If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears by The Mamas & The Papas

If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears

The Mamas & The Papas

3.43
Rating
29948
Votes
1
2%
2
12%
3
40%
4
34%
5
12%
Distribution

Reviews (page 4 of 15)

Record starts of with some great songs, but then it gets quite repetitive, which is a problem I have with many 60s Records. But then the mighty "California Dreamin`" comes somewhere in the middle of the record. Banger of a song.

1960s scooby doo music

This was good.

Slatki album, kul su mi oni oduvijek i originalni na svoj način. 3/5, 6/10

8/10 (changed to 4 from 3)

Beautiful album

This album has great harmonies and a laid back 60s charm. There are a couple of undeniable classics, and the voices blend beautifully, but as a full album it was a bit uneven. I enjoyed it overall though.

An album that is distinctly a sound of the 60’s. The vocal arrangement works well with a strong lead singer and multiple backup singers in harmony on every track. The music is simple but good. Lots of tambourine and clearly defined instruments carry each tune. Monday, Monday and California Dreamin are timeless and make this album a winner.

Ah, it’s the classic California vibe, before it was all weed and wildfire. Quite a debut on this time capsule of an album.

There isn't another group with harmonies as beautiful as The Mama's and The Papa's. Well composed songs arranged nicely onto a dynamic album. They don't come to mind often (at least not mine) but they are certainly one of the great groups of the 60s.

They were very popular in the counter-culture scene because they sang catchy songs, mostly written by others that are just uplifting and moving to listen to. This is music to brighten your day, right in-line with the hippie flower power movement.

Monday, Monday. I feel this one in my soul. I love the harmonizing in Got a Feelin, though the lyrics are rather simplistic. There are a ton of great songs on this album.

3.5 stars Catchy, quick, simple with good harmonies. Thought it would be cheesy but ended up liking it.

Ännu ett band som det finns en anledning till varför man bara har hört en av låtarna.. alla andra var zzzz...

60s music. Great.

Already listened to it, though really good

I really like The Mamas & The Papas; I love this kind of music. I know most of their songs sound similar, but I really enjoy listening to them. I liked this album.

A really nice 60s sound

This was ok.

Muuuuy chulo

Great bubble gum pop. Listen to the mono version if you can find it. Sounds much better than the stereo.

Classic 60’s listen

A timeless classic. And I love Mama Cass, rip.

pleasant

Its a 3.5 for me, but just on the sheer volume of singles I know for this I'm bumping to 4.

Is this the best album that features a toilet on its cover?

Fine. Most of the non-singles here are nowhere as good as the singles.

I love The Mammas and the Papas. So much.

Easy listening, california dreaming went platinum as a kid

Hokey but enjoyable -

They don't make them like that any more, do they? It's very antiquated music. It sounds like Oldies. There's nothing wrong with that. You just very rarely get harmonies like that anymore in music. Monday, Monday & all the other hits are great. The slower cover of Do You Wanna Dance is interesting take. The In Crowd was good with the antiquated lyrics: If you're Square, don't go there is hilarious. 3 Ham Sandwich.

Hippie music from the '60s. That was before my time. Still, that era had an influence on my youth. There are a few tracks on the album that I really like. But the album as a whole is more than enough of that sound. I’ll listen to individual tracks again, but probably not the whole album. 3/5

California Dreamin’ may rank in my all time favorite songs. Love the vibe. The rest of the album is fine too. Enjoyed the harmonies and such.

I imagine on release this summed up a lot more going on in the world at the time

I’ve heard this one before. I’m a sucker for a good vocal harmony, and I love the production on these early/mid sixties albums. The radio hits are all good and there are some nice deep cuts as well, although there’s some filler and the last song doesn’t really stick the landing. Altogether a solid album.

Listening session: april 9th, while going for a walk Listened to before: listened to one song before Thoughts: I just love 60s songs with lots of harmonies and especially when it contains Cass Elliot’s voice Favourite tracks: Monday, Monday, Got A Feelin’ & California Dreamin’

Yes! Love The Mamas & The Papas and this album is fantastic from top to bottom. The sound amazing, the songs are great, and there are some stunning covers in addition to originals. Most of my favorite of their songs are on this album, and I discovered so I’ve never heard before but now love. A very easy 5 stars.

Sonido típico de los 60's, claras influencias de los Beatles (no copias, influencias). Bastantes temas similares entre sí. California Dreamin es un temazo y siempre va a ser un temazo. No se salieron mucho del molde, pero los amo aunque sean abusadores.

Me sonó todo el álbum a una película de Tarantino :p y la que más me gustó fue California Dreamin’

Classic is often over used, but this is a Classic Album among the few classics of all time.

muy guapoo, tranquilillo y la duración es la correcta

I liked this, realized I kinda like 60s.

Yes, yes, California Dreamin' is legendary. And I'd happily listen to that over and over. But the rest of the album is the generic pop of the 60s.

Well this was alright. Some country vibes, early pop blues and modest harmonizing here and there. Doesn't set the world on fire but quite nice for driving.

Classic album feels from a certain era late 60s early 70s

Not a bad album, easy listening. I new a few songs already, I will listen to it again a few times. If I will remember it and search for it to listen to, probably not. Some songs I added to my playlist, to remember.

“monday, Monday” and “california dreaming” pretty good… otherwise, sappy wilp/narc music

Звучал с некоторой архаичностью еще в момент выхода, кажется.

