Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 4 of 15)

Nada en contra, muy lindos sonidos y la voz de Fiona… pero me quería pegar un tiro del aburrimiento mientras escuchaba el álbum. No soporté

Fiona i sin kjente og kjære singer-songwriter/piano rock-stil. Hun er flink, og det hele er ganske nydelig. Samtidig er det litt kjedelig, og jeg kommer neppe til å tilbringe mye tid med dette albumet i fremtiden. Top 3: Sullen Girl, The First Taste, Sleep to Dream

4.25 - oh my sweet Fiona. I love her later albums a slight bit more, but anything she puts out is golden. Fav songs this time around: Pale September // Carrion // Criminal // Sullen Girl

not for me

Its not horrible

i lowkey like it

not done.

Very Blue

Pretty good

Intelligent lyrics, sung well.

The video for Criminal made 13 year old me have interesting feelings, and also wonder why she was wearing so many layers of undergarments...

spectacular! give me 14 of them right now

Fiona is an absolute killer vocalist. I love how subtlety she blends pop with jazz just enough to make it unseen to the average listener, but a spice for the engaged audience. Her melodies and poetry go hand in hand perfectly, which are just masterwork. For the musical era, she chooses such an interesting genre and feel for her composition, and it's incredibly original as it is great. The closing track to just hits so hard too, and to be using writing such extravagant arrangements for her DEBUT mind you, is just incomparable talent.

QUE MUJER LPM

Tidal de Fiona Apple me impresionó bastante. Es increíble que a los 18 años ya tuviera las conexiones y la oportunidad para crear un álbum así. No es mi género favorito, pero aun así se siente el talento y la intención desde el principio. El disco suena bien sincero, como si estuviera narrando exactamente lo que estaba viviendo en ese momento. Tiene una carga emocional fuerte que lo hace destacar, incluso si no es algo que escucharía todo el tiempo. En general, le doy un 4 de 5, más que nada por lo honesto y auténtico que se siente el proyecto.

I added every single song from this album onto my 'liked' songs on Spotify, so that I could come back and put them on my playlists. I was listening to this song while cleaning up around the house and drinking my cup of morning coffee. It's a beautiful spring morning, just chilly enough to leave the windows open, and this album gently soothed me as I worked on my chores. Fiona's voice is dreamy and inspiring.

When I was 19 I was joking smoking pot and trying to get laid. Certainly wasn’t recording a masterpiece.

nobody understands her :( seriously.. to me it seems every song is about someone who mistreated, didn't understand her, etc. and lyrics wise we got some deep stuff like: "You'll say you understand You'll never understand" Again not my cup of tea. But I'll rate it 3 stars like every other album that is in my opinion well made, authentic music.

Used to love this CD. Still enjoy it quite a bit. 4/5

This was a lot more straightforward than previous Fiona Apple albums we have done, but still very pretty. Enjoyable, but maybe not her finest.

Easy to listen to, lovely in places, got a bit samey and relentlessly melancholy by the end

Not really my cup of tea, but a great sounding album, very nice production. The opening track Sleep to Dream is great. I like the slower tracks too.

R&B/soul/jazz flavoured swung instrumentals and piano ballads, between jazzy and rappy fast talking, and all of this does not much for me. I think it is just too much vocals, singing, words for me. The instrumentation is nice, it has a warm analogue quality. The first cut is terrible, the tracks after get better. She is angry, she is feeling, she is hurt, but something about this just doesn;t really land

This is going to be a long walk so bear with me for a bit. Because of my job I would have to walk through an area of the city I worked in that was 99.9999999999% students at the University I worked at. When I was in school there this place was mostly frat houses but also a pretty low cost (for that close to the University) area for students to live. By this time the whole city and especially around the University were going through pretty rapid gentrification and change. The area around the University where students lived were mostly small quad apartments nothing over 3 stories tall. These were being bought up by developers and torn down to build multistory monstrosities. One day on my way to work one of the quad plex apartments must have been bought and was finally getting rid of the residents so they could rip it down and build a 'luxury' student living experience. (Quick aside here, but maybe kids just leaving their parents house should not be living in 'luxury'. I mean I get that there are some rich ass kids that go to this school but shit they are prolly in the greek system anyway). Sorry, so one of these places was being torn down and someone was just putting years of physical media out on the side walk in big plastic bins. We are talking burned DVD's full of data, VHS tapes, cassette tapes, CDR's. I went to my office and grabbed some bags and walked back up there to collect as much of it as I could before either the trash got picked up or someone else got this treasure trove just sitting on the side walk. It took me about a year to go through it all, there was a lot of bootlegged porn and music from torrent sites and the tapes and mini discs were mostly music, but as I got near to the end I hit what was the goldmine. Some girl (I hope the owner of all this stuff) had what I can only assume was an audio diary and maybe they forgot that this one tape was not a mix tape, or forgot to get rid of it, but it was a 90 minute tape that the A side was her complaining about her boyfriend, the B side was her clearly intoxicated and still complaining about said boyfriend but about 10 minutes in you can hear her put on Tidal by Fiona Apple and start to sing along to it letting out all the pain and suffering she has held inside of her because of this shit boyfriend. And that is why this album gets 5 stars. Also since this album is not listed we all need to recognize that this album title "When The Pawn Hits The Conflicts He Thinks Like A King What He Knows Throws The Blows When He Goes To The Fight And He'll Win The Whole Thing 'Fore He Enters The Ring There's No Body To Batter When Your Mind Is Your Might So When You Go Solo, You Hold Your Own Hand And Remember That Depth Is The Greatest Of Heights And If You Know Where You Stand, Then You Know Where To Land And If You Fall It Won't Matter, Cuz You'll Know That You're Right" is 100% about Paul Thomas Anderson.

* Sleep to Dream: malarda * Sullen Girl: floja, pero no tanto como la primera * Shadowboxer: same as last one * Criminal: meh pero mala * Slow Like Honey: la mejor hasta ahora, pero solo por la instrumental, la mina es floja * The First Taste: meh * Never Is a Promise: creo que esta es la mejor en cuanto instrumental y vocals. * The Child Is Gone: flojaza * Pale September: meh * Carrion: malaza en conclusión, no me gustó nada, la mina es flojísima, las instrumental hay tres o cuatro que safan pero las demás flojas

I’ve heard this before but it’s been a long time, probably not since the 90s. I remember thinking it was good but not really my thing as I had finally gotten into hardcore and was looking for heavier stuff. It’s really impressive how full the songwriting is and how mature considering she must have been 17 or 18 when she wrote these. Most of the songs are really great, with 2 or 3 that are bordering on filler territory. It’s a good album altogether.

