If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears by The Mamas & The Papas

If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears

The Mamas & The Papas

3.43
Rating
29948
Votes
1
2%
2
12%
3
40%
4
34%
5
12%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 15)

Some great songs on this

Essential album that helps define the age that produced it!!

The one song is really good I'll give it. The rest are dece Will I listen to again: 10%

Imagine hearing this for the first time when the album was released in 1966. Such a fabulous sound, amazing harmonies, fabulous songs. Brilliant and era defining.

This was great. Slightly reminiscent of The Beach Boys with the harmonies, but I think that's more a reflection of the state of pop music in the sixties than The Mamas and the Papas blatantly copying their style. This is definitely unique, with some great tracks, California Dreamin' being the monster hit, of course. Not quite deserving of five stars I don’t think, but certainly essential listening for anyone interested in the swingin' sound of nineteen sixty-six!

I have never realized how corny the lyrics are

Outside of the mega-hit it's sort of average but still somewhat imaginative, but California Dreamin' mostly steals the show and keeps it

not bad, decently enjoyable listen. a few good tunes. california dreamin holds up well. i also quite enjoyed 'you baby'. 3.1/5

I have a definite soft spot for this type of music and this band.

The vocal harmonies make this. I get this ethereal, rose-tinted glasses nostalgic vibe from this, for some reason. I wouldn't be born for over 30 years after this came out. Most of the album has a strong 'soundtrack in a 60s film' vibe so maybe it's that California Dreamin' kind of annoys me though, but I can't really put my finger on it 3.5 Highlights: Spanish Harlem, Go Where You Wanna Go, Monday Monday

pretty good but absolutely carried by california dreamin

Great album

The songs I liked were 5 stars, but I didn't enjoy like half of them.

Absolutely brilliant tunes. Very enjoyable. Great dynamic.

The Mamas & The Papas are just, to me, what the Summer of Love 1967 sounded like, and here they are in full swing.

That guy was a total creep. The two gigantic hits plus a couple of other tracks make this record worthwhile

омага це легендарна пані з бананом оце ахахахха клас

60 years later and still immediately recognizable. Influenced and influential but they still are the ones who sound like them. That's impressive. While there are a few forgettable songs here, half are classics and the other few are solid. 9/12 great does that mean 4 stars instead of 5? Or does their uniqueness merit the extra star? I'll decide tomorrow.

Cozy and competent, but not very exciting.

Just when you think you've heard everything The Mamas and the Papas have to offer, the next song comes on and you confirm that yes, you definitely have. It's still good though.

Couple of good ones on here but all in all not too much to bring back to this album again

it was ok, california dreamin made it better but not my favorite

Oh, great, a 60s pop album for the 4th of July. Not exactly what I'd call quintessentially American music, but at least the band hails from the US. A problem with pop as a genre is that it tends to age really poorly, which is usually because it's a product of the era it was made. This album is no exception; it sounds incredibly 60s-and not always in a good way. Though the vocals are pleasant enough, they sound incredibly old in a bad way that proves detrimental to my enjoyment of this album. Lyrics are frequently basic but not terrible, and the underlying songs are decent enough. However, this album fails to convince me that it's essential listening in a sea of other 60s pop. While the Beatles and other bands were revolutionizing music as we know it, this group was putting out this album that could have been made 5 years earlier. There are some good songs, but most of it is disposable pop. This album is ranked #6 of 18 albums for 1966. Other 1966 albums rated by me: Revolver(1/18)-5 Wild Is the Wind(3/18)-4 Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, and Thyme(4/18)-4 Aftermath(7/18)-4 Face to Face(8/18)-4 Midnight Ride(13/18)-2 Fred Neil(16/18)-3

I guess it's worth hearing once to just be able to place the music that is abused to do establishing shots of San Francisco in the mid 60s in all movies.

Dette kunne kun vært skiva som hadde California Dreamin'. (Alle som har sett Chungking Express vet at skiva fint kunne bestått av California Dreamin' 12 ganger på rad.) At skiva inneholder flere gode låter var hverken en selvfølge eller i det hele tatt nødvendig, men det hjelper jo på sluttsummen. Etter å ha sett nærmere på hvem som har skrevet låtene, så kommer det frem at det som var bra var skrevet av Philips og det som var mindre bra var covre. Release the Philips cut? Tror det kunne vært en femmer. Idag lærte jeg også at albumcoveret var kontroversielt fordi det inneholder en avbildning av en toalettskål. Jeg prosesserer fortsatt denne informasjonen og velger kanskje å fortrenge den som den anglophonske verden fortrenger sine menneskelige behov til the wash room som kun inneholder et implisitt toalett.

Overraskende bra fra et band jeg har sett på som et one, kanskje two hit wonder-band.

Some songs are cheesy, but their voices blend incredibly. Mama Cass in particular sounds beautiful. Plus, California dreaming’ really spoke to me when I was missing California!

Excelente disco, se nota que el estilo tranquilo, sereno y Hippie eran insignias de ellos

648/1001 2026.07.01 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑

Not my type of music, but I can appreciate the vibe of the album. Just a groovy vibe overall and I can get jiggy with this

So I knew a few of the songs, and I guess the rest was alright, but this 60s pop rock or whatever doesn't really do much for me.

California Dreamin’ is the only remarkable thing about this album. Three stars for that song and that song only.

In and of itself. Perfect. Nothing to take away. Five.

Day906 - “california dreamin” alone makes this a great album and then throw in “monday monday” and “you can go where you want to go” and you got yourself a stew baby.

