Reviews (page 5 of 16)
Not a huge fan of punk generally, but at least it has teeth. What good is toothless punk?
To be 14 again…
Veramente insipido.
Very first half heavy album, first 4 songs plus Wake Me Up When September Ends were great but the other ones were either boring or just straight bad, very inconsistent album
love this one - on a scale of 1 to fun = Very fun! 4/5 #Musicsky #albumsky
Zajebista płyta, niektóre kawałki już znałem głównie z radia. Czuć, że jest to jedna z lepszych i ważniejszych rockowych płyt.
Perfect
2026.03.09.
Have already listened to this all the way through back in December 2024 Loved it, Green Day's best, still hits Top 3 Tracks 1. Boulevard of Broken Dreams 2. Wake Me Up When September Ends 3. Holiday Gave it an 8.8/10 previously, relisten today = 8.8/10 wow
Too longs songs, but the album have a punk pop rock energy very interesting, even cool for your decade.
Listening this album entirely for the first time and realizing that I missed great songs in the past. And some songs that I already listened before, listening now feels like I am 15y old again. Really nice!
Pop punk rock opera, loved it when it came out still do. 5 Star
Day 209 Highlights American Idiot Wake me up when September ends Whatsername
used to listen to it as a pre-teen so it took me back to those times. I don't listen to music like that anymore but I realized that I still enjoy it. -1 star because I couldn't listen to it again today or the next few weeks ;)
Nice, a lot of classics, the reintroduction of green day to the new century
Listening to this in March of 2026 while the headlines are all about the US war in Iran feels somehow appropriate, though I suppose there’s a certain timelessness about American military adventurism in the Middle East. I have to give Green Day a fair bit of credit for having the ambition to write a rock opera about social dysfunction in then-contemporary (and now as well?) America particularly when they first found fame through songs about smoking weed and jerking off. And that most of that era of pop punk seemed stuck in perpetual adolescence even when the musicians and listeners were far too old to keep up that ruse. For me, the ambition doesn’t quite match up to the results. To take an example, the second part of “Jesus of Suburbia” sounds like Bryan Adams’s “Summer of 69”, which I guess works for singalongs in the arenas and stadiums Green Day was playing, but it’s just all kind of middle of the road and, well, not very punk rock. It sounds and feels safe. Billie Joe Armstrong has some nice vocal melodies on this, but the music doesn’t veer far enough from the three chord thing they were doing before to pull off something like this. It’s not a bad listen, but not something I feel that I need to hear again either.
A generational album no doubt, but its cracks are definitely showing. Its commentary is surface-level, with the band never making any actual attempt in political discourse. The music itself is fine I guess, and the hooks are still somewhat catchy.
I can't believe how well this holds up. Especially American Idiot. It's almost prophetic. 20 some odd year old album still the same problems. I wish I had listened to it back then but I didn't care & was in a different place musically. Still a great rock opera. 5
Another childhood classic. Lots of nostalgia and yet no notes.
Banger after banger.
When “punk” goes mainstream
Still relevant today - captures that feeling post 9/11. Listening in order it tells a story.
Loved the album! Maybe the best Green Day album with how every song was a hit for me. A very fun and unskippable album!
Mwah
first time listening to green day, wish me luck. it was really interesting how i have never listened to green day but apart for their iconic songs, i got a feeling of nostalgia listening to the ones i didnt know, weird but i guess being born in the 2000's, i inherited some kind of fondness to music of those years without even know it
American Idiot is a fine album, but I still prefer the earlier albums like Dookie and Insomniac.
Hot dog this is much better than I remember. It's not quite as fun as Dookie, but it makes up for it with the righteous anger and drive. Obviously the title track is one of the great openers, all stop-start, angular riffs and an absolutely banging chorus. The other singles are also really evocative and mature. The rest of the album is a tiny bit one paced in places, and I'm not sure every song should be as long as it is, but this was super strong.
The pros: Iconic, genuine, defines an era, unbelievably catchy singles, some hidden gems thrown in like "Novocaine," ambitious, and great use of chords and themes to tie the overarching concepts together. Cons: Billie Joe's voice can grate on your ears a bit, it can come across as privileged whining, the Bush era critiques feel dated in the 2020s, has been milked for every cent, and sometimes the message feels a bit devoid of substance. Despite the warts, American Idiot ultimately holds a well-deserved spot in the American consciousness. This is probably the best that pop punk has had to offer, culturally. As for my rating: I've gone back and forth as to whether American Idiot is a strong 4 stars or a weak 5 stars. For now, I'm going to be generous and give it the 5. In light of the impact American Idiot had (and the fact that some of my critiques are less to do with the musical quality itself), I feel a 5 is appropriate. I will revisit this one and edit if necessary.
I liked American idiot, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Gran álbum, de lo poco que no se siente tan tan comercial de los años 2000 en mi opinión, no fue pesado de escuchar, este álbum tiene elementos de opera a lo que había visto antes y si hay un par de canciones que muestran eso en acción, tratan de tocar temas serios y crítica entonces les quita el aspecto de ser vacíos a mi parecer 3.7
Just an exceptional record.
Very nostalgic for 13 year old me
Wake Me up When September Ends is just an incredible song. I'm annoyed by the double song tracks. I don't really understand the point if it's done for every single track and makes the songs 10 minutes long. That being said, in every song, I found something that I liked. They just all sounded too similar for me to give a higher rating than this.
I don't like Green Day at all, I think they are a cringe factory. But unfortunately, this album is perfect. There's literally no skips, the songwriting is phenomenal, and it's just a damn pleasantry to listen to. There's SO many classics on this thing it's unbelievable. I find it hard to believe people like Dookie over this.. Dookie sucks. It is literally named after a shit.
It feels insane listening to this again after more than twenty years. Conceptually, it's a great album with biting and clever lyricism. A lot of memories come back to me listening to this and I can't help but think, given how insanely popular this is, how did we end up here exactly? I really do not like pop punk, it is one of my least favourite genres. I have my problems with this album but I do love it, and not just because it evokes a lot of memories for me (if anything, that should bring the score down). It's a fantastic album with massive hits and the songs that weren't singles are great. I can't bring myself to give it a 5 but this was a LOT better than I expected it to be or remember it being. Highlights: American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends
Afraid I don't know these guys...the only Green Day I know of made a couple great albums in the early 90's. Wonder what happened to em
When to listen: feeling like raging against the man, millennial style. Can’t believe how many angsty teen hits were on this one. But was more impressed when I thought about the global influences, the lyrics, and the gestalt of it all. It sounds like a band the weird kids formed in their garage and they’re finally playing the school talent show… and I kinda love that?
2.6 stars
Album 65 Top 3 favorites off the album: Jesus of Suburbia, Whatsername, Are We the Waiting/St. Jimmy We finally got it, folks. The very first album I ever listened to by choice, for myself. A completely legitimate copy on the CD rack and not a burned one from one of my parents' friends, of course, listened to on my mom's CD player that is now sitting on my dining room table. This feels like cheating, too, because I enjoyed it then and I enjoy it now. Maybe I'll reframe it in my head as a treat for getting through a bunch of albums I didn't enjoy so much. Now that we've gotten that out of the way, PUNK ROCK OPERA??? I totally missed the storyline that was going on until today. Perhaps I'm not the only one. Crazy what reading does for you, huh? I was maybe going to cheat and skip this one and just review based on my memories of it, but I'm glad I did a full listen. It sounds different than I remember it. I often forget just how many songs on this album have been played to death, but I still enjoy them. I've always liked Jesus of Suburbia, though. It was something of a life changing experience listening to that one for the first time with the variation in sound. I'd never heard a song quite like it. I think this album as a whole is their most successful for a reason. I'll wait to see if they prove me wrong, but Revolution Radio is the only one I own for maybe two songs total, and what I've listened to of their earlier stuff was okay-good, not my favorite. As with most things, my relationship to this album has changed a bit over time. The almost-emo middle schooler dealing with loneliness for the first time became a high schooler who had a small group of good friends but felt pulled in a lot of directions to be different for different people, went to college and stopped being good at being different selves away versus at home, kind of collapsed in and exploded all at once, and now we're here. All that purpleness to say: I still indulge in Boulevard of Broken Dreams sometimes, but more as a hug to the parts of my former self I still have that genuinely felt *that* disillusioned with human connection. I think everyone feels that at some point. This album is really, really good for being that age. It's one I still come back to at certain times, too, when I'm feeling like that kid again. My favorite songs have also changed some over the years. Jesus of Suburbia still clears easily, but I forgot Whatsername even existed until today. This was a fun revisit. I think I'm kinder to my younger self because of it.