Escuchando esto un lunes, que coincidencia. No es mucho mi estilo. Cada canción se derrite junto la otra. Buenas melodías. A excepción de 3 canciones, el álbum no me resulta muy memorable.

Si, es el álbum que tiene California Dreamin', mas que ese hitazo no hay demasiado, dos o tres temas más que son lindos y pegadizos, pero es otra banda tratando de replicar la fórmula Beatle, igual está bueno para ponerlo de fondo.

Amazing vocals and harmonies. About 3 classics and the rest are forgettable.

čavoglave dreamin > california dreamin sasvim neloše, al malo svaka pjesma predugo traje, pa postane repetitivna

So great! What a time capsule.

Enjoyed it. Definitely could see the influence that it had on music throughout the years. Realistically, probably won't listen again though.

It's Monday Monday listening to this album So far so good. Since starting this journey of listening to the whole albums there some good deep cuts.

This will probably grow on me, and it's better than many of the 3s I've give, so a generous 4.

Safe, groovy filler. It really puts the boundary-pushing folk rock classics in sharp relief.

Gorgeous vocals. A lovely album.

California Dreamin'

fantastic folk rock

This album looks exactly how it sounds. You had four incredibly talented voices with exactly zero vibes. The highs are high but generally it's too corny to enjoy.

Very middle of the road album but I will admit the lyrics were fire. I dig their blend too. Highlights: California Dreamin (ofc), Spanish Harlem

California dreaming into a great album from this time

Swooping pop sounds from some tracks, Beatles sound from others. Straight Shooter sounds a lot like Baby You Can Drive My Car. Go Where You Wanna Go is a great track. The rest of the songs are less remarkable, but I enjoyed the album.

What if we took the Beatles, put them in sunny California, and let them rip. Thats what happened here I am sure of it.

Oh yeah, the Mamas and the Papas. So many songs on here that we've all heard over the years, with their lovely harmonies and memorable tunes. One thing I have to complain about is these apostrophes in the band's name on the album cover. I can't believe (my eyes and ears) that they would let that go through. 3 stars. I know this is objectively good, but this genre isn't for me.

It is of course an album based around the two big hits “Monday, Monday” and pop masterpiece “California Dreamin’” but it is nevertheless a reasonably decent listen all the way through. The blend of the voices is the focus and the flower-power sunshine sound paints an idyllic version of the mid 60s. Probably more culturally significant than musically though.

En efecto, no confíen en los lunes. Me siento ignorante que neta no sabía de quién era california dreaming siendo una rola tan famosisima lol. Corto pero wonito, me gustaron mucho sus letras

al menos así a la primera, ninguna de las rolas que no conocía me atrapó mucho (igual le debería calar a la versión en mono). pero ufa, obvio california dreamin es un perfecta y monday monday pue que me guste todavía más

Knew a lot more songs on here then I expected.

1/5 not my cup of tea, refuse to elaborate more.

Somewhat a nostalgic rating in that I heard this in both of my parents' households growing up, it also captures a certain sense of California that I felt growing up in the state.

Hyviä hittejä löytyy. Lopulta ehkä hieman tylsä, mutta hitit pelastaa.

Twelve very catchy songs, and they blast right through them. Favourite track: Straight Shooter

Yeah man it was just another old folk/rock album. It was alright. Again, I didn't hate it, I recognize the talent and everything else. I appreciate it for what it is. And of course California Dreaming is a certified hood classic. But dude idk if it's just the sheer number of these kinds of albums on this list or what but I don't want to hear this album ever again, or any one like it. I'm having some Folk burnout I guess.

Lovely! Very chill.

i don't like folk but I can imagine it was a banger in the sixties cali

Wong Kar Wai hizo icónico este album

I believe the word I'm looking for is "frisson." Those harmonies, man. Holy Jesus.

delightful

Classic. Very clean sound that manages to blend a lot of genres that hadn't necessarily been done together before. You can hear the folky roots pressing up against the nascent psychedelia of the era, as well as hints of classic post war vocal groups. All together it's a nice listen. Nothing mind blowing, but the vocals especially are really dialed in. I'm going 3.5/5 on this one.

Great harmonies. The album does sound dated though.

California Dreaming is really a pretty fantastic song. The lyrics and haunting backing vocals capture the vibe of a dreary grey day that really resonates this time of year. That said, just about the rest of the entire album I found sleepy and honestly kind of boring. It felt like there was really a lack of creativity. I get that this is a pop album of the time and not something avant garde but I did expect there to be a little more edge to this.

Ironically, this is not what I want to be listening to on a Monday morning. At times it reminds me of earlier Beatles, other times it reminds me of the Beach Boys, but the harmonies are a bit too saccharine for my taste and a lot of it feels like bubblegum pop. Coincidentally, yesterday's album from the generator was another album from 1966, the Mothers of Invention's Freak Out, which is essentially the exact opposite of this album and it's one I much prefer. I feel like it's albums like If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears that lead to Frank Zappa's satire and parody on Freak Out.

I love this bubbly pop SpongeBob type music

It's quite good. Very enjoyable. 3 & 1/2

In a nutshell: Harmonies! Harmonies! Harmonies! Lovely harmonies. Good bass. Feels sterile and chaste in parts. Overplayed singles. Overall: 3/10

Great album, some classics

Quite comforting really.

