Reviews (page 3 of 16)
I thought I would dislike the soft moments on the album more, but I really enjoyed them. I've heard this album before and expected to enjoy it as a whole, but found new favorite moments than I'd previously found in listening to the song single by single. American Idiot and Jesus of Suburbia are of course excellent, but I loved Are we Waiting and Give me Novacaine were new favs. Homecoming is by far the weakest portion. Feels like a 7/10 project, maybe verging on an 8. Other than Homecoming it's very strong, it's just not necessarily the most engaging or interesting style to me.
Kjennskap: 80% Første album med en del sanger jeg har god kjennskap til. Vokste opp med dette. Mye bra, men litt tungt å høre på i lengden. Fav: Wake Me up When September Ends
Second go round with rock operas on the generator: I already got one of the earliest, now I’m reviewing one of the latest. I really enjoyed this album, I’ve heard it a few times before, and in my opinion it still holds up. I think one of the main things that makes this album feel timeless is how it feels like it has a universal message. It may have been written at a certain moment in time, but the themes still feel applicable to the modern day. The song Holiday, one of my standouts, was written overtly as a clapback to the Bush Administration, but still feels like it could be used as a rallying cry for a variety of political injustices. Another song that I believe captures this is Jesus of Suburbia, another standout track, which captures the egocentrism and frustration of adolescence without seeming whiny. Besides the story elements of the album, it also is impressive musically. A lot of the songs feel like the music fits the lyrics very well, such as the slide guitar and floaty atmosphere of Give Me Novacaine, my third standout, where our protagonist takes drugs to ease his declining mental health. It’s a tough choice to pick my final standout, but I’d have to go with the album closer, Whatsername, which uses both melancholy lyrics and music to depict Jesus’ emotional vulnerability at the end of his journey. Overall, I think this album resonates because it touches on a lot of things that are applicable years after the album was complete, and I would highly suggest checking out this album.
oh boy, this one is going to be a doozy. probably one of the biggest 00s rock albums ever, american idiot is green day's seventh studio album, and if this isn't the album that made their name known just about everywhere, then i don't know did. created as something much more dramatic than their previous work, american idiot presents itself as a pop punk rock opera album, the story involving a guy making some bad decisions and the intensity inspired from world events like 9/11 and the war in iraq. this album was made shortly after master tracks were stolen from an ultimately cancelled album by the group. this album represents the true pinnacle of the band i think. i think i might have discussed this in my review for dookie, but green day has a trademark sound that's unmistakable compared to other pop/punk rock artists, and the sound of this album ultimately is similar compared to the last one i heard. even with this in mind, this album essentially is a MUCH better set of songs using this same music style. i don't even need to yap about some of the most famous tracks in this album because most everybody, both young and old know just how catchy and memorable a lot of these songs are. it's a cultural staple of pop punk, and no rock CD collection should exist without it.
Such a classic and nostalgic album. My cousins introduced me to this as a tween so I've known the hits from the album for 15+ years. I actually had no idea this was a "punk opera" though - that adds another level to the listening experience. I did notice the recurring references to Jesus of Suburbia, so those make sense now that I know he is the main character. This should be a 4-star album for me, but I'm feeling 5 right now. I just really enjoyed listening through it today! The first half of the album is particularly filled with bangers.
Green Day definitely changed their sound to lean into the pop punk era for this album. Which clearly worked since this album exploded in popularity. Hands down it is my least favourite album of theirs. Though I cannot comment on any of their new music beyond this album. Kerri was psyched to hear this one this morning and I wish it was Nimrod
Honestly a much better album than I remembered. I wasn't big into Green Day as a kid. But, I had heard this album. It's honestly really good
Nostalgia bomb, owned this CD when I was just a little wee lad. I honestly must have just played the singles over and over, cause as much as I love the middle section of this album, I remember it way less than the first few songs. At this point American Idiot, has been re-played into the ground to the point where I don't think I can truly enjoy it anymore. I played the shit out of Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams as well, but those two still hit hard. Favorites are definitely Jesus of Suburbia, Homecoming, and my all-timer, Wake me up When September Ends. Love belting out to it. ZERO filler on this album, every song is really fucking good imo, truly feels like Green Day captured lightning in a bottle here. I don't think any of the music they released after this was able to reach these heights again. The heights this album hit are truly impressive, feels like every millennial and their mom has listened to these tracks. Even gen Z are familiar with the hits off this one. 9.5/10
Fun!!
Very good if you like approachable pop punk. Some very memorable tracks, including a few I had forgotten about, and Green Day's sound is distinctive enough for them to be easily differentiated from other pop punk bands.
With Green Day I have a love and hate relationship. Sometimes when I hear a song I really love it but the most part of their discography doesn't anything to me. Also on this album a few great songs, for ezample the epic Jesus of Suburbia. But also some standard punk rock tracks, especially in the middle of the album
Basically ticked all the boxes I expected. Profoundly 2000s but in all the correct ways. Fun!
I have to give Green Day credit for their ambition here. An ultra-political punk rock opera is certainly an interesting idea, and they almost stick the landing. The music here ranges from good to excellent, but I felt the strongest portions were when they stuck closer to their punk roots, like Holiday and St. Jimmy. The longer 9 minute suites felt strangely repetitive, and I didn't think Billie Joe Armstrong's voice fit the ballads. The narrative aspect of this album starts out strong, but ends up falling apart by the end as they begin straying away from the core themes of the album. The political messaging didn't fully work for me, either; while I do believe the band had specific critiques of the American government, it hits a strangely individualistic note that ends up diluting the message. As I said, I respect the ambition, and most of it ends up working, but a lot of it doesn't fully land for me.
tried playing along with the album and it really was all power chords lol crazy and really fun experience, that being said listening gets a bit repetitive. boulevard of broken dreams and wake me up when september ends still the only songs id listen to again
Probably the best pop rock/punk band out there. This album is so by the book, but maybe that's what makes it so good? I love "Jesus of Suburbia".
This is not my type of music. But the album is catchy and quite driving. But it is very monotonous for me. It fits the background for the working process.
Classic
Classic
I didn't enjoy any of this. I think it's trying to be ironically idiotically American but actually it comes over as sincerely idiotic. Maybe in a different way to the most obvious stereotypical American idiocy but this is its own flavour
la sube
I love this LP!
I'm not typically one to enjoy theatre, but a rock opera this theatrical is nothing short of amazing. The immersion you get from this album into the world of St Jimmy is truly something else. I do love a concept album with characters, a narrative, and an overarching story. And this one honestly has me invested in the main character more than any other. And to go along with the masterful lyricism of this album, the amazing music is there to back it up too. Punchy and ripping guitar riffs are all over this project, and Billie Joe Armstrong's vocals are truly one of a kind with his passion and intensity. It's just such a well crafted and put together album that knows exactly how to pace itself. I really enjoyed revisiting this again today, it's been a few years since I went through a huge phase being obsessed with this so I'm really glad to know that it holds up just as well as I would have hoped.
Hit album from Green Day
This is what happens when punk rockers grow up. From the same kids who made Dookie this is an incredibly ambitious album with great songs. Run time is a touch long but the songs are good and never overstay their welcome. Crazy to think that this album inspired musicals. Frankly it’s a work of art.
i remember dancing to Holiday in my friend morgan's house when we were 10 years old, having no idea what the song meant, but rocking tf out. my best friend Marie and I were obsessed with Boulevard of Broken Dreams and we thought the "uh huh uh huh" refrain was really funny for some reason. I heard Wake Me Up When September Ends so incessantly on the radio that I grew to hate it, and still I really dislike that song. Otherwise, I always appreciate Green Day's ability to diagnose hypocrisy and flay the myth of American exceptionalism and while some may see this album as too pop, i was so young when Green Day were putting out their more punk albums that I just thought they were cool.
Some hits. A bit overrated
Been fucking WAITING for this one. Love it to pieces, hate that it's still so damn relevant. Absolute banger of an album with hit after hit, and my top 3 Green Day songs. I love Dookie, but American Idiot is my #1 from this group.
If this had been vinyl an amazing side killer after killer after killer. One or two tracks just bring this down a touch almost perfect.
I wasn't enjoying the sound of this album, but I understood there might be lyrical merit to it. I looked up the lyrics, and I liked the albums lyrical rejection of black-and-white thinking. This is the only artifact I can appreciate.
I mean it was better than DOOKIE
Absolute classic
This is really a great album. Green Day was a little after my era, but proof that the kids are alright. It rocks hard and the lyrics are terrific.
