Reviews (page 5 of 15)
Not a fan of her voice nor the lyrics, but the album is well produced and succeeds in bringing back a long-lost epoch, even if it is not your cup of tea. 7/10
Piano notes, smoky melodies and melancholic belters. Raw, but not sorry for itself.
Excelente
4/5
There are no skippable songs on the album. Every song hooks you in immediately with a classic blues/jazz or even reggae rhythm followed by a fantastic vocal performance. The songs are unsubtle when talking about addiction, depression and abuse. Amy puts everything out there. Definitely should have gone to rehab.
Her vocals pair well with the horns, distinctive percussion at the low BPM and fun unique instruments for various songs. Creates that old school sound like an underground jazz club shrouded in dim lights.
Amy Winehouse had a great voice, electromagnetic look/persona, tragic story and Rehab is a legit great song but otherwise, it feels like a schtick. Not that a or this schtick is bad, but the appeal is situational.
The genius of this album is how Winehouse embraces the tabloid version of herself with no fucks given and owns it while belting out fully realized songs in her self-assured, brassy voice. Her songs are by turns funny, empowering, tender and heartbreaking, and she has grown since her debut album, which we reviewed earlier. TIL The Dap-Kings were the backing band, which explains how the musical accompaniment is so good, and Mark Ronson’s production is spot-on by keeping things sounding crisp and clean but otherwise leaving it to all the talent on hand. God damn, what a talent she was.
Still sounds as fresh as when it burst onto the scene. Tragic she didn't live long enough to make more like it.
мне просто не заходит, пытаюсь слушать каждую песню хотя бы до половины, дальше меня не хватает, хочется выключить. не уверена, что мне нравится голос певицы, вроде бы он интересный, яркий, но как то бьет по ушам. очень высокие рейтинги, возможно я чего-то не понимаю, но ничего стоящего не услышала в этом альбоме 1/5
Rating probably partially influenced by subsequent events, but this is a stormer
Great voice, cool mix of retro/modern soul.
Not too bad. Fairly enjoyable.
Good
Silky backing with silkier vocals. Prime length
Not my usual style but can’t deny how good she is!
My mother-in-law is, in her own words, something of a poetess. Not that I’ve heard her read any of her poetry. Mostly, I understand, she delivers her poems as gifts or tributes on special occasions. I haven’t been the recipient of any such gifts. However, I did once find her notebook after she’d visited. I didn’t open it, but a ragged A5 page fell out and I couldn't help but read. Of course, it is wiser to never engage with a family member’s art, that way you never need to have an opinion on it. But I wasn’t prepared for the inelegant doggerel and tortured syntax, the clunking end-rhymes, and repetitious AAAABBAA scheme. God it was awful. Not only in form, but in content: a self-pitying, fatalistic howl that would surely be cliched if it weren’t so obviously pulled from the hidden core of the author’s soul. This was not long after my father-in-law became terminally ill, so I would have expected poems of sadness, loss, but not such unrepentant bleakness. This poem characterised all life as a waste, the love itself a game that was not worth the candle, and my mother-in-law’s existence completely without value or vitality. Why even try when fate was so completely stacked against you? To play is to lose. It broke my heart to read it. And, even moreso, because it was also bad. That she could find, in her lose, only cliche, not even beneficial platitude or bromide. My poor, beloved mother-in-law. I couldn't write so much as this, if the joke didn’t end up being on me. I’m not that ignorant. The truth is that I still haven’t seen my mother-in-law’s poetry. But I have heard her sing. That’s the party piece that she will break out at any gathering. And she learned her repetoire from hand-written lyrics she jotted down from the recordings. One of these was Love is a Losing Game by Amy Winehouse, a scrawled lyric I mistook for an original poem. Scundered. It is a much better song than a poem and I wouldn’t dare to judge a song by - or solely by - that criteria. Lyrics are, after all, only instructions for performance and Winehouse’s performances are generally terrific. Her lyrics elsewhere are much better. But I can’t help but imagine Mark Ronson’s internal horror at being presented with any of the lyrical ideas on this album. How could one respond professionally and personally to such unvarnished - raw and unsanded even - confessional? Lyrics that have homed in on the dark generalisations of her debut and made them more pointed. This is reportage rather than reflection and the report is from an absolute bombsite of a life. I won’t presume that Ronson prioritised his commerical obligations over a moral responsibility to his collaborator - you can do both and he wasn’t alone, there was a whole industry. And Winehouse, although vulnerable, was a grown adult who would probably want to make the record anyway. Yet it is hard to decide the purpose of the improved, glossier production of Back to Black over Frank: Is it to combat the bleakness in outlook and attitude? The offer of commercial success to draw her away from the edge? Exploitation? Or simply nobody knowing any other way? I don’t know. The pop machine keeps working regardless. When people criticise Neil Patrick Harris for his tasteless Amy Winehouse cake after the singer’s death, surely they must recognise the tastelessness in the Amy Winehouse project fullstop. Is Rehab a great song? Sure. Is it a great idea? Probably not. Would you record with a friend in that scenario? Would you release it and make it public property? Would you make the refusal to seek help her brand? Generally, people make art to express themselves freely. They do not expect it to become a prison. But it can do: one is caught in the financial prison of contractual obligations or the artistic prison of audience expectation. What we find on Back To Black is Amy Winehouse’s inability to use art as a way to escape the things she was feeling. Rather, it hemmed her into them further. We also find the limitations of her producer, Mark Ronson, of commercial success - or commercial-mindedness - to bring freedom. Like Kurt Cobain before her, another member of the 27 Club, fame and fortune made things harder, not easier. It is not love that is the losing game, but success. One should be careful of what feelings you shift from public to private. It cannot be unmade and you cannot go back to black. 3 The cluttered arrangements on Frank lacked a little inspiration so Back to Black saves everyone the trouble by fully embracing procedural pastiche of Motown. The horns and strings are restricted to neat, functional lines and suppressed in the mix. Nothing is free - even Winehouse’s vocal style is dramatically reined in; there are no more jazzy flights of fancy. The longest track here is just over 4 minutes - Frank had several over 5. Originality is out, discipline is in. Behind this slightly depressing regiment, Mark Ronson’s dedication to that one drum filter both unifies and neuters the music. No point in pretending this didn’t work. It isn’t just a question of 20 million albums sold - some of it is genuinely terrific; Rehab and the title track in particular. Virtually all the terrific, no doubt, belongs to Winehouse’s voice and lyrics, but we should credit the tidily uneventful arrangements and mixing at least for leaving her room to be brilliant. This is a rather depressing listen all the same. You can’t help hearing much of it as Amy Winehouse nudging and winking at her impending destruction. The album makes hay out of the problems the woman clearly carried with her but there is no sense of introspection; no catharsis in expression even. There is just a hollowness, underscored by the sign-off with the breezy ‘Addicted’. This is maybe why the most powerful moment - one of the only powerful moments - on the album is the bridge of Back to Black. Winehouse intones the single word like a mantra - lonely, hopeless, nihilistic. Heartbreak and death consciously reduced to a neat logo. Sold. 2.5/5
Respect to old Motown vibes! I have listened this album several times but not for many years. Still sounds as I remember. Great album but doesn't bring anything new to table.