I generally don't like older music like this, but it was really good. Easy to swing your body to, great song writing. 8/10

liked the voice but not really my style

I was pretty disappointed with this one. While Monday Monday and California Dreaming are undisputed bangers, the rest of the album is just not great. Some songs are better, some less, but nothing truly exceptional. (Got a feelin is a great song) It'll be a 2.4, 5

No me gusto. Aunque California Dreaming es un hitazo.

Monday, Monday - 3.5/5 Straight Shooter - 3.5/5 Got a Feelin' - 3/5 I Call Your Name - 3/5 Do You Wanna Dance - 3/5 Go Where You Wanna Go - 3/5 California Dreamin' - 5/5 Spanish Harlem - 3/5 Somebody Groovy - 3/5 Hey Girl - 3/5 You Baby - 3/5 In Crowd - 3/5 California Dreamin' alone makes this album worth it. However, the rest of the album is just mush so that's 2 stars for one song along and 1 for the rest of it. Overall: 3/5 Favorites: California Dreamin'

Don't listen to with only one earphone in lol

Nostalgic👌🏼

A vivid and powerful picture of love in the sixties.

Going in knowing I already love at least two of the songs on this one. This album is a good time. Very 60s in all the best ways. Each song is unique enough to go back to.

3.5 - oddly enjoyed this

This is just one of those albums that is nice to listen to. Not a bad song on it and several songs that are absolute classics. It's all about the vocals for the Mamas and the Papas, and their vocals are amazing on this album - each song highlighting different members of the group. Nice and easy listen!

I have coined a new phrase after listening to this album, "Aggressive Harmonies". I was expecting this album to be a continuation of my 4 streak. At only 34 minutes long I was expecting a situation like that Simon and Garfunkel album i had, just wowing me with a handful of beautiful sweet songs... but here we are, stuck in my headphones with 4 people singing over each other singing stupid stuff. I like California Dreamin' and can forgive the business of the song when it's sandwiched in an Oldies mix, but even it is a little much when you're just listening to a half hour of vocal one uppery. Also, Do You Wanna Dance does not need to be re-recorded and re-arranged, it's pretty perfect as is.

Beautiful harmonies. Perfectly blended folksy-poppy good time. It was exactly what I needed at the moment. 5/5

It's okay

Couldn't get in to this at all.

Nice classic 60s album with three all time classics. The production feels very dated which does hold it back a little, but a very nice listen. 7/10

It was not my thing but that might've been soured by what happened to the band afterwards so it just feels hollow to me. Favourite: California Dreaming Score: 5/10

Pleasantly surpised, genuinely thought it was going to be shit but California Dreamin was one of the most normal songs in the album, it is THAT good.

came for chungking express and a jens lekman sample-source, stayed for the wonderful vocals! the second half of the record is a bit more cookie-cutter, but it's all so well-sung and pleasant, and the good stuff is genuinely emotionally diverse and interesting. lovely!

Whilst California Dreamin is one of the best songs of all time, the album was a dull washed out experience with often annoying stereo mixing that I wouldn't want to hear again.

Clásico entretenido California Dreamin es un temon, y además tienen otras canciones que no se quedan tan atrás

The vocals including the harmonies are just incredible on this album. Instrumentals are amazing too. Some of the lyrics are extremely cheesy, even for me, but I still love this album.

What a great album! California Dreamin’ was my favorite, of course, followed by Monday, Monday, I Call Your Name, Go Where You Wanna Go, and Straight Shooter! While I didn’t “save” (like) the rest of the songs, they were still a fun listen, so I’d consider this to be a very solid album.

so good ALWAYS !!!!!!! two amazing albums back to back i could CRY

starting with monday monday was special great album, love their sound

Incredible harmonies wowee. Just a a lovely listen overall but would I bother listening to the entire album again? Nah Favourite song in this one is California Dreamin (again sorry if that’s basic) the harmonies really shine in that one.

no esperaba nunca chocarme con esta banda, las voces melódicas de las mujeres de la banda suena bien

Slick listening I like

60 years later, it still plays like a postcard from a dream that somehow became real.

This is a decent album some big hits. I liked Monday, Monday and California Dreamin’. I’m not sure if I liked much else. The harmonies are good. I just think it’s soft pop music.

Gammalkoselig pop rock fra mødrene og fedrene. Albumet med den legendariske California Dreamin’, i tillegg til et drøss med andre gode låter. Top 3: California Dreamin’, Straight Shooter, Go Where You Wanna Go

Very summery, very wholesome, and ridiculously sugar-y 60's pop album. The big hit "California Dreamin'" is of course the best thing here, but the rest is nothing to scoff at. A jolly good time all the way through. Key tracks: Monday, Monday California Dreamin'

This felt a lot longer than it was. I think I've heard the popular ones way too many times and the rest of it was already been digested by pop culture long ago. It sounds really dated and boring. Pretty songs though!

Tiesin avausraidan. Vaikka laulut on taidokkaita, ei oikein iske.

Melodias envolventes, vocalizações que enchem as músicas. Cada faixa para a outra sem esforço, partes do disco são mais "groovy" outras mais introspectivas. Grande surpresa para mim que achava ser um grupo mais comercial.

Кажется, этот альбом пришелся бы по душе моему папе. Он напоминает мне советскую музыку 70-х и 80-х, светлую, грустную, простую. Очень люблю California Dreamin'

"California Dreaming" me dejo las expectativas muy altas, no es que me haya parecido mal el álbum, he descubierto canciones que suenan muy bien, pero en general me ha decepcionado un poco.

honk shoo

It's nice folk and groovy. Really nice vibes. If this was my favorite genre it would be a 5.