Favorite Track: Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Me recordó al de The Clash: hacen mucho con poco, y si fuera la mitad de corto sería perfecto.
Oh Greenday! Greendayy are awesome. Easiest 5 star if my life, even though it's not my favourite Greenday album.
Feels strange to say that I'd never actually listened to this before, given how much I'd treasured everything from 1,039/Smoothed Out Slappy Hours, via Pinhead Gunpowder, and right up to Nimrod as a young'un. Don't really need to hear any of the singles again (especially 'Wake Me Up...'), but there's enough here in tracks like Letterbomb to make me want to merrily break out the Dookie guitar chordbook, so that's got to be worth a three, for the old days.
Heart says a solid 10/10 as my 17 year old self loved the album and I had the pleasure of seeing the album played in full a couple of years ago at Wembley. The album starts relentlessly and the drums, bass and guitar along with the solid vocal chanting out causing a euphoric atmosphere really drumming home why I love the album, the production on point and the seamless change of tracks really works. Every track even with the political line running through it can be forgiven. The Irish feel to some of the tracks and the constant natural joining in with the singing and chanting makes it such a great album. The two ballads are top notch amongst the rock opera that’s on show. My heart said 10/10 and so does my head despite the obvious flaws, I don’t care about the flaws as the good outweighs the bad. Best track- so hard to pick. ‘Holiday/Boulevard’ ‘Jesus of suburbia’ ‘Wake me up’ All in with a chance but today I’ll go with ‘are we the waiting/St Jimmy’ Worst track- ‘give me novacaine’ although once ‘she’s a rebel’ hits in I don’t care I’ve heard it! 10/10 (probably should be 8/10 but I don’t care!)
Green Day - American Idiot In small doses I quite enjoy Green Day but this was just too much pretend punk for me. The riffs are punchy without being in your gut punchy. The lyrics are typical US kid rock stuff. The musicianship is ok, but nothing more. It's just the right kind of 'punk' to take home to meet your parents. And I suppose that is why it has sold millions upon millions of copies. And I could kind of cope with the safeness of it all, if it wasn't for the horrible treated, pitch-corrected vocals. To me, that betrays what they really want which is success, not authenticity. Turning it into a Broadway show kind of says it all, really. Best Track - I liked the run grouped as `Homecoming' Worst Track - didn't have one. In the same way I still eat plastic cheese if the mood takes me. 5/10
It remembers me of tony hawk games, but even with the nostalgic stuff it bored me while listening.
I remember Green Day making a slash and their one song I recall hearing on the radio was “The Reason.”
Again, I am biased. I repeat, I am biased. This is better than Dookie at least
Fun to listen to the protest songs of yester year, quite sad they're licking the boot now
Lots of meaning, made into a musical for a reason. I didn't realize so many of the songs were paired together.
forgot how good this was
I'm too firmly millennial not to give this five stars.
I liked few songs, but in general this is not my style of music
Fantastic album!
What can I say? This is exactly what I want from an album. Loved it so much I relistened to the entire thing. Great energetic punk record with some fun guitars and lyrics, but doesn’t shy from getting emotional and slowing things down. Sounds so Green Day, but in the best way possible. Would be shocked if I never picked this up again. Also just becoming so relevant in regard to modern times 😬.
Jesus of Suburbia starts off decently but it's far too long imo
EL disco de Green Day. Voy a poner esto antes ni siquiera de ponerme a escucharlo. Si no hubiera escuchado cuando era adolescente no habría acabado escuchando la música que escucho, creo que ni siquiera tendría los mismos gustos, me ha moldeado de una forma increible. Le voy a dar 4 porque sé que los hay mejores pero vamos, en mi corazón le doy 20.
Bueno me lo escucho (tu abogada de confianza contestando demandas con american idiot de fondo) pero te puedo poner la reseña ya mismo porque me lo sé de memoria.
Me ha gustado bastante. Mucha cancion mitica. Me ha parecido guay lo de las canciones dobles
I like concept albums in general and I want to like this. I think maybe it would be a good album if literally any other band had made it. Billy Joe Armstrong’s proto-emo vocals just make it annoying to listen to.
I really thought I'd like this more. It's too angry punk, I was expecting more pop punk. There's just no singing...
Wake me up when September ends, es una canción perfecta para su época y para su estilo, después de ser unos locos hardcore se paran y te cuentan algo que importa. A partir de ahí un disco en su línea divertido, rockero, que pide ser joven y saltar en un bar o en un concierto con sus canciones. Me guardo esa canción y también Jesus of suburbia y Holiday/Boulevard of broken dreams.
I don’t rlly like greenday anymore
It was a very good listen, not much more to say but it kept me engaged.
I enjoyed that trip down memory lane
Great, but I appreciated Dookie's raw, unfiltered punkness much more than this: which is a tad more cleaner and more polished. I want some gritty punk, man!
Punk music can be split into two distinct eras: the early era where it was sped up 12-bar blues, and the later era where it became 4-chord songs. Oh how to rate this one. Love the political energy which hasn't aged a bit, but it's also steeped in that pop sound. So polished, a true punk rock opera, but with 4-chord songs... But it's only the radio hits that have that going for them. So is that really the album's fault or the audience?
Listens: very familiar I didn't really know what rebellion was in fourth grade (or honestly really at any point in my childhood), so it's kind of funny to look back and see what this meant to so many other kids my age or slightly older. Granted, I had liberal parents, so the liberal attitudes expressed by this album (Bush bad, war bad) didn't feel rebellious so much as simply righteous, even if I had no idea why Bush was bad or what we were supposed to be doing in Iraq or Afghanistan anyway. (I was nine!) The album offered plenty of edginess besides, from denouncing the tv-watching masses (thus allowing me to feel superior to my classmates) to calling Americans idiots (weren't my parents always saying that?). Of course, the majority of the edginess—and much of it is that, just edginess—was lost on my tiny brain. Kids being fed too much "ritalin"? Must be some sort of junk food. "Kill all the 'fags' that don't agree"? Just a mean word to call someone. Saint Jimmy "blew his brains out into the bay"? I was terrified to blow my nose after that, lest my own brains be blown out. That all aside, I was obsessed with this album. It maintained rotation on my little discman for years, and though much of its charm has worn off for me at this point in my life, several of its songs are still huge favorites of mine, "Holiday" and "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" especially. To me, the joy of this album was less in its (honestly fairly shallow) political commentary than its many twists and turns, its perfect production, and its *coherence* as an album. All the track segues excited me so much as a kid, especially the two nine-minute song suites, which expertly weaved tiny punk song ideas into tight, polished entrees. In a time before I'd discovered Nine Inch Nails' The Fragile, it showed me what an album could do, what it could be. In general I detest pop-punk, but though there are definitely cheesy moments, this album never felt like the whining, cynically teenager-aimed music of Blink-182 and their ilk. Sure, it's a concept album built around the teenage "Jesus of Suburbia", but even today it feels more like an expression of concern for the youth rather than an attempt to court them. Green Day (already legendary by that point, of course) went on to continue to flirt with vapid radical symbolism, talking about "revolution" like it's nothing more than a metaphor, or a fun plot point in an RPG game. Anything they had to say, they said on this album. Sure, 2004 was a very different time politically, but even so it was not exactly a hot take that the Iraq War was unjustified. Nonetheless, the album's role as a rallying cry for liberals was culturally significant, even if it didn't help defeat Bush (alas), even if the messages stunningly went above many conservatives' heads as well.
Very nice
Punk opera. I've listening to these songs here and there because they were part of the mainstream, TV/movies. I enjoying reading a comment that this was just one long song. The transitions are not noticeable, and it doesn't get boring. As relevant today as in 2004 is a cliché but there you have it. The more things change, the more they stay the same. Now I can just enjoy the rest! Yes, this is top tier.
there were a couple of high points - the Who inflections, especially, and the band was extremely tight, but the hour long listen dragged by
Unlistenable garbage (in my opinion)
4.5 stars! Nostalgic, pop punk with some fantastic songwriting. Just a little too punk for me to give it a five. As close to five stars as you can get, I just don’t connect with it enough to give it a 10/10
Exactly what I needed today
Ok
Hyvä platta ja kai tätäkin voi jonkinnäköisenä "aikansa kuvana" pitää.
Hittibiisit on kyllä edelleen kovia, mutta ei niiden ulkopuolelta oikein löytynyt mitään uutta kivaa. Mutta mennään nyt nelosella silti.