A few good songs and I like the old timey melodies but nothing I love. 2.5

fave song: The "In" Crowd

THIS ALBUM IS SO FUCKING GOOD

# An In-Depth Review of *If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears* by The Mamas & The Papas The Mamas & The Papas' 1966 debut album, *If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears*, occupies a fascinating and somewhat contradictory position in rock history. It's a record that simultaneously represents a pinnacle of studio-crafted, sunshine-drenched pop and a testament to how a single, era-defining song can overshadow and create a sense of dissonance with the rest of the album. It's a beautiful, expertly produced artifact of its time, but one that also reveals a band still finding its voice, caught between being a formidable creative force and a commercial vehicle for the pop charts . ## Lyrics and Themes: The Bittersweet Dichotomy The most compelling theme of the album is the poignant dissonance between its sound and its lyrics. The music is often warm, gentle, and exquisitely harmonized, evoking the laid-back California lifestyle. However, the lyrics tell a different, more melancholic story. The album's two most famous tracks perfectly capture this dichotomy . **"California Dreamin'"** is the ultimate expression of wistful longing and bitter-sweet melancholy. Written by John and Michelle Phillips during a harsh New York winter, it's a simple, heartfelt cry of homesickness . The now-iconic opening lines, "All the leaves are brown / And the sky is grey," paint a picture of a dreary reality, which is contrasted with the comforting, if distant, dream of L.A. It captures a specific moment of personal isolation that resonated with the broader anxieties of the 1960s . **"Monday, Monday"** continues this theme, albeit in a more pop-oriented package. It's a song about the pain of a tumultuous relationship, structured around a familiar weekly cycle. The narrator describes the "bittersweet" nature of a love that is present on some days and absent on others, capturing the deep pain and confusion of a dysfunctional relationship. This theme of interpersonal complexity is a recurring one, informed heavily by the real-life turmoil within the group . Beyond these hits, the album is heavily focused on personal, often shallow, themes of love and romance. Tracks like "Straight Shooter," which ironically feels the most straightforward, deals with a demand for honesty in a relationship . "Got a Feelin'" is another song that touches on themes of betrayal and jealousy, with a ticking clock in the background adding to the anxious and ominous mood . While these songs are well-crafted, the lyrical content can feel somewhat trivial compared to the profound societal and cultural undercurrents of "California Dreamin'." This lack of thematic depth in the majority of the album is a common critique, with many songs sticking to conventional pop tropes of love, loss, and yearning . ## The Music and Production: A Masterclass in Vocal Harmony From a musical standpoint, the album's greatest strength is undeniably its vocal performances. The group's blend is nothing short of extraordinary. Their approach was more akin to a classical vocal ensemble or a doo-wop group than a typical rock band . Each singer had a distinct, complementary role: Denny Doherty's warm, expressive tenor often carried the lead melody, providing the narrative anchor . Cass Elliot, with her powerful and soulful alto, provided a deep, resonant foundation for the harmonies, while Michelle Phillips' high, shimmering soprano floated over the top, adding a layer of ethereal beauty. John Phillips, the group's primary songwriter and arranger, masterfully wove these distinct voices into complex, four-part counterpoint . The production, helmed by Lou Adler and recorded with legendary engineer Bones Howe, is polished and precise . The group benefited from the exceptional skills of *The Wrecking Crew*, a collective of elite Los Angeles session musicians who provided a flawless instrumental backdrop . The instrumentation—acoustic guitars, soft bass, and gentle percussion—was perfectly calibrated to support, never overpower, the vocals. Key instruments like Bud Shank's iconic flute on "California Dreamin'" and the harpsichord on other tracks served as elegant ornamentation . ## Influence and Legacy: Defining the Sound of an Era *If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears* was a massive commercial and critical success, reaching #1 on the Billboard 200 chart . It was a blueprint for the burgeoning genre of "Sunshine Pop," a style characterized by its bright, layered harmonies and polished, radio-friendly production. The meticulous, studio-as-instrument approach mirrored the work being done by The Beach Boys on *Pet Sounds* and The Beatles on *Rubber Soul*, placing The Mamas & The Papas at the forefront of pop music's evolution . The album's iconic cover art is a significant piece of its legacy. The photograph by Guy Webster, showing the four members casually lounging in a bathtub with a visible toilet in the corner, was so controversial that it was censored by some distributors. This simple, humanizing image broke the polished mold of band photos and perfectly aligned with the album's title—a playful nudge to trust what you see and hear . Its lasting impact is confirmed by its inclusion at #127 on *Rolling Stone's* list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time . The album's influence can be heard in countless pop and folk-rock acts that followed, with its vocal arrangements and production style becoming a standard for harmony-driven pop. ## Pros and Cons of the Album To summarize the strengths and weaknesses of this seminal record: **Pros** - **Iconic Vocal Harmonies**: The record showcases some of the most beautiful and intricate vocal arrangements in pop history, with each of the four singers bringing a unique and essential voice to the blend . - **Two Timeless Hits**: It contains "California Dreamin'" and "Monday, Monday," two songs that are not only chart-topping classics but also masterpieces of bittersweet pop songwriting . - **Pristine, Influential Production**: The album is a landmark of 1960s studio craft, setting a high bar for pop production and defining the "Sunshine Pop" sound . - **Historical Significance**: As a debut album, it's historically important, representing a peak of commercial and creative success before the group's internal conflicts derailed them . **Cons** - **Uneven Quality**: A significant portion of the album consists of covers and less memorable originals that feel like filler compared to the towering singles . - **Lyrically Shallow**: The lyrics, outside of a couple of tracks, tend to be overly focused on standard, unchallenging pop themes, lacking the depth or social commentary that defines the album's best work . - **Instrumental Stagnation**: The backing instrumentation, though proficient, is often formulaic and safe. It rarely takes creative risks, functioning more as a pleasant accompaniment than a driving force, which can make some tracks feel similar or lackadaisical . - **Over-reliance on Covers**: With five of its twelve tracks being covers, the album can feel like it's padding its length at the expense of showcasing the group's original songwriting prowess . Ultimately, *If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears* is a classic of the era precisely because it encapsulates the ambitions and limitations of its time. It is a beautiful, flawed, and essential document of a band that, for one brief, shining moment, perfectly crystallized the sound of a generation, even if they themselves were not quite sure where they were going.

couple good tunes, otherwise just meh

I do love that 60s sound; it rings with a fun, positivity and purity that is sort of lost in modern music. Ironic then, considering the history of this band and it's members, barring Cass Elliot who - after hearing this album - did carry the vocals for the rest of the group. Despite that, the vocal harmonies on the whole album are pretty gorgeous, noticed first when hearing "Got a Feelin'". Due to my limited music vocabulary and untrained ears, it would be better for me to list my favourite tracks here rather than break down each one, so here goes: "Straight Shooter", "Got a Feelin'", "Go Where You Wanna Go", "California Dreamin'", "Somebody Groovy" and "The 'In' Crowd". Couple of flat tracks but otherwise a super solid album. Their sound is great.

Not bad for what it is.

Man, their harmonies are outstanding. An absolute classic of the 60’s. Monday Monday and California Dreamin’ are songs you literally couldn’t miss. They get radio play all the time. There’s a lot of variety to these songs. The band had a really short period of time together due to… many reasons, but this is a great album and absolutely belongs on this list.

Rating: 3.5/5 Playlist track: I Call Your Name Date listened: 02/07/26 (during thesis!!) Listen when: Baking Went into a crazy deep dive at the library while procrastinating my thesis about the group drama.. affair within the 4 person group with a married couple is crazy.

dalifornia creamin

It's hard to not like The Mama's & The Papa's music. Their harmonies are infectious and their hits are just great examples of what they could do. As debuts go, this is top tier. "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin" are the big hits but "I Call Your Name", "Do You Wanna Dance" (cover), "You Baby", and "Go Where.." are strong entries. M&P were a vocal powerhouse and a lot of the music still sounds great today. I guess the formula for incredible music in a co-ed group is tons of internal tensions, some drugs, and a microphone. It worked for Fleetwood Mac and it worked here too. (3.5/5), rounded up to '4' because of the hits.

Most everyone is familiar with the hits from this one, and there are plenty. And if you're into researching the baggage that comes along with the artists on the list, there's plenty to unpack here, as well. The controversial cover that was pulled from shelves, the banana eaten on the Ed Sullivan Show, the Fleetwood Mac style love triangles, the affiliation with the Manson murders, and of course, there's John Phillips. All of that aside (or taken into account), I found the album itself enjoyable, humming along to the ones I knew and tapping toes to the ones I didn't. Reminiscent of the Beach Boys, with large doses of Motown and a pinch or three of the Beatles, they blended into a bluesy-folky energy that was hard to dislike. It isn't necessarily my thing, and it won't be going into heavy rotation or anything, but it still earns a 3.5/5 that I'm happy enough to round up.