Monday Monday - I feel like this song kicks of so many movies. Maybe not, but it should. Overall enjoyed this album.

so.... do you believe your eyes and ears?

243/1089 starting off with monday monday and they certainly have a distinct and era-specific sound, i don’t hate it California Dreamin’ is SO good, the rest of the album is just nice though i think 53/100

This was pretty good. Very folky but their choices really go together nicely.

The album is mostly covers of other songs, California Dreamin' is alright, but they sound just like a calque of The Beatles. Not my jam, not my flavor, also fuck John Phillips.

Definitivamente un estilo musical que no es para mí

This is a 60s, acoustic guitar and harmonies album. Its has a few blues-y moments here and there. Like at the start of "I Call Your Name". But the overall feeling is mostly folk-y or swinging 60s mop-top style rock. The big hit from this album is "California Dreamin'". And there are a handful of other familiar songs too. This is a fun album, full of enjoyable riffs and uplifting vocals. All four voices in the band compliment each other so completely that you cant imagine any of the songs sounding any other way that as they do on this album. I enjoyed this album, but I dont think that it is my preferred style. Im not 100% sure I would listen again. But not because I dislike any of the songs. I just dont love them. (2.500)

Was good for what it is, but wears thin after a while

Monday, Monday, California Dreaming, and Go Where You Wanna Go are all iconic songs from the 1960s. California Dreaming is also on that list of 5 or 6 songs they play in film or TV to make sure you know for sure a scene is taking place in the 1960s. This is not music I generally listen to and it's hard to appreciate the cultural impact of albums like this and 60's folk music in general. Definitely worth listening to just for some of the harmonies alone.

Couple of classics

Sounds dated but gotta admire the harmonies and album in general. Worth playing again, it sets a decent vibe.

I really I could go 3.5 here, but I feel like I should round up instead of down because of the impact of the album.

This was great. Even hits aside, it was an enjoyable listen throughout.

It’s fine. Nice harmonies. I don’t really connect with any of it though. 6/10

Cerramos la semana con una banda clásica, que como a tantas de este reto sólo ubicaba por sus temas conocidos. Disco ideal para una mañana fresca de pre-otoño, como todo lo folk/hippie. Me encantó su versión de "Do You Wanna Dance", la cual conocí en su momento por los Ramones. Y demás está hablar de California Dreamin', un clásico eterno. Gracias y hasta el lunes.

Idk how to explain it but it feels like such an autumn album. I fuck with it

Production value's elevate this beyond the beatific voice's. Don't look too closely or you see the teeny styling's. (Whoever organized that cover, by the way, should have his head dunked in the toilet--tries to make them look gritty. Why?) I kept wishing a song had more than one thing to notice. Despite all that, this deserves praise for that one idea.

Fantastic! I think I knew every Sol and they were all beautifully executed. Mama Cass is the bomb.

While the groovy sentiments are a little hard to stomach, and "The In Crowd" is almost offensive, there's a lot of good music on this record and a few standout tracks. Ultimately, the weak material weighs equally on the scale with the high points.

Yeah, I love these guys. Incredible songwriting and arranging by John Philips, fantastic vocals, mostly by Denny and of course their not-so-secret-weapon, Cass, and then it's all pulled together thanks to incredible Wrecking Crew sessions musicians. (Plus their covers always so interesting. "I Call Your Name" is one of my favorite Beatles covers.) What a great group and what a phenomenal debut. Yes, there are a couple of meh songs on here, but the rest are simply stunning. This one and their third album Deliver are sunny California '60s music at its absolute peak.

I enjoyed this so much. I wish Mama Cass had a longer life and we could have heard so much more from her.

7/10 California Dreamin is massive - one of the greats. Monday Monday is also top drawer. Everything else ranges from really good to not bad. But always with those harmonies, it's such a strong album

Oddly enough I was never a huge fan of this group. Back when they were current I thought they were above average at best. But after listening to the absolute crap that gets out on this list day after day these folks sound like heaven. Five stars just to fight back against the Limp Bizkits and Radioheads of the world (not to mention groups even worse who were so bad you can’t recall their names).

Such a happy album, full of sunshine. The layering of vocal hamonies is delicious and makes every track fun to sing along with. This is unmistakably 60s, the sound, the themes, even the production values, as though they bottled the decade and this is what it sounds like when you unscrew the cap. Very enjoyable.

Shockingly disappointing, even outside the non-musical reasons this is problematic. Just not good.

Firstly, California Dreamin is one of the all time great songs. It’s so great. The rest are mostly middling but do have a nice sound. Secondly, I went down such a Wikipedia rabbit hole and this band was insane actually. John Phillips sounds like he was pure evil. I really feel for Cass Elliot though, particularly as I am about the same weight as she was (that she constantly ostracised etc. for being) and also I am currently the same age she died at (32). So I actually was super moved reading a bit about Cass and I feel like she still hasn’t gotten the justice she seems to deserve. (3.5 stars)

Not bad at all. Fun songs, pretty harmonies. Only giving it a 3.9 because I don't think I'll remember it tomorrow.

how I sound in the shower

Yeah, you know you could throw out most of white people music in the 60s, even 70s if somebody dug deep enough in any artist's history. Not trying to justify what he did at all, fuck the guy, but I do believe we can disconnect the art from the artist to some extent. So keeping that in mind, they do sound like some other bands in the 60s, but I think this album of theirs can stand toe-to-toe with some early Beatles records and Beach Boys joints. I think this with it's 35 minutes is a non-stop banger after banger. It's crazy how there are no real skips on a record from 1966. It is one dimensional by today's standards, but it's just perfect for what it is. Tempted to give it a lower score, because of John, but I loved the record and it's sound. So it is a 5 for me.

people forget every album used to be like this. mostly covers or songs people wrote for you specifically. mama cass obviously is the biggest talent here, you could have plugged her into just about any band of the area and she would have fit in. john phillips is one of the most evil pop stars who ever lived and that's saying a helluva lot but he wrote great songs so we throw our hands up i guess.

really enjoyed the folksy-feel, and want to listen to again!