Joo tätä on tullut joskus oikein kuunneltuakin. Ihan siinä hilkulla, ettei mee sietämättömäks saundien sun muun tuotannon osalta. Joku mai kemikal bromance sitten käytti samaa tuottajaa ja teki aika samankuulosta tavaraa viivottimen kanssa ja se on sitten jo ihan hirveetä ulostetta. Mutta tässä nyt sillain tää pumppu nyt loi nahkansa uusiks ja pysty työntään semmosen "hei kasvettiin aikuisex" -levyn. Semisti menee yliyrittämisen puolelle, mutta on tässä paljon hyvääkin biisiä. Osittain sitten kun niiton soiteltu helvetisti niin on sit ähkyt ja kai se on pakko kattoa homman ohi. Siinäkin mielessä tää on kans vähän JÄNSKÄ taitekohta, että tän jälkeen tulleet riin deit on niin epämiellyttävää, ettei niitä halua ees yrittää kuunnella. Eikä tää loppujen lopuks niin paljoa niistä eroa. Periaatteessa nelkun levyn, mut kyl tää "veden virtaamisen" jälkeen on kolkki, kun nää kaikki rokkioopperat sun muut vaikuttaa vähän semmoselta, että pitäs jotenkin uudistua mut ei sit kuitenkaan ihan osata. vaan menopunkki on leipälaji. Ihan hyvä yri kuitenkin.
Jahas, toinen Green Dayn levy ja toinen vitska Green Daylle. Tämä käy Dookien kanssa kovaa kisaa omasta Green Day -kakkossuosikkilevystä Insomniacin jälkeen. Todella paljon parempi rock-ooppera myös kun jo aikaisemmin tässä haasteessa vastaantullut Tommy. Onhan tää sillain varsinkin soundillisesti varmaan aika kaukana siitä visiosta mikä Green Dayn on pannut liikkeelle. Mutta onhan tämmöset loppuun asti hiotut rokkisoundit melkoista karkkia omalle korvalle. Vielä kun biisit kantaa ja sanomaakin on, niin ei voi muuta sanoo ku hattuu nostaa. Tässähän on ihan Green Dayn ykköskorin biisejä useampikin: Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday, Letterbomb, Are We the Waiting, Wake Me Up When September Ends... Muistan että aikanaan Boulevard of Broken Dreams ärsytti kovastikin kun se soi ihan kaikkialla, mutta vanhemmiten siitäkin ärsytyksestä on päässyt irti. Helppo vitska, ja yksi varmastikin kaikkien aikojen eniten kuuntelemiani kokonaisia albumeita.
6.5 / 10
4,6 Highlights: Holiday, Boulevard Of Broken Dreams
Love Green Day. 5 stars
It’s held up well.
I don’t waste my time with Green Day.
For some reason I always convince myself that I'm not a Green Day fan, but it turns out I'm wrong I'm not the biggest fan of the title track, but the album on the whole is ace. I thoroughly enjoyed it
I remember when this one came out. Found a lot of the singles enjoyable and catchy. That is until it got overplayed and it's brilliance was shoved down my throat. Revisiting it, in whole, it's okay. Still some fun, but a lot of my bitterness remains and I can't see it's brilliance
2000s teenage angst at it's biggest and loudest. Never been that crazy about concept albums/rock operas, and this doesn't move the dial for me. Some the band's strongest singles on this however, just a decent pop-punk record all around. Fav Songs: American Idiot Holiday Boulevard of Broken Dreams She's a Rebel Wake Me Up When September Ends
I like the singles from this album. I appreciate the band’s distinctive sound. I like the singer’s voice. What I found listening to this album—which is 57 minutes long but has only 9 songs—is that I don’t need a whole Green Day album. A couple songs is enough. ;)
A little frontloaded and cheesy, but still a total blast all these years later!
Не погано,але не моє,оцінка:6.5/12
I've enjoyed this album since teenagehood. Listening again, I've definitely grown in my tastes but it still is a nice listen.
2,5
1st album was cool, this was just overplayed on the radio.
Rico disco, tiene un par de temas medio olvidables así que se come 4 estrellas. Aguante Jesus of Suburbia vieja. Sape
Very high energy for sure.
Something familiar with enough unknown tracks to keep me interested throughout. This is the most thought I have given to the band to this point so reading about the journey that led to this album was very engaging. The theft of the masters, the band being on the brink of splitting and coming together to focus their attention on a punk rock political opera is quite a ride. I'm not into opera's or musicals due to my own limitations but I wasn't even aware there was a grander story being told here before now. I think the music works really well, they lean hard into those big booming sounds from the drums and bass guitar and it creates a lot of Anthemic sounding moments which is easy to listen to. Vocals are hard to parse on their own just due to how much ive heard it growing up but its got a hard punky edge when it needs to and doesn't bother me. I'd be happy to have most any song come up in a random playlist without skipping although some of the longer tracks can begin to overstay their welcome on repeat listens.
Bon, ben c'est clairement pas mon truc. L'espèce d'entre-deux entre du pop rock et du punk, non seulement ça ne me parle pas, mais en plus, ça me rappelle des mauvais souvenirs de mon stage où un de mes collègues mettait tout le temps du Pennywise. Heureusement, Green Day, c'est beaucoup mieux que Pennywise?
It's Green Day alright
It was such a full-circle moment when I had the opportunity to hear them play the entirety of this album live at a festival for its 20th anniversary after listening to it religiously when I was a teenager. This might actually be one of my favorite albums ever.
Alright not very exciting first album but there were some enjoyable parts didn’t listen through though
Great album, great entryway into punk.
reminds me of naomi. I thought the songs were good but i dont think id choose to listen to them myself.
It was fine a few great songs other were eh
Neprišiel som im nikdy na chuť. Niektoré piesne sú fajn, ale zvyšok má nechytá.
jao brate bas mi se ne slusa ovo
4.5
Dookie and Nimrod are the better albums, yeah? But honestly, I’m looking forward to this like a kid on Christmas. Too much mid-60’s again of late. Need a good palette cleanser. Man, I forgot how epic that opening is! And Jesus of Suburbia. What a song. The whole album works. Maybe it’s just my mood today, but I think it’s masterful and fully realized. 5 Boolean: TRUE so true
some ok songs
A big hit from my early teen years. Quite good. The rest of the album surprised me considering the first 2 songs are mega hits. I like the 2 song tracks, they make for seamless transitions.
A modern classic. Green Day had experienced an underwhelming response to 2000's Warning (actually a pretty good album -- 'Minority' and 'Warning' are total earworms), so they'd been written off by many. Part of that was due to a shift away from their California punk sound, a backlash first witnessed with their smash hit acoustic ballad, 'Good Riddance'. Billie Joe Armstrong has said before in interviews that he never intended to be a pure punk songwriter, that was just the scene they grew up in and where a lot of their early influences came from. American Idiot marks a natural evolution of their punk rock sound towards a less-punky alt rock. That's a fine distinction to make for those outside of California's punk community but there came a point where the jam/show/flop house that Green Day played their first shows in would no longer let them in the door. Punks are, almost as much as metalheads, obsessed with what is and isn't punk, so the distinction was meanginful to both Green Day and their longtime fans. It's a counterculture thing -- rejecting the mainstream is easy when the mainstream is rejecting you; when people start buying your records and you can just do what you want, there's a choice to be made and it has profound effects on your financial situation. The number of punk bands touring for gas money and subsisting on ramen declines sharply as those things start taking a physical toll as their twenties wane. Anyway, a concept rock album about the political decline in America was a real swing from these guys. It was also timely: 2004 was deep into the Bush II presidency and three years post-9/11, leaving a lot of people questioning whether the response to the September 11th attacks were right (spoiler: they weren't!). Wikipedia rightly notes that the only overtly political songs on the album are 'American Idiot' and 'Holiday' but the whole record is suffused with the sense of 'what the hell are we supposed to do?' Armstrong is 13 years my senior but this sense has been pervasive and lasting for my generation. Anyone who still thought that the Iraq invasion was a good thing in 2004 was probably a committed Toby Keith listener and not a part of Green Day's target market -- but that unease of cultural schism (the early days of alternative narratives which would morph into alternative facts) suffuses American Idiot. It has two medleys ('Jesus of Suburbia' and 'Homecoming'), a reprise (there's a 'St. Jimmy' callback in 'Homecoming'), a ballad and it even opens with a classic Green Day-style punk tune in the title track. The production is relentless, with medley arrangements flowing seamlessly into split tracks. It's also extremely clean. There's much more to the recording than just three instruments and three voices but the primary members and their respective specialties all shine the brightest -- and deservedly so, with all three sounding as good as ever. If you want to nitpick, Dirnt's very best basslines are found elsewhere (it's 'Longview') but that's not to say his playing is bad on American Idiot. It's very good, just less iconic. This is a 5/5 on its own merit, for the place it holds in Green Day's catalogue and because of its generational significance. But also, if you like this, go back and listen through Dookie, Nimrod and Warning.
