Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd

Wish You Were Here

Pink Floyd

4.3
Rating
31898
Votes
1
1%
2
4%
3
13%
4
27%
5
55%
Distribution

Reviews (page 10 of 16)

Great album. I knew the title track before but I hadn’t sat down to listen to this album. Needs more listens but a great introduction to Pink Floyd (if necessary).

One of the greatest albums of all time

You can see a lot of studio work on this album where everything seems to come together at the right time and well in tune. This is a tribute to Syd Barrett. Each song on this album manages to transform into a pure and sad portrait of longing.

wanna eat this album

Wish it was better.

i wish you weren't

really long songs. Lots of cool instruments, its like songs for staring at the ceiling at night thinking of how cringe was what you said at middle school that one time. I love the guitar in Have a Cigar, its so melancholic.

Better than i expexcted 3.5 to 4 stars good background music rock album

Have not really listened to much Pink Floyd as had previously dismissed as wanky toss when i was in my punk phase and never really revisited this opinion. Roll forward 30 years or so and its much more up street and very much enjoyed large parts of the album - unfortunately there are some wanky bits like the sax solo - but still happy to give it a solid 4.

Wish You Were Here Pink Floyd are on the list of ‘Bands I really must get into someday’. Today (and yesterday) is that day. Obviously I’ve heard a lot of Pink Floyd songs in the ether and I know many of their songs by cultural osmosis, but listening to this on repeat I can see why people love them, and how people might think that listening to it stoned out of their minds at 3am might give them ‘the answer’. I don’t know what that question is that might lead to a drug fuelled psychic awakening, but this does answer my question of ‘What’s a Pink Floyd album like?’. Listening to this it’s a meticulously built 44 minutes of brilliantly layered, slow tempo sonic atmosphere, movingly structured around a loose concept. Although there are distinct songs it’s really about experiencing the whole thing, the feel and movement of the full run time, with synths, solos, melodies all unfolding at a languid pace, all with an occasional disquieting undertow. The solo on Have a Cigar is particularly good. I don’t know if this is prog rock, I suppose in a way it is, but it’s far richer and far better than the Yes and ELP albums we’ve had. It may share the same seriousness, but it never crosses into unintentional pompousness or silliness, it feels self contained and self possessed in a way those other albums don’t. Having never listened to a Pink Floyd album before, but having been keen to give them a listen I’m glad this lived up to expectations - perhaps today (and yesterday) were supposed to be the day I liked it, the psychedelic mystery of Pink Floyd was fated to reveal itself on this very day (and yesterday). 💎💎💎💎💎 Playlist submission: Shine on You Crazy Diamond (all IX parts)

Despite the album being languorous, indulgent, bloated, there is such a commitment to it - something completely imperious about this album. I don't think it has the warmth of Dark Side - it feels a lot more clinical. But there is an ambience to be enjoyed, and you can cast aside the pretension of a song in 9 parts. An album which conjures a mood and does it really well. And included one of the greatest tracks of all time, in the title track. It's so close, but it gets to a high four.

who is pink ???

This is my favorite Pink Floyd right now. I listen to it every day as I row. As dark as they are (and it is), I feel so much joy when I listen to it.

Top Floyd album for me.

I don't have to listen to this , this album is the soundtrack to my life.

Amazing album! Only five songs, half of which are a multi-part tribute to Syd Barrett. To top it off there's Welcome to the Machine and Have a Cigar. "By the way, which one's Pink?" This and Dark Side of the Moon are probably as close to perfect Pink Floyd as you can get.

Veldig, veldig bra. Det meste sier vel seg selv. Kreativ og eksperimentell musikalsk stil, med fornuftig mengde saksofonsolo og gitarsolo. Mer sofistikerte tekster og tema enn Dark Side of the Moon, men kanskje litt vel ordfattig til tider. Noe misfornøyd over at de antatt improviserte delene på Shine on You Crazy Diamond er litt vel repetitive. De kan finne andre ideer. 9.1/10

To my mind, this pales in comparison to The Dark Side of the Moon, but still a great album.

Wasn't bad but not Pink Flloyd's best....

Enjoyable - wasn't as bad as I thought it was going to be. I think you need to be in a nothing mood to listen to it. Not a stand out - was excited when I saw the Band, left a little "meh"

Masterpiece. Enough said.

Very good

First recommend album, funny as it’s one of my favorite albums already

Love this album.

Classic album. Not my favorite (that would be Piper at the Gates of Dawn) but its still worthy of 5 stars.

Pretty solid if you’re in the mood for it, which I wasn’t necessarily but I can see why people like it.

My favorite Pink Floyd album. Scathing commentary on the record business. The best lyric on the album -- "By the way, which one's Pink?"

What an epic suite and touching tribute to a fallen friend. The whole thing was great. David Gilmours guitar solos and Richard Wrights keys parts were out of this world. “Have a Cigar” is absolutely chilling, and the title track hits differently in the context of the full album.

First of all, I really don't know how this stacks up against other Pink Floyd albums, as I think Dark side of the moon, animals and this are the best, but none really stick out as the best out of the 3. I thought before listening that this was my clear favorite, but I'm really not so sure now. The long songs at the start and end if counted as one (or maybe even if not) could possibly be one of my favorite songs (let alone Pink Floyd). Conceptually as well, while not being as frontal as Dark side of the moon, still works out really well. However, I do think that some of the synth elements are a bit too much, or too overpowering, like on the second song and generally I think they are done better on dark side of the moon. I do also think that the title song is a little bit overrated. Favorite songs: all of them except the welcome to the machine. Score could easily be a subject to change, as I might totally rethink upon hearing another Pink Floyd album for perspective but... Overall around 9/10

Frickin perfection. Ventures into every style you could imagine flawlessly and at full speed. Naturally SOYCD are the standout tracks, but the middle stuff it also perfection. Damn. Fav Songs: All of em

Floyd doesn't produce songs, they make albums that are a whole experience and just the songs never sound right without that context as amazing as they are. Making albums like this is a lost art.

Pretty good on a distracted first pass! The shine on first section was brilliant, second section less so (though I enjoyed the fade), title track was nice. Already knew the lore and was a nice tribute. Will relisten with full attention in the future

Wish You Were Here feels less like an album and more like a shared silence with weight behind it. From the opening mechanical churn into “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” it immediately establishes a sense of absence, loss, and quiet grief that never fully lifts. Nothing here is rushed or showy. Every note feels considered, patient, and heavy with meaning, as if the band is choosing restraint because anything more would cheapen what they are trying to say. What makes it hit so hard is how personal it feels without ever spelling everything out. The themes of disconnection, exploitation, and mourning seep into the music naturally, carried by slow builds, spacious arrangements, and melodies that ache rather than soar. David Gilmour’s guitar speaks in long, mournful sentences, and the band leaves enormous gaps where emotion is allowed to breathe. Even the title track, simple on the surface, lands with devastating clarity because of its honesty and lack of sentimentality. By the time it ends, Wish You Were Here leaves you sitting in the aftermath rather than offering closure. It does not resolve its sadness, it honours it. That is what makes it so powerful and endlessly replayable. This is music made with empathy, patience, and deep understanding of loss, both personal and artistic. Five out of five feels inadequate, because this is one of those rare records that goes beyond rating systems altogether.

