Reviews (page 6 of 16)
Pretty good. I liked have a cigar and already heard wish you were here. 3.7/5
10/10 no notes
It’s Pink Floyd. You know what you’re getting. This was too early in their career to not be good. Choice cut: Wish You Were Here
It just an amazing album that is required listening in the history of rock and pop music.
now i'm not just saying this because ana has me at gun point, but i enjoyed this a lot! i really love the guitar tones over the course of this album. they all sound fantastic, especially with those delicious synths in there too. it's the kind of album that makes me want to lay in bed with headphones on to appreciate every bit of the instrumentation so i appreciate how clear the mix is. i'm late to the game on an album like this so me saying "yeah this sure does evoke a strong mood" is another drop of water in the ocean, but hey so it goes.
Okay so I've listened to this album so many times in my life I have genuinely lost count, it is probably in my top 10 favorite albums ever. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is an incredible, mostly instrumental ode to a former band member. The titular song helped keep me sane in my first couple of years of University when I felt very isolated and alone. This entire album just sounds so spectacular. I feel like I can't say anything about this album that hasn't been said hundreds of times before, the highest of 5 stars.
I love it
Masterpiece, no more to add
Lots of great stuff here, I can see why it's such a well loved album. Love the thick guitar/bass stacking on Wish You Were Here. But since I'm rating these based purely on my enjoyment, it gets a 3.5 for the whole thing being very downtempo, and as one review I read said, "it's like they knew we'd be trippin'". So me not trippin' is not the target audience here. I imagine I'll like this more as I get to know it better.
Amazing rock album first time sitting through it and my favourite was definitely have a cigar and wish you were here i had already heard shine on you crazy diamond so i don't rate em in my first time review
Amazingly, I'd never listened to this all the way through. It's a trip - definitely feels like going to another world, and it's the prototype for so many things that have come after it.
One of the greatest albums by one of the greatest bands.
Gooooood
Favorite Track: Wish You Were Here One of the greatest album covers ever. Great sonic exploration. Love how sparse and melancholy it can be at times. Rock isn’t dead, but a guy who will tell you it is may be right about this album.
Favourite Song: Wish You Were Here
trop long et répétitif, je pense que je suis pas la cible. je peux apprécier le travail qu’est l’œuvre mais je ne prend pas vraiment de plaisir à l’écouter.
Shine on you crazy diamond and Wish you were here are both commonly known to be written for Sid Barrett. Post his drug induced psychotic break. So I suppose this is his epitaph, in a way. Full of squashy synth, R&B guitar and experimental sound effects. I especially liked the dystopian story that was played out in Welcome to the machine and the feeling that someone was playing along to the radio in Wish you were here. I liked this a lot. (4.755)
8.5
Better than I remembered. Peak
Made me feel cool
Picking up where The Dark Side of the Moon ended… superb
Right now this is probably my favourite Pink Floyd album. The masterpiece that is Shine On You Crazy Diamond of course takes the prize for the best song. All 9 parts are magnificent, and the fact that they're divided into two tracks —first and last in the album— really gives the album a full circle feeling. What I love most about Shine On You Crazy Diamond is probably that one four note phrase in Part II diamond is so simple, but at the same time so magical. I love the sax solo at the end of the first half. The glass harp at the beginning is fully engraved in my mind with the many times I've listened to it. But most of all, it's David Gilmour's guitar work throughout the whole Shine On You Crazy Diamond that makes it so great. He's truly a master of his craft; definetly one of the best guitar players I've ever heard. It's also interesting to just listen Shine On You Crazy Diamond from beginning to end, all 9 parts without the other songs in between, as a way to appreciate the piece in full. The title track is obviously a classic, but I like Welcome To The Machine even more. Again, I love Gilmour's guitars in this, but the synth solos in this song are exceptional and so powerful. Roger Waters did a phenomenal job in the writing and composition in this album, but for me it's Gilmour's guitars that really make this whole album a masterpiece. The fact that my least favourite track in Wish You Were Here is Have A Cigar, which is still great, says a lot about not only the overall quality of the album, but throughout every second of it.
Pink Floyd. Considered great by many. It's a band I really like when I'm in the mood for it, and will skip over if I am not. Wasn't feeling it today, which is okay since I know it well. So for me it cannot be a 5 even though it has 5 days, because it also has 2-3 days for me. so 4 it is. I'd own it, I will listen to it again.
Sad existential bromance album without a single song under 5 minutes
A vibrational experience, howling out for a lost compatriot
1. Shine on you crazy diamond: I didn’t expect to liked it so much but I really loved the beat, rhythm and the variety of instruments, my only complaint is how long the song is and how little lyrics it has. 2. Welcome to the machine: did not like it at all, I mean it wasn’t awful but the beat was to much, kind of made me feel anxious. 3. Have a Cigar: kind of a love/hate relationship with this one, the rhythm was a vibe but I hated the way they sang the lyrics. 4. Wish you were here: not really enjoyed the beginning but after my initial hatred I actually enjoyed it, it reminded of the type of songs my dad listens to, overall just a chill/cool song 5. Shine on you crazy diamond (6-9): the windy noise from the beginning was super dreadful, after that the song was a complete vibe, loved the way the variety of instruments sounded together, there was a part in the beginning that felt similar to parts (1-5) but with an edge so absolutely lived that, only complaints would be a part were it felt like someone was high pitched screaming in my ear, the longevity of the song and that overall it sound similar to (1-5) but I guess it makes sense since it’s technically the same song. Loved it as the last song on the album. Overall review of album: 7.8/10 As someone who listens to the same 5 song on repeat I didn’t expect to like it at all but it truly surprised me, I don’t think it would be the type of album I would listen to all the time but I mean I’m also basic. Extras, I really loved how the album started and ended, it felt nice how the beat started to vanish at the end.
One of my all time davorotes
Скучаю по тебе, EBALO_DROBITEL_2004. Зайди в онлайн…
quite experimental. i like it
Mellow and good. Probably unfathomably groundbreaking compared to everything else back then
ich liiiiieb das album. ziit lang gfunde s sseg besser als dark side. shine on you crazy diamond fangt sooooo guet aah. d synths de akkord wo afoch liit und denn gilmour soooloo. aso perfekti melodie über de komisch moll-blues wos do zemekocht hend. insaane cool. uuh denn de chord. fuck yeh. sooo guets solo. i chas immerno. aso mitsinge. de gsunge teil scho au seeeehr geil. welcome to the machine isch de ersti the wall song irgendwie. aso finden suuuper.