Fiona fan, but Tidal is good but not great

las influencias a Lana están calcadísimas así que entiendo lo de ser pionera en alternative pop. Sullen girl me pareció muy linda y calma, y no ha sido un album malo por ahora. Slow like honey tiene todo lo que no me gusta en las canciones de Lana. Shadowboxer y the first taste suenan a Shakira Mebarak. Canta bonito.Final del álbum está un poco aburrido

of course i like this

I'll admit I stole this from Apple Music, but it perfectly sums it up: At the time, albums like Alanis Morissette's Jagged Little Pill and No Doubt's Tragic Kingdom (and events like the all-female Lilith Fair tour) had brought a feminist edge to the mainstream. But Tidal is both angrier and subtler. Apple knows how to make herself ten feet tall ('Sleep to Dream') while also expressing how small society has made her feel ('Sullen Girl'). She sounds older than she is ('Shadowboxer'), but points out that sexual abuse has a way of making you grow up fast ('The Child Is Gone'). If she takes pride in her powers of seduction, it's only because it's one of the few she's allowed to exercise ('Criminal'). While Billie Holiday—a childhood influence—transformed her pain with laughter, Apple wields hers like a blade: discreet, but it'll cut you."

Loved it, had only listened to Fetch the Bolt Cutters before.

Yeah, good. Had not heard of this artist or album before. Liked the first track instantly, trip hop beats and swooshy string arrangements. It was a bit disappointing that this remained best track on the album for me. A lot of tracks have a really similar tone, many with very similar chord progression/melodies. I would listen again and it might be a grower.

This was excellent. Never heard of her before

Enjoyed this. Shadowboxer is excellent

She's actually very good

This was great, Florence Welch owes a lot to Fiona Apple

Soulful mostly lower register voiced singer that doesn’t try to stretch too far outside of her range. Lyrics ache and yearn. Songs seem to take their time, unhurried to get where they’re going. Overall, album holds up after 30 years. Nice one to visit but not one i’d think to play

Better than I remember but still just not really my jam.

Trevlig lyssning men det kan väl inte mäta sig med gårdagens album

Stark trea

Vilken debut ändå! Unikt, roligt, sjölvsäkert! Men är det en fyra? Äh, svinstark trea efter ett varv iaf.

Gillar detta också, men kommer inte ifrån att jag saknar det mer råa och experimentella från igår! Stark 3a som kanske hade växt om jag lyssnat en vända till.

Oooh Fiona Apple-bonanza! Inte riktigt lika bra som förra. Lite enklare och mer lättlyssnat men vilket debutalbum haha

omg vad är oddsen!! vilken lycka!

Hard to knock this one.

This whole album had kind of a cabaret feel to it, and “Slow Like Honey” especially leaned into that. It sounded like the kind of thing that could've influenced somebody like Amy Winehouse a few years later. Fiona Apple has that same smoky, dramatic way of delivering a song where even the quieter moments still feel a little theatrical. I’m almost certain I’d heard “Criminal” before, and it was pretty catchy. That was the obvious standout, but the whole album had a strong mood to it. “Carrion” was a solid closer too.

Absolute godsend sent to me as the only music I had downloaded during a three-hour train journey on the floor of the vestibule. Good thing this slapped!

Love the melancholy vibes she brings to every track. Love the tender vocals and criminal is a classic

honestamente no le preste la atención necesaria asi que debería revisitarlo en algun momento

Surprisingly sophisticated. I’d dismissed her as pop and I was wrong.

130. nice

Off my first listen this feels like an album that I will listen to for the rest of my life. Every song on her does something interesting musically and also has something to say that feels so honest and really catches your attention. Not to do with the record but the cover is also really cool. Fav tracks: Sullen girl, Shadow boxer, slow like honey, The first taste, and Carrion

Esquecível

Strong 4

Fave songs: • Criminal • Slow like honey • The first taste Chilled out, sexy vibes but a bit strange/boring at points 6.5/10

Liked the personality, originality of the music and her voice, too. She was only 18 years old when it was released...

I had never heard of Fiona Apple but full marks. 10 years ahead of her time considering where similar artists were in the 2000s. Gorgeous voice, moody song writing, full marks.

Day829 - fiona apple seems way ahead of her time on this album and it all still sounds fresh

There are some big tunes on here, and I thoroughly approve of the tone and subject matter, but I'm afraid Fiona seems a bit too fond of the dreaded boogie-woogie piano backing to give this my full enthusiasm.

Although I didn’t save anything this was refreshing and I will be back to listen again.

My first deep dive into a Fiona Apple album and... it's fine. Lovely at times. But most of it drifted along without getting my attention. Expected more

Part of my regular rotation in the ‘90s, it’s been a while since I listened to the full album. A lot of the songs still hold up really well.

Didn’t give it a good shot maybe

This is hard. I love FionaApple. I got to see her live. And as good as this record is, it is not her best. The highs are perfection (Never is a Promise, Shadowboxer), the good are great ( Slee to Dream, Criminal, Carrion) but the mediocre- albeit still good- are exactly that: mediocre (The First Taste, Child is Gone). She once said that she couldn’t sing yet on this record. Not sure how accurate that is but this one sounds ‘immature’ relative to her next record. In any case, it’s Fiona. Killer, Killer album.

Pretty good vibe album, but I don’t see myself coming back to it… maybe ever. Nothing really stood out.

I forgot how much I like Fiona. Really it was a different album than most 90s music. In a way she was in her own genre.

Great voice, can wear you down.

I don't know how I feel about this. It's like one minute I like this and then the next I don't. Sometimes it would even happen mid-song.

Fiona Apple had a great voice but, I was not feeling this album at all.

Ce que j'aime beaucoup c'est que les paroles sont très personelle d'une manière qui n'invite pas du tout à projeter ou s'identifier, c'est toujours son histoire Malheureusement ça me fait pas autant d'effet que je voudrais pour l'instant :'(

When this came out, her videos got a lot of play on MTV. But they all seemed to fall into the category of ‘lady singers who wriggle around on the floor, singing everything unnecessarily provocatively’. It was just like what Jewel and Britney were doing. Boring, undermining, powerless pickme bullshit. So, I never wasted my time listening to her.

Su voz es bellísima y tiene excelentes canciones.

I really like the femme fatale vibe songs but some tracks were too sappy for my taste

Hostestly, I wish I liked it more. I was excited to see this was by Fiona Apple, cause my mom likes her, but I feel like the album fell short. A lot of the songs felt repetitive and had a similar structure. I mean, that's fine, but not what I look for in an album. There was so major differentiation between songs, which can make the album a bit boring at times. I like variety, and when an artist can pull it off it's really enjoyable. I don't think Fiona really executed that for me. I wish there was some kind of climate in her songs, or more string solos accompanied by her vocals. A few of those songs did hit tho, so it's not all bad. Especially the last one, Carrion, that one is good. Fiona's voice with the string instruments definitely brings the album up from a 2 to a 3 for me. Her voice has a nice range which is a plus. And once again, I'm a sucker for classical instruments used in pop music.

This is almost a perfect 3.5, but I bumped it to 4 because she was horrifyingly Mozartishly young when she wrote these songs. Also, if I ever became a professional wrestler with a Saul Goodmanesque character I would totally use "Criminal" for my entrance music.

