Reviews (page 8 of 16)
Much longer than I expected but loving the guitar
I think Pink Floyd is one of the best (if not THE) best bands ever and this album proves why. Amazing songs. No words needed, an easy 5*.
I've already listened to his album (1). Arguably Pink Floyd's best, but my personal favorite is Animals.
only 5 songs and super long Great music and contains one of my favorite songs, "Wish You Were Here", along with "Welcome to the Machine" and "Have a Cigar"
Starting to enjoy songs without much lyrics in them. Melodies can convey more than words can. Really funky beats and synth. Cool vibes.
Iconic. Title track is one of the best tunes ever written. Shine on you crazy diamond is a sprawling space epic and Pink Floyd at the ethereal best. Have a cigar and welcome to the machine are their digs at the music industry and, to be honest, are nowhere near as good as the other 3 (!) tracks on this album. Really hard to rate because when it’s good it’s untouchable but a couple of relative duds in an album of 5 tracks means it can only be a 4 star.
The ultimate headphones album.
I own it already. Shine on you crazy diamond is pink floyd's best song and david gilmours best solo. This is the best album with the wall a close second. Every song is superb and considering half of it is Shine on you crazy diamond, this could not be an easier 5 stars
No notes, banger
Even though I typically do not enjoy mainly instrumental music there is something special about the way Pink Floyd does it. Even after many times hearing it it’s still great to listen to.
I have had this on cassette, special edition CD, and vinyl. It is tied for first place with *Meddle* for the title of "Favorite Pink Floyd Album." I will never be upset about the opportunity to listen to it again.
5/5 no notes
Maybe not something I’d return to, other than the title track, but a good album.
I used to think I liked Pink Floyd, but I don't really enjoy them anymore. This album tried my patience. At least the cover is cool. Standout track: Wish You Were Here
Bueno, descubrí como 70 canciones más gracias al reproductor de spoty
Esa guitarra de shine on u crazy diamond… sexo!!!
Отлично
I’m now closer to death but no closer to the truth.
A very Melancholic album by Pink Floyd. It sucks you right in and takes you on a journey about missing a person. It captures those feelings very well and in my eyes the perfect place for solace. Though without any context of what this album is supposed to represent and the things they have been going through at the time of making, it makes it fall rather flat. Especially the two songs "Welcome to the machine" and "Have a cigar" are just okay on their own and mostly just shine because of the story behind them. If looked at for the sole purpose of being against the music industry, there are definitely better songs about that. So it makes sense that when this album came out it wasnt received all to well. Im mostly debating whether or not this is an album I really have to hear before I die. To me the only good reason to listen to this album is "wish you were here". It definitely carries the album but can perfectly exist on its own. Without it, the album would wish it was there..
Excellent album, especially the title track.
Best Song: Wish You Were Here Pink Floyd is one of my all time favorite bands so it is no secret that this album would be part of my rotation. There are now bad songs and nothing bad to say. An absolute masterpiece. 5/5.
The only to compete is Dark side of the Moon
Wish You Were Here' is my all time personal favourite. It was my first ever vinyl. It introduced me to Pink Floyd. It changed my views on music. It paved the way for my ever growing obsession. It is perfect from start to finish. With 'Wish You Were Here' Syd Barret got the most transcending, most otherworldy beautiful tribute any person on earth has ever received.
peak
One of the best albums of all time
I'm a long time PinkFloyd fan and am very familiar with this album already. It's a classic. The songs on this are amazing. And though it's easier to have no bad tunes when you have a lower number of songs, this album doesn't have any missteps. It's great from beginning to end. Personally, I've always liked the way they have bookended this album with Shine On You Crazy Diamond. In my opinion, none of it is as good as the three songs in between, though that's a super high bar, and it's always interesting to hear all of the different layers in those two halves of the song. As for those tracks in between: Welcome to the Machine is probably my favorite song on this album. It's far from a traditional rock track, no doubt, and the lyrics are very ominous. But I love how all of this comes together to paint a pretty dark picture. A great, great tune. Have a Cigar is more of a traditional rock song in some ways. Love the lyrics to this, especially the "by the way, which one's Pink" line. Even if they are brief in nature, still really well written. Wish You Were Here is quintessential Floyd. A great song that couldn't have come from any other band. This is what really strikes me about this album, is how well constructed it is. Frankly, I've always preferred David Gilmour as a singer to Roger Waters, though Waters is undoubtedly the better writer and the more meaningful stuff has come from when he was in the band. Wish You Were Here as an album is a great example of this. A 5 star album, no doubt. Amazing songs, powerful, great playing, and a complete album.
