I don't like short songs 5.5/10 Spaceship had good bars and was very catchy but did have a ton of pizza or anything special to set it apart from the rest of the music 7/10 Jesus walks was good but had some kinda random part like that one auto tuned voice which were all good but it was a bit much other than that it was good 8/10 Never let me down was good I liked listening to it wasn't anything special but good 7.5/10 Get em high was obviously not my favorite and other than the lyrics which I didn't love it didn't have a ton about it 6/10 Both workout plans weren't great again with bad message didn't even listen to he whole song 4/10 Didn't listen to the rest not bad music just nothing worth much of my time other than a few of the better songs which are weak
Naja, Kanye West scheint ja ein recht unangenehmer Typ zu sein. Antisemitisch, Rassistisch, Nazi-Fan, Trump-Fan. Unsympathisch. Aber das Album und die Musik ist nicht so schlecht.
You can lie and say this is bad because he’s said bad things but take all that away, listen to this music, and you’ll realize, you’re just lying to yourself because you want to hate. His music still bangs.
Not a big fan of hip hop and rap. But this is really a great album. Great hooks. Good lyrics that are about more than most other rap songs. Really enjoyed it
Nok mit mest hørte kanye album. Det siger ret meget. Kæft jeg har hørt det her meget og er super glad for det! Et af de nemmeste 5/5 indtil videre :))
I'm going to avoid looking at his reprehensible politics in this review, and focus on the album itself and the influence. For anyone like myself who really isn't a fan of gangsta rap, you can thank Kanye for nearly completely destroying that genre and essentially ushering the alternative hip-hop world to the mainstream. As a debut, it's incredibly polished and impressive. The skits are far less irritating compared with many of its' contemporaries. I still think it's the weakest of his original trilogy, but We Don't care, All Falls Down, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, Slow Jamz and Through the Wire are fantastic enough to warrant the 5. But yeah fuck Kanye, go punch a Nazi today. 20/10/24
All aboard the controversy express. Led by this moron. Yes, he’s an idiot, but I’ve heard this is one of his best. I’ve never really listened to Kanye beyond the radio slop, so we’ll see. Jesus. 76 minutes??? Ugh. I worried that this will be clean sounding “bling era” jay-z tinged rap. So far, we’re sounding like a jovial “love the way you lie.” It’s a little infectious. The rap is nothing special, but the beat is weird. Lots of interludes of course. All Falls down is my least favourite kind of rap. Overly dramatic, female chorus. It ends up being fine as it feels like it has something to say. You can see how he stands out. This is not run of the mill, it’s just far too polished for me thus far. This one is no good. Even the feature is underwhelming. The flows are annoying here and the beat is far too simpering. Interminable and boring. There we go. Some grit. This is a hit, but it’s the best one so far. It feels tongue in cheek preachy, but there is an element of cringe to most religious stuff of any denomination. There is the prodigal son. The lamest rapper of the 2000s. Jayson Zee. Needless melancholy. The lyrics SUCK but the last rapper at least has som vitriol in his voice. This is all too sappy. Am I wrong in saying this feels built for the radio? It’s all so clean. Oh boy a Common feature!!!! It’s a clean-off! In all seriousness, this one is cooler. Talib Kweli is a nice feature. Was common even here? Anyway, this one still has that Kanye flow which I’ve realized is always the same. Come on. This sucks. I’ve got a new (er) workout plan. 3 x 10 turning the volume down, 3 x 12 eye rolls at horrendous lyrics, then finish with skipping songs until failure. Give that a rip. Whoa! It gets worse!! I’m not a “sexy r & b” guy. Listen, I’m a white guy not born in the 60s. Oh buddy. It’s 2004 and I’m playing NFL Street 2 again. This is good. Lyrics in first verse are fun. The Mos Def Kweli reference is funny. This song is so very 2000’s but not in such a glitzy way. It kind of stayed where it was, but this one was ok. Good sample on this one. Boring rap verses again. I’d almost listen to this one as an instrumental. It’s funny, that the degree stuff is still pretty relevant. It’s an adolescent criticism in many ways, but it’s also right. Two Words. Much better. Yeah this one is one of the passionate songs. Less screwing around. I don’t know man. I keep saying the same thing, but the pop sensibilities kill me. Luckily this one has less of that. Boring. This hasn’t felt as long as it’s been, however we have two songs to go. Oh god it’s like inspiration rap. I can’t deal with some of the sounds. The shimmering transitions. The lyrics are boring to me. I’m sorry. Fuck the 12 minute song. Get outta here. Ugh. This was not great. Listen, people love(d) this guy. He’s popular. I get it. He’s definitely unique on and off record but the flows are samey, the lyrics are funny at times and others sound like this review. Sloppy stream of consciousness that really doesn’t pack the punch I expected. The samples range from incredible to grating, and the rap is just there. This is mediocre. 2-2.5 HIGHLIGHTS: Jesus Walks, Get Em High, Two Words
Solid album but fuck Kanye
I miss the old Kanye.