Liked half of the two part songs
Ah, loved this album :) Turns out I still do too! Not that it’s actually been all that long since I heard it last, admittedly. Did send me down a bit of a Green Day hole though - which wasn’t a bad thing.
Really doesn't do anything for me but giving it a 2 feels harsh.
This was a pleasant surprise - I've always kind of avoided Green Day
classiqua mais pas trop mon truc
It’s an okay album. I remember all the hits being overplayed on radio. They were catchy. Green Day can write good pop punk tunes. This album isn’t amazing but I can understand why it’s on the list.
Super nostalgic, great album.
A great album. Not the masterpiece it was first touted as, but it is incredibly strong. There is still too much filler on it, and that lets it down.
офигенный альбом
punk rock
For npcs. Disgusting and brainless
Favorite songs: American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Are We the Waiting, Extraordinary Girl, Wake Me Up When September Ends, Homecoming, Whatsername
Post-punk classic. One of the best albums of 2000s. A must listen for every (punk)rock lovers. Even the album cover rocks. Favorites: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends, Holiday
I remember listening to this one in my childhood. It holds up pretty well today, sans some of the wording and lyricism. Favourite Track(s): Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends Least Favourite Track(s): Letter Bomb, She's a Rebel, Give Me Novacaine
Didn't like the notes too metal, also didn't understood much might visit latee
Surprised me with its musical force. Their political lyrics are kind of lite-beer but the songs pretty fuckin rip. The band can find a groove and get a loud, live-on-stage feel. They’re still not punk - they were never punk - but they’ve found a unique sound. And I still don’t know if Billie Joe really sings like that or it’s a bit.
*American Idiot* is a rock opera. It’s a band from the later era of punk—or at least the songs have a wonderfully punk sound. It makes for a great listen, provided you’re in the right mood or willing to get into it. It might not be the ideal choice for waking up first thing in the morning, though. Still, after the first listen, I’m giving it 4 points.
Know this
pretty much sort of okay!!! theres obviously a handful of tracks on here that like....it feels weird to say i Like them so much as im just Attached To Them in a way that feels different from my normal avenues of Articulating An Opinion On Music. as for the rest my general green day feelings apply....i struggle with billie joe's stiff singing (tho he's found his Timbre at this point for poppy deployment), and despite the leap in ambition this is still a p samey record across its mildly bloated length, but i do find the personality of the band very likable. its a pretty spotty tracklist but even if it wasnt, i rly only have so much appetite for green day songwriting at a time. this is kind of Tommy for gen x and millennials, for better and worse in both overlap and differences. tommy is so bizarre that its remained an object of fixation and frustration for me, where american idiot i know Exactly what it meant emotionally to both its creators and its audience. its easier to appreciate, but i am less likely to think ab it i suppose.
I don’t like Green Day. I never have. I’ve given them plenty of chances over the years, but their sound just isn’t for me. There are a few exceptions, though. I was 14 in 2004 when American Idiot came out, and it was everywhere. At school, my classmates would play it between classes. Every “skater boy” (shouts out to Avril!) with a guitar would try to cover songs from the album during lunch. I say “try” because they sounded terrible—but their enthusiasm was genuine, and all the girls would swoon over their attempts at Wake Me Up When September Ends. Songs like Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams were on constant rotation everywhere my friends and I went. It was impossible to escape American Idiot. Because of that, I ended up growing attached to several of its songs. Despite my overall dislike of Green Day, there’s no denying this album has some genuinely great moments. More than anything, though, American Idiot is tied to some wonderful memories of my teenage years. It’ll always have a special place in my heart.
I have listened to most of these songs many many times before, but never approached the whole album. I was surprised to find such a cohesive and enjoyable record. Green day were inescapable in this period and for good reasons
I can't say its my type of thing but to be fair Green Day made quite an astute come back with this album and in its genre its got snappy songs, some great writing and some astute - if not wholly original - political messaging. In the context of a massive 2004 crossover pop punk record it ticks a lot of boxes
Hittiä hitin perään. Sama energia koko albumin ajan. Biisit sulautuu kivasti yhteen, mutta on kuitenki erilaisia. Very nice.
Nicht alles so langweilig wie Boulevard of broken dreams. Paar Sachen gehen ganz gut nach vorne, aber manches ist schon eher mäßig interessant. Bekommt dann ziemliche Längen und endet eher schwach. Schade.
I really enjoyed this. Was never really into them when this came out but due to people in work have listened to their latest album and liked that so when this showed up was interested in listening and it didn’t disappoint.
Not been a fan of Green Day (which is to say they’re a band that just simply passed me by - see also Foo Fighters). But this was bouncy and brash, and the production was clean. Liked.
This is a good album, I just don't love it enough to give it the full 5 stars.
Massively overrated album
Nicee
I knew of Green Day but had not paid much attention, also dimly aware this was some kind of concept album. I listen to it while I read about it. The sound is often neat but not wholly appealing - they were maybe struggling with pressure to invent endless 'novel' riffs from a limited palette. As the album goes on, too many sections with limited dynamics, too many power chords, fortunately there is also some variance in styles. I read some lyrics but am wholly dissatisfied with the lyrical/conceptual side. As others have said, it strikes a vaguely critical (dissatisfied) pose but without any content or compassion, nothing about economics, class, race, gender or any real people - there is just a small number of gestural points but not joined up at all, lots of repetition. I was struck by this statement (indictment) from Wikipedia: "The album's story is largely indeterminate, because the group was unsure of where to lead the plot's third quarter. In this sense, Armstrong decided to leave the ending up to the listeners' imagination." That is a very weak base for an album, tour, musical and attempted film! So, I understand that this was popular with a huge number of people and feels like a shared experience of some sort of rebellious pose, but it doesn't work for me. The music is not hopeless but I have no interest to re-listen. It's Pretty Poor, 3/10.
Awesome
Love this album, suited the times. Great live group tpp
woah woah you cant say that buddy
No thanks. Reminds me of middle school but not in a good way.
Mhmm interesting
Another Great Album. Followed it up with Dookie. Excellent all around.
An absolute pop punk classic. So many bangers. The first album I’m reviewing that I’m biased towards. You absolutely need to hear this before you die. If it were 20 years ago, I think I’d rate it 4, but eh - I’m rating it higher with the power of hindsight and knowing the impact it’s made, and seeing how much of a triumph it really was. I think it deserves the 5.
I remember this album was pretty big when it came out. I was always hearing Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake Me Up When September Ends. This album was just ok, I felt like it got a bit boring after a while.
Classic
overproduced
Classic!! Love Greenday!
My dad would crank this almost every morning he drove me to school and I still. Fucking. Love. This. Record. It’s a perfect pop punk album. It’s a perfect concept album. Listening to this record always makes me so emotional and reminds me of how much I love music.
Never a HUGE Green Day fan. Loved Dookie when it came out like everybody else in the 90s. This album makes me yearn for the days tot George W. Bush’s stupidity versus what we have now.
It's American Idiot, man. This album has American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, and Wake Me Up When September Ends on it. It's a generational album. From start to finish, it's amazing. My dad still cries every time he hears American Idiot because he loved the song until he found out it was about him. He's the American Idiot the song is talking about, and now the song is "political" because of that. Worth it for this alone.
Amazing album 5 stars!
So the hits are there for sure. The songs in between though, are just ok.
Wish I was alive when this album was still hype, maybe then I’d enjoy it.
This was THE formative album for me when I was first trying to develop my own independent music taste. This was the greatest album of all time when I was 14. I'm 26 now and I've listened to a lot more since then. I don't think it's the greatest anymore but man, do I still love this album.
I knew the singles but was surprised by the big 9 minute songs. I liked it all though.
One of the best things to happen to me in 9th grade is listening to this album for the first time.
Maybe I’m the faggot America…
Green Day is awesome - I love the punk influence. I would give a 4.5 if I could. This album is a repeater for me - so fun!
Writing catchy songs is an under-appreciated skill. The songs here are so catchy and earnest.
