Reviews (page 4 of 16)
Great listen from a solid band, nostalgia certainly helps here
so many hits, was good to listen as a body of work rather than just singles
un toque pesado es que no lo escuche solo quizás eso hubiese estado bien pero seguro lo terminaré en algún momento, más metido en el genero supongo, lista naranja. 🍊
Irritante. No veo de dónde los Green Day son tan amados. Le pongo dos estrellas porque no considero que sean malos músicos y de pronto salen buenos momentos, pero ni les creo su música, ni su postura y en general el disco me puso un poco de malas. Y los grandes hits de este disco me parecen odiosos.
Ok. This is definitely a progression in songwriting from Dookie. But it's still not my taste. It's pretty solidly done throughout, but again, not my taste. Was I glad it was over? Yup, but it doesn't deserve a 2.
Alright album. I feel like it's technically punk but too mainstream for me to actually feel like it's a punk album. More like "pop punk" I guess. But it was still a nice listen and like how later tracks reference previous tracks St. Jimmy and Whatsherface. Overall good album but not something I would listen to again tbh.
Hmmm... this felt pretty manufactured to me... as if, perhaps unironically, the target consumer were, in fact, the American idiot, himself... It's not really punk... it's not really rock... it feels more like a (successfully) calculated cash grab than anything else... Personally, I wasn't able to find anything relatable nor even all that interesting here, but, like 'The Marshall Mathers LP' before it, I guess it still deserves a slight bump for achieving what it seemingly set out to do: make lots of mainstream money... the singles have certainly been brutally overplayed at any rate...
There is some relevancy here based on current events. So there is that. Yet I couldn’t help but be annoyed by all the two songs in one track nonsense. It didn’t help with make this album longer than it needed to be.
The fact that the highest-rated review of this album is bashing it just shows how good the album is. I've never listened to anything past the singles and never really deeped the album before, but listening to this now in the state the world is currently in just solidifies the importance of education.
Cringe 90’s music to my ears but see why it was so well received from that generation
awesome album loved it
This album shouldn't get 5 stars. But how can you not make such rating when it reminds you of such good times?
suna hai
First listen of this adventure through 1001 Albums and I was pleasantly surprised at the flow of this album and the lyrical content which seems timeless.
its alright, the songs are too long tho
Yayaaaaa 13yr old me wasn't into this... But I really appreciate the nostalgia.
It is a really solid slice of highly polished stadium rock. The melodies and riffs are simplistic and catchy, though it does lack some of the energy of their earlier work.
I was all ready to rag on this but, when viewed purely as a pop album, it does what it sets out to do well. Catchy riffs, some quotable lyrics, and maintains energy. I’m still not much of a fan though and, despite it trying to rail against the politics at the time, it comes across as quite shallow and lacks any real sense of vitriol behind it, possibly due to a pervasive view that this is where they ‘sold out’ and targeted the arenas rather than the more grimy gig venues with music that had greater mass appeal as a result.
So Green Day has grown up and stopped singing about farts and jerking off in favor of a “concept” album about the “Jesus of Suburbia”, huh? Still don’t like them but I’ll admit a little nostalgia for purveyors of power chords that their sound is indicative of. Under all the production and distortion most of these songs are basically corny doowop songs that don’t really push the truth of music forward in any way.
If you like power chords and that annoying way Armstrong sings, have I got an album for you. This album.
it was good but not my style
This might be the greenest day. No song overstays it's welcome. It feels tight and doesn't feel too dated.
Nothing new here, but enough catchy pop tunes to keep it interesting
I think that I haven't ever listened this album through. Almost all songs are somewhat familiar and radio hits are rather worn out. Still this solid album that could be rated as weak 3 stars.
American Idiot was a weirdly emotional revisit. Back in the day I listened to this CD to death, heard the hits constantly on the radio, and even saw Green Day live a few times. I expected the album to feel boring now because these songs have been played into the earth’s crust, but surprisingly it still sounds really good. Jesus of Suburbia and Wake Me Up When September Ends still hit somewhere deep inside. Not every song survived equally well though — Holiday now feels more like mandatory mall punk cardio than an actual revelation. Still, the album has aged surprisingly good.
#390 / 1089 Heard before? ✅ Revisit? ❌ US pop-punk has never been to my taste, I like NoMeansNo and Bad Religion, but the poppier "skate punk" side of these things does nothing for me. Give be G.B.H. or Exploited or Napalm Death any time. I've heard some of these songs before, while they do have the radio hit quality to them, this is not the style of punk rock that I like. I like my punk music angry, unpolished, fast and to the point. Not rock opera with grammy ambitions. Disinterested 2 out of 5, this is not annoying enough to justify just one.
