Reviews (page 9 of 16)
While my rating will show 5 stars. I’m rating it 4.99, I have to deduct something for that sax solo on Shine On You Crazy Diamond Pt1. This the first time listening to this album in some time. An enjoyable listen.
a little less accessible than Dark Side or The Wall, but just as epic and well-built.
Perfect
Eigentelch send alli lieder no zemlech geil, dör das dass sie jedoch huere lang send wärdes ergendeinisch au chli langwiilig. För e Hendergrond esch es aber super.
It’s just perfect. Handily a greatest album of all time contender.
This is a top 3 Pink Floyd album of all time. Not a single miss. Every song seems to build on the one before it with a crescendo in the final minutes of Wish You Were Here. Then it lulls you into a feeling of relaxation in the first few minutes of Shine On to raise you up again and say farewell.
One of the best prog albums ever. I semi understand the hype, although it's not one of my favorite genres. 9/10
I don’t think there’s anything left to say about this album. Pink Floyd is one of my favorite bands and this album is a masterpiece.
With the weight of public opinion so dreadfully pitched the other way, I’ll just have to wear the accolade of “most tedious contrarian” when I say that “Wish you were here”, one of the 20th century’s most popular and regarded songs, does Pink Floyd a disservice. For the longest time – 35 and a half years plus “Shine on …” and a minute of “Welcome to the machine” – I thought that Pink Floyd was essentially “The Wall” and milquetoast soft rock (would we say pumice?). You have to laugh. Or, more accurately, you have to join the millions before you who, hearing “Welcome to the machine” for the first time, had sat and felt the synths slicing through their matter; calved as the down stroked acoustic guitar startled them into an alertness that, with a simple vocal harmony, so quickly becomes transcendental; rising, rising; back down to the interminable throb of the machine’s whirring engine. And all of that over the course of about a minute. (Note: a quick search reveals I’m not alone in hearing Stranger Things’ theme here… but it’s a small club!) This album puts me in my mind of early Mars Volta, contemporaneous Steely Dan (I’d imagine there was some mutual admiration going on) among others – a good mind to be put into. “Wish you were here”? Nah, still a bit fusty for me. The rest of it? Fucccckkkkkkkkkk…
So far the streak has been absolutely incredible. I absolutely love Pink Floyd and have been a fan before taking on this challenge. I love WYWH, although its probably not my favorite Pink Floyd album and I dont always want to listen to "Have a Cigar" and "Wish you were here" (because I've listened to it so many times already) I absolutely love "Shine on you crazy diamond" and "Welcome to the machine". Even if lyrically I am still a bit uncertain to which degree the latter resonates with me, musically I adore every second of it. This is an absolutely definite and easy 5/5.
Rare to find an album where each song is a five star banger. I know it helps there are only 5 songs. This is my 3rd favorite Pink Floyd album, you'll never guess 1 and 2.
Such a legendary record
Excellent! Absolutely loved it!
Pink Floyd is that constrained my any typical song structure or even album structure. When I listen to a 10+ minute song from a jam band or a prog rock group, I get bored. It sounds like they are wasting my time. But when Pink Floyd does it, I understand why each minute of the song is important. I understand where it's going, and why the full progression is needed for the full impact.
One of the greatest of all time
A few cool moments. But mostly just boring.
Calming. Bit weird, but I really enjoyed it.
What is there to say about this album? Absolutely formative in my development as a music listener and a musician. Nostalgic beyond belief. Without a doubt in my top albums of all time. My wife and I still use "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" as our headphone and speaker test song. An album that defines timeless.
4.5/5, such a tight album with some all time songs, great story and commentary, only thing is the last song takes slightly too long
It’s all about Syd, right? “Shine on…” is famously about him, but hearing all the other songs bookended with “shine on” got me thinking the album is a love letter.
I can tell that there’s artistry here but not for me
An all-timer from the prog rock masters during their peak. None of their other albums can top Dark Side of the Moon, but this comes close, along with The Wall. But that one is so goddamn depressing to listen to, at least this one has a few fun moments amid the darkness. And by that I basically just mean their one fun kinda upbeat song that's still a funky, cynical take on music industry executives. But some of the Shine on You Crazy Diamond sections are fun, too. And though the title track is a somber, melancholic statement on the loss of Syd Barrett, it always struck me as hopeful or at least, accepting of that loss and not in any of the other stages of grief. There's a reason it was rated #18th best rock song of all time; I'd never rank it that high, but people def respond to it. Pink Floyd's early albums are more fun and weird, and their later stuff is less than stellar but their peak concept album phase is them at their best, and this album fires on all cylinders. It's a more than worthy follow up to Dark Side of the Moon, but I will add that I actually play Animals and Atom Heart Mother more than this album. The songs on those two albums are more enjoyable/easier to relisten to than these, at least to me. But I'm sure part of that is having way more fatigue with this album from classic rock radio growing up. Wish You Were Here is a better album than either of those two, though its inclusion on this list is interesting. The Wall is probably more popular/has a bigger cult following and DSOTM is an all-timer, so I'd expect those two to make it over this. But it's not a bad pick!
Must have really been something to have Led Zeppelin and Pink Floyd making new music at the same time. Wish You Were Here reminded me of Animals, which I adore! Have a Cigar is a trip.
I know I should like this more, but I just...don't?
Devastating. Unless I want a good cry, I’m not putting this on..so that complicates the ranking. But god it just oozes emotion.
very sweet of them to dedicate a whole album to their best friend who went insane
Needs no explanation
Amazing. I'm happy this was suggested - I haven't listened to it since the first time I heard it five years ago. I'm happy this album made its way back to me.
This was good overall! I think the musicianship and production were fantastic, they really created a vibe that was compelling by and there were ebbs and flows through the album. I think I didn’t “get” a lot of it though, with the many parts and lack of an overall message in a lot of it. Its again not really my taste, and also I think I have heard other Pink Floyd songs that were more my speed.
ABSOLUTE CINEMA
This album on repeat man! Love how the album starts and ends with “Shine on”, makes it into a story or journey. “Welcome to the machine” and “Have a cigar” are great biting parodies/criticisms. But musically not that special. “Whish you were here” is very special, pretty emotional song to me.
Absolute classic
Certainly one of the all time great album. This record has a dear place in my heart and reminds me of my best friend and his cool ass dad who introduced me to Pink Floyd as a kid. A ten star record.
I can’t comment on this because it is one of my all-time go-to favourite albums. Automatic 5-er.
Faworyt, do którego chętnie wracam
hooooly
hell yeah
Brilliance. Tenderness. I love this album, always have but it makes me sad for Syd's demise.
It's an epic tale that's best when accompanied by visuals from a show. I can listen to a few of the songs over and over, but for the majority, they float around into the background.
Complexity arises from simple elements. Those simple elements in the right hands create sublime compounds.
Oh look! A Few Lines of Code told my brain to manipulate my pocket-sized supercomputer into playing one of the best sequences of sonic vibration in the short history of recorded music, thank you A Few Lines of Code!
2nd favorite Pink Floyd album after Dark Side
Good album, not as good as dark side. Have a cigar and to a lesser extent Welcome to the machine feel a bit forced and clunky. Shine on 1-5 and Wish you were here are all time great songs.
Absolut classical album that keeps getting better and better with every listening
A timeless classic, that always brings me joy to listen to. I cannot tell which Pink Floyd album fullfills me the most, but second to "Animals" this is probably on the top.
I listened this Album on Eastern Holiday with my kids (6 and 7 yo) while we were building Lego. The album supported perfectly atmosphere. The non typical musical instruments, like the clock sound, caught their curiosity and kept them calm and concentrate. "Wish you were here" is definitely on my list for children.
I am not the right demographic for this record. What others love about this, I really don't like. This is only 44 minutes long, but my god. I feel like those 44 minutes warped and expanded somehow. A lot of these songs fail to really get going. I am far too sober and it is way too early in the morning for me to appreciate this. Ok--now to the songs: Shine on you crazy diamond (pts 1-5): wow. Way too long. Nothing interesting happens, there's some singing, then it is all wrapped up with god awful saxophone. Not compelling. Sax can be grating. Welcome to the machine: why is there so much synth on this record? I can totally see why there are Pink Floyd laser shows. I suddenly feel like watching bladerunner or a clockwork orange. Have a cigar: this one is a little more promising than the rest. It's also the shortest. It's still kinda boring. Wish you were here: west coast country meets synth. I'm glad I'm not "here." Shine on you crazy diamond (pts 6-9): oh good, there's more! And this time, it's screechy. I feel like I'm trapped in a boomer's garage while he plays records from his youth, drinks brown liquor, and waxes poetic about his college years. Get me out of here!
can not give less then 5 stars for the album with the best song by pink floyd (shine on you crazy diamond)
Not my cup of tea, but it’s a great album. Very good!
