Reviews (page 4 of 15)
As a debut album it can became an isn't hit and now a classic it has to 5 stars all the way
It's just not for me, and I put off listening to this for ages too.
Meat Loaffffff. A dramatic and exciting album with various great aspects to it. Can hear its influence in other bands. I feel like I’m in a theatre production while listening which is nice. Made work 10x more fun!
My mum is a fan of this album, certainly the title track, so I'd say I'm familiar with it but I've never sat down with it myself. It's a kind of dramatic rock that I've never been that into, but I can't help but smile at some of its cheesiness. The whole thing has a kind of musical theatre quality to it, which gives an interesting feel to some songs. Not that surprising that it's been adapted for stage (apparently really quite badly) I aught to enjoy the instrumentation more, particularly how much piano there is, but stuff like "Heaven Can Wait" and "For Crying Out Loud" just feels so completely stifled by the vocals for me. "Paradise By the Dashboard Light" plays into the strengths of the album very nicely, hard to say whether I prefer it or the title track. I can appreciate what it's doing, but it doesn't resonate with me specifically. Probably a 2.5, but I'll be kind and round up
This is a 3.5 for me. I think ill begrudgingly give it a 4 cuz I did enjoy listening and its better than a 3. Classic rock and roll tbh. I can hear the beginnings of power metal bands like Iron Maiden in this album with the vocals. It just felt as if there was a flavour missing. Like if you made food and you knew there was a seasoning you needed but couldnt figure out what the missing flavour was.
3.5 You have to love it its a crazy album its theatrical its awesome that said I think its a great composition as a whole but it has some boring parts and I think its one where you wanna sit down and intentionally listen to the whole thing. It would be a good album to listen to while driving i think... Its very Stimulating for the brain. But well I think a lot of these songs I would not like to listen to them individually. Thats why its a 3.5 at best But Side note. Last year I was watching rocky horror for the 6th time and i realised god meat loaf is actually really sexy. Somehow This hadnt occured to me in my first 5 watches but it was a very strong passion i felt all of a sudden. And Thats why im rounding it up to 4 stars from a 3.5 favourite song: bat out of hell
Can definitely feel the musical theatre inspiration, it was an okay listen but I won't be listening again I don't think
straight elton john but somehow he still made a flamboyant gay rock opera album. love it, big theatre kid vibes too.
I actually kinda liked this album. A lot of it is very over dramatic piano slamming, but it’s supposed to be as a rock opera. I found it interesting to listen to but it probably won’t make the cut to my favorite albums.
My dad and Jack Black probably love this
Exhausting in a heterosexual theatre kid way.
My memory of seeing Meatloaf was at Knebworth when he had a cast for his broken leg and was pelted off stage by everyone throwing mud at him, wrong act for the crowd there to see Deep Purple and Scorpions. Was never a fan and this album is overplayed, overblown and just over produced. Can see why a lot like it though.
The title track is pretty good (although a touch long). The rest are generic power ballads. I was expecting to enjoy this but it meandered into poor man’s Elton John territory.
Banger
Another nostalgia for the 8 track era entry. I spent so many hours listening to this in my uncle's pickup. It's like a camp version of the E Street Band. I can still sing along to all of the tracks. Aside from the spoken word wolf nonsense and the overly long orchestral closer this would be a five for me. How many albums on the list feature a Baseball Hall of Famer?
6/10
Just the greatest rock opera album of all time
One of the best albums of all time!
not sure why but this album don’t really connect with me, had a sound overall that I didn’t really like
A light 6/10. I get the appeal—it’s dramatic, over the top, almost theatrical… but it just didn’t fully hook me. I respect the ambition, but it’s not something I’d come back to much.
I feel like a dad. Nothing memorable here. 2/5
Holy shit, everyone should read about the history of this record. This is one where the context really helps. It is a rock opera, so the lyrics provide important context too. The short version is that Meatloaf and Jim Steinman worked together on several touring musical theater productions. During a National Lampoon tour, Steinman was writing songs for a Peter Pan musical. That musical was never really performed, but the songs were reworked into Bat Out of Hell, which would go on to be the best-selling album of the decade and one of the best-selling albums of all time (~40 million copies). Meatloaf and Steinman had a really hard time finding a record company willing to produce the record. They ended up practicing Bat Out of Hell for 1.5 years before Clevland International Records picked it up. Album sales started slowly but within six months it became a bestseller and continues to sell hundred of thousands of copies a year. Meatloaf and Steinman went in different directions and the next two Meatloaf albums bombed. Meatloaf ultimately went into bankruptcy, rebounding somewhat we they teamed up together for a sequel. The both died, 9 months apart, to the day. There are so many parts of that story that are hard to believe. How did the lyrics emerge from a Peter Pan story? How did the album sell more copies than any other album of the decade? I mean it is good, but is it that good? How can someone go from selling millions of records to financially destitute over several years? Anyway, this is a fun album. Over the top, often cheesy, lyrics. Some of the songs have some decent instrumentation, there were moments that stood out for sure, but nothing particularly groundbreaking. This is, after all, essentially a Broadway Musical with an ode to rock. All this is not to say that I didn’t enjoy the record. I did. I just don’t understand how this album could follow only Fleetwood Mac’s Rumors and Pink Floyd’s DSotM as the longest standing top charts in the UK. Maybe you just had to be there. The album is certainly unique, I'll give it that. That said, there isn't anything here that isn't done better elsewhere.
Pageantry with nothing to show.
I know some songs on this, but never thought of playing through the whole thing. Apparently this is the best-selling album of all time in Australia (where I live). So I better get with the program :-) Title track: definitely epic, merits the Thunder Road comparisons. You Took the Words Right Out Of My Mouth: over the top - the video (and reading Meat Loaf's bio) encourages me to think of the big band, big show, rock and soul scenes of the 60s and 70s :-) Heaven Can Wait: a bit schmaltzy, but could work fine in a musical, ie fits my image of the somewhat-hypothetical musical being passionately worked up by Steinman and Meat Loaf. Two Out of Three Ain't Bad: yeah I get why it's popular, but it does go on a bit .... Other songs: yeah yeah okay. Overall, it's Okay, 6/10 :-)
Was expecting metal but was not at all disappointed.
I didn't expect to enjoy this album at all... however, I was incredibly surprised to find that I enjoyed this album from start to finish. I will definitely be listening to this one again. The vocals are great throughout, with the instruments supporting. I really enjoyed the use of piano in such a 'rock n' roll' setting; It really added a nice touch, and gave me something interesting to listen out for, especially in the introduction of 'Bat Out of Hell'. In particular, I really liked the addition of the saxophone in 'All Revved Up with No Place to Go'. I am not usually a big fan of overly long songs; however, in this album, each song has a reason to carry on. There are new parts being added, texture changes, or even a completely new-sounding part, like in 'Paradise By the Dashboard Light'. Due to there only being 7 songs (and all of them being good contenders), rather than picking 3 favourites, I will rank each track from favourite to least favourite. Ranking: 1. Paradise By the Dashboard Light 2. Two Out of Three Ain't Bad 3. All Revved Up with No Place to Go 4. Bat Out of Hell 5. Heaven Can Wait 6. For Crying Out Loud 7. You Took The Words Right Out of My Mouth
'Paradise By The Dashboardlight' is fine, but I don't really care for the rest... 2 stars
Surprisingly solid album.