Wish you were here is a great song
Oh, by the way, which one's Pink? 10 stars
I listen to this album at least once a month.
Slaps. Just as good as the first time I heard it blowing smoke out of my window in hs. RIP Budster.
AMAZING!! Genuinely so besutiful, i didnt like wish u were here too mcuh but the rest was perfection, loves the instrumentals and guitar portions sm!!
Phenomenal album from one of the greatest bands of all time.
For two members of the band this is their favourite album. And they are right. It's my favourite too. Every track is not a personal story or about industry and fame. It's also a bit the emptiness of modern life and lost chances. Musically, this prog rock record is a lot simpler than other prog records with it's 4/4 and blues riffs. However, it all works so well together that we can stop this "Is PF prog or not?" discussion. Yes, they are.
pensé que no me iba a gustar porque tanta gente ama este álbum pero puta que es exquisito de escuchar
One of my favourite PF albums
8,7/10
This is amazing, what an album
Easy 5.
Classic album. One of Pink Floyd’s best.
5*
All the parts that involve singing are decent, all the pure acoustic parts just fly right by me.
First Listen: Feb 02 2023 METRO BOOMIN REFERENCE!?!?!?!?? i remember finding a bulk of this album very underwhelming. The first and last tracks were incredible, but overall its very overrated. there are many far better pink floyd albums it feels like a really good prog rock song interrupted by a 17 minute snoozefest. the middle is so overrated
2 I didn't care for that very much
Not my vibe
9.7/10
Really lovely trip
This is my favorite Pink Floyd album and I love them all. There has been too much spilled into for me to contribute anything new, except if you are not aware please look at the history of the band and the context in which it was made. Worth it
Not really my thing, i can appreciate the sound though - it’s not quite like anything else out there.
Top tier album as always by Pink Floyd
One of my favorite Pink Floyd albums
classic
Meh (2.5)
5.0/what a legendary project. i love this album so much. vinyl in collection.
I think the fact it has less tracks makes it easier for it to be a better record because of how compact it is but also more difficult to decide what the best part of it is. Just a really great sounding record all around packed with classics. I love it.
Each song gets lost along the way and they're amazing
Amazing
Pretty excellent. Wish I hadn't been overexposed to all the big moments before hearing them in context
A perfect album, not quite as good as DSotM in my opinion, but it's very close. Parts of Shine On was played at my friend's funeral, so I don't listen to this album as often as I used to. That's a shame though, because it was nice to think of him today. He died far too young, but squeezed a lot of living out of his 18 years. Some of my favourite guitar playing ever on this album as well. I'm starting to wonder if Gilmour is actually my favourite guitarist.
Brilliant from beginning to end.
This is the greatest album of all time. No debate. I need to buy the vinyl and give this another spin.
Pink Floyd is lame.
Fantastic, prog with beautiful melodies.
Not for me but sounded great
Like dark side of the moon, there are some great moments like “]Wish you were here” and the parts of “shine on you crazy diamond” where they’re not just jamming. Unfortunately for me most of the album feels like filler
Hippie space blues for your mind stadium. Absolutely based.
Hate the politics. The album is undeniable
Surprised how much I enjoyed this and the rating could easily become a 5 in time. Very cohesive
Really liked this! Surprised! Good old fashioned rock n roll.
THIS is my favorite Pink Floyd album. An absolute masterpiece that never gets old. It’s a journey every time I listen. Takes me back to my high school days getting stoned and chilling in my room staring at the glow in the dark stars all over my room. The guitar tones, synths, lyrics EVERYTHING about this record is perfection.
It’s so fucking rad, honestly
Absolute classic of an album, been a long time since I heard it and totally get why it changed people's whole lives and perspective on music. Game changer.
4.0 rym
All of you people giving this 5 stars need to give your head a good wobble I swear people just jump on the bandwagon and 5 star because its a "classic" This was background noise at best, and not even good noise 2 ⭐️
:(
iconic and creative blah blah blah. decent listen. self titled track wins once again.
DAMN THIS IS GOOD hold up I can tell why Ben likes this, 😮
pota
Already knew it was a 5, but will always slow down and take a moment to listen to this album when prompted.
Absolutely solid and an all-time great
No idea how this made the list some of the most bland dull music ever made.