124. If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears - The Mamas & The Papas (1966) 6.26.26 Variety: 2 Adequacy: 3 Listenability: 2 Uniqueness: 1 Emotionality: 1 = 1.8 rounded up to a 2 INTRO This one is going to be rough. This is a group whose stuff I heard so much in my childhood that despite the obvious talent and classic status of a lot of their songs, I grew to loathe hearing. To this day I will usually skip or change the channel if I happen across any of their stuff on the radio. It's not helped by my dislike of all things flower power. And while this was '66 and maybe just outside the worst of the hippy movement, their whole vibe reeks of all that stuff. I'm all for love and peace and whatnot, but I'm a cynic through and through, and just see this as a failed non-movement that was primarily an excuse to abuse drugs and for guys to scam on women. Sure there were true believers, but they very quickly got drowned out by those with bad intentions. I look at the Mamas and the Papas and I see the Manson Family just a hop, skip, and a jump away. Over exaggerating? For sure. But culturally I think some of that starts here. "(Bah, da, bah da-da-da)" THE TRACKS Side one "Monday, Monday" - Objectively it's really hard to find anything to criticize about this song. Beautiful harmonies, a nice arrangement, some great melodies. The lyrics are a bit contradictory I guess - which is it? Is Monday so goof to you, or is it untrustworthy? Maybe both? A song's narrator is allowed to be confused I guess. Just always bothered me a bit. The mid 60's muddy production actually helps the song too I think, giving it a kind of timeless feel. Hard to argue with. "Straight Shooter" - Was that opening riff in the back of anyone's mind when "Last Train to Clarksville" by the Monkees was recorded? I'm fairly certain studio guys from the Wrecking Crew played on both albums. Will have to research this. They are not exact, but similar enough that it stands out to me. "Last Train" eats this one's lunch, but... This is one of those tracks where the harmonies ( while always solid) and the group dynamic does not work for me. Vocal harmonies are great, but are much more effective in support of a lead vocal. This would hit better for me if a band like the Searchers or Herman's Hermits got a hold of it I think. "Got a Feelin'" - This is a prime example of the stuff I like least about this group. Despite the professionalism on display, it's so weak and muddled and undynamic. "I Call Your Name" - This was a very middle of the road, almost vaudevillesque take on nobody's favorite Beatles song. A throwaway song they gifted to another band, by the way, before recording their own version. Overall this felt like the sort of corny Sonny and Cher Show kind of family-friendly tv show arrangement of the sort that appeals to the inner snob in me ( which I've very much tamped down over the decades) to begin rolling his eyes. With barely any changes I can imagine this as the sort of thing that would be performed at a "cool" church by a family band with coordinated outfits. "I call your name" "Jesus... Jesus..." "Do You Wanna Dance" - In what world would you ever want to hear this maudlin, sappily arranged energy-sapping travesty when you've got infinitely superior versions by Bobby Freeman, The Shadows, the Beach Boys, or Del Shannon? Dreck. "Go Where You Wanna Go" - Maybe the muddiest track on here yet, with what sounds like a bad attempt at a wall of sound technique. The strings didn't help things on what sounds like it could have been a deep cut on a Leslie Gore release. The harmonies are a neat trick but are wearing thin by this point. Good idea to lead side two with their best material. Side two "California Dreamin'" - Their signature song I think, and easy to see why. In addition to the catchy vocal melodies it's got that killer flute solo. And that mid 60s production really gives added weight to the sad vibes. This is possibly the only song in their catalogue that carries any real emotional weight, even if that effect has been deadened for me by far too many listens. I can't deny how iconic it is though. "Spanish Harlem" - Ugh... An another awful take on no one's favorite, this time, Ben E. King song. At least his version has some life to it and an interesting arrangement. I don't even care for the Aretha Franklin version. This is fodder for Tom Jones and Neil Diamond types to perform on milquetoast variety shows. Maybe Roy Orbison could have done something with this. These guys had no chance. "Somebody Groovy" - This is a move back in the right direction, and plays toward the group's strengths. It still ends up being pretty middle of the road, and lifeless though. Maybe the nature of singing a co-lead vocals in harmony but the side effect is that there's zero emotional impact. "Hey Girl" - This one felt comparable to the very early Beatles ultra generic "hey girl" type songs, but in slow motion. Played at 1.5 speed the comparison holds up I think. "You Baby" - This was a marked step up, and despite being slower sounded like it could have been snappy number by the Bobby Fuller Four or a similar act. No sappy strings to ruin the atmosphere, and I'm a known sucker for some well used handclaps. As close to pure bubblegum goodness as anything on this album. "The 'In' Crowd" - Totally against type here, the group tries to add a little soul into the proceedings. Cass has got a great distinctive voice, but this is not her bag. This is prime Motown girl group material, and would have maybe worked well for Martha and the Vandellas or even the Marvelettes. Cass performs on this like she should be belting out classic standards instead of this tyoe of thing ( see her version of "Dream a Little Dream" ). HIGHLIGHTS - "Monday, Monday" - "California Dreamin'" - "You Baby" MIDLIGHTS - "Straight Shooter" - "Somebody Groovy" LOWLIGHTS - "Got a Feelin'" - "I Call Your Name" - "Do You Wanna Dance" - "Go Where You Wanna Go" - "Spanish Harlem" - "Hey Girl" - "The 'In' Crowd" FINAL THOUGHTS When it comes to popular music of the era, I'll take the Doors or even Jefferson Airplane over these guys as at least the darkness of those times seem to be present in the music. And if we're going ultra positive vibes I'd rather listen to sincere goofballs like The Free Design with their severely uncool but equally pretty vocal harmonies. I think overall this one was maybe a bit easier to digest than I expected, especially as it didn't contain ALL their hits. There's also way less of the "peace and love, man" aesthetic than I thought there would be. This really fell a bit more on the side of the folk rock vocal group side of things and would compare it favorably to stuff from the Kingston Trio, and Peter, Paul & Mary and the like ( also not any favorites of mine). That said, a lot of the stuff on hear I found to be very grating, and just don't think it held up. And even the originals from these guys it most often feels rote and mechanical, no matter how pretty it is. Can't say I was looking forward to this one, and turns out my opinion has not changed too much. PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Think maybe just the highlights, though "Monday, Monday" I could take or leave FURTHER LISTENING - Kites Are Fun by the Dree Design - Come the Day by the Seekers - Like to Get to Know You by Spanky and Our Gang - Summer Days (And Summer Nights!!) by the Beach Boys - The Monkees by The Monkees - And Then...Along Comes the Association by The Association - Happy Together by The Turtles

"California Dreamin'" is the highlight here. That opening acoustic guitar is immaculate. For me it is in the pantheon of songs of the Mythological California of which there are many. California loomed large in the psyche of 20th century America and beyond. I love the song. The remainder of the album is quite pleasant in its own right. Right in the wheel house of that 1960s folk rock sound. These tracks are full of harmonies and the right blend of pop sensibilities. Mama Cass and Mama Michelle outshine the guys for sure, in my opinion. In the end though it does all come together for a light 35 minutes. Just stay here though, stay with the music here on this album. There is tragedy on the horizon for this band. Their run was short but sweet. Don't go reading on how the story ends. The music is pleasant enough. Let's let the music be enough. Just keep dreaming of California. We'll get there one day. Promise. 3/5

I didn’t really love this. California Dreaming deserves its place here but the rest was sort of grating.