1. 3/3 2. 2.5/3 (The sections are great, but imo it runs kinda long) 3. 3/3 (This is a great double song, but the sound is starting to get repetitive) 4. 3/3 (Great switch-up in the sound when it was starting to get stale)
taki spoko
Baby's first "political" album. Having been completely overexposed to the singles of this record back in Junior High I expected this to be a cringy snooze fest but I was pleasantly surprised how hard this thing still rips in 2026. Some of the tracks are too long but generally enjoyed it despite my misgivings.
clearly most of them are
it's good but not my vibe
A monolith of an album that pretentious dweebs such as I would be quick to belittle so they can go back to glazing 'Dookie.' That desire is a fallacy however, this album is pretty cool. Chronologically this album finds its self in an transition for the genre of rock. The Strokes and other cool guy* rock bands were actively embarrassing the pop punks of yester year. All the while bands like MCR were turning pop punk into emo. In a way, this album feels like the last hurray for a genre that would fade away from the mainstream. But I mean fuck, its a good celebration. The most iconic songs off this album are well remembered for a reason. Not many can invoke bratty swagger like Billie Joe Armstrong, and the drumming on the album is always energetic and tight. They're simultaneously hooky, danceable, and triumphant. Those adjectives do carry over into most of the songs of the album, HOWEVER, it does make it a tad stale at times. "American Idiot" and "Holiday" pulls this sound off the best and the most interesting music is afterwards, found in the departures from this sound. "Jesus of Suburbia" and "Wake Me up When September Comes' being my favorite off the album. The former brings me great joy as pop punk rock opera is a silly statement and I enjoy reveling in that sound. The constant change in song structure and focus on story telling being the highlights. The latter is perhaps the dead dad song of all time, its not very deep, but truthfully that feels like one of it's strengths. It can be exhausting trying to make your grief feel flowery and vast in it's meaning, the comfort of sleep during such times is certifiably 'real as fuck.' The detractors of this album are a tonally samey mid-section and guitar sound that is a lil boring on this pair of ears despite suiting the music well, please play anything but a power chord, I dare you. its gonna be a 3.5/5 *cool guy rock bands also include bands like yeah yeah yeahs and metric, its a gender inclussive term, promise :)
Listened to while running at 6:00 km pace. Great rhythm!
This was the album everyone a few years younger than me frothed over and that makes sense because it’s political commentary for kids. The lyrics would have to actually say something to have any sort of weight, but the slick production would totally undercut the punk credentials of any genuine message. It’s the most heavy handed attempt at a concept album, just cringe through & through. Facile, shallow, bitterly disappointing. Drums sound great.
I like this a lot, but something holds me back from giving it a full 5 stars. Just a gut feeling.
Not a massive Green Day fan but this album surely has some bangers. Highlights: boulevard of broken dreams and wake me up when September ends
There's something insanely poetic about a "punk" group that wrote an entire album raging and resisting against the Bush Administration only to turn right around years later to become bootlickers of the Bidens championing AGAINST Free Speech and bodily autonomy. Sooooo punk rock (insert eye roll here). Regardless, this album has one of the best 5 opening track runs of any album, and that segue from Holiday into Boulevard of Broken Dreams is an all-timer. They're posers, but I can still appreciate a good record when I hear it.
Green Day's rock opera, their concept album. I listened to this album 5 years ago and it was very good, and on this re-listen I find I only love it more as my love for concept albums grow. Fav Songs Jesus of Suburbia Homecoming Give Me Novacaine Is it Top 1001 Worthy (is it essential)? Yes, a impeccable early 2000's rock album with a very strong collection of songs; an incredibly enjoyable experience
Classic Green Day. Still think Dookie is the GOAT
i bet if you were a lower middle class teen in this era this hit so hard.
Belting album This album means so much to me in terms of some friendships and times
Not the biggest green day fan but undeniable how influential these guys have been. Some great chord progressions on this too plus the production pure punk rock in your face
I have to applaud the ambition and the scope here, but Green Day is essentially doing a stadium punk version of Zen Arcade and it's missing the desperation and the heart. The songwriting is legitimately good and I also recognize that this just simply doesn't resonate the same way to me as others. But they've made much better music that was much less regarded.
Thinking they're The Who lol.
I haven’t listened to Green Day on purpose since Dookie so I’d never heard this one. It was much better than I was expecting. And 7 minute songs?! Who knew.
Not for a second would I deny that this record is an iconic, era defining punk rock album. And for the most part I love it. The first half of the album reminds me of my teenage years and it's superbly well written. The downside for me though is that I do find the vocals quite jarring and I always have done with Green Day. I always come away from listening to their songs unsure how I feel about them and there are parts of this album that makes me feel conflicted. It's still a strong album though and gets a light 8/10 from me.
Muy buen disco de Green day, para mi el 4to mejor disco
I was in high school when Dookie and Kerplunk were big, but somehow I skipped past American Idiot later on. I think it was probably the fact I didn't care for that September song back then. But wow, listening to this whole album start to finish, I have a new appreciation for that song and I must say, what a freaking masterpiece! Every song is essential and I will add this entire album to my library.
Easiest rating I've given so far. Forgot how good Green Day are. If it was released today (US/Iran war going on) it would be very topical. Just a blast.
Even in 2026 Green Day has a really good sound that although not new lives on.
I have fond memories of this album and it's hard for me to listen to it without the nostalgic feelings. Regardless, it's a highly polished punk album with song variation, high earworm potential, and infectious energy. Not all songs have this floating transition between them, but many of them do feel so perfectly fitting to be listened in a sequence and "Jesus of Suburbia" itself sounds like a mini-Punk-Rock-opera already.
Youth. Green Day were everywhere — American Idiot was inescapable in a way that only happens to albums that define a moment. Revisiting it now: still holds up, and then some. Punk rock is not my daily world anymore, but this isn't quite just punk rock. "Jesus of Suburbia" is nine minutes long and moves through five distinct sections — a mini rock opera from a band supposedly built on three-chord speed. That ambition is real and it works. The album is also political in a way that hasn't aged out. 2004, peak Bush, post-9/11 paranoia, media manipulation, suburban numbness — the "redneck agenda" Billie Joe was shouting about then maps onto now almost uncomfortably well. Some albums date. This one keeps finding new relevance. 4.5/5 — filed under 5. Defined a generation. Still talking to it.
Do I think this is brilliant because I listened to it so much, making it sound so very familiar? Or did I in fact listen to it so much because it is so brilliant? Actually, I don't really care. I loved it when it came out, and I loved it every bit as much relistening now. I think that the songs and the whole album is excellently constructed, the sound is guitar-heavy, just as I like it, and I somehow have a knack for these background "ooooh"s that are employed always at the right time. There are lots of well earned hit singles on here, but I love most "deep cuts" even more, like the fast paced "Letterbomb" or the beautiful closer "Whatsername". There is not much keeping this from being a 5/5, for example the opening title track being average instead of as brilliant as the rest. 4.5/5 - near perfect
The Green Day record everybody knows. It's also, according to many fans, their worst album of their peak years. I feel that's revisionist history, given the musical marring a rather good discography. It's no dookie, and that's for the best. Green Day got a lot less one-note as the years wore on.
Un clásico. Todo el mundo conoce al menos 3 canciones de este álbum y las ha cantado a pleno pulmón.
Green Day - nothing special. More american than idiot.
круто, есть хиты звучит и не скучно можно переслушать с комментом про диснеевский рок согласен 3.6
RATING: 5/10 HIGHLIGHT: Jesus of Suburbia LOWLIGHT: St Jimmy
When American Idiot came out, I remember being so anti-Green Day that I never really gave it a chance. Twenty years later, it felt like the perfect time to finally sit down and listen to it properly. A lot of that prejudice came from Dookie, which I really disliked as a teenager. Because of that, I assumed Green Day were all loud, shouty punk rock with little substance. American Idiot proved me wrong. There are some genuinely great songs here, and a lot more variety than I was expecting. What surprised me most was the ambition of the album. Yes, there are the big, energetic rock songs, but there are also some excellent ballads, strong melodies and surprisingly good storytelling running through the lyrics. It feels far more considered and mature than I had given it credit for all those years ago. It's still not a genre I would naturally gravitate towards, and I probably won't be rushing back to it regularly, but I came away with a much greater appreciation for Green Day as songwriters and musicians. Sometimes revisiting an album years later can completely change your perspective, and that's definitely what happened here. Favourite tracks: “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” Least favourite tracks: Everything on the album was worth a listen Album artwork: Cool album cover
Masomenos, despues de los hits tiene algunos temas que estan buenos pero no son algo que escucharia
я ненавижу это гавно
No es mi favorito de GD Pero definitivamente extraño los tiempos de rock band, pizza y refrescos todos los viernes con mi hermano. 4.8
classic.