Absolute pop punk HOF. Greatest album
Love this album. I was the perfect age for this when it came out and the first 4 songs are probably the best start to any album in the 2000's. 5/5 album
Not quite as bad as I feared, and while I do like pop-punk this isn't for me
Always kinda shunned it, but this is a good record. Great songs, slightly too tight production for a punk record, but the anger and emotions are there.
Legendarisch, zo veel iconische nummers en de onbekende nummers zijn ook bangers
I never liked Green Day. Even when it would have been cool to like them as a teenager, still couldn't fake it. I listened to this whole album and it's the same all the way through? I appreciate the sentiment of it but I just really don't like them.
Great!
Green Day were the second band I really got into after Queen when I was 13, I loved everything from their first album to warning and a chunk of this album but this is where I see the band going downhill personally
I hadn’t heard this in a very long time because back when I was a LOSER I deemed this too uncool to enjoy. Now that I am smart and beautiful I think it’s pretty good.
talvez se eu tivesse menos de 14 anos
Great album, really into this style of music right now so its a nice surprise from the generator. Boulevard Of Broken Dreams was my fav song of the album. Holiday and Letterbomb (my fav first listen) were my other highlights
Been a few years since I've heard this album in full. I think the narrative, of disenfranchised kids finding community and conflict in each other amid a highly politicized and war-glorifying societal climate, still holds up, but musically everything got a bit samey over nearly an hour. Was considering 4 stars, but downgrading to an honourary 3.5.
This may be my favorite album of the nearly 400 albums I’ve listened to from the 1001 so far. I want to go back in time and kick my own ass for not listening to the full album sooner. Massive hits with staying power throughout. How did I go my entire life not knowing that Holiday went into Boulevard of Broken Dreams? How had I never listened to Jesus of Suburbia or Whatsername?
You know what, this album is sick as hell!!! Went into this already fondly familiar with the big hits, though fully expecting to be let down by the deep cuts as with many past albums. Instead, the album experience completely recontextualized the hits, and I can confidently say there is not a moment of filler on this!!! You mean to tell me Holiday led into Boulevard of Broken Dreams all this time?!?! The lone guitar note transitioning the two genuinely blew my mind! The concept album angle was also a really pleasant surprise. Even if it's not as topical today as it was back then, that cohesion elevates the album so much to me. I was on the fence about the rating until I found myself listening front to back two more times today, each listen better than the last. How can I argue against that? Banger banger banger. Standouts: American Idiot • Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams • Are We the Waiting / St. Jimmy • Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel • Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb • Homecoming
While listening to this album I realized that there was a period in my life where I was actually listening to this album very frequently. The fact that I could not remember when, or why, or even that I had done it, says everything I could possibly say about this album.
Great album, already super familiar with it. Jesus of suburbia is a great 3 parter References to a mysterious woman and then closing the album with whatsername So many bangers, glad they didn’t break up just prior to this album
Good
Gut
The songs on here that stood the test of time are truly great - but there is a lot in this release that’s just super mediocre/forgettable. I wanted to give it a 4 but I’m just not gonna spin this whole album again - some of the bangers yes, but there’s too much fluff in this imo.
Great guitar licks, the harmonies feels kinda 50s/60s lite. Kind of like pop-punk. It's good, but it gets dull after listening to it so many times.
I hate to admit it... I really do...
Definitely one of my favorite albums.
a couple of iconic songs that are good, the others are a bit long but maybe would like if i listened more
Some decent songs on here. Not quite as energetic as you would expect from them. Like the theme of the title track. It’s an okay album. 2.5/5 Might listen again
this actually sounds pretty good omg.. the first song reminds me of da johnny test intro
Had a few really nice tubes on it. I meant to type tunes but I'm going to leave that. They're nice tubes and I enjoyed them. I've never been a rock opera guy. I am a punk fan. I'm conflicted.
Maybe the high school nostalgia affects my judgment a little, but I liked this album when it came out and I still do. This isn’t really your standard pop punk album either, especially with it being a concept album. It feels bigger and more locked in than that, and as a protest album it really captures the attitude a lot of artists had at the time. The front half is definitely loaded, especially those first four tracks. That stretch does a lot of the heavy lifting and gives the album a ton of momentum right out of the gate. “Are We the Waiting” is probably the weakest song on here for me, but even with that, there’s too much good stuff on this album for me to rate it any lower. Favorite song: "Holiday"
Green Day are about as main stream and big as punk can get and remain recognizable. Musically this stretches a little thin and it’s not exactly a master’s thesis conceptually. But it is a really good distillation of a current of thought from its time of release, so it’s certainly worth a listen for that, and it’s highlights are great for a revisit.