Fantásticas armonías y agradables acordes. No me había dado cuenta de lo realmente buena que es California Dreamin hasta que salió escuchando el disco. Un diamante en una mina de oro

The good, the self written songs are classics, the harmonies are amazing and everyone has amazing voices. The not so good, the really weird production some songs sound relatively modern while others are super dated sounding. The covers aren’t done as well as the self written songs. Ok album and glad I listened to all of it

Melhor canção de karaoke

Super nostálgico, clássico para roadtrips na minha infância. Ter 4 vozes a harmonizar e funcionar tão bem é de valor

Engraçado, mas California Dreamin não carrega o album todo, há várias músicas que soam todas iguas

Bom álbum. A California dreamin faz me lembrar da Ines original

cool classic

Actually I enjoyed pretty much, It was shocking because I didn't expect it to be so cool, put I mean It has a really cool cover so, I thought It was going to be more country

I could not believe my eyes or ears

Beautiful voices

Beautiful, iconic music from the sixties.

It was fine

Teško je ocijeniti neke ovakve stvari koje nisu nimalo za mene ali više poštujem ovaj album nego hiljadu Beatlesa koje sam natjerana slušati a još su i lošiji i manje stvoreni za mene nego ovo.

I’m inclined to give it a bit of a bump because California Dreamin’ is an all-timer song and Monday Monday’s a bit of a classic too, but the album does just sort of wash over you for the most part as a collection of similar smooth sunshine pop sounds with no friction or variance. And for as much as the harmonies are beautiful, you’re competing with the likes of Pet Sounds-era Beach Boys and middle-era Beatles so you kind of need something that goes beyond just that, which the Mamas and Papas really don’t have generally here

This is such an enjoyable listen and brings back a whole load of memories. California Dreamin' became a go to pub singalong while in university in the early 90s and became a bit of an anthem with some of my closest friends. There are so many rich layers in this album. The harmonies are gorgeous, the musical arrangements are varied and interesting and, although the songs are based around the pop-side of electric folk, they all sound different. Straight Shooter is quite a rocky little number, before we move into the dreamy Got A Feelin' and then we get the wonderful music hall number I Call Your Name. Despite experimenting with different styles, the whole thing flows beautifully and remains consistent throughout. It's just a feelgood album and definitely one that will be saved on a playlist to return to on a chilled Sunday afternoon on the future. A high 4 stars.

this is kinda underwhelming outside the big singles, which are SO GOOD

cute but safe. typical 60s music

Some good songs, meh really.

Folk, folk, and more folk. Please enough

The charting songs are the good ones; the rest are meh.

Its nice to hear on headphones a mid 60’s attempt at stereo mixing.

So much nostalgia.. Artistically I could say so much but the sentimental part gets me and mesmerizes so much so that I could listen to them for hours. Once I had fallen asleep on a roadtrip listening just to them and dreamed with their music. Thats more than just notes and chords yaknow?? Favourite tracks: Monday, Monday; Straight Shooter, California Dreamin’

This was ok. California Dreamin is a great song. The rest of them are alright. They were doing weird stereo things, had some good harmonies. None of the other songs stood out but were listenable.

Very nice

i liked it

Mid except for California Dreamin'

Thought it was a bit boring until a banger song came on. Turns out i had accidentally queued Black Sabbath.

6/18/26. Good 60s pop album with tight harmonies. California Dreamin’ is a classic that I’ve heard countless times before, but there are a couple other gems packed in here.

It's fine. Nice pleasant enough listen. Don't know if I'll regularly be returning to it but I didn't dislike it.

cuteness, not rlly my thing tho, beach boyzy but less cool?

Preference - 3 Musicianship - 1 Legacy - 1 Total - 5

Not one I was expecting to enjoy too much, but damn this is a catchy album. It probably helps with all the covers being somewhat familiar from other versions. Plus California Dreaming is an all timer for a reason. A bit before my time but you can definitely feel the nostalgia. 3.5* rounded to 3*

They got their most recognizable songs on here and then everything else is unrecognizable and sounds the same

Two things. 1) I find this album to be fairly middling except for the two biggest singles off of this album. 2) Listening to "Spanish Harlem" keeps making me think its going to segue into the Little Drummer Boy. Bah-rum-pa-pum-pum.

California Dreamin is one of the best songs ever. But I find the Mamas and The Papas music to be very daunting despite that not being the intention? It has like, horror movie vibes to me, maybe it's just the folk pop mix of the 60s

So many bangers! “California Dreamin’” and “Monday, Monday,” to be sure. But also songs like “Spanish Harlem,” “Go Where You Wanna Go,” and “I Call Your Name.” And no other band sounded like this. Swoon.

Pre Listen: Hey, I know and like these guys! Everyone and their Grandma ought to know California Dreamin' , I've listened to some of their work outside that, and I'm excited to hear some more. Notable Tracks: Do You Wanna Dance - I love this song, feels so nostalgic. Would be my favorite, if it weren't for ---> California Dreamin' - Certified gold-standard classic. If you hate this song for any reason other than "I've heard it too many times", what makes you human is called into question methinks. Go Where You Wanna Go - It's alright, but it is my least favorite track on the album. Can't really articulate why, I just ain't feeling it. Post Listen: Some more good ol' classic rock. Decent variety across the songs, with the sounds ranging from rock, to pop, to folk, to a bit of ballad. Nothing is too long, nothing is too short, it's just good ol' classic rock. I particularly love the harmonies between all of them. All four vocalists have that spice that makes it such a charming album. Everything else, the instrumental overdubs, the percussion, the guitar, it's all very solid. This album's a staple of classic rock. Enough said. 4/5

Hey! It’s been a while since I got an album where I already have a track saved. This’ll be a treat! I love California Dreamin’. Great song. I heard it at a baseball game recently; might have been someone’s walk up song or something. I Call Your Name was so good. Who knew a Beatles song could sound so good. Thank you Cass Elliott for blessing my ears. Christ, this was a great one. Just a really talented, harmonious group of people. Their version of Spanish Harlem was just mesmerizing and I’m willing to bet it’s gonna be one of my most listened-to songs for the month. 5.

California Dreamin and an assortment of half assed tunes from a band of weirdos

Kinda meh. Some songs are forgettable, some are really good.