Green Day on üks nendest bändidest, keda ma diskriminatoorselt väldin. Mul on mingi vastumeelsus trendika internetimuusika osas ja jah ma tean, et see on jabur, aga ei ma ei selgita. Igatahes, see on selline muusika, mida ma naudiks ja salvestaks kui nad poleks Green Day. Näiteks see boulevard of dreams on laul, mis on hea, aga ma seostan seda sügavalt ujumisvõistlustega niiet ma ei suuda olla chill seda kuulates. Selles albumis oli ainult üks skipp, ehk tegelikult võin öelda, et tegu on hea muusikaga. Mulle meeldib, et nende lüürika, niipalju kui ma sellele tähelepanu pöörasin on päris punk ja nende sõnum ka. Annan albumile 5/5, mitte 4/5 ja võtkem seda kui vabandust (ma ei kuula toda albumit uuesti).
I had no idea this album was so good. I love Dookie and had stupidly assumed that nothing they had done since could touch that. This is amazing from the first to last track. I knew the obvious hits but there are so many more great tracks here that I didn’t know. Jesus of Suburbia might be their best song and I had never heard it. Shame on me.
Halfway through Jesus of Suburbia I thought I was really going to like this. Then their sound wore thin. Then it wore really thin. RYM: N Saved a song: N
325/1001 Green Day - American Idiot Heard before? ✅ Revisit? ✅ I played this to death at the time of its release, but definitely less so now. It's an ambitious album, but also feels just a little too long. American Idiot and Holiday are such great tunes.
Loved this album as teenager and still love it now. A no skip album for me and gets me singing along with ease
So gas
This is a classic for my generation. I have listened to the musical as well. Love the instruments, super catchy songs I really like Green Day and there are several iconic songs on this album
Lots of hits, great album
all day Green Day W album
I still love this album, but not as much as I used to since I'm not angsty and young anymore.
Este deve ser o album que mais ouvi! Acho que faz parte da minha personalidade, uma boa validação da Catarina pre-adolescente. Ainda tenho a t-shirt bem guardadinha, mas não sei o que se passou com o poster de metro e meio do Billi Joe que saiu na revista Bravo..
Já estava a precisar dum album que desse mesmo gosto por. Nostalgia ftw
Acho que muito da nota e nostalgia. Mas acho que foi assim o primeiro álbum que comprei com qualidade.
Dunno if green day expected this one to be relevant 22 years later.
From 924 Gilman to this...man what a shame
66 albums in and finally one that I’ve listened to before. It might be boring of me, but hearing it again has maybe made me appreciate it even more. Sure, it’s a bit ‘ooh edgy’, but come on, it’s brilliant. A brilliant album, and one that’s even better listened to as a whole to really appreciate the amazing transitions between tracks.
Biggest album of my generation, but on fresh listen through quite a lot fell flat, especially toward the end. Tough one to rate
One of my favorite albums when I was in high school. Grew up with my older brother's Dookie and Nimrod cassettes, and this definitely sounded different than what they'd played before. It's not as in-your-face as bands like SOAD, but it definitely reached a wider audience, and that was worth something. It only got worse when they started huffing their own farts and making musicals and shit based on the album. It still holds a place in my heart, and it's one of the few albums I know all the lyrics to heart because of how much I listened to it.
My brother hates this album & is an American…if only there was a term to call him…
Baby’s first corporate-backed, surface level attempt at being political punk. Your least favorite soccer mom’s favorite punk band. No place on this list or any list of best albums.
I’ve never been a fan of Green Day. I think all their songs kinda sound the same. And this album was so overplayed when it came out that I literally couldn’t stand it. I can’t even get through the song “wake me up when September ends”. Honestly I think the only reason this is on the list is because of the whole political scene at the time. Which is probably why I also dislike it so much.
PEDAZO DE DISCO. Obvio lo había escuchado ya. Muchos temas que escuché en la adolescencia. Es casi un no-skip. Me dio mucha curiosidad ver la cantidad de temas "dobles" que pusieron. Será porque no sabian si iban a ser exitosos por separado? Extraña decisión, pero quedó barbaro. Dsp los sacaron cada uno x separado en el disco 2. No recordaba que estaban tantos juntos. En fin, me encanta el disco. Green Day es un bandon. Me estaba fijando que el primer disco lo sacaron en el 91'. Tardaron casi 10 años en pegar un disco mega mega comercial. Y estamos hablando de Green Day!
Banger wie Holiday Overall gut aber nd ganz so meins
bom não esperava, eh um rock pauleira classic
SIngles are good but I found it a bit boring.
Genial...!
An album that is not only amazing, but it also really captures the feeling of America in the 2000s.
plenty of good ideas, lots of enthusiasm, and very good recording/mixing/mastering, but there's more vocals writing than instrumental writing, and it ends up somewhat samey. also, you can't say that word, buddy.
Album 213. American Idiot (https://open.spotify.com/album/5dN7F9DV0Qg1XRdIgW8rke?si=pOGFxsazRjaxSepo1xia2Q) — Green Day (2004) I'm biased and I don't like it. Yes, it's a big album in different ways and blah-blah. Pop punk sounds like shit to me. 2/5 Liked: — American Idiot — Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Really enjoyed boulevard of broken dreams, would consider buying the vinyl
Good album the whole way through.
Loved this album - had just moved to Guernsey and listened to it on my 30 min walk in/ back from work. Still rocks.
Enjoy the punk pop. It's not deep, it's not punk, but if it energizes some teen-bobbers into being politically aware and is a gateway into finding the punk era, then good. Great when old(er) farts can get the kids to follow them.
So not up my alley but this was one of the first non-Christian or country albums I was allowed to listen to for some reason??? Brings back a lot of memories. We were only allowed to listen to Boulevard of broken dreams and holiday though I’m pretty sure we had gotten a karaoke machine for Christmas one year and those two songs were both on it, which is why we are allowed to listen. The only other song I remember being on that karaoke machine was toxic by Britney Spears when I was alone, I would rock out to toxic, but when my family was around, I had to pretend to be more of a Green Day guy.
There’s idiots in America?!?!
Excellent album. 100% an album you have to listen to at some point in your life.
A classic! Love it to death
I like Green Day a lot. High energy, happy, angry head banging sound. Remind me of the Dead Kennedys gone mainstream.
I hated their sound when Dookie came out, and I hate it now. That clean, 90s production style, the guitar sound, the way the drums are miked ... everything about this causes waves of hostility to be unleashed within me. They are good at what they do, which explains their successful careers. But I hate what they do.
Acknowledged, Green Day flipped the script on themselves and did things they'd never even contemplated while their global fame/money machine was being built. And, being a poser had real weight when I was 15, at least in a world that included Pete Verdone. Green Day challenged my understanding of the trajectory of punk, and upset my understanding of the social order in force at the time. So I rejected them. I still don't care for their music.
I found it annoying at best.
Another record where I vacillated a lot. At times I caught myself thinking, this is a surprisingly enjoyable song. Then I would think, well that surprisingly long song had an enjoyable section. I thought I would like this a lot more than I did, considering I have generally positive feelings about Green Day. But those feelings don't appear to be based on this particular album. Overall I felt there was something here, but more judicious editing would have helped a lot.
skibidi toilet yep 4.5
Apart from the hits I wasn't sure what I was going to think about this. After thinking on it if I give it less than a five then I am lying to myself.
Recall this being on my older brother's ipod. That alone made it cool in my eyes. I was excited to revisit it, but have to say the hits from this album remain the highlights and the hidden gems I was hoping to discover were not exactly there. Feels very of a time and a place to me. Boulevard of Broken Dreams and WMUWSE are the best two songs, and I wish they went into that mode more often. But good, definitely solid.
2004 1. American Idiot: Classic Greenday banger. 2. Jesus of Surburbia: familia. Very nostalgic. 3. Holiday: this album is hit after hit. 4. Boulevard of Broken Dreams: hit. 5. Are We The Waiting: unfamiliar. Softer. I don’t mind it. 6. St Jimmy: unfamiliar. Nice lead in and fits well. 7: Give Me Novocaine: unfamiliar. Softer again. Don’t mind but a bit dull. Others do it better. 8: She’s a Rebel: right style, bit nothingy to me. Easy filler. 9: Extraordinary Girl: as above. 10: Letterbomb: hmmmm I need another listen. 11. Wake Me Up When September Ends: such a huge hit at the time. Practically had its own cult. Well written hit. 12: Homecomeing: need another listen. Gosh it’s long. Many songs in one. Not a fan of the inserts. 13: Whatsername: fine. I feel like the lyrics of this would have suited Dookie better. There a pull between different greenday eras/identities. Quite a front-loaded album, hits wise. Not at all bothered about the second half. Really of its time - it was THE sound. It’s weird listening now when all the problems that it speaks of are deeper/more entrenched and more polarising now than they were even then, and also feeling like all the radio and fame over the years waters down the meaning?