2000s alt-rock. Absolute classic of the genre. Rock opera concept album, very political, punk influence.
cool cool cool teenage dirtbag kinda album 🤟🏻🖤🎸
I'm not a huge Green Day fan, but they kick so much ass. I'm glad they made this record.
Punk rock opera. Energy from start to finish. It tells an amazing story that was extremely relevant in 2004, and even more so in modern times. This is a 5/5 album, and always will be.
not my favorite but nostalgic
This album greets me like an old friend. Every time I hear it I feel totally justified in my love of Green Day despite their recent and gigantic missteps in the studio.
American Idiot, Holiday y Boulevard of Broken Dreams son las canciones de mi adolescencia, me levantan la energía al toque. Jesus of Suburbia, me aburre. Prefiero su alterego St. Jimmy que es para matarse en un pogo. Pierde sentido en mi casa. El resto son bastante olvidables. WMUWSE- me hace llorar siempre. Es hermosa. Todo el resto están bien pero es un poco más de lo mismo y no son canciones que escucharía a diario. Sé que me pierdo lo conceptual porque ni idea las letras, pero bueno.
I wanted to hate this album more but it was pretty good. Teenager in me is joyed. I don't appreciate this as an actual punk-rock because there's way more bands that do it better and more genuine, but it's a pretty solid pop-punk with some bangers like Boulevard of Broken Dreams or Holiday. But otherwise I'm not a huge fan of Green Day.
The once loved and jubilant band is desperately grasping for the dookie days with this stagnant album.
I liked Green Day for their short songs. Dookie is part of my teenage soundtrack. I applaud them for taking punk and wxtending it to a 9 minute epos. I was never a fan of JoS, but on an album, it works
Unbelievable album
Green Day is the U2 of punk rock.
Love it !!! One of my absolute favorites!
So much melodrama, self-importance, angst - and I love it all. So many great hooks and memorable lines. Maybe my favorite Tre Cool drumming performances? Always been a huge fan of She’s A Rebel and Whatsername
I already knew most of the album and had never listened to it before. I think I enjoyed the unreleased songs more than the ones that everyone knows. I’m not a big Green Day fan but this was a lot of fun and very inventive for a pop punk band.
Had heard the singles, for me, Dookie was good fun, the rest of their catalog hasn't been hugely interesting. Now, the title track is one I've enjoyed since first hearing it, the rest of this is just alright. I was impressed at the fact they threw down a couple of lengthy tracks with some structure to them, but I'm not rushing out to hear this again.
Uggghhhh
Rate: 10/10. Green Day nunca fue música para tibios, recuerdenlo. En lo personal, soy muy fan de las portadas y este álbum tiene una portada sencillamente muy linda.
Light 4
This is Green Day's masterpiece and finally fulfilled the promise they had shown with Dookie a decade earlier. It's slightly below the level where I see my greatest albums of all time, but close enough that I'm rounding up (rather than a seriously considered down) for this rating.
not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue
Classic childhood memories rooted in this one. Very well put together and ground breaking.
Fire
This is a pretty solid album. Boulevard & Wake me up have always been my top songs of theirs.
A punk rock concept album? Seems kinda silly now. But at the time this landed it was a huge re-start for a band that clearly couldn’t last on the Dookie model of making music. An ambitious effort that at times is pretty long in the tooth, and yet still sounds a lot newer than it actually is. Probably because the idiots being sung about are in full force today.