Pink Floyd's second best. Close to their best, but not their best. Second best if you must. This album's incredible. Opening up the first track, you get a fade-in, which I feel like I so underappreciated because they're one of the best ways to start an album. Then, the guitar is introduced. The notes are a bit all over the place but they still manage to be somehow pretty memorable. It's kind of pretty. Then, the iconic riff comes in. It's so empty, like something's missing, like you're speaking to a ghost and it's saying something you can't understand. Then the beat comes in makes it weirdly upbeat. It's not happy, though, it's more mysterious. The riff even changes every now and then to even more ominous notes. Then, ANOTHER guitar starts a solo, and it flows so well with everything else happening. It's also kind of mysterious, like you're looking for something, but then it goes fucking off. Kind of frustrated, kind of like you're searching for something, or someone. Quickly, things calm down and the beat, bass, and guitar loop a basic instrumental while a synthesizer gives a spooky yet empty melody. And that's exactly what that part is: empty. And then, boom fucking guitar solo again. It has the same sort of mysterious vibe to it. It's weird, like, you can bob your head to it but then if you really pay attention, it's kind of horrifying. Then, the vocals come in. I will admit, the vocals are a little bit lackluster, at least the impact of them is. When the "SHINE ON YOU CRAAAAAAZY DIIIIIIAMOND" part happens, it sounds like it's trying to be reminiscent of the Us and Them but it feels a little empty. Not in the way I've been talking about it either, just weirdly empty. I do want to give massive props to the lyricism here though because they're fucking gorgeous: "You were caught in the crossfire of childhood and stardom Blown on the steel breeze Come on, you target for faraway laughter Come on, you stranger, you legend, you martyr And shine" They're simple and there's not many layers besides that second line, but it works. It's not supposed to connect with everyone, it is about who the song was written about and that's it. I also really like "Well, you wore out your welcome with random precision." I could give a couple of other examples, but that'd go on for too long and not really add anything. I'm not the greatest fan of the saxophone part at the end. I usually like when Pink Floyd adds a saxophone to their song if it fits well, but here I fear it just doesn't. I guess the first part is fine, but--and I may be wrong-- I believe they switch types of saxophones a bit through the solo. I think it either changes from a tenor to an alto or a bari to a tenor. I don't know for sure though, I'm no expert about saxophones, it's not like I play the instrument. Actually, I do play the instrument, it's like right behind me, but that's besides the point. The guitar and the synthesizers are sick as hell on Welcome to the Machine; goosebumps. Not really, people who say they get goosebumps from music are kind of stupid, but you get what I mean. I guess the vocals are a bit out of range to the point where it would probably hurt at least a little bit, and the lyrics are definitely layered but not the best layers I guess. Like sucking on a monkey brain-flavored lollipop so you can get to the gum in the middle. Not really worth it. "What did you dream? It's alright, we told you what to dream." Sure, maybe my meaning would be a little more vague, but I could definitely write something like that and then look back at it as "pretty mediocre." There are some good bits, and I like the storytelling but they aren't nearly as good as some of the other lines on the album. The instrumental part after the first verse, which I think also happens after the second one (update: it doesn't), where everything is building and building is just absolutely fucking crazy. It feels something like you're quickly trying to escape something extremely dangerous, or meeting up with an evil you slowly realize is dangerous. Have a Cigar is a masterpiece in its field because of how goofy, yet extremely biting it is. The synths introduced harmonizing with the guitar is catchy but changes things up every now and then, which fits the "fuck the industry" idea. Try singing this song how you imagine the character singing this song would sing it. Did you sing in a lower voice than your usual voice? Did you sing like your alcoholic uncle talking about his fourth wife that divorced him and smoking a ciggie around a campfire? Now listen to the song. Boom, it's just that. The vocals are exact, almost too perfectly fitting that it sounds like a mockery. And the lyrics are fantastic too, they're so over-the-top, you can tell they're mocking the industry rather than sympathizing with it without even thinking. Like I never thought someone could think otherwise until I wrote that sentence. Of course, I have to give a nod to one of the all-time greats: "The band is just fantastic, that is really what I think Oh, by the way, which one's Pink?" Now comes easily the best song on the album and what's a good contender for best song in the Pink Floyd catalogue (Dogs and Great Gig in the Sky are other good choices) and what's even a good contender for best song ever. Which, funny story: when I first listened to this album, that was my third time listening to this song. And I still couldn't find the appeal. I wasn't a Pink Floyd fan on the first listen, which makes sense, but the second time, I enjoyed most of their music and the third, I was basically becoming a fan. Reason why: the melody. It's gotten trapped in my mind a couple times since but it's very much not a "catchy" melody. It goes all over the place, up down down up down up down down blah blah blah, and it adds to the rawness. The instrumental is detailed so perfectly, the piano plays at the perfect time, the guitar and the snare fit perfectly hand-in-hand, everything about the instrumental is genuinely perfect. The lyricism is top-notch too. You know, I made a Reddit post trying to figure out the lyrics to Wish You Were Here once. Okay I copied what I said and put it on a Doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/118W_jHs0RHheZiCZn7P4zLEDGffiMCG2d-BB8gOttOE/edit?usp=sharing Back to the lyrics. They're fucking fabulous. Dense, textured, yummy. "Did they get you to trade your heroes for ghosts?" is a good example of a 10/10 which is insane considering it's nowhere near the best lyric on the song. Argument can be made over what the best lyric on the song is, but personally for me, it's easily the first line of the chorus: "How I wish, how I wish you were here." It's direct, but it's raw. It's heartbreaking. It makes you think of someone YOU miss. It makes you remember things, it makes you regret things, and it makes you bawl your eyes for hours in the corner by yourself. Then, of course, the rest of the chorus is beautifully crafted lyrically as well. Each line on that part is just so fucking gorgeous that I can't do it the justice it deserves, so just go read them if you haven't already. And read them thoughtfully. I will add this, though, I do love the circle back to the start of the chorus, "...wish you were here." It feels like a desperate plea. It feels so full of hope, yet hopeless at the same time. Genuinely one of the best songs I think I've ever and will ever listen to in my life. And I didn't even get the chance to fully digest it on the first listen. Or second. Or third. Until like maybe the ninth or tenth idk. Admittedly, this song is the one on the album I come back to the least, Shine On You Crazy Diamond 6-9. If I had to guess, I've probably listened to it somewhere from 5-9 times. Wait. 6-9 times. And it's not the song's fault, I think it's a great song still. It just doesn't move me the same way 1-5 does. The latter half of the sixth part is basically a jam-out section, which isn't the only one on this song. It's kind of similar to the first track, where it's very fun at times but weirdly on edge. Like running from the cops on foot. Actually, maybe that's not fun. I don't know, I've never tried. That's not the point. The guitars and bass goes off and the beat is repetitive but works well. Then, another guitar (or just a guitar, I think the leads in the upbeat part are guitars but they may be synths) comes in and introduces the same riff right before the vocals in 1-5. And it's smooth. Really smooth actually. Kind of reminds me of Two-Headed Boy Pt. 2's (by Neutral Milk Hotel) transition, except that one's 10x smoother. And that's exactly what it does, welcome the vocals. If I had to choose between this vocal part and the first one, I would honestly choose the first one pretty fast. The first one has way better lyricism and vocal execution, but I do still enjoy this one. And then the waiting room music time. Hell fucking yeah. No notes on this part really but that the playing is lively and fun. You don't like fun? Fuck off, you fucking pussy. And now, the last part, similar to the intro of the album but different melody-wise. And honestly, yeah, this part is way better than the intro. I don't know if I would consider it melancholic, but it feels a bit uneasy. It's kind of gorgeous now that I'm really paying attention to it. Anyway, yeah that's my review on Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd. Now fuck off you fucking loser. Favs: Wish You Were Here, Have a Cigar, Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 1-5 Least fav: Welcome to the Machine EDIT: 4>5 certain moments grew on me

Absolutely beautiful. Just last night I was lying in my bed, under the covers in a bliss listening to this song, wondering when will this appear in the generator.