Great album! Lots of instruments and different genres all in one. The whole album flows so nicely song to song, and the arrangement of each piece seems really well thought out.

The music is pretty fine. It's not the best thing in the world, but I'd listen to it again. California Dreamin' is great, but none of the other songs stood out to me.

Love 7 of the songs, the rest aren’t bad, just meh. Harmonies are gorgeous. Cass’s voice is one of the greats.

Straight shooter "every other day" is perfect. For some reason the in crowd had a very different feel to me than the rest of the album.

Some beautiful songs...

Some good songs I know and one or two that are new to me that I liked. Generally samey, and the cover of Spanish Harlem going "lala lala" throughout annoyed me. Generally good tho

easy on the ears fav : california dreamin

Vocally simple but really effective.

I have always loved The Mamas and the Papas. Mama Cass can sing me anything she wants. Oddly enough, my two favorite M&P songs are not on this album. Wtf is with The Mama's and the Papa's tho. Good god. I can barely bring myself to type it.

Silky smooth harmonies and catchy tunes. I have this record and it does not disappoint. And the cover makes me smile too.

Great album spotty but overall great listen!

not being super impressed by this but still nice to listen to, i’d listen to it when i’m struggling about what i want to listen to

California Dreamin’ is a five star banger. The rest of this record bored me.

Notablebtextzeile: Any time of the year, don't you hear? Spending cash, talking trash I'll show you a real good time. Auch wenn sie hier fast irgendwie zufällig Rapgepose erfinden, finde ich die künstliche gute Laune, die "ich bin besser für dich Baby Lyrics" und die abstrus kitschigen Arrangements gepaart mit der penetranten Kalifornien Ideologie echt unerträglich. Hier spätestens wird Hippie komplett Mainstream und Pop und jeglicher möglicher Gegenkultureller Elemente enthoben. Ne, ne, ne.

Nope (nonono, nonono, nonono). Zu weichgespült. Gar nicht meins.

Tut niemandem weh. Schön zu hören.

banger, so many good songs on this album, very cohesive, love the sound 4.5/5

Pretty groovy

Reminded me of something that would be played on Euphoria in an ironic way.

All beautiful and amazing and feel good, it feels like the weather is getting warmer and I’m in the convertible roof down, sunset

Hoe for left right stereo.

Beyond the two hits, there’s not a lot to love on this record, but nothing to hate either.

I really love the Mamas and the Papas. „The In Crowd“ is a really stupid song, but it completely captures Mama Cass’s vocal talents.

Good album, didn’t skip. Just not my speed

This is a nice calm listen. If feel like the quintessential music you think of when you think of the 1960s. It also feels like listening to it while high and laying on a hillside on a summer day would be wonderful.

Un grupo especial, con un toque reconocido al instante y una capacidad melódica fuera de toda duda. Canciones memorables, algunas de ellas aquí como la inicial Monday Monday o California Dreamin´(que solo llegó al nº4). A mi la que más me gusta es I Saw Her Again, incluida en el siguiente y homónimo disco. Fuera del escenario la banda no relucía igual, más bien era un drama de celos, alcohol y complejos hasta que se acabó todo. La figura de Cass da para un libro entero. Cualidades vocales tan grandes como su denostada imagen (incuido el falso mito sobre muerte cuando en realidad simplemente falleció en el apogeo de su carrera por un infarto mientras dormía -misma habitación e incluso cama en la que moriría poco después a la misma edad que ella Keith Moon de los Who...). Siempre nos quedará Dream a Little Dream of Me, sobre la que sentó la versión definitiva. De este debut, polémico inodoro en la portada al margen, todos los temas relucen. I call your name gana muchos enteros respecto a la versión original de los Beatles. Do you wanna dance o Go Where You Wanna Go están al nivel de los mejores Beach Boys, incluso You Baby. Se trata de folk melodioso, perfectamente ejecutado. Las escuchas y sabes que solo Mamas podrían sonar así. Sorprende Somebody Groovy, que podría estar entre lo mejor de un disco de Jefferson Airplane. A buen seguro Paul Simon tomó nota de este tema. Cierran con el clásico The 'In' Crowd, que ya había sido un éxito con Ramsey Lewis o Dobie Gray un par de años antes. No aporta gran cosa, pero tampoco desentona.

Good times great oldies.

Kjedeleg

Mostly enjoyable. Liked CA Dreamin and Somebody Groovy best.

3/3/26 - Listening while doing some work. I was a bit disappointed in this album given what I know about the Mama's and the Papa's. It was fine but not anything I need to listen to again. Top Song - Monday, Monday

A very pleasant listen. Maybe it’s more a weak 4.5, but with California Dreamin being such a banger I’m gonna go to 5.