I would first like to acknowledge that Kanye is a nazi sympathizer and an anti semite. For the purposes of this review I will just be looking at the art and not the artist. This album is quite the way to announce your way on the scene. So many different styles and bangers. The skits don't feel over bearing or getting in the way of the music and help tell the story of the album. Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down and many others are absolute rap bangers. It's a shame Kanye hasn't taken care of his mental health and allowed himself to fall from what little grace he had previously
Fuck Kanye
I mean….. cmon.
Not really into rap so I can’t really review if it’s good or not. ?
I know a lot of people refused to listen to this and as a Jewish man I certainly have no love for Kanye and understand he is the worse kind of anti-semite imaginable BUT I still have this a listen. ( Honestly i would have to refuse Eric Clapton albums based on how screwed up his world view is but I still listened to his stuff.) All that being said, this is an amazing album. Kind of reminds me of how I felt about Lauryn Hill's The Miseducation of ... when I first heard it -blown away by the versatility of the music. Production values are through the roof and I really liked every single song. Hard not to give it 4 stars based on merit and based on just enjoying it. He is still a primo douschbag but he made a classic album.
Nope not listening. Fuck that nazi
I remember how impactful this album was when it first came out. Listening to it in 2024, it feels like a classic. Slightly dated with some of the sampling techniques, but still an album that kicked open the door and introduced most people to Kanye West
Absolutely not giving this bigot any streaming money
i miss the old kanye
when he’s not too far up his own ass, he’s a genius
Cannot support Kanye
The idea of separating the art from the artist has always been an interesting and divisive conversation. And one that I’ve never been able to give a definitive answer to. I feel partly inclined to begin this review with that topic because, whether his die hard fans like it or not, it applies to Kanye in many ways. From early on, he has been a controversial figure who was willing to take risks and put himself out there one hundred percent. That includes the good and the bad. Now, when it comes to that separation, it depends on what era of the man we are talking about. If we look at Ye as he is now, the man is broken, and the separation shouldn’t be made. Especially considering the anti-Semitic rhetoric which he continues to push in his new music. But the Kanye of the early 2000s is a different person entirely. It’s hard to explain just how on top of the world he really was during this time period. The Higher Education trilogy absolutely cemented him as one of the era’s greatest, and it seemed as if he could do no wrong. And The College Dropout is potentially the finest of the three. It’s rare for an artist to come out swinging so hard for their debut. And it’s especially rare for an artist to be nominated for so many awards and simultaneously win many of them after said debut. But that’s just the kind of person he was. I feel like most, if not all rap fans had a Kanye phase at one point. I know I did. I see it as a right of passage. And every bit of what made this era of him so great is felt the moment you turn this on. People should continue to look at his early works as a case study on how to structure and pace a hip-hop album in a manner that is effective and leaves the listener feeling satisfied. His production style and songwriting choices, influenced by the likes of J Dilla and Q-Tip, leads to some of the catchiest hooks you will ever hear on a rap record. If you don’t get the melody to All Falls Down or We Don’t Care stuck in your head, are you really even human? There is just such a clear love and care put into which samples are used, where the drums are placed, and how everything comes together. It’s seriously unfortunate to see how far Kanye has fallen from grace. It’s a combination of so many things, and mental health is a serious thing that people still don’t acknowledge enough. I admire Kanye as an artist because his catalog is undoubtedly one of the strongest ever made. But I also know what once was is long gone by now. Rating: 9/10
Lots of hits on this album. Still not exactly my taste, but pretty solid.
Not impressed.
For a debut album, it does great. The use of pitched soul samples is excellent, beats and production are good, lyrics and features range from goofy one liners to harder hitting verses, it's a solid debut and a good showing of what would come later in his career, and why he would be considered one of the better producers in hip hop. Obviously with his controversial history (especially as of late) I can see people wanting to avoid his works all together, however I knew a friend that had the CD from ages ago and asked to borrow it. I'd give the album a 8/10.
Insanely good. Every track is beautiful. Blown away. There is no doubt in my mind this is a top tier album.
no thanks. really, the only purpose of this project is to broaden my own horizons and i heard this back when it came out, i remember it, no reason to give him even the tiny useless amount of money from streaming it. it was fine back then. I'm sure it holds up fine, but I'll never be listening again of my own volition
One of the best hip hop albums of the 21st century. Essential hip hop.
This plays a little long and there is some filler here. Not really any specific callouts but this album has a good vibe and style, and is really strong for a debut. Not quite a 4 for me but I’ll round up. 3.75/5
Probably the biggest challenge separating the art from the man when listening to Kanye. I didn’t want to like any of this, but ended up being surprised, probably due to the obvious shift away from gangsta style. A pretty strong debut. Rating down because of length, overuse of chipmunk pitch-shift vocals, and inclusion of unnecessary talking tracks that IMO actually take away from poignant messages being delivered in the actual songs.
Really a shame he went off the rails because this was pretty great.
I’m annoyed by how much I like Kanye. An incredible debut. Hard not to like it despite the man behind the music. I don’t think it fully reaches the highs of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, but it’s darn close. 4.25/5
2.5, too much nonsense between tracks and the 12-minute last track .... ugh.