Really solid, but the whole rock opera thing is tough to pull off without occasionally feeling hokey. Even if that’s the point, warrants a downgrade from me
Biggest complaint being that this was so overplayed. But after stepping away for a while and coming back, I enjoy this a lot. Saw these guys play the full album at wembly in 2024 and it was greatness. Not sure there’s a band that gets as much out of power chords as these guys. 4.5 and rounding up
One of those albums I listened to a bunch when It came out, it got played into oblivion, and now I generally skip. That said, it is objectively a solid album with a bunch of hits. And really benefits from this country really growing into the American Idiot moniker over the years... sheesh. 4/5
Every song very similar, hadn't realised that theyd done boulevard of broken dreams. Very much american coming of age movie music
Knew most of it, much easier to listen to than some Green Day albums good for time released
As a teenager, my wife had a friend, another teenage girl, who was taken on tour with Billie Joe Armstrong and trafficked across several European nations for his pleasure. Although, I didn't mention it in the review of Play, this is also true of Moby. I won't be taking seriously any politicking - on American Idiocy or Animal rights - let alone moralising from them. Ignoring the lyrics and attempt at a narrative - much more a musical than an opera - it is hard not to hear The King is Half Undressed by Jellyfish and The Passenger by Iggy Pop and a dozen other popular riffs, chord sequences, and tunes. This is not decry plagiarism, which is an open hazard of any pop songwriting, but to identify American Idiot's music for what it is: repentant, reconstructed, barely considered rock'n'roll. There is nothing daring or inventive here and, if the politics are naïve, the music is even more so. 1.5 Yesterday, on the daily album drop page in the Reddit community for this project I encountered an all-too familiar response to Joanna Newsom’s Ys - 1 star, couldn’t listen to her voice. That Newsom’s music - for me as powerfully beguiling and absorbing as anything I’ve heard this century - can be fatally hamstrung for a listener by a simple distaste for the particular timbre of her voice seems tragic to me. However, that’s perhaps as far as I can criticise that (common enough) response to Ys without hypocrisy. Truthfully I have only listened to 4 of Green Day’s 14 studio albums but I know for certain that I cannot stand any of them, because Billie Joe Armstrong is the singer on every one. Billie Joe’s voice - to my ears Yogi Bear with pretensions - defeats me before a shot is fired. To my credit, over those who abandon Ys before Monkey and Bear have even got out the gate, I listened to American Idiot in full, twice today. “Well done you!” the Green Day fans may well concede, “For does not American Idiot, just like Ys, have multiple songs over 9 minutes long?” Honestly, no it doesn’t *really* although it does have Wake Me Up When September Ends, which lasts forever. Yes - the tracks Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming clock in over 9 minutes, but each is really a volley of several short, simple songs, only bearing the most superficial of musical and lyrical connective tissue between. In the ‘Digital Edition’ of this album - whatever the significance of that is - all of the tracks between Jesus of Suburbia and Wake Me Up.. are presented as part of a diptych. This is novelty and window-dressing and that’s all the name-calling I will do about that. So I listened twice and it was no great trial of concentration; instead my energy was focused on trying to be fair. Because I am aware that lots of people - not least among my own generation - treasure this album, not enough to have gone to see American Idiot the Musical of course, but still - treasure it, so they do. So what, in fairness, should I focus on here? Not the musicians. Can any Green Day fan pretend that there is any distinctiveness in the guitar, bass or drums? Could be me doing all that sawing and palm-muting, could be my wee brother - you’d never know. There are no musical ‘ideas’ in Green Day’s playing outside the ordinary gestures of their genre, large though the band may loom within that genre. So everything must be staked on the songs themselves. Surely then, with the divisiveness of Billie Joe’s voice also acknowledged, we can do no less now than invoke a comparison between American Idiot and the work of Bob Dylan. It’s only fair. Jesus Christ, this is fairer than fair. Whoever enjoyed such magnanimity from a listener? Bringing out Dylan is perfect justice. For is not American Idiot celebrated as one of the iconic popular political texts of its era? There was George W Bush and Iraq and what not…’grrrrrrr‘, said America‘s youth, before a pitifully small number of them turned out to help stop him being reelected in a landslide. Still, it is doubtful that American Idiot would have had the same resonance under a John Kerry presidency, useful to America and I dare say the rest of the world as that would have been. Like Green Day, Bob Dylan did a decent bit of resonating back in the day as well. Yet when I think about the songs of his ‚protest‘ era and American Idiot, you might be surprised to learn that it is the differences rather than the similarities that really struck me. There are notable examples of Dylan in protest mode using the narrative ‚I‘. A Hard Rain‘s… God on our Side, and Masters of War spring to mind, and let’s