WUHUUUUUUU shine on you crazy diamond isch halt sooo schön UND eis vode beste albumcover findi WRLCOOOOOME TO THE MACHIIINE ICH LIEBELIEBELIEBE have a cigar de synthi am ahfang isch eifach so guet vlt spinn ich grad au aber wish you were erinneret mich auchli ah comfortably numb hans gfühl trz de lange lieder etc. ischs album eig reecht zuegänglich? bim synthi am ahfang vo pt. 6 mussi immer an manfred mann denke hahahah au d idee vomene lange stuck, wo als ahfang und endi vomene album dient findi SO GEIIIILLL call me usain bolt ade weltmeisterschaft 2009 in berlin will ich töne wie ein gebrochener rekord: FUNF
A lot less lyrics then I would’ve liked but nonetheless I really enjoyed it. I forgot what it was like to have songs longer than 2 or 3 minutes
Easy 10/10
* Notes: Consisting of only 5 songs and being 44 minutes long is insane. This is PEAK stoner music, but also something you could throw on in the background and just zone out to * Overall: A very chill album; showcases the psychedelic sound Pink Floyd is known for; Peak stoner album
Very interesting, sounds great
01) Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I–V) - 10,0 02) Welcome to the Machine - 9,0 03) Have a Cigar - 8,0 04) Wish You Were Here - 10,0 05) Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI–IX) - 9,0 TOTAL: 9,20 (92/100) Current ranking: 40/784
I know this album already, and I'd like to like it more than I do. Lots of long, noodly stuff around a couple of good songs.
Always avoided this band. Listening to the whole album actually made me re-evaluate that position. I understand this project a lot better now.
C'est toujours excellent du Pink Floyd
Pretty great chill album. 4 stars for me. Sort of reminds me of 2112 how it’s good to turn on in the dark vibing
Decent album, not quite my speed but had some good vibes
I wish I could give this album 6 stars. Love it
Classic. Incomparable. A must.
I mean, this album might not be for everyone, although for a lot of people it its great. You can say all you want. But this album has the ability to be enjoyed in special ways that give it a whole new dimention. I have memories with this album long before we started this. Im nog too big into this gerne of music, but im big into Pink Floyd. Love their stuff and love this album.
Some of the fastest 45 minutes to pass. Dreamy, but somehow also energetic. The guitar cries like it is in beautiful anguish. If I had to pick a gripe, I dont appreciate the parts that are noise/not music, but hey it kinda fits the vibe 5/5
Look, I am a white man who listens to prog rock/metal. I pray daily to the Holy Trinity: the father (Steven Wilson), the son (Mikael Åckerfeldt), and the holy spirit (Maynard James Keenan). I cannot pretend I won't give this amazing album a 10/10. I am also the target audience as I am spiritually a stoner from the 70s.
This website is now just spitting out random album notes from previous when it comes to rating time. It replaced my album notes for this album with Pronce ones done ages ago! Frustrating. Anyways. Love this album. First track is heartbreaking. Dave Gilmour’s guitar is so emotional and beautiful. Its his favorite Floyd album and i think i agree with him.
I dont really love the length of these songs, 5min is fine but 13?? nd mostly instrumental as well.. overall i thought it was a nice album, wouldnt consider it a great one over the top but it is a good album, it has nice songs, my favourite being wish you were here, and i guess i do understand how people highly rated this album. not really one of my favourites but still a great listen and i would love to hear more of pink floyd and figure out which albums of them i like the most, i love the genre itself as well
Very psychedelic. Perfect mix of psychedelia and prog-rock. Have a Cigar is one of their heaviest tracks. Really great album! Welcome to the Machine sounds like Wish You Were Here and Have a Cigar combined. Wish You Were Here is very chill and acoustic. Good for a funeral.
Yeah yeah it's Wish You Were Here, of course it's a 5. What do you want from me? Every song on this album is perfect. Well I mean, Welcome To The Machine is kinda weak—it's the least perfect song on the album—but the music video saves it. I love the part in the title track where there's like 5 acoustic guitar dubs strumming with different patterns and then they all land on the main lick together.
In the beginning it like instrument playing in the first song to build then the lyrics comes in in the whole album. It was like mixed with different type of emotions like you would go from screaming to sad just like I don’t know what I’m doing here, 8.5/10
Good album
I have not listened to this album or Pink Floyd in a long time. Remember getting into this in college, so years ago. The album dedicated to Syd Barrett is a great one, interesting songs and musicality abound in the album. 5.
50 years later, this holds up very well. It's impossible to believe that for teenagers today, listening to this is the equivalent of us as teens listening to something recorded in the 40s. THE FORTIES. Jesus Christ.
While I wouldn't put it past my more strident younger self to have hostility toward Pink Floyd, my memory is that I was more indifferent than anything else. Their looooong, proggy songs could sound like they were playing at the wrong speed on a turntable. Wish You Were Here still has elements of that, but I have generally positive feelings toward Pink Floyd these days. I'm not a fan and likely won't return to this, but I appreciate them and their artistry. 3.5 stars.
i have already heard this
An amazing album - my favorite from this band. "Shine On" with all its parts that bookend the album, with my most beloved song ("Wish You Were Here") landing perfectly in the track list...it's just a great listen.
Heard it before. Oh man, I have an interesting relationship with Pink Floyd because I used to really dislike them when I was younger. Then something clicked one day and Wish You Were Here definitely was one of those albums that converted me. It's just perfect length and every single song here is gooooood. Perfect in every way 5/5
Es git en grund wieso de papi da sals platte het. Incroyable. Magnifique.
This album didn't really get me hooked at any point. I do enjoy the lyrics once I learned what happened to one of the members and they were beautiful. But I do not believe that the psychedelic aspect of the music is really for me but I do see how people really enjoy it.