The start of my love for Floyd.
this isn't a record in the sense of what the separation of tracks is literally. rather, it is one long composition telling a loose framework of events leading up to its creation. several things are happening in this album that pull the curtain for Pink Floyd as a group. its been done to death what they are talking about and what concepts are displayed. i personally like this more in theory than practice. earlier Pink Floyd with Syd is my style, and that era is a huge theme in this. when it comes to prog rock and ultimately the power of storytelling, this is the meta holy grail. besides the wall, (lol) this basically is the artists showing the audience the truth in a way that can't be censored or delineated by forces above them. without being too on the nose, they are saying that the music industry is not a magical place, but instead a slimy organization that causes individuals within it to make horrible, long lasting decisions. from start to end, you are sucked into the shoes of the band from humble beginnings to gigantic undefinable ends. of course on a technical level, this is probably the best that's ever been made. while seemingly short, its so concise that it never skips a beat, never lulls in silence unnecessarily. styles for the time are lightyears forward as what would be standard in rock for incorporating any influence necessary to tell the story that no one genre can. listening to this zaps you to a period in music where a portal is opened and you have this built in lore that goes with the record and follows the band on tour and adds to it with live experiences. it shatters the expectation of song length, adding debate to what is the best of time versus what goes on the radio. i have tried to be into this particular piece, and i do like all the sum of the parts, but its always been an album that friends and music heads talk about more than i listen to alone. 4/5 because of how relevant this is today. the title track hits home because it is famously about the previous singer, his decline, and the remorse felt after his absence. any musician will attest to this feeling.
Damn. Never heard this before. Just damn.
Not all Pink Floyd albums are brilliant. This one is.
i get so unbelievably happy when i get generated an album that I've already heard a million times before. Once in a lifetime band, once in a lifetime album. Nothing I can say will suffice, and there is nothing I could say that has not been said a million times before me.
I’m not sure I really got the concept of this one (something about the corruption of the music industry I think?), but liked it nonetheless. Wish you were here is an all time song.
Struggling to listen to this. It’s good, but there are events of my life associated with this band and. So I never listen to them. Never listened to the full first or last “shine on you crazy diamond”. Skipped “have a cigar”. I’ve heard that one a lot. I’ve always loved “wish you were here”. Listening again and I still love it. I hate admitting that I like this album. Some of the songs are really overplayed or were where I grew up. The second “shine on” to close the album is really great. I think I’m a third through it and I love it. Vocals just kicked on. No one sounds like Pink Floyd.
I've not listened to this one before, I love pink Floyd, this isn't my favourite but it's quite a nice album listened to altogether
2/4
-have a cigar
What a great album cover first thing, that needs extra points. Crazy Diamond is absolutely peak. I was joking about Born To Run having 8 songs but being 40 minutes long, this feels like it earns it by having a much better vibe. You can really fall into the music and get lost in it. Welcome to the Machine is the weakest point here but even then it's still a decent song.
It was fine. Actually enjoyed Pink Floyd.
Easy 5. Glorious and luxurious. Moody but my mood lifted in listening somehow
The best pink Floyd album for me
The second best Pink Floyd album for me
This was a happy reprieve after some of the stuff that we have had lately. A masterwork.
Absolute heavyweight entry. Nasty hooks together with the sort of English brooding that nobody does better than Pink Floyd.
Yes, sure.
Jumallevy. Tää on kuunneltu sata kertaa mutten ikinä tylsisty! 5/5
Kokonainen, letkeä ja ylipäätään hieno teos, vaikkakin poikkeaa hieman aiemmasta tuotannosta. 5/5
Enkelte partier blir litt langdryge, men på sitt beste er dette et mesterverk. Beste låt: Wish You Were Here
There is literally nothing I can say about this album that hasn't already been said.
one of the greatest
Peak absolute peak
I played the hell out of this album when I worked in radio years ago, and it's seared into my soul. That David Gilmour guitar hits those pockets like no other. What a record!
Musically great if you like this kind of thing, but it's almost just instrumental.
4.25
Overall: 10/10 Beautiful. I've always adored this album. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is an epic tribute to an old friend. Welcome to the Machine is electronic goodness. Have a Cigar is the hard rocker with probably my favourite bassline in any Pink Floyd song. Wish You Were Here is just one of the best songs ever written. This is definitely an album everyone should listen to before they die. Fav Song: Wish You Were Here Least Fav Song: Welcome to the Machine
One of the best albums of all time.
Among the best of the band, very few songs, but each and every one were very good in it's own way, the psychedelic waves at the beginning and the end, and the memorable songs in the middle. Very good record all around.
Great album!
Ha...easy.