An interesting debut album filled with an abundance of short rock driven numbers. Refreshing after those boring long drawn out numbers of others. Reminds me of early rock n roll releses.
This is not punk. This is pop.
05/29 Some good moments in it. Not bad
I will forever be pissed at Green Day for not doing the "don't wanna be in the MAGA agenda" thing at the Super Bowl. What a bunch of cop-outs. My gripes with this band aside, this album is atrocious. It's so painfully basic in a way that punk music shouldn't be. It's kind of hard to call it punk music at all. It's alt-rock that sometimes insults George Bush or suburban neighborhoods, I guess. The music is all chord progressions I've genuinely heard in nursery rhymes with some of the most bland and unmotivating lyrics I've heard in an album that's trying to be whatever unmotivating isn't. I don't even care that half the album is overplayed, I haven't heard half of these songs in a year or two and I like them LESS than I did then. Special bonus points to Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams for managing to ruin an almost good song by tacking a boring radio hit to the second half. That's how the entire album is, although "almost good" is a stretch for anything that isn't Holiday by itself and the latter two parts of Homecoming. I swear the only reason this album got anywhere near as popular as it did is because they tried to make the most un-punk punk album imaginable, and they sure as hell succeeded. Genuinely one of the worst albums I've had on the list so far.
banger
Was so so close to a 5 for this one, but a couple of weak songs and pretty bad mixing kept it a 4. So many anthems, imo their most cohesive record. These guys took the 4 power chords blueprint and ran with it to make such catchy pop /punk rock. Holiday is still one of my favourite songs to play on guitar, as well as one of the first. Good stuff.
Again not a bad listen but didn’t really blow me away either. I can appreciate it
Absolute banger of an album!
Well this one's hard as hell. Im just over 30 at this point. This album was everything to me when I was young. But now I wouldn't say i like it that much. But it informed so much of my musical taste down the line. Its pop punk with the tiniest smidgen of punk. This is 99% a pop record. I see that ad i got more exposure to the genre. But I still get down to alot of it. Some of it is bad or has bad parts but Im so nostalgic for it that it almost doesnt matter. But it still matters. Im kinda stuck here. I like older green day well enough but this is the line in the sand where I kinda loose that love for them. After this I would say they just kinda suck. And this record ruined them for me at least. But I have to give it props for being the introduction to my favorite music. Without this silly melodramatic theatrical slop of a record I woulda been on whatever club music was poppin in the early 00s. I dont know. Old me would give this an easy 5. And new me probably gives it a 3. Still some good songs and alot of bad stuff too. Middle of the road. But I think I need to split the difference on it. Fell out of love but still cherish the time we had kinda thing. Like my ex girlfriend... your mom.
Something about the mid 2000's and Pop Punk in the cultural zeitgeist just helped make this decade one of the best for rock music for me. You had artists like Jimmy Eat World and Fall Out Boy cracking the mainstream with Paramore not far behind, and then you had My Chemical Romance and Green Day proving that punk rock could be artistic as well as rebellious and loud. American Idiot comes hot off the heels of the first George Dubbya term and boy has it got a lot to say. It's right in the name. This album is a rock opera of disillusionment and disenfranchised suburbanite youth bucking against a system that's making it increasingly clear that they aren't meant for greatness; or hell, comfortable living. I could delve into the various themes and characters, and the loose plot that follows the songs, but I think as of now that would be a waste of time. There's a freaking Broadway production of this album, and so many other more eloquent writers have dissected this record that I feel like I couldn't offer anything new to it really. What I will say though, is that this album shouldn't have worked as well as it did. You've got your loud and punky anthems with the title track and "Holiday", an ode to loneliness with "Boulevard of Broken Dreams", and several multi-suite tracks with "Jesus Of Suburbia", the "Are We The Waiting/St. Jimmy/Give Me Novacaine/She's a Rebel" medley and the penultimate "Homecoming". These songs really put proof to paper that even though Green Day built their career so far on the foundations of four chord skate punk and hardcore roots, that they could take those influences and stretch them into grandiose territory to make something that's epic and multigenerational. Now not every song on this record is as incredible as the highlights, I particularly feel kinda lukewarm on "Extraordinary Girl" and even though "Whatsername" is a cute song, as a closer it's rather underwhelming following "Homecoming". Oh and I didn't even MENTION the heart crushing ballad of "Wake Me Up". A song that; similar to "Chop Suey!" by SOAD, has been memed to death that the original emotional intention and impact has been so watered down. This powerful anthem to the memory of BJA's father passing away; coinciding with the tragedy of 9/11, is a generational cry of SOS. The weight of this song still carries heavy in today's world as it seems every month something horrible is happening in addition to the personal struggles we all face. It's pretty exhausting physically and emotionally and this song has aged wonderfully because of it. So yeah, this is a pretty damn fucking important record not just for the rock canon of the oughts and Green Day's career, but also for the jilted youth of America that keep returning to this music and singing it's songs of restlessness. BJA is no Bob Dylan or Woodie Guthrie, but he sure embodies that rebellious spirit that's not afraid to call out the harmful administrations and societies that continue to pursue harm and control. I'll be blasting this record till I die I'm afraid.
I like it generally, timeless classic like American idiot, wake me up when September ends and more are insane. I see why it's rated so so highly. Interesting having dual songs, not sure I like it because its not 'playlist worthy'; I'm not listening to an 8 minute dual song normally. But listening as an entire album at once is great. I guess its 20 years ago but all of of songs sound very similar. Overall cool tho
Que des hits mais écouter l’album du début à la fin sous 35°c c’est un peu surstimulant
music that literally defined an era, and manages to maintain relevance, really couldn’t ask for more in a band.
One of my favourite albums ever, so consistently perfect. This album has so many great songs, it’s also nostalgic for me as well as it being an objectively great album. I was very excited to see this pop up as my album of the day. They represent punk perfectly, with a unique sound that feels like it’s theirs and only theirs. Love this album
A casualty of the Loudness Wars*. If this were mixed better, it would easily be 4 stars. Very good songwriting and musical performances. Unfortunately, the volume being maxed out and flattened just kills everything. The dynamics are all gone. It just becomes monotonous, flat, and fatiguing. And it's entirely the fault of the mastering. *For those who don't know... this got bad in the late 90's and early 00's. When mastering a recording, if you turn up the volume level in a mix, it eventually hits a ceiling. Eventually the quiet parts are just as loud as the loudest parts. So there is no dynamic contrast. But recording studios did this so that, when played on the radio, your song wouldn't be quieter than the ones around it.
One of my favourite albums already but listening to it with "new" ears confirmed it's still an absolute classic for the genre
Very good album.
Instant 5 stars. Still listened to it again though.
I’ve been listening to a lot of Green Day recently. I didn’t mind the long songs on this one. Starts off very strong. Not as good as Dookie but still good.
Some bangers I guess but I don't really enjoy this genre that much. Also the songs are soooo long. Probably the best punk? rock? album out there tho I just don't like punk rock 3.5/5
lowkey I did not super enjoy listening to most of this but it'd feel like a fraud not rating this high because tween me was a Green Day listener. Whatshername I enjoyed and also boulevard of broken dreams too. idk if these are the best songs on the album or if its nostalgia bc those r def the songs I listened to most #backinmyday
Another solid green day album. Don't like quite as much as dookie
I enjoyed a lot of songs which are super famous, but the album didn’t really have the WOW factor for me. It’s a solid album but I’ve unfortunately not been able to get into Green Day. I’m yet to put my finger on what’s exactly putting me off but I think it’s vocals… no offence Billie Joe Armstrong.
I can understand why my sister likes this album, its very driving sound and message of disenfranchisement work pretty well As an album it's quite one trick: it's raw, it's angry, and it's loud. You can argue all you like that it's inflammatory, exaggerative, and/or shallow, but I think as much as these are true I find the frustration lands for me. Nevertheless, I think it's good the album ended when it did — much more and I think the formulaic nature would probably start to wear me down The bass is better than I expected, does some nice counterpoint stuff and they give it breathing room which I appreciate The title track is a strong start, and the standout song on the album for me. It's no Fortunate Son but it certainly carries its anti-war message effectively anyhow
I've never actually listened to this, or went out of my way to listen to Green Day in general. I am pleasantly surprised. I have an aversion to this genre as I have bad expose to other bands that have extremely whiney vocals, and always found the music a bit corny, but I didnt feel that with this one. Was genuinly pretty good. I recognised a few songs that I didnt even know were Green Day songs in here too. Would listen again tbh.