As near to perfect as albums get. It’s pretty hard to put down in words just how great this album is, but it’s Floyd firing on all cylinders: Wright’s delicate build up of synths during the intro and outro tracks, Waters’ acerbic lyrics, Gilmour’s unmistakable guitar doing unspeakable things, and Mason’s rock steady rhythm keeping it all together. Nestled amongst this, one of the most beautifully heartfelt songs ever written about their former band mate. It’s a good one this.
An album about loss and disillusionment and a critique of the music business (which by this point has made them millionaires). It is as prog rock tends to be; ponderous, self-indulgent and self-importantly sententious. It is also beautiful in its way and very much of its time, in terms of the soundscape. It has the trademark atmospheric sound effects, overlong solos and some creative chord work from Rick Wright (always my favourite band member). It’s two shortest tracks, the title track and Have A Cigar with Roy Harper singing lead are the best tracks. As always with Floyd in this period I wonder what they thought would happen if they ever broke above their walking pace slow rock tempo. At least 50% of Nick Mason’s career is spent playing the same beat at the same speed! I also wish Rick Wright had played more piano and less plastic sounding synth. Overall the creative concepts are, well, creative, but they do sound a bit tired and lacking in energy and and commitment.
Very 70s, I didn't like it much
A beautifully progressive mixture of just enough rock, contemplative atmosphere and striking lyrics.
Sounds like guitar and saxophone and a little alien feel. Reminds me of animusic. A little Beatly. Short album. Also reminds me of Alan Parsons.
This album's a real pleasure. I was particularly struck by the mix of synths and analogue instruments on Welcome to the Machine, still managing to sound quite contemporary to me, despite being 50 years old! Amazing foresight, continuing influence, or mere coincidence of the neverending roundabout of musical fashion: you decide!
I enjoyed the single, but the other tracks were not my thing.
Pink Floyd's best album (in my opinion) and one of my favorite albums of all time. A flawlessly executed work. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is genuinely one of the greatest songs ever conceived, and all other songs except Welcome to the Machine slap (it's not bad, I just don't really like the vocals, and the synths are a bit too much). It's not quite a 10/10 for me since “smooth” music like this is not really my thing and I like something more energetic, but it's extremely close. I'm totally nitpicking, by the way. It's a phenomenal album, but it doesn't suit my tastes as well as some others. 9/10
Solid and unique music style. Definitely shows psychedelic rock’s origin in blues music. Too short and nothing really stuck out to me. The Wall is much more of a fun listen.
Very experimental/trippy album - honestly think I liked that more than the actual songs. Regardless, overall a great album and definitely solidifies the vibe of the mid 1970s. 4/5
4.7- Beautiful instrumentation. Key changes, tempo adjustments, the harmonies, it’s all masterful. In my opinion, this album was created for the ears of other musicians. There’s so much happening and so much to acknowledge as well as appreciate, but it’s not too much where you get overwhelmed. HIGHLY recommended headphones. The only thing I’d take off for is the lack of actual vocals, but that’s just Pink Floyd. It’s experimental and can’t be everybody’s cup of tea… like all music. My favorite song was “Have a Cigar”
This is an old friend. In coming back after a long time, it reveals details and textures I didn't originally pick up on or know about. I really like the way Waters' more chunky disco funk, (my attempt to describe it), is sandwiched between Gilmour's more atmospheric space blues. The moment the electric Rhodes comes in for the last few sections of Diamond was and still is a real treat for those familiar with the song but not the full album version. Really, this all hits harder for me now than it ever once did.
Найкращий їхній альбом
10/10
mmmm classic. Have a Cigar is one of my fave Pink Floyd songs. 4.5
Pre-lisrening, this is an album I enjoy. And not just because of weed. This listen was no different. A good example of a complete album rather than a collection of songs on an album.
Pink Floyd ought to be a wonder of the world, given that they followed up Dark Side with this, which is also perfection. Amazing production, great playing, deep songs. "Shine On" is so good it fully deserves nine parts. "Have a Cigar" and "Welcome to the Machine" are equally disturbing and powerful. The title cut is easily one of the top few songs ever penned/performed – heartbreaking, beautiful, an anthem for deathbeds. Their massive commercial success was well deserved; every once in a while, the market gets it right.
3 minutes of ok music, 40 minutes of synth mats, and boring guitar solos. Will never get Pink floyd.
Das Album Wish You Were Here wurde 1975 in den Abbey Road Studios in London aufgenommen. Die britische Rockband Pink Floyd, bestehend aus David Gilmour, Roger Waters, Richard Wright und Nick Mason, knüpfte mit diesem Werk an den Erfolg des Vorgängeralbums The Dark Side of the Moon an. Es zählt zum Bereich des Progressive Rock, wobei auch Elemente von Psychedelic und Artrock eingeflossen sind. Inhaltlich bezieht sich das Album vor allem auf die Entfremdung im Musikgeschäft sowie auf die psychische Abwesenheit des früheren Bandmitglieds Syd Barrett. Dies wird besonders in dem zweiteiligen Stück „Shine On You Crazy Diamond“ deutlich, das als eine Art musikalische Würdigung Barretts gilt. Der Titeltrack „Wish You Were Here“ wurde über die Jahre hinweg zu einem ihrer bekanntesten Lieder und zeichnet sich durch seine zurückhaltende Instrumentierung und emotionale Direktheit aus. Auch „Welcome to the Machine“ und „Have a Cigar“ greifen zentrale Themen wie Enttäuschung, Zynismus und Kritik an der Musikindustrie auf. Die Produktion zeigt einen klaren, durchdachten Klangaufbau, der oft ruhige Passagen mit experimentellen Elementen verbindet. Dabei bleibt die Atmosphäre des Albums über weite Strecken melancholisch und nachdenklich. Wish You Were Here ist ein ruhiges, durchdachtes Werk, das sich mit persönlichen und gesellschaftlichen Themen auseinandersetzt. Durch seine konzeptionelle Dichte und die musikalische Ausarbeitung bleibt es ein prägender Bestandteil des Repertoires von Pink Floyd.
Finally! Probably the closest anyone ever has come to perfection! This album means a lot to me and it's probably my favourite of all time!
Outstanding
6 songs isn’t enough. Only reason it’s not 5 stars
Beautiful music! 5+++++
This album is modern day classical music! Pure genius! The transitions within the songs tug at your emotions and have you yearning for the next note to be played. Every song is a masterpiece! Gilmour’s guitar is a master class in guitar playing! Entire album is just clean and flawless! How does a band follow up one of the greatest albums of time? They create Wish You Were Here! Arguably one the greatest albums of all time!
Epic , but even more epic listening to it for its epicness. Every song interwoven together to tell a story about Syd Barrett
No words
Canny this. Started slow, a bit Dire Straitsy for my liking, but picked up. Have a Cigar was my favourite, possibly bringing back nostalgia from a compilation I had as a kid that had a Foo Fighters cover of it. Can’t see me returning, but it was good. I think I preferred one of the other ones we had, but the fact I cant remember which one it was proves I probably wont be back
Normally I can't see the appeal of Pink Floyd but I have to concede this was great. The dark bladerunnery sound worked so well. Being light on vocals seemed to put the focus on interesting music and 44 mins for a prog album is a good length, felt just right. Even the bass sounded like it was at the right level. 4.5, will listen again.
I know the main songs from the album, and re-listened a few times to solidify my thoughts. Incredibly influential - I can hear Dire Straits on Part 1, I can hear Daft Punk in places, I can even hear Shakira mid-way through Part 3. Thrilling throughout. I do have this unfair view of Pink Floyd associated with a bald, biker-jacket wearing, pool ace from the AJ, who ruined our ownership of the pool table on Fridays between 2011 and 2014. This album is a bit of a work of art. All of the meandering leads somewhere - very little cyclical repetition, plenty of interesting riffs and solos, and I love the sound of the guitar. Pretty timeless, sounds considerably more recent than 1975.