Really enjoyed this one. Very much of it's time but the songs were all great.

Great album, motown hints different tempos.

Cass has a great voice. Some lovely harmonies but the lyrics are cack. If it wasn't for California Dreamin' this would be 2 stars.

Haircuts looking well dated. 4/5

Classic folk group sound. Never really been blown away by the Mas and Pas.

California Dreamin' ! Strong 3 !

I was sooo happy I got this album. I love California Dreamin’. And today was a good day to listen this album cause the weather was perfect. All rainy and cloudy. So I could get the fillings better. Honestly I want to be in California now too. 😭

acho que essa combinação das vozes pegou muito forte, gostei bastante da instrumentação, acho que tem aquela vibe mesmo anos 60, gosto bastante dessa parada e no mais o álbum supera bastante do que eu achei que seria, as vozes preencheram lugares que não tinham onde ir e assim esse álbum ganha um lugar interessante

One of those albums that transports you to the era in which it was recorded. So many iconic songs I've been used in movies. Complete, short and sweet collection of songs.

So good! Loved every minute.

por desgracia las canciones q no son super clasicos en este album, que son pocas, son bastante mediocres

Quite good. California Dreamin' is a tune!

Like slightly more lame Beatles.

Here we got some classic pop music. The mamas and the papas both mesh well together. In so as the male and female vocals lay perfectly over one another. Thats the whole thing these people do. Thats my biggest takeaway. They can harmonize so damn well. The rest of it is fine enough but I really am stunned by the vocals. Everything else just works well enough. Its classic pop music. Nothing too special. The best songs here are obviously California dreamin' and monday monday. Both are great in thier own right but there is a reason you still hear California dreamin' to this day more than 50 years out. Its one of those songs that will always be i guess. And even if i didnt get too much more from this record, thats an accomplishment for sure

Suena a The Beatles. No es mi estilo. Rock sesentero.

Unfortunately I only care about California Dreamin’

Excellent album all the way through.

I don't have a single bad thing to say! Just delightful

This album is definitely an all timer for me. My parents listened to it all the time growing up and I always think to save it and forget. So I'm glad it's come up now.

so lovely, 4.5

Quite relaxed, though I found some of the accapela-esque sections a little odd with backing vocals. Certainly worth a listen further than 'California dreaming'.

It's like if you took all the interesting bits of 60's music straight out of it. Every harmony sounds the same, and there's nothing raw and no edge left to keep any song interesting.

3 stars on mono, 2 stars with the trolling panning

I've had a pretty consistent experience with these 60s albums. They all have a big single or two, and the rest of the songs range from meh to god awful. So when this came up for today I was expecting that same situation. Fortunately, this album is pretty rich in strong songs. Yes, the singles are the standouts, but there are some excellent deeper cuts - "Got a Feelin'," "I Call Your Name," - I even enjoyed "Somebody Groovy." Most people will probably give this a 3, and I can see that. For me, though, it has to be - FOUR STARS

overall good but california dreamin' overshadows the rest

4/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/the-mamas-and-the-papas/if-you-can-believe-your-eyes-and-ears/ This is super fun!!! Of course I knew California Dreamin', but the rest of the album is as least as fun as that one. Gonna be one I might return to!

3.5 - Good

3.5 estrellas pero lo bajo a 3

"Spela, spela bandy [bandy bandy], Spela, spela bandy [bandy bandy]"

California dreamin är en fin läckerbit med skönsång och harmonier. Monday monday, också trevlig och lättsam 60-talspop. Men i övrigt rätt tunt. Låter omsöm som något bortglömt ur Beatles-katalogen, ömsom som Family four i schlagerfestivalen.

Väldigt ordinär 60-tals pop. Calafornia dreamimg sticker förstås ut. En klasslåt. Gillar även somebody groovy. Men därutöver? Absolut inget värt att varken ställa inskivsamlingen eller att lägga på minnet.

En 60-talsbagatell. Två saker jag ogillar med The Mamas & The Papas: Nr 1 The Mamas Nr 2 The Papas

Fun but definitely sounds 50 years old

For some reason went in expecting this to be Motown or something like that. Hit and miss but California dreaming is an absolute banger

A fun album, so good songs and a solid 3.

A pleasant surprise. I'm feeling generous

A decent album overall, but California Dreamin' dwarves the rest of the songs.

Good sound

Nice harmonies and a few fun lyrics but feels stagnant after the first couple songs. Highlights: "Got a Feelin'", "Somebody Groovy", "You Baby"

just ur average 60's pop rock album, not to bad, nothing special tho. good length.

You know, it's exactly what I thought an album from The Mamas & The Papas would sound like. Just decent 60s songs with great melodies. I'm sure it would have sounded better at the time, but this sound dates it very easily. California Dreamin’ is a classic for a reason and is leaps better than the rest of the album. Not half bad.

nice acapella, if a bit forgettable. I'd probably relisten to it as a road trip album

Two classic songs. Harmonies and very pleasant.

Creepy hippies

Besides the california dreaming hit not much to listen to

it was ight, nothing too good but good easy listening

Some classics but not really my thing

Some good 60's hippie dippy sunshine goodness.

This was good. A very listenable pop/rock album. I'd give it 3.5 if I could

So many great tunes on this one! Surprised they are all on the same album. Highlights: "Monday, Monday", "Go Where You Wanna Go" and "California Dreamin'"

Quite boring but i guess it's a classic

No exactly my taste in music, it sounds very samey to me. Funnily enough, the most famous song "California dreaming" is my favorite just because it feels like its got more substance to it. Shoutout to somebody groovy too, a bit of a sleeper. probably a 2.5 for me, not my jam personally

Yet another disappointment from the 60s. There are three great tracks here, the rest of the songs are completely forgettable and interchangeable with any other similar style song. Very middle of the road album.

Die amerikanische Vokalgruppe The Mamas And The Papas – John Phillips, seine Frau Michelle, Cass Elliot und der Kanadier Denny Doherty – nahm ihr Debütalbum zwischen Oktober und Dezember 1965 in den United Western Recorders und den Eastwest Studios in Hollywood auf. Produziert von Lou Adler und eingespielt mit Mitgliedern der legendären Wrecking Crew, darunter Schlagzeuger Hal Blaine und Bassist Joe Osborn, erschien das Album im Februar 1966 bei Dunhill Records und stieg auf Platz eins der Billboard 200. Es ist Folk Rock als urbane Verheißung: warm, präzise, von einem Licht durchdrungen, das nur Los Angeles kennt. Das Herzstück des Albums sind die beiden Singles, die seinen Ruf begründet haben: „California Dreamin'" – ursprünglich ein New Yorker Winter im Wunschkleid eines Sommers – und „Monday, Monday", das einzige Nummer-eins-Single der Gruppe auf dem Billboard Hot 100. Was diese Songs trägt, ist kein Trick, sondern Stimmarchitektur: vier Stimmen, die sich so selbstverständlich ineinanderfalten, als wären sie nie getrennt gewesen. Auch die Coverversionen des Albums – von „Do You Wanna Dance" bis „Spanish Harlem" – klingen nie wie Fremdmaterial, sondern wie Eigenbesitz. Was das Album von einem bloß sehr guten Pop-Debüt unterscheidet, ist die Abwesenheit von Anstrengung. John Phillips schrieb Melodien, die so einfach klingen, dass man vergisst, wie schwer einfach sein kann; Adlers Produktion rahmt sie ohne Überladung. Fifty Jahre später klingt nichts davon nach Periode – nur nach Song. Kein anderes Album dieser Gruppe hat diesen Augenblick der Schwerelosigkeit wieder erreicht.