мне нравится кантри звучаение, очень понравилась песня whatsername
ok ok ok shut up
ughhhh I respect Green Day so much, they're so important to me, I've listened to them a lot during my teenage years. I like some of the tracks and I like that the album is conceptual and conveys the message for all the rebellious kids to stay true to themselves. BUT the music itself is not very impressive if I listen to it objectively. However! I do like that it's stylised as a musical, because it enhances the story. And of course I should mention my appreciation of the pure emotion in Billie's voice, this is the thing that hypnotises you as a raging teenager.
1001 Albums Vol. 0024: American Idiot ============================================================ Introduction: Well now, this is one of the few albums that I knew I would eventually come across. And, on top of that, it's one of the few (probably) albums that I'm actually very familiar with. This isn't necessarily due to me listening to it from my own volition, however. Like with way too much music in my life, it was shoved down my throat when I was younger due to someone I know really liking a particular few songs on this album. It actually wasn't my dad though. If you actually understand why I wrote that last sentence then I actually love you by the way. Anyway, the point is, I"m pretty familiar with the more popularized material from this album. Songs like Boulevard, Holiday, and September, those kinds of songs. That being said, the less popularized, and arguably worse material, I am barely familiar with. I went through a brief phase in my life where I was independently into Green Day and tried to give this entire album a listen a few times, but all I would do is listen to the better songs and just let the stuff in the middle of the album play for a few seconds before scrolling to the next song. You could say this was due to my hyperactivity, but I personally just think it was because I found the songs boring. I mean, I know a lot of people who would likely agree with me on that stance. Either way, who the hell would say that Saint Jimmy is their favorite song off American Idiot? Nobody...nobody with a brain at least. Anyway, let's actually get into the album now. This album, released by Green Day in 2004, was a major, major release of the early to mid-2000's. Seriously, this album could genuinely be considered a cultural phenomenon due to how much of an impact it had upon its release. The influence that this album has on people now is still undoubtable as well. And I'm not talking about how pretty much any album can be considered "life-changing" to a specific group of people either. This album impacted fashion, musical taste, and just did so much for so many people. Now, impacting musical taste? I mean, that makes complete and total sense. What about fashion though? Well, Green Day had a very peculiar, one could even say avant-garde, fashion style in the early 2000s and even nowadays to an extent. Its members wore very alternative styles, borderline rebellious styles of clothing, wore heavy eye makeup, had very peculiar hairstyles, and were just all around different from what would have been considered the norm at the time. If this sounds at all familiar to a modern subgenre of fashion, that's because it is. While emo as a genre of music and fashion did exist before this album's release, this album brought both the genre of music and the fashion style to mainstream attention. Many people, specifically young people, felt as if this album resonated with them on a personal level. This resonation ultimately contributed to the massive rise of emo as a genre of music, fashion style, movement, and so on throughout the 2000s. And, of course, the effects on this can still be seen today. Overall, I'd say that this album had almost like a Ziggy Stardust effect upon its release. I will say already, regardless of the overall quality of the album or music, I appreciate how Green Day tried to frame their public image after what they had expressed in their release. It adds an undoubtable layer of depth to the music and makes it feel as if the album is a personal look into the mind of an artist. You could of course call it all an act. That being said, I'd still take an act over looking up the faces behind this album and realizing that the lead-singer is the most typical Joe-Schmoe that you can find on the street...like some other artists in the same genre...much like Pierce The Veil....Nevertheless, I like this aspect. If anything, you could compare this to metal artists having long hair in the 80s. Yeah, this does feel a bit more like an act than that did due to the sudden tonal shift from Punk Rock to Emo Anthems, but I still like it nonetheless. I thought that David Bowie was awesome whenever he turned into one of his characters from an album, and that was an act. You can't change my mind. You just can't. Now, with all that said, I've gone on long enough. Let's get into one of the most influential albums of the 2000's. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Track 1: American Idiot Score: 8/10 Track 2: Jesus of Suburbia Score: 10/10 Track 3: Holiday Score: 9/10 Track 4: Boulevard of Broken Dreams Score: 9/10 Track 5: Are We the Waiting Score: 6/10 Track 6: Saint Jimmy Score: 8/10 Track 7: Give Me Novacaine Score: 7/10 Track 8: She's a Rebel Score: 6/10 Track 9: Extraordinary Girl Score: 5/10 Track 10: Letterbomb Score: 8/10 Track 11: Wake Me Up When September Ends Score: 9/10 Track 12: Homecoming Score: 7/10 Track 13: Whatsername Score: 8/10 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Conclusion: Alright, I'll admit, listening to this thing in full was quite a strange experience. The highs were as high as I remembered them being and the lows were surprisingly low. I mean, it wasn't too terrible overall, just quite a strange experience listening to everything that I had been missing this entire time. That missing stuff obviously being songs like She's a Rebel, Letterbomb, Saint Jimmy, and all of the other lesser known songs off this album. Just have to get that out of the way Now, that being said, did that missing material change my opinion of this album? Well...it unfortunately kind of did. Not in a good way either. I mean, this album is still pretty great overall, but the quality is very mixed across the runtime. For starters, unless you're wanting the full experience of American Idiot, then I wouldn't say you're necessarily missing anything by just listening to the big songs. The big hits songs are where most of the quality went into this album. They're the best part of the album without a doubt. That being said....I'm here TO talk about the full experience of this album so...it's still pretty good overall. I mean, it has a pretty well-written story, its music is generally pretty good throughout most of the album, and there were genuinely moments on here that felt very unique to listen to at times. Firstly, I'll mention the music that this album has to offer. Obviously, as I went over in the intro, Green Day as a band had a major tonal shift with this album. They transitioned from a much more Punk Rock sound to a mix between Pop, Punk, and Emo. This mixture should already create a very distinct sound for this album, but Green Day's...honestly pretty good writing takes this personality of sound a lot further. They managed to create music that felt grandiose, edgy, rebellious, and distinct to this album all at the same time. It may have been because of certain production choices such as the layered vocals or loud guitars, but there are just so many melodies off of this album that simply feel rebellious in nature. And I mean that in nothing but a good way because that feel is exactly what this album was trying to capture. Through both the music and narrative this album presents, it attempts to capture the feeling of being carefree and reckless. It tries to capture a feeling that, to an extent, many of us can only wish we could experience. I'm not necessarily talking about the drug use, alcohol use, and potential violence that this album presents, but rather the carefree nature of it. This album's overall theme is very relatable to basic human nature, giving it, at least to me, a way to personally tie it back to myself and how I feel. This feeling is objectively a way to make good music. The listener should be able to feel and, on some level, relate what the album or song attempts to present to you. This album does exactly that throughout its runtime. Now, that being said, how does the story of this album tie into the rebellious nature of its music? Well, this story will be quite a doozy, but I'll try my best to explain it all. So, our unnamed protagonist, who is likely somewhere from his mid-teens to mid-twenties, realizes how crappy America post-9/11 truly is. Our unnamed protagonist creates the name "Jesus of Suburbia" for himself because he thinks that he's miserable and the world is a terrible place. He also reflects on his own insecurities and eventually decides to leave his home because of his hatred and spite. Holiday's purpose on the album is just to give us insight into Suburbia's political opinions and how he views the government. Nothing much more to say about it. Suburbia eventually realizes how lonely he is from simply living alone on the streets and decides to start hanging out with the wrong people. Suburbia then finds who he considered to be his people in Are We the Waiting. This then leads our protagonist to change his identity again to a rebel by the name of Saint Jimmy. Jimmy then starts to do alcohol and drugs because of the people he's hanging around. And now we get to a very central theme of the album. Love. Jimmy meets a rebellious girl who he considers to be a saint and extraordinary. Jimmy and this girl then start dating for an unspecified amount of time before they break up in a pretty cruel way in Letterbomb. Jimmy goes over the situation in his head and ultimately feels a sense of sorrow and grief from his breakup. It has a profound effect on him. So much so that he reflects on the direction that his life is going in a whole and comes to the conclusion that he's in a terrible situation. He eventually decides to return to his home which he had abandoned for however long by then, get a job, kill off his Jimmy persona, and so on. Now, this would be a cool enough album with a cool enough message about politics, society, rebellion, and so on. However, the last song adds a whole other layer of depth to this album. Our protagonist, who now doesn't have a name anymore, reflects on his time with the girl he was with in a pretty nostalgic and somber way. He questions whether she is married, admits to himself that he will never forget her, and so on. This song is honestly pretty bittersweet and adds a whole new layer of emotional vulnerability to the album. Yes, this album tackles many themes across its runtime. It tackles people's rebellious nature, how society can influence one, drug use and its potential effects, politics, which, especially in modern America, I do not want to get into at all, and many more themes. However, the message of love is this album's most personal and relatable message to anyone no matter who they are or where they live. In my opinion, it's trying to say that no matter where you are in life, however good or bad, love is a profound feeling that can stick with you throughout life. You can create an entire fake persona for yourself and decide to throw it away later, but love is something that can stick with you no matter what you are. That message is very profound and thought-provoking. It's honestly a great message and the overall best part of this entire album. Now, that being said, why am I just giving this album an eight out of ten if it had a very profound effect on me? Well...firstly, it took the entire damn album to have a profound effect on me. It wouldn't have had the same effect either had it not been for the inclusion of the final song. Other songs that I've listened to have managed to achieve a similar effect in much less time than this album took. On top of this, the music that this album presents can be a bit thin at times as well. There's a very Progressive sense across most songs on this album, but it can still get a bit thin at times, especially on songs in the middle. Some songs are simply a bit forgettable as well. Nothing more to say about that. Now, with all that said, would I consider this album to be a masterpiece? Not quite. It's definitely great. I don't think a lot of people give it nearly as much credit as it deserves, and to be fair, that may be due to how mainstream this album was upon its release. I mean, really anything being too overplayed or too mainstream will eventually cause someone not to like it. It's inevitable. That being said, this album is still quite great. It has a good message, good music for the most part, and had a major impact on society upon its release. I like it. Everyone who gave it a one of five will just have to kill me to change my mind. ============================================================ American Idiot Score: 8/10 Song Average: 7.7/10
Good but all their songs sound the same to me
Green Day has great pop instincts....good melodies, pop-punk, with some topical influence. Was a little long/repetitive, but is an important document of its era/political moment, so I'll average all that out to go 3.5 with a round down.