I heard from many discussions that this album sounds totally different from what the cover implies, and they are right, as the art suggest this is going to be a hard rock / metal album. Regardless of being aware of that fact, I wasn't prepare for the absolute levels of corniness of this album. This thing combines all that I hate from piano rock and opera rock, being very cliché and overly dramatic. There are some aspects that are a bit admirable (to say something). The guy can certainly sing, the song writing can be quite ambitious and there are even some moments of fast tempo with a frenetic energy, like the fast piano at the intro. However, everything is so incredibly over the top, that instead of moving my head along the rhythms or melodies, I'm dragging my face with my hands hoping for it to stop. I usually listen to these albums about 5 to 10 times, but with only having listened to this project 3 times, I already had enough. To me this is like feeding moldy cheese to an lactose intolerant. I cannot digest it at all, and it is a really bad time.
One of the greatest of all time.
Have I listened to this album before? No How familiar am I with this album? Somewhat familiar, I know some songs and I remember a show about it How do I feel about this artist? Meat Loaf is fun Favorite song(s)? Paradise By the Dashboard Light Overall Thoughts: Fun listen, recognized a lot of it. Would be interesting if the Neverland musical actually got made and we could see all these songs in context.
Another iconic album I haven't got round to listening to yet, so I'm glad it was included in this list. I had a lot of fun listening to this one, it's a solid rock album with some glam rock vibes. I will be buying on vinyl if i see it!
Totalmente impactado con el 3er track heaven cant wait que no me esperaba ni un poco jajaja. pensaba que iba a escuchar un disco de metal totalmente violento y escuchar este track todo melodico fue un impacto Buen album, entretenido. Bastantes sonidos rockandrolleros, quizás no hubo nada que me despierte atención y me saque de onda para decir wow que obra, o quizás solo fue un dia en elq ue estuve concentrado en otras cosas. Son 3 las estrellas
Theatrical, melodramatic, and absurd... in the best possible way. It's like the soundtrack to an unreleased rock-and-roll musical. It's self aware of how goofy it is, but delivered with such complete earnesty to come full circle to be earnest again. This doesn't have to be your favorite style, and you will still find it amusing to give a full listen to at least once.
okay straight elton john!
Paradise by the dashboard light is so good. but god Meatloaf and this theater rock is just not my style.
I don’t understand if I really liked it or not, especially after knowing this was written for a musical. I wouldn’t listen to it normally, but as a musical I understand the vibe they were looking for, really camp.
Don’t think there’s been an easier 5 stars to give
Paradise by the Dashboard light is awful
So fun to listen to this guy
This is non-serious, camp, theatrical, rock and roll. A high 3 from me.
I am predisposed to dislike musical theatre.
When it's got a good hook, I enjoy musical theatre and the more theatrical end of pop music. Even though the words “rock opera” don’t get me particularly excited I found the title track of Bat Out Of Hell to be pretty awesome - it's got a hell of a driving melody and plenty of character. Unfortunately it is in no way representative of the vast majority of the album which is home to too many overwrought takes on overlong Elton John-style ballads which are sadly not my thing. Occasionally they’ll bloom into something else, but not often enough for me.
Meat Loaf gets a surprisingly high 3 from me, it was like a more theatrical and less self-serious Springsteen. I loved the big moments and one of the ballads got me, some of it was too much in the direction of stage musical for my tastes but what a fun record.
Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached Peak Theater Kid - melodramatic compositions, operatically performed, as part of an imaginary rock musical existing in the mind of America's favorite singing defensive lineman/*Rocky Horror* refugee and his psycho(-sexual) songwriting buddy. Producer Todd Rundgren allegedly thought this collection was a parody of Springsteen, and maybe he's right - at the very least it's an *exaggeration* of Springsteen, taking all his self-serious tropes (sex, motor vehicles, sex in motor vehicles) and cranking them up to eleven and seeing what comes out. And what comes out is surprisingly genuine fun, irony, and heartache - or maybe that's not so surprising if you're at a good show. I feel tacky for loving it but I love it anyway - that's probably the frustrated Theater Kid in me talking. (Hint: play it *loud* for best results, and maybe in the car or the shower where you can sing along at full volume.)
Progressive rock, huge in scale and maximalist production. In my head meatloaf was a guitar band, surprised to find it was very much piano led rock like Elton John, but more progressive. Didn’t love it, I see the appeal but I won’t come back to this album.
If you’ve never once left like a bat out of hell in the morning, just to come crawling back, or had to decide on the spot at a wedding when your drunken girlfriend was pissed she wasn’t the bride whether you were all in or not, or if you’ve never drawn first blood to avoid losing the game of love, then this ain’t fer you chump. We need more opera rock in this world.
Despite all my shell I am still just a bat out of hell
Not my cup of tea . Never has been 2/5
Pretty epic
Kæft en seriøs omgang rock'n'roll! Bliver lige lidt for underligt med "You Took The Words Right Out of My Mouth (Hot Summer Night)" :o Kommer med alt sandsynlighed aldrig til at sætte det på igen :i
"You took the Words Right Out of My Mouth" var et lidt et lavpunkt, men ellers, what's not to like? "Grandly silly, irresistible album".
*50 Gennemført overproduceret, Elton John på crack, som bare ikke er min smag. Kunne uden tvivl fungere som en musical, jeg aldrig vil tage ind og se, men som sikkert vil gøre sig rigtig godt på salg og anmeldelser. 2 stjerner til Michael Lee Kødbrød og Jim Steinman.
Jeg synes faktisk at det her var overraskende fedt. Jeg kommer ikke til at købe kværnen, men det var en en underholdende tur bagpå.
eeeeeejjjj, jeg har simpelthen hørt det her så meget - men det gør jeg ikke længere. Af gode grunde. Jeg synes simpelthen, det er irriterende nu. Jeg har ikke tid til musical-rock længere. okay... ovenstående var skrevet, inden jeg faktisk gik i gang. det er jo crazy det er så fjollet, så ekstravagant, dekadent, et overflødighedshorn af klaver, vibrato, motorcykler og høj fart ud af helvede det kræver lidt, men det giver så meget til gengæld okay så - værsgo, tag mine fire stjerner 3.8
To gode numre giver 2 stjerner - ellers er det godt nok lidt op af bakke.
Det bedste ved albummet var covered. Fin musik, men det siger mig ikke meget
ved ikke rigtig hvad jeg skal sige eller mene... Tænker ikke opera rock kan gøres meget bedre, og det er svært at sætte en finger på både Meat Loaf eller musikerne. Men det er så langt fra noget, jeg selv ville sætte på - plus at nogle af numrene læner sig lidt mere ind i 70'er/grease-agtigt territorie end jeg har det komfortabelt med. Der er også flere tilfælde, hvor det skinner igennem, at albummet er baseret på en musical, hvilket heller ikke ligefrem trækker op i min bog. Kan ikke komme højere end 3
Ahh man….love this album. Have done since I was a kid. Just takes you on a journey through the songs. And as I’ve grown older so the songs have spoken to me in new ways - different songs become favourites at different times, depending on where I’m at in life. My only complaint is it’s such a crappy recording…but it’s a minor point. As a rule I absolutely loathe musicals, but this is effectively the exception to prove the rule. It’s the songs to a rock opera / musical that never existed except in the listener’s head. Probably why I like it…none of the sudden, jarring breaking into song from the linking dialogue. edit - I'm depressed to see a musical has now actually been created - I'll skip that! Easy 5 for the album.
this is going so many places and doing so many things but really it is musical as they intended - short moments I liked but overall won’t be putting on I am not a metal leaning theater kid
It's pretty OK, I suppose. It's pretty funny that he seems to have made a whole "opera" about a one night stand.
Quite an operatic experience overall, which I always find myself appreciating. There's such a weird dichotomy, though, between the badass cover and album title and the artists name being Meat Loaf and being a guy who does not appear to be badass at all.
its fine but its not for me
No esta mal
I think this is the first time I have ever intentionally listened to this album yet I knew all the songs but the last one well enough to sing along. Just from hearing them on radio and in TV and movies. Probably deserves more than three stars of being one of the top selling albums of all time but it's not a repeat listen for me.