- each song is different in its own tune and vibe - the vocals are genuinely perfect idk - Cass Elliot yes - The songs feel so short eventhough most of them are really long ones (probably has to do with it being good, glaze ik.)

-CALIFORNIA DREAMINNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN -MAKE UR OWN KINDA MUSIC GIRL -uhh meh album ig other than some bangers, relisten quality not too high id rather just listen to carti. -id crack the one girl tho - yes thanks 4 reading

The hits on this album are undeniable - or I’ve heard them so much that they have become undeniable. Sure is it kinda souless and campy 100% - but are those hits also timless oddly so? Also, yes.

Some nice music, elevated by Cass Elliot's voice. Harder to listen to these days, though.

# Album Name: If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears # Artist: Mamas and the Papas # Rating: 5/5 # Comments: What a great album. Love the 60s vibes. Id imagine a lot of babies were made listening to this album. # Top Tunes: Whole thing # Would I listen to it again? Yes

Pretty, but outside of a handful of great tracks, just a little lacking.

fairly straightforward stuff but that "stuff" is the most beautiful shit humans can do. high floor

Classic pop bangers

An album synonymous with the 60s. The covers here while don't surpass the originals by any margin carry the band's iconic sound. Always felt "Straight Shooter" was heavily underrated, that bass line is cold. "Go Where You Wanna Go" aka "Michelle Phillips wants to fuck around" is also a heavy hitter to me.

I’m a sucker for 60’s pop rock. This was a good listen, nothing revolutionary but solid catchy tunes. 4/5

Loved them

One iconic song, two other good ones. And never really went anywhere as a band. But like giants compared to the previous 15 albums, which were so blah I didn't bother scoring them at all.

Perfectly fine stuff and, I guess, indicative of a certain time and place. But nothing that exciting - another one where you question why it's in a list of things you MUST hear. It's not brilliant, it's not unusual, it's innovating. Just a perfectly pleasant listen.

2.5/5 Californian Dreaming is the standout but there's not too much else that interests me on this album. It kind of sounds like all the other music around this time. It's not a bad thing, it just doesn't do much for me

Non è il solito album di canzonette anni '60, ma un disco dal sound riconoscibile, per niente copiato da Beatles o Stones, con cui la band raggiunge atmosfere hippie psichedeliche. Per quanto riguarda il mixaggio, è da notare la netta separazione di strumenti e voci in stereofonia, che garantisce il pieno apprezzamento di archi e voci femminili (che contraddistinguono la band) che armonizzano su una base ritmica che fa da sottofondo.

The harmonies are lovely. Almost all of the tracks kept my interest and were a joy to hear; even 60 years after the album dropped.

Perfect album for a summers day, which is was yesterday.

I was kind of expecting a little more. They have a couple of really good songs on here for sure.

Pretty good and I was surprised to know that they wrote/performed California Dreamin

Solid, if it didn’t have “Monday, Monday” and “California Dreaming” this would be a 3 but those two bump it up. Decent album, nothing crazy they’ve got really nice harmonies.

meh. if I wanted 60's harmonies, I'd listen to Beach Boys

I liked it.

Conocía solo un par de temas del álbum, California dreamin y Monday Monday. No son el estilo de música que más me gusta. Me parece que no tienen emoción en sus letras, voces e instrumentalmente me parecen bastante apaticos, pero me encontré con unos temas que si me gustaron mucho. The in crown, Somebody Groovy y Do You wanna dance

California dreaming es un exito tan gigante que solo eso ya la hace merecedora de ingresar en una lista de 1000 discos.Pero para mis gustos no entraría ni en una de 10000.

Nunca habia escuchado algo que no sea California Dreamin pero me lleve una sorpresa, no pense que me iba a gustar tan poco la banda. No me da una energia ni linda ni oscura, simplemente la musica rock psicodelica no me va mucho, ejemplo los beatles en sus canciones mas psicodelica tampoco me gusta, nose si lo relaciono mucho con las drogas o que, pero no me llevo mucho. Me imagino viendo una peli como la masacre de texas o la tipica pelicula yanquee que va menejando un grupo de hippies en una combi por una ruta. Top Picks: 1- I Call Your Name (es la que algo me sorprendio tiene algo disinto) 2- California Dreamin 3- me da igual

Wow, it's incredibly how dated it sounds, comparing it to other 60s stuff... But those great vocal harmonies makes up for it. Best track: Got A Feelin'

It’s fine

It's 3.5

Música agradable, acompañante. Se siente californiano. También se siente antiguo, pero con clase.

It was not as memorable as I expected, with a few exceptions it was relatively interchangeable with a lot from that era

Aside from the two really big songs off the album I didn't enjoy this. I think Brian Wilson and the Beach Boys did the California/hippie/harmonies thing better. I wanted to go and find a cardigan with leather patches on the elbows while listening to this album.

Give it up for star vocalist Cass Elliot, obvi!! Inarguably a classic. Arguably? A little boring. At times, the harmonies could get a little sickeningly sweet and fatiguing to me, but they’re dreamlike and gorgeous. Standout songs for me upon first listen are of course California Dreamin, Straight Shooter, and Got a Feelin. I’d like to listen again, but I don’t see this becoming a staple in my collection anytime soon. The Beach Boys just do it better imo.

Mix dégueulasse ??? L’instru à droite et les voix à gauche… dégueulasse. 3 chansons de répit et c’est reparti… ouais ça va que c’est des années 60 quoi. Y’a une version mono MDR. Bon c’est vachement mieux. Sons de hippie

very pleasant

a few tolerable classics.

It was alright. Realized the hits instantly.

i am a fan

I thought I recognised the style and the vocalists and I did! I grew up listening to some of their songs and this album is brilliant and surprisingly nostalgic for me. I'd give this a 4.5 any day of the week and if that means rounding my rating I'll happily round it up to a 5/5 because it's absolutely my kind of music, nostalgia or not<3

Amazing yet predictable pop harmonies, lush reverb, beautiful songwriting, instruments decent but not notable.

A mostly forgettable album that gets an extra star for that flute solo, which is one of the loveliest moments in 60s pop music.

One all timer here, the rest throwaway. Also, isn’t it kind of crazy that when Papa John Philips’s daughter wrote in her 2009 memoir that her dad had groomed her into a ten year physical relationship, the media reported it as a tawdry but consensual affair? I guess Monday, Monday is pretty good too, but I prefer Neil Diamond’s cover.