keep the generosity flowing here: ‚But I see through your eyes/ And I see through your brain/ Like I see through the water/ That runs down my drain‘ ..is by no means too good to have come from the pen of Billie Joe Armstrong. Just as often however, the ‚I‘ is entirely absent from Dylan‘s protest; Blowin‘ in the Wind, The Times They are a Changin‘, Hattie Carroll, and Hollis Brown among others. Dylan (as ever) was capable of becoming poetically absorbed enough in his subjects that he was never stuck navel-gazing. There is no ‚I‘ in Like a Rolling Stone either, a song often understood as being caustically personal. Can the same compliment be paid to Billie Joe? ‚I‘m not a part of a redneck agenda‘ (America Idiot) ‚I beg to dream and differ from the hollow lies‘ (Holiday) ‚I walk alone, I walk alone‘ (Boulevard…) ‚Is she dreaming what I’m thinking?‘ (She’s a Rebel) ‚I don’t wanna stay/ Get me out of here right now/ I just want to be free‘ (Homecoming) These are not examples of an isolated ‚I’ (as we find for example at the end of Dylan’s Chimes of Freedom) these songs hinge on the narrator’s own belly-button. These are not the only songs that do it and in fact I also exclude here anything from the most egregious example - Jesus of Suburbia - because it is far too rich in self-obsession, whether or not one reads some of it as the mere portrayal of a ‚character‘, to be reduced to one or two lines. Lies and injustice are only as significant as the effect they have on Billie Joe‘s experience and identity. Where there is any respite from this torrent of energetic egotism, the results are worse: "Sieg Heil" to the president Gasman Bombs away is your punishment/ Pulverize the Eiffel towers/ Who criticize your government The poetic poverty of those lines is only eclipsed by the crassness of the sentiment; Billie Joe indulging in imagining a violent suppression of political dissent when America’s government had not only actually, back in reality, bombed and invaded Afghanistan and Iraq, but passed the Patriot Act which defaced its own citizenry‘s rights to free speech and privacy. Billie Joe found himself entirely unable to address those realities. The less said about the ‘gasman’ bit the better. Billie Joe was simply not the songwriter for the hour that had come. 9/11 - a subject Springsteen gamely devoted an album to, even if he didn’t cover himself in glory in the analysis - is here quietly folded away as a subtext to a confessional about Billie Joe’s loss of his father 20 years before. Perhaps that struck some listeners as a touching juxtaposition. I thought it was, again, crass, the worst song on the album, and in my personal opinion one of the worst songs ever to rhyme ‘rain’ with ‘pain’, which is to say one of the worst songs ever written. Is there really ‘protest’ at all here? There is perhaps a spittle-thin veneer of disapproval for America’s governance, and the influence of the increasingly powerful right-wing media; although not even that much is observed - it’s just ‘the media’, and if we are being that inexact with the term, why shouldn’t Green Day of Warner Music Group be thrown in there with the rest of the accused? Of course almost all bands who claim any kind of outsider status to the maschinations of consumerism and corporate oppression are indulging in a spot of hypocrisy. But I well remember walking past Clinton Cards in the early to mid noughties and seeing a whole Green Day stand; posters, wrist bands, patches, key rings, who knows what else… not Rip-Off mind you, where you could dump your money on pruck from any number of rock bands, CLINTON CARDS where you would typically pop in to grab an emergency birthday card for your granny and the fuckers had their OWN STAND. No wonder America’s youth forgot to vote in November 2004 - they were all out buying Green Day stickers for their skateboards. I fear ‘fairness’ may have fallen a little behind me now but I would like to point out that Billie Joe isn’t exactly fair either. In the midst of any such flurry of accusations that Green Day’s material is too shallow to pass for real protest or decent art there is a subtle sense here that Billie Joe (and those fans just here for the puerile thrill of the chunes) can always fall back on not caring: I don’t care if you don’t care/ I don’t care/ Everyone’s so full of shit (Jesus of Suburbia) Yes there it is. That’s the essence of punk rock isn’t it? We target authority in superficial ways and take credit for anything resembling a palpable hit against it but we don’t really ‘care’ at the same time - go listen to your Joan Baez, boomer. Not caring is a powerful piece of rearguard defence and part of the defining spirt of every true punk from Joey Ramone through to Dick Cheney. Hard to believe that there are people out there who think Green Day ‘sold out’ in some way. Who are these ‘American Idiots’ though? ‘Rednecks’ is it? Because to be fair to rednecks, it is often less that they are idiots than that they, too, don’t care. Watergate does not bother them. Does your conscience bother you? 0/5
I feel like this is when Green Day got bigbig and all their true punk rock fans stopped thinking they were good because they were huge on the radio or MTV and little pop kiddies like me started singing along. I think they’re one of the few pop punk rock bands that stood the test of time and they’ll be remembered for the place they held in their genre and era. I’m glad they’re still sticking to their message, and giving a middle finger to the man, even as old men.