This surprised me as I didn't really take notice beyond the singles when it came out. I think the second half isn't quite as strong but it still has energy all the way through. The start of Boulevard over the end of Holiday was a nice touch.
Concise, loud. This plays like a mission statement.
Much better than I expected. Lots of humour, and punk energy in commercial form.
American Idiot was released at the perfect moment for me, just as I was getting into music. Unfortunately, I was getting into completely different music and was ideologically opposed to all forms of pop punk and emo. This meant that I wasn’t able to appreciate the classics released across my childhood. As I’ve aged I’ve matured enough to appreciate the music from my adolescence. Looking back, it was audacious for Green Day to channel their creativity into multi-stage, prog-like song structures with clear political messaging. These songs are nothing like the super short nihilistic ones that made up Dookie. They are linear, longform and operatic. I would love to know if they took any nods from NOFX’s War on Errorism, released the previous year. Even when American Idiot is not overtly political, it sums up the experience of a young person in Bush’s post-9/11 America. Both bands proved that pop punk could handle themes more complex than teenage angst and skateboarding. Although they remained indispensable in soundtracking a PlayStation 2 rendered Tony Hawk. American Idiot is possibly the most memorable and iconic pop punk record of all time with crossover appeal that spilled into mainstream, non-teenage angstridden culture. These big pop songs pleasingly still hold up.
Mid to high 4 for me on american idiot, we both remember it v fondly, the singles still hit hard, but it sags in the second half - still, iconic moment for pop punk and pop rock
Great
American Idiot Jesus of Suburbia Holiday Give me Novacaine/She’s a Rebel Letterbomb
American Idiot Jesus of Suburbia Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams Are We the Waiting Homecoming
A*
This album has held a special place in my heart for a long time now. It was one of the first albums to get me into music in general. This high energy punk rock opera is well paced for a double album. So many great and iconic songs on one album. Favorite Track - Jesus of Suburbia Least Favorite Track - Whatsername
I’ll try give this another listen at some point but overarching sentiment is its hard to seperate what are i think very good songs from the very particular vibe and era that they evoke and also mid oughts animated films
I often forget that this is Green Day’s SEVENTH studio album but god is it a good one. I’m partial to a concept album but a concept album done WELL is something else. I know this album is steeped in deep nostalgia for me but I’m pretty sure it’s not clouding my judgement here. This is a 5-star-er, if only because it taught me that I can be loud and defiant and angry. I really enjoyed returning to American Idiot and will be glad to do so again.
An album I don’t think I’ve ever listened to in full but have been meaning to! Iconic singles on here and ones that I remember loving in year 4. Christmas 2005 I was so disappointed to be given the Green Day International Superhits album because it didn’t have any songs from this album (I would later learn that their early career songs were also great). Lots to love here: the ambition, the storytelling, the dynamics and also the brazen political messaging. Also, songs like Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Holiday still sound so good. I love Jesus of Suburbia even though I have to brace myself for the r-word every time I listen to it. 4 stars only because the second half did not really live up to that opening run. However, Whatsername is a great closer and now one of my favourites
Well written pop-punk songs with good hooks but a voice that irritates the shit out of me. I can appreciate it. Whatever.
3.5
Generationally ubiquitous album that is pretty damn corny at the end of the day. Green Day trying to be artsy with 9 minute song "suites" seems like a reach to me. At the same time, half of these songs and riffs are coded to my brain forever so I'll just give this a three and stop thinking about it.
LOVE. This entire LP is awesome.
Not my favorite. Probably the hipster in me but the popular songs felt like a chore. I enjoyed the double feature aesthetic of each song but the songs were a bit too long. I won’t be returning to this.
Obvious 5star for me. Love the concept album
what a fucking good album, iconic in all its right and wrongs, from the iconic album cover to the hit after hit after hit tracks. you have to love it from the punky guitars and political opinions, and SLURS. its a good fucking album. birthed in the middle of the advancement and the more corrupt the world grows, the harder the album goes. unlike dookie which was closer to punk, they went undoubtedly closer to pop in this track. but the lyrics remain relevant and angrier than ever. this album birthed every single track that everybody knows, punk or not ur gonna sing to either american idiot or holiday/boulevard or wake me up. the album js throws u into it, its so amazing. they strayed away from the the offspring, descendants stuff and took more of an explosion to pop-ification. amazing still.
Soft "punk" rock for middle class socialist brats from suburban families who never really had to work.
Just incredible
I was firmly in my teenage years when this album came out, I would've been exactly the target audience, but I'd listened to Dookie and Nimrod before this, so my general reaction to this was "what is this punk opera shit about". For many years I avoided this album. Listened to it last year as my partner was due to go to their gigs. Still didn't hit. Sitting down with it again, it's still a frustrating album. There's some great tracks in this - Letterbomb, Extraordinary Girl, and with the exception of Jesus of Suburbia which is about 2 minutes too long, all of the singles still hold up. Does it make me take back all the crap I gave it 20 years ago? Nah, but it's not a bad album.
Nostalgi. Fattade aldrig att det var en slags punk-opera. Hade negativa förutfattade meningar men detta är inte alls så dåligt! Kanske inte lyssnar på hela igen men en stabil 3:a
Crisp and excellently written pop-punk. I made fun of this kind of music so relentlessly when it first came out, and now I really just appreciate “good tunes.” I do think some of the political/concept album stuff is still pretty cheesy and think the horrible musical nullifies some of its legacy. The gulf of quality between singles and the rest is pretty noticeable for me, too.
A classic! Still holds up to this day. Big fan of the "rock opera" style songs/arrangements. Pair with a cold American IPA, obviously.
Nice punk pop rock album
This album is pop punk rebellion. The instrumentals are great and Billie Joe Armstrongs vocals and writing are in incredible. This album is filled with bangers from the title track to the much more melancholy wake me up when September ends. There are a couple of songs that are in protest of war and commentary of post 9-11 culture. But then there are songs that tackle issues with mental health, loneliness and loss of loved ones. This album has range and it bangs.
Love!!
A real modern rock opera going far beyond the boundaries of their earlier punk rock stuff. Masterfully composed and played with lots of sixties pop influences it is also great fun to listen to. Their Magnum Opus in my opinion.
An all time classic album for a reason
Only enjoyed last song but I don’t really like pop punk.