Yasssssss Obviously most of these songs are very famous and maybe I've heard some so many times that they lose a little bit of their appeal (specifically "Wake Me Up When September Ends"... just makes me roll my eyes at this point). But they're still awesome.... I think to me, the ballads have worn a bit thin but the classic tracks like "American Idiot" and "Holiday" remain great. While most of this album is super familiar to me, I really enjoyed "Extraordinary Girl/Letterbomb" which I haven't listened to in YEEEEEEARs.... perhaps my favourite song on the album? dookie clears tho
The emotions this album triggers remembering a Cote d'Azure Road Trip alone are worth 5 stars. What a fun, melodic punk album with hits for the ages. American Idiots!
Not heard an album of theirs, quite enjoyed this, almost a 4
Classic. When I was younger I didn’t like Green Day but I love them now. Great listen always.
Beautiful
Have heard so many of these so many times on the radio over the years. Fine, but played out and nothing special to begin with.
1. American Idiot -- 8.3 Great. Classic. 2. Jesus of Suburbia -- 6.7 Holy moly this is a long song 3. Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams -- 9.1 THE ONLY ROAD THAT I HAVE EVER KNOWNNN 4. Are We the Waiting / St. Jimmy -- 7.2 5. Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel -- 7.4 6. Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb -- 7.4 7. Wake Me Up When September Ends -- 8.5 8. Homecoming -- 7.5 9. Whasername -- 7.7
A nephew of mine is a big fan of Green Day. I can understand that.
3.5, otro disco que me devuelve al cole (bad fan porque fue en el 2012)
Sell-out punks
Green day gör rockopera i Jesus of suburbia. Det spänner över musikaliska referenser från The Coral-pop till Iron Maiden-galopp och någonstans där i mitten låter det väldigt mycket Summer of 69 med Bryan Adams. Det är ändå en okej låt.
United och Tottenham undvek förra säsongen nedflyttning, inte tack vare egna prestationer, utan tack vare att det fanns andra lag som var så fruktansvärt dåliga. GD undviker ettan, inte tack vare egna prestationer…
Eurovision komplett med tonartshöjning. Är det Jon-Henrik som gästar i We are the waiting? Könsrock utan kön. Medelålders män som tror de fortfarande riskerar att bli utsparkade från High school. Sk. Punklåtar över 3 minuter. Fruktansvärda trummarfills och gitarrsolon. Jag behöver tvätta öronen med svintask efteråt.
Not for me
4/10
I'll just have to let my nostalgia do the talking here, it's unavoidable. American Idiot is the first non-compilation album I've ever listened to, any and all objectivity goes out the window with that fact alone. Not to mention that they're the first band I've ever seen live and that I've learned how to play guitar almost exclusively with their songs. While I'm way more into their early work nowadays, there's a lot to love about this album as well. First of all, the hooks are consistently pretty good, and the mixing accentuates that perfectly. While the guitar is the most prominent part of every composition here, it's massively carried by Mike and Tré's tremendous energy. My biggest gripe with Green Day albums made after American Idiot is how little attention Mike gets in the mix, but that's not a problem here at all. In fact, I'd argue he's the star here. Billie Joe changes his vocal delivery and tone for this album pretty drastically. While I prefer his younger, sloppier, rawer delivery of the '90s, this change was a wise choice for this album and helps prop up some of the more emotional moments sprinkled throughout. Finally, the song structures are ambitious, well thought out and executed almost perfectly. I never agreed with the critique of American Idiot being too shallow in its presentation of political themes and emotional turmoil. Sure, Billie Joe has shown himself to be a lacklustre songwriter in this department for the last couple of Green Day albums, but those criticisms don't really apply to American Idiot, in my opinion. It's an attempt shove it in a particular punk sphere it just doesn't belong in. They're not Bad Religion. This is a rock-opera about an edgy, moody teenager, of course the songwriting has melodramatic tendencies and lacks nuance. I wouldn't have it any other way. I'm not gonna act like it's a flawless album, though. It has a couple of weak tracks, mainly She's a Rebel. Also, as I've already mentioned, I definitely prefer their more energetic and bratty albums, such as Dookie, Insomniac and Nimrod, that type of pop-punk is when they're at their best. Favourite track: Holiday
7,15
To much the same
fun, got me reminiscing
American idiot is so relevant today Everything else has been boring Sample the beginning music of whatsername
🖤😮💨✨
Overblown and overrated. But we sure did play this one out back in the day.
3 for the nostalgia. My brother loved this album and I secretly loved a few songs, but would have never let him know at that time.
A near perfect album that is still woefully relevant.
I liked this album. Kind of like a punk rock opera. Has a thread to follow, and some good songs with food for thought. Worth giving a few spins. 3.5/5
============================================== ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== -------------------GREEN DAY------------------ ---------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------- -----------------AMERICAN IDIOT--------------- ---------------------------------------------- ---------------------(2004)------------------- ============================================== ============================================== -----------------CALIFICACIÓN----------------- --------------------★★★★⯨-------------------- --------------------(4,833)------------------- ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== 1. American Idiot (★★★★★) -Fav 2. Jesus of Suburbia (★★★★★) -Fav 3. Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams (★★★★★) -Fav 4. Are We the Waiting / St. Jimmy (★★★★★) 5. Give Me Novocaine / She's a Rebel (★★★★⯨) 6. Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb (★★★★⯨) 7. Wake Me up When September Ends (★★★★★) -Fav 8. Homecoming (★★★★★) -Fav 9. Whatsername (★★★★⯨) ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== PUNTAJE TOTAL 5+5+5+5+4,5+4,5+5+5+4,5 = 43,5 ============================================== ============================================== PUNTAJE PROMEDIO 43,5 / 9 = 4,833 ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== CALIFICACIÓN FINAL ★★★★⯨ (4,833) ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== ============================================== COMENTARIO -Nunca le presté tanta atención a este álbum, y ya me gustaba de antes, ahora que entiendo mejor la intención, me parece muy bueno, una genialidad, llena de buena música y letras, con una estructura pensada y excelente ejecución y resultados. ============================================== ============================================== ==============================================
This is an album from my childhood man. I remember looking at my older sister’s cd collection and her playing this for me on her computer.
Monday May 18th, 2026. I love Green Day. The lyrics are very meaningful and the guitar is awesome. 9/10. My favorite song of the album is American Idiot, the guitar on it is just *chefs kiss*.
While I appreciate Green Day’s willingness to stand up for good causes, their activism has always felt a bit shallow… and this album definitely illustrates that pretty well. There are some strong, energetic moments in here, but the length gets a bit draining after a while. “Jesus of Suburbia” is a wonderful example of this–none of the many sections of this song stick around long enough to feel fully fleshed out, and they don’t even flow into one another very well. It says a lot that my favorite songs off of this album are mostly due to their nostalgia. Basically, I think I just prefer early Green Day, when they were a little more wild and weren’t trying to be taken so seriously. Favorites: American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends
Did we need a rock opera from a band that made their trade on hooky pop-punk tunes that would rarely even touch the 3 minute mark? I would say no, but the world disagreed. This just doesn't work for me, the whole idea of it turns me off, I guess. I'll always appreciate Green Day for their run from Kerplunk to Nimrod, and I still return to those records for a nice hit of nostalgia and songs that get in and out without wearing out their welcome. These songs do not do that for me. 16 year old me had already moved on from Green Day, imagine how 38 year old me feels.
A friend of mine once said that it's hard to believe that Green Day has two of the most important albums in our lifetimes, 20 years apart from one another. I do not disagree with him. Dookie kicked off the goofy pop punk movement of the 90s and then American Idiot went back to punk rocks and told a story of how the government loves to fuck us all over. This album his filled with hits and scathing commentary of the country we were at the time of release. What is mind blowing is now, in 2026, how much worse it is and maybe we are ready for a sequel? American Idiot 2: MAGA edition. I'd buy it. I'd listen to it. Anyways, this record is amazing and should be listened by everybody.
Less punk but still fun
I don't like it that much Not for me.
You have to be an American Idiot to enjoy this.
An socio-political album that perfectly explains the USA and their uneducated citizens. Perfect depiction of the USA current state today written 22 years ago and could have been written in 1960. Timeless masterpiece of our times. This cemented Green Day as a top band for the rest of music history
A couple good tracks.