I used to listen the heck out of this album. I burned a CD-R for car use, it was one of the few pieces of music my ex-wife would listen to without whining, along with Duffy's Rockferry. I like most of the album songs, some of it turned out to be a bit iffy as far as her decisions in life go. There are a few songs I don't like as much, for instance that one with kinda crappy reggae vibes, but overall a great album!
What a talent. A big departure from her excellent debut (which I may still prefer), but love the nostalgic sound and of course her voice
Powerful album!
Another album that I was familiar with but had never listened to fully. It did not disappoint. The songs I was already familiar with sounded great in context, Tears dry on their own being a real highlight, and the rest of the tracks were good as well. Overall though the album tracks never did top the singles so it didn't blow me away, still a good listen so I'll give it a 4.
Perfecto
Saknar henne och hennes coola röst. Sjukt att hon under sin livstid bara gav ut två album varav detta är det sista. För mig banbrytande och coolt. Jag minns henne som häftig när hon slog igenom, att hon gjorde något nytt. Det är fortfarande en mycket bra skiva som producerade så många bra singlar. Hon var en talang!
What a voice
It wasn't for me. Didn't feel creative enough for the year. 2
her voice is not appealing to me
Best album ever
Awesome album, beautiful voice. One of those album you can listen top to bottom without disappointment
I was a bit of a contrarian prick when this record came out and didn’t deem it worthy of a second listen. I was completely wrong and I’m glad this got generated for me to give a second chance.
8.5 / 10
- very groovy and Jazzy - Incredible Voice and instrumentals - upbeat and bouncy songs are incredibly catchy - weird dissonance between subject of the lyrics and instrumentals, probably very intentional - the slower songs ( me & mr jones, love is a losing game) are “carried” by/ focus on her incredible voice - comes together as an interesting painting of a troubled and passionate life. - it has a cynicism to it that is mostly enhanced by the irony of the contrasts between bouncy jazz tunes and lyrics about addiction and a life that is falling apart (best seen in rehab, which carries itself with the defiance of a misunderstood and headstrong person that won’t change her ways) - gives the album a tragic sense of self awareness in hindsight
An iconic album with fantastic songs!! The type of songs you can't help but sing along to.
I mean, she has phenomenal musical ability. I'm familiar with Amy Winehouse, but her accent completely threw me off since it's my first time listening to her. I like this album, it's not up my lane tho, idk how to explain it, I will def be listening to songs from this album when it comes on shuffle but probably won't seek it out in my playlist.
I’m not sure what the hype is for Amy?
I don't know that i've listened to this entire album before. It was great.
I am very conflicted on my thoughts on this one. On one hand its easily enjoyable, singable, and performed with a soulful voice and a brass section rarely appearing in 'pop' songs like this. On the other hand, I can't help but feel a more raw production, perhaps more depth to the instrumentation, would being this album more in line with old soul records. Regardless, the lyrics, though rather exoteric, remain incredibly memorable and fully explore Amy Winehouse vices and life at this stage. Its actually shocking at times how vulnerable and exposing she is about her experiences. I'm rating this album as a 4 - accounting for my personal enjoyment and that despite its polished production it is peerless for its time of release, though i could see it argued as a 3
Best: You know I’m no good. Overall, I think I am inclined to rate this album higher more because of nostalgia/familiarity than my actual enjoyment. The Neo-Soul/Jazz Pop style of Back to Black isn’t one that I would typically gravitate towards; however, I did feel like it was produced well. The variety of instruments was great, loads of horns & brass, piano, guitar, etc.; progressions were uncomplicated, which worked with the lighter sound of the album. Given the upbeat tone, I expected the tempo to be faster than it actually was; however, I do think this worked in AWs favour as it allowed her to really showcase her vocals, which were, in a word, incredible. She sings with such an amazing, smoky, soulful quality in her voice; the way she shapes every syllable on longer notes with so much control and so effortlessly is impressive. The lyrics are witty and sarcastic even while addressing topics like addiction and heartbreak; the contrast between the brutally candid lyrics and the upbeat tone of the music created a sense of dissonance to what could have easily been a much darker album. It feels unfair of me to rate the album low because objectively it is very good; however, I don’t think I would listen to it again, even though there are a few songs I could probably sing every lyric to.
Her voice with the jazzy pop beat made her who she is. Nice!