AWESOME!!

My Ex would play this album at high volume when she was upset with me. So I didn’t give it a fair shot for years. It’s fuckin brilliant

Fiona Apple has an amazing voice, there’s no denying that, and a few of the songs on here are fantastic. I bought the CD back in the 90’s based off of them. The album as a whole gets too somber and brooding though. You have to be in a certain mood to fully appreciate it. It was still an enjoyable listen and I have that CD sitting in a Rubbermaid tote down in my basket somewhere, along with the rest of my 90s/2000s collection.

This album is a little on the slow side for me, but ultimately there’s some good music happening here. Fiona Apple has a great voice and a couple of the tunes were catchy enough to draw me in for a closer listen. Far from being on my list of favorites, but this was enjoyable.

The singles are the strength of this album which meanders for too long in the same mournful wallow.

"If you ain't Fiona Apple I dont give a rats ass." Take that Barbara Streisand! Sorry, had to do it. Now on to my review. Better than I remember, Criminal and Sleep To Dream are fantastic songs. Fiona has an immpressive vocal range which shines in spots, but she falls back on the moody and breathy voice on many of the tracks, which without the dynamic arrangements of Criminal and Sleep To Dream fall pretty flat for me. That said, it's still a decent album.

Believe it or not, it's my first time listening to Fiona Apple, and what an artist is she to listen to for the first time. It's a wonderful, powerful record. I absolutely love it. It's her debut and her voice sounds so mature, her songwriting so on point and unique. But it does feel like a debut. The production is not perfect in some songs, and I think their will be many more highlights in her career (that I'm expecting to discover soon). Anyway, it's a very very high 4

Love this album. Her second is still my favourite. But this is also really really good. Love her voice. Love her style. Love this album.

Great angsty pop music. It is all good but isn’t my favorite album of hers

Heard Before? Yup. This was big when I was in high school. Notes: - probably my least favorite Fiona Apple album. she just keeps getting better. - songwriting is clever, wise and deep, especially considering her age. comparing this to the debuts of other teen prodigies (Alanis, Adele, Lorde, etc.) is illuminating. Fiona all the way. - despite being mostly piano ballads, she fits in better with the likes of PJ Harvey and Liz Phair than the other balladeers of the era. - arrangements are near-perfect. so dynamic, great use of mallet instruments, decent drum sounds, and extended codas that cast a spell, instead of repeated choruses that exhaust me. - production is so competent as to be almost invisible. - the drum-free sections drag a bit, and this kind of melismatic singing, while impressive, wears on me. Verdict: A stunning debut by a major talent, and one that has aged well. I don't know how she made it through the gauntlet of industry exploitation, but this is already the sound of a singular artist. Listen Again? Eventually, yes. But I should really revisit "Fetch the Bolt Cutters" or "Idler Wheel" first. Those are brilliant.

Para escuchar 1 sola vez en la vida

Me aburrió un poco, pero me gustó mas la musica, mas melodica, suave, like it

- Fiona has a great voice with a lot of character - it's strong, but also melodic and expressive (though, sometimes it gets out of tune). - Some great piano playing, as well. - I also really enjoyed the thoughtful and emotionally raw/vulnerable lyrics. - All the songs were good, but I think I liked Never is a Promise best. - The album feels a little long - a song or two could have definitely been left off (maybe the last two) or shortened (Slow Like Honey).

Not for me.

Pretty incredible that she wrote this album as a teenager. The complexity of the music and lyrics are insane for someone at an age where I was mostly making fart jokes and trying to avoid doing homework. That being said, the teen “angst” might be the only (slight) negative. It feels like she’s wallowing a bit here, where on her later albums strength and resilience are more present. But really good stuff.

Fiona is everything right about the female voice. Soft, silky, and soulful with a near-hidden strength to it. Easily my favorite artist from the Lilith Fair group of the late '90's, she combined the child-like free spirit of Bjork with the powerful vocals of a Sarah McLachlan. Love this album. Influence 4. Quality 4. Hits 5. Intangibles 2. Love this 4.

Jazzy bluesy moody poppy

I own and love the song Criminal. I’ve loved that song since this album came out. I also know and like Sleep to Dream and Shadowboxer. The rest of the songs were all pretty boring. They all kind of sound the same.

What a rich album. Amazing vocals that seem to get stronger and stronger as you journey through the track list, interesting lyrics that ask you to engage, and full bodied instrumentation that capture your attention.

This album makes me nostalgic for something I've never experienced. It makes me think of dark bars in a rainy new York. This album is pure vibes. Love it.

Not bad. I think id like this if I was in more of a 90s mood

I had never heard a Fiona Apple song until I heard this album. Here's how it went: Into track 1 - Cool, I like this. Very of its time but this is clearly going to be better than I expected. A few tracks in - This isn't TOTALLY my cup of tea but I can hear that it's good. Very interesting music, some complexities but mostly driven by the vocals and lyrics. Midway through the album - fine, I have now heard Fiona Apple and can appreciate her. Back end of the album - this is taking a lifetime to end. Overall thoughts are that she's heavy talented and I'd have no issues listening to another album but outside of the first 3 tracks, I'm likely to never return to Tidal. A high 2 because I can't quite justify a 3. I didn't enjoy all of it.

Meh, niet mijn ding.

This might be one of the most miserable, twinkle-yet-disgusting albums I’ve ever sat through. While listening I felt drained, annoyed, and honestly kind of grossed out the whole way. It’s raw as hell, super repetitive in that whiny piano-and-voice way, and just felt completely meaningless and seamless in the worst possible sense — like one long, exhausting sigh that never actually goes anywhere. It’s not a concept album or anything with a big story. It’s basically 18-year-old Fiona Apple spilling all her teenage angst, heartbreak, trauma, and self-loathing onto the tracks. A lot of people praise how honest and vulnerable it is, but to me it just came off as tiresome and overly dramatic. She sounds like she’s desperately trying to copy Tori Amos or maybe even early Kate Bush in that dramatic, artsy, piano-driven style, but it didn’t click at all for me. The songs blend together into this murky, repetitive fog of misery and I couldn’t wait for it to end. Look, I get that some people connect hard with this kind of emotional nakedness, but for me it was pure torture. The production is decent and her voice is strong, but the whole thing just felt fucked up and pointless. Zero chance I’ll ever put this trash on again. Hard pass.

Thoroughly enjoyed. Lounge vibes

Muy bueno: potente voz

Amazing album, brilliant songwriting, still probably the weakest fiona apple. Crazy that she has two albums on the list but not when the pawn or idler wheel.

This was really fucking boring

Incredible instrumentation! Fantastic production! Great, clever lyric/song writing. This record has it all amd is an impressive debut.