Rubbish
A priori négatif, notamment de part ma dernière écoute. J’imagine du punk/garage rock moi et très adolescent American idiot est bien quand même ! Je pense que j’aime pas le chanteur et que je trouve les riffs fainéants. Jesus of suburbia par exemple je trouve que c’est une mauvaise chanson. + en 2004 ils utilisent le mort « retard » au 1er degré, ils sont pas bases mais ça ne m’étonne pas D’autres rifs sont efficaces et faut avoir assez cultes (holiday). Mais la voix du chanteur me donne vraiment mal à la tête. La transition holiday dans boulevard est superbe Les paroles sont emos au point d’être énervantes, ce qui est totologique, mais avec cette voix insupportable et ces rifs benêts ça rend vraiment l’écoute difficile. Ça sent le 5 de merci pour les travaux C’est vraiment un des trucs les plus corny que j’ai jamais entendu
I’ve been avoiding this album for more than 20 years — tired of people telling me it was great or a big step forward for Green Day, or it had something important to say. I was a mostly-unwilling participant in Green Day being the soundtrack to my high school years and I was damned if I was going to let it follow me into my 20s as well. 20 years later, I think I was right to avoid it. It’s not horrible, but it has none of the fun and great tunes that made me enjoy Dookie despite it not being my favorite type of music. All the unavoidable radio songs still make me wince and hearing them in the context of the record doesn’t help. Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams probably fares the best of the hits. All that said I do appreciate that Green Day couldn’t make slacker teen punk music forever. It would have been worse if they entered their 30s still trying to recreate the feeling of smoking pot in their parents’ basement. A sprawling rock opera wasn’t the way I expected them to move on, and it’s not something I was interested in hearing — particularly from them. The middle section of the album is the worst part, playing out like a tiresome pop-punk version of Abbey Road, full of semi-unfinished loosely connected ideas. All that said, there is so much evidence throughout this record that Green Day is a band who is meticulous about their craft. It’s kind of daring for a band associated with music that loudly shouts, “who cares!?” to clearly care so much. Maybe part of me wished they still appreared to be as effortlessly cool as they did in the 90s, but looking back now I can’t fault them for realizing that version of Green Day had reached its expiration date. I probably won’t listen to this again. I respect it, even while I admit it’s not really for me.
Es un album increíble de principio a fin. Sin duda no te aburres en ningun momento y sin ser amante de este género, son canciones que cada vez que la escucho, las disfruto al máximo.
I’m still not convinced a 9 minute punk song works, but the two on American Idiot are probably the closest anyone’s ever going to get. I was familiar with the bigger hits off this but the other songs are basically just as good too
I wanted to give this a 1 based solely on Billy Armstrongs Haircut. Also wanted to give it a 1 as it comes off as pretentious drivel, a punk opera with an 8 minute song? Go fuck yourself. Also wanted to give it a 1 because the power chords, learn music you dick fucker. But alas, there are some hits, even if they've been so overplayed I would be happy enough to never hear them again.
Suburban Jesus is better than i remembered
its alright Not my fav but is a classic
This album is really excellent. Melodies are catchy and so well supported by the instrumentation. His voice is funny but fits the music so well.
Teenage musicality, pre-teen politics.
Uber strong start that goes gradually downhill before rallying a little at the end. 3.5 stars really.....
A pretty good album, some good songs on it
It’s about as subtle as a sledgehammer but ultimately a good collection of pop rock
Super good rock album
Been a little while since i listened to this but knew it would be 5*s. Possibly forgot just how good it is though - as well as being a stunning album choca with hits it just has so many smaller moments that grab the attention in such a unique way. The 'Dearly Beloved' bridge on Jesus of Suburbia The transition from Holiday to Boulevard The whiplash switch from Are We The Waiting to St Jimmy The slide guitars on Give Me Novocaine The brief 'American Idiot' vocal callback on Homecoming Aside from all this, I have a lot of love for Billy Joe's vocals, and the band absolutely nailed the concept album. 10/10
Geenday uh american idiot is good and if the music of its genre they do a p good job but just not the right type of noise for me.
Green Day's most graduated album. While kerplunk and dookie are their roots, they've grown up in this rock epic. Outstanding album.
I kind of get it but it’s just annoying. It sounds like everything else I don’t get it.
When Green Day first appeared, they were a bit too poppy and commercial for snobby 19-year-old me. It's been strange to see them become elder statesmen of rock. These days, I like their politics and I can see that they make an impressive noise for a simple three-piece punk band. I enjoyed this, but only the singles really stood out for me.
A welcome evolution from their pop-punk sound in Dookie! Sad that I was born too late to really enjoy this album in its heyday. Really interesting to hear Green Day try out operatic-punk, which goes well with the heavy-handed topics it addresses.