A classic, but not one that I'll listen to often.
More Rock Operas! More Piano in rock music, Litschy
What I imagine Todd’s rock opera to sound like
Just because it's schmaltz doesn't mean it's not five stars. Generationally I'm firmly in the Bat Out of Hell II I would do anything for love but I won't do that era, but I know this shit rocks. Having seen Max Weinberg and Roy Bittan - core members of this ensemble - still kicking ass well into their 70s live last week at the Forum in LA certainly didn't hurt in priming me for this.
I guess....this....I just....I don't.... The thing is I don't really understand in what context I'm supposed to listen to Meat Loaf. Is this for people who love show tunes? Is this for people who tried to get into Sabbath but prefer something more upbeat?
This is as over-the-top as I had expected and hoped. I feel like I'm listening to an original cast recording of a Broadway production, which makes sense given Jim Steinman wanted to do just that. As such, I'm not a musicals or Broadway person, so this isn't for me. But it's fun and ridiculous and definitely worth a listen. 3.5 stars.
That cover looks like it's straight out of a metal album. Suffice to say, my expectations were wrong. Epic rock opera jams are fun and dandy on their own, but with a full album, it can get exhausting. Meatloaf has some good vocals and good tunes, but, nothing that really stands out to me that Queen doesn't do way better. It's fun to listen to, at least.
Jack Black's dad is a hypocrit, he played in meat loaf. In all seriousness, expected a heavier tone from the artwork on the album cover. Instead we got Elton John with more guitarwork. The movements are impressive but not all of them land and make the songs meander as a result.
such a fucking banger
Metal ass cover for an album that sounds like Billy Joel playing on Broadway.
me ha gustado una canción solo
Greatest album of all time. No notes.
I think on another listen i’d be more into this and i wasn’t not into it but i couldnt get over that some of them sounded like parodys (i guess theres a genre of meatloaf parody). Some very singalongable songs.
I feel like Meat Loaf gets a bad rap but this album fkn slaps?
Enjoyed this way more than I expected to! Not sure it really deserves 4 stars but 3 felt insufficient for the fun energy going on while I listened to it
Bruce Springsteen already did this album with Born to Run but even ol’ Brucey knew to be a bit more restrained than this. Grandeur for the sake of grandeur wears thin early, and turns everything from halfway through track 1 into a slog.
Been waiting for this one. My brother's all-time favorite album. I've heard every song from it many times, but I don't think I've ever listened to it as a whole before. Bombastic, ludicrously over-the-top, and just fantastic throughout. A perfect vehicle for Meat Loaf's massive vocals and Jim Stienman's good-enough-is-never-good-enough song writing. 4 1/2 stars.
Is it me, or does Meatloaf just sound instantly dated? All the stars for Paradise by the Dashboard Lights ... that's the one song that doesn't seem to age. Also note ... one of the best album covers ever!
its alright. the first song beautifully blends two very different styles, but the rest of the album more or less meanders.
Am I crazy or is the title track almost a total rip of Springsteen’s “Thunder Road”? That topline melody sounds awfully familiar. I guess I thought I’d like it more? I’d heard “Paradise by the Dashboard Light” a bunch growing up on the radio, but otherwise I came into this with fresh ears. It’s one of the best selling albums of all time; surely that means I’ll get something out of it. His voice is deceptively classical, sometimes pushed into rock grit. There’s some nebulous story going on about escaping hell. I just didn’t think the songs were very exciting; even “Dashboard Light” (which I would’ve previously called an all-time banger) doesn’t hold up as well as I remember because now I can hear how much it sounds like the other songs on this thing. He repeats his ideas too often. “Heaven Can Wait” might as well have been as long as the rest of the songs. The lyrics had me shaking my head sometimes too. (“You’ve been cold to me so long/I’m crying icicles instead of tears” - yuck.) I am a theater kid at heart and this was still too much for me. I will probably still revisit “Dashboard Light” in a year or so when the bad taste is out of my mouth.
Two amazing songs and some really over-dramatic power ballads. Nah but seriously, "Bat Out of Hell" and "Paradise" are some insanely awesome Rock Opera tunes, and the whole team of musicians and engineers that came together to make those songs deserve all the flowers cause holy shit. "Hot Summer Night" was pretty good but that little bit of dialogue at the beginning really makes my skin crawl. I think it's the tongue sounds in between the words being said lol. "Revved Up" is fine but damn I wish the whole song was as awesome as the ending to it. All the ballads in this album leave a lot to be desired tbh. "Heaven Can Wait" is really really sleepy, especially coming after The first couple tracks. "Two Out of Three" was a big "oh that song!" moment, but it felt so much longer than it needed to be. "For Crying Out Loud" was a pretty decent closing track but honestly the 8 minute run-time felt a bit too over the top for my comfort. "Paradise" is such an intense song, that following it up with an equally demanding 8 minute long power ballad feels like too much. Still all that being said, despite the low 7/10 rating, I do think this album is pretty good and even fun in a lot of places, it just gets to be a bit much after a while. Probably a great album for a car ride down the highway.
Oh man, it's a lot. I know it's intentional, and I love it, but you really have to be in the mood for this album. It is definitely reminiscent of being a teenager, the back and forth of emotions, lust, love, hate, and hormones. The second song loses me with its introduction, will avoid it in future listens. Paradise by the dashboard light is exactly what I remembered, beautiful chaos. Bat Out of Hell and For Crying Out Loud were similarly enjoyable. The album seems like what you'd get if Bohemian Rhapsody was a whole album and took itself way less seriously, intentionally taking you on a whole dramatic journey and laughing at itself with you.
Lo escuche todo, no me resulto interesante. Por momentos me sonaba a obra de teatro musical donde las palabras estan metidas en la melodia de manera forzada con tal de contar la historia.
Me gustó ese carácter barroco, es como un barrocko. Muy teatrero, pero muy extenso. A pesar de que son solo 46 minutos lo tuve que escuchar en varios momentos porque se me hizo un poco largo. Si bien no me gustaron canciones en particular (solo una), sí me gusta como álbum.
Heard this album about a million times
As subtle as a brick to the face and unashamedly so.
Totally ridiculous and overblown to a level that makes you think that steinmans co writer was a truckload of cocaine, and yet it works. It works because Meat has so much charisma and theatricality to his voice that the insanity going.on around him has no choice but to bend to his will.
Super cheesy and theatrical with about as many hits as misses. Almost certainly won’t come back to the album, but I’ll return to the highlights. Favorite Songs: “Bat Out of Hell”, “Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad”, “For Crying Out Loud” Least Favorite Song: “All Revved Up with No Place to Go” Mid 3.
Not that bad but not really my style Songs are not as intense as the cover
rock gitu gitu yee
non avevo mai sentito prima questo album e sincero ero convinta che non mi sarebbe piaciuto; invece sono stata sorpresa in modo positivo e qualche traccia mi è rimasta in testa tutto il giorno. le mie canzoni preferito sono state two of three aint bad e la title track, e sono positiva che in futuro lo potrei riascoltare.
A pretty classic album. Nothing else really sounds like this.
So the album and everything about it before opening it suggests its rock, hard rock maybe. But im assuming this is the definition of a rock opera. Its good for the type of music I think, only 7 songs? But not for me. I would be annoyed if someone put this on for a road trip
loved this
I might be more like a 3.5 on this but am giving extra credit simply for the album cover. For being one of the most popular albums of all time, there were a few songs here I hadn't heard - Jim Steinman could sure write a song and play the piano, and a few of these are probably the best "rock opera" songs ever recorded. That said I think it's best at its most fast and furious (title track, Paradise, All Revved Up) and worst at its slowest and schlockiest (Two Outta Three, sorry). But the heights are really really fun, and the lows are more "just OK" rather than actively bad, so 4 stars it is!