Don't like them, didn't listen.
dookie הכי טוב
Fine although very classified in that era, 2 good songs
2/5
He escuchado este álbum, conozco al grupo, Green day es una de las bandas que escuche cuando era adolescente. La canción que más me gusta de este álbum es Wake Me up When September Ends y Whatsername, creo que son unas de las canciones más emblemáticas para mí.
Fazia mais de 10 anos que não escutava nada deles. Envelheceu mal, hoje achei bem chatinho
Highlights: St Jimmy, American Idiot, Holiday, Jesus of Suburbia. In a nutshell: the Millennial Quadrophenia. Overall: 7/10
I'm probably being a little generous here, and I'm definitely giving in to a certain amount of nostalgia. Getting a couple critiques out of the way: The band's shift to a more arena rock sound is mostly a lateral move. I really miss the active bass lines and rawer sound from their earlier work The lyrics and the whole Saint Jimmy story are a little on the cheesy side That said, I love this album from start to finish. Most concept albums have a really hard time finding good singles that still fit the surrounding storyline, but this one does a great job of balancing those needs. The writing, the execution, and the vibes are all excellent.
like, ok, it’s basically Green Day doing a worse Bad Religion, and it can be overly earnest, and it’s still obviously a big political rock opera concept album from the guys who got big writing a song about the tedium of masturbation but I’ve got a soft spot for Green Day. I like when bands are probably reaching a little too far, ambitions over honest appraisal of their abilities. I love concept albums (that aren’t Tommy or Kilroy Was Here or Music From the Elder). It’s hard not to like an album trying this hard, when it jams basically a summary of itself into a nine minute song with five acts like some kind of concept album inception. There’s also just some great tracks on here. Holiday, Whatsername, Give Me Novacaine. Holiday in particular feels like an old sneering Green Day song with some Bad Religion edge to it. They’ve also got one of my genuinely favorite bassists. Mike Dirnt has been putting out secretly killer bass lines since Dookie, punching way above the band’s weight class, and that does a lot for this album. Is this a real four or am I being a little too charitable? Man, I don’t know. 100+ albums in I’ve given up on caring about how objective or consistent I am in my review criteria. Sorry other albums that are probably better than this and still got threes
I had such a tough time picking a favorite song from this album. It helped define the 00's, and it was everywhere then for a reason: every song here is still incredible now.
3.4 3x watched the music videos (extended) as well. doesn't compare to dookie
Classic Album. my childhood haha
This shit fucking honks why would this even be on the list?
Hmmm, I get why they were popular and I did listen to Green Day in that timeline but I was never a real die hard. They do have a clean, crispness to their punk energy that is very specific to them. Stylistically, unique and worth a listen. This was a decent album.
takes me back to the good old days. so many memories associated with this album. one reviewer said 'green day makes music that encapsulates how it feels to be a teenager' and i think those are wise words
Enjoyed this, felt vital throughout, very full sound
We listened to "Wake Me Up When September Ends" in World Music. Green Day performed "American Idiot" - I'm not apart of a MAGA agenda! - for the superbowl something. Over 20 years later still remains ridiculously relevant.
Absolute fire... Love this entire album! It grows on me more and more all the time.
Good one. 4 stars
I like this. 4 *
Awesome, just awesome. Remember buying this when it came out and listening to t on my walk to work. American idiot - what a salute to the president!
Awesome album
Surprisingly good. Nostalgia for a time i was barely concious.
10/10 album
1: American Idiot 2: Wake Me Up When September Ends 3: Holiday/ Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Their best record since Dookie, bursting with purpose…and sadly relevant again. The longer medleys don’t necessarily work so well but the overall impact remains.
So much better than I expected (memories of the title track meant I was anticipating a 3.5 or 4 for this). I understand why the title track exists and it really did pull me in as a youngster, but I'm so glad the rest of the album is so much more nuanced and whole, and so less grating. I of course remembered how much I have loved Boulevard and Wake Me Up for decades now, and Jesus of Suburbia and Are We The Waiting are as good as I remember. But the other album songs I haven't heard before (never actually listened to the whole album before?!) are so much better than I anticipated. Brilliant album. 4.5 rounded up!
Good, but doesn't hold up as well as I would like
It’s always been a great album.
Great album, young or old you should enjoy this
I love Green Day so much !! This album is a classic I don't care what y'all think
très sympa. agréablement surpris, bel album complet. 3.5/5
Ja lekkere rock
reminds me of car rides with my mom
hf
Preeeeetty sick, unexpected that this hits so deeply
When I as listening or the first songs I thought that I should recognize them more, but then Holiday… came!! I enjoyed this album.
Eternal banger.
Loved it
Already know it!
Green Day – American Idiot (2004) On Day 55, American Idiot delivered a high-level experience that justified every bit of its massive reputation. It took a long sitting to fully digest, but the project is a definitive masterclass in how to execute a rock opera in the modern era. What stands out most is the production capability. Rob Cavallo and the band created a sound that is incredibly crisp and punchy; the drums are massive, and the guitar layers have a "tuff" clarity that hits the brain just fine. This isn't just raw punk—it’s a sophisticated, "immaculate" recording that shows off peak technical chemistry. By tackling heavy political themes and social frustration, they managed to avoid the shallow pitfalls that many of their peers fell into. The "conscious" narrative following the Jesus of Suburbia adds a layer of substance that makes the whole body of work feel vital. Jesus of Suburbia is a nine-minute triumph of songwriting, and the transition through Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams feels like a cinematic journey. Other highlights like Give Me Novacaine, Letterbomb, and the emotional weight of Wake Me Up When September Ends prove that this is a dense, rewarding project. Rich history backed by high-level execution makes this an undeniable 5/5.
makes much more sense when im older
Huge album full of hits. When it's good it's great.
Meh
Loved it
The epitome of what I think when I hear Green Day. Classic punk rock album. Tells a story through the songs, which is not something I see much now. Thought adapting this to a Broadway musical was odd before, but after listening completely understand why! 5/5
"All I've got is a red guitar, three chords, and the truth" -Bono "And look what we can do with those three chords, bitches!" -Billie Joe Armstrong
Did not expect to love this as much as I did! Thought I would think the hits were overplayed but they still hit and the other songs do too! A bit nostalgic but didn’t seem dated - 4.5
I can understand why people like it, but it’s still quite generic, even repetitive.
It’s a huge day to be a white boy
This is probably the best album Green Day did after Dookie, and is certainly the last truly great album they did (though I have to admit Revolution Radio does have its moments). Spawning some of the band's best-known tracks, this is the one even non-fans have heard of. So yeah, just for playability alone I'm gonna give it five stars.
Anybody who learnt guitar in the early 00s knew this album back to front (so this review is dripping in Nostalgia)! It's excellent! Blended well and full of great songs!
Eins der prägendsten Alben für mich.
Überragendes Album. Es gibt wenige Alben, die für mich vergleichbar wichtig waren in der musikalischen Sozialisierung. Zudem ein Konzeptalbum, was sehr gut gealtert und auch heute noch relevant ist.
Wusste lange gar nicht, dass hier eine Story erzählt wird und hab mich nur gewundert wieso abseits von den jeweiligen Songs ständig von "St. Jimmy" und dem "Jesus of Suburbia" die Rede ist. Album ist ein unbestreitbarer Klassiker, hab ich damals rauf und runter gehört, bevor ich überhaupt wusste, dass Green Day schon uralt sind und bereits Klassiker in den 90ern veröffentlicht haben. Im Gegensatz zu "The Wall" funktioniert das hier auch ausgezeichnet ohne die Story dahinter. Auch die beiden Longtracks sind großartig umgesetzt. Wäre gerne bei der Album-In-full-Tour dabei gewesen.
Müsste mein erstes Nicht-Linkin Park Album gewesen sein, dass ich mir gekauft hatte. Deswegen war der Rock am Ring Auftritt 2024 auch einfach absolut fantastisch (für mich), das Album in voller Länge war einfach nur umwerfend. Ein absolutes Meisterwerk vom Anfang bis zum Ende. Leider immer noch relevanter denn je.
Hit-Album durch und durch. Obwohl ich das glaube ich noch nie in Gänze gehört habe - bis jetzt. Sind eigentlich alle Konzeptalben erfolgreich oder gibt es so viele Konzeptalben?
Da muss man nicht mal großartig Punk-Fan sein, um die Bedeutung dieses Albums anzuerkennen. Wirklich eine Ansammlung zeitloser großartiger Songs.