I think this is relaxing in a way. It reminds me of what it feels like to follow your own path. That it gets lonely but thats is not the reason not to take it. It gets better… The entire -ballad? Should I say?- is a preparation for that. It is an auditory example of the say “good things take time to fester”. You have to be patient. One more thing, it feels somewhat foreign, this feeling, unknown or better yet, unexplored. Yet this is not the first time I have been at this place. It has been quite some time though. That might be my queue, my signal to go on. To start this other new part of my journey and tread lightly, every corner has a new mystery.

This is the second Pink Floyd album that's been generated for me in a four-day span. I can do without the intro, and the outro, but other than that, it's an excellent example of Progressive Rock, and the peak of Pink Floyd. I just wish it was a bit longer. When I use this generator, I need to welcome the machine, and take whatever I get thrown at me. Favorite song: "Wish You Were Here".

Enjoyable prog rock. Standout is the opening first pat of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" which brings the listener on an ethereal ride. Other standout is the title track which sounds like a more mainstream rock song with the vocals sounding a little like folk 60's singers.

Wonderful! An absolute essential and classic.

Kinda fun, and "Wish You Were Here" might be my favorite Pink Floyd song. I appreciate the rest of the album for what it is, but I don't love it. 3.3

Perfection

I prefer Animals, but this is still a perfect album

Excellent, not as well rounded IMO as Dark Side of the Moon, but still magnificent for the most part.

Bit of a strange album. It's a few good songs sandwiched between 12+ minute long jam sessions. I liked it, but it's nowhere near The Wall.

The length of the tracks daunted me at first. But this is a wonderful, relaxing album to listen to. I can see why Pink Floyd has such a legendary status - the album's autobiographical themes gives it power enough to stick out.

Beautiful playing that remains relevant to this day. It tugs at the heartstrings with its opening and the poetic lyrics have not ceased to be applicable. Shine on and wish you were here are the standouts. But the long jams in between had me reaching for my guitar too to learn those riffs. Wish you were here is amazing, everyone should have listened to it.

Ça partait mal, avec l’intro de la première chanson, où on se sent comme dans une séance de massothérapie, jusqu’à ce que la guitare embarque, un peu mieux.je ne suis pas un fan des chanson instrumentale de 15 minutes, je vais essayer de rester ouvert 😊Fiou ! il y a de belles harmonies vocales vers 9 minutes. Les paroles et la musique de « Welcome To The Machine » n’accrochent, comme dans « La Maudite machine » d’Octobre en 1971, le système qui nous avale est un thème fort qui me rejoint et qui est très bien exploité ici aussi. Thème qui se poursuit dans la très bonne « Have A Cigar », dans laquelle on dicte à un jeune garçon comment être un bon soldat et comment plaire et faire de l’argent facile. Et la transition vers « Wish You Were Here » est juste parfaite, avec le sampling d’une conversation ou un adulte puissant semble donner la morale à une personne qui semble en douter en lui disant « disciplinary romains mercifully ». Je connaissais ce gros tube, mais j’avais j’avais jamais pris le temps de lire les paroles si belles et qui sont comme un appel à l’espoir d’un possible meilleur dans ce monde si formaté et aliénant. En bref, un très bon album concept qui se tient et dont je reconnais qu’il ne peut être noter que par 5 étoiles. Je souligne aussi la très belle et forte pochette d’Hipgnosis, un collectif qui aurait signé les pochettes de plusieurs groupes progressifs du temps, dont plusieurs autres albums de Pink Floyd.

Je n’arrive pas à croire que je n’avais jamais écouté cet album! J’ai pourtant eu une période Pink Floyd à l’adolescence, mais j’avais décidé de consacrer mon 20 $ à l’achat de Dark Side of The Moon que j’ai écouté jusqu’à plus soif. Et la phase Pink Floyd est passé et je n’y suis jamais vraiment retourné. J’avais aussi un préjugé négatif pour la chanson titre qui, dans mon esprit, avait été contaminé par tous les apprentis guitaristes de mon école secondaire! C’est un disque exceptionnel, je l’ai écouté plus de cinq fois durant la journée. Ce sera mon premier 5 du défi !

I got so immersed in this album that I didn't realize that the sirens I was hearing were not part of the music

10 ★★★★★

A top 3 Floyd album for me. I love "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" and the title track, but not as high on the two other songs. High 4.5 stars

Perfect album. Every song is a highlight. 5 stars.

A pretty gargantuan gold-plated 5 star for sure. The first 8 minutes of Shine On You Crazy Diamond are grander than 1500 Mozart symphonies and maybe is the finest stretch in all of recorded music and the rest of the album is pretty great as well. Like a tumultuous epic voyage filled with the scrummiest mountain-sized pangs of sadness and regret and a great statement from the band about the music industry after the all-out success of Dark Side Of The Moon. Only 4.3 on the global charts… wish it were higher!

5/5 Yeah, this is stunning

Tastes like good wine. A very satisfying album experience. Fave Tracks: Shine On (all the parts), Wish You Were Here 4.5/5

Excellent

Lots of instrumental parts and pretty mellow

It was fine. Nothing really stood out for me and it wasn’t the best of Pink Floyd albums, in my opinion.

shine on, pts 1-9 is like 30 minutes.

One of the greatest Album of all time and my personal favourite.

Fuck yeah

4.5/5. Great record

Loved it

Without hesitation, one of my top 5 albums of all times. Serious. It is Pink Floyd ash their truly musically best. Amazing. Get wept away with "Shine on you Crazy Diamond parts 6 - 9?" its a 10 not a 5. Darkside is also top but more so for the production and creativity; I prefer this to Darkside.

Very remarkable album, I feel I need to listen it once more

Nice to listen to but not my go to genre

What a beautiful album.