Falls shy of the massively weird genius of "Dark Side," but follows that up admirably. Much better than the bloated, indulgence of "The Wall." "Welcome to the Machine" grates more than it needs to, but the rest works: "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" could be twice as long, and captures Floyd at its maximalist hypnotically harmonically melodically symphonically gorgeous best. "Have a Cigar" and the title track are both perfect, of course. It's too slight to merit 5 stars, but it's very good stuff - this isn't a one-great-album band.
Geita
wonderful, of course
Album 820 of 1089 Pink Floyd & Wish You Were Here (19756) Rating : 5 / 5 I came to this one later in my music listening life. My sisters had it when I was a kid, but I wasn’t supposed to mess with their albums—I'd just stare at the cover with the man on fire and wonder what kind of music was hiding inside. Now, I totally get why it’s always in the “greatest album of all time” conversations. This morning, 5 a.m., coffee and smoke on the porch—I wondered if it might feel too proggy for my mood. It wasn’t. It was a complete, emotional, sonic work of art from beginning to end. This one will certainly be in the discussion when I have to pick a final top album at the end of this.
Another top tier album. Almost a 5 but not quite there. All great songs though and will listen to again at some point in time. Have to be in the right mood to listen to it. 8.5/10 (4.25/5)
Amazing creativity and song writing, with such iconic songs/sounds.
One of my favourites. Shine on you crazy diamond is perfection
5song album?? 13.5min,7.5min,5min,5min,12min songs. Ridiculous! Still sounds excellent. Except for the 8min of car noise and whooshs at the end of the tracks
I admit to loving Pink Floyd, and I find this to be one of their best albums. There are great songs on here like “Wish You Were Here” and “Have A Cigar”, but what makes this record work is the atmosphere and resulting hypnotic vibe it creates. A mesmerizing and enthralling listening experience that was a seminal one as a young person and still hits home to this day.
Really enjoyed it, and I completely see why and how influential it was. Great instrumental and vocals but got a little boring towards the end
Rock + jazz this is probably one of the best albums there are I really like the line “did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in the cage” for how it challenges pacivity
one of the best
album so good i pissed myself
One of the greatest of all time
Shoulda done acid first
i’ve been in a massive slump for this project but i might as well write something about this. i’ve listened to this album a million times. wish you were here is one of my favorite songs ever. the whole album is just amazing pretty much. i don’t want to write all that much but man pink floyd was so fucking good. wish roger and dave liked each other more back then we could have even more bangers
Not my favourite Pink Floyd album but still very good. 4 stars or B+.
Excellent. Transcendent, deep, moving, and a must-listen for any rock n roll fan.
Really do.
their most iconic album
FOR CRYING OUT LOUD, ITS 5 STARS!
No review needed.
What an old favorite. Not much more can be said that hasn’t already. I think one of the first albums I ever bought as a kid when it first came out. Sitting in my room with the headphones on. What a trip.
5/5
Fire
Absolute masterpiece. The story and concert behind this is one of the best ever. All 5 songs are incredible. My second favorite from them 10/10 5*
9/10
Classic Brit Rock.
eh
Have you ever had a friend who thinks of themself as "an intellectual?" In reality their "intellectualism" is just their excuse to be pompous and ridiculous about mundane things or to embrace incredibly unpopular opinions. This album is that friend. I think it wanted to be an intellectual album. Instead, we got an album that takes itself way too seriously while having the overall plot/musical development of the average sea cucumber. What a pompous, unfortunate album.
what am I supposed to say. 5/5 like.. yeah
I'm just not a Pink Floyd fan, sue me
The style of yelling in welcome to the machine made me want to shove my ears into a woodchipper machine. If not for that it would’ve been a 4.
i liked this a lot! good reading music. wish you were here is great
Going somewhere but not totally succeeding. Bonus points for ambition though! 3.5
Not a big Floyd fan but if I was going to like a record it would be this one
♫ Listening to "Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 1-5" by Pink Floyd (Wish You Were Here, 1975) ♫
Kult! Avslappende å høre på, uten at det blir kjedelig. Tror det er mange lag å oppdage her ved fremtidige lytt. Noen partier blir i overkant lange og rare, men virker ekstremt gjennomført.
One of my favourites. Incredible
Dark Side may have the most memorable songs, The Wall may have the most memorable story, but I think this is Pink Floyd's best album. The songs are long and slow but they never meander and always feel like thy have purpose. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is a psychedelic adventure that bookends everything but Welcome to the Machine, Have A Cigar, and the title track all stand alone as well. Gilmour and Waters obviously have hated each other for 4 decades (and Waters has gone to the loony bin himself) but I'm grateful we got 4 classic albums out of them over 7 years.