Another great pink Floyd album, I almost think the album art is just as iconic as dark sides.... It's the one that I remember being most interested by as a kid. Shine on (both tracks) and wish you were here are the best bits here. I remember listening as a teenager and being amazed that I had to wait so long for the song to get going, I'm more patient now! I think dark side is better, but still 5
Classic PF.
All timer
Pink Floyd… more like….. Pink Floyd. am I right
Not a huge Floyd fan, but Have a Cigar and Wish You Were Here have always been good songs. So pretty easy to listen to this album
This is the first time I've listened to Wish you were Here since probably 1995 in its entirety. My Dad was/ is a big fan so I heard this album and the radio edit singles all the time as a kid. It's a great album but I can't go over 3 stars. My main criticism is that for all its jazzy pretensions ithe playing doesn't really blow you away. They were a great band and I appreciate their work but this doesn't hold up well for me.
How do you follow Dark Side of the Moon - Like this! Awesome!
man this rocks
This album is one of my constant and beloved musical companions. I first heard it in 1977 in my then new peer group - I was the New Kid on The Block - and was immediately hooked. I've been listening to the album ever since. I wouldn't have to listen to it at the moment as part of the project. The last time was not long ago. But, hey, why not? There's always time for great music. 5/5
Stone cold classic. Not a bad song in the bunch. Favorite: Wish You Were Here Would I listen to it again: Yes
All the stars. A great album and piece of musical composition. Gilmour plays the shit of that guitar throughout. the title track is a quintessential rock crowd pleaser, the diamonds are wandering, expansive and sad odes to their founder and a descent into a complicated mind. Have a cigar is a brilliant skewer of the music industry and welcome to the machine gives me terrible anxiety. I will day that I've always been surprised and impressed at the popularity of Floyd across the general population. The music is a lot weirder than most people.
I like lyrics man. This was painful for me actually I'm not a patient person
I love Pink Floyd and a lot of these songs are awesome. However it also contains a song I’ve always disliked “welcome to the machine”. I hate the droney nature of it. Overall a great listen
⭐ Review: 4.9/5 Spacey Existential Gut-Punches This album isn’t here to entertain you. It’s here to haunt you, hug you, and then gently whisper, “Remember when things meant something?” It’s only 5 tracks long, but somehow feels like a decade of your life flashing before your eyes while you stand in the rain at an abandoned carnival.
Amazing album. Of an an age with this classic
No to jest klasyk. Chociaż ja mam problem z progresywnym rockiem i utworami, które trwają rok. Mimo tego Wish you were here jak w liście przebojów trójki: u mnie wysoko, bo to piękny, pełen emocji utwór. 7/10.
Great journey all the way through
It’s not a bad album. But you know how time flies when you’re having fun? This album feels like every song takes half an hour (which it probably does…)
En bra vändning för pink floyd, att ha fyra låtar gör det mycket mer fokuserat.
a ouvir. PF é muito chato mas pode ser q mude de ideia
Overall it has a strong take on the instrumentals and feels like a ride to listen. However, lyrically feels very weak apart from the popular boy wish you were here
Never been able to get into PF. Nothing really wrong with the music. It just lacks something. No doubting the vision. This just sounds like it could be a soundtrack to Shoestring.
This album is a loving tribute to Syd Barrett (an ex bandmate who was forced to leave after continued use of LSD) which reflects how the band felt about him even after they hadn't seen him for years. The instrumentals are incredible with expert use of synths and incredible guitar riffs and solos. Everything just comes together creating one of Pink Floyd's best albums.
Wish You Were Here is the only Pink Floyd song I enjoy. This record did not change my feelings on that. I skipped ahead through most of these tracks. Even when I got stoned I hated this.
Listening to this is like “…are we sure Dark Side is really the best Pink Floyd album?” Because god damn is it an album of sheer perfection. Those without the patience for the opening and closing tracks are simply wrong. This is one of the easiest 5-star ratings I’ve given out yet. Must-listen #110.
Amazing
forever a classic :)
Very good
Ethereal I would say. I understand why it's on this list now. Pink Floyd is a legend for a reason. It's pretty cool to listen to this
The 70s were a wild time for music and these guys really pushed it. The production is remarkable and the patience required of the listener basically forces you to smoke a j, sit back and relax. Not a radio friendly unit shifter: but then Wish You Were Here pops up and shows that they have the ability to drop an absolute banger in amongst the jams. Remarkable.
Absolute classic of my teenage years. First listen in quite a while and still holds up really well, which is more than can be said for anything Pink Floyd put out after this one. Had forgotten how excellent the second half of Shine on you Crazy Diamond is in particular.
★★★★★★
This is a night album - it just hits harder after dark. I'm very familiar with Wish You Were Here, but it took me 3 tries to listen this time because I kept falling asleep before Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Pts. 1-5) even finished. It puts me in such a relaxed, meditative state; it's like a spell. I had incredibly restful sleep each time this happened. But I finally managed to stay awake for the whole thing, and it's as brilliant as ever. I don't love it as much as Dark Side, but that's a tall order. This album is so deliciously atmospheric, and it makes me feel like I've found refuge on some habitable planet after being lost in space for ages. Maybe there's no other life to be found, but at least there's solid ground and an opportunity to rest. To breathe fresh air. It's lonely, but there's music because I can still sing. There's curiosity for what comes next, and that fuels the will to continue on.
Three of the greatest songs ever written sandwiched in-between two of the greatest instrumentals ever. It's pretty good
It's Pink Floyd. It's one of their best albums. You are reading this. Do the math.
my top 3 favorite album of all time, a piece of fucking art. this album has the perfect runtime, perfect tracklist, perfect production, perfect writing, perfect vocals, perfect concept... perfect everything. it’s just 5 tracks, but all 5 are among my favorite songs ever. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is probably my favorite song of all time. no words for how good this is. the concept hits just as hard as the music. it’s about absence, alienation, the coldness of the music industry, and of course, Syd Barrett. but what makes it even greater is how universal it feels. Wish You Were Here doesn’t only mourn Syd, it provokes sadness for anyone you’ve lost. musically it’s unmatched. the guitar riffs are iconic. the synths on Welcome to the Machine feel like pure ascension, wrapping you in dread and wonder. starting and closing with Shine On You Crazy Diamond is genius it gives the whole album a cyclical, eternal feeling. Wish You Were Here itself is an anthem, both intimate and massive. Have a Cigar is the fun moment in the middle, but still sharp in its satire of greedy record execs plus it holds one of the best guitar solos ever. the acoustic playing is gorgeous, the electric work is pure genius. David Gilmour’s tone and feel are untouchable. every note is placed with so much emotion it hurts. in my opinion this is the most perfect album ever made.
5 - mastapiece although the send half of shine on wasn’t my favorite
I was took on a journey through time. This album feels like a nice drive on a Sunday. A walk through nature or a 70s movie. This album brought me some peace and I plan on buying this record on vinyl.
This is what listenable prog rock sounds like. Experimental within cohesive concepts and overarching themes. This isn't an all-the-time album for me but there's plenty to love from the inspired reflections in the lyricism, fantastic use of early synthwork, and epic overtones.
It's alright. Dreamy. No stand out song
Discazo, increíble
"Wish You Were Here" may not be the most memorable album of Pink Floyd's career, but it is still very well appreciated for its cohesion in terms of production and lyrics. It falls a little short of the band's great albums, but it is still an excellent work.
Is this sacrilegious? Cool album but probably wouldn't turn it on myself
Not a bad tune on it! One of my all time favorites and it flows like a novel! "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is an epic song with depth, insight and substance. "Wish You Were Here" is pushing a Billion Listens! Every song on here has over 70M listens which is a testament to it's longevity and popularity. Half the album still gets airplay on FM and streaming radio. You can't knock the musicianship, the influence and the popularity. This album deserves a spot in the Top 1001 for sure. 4 solid stars.
Another album I'd already listened to... Oh well, at least this one is great. Pink Floyd can be pretty hit and miss for me, but this record and Meddle are pretty undeniable. A beautiful sendoff to one of 60s rock's most mercurial figures. Sometimes I feel like this album sacrifices immediacy for atmosphere, but then I bowled over by the gorgeous melodies both acoustic and synthesized. Great record
Yellow
I don't think i can say anything that hasn't been said about this album. Opening and closing of AWESOME rock music - coupled with some of the greatest albums ever. 5/5. Pink Floyd is undeniably one of the greatest bands of all time. No questions asked.