I simply do not understand it
More Pink Floyd. Why? Always theatrical. Always creative. Listened before? N Saved tracks? N ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Liked it a lot
Didn't expect a sax solo. It was fine, I guess.
One of my favorite albums. 10/10 front to back.
incredible guitar components but at times slower than I would have liked it to be. A decent listen but not quite my cup of tea.
Some great moments but a lot of rambling instrumentals.
pretty good, can see how this would start the psych pop evolution
Hall of famer right here
Um álbum completo, equilibra as evocações emotivas com uma técnica refinada de composição e arranjos. Maravilhoso!
It's very good but probably my 4th favorite by them
31/12/25 Wish you were here, Pink Floyd, 12/09/1975 genere: rock progressivo, art rock, rock sperimentale storia: Wish You Were Here, pubblicato nel 1975, nasce in un momento delicato per i Pink Floyd. Dopo l’enorme successo di The Dark Side of the Moon, la band si ritrova sotto pressione, disillusa dal successo e sempre più critica verso l’industria musicale. Questo stato d’animo permea tutto l’album, che riflette su temi come l’assenza, l’alienazione e la perdita di autenticità. Il cuore emotivo del disco è l’omaggio a Syd Barrett, fondatore del gruppo, allontanatosi a causa di gravi problemi mentali. La suite Shine On You Crazy Diamond è dedicata a lui e rappresenta il rimpianto per un amico e un talento perduto. Durante le registrazioni, Barrett si presentò in studio in condizioni tali che i membri della band faticarono a riconoscerlo, rendendo il tributo ancora più doloroso e reale. Accanto a questo lato intimo, l’album critica duramente il mondo della musica e del business, in brani come Welcome to the Machine e Have a Cigar, che descrivono un sistema freddo e disumanizzante. La title track Wish You Were Here sintetizza tutto: il desiderio di connessione, di verità e di qualcosa che ormai sembra irraggiungibile. Anche la celebre copertina, con due uomini d’affari che si stringono la mano mentre uno va a fuoco, simboleggia rapporti falsi e opportunismo. Con il tempo, Wish You Were Here è diventato uno degli album più amati della storia del rock, proprio per la sua capacità di unire critica sociale e profonda emotività. considerazioni: Già conoscevo l’album, principalmente per shine on you crazy diamond pts 1-5 e wish you were here. Le basi strumentali sono la cosa che ho apprezzato di più dell’album insieme al significato dei testi. Una canzone che sono contenta di aver scoperto con questo album e “Have a cigar”; l’assolo di chitarra altrettanto fantastico proprio come il significato della canzone. Credo sia molto attuale se ci si ferma riflettere; la musica continua ad essere un business e non più musica. Mi ha fatto piacere iniziare con questo album dato che i Pink Floyd sono la band preferita di papà. Frasi preferite: “We’re just two lost souls swimming in a fishbowl year after year” (Wish you were here); “Oh by the way which one is Pink?” (Have a cigar) Voto complessivo: 9-/10 l’unica pecca che forse non lo è più di tanto è che le canzoni siano poche ma penso che questa scelta sia coerente con i temi trattati all’interno
Flawless from start to finish
The first and last song were too long and for what Not my style
I do like Pink Floyd but am not a really massive fan aside from Dark Side of The Moon, but I really enjoyed this from start to finish. Loved the opening track 'Shine On You Crazy Diamonds (pts 1-5)'. That had me hooked.
Lovely tribute + anger at industry.
Guitar and surrounding instruments definitely stands out in this album. The work it self is very hypnotic and feels ahead of its time for an album produced in 1975. This album is the perfect depiction of Pink Floyd as a band.
Fantastic album where the space between the notes is important as the notes themselves.
Halfway through the first song and I already know this will be my first 5 star rating. The vocals aren’t as gripping as the instrumentals - wait no vocals do the heavy lifting in Have a Cigar. Ironically, Wish You Were Here is my least favorite track
So much depth. I do sometimes wish there were no lyrics. It was just all one ambient piece. I also thought I would find it tough to listen to one song for over 12 mins but because of the amount that’s going on I didn’t even realise.
All time classic, I've loved this since I was 16. A real gateway record I think away from the 3 minute pop song into more experimental interesting stuff. 50 years ago is mental
Incredible. No stand-outs, they’re all great.
It has been many long years since I’ve played this sucker. I still felt familiar. Have a Cigar and some parts of Shine On would fit seamlessly onto Maggot Brain. Roger Waters little rants against UK’s social infrastructure are sadly, still relevant. For me, this is the best Pink Floyd ever got.
In just my last review I was shitting on Jeff Beck and his guitar wank. This is guitar wank done right.
Why was this 10 hours long
Shine on you crazy diamond- abnormally long but extremely powerful Welcome to the machine- makes me feel like I'm transcending Have a cigar- groovy, upbeat and generally fun, gorgeous ending Wish you were here- pure and beautiful, I love the tone of the guitar
oh my, this is one of my favorite albums ever. I own it on vinyl. So so good
Obviously great album. All time classic.
Already knew most of these songs, so I liked it. Pink Floyd is definitely a vibe I have to be looking for, but when it hits it hits.
My favorite album thus far on this journey
Perfect album
An unbelievably fantastic follow-up to one of the best albums of all time. This displays Pink Floyd at their peak of creative flair and instrumental powers. Gilmour quite heavily outshines his bandmates on this record, from the unforgettable riff on 'Shine On', to the acoustic behemoth of the title track. We even see Floyd at their strongest lyrically, lambasting the music industry and a deep yearn for connection with their former bandmates. Best Tracks: - Shine On You Crazy Diamond - Wish You Were Here - Welcome To The Machine Worst Tracks: N/A Rating: 10/10
not my usual type music but I get why it’s so popular - some moments weren’t super me but I liked it!
5/5
Een van mijn favoriete albums ooit. Inspirerend, hartbrekend ronduit geweldig. Een geweldig psychedelisch rock album.. Favoriete nummer: wish you were here/ shine on you... pt 1-5 Minst favoriet: geen
حلو بس ممل بعطي الباند فرصه ذو
Really pleasant listen, complex instrumentals. Not my favorite Pink Floyd.