Wow
Peak
Fine album.
One of the all time greats and a personal long time favorite
1 star per song
Wish You Were Beer
Goes down like a breeze, great album that deals with what they were at the moment(top rock band with Have a Cigar and Welcome to The Machine) and who they used to be with Syd Barrett (Shine on You Crazy Diamond and Wish You Were Here)
S+ tier music, solid gold from start to finish. wish you were here is the weakest song and it's a great song.
I have the records, I have the posters, I have the cigar. They don't tell you how small the man on fire is in the sea of white on the record.
10/10 Which one’s Pink?
Classic Pink Floyd
An album in a world of songs put back to back on a list. An arc of music in a world of squiggly lines. It’s magnificent, still. And the title track is one of the greatest songs of all time. Prog rock artists that remembered to write songs made albums that stand above the rest. It’s such a joy to go back to this album, as I often do.
Welcome to the Machine is one of the best songs ever written
One of my favorite band and on top of that, two of my favorite tunes on a great album.
The shine on you’s en wish you were here geweldig. De 2 andere nummers niet zo. Eigenlijk 3.5 maar Wish You Were Here maakt dat het dan toch een 4 is
Great album, one the best.
Long tracks, alot of music and not alot of vocals. I like their sound. I need to listen to them more.
The title track 🔥
Shine on 1&2 and Wish you were here are otherworldly, but listening to this front to back as an adult just doesn’t hit the same way as when I was 13. If I could do half stars we’d be at 3.5/5
Enjoyable. Won’t seek this out on my own, but wouldn’t hate to listen to it again.
Simply Iconic. This album captivates you from the moment you dulg into it by playing shine on you crazy diomand. Every track amplifies the experience, and I found nothing lacking in any aspect in the album.
Spectacular band.
It was okay. I'm not going out to buy it, but if someone put it on I'd listen. I think the biggest problem was that the songs felt like they lacked structure. It just felt like some really good musicians noodling around on their instruments.
Typically throughout this list l, I’ve not enjoyed “Psychedelic Rock” and I’ve never been a big Pink Floyd fan. Some of their songs are okay. I found this album intriguing though. Maybe it finally clicked? It’s definitely a “sink into the couch” kind of album, but there’s something about this particular Pink Floyd album that got me. I think it was the intricacies of the instruments.
First duplicate band. I enjoyed it quite a bit, but I wouldn't relisten.
Solid 4.5, classic album, wish it went out a little bit more absolutely though
An easy 5
mate, its wish you were here. the best pink floyd album.
Before University gave me much better things to do on a late Friday night, I was a Friday Rock Show regular (God bless Tommy Vance). Shine On You Crazy Diamond was a fixture in the annual Top 10. And deservedly so. I have heard most of the tracks on WYWH over the years but have never listened to the album end to end. “Shine On” is a masterpiece. It’s a track that feels far shorter than its actual length. I wasn’t sure about reprising it at the end of the album. I thought it was lazy. But on subsequent listens, I appreciate the bookend. Of the other 3 tracks there’s no weakness, though it does seem odd to have Roy Harper singing on Cigar - but it works. Of the Pink Floyd albums I know (this, The Wall and Dark Side Of The Moon), this is my favourite.
i like it!
3,9/5
One of those albums you sent to aliens because it is so good. I won’t hesitate to give this to anyone that wants to expand their tasting music.
A classic and a favorite.
My favourite pink Floyd album
One of my favourite Pink Floyd albums.
A masterpiece and not even my favorite album by Pink Floyd.
Welcome to the machine och Have a cigar öppnade mina öron på ett sätt som få låtar nånsin gjort när jag hörde dem under tonåren men resten av albumet har växt på senare år och alla fem låtar är bland dom bästa låtar som gorts. Tror inte det finns ett enda album med högre lägstagrad än detta. Det enda negativa är att albumomslaget är lite tråkigt, annars total perfektion från början till slut.
Gillade mer än förraa gången jag lyssnade! Titelspåret är 5/5.
All time great
Very vibey, felt like I should be high
5 sterne
Perfect
43 minutes for 5 songs is quite a length. Lots of hype around Pink Floyd I've heard some of their stuff before including the titular track, but never listened to this whole album. First part of Shine On is kinda haunting. Welcome to the Machine is interesting and experimental. Have a Cigar is great. Weirdly, the well known title track is probably the weakest song on the album for me. Overall, an excellent listen.
Just not my thing
This album is one of my favorites!!
Заслушанный до дыр.