Didn’t enjoy this as much as I’d have thought. Quite alternative 6/10
Beautiful album
Immaculate first half, great overall atmosphere
Approx. 10 years ago, Wish You Were Here was one of the few songs I learned how to fully play during my short stint as a guitar player
I don't really like Dark Side of the Moon. It's similar to that. YES I DONT KNOW EITHER
One of my favourite Pink Floyd albums. The entire album is brilliant, and I remember listening to the album in its entirety on the radio the night before it went on sale and I was completely blown away.
Yep this is still my favorite Pink Floyd album.
This is a nice follow up to Dark Side of the Moon. Super mellow and slow burning. Not my favorite Pink Floyd album, but it does have two of my favorites, Have a Cigar and the title track. I love the cover art. Normally, I'd give their albums a 5, but this gets a 4. The songs are too long, yet the album is too short. Not sure if that makes sense. I want more.
I listened to this late at night, in bed with headphones, in the dark. I probably shouldn't have because it was so late; I should have been sleeping. I figured I'd listen to a little before I nodding off, but once the album started, I was enthralled and made it through to the end, and I'm glad. This really is a complete and cohesive album that deserves to be listened to in its entirety. The songs flowed into each other with seamless, quirky transitions, kind of like Monty Python sketches linking one into the next. And I'm glad I got to listen to it so attentively, in bed, with my eyes closed. It was an incredible experience, and I could really focus on the simple lyrics that hit so hard on multiple levels. And I could focus on each little detail of sound, recorded so cleanly and clearly--yet still with human warmth--as it sparked feelings and images in my mind. It felt like a musical painting, with all sorts of sounds expertly evoking colors, shadings, dimensions, coming together not in the usual drums, bass, and guitar way, the usual verse-chorus-verse way, but in something more abstract yet vivid, precise, and deliberate. The creation of mood and atmosphere, the moments of beauty undercut with tension, and the often surprising audio techniques at times gave me chills. Is this because of the music itself or because I wasn't trying to listen to it while washing dishes or following GPS something, like I often do? Probably both. In any case, it is inspiring me to try to slow down and carve out some quieter time for some of these albums when I can.
Another great one by Pink Floyd. Those four notes in Shine On You Crazy Diamond are iconic. Wish You Were Here is such a great song. Just another solid album from these guys.
While I do think this band is overhyped occasionally, I can’t deny the brilliance of this record. Shine On has to be one of the greatest songs and guitar solos ever written, and it is captivating from start to finish.
weird but the actual title song is good
The title track is the best one on the album. Enjoyed this a lot, but for me it fell just a bit short of the transcendent experience of Dark Side of the Moon.
now this is podracing
Can it ass whole
Amazing songs/moments that still hold up even after being played a ton on the radio; best experienced as full album.
When the chorus on the title track hits... hoo boy...
This used to be my favorite Pink Floyd album, but I've come to discover Animals and Meddle, and it leaves this album paling in comparison. Still, their best that the generator has to offer, for sure.
Wish You Were Here – Pink Floyd – 5/5 A timeless classic that I first listened to in high school, and it still holds up as one of the greats. The album is a reflection on loss, alienation, and the downfall of former bandmate Syd Barrett, whose struggles with mental health and the pressures of fame inspired Shine On You Crazy Diamond. It also critiques the cold, profit-driven nature of the music industry, especially in Welcome to the Machine and Have a Cigar. The title track, Wish You Were Here, is one of the most powerful songs about absence and longing. Pink Floyd’s music is forever, and seeing Roger Waters live eight years ago made me appreciate it even more.
I love this album. I have since the first time I heard it. The only (slight) black mark is the use of Roy Harper for lead vocals on "Have a Cigar". I have never been a fan of Roy's singing. Still, even that isn't enough to detract from a, very rare for me, 5/5 score. Pink Floyd at their very best.
One of my all time favorites, I just wish Roger Waters wasn’t such a dick
This was good to listen to in the background and I liked it all. Not my favourite but I appreciated the effort Pink Floyd
I liked it 👍🏾
great record
Great album!
So, so you think you can tell? Really great album, Shine on you crazy diamond part 72 is the only thing keeping it from 5 stars.
Not their best
Dull
Takes a while to get going, sounds nice while doing it though.
I was astonished the moment Shine On You Crazy Diamond started playing, the drop is completely unexpected. It's definitely an interesting listen, you're either gonna like it or dislike it. It goes down in quality at the end especially the title track.
I have never listened to Pink Floyd before. I now know why. This is not for me. No part of this connected with me in any way. Just endless noodling guitar parts and meh vocals.ugh.
WYWH was probably my first Pink Floyd album. I loved it, and unsurprisingly, I still do. Back then, the lyrics just made some kind of sense to me; the references to the music industry and Syd Barrett's departure evaded me. The context makes this album much more complete and nearly perfect, as the music reflects the lyrics and vice versa.
Ah, prog rock. Who else can get away with the opening track taking nearly nine minutes before a vocalist appears? Heck, let’s throw in the guitar solo too before the singer! But that’s the beauty and intrigue of Pink Floyd and prog rock. Rules are meant to be broken. I was late to the Floyd game. Sure, I knew the big hits off The Wall and Dark Side of the Moon, but the rest of their work didn’t get to pour their sonic vibes over me until much later. I have a confession, sacrilegious opinion even, this is my favorite Floyd album. While DSOTM and The Wall are fantastic, they are somewhat complex albums sonically. Wish You Were Here is an album that I can lay down on my couch, crank to 10 and enjoy the mood of the music as it washes over me. I don’t even care about the lyrics. I find it to be a sonic feast mostly in its simplicity. It’s almost not trying hard to grasp, but interesting enough that it is not quite letting you be lazy either. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is a tribute to Syd, a founding member of the band that was deemed a creative genius. He struggled with mental health issues and substance abuse and was eventually ushered out of the band. Lyrically it is simple and not hard to grasp. But musically it is a complex, multi part composition. I saw Floyd’s live performance via DVD from their Pulse album series. Shine On was the opening song. It’s a perfect buildup with synchronized lighting. I imagine it was a treat to experience live. Now I can’t say inserting Crazy into the title seems appropriate today, but I’ll that slide. I struggled with ranking it a 4 or 5. I could change my mind on a later date, but today, it’s getting a 5. If I could only pick one Floyd vinyl purchase, this would be the one.
I think I’m a point in my musical journey where I’m not all that interested in things that, on the surface, prescribe self importance. In our current day and age, if I see enough people talking about a rock album or band being “one of the greatest ever”, I hesitate to fully commit time to listening. This is due to a lot of things. Mainly being just how often non-straight-white-guys are left out of the canon of not only rock, but mainstream music as a whole. It’s kind of a conscious rejection of the Rolling Stone Magazine canon of western music. There are several albums that are left off of this 1089 album list that feel like no brainers considering their importance to non-rock genres of music. (I’m beyond baffled that D’Angelo has one album on this list and it’s not Voodoo). I’m mostly glad that poptimism has more or less beat out rockism in the current zeitgeist. Pink Floyd one of those bands that I could neatly place into this box of overly-praised rock music for me. Stuff that is usually pretty good, but since I don’t have an emotional connection and my favorite artists of today don’t often site as influences on their artistry, I tip toed around them. This group also included groups like Radiohead and The Rolling Stones. But just like Radiohead, The Rolling Stones, Led Zeppelin, etc. these groups often more than prove their worth and that they are 100% deserving, at least a little bit, of the heaps of praise that are tossed on them. It’s good, but not as impactful/influential as some would like you to believe. Wish You Were Here is great though. The guitar solos capture emotion better than many other noodlers of yesteryear. This album has way more SONGs than the 5 tracks that are listed here because each weave in and out of different, but related sonic motifs, making the overall runtime just fly by. Nothing drags. The vocals are really great. And to cap it off, the title track is making a really solid case for one of my favorite new-to-me songs of this project so far. It’s good. You got me. This one deserves the love.
Love it!