5 Stars, and in my opinion, the best Pink Floyd album. For me, this release arrived at a most impressionable age. I used to put it on, sit on the floor and stare at the burning man, read the lyrics on the liner, and just listen. In later years, with a little grass, i’d spin it and run wild with imagination. Now, many years later, it still stops me cold. Music is truly an amazing medium. It has seeming endless reasons and uses, and is ever evolving. Many tracks are there to add or enhance your current experience, like dancing or driving or fucking. For most, it’s just to provide background. This album tells a story, using lyrics, but mostly with music and sound. To truly experience, listen at night, alone, by fire or candlelight, preferably as a storm rages outside. Use good headphones…. you’ll want it loud, to catch notes and sounds played so quiet and delicate. If you enjoy recreational drugs, definitely use them here. And just listen. And imagine. Damn near Spiritual. God Bless Pink Floyd.

Really enjoyable prog rock album. Their musicality really shines. Another reviewer mentioned that Pink Floyd is best enjoyed as a whole album, and I completely agree. This album is a vibe on a Sunday afternoon. Highlights: shine on you crazy diamond (both), wish you were here

Even though I’m very familiar with this album I’ve still given it a good listen. In many ways this is like the difficult second album, coming as it did after DSOTM. Having said that they still put in a good show and Rick Wright did some great keyboard work. Not their best album for me personally but still a very solid album and deserves its place on the list

It's interesting to comeback to what I thought at age 16 was my favorite PF album, back when I wasn't all that into listening to albums or judged just based on what songs were cool but I was *almost* there in listening to all the songs in an album. It's almost been a decade since (ouch) and it's weird to realize how much I still remember about this album (and also enjoy) but also how much I didn't remember like the smaller details to the instrumentals, particularly the synth work on the Shine on You Crazy Diamond suite orthe foils in Welcome to the Machine. It's the kinds of things that make me realize that there is still a lot that I can dig into these older albums that I didn't realize initially now that I'm more conscious of these things. Anyway, unlike other prog albums I heard before this one is one of the best, maybe it's how emotional and mechanical/space inspired it can be, there's no grand concept beyond being an ode to Sid Barrett and struggles with being a band but it's just really good at acompaning this instrumentals thay fit just what they wanna communicate and I love that about it I'm glad I could return to this one with a fresh outlook on it and still come out of it enjoying it a ton

найс, вайбово, претензий нет. подойдет для вечернего прослушивания, немного напомнило группу space

Could never go wrong with Pink Floyd. Awesome album!

Sparse but filled with emotion. Zero filler songs. This album says what it needs to say and that's it.

So good. Not their best but pretty close.

Thus took me back to high school and a friend back then that sat me down to listen the album start tk finish in its entirety. That is truly how it is best experienced although a song like Wish You Were Here does stand in its own. This album deserves a five just for Punk Floyd having the vision, the concept.

My favourite Pink Floyd album - the title track is one of the best rock songs ever, poignant and yearning with a beautiful guitar riff. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is an epic tribute to their former friend Syd Barrett, that manages to entertain and build to great moments despite it's length across two tracks Every track is good of course, Have a Cigar and Welcome to the Machine have some great, cynical lyrics and I like the synths too. Love this one even better than The Wall / DSOTM

While beautifully produced and played, this was a lot of window dressing just to get to the title track and then an outro of equal spatial masturbating. Not my jam. Math blues rock I could get high to and stare at velvet paintings for a few hours. At this point in my life I will pass. Still it is a highly influential band at their height.

10/10 Probably the best album of all time Favourite Song=Shine On You Crazy Diamond Part 1-5 Least Favourite Song=None

Some good tracks, I don’t love it but for the good tracks a 3

Hell yeah, Pink Floyd. I mostly just like "Wish You Were Here" though.

This is just really good. I’m too lazy to elaborate but it’s really good.

Great album and vibe from start to finish. A masterclass on what you can do with a very simple chord structure. Not an all time favorite for me, but great nonetheless

Boring, too little vocals

I grew up listening to this album and specifically, the title track so it was really good to listen again with grown up ears.

One of the greatest albums of all time and in my opinion the best Pink Floyd album. Its just a musical masterpiece

Very much an album listen; it’s just so nicely tied up into a cohesive package. Grew up around this music, so there’s some bias, but I still won’t give it a 5.

pretty long songs but yeah good

Good. Feel like I need to have good speakers. Still can’t fully get into Pink Floyd

triggers bittersweet memories, possibly the coolest album cover of all time keeping mum's vinyl copy

One of the greatest albums ever. Huge, sweeping, yet also intimate. There I nothing I don’t like about this album.

Splendid

Amazing complete album

5 booms BOOM 💪 BOOM 💪 BOOM 💪 BOOM 💪 BOOM 💪

It's good innit. It's not my favourite Floyd album but it's certainly got its charms! Nothing quite like being at work listening to "Welcome to the Machine" though... 😬

not enough voice

How do you follow up one of the biggest albums of all time and your possible creative and artistic peak? By doing it again obviously. Feelings of guilt by ditching the acid casualty and becoming obscenely rich forced the band to stretch out and get back to doing their more lengthy prog numbers. Some may feel that this album isn't as accessible as the previous number but that's part of its charm. This used to be my favourite Pink Floyd album. It still is, but it used to be too. Best Tracks: Shine On You Crazy Diamond (parts 1-5); Shine On You Crazy Diamond (parts 6-9); Wish You Were Here

Love it. Obviously very experimental

Оригинальная музыка. Теперь понятно, откуда многие берут рифы и сэмплы. Но всё же не моё.

come on, not a single skippable song.

Bit of a classic and only Have A Cigar stops it being a five star. Four and a half 😊

The first Pink Floyd album I ever purchased. It was really good great on headphones, especially I don’t think as good as dark side of the moon of the wall but after those two This is MY FAVORITE.

3/5 Solid, but only one banger.

Tough to follow up the greatest album of all time, but a worthy effort. Still a great album.

A great album... Every song is a classic. Pink Floyd at their most heartfelt, with great lyrics throughout. And maybe the best album cover in rock music.

This has always been one of my favorite Floyd albums despite some songs being long and the album only being five songs. It is solid in each song.

They are up there for one of the best bands of all time. They are one of the only bands that is good at having 7+ minutes songs on an album and it’s still enjoyable and impressive given nowadays a typical song is at most 5 minutes but slightly above 2 minutes

Was kinda expecting this to be a 5 but no dice. The two 12 minute songs was really what hurt it. Also I didn't think the other two songs were phenomenal, but really well done. "Wish You Were Here" is the best song on this album (and one of their best of all time) but that's kinda the only shining moment on this album. Everything else is just kinda meh for me although production wise it is really well put together and sounds good, just didn't connect for me.

I like some Pink Floyd but just not the long, drawn out instrumental pieces....and there are several on here. Shine On is a great piece, once they get to the lyrics. Wish You Were Here is just a fantastic, fantastic piece (and one of my favorite by them). Rating gets bumped up just because of that track alone

The problem with this is once you allow Gilmore and co more than 5 min to make a song it all goes a bit wrong

Monumentalny album. Początki prog rocka pokazują, jak ten gatunek powinien brzmieć - Floydzi wykorzystują wszystkie możliwości długiej, meandrującej formy zamiast przez 15 minut męczyć tę samą gitarę i nic więcej, jak to często ma miejsce w późniejszym rocku progresywnym. Jest to kolejny album czerpiący z szerokiej tradycji muzycznej po to, żeby zbudować coś zupełnie nowego. Mocne inklinacje bluesowe (gitara w pierwszych utworach), jazzowe (saksofon) a nawet funkowe (późniejsza gitara), lirycznie i wokalnie czerpie z Beatlesów pełnymi garściami. A mimo to brzmi zupełnie świeżo i nowatorsko. W tej muzyce można się roztopić, a jednocześnie wymaga dużej uwagi. Łatwo się dać zgubić 30-minutowej narracji Shine On You Crazy Diamond, wydaje mi się, że właśnie dlatego twórcy rozbili go na dwie części i dorzucili trzy piosenki w środku. Diamond mogłoby w pojedynkę robić za cały album. Oni stworzyli muzykę rockową od nowa. Po Beatlesach być może najbardziej rewolucyjny zespół w historii zachodniej muzyki współczesnej.