Like the vibes and instrumental Fav song - Welcome To The Machine 4/5
One of those really classic albums I just never listened to. It was pretty good. Glad I finally heard it but also who cares.
I was obsessed with this album around 1994. Music like this just doesn’t exist anymore. In my top10 all time
LOVE IT. know that isn’t too surprising but first time I’ve actually properly listened to them. Maybe helped by just waking up, having the headphones in and going on a proper journey through all the soundscapes and many, MANY layers to each song. SUCH great production. Enjoyed ‘wish you were here’ the song, but actually my least favourite on the album, which was surprising. Great bookends in the intro and outro too. Great album in so many ways. Excited for the next PF albums on the list now.
Top Three Songs: 1) Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts 1-5 2) Wish You Were Here 3) Have A Cigar Bottom Three Songs: 1) Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts 6-9 2) Welcome To The Machine 3) Have A Cigar
This is awesome. I like The Wall even better, but this is great as well.
This album makes me understand why pot was such a big deal in the 70s.
Kom igen, get aload of This guy
Uno de los mejores álbumes de la historia.
I DISTINCTLY remember hearing this album for the very first time... heck, it was Pink Floyd... so you KNEW to take that precious record to your room... put it on the stereo... get your headphones on, and spark up your... um... relaxation method of choice... ahem... and as the kids say, "get into it"... if you are not of a certain age... if you are not used to being ENGULFED by a sonic piece of ARTWORK... the beginning of this record will hit you differently, but to me... it was the ULTIMATE way a record should start... "Shine On You Crazy Diamond"... is a masterpiece in and of itself... from it's opening strains... to when the whole band kicks in... it's like when "The Wizard of Oz" turns technicolor... The Drums... the arrangement... everything... BEAUTIFUL... PERFECTION... and when you think, how can this get any better... "Welcome to The Machine"... wow... EPIC piece... number two... and then... "Have a Cigar" sung by Roy Harper... they say Roger couldn't sing it, and David turned it down... turned it down??? lol... whoa... anyway... all three songs to begin the record were tape measure HOMERUNS... and then you heard the beginning acoustic guitar part of... "Wish You Were Here"... one of the greatest songs of my lifetime... and you knew Roger meant Syd Barrett... the crazy diamond, himself... poignant... beautiful... and then close with "Shine On..." as a reprise/curtain closer... an absolute breathtaking piece of art... Five stars... six if it were allowed.
I guess I'm a Pink Floyd fan now. This is why I started going through this list for. I found a masterpiece that I had never heard before. The only bad thing I can say is that I liked Welcome to the Machine a bit less than the rest of the album.
Having now listened to this and the wall i assume they felt one decent track was sufficient to justify an album and then then name it after that song. This album could and should have been a single with s shortened version of track 5 as the b-side. Overblown pretentious crap
My biggest problem with this album is that it feels like hard work to get to the good stuff - and this has some good stuff (compared to The Wall, which I heard earlier in the project, and was utter tripe beyond the title track). It just doesn’t really feel like it was worth the effort, which takes all the shine (ahem) off of it.
"The album begins with a long instrumental preamble" says Wikipedia and it was accompanied by a long sigh from me. Pink Floyd are a band where I really love parts of songs (the actual lyrical part of Shine On You Crazy Diamond is great*) but you have to wade through so much noodling to get to the good bits. I could have also done without the parts that made it sound like my headphones were broken. I like the majority of the title track though. * I absolutely accept this might be down to nostalgia - both parents loved that song, and Pink Floyd in general, so I heard it a lot as a kid. I enjoyed this more than The Wall, so I'm going for a 3, even though I think it's technically a 2.5. 3/5
One (maybe one and a half) good songs strung out into a whole album … yawn
All time God tier masterpiece
Masterpiece - nothing less🤌
3.5 I’m not a Pink Floyd guy, never have been, not one of my classic bands. This is the first album of theirs I’ve listened to all the way through. Also crazy it took over halfway through this project to get my first album of theirs. I know they show up multiple times on this list. I really liked the middle three songs. I found Crazy Diamond a bit indulgent, and that’s over half the album, so! But production is amazing and practically perfect. I definitely see why this is people’s favorite band of all time.
Loses one star for wankery self indulgence but there's some genuinely inspired guitar playing and very cool song structures.
The GOAT
all time classic
Trying to get through this backlog and I do not need this depressing shit right now! But it was mostly pretty good. Did not enjoy as much as The Wall, but enjoyed more than The Rainbow Triangle One.
Synth rock. Just really don’t like this type of psych rock. One more star for the title track, which is wonderful.