Warum gibt es hier keine 6 Sterne? Eines meiner absoluten Lieblingsalben. Klare 5/5
When I’m in the right mood & environment, I know I’d enjoy this. But I couldn’t listen to this every day. And it would never be a choice to play it. Their music for me has a time & a place. That time is at home in the evening. With narcotics.
einer meiner ersten alben ich liebe es.
Oh, to hear this again for the first time someday...
This experimental Rock reminds me mostly of Ambient while being too annoying for that. The tempo stays plodding and druggy with a somniferous vocal delivery to match while someone thought it would be a good idea to water it down with synthesizers.
Build up and transitions were flawless
Legend
Ya lo había escuchado ajjsjs, mis favoritas la primera y la última
No sé qué decir, 10
Wish You Were Here may be my favorite PF song, but the rest of this album is nowhere near some of their other work. Dark Side is the pinnacle.
Absolute masterpiece. One of the greatest albums of all time!
3.4.
One of the easiest 5's I've given. Personal enjoyment: 5 Relevance to this list: 5
Brilliant. So entrancing, and euphoric. The sublime encapsulated. So yeah it was alright
8.5/10 A deep cut for love for hx drug use and death of friends mixed with production quality I would get stuck in an elevator for 2 days with.
5 songs and 45 minutes long? Oh boy. But it's not bad. The two 12-13 min songs are complementing the other three songs well. "Wish you were here" is good
its not bad but not my taste also why are the songs so longg
A classic and has its place.
Loved it.
Beautiful.
в качестве фоновой музыки - отлично
Lots of instrumental. I’m surprised people like this so much. Maybe it’s really awesome when you’re high. Wish you were here is good but I just don’t really see the appeal to the rest of it. Maybe if i was really into guitars I’d like it more.
The best yet.
Feb 26th 2025 (Wed) | Day 3 - Fav song: Welcome to the Machine #1970s #1975 #spotify #'25 #feb '25 [4.5*]
Canción favorita: No podría elegir una en particular, es un álbum que se debe escuchar de principio a fin. Pink Floyd es una banda especial para mí, porque me conecta con mi hermano y papá.
Atmospheric and interesting.
Parece que estou desbravando novos mares. Que álbum bom. Mdssss
This is one of the best albums in the history of rock by one of the best bands in the history of rock. Of course, it's a bit pompous. Of course, it takes me back to off-campus college housing, a room full of guys, knocked back on the couch, listening, mesmerized, or late nights, falling asleep to it after partying. I liked it then because it's perfect. I like it now because it's still perfect. Five stars.
Just beautiful
Excellent
Sublime and majestic! Perfect!
Taustamusiikkia, ei hassumpaa, mutta en itse perusta kymmenminuuttisista kappaleista albumilla.
One of my absolute favorite albums of all time.
Great album and one of my favourite songs
I mean, if not for one other pink floyd album, this would be the bands greatest accomplishment.
What an album - 5 songs but almost 45 minutes, and it was such an adventure listening to all NINE parts of Shine On You Crazy Diamond. I think that this album is great, but it's not for all occasions - you can't really listen to it and party, it's more for when you're in a relaxed mood and want to have this playing in the background.
Favourite songs: - Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 1-5 - Welcome to the Machine - Wish You Were Here - Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 6-9
I don’t get it
As with all the albums on this list, it really doesn't matter what I say...but like, extra on this one. I could tell you this album is a masterpiece, the GOAT, well mixed, well written, contains one of the best songs ever written, etc., or I could tell you that it's an overblown slog of self-indulgence that takes too long to get through. The fact is, you've more than likely heard all those things about it by the time you see this. The only thing I want to tell you is, if you've never sat down and listened to it all the way through, do that, and please make up your own mind. It's well worth it to be part of the conversation. That and, timestamp 6:26 into SOYCD Pts. 6-9 = perfection.
I had a cigar of my own (hats off to Roy Harper) and took a solo stroll through mossened trails—blanketed by downed Douglas firs following some nasty wind—with this album, setting a scene that helped me unlock yet another layer of appreciation for an album I've heard 10,000 times.
A classic in all shapes and forms. Explendid atmosphere, performance and production. I don't give it 5 stars because I don't think is perfect, but is almost up there.
I like PF a lot but I find this one a bit smug and dare I say it , a bit boring. Still a 4 though.
Masterpiece
Fantastic psycho- Rock!
Great
A cinematic listening experience. It’s dramatic and sweeping and feels like one whole piece of art instead of a collection of pieces. This album is best listened to in its entirety, but the middle tracks are great on their own as well.
A fantastic album. WYWH has, at several points, been my favourite record of all time. There's something so surreal, satisfying, soul-wrenching about the Pink Floyd sound, especially this timeless stuff from the 70s. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, in all of its nine monumental parts, is a master class in musical restraint, motif development, instrument layering, production, synth technique, guitar technique, chord progressions... I mean, seriously, what's not to love here? The four resounding notes ringing out at the beginning of Part 2 that changed the world of progressive rock forever. The lush choral delivery of the song title that sends the listener into a heady euphoria. The incredible chords, matching Roger Waters' indescribable poetry to Syd Barrett. (SOYCD may well have my favourite chord progression in any song.) Then we have a heady transition into the mind-blowing guitar-synthscape of Welcome to the Machine, the groovy, heavy electric jam of Have a Cigar ("Oh, by the way, which one's Pink?), and the mesmerising acoustic anthem Wish You Were Here. All of these songs could easily have a feature-length documentary on their genius, their power, their general excellence in pretty much every regard. I'll restrain myself from writing the equivalent of two phone books about WYWH. It's great – as close to "objectively great" as music can get. Everything else I want to say has been said already by critics, fans, or your local Joe. I will, though, highlight one of the best lines in rock history: "We're just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl, year after year." Damn. 5/5 Key tracks: all
Um dos meus discos favoritos de todos os tempos
Had this one on CD in highschool. Enjoyed it then, and still enjoy it now.
The psychedelic factor definitely takes it up a notch. I was staring at my ceiling and wondering why the walls looked so funny. THAT is why I listen to music.
I feel like I enjoyed the music more than I should have. It was pretty chill and simple. Would have preferred more vocals
periodt, the song ate and i love the track so much but it could do better JKK
A fantastic album. A complete joy to listen to.
I don't listen to Pink Floyd as much as I used to and this was never my favourite album but I still like it a lot. Giving it a 5 despite that speaks a lot for how good some of their other stuff is. Kind of had me forgetting how good it actually is I think of the album's biggest strengths is the variety in styles. Between the spacey, long winding SOYCD, the bluesy, rocking Have a Cigar (with one of Gilmour's best ever solos, imo), the sombre, folky title track and the sort of eery, electronic Welcome to the Machine, each track clearly stands apart and has its own identity. That with the order of vocalists (Waters-Gilmour-Roy Harper-Gilmour-Waters) adds to that and, to me, helps give the album a clearer structure The title track is a bit overplayed but I would never say I don't like it. I just never really feel like putting it on Stellar stuff 4.5 Highlights: Have a Cigar, SOYCD (Parts 6 - 9), SOYCD (Parts 1 - 5), Welcome to the Machine
compuesto por Dios.
lo voy a volver a escuchar pero ya se cuanto es, para qué mentirnos.
I normally hate albums which are all about how hard it is to be a rock star, so that oughta tell ya how unbelievably amazing this one is. Epic and astoundingly personal at the same time. A monumental achievement. I hope all those people who keep buying Floyd t-shirts actually give the music a listen some day.
This is one of those albums you must listen to all the way through in one sitting. Favourite Songs: ALL OF THEM.
I love this album. Shine on you Crazy Diamond is such a great song. I love how it flows. This album as a whole flows so well with songs leading into one another. 5 stars.
Great album. 5/5
Love the funky synth sounds
Another one that I haven't listened to a ton other than Dark Side of the Moon. This one is pretty solid. One or two that I enjoy
It is utterly ridiculous to include this on here but not Animals. The author of this book should be shot against a post for making that call. This (and Animals) is one of the best albums of all time. End of review.
I get that on a 1001 albums list you are going to get some critically acclaimed and universally beloved albums but it always feels weird when it comes time to writing stuff for it. I really don't know what to say. banger fucking album
POTENTIAL JOJOS BIZZARE ADVENTURE REFERENCE?????