Huvin erilainen levybkuin kuvittelun. Fiona Apple on entuudestaan täysin vieras. Hyvällä tavalla Adele-viboja. Nämä biisit tehty ja äänitetty, kun neiti ollut 18-18 -vuotias! Älytöntä! Hyvät biisit ja mieletön ääni! Mutta myös upea bändi ja soiton dynamiikka. Suosikeiksi nousevat Sleep to dream, The first taste ja Carrion. 5/5

Much Better than Expected!

Is it me or does she sing out of tune betimes?

I liked Fiona Apple's debut album a little, but I should have liked it more at least on paper but outside of 'Criminal' which is a great song with a hella sweaty sexy video LOL and to a lesser extent, Slow Like Honey which is also pretty smokey good - I just liked Tidal OK. This seems like an album aimed directly at girls who wear reading glasses to appear smarter, read Sylvia Platt, date men old enough to be their fathers, love Billie Holliday and order the most expensive thing on the menu on dates for no greater reason than because they can. Wait! Did I just describe myself at 19? Hey, Nineteen! I do like any Steely Dan album better Tidal not that you asked. So, yeah this should be in my Top 100 albums of all time all things considered but it's not but I like it a great deal more than her later albums (her entire back catalog, really) which I don't like even a tiny little bit. I hated 'Fetch the Bolt Cutters' oh, God was that a difficult album to get through, let me tell you! Her green eyes look pretty on the album cover of Tidal and batshit crazy on the album cover of 'Fetch the Bolt Cutters' and red or just not there on her other albums. I have the single for Criminal (on cassette) and her eyes look awesome in fact she looks like what I pictured her looking like based on how she sounded on the radio the first time I heard her Pretty obvious what Sony was going for and on a marketing level Sony was likely right- she could have been bigger and sold millions more records if she had used her looks to get ahead but to her credit, she wanted to let the music make or break her and that's pretty admirable for a teen girl (pretty admirable for anyone)- I 100% would have listened to Sony & posed naked on the album cover of her second album (When the Pawn...) but I'm shameless when it comes to getting my way just like that TV show on HBO. Euphoria, I think with Sydney Sweeny and a bunch of other pretty people being drama queens (and kings) and having hot pretty sex all the time. The It girl of the mid 1990s could be accused of cosplaying a sultry torch singer in some wonderful old film noir blast of cinematic poetry but not by me as I think to an extent we all cosplay pretty much from early childhood to about 15 minutes before we expire in our comfy death beds. All right, Mr. Dimery, I'm ready for my close-up.

This album kicks off strong. It's got some edge to it and I like it. "Criminal" is a highlight for sure, I think this album loses a little steam on the back end. But for the most part it really kinda rules.

This was boring imo..

This is a really great album, each song has merit. Fiona Apple's voice sounds great and the lyrics are thoughtful and emotive. Even though the whole album is good, 'Never is a Promise' is truly superb and deserves a special mention, a wonderful song. Favourites: Shadowboxer Criminal Slow Like Honey Never Is a Promise

For one reason or another, I've avoided artists such as Fiona Apple. I remember when Fetch the Boltcutters came out and my friends were largely so hyped for it. I couldn't care less and didn't get it. Now I sort of do. This album would create a life-long fan of an artist, regardless of what they put out after.

definitely feels more unpolished than when the pawn. female rage has been an interesting theme of exploration yesterday. Watched forbidden fruits, was much more a fan of this album than the movie. Fiona Apple is a legend, this as her first album is a solid beginning

mid songs but the songs that were good were genuinely like 9 out of tens the rest of the songs were like mid or boring or slop

Quite good

Such a good album.

Piano-driven alternative pop and jazz-tinged singer-songwriter music built on moody keys, restrained drums, and confessional, expressive vocals unfolds with slow, heavy introspection. Listening feels like sitting through an overlong late-night confession where emotions linger without release. The atmosphere is intimate and emotionally charged, but the pacing and sentimentality can feel overly sappy and dragging.

💕💕💕💓💓💓💓❤️❤️❤️🖤🖤🖤

Wow. Well 1- as I was listening to Sleep to Dream, I learned she wrote this at 14?!!!!!!! Incredible track. Incredible artist. Totally took me by surprise - this is a new fav!

Not sure I have to listen more to it

La música no sé si me gusta, i mean it’s alright y si la entiendo en el contexto de su estilo, pero a mi se me hace cansado oír un disco en el que sólo importa la voz y está tan arriba de los instrumentos todo el tiempo xd Canta bien cuando no se pone en modo rockera, pero igual no me fascinó

Love this album already

More more of a jazz influence than I was lead to belief by the only single I knew from this album. Definitely still has that 90s angst to it, but I found it much more low key and relaxing than I expected. Criminal

Oh how excellent she is

i fucking love fiona apple

Ass album. Very very similar sounding piano track for all of them. Singer has the feel of "oh I'm so hot, I get all the boys and I know it and I'm so bad" shut the fuck up honestly. No progression to the album a collection of shit songs.

Enjoyable listen. Thought the instrumentation was top class- piano was played really well and the drum beats matched the feel of the songs well. However, a lot of the tracks were quite similar and I think the strong start lost momentum with a lot of quieter tracks. Still solid and a nice album to listen to, but nothing special.

Top level pop. Amazing song writing, great composition, interesting shift of wibes.

What a great album. I haven’t listen to this sense the 90s. I think it was more nostalgic than music.

Jesus, what a voice.

A couple of her greatest tracks reside on this record, but the sound is a bit unfocused overall here. Am I supposed to feel sorrow? Angry? Braggadocious ambivalence? I like Fiona's style when it's more well-defined.

Some track are kinda good, others not so, kinda worked for the radio. Not my cup of tea, but impressive to some extent

I GOTTT MY FEETTT ON THE GROUNDD AND I DON'T GOO TO SLEEPP TO DREAMMM

Good debut album with strong staying power. Knew most of the songs-but never listened the whole album.

I’ve heard a lot of great things about Fiona Apple so I was happy to get this one, and I wasn’t disappointed. It plods at times, but it’s a beautiful album overall with a lot of emotion. The vocals are stellar, and the production’s really something.

Feels like the perfect album for a wee night with a glass of wine and some long looks out the window, rather than a bright an smelly walk in the country. It’s good though! Favourite track: Never is a Promise

I talk to a somewhat mentally unstable lady online occasionally and mentioned I got this album for today and she said I ”triggered” her ’cause there’s a song about rape or something on it. Anyway, I listened to it while working out at the gym (leg day) and didn’t really remember anything about it afterwards. But nothing really irritated me either, so I guess that’s a basic two stars.

Way too much tambourine.

I liked what I could hear over the concrete mixer

She is a sorceress. The range on this album is great. Some feels so intimate like she's singing softly directly to you. The bigger moments have such awesome angsty buildup.

Jazzy and soulful with some nice songwriting to boot. Reminds me of Alanis Morissette. Beneath the smooth facade lies pain and heartbreak (3.5).

This is good. Like the arrangements and Ms Apple's voice. It's a little laid back for most days, but ⭐⭐⭐

I like her voice and the songs are pretty, but they're too mellow and boring for me.

not my thing

Never heard of her, sounded like generic pop. If this album was a color it would be beige.