This album reminds me of having dinner at the cottage with my parents over a nice glass of wine. It was the perfect start for me
perfection — I've never actually listened to the entire album, but boy, what a gift!
Probably the best of what pop can do in the modern age: smooth vocals and pleasant orchestration.
Damn she bad! This albums pretty good and I love her vocals. The bass is addictive in this album and works great! Peak music fr.
Amy Winehouse was not someone I really got into back in the mid 2000's. I didn't care for the song Rehab and didn't give her music much thought after that. I was saddened by her inevitable death, but even then I didn't do a dive into her work. I've heard a few other songs here and there, but even those never really impressed me much. I was interested when this record came up today, as it felt like I never gave her music a fair chance and this was my opportunity to do so. The only song that I strongly liked, after listening today, was You Know I'm No Good. With it being the second song, I was hopeful that maybe I was going to be pleasantly surprised with the rest of the album. As the record progressed I wasn't finding that to be the case and I was questioning myself why I wasn't enjoying it. I really liked it musically, and it was well produced. She has a vocal sound that I like from artists of an earlier era, and I wondered if this came out in the 1950's if I'd feel differently about it. Then it hit me as it felt very affected, and I found it to be off-putting rather than an homage to past jazz/soul singers. I didn't find this to be a bad album at all, just one I don't care that much for.
Day 188 Talented but not for me. Highlights Back to Black
Realized I only really knew half the songs. It’s so good, but makes me sad.
I completely ignored Amy Winehouse when she was alive but came to appreciate her talent later. Love the title track but the rest of the album is not quite a 5.
Amazing. 10/10. No notes.
Very well produced, well made R&B. I think part of this album’s legacy is due to Winehouse’s premature passing, but it’s still a very solid album in it’s own right.
It's a favorite.
bombo
Perfection. As simple as that. Beautiful record. I love it from start to finish with zero skips and no filler whatsoever. Stunning !
Even though i was around for the rise and fall of Amy, i never listened to the album fully. I really like Ronson's production and the singles are amazing, and Amy's personality shines through even on the deep cuts. I've never cared much for Rehab, but You know i'm no good is an all timer. If the non-singles were better i'd rate this higher.
Forgot how amazing this album was
rip mac miller
Banger
She seems to be really good at what she does. But what she does do, does nothing for me, I’m afraid.
Such a beautiful, beautiful voice. Every song was enjoyable.
I didn't realise how much I knew of this album, but I was singing along to almost every song. There's so much life in these songs, but also so much sadness and self-deprecation. Her voice is unmatched, and the arrangement of the songs is brilliant. Very close to being a 5 star for me!
To be honest I haven’t heard much from Amy. Just the usual ones. I do like this album but it’s not my fav. But I can see why people really liked it. 3.5
10/10
I was expecting more? Great voice but something in the mix/production was just off to me. Instrumentally was just boring. Mid 3
Soul with strong female vocals. This should be my type of music, but I'm not really feeling it. I don't like Winehouse's voice, and the instrumentals aren't that interesting to me (perhaps because of the pop and r&b influence).
I’ve cone around to Amy Winehouse. I can’t deny how good her singing is, and I love contralto voices like Fiona Apple.
A masterclass in soulful pop. Incredible production paying homage to the peak of Motown without sounding derivative or hokey, raw lyrics that make you feel like the story being told is your own. And Amy's voice, my god her voice is pure buttery delight. I often think about what could have been had she not left us so young. What kind of music would she have graced us with on her follow up to this absolute classic of an album.
I always liked her. Great album.
Enjoyed the nods to classic R&B
Amazing voice, enjoyed the album.
Amazing, showstopping, slayed the houseboots down Huston i'm desceased 11/10 all bangers.
Perfect album
took me back! I enjoyed listening to it
When you listen to this album, it makes you remember how much of a trailblazer Amy Winehouse was for female artists. She totally broke the mold about what a female pop artist should sound like and the type of music they should make. I always felt like Amy Winehouse was one of those people you would describe as an "old soul", and this album perfectly depicts that. She did her own thing and she did it beautifully!
Soul music! Looking at the list I see some songs I already know, some I don't. Hit play, quickly pick up on great singing, good playing, good tunes, great arrangements and production (Salaam Remi and Mark Ronson, mmm). Lyrics quite wild! I start reading more widely - oh dear - I knew she had AOD problems, didn't know it was that bad ... That sadness is now hanging over this record for me ... doesn't make the music any worse, but kills my excitement for the "wild vibe" - while leaving the tensions as mesmerising as ever. Went back for extra listens, particularly the songs I found most interesting - some very striking packages of music, lyrics, delivery, eg Tears Dry On Their Own. My appreciation deepens. Some songs are so-so, but overall it's Quite Wonderful, 9/10.
One of the most unique and soulful albums of my time. I still remember the first time I saw her sing Rehab. She blew me away.
This my 41st album and the first time I've been left genuinely wanting more. (Seriously, only 34 minutes.)
I knew the singles but not the album, the track Back to Black is just killer, but I enjoyed the whole thing. 4 stars.
Bruuuuv
aguante amy
classico
her voice to me sounds like a James bond song, super cool instrumental track
I get it now, first time listening and I get it. Especially for the final two tracks, excellent music and an excellent voice
3.7 never really listened to Amy Winehouse, but she aaaight
after to listening to a lot of 60's soul which helped inspire her, man she did really well on this album.
She had talent, that's for certain, and I would have loved to see her songwriting mature. But the production is so airless. You have the players... let them breathe!
이건 제가 무조건 좋아할 수 밖에 없죠 허스키한 여성 보컬리스트인데
Fantastic debut, with Amy’s soulful voice shining through and well produced horns and backing. A couple of bangers, including ‘Rehab’ and ‘Back To Black’, with ‘Love Is A Losing Game’ another highlight, if very sad. 2nd half of the record not quite as stellar as the first, which holds it back from 5 stars.