Very good album
Loved the album! Bat out of hell was my favorite song but they were all interesting and unique
Yea it's Meat Loaf, yea it's cheesy as all hell. But come on now it's still awesome.
Beaucoup plus fun qu’escompté!! Hyper mélodramatique et kitsch mais dans le bon sens, j’aime bien le côté Supertramp/comédie musicale
Grandiloquent et exubérant sur les titres vraiment rock, EltonJohnesque sur les balades : bien kiffant. Quelque part entre 4 et 5.
Should hate but some really enjoyable tunes
This is gloriously ridiculous and amazing
It was alright. Bat out of hell is great. Some bangers and some mehs. Better than expected
This was surprisingly better than I thought it would be. Meat loaf's theatrical style was unique enough to keep the album feeling fresh. I don't appreciate some of the more misogynistic lyrics but of a time I guess.
Pretty stupid!
So cheesy, but I liked it. I want to see a biopic starring Jack Black.
It is what it is
i liked it
Bat Out of Hell is completely my thing. I loved it. Big, dramatic, and full on, but it never loses me. It held my attention all the way through. I just enjoyed it for what it is. Five stars.
More theater kid shit. Everything I hate about a rock musical and nothing I like about rock.
Clearly these guys are all in on this album. Surprised to read it in a top 10 in albums sold, so obviously appeals to lost of people. It was a bit too theatrical for my taste and aside from the novelty factor and the icon Meatloaf was, not really a huge fan of his music.
This is pretty much exactly what I was expecting; a dramatic, maximalist, theatrical album. Honestly, while it’s not my style at all, I actually enjoyed it more than I thought I would. That said, I won’t be adding it to my regular listening rotation.
Mal was gutes. Hat ein par zuemliche banger drauf. Mag ich
I think this is severely overrated. I kind of hated it
Pretty basic but a fun, epic, energetic album. It’s doesn’t stand out much, but definitely has its moments. Not much else to say. Enjoyable album but hardly special. 7/10
I love this album. I would’ve rated it a 5 without even listening to it, but I listened to it anyways because it’s a 5. And now that it’s over I rate it a 5. It’s perfect, rock and roll for drama kids and im all for it!
Pretty extravagant, kinda cliche.
Not a fan. Music is to dramatic
I always admired the theatrical flair of this. People like to use the term "rock opera", well this is the quintessential rock musical theater. Despite all of that, I don't find most songs to be super memorable, but it still is legendary and great album, 4 stars
Как рок опера - это хорошо
Estuvo bueno el álbum, me gustó que no es música que acostumbro consumir y fue una experiencia diferente
Campy, theatrical, over the top, even silly at times, but so much good fun! Also, lots of solid musicianship and composition- let's not forget the genius of Jim Steinman and his amazing writing and scoring. As I was listening, I wondered why there has never been a Meatloaf musical because this album seems like it was scored precisely for one. Turns out, in 2026 there is one in development! About damn time.
What can I say? I’ve been listening to this album more or less since it’s release and it’s ace! Totally over the top and silly in so many ways but I love it!
I have liked this album since I first heard it when I was 9. But I didn't need to give it another spin this morning.
este no me volvio loca, senti que era el soundtruck de una pelicula random. osea, con esa portada super rockera esperaba algo mas divertido, nada mas. en realidad esta buenisimo, solo que no matcheamos del todo!!!
Enjoyed!
Какой-то слишком пафосный и любвеобильный рок
i aint listening to alll that
Absolutely fabulous and over the top. If you can't enjoy it then youre just a bit fucking miserable aren't you.
haunts my every waking moment
I bought this record when I was 15 and played the hell out of it. I loved all of it - the incredible piano, the booming voice, the over the top theatrics. I still have my record from 1985 and I still love all of it. I have so much listening time invested, and so much nostalgia wrapped up in this album, it’s impossible for me to be unbiased. There’s nothing like belting out these songs at the top of your lungs when you’re home by yourself. 🦇
A master of the rock & roll ballad, Meatloaf loves to add the dramatics into his songs and isn’t afraid to sing a 10-minute jam. All around, his music is very sound and I like his passion and energy in every track. I don’t know that this is his best album, but having the timeless classic Paradis By The Dashboard Light immediately elevates this whole compilation.
It’s hard to hate on any part of this album. It just rocks out with impassioned vocals and the instrumental side is interesting and keeps your attention. Yes, it’s over the top, but in an engaging way and no more so than “I love darkness” heavy metal or “ I love my baby” Pop and R&B jams. Plus, it’s meatloaf … it ain’t fine dining, but everyone loves meatloaf.
Over the top and ridiculously dramatic, but damn this is a super fun listen.
Intro Song, "Bat out of Hell", an absolute banger.
Bombastic! The writing and performances were over the top. Very Springsteen-esque. I didn't know that this was developed from a musical but it certainly sounds like one. Fun and enjoyable.
This is what Rock and Roll and dare I say MUSIC is all about. Thos is a great artist using 100% of his talent and creativity to produce a strong cohesive piece unique to himself above all. Classic radio hits, genere bending arraignment, soaring rock melodies., this album has it all
I enjoyed this - felt similar to Bruce Springsteen to me. Not in love with it, but it was a good album!