War nie der größte Green Day Fan und finde auch hier vieles zu lang, aber ehrlich, dem die 4 Punkte abzusprechen fällt auch schwer
a classic, i love this album
Excellent album, great anthemic songs. Green Day is best when they realize they're not really a punk band and play towards there melodic strengths.
Not bad at all, 3 straight bangers that everyone would know but doesn’t dip much after those
Long songs, great vibe though.
I'm assuming this came up for me today due to the fact that it's the Friday before Super Bowl Sunday and Green Day was tabbed to play some sort of pre-game show which sent the fucktard conservative MAGAs into a torrid grievance state. Anyway, I don't know what I was listening to in 2004, but it wasn't this. Actually, that's not true. Songs off this album were absolutely everywhere and completely unavoidable. But it wasn't my vibe. Like anyone else, I had a copy of Dookie when it came out and I liked it....still kind of do. But shortly after that I discovered Hendrix, Led Zeppelin, Floyd, Sabbath and that's what carried me through high school along with Pearl Jam, Soundgarden and some rap like Tupac and Biggie, Nas, DMX, Snoop and Dre. Suddenly, I saw Green Day for what they were...just pop punk. I never bought another album of theirs and ultimately found Billie Joe Armstrong's voice to be kind of annoying. They had some catchy songs on the radio from time to time but I never wanted to buy an album. And when this came out, I just rolled my eyes. So this is actually the first time I've listened to it the entire way through. It's not bad, but it's not great to me. I'd rather listen to Dookie any day, but that's probably because there's some memories there of being a kid and having that album. You can see where they pushed themselves a little bit creatively on this one, but that's it. Really don't feel the need to come back to this album, so it's a 3.
#1. Heard some songs but never listened as a whole before. OK, bad start. Maybe I was a bit prejudiced, but I've never liked Green Day and this was a confirmation. Some of the most popular songs were almost ok, but overall it was too cheesy and boring.
I like Green Day, but a whole album was pushing it for me. Very similar sound from one song to the next, much like AC/DC, but I simply don't vibe as much with pop punk.
I like Green Day - great album with the songs I know!
Extremely theatrical and a little more pop than pop punk but still pretty solid.
Wasn’t a huge fan of this when it came out. On a re-listen not much has changed.
Corporate Disney Rock Sucks
Too nostalgic for this to not rate it on enjoyment alone. Jesus of suburbia has to be one of the quickest feeling long songs ever, and it's packed full of catchy riffs
Some proper bangers on here, I forget how many good songs are on this album. Without checking I would’ve said “American idiot” and “wake me up when September ends” but holiday, boulevard of broken dreams and Jesus of suburbia (I forget every time how long this song actually is lol) also all slap Second half definitely does fall off a bit though, after give me novocaine, September is like the only non forgettable song imo 4
A couple songs are ok and nostalgic but overall I don't enjoy this.
Альбом, поразивший своей концептуальностью. Зная несколько популярных треков из альбома, я бы никогда не представил, насколько здесь связанная история, в которой каждый найдёт для себя что-то свой. По исполнению мне всё же не так близко, хоть Wake Me up When September Ends является эталонным треком группы для меня, именно он не связан с историей Иисуса/Джимми, на которой держится весь альбом. Меня правда погрузили в интереснейшую историю, так ещё и с полностью закрытой концовкой без недосказанности. Но музыкально это всё же не поразило меня наповал. Лишь из-за этого альбом получит 4, но уверенных балла
Офигенный альбом, то что не надоест
Ok. This one caught me off guard. I wasn’t looking forward to the listen, but came away with a new appreciation. The political observations are wonderful.
Amazing
Absolute classic. Their last good album IMO
All totally objective evidence shows that this is a great album. There is no reasonable argument against it. Gonna take away a half-star for the legal actions taken on behalf of Green Day against Dean Gray and their incredible mash-up tribute album, "American Edit." Lawyers? Not very Punk Rock. * "American Edit" is not available through any streaming platforms, but third parties do keep it alive on YouTube. Trust me, it's worth your time.
It's good, but almost every song reminds me of a different song from someone else. I don't care for this album, but I can't deny it's good... If that makes any sense.
More rock than punk which suits my taste
I’m not really a big Green Day fan. They had some catchy stuff early on that nicely blended punk and pop. But this album, this album I feel is pretty special. Brilliantly done.
If this GreenDay album is on the list I hope it means that either Dookie, Kerplunk, or Insomniac is on the list. Not saying all four need to be, but I'd easily pick any of those three over this one to be on the list. Despite listening to them in the 90s I haven't really listened to them since then. This sounds like Green Day of the 90s, but a bit more polished and less raw and a little less angry. Also, the middle part of Jesus of Suburbia is totally a copy of Summer of 69.
Greenday American idiot- I was never into Green Day when they had their biggest albums. But looking back I totally appreciate how good and influential they are. Probably the best punk band I can think of. Cool how songs are paired on here with some nice transitions.
Man i havent listened to this whole album in probably over 20 years. Such a great concept album from a great band.
It’s great. I love Holiday.
This album is pure nostalgia for me. GreenDay was my favorite band from 11 to 14 years old. It tells the current state of America very well with a song such as American Idiot (even though its from more than 20 years ago). I am listening to the album on Spotify (sadly), and Holiday and Boulevard of Broken dreams (Green Day's 2 best songs) are together on a single track and the transition between the two is just perfect. However not every song is amazing and it was kind of disappointing hearing the whole album because the songs that are actually good I already knew and the rest was just meh at best.
nostalgic wishing for better days and hazy sunny days. My memories of this album are strong.. discovering bad words and slurs with friends and giggling about it, or screaming bolevard of broken dreams with my mom on the way to school. Hell wven the one sided beef I developed with When September Ends... this is quintessentially my childhood and early adolescense.
I mean...
Gosh, I’ve always liked it but actually really love it. What a glow-up from post-punk vibe of Dookie to enduring anthems like Holiday and Wake Me Up.
tragicomedic timing to get this album recommended today tbh. it's pretty good overall
Good stuff but nothing special
banger and "bankers" album! takeaways: jesus of suburbia, whatsername
Album kind of trails off at the end, but has some absolute classics of the generation.
Enjoyed this more than expected. Still feels childish
Awesome stuff
Another album I grew up on. So there’s a lot of sentimental value to this rating but the opening run of American idiot, Jesus of suburbia, holiday and boulevard of broken dreams is a near perfect run of music.
Cool
Maybe it's the nostalgia, maybe it's the frustration with the current state of fascist America governance, but I'm this is a five-star album. And by the time this was released, I was pretty firmly into local DIY punk and hardcore scenes, so this wouldn't have been big on my radar, outside of the obvious hits.
First stuff. Punk for the masses.
It couldn't be anything else
I think It's maybe like 8 years too late, as far as my life goes, for me to really fall in love with this album. Just as far as my musical taste goes, we're not exactly starting in a great place here. This is a combination of pop punk and musical theater, which takes itself *very* seriously. Additionally, the message here is really intended to resonate with people who, are like a decade younger than I am now. And the path America has taken since this came out honestly makes some of the messaging feel dated, or even detached. I understand this is about generational aimlessness and how cruelty lives quietly (or sometimes very loudly) in traditional American cultural values. Which I think is an admirable enough thing to dial in on. But it also feels like Green Day really thinks they can save American society with pop punk, and today that just feels really naive and self important. Additionally, a friend of mine holds that making a Broadway musical out of your album instantly obliterates your punk credentials regardless of who you are, and I can't agree more. But regardless of my complaints with the concept and execution of this album, it does get out a couple of pretty great songs. My favorite song here is Holiday, which is just driven by a fantastic bassline in the punk tradition. I also like St. Jimmy, and Letterbomb, which just work as great pop punk songs. I think Wake Me Up When September Ends is good too, mostly for it's earnestness. I'd also like to shout out *parts* of Jesus of Suburbia, and at least acknowledge that American Idiot is a particularly catchy song, even if I don't particularly like it. But, as this album is sequenced, Holiday, St. Jimmy, and Letterbomb are all tacked inseparably onto other songs that I don't really like (including Boulevard of Broken Dreams). Holiday plays first, so it's not as big of a deal there, but if you just want to listen to Letterbomb or St. Jimmy, I have to either sit through a song I don't really like, or like skip around. And I understand that this has been changed on some re-releases of the album, but it was obviously an intentional decision when this came out. I'm reviewing American Idiot, not American Idiot (20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition). Although, just on principle, I think Homecoming is the weakest track here. Jesus Of Suburbia is an epic that works on this album, it's multi-phased and it isn't too ingrained into the plot of the album that it does just work as a song. But when I listen to Homecoming, it actually feels like I'm missing something without watching the musical, or reading the liner notes or something. It's too tied to the narrative that it doesn't feel like I'm getting a complete experience without checking out another, related piece of media. I think, within this context, that constitutes a failure of songwriting. I don't really hate this album, a lot of the *bad* songs are more inoffensive, and there are highlights. But I found that the concept and execution here took more away from the album than it added to it. I understand why this is important to people, but it will never be for me.