That voice!
Heard Frank recently because of 1001 and it blew my mind the evolution of Amy from there to this. The music is amazing, the lyrics are profound and Amy's vocal range is beautiful. Going to definitely listen to it again soon.
It was a great listen!
Still enjoyable.
Ive had her first record before and both of them are equally great. Its still wild that this type of music was popular in the club banger era of music. Probably different demos but still. To have akon and Amy doing their things at the same time is still insane. Its sad that this is it. And she definitely should have gone to rehab but its still a great song. A bit sadder but still great. The title track is great too. Also me and mr Jones is a standout too. Hearing the word fuckery with these instrumentals is funny. Its just a good record with great vocals and a fun style that would have maybe only gotten better.
Good overall, although not my usually liked stuff. I can appreciate
Best album of the decade....possibly
Decent 4
Would rather listen to the pioneers of this style than the emulator.
No no no
Stórkostleg plata, stutt og hnitmiðuð og algert bangerasafn. Rehab er soundtrackið við bíltúr lífs míns.
I am bias because I already loved this album, and I do so even more now.
Ok but wouldn’t listen to it on a whim
Ay bunu diğer albümünden çok daha fazla sevdim zaten bildiğim şarkılar da vardıııo yüzden 555555
We have all heard the jokes, but you should really hear the album too.
This is a cracking album. It's shame Winehouse's career was cut so terribly short. A terrific voice, great lyrics.
This is a very good version of a thing I don't like very much
Great voice and the retro style is really interesting. Not afraid of dark subject matter
One of my favorite voices of the last 30 years. This album in particular has so much of what I love about soul music. It's not perfect, but neither was she.
Good song, great singer. Good listen, doesn’t really move me though.
Cool! 3.4 if i could
Oh my god, this is the album with You Know I'm No Good. I can't believe I have never done a deep dive of this album. My goodness I knew i liked Amy's voice but DAMN GIRL holy shit. TITLE TRACKKKKK<3 oh wow the brass on these tracks. Oh had I thought to listen to this album in my teens, I would be insufferable.
Idk why but I thought she was from the 60s? She’s got an amazing voice that carries so much soul.
Music is a 3. Amy’s voice is a 5 (minimum). Took the avg: 4
A classic for sure but more skips that didn’t resonate with me than I remembered. An all time voice and presence gone far too soon. I still like Frank better.
No skips. Derivative? Yeah, I could see that. Do I give a shit? I don't, I can't: the 34-minute runtime puts this at #1 of 1089 for quality per second of playback. Her voice, her lyrics, the punches still deck me 20 years later. Listing the ✅✅✅✅ songs here only: Back to Black Tears Dry On Their Own Wake Up Alone
Never gets old and always feels of the moment. A perfect album that makes doing something bad and raw and gritty just feel so damn...good.
I remember being really high but having to watch Amy Winehouse sing “Rehab” on one of the late night shows with my parents because our friend Ian was playing in the band. Couldn’t really figure out what to make of it at the time.
🖤
Rehab 4/10 You Know I'm No Good 3/10 Me & Mister Jones 2/10 Just Friends 2/10 Back To Black 4/10 Love Is A Losing Game 3/10 Tears Dry On Their Own 4/10 Wake Up Alone 3/10 Some Unholy War 3/10 He Can Only Hold Her 3/10 Addicted 3/10
Great songs, hell of a voice, TERRIBLE mastering. The drums are downright deep fried.
One of the all times, every song carries its own and Amy is in full swing. An incredible talent, a star of the likes we'll never see again. SPUN
Yes
adele if she couldn't sing
My contrarian nature meant I largely avoided this at the time as it seemed like a hipster fad with no musical merit. Happy to admit I was wrong. She has a uniquely powerful voice, and this album is full of well written, Motown inspired modern-day anthems.
well duh
Just an amazing album. It's a smooth ride. The story-telling ballads allow you to just kind of get lost in the listening. Winehouse's voice is phenomenal. "Me and Mr Jones" is a long-time favorite of mine, with "Tears Dry On Their Own" being a close second. Love this album. Utterly timeless.
Cannot say that I ever liked Amy Winehouse. Didn’t like her life choices or her music particularly. She was a strong singer although it got a bit shrieky on certain songs which I never found easy on the ears. Always tragic that a young person was so troubled that she died so young when she had the talent to make a bigger mark than she already had. Despite my ambivalence to her I do actually have this album on CD. Not out of love for the music but more the significance of the album which is highly regarded by those in the know. Thought I should have a copy but I bought it cheap from a charity shop second hand. To be true to myself and my scoring system I should only give this album 1 star. But given its popularity that would put it at the top of ‘albums I like less than most’ which at time of reviewing would put it at -3.01 and ahead of Rage Against the Machine on -2.99. This album and Amy do not deserve that ignominy so marked up accordingly. 2/5 30/1/26
What a legendary and fantastically produced album. Depressingly hard to listen to considering lyrics about the substance abuse that lead to her death. But wow; so tight Mark Ronson production, especially the drums. Though I’ve never listened to this album front to back, its popularity made this a nostalgia trip into the past, partly because many of the songs I’ve heard many times before, and partly because vocals and songwriting style have clearly inspired so many artists after her. A piece of cultural bedrock.
Great
phenomenal album, truly a no skip what a legacy to leave, love amy love this album and there’s truly nothing like it. such a cohesive sound you forget its not just one long song. this woman truly knows how to tell a story: 10/10
now I’m obsessed with Amy Winehouse
While this is better than the other album of hers I got on here, I just can't get into Amy Winehouse.