its kind of trash, but likeable trash
I remember as a kid reading all the rock magazines, and inevitably, an article would bring up Meatloaf’s Bat Out of Hell. I had no idea who or what Meatloaf was, but by the time I got it on cassette from Columbia House, I soon realized I’m not sure I’d ever really know who Meatloaf was. He was rock, he was pop, he was a Broadway musical, he was metal, he was incredible. As I got older and discovered the joys of Bruce Springsteen, I realized there were some similarities between Meatloaf's music and the Boss’s music. In fact, and I was just told this by my good friend Wikipedia, there had been people who claimed Bat Out of Hell was just a rip-off of Springsteen’s Born To Run. I’ll admit, after hearing Born To Run, I, too, thought it reminded me of Bat Out of Hell. Meatloaf apparently hated the comparisons, and I can understand why. No one wants to be compared to someone else, much less to a rock icon. But, I put Bat Out of Hell on equal footing as Born To Run. Both are in my top albums list. Track one is the title track, Bat Out of Hell and it’s a masterpiece. The music is so good, so heavy, so well composed. And Meatloaf is a great singer, but he’s an even better belter. He just belts it out there. Though he can get quiet if he needs to. This was the third single of five released from the album. It hit number 23 on the Billboard Hot Rock chart. God, I love this song. It tells a tragic story of a motorcycle dude who promises to come back to his lover before dying in a wreck. His heart then flies out of his chest, still beating, mind you, and then flies away like a bat. Out. Of hell. Every time I hear it, I get chills. After getting to the age when you like to research what you’re listening to, you find out that someone named Jim Steinman wrote all the music. Then you realize, he’s a genius. Then you see that Todd Rundgren produced the album. Then you realize, he’s a genius. It’s no wonder this album sold 14 million albums in the U.S. alone. It must be pointed out that, beyond the music and Meatloaf's singing, the lyrics of these songs are perfect. You get a story with each song, and sometimes it's a funny story, and sometimes it's sad, but each story is worth finding the lyrics and following along. And, I'm not a big lyric guy. Track 2 is You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth (Hot Summer Nights) and, supposedly, Meatloaf asked Steinman to write a song that wasn’t 15 or 20 minutes long, a pop song. And this was what Steinman came up with. This was the first single off the album. It’s not the best song on the album, but it’s very good. The song reached the 30s and 40s on the U.S. charts. It’s got a very 50s girl group sound to it, like The Leader of the Pack. Great song, but there are better songs on here. Track 3 is Heaven Can Wait, and it’s another ballad with a very Springsteen-sounding piano and strings. It’s a really beautiful song. Meatloaf really sings so softly on this song, and it goes so well with the music. I don’t think I’ve ever really listened to it close enough to hear just how amazing it is. It’s a very melancholy song, and I almost want to cry. I have no idea why. Is anyone else becoming soft as they age? Track 4 is All Revved Up with Nowhere To Go and it was a single in the United Kingdom. This song has the Springsteen sax with the Springsteen piano. Such a good song. It sounds like it could have been an outtake of Born To Run. This song is also more of an old-school '50s-sounding rock track. I imagine both Steinman and Springsteen listened to the same music growing up, and it really shaped their outlook. In addition to Meatloaf, Steinman also wrote music for Bonnie Tyler, who is criminally underrated. It’s probably why I love Tyler so much. I always looked at her as the female version of Rod Stewart, and I don’t have to tell you how much I love Rod. Track 5 is a great ballad and hilarious. It’s Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad. It’s almost a reverse Baby, It’s Cold Outside, as Meatloaf doesn’t want to go out in the cold and wants to stay in and make sweet, sweet love with his chick. But his chick wants him to say he loves her, and Meatloaf, well, Meatloaf ain't the loving kind. He says, I want you, I need you, but there ain’t no way I'm ever gonna love you, but, hey, two out of three ain’t bad. Brilliant. Then we find out that a girl he was in love with said those words to him and broke his heart, which led him to harden his heart to love. I really love this album. Track 6 is the big one, Paradise By the Dashboard Lights. I mean, do I even have to talk about this song? It’s THE Meatloaf song and one of the greatest songs ever written. It’s about two teenagers trying to hook up, but the girl won’t go past third base unless Meatloaf says he loves her. The way they incorporated a knockoff Phil Rizzuto to make their make-out session sound like a baseball game is one of the greatest things in musical history. This song makes the album a must-listen on its own. The last song is For Crying Out Loud. It’s another quiet piano ballad with Meatloaf using his softness to really bring you down after the bombastic Paradise. Remember that? How bands used to agonize over the order of the songs on an album? Now, you don’t even think about really releasing the album at all, you just put out singles. I’m still an album guy and always will be, I guess. When For Crying Out Loud gets going, it really picks up, still just the piano and Meatloaf, but it builds perfectly. Just a beautiful love song. This album is perfect. There aren’t many in this world. Every song is good, and there are at least four brilliant songs on the album. This is a must-listen album if there ever was. It’ll make you laugh, it’ll make you cry, it’ll fire you up. It’s just incredible. Listen to it as soon as you can, and if you’ve heard it before, but not in a while, listen to it, then listen to Springsteen’s Born To Run and really give yourself a treat.
Quite fun, but not that good
His voice is one of a kind. This album is fun and nostalgic and pretty damned solid. Theatrical rock.
Mid, mellow-dramatic, predictable. Maybe in its day it sounded more dynamic, but I can not hear it with those ears. Meatloaf does have a skilled voice, but it is applied to tepid mediocracy.
This sounds like someone bellowing at a piano in a noisy pub. The songs don’t do anything for me and I really don’t get the huge appeal this album seems to have. I think the style of music just isn’t for me.
Enjoyable and pushes its aesthetic so far that it becomes self-reflexive in an interesting way.
Before even listening, I know that 15 minutes of live performance tagged onto the end of a record is not why this album is on this list. So starting today I'm deciding to find the original standard release and listen to that instead whenever this site links me to another deluxe extended edition for some reason. Anyway... This album is curious. It's produced like every song is a stadium anthem, but I don't think all of these songs fit that bill. They were afraid to get small when the moment called for it. Sounds like they were aiming for the ultimate big album, and forgot to consider the individual songs when they made that decision. As a result it's frequently emotionally disconnected from itself. And also a lot of these tracks are just mediocre songs that they decided were finished being written anyway. Now it's not nearly all bad because a couple of these songs *are* stadium anthems. There are some standout great hooks and memorable moments, but too frequently they aren't well support by also having a great arrangement and aren't songs that are good for their entire runtime. I get why it's on the list, but it's just an okay album all things considered. 3.0/5
Good god.... okay, you've gotta respect the POMP and the commitment to the bit, and the BOMBASITY of it all -- including Meat Loaf's freaking pipes. Still, mostly sounded like a rock musical about one night of horny teenagers being horny....
Honestly, the title and album art does not fit the music on the album. I was expecting something.. harder, more metal, or more gritty. This is something in the vain of Bruce Springsteen, Billy Joel, or Elton John. It's fine. But I would've hated to buy this album in the 70s based on this cover and then get like.. "Born in the USA" ass vibes lol
I love Meatloaf. It is joy in a bottle, cheeky delicious happiness on a record. It looked so dangerous as a kid. It is the hands down best solo dance party album of all time and should endure for all time.
My parents had this on vinyl, 8-track and CD. I have listened to this album more times than I can count so I might be biased. It's a 5 star for me although I'm not quite so sure it's an actual 5 star. But I don't care, I have too many memories wrapped up in it.
I certainly do not have the connection to this record a lot of people my age or older do. However, my mother taped "two out of three ain't bad" off of the local AM radio station and played it a lot when I was a wee lad, and I always enjoyed it even though it bummed me out.
Can’t take this serious. the songs are good but the dialogue and a lot of the vocals really bring this down. The lowest possible 3 stars
This album is amazing. Perfect. So dramatic, but great. The intro to "You Took the Words Right Outta My Mouth" is cringe, but other than that this is great. So much fun and literally not a bad song. Such a horny album lol Liked Songs: The whole album
3.5
Malade !
This album is a true shakespearian comedy. Absolute gas.
I can see why some love it. I can see why people hate it. It’s very of its time, lyrics are pretty bad in general, but I think the album achieves what it set out to, so who am I to criticise
EL TEMA es temazo, pero el resto no me encantó
What a bombastic and perfectly over-the-top rock-n-roll romance opera! I was exposed to this record as a kid, Mombo karaokeing the silly fuck out of it while hosting family dance parties in the living room. At the time, I thought it was goofy shit for the olds, but guess who came around? Exciting, energetic, and drenched in sweat: this baby has enough hammering piano, whaling sax and shredding guitars to elevate gym shorts. Maybe a page or two torn from Elton's book, but who cares? This chunk of tunes is so rich with frenzied passion, you don't even mind the spit hitting your face. Spanning the complete gamut with the metal-as-fuck "All Revved Up" to the gloriously beautiful ballad, "Two Out of Three", Meat Loaf served a timeless joy ride of rockin' sex fuel, hot-n-ready.
Dripping with energy and above all, P A S S I O N. "Bat Out of Hell" is a helluva opener for a debut album! You really get a big bite of Meat Loaf and what the meal's gonna be. The music is lush, cheesy, over the top, and I’m floating on the clouds. Cocaine is a helluva drug.
Hate it. I get it’s theatrical and over the top but it’s like listening to opera by guns n roses. Not for me
My Fav
I love this album SO much.
This album art and title is WAY more metal than it deserves to be. Meat Loaf is just so fucking weird. Why was this guy popular?
a bit boring
I felt very white listening to this
His name may be Robert Paulsen, but this much melodrama and everything turned up is just too much for me.