Attention seeker music 9/10
This album has two themes going on here, one is spelled out in the title and the other illustrated in the album art. The two themes being: 'General longing/missing someone' and 'we fucking hate the music industry'. Pink Floyd were not a band that was on the track to stadium-packing, merch-peddling stardom. In fact, in the mini-doco attached the Live At Pompeii, during the recording of Dark Side of the Moon the interviewer lays out the mood that rock is dying and Pink Floyd with it. And then DSOTM came out and made these guys a household name. With fame came way bigger demands from their studio and the creative pressure to top their last album. This got them thinking about their old bandmate, Syd, who lost his mind as they began to achieve success and they just decided to not pick him up for rehearsal one day. It is often interpreted that Shine On You Crazy Diamond is a personal tribute to Syd, but rather it is a song about people who have withdrawn entirely being unable to cope with modern life. Having said that, after the famous visit to the studio that Syd made where Roger Waters was moved to tears, Richard Wright added in the keyboard riff from See Emily Play to part 9 of SYCD as a small personal tribute to Syd. Syd thought the song sounded old and did not like it, it would be the last time any band member interacted with him until his death in 2006. Welcome to the Machine is an angrier song (a sign of things to come as Waters became the leading creative force in the band), and was my favourite song growing up as a child and the first Pink Floyd song I had ever heard at the age of 10. The message seems cliche and trivial now but when I was a kid and it clicked that this song was taking aim at industry coopting youthful rebellion and exploiting artists transformed this song into a lot more than 'a Floyd deep cut I adored as a kid'. This album, Waters' lyricism and this song specifically; when I really listened to the lyrics is what really got me into music made me look at music in a different way. Side B opens with Have a Cigar which is a delightfully sleazy song. The opening riff and keyboard makes you think of an overly-carpeted 70s conference room where it smells like cigarettes and music industry ghouls with fat ties and kitschy glasses. Getting Roy Harper to sing while Waters was unwell was a happy little accident and adds to the bite of the song as a critique of the music industry. What can be said about the title track? The production here is unreal, the little effects, the radio intro and Gilmour's cough over a faded version of probably one of the most iconic rock riffs of all time. As with SYCD, a lot of people have said this song is about Syd but what makes this song brilliant and beautiful is that it's not. Waters' lyricism, Gilmour's guitar, Mason's drumming and Wright on the keys all come together to make this pretty vague song about distance, loneliness, alienation and missing something personal for so many people. It really is the peak of Floyd as it's one of the last times that Gilmour and Waters would really collaborate so wholly on a track (the next time would probably be Dogs and Comfortably Numb which are also two of the best songs that the band ever made). The song fades into a return into parts 6-9 of Shine On You Crazy Diamond, closing out an album that is incredibly near and dear to my heart. Even without knowing the context and story behind the band and the album and being a kid who did not have the best grasp of the English language, I loved this album. I am extremely passionate for my love for this album, it never gets old for me. I could listen to this entire album in my head from memory, it's the reason I don't have an internal monologue. To me, this is the best album ever made. Highlights: What do you think?
The song Wish You Were Here is my favorite Pink Floyd song, love the guitar in it and the way it builds up. The other songs on here were alright. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is good but too long for my tastes. 8/10
This is one of the most significant albums in my early musical development. My earliest concrete memory of viscerally feeling music, and of synesthesia was with Welcome to the Machine. In 6th grade, my mom took me to a play about Syd Barret and a guy trying to keep his Western rock records safe from the Soviet secret police (to actually explain is is beyond the scope of this review). Periodically they would kill the lights and play a piece of a song very loudly. When they played the giant synth line of Welcome to the Machine, I remember feeling like something was filling up inside my chest, and in the dark of the theater I was half seeing these thick green bands of light (kind of like a waveform visualization). I listened to Wish You Were here non-stop after that. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is one of my most perfect pieces of music (except for the guitar fill at 9:19, that always seemed like it didn't fit). Welcome to the Machine has a special place for me because of that moment in the theater. Wish You Were Here is one of the first songs I learned on guitar. I like it less now that I did then, but I'm always happy to hear it. Have a Cigar is cool, but not as transcendent as Diamond or Machine. Also Jesus Gilmour's slide playing on Diamond pts 6-9 is as good as any guitar I've heard (that is what is on while writing this sentence, hence the call out). Album Cover: (A+) They actually set that guy on fire. That's real.
WTF is wrong with you people??? It can't be anything but a 5. It flows together perfect, absolutely iconic album. Actually gives me goosebumps during certain parts.
This album is sweet. I listened to it as one long song. This is far from my first time listening to it, so I don't have a lot of new listener takes to provide. It's the kind of album you just fall into. It makes me feel like I'm in bed and high. I have a memory of listening to a live performance of this entire album with my friend Dan in his truck. It was almost ten years ago and I remember it, so it must have affected me. Not a lot of individual moments stand out, but the entire thing blends in to one rocking song. "Wish You Were Here" is legendary. 8/10
I was the biggest Pink Floyd fan when I was freshman in high school. This might be their best. Returning to this album 20 something years later, I’m able to hear more clearly how it ties into other musical movements throughout history. Overall it’s funkier and groovier than I remember. “Welcome to the Machine” is a Kraftwerk track. “Wish You Were Here” is country. “Shine On” has elements of Albert King and the jazz. And darn, the whole time I was marveling at the musicianship of David Gilmour and Richard Wright, and at Roger Waters’s lyrics. And the amazing engineering and production value. I got a lot of love for the eclecticism, the concept and the personal feel to the work. Great.
Great album, almost a 5. I think Animals and Meddle might be better though
Following Dark Side is a daunting task, considering it is one of the highest bars and most successful rock albums of all time. The songs here are long and it has a feel of its own compared to their other most commercially successful work. I have grown to appreciate this album more over time considering the bands history and where their thoughts must have been at that point in time. Only 5 songs but this packs quite a punch. Not quite a 5 banger but it’s close IMO. This is a perfect example of why this excersize needs a 10 point scale. Rounding up here… 4.5/5
Doesn’t quite rise to the level of Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall, but comes close. The title track alone helps push it there and to this day is simply timeless.
The structure of this might cause it to lose points with some people, but I love this one. A great album for anyone who’s ever lost a friend, whether to madness or the Los Angeles Lakers. Luka forever.
Always have love for David Gilmour. His guitar is so distinct and bends are one of a kind. When “shine on…” kicks in it is an iconic hook. The groove on have a cigar is great. Wish you were here was one of my early (and fav) songs to learn on guitar. Shit, I was leaning to a 4 since there’s not a ton on the album (really just 4 songs with heavy jamming). But after writing this I gotta give love and round up by the tiniest of margins.
Not sure why I hesitated on giving this a 5 bomb... it's great and came on the heals of a terrible week of albums. Not to mention helping us cope with the loss of a loved one (RIPIP Luka). Bookends can get a bit tiresome, but there's simply too much goodness here not to give it the highest grade. 4.5/5
Flows together well
Not their best album but still good. The title track is probably the best one.
I went into this expecting to enjoy it - I like a bit of psychedelic rock, and Dark Side is obviously a banger. I expected to enjoy the title track and a couple of others. I didn't expect to be blown away by this album - honestly, it's amazing! I've listened to it three times already, and will probably again in the very near future. The guitar lines swoop and soar, the atmosphere is incredible, and I love every single track. I didn't think I could be surprised by something 50 years old, but here we are - what a blast this was :)
Favorite Track: Have A Cigar
My favorite Pink Floyd album. They are, generally speaking, not really my jam, but I do listen to this album semi-regularly, especially the title track
Their best album
Fantastic album.