Felt more out together and tight than Frank, not my favorite music but she was clearly a very talented singer. RIP
A classic, paired back arrangement and beautiful voice
10/10 such a creative and beautiful album, i’m still torn that she passed away so young
Listened before
rehab is pretty fire, just very repetitive. you know i’m no good is also very good, i like this me and mr jones is hot ass, if this is your favorite song then you have no taste in music i’m not listening to the rest of the album, is so shit
Absolutely wonderful album. Perfect for a nice dinner. Relaxing and classic, with tons of nostalgia.
10/10
What a quick yet impactful 30 minutes with a really a unique sound that sounds so similar to what the 60’s sounded. Amy just gives a powerful independent perspective about herself and her music I just can’t help but feel bliss and optimistic when listening to it all.
Good but overplayed at this point.
• Rehab is a great opening track for this album. We studied this song in class as an example of how to write horn accompaniments, and it's easy to see why. This song is Amy Winehouse's sound in a nutshell, and it's a sound nobody else in modern music has really come close to replicating. • Back to Black is also iconic for very good reason. • Tears Dry On Their Own makes good use of the Ain't No Mountain backing track. It's uncommon for me to listen to a song sampling a very famous track and not feel like it's just a worse version of the original (see: Anxiety, I'm Good), but this song somehow avoids that. Amy Winehouse was one of the more unique voices of the 2000's, and her talent really couldn't be overstated. There's a reason her music still resonates with people today. There were a few songs that didn't quite grab my attention, but the songs that did were all great. The singles in particular were all fantastic, and her most popular songs definitely earned their popularity. Favourite song: Rehab
Not really my cup of tea even though she was very talented
:)
Iconic album! Set the tone for a particular retro sound for the new generation
All time album. Easy 5/5. This is Amy at her best. I listened to her debut on this list as well and it doesn’t hold a candle to this one. A perfect sound start to finish. The title track is my favorite, but there are so many gems on here.
3.5/5
Es buen disco, pero sobrevalorado. La producción me sigue pareciendo rara porque no suena limpio, es como si sonase a través de la radio. Y en cuanto a la cantante, está bien, pero muy amanerada y forzada, no me parece el talento que muchas veces se quiere hacer ver.
Love how frank she talks about addiction long before it was normalized
Definitely a fantastic pop album. Nearly every song on here is just solid pop glory.
My nostalgia for this era probably made this rank higher, but the first 3/4 of this album is great, with the remaining still good listens.
My rating 4.2 Fabulous album. Love the nostalgia sounds alone side the cutting lyrics. Just Great.
I was excited to listen to this because I had only heard the singles, but I came away kind of disappointed. It seems a little bit one note to me. I can definitely see where some of the more recent European pop stars are influenced by this, but it’s not something that I would go back to.
Voice, horns, lyricism, feeling, - this album has everything
Really stellar. Didn't know I'd heard so much Amy Winehouse already. Excited to hear some of these again
really solid and cohesive album. I was surprised at how many songs I actually knew! love how much bari was in there
Classic album by Winehouse. Solid listen all the way through, and shows serious maturity after her first album. Too bad we lost her. 5/5
One of the best pop albums of the 21st century. So many bangers. Favorite track: Back To Black
The last time I saw her perform was at the V Festival in 2008, and in 2025 I stood in Camden and saw her statue. Knowing there will never be another chance to hear that voice live makes the album feel heavy in a way that goes beyond music. Listening to this album now simply makes me feel sad — sad that such a voice is gone, and that all we have left are the recordings.
If anyone was ever born to sign the theme song for a Bond movie, it was Amy Winehouse
I'd heard OF Amy Winehouse, I'd not heard Amy Winehouse. I was not prepared for this to be this good. Fuck yeah. Four stars.
Peel away all of the substance abuse and mental health issues. Peel away all of the hospitalizations and legal troubles. They're all part of a larger tragedy about how we lose great great artists way too soon. Remove all of that and you still have this amazing phenomenal voice that is still mesmerizing.
Don’t understand the love for her.
Initially I was thinking 5, but then some songs dragged. Then some Jamaican rhythms kicked in, which is always a plus. In the end, I dig her voice, and most of her music.
So much better than the other Amy winehouse on this list. It’s got a much more serious approach than essentially being an hour of “fuck my man I hate him so much.” You can see how much she matured, makes it all the more tragic
Une voix incroyable, un morceau d'anthology, mais c'est globalement pas trop mon kiff.
a perfect album
I love this album, but I was 13 when it came out and it was one of the only albums I owned, so I am biased.
Loved!! I’ve owned this album since I was in high school. I loved singing all these songs. I sang a bunch of them at Karaoke at a family reunion back in the day. I didn’t want this album to end!
All the components of success are in place — a pleasant voice, reverences to old Motown releases in sound, the lyrics are mostly about love... At the same time, the album owes a considerable share of its popularity to the people who made the sound here, Mark Ronson and Salaam Remy; the songs from the former, in my opinion, came out more interesting. The audience and critics rated the record extremely highly, and overall it's not bad, but I don't understand this degree of enthusiasm, maybe it's just not for me.
me encanta este álbume!!! grande amy te extrañamos
Amazing beautiful album. I loved her vocals. Imma need more of this kind of music here please.
Amy Winehouse was super talented, but this album just really is not my style. It has some catchy jams, but I don't really see what all the hype is about.
2/3. Really great album, I'd heard it before but it was nice to come back to. Great voice, love the production, and the running theme of love and hate and addiction and the blurred lines between them plays out beautifully in the lyrics.