This album is a quick hit period piece with fun songs and is featured on the Once Upon A Time In Hollywood soundtrack, one of my faves. An easy 4.5 rounded up.

"Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin'" are certainly the hits on this album that have made it big and lasted, but more of them probably should. This thing was a joy to listen to on a rainy day and I happily listened to it again when it restarted. I might need to go back and update my review of Happy Trails. It might not be that I don't like psychadelic rock, just that I don't like Quicksilver Messenger Service...

hippie classic i guess, not really my mood again

Un par de canciones que conocía, el álbum bien en general

Was a fun listen. No takeaways from me. I was surprised to see this labeled as "pop" music. Apparently I would've enjoyed pop music back then!

Very good

It's a nice album, interesting, several great songs, specially Monday Monday and the classic California dreaming. However, some of the songs are just a bit boring. 3,4.

Tastier than a ham sandwich. Pure 60s hippie bliss and it's beautiful.

I listened to half of this one and was like no

California Dreamin is awesome and I liked Go Where You Wanna Go. Rest were meh and I hate Monday, Monday

I don't know what to tell you, this is so good. A couple low points (Spanish Harlem, Do You Wanna Dance) but mostly love it. Straight Shooter and Somebody Groovy are great.

another King's Classics album, for sure. wonderful stuff, but why did every white friend group in the 60s decide they would start making music that sounds really ominous and strange sometimes?

I like California Dreaming, and I don't remember the rest of the album (nothing too bad or too great, just good listening).

i like the idea that there's a subgenre called "sunshine pop" and that these guys operate within it. i don't really give a shit about the insane genrefication of every song ever released, but this one feels fitting and i don't know what else to say about this album since i feel just warmer than neutral about it (but "Do You Wanna Dance" is cute and fun)

all the leaves are brown (all the leaves are brown) and the sky is gray (and the sky is grey) and i had a good time (i had a good time) listening to this album (this album) to be entirely too long-winded, my grandparents' wedding song was Happy Together by The Turtles. you may say to me "but that has nothing to do with this album" and to that i'd say "i really don't care what you're saying right now this is my review and i'll get there." the thing about Happy Together is that there's this almost creepy sound to it that used to give me nightmares. i've never really known how to describe it, but it's something about the harmonies of the lads in The Turts, but there's also just kinda a dread in the melody. once i grew up (22), i realized that i actually really like that *almost* creepy sound to the song. now for the climax. this album had that almost creepy vibe entirely throughout and i thought that was cool (and that was cool).

This did not hit for me. Several of their songs have made it into contemporary culture and most are fine, but damn I hate California Dreaming so much. It ends up in modern media in the most vapid ways possible. The lyrics were also not my favorite. I'd bet you could assemble the entire album's lyrics by combining various Live, Laugh, Love-type posters from your nearest suburban neighborhood. I barely got through it, unfortunately.

The Wikipedia section about the album cover was something else... Love the harmonies.

This kind of got me in a Stockholm Syndrome kinda thing. I started it like 4 times and got bored and then finally I said "okay we're doing this" and it was fine. All the leaves are brown and all that

pleasant as hell

Folk Rock without any highlights besides California dreamin‘

like boring not my favorite. good background music

Non stereo voice/instrument hurts my ADHD brain, got 1 1/2 songs finished. Bit of an unfair rating but it is what it is in that state

Aurally inoffensive.

Beatles but a lot worse and the stereo-effect/split is haunting on some tracks. But 2 bangers at least.

Obnoxious, didn't even get as far as California Dreamin.

the monday track is so horrible. The rest is just lame.

You can really feel the time of this record. It sounds so of its time, but I enjoyed it. I felt it was a bit repetitive and wasn’t really extraordinary, but I really enjoyed the almost haunting sound of their voices mixed with the poppy music.

This was fine, not really my kind of thing. I could enjoy the songs and they were inoffensive but they weren’t anything exciting to my ears.

Damn good, wow

Ah! Takes me back to childhood trips to my nana's.

Dober album

Shana loved this one.

That’s way too many people for one bathtub!

I don’t know. Two classics. Some decent songs. Some fluff. 3 stars for reminding me of the Brady bunch.

Richtig cooles album, leider kein song richtig usegstoche für mich, hans aber richtig enjoyed

Dollarstore beach boys und ich mag nd emal beach boys so richtig

Enjoyable if a bit forgettable.

"Santa-Barbara" by The Mamas & The Papas is certainly impressive. A quartet, two members of which are husband and wife, and the wife sleeps with the third member, who is in love with the fourth singer. Fleetwood Mac, if not envious, will certainly sigh with understanding. But all will be revealed only after the recording of this debut album, which is very good. Sunny, positive folk rock, sung by four different but perfectly complementary voices. The quintessential sound of the sixties, it's no surprise that Tarantino used one of the songs for his "Once Upon a Time in Hollywood." And, of course, the cover, the toilet on which horrified major US retailers who refused to stock the album. Band had to urgently cover it with an advertising sticker, and later they removed even the bathtub. And you say: "Arabs paint over women in albums"...

Enjoyed the whole album more than expected, it was perfect for a cloudy winters day

Mamas and the papas have some classic classic songs and they are here on this album Spanish Harlem in California dreaming have stay in the test of time along with Garfield’s favorite song, Monday, Monday but when you look deeper inside of this app when you find some real gems like do you wanna dance? there are some songs that I will not be returning to. like hey girl, in the end crowd along with. got a feeling I just feel like the ending of the album. The song started to sound a little too similar. Still a great album and definitely worth a listen and I would return to the mamas and Papa’s to hear what they have in another album.