Um bom album de prog. Gosto de progressivo e gosto de Pink Floyd. Algumas músicas já tinha ouvido antes, seja em covers, seja as originais. Enfim, muito bom

pink floyd você sempre será famoso!!!!! wish you were here primeira música do mundo!!!!

I don't know why I like this so much more than a lot of other prog/art rock on this list. Maybe nostalgia? Maybe the format? Their most "art" song is split in two to open and close the album. It's a slow introduction, which builds to a more complex piece, then mirrors that on the second half. In the middle are songs that are a bit more "radio friendly," but they are still experimental. overall, I really enjoy this, it's got a couple great songs, and the album as a whole is quite well realized.

Atmospheric and generally pretty excellent

I bought this in 1980, I've loved it ever since.

11/18/24. Amazing album, just beautiful songs and flows like water. Can always revisit this one anytime for any mood.

Absolutely incredible from start to finish. A classic

Maybe it's because I'm drunk and I've been crying for the past hour over an animated film, but I really liked this, and I've tried to like Pink Floyd before. all parts of 'Shine On You Crazy Diamond' were great. The others were kind of whatever on a second listen.

I love it. And the obligatory joke is everyone that haven't listened to this album.

Świetna muzyczna podróż. Żałuję, że mam chujowe słuchawki, chętnie odsłucham ponownie w lepszych warunkach. Płyta moim zdaniem mocna nie tylko muzycznie, ale też tekstowo. Pierwsza część "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" to dla mnie absolutny sztos (5/5), potem nie czułem już aż takiego zachwytu, ale dalej solid. Mocne 4 i czekam na inne płyty Floydów.

Another album where it's impossible to do it justice in words. There's so much detail here. Sonically, it's almost perfect for me. The guitar, bass and drums all sound great but it's the keyboards that often take center stage. Especially in the spacey first part of Shine On You Crazy Diamond and the dystopian sounding Welcome to the Machine. The soloing is bluesy, especially obvious in Have a Cigar. The title track is the highlight. Beautiful lyrics. Acoustic guitar and piano building to a crescendo. There's no big solo, just a fade out and windswept segue into the last track. The second half of Shine On is darker, brooding. It's a masterclass in creating atmosphere.

One of most overrated bands

Wish You Were Here (song) is among my favorites. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (all parts) are tutorials in guitar creativity and excellence.

Oh Wish You Were Here. I used to make out with an old boyfriend to this album (his pick not mine), which after listening to it again was probably an odd choice 🤔 But the feelings remain. David Gilmour has the voice of an angel, doesn’t he 🥹 and the title track Wish You Were Here is just perfect. Have a Cigar is my second favorite. Listening to this album all these years later, it did feel a bit monotonous at times (10+ minute long songs are typically an automatic no for me), but the album is still absolutely magnificent. I think I’d prefer listening to it with someone though, instead of alone. I feel like it’s a real hang out and shoot the breeze kinda album, more so than a make out one. But it was certainly a nice trip down memory lane.

An incredible album from top to bottom. Might be my favorite Pink Floyd album - the soundscapes they managed to put together put me in a peaceful place. Melancholy and beautiful.

Not my favorite Pink Floyd album, but dang is it good.

I actually like Barrett-era Floyd quite a lot, but 12 minutes into this album, listening to some self-indulgent tinny 70s brass parping, I realised I was giving this unwarranted interest. If this band wasn't called Pink Floyd I wouldn't give this a second thought. Self-important, self-indulgent, self-regarding. Impressions of an art student's final project with the sound effects and collages. Also I hate the whiny synths and sustained electric guitar notes.

Hm. Like the radiohead of their time. Portentious ass motherfuckers with a lot of talent, but not quite enough to support their pretension or to earn the right to not just deliver some tight rock and roll that they have proven they are capable of. Shine on has an interesting story, and sid fucking showed up even, but it just kinda sounds like their keyboardist just got the first pitch wheel in the world for christmas. Roy harper an interesting cat, and the title track is powerful good, but the record company bad shit just like 'money' is some plodding ass moralizing.

Shine On You Crazy Diamond (I-V) - A+ Welcome To The Machine - neat almost prog song with nice keys and effects Have A Cigar - Also has cool keys Wish You Were Here - A++ Shine On You Crazy Diamond (VI-IX) - Pretty funky. Nice continuation of the first song. This album was much more prog than I was expecting even though I've heard half of it before. Near perfect album, especially for the time.

come on. Let's get real pretty please.

really it doesn't take a genius to see why pink floyd's works are on here; these symphonic and progressive masterpieces will stand the tests of time. every single track is an experience that nobody will forget. songs of loss, the music industry, and spacey rock movements span this record. it's impressive.

This album was just 50% shine on you crazy diamond. Good song I guesss. Nice guitar work.

The song(s) Shine on You Crazy Diamond are some of the best composed and atmospheric rock songs to-date. The song Wish You Were Here is beautiful in its simplicity. Have a Cigar and welcome to the machine are about 3/5 for me. Considered as a whole, while this isn't their most seamless listening experience, a damn good album. 4.5/5 -> 5/5.

Love this album. I enjoy it even more as I’ve gotten older. David Gilmour just ripping that strat. So good.

Classic Floyd, but only worth 3 stars in my book

This is healing the soul

Pink Floyd are not my band. Favourite track: Wish You Were Here.

Sonic masterpiece.

Too many long, slow instrumental sections. Wish you Were Here is a good song, but also the only one that’s way too short.

A deeply bitter and paranoid album, which contains a stark beauty for all that. Knowing the history behind Shine On You Crazy Diamond makes it hit that much harder.

Easy 5. Can't wait to listen again

“Wish you were her”…how many of these is he going to send?

seems it was actually pretty decent. Will listen again

A very good album, with a mostly instrumental song beginning the album and closing the album. Standout track: Wish You Were Here

The opening songs and wish you were here were great, the rest just alright. Good album though

sorry to everyone who knows an unbearable person with a poster of this album on the wall. but this shit slaps.

A+ listen. I think I have zero negative criticisms.. I think some of these bands over time get so hyped that you end up only hearing negative shit - its not interesting to say Pink Floyd rules... But they do! Of course I know these songs, but i can't say I've listened to the album front to back, maybe since I was a kid. It really creates a world that is both dystopian and cold but for some reason you want to stay longer. The structure is tremendous as well, bookending with Shine On... Iconic album cover. Just noticed Welcome to Machine has no drums! Props to Pink Floyd for making the music they wanted to. Fucking sick album!