Beautiful ballad vibes. Minimal instrumentation to really highlight the voice and story telling.

I tried coming up with a better review, but god she is such a vibe after having a shit day at work!

How has this been reviewed so highly?! It's one of the most drab records I've ever heard. The songs were all excessively long, and sleep inducingly dull. I consider myself to have a very broad music taste but this was near unlistenable for me.

I would love to relisten to this in the winter

GENERIC MUSIC FOR WOMEN WOMEN DONT GOOD MUSIC TASTE BAD

I feel on the verge of tears and I love it.

Great album. Love her voice paired with the piano and slow jazzy music.

90s angst in the best way

An old favourite, always an enjoyable listen.

I respect Fiona Apple's ability to be herself musically and stray away from sounding like someone else or pretending to be the next big thing. Her debut album is overall pretty solid aside from a few "sad white girl playing piano" songs (the white woman's version of sad white guy playing acoustic guitar). The result is an album that ages very well.

I very much enjoyed listening to this album. Fiona Apple is an exceptional songwriter both lyrically and in song structure. My favorite track was Like Honey. I'm really surprised she has only released 5 albums.

have loved 21st-century Fiona for a long time now, so was very happy for the opportunity to go back to the beginning! i know people love this one, but to me, it's very much her first record and she was very young! stunning voice as always, and the run of tracks from Sullen Girl to Slow Like Honey is pretty inarguably great, but a lot of the others go on too long, and the jazz influence on display here is a little stale compared to what would come later. always listenable, always beautifully sung, just very much her first record

Album #45, Fiona Apple, Tidal ⭐⭐⭐⭐ I absolutely love Fiona Apple’s 2012 album The Idler Wheel…(etc). I’d nearly rank it among my favourite singer-songwriter albums ever. I first listened to it the year it came out without really knowing much about her, and I still go back to it all the time. Songs like Periphery and Anything We Want are among my favourite songs by female artists and singer-songwriters in general. So I’m a bit of a fool for never really listening to the rest of her catalogue. I tried the first few tracks of Fetch the Bolt Cutters at one point, but for whatever reason I had to turn it off and I never went back to it, even though I know it’s hugely loved. Other than that, I hadn’t heard a scrap of her music. She’s one of those artists where I’ve always had this feeling that I’ll probably love the rest of her work, so I almost kept it in reserve, thinking at least I’ll always have more Fiona Apple to discover. So this is my second Fiona Apple album and it’s so good. Someone should make a list of the most impressive albums ever released by teenagers. This should rank very highly. She wrote this when she was around 17 to 19 years old, which is mind-blowing. The maturity of every element of it shows a kind of wisdom and experience way beyond her years. Her voice is husky and beautiful, and the chord progressions and melodies across the album are just gorgeous. At one point listening to Pale September I genuinely felt like I was in a bit of a trance. The lyrics are excellent throughout as well. She weirdly reminds me of Jeff Buckley at times, another jilted chanteuse, but she’s even better. My favourite tracks are probably the three singles, especially Shadowboxer. There’s a bit of a trip-hop feel to them, which I love. Sleep to Dream really shows that more aggressive side of her voice. The drums and instrumentation are fantastic, and I really like how nearly every song expands into an instrumental outro where the band stretches the musical ideas out. So why isn’t it a five? Honestly this might be the strongest four I’ve come across. The middle section of the album, around Slow Like Honey to Never is a Promise sags a little for me. It leans more into straightforward singer-songwriter territory and some of the songs start to feel a bit melodramatic and less interesting. That stretch brings the score down slightly. But still, this album has genuinely given me another reason to live because now I have to go and discover the rest of Fiona Apple’s catalogue. She’s very obviously a genius. So yeah, an extremely strong four stars.

Always confused her with Tori Amos. 4/5

Fiona has a really good voice, but there's a quality to it that doesn't vibe with me, not sure what it is, but it's almost monotonous. I did kinda enjoy this album, but I'm a sucker for piano and there's quite a lot of piano backing. However, it did get pretty boring. The album is nearly an hour long and there's only a couple of tracks that stand out as different in terms of tempo and atmosphere. I'd maybe have gone for a low 4 if I liked Fiona's voice, it's not a bad album, but as a singer-songwriter album I think the voice is the most important aspect, so I'm going to go with a 3.

Dull, she has a nice voice but non of the lyrics stood out to me and the backing instrumentation is quite repetitive. Not really sure what it's trying to achieve. Mid 2

Much better than I thought it would be. The one big song, but the rest were pretty chill and bluesy.

Sikkert bra dette. Men veldig kjedelig, og veldig mye likt.

First Fiona Apple album! Beautiful contralto voice. Stellar production. Mellotron!! Can't wait to hear more. Favourite tracks: "Sleep to Dream", "Shadowboxer", "Carrion"

She wasn't even 20 when she made this. Amazing.

The astonishingly great debut album from one of my favorite artists still sparkles. Every track is a gem.

Solid rhythm and mood throughout, with her slightly shaky vocals adding character; “First Taste” is the clear standout for me.

Hard to believe that this album was written before the age of twenty - every song feels like it has such a weight behind it, and Fiona's presence on each song is towering. Despite this, the hooks and instrumentation are amazing, particularly the one two punch of Slow Like Honey and The First Taste. Wish When the Pawen would be on here too, but this is probably the best Fiona album on the list.

I had only heard Criminal before. It’s ok but not amazing.

This sounds like somebody in a vulnerable state, at an open mic bar with a band, half drunk and half medicated, trauma dumping on the audience. There's a lot of pain and anger there. Even though sometimes the songs sound too happy for the lyrics, they are impactful and serve her voice and delivery really well. Good stuff altogether.

Imagine giving me a Fiona Apple album. Imagine giving ME. A Fiona Apple album. I have listened. To every single Fiona Apple album. She is my fourth favorite solo artist of all time. She does not have an album below a 9. This album is especially good though, so let’s talk about it. First of all, the entire first side is straight-up spotless. The first five songs are five of the best songs ever made, and that’s said confidently. Sleep to dream, sullen girl, shadowboxer, criminal, and slow like honey are all like insane highlights. It’s like weird and kinda unfair that all five of those songs are on the same side of the same album. The second side is definitely worse, however, it’s still great! The first taste was a song that initially I was kinda lukewarm on, but L-rdy it’s so well produced. Those guitars… what. Never is a promise was always a favorite, though my enjoyment of it has waned since I first heard it. Idk, just sounds more dull now. It’s the same with the following two songs on the album. However the closer is great, even if I prefer the switchup to the rest of the song. Anyway this is a fantastic debut and Fiona Apple is so awesome. 9.5/10

Such a powerful voice I'm obsessed with it. Sometimes you can barely hear the emotion in a singer's voice and it sucks. I can feel her anger and sadness and that's more important than simply having a good voice. Liked criminal and sleep to dream.