Ah, encore un album qui mérite totalement sa place sur cette liste (c’est pas si courant, hohoho). En matière de prog, on fait difficilement mieux. C’est un album riche, planant, créatif, ultra-personnel et tout simplement sans défaut. 5 étoiles, ça ne se discute même pas.
This was meh
Me too.
That is some sweet album art. There's a lot going on in this record. It feels like it's traversing through different rock genres, all while making every track connected to the next. Favourite Track(s): Have a Cigar, Shine On You Crazy Diamond (All Parts) Least Favourite Track(s): Welcome to the Machine
Songs are quite long, longest being track 1 at 13:32.
Before listening: I am familiar with Pink Floyd but do not usually gravitate towards them ever but that's not to say they are bad or anything. The album name is familiar but this cover art is not. I think the cover art is striking and not something i would associate with a band or even music it feels very high art. The framing of the burnt photograph with the subject also burning doing a deal with himself, there's a lot to be said about this artwork. I assume the association with the album will translate to self sabotaging in some capacity along with corporate America and performance of self. Listening: Very Blade Runner start, sadness of place in space. Ethereal. Fever dream energy, will there be singing? almost 9 min i see. Unfortunately the singing does not fit the vibe i was having a second ago. The saxophone is great. We in an industrial building going to work, the world building is cool. Dark energy, i might be darker if i were reading the lyrics but i am not. There is a lot to unpack with this one, very experimental. There is a complexity that requires more focus than I'm giving it. I always enjoy ambient sounds to create a full picture of a setting at the start or end of a song and its done well here. There is a lot of story telling happening, its going over my head a little but the feeling is persisting. Wish you were here was the most digestible, very radio ready in a good way. It feels like being put to bed for the last time, in a child like sense and an end of life sense. After listening: Very somber, profound. Not at all exciting like i thought Pink Floyd was but i also know my limited understanding of Pink Floyd is just wrong. I enjoyed this more in an art gallery type of way not on the way to work kind of way. I feel heavy. 8/10
Another classic. I had this one on vinyl too, until the fire. Fuck you, fire.
For me, Music should make us feel. Some feelings are unintentional- like that weird shit on the list that just makes you feel angry - but good music endeavors to make us feel intentionally a certain way. The gold standard for that type of music is Pink Floyd, who effortlessly evoke emotion through sound.
Classic
Fucking awesome
Wish you were here good- not in the mood for some of these songs but I want to revisit cause I know they’re good
okay
Saxophone in the last 2 mins of shine on you crazy diamond 1-5, no notes The synth throughout!!!!
Fantastic! Top to bottom. Complete listen. My rating 4.8
An absolute monster album. Love this so.much
Good progressive album wish you were here best stand alone song
Shine on you crazy diamon - I love how they can make guitar speak. Vocals are soft but theatrical. Welcome to the machine - Industial sounds go well with acustic guitar in this song but I don't really like vocals here. Wish you were here - My favourite track on this album. It feels like watching sunset from the porch of cabin, summer evening with your closest friends and/or bitter sweetending. Have a cigar isn't much outstanding for me 'cause of vocals which i don't really like here. Overall really good and iconic album. I liked it even though I wouldn't have listened to it if it hadn't been recommended to me. Itstrumentals were perfect but I'm not a big fan of vocals in all of these songs. But i can feel that Wish you were here will stich with me for a long time.
Before I started listening it I was wondering "Is it really that good?" Then I got goosebumps when vocals started on the opening track.
Amazing album. I love smoking a fat doobie to this and chugging some good ol’ miller lite
It’s alright, Pink Floyd leave me a bit cold in the main. Couple of tunes that are great. Otherwise just kicks along
Background listen. Got pulled over while listening to this.
Just listened to this and now gladly doing it again on the 50th anniversary remix. One of the first albums I truly loved when getting into music in junior high. Only low point to me is Welcome to the Machine which is a bit too drudgy. But easy five stars for this prog rock masterpiece.
Not even their best album and it's an easy 5. Shine on you crazy diamond is just so good. The whole album is amazing.
Good album overall. Floyd does it like no one else. That being said… there were a few times I found myself saying “could we get to the point?” Bit rambly at points…
A great band, a great album, and just a fun listen. The guitar licks are groovy and this is the kind of album you could bump over and over again
enjoyable as hell
to quote my brother, "wait, this is one song?"
Is this the greatest Pink Floyd Album ever?!?
Overall rating: 9.5 Favourite tracks: Wish You Were Here (classic), Have A Cigar
Love this album, Shine on You Crazy Diamond may be a top Pink Floyd song for me and then just every song after is a classic.
It's really difficult to try and listen to this album objectively, having listened to it almost daily in high school and countless times since then. Still, I picked up a few new nuggets like the cough and light breathing in the beginning of the title track. This whole album just transports you to another world and shine on feels like the vehicle that takes you there. A great example of when gimmicky production tricks pay off and create a true soundscape. Love this album, king of kings.
I'll start by saying that "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" is my favorite Pink Floyd song (or parts 1 -5 are?), and probably one of my favorite guitar songs ever - such an incredible journey to open an album with. Also David Gilmour's tone, economy, and touch make me want to cry, especially given the topic of the song. (And it even has a bari sax solo!) Whenever I listen to this album however, I always feel a little disappointed by "Welcome to the Machine", like there's a drop-off and its kind of just a slog. But they pick it back up with "Have a Cigar" and the title track is obviously a classic...I am so torn between a 4 and 5, because it's an awesome album and includes my favorite Pink Floyd song, but only has 5 songs and one of them I don't care for. I'll go 5 because we're on a heater of classic albums lately.
Liked it
I mean.
I tried to come up with a reason not to give this to a 5 and failed horribly.
4,5/5 - timeless classic. amazing artwork, could stare at it for hours.
A little self indulgent. With their other work, I'm not sure this belongs here. i used to love Shine on you crazy diamond, but lets see what else comes from this app.
Another flawless album.
4/5
My third favourite Pink Floyd album and still unutterably brilliant. Honestly you have to be a total psychopath not to absolutely adore this album.