I'm not going to lie, this isn't my favourite GD album and it's not their biggest (either by numbers or in rock history). However, it had a massive commercial impact and restored their relevance with its pivotal, redefining sound from pop-punk to punk-rock. The arrangements are bigger, tempos and moods are more varied and lyrics have more emotional depth. They reshaped their audience and catapulted themselves across generations whilst maintaining their identity. This is an easy 5. I just hope this isn't the only GD album on the list!
Love it
I remember the boys listening to this album. Pretty good listen.
excellent
When this hit I was BIG into it, but around the time it was turned into a Broadway musical I saw a production and did not like it. Was totally soured to it, so I had not listened to it for about 10 years. Returning to it--aside from the f and r slurs--the album is a masterpiece. The only song I was like nah was Extraordinary Girl. Sometimes inspiration hits weirdly and after Green Day's previous pop album I think they were left for dead--they even did a greatest hits, lol! Something inspired Billie Joe and I was glad to listen again!
4.5. Cracker. Some songs less banging than others.
Interesting album, a couple of songs with various styles in the one song.
What a bangger
Top tier concept album that suffers from some individual tracks not being able to stand on their own, middling album without the concept and large scale songs that are on both sides
Wauw, dit is volgens mij een soort Rumours voor pop-punk. Ik ben geen groot pop-punk fan, maar bijna elk nummer komt bij al bekend voor haha. Lekker album om de week mee te beginnen in elk geval! Wel een heel stom kritiekpuntje, maar ik vind het ergens jammer dat de nummers gecombineerd staan. Ik vind Holiday namelijk een VEEEEEEL beter nummer dan Boulevard of broken dreams. Kan komen doordat die laatste wel echt overplayed is, maar soit. Ook is het middenstuk wel echt flink minder dan wat daavoor komt. De eerste 2/3 nummers zijn allemaal hits. Dan is het een tijdje een stuk minder, dan komt Wake me up when september ends en dan is het weer uitzitten tot het einde. Poppunk loopt wel een beetje tegen het probleem aan dat het goed klinkt, maar ook een beetje als meer van hetzelfde. Daarnaast; de lange nummers van bijna 9 minuten? Waren echt niet nodig. Zo begon dit album erg lekker en neigde ik meteen naar 4 sterren, maar gezien de 2e helft en het belachelijk lange Jesus nummer waar maar geen eind aan komt, word het toch 3 sterren voor mij. Prima pop-punk, maar niet iets wat ik snel nog een keer aan ga zetten. FAVO: American Idiot, Holiday/Boulevard of broken dreams, Wake me up when September ends
Bubblegum punk or just pop wearing punk sensibilities? Kudos to them for rebounding and reestablishing themselves 10 years after Dookie for a new generation.
The first three songs + the first double track might be the best start to any poppunk album ever. Usually I don't have the patience to listen to long songs, but Jesus of Suburbia manages to keep my interest. The last three tracks are also of really high quality. It's those three couplets in the middle that make American Idiot lose one star, as they are mediocre at best. As a rock opera, it is much better executed than Tommy, in my opinion. Just to be controversial right at the end.
Trash
I think the stigma that's surrounded Green Day for decades is finally starting to fade away. for years within punk and underground music culture, this band was the poster child for the word "sellout", a once-beloved Bay Area punk trio that signed to a major label, became a ubiquitous, best-selling rock act, and lost all their cred in the process. now that Green Day are firmly in their legacy years, it's allowed for a more measured appraisal of their work by many, myself included. I've never really had that kind of smoke for these guys, to be honest; and in revisiting their first seven albums, I grew to appreciate their evolution and trajectory. sometime around the late 90s, Billie Joe Armstrong's strengths as a songwriter started to really come into focus; the batch of tracks on nimrod. show this off particularly well. with American Idiot, Green Day also did something fairly punk (as much as a major-label rock band could): they were one of the first artists of their stature to position themselves firmly against then-President George W. Bush and the war in Iraq. this is a concept album which, nominally, tells the story of a group of young people disillusioned by the "television dreams of tomorrow," a false hope of a bright future being propagated at the time by every sector of the U.S. media, with the supposedly righteous and just War on Terror being positioned as an unquestionable good. as they come of age, they realize that the world they were promised is gone, and they turn to drugs, sex and other vices to cope. the anti-Bush position has become much more popular over the years, but Green Day deserves the props for being early to the party. I said this album "nominally" tells a story because, if you've listened to this thing, you know that the plot kind of falls apart about two-thirds of the way through. the individual songs that make up American Idiot are often some of Green Day's finest; the title track and "Holiday" are the best political moments, and there's plenty of uptempo punk ragers counterbalanced with sentimental ballads, all of which the band pulls off really well. there's also the two 9-minute suites, easily some of the most ambitious material they ever recorded. where this album suffers most is in its weak narrative payoff. the songs on this album would later be combined with a few from 21st Century Breakdown (another concept LP with a half-baked narrative) to form a musical which gives the American Idiot story a more concrete narrative, but even then, it's still pretty loose. strong 7/10.