One of my favorite punk rock albums of the 2000s, and there are a handful of them.
Abhorrent
Man. Spoken through and to a generation that connected Gen X through Grunge and Hip-hop and into the new century. Few albums are more of a watermark and even fewer are still adored and respected thirty years later.
I mean this album is perfect
"Jesus of Suburbia, a lower-middle-class American adolescent anti-hero" is just awesome. Maybe it's my nostalgia, but this holds up. Among the litany of major bleh punk-rock in the early 2000's, this stands out. Also, green day! weed day! cmon. love that
I'd forgotten how much I love this album!
Really respect this bad for bringing punk music into the ears of mainstream listeners. Definitely prefer their earlier work (lol this album is >20 years old), but this is good nonetheless!
Good album
Бодрый и записан точно.
Pourquoi Americana de The Offspring c'est un chef d'oeuvre et ça c'est mid+ ? Probablement parce que j'ai découvert le premier à 12 ans et le second à 37 ans.
Remember this well, though not listened in many years. You can really see how this became a musical.
Released in 2001 to mark the accession of one, erm, non-intellectual President, this still hits hard today, if not harder, thanks to the presence of an, erm, actually not erm, let's be brutally honest here, utter fuckhead in the White House. Five stars all the way.
Hey, I have one solitary melody. Let's start a band and be hugely successful. Let's also tell people we're actually 'punk' and see if they'll believe us! Let's be teenagers well into our 50s, at least. Okay, grab your three chords, let's make money!
Let's get this out the way first. This might call itself punk, but do yourself a favour and listen to Wire: Pink Flag The Clash: Live at Shea Stadium Gang of Four: Entertainment and see what punk can really be. This is polished, slick and commercial. The political message is a bit obvious and tries to be angry, but doesn't bear comparison with Jello Biafra singing "Kill the Poor" And then it decides to be "Rock Opera" and, boys, this is no Quadrophenia. It's solid, well played, enjoyable rock posing as something that other people did better. Perfectly fine on its own terms, but with aspirations beyond its grasp.
Five star album, maybe it’s the nostalgia. But this was always one of my faves growing up, I think it still holds up really well.
I quite literally felt like I was living in 2004 during the listen - pure nostalgia. Loved it. 3.5
Me at 13 would give this a 5 out of 5, but modern day me has such a hard time revisiting this teenage classic simply due to the endless amount I once played it. I’m not even including the incessant amount of plays the singles garnered at the time, which are all songs I am basically incapable of enjoying at this point. I still think they’re good songs, and this is a great album (Jesus of Suburbia still kid of blows me away), but it’s also one I have zero desire to revisit at this point in my life.
The most important rock album of my generation.
I don’t wanna be an American idiot!
Spent the better part of my teens and twenties in denial of this album. Clout chasing the classics like Dookie and Insomniac. But when my 30s came knocking and the pangs of the 9-5 dread, anxiexty surrounding bills, and the permenant sense that nothing will ever get better in this country American Idiot has gained a new place in my mind. It is as good as everyone says and deserves it spot in the pantheon of classic pop punk albums (and great albums of all time). Truly and openly explores life in the economic hellscape of late stage capitalism through the lense of an '04 punk. Without smartphones or content creators. It's still a cycle of dread and anxiety until you make like Jimmy and blow your fucking brains out. Or die with grace like the rest of us. It also explores themes of love, loss and growing up against a dynamite oughts pop punk sound. Nothing to be upset about here. Go figure.
I mean, 5/5
This is one of my favourite albums of all time. It was the first album I bought with my own money, and I listened to it tremendously as a teenager. I love almost everything about it and will gladly listen to it over and over again. This is an automatic 5/5
I'm surprised how many songs from this album I've heard before. Never really paid much attention to Green Day but this album so far is pretty fun. Surprisingly great album, did not expect to enjoy it this much. I think their sound has always been a bit repetitive to me but it works in this album. Surprised that an album that came out 10 years after their big hit would be this good, especially for pop punk.
Hated this on release. Listening to it again, it's still kind of annoying. I don't HATE is anymore... but it's not really drawing me in. Just kind of mid.
Solid album with some huge hits, gonna take a little more listens for me as I expected something different. To me it seems like punk, just more mainstream and more polished. Not like that raw punk for example dead Kennedys. Still solid tho
Ugh. Although I hate to hate on local Berkeley boys, I really dislike Green Day’s defanged and arena pop rock take on “punk.” I do have to give respect for the ambition of mounting a rock opera, resurrecting that hoary trope from the ‘70s and making it…I guess fresh? I did see it like 15 years ago and didn’t like that either. There are a couple tracks I like on here despite being curmudgeonly overall towards the hometown guys. Three
I already love Green Day and this album, so this is a biased rating.
I predicted it had 13 tracks before listening to it. 3/5
One of the all time bests.
What a great album, makes me think of my brother and playing video games with him. This album is full of hits like the title track, American idiot, boulevard of broken dreams, and wake me up with September ends. Green Day is a great example of early 2000s punk rock. I would gladly listen to parts of this album again and again.
I was never one to lean into left-leaning politics in my late 20s, but political themes aside, I was completely blown away the first time I listened to 'American Idiot' from start to finish. I’d already been a Green Day fan for nearly a decade when it was released in 2004, and it made me realize just how much Billie Joe Armstrong had matured—both as a lyricist and as a musician. While many people point to Dookie as their unsung masterpiece, this is the album I’ll always come back to first. Twenty years later, there’s still something haunting about “Whatsername,” the album’s closing track. I get hung up on it every time I listen, usually replaying it more than once. At 29, I struggled to put into words how that song made me feel. It forced me to confront the reality that I was barreling toward my 30s without ever having truly found love. The woman I’d been infatuated with before moving across the country—and the five years that followed—had convinced me I never would. That, thankfully, wasn’t the case. Still, this song perfectly encapsulated that sense of longing and melancholy of the girl who got away, somehow making me feel comforted at the same time. The purpose of art is to evoke an emotional response, and this album does exactly that every single time I hit play.
I have tried to listen to punk music in the past and it just never resonates with me. I find this more enjoyable than early punk (Ramones, Black Flag, Misfits, etc.), but it still doesn't produce any lasting effect. The songs are repetitive throughout and even the chord progressions appear on multiple songs. Only the slower Give Me Novocaine and ending breakdown of Boulevard of Broken Dreams seemed to really break the power chord monotony for me. Maybe if i paid attention to the lyrics or message I would get more out of this, but that's not how I listen to music most of the time. People really seem to enjoy this and it's likeable enough to listen to when it comes across on a playlist, but it's nothing I will ever go out of my way to listen to.
10/10 - now this is how you mix rock and political lyrics
i saw this album live! love the whole album and the meaning behind the songs. love u billie 🫶🏻
I can't believe that this album is more than 20 years old, and no-one learned the lessons they were preaching.
Dit was (samen met death of a bachelor) de eerste cd die ik gekocht heb hihi. Na eeuwen niet te hebben geluisterd, was het zo leuk om het toch weer te horen. Het zit echt wel gewoon goed in elkaar! We hebben nu ook meer toegankelijke punk nodig, want de wereld is bizar.
Maybe I am indeed the faggot, America...? (How did they know??)
teveel naar geluisterd als 13 jarige in de overtuiging dat t punk was. jesus of suburbia blijft een banger
I really wanted to like this album. I think Green Day get a lot of flack and I have a bit of a soft spot for them. I also genuinely like a lot of music that falls under the pop punk banner. I think this is a good gateway for a younger generation into punk music and I appreciate that. All that said I felt like this album was pretty hallow and repetitive.. I was waiting for a breakthrough moment where I could say to myself "see they aren't that bad!" But it never really came. I still think this album and this band deserve to be mentioned in the conversation of important and influential music of the past however many years... But this album under delivered for me.