I get the vibe but it isn’t for me.

1996. Great debut album by Fiona, a well acclaimed 90's album with heart and a depth of story and lyric. Overall pleasant to listen through.

I dont know if I know a single Fiona Apple song but I do know the name. Apple's debut album "Tidal" hits from the opening and maintains a raw energy through the first 4 songs. I think pop is a bit disingenuous here. I would call this "girl grunge". It doesn't have the grizzliness of Cobain's tone but the lyrics, tone of music, and overall vibe really strikes me as a bit grungy.

Had a great (is that the right word for an album as sad as this) time with this one. First time I've listened to Fiona Apple so I'm rather happy it's started off this well!

Tidal is one of those debut albums that immediately feels fully formed. Fiona Apple arrived with a distinctive voice, sharp songwriting instincts, and a band that understood how to leave space for the music to breathe. What stands out most is the production and arrangement. Many of these songs unfold patiently, with piano, rhythm section, and subtle textures locking together in ways that feel intentional but never overproduced. The grooves are understated but effective, and the space in the mix lets every part contribute without crowding the song. Apple’s melodies are another highlight. Several tracks reveal themselves as quiet earworms — the kind of melodies that creep back into your head later in the day. Songs like “Sleep to Dream,” “Shadowboxer,” and “Criminal” balance emotional intensity with strong musical structure, giving the album both depth and accessibility. While the album may stop just short of all-time classic territory, it’s a remarkably confident debut. The synergy between the songwriting, performance, and production makes Tidal feel cohesive from start to finish and rewards repeated listens.

Honestly very bored by it. I just wanted to hear same era PJ Harvey instead.

Musically interesting. Very beautiful. But somehow it just doesn't capture me. I don't know what it's missing. It's not bad at all, but it's just somehow forgettable.

Not really my vibe.

Well Fiona has managed to make a pretty lengthy career out of awkward sad girl. This is not my vibe as the kids say but I do recognize that quality of both the music and lyrics on several of the tracks. Specifically Shadowboxer, Criminal and although the song is a little slow, I was taken by the quality of Never Is A Promise. The record goes into sleep mode for me after that track. I am certainly not the demographic for this record at any point in my life. I get it. Really. Music is about connecting with the songs on some level and then being rewarded intrinsically for making that connection. Teen girls found a way to make this album a group conversation and reinforce the ties that bind. For me, this would have been a lady jam in the movie White Chicks. Nothing against Fiona or any of the other similar acts of varying levels of angst driven balladeers such as Alanis, KD Lang, and the rest of the Lilith fair homegirls. It’s just not me and it will never be. Certainly, not in the Top 1001 albums I should hear before I die. And just so we are clear - I listen to every word and note of every record in this challenge. This is a serviceable record but overall rather lifeless. 3/5

This was a great album. I should listen to more Fiona Apple.

I know Fiona based off her Beatles cover of across the universe, and the fact that I see her name a lot on tinder. Welp, this is not what I expected. There wasn’t anything particularly interesting here for me. The hit (criminal) is good, shadow boxer is good, and I really liked the jazzy score in Pale September. It’s only bonkers that this album feels so fully realized at only 18?! I don’t know how frequent I’ll revisit, but I’m definitely gonna check out more of her stuff

Zachary Female singer slop and I love it and I eat it up! I am stuck between a 3-4 I love the vocal melodies you can hear imogen heap and caroline polechek and Dido and I love it all. These love songs and empowerment Never is a promise with the violin and piano just beautiful and it is poetry in motion. I will be listening to this and now finally diving into fiona apple.

I remember Fiona Apple being an influence on my adolescence; however, similar to then I could never latch on to her vibe. Regardless, it was nice to listen to this album. I just may not revisit it going forward.

Lush and strange throughout, woven with dark threads

its alright, but still not my taste, her second album i got

The second album is more my style

Didn't like her voice, didn't get into any of the tunes. Meh all a bit backgroundy. Lyrics have a lot of attitude but didn't make it any less forgettable. Is Badass Background a genre?

Not my cup of tea.

GOD TIER album. And she was 19! It’s been in my rotation for 30 (gasp) years and it holds up. Sleep to dream, shadowboxer, and, of course, Criminal. Brilliant record.

Not a fan and i don't get the appeal. Mediocre.

Album Review 087 Tidal by Fiona Apple (1996) Rating 2.5/5 This is the first time I’ve knowingly listened to Fiona Apple, although I may have heard it countless times in book shops or queues as it is perfect background music. There may be some really strong, emotive stuff here but I simply didn’t have enough interest from the start to find it. Ask me to hum one of the tunes or repeat a lyric and I’d be at a loss.

Not familiar with this artist or album but pleasantly surprised and want to hear more

For a record that was basically promoted as a pop album with big music videos, lush production, focus on Fiona as a big star etc this is really out there. It's a record focused on the lyricism which is mostly dark and disturbing, all of the tracks are 4-5 minutes long at least and Fiona Apple is definitely not a conventional pop star by any means. Altogether this is an outstanding debut record - close to a 5 for me

This may be my new favorite Fiona Apple album. A lot of really great songs, but I think the second half does dip in quality just a little bit. I don't really know what else to say, just an overall really solid album. High 4.

An excellent album that exposes the talent of Fiona Apple. Really a groundbreaking record.

Fiona Apple was only about 18 when she made this album which is just mind boggling. It is incredible. It reminds me of Alanis Morissette's Jagged Little Pill, but smarter and more complex. Just better musically. Sleep to Dream and Shadowboxer are great, but Criminal stands out, it is an amazing song. Apple is an amazingly talented artist.

Loved this album when it came out. Still do.

Ooooft this was really not my thing at all. Found it quite uninteresting. I guess her voice is kinda cool, but the songs and the melodies are meh. The ambience would be good for the end of a shrooms trip, hence my 2 star rating

moms, this one is for you!

i loved this album! i see how she was inspired by stevie and also how she inspires female artists today the pushing piano rhythms make the songs so enjoyable

Tidal showcased Fiona Apple's talent when she was young, every song sounds like it has genuine emotion tied to it and it's unique in a way that makes it stand out from other albums released by female artists in the 90s. 4.3/5

Wow. Somehow I slept on this album when it first came out. I remember not liking "Criminal" because of how much it was played on the radio, but this album is great. Dark, moody, brooding with some great vocals and on point string and piano arrangements. Big fan now. Highlights: "Sleep to Dream", "Shadowboxer" and "Never Is A Promise"

Really enjoy the jazz influence that Fiona brings to what turned out to be a nice 90s pop record. Kind of gets a bit too soft for me sometimes going into the 2nd half, but still a nice listen. Really like the piano vamp/riff on The First Taste, and Shadowboxer and Criminal definitely earned their slots as singles. Hearing Mellotron strings on an album is also always appreciated, one of my favorite sampled instruments. 8/10.