I do wish the tracks were shorter, but that's prog for you, eh. Obviously good, not sure if I'll save any cos they're long, but I liked it.
Another top 10 prog classic…
I don’t think I’ve ever listened to this album during the day before, and certainly never just with tea and biscuits to imbibe. I still really enjoyed it though. So that’s good.
Off the cuff remark: Hated self-indulgent, bombastic splurge of Floyd when I was, ahem, younger. Old dads hippy nonsense. As an old Dad it holds a little more interest and certainly recognise influence on other stuff I like much more, but... Standout Track: Wish Yo Were Here Revisit?: probably not.
Opmerkingen niet nodig.
Legendarisch.
Peak Pink Floyd sans the concept. Five (well, technically four) killer tracks.
One of my favorites. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is a masterpiece.
Not bad, 3/5. Didn't like two of the songs.
Legendary
fairly decent!
Ok
Definitely one of my favorite albums of all time.
It takes me places every time
Found this strangely melancholy and menacing at the same time. Ot really felt like an opera, no one track stood out (well except maybe the eponymous track) you had to listen to it as a whole. I own both the Wall and Dark side of the moon, but this was different,more subtle, more wounded. It's almost operatic. “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” is broken into two long bookending parts that frame the whole thing, like the overture and finale of an opera. The middle tracks — “Welcome to the Machine,” “Have a Cigar,” and “Wish You Were Here” — are like dramatic arias or scenes, each adding layers to the themes of disillusionment, exploitation, and loss. Loved it.
One of my all time favs, prolly favorite pink floyd album
A classic! Better than Dark Side or the Wall, but not as good as others.
One of the greatest. All top class sounds. Pure brilliance. May even be better than Dark Side in some ways, although I'll always love that more. They really are the finest prog rock stars of all time
A perfect mix of aching heartbreak and seething anger make this superb album a must listen. This is gorgeous, visceral and achingly sad which is best suited to listen with headphones late at night. Just magnificent!
thought pink floyd was kind of boring but i liked this a lot!
While this isn't my favorite Pink Floyd record (that would be Animals, criminal that's not on the list), its still damn near flawless, and one of the greatest albums of all time. At one point in my life, Wish You Were Here was my favorite song of all time, and the lyric "We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl, year after year" is easily my favorite lyric of all time. Never fails to get me to tear up. The psychedelic prog epics of Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts 1-5 and 6-9 are masterful, and never feel indulgent, masturbatory, or like a Frankenstein's monster of different songs like a lot of prog does (Yes, Genesis, Dream Theater - but to be honest, Pink Floyd has never "felt" like stereotypical prog. Their music, even at the longest run times always felt focused. Perhaps its the psychedelic aspect shining through). Welcome to the Machine is one of the best The Wall songs (Hey You is the only track on that album that matches the quality of Welcome to the Machine), and its not on that record. I've never been a fan of The Wall, and I'll get to that when the project throws it my way, but Wish You Were Here is the record The Wall wishes it was. Focused, concise, whole tracklist of bangers. Have a Cigar is the only track on this record that I think doesn't rise up to the same level as the rest of the track list, it's got some of the style of The Wall that I don't care too much for, but its still a great song. Overall, masterpiece of a record.
jeden z lepszych kawałkow shine
Perfect
My least favorite Floyd album
Epic landscape, Ennio Morricone style motif, keyboards sounding like horns. There’s sadness, anger and loss in the lyrics before the sax solo brings the love. The last few bars then become corporate and dark sounds begin. Welcome to the Machine… Country blues guitar herald Roy Harper in a big Stetson singing in American accent, Have a Cigar. Title track is angry and spikey. Shine parts 6-9 doesn’t quite echo the majesty of the opening. Brilliant nonetheless.
Fell asleep until Have a Cigar then went back to sleep after, like other Pink Floyd albums much better
One of the greatest in all universe and every universe.
Clasic
I love this album
4.5
Who doesn't love Pink Floyd?
Completely perfect
Classic Album
very nice experience, great instrumentals. i’m between a 4.5 and a 5 but i’m picking 5 stars.
It’s a classic. Pretty much perfect start to finish. Not much I need to add
Perfect listening. Made me cry for obvious reasons
No words - just Collin...Wish You Were Here. Thanks for sending this to us today. You're always with us.
Everything you encounter is so lush; amazing sounds, masterful recordings, and that plate reverb softening and blending it all; tracks crafted so meticulously into this luxurious whole; delivered with perfect calm and patience. It rambles and it wanders and it gets lost and found and in the end its just this indulgent sonic experience that never gets old.