Did not expect this type of music with such a cover. Idk if I return to this album but it was not bad
Prima album, heel corny
This album is very nice, the production is cool, the lyrics are a bit repetitive, the lyrics are of a high pop rock that doesn't compromise on low pop rock.
no idea what to rate this tbh. felt misled by the cover but it wasnt bad, jjust seemed like a lot of other stuff ive heard.
Super fun album!
I was not familiar with Meat Loaf's music, so this was a nice discovery ! I enjoyed the album as a whole, although no track emerged as a favorite.
earnest yearning fuxk-opera by horny 70s rock nerd
Not exactly my type of music. I feel like this is stereotypical jock music from those older movies. This album is just odd.
I'm a meatloaf ho
It's a musical theater pastiche of Born to Run, as if Born to Run wasn't already plenty theatrical. This record has been deep in my bones since I was a kid, but I haven't really spent any significant time with it as an adult. I respect the hell out of Jim Steinman (dude's track record on the charts is incredibly impressive). On this album, he takes a million big swings, and just keeps Socking. Fucking. Dingers. Every time. I am definitely not too cool to give this five stars.
His best
A lesson is theatrical rock. Great performance from Meat Loaf, great songs from Jim Steinman and a masterclass in production from Todd Rundgren
Great Album
Another terrible one. 0.5/9, 23.57%
An epic chaotic masterpiece.
Interesting. Didn’t hate it, didn’t love it. Had some good stuff not really any bad songs. Solid 3
Assez bonne surprise, pas trop mon style mais très quali pour la vieillesse
Roquero muy arriba
Actually great, enjoyed it! Though I feel like the album cover doesn't quite capture the music 😅 it was more like Springsteen or Elton John than the metal I expected
I just like how theatrical Meat Loaf is in his music. Politics aside, there's just good flair.
“I swore that I would love you to the end of time! So now I'm praying for the end of time To hurry up and arrive 'Cause if I gotta spend another minute with you I don't think that I can really survive” “Bat Out Of Hell” has always felt extremely unique to me. It’s relentlessly uncool in its theatricality but it remains just on the right side of corniness. It feels like the kind of thing that would inspire embarrassment if someone were to walk in on you listening to it and yet it doesn’t. We all seem to have agreed that as over the top, camp, and downright silly as it is, it is just brilliant. When I revisited it I found that I had left the slower tracks (“Heaven Can Wait” and “For Crying Out Loud”) out of my library on Spotify. I can only assume this was youthful churlishness at the idea of there being any slow tracks on a rock album. On this listen I swiftly rectified this and heard the quality in these two songs as well as what they do for the pacing as a whole. There is nothing I would change about this album. It is absolutely iconic and tremendous good fun.
Pretty good. Nothing really stuck to me though. Very 70s 80s ballad type. 5.1/10
3.5
7/10 - Really liked this, long orchestral rock songs
First off, shoutout Todd Rundgren. I feel like his production and insight to this album is what makes it sound so good. This is a very polished album. Music wise, it was not bad either. Meatloaf can definitely sing and it’s interesting to hear him on the non balled like songs. Think this album would be better if the first and last songs were trimmed down.
This meatloaf has a lot of cheese, but “Two Out of Three Ain’t Bad” ain’t bad. The rest of the album is laughable but not enjoyable.
Im not big into musicals I general but I think this album stands on its own outside of that style. The jaunty piano, pushing vocals and heavy rock sounds all come together to make something unique
4.5
Billy Joel meets Elton John. Super campy, no idea why the album cover is so metal. Good... not great.
Not sure how a bloke who never penned one word or note of his own music can be on this list. It was okay in parts, the last tracks rock n roll bits were quite fun but ruined by all the random interludes. Overall just feels like every rock cliché rolled into one album. 2 stars cos I did find myself bopping along a few times.
Es como si el soundtrack de guardianes de la galaxia y supernatural tuvieran un hijo
-mmmm interesting -very Dad music -I don’t hate it but wouldn’t listen to it again Liked: the end of You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth
One experience that was lost when we all started streaming music was going into a record store, flipping through the bins, and pulling out a record because it had an eye catching cover. Because look at this album cover! Conan the Barbarian exploding out of the ground in a creepy cemetery riding a Harley adorned with a horse skull! This is not at all the face-ripping Judas Priest soundalike you’d think from the art. Though to be fair, we’ve all known that for a long time. I have to admire the audacity here though. This album is completely ridiculous, over the top and dramatic, it seems like Meat Loaf is very aware of how ridiculous it is, and still he’s fully giving it. It’s theatre kid rock. It’s in bad taste, not because it’s offensive or anything like that, but just because it’s so schlocky. In the Standard Histories of Rock Music, the year this album was released, 1977, was the year that punk broke out, supposedly wiping all this stuff away. The sales figures of Bat Out of Hell alone paint a more realistic picture of what people were actually listening to.
Not my personal favorite, but this is classic anthemic 70s rock.
I can confidently say i’ll never listen to this album ever again
Yeah, not for me. Great production quality, and well rounded album though.
Oh, so dramatic! And so good. And so romantic, especially to some seventeen year olds. This was the time when ya listened to entire albums in one listen, and Bat Out Of Hell told a fun story. You didn’t get to see him on the album cover and there was no MTV yet, so no one really knew what he looked like for a few years. Meatloaf was the first musician that I’m aware of that didn’t care about the glamorous “Hollywood” image. The lyrics are poetry, there are some truly classic lines. Bat flits in at (4.49*s) Ain’t no doubt about it we were doubly blessed…
Michael (Marvin) "Meat Loaf" Lee Aday shot like a bat out of hell onto the stage with this debut. The writing brings the drama of teenage puberty and also makes it funny. Although there are many long play songs, they switch up and don't get tiresome. You actually want then to keep going. "Paradise by the Dashboard Light" is probably one of the best written songs about trying to get laid as a high schooler in the 70s. Putting "Heaven Can Wait" and "For Crying Out Loud" as lowest ranked tracks but don't necessarily need them cut. Epic performances by the Loaf and Foley throughout the album. I want to see a re-release of the live-action musical with Jack Black as lead. Meat Loaf is a legend, may he rest in peace...his name was Robert Paulson. 3.87 stars for rounding home base.
Meat Loaf's Bat Out Of Hell is such an endearing album. As a child the album cover of a motorcycle flying out of a graveyard with a huge bat gave me the sense it was going to be a dark, foreboding, hard rock album. Instead I was greeted with a collection of romantic ballads disguised as a rock album. Meat Loaf digs his heels in and belts out some cheeky teenage love songs with a wide variety of flair. The whole thing seems like a load of fun from Meat Loaf's sweaty vocals to the backing band solos (and accompanying vocals where they apply). It's loaded with puns, innuendos and references that make you think of high school days as a horned up teenager in all the best ways. It's a great collection of tracks from that finely walk the line between a variety of genres effectively. Not sure why it works so well but it does. While the vocals rightfully get the bulk of attention I found myself more and more drawn to the piano and backing accompaniment than on previous listens. I was previously unaware that Todd Rundgren and members of the E Street Band were involved but each of their contributions are good. Paradise By The Dashboard Light will remain one of the great anthems that I love but there's so much else on this album worth listening to. I have so much affection for this and was excited when I saw it on the list. I'd agree this is one you have to hear before you die. 3.92 stars
I meet meat loaf in Rocky Horror Picture Show (one of the greatest films ever made), it’s great to see his music in here, such a fun and campy album
ich dachte meat loaf wäre heavy metal😭, trotzdem sehr gut 80s rock, ich wusste dass ich 'paradise by the dashboard light' kenne, hmmm woher wohl, GLEE
I just found out that Bob from Fight Club actually has a secret life as a rock star. While my brain is trying its best to process this information, I can say that this album has a grand sound that mimics a rock spectacle. It has a lot of soul and it just sounds good. It doesn't rely on typical song structures and it does its own thing. One downside that stands out is that songs tend to drag a little, but overall it was a pleasant experience. My favorite tracks are the opening "Bat Out of Hell" which sets the tone perfectly and "Two Out of Three Ain't Bad".