I've always had a bit of mixed relationship with Pink Floyd in that whilst I love Dark Side and a fair chunk of The Wall, they've never properly clicked outside of that. Wish You Were Here kind of exemplifies that for me as across the 5 tracks there are some really strong moments, but equally there's stuff in here that just doesn't quite land for me. For me Wish You Were Here really shines in its opening and closing tracks. I really love how these tracks meander between genre, opening the album in a more ambient mode before shifting into prog-rock and building anticipation for what's to come. There's a really great sense of progression and narrative that I think is lacking from stuff like Have a Cigar and the title track (which honestly I've always found a bit dull compared to other Pink Floyd tracks)
Not Again
It's not too terribly often I think about Syd Barrett. I mean, as I've said before, the early years of Pink Floyd aren't exactly my thing. Even as much as I can say I do like those first two albums, that kind of psychedelic space rock isn't usually what I want out of the band (or in general, but that's besides the point). It might be a bit typical, but the run of albums from THE DARK SIDE OF THE MOON to THE WALL is way more my speed — alongside records like MEDDLE and (yes, really) THE DIVISION BELL. I've even listened to THE FINAL CUT more; it's honestly not really that bad. And if I don't often listen to THE PIPER AT THE GATES OF DAWN, you can imagine how much I've listened to something like THE MADCAP LAUGHS. Now that's an album that requires just a bit too much serious consideration than I'd like for a casual listen. Goodness, it's gonna be fun when my group gets to that one... But all the same, I'd never dare speak ill of Syd Barrett. And frankly, whenever I do end up thinking about him, it's pretty common that I end up coming to the conclusion that he's the most important member of the band. Absolutely, they would not be the same without his influence — even if, specifically and tragically, that influence came from his absence... Like, if it weren't for Syd, would we have "Brain Damage"? Or large swathes of THE WALL? I know for a fact we wouldn't have today's album, that's for sure. Syd and the shadow where he used to be loomed so largely over the band, it's hard not to have respect for him. And there's nothing they ever did where you can feel how much respect they had for Syd, and how much they missed him, as WISH YOU WERE HERE. Let me lay this down right now: this is my favorite Pink Floyd record. Full stop. DARK SIDE OF THE MOON and THE WALL both make good cases for coming close, but in the end, nothing can. Not really. I mean, if I haven't listened to it as much as I have THE WALL, that's only because I'm trying not to lose any part of its magic to overplay. It's... It's just special, y'know? Honestly, for most of the day I was worried I wouldn't have anything to say about it. I was excited as the dickens when my group got it; it was the fastest I'd hopped on listening to an album since ACE OF SPADES. But as for actually talking about it... Well, as I've discussed back when I talked about MY AIM IS TRUE, there are just some albums so deeply entrenched in my soul that it's hard for me to find the words to say about them. And if that's true for MY AIM IS TRUE, then it applies a thousandfold to this album. Part of me can't even really fathom articulating the words. To me, this album's greatness goes without saying. If this album doesn't just speak for itself, then no other does. But if I could try... Well, it's just like I said: there's nothing else in their whole body of work where you can feel how much they loved, respected and missed Syd like this album does. The fact that half of the album is dedicated to a song celebrating Syd should tell you enough all by itself. And... Gawd, "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is beautiful: all nine parts, and all twenty-plus minutes. If it hadn't been split up to bookend the album, it'd beat out "Echoes" as the greatest single track of their entire career. It aches for Syd, and it's very sad that he's gone, but at the same time it doesn't forget to be happy about who he was and what he did for the group. It kind of plays to me like a memorial service, honestly. Like, it's not the funeral, where you're actively mourning someone, but... It's the memories. It's looking back on all the times you had with someone, good and bad. And there's just this... This hole in yourself where they used to be. And I don't think that feeling is better encapsulated on this whole album than those three guitar notes. Like, it's incredible that just those three notes can evoke so much and so many feelings. I'm in awe every time. Chills, seriously. "Wish You Were Here" evokes largely the same feeling, albeit in a smaller setting. If "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is a large-scale celebration of a loved one, surrounded by family and friends, then "Wish You Were Here" is when a song comes on the radio that quietly brings everything back. Like, you're just about to get out of your car, stressed out about some bullshit or whatever, when you hear those notes come over your radio and — and suddenly, you're out of place. You just can't bring yourself to leave until the song's over. You just can't. They're too important to ignore. And, y'know, whoever you're thinking about, they don't even have to have passed on — Syd wasn't when this album was released, and he wouldn't until a few decades later. It's just, whoever you couldn't have imagined living without, but have had to face that reality anyway. And it tears you up inside, because you don't know when you're gonna see them again, but the idea that eventually, some day, you will — that's what gets you through. And speaking of that bullshit that stressed you out, that's what the other half of the album is about — music industry bullshit, specifically. About a cold, unfeeling, mechanical industry that chews up and spits out any talent unfortunate enough to try and get too close. About executives and management who care so little about you compared to the bottom line they can't even be assed to remember your damn name — and yet when the big bucks start pouring in, they act like they had anything to do with it. Well, beyond trying to crush your soul into just another cog, anyway. They're an empty suit in the desert, selling you dreams but leaving you with nothing but burns from broken promises. These songs aren't as clearly angry as the ones on ANIMALS are, but you can still feel it beneath the sarcasm and haunted warnings. "Have A Cigar" is the only other song in the band's discography to have a guest vocalist (here it's Roy Harper), and it says so much to me that someone outside of the band ended up singing these words. It's not exactly a happy album, if you somehow couldn't tell. Honestly, put all together, I can't help but imagine a story. One about someone who tried to hack it in the music industry, but ended up getting so lost in the shuffle and burned out that only the memories of their loved ones could carry them forward. And even that couldn't last forever — after all, that's not them singing "Shine On You Crazy Diamond". Whether or not this reflects Syd's story, I'm not enough of an expert on him to say. But that story, and its emotional resonance... If that ain't one of the big reasons why I keep coming back. And I haven't even gotten around to mentioning the musicianship yet! It's all top form, across the board. Like, I wanna highlight Wright's keys on "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" specifically. They're the star of the song, and most of the reason why it's as good as it is. From the opening solo over those ambient glasses, down to the slow funeral march, followed by the "See Emily Play" that closes the album... Everyone else is amazing, especially Gilmour for playing those three notes on "Shine On" and that opening solo on "Wish You Were Here", but Wright especially deserves credit. Absolutely insane that Waters would later fire and demote him to session musician come THE WALL, goodness. If all my blabbering hasn't made it evident, this is an absolute 5, among the strongest I've ever given. Across 44 minutes, it just does not miss. It's simply the most stunning and beautiful music they'd ever make. Like, I understand why THE DARK SIDE OF THE MOON is often held up as the greater achievement. It came first, it has the hits, and people probably generally resonate more with its songs about aspects of life than they do this album and its themes of alienation. And don't get me wrong, I hold DARK SIDE in the same high regard; this isn't a competition about which one is better. I just agree whole-heartedly with Richard Wright and David Gilmour when they say that this is the best Pink Floyd record — 'coz it is. It might just be my favorite album of all time, honestly? If it's not, then it's certainly top 5 — or, heck, top 3, actually. And I still don't know if I've used enough words to express how I feel about it. It's just that big in my mind. And, y'know... I can't imagine being any of them on the day during recording when Syd came to visit — during "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", of all coincidences. Where they couldn't recognize him for minutes because he'd lost all of his hair and grown overweight. I've seen the picture — it's a little hard to look at. Roger Waters was so distressed by how Syd looked he was reduced to tears. And there's this one I've read — I don't know how true it is, but there's one anecdote about the visit I've always remembered. It's when Syd stands up and says that he's ready to play, only for the rest of the band to have to tell him that there's nothing for him to play. It breaks my heart every time I think about it. And that's pretty often when I'm listening to this album. Bless it, for everything it's worth.
What more is there to say on this asides from What An Album. Solid 5 Stars.
That’s a 10. Going into this, I only had ever heard “Wish You Were Here”, and even then, I mainly knew it from, oddly enough, the Ninja Sex Party cover, which I’ve listened to more times than the original. It’s a great cover, sue me. However, listening to it on this first runthrough of the full album, with the context of everything that surrounds it… yeah, the original is miles ahead. The whole album is a masterpiece. Grieving someone who is still alive is a curse afforded only to those with such empathy for the wellbeing of others that it affects them personally. (Yes, this includes Roger Waters, despite how much of a dickhead he is nowadays.) It is a curse that I have held a few more times than I’d care to admit, and it’s a curse that this album displays in a way that I haven’t necessarily heard captured in musical form. Granted, this is grief with a tinge of celebration, and perhaps some relief that Syd Barrett didn’t truly get caught up in the machinations of the machine & the executives that the rest of the band so artfully complain about on this album… but it’s still grief. It’s grief that other people can & likely will put into better words than I ever could – I’ve been trying to write something for maybe 30 minutes now, in an effort to put my full thoughts into words, and I keep staring at this blinking text cursor rattle my brain. All I know is that Pink Floyd knew how the hell to put that grief into musicality that may never ever be touched or replicated. There’s not a missed note, beat, or lyric through the 44 minutes this album goes for, and it feels like a privilege that I get to listen to such a grand representation of a cruel, cruel curse. It’s a fabulous album, and it certainly ranks within the top 5 of all the 401 albums we’ve now gotten, at least for me. It’s a 10 – just go listen to it. No words can do it justice.