Super consistent in a very entertaining way, good sounds all around. Favourite track: The First Taste

8/10 Not gonna lie this might be my least favorite of her albums, but it's an excellent debut. Really pleasant piano playing, but the album starts losing momentum near the end.

Super peak album it inspired me to make a playlist with a similar vibe 🐠

I’ve only listened to Fetch the Bolt Cutters and the Idler Wheel but I should've known anything from Fiona Apple was going to be good

Good album. Lots of known songs. Would enjoy falling asleep to it.

Nice change of pace from the previous albums. Really like Fiona Apple voice and she has a great supporting band and instruments. Very nice variety of songs too and just an overall nice listen.

Sleep to Dream - 4.5/5 Sullen Girl - 3.5/5 Shadowboxer - 4/5 Criminal - 4.5/5 Slow Like Honey - 3/5 The First Taste - 4.5/5 Never Is a Promise - 3.5/5 The Child is Gone - 3/5 Pale September - 3/5 Carrion - 4/5 I came in expecting this to be another 3-ish star review after my first foray with Fiona Apple being Fetch the Bolt Cutters. I was surprised to hear that this was not at all like that album and in fact I think I like it better than her newest album on here. A wide range of emotions on display and feels a lot less neurotic. I can now see why people enjoy her as I was mostly on the fence with her. Overall: 4/5 Favorites: Sleep to Dream, Criminal, The First Taste

Sounds like the Norah Jones era

Solid album, great to put on in the background.

This was a journey! Very Quintessential modulations and beat changes on a dime that I now realize have always been Fiona. Nothing feels sporadic tho. Everything feels carefully timed while and she creates these movements in her song that feel very true to piano. Never felt like I was listening to a 5 min song. Really enjoyed it all around - and to think she put this out at 18??? Highlights: Sleep To Dream, Shadowboxer (ofc), First Taste

Well crafted maybe not 100% my thing

estaba obsesionada con este álbum cuando salió, incluso lo llegué a tener en una usb para escucharlo en mi carro cuando el bluetooth me fallara. revisitarlo completo fue grato, trayendo de vuelta los tracks icónicos que lo componen.

muy bueno

Not breaking through for me, but talented

I remember getting this CD in my last Columbia House 12 CDs for a penny haul. Looking back, not sure why, maybe just cuz I had the hots for her. I don't remember listening to it much at all, but this is pretty great, even if something I'd not make a regular listen.

I went into this one fully expecting to give it a 1 or 2 after how much I disliked "Fetch the Boltcutters". However, this album was fantastic. I knew "Criminal" was a great song going in, but the rest of the album was suprisingly good.

Criminal is just that. Each word seems to have like 40 syllables when she sings. All the songs also kinda sound the same...I found it boring. I wanted to like this! I just couldn't find anything that grabbed me.

shakespeare never died her name's fiona apple

Standouts Sleep to Dream Criminal

I’m so tired of this shit! This is 1001 albums and I’m just not in the mood I listened to most of the songs, I like her singing alright, but it’s so unbelievably boring to me right now. It also just doesn’t feel 90s to me like it’s in the wrong decade out of place. It feels more 2000s or 2010s in a bad way somehow.

I'm enjoying this well enough even if I'm having a hard time placing it. Some tracks are a bit much "soft singing over plinking piano". 3

Weird, not my vibe.

It's very pretty and well done songwriting and singing. Fiona Apple is one of those "Your favorite singer's favorite singer," types. And there's good reason for that.

This is a bit better than th dross we had before. I’ll admit I’d been aware of Fiona Apple but not actually heard her stuff. This is great. And even should be on this list.

Yeah ok, here we go. Fiona did something really special here. The drum sound/percussion drive so much of this, great rhythm that links perfectly into her voice. Those descending lines and her heavy left hand piano playing, it is mesmerising. The way she sings and the notes of the chords drop ahead of her, I'm lost in that sound. Sleep to Dream/Shadowboxer/Criminal/Child is Gone all best exemplify that approach to her song writing and performance. It move me every time. About half way in she moves back to more conventional structures, Slow Like Honey et al. This is what this list shuold be about, if is fabulous music by an extraordinary performer.

Hard to believe she was only 19 when she released this record. That's a pretty prodigious talent; great voice, excellent songwriting, terrific piano playing. John Brion was an appropriate choice for production; his aesthetic is well aligned to the material and does not overpower her distinctive voice and playing. I can hear his idiosyncratic approach (weird keyboard instruments, for example, and some of his usual session guys), but it still feels like her artistic vision. I find this most compelling when she stretches out from the soft jazz form (and the good news is that she followed that more adventurous direction on her subsequent albums). I find the lyrical concerns uncomfortable by design; this is a young woman coming to terms with some pretty big feelings. Angst and trauma were big in the 90s, with Kurt Cobain as the patron saint of unfiltered pain -- the baton was taken up by a bunch of other artists, notably some of the biggest female artists of the decade, like Alanis Morrisett, Tori Amos, and Fiona Apple. I re-watched the videos from the album (especially 'Criminal'), and don't feel like she was well served by the porn aesthetic used there. It was attention-grabbing, sure, and I get the "my sexuality is part of my feminine power" discourse that was around at the time, but it feels borderline exploitative and certainly gave permission for some viewers to disrespect her artistry. And I think that is the point; time has confirmed that Fiona Apple is an artist. This is honest and shocking and melodic and seductive and angry and sophisticated and surprising. That's a great record.

So angry so sad ahhhh Aufbau des Albums ist krasss

4/5 half way through

ну мені не зайшло взагалі шось

Deep and rich, and soothing. There is so much layered in and interesting to these songs.

better than i thought it would be. her raw vocals are good and i like the understated piano and melodies. not sure that i will go back to this album a lot, but glad i listened to it

Very close to giving this a 5, but just not quite. I love the quality of her voice, the arrangements are beautiful with her piano playing, strings and vibraphone throughout, and it's really quite an achievement to have written this as a teenager. First Taste is the first moment I was really surprised by the groove and the next track is just a stunning ballad (the harmonies on "heeeights" oh man). This would get a 4.5 if I could, just love the vibe of it.

Good album. I haven't been able to listen to it with the attention it deserves, but I enjoyed it. I enjoyed songs like Shadowboxer, Sleep to Dream or, especially, Criminal.

gorgeous...

important album to me in high school. so many lyrics just hit the spot… imagine this being your debut

Fantastic!!!! How can you write these songs when you are a teenager.....

Muy buen álbum

incredible time

This is one of the best albums of all time, and certainly one of the best debuts of all time. I first heard this album about 8 years ago, and it has never left my rotation since. It is without a doubt one of my all time favorites. There was so much controversy surrounding Fiona Apple and what the industry wanted her to be when this came out, but the music speaks for itself. It's poetic, genre defining, edgy, poppy, dark, and just beautiful in every way. Shadowboxer is one of my top 5 songs of all time. This album, and Fiona Apple in general, deserve way more recognition. Top Songs: Shadowboxer, Sleep to Dream, The First Taste, Carrion, Criminal

17. She was 17 when she wrote this. Bonkers. Solid vocal range. Great playing. Actual arranging. Solid production. I like her album Extraordinary Machine more but this is, in my opinion, more of a feat. This is one of the few albums I've wished for half star rating systems for as I'd go 4.5 I can't in good conscience give it a 5 but it's close.