Rehab - 4.5/5 You Know I'm No Good - 4/5 Me & Mr. Jones - 4/5 Just Friends - 3/5 Back to Black - 4.5/5 Love is a Losing Game - 3/5 Tears Dry on Their Own - 4/5 Wake Up Alone - 3.5/5 Some Unholy War - 3/5 He Can Only Hold Her - 3.5/5 Addicted - 3.5/5 A tragic and melancholic piece hidden behind a devil-may-care and soulful attitude. Winehouse has a unique voice that sets this album apart from its contemporaries and will keep it being listenable in the future. Overall: 3.5/5 Favorites: Rehab, Back to Black, Tears Dry on their Own
Absolutely excellent. 5 Stars
Favourite Songs: Rehab You Know I'm No Good Me & Mr Jones Back To Black Addicted
Ive done this album a day thing before and this was one of them. A classic no skip album. I dont know why I dont listen to her more often. It's so raw and real while maintaining its playfulness. I love how she gives credit to her contemporizes something people are rare to do today especially in when crediting black artists. In back to blacks case amny have tried to repeat it and have failed.
Not a fan, never got the hype.
A bit too repetitive. The songs are good standalone but I wouldn't want to listen to an album. Talented singer but the music wasn't really the type I like.
My queen Amy. We miss you a lot.
This is such a great album with some really good songs that are poignant and sung by someone with an incredible voice. lots of notable songs and an album I would happily listen to time and time again. I already own this. this album holds out with love is a losing game on its own, which is the standout track. 4.5 Stars
I remember the time period when this came out. I wasn't really a fan then because it sounded so much like artists that did before and better. I get it. I think she has a cool voice, and there are a few tracks that are pretty good, but I still think there were others a long, long time ago that did it significantly better.
The only thing that I knew of Amy Winehouse was that she died of alcohol poisoning. That being said, I really enjoyed this album, and thought it was fun with a throwback vibe. It gets four stars.
A classic album tainted now by Amy’s personal life. The album barks back to 1960s soul with the production skills of Mark Ronson. The album is littered with fantastic songs, great playing, great singing, brilliant lyrics and fantastic production.
I appreciate her voice and fervor, but find the album pretty much one-note. The popularity of the Rehab song just depresses me--rehab could have helped. The retro vibe is supremely well-done, indeed, and it is a pity she died before she could explore that avenue to its fullest.
Although I knew every song it was interesting to listen afresh after a while away. I think she has a great voice although she sometimes comes across as mimicking. There are some fab tunes on here but again, so maudlin that I can only take it in small doses. Also the themes are slightly wearing but it hit today.
I've mentioned before that I never quite warmed up to Amy Winehouse's affect, but I am mostly indifferent to her musical endeavors. While I never quite got the frenzy over her work, I think I came around a little on this listen, and there are a couple of songs that I downright enjoyed. I'm not exactly over the hump, but sure, this was pretty good. Can't hear her without feeling a pang of sorrow over how no one was able to help her beat her demons.
I dig the retro vibe. Up to a point. Sometimes the homages become outright ripoffs, which was distracting. Her limited range and affected singing style also gets to me. She's clearly a star. She can clearly sing. But like Adele, she keeps doing the same things in almost every song. But unlike Adele, I like her a lot more. When it works, it works really well. The title track was unfamiliar to me and it's a stunner. Love is a Losing Game is another classic. There were others that I dug, but in general, there's something that keeps me at arm's length. I guess what I'm saying is I wish I liked it more. (Unsure what to give this. I feel like a 3 is too low but a 4 seems high given the conflicting emotions I had. But, at least I had emotions...?)
I was really wow’d by Amy and her band when they first hit. Now I mostly get sad listening to this album. Also starts to sound the same.
Perfect vocal. Back to Black song is a masterpiece. It's just unbearable pain! What a pity!
Great album, cohesive. The latter half is much better than the first half. Favs: love is a losing game & addicted
Awesome.
Love is a losing game, tears dry on their own, and addicted were all new to me. How had I not listened to this whole album before? Amy, we didn’t deserve you. But we are so grateful you left us with your profound music.
I am honestly surprised by Winehouse's sound. I admit I never listened to her music though I heard so much about her. She sang with the sounds of old souls (Ella Fitzgerald, Billie Holiday and Frank Sinatra) and I absolutely love her music. Will definitely return to this album and explore her other offerings.
HELL YEAH LITERALLY WAS LISTENING TO HER A COUPLE DAYS AGO cause i remember my last taxi ride in milan having her on aux. guys we already know the rating. shes literally perfect to me.
This would be a brilliant instrumental album but for me, it's ruined by the vocals. I do not enjoy AW's singing voice and found myself trying to block it out.
But to walk away I have no capacity, my tears dry on their own
6/10
Great album with a voice like that it’s hard not to give it a 5
Such an easy listen for me. Love this one.
Absolutely impeccable album. Start to finish a belter. A story told through song. What more can be said?
All this time I thought Amy Winehouse was "just" a popstar and meanwhile she was making blues and soul music… Is it pastiche? Of course. It is also pretty damn good all the same.
She's great, I can't explain. I love how you can feel and hear the artists the genres, and the culture that influenced her, yet it's so original and one of a kind. The instrument are perfect and her voice inside. Addictive, unrepeatable. I cannot put into words how important she is and her music with her. Timeless, so well produced, so well written. It combines new and old, vintage and modern in everything. It's so detailed and you can just feel the attention, the passion, the talent. Ok, I'll stop, I just love it.
One of my favorite albums
A no skip album from a generational talent. Her voice, her lyrics, this album is everything. Favorite song: Love is a Losing Game.
i don't listen to her in my spare time but i can't deny the impact of this. i'd heard the majority of the songs before many times which speaks to how iconic it is
Love you Amy rest in peace sweet girl
Banger after banger
Such a great but sad album
😍🤩
One of the finest recording of the 21st century, helped by the production of mark ronson and salaam remi. Retro meets modernism. Who knows what could’ve been had rehab not been necessary…..
Great voice and opening track but it started sounded a bit too much the same as the album went on. Plenty of other better modern soul singers like Sharon Jones that would put her in her place
A timeless blend of modern R&B and old-school Motown
Dét kender jeg godt, men har ikke hørt længe. Skønt album, dejligt genlyt.