A little melodramatic for me on the whole. Songs about being annoyed by the music industry that has made all your dreams come true (have a cigar) might be my least favorite artistic theme. wish you were here is an incredible song but as an album, wish you were here is is more morose than engaging. Guessing this will be an unpopular take.

Not Floyds best or even second best… maybe not even the third best… these guys truly knew how to make album pieces Everyone knows the middle of the album. The shine on you crazy diamond segments are super under appreciated in my opinion. Loved the sax SOLOS at the end of parts 1-5. Baritone to Tenor sax? Wish You Were Here is potentially pink floyds best individual song ever written. Beautiful lyrics and simple instrumentation with that patented synth sound. Ive heard that track 1000s of times - mostly amateurs learning their first guitar solo (myself included)

This is some indulgent classic rock I can get on board with. Shine on you Crazy Diamond is so, so fucking long, but I love the buildup and the atmosphere. I heard this song for the first time in a gem store in Evanston, Illinois (I have no idea why I was there) and was captivated listening to this long buildup while I looked at sparkling gems. Thinking back, I wonder if they only played gem-themed music there (or if they think of all hard rock as on-theme...). I had never like the Pink Floyd I'd heard before that (Dark Side of the Moon didn't grip me the way it got other people), but after hearing that track I put on this album and it clicked. Wish You Were Here is beautiful too. I really like this album.

Dark Side was one of the first albums served through this site, in the first couple of weeks I was doing this alone. At the time I gave it a 4 - thought I needed to leave room in the ceiling. I would give it a 5 now. I really like prog rock, through composed stuff, and albums that hang together beyond individual hits. I didn’t realize how much of a full album band Pink Floyd is, probably why I never really “got” them. They’re kind of the perfect band for this process of slowing down to listen to the whole thing. Maybe I’ll end up reranking this as well, enjoyed this a lot - man I love the title track - but didn’t really enjoy this as much as Darkside.

Typical Pink Floyd.

A phenomenal, sentimental work. My first listen to Pink Floyd and what a stellar introduction to the band it was.

Not Dark Side of the Moon but still quite good.

Espectacular!!! Lo escucharía por primera vez hace 30 años y sigue sonando igual de bien. Todas y cada una de las canciones son espectaculares y el sonido es de otra galaxia.

Underrated hidden gem

Perfection

4 stars for wish you were here the song, flawless, no notes. the rest was aight

idk what was happening when i put this album on yesterday but i really connected with it lol. i had just gotten my flu shot a few hours before so maybe that was kicking in? I've never really been a pink floyd fan and i hadn't heard any of these songs beforehand but this was good enough for me to listen to it 2-3 times. definitely will revisit these tracks in the future. favorites: all of them, particularly welcome to the machine and wish you were here

An experience that really requires listening to uninterrupted in one sitting. Has peaks and valleys but the overall experience is quite good. I do think it would be better without the middle track.

I mean, it's a timeless masterpiece! Monster hits every single track (Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Welcome to the Machine, Have a Cigar, and Wish You Were Here) Some of the best and most popular progressive rock music ever written. No complaints, only positive thoughts for this one. 5⭐️

Love it and def going to listen to it again!!

A couple of good songs, rest ok'ish

On kyllä älyttömän kova. Ambient hetket vie kyllä johonkin ihan muualle ja David Gilmourin soolot on viimeisen päälle suklaata. Wish You Were Here on se helmi tietenkin.

I can't rank all of Pink Floyd albums in quality. but this is amazing. Probably Wish you were here is one of the most overrated songs of their work, even though it's way over the top in the whole industry.

I mean this has to be one of the greatest 5 track albums ever right? You got an insane 13 minute intro which they shredded then you end the album with another incredible 12 minute song. Then you got a classic record and the two “filler” songs are damn incredible as well. Plus the album cover is five stars on its own. Kudos to them!

This gave me an immediate Shine when it came up. Immediately transports me back to listening to Dad’s records On his stereo in our first house. You remember little shards of music from your youth. It’s Crazy how then listening as an adult, it all fits together as a mixture of memories and new discoveries - I found myself flipping it over and listening twice in one sitting. A true Diamond of an album.

Wish You Were Here is not the best Pink Floyd album. But it is the most accessible of all Pink Floyd albums. It consists of four songs; and three of them became FM radio staples (Welcome to the Machine, Have a Cigar, and Wish You Were Here). The fourth song (Shine on You Crazy Diamond) is 26 minutes long, and is wisely split into two tracks that bookend the album. Conceptually, Wish You Were Here is also one of the least dense Floyd records. The songs are split between sorrowful odes to their fallen leader, Syd Barrett (SOYCD and the title track), and scathing stabs at the music industry (Welcome & Cigar). The music is engaging; and apart from Shine On, the songs are relatively concise. The tracks about Syd are earnest and heartfelt. The tracks about "the machine" are cold and cynical. But on the whole, the album doesn't overstay its welcome. And if ever Pink Floyd was making deliberate moves for radio, it's here in the title track, and Have a Cigar. Wish You Were Here doesn't have the lingering impact of Dark Side of the Moon, or The Wall; but it is probably the best entry point to Pink Floyd fandom. And that's good enough.

Rating this one wasn't hard.

Hats off to Roy Harper, I'd like to have a cigar with him.

Epic space funk This album changed my life!! Shine on You crazy Diamond

Probably one of the greatest albums of all time, it’s a shame PF’s best albums are so good that you can’t put them all in the top 5 of all time, but you really really want to. But this one out of all of them makes it in for sure.

I like Wish You Were Here. Nice twist on the Rednex classic! There’s also something intriguing about the first part of «Shine on…» (except for the saxophone solo), but I don’t really care for the three other songs. Too much noodling, not enough song

Typical Pink Floyd - not our favourite but still v listenable

Erreicht nicht ganz die Größe wie andere PF Alben…8/10

Definitely a GOAT contender 4.6 stars

One of the greatest by one of the greatest

I've loved this ever since a friend of mine wrote it in the sand.

I don’t really like Pink Floyd But this was surprisingly good. David Gilmour‘s guitar licks are fantastic. My main criticism would be that “Shine on you crazy diamond” song was awfully long.

I have heard all of these songs over the years. I really like wish you were here, but the rest of the album is ok for me.

wow no notes just vibes

the middle 3 songs are my favorite of all of the Pink catalog.

Excellent

**An ok album, just not for me

Masterpiece. Always gives me chill listening to it. Back when I was starting school and was listening to this on the bus ride to the school, I was so hooked, almost missed my stop.

I liked this album a lot. This the 4th album of Pink Floyd's I've listened to. Not as good as "DSotM" though, that one is unbeatable. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is incredible and never gets dull. The other songs aren't filler at all. 4 stars for "Wish You Were Here".

A piece of prog rock perfection. Doesn’t overstay it’s welcome - works as background and foreground music.

If this isn't a 5 I don't know what would be.

I wish I liked Pink Floyd. It feels like I am breaking a major Dad Law by just not enjoying it.

Schönes Album.