If a 5 Star Album has "Three Good Songs & No Bad Ones" (a la Roger Ebert's view of Great Films), then what should we rate an album in which every song is good? Think how "Rumours", "Led Zeppelin IV", "Dark Side of the Moon" are projects deserving more than a perfect rating. While I wouldn't say Tidal is as amazing as the three albums I've just listed, it is comparable in that I saved every track to my personal playlist. Beautiful singing accompanying Beautiful lyrics accentuated by Beautiful piano.

Fiona Apple's “Tidal” is a singer-songwriter album characterized by alternative vibes that are typical of the 90s. This makes it sound familiar to me without being particularly striking—for people my age, it's probably easy listening. There's not much more to say about it; for me, “Tidal” is okay, in the sense that it's average.

Polished turd

Listens: 3 Standout Tracks: Sullen Girl, Criminal This album was decent enough, but it never really hit any sort of exceptionally high note for me. It's pretty middle of the road adult contemporary. With the exception of maybe one or two tracks, everything sort of blended together and felt monotonous. Tracks sort of meander around and then end. To be clear, I express no dislike of what I heard, but the album will most likely fade out of my thoughts, having left no serious, lasting impressions. It reminds me of (what limited exposure I have to) Sia, just without the same level of pep. It's fine.

One of the great debut! It's shame The Pawn and The Idler Wheel aren't on the list, but whatrugunado? Sleep to Dream Shadowboxer Criminal The First Taste

This was a decent album, I really only knew of criminal but this whole album was decent

one of my favorites popped up today!

Awesome record. Had never heard it before.

Enjoyed the singles, it's clear why Criminal got so popular as it was the only one I had heard before. Her piano skills make the album work I think and her goals are good and emotional, probably a little "rambling" for my tastes.

I really loved this album and am still a little torn between 4 and 5 stars. Criminal and Carrion are my favorite songs; Carrion such an awesome way to end Tidal. A few of the other songs weren't as strong but the project as a whole is really cohesive. Love her voice and how much emotion she packs into her songs.

I wish every song on this album was Paper Bag instead. It was fine.

Nice relisten after many years. Never a promise is a gem.

Perfect mix of slowed down smooth jazz songs and more upbeat sounding pop songs.

Pretty good. Like Sarah McLaughlin or Norah Jones with a bit more of an edge. I can see how she would've thrived in the '90s.

Depressing

𝘛𝘪𝘥𝘢𝘭, Fiona Apple’s debut with its understated, almost enigmatic one-word title, is a surprisingly assured introduction. What stands out immediately is how complete her artistic voice already feels: the smoky, flexible vocals, the brooding piano work, and a lyrical sharpness that cuts far deeper than one would expect from a nineteen-year-old. The album moves with a kind of simmering intensity — intimate one moment, volatile the next — yet always grounded in her distinct sense of melody and phrasing. It’s not a flawless record, but it’s a fascinating and confident beginning, one that makes it easy to understand why Fiona Apple became such a singular presence in alternative singer-songwriting.

Good voice. Boring

The First Taste is the best song ever made. Rest of the album is chill

Solid 4 star from Fiona Apple

I liked shadowboxer and the first song on the album

I knew of "Criminal", but was clueless about the rest of the album. This is a great one!

Fiona's first album is one I haven't heard in many years, but "Criminal" is still a favorite after all this time. Revisiting it for this was a little more enlightening; I have more of an appreciation for the sort of atmosphere she cultivates. Dark, sultry, lonely and striking.

not my favorite album by fiona, but it is still amazingly good.

My second favourite Fiona apple album but only because here second is so good. Criminal and shadowboxer are 2 of the very best and it’s crazy to me that she wrote this album when she was 16/17.

I liked this a lot more than her other one

I had never heard this album before and really enjoyed it. I love her deep strong voice but it is pitchy. A resounding four stars.

++: Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, Pale September, Carrion +: Sullen Girl, The Child Is Gone +-: The First Taste, Never Is a Promise 8,2/10

This listen was quite a revelation. I was quite aware of Fiona's talent and have listened to her music a fair bit, but I was not aware of how magnificent this first release is. It set me on a path to listen to her discography, wondering what else I missed. This first album, though, wow. Unique arrangements and a style of music all her own. A powerful, nearly terrifying voice that pierces you with her mercurial emotions. Far exceeded my initial impressions of her early music.

I got this on exactly the right day for me personally. I have a raging headache and I would have bet any kind of music would be too much for me, but Sleep to Dream, the first track, instantly clicked with my energy today. Fiona Apple would be the perfect hangover, sick day, COVID isolation, heartbreak, or lazy day music. It would be worth dumping your boyfriend just so you could drive around at night crying and listening to Tidal.

Lame 90s

Was much more jazzy than I expected! High 3 rounded up

Pretty good but meh

While I think this album falters a bit in the second half, I love her voice and lyricism.

comme un morceau de beurre qui glisse dan une peole a peine chaude

Another new one for me. I've only ever heard the name. I dig it though. She has some Florence and the Machine/ Ingrid Michaelson vibes, but jazzier. Will definitely listen to more from her. I'm really enjoying learning about new (to me) artists with this project.

This one felt a lot like a breakup album. It seemed good but I just couldn't get over that vibe.

Pretty good

I really enjoyed fetch the bolt cutters - but this is falling fairly flat to me. Possibly because i have been listening to Joni Mitchell at alot (unfair comparison perhaps) - but its leagues above this. There are the odd moments of joy but mostly its a bit meh.

Tidal Based on already loving Criminal and how much I enjoyed Fetch the Boltcutters, I really wanted to like this more than I actually ended up, finding some of it great and, unfortunately, quite a chunk of it musically and melodically pretty flat. Sleep to Dream, Shadow Boxer and Carrion are excellent, musically and thematically dramatic, and Criminal is superb, a brilliant song. Lyrically the rest is good, but musically I really struggled to connect with it, everything feeling pretty horizontal and lacklustre, none of the melodies or piano parts really grabbing me. The good bits are still great though, and maybe it will click if I come back to it later, so I think I’ll give it a 3, even if I was, sadly, underwhelmed by it on this occasion. 🌊🌊🌊 Playlist submission: Criminal

As a debut from a singer/songwriter it's incredibly sophisticated. Especially when you think she was 17 when she recorded it. The only two I don't like are the Latin-tempoed 'The First Taste', which is like a track on a salsa-class mixtape. Then there's 'Slow Like Honey', which is more like 'wading through treacle' (ammirite?), tipping into laborious dirge at nearly six minutes. It's a strong album, and impressive debut from a precocious talent, with the occasional slumbersome melody.