Second and final Amy Winehouse album. It's been a good while since her last - almost 350 albums, the longest gap to date. I haven't gone back to Frank and it has sadly had it's must-listen status revoked from future editions of the book, so I guess I'm vindicated. This album hasn't, however. I'm confident that Amy Winehouse will never be within my sphere of interest, but I'm hoping to get her appeal through listening to this album. I know that it's a big deal and I want to appreciate Winehouse purely for being an iconic musician. It's more polished than her debut and I appreciate the short runtime, but everything beyond the two big hits failed to resonate with me. Those two smash hits are carried by some solid songwriting and good vocal performances, which more than compensate for how milquetoast the soul/R&B instruments are. By comparison, the rest of the album lingers/blends together and doesn't do nearly as much to grab my attention, which left me disengaged for much of the remaining runtime. There's some decent instrumentation peppered here and there, though never enough to substantially elevate the material. Overall, I was pretty bored by this. I've heard "Rehab" before. Not sure where, however. It's decent. I like the plucky sax, and Winehouse's vocals are decent. Way better than I remember them being on Frank. I've heard "Back to Black", too. I recall hearing it through Jet Set Radio Live, though I'm sure I've also heard it prior to that - likely through the radio. The spy/thriller feel of the track is pretty fun. The songwriting and Amy's vocals do a good job of elevating that feel, and the strings/gothic-sounding bells give the track an appealing, dramatic feel. Book time. This was added to the 2008 revision, replacing Frank. References motown and black music of the 60s. "...this is the real Amy. And the real Amy is music's soul savior". Not sure how I feel about that last comment and there surprisingly isn't much of substance to this entry, but I know this is a big deal and one of the best-selling albums. I cosign this inclusion.
Wow I love this…I’ve never listened to her before, nor do I know much about her, but from what I do know, this album is actually very sad. Behind the very jazzy energetic instrumentals there’s very real and raw lyrics telling her story & the struggles she was facing.
Pretty good love her voice
10/10
I mean, there's a reason this is one of the best selling albums of all time. I do wonder sometimes how her legacy would have been affected by music after this. I think ending on a high note can have a really different impact on the world than ending on a low, and I think it'd be interesting to see how things would've panned out if she had gotten clean or broken apart from her father or something. Favorites: Rehab, Back to Black, Some Unholy War
Another one that I've had in my collection for ages after picking it up in a bargain bin sale, but that I've never bothered with. This record is a definite improvement on the debut, generally being easier to stomach vocally and it has a stronger sense of songwriting nous. The big hits/obvious highlights here do the heavy lifting. However, I can't help but find the overall experience still somewhat fatiguing - particularly as the back half went on, I was eyeing up putting something else on. This could end up joining the clearout pile as I'm not sure when I'd elect to put it on again.
This is a tough one to rate because she is SO damn talented but some of her music just isn’t for me
what a smooth ass album. great melodies and chord progressions. amy's voice is electric. I've never listened to a full album from Amy before but I know her hits. the vibe of this album is great. really great percussion in her songs as well. i like this!
I love this album. I can not count the number of times I have listened to it. Now I am playing it for my daughter.
Great album!
so like... this is what every single pop girly from the late 2000's and 2010's was ripping off, and it DEF deserves all the accolades, with the lovely jazzy stuff to it and just the brilliant vocals, such a cool album for sure
No doubt about the significance of this album, just a high-quality pop record that really matches the era of Motown artists, but highlighting modern issues and scenarios. Compared to her other album, she really found her groove and props to her for that. Undoubtedly one of the most recognisable vocals in music.
This is wonderful. Her range in the middle made for easy listening.
I’ve seen complaints recently that albums are getting shorter, but this is an excellent example of a perfectly concise, iconic record. Timeless sound in a modern setting. Listening reminds me of what a great we lost, wondering what she would have gone on to create.
AMY FOREVER
There’s no way this album was getting anything less than 5.
me encanta, no hay nada igual
Not my type of music
8,8/10
Took me three listens to enjoy it to its full potential. This one you need to listen in silence to really get it.
One of my all time favs
I'm obviously aware of some of these tracks because how could you not be as they've been played to death on radio and elsewhere since its release! It's always mildly annoyed me how much attention she got and I whilst she's ok, I don't rate her anywhere near where people seem to singing, as she does, mostly throwbacks. So this is a well produced album and there's some decent songs on it but there'll always be that disconnect for me and frankly there's better female UK soul singers that I love so I'll stick with them thanks!
I'm being honest I've heard about Amy looooong time ago but because I've just heard back to black (the song) and actually it was a great album, her vibe was just so unique as well as her voice, im gonna listen more about her music actually this album was and it is incredible and so smooth, I love it.
LOVE LOVE LOVE
It feels like a very very good album, but I just don't vibe with this kind of music.
Love
funk
Absolute banger of an album. The roots in Blues and ska and that raspy rebellious voice of Amy’s is undeniably great, and worth every second of my time listening to this album.
Smokey jazz.club.
A modern masterpiece
Better than expected. Very charismatic and catchy.
Solid album
not my thing
Great album start to finish. There's not a single bad thing to say.
good album
First time fully listening to this album which is long overdue. Extraordinary voice, love the jazzy music, iconic, love and addiction. I listen to it twice and it’s a vibe I could relate with some lyrics as well. Favourite is probably „love is a losing game“ and „Addicted“ (ofc back to black and rehab as well, famous for a reason)
I need to listen to diss
Insanely influential for singers like Adele. It's crazy how much of a distinctive style she has on this album. You'd obviously recognize her voice anywhere, but also the instrumentation (drums & trumpets), and her raw and unfiltered writing style, singing about drugs, alcoholism, her goo-for-nothing ex relationship she can't let go off. Obviously very influenced by Black soul singers. Had no idea Amy and Nas crossed paths, worked together and more?? Back to Black is one of the most recognizable 00s tracks, goes so fucking hard with that beat and the instruments
Have listened to before, great songs popular for a reason!