Nice songs. A pleasant time capsule into 60s pop

I liked it. Classic stuff.

in retrospect, how does this album hold knowing the story behind it?

The Apostrophe's. But yeah, this is a good record!

I have been trying to separate the art from the artist in this project, and sometimes it's quite hard to do (Kanye?). In today's case it was very simple. John Phillips was a horrible human being, and I mostly didn't enjoy this album. The song I sort of liked was the one that was Beatle-esque, but ironically the Beatles song on the album was one of the worst cover versions I've ever heard. There was nothing specifically horrible about this. I just found myself getting annoyed with just about every song. Straight Shooter was the least Mama's and Papa's sounding, so it's the song I liked. Since it was the second track I thought that things would get better, but they didn't.

Great songs, great harmonies.

Nice vibes, un po’ film tarantino

Chill listen for a walk. Couple of really good songs I’ve heard before and others I hadn’t but sounded decent

I love the song California Dreamin. The rest was ok. I wish this album could have been recorded with modern recording techniques.

3.5 - I'm surprised at both how many of these songs I knew and how many I really liked.

An iconic hippie album in 1966…a new sound of blending voices. California Dreaming is my fave…brings back my youth!

amazing music by 4 very troubled individuals

Catching up with this after listening to The Village Green Preservation Society by The Kinks was a mistake. This is exactly everything I dislike about 60s pop rock. It's just so dull.

absolute peak. classic favorite

Excellent album. Enjoyed every song. Love the harmonies and Denny Doherty’s lead vocals. You get to go back to a beautiful time with this one.

De este álbum sale la canción de California Dreamin , famosisima, es muy de señor 80-90s

Certainly highs and lows on this, however I can't shake the feeling that I'm listening to a fun time capsule with this one.

Adequado. Puta nome tosco pra uma banda, ein? Mas ok, eles gravaram California Dreamin’. E realmente, é uma canção brilhante, tocante, assombrosa, linda de doer… Mas é isso. O disco é isso, California Dreamin’ e alguns outros cortes que não valem muita coisa. É triste porque é perceptível que o grupo era talentoso. As harmonias são ótimas, mas de resto, o disco não passa de adequado, formidável no máximo. Acredito que aqui temos uma situação de “lugar certo, hora certa”. Por isso quero dizer que não consigo imaginar qualquer outro período na história da música popular que um grupo como esse faria sucesso, a não ser nos anos 60, na década da inovação e da quebra de paradigmas. California Dreamin’ carregando a nota inteira do disco. 2.5

Um clássico é um clássico, né, não tem jeito <3

More oldies. Some decent ones, some boring ones.

Fun, wasn’t too long and had variety

Day 40 — The Mamas & The Papas — If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears (1966) Listened: May 11–18, 2026 Genre: Vocal Pop / Folk Pop / Sunshine Pop Vibe: Lush four-part harmonies riding the same melodic pop wave as the Beatles — bright, California-dreaming sixties pop with a warmth that grows on you despite yourself. Highlights: • Monday, Monday • Straight Shooter • Do You Wanna Dance • Go Where You Wanna Go ★ California Dreamin' • Spanish Harlem • Somebody Groovy • You Baby Impression: Took some mental effort to take at genuine value — the polished pop surface and Beatles influence made it hard to fully trust at first. But the songs that landed did land. California Dreamin' is the real thing regardless of anything else. Sits comfortably in the catalog as enjoyable sixties pop that rewards a relaxed listen. Rating: 3.5/5 Keep songs? Yes Revisit album? Yes

I’ve definitely heard some more memorable folk albums during this project, but there were still a good one or two in here

Solid. Songs just the right length to not overstay their welcome. Cool harmonies. California Dreamin' is one of the best songs ever made.

195 / 1089. I loathe "Monday, Monday." (Three of the four members agreed with that assessment.) And for very good reasons, I despise John Phillips and seriously dispute his "reputation" as a songwriter. Guy Webster should have flushed the negative of the cover image down that toilet. And whoever typeset the damn album cover with two incorrect possessives should have been immediately fired. While there are certainly lovely harmonies sprinkled through the 12 tracks, those tracks are some of the most gag inducing music the 1960s had to offer (hence my animus for "Monday, Monday"). The group was just chasing trends left and right better exemplified by their contemporaries. I'd give this a 1/10, except for the fact that "California Dreamin'" is indelibly and beautifully linked to Wong Kar-wai's Chungking Express, one of the best films of the 1990s. So I'm giving it a 2/10.

Better than expected. Solid 4.

California Dreamin' is doing some real heavy lifting here. This was a good and short album but very few of its tracks were memorable and almost all of them could be exchanged and confused for each other. Not a bad album certainly, this type of sound is certainly worthy of its place within such a great mass of albums, but it is not my thing. California Dreamin' is famed for a reason, and I enjoy that every time I hear it, but it alone saves this album from being a 2. 3 is likely objectively a more fair place for it regardless, but for somebody with my taste it is a real close thing. Don't regret my time with it, glad that time was only barely over half an hour.

This album just wasn’t for me, but “California Dreamin’” is a classic that I will always love.

Great vocals, brilliant melodies, amazing harmonies. This is what I'd expect from Mamas & Papas and it delivered. Some songs I'd already heard before (California Dreamin', Straight Shooter) and some new ones that I love much as I Call Your Name and Go Where You Wanna Go. The blending of all their voices is so pleasing to hear.

1966 was when my mother was born. 1966 was when my grandparents lived through. I wonder if they listened to this album during those times. I like

delightful

A couple of all-time classics interspersed with nice but forgettable 1960s pop.

The vocals on this are really lovely, it has the feeling of a girl group album with its vocal harmonies and the trading off of lead vocals. The lush arrangements and nice and give the songs some depth. "Monday, Monday" is the strongest song for me, and "Spanish Harlem" is really interesting with the very up-front vocals. Despite its strengths, it's held back a bit by the hooks and songwriting, which are only OK and a bit predictable, respectively. Under the vocals and strings is some pretty standard 60s pop rock - pop rock that can be a bit slow and sleepy at that. Those elements certainly do elevate it, but not enough to make this with hearing outside of a few songs.

I love their harmonies. Of course, California Dreamin' is a fucking straight-A banger. Monday Monday is also just pop perfection. I love this type of 60s music, even some of the more dated sounding songs are great.

Monday, Monday: 8/10. this whole album already sounds awesome and it's only the opener! which is why I'm also not giving it a huge grade. Straight Shooter: 7/10. underwhelming compared to the previous one tbh... great potential but not so awesome execution, could've been more explosive Got a Feeling: 7/10. not very relevant I call your name: 8/10. quite a vibe Do you wanna dance: 7/10. not bad, slow but not bad Go where you wanna go: 8/10. catchy again ayeee California dreaming: 9/10. FOR THE MEME VALUE. I HAD NO IDEA IT HAD THIS SONG Spanish Harlem: 7/10. a vibe but it reminds me of church choirs Somebody groovy: Hey girl: 9/10. very nice I also liked the lyrics You baby: 8/10. not bad but not extraordinary to me The in crowd: 7/10. I don't know what I'm listening to anymore all these songs sound a little too similar. It's not bad completely tho

Classic maar naast de hitjes ook gedateerd

I was surprised how familiar I was with this. Giving it an intenful listen, I rather enjoyed it.