Never been a Pink Floyd fan but enjoyed this and it might be the entry for me to listen to some more
Fine - I understand why people love this band.
a timeless masterpiece
extremely long songs, especially / more specifically shine on you crazy diamond, pts.1-5;6-9 the songs aren’t bad, just very long, which I feel like is a bittttt exaggerated but idk maybe it’s some lore of theirs which I haven’t understood yet. I really like the transition from wish you were here to shine on you crazy diamond, pts.6-9.
Was already in love with the song wish you were here so was cool to hear the rest of its album. Classic pink Floyd, long builds and random sounds that work. Have a cigar reminded me of Ronnie from work? None the less this is a 5/5.
"Welcome To The Machine" is very good, but something had to fall off to stick to my top 3 songs per album rule. This is meant to be enjoyed as an album, the 3 songs in the middle lose their luster if consumed as singles. An amazing experience, probably the "highest" 5 star rating so far (though I'm still at the beginning of my journey). Fav Tracks: Shine On You Crazy Diamond (all parts, 1-10) > Wish You Were Here > Have A Cigar Current Fav Album: Wish You Were Here - Pink Floyd (#11/1089)
What can i even say about pink floyd?
not long enough Can I give more stars?
Somehow i've never sat down and listened to this properly, even though it's iconic.
PERFECT Best Song: WYWH Love the album, very thematic although I needed to read about the context to appreciate it, which is fine. Love Have a Cigar and WYWH, balances Shine on... and makes the album more accessible. PERFECT
10/10 Amazing follow up to Dark Side, I loved the classic Floyd blend of psychedelic and progressive rock but also the bluesy feel. Sandwiching a few shorter songs between two (one technically??) epics felt like a great example of not sacrificing quality for quantity. I like that you can sit down for an hour and experience the album as a whole without distraction and how this allows you to feel the mood shift from dark to light. Vocals on wish you were here are amazing and you can really feel the deeply personal emotion while listening. Best song: Wish you were here Worst: None?? This is where PF peaked in my opinion everything, pace, structure, tone was beautifully crafted. This is the perfect album.
Instant 5/5
Amazing every song is amazing
It's been a while since I listened to all of Wish You Were Here and I remembered it being a solid 4/5. But relistening to it, it's actually even better than I remembered. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is way better than I remembered, Welcome to the Machine is fantastic, Have a Cigar is one of my all-time favourite Floyd songs and Wish You Were Here is absolutely beautiful. Zero filler even though Shine On You Crazy Diamond runs for 26 minutes in total, and I'm generally not a fan of extremely long tracks. I think I'd be lying to myself I gave this anything less than 5/5 when everything about it is so great. Even the cover art is iconic.
One of the best albums I've heard.
First Pink Floyd album! yesssssssssss. Not much left to say about this album that hasn’t already been said. Life changing piece of work both for those that made it and those that get to listen to it. SYD is just beautiful from top to bottom. The intro to this album is so etherial. Backstory, production, mastering, weight - all there. I still remember being slightly baked driving around my hometown as a lost 17 year old preparing for the unknown that comes after graduation of High School, I know you do too. Shine on, you crazy diamond. 10/10
Probably my favorite Floyd album and one I ritually came up to while tripping my freshman year of college. One of the most impeccably produced albums of all time with an insane story behind it (Syd visiting the studio while recording is an all timer).
The first time I listened to Pink Floyd, I ate a pretty large amount of mushrooms and listened to "Dark Side Of The Moon" while watching The Wizard of Oz. Well, it turns out all Pink Floyd albums feel exactly like that.
I really love this album. Even after high school, even after pot, I just like to put this one on.
Their best album in my opinion. The first from them that I've listened to where I didn't think that a few of the tracks could be dropped, or felt indifferent to. I like every song here. 5 Stars.
Yep, 5.
Legendary
This record is a masterpiece. I would argue that it’s their best and most inspired work. The subject matter is so personal and the music is perfectly executed. They’d found a perfect musical and lyrical balance and they captured everything perfectly. There’s just so much emotion packed into it and even in the parts without lyrics it shines through.
10/10. No notes.
One of the greatest albums of all time. Nuff said
Viisi biisiä? Näin ainakin aple musicissa. No joo. Psykorokkia. Elokuvasoundtrackmaista meininkiä. Ei tätä voi vihatakaan
Good vibes! I would play this in the background while doing something I really enjoy.
Can be a little laborious to get through Shine On but it has its high moments. And Wish You Were Here is one of the best songs ever written.
legends
This is a good one from start to finish. Enjoyed it.
Syd Barrett's story is very interesting to me. He basically fries himself with LSD to where his band, his best friends basically, can't stand him and leave him and eventually write an album, widely considered one of their best, about him. He shows up to the recording of the album and he's so far gone he can't even recognize that the album is about him. Stick to alcohol kids
Haven't listened to this one in years. I bet it holds up? So musically - the opening track has a 9 minute guitar solo to start, and then the song begins. That's a little much for me. But honestly - it mostly works! David Gilmour's playing is so expressive and lyrical. I don't even mind. And that riff that comes in at 4 minutes is excellent. The second round of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is a little less impressive to me, but it's pretty fun overall. The three "real" songs in the middle are all excellent musically. My main issue with this album is the theming. Wish You Were Here seems to be about Syd Barrett and the many pitfalls of the music industry. An industry I am not defending! But I'm sorry - am I supposed to empathize with a rock band that rose to stardom at a time when rock bands had a huge amount of creative control over their work, could make tons of cash from recording as well as touring, and were often seen as gods on Earth? "But I didn't like school!!!" Oh cry me a river, Roger. "THEY WANTED ME TO GET A JOBBBBB" Jesus. Get a grip. FOUR STARS
I’d never listened to Wish You Were Here (1975) in its entirety before. I’ll admit, I was immediately skeptical when I saw it’s just five tracks but 44 minutes, thanks to the Shine On You Crazy Diamond bookends. I was expecting another The Wall, which I thought was good but not great. Instead, what you get is something more akin to Dark Side of the Moon. This truly felt like a perfectly cohesive album. I don’t know if it’ll end up beating out Dark Side when I get there, but this has risen to the ranks of 5/5.
2/5 not the worst thing I've ever heard guitar parts and vocals were good but the generic use of synths got boring it felt like a 45-minute intro to a song but i appreciate what they where trying to do
Obviously 5/5. No notes.