This one is really a masterpiece. In my mind, it’s always overshadowed by Dark Side of the Moon, but in all reality, they’re both amazing.
Says something when you know every track without ever hearing the album as a whole. And it is better as a whole. “Shine On…” is my go to for destressing. Obviously 5 stars.
This is obviously a pinnacle of the prog/rock genre, and it is beautifully made. Really amazing sounds and progressions. And amazing that this was just a few years after the Beatles. But on the other hand... this is kind of clinical and detached. I feel like I'm watching the prefects put on a concert.
Sååå godt
Just brilliant.
Absolutely brilliant album from start to finish. Beautiful moving music. Gilmour's guitar work simply incredible. Lyrically poignant.
3 5 stars. wish you were here, have a cigar
Outstanding
Fkn banger! 11/10
I have never been so happy for an album to mercifully end.
This one’s a 5. I’ll take any opportunity to listen to it with purpose though My experience here is tainted, but this is the good sad. Like five eulogies at an Irish funeral in an album. A farewell too soon, but more importantly an appreciation for the struggle, a celebration of the good times & a triumphant send off to close it out. One song added to my playlist, whole album’s in the 1001 playlist - even though that butchers the design of the album itself.
Pre: Never been a Pink Floyd fan, but admittedly I'd never listened to an album the whole way through, which really is their whole deal; I imagine this is the prog equivalent to having never seen Star Wars. Post: Almost exactly as I expected. Nothing I hated, nothing that compelled either. Highlight: Have a Cigar (in particular the vocals for "ride the gravy train")
Pre: Well first of all I've listened to the album dozens of times so not sure I can remember a pre-listen. Though going into this it is my least favourite of the 'Top 4' of Dark Side to The Wall, though this does still place it as an amazing album. My memory of this is basically some amazing songs and some lengthy intermissions between that vary in quality (I'll leave any ideas of what that means to me up to you). One issue that does kinda bother me about the idea of this site/book is that you don't really need to listen to this album I think. It certainly wouldn't be my Floyd number 1 recommendation and if I'm being honest you don't need to listen to all the Pink Floyd albums before you die, 2 or 3 would certainly do with more if you actually like them. Funnily enough as a background to this, I received this for Christmas this year and hadn't listened to it yet, so it's one of my most recent albums I've gotten. That's a nice contrast to Kind of Blue which I saw on sale the weekend of that appearing in this list (not that I've listened to it yet but cmon I've been busy!) Post: Okay I thought I preferred Animals but this may feature David Gilmours best work. Both halves of Shine On has some of the best guitar work around. The other side of this though is that I think this has some of Waters' weaker singing even when his songwriting is strong. The same could also be said for Wright and his synths which can be interesting like on Have a Cigar but ultimately I think the album is worse off for them. Welcome to the Machine really does cause so much momentum to stop that it could be fine on another album but the quality of everything surrounding it shows too big a gulf on pretty much every front. Speaking generally of Shine On, but this does cover the whole album, one of my favourite parts of this record is listening to each instrument not in the lead role and appreciating how often they will deviate from the same timings or pace of the song in a way that stills feels sonically cohesive. It's not unique to the record, especially from Floyd, but it is quite noticeable here. Ultimately I'm giving it a 5 but it feels like a forgiving 5 because of WttM. Sucks that for me this album has such a weak spot but as a whole it just hits too good for me to deny it. Highlight: Wish You Were Here (c'mon now, it's crazy to think another track here could top that!)
Much like the iconic album cover, this goes hand in hand with the memory of founding member Syd Barrett to whom this album was inspired by and in tribute to.
Love everything about this. Contemplative, moody, great to listen to while working.
Great to listen to more Pink Floyd, I think musically it’s amazing and to hear it live would be incredible, but the lyrics don’t mean much to me and ad much as I enjoyed it I’m not sure I’ll be going back to it
It's hard not to hear this through the lens of film and TV of a vaguely spacey/SciFi flavour, almost more like a soundtrack to an idea than an album. I am conflicted really. I like this that are languid, spacey, meditative. But the melodies just don't snag me, and it's like the band is alergic to hooks, except for the chorus of 'shine on'. Did they ever snag anyone who wasn't also listening under the influence of something?
Masterpiece
An album of love songs to a best friend going through a mental health crisis.
Do you think you can tell?
I won this album on vinyl and it's one of my favorites. Such a great variety of awesome sounds from Pink and the boys. I listened to it twice. Five stars easily.
Best enjoyed as one continuous listen rather than listening to each song individually. Comes together brilliantly, and wish you were here has to be one of the best songs of the 70s
3.5/5 - good rock album
Wish you were listening to this album right now as it is a continued masterpiece in the Pink Floyd collection.
5 songs, 43 minutes, one incredible album. I know “Wish You Were Here” is a great standalone trick, but this album demands to be listened to from front to back.
One of the great classic rock albums of all time
My favorite Pink Floyd album.
not up to my appeal but it is good for it's own right
I really think this is Pink Floyd's sharpest work, a perfect union between the pop sensibilities of dark side and the ruminations of animals
This is great. It's sounds like I'm floating around in space. And things just happen around me. And I wasn't even under the influence while listening to it. The engineering on this album is really impressive. Listening on headphones is quite a wild experience.
Need to listen to this on shrooms
The emotion of Syd Barrett's absence adds to this. I am not as violently opposed to prog as I was in younger days. But my old view that this is still the slow, noodly music that punk was sent to destroy still holds in part.
GOAT album
Best album ever? Less universal lyrics than Dark Side of the Moon but an echoey, gooey, spacey sound that delivers on every listen
This is my favorite Pink Floyd album and probably the only one that I still love now. It is truly a perfection. I don't need to say anything else, straight to 5/5.
More intentionally ambient than the wall, and more cohesive and shorter (even though I suppose shine on is like 15 minutes lol)
Sensational album. I've listened many times before this and I'll listen many times after. 100 out of 5 stars.
Absolute unit masterpiece of an album. Would absolutely listen again
So much beauty in this album. I feel like Welcome to the Machine drags it down just enough to miss out on five stars. But not to worry Pink Floyd will reach that summit.
This one is just obvious. Good first pick.
Hhh
I know this is a classic, but 5 songs and no interesting lyrics?
this is boring. also I consistently think that "Wish You Were Here" (which is boring but I still kinda like it, definitely more than the rest) is "6th Avenue Heartache."
The best
I'm bored of this album now. Great when I was thirteen and did not have wide musical tastes. Best song: Have A Cigar. Worst song: Welcome To The Machine. All a bit self-indulgent. It's all a bit slow. WYWH is a good song, but now a bit too twee.
Sublime
The follow up album to DSOTM could've easily have been a dud, but not in this case. Leaning more on the bluesy guitar riffs and bends of Gilmour and the sublime musical landscape of Wright, this is a masterpiece. Added poignancy of Syd Barret turning up to the recording sessions of SOYCD. Wish you were here is surely Water's finest hour. Must say I can't fault this. Five stars.
Wish You Were Here is both an absolutely incredible album and title track. Just an incredibly cohesive album.
This album is great. I think the guitar work Pink Floyd puts into their music is probably the best it's ever been. I like it more than Hendrix, Clapton, and Zappa. The atmospheric composition just speaks to me and I haven't even gotten into the themes and content of any of the albums other than The Wall. I'll definitely put some energy into a deeper dive because Pink Floyd is quickly moving up as one of my favorite bands.
I love this album, and have for a very long time. I think “Shine on you crazy diamond” is one of the best musical tributes to anyone and anything ever written. It’s not bombastic or overly wordy. Just a memory of someone the band clearly loved (who wasn’t even deceased at the time). The other three songs are all special in their own way, though “welcome to the machine” isn’t as good of a standalone song as the others. This album shows what I would consider the two sides of Floyd. The diamond suite is their much less commercial, virtuoso and psychedelic side, while the three middle songs show their capability to write thoughtful accessible music for anyone. Few bands have been able to bridge the two worlds so easily, and even fewer have since. It’s a masterpiece, I like it even more than dark side of the moon and the wall. One of my all time favorites.