It's fine, a lot of it is pretty typical 60's pop tunes. "California Dreamin'" is the standout tune obviously, but there's really nothing here that gets me out of my seat. The album feels more like a smattering of tunes and not really like a thought out production. Speaking of that, damn is thing in need of a remaster. It's extremely dated sounding and the way some of the vocals are mixed in the different channels is really bad. Just yeah, it's not something I would rush to listen to again. Not bad, just not my thing.

Short and sweet

Love them. Great album

Ok, some good tunes but of its time

3.5 rounded down to 3. The hits were hits for a reason. Great singing and arrangements.

Groovy hippie music

Excellent sound engineering. I was expecting the harmonies, but the bass lines surprised me.

Nice album. Enjoyable music. Catchy tunes.

Really funntongonback to this. +1 for inclusion of a Spanish Harlem cover.

I have a soft spot for 70's era pop music bc my mom listened to a ton of it.

Solid catchy songs and doesn’t overstay its welcome. Like a lite blend of abba and the beatles, just not quite making a mark

Solid. I’ve always enjoyed The Mamas and The Papas, but some of this album just didn’t do it for me. Obviously California Dreamin is a classic. Monday Monday is okay. Most of the covers are fine but not great, except In Crowd

I thoroughly enjoyed this.

Got boring fast. To be honest, I’ve never really liked California Dreamin. At least they made this a short album.

Beach Boys on even more estrogen These lot were better than the Beach Boys in all fairness

I will NEVER forgive them for what they did to Cass Elliot. She was truly an amazing artist and society failed her. My rating goes solely to her!

It's a 60's pop act. There's not much more to say. They're good, the harmony is beautiful between the singers. They're not groundbreaking. My rating: 4/5

I liked this. The singles are obvious standouts and have aged really well. The remainder are either good originals/ cover versions, or at worst still passable.

Most of the tracks are just average, but there are 2 or 3 (maybe 4) that are pretty good, especially "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin".

It’s pretty much a greatest hits album.

Classic album. Sounds much better in mono.

Remember when the Brady Bunch went to Hawaii and Bobby found an evil idol? What a crazy thing to happen. Greg crashes surfing, Bobby almost killed by a painting, and Peter is nearly bitten by a spider. Then Bobby gets rid of the thing only for Jan to bring it back. Then the crazed archaeologist tries to kill them. After that they have a big party, but like the crazy part was that the trip was all expenses paid, and they even brought their maid. That had to cost a small fortune.

Loved this, the vocal harmonies are luscious

Loved it. Great tunes, harmony, arrangements.

imponente.

Classic album but not really for me. I’m sure there are deeper motifs embedded in the lyrics and background vocals. Lots of chorus effects.

Very solid album from start to finish. No dead weight.

The is some really good folk rock enhanced by fascinating vocal harmonies. It's a great listen. Favorite track: "California Dreamin'"

yeah i fuck with it. california dreaming obviously i knew already but monday monday sounded familiar as well.

my dad's mom was a hippie and said he grew up on the mamas and the papas so i was a little distracted imagining him listening to this as a kid. harmonies are awesome and very consistently good throughout.

PLZ DONT RECOMMED TRASH OK

Listened on a Tuesday Tuesday. Very groovy. Bonus points for Cass Elliott guest starring in a Scooby Doo episode.

Pretty easy listen but not really my jam. As a funny anecdote I never new that the Beach Boys covered one of these songs until I listened to it here.

It's a good one

A wonderfully recorded record. Kinda curious what a mono mix would sound like. Really loved the tracks "Monday, Monday", "Straight Shooter", "California Dreamin'", and "Somebody Groovy"

Great harmonies, enjoyable tunes, just a really solid album.

Harmonies a bound!

Lovely to listen to. Made me want a road trip

Very solid

it was okay. love the harmonies, liked a few of the songs (of course california dreaming), hated one of them, overall cohesive album though. was not expecting i call your name

California Dreaming is maybe the best song about California ever written. The rest generally sounds pleasant enough for my very not rock n roll parents to have enjoyed when they felt like wilding out.

This is just not for me.

Why do I accept this, yet find Simon & Garfunkel rage-inducing? I'm not sure. Both of groups have songs that liberally use the word "groovy," which is cringey. And there's plenty of cringe here beyond "Somebody Groovy," like "Spanish Harlem." But "California Dreamin'" is an undisputed classic, and "Monday Monday" is lovely. The rest doesn't do much for me, which is to be expected. That said, justice for Mama Cass.

firest album ever wow

The production, the synergy, the mellowness was very much giving American Beatles... there I said it! Great record maybe apart from it tailing off towards the end.

I like the harmonies in this, it's nice and easy on the ear. Listening with headphones the voices are interchangeable out of the left and right ear which is v v pleasant. California Dreamin is such a good tune as well

Maailman typerin bändin nimi! Olen joskus nimen kuullut mutta en tiennyt yhtään biisiä, en edes California Dreamin’ia. Hitokseen hittejä tällä albumilla. Ikivihreitä. Kuulostaa 1960-luvulle mutta jotenkin positiivisesti. Einyhtään huonos biisiä. Itse asiassa ihan mieletön albumi. Kestohittejä ties vielä montako kymmentä vuotta. 5/5

A bit bland and cheesy for me. The harmonies are too much. That cover of Do You Wanna Dance? is truly awful. But there is California Dreamin' with its strange ambiguous lyrics. The cover is cruelly amusing with Michele Phillips sitting in the lap of her new lover while literally giving her miserable looking husband the boot.

Cool 60s vibe, especially if it was a trip in a desert or somewhere remote with some friends. I especially like california dreamin' something about it is so ethereal, makes me nostalgic for an era i never knew.

Beautiful close harmonies are one of the most pleasing things to hear

Good clean pleasant listening. The hits are fantastic. Makes a fella want to drive to California with the windows down.

This is the kind of album that plays better on AM radio road trips. The "misses" on this still have really high floors and the harmonies are incredible.

This album is the auditory equivalent of the soft, fuzzy feeling of being just a little high (complimentary), which describes a lot of people in '66 (especially with that shitty shwag weed). (3.5) Everyone knows Monday Monday and California Dreaming, which are still great, but Somebody Groove is a jam too.

Some classic songs for sure! Appreciated the listen.

Standouts Monday Monday California Dreaming

Wonderful

California Dreaming 5/5. Rest of album? 2/5

Wasn't expecting this to be decent. Also I was surprised to recognize California Dreamin'. I remember hearing it on the radio on the oldies station my parents used to rock when I was a kid. Man...

Fabulous and classic

I could contently listen to this whole album, plus who doesn't love california dreamin'

Pleasant but not my vibe for the most part Favorite song: California dreamin (obviously!)

Iconic group of musicians I’ve always loved their music