I love a good rock opera. It's dramatic and cheesy, but a ton of fun to listen to. Mr Loaf puts 110% into every song and the energy is infectious. There are plenty of excellent over-the-top tracks but the ballads are pretty good too and the contrast helps to stop things feeling too boring by the end.
Oh, Meat Loaf made the cut?? Interesting. Admittedly, I only know him from his acting. Specifically from The Rocky Horror Picture Show and as Robert Paulson in Fight Club, one of my all time favorite movies. The dude could really act well. As a singer though, this is a little too silly, too light, and has way too much filler for my liking. The first song, “Bat Out of Hell” is pretty good. Not amazing, but he’s got a hell of a set of pipes on him and can hit those high notes spectacularly. It’s my favorite song on the album. Everything else is either a slow ballad that I don’t care for, or filler that just drags on for longer than I really want or need it to. “All Revved Up with No Place to Go” has a pretty neat sax solo that I thought was worth mentioning, I loved that. I still enjoyed this album, but I’ve got a lot of nitpicks with it and things that didn’t really vibe with me. It’s immensely theatrical and to that degree I conclude it must be a theater kids wet dream. I am not, nor have I ever been or ever will be a theater kid, so the charm doesn’t really register with me. It’s 46 minutes long, which is always a good length for an album, but I can only say I only really enjoyed a single song. Nothing was unbearable, but nothing was objectively great either to me. “Paradise by the Dashboard Light” is fine, it has moments of greatness, but it just goes on and on and I lose interest about halfway through. This album is fine, but I for sure won’t be returning to it. The few and far between moments when it’s over the top and fast paced, it’s also generally a bit repetitive and drags, but those are my favorite parts of the album. The rest is just a bunch of filler and heavily filled with lighter ballads that I just do not care for. I almost want to give this a 2, but in the rare moments it’s good, it’s more than worthy of a 3. We’ll call this one a 3.2 and move on to the next one. At the bare minimum, it was actually really cool to finally hear the late, great Meat Loaf sing. Now I can say truthfully and wholeheartedly that I preferred him much more as an actor and really mean that.
Not my typical style of music, but I just have too much sentimental value of listening to my parents play this all the time when I was young.
Overdramatic in a good way, but the songs really could have used some trimming down at times. I love long songs, but these don't feel like they really offer much new after the first few minutes. I love Meat Loaf's voice, though; it's powerful and sonerous.
Denne
Superb. Compulsory for any crazy rock n roll party
Helllllll yeah, theatrical, operatic, rock and roll
5/10, had fun moments, was definitely better with the wider variety of instruments, wished there was more saxophone. Some of the songs were very forgettable and felt like they dragged on a bit too much.
Did not expect to like this one as much as I did! Honestly was a banger, not sure it made a Meat Loaf fan out of me but was a very pleasant surprise
A little self indulgent for my taste but had some decent tracks. I will say I about bursted out laughing when he started “praying for the end of time.” Regretting my 3 out of 5 for the to british album. Definitely better than that one
Really enjoyed it
I enjoyed this album more than I thought I would. I think it's a bit silly and doesn't take itself too seriously, and the lyrics are pretty hilarious. Stuck between 3 and 4 but I'll default to 4
First meat loaf album who cheered. Ok devious piano. Is meat loaf a guy or a band. Is this like a tame impala situation. Interesting. Holy shit I don't gaf. Like I genuinely don't care. What the fuck is this. What are we doing. I actually don't like any of these. Mr. Loaf I'm not a fan. Somehow this is not what I thought Meat Loaf would sound like. Favourite: You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth Least favourite: You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth
Reminded me of Queen someone
LMAO
3.8
I'm not the biggest fan of this style of music, but it's undeniably very stylish and Meat Loaf is a terrific performer. Plenty of classics on here and, despite a few lengthy tracks, it's overall a pretty tight 45 minutes and a lot of fun if you're in the mood.
Genuinely didn't expect to love this album as much as I did. Maybe my mom does know ball.
It's impossible not to enjoy Bat Out Of Hell, honestly put it on and just TRY to deny it. Meat Loaf himself has a hell if a voice, and no wonder, he spent most of his career outside of Meat Loaf in Musical Theatre, delivering iconic and definitively versions of roles like Rocky in Rocky Horror. His pipes were made for the stage, and the 70s. Of course its cheesy, of course it's not "cool". But its fucking awesome fun, it's rock and roll, it pianos being absolutely battered. Its over the top and it's going to put a grin on your miserable little face. Get at it.
First and last track were great, rest kind of faded into background but that's probs more my fault
Did think meatloaf was a metal band so this was a bit of a surprise. This is quite theatrical, and I do recognise some of the songs already from my mum singing single lines from them lol 3
Eh. Not likely to relisten.
If this doesn't make you realize why punk rock exists, I don't know what will.
I happily let them get on with obsessing over this while my instinct helped me not to engage. Eventually I gave in and checked it out properly. My instinct had been right all along. Now I’m having to listen again, but this will be the last time. A well executed Springsteen/Elton parody pumped with musical theatre steroids and stripped of all semblance of nuance. There you go, summed up in under 20 words. I used to think “fair fucks to the guy for overcoming being a socially anxious fat lad” but it turned out in the end he was kind of a pos so I can return comfortably to my instinctual position.
Might just have been in the exact right mood but I can’t fault this, it kicked ass and I loved every second. Big and bold and fun and I want to see the futuristic Peter Pan musical it was supposedly developed from so bad.
LIKE A BAT OUT OF HELL I'LL BE GONE WHEN THE MORNINGS COMMESSSS (sick guitar solo). Is there any better album to yell along to at the top of your voice on a long car trip? Fucking banger. Have always loved this album and always will.
Energetic and fun
How can a meat loaf contain such obscene amounts of cheese
Rock musicals still very much not my thing but this one's not bad.
Very much enjoyed the whole way through
Nice album with awsome playing and nice theme through out.
Thought it was going to be more interesting than it was but out of songwriting, production and intrigue... two out of three ain't bad.
Despite the over-the-top, cheesy/corny/cringe, it's impossible not to love this album. A perfect masterpiece.
I can see why this is popular and considered to be great, but I don't like this album very much. It's just a musical with distorted guitars. I don't typically like musicals so this doesn't do much for me. That said, Meat Loaf is a vocal tour de force and the songwriting is good.
Utterly silly.
STILL a (mostly) perfect front to back barn burner
This album is a rollercoaster of emotions. There are periods that are like wow I kinda like this and then there are periods that are like wtf. The album starts off purely instrumental and it sounds good and then the vocals come and its like wow this feels like a theater kid. I thought that would ruin the album, but I got used to it. The songs are too long and drag on. You think its about to end but it keeps going and I wasn't a fan of that weird Disco transition that came in randomly for a bit. The songs are a bit overproduced, but they sound good and the instrumentals were the best part of the album for me.
Cheesy, campy, very 70s. Like a time capsule
phenomenal rock opera. the bat out of hell song is an absolute banger
I’m not a huge fan of meatloaf. I mean…it’s good…don’t get me wrong..it’s good music…he made good music.
No
Over-the-top, but thar’s exactly what they were after. There’s nothing else quite like this. Hard rock for theatre kids.