Green Day, and this album in particular, were huge when I was in middle school, which was a time in my life where I would only listen to classic rock and "punk". You know, the kind of punk that got played on classic rock radio stations from time-to-time? Comically, I think Green Day are literally the kind of punk that gets played on classic rock radio stations now. Anyways, at the time, Green Day's brand of pop punk felt like the most corporate sellout and least punk music I'd ever heard. Now, I realize teenage me was a closed-minded idiot, but admittedly, I'm still struggling a bit to get past those feelings while listening to American Idiot now. I can hear the punk influences and the societal commentary is right in your face, but it feels so hollow, fake, and safe. Paint-by-numbers punk music with no real edge. Honestly, this kind of feels like my generation's U2. An uber popular band with decent songs, but it just doesn't really do it for me. Am I still just being a closed-minded idiot? I don't know, probably. Maybe I'll come around when Dookie is generated?
Great songs
4.5 stars A lot of music from freshman year of high school for me this last week. I was coming off of being a punk snob when this came out and pinched my nose at Green Day. But eventually I gave in and bought it and liked it, although I didn’t make a big deal about it. Nowadays I ca finally say that it’s really good and an achievement without worrying about my punk rock cred.
Лёгкий рок для подростков с реддита. Песня для титров солнечного приключенческого фильма, вайб Финес и Ферба. 3 из 5 Но ещё раз слушать вряд-ли буду. Слишком мотивациионный, американское единство, день благодарения и т.д Кринжовая речь главного баскитболитса школы о том какие бедные американцы и что бы пережить кризис нужно быть вместе. Под конец просто хотелось побыстрее закончить альбом и слушать что-то приятнее. Действительно понравилась только первая песня и то не на все 100
Not a green day fan, could barely get through it.
Despite this feeling very much like a diluted version of earlier Green Day, it is a rock solid album and an enjoyable listen.
A few famous songs. Overall not my taste.
did i come of age around this time? no. technically im too young but it was still pivotal in childhood development
oh HELL yeah brother
american idiot, nada mas que disir
Tracks meander and blend a bit, but still slaps thematically and sonically
The sweet spot between punk band and arena behemoth. I'm old enough to find the former much more formative and interesting, but there's no denying the cultural impact of this record or the way it single-handedly solidified the band's iconic status. Hardly a wasted moment in this nearly hour-long collection of vitriol, vulnerability, and effortless pop hooks.
The album that inspired basically all modern pop punk. His voice and songwriting/storytelling is fantastic, but those drums really take it to the next level. Perfectly encapsulates the feeling of being young and depressed
Not my favourite Green Day album by any means, but an interesting artifact of a very particular moment in time.
green day is the definition of mid
Dookie is better but this is still fantastic
Classic punk album. In Green Day's breakout album their assertive criticism of America and its people became the rallying cry for anti establishment groups. Green Day set the standard for what a true punk album is supposed to stand for and sound like. Loved it.
Very pointed and artistically deeper than most of their work. It was a great album to come out in 2004. I remember playing this when it came out in high school. I preferred and still prefer their earlier output but this is a great piece of work.
A classic. Been listening since Tony Hawk American Wasteland
Jesus show tunes. Really awful.
I liked a lot
Don't wanna be an American right now even more then back then.
LOVE
Buena fama ganada la de Green Day con este “American Idiot” (¿se estaban anticipando a la era Trump?). Este es un álbum pulcro en su producción, más rock que punk (ya quedó atrás la etapa de “Basket Case”), un verdadero producto para contentar a las masas y llegar a un público más amplio. En mi opinión, un poco pretencioso (¿un disco conceptual de punk-rock en los 2000?), pero lo cierto es que coló. Contiene una curiosidad que a mí me evoca un poco a swinging sixties meets The Kinks (“Homecoming”), no sé a vosotros. Muy notable.
Good album, I think it just got a little repetitive for me as we went through. Songs were long but had two sides to them. Some standouts include Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novacaine/Shes a Rebel, and Wake Me Up When September Ends. Overall 3.5/5
82/100. Fav Song: Are We the Waiting/St. Jimmy. Pretty good, very dad music.
Don’t wanna be an American idiot
Please note that I can't rank this from the counterfactual universe where it wasn't the most important album in my life at the age of 13. I basically never listen to this anymore, but when I do I'm reminded that it's actually really good. If it were a 40 minute record containing just the singles, Homecoming, and maybe one other song to preserve narrative continuity, I think I'd be lying by giving it anything other than a 5. It flags in the middle in a big way though. It's also quaint—almost cute—in the Year of our Lord 2026 to listen to a record that is in large part about how George W. Bush is a fascist and the American apparatus of the time is basically Nazi Germany (Kristallnacht is invoked for instance). Not to excuse GWB of anything, but it sure hits different today!
I claimed I would give a 5 to this before listening because it was my favourite album in middle school, which means it's one of my favourites period on nostalgia alone. I did listen again for due diligence and I will say, it definitely is not perfect - the choice to end the album on Whatshername is baffling, I forgot the r slur and the multiple f slurs (I mean I knew they used it but forgot it was more than in American Idiot), and it's not as cohesive as I thought it was. However, I do still think it's a great album and I will always get turnt at Emo nights when they blast American Idiot or Holiday.
I was going to riff on this but it does hold up as an ambitious pop-punk album with theatrical scope
Ugggh, I'm sorry to be that person but no thank you to a pop-punk rock opera. I can appreciate the concept, and the political message, but their sound here is way too polished, and I kept getting annoyed at the repeated tactic of completely changing up the beat/melody of the songs halfway through them. I fast forwarded/skimmed through most of this.
This album came out the year after I had graduated high school and I don’t have the same nostalgic connection to it as some of us. I think of Green Day as being the dad to a whole bunch of goofy punk pop bands that followed them, and then with this album the dad is angrily trying to assert that the family is SERIOUS about politics just like Grandma and Grandpa were
Full transparency that this rating is fully colored by weapons-grade nostalgia of this being one of the first things I really got into a full album as opposed to individual songs I bought on iTunes. I cried one time when I wasn't included to sing "Wake Me Up When September Ends" at Nature's Classroom. Haven't listened to it in a while but this album still fucks.
4 ½ soundtrack to my youth. Still sounds great today.
I can see the effort that went into this but I'm not a fan of the general sound. I like a couple of songs from their earlier albums but overall the vocal style gets on my nerves.
good vibes anni 2000
Catchy songs but overplayed
Hold up really well in the political climate we have in 2026 with the US continuing to act like a bully on our planet.
How do I best communicate the eyeroll emoji in a review?
This album is so nostalgic to me; countless hours spent listening to this after school while playing Tony Hawk Pro Skater 2. Knew it end to end. Two years ago I got to see their 20th anniversary tour of this album, and being at the barricade, was one of the best concert experiences of my life. This many years later, the Bush era criticisms are maybe dated but still valid. What a banger of a concept album. The singles from this got tired from all the air time for me, but the whole album is so good. Highlights: letterbomb, homecoming, jesus of suburbia (those transitions go so hard), st jimmy (the energy!)
Memories, memories <3
A teenage classic, some of it is a bit cringe these days but I loved it when I was a kid! Took a nice trip down memory lane listening to it.
Wordt ik niet perse warm dan wel koud van maar best behoorlijk
So cringe. I'll leave it at that not to be too impolite.
All the songs work well together, could get a five for Jesus of Suburbia alone for me
Not totally for me but I respect the cultural impact of the album Favourite songs: Wake Me Up When September Ends, Whatsername Special shoutout to Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams I love long songs
Fine but trite. I would have loved it at 13, but at 15 I was too old for it
Late comers basically copycat british punk cleaned up for the us market. Well produced but im not 15 years old and ive heard it all before. Singer looks like bit of a tit.
Not for me
Definitely their best album although listening to Green Day just makes me want to listen to the bands they copy. Totally understand why this would be a 5/5 for a younger listener.