As mentioned in yesterday's review this is one of my absolute favorite albums. Didn't listen to it yesterday, will this evening with a nice drink and will thoroughly enjoy it.

Huh. Pink Floyd achieved melodic perfection for an entire album. Their other albums have been mid with one to two songs that transcend, so I did not see this coming. Five stars I guess.

Nearly perfect. I love the mood listening to this puts me in.

Quite self indulgent but a lot of it is quite good. I think.

It make me cry, it's perfection from start to finish. It's impossible to tell the best song, even the best album of pink floyd. But this is a masterpiece I could listen to for the rest of my life.

Everyone says they like a bit of Floyd but only hard-core fans actually listen to a whole album. I like this album but in my opinion if falls far short of Dark Side of the Moon.

Really enjoyed this! About time I listened to the band I likened Coldbones to if anyone over 50 asked about our sound. Definitely some elements we share but this album is a trip and the production is so good. Some super cool panning going on! 45 minutes was about right as well.. Gorillaz should’ve taken note!

Pretty nice. Would be better with some LSD

Yeah nice. This is cool. Loved all parts of Shine On You Crazy Diamond and the moody themes throughout 🙏🏻

Rating out of respect but would never put this on again. Maybe if I had the original 1st pressing on vinyl, in ex-council flat in London I purchased for £500k and furnished it with the most minimal art deco furniture, whilst enjoying a Batchelor lifestyle, reminiscing of that women who I briefly knew. But yeah, not for me.

This album has to be listened in its entirety. I hadn't appreciated Pink Floyd as much as they deserve before this. It was atmospheric, a love letter to a former member and probably mental with a belly full of drugs 😂😂 I really liked it, although it's more an experience than something I could just pop on.

It's "epic" in scope, but just don't think it's for me overall

One of the top albums in my opinion. .

Much more of an instrumental album than I realized but very good nonetheless.

The more albums I listen to on here the more I realize how much these rock and roll heads love blues

Dreamy, groovy, beautiful. This feels like a movie soundtrack because of how seamless it flows together. Minimal vocals and the instrumentation carries this record, but even when there are vocals, it adds as a fitting layer to an already harmonic and melodic piece. Yes, Pink Floyd is revered, but I had never listened to this record in its entirety before today, and I'm happy I did at some point in my life.

5 tracks for a total of 43 minutes is impressive in a way. I don’t actually hate this one, there are some interesting parts and overall it’s catchy, but I do get a little bored with most of the songs, they just keep going…

My favorite Pink Floyd album, it’s the one I’ll put on first (never the wall or dark side). Love the guitar work here too

The song ‘Wish You Were Here’ is undeniably powerful and touching but the style of the song felt like it doesn’t really fit somehow. ‘Shine On You Crazy Diamond’ has their signature experimental sound, but the overall album felt overly drawn out at times. The lengthy instrumental sections became tediously long. The album has some moments of brilliance, however it lacks any cohesion for my liking.

masterpiece

I wish I were there too

"Have a Cigar" and "Wish You Were Here" are gorgeous bits of music.

We’re all just a bunch of lost souls in fish bowls. Great top to bottom. My favorite Pink Floyd album.

very long intro quality music

Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) 4 Welcome to the Machine 4 Have a Cigar 4.3 Wish You Were Here 4.4 Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI - IX) 4.2 Score: 4.18

Imagine being a band with 5 or 6 legitimate masterpieces in your repertoire

Nice atmospheric and moody. Worked well as an album. Stand-out: Have a Cigar

Classic and timeless

Might be my favorite album from start to finish, but this is only my 3rd day hear, so hopefully there are more favorites to come!

Classic album.

Wish You Were Here is a belter. Liked Shine On You Crazy Diamond too although a bit long. Gonna give it an extra star for how clean and crisp the quality is.

Það fyrsta sem ég hugsaði var epískt en varð svo hræddur um að platan myndi missa flugið og ég yrði þreyttur á henni. Það gerðist aldrei og ég nau plötunnar allan tímann og langar að hlusta á hana aftur við fyrsta tækifæri

shine like a diamond

This album is SO GOOO, going into permanent rotation!

Probably the best collection of songs about the music industry and the toll it takes on artists.

Roger Waters is the man.

There is nothing that hasn’t been said about this masterpiece so I will just add in a personal anecdote — i’ll add that I cherish the rides over to the cabin or night hike drives where this was a new, exciting, fascinating album. The vast expanse of Shine On juxtaposed with the stripped rawness of Wish You Were here captivated our attention and soundtracked our good times. For that, I am forever thankful.

Fucking amazing album

I can see why everyone loves this album, but it still is not my cup of tea. I guess I am that based preferring Radiohead, Queen, and god forbid Linkin Park over Wish You Were Here

One hundred percent. Absolutely deserves to be on this list and is an essential album.

DON'T EVEN NEED TO LISTEN LOVE LOVE LOVE

I give Pink Floyd all the credit in the world. Important band for sure. But the overwrought songs are just not for me.

I enjoy listening to Pink Floyd and this is an album I haven't heard before. I liked Welcome to the Machine the best.

Love it. Didn’t think I was a Pink Floyd fan beforehand and maybe I’m still not, but this album is special. Opening track steals the show but the artistry and storytelling on Welcome to the Machine is also remarkable. Essential to listen to this in full, undistracted, and let the music take you.

One of my favorite albums and one of the greatest albums ever made. Probably their best? Dark Side is close but I find myself leaning this just a bit most times. An essential listen for any music fan.

Only drawback for me is the reprise of Shine On (gets a bit w**nky with all of Gilmour's soloing). Other than that, excellent.

There are probably not many albums that have had as much discussion, dissection and dialogue as this. I'm not going to try and out-review anything that's come before, but I will say that this is, genuinely, an exceptionally good album. I've been familiar with the album art since the re-mastered CD re-release in 1994, but this might be the first time I've noticed the burn-out in the top right, which is genius in more ways than I care to talk about here. Onto the music. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is indulgent in a way that only prog rock from the 1970s can be. Indulgent it is. Sumptuously so. At 13½ minutes long, it can't be described as anything other than "long" - but what glorious minutes they are. One stupours in it. Not many tracks are as dissociative. In one way or another, it takes up most of this whole album. Welcome to the Machine is pleasingly, well, mechanical. It follows some of the themes present in Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall, though very much fails to do so as well as either of those others. Have a Cigar noodles along capably, with soaring guitars that never really seem to reach a destination. Wish You Were Here asks the most important question - you think you can tell heaven from hell? Well, I thought I might have been able to, but now I'm not quite so sure. It is the title track of the album for a reason. It fits best with the sleeve art, for sure. Given Pink Floyd's massive success, it really does tell how much the ideas of missed connections, lost opportunities and the melancholia of ageing resonate with music lovers. All that hyperbolic guff out of the way - onto the negative aspects of the album. The synths are dated. I've no idea what they could be replaced with, but it's so inextricably tied to the mid-70s that it's almost all you can focus on as they squeal away. And that's a bit sad. It's also not Floyd's best work. That has to be Dark Side of the Moon. But claiming that an album is "bad" because it's not the best example is ludicrous. It isn't a bad album - I'd even go as far as to say that it's a magnificent album. But every time I listen to it, I always kind of think to myself "Perhaps I should put on Dark Side instead?" and that's an odd thing to think.

annoyingly boring

Meditative and enjoyable-peaceful

Their creativity, patience, and innovation shine here. They let their music breathe in a way few artists allow. This is an odyssey through space that you can really sell into. Built for a good set of headphones, stars, and maybe some LSD if you’re feeling adventurous.