One of my favorites albums
Damn. Masterpiece - Front to back. The 2nd of four consecutive 5 ⭐️ albums from Pink Floyd. All 4 are in the top 100 all-time. 🔥🔥
Classic. So good. Could play this forever. Studied them in college so some nostalgia hitting here probably.
3.5 stars: I really like what it stands for conceptually and contextually, but another album I wouldn't just put on to listen to again.
David Gilmour has absolutely mastered the emotional pull of his soundscape. This richly gorgeous and funky album is no exception. I love pretty much everything he does. The rest of Pink Floyd can come too.
It's a nice listen. For some reason, I sort of didn't want to like it - some kind of prejudice against the idea of Pink Floyd and how they come across - but it's a really nice sounding piece of art.
10/10
Ganska bra men betydligt svagare än Dark side of the moon och The Wall.
One of the all time great rock records, the production is amazing, Gilmour's guitar work is fantastic. A conceptual album that really needs to be listened front to back to appreciate
Their funkiest, proggiest, and most beautiful work — all on one 44-minute LP. Pure magic.
Tremendously good. Great guitar work, light and airy, lots of room in the music for each instrument.
A true classic that stands the test of time. This is an album that I will definitely listen to again!
Masterpiece
Shine On should have been its own album. The other three songs on this album are just filler.
Brilliant but boring, across the album and even within tracks. Title track is wonderful, but even that is flawed, I never liked the keyboards towards the end. And why two variations of such a long track to open and close the album? Not their best, too proggy. Punk was a welcome reaction to stuff like this.
I do love the title track, and parts of the lengthy opener were great, but this one does feel slightly self obsessed and anti-listener compared to some of their better albums.
Mostly sensational but just begins to lose my interest in a couple of places.
Favourite songs: Wish You Were Here, Have a Cigar, Shine on you crazy diamond (pts, 1-9)
I felt the "Crazy Diamond" guitar solos ran long, but the songs in between are all just first tier Floyd...
really good rock album. there's definitely a story here but im not sure what loving the instrumentals as always
Very cool album
Hadn’t listened to this from start to finish for many years, and it was such a treat to spend time with it again. No songs skipped, even after multiple listens in one day I was hearing new things.
Beautiful album, will defiantly listen again
Another classic Floyd album
Pink Floyd is iconic. They're objectively a good band. I thought this album was fine.
Niti je ovo najbolji prog album ikad niti su oni najbolji prog bend ikad ali je ovo izuzetna muzika.
Love it. Long time favorite. Perfect.
I mean, it's Pink Floyd.
Just a fantastic album with so many incredible riffs and solos and moments. Pure mood. A scary dream.
One of the greatest albums of all time, and this isn't even my favorite Pink Floyd record. Goes to show what an incredible band they were.
My all time favorite Floyd album. Incredible headphone album with great instrumentation, meditations on grief and loss, and a farewell to Syd Barrett. "Oh by the way, which one's Pink?"
Favorite pink Floyd and not even really close. Five stars for five masterful, cohesive, terrific songs
Slightly overrated, but ultimately a journey with some truly beautiful songs
Peak Floyd
3.5
Being the most turgid Pink Floyd album is an achievement unto itself.
This was the first time in several decades I have listened to Wish You Were Here, an album that was foundational to high-school me. Yet while the odes to erstwhile bandleader Syd Barrett are poignant — the song "Wish You Were Here" is a classic — this has never been one of my favorite Floyd releases. To me, it marks the point where Roger Waters’ various obsessions and unresolved manias began eclipsing the band and he exerted an increasingly heavy hand over Pink Floyd’s musical and lyrical direction. Things from here would get increasingly heavy, and less fun, conceptually. Musically, I also feel like WYWH personifies the mid-70s rock bloat, with lethargic tempos, fat synths and a reliance on studio wizardry over songcraft. It's kind of a depressing listen.
Had never listened to this album before. It sure gets noodly!
First, it's a shame that in the cd/streaming era, listeners won't see the amazing sleeve photos from this LP. About the music: while I know how they are related, I always had a problem balancing the heartfelt tributes to their broken former band mate ("shine on you crazy diamond" and "wish you were here") with two largely throwaway songs about how the music industry is full of vapid cheats. This was always the gamble with PF albums: if you dont like a song, you're stuck with it for 7 to 22 minutes. I like 3 of the 5 songs here and actively dislike the other 2, so how to rate this? Three it is!
I suppose my favorite Pink Floyd album. Not sure what else to say about it.