Sick album
Not for me, need more lyrics. Love wish you were here tho
I enjoyed some of the instrumental jam type sequences throughout the first and closing songs. Nice to get lost a bit in the journey of that, but overall I found this album pretty boring and slow. I didn’t feel any stirring of emotions or feeling as I listened.
3/1089 no lyrics for the first 9 minutes but that doesn't matter at all. This album is amazing. Shine on you crazy diamond, all 9 parts, has been one of my favorite songs for over 30 years. Chills hit when this album starts. Hits...all of them.
I enjoyed this album. Very cohesive and reflective.
Fantastic
Outstanding tbh. Best prog rock I’ve heard. Crazy Diamond man fuck yes life is good.
Great synth, wish the vocals were less forced, I've heard it a hundred times so it's comfy
The synths on shine part 8/9
Classic
Wish Animals Were Here
album with excellent songs, very recommended!
Wat langdradig, maar nog best ok. 3/5
No notes
I like Pink Floyd but this was a bit much.
There is some interesting stuff here and I feel for them. It just really doesn't do it for me.
Depois dessa pedrada estou com medo do próximo
Top 3 Floyd album, probably a top 20 album ever for me. Not much else for me to say. Other than Wish You Were Here, which is still a great song, every other song rocks.
Even the really long songs were enjoyable.
This is an incredible album honestly. I would listen to it 1000 times more.
first one i've listened to on vinyl. an all-time favorite, no notes. rip syd
'Wish You Were Here's is not my favourite Pink Floyd album, but it is my favourite PINK FLOYD album, if you see what I mean. Obviously I STAN SYD and he is the creative genius/painter/martyr/legend whose name should always be marked in the history books next to this bands legacy. No amount of public bickering, name calling or general posturing on David Gilmore or Roger Waters part could ever see them bestowed with such titles. However, this fantastic album is testament to the groups collective creative powers in the absence of their seer of visions. It was not pioneering in any sense as far as I can tell - but find me a guitar solo which tells a story better than that in 'Shine On' and I'll eat Bela's copy of 'Piper'. Add 'Wish You Were Here' to that and you've already got five stars. The rest is a bonus. Which is why, for me, this is the classic PINK FLOYD album. It's straightforward storytelling so deeply meant that you can feel it in your bones. Syd was still shining in 1975.
high 5 pink floyd are so good you forget how proggy they are. im not saying its bad to be proggy, but usually when you listen to something proggy you just think, "wow this is proggy", with this album you just think "damn this good". How many 10 minute guitar solos are there where your on the edge of your seat the whole time?
Every time I go to listen to pink floyd I think this will be the time, but every time it just goes on and on. It all just feels so ploddy and strained. Shine on you crazy diamond is really good of course, pts 1-5 and 6-9, but everything in between I just can't get on board with
“Did they get you to trade your heroes for ghosts?” Professional frustration and personal grief entwined on record with each band member at their best. I would readily call this album perfect.
Good smooth rock album with clean vocals and instruments. While short I really like it. Not much else to add when its a old school rock album. A genre I listen to and have listened to a lot.
I fell asleep to this disc in the changer with 4 other PF albums more nights in college than I could possibly count.
Immediately said hell yeah when this one popped up! Perfection
One of the greatest of all time
Banger, culte, quoi dire de plus
Qu’est ce que vous voulez que je vous dise ?! Encore un album banger, un de mes préf de pink Floyd. D’ailleurs « wish you were here » est peut-être bien ma préférée. Elle n’est pas représentative de PF; elle est simple mais elle fonctionne sur moi. De longues chansons pour album assez court, c’est une vibe.
Quelques passages iconiques mais je suis pas le plus grand fan de pink Floyd, c'est un peu trop lent à mon goût. Ça reste très bon 4/5
Already listened to this one too sadly! One of the best albums ever created. From start to finish a work of art. Like a river flowing into the sea, each track seemlesly connects to the other. Though in isolation, each track can stand apart from the others successfully. So much raw emotion this album has pulled from me over the years, with special attention to the first Shine On and the title track. The chomping cynicism of Welcome to the Machine and Have a Cigar bites through to the aorta of capitalism, only to realize how poisonous that blood was. A masterpiece
One of Floyd's most iconic works, with memorable riffs and lyrics. A true masterpiece of prog rock
One of the greats by one of the greatest.
I’ve always been a Pink Floyd fan, and while this isn’t the album I personally reach for first, it’s hard to deny how powerful it is. You can hear a band wrestling with the weight of its own success, in a kind of creative vertigo. Dark Side of the Moon didn’t just make them famous; it rewired what they thought their careers were going to be. When you actually reach the summit you’ve been climbing toward for years, what’s left to push against? That tension saturates this album. The sessions famously drifted: long periods of aimlessness, experiments, jams, false starts, like they needed to exhaust every distraction before they could face what the record really wanted to be. And then it crystallized into something stark and vulnerable: a tribute, a longing, and a quiet admission that success can hollow you out if you’re not careful. “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” isn’t just a eulogy for Syd Barrett—it’s a mirror the band had to hold up to themselves. Wish You Were Here feels like the sound of a group trying to re-anchor their identity, trying to remember why they even started making music in the first place. It’s beautiful, yes, but not in a polished way. More like the beauty that comes from honesty after a long period of drifting. A band suffering from their own success, rediscovering purpose through grief, nostalgia, and a plea for connection.
Pretty sweet. It took a couple listens for me to come around on PF.
One of the best Pink Floyd albums out there. Shine on you crazy diamond is a fantastic prog psych rock song, and it makes up like half this album. Not much else to say. This album is great.
Hard to say a whole lot about a perfect album. When I'm not in the mood for the 25 minutes of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" I still have 3 of my top 5 Pink Floyd songs here. That being said, that 25 minutes is nearly perfect.
The best Pink Floyd album, pretty easily in fact. Its actually pretty crazy that an album that sounds like this is as big as it is. Fully deserved tho.