5/5 perfect album 💿
lovely 🥹
El amor es en definitiva la musa más prolífica y eso lo vi en este álbum. Amy escribió y cantó con tanta pasión en este álbum que es imposible no sentir muchas de las canciones como cercanas a uno.
Now here's the thing about Amy. I'm not a fan of her voice, or her songs, or even herself. But, there is just something about it all that just fits. She is the epitome of the whole being greater than the sum of its parts. In her case by a factor of ten. I just can't help but admire her. Still doesn't mean I like the album though so its just, a 2
Sensational song writing, story telling and production to support her amazing vocal. The whole album just flows.
I've never listened to this all the way through before. There was a lot of hype around thus album at the time, but i had better things to do than have anything to do with an album which was being advertised at the time on TV. That was an instant turn off for artists lucky enough to be plugged like that. The other artist to be plugged like this was Micheal Buble, that is the same standing Amy Winehouse had in my books. I digress. The album is very good, the style of jazzy blues or what ever it is complemented her exceptional vocal performance. Very enjoyable, and I night give it a listen again when no one is in earshot.
Not a big fan of Amy, good album though. Favourite song - Tears dry on their own. 7/10
Didn't really care for Rehab when it was big, but this album is really much more than the single. Enjoyed it quite a bit.
fun but nothing special. Many crowd favorites though.
Most enjoyable songs --------- Rehab You know I'm no good Back to black Love is a loosing game --------
Love it
Not my favorite
all times fav perfect masterpiece
Album 7 Top 3 favorites off the album: Tears Dry On Their Own, Back to Black, He Can Only Hold Her I remember thinking the first time I heard something off this album that Amy Winehouse was from a whole lot earlier than she was. 50s, 60s. I was surprised that I was old enough to remember hearing she had died. I think the album has a good sound. I like the saxophone. Winehouse has that gravelly vocal quality and lower range that I dig. I guess I had the album built up in my head, and everything inevitably falls flat when you do that. It's not one specific thing over another, which may seem unfair. This is unusually short for an entry. I don't have much else to say. Definitely a good album, and makes me wish I could rate in half stars as well.
Good album. I haven’t listened to any of these songs for a long time and I don’t actually like the album quite as much as I thought I did. I don’t remember her whole thing sounding as much of an affectation as it does listening to it again now. She had a great voice though she was obviously very talented and I like and appreciate her vulnerability.
The brightest candles are always burned at both ends. Amy Winehouse sang jazz standards and was refreshing to hear in the 00's. This album would fit right in a collection of 60's girls groups.
Oh Amy, how I love you. The last four songs drag a little, but the album is undoubtedly a 5. Amy was one of a kind, and a great songwriter.
not my thing
I wanted to like this album less but its really good, as long as you skip rehab (overplayed).
There is absolutely nothing about this record that I could say that hasn't been repeated in effusive praise elsewhere. I cannot believe this is 20 years old this year. Rest in peace, Amy. You gave us more than we deserved, and we asked of you far more than we had any right to.
Brilliant album only marred by some song lyrics feeling very uncomfortable, particularly with the hindsight of 20 years and a few documentaries.
Beautiful and smoky. What a loss.
Really good vocals, very inspiring, true story, story telling, amazing, chill session
I'll voice an unpopular opinion, but Amy Winehouse's vocals are absolutely grating, as is her music, which barely changes from song to song. Apart from the first song, there's absolutely nothing worth listening to.
It wasn't bad. I liked Amy's voice but not my favorite songs.
I know it well enough to already know I love it
***A good, easy listening album
I mean its iconic, absolutely timeless
Love it! Zo veel hits en echt een goede leuke vibe! 8/10 Wel
Even before listening to this I know I’m going to LOVE because I already like a lot of these songs. Ok going to be honest I haven’t finished but I love her and the songs I’ve listened to. That’s all.
Great album. Too pop y for me
Like it.
100/10
- tämä on kyllä solidi platta, voisi jopa sanoa että no skip levy
Great voice.
love amy winehouse 🤍🤍🤍
1. Wake Up Alone 2. Tears Dry On Their Own 3. Love Is a Losing Game I love this album a lot. I like the instrumentals and the mix of slow/fast songs. Some are really music oriented and others are more mainstream pop but they all work well together. I have given it 4 mostly because this is not my favourite Amy album, I prefer Frank. But, i would have given it 4.5 if I could because it’s not missing much. I like the talking/singing style of some Frank songs and more emphasis on the instrumentals which is not on this album as much. (Frank also has an intro/outro which I love).
She gets clowned so bad, maybe deservedly so, but this is good music with “voice of a generation” level vocals. I enjoyed this way more than I expected to!
Perfekt
Really excellent in most regards. Obviously Amy's vocals are exceptional; it is remarkable that she does channel the great female singers of the 60s - especially Ronnie Spector - but still sounds super current. Funnily, I think the thing that is often lauded - the production - lets it down a little. It's just a touch too bouncy to let some of the vulnerability of the songs through. It's possible that the number of sub-par imitations that arrived in Amy's wake haven't helped with that perception though. Still, a really great experience to listen to it in full for the first time in a very long time.
4/5. What a legend
We miss you mama. Such soul in that voice, such sorrow in those words.
Unbelievably talented. What could have been
Eh
Masterpiece, sad she's gone.
Would be 5 if Rehab wasn't here. Vibed with the rest. Three songs added to my favorites.
This has been on my desert island list since the first time I heard it. RIP Amy 💔
timeless classic! whoever doesn’t like this album doesn’t like music, period
actually so good