Would be a 5 if it wasn't for the last 3 songs. The 'In' Crowd is okay but deffo not a closing track.

IT’S JUST AMAZING

Nope, low rent Beach Boys, and I don't particularly like them either. Most of this sounds to me like it came out in 1956 not 1966, the same year as Revolver. Whenever this music shows up on a movie soundtrack I'm annoyed by how on the nose it is. My overall enjoyment of the album was in 1 star territory, but I'm giving it 2 because they do have nice voices and there were a few pleasant moments on the drums and bass. California Dreamin annoys me overall, but there is a cool sound hidden in there.

81. all the leaves are brooown

Monday monday - 5/5 Straight shooter - 4/5 Got a feelin - 2/5 I call your name - 3/5 Do you wanna dance - 4/5 Go where you wanna go - 3/5 California dreamin - 5/5 Spanish harlem -5/5 Somebody groovy - 4/5 Hey girl - 3/5 You baby - 4/5 The "In" crowd - 3/5

This was the very essence of "easy listening". It was pleasant.

Several reactions to hearing this much-beloved album for the first time: - It sounds a hallmark of its time, evocative of so much other folk-rock from the 60s. - It also sounds dated. No one makes music that sounds like this anymore, so heavily focused on singing harmonies. - It's bittersweet to hear this, especially when the vocals are beautiful, knowing what happened to the group. - California Dreaming and Monday Monday are still great songs. - By track 8, it was all sounding the same.

3/5 It's really hard to believe this and my last album (Nina Simone's Wild is the Wind) were BOTH released in 1966. In comparison it feels far from revolutionary or extraordinary. A lot of the reviews on this site seem to say it's "fine" and I would agree. It's very agreeable music that doesn't say a whole lot or engage me as an album past just being some songs. Maybe there's more past that but it's not really engaging enough for me to care to look for more than that. "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin" carry the album above a lower score.

Yeah, I didn't hate this but it's not something I'll go back to. You can't deny the greatness of "California Dreamin'" but the rest is just alright.

California dreamin...super! c

not bad at all

Kind of one of those albums with lots of songs you know that you don't know you know. So I thought that these were all cover versions in a fine kind of 60s folk pop way but maybe not as good as the more well-known versions like Spanish Harlem. But it turns out these are some of the originals like Monday, Monday... and California Dreaming. So definitely some pretty serious song writing chops going on. But didn't warm to it massively. 3 out of 5 stars because of California Dreaming.

I just couldn't do this. I tried. It's not horrible but I just don't like the folky-poppy, all the four-part harmonies (if that's what they're called), too folksy for me. Did not enjoy.

Breezy 60’s folk pop elevated by a couple of great songs in California Dreaming and Monday Monday. A perfectly pleasant album. 3.3

It's brilliant. Never actually listened to them other than knowing the big hits. These songs stand the test of time and you can hear how much they have influenced those who have followed.

The 60's had a good amount of one-or-two hit wonders, and whether you like it or not The Mamas & The Papas fall into that category too. The problem with those artists is that usually they can't build up on the sound of their hits and just end up either trying to recreate it or do something much worse. That being said, there is nothing wrong with this album or band and they actually manage to put out some other charming, lush vintage pop rockers. Straight Shooter is a good example, I actually like it more than Monday, Monday. No song recreates the magic and beauty of California Dreamin but ago Where You Wanna Go is close enough. The rest of the album is quite lush and minimal, sometimes a bit too much. The vocal performances tend to be a bit faint, the instrumentation - a bit washed out. There is some filler which is a bit sad for a 33 minute album, but enough solid moments to keep it entertaining.

This album makes me feel like it's Sunday and I live in the suburbs in a little house and it's early in the morning and the sun is streaming through the windows and plaid curtains and filling the room. This is the songs that would play through the radio while I had some tea and an egg for breakfast as I planned out my peaceful day at home. A perfect sleepy morning. I mean all of this in the best way. This type of music really holds a place in my heart. It's interesting because it's so different than the usual music I listen to, but it's definitely just a part of the person I wish to be, the part that wants a peaceful life in the morning (not necessarily and preferably not in the suburbs actually). I like every song on this album. Favorite tracks: Go Where You Wanna Go, California Dreamin', Spanish Harlem

Pretty good!

Monday Morning has been overplayed but this is a surprisingly enjoyable album, nice harmonies and some really nice moments. Hight 4

Enjoyable and easy. Some big hits, some covers, and great singing throughout.

Landmark album.

Classic jangly folk-pop. I have to admit that those apostrophes really bother me, though.

Mooie samenzang, soms wat braaf.

18/02/2026 *1. monday, monday - immediately very beach boys.... 60s wall of sound save me..... reallly love all the vocals. the strings!!!! the chorus!!!! *2. straight shooter - more rockier? bass is reallll nice.... their voices together are sosososo nice! love it! *3. got a feelin - soo beautiful immediately.... love the ticking sound in the back and the bells.... gorgeous singing..... soft guitar..... bit psychedelic? *4. i call your name - piano. cass eliot.... tempo change..... love the bass... fantastic ending! 5. do you wanna dance - the strings and backing vocals just kicked in.... sweet.... enjoyed the other songs more though :) 6. go where you wanna go - strings! the lyrics aren't as joyful as the music.... contrapuntal.... loved it! *7. california dreamin - already great! flute solo! drums and bass are really nice together. *8. spanish harlem - love the harmonies.... very dreamy.... *9. somebody groovy - nice drumming.... bass is great! *10. hey girl - bass break! loved it <3 11. you baby - kindof surfy? loved it, but a bit too cheesy for me. *12. the "in" crowd - cass eliot.... 60s easy listening/baroque pop #1 fan!!! was expecting california dreamin to be my favourite from here, but got a feelin was completely beautiful, will be on repeat indefinitely, literally listening to it as i'm typing. beautiful album, may be cheesy and schmaltzy but it hits some niche in my brain that makes it go haywire! love it!!!!!