It took me 351 albums but I finally got a Pink Floyd album! Pink Floyd is probably my favourite band of all time. I’ve listened to all their albums countless times (yes, even The Endless River) and I love pretty much all of them. This album was never going to get less than 5 stars from me, it’s just incredible. They set an insane standard with Dark Side of the Moon and to follow it up with this, just wow! Interestingly, of the famous four album run of Dark Side, WYWH, Animals and the Wall, this one is possibly last for me. It’s a phenomenal album though and everyone shines on it(no pun intended).
I like this but it doesn’t totally personally connect for me… will prob revisit it in time!
ok like i hear the music, and I think its good. I like what im hearing... and this album is basically a Roger Waters album so i like it even more... but then i just have never understood the ppl who think floyd is the best band ever... like theyre good!!!! but idk
Would have rated higher if vocals were better. Great instrumentals.
(100/🤪💎💎💎💎💎💎)
Great driving music
They called this shit a concept album but didn’t even stick to a concept. & no, you’re 13 minute tracks aren’t impressive when they’re literally just four separate songs put into one long track. I like two Pink Floyd songs, they suck.
Who gives a shit?
Wish you were here is one of the all time tracks. Shine on you crazy diamond are also stellar. The album loses me a little through the middle with welcome to the machine, and have a cigar. I think it’s probably part of a broader concept. I don’t dislike those tracks, they just pale in significance. It may be a reflection of my attention span, or perhaps my generation more broadly, but there is a lot of ambient noodling on instruments that I find a little tedious. All in all, it’s a stark contrast to my day one Duck Rock. 4/5
Jakoś bardzo mnie to nie grzeje. Nie mój klimat, ale nie jest złe oczywiście.
Wow the electronic instrumentals sounds very dreamy and futuristic. very good background music though
Dope. No notes!
great
Flawless
The best Pink Floyd album, full stop.
Honestly don’t have anything to say about this one
The best Floyd album, with meditations on loss and the price of fame. The big question throughout: was it worth it? Pink Floyd equalled this several times, but they never surpassed it. The shimmering textures and expressive performances seem like they would feel self-indulgent, but instead there's an aching feeling. This is some of the finest rock music from the 1970s, and some of the finest music ever.
5 songs all really long, wish you were here carries
The thing about Pink Floyd is they take a lil while to start singing
lovely!!!!! i love a long song
Adore this album.
5/5 It's simply one of the greatest albums ever recorded. Won't say much more.
absolute best
Truly great album - proper ethereal!
Forget albums to listen to before you die… I want to listen to this one as I die. Please make this my life outro.
Riff of first track goes hard. And the “how I wish you were here” line
Welcome to the Machine is a very interesting song with some interesting instrument choices. Very cool. On the whole, it's not the most thrilling album, but it's certainly an interesting one. 3/5 stars.
A solid jam album with some classic hits
Tämä Pink Floydin levy oli minulle vieras, mutta on kyllä melkoinen helmi! 6/5 ja täytyy laittaa hankintalistalle.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Levyn alku oli vähän liian rauhallista vaikka kivoja kitara fiilistelyä mutta loppu olikin yhtä ilotulitusta loppuun saakka. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ei ole tämä bändi ikinä uponnut niin paljon kuin sen ehkä pitäisi. Kova levy kuitenkin.
I'm not a big Pink Floyd fan, I've found a lot of their albums pretty hard to get into or a bit boring. I think I like this one a bit more than most I've heard. It has a bit of a different style to it that I prefer Standouts Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Pts. I-V) 4/5
Classic album. Long moody tracks and a little bit self-indulgent, but enough great moments for core and more general fans.
One of the greatest easy-listening albums ever made. Oh, and Have a Cigar. 5/5
Hadn't listen to this album in its entirety before. Started slow and wasn't sure when it was gonna kick in. Gotta have been wild as a teenager in the 70s getting to the record store and queuing this up. Would've blown a lot of minds.
Not my favorite of theirs and yet it is still Pink Floyd. 3.7
Dare I give a 5 star??
the guitar tone on shine on you crazy diamond is so tasty. Those licks and riffs are delicious and the build up is so well crafted. Could listen to that song all day. Machine is a bit odd, I’ll grant ya that, but it goes hard. have a cigar is such a funky treat and wish you were here is the greatest platonic love song ever written
Fond memories of getting high as shit with Tyler and listening to this on Isaac's couch. Not the world's biggest Pink Floyd guy but this is definitely my favorite. Plus one for the nostalgia piece.
I always wrote this album off for the songs being too long. I don't think you could fairly say I was too wrong. Banger
Me gusta mucho. Creo que empiezo a entender esta gente. Se parecen mas al jarre o a vangelis que a otras cosas
The birth of chill. One of Pink Floyd's Big Four. Perfection
I just cannot swallow this attempt at emotion, it rings so hollow and trite to me.
this album feels like unc popped a tab around the campfire and started telling you about the good ol days
Too long and boring but my god those guitar tones
I'm familiar with most of these songs but I'm not sure I've ever actually listened through. It was a great one to settle into. So much going on and still feels so self-assured in its style.
Who knew songs could be over ten minutes and good! Very interesting perspective that this record really only has five songs, but is still one of Pink Floyd’s defining works. It’s just not my personal favorite of theirs. Best Track: Wish You Were Here
A few songs--and one of my favourite Floyd songs, "Wish You Were Here"--embedded in a symphonic prog rock elegy that somehow transcends its longwinded excess. Or maybe that's the point. Really sad. Not a real Pink Floyd enthusiast, but I used to play a tape of this in my walkman to fall asleep every night during one particularly angsty phase.
Classic. Love all the soaring moments, but the end just seemed to be phoned in.
It’s hard to listen to this with fresh ears since, amazingly enough, all the songs are classic rock radio staples. And PF have always been too ponderous and self-important for my tastes. But they also had a keen sense for melody and the guitar work and arrangements can be stunning.
this one is a classic
Great performances and atmosphere. Felt a little samey to other Floyd stuff I've heard in the part though
really long but enjoyable journey, looking forward to the others
I love this intro so much. Textures + synth sound are perfect. That clean compressed guitar lead. Oof the chord changes. There are few more iconic 4 note figures in the history of music than this guitar part. The first time I really listened to this record I was dog/house-sitting for my friend's dad, and he had a huge speaker set up in his basement. Perfect way to experience this record. It is also amazing on headphones though. Welcome to the Machine is absolutely massive. The way the synths climb! Roy Harper on vocals on Have A Cigar. Listen to 'Forever' if you haven't heard his own work! Wish You Were Here. One of the first songs I learned on guitar. Classic, beautiful, a hit for a reason. I've come to realize that this is my favourite Pink Floyd record. It's still sprawling and epic like some of their earlier stuff, but when the songwriting really kicks in, it's precise and beautiful. Guitar work is amazing and synths are otherworldly.