4/5. I was not familiar with Meat Loaf's work outside of "Paradise by the Dashboard Light" before this listen. It's a fantastic album, and anyone who enjoys lofty rock unafraid of bringing in influences from other genres will treasure it. Meat Loaf is an incredible singer throughout, the instrumentation is excellent, and the lyrics, although never unique or complex, are well done and delivered masterfully.
A band I’m aware of by name only. I’ve seen the musical Neverland so I was intrigued to read that this album was developed from it and later on had its own stage show as well. I’m sure this would be more enjoyable/interesting for me with additional context from a show; and sometimes musical soundtracks can stand completely on their own, but I’m surprised to hear about how well the album sold.
Great album, and artist. Died way too young. Hours listening to this album.
4.5/10
Oh this is such fun!! Gloriously OTT and somehow timeless. Cannot believe some reviewers on here are taking this seriously. Great songwriting, fantastic musicians and songs you want to bawl along to. What’s not to love about that?
I always subconsciously loathed any time I heard someone or mention to Meat Loaf. I have no good reason why, perhaps the name sounded pretentious? I don't really feel that way now after listening to Bat Out Of Hell. I hadn't heard any Meat Loaf song or him talking or anything in general except for "Paradise by the Dashboard Light" but I remember not liking it, too weird I suppose. I only remembered the song now when I got this album because of three things I remember from it, Meat Loaf song, duet with female vocalist and long song. The song on a re-listen was much better received by myself, for sure. Though I do wish the song was more like the first 3 minutes of the said song which is S-tier, but rest of the song is maybe a strong B. This album seemed to me very meticulously done. Just everything about it, every minute detail is exactly in the right place at the right time, just so WELL done. The album really gives off the impression that this is an album created by a perfectionist where every possible perfection was perfected. Hope I got the point across enough, but I really do feel that impression. (I don't mean well done as in I extremely like it, more like it was well thought-out.) The backstory of the album that I read on Wikipedia was a real trip and a half, just like the multi-part 8 minute songs featured here. Highlight Song/s: "You Took The Words Right From My Mouth (Hot Summer Night)" and "Paradise by the Dashboard Light"
favorite: You took the words right out of my mouth (hot summer night) "On a hot summer night would you offer your throat to the wolf with the red roses?" "Will he offer me his mouth?" "Yes" "Will he offer me his teeth?" "Yes" "Will he offer me his jaws?" "Yes" "Will he offer me his hunger?" "Yes" "Again, will he offer me his hunger?" "Yes" "and will he starve without me?" "Yes" "and does he love me?" "Yes" "Yes" "On a hot summer night would you offer your throat to the wolf with the red roses?" "Yes"
5/10 This is not a bad album, but it's really, really, really not my kind of music. Every song is twice as long as it should be; for as elaborate and over-the-top each song is, they're all pretty dull; and I just don't like it tbqh.
Meh
Some familiar tunes. Good vibe.
Not bad. I liked the piano rock elements, but I don’t think this was amazing as sales numbers would imply. 3.5/5
i mean this is a masterpiece. it doesnt do a ton for me but it's amazing.
What a voice! This one stands the test of time.
Part prog, part Springsteen, part Broadway spectacle... all cheese. So why do I love this album so much? I don't know if it's a "Great" album, but it's a ton of fun, and that's all that really matters to me... 5 stars all the way.
Paradise by the dashboard light is so fire
glee cover, songs too long
It's not my favorite but not the worst.
I know more about his guy as an actor than as a musician. Do the time warp robert Paulson. I guess I know paradise by the dashboard lights. And its a fine song. A bit too melodramatic if thats the word for it. Performative? And the rest is about the same. His voice is fine. The music is fine. The songwriting is fine. I will say that album cover is very sick. In a sort of dorky kinda way. I think its too ballad heavy for my tastes. At the end of the day its ok. About as middle of the road as you can get. I can see what others who love it might see but for me its just alright
20# ABBA if they we're rockin instead of poppin. You have an album cover that looks like the most metalcore metal has ever been and then give clapping session in a middle of a song, what? Um, this is not for me, no no. It's teatrical... feels fake, premeditaded, like too calculated, previsible. Don't throw this kind of rock ballads to me. I like teatrical in projects like Black Midi's Hellfire, i don't have the words to describe what they do right, but they hit it like a needle in my butt, wait what? And I don't like to be that guy, but the mixing..? flat, i like my drums not that faraway of my ear. Listening to this at full was hard, geez
His name was Robert Paulson.
Really fun, enjoyed the dramatic, almost operatic vibe.
Good album.
What is Rocky Horror Picture Show was just one guy and it rocked more? Bonus points: put that guy in Rocky Horror. This was real fun, I really enjoyed this listen. The duet especially was killer. Took me many years to get around to listening to any Meat Loaf and it was worth the wait, I'll have to check out more of his stuff.
It's been a very long time since I've heard this album, and it did bring back good memories. I kind of forgot how good it actually is. However, some songs are more memorable than others
It was fine
That was REALLY great. I love opera rock
Much more broadway musical-esque than I expected. Found myself dancing.
Not a musical fan, so I wasn't surprised to find out this was adapted from a musical. No thanks.
70s rock opera with incredibly cheesy lyrics, pass
I still think Meatloaf and John Kruk are the same person. Fun time!
What a great album. Cheesy and over the top in all the best ways. The energy on this album is off the charts. My father was a big Meatloaf guy, and I currently own his hand me down copy. It’s perfect in its ridiculousness…and that album cover 👀👀👀👀
With the help of Jim Steinman, Meatloaf has created a classic mixture of drama, rock and roll and humor
Amazing record. So theatrical. A 3,8 for me.
- Why is the title track so long, jeez - This is a very horny album that’s also profoundly unsexy, a bad combo - Wikipedia tells me many of the songs on this album were written for a musical, which tracks. I don’t think you should be legally allowed to have cover art of a dude riding a flying motorcycle out of hell in the middle of a graveyard, when the album itself is mostly melodramatic show tunes.
5/10
Fun, theatrical, and over the top
It feels too overdone for me. Admittedly, I think my opinion improved a bit when I read that this was developed from a musical, as that explains the direction of this to some degree. The songs are well composed. I might like them more presented in a different way, but I really wasn't into this particular hard rock production on some of the songs. I did like the second half much better than the first. The standouts for me were "Heaven Can Wait" and "For Crying Out Loud". 3/5 because I actually liked it towards the end.
Bombastic cheese. Mr. Loaf is treading water in a sea of retarded sexuality and bad poetry.
Quintessential 70s rock album. This album was meant to be listened to on the family record player or the 8 track player in your American muscle car. Every song is ridiculously long, but somehow it works. This album just makes me happy.
I honestly thought Meat Loaf was a nu metal artist (the name gives off the same vibe as Limp Bizkit and Korn to me) until last night, when I saw that some of the reviews referred to Bat out of Hell as "theater kid music." After listening to the album... I'd say that pretty much checks out. I definitely wasn't expecting music in the realm of Elton John and Queen, but the LP isn't a bad listen – maybe a bit bombastic, but the writing is solid and the theatrics sell the experience more than they hurt it. I found the title track to be particularly fun! That said, some of the slower ballads like "Heaven Can Wait" and "For Crying Out Loud" (the latter of which is nearly nine minutes long) didn't do much for me, which kinda dragged down the wider experience. How this became one of the best-selling albums ever is beyond my understanding. Highlights: Bat out of Hell, All Revved Up with No Place to Go, Paradise by the Dashboard Light
this was surprisingly decent but a bit overly theatrical especially the last couple of tracks
Great album
блять эти ебаные рок оперы с непонятной структурой, сраной пианинкой и все в таком духе. нахуя? не знаю. гитара и роцк там чисто фон
I can't tell if it's because my brain is a mush right now but this sounds so hilarious to me. unironically a good time