оч попало в настроение поплакать

хороший, теплый, старенький с хитами переслушать конечно можно 3.6

Iconic album cover containing a grammatical error and a toilet... Michelle's banana eating on Ed Sullivan in protest of lipsyncing California Dreamin'... Infidelity between band mates well before Fleetwood Mac formed... ...sometimes legacy tips the scale.

Musique très sixties. Un peu (beaucoup) dans le style des Beatles, américains, groupe. Ambiance Ivy League. « California Dreamin’» est très connu et représente au mieux l’album. « I call your name » est très sympa. Note : 7/10

California Dreamin'

C'était pas mal les Mamans et les Papas.

A nice shiny apple with a couple mushy spots.

I mean not all of this is jaw-droppingly good, but it's just too pleasant to give any less praise to. A very nice record.

#41/1001🇺🇸 60s California - what a time to be alive. Monday, Monday was the perfect start to my Monday morning. California Dreamin' is one of the most perfect songs ever written: the lyrics, the harmonies and the flute solo!! I'll never tire of hearing it. I enjoyed the cover of Spanish Harlem too and the rest of the album just breezed by nicely. A perfect document of its time, there is a lot to enjoy here and i feel a bit mean just giving it a 3 but the review is for the album. Not just one track. Best Tracks: California Dreamin' on repeat.

This album is what you’d expect from a group with this name from the 60s. It’s got a little bit of rock and pop elements and a bit of a groove. It sounds good, but i personally wouldn’t go out of my way to listen to this album.

It's nice. Fun. Would I pay for it? No. Would I turn it off? No. Is it a 3? Yes, about as 3 as an album can get.

best album oat

Well it has a couple of classics and is performed well. I expect sounds more ordinary today than when released. Probably won’t be replaying very often but a generous 4.

2 admittedly great songs do not make an album essential listening. Besides, you've heard these songs a million times already. Unless you're completely immersed in the 60s folk vibe this album gets pretty boringly repetitive. I would go 2.75 but that is not an option here.

Outstanding from start to finish. Like early beatles but with folk time and some psychedelic. Great harmonies, cool production, some mad stereo moments. Huge hits but the rest is also strong. First time I've listened to a whole album. Really good

'60s counter-culture icons in errant apostrophe horror! Have only heard the really big hits, which is surprising, as the really big hits are near perfect. Straight Shooter is a cool slice of California guitar pop, Monday Monday and California Dreamin' are the aforementioned big hits. Some of the stuff in the middle is, well, middling. The Beach Boys cover is inessential, i imagine it would have been even more so in 1966? Ditto Spanish Harlem. Honestly - this plays like a group of overnight sensations rushed into making an album, familiar cover tunes and all. But - those hits make this a very worthy listen.

Yeah, these guys were amazing. The hits are superb and the album overall is a cracker.

Reminds me of mom getting the house together in the morning. Love this album, it’s nostalgic for me

This was one of the albums that surprised me in terms of how much I thought that I would like it.

i had a run sometime last year where I listened exclusively to this album for a month

I believed the ham sandwich story until I Googled it while listening to this album. The album rips, by the way.

I can appreciate what it was at the time, but it feels a little bland when you consider all the other folk options from the same era. I never knew about the controversy, I guess if they were still performing in 2026 they would have been a no-brainer pick for the TPUSA alternative halftime show. I didn't hate it but I don't think I'll be returning often. On the plus side you can listen to the whole thing in the time it takes to pinch a loaf.

California dreamin

Album No. 0153 on my list. Like everyone else, I had of course known "California Dreamin'", and "Monday, Monday". But that was it. I had not ever listened to any other song from "If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears". I know that this is a hallmark record of the hippie era, so I was curious what I was getting into here. To be honest, none of the other tracks quite reach the level of the two aforementioned hits, i.e. the album's two biggest hits. I like the singing on pretty much all tracks - the band really had quite some talent. But I'm not the biggest fan of the lyrics as well as the overall vibe. Yes, it's a pretty good glimpse into the whole hippie thing, but I think it's just not my cup of tea. Beside the two mentioned uber-hits, I'll add "Go Where You Wanna Go" to my playlist, because it's such a peak hippie song. Regarding the final verdict, I'm kinda unsure and torn between 3 and 4 stars. I guess that once again I let fate decide and toss a (virtual) coin, sooooo... ... 3/5 stars.

Pretty lovely. Holy shit what a messy group. This is certainly a product of its time -- I could have guessed this came out mid-60s from 3 seconds of any song on the album. But, the harmonies are lovely and the songwriting is solid. Super pleasant. Only duds for me are "Spanish Harlem" and "You Baby." "Straight Shooter" is the surprising standout.

One great track. The rest is forgettable. This list should be about great albums, not mediocre albums that contain one historically significant track.

No. 105 easy listening with a few great songs.