Our Super Bowl national anthem singers 🙌
Awesome and up there with Tommy. Great music that tears down the suburbia myth. It is a classic for all times.
jel samo meni (i mom bratu također) ovaj frontmen, bili bob džons il kak se već zove, izgleda ko rej vilijam džonson? možda čak i ne liče toliko al imaju ful sličnu vibru prva pjesma - prvi mp3-plejer u osnovnoj, hahahha, strašno. sjećam se kako gledam fleš-animacije sa stikmenima, kolju se automatskim puškama, a ovo svira u pozadini uglavnom ne valja ovo baš. ima još dvije mim pjesme: bulevar bla bla i ona wake me up when september ends. ostatak isto nije baš nešt. ehhh. i još traje sat vremena, brate
As someone who skipped American Idiot in favor of Green Day's earlier albums, it's an interesting listen: they dial up the pop-punk but also drive home stronger, more pointed messaging in their songwriting. I've always heard of AI as being the album where Green Day veered harder into pop than punk but, listening to the album cover to cover, I think that's not entirely fair. This is a transformative album and either you like what they become or you don't, but it isn't less punk for the glossy production.
Jak byłem nastolatkiem to moja przyjaciółka zakazała mi być emo i nosić buty z czaszkami. Zakazała, bo sama była emo i nie chciała konkurencji. Cieszę się, że teraz mogę mieć czachę zamiast serca i w każdy wrzesień wrzucać "Wake ma up".
Mnie też brzydzi imperializm USA i czekam aż spłonie, czego tu nie lubić. I nawet są biseksualni. Nie no, tak zupełnie poważnie, co mam oceniać? To jak bardzo mi się podoba na mój dzisiejszy gust? Czy to że pamiętam jak wyszedł i robił furorę i mój stary podcinał sobie żyły, ale w złą stronę, więc niewiele z tego wyszło oprócz zamieszania, a ja słuchałem Boulevard of Broken Dreams i słucham nadal i od tego czasu 20 lat jak słyszę gdzieś American Idiot albo Holiday to prymitywna część mojego mózgu niezmieniona ewolucyjnie od czasów kiedy życie wyszło z wody na ląd (woda reference dla Julka) zaczyna wydzielać endorfiny zanim się zdążę zastanowić, czy ja to właściwie w ogóle lubię? (jakby ktoś pytał to for sure wiem czym są emocje i jakie można mieć, btw) Pewnie, że jest zbyt banalny i zbyt popowy jak na to, czym twierdzi, że jest (a dla mnie osobiście jeszcze zbyt yyyy upbeat żeby słuchać na codzień). Ale życie też jest zbyt banalne i co zrobisz. To nie jest punk i to nie jest nawet początek pop punku, a w ogóle to Billie Joe był w moim obecnym wieku jak to pisał, więc mogłoby być nieco bardziej wnikliwe i mniej nastoletnie (ja rozumiem, że podmiot liryczny jest nastolatkiem, ale zamysł był taki, żeby teksty były świadome politycznie, a ta świadomość polityczna ogranicza się w sumie do stwierdzenia, że wojna jest słaba a Bush chujowy, a woda mokra), ale może wtedy nie byłoby tak popularne wśród nastolatków i 13-letnie córki kolegów moich rodziców z którymi mieszkaliśmy przez zakładam że najgorsze kilka tygodni w życiu mojej mamy (która swoją drogą jest z tego samego rocznika, co BJA, więc też była wtedy w moim obecnym wieku) nie musiałyby uciekać z domu bo poszły sobie bez pozwolenia wydziarać na kostce ten granat w kształcie serca i ojciec im groził że im to wypali i nie miałbym do tego takiego sentymentu jak mam. No i lubię, jak album stanowi całość, a nie tylko zbiór losowo dobranych utworów, chociaż jeśli o tę całość chodzi, to końcówka nie wjeżdża tak dobrze, jak początek — ale to znowu też ma sens, bo proces dorastania zabija oba, i rage, i love, i summa summarum ten główny bohater okazuje się po prostu zwyczajny. Jak masz te emocje których potrzeba, ale nie ugruntujesz ich edukacją i nie ukierunkujesz działaniem, to zamiast zmienić świat rozpłyną się w niewyraźne wspomnienia, rzewne albo wstydliwe, zależy jak bardzo teraz próbujesz być normalnym członkiem społeczeństwa. I tak jest najprościej. Choose life. A Green Day po 22 latach sprzedaje ekologiczną kawę w ziarnach, jak Nergal, lol. Nic dziwnego, że rewolucja należy do młodych: starsi są zbyt wrażliwi na syreni śpiew Zakładania Firmy. THIS is the dawning of the rest of our lives. A USA robi kolejny syf na globalnym południu, a Green Day tylko zmienia nazwiska jak na koncertach śpiewają w American Idiot, czyjej agendy nie są częścią. I można kupić ekspres do kawy z tym granatem w kształcie serca, i te trzydziestoparolatki z dawno wyblakłymi dziarami na kostkach mogą sobie zrobić w nim kawę po pracy i powspominać. O ile dożyły zwyczajności.
Nostalgia super i z tego powodu daje 4. No skips album? Właśnie niektóre troszkę skip. I te których nie znam na pamięć były takie nieporywające dla mnie mimo że były upbeat. Wake me up when September ends
Bitch please ofc, że 5 ★ Słuchałem tego w gimnazjum. Słucham tego teraz. Zdecydowanie mniej niż w gimnazjum, ale lubię sobie wrócić. Po pierwszej nutce American Idiot, mam flashbacki z okresu bycia nastolatkiem XD Do słuchania w pracy bardzo przyjemne. Szybkie i pobudzające. Chciało mi się mniej spać niż zazwyczaj w pracy.
I heard Boulevard of Broken Dreams out in public yesterday and thought "This is a great song. I gotta listen to this album again." I even texted my brother about it. And then the next album generated for me is this album. Amazing timing. This is as classic an album as there is from the 2000s. The title track is snappy and the kind of radio release you'd expect from a punk band, but Green Day is no normal punk band. Two nine minute sagas in multiple parts on an album that is still so clearly punk rock... A punk rock opera, in every way. A huge achievement for a band 15 years in. And Green Day's best album.
A strong 4. Green Day do what they do better than anyone, and the theme/concept/callbacks are well done. The multiple song parts are all great - it was fun, rather than life changing - but then I was already in ny 20s when it came out. Maybe if I was 15 it would have been my RATM, or Nevermind, or NMTB. That said, you can't fault the quality of the singles...
I was never a fan of Green Day and I don’t like American Nu-metal or shite college boy punk. But I really enjoyed this- there are some great songs and enough variation to lift the whole. Good surprise.
Did I know prior: Yes Favorite Song: Boulevard of Broken Dreams I still remember the first time I heard Green Day on the radio and watched their music videos for American Idiot and Wake Me Up When September Ends on MTV. My rating is a little skewed because of the millennial nostalgia of it all, but I'm also a sucker for a concept album with a consistent narrative and I think this one is highly successful.
Får 3 fordi Boulevard of broken dreams ga meg 5 på musikkprøven på ungdomsskolen.
Quality arena rock.
Je comprends mieux la hype envers Green Day: du «grunge» dilué avec de la pop rend tout ça très catchy et accessible au grand public, en plus d’être extrêmement radio friendly. En vrai, moi même j’ai bien aimé mon écoute, l’album est tight et dépourvu de fillers, ça vaut bien un 4!
I forgot how hard some of these songs hit and I love how politically charged this album is, feels relevant to our current times.
didn’t finish. have heard lots of songs on this album. just not really my taste realized i felt like i was wasting my time.
yea its a fun album. good political commentary and again, its fun. 6.5/10
A classic. Album is great top to bottom
2.5 plutôt, la musique est pas folle mais tout réside dans le message politique quoi
not really my style biut i really liked one song called psycho killer
I wanted to dislike this! But I couldn’t - bar the odd acid flashback of manga haired guitarists jumping off speaker stacks, there was lots to like here. Weird song title mash-ups means loving and hating the same song. Jesus of Suburbia was very enjoyable.
Great album. Well put together. I was a fan of Greenday before but this album really shot them into super stardom.
Favourites: 1. Jesus Of Suburbia 2. Whatsernam 3. Holiday Least Favourite: Homecoming
8/10 Favorite: Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Who had "toy piano" on their Green Day bingo card when Dookie came out?
An album that has aged surprisingly well. The title track's lyrics are even more appropriate today than in the Bush era. Definitely is channeling The Who's Tommy vibe into a modern punk rock opera. Could have used a solid LBJ shout-out, though.
Good rock album
masterpiece
I liked this more than I thought I would. Concept albums aren’t my thing and Green Day usually sounds very samey to me. But all of the things to like about Green Day are here with punk rock chord changes, breaks, and signature melodies
Iconic as always
Ahhh, to be in college again. This albums evokes nostalgia, which is nice. Not sure I'd reach out for this though in future, I've outgrown this early 00s pop-punk-rock.