I’m a big Pink Floyd fan so have listened to this album countless times over the years. Love them and love this.
Is this the best pink Floyd album ever I think it could be. I think it's certainly the one that I would keep if I could only keep one
It's not really my thing as a whole, but it was perfectly enjoyable. It just doesn't engage me that much....... and then Wish You Were Here starts. There are very few songs this emotionally powerful. It's up amongst the absolute best, especially knowing the story of Syd Barrett. I try hard not to let a single song influence the overall score too much, but this makes every other moment of the album worth it.
Pretty cool, but not as good as Dark Side of the Moon. Liked the instrumental sections and the electronic aspects. Favorite Track: Wish You Were Here
Really liked this — started off poorly because I wasn’t open-minded wrt the intro but picked up throughout the project
Amazing
Yeah, I like it! Didn't expect that. This is slightly more subdued Pink Floyd? Not too spacey, not too weird, good vocals. Yeah, nice.
Great!!
I’ve loved wish you were hear since I first heard the song in middle school. Been a while since I’ve listened to the whole album. Wonderful.
A solid, but overrated Pink Floyd album
5 ⭐
> dark side
On continuous play.
Another great band! Great music, unique sound. Music spans generations.
nicht wirklich meins, hab mir halt nirgends gedacht wow wie cool
The individual tracks were quite long and didn’t really grab my attention but nonetheless a decent album
Interesting album. I love the way David Gilmore plays those solos on guitar. My favorite? Wish you Were Here! This is when I pick up my acoustic and follow along with the music.
Probably the best prog album ever made
9.5/10
not everything on this album is perfect for me But Wish you were here now is great
Best of the big 3
they were kinda dragging it a bit too much...a couple of good songs a couple of bad ones
Wow. I never really sat down and listened to Pink Floyd. This was quite a journey. The tracks are long but don’t feel like they drag on. The production is perfect and every note feels immaculately placed (even the sexy sax solo!). I’m looking forward to hearing more from them.
One of THE albums for me. Perfect in every way. One of the few albums I rate six out of five.
Syd Barrett had been out of Pink Floyd for six years by the time the band reconvened at Abbey Road Studios to attempt the impossible: following up 'The Dark Side of The Moon'. The 1973 hit record had brought Pink Floyd kicking and screaming into the mainstream rock world, a newfound status the band were never comfortable with, and would eventually bring about the capitulation of the group's classic era in the mid-1980s. So, with a lot of pressure on the band to follow up what has since become one of the most important records ever made, what did they do? They ruminated on "the madcap laughs" they once shared with their former bandmate. 'Wish You Were Here' is Pink Floyd at their most solemn and introspective: using the example of Syd Barrett's mercurial genius and descent into madness to craft an unbelievable work of art that, in my view, betters and outshines 'The Dark Side of the Moon' in every respect. 'Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Pts 1 & 2) is a seminal menagerie of synthesized transcendence (courtesy of Richard Wright), explorative guitar (courtesy of David Gilmour), epic percussion (courtesy of Nick Mason) and an extraordinarily dense concept (courtesy of Roger Waters). This is, bar none, one of the greatest pieces of popular music ever recorded, and easily Pink Floyd's finest 25 minutes of tape. And yet, they still find time to attack the music industry ('Welcome to the Machine'), call out greedy executives ('Have a Cigar') and lament on the loss of Syd from their tribe ('Wish You Were Here'). Pink Floyd leaves no stone unturned here. They do it all with intensity, fury, parody and sadness. Syd Barrett actually showed up during the recording sessions for 'Wish You Were Here': overweight, with a shaved head and eyebrows: and the band, initially not recognising him, were greatly emotional once they put two and two together. He said 'Shine On' "sounds a bit old", engaged in more awkward conversation on and off, and was out of their lives again, never to return to the fray of Floyd. 'Dark Side' may be Floyd's most iconic album, but 'Wish You Were Here' is their true masterpiece: a sprawling achievement steeped in sadness, reflection, anger and higher thought. It's the perfect culmination of Pink Floyd's transcendental journey up to this point, but also paves the way for Waters' growling megalomania and distrust of authority that would manifest on the group's next two releases. Best songs: Who listens to a Floyd album for a particular song? Hilarious!
Another where another opinion on this one isn't going to make much difference. I like this album, I was later to it than other Pink Floyd big albums but now really love it
The third best Pink Floyd album.
Approaching its 50th anniversary in a few weeks and this still sounds fresh and interesting. A true classic.
Firstly, I’ve never liked “Welcome to the Machine”, which, given its length and the fact that it’s one of only five songs, is a lot to overcome. Secondly, although I like everything else, I differ from the mindset that others have shared so far: for me, it’s absolutely no contest between this and Dark Side, which is as five-star an album as five stars can be in my book. Pink Floyd isn’t even one of my absolute favorite artists (they probably wouldn’t crack my top 50, at least), but Dark Side has always sounded like sheer perfection to me, whereas WYWH has always “merely” been an album I really like. I think “Have a Cigar” is cool as hell, SoYCD is a hell of a composition (I particularly love parts 1-5), and though I may have suffered from burnout in the title track at one point in my life, I’ve come back around to having no issues with it (and thinking it’s a gorgeous, flawless song). As always for Floyd, the performances are nothing short of stellar, and if someone were to argue that it was the emotional apex of their catalog, I wouldn’t disagree at all (if anyone is somehow still unaware of the story surrounding this record, it’s well worth your time to read up on it). It’s just not my preferred album of theirs, or in general. Undoubtedly a 5-star achievement that, in this horrific game of applying a stupid fucking number to assess personal enjoyment, is a high 4 stars for me. 4/5
What a 5 breathtaking 5
Love it