Solid album start to finish.

Yeah... Perfect album. I don't think there is a bad thing in here. The story behind the recording, the cover. All clicks.

Short but sweet

Oh, please. Twist my arm and make me listen to one of the greatest rock albums ever recorded one more time. I mean, it's frickin' Wish You Were Here -- it's basically a perfect album from start to finish, can be enjoyed in any state, and has some of the best guitar work ever rendered to vinyl. Pink Floyd's run through the 70's is pretty much unmatched by anyone except maybe the Stones or Radiohead.

You can tell when an artist has the sauce, and Pink Floyd has the sauce. Both prog rock jams, Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 1-5 and Pts. 6-9, are awesome and sound fascinating and feel like a true journey. While Wish You Were Here is a classic, I think I liked Have a Cigar a touch more. Definitely an album you have to commit to the whole thing for, as each song doesn't work too well individually, but if you have the time, then it's a really awesome 45 mins.

this could potentially be my favourite floyd album, it was dark side of the moon but this was amazing, the 8 minute guitar introduction and then those stellar vocals on the first 5 parts of shine on you crazy diamond was insane, welcome to the machine was an intense second track to get into with a really interesting instrumental, very eerie in some aspects, have a cigar grew on me, really groovy song, really enjoyable, with you were here is one of the best songs of all time, it all makes sense on that song, and the outro is enough to blow anyone away, i love how the intro and outro are tied together. amazing album, nearly perfect, a benchmark in history.

Best album ever

This introduction is transcendent. It feels like entering a new world or something. Overall I loved how structured the album was, it had a clear beginning and end with the last track. My fave song off this was Have a Cigar. Felt very bluesy which I love.

Listened to this a few times. Good one to relax to

How do you follow Darkside of the moon? With Wish you were here. Another perfect/near perfect Floyd offering. Waters continuing to steer the Floyd machine through a critique of the music business sandwiched by fond memorium to fallen comrade Syd in the songs Shine & wish you were here. Even the cover art is a joy to behold, I fondly remember mine coming with 2 postcards of Stigg’s artwork. A rightly regarded classic.

Allegedly the most enjoyable album Floyd ever recorded with Watrers and Gilmour. Unannounced during the session a Syd Barrett - fat, bald, unrecognisable - walked in to say hello. 'Shine On..' was about him. And then asking the artist next door - Roy Harper - to have a go at the vocal on 'Have a Cigar.' So well his go, it was the take used. Happy days, seventies myth and bonhomie and a cracking record to boot.

Absolutely sublime

Incredible prog album.

Listened to most of this on a stroll through London on a Saturday morning. This album is like a dream or a journey where everything shifts around and new views come into perspective, but it's musically watery and the majority of the lyrics are predictable rhyming couplets. Wish I Liked It.

What a bloody beautiful album this is. I'd give it the biggest metaphorical applause that my two measly ol' hands could manage

Any album with the balls to start with a 10+ minute song is a 5 from me.

Wonderful homage to Syd Barret. Amazing record, as good as DSOTM

The second album I’ve gotten that I have on vinyl. Albums just don’t get better than this one unfortunately🤷‍♂️

# Playlist track - Wish you were here # Notes - The weird thing about this album is that it's only 5 tracks long. Each track ebbs and flows in all kinds of interesting directions. - There are long solos and weird explorations, yes. - But they just work together. One moment melts into the next and you never feel stuck or waiting for something to happen. - And, of course, there is the title track, which is just the perfect amount of trippy, sad, and emotional. - Definitely worth listening at least once in your life! 5 stars!

yep it's still good. ya gotta hand it to them. i wish that the shine on you crazy diamond parts were broken up into individual tracks for the sake of the current ~streaming era~ but like most things of that ilk, i appreciate that the work is so linked to the original physical format (i.e. a vinyl record)—i think it's a great demonstration of how practical technological limitations influence our conception of something like music. the medium is the message as they say 😳 idk if that makes sense but we can talk about it later lol. fav tracks: have a cigar, wish you were here [i may or may not have teared up while listening to the latter......EMBARRASSING!!!]

yeah that was good. not much else to say i haven't listened to this probably since high school but it still hits

I find Pink Floyd, pretty boring. I like the song "Wish you were here" but this is an album I would listen to our of choice.

Outside of the title track I’m sorry this was mostly bullshit

I have heard all of these songs at some point, but I didn't realise until today that I've never listened to the whole album. Why I haven't is hard to say, because this is an amazing album despite all the people saying its an amazing album.

Yes, it's true. I'm taking psychedelics while l'm listening to Wish You Were Here. It just happened to be my album of the day, and... INCREDIBLE. 10/10 experience. Very much would recommend. It was a low dose, so plenty of werewithal left to write a review.. no tangerine trees here. What I love about this album is its drama. I love that it's just this long-playing film, leading to these soaring highs, biting lines. It's really a play. But it's also the Perfect 70's Prog Album. All the lovely sound effects, Prophet synth leads, gorgeous guitar drama. It's all there. Really a compelling piece of art. I think I liked this album the way people like Dark Side of the Moon. For my money, this album does what people say Dark Side has on the tin. 5/5

how am i NOT giving this a five???

Was I just complaining about bad graphic design? Feeling much better now. Nothing on the cover of this album indicates who it is, what it's called, nothing. Just two suits. Wild but the PERFECT image for the music. Peak Hipgnosis and peak Pink Floyd. Peak album era. The imagery enhances the music and provides an entry into whatever world this is. The music has you doing a double-take back to the cover. Many levels of genius here. The album's pretty good, too.

I knew dark side of the moon and The Wall….I knew a little of this album. This is an excellent album and as I listened to it, I totally get why it is on this list. They had a sound that you could just keep listening to.

I don't hate it, I just don't understand why it is so popular.

Some people say this is one of the greatest album ever recorded and all other who dont think that are just plain wrong.

Gonna be unpopular but its kind of slow and draggy to me. I like Have a Cigar, but honestly felt like it was much longer than 7 minutes. I also didn't see how there were 5 parts to the first Shine on Crazy Diamond. Is it beautiful, yes...is it trippy, yes....is it talented and cool, yes. If I am feeling really introspective and thinking, sure I would listen but it is not something I would listen to all the time. My favorite was Shine on You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 6-9 Not bad, but not my favorite by them

One of their best. Great album!

I love this so much. Crazy Diamond is just perfect and beautiful. The whole album is a work of art and makes me cry. Pink Floyd is timeless, and there is really nobody else like them.

We know this album and the lyrics to all four songs, it’s a sing-a-long from start to finish. Fun listen. Both give it (4.3*s)

There's nothing bad to say about this one, not even the long runtime on all parts of Shine On is negative for me. Nothing else needs to be said. Stellar.