Incredibly dull and soulless for an album which is trying to send a message. Sounds like it was made by a bunch of rich 14 year olds.
Green Day was the first band I loved. when I was 13, i listened to Dookie for the first time and my mind blew apart. I wasn't into music until then, but this album cahnged the course of my life like nothing else. I was on the green day wagon until around Nimrod, when I decided they were poser and started to listening to "serious punk". Last year I went to see my first green Day show, not expecting much since I didn't follow their career at all, and it was AMAZING. These guys never stopped. They never grew too old for this shit, too good for the band, break it up over solo career ambitions, have to prove their musicianship by making artistic or complicated music. This is much more punk than many of the "serious punks" I steered myself towards. Punk isn't what you wear or what you listen to, it's being true to yourself and your path, and giving absolutely 0 fucks what others think of it. Now to the album... Not everything is a banger but it's got enough bangers to be a bonafide 5 even without the nostalgia bit. Yes, it's not their best, but it's a proper pop punk anthem laden to speak both to punk lovers and outsiders.
Biased as loved this album growing up. Still really enjoy a lot of the themes and the structure of the album
One of the best punk rock albums out there
Emo stuff from 2000's. That one guy who's bulliied at the school.
Simplemente hermosoo
It's weird being nostalgic for an album that I didn't really like at the time, but this feels like a soundtrack to such a big part of my life and I really didn't mind it at all.
Here's how my uneducated brain sees genre. Punk: Short form, high energy, anti-establishment, jagged, raw. Prog: long suite compositions, connected concept albums, high technical skill, cerebral or fantastical themes Then there's these guys here. Decades after punk establishes itself firmly as the anti-prog they're like "hey let's make a concept album with a bunch of long connected suites". I think that's hilarious. That it pisses off the punk "purists" just makes it even better. Kill your idols, y'all. Just say yes to disco covers of "Comfortably Numb" and pop-punk rock operas. Why? Because it's challenges what you hold sacred and that's how you grow. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I've had this album since just after it dropped and it's incredible. You want the boots-on-the-ground zeitgeist of 2004/2005? Here you go. Take this and take Mezmerize/Hypnotize and get out of my face. You don't get "educated, nuanced" feelings about the political issues of the day. Average people don't have nuanced political understanding. They have visceral, nightly-news, sound-clip understanding. They have "got to get up and go to school/work with all this dread inside me" understanding. They have '"why the f*** are we starting a war with Iraq? what the hell does Iraq have to do with anything?" while they have to choose between paying rent and their kid's medicine' understanding. They have 90s level homophobia (the 90s sucked y'all, and Friends is a shit show) as their cultural backdrop. They have newly emboldened hyper-nationalism and people attacking other people on the subway for *looking* Muslim as their daily climate. Columbine is a fresh memory and a bright new scar. 9/11 is a fresher memory and isn't even scarred over yet. Certain news outlets would run segments mocking Americans for not being able to find Iraq on a map. This was supposed to be proof that we were a bunch of uneducated, politically unaware boobs who should be ashamed of ourselves. Actually, it just proved how much we had no business starting yet another war with a country the average American didn't know or care about. Can we have healthcare? Nope, gotta' kill more brown people so Halliburton can cash in. "Another protester has crossed the line to find the money's on the other side." Hi, that's me. I was that protester. When you realize you're not appealing to any kind of humanity and your government doesn't represent *you*; that you're up against Corporate special interest with infinite resources and you don't have the means to even move the needle? Yeah. This album is the soundtrack to my disillusionment. The media literally televised us blowing up cities full of people. Live. As if it was entertainment. They called it 'Operation Shock and Awe' like some kind of WWE show. It was disgusting. It was everywhere on an endless loop. It was traumatizing and I didn't even realize that until just now. Writing it down. Being force-fed mass murder as entertainment was traumatizing. I was 20 in 2004. 20+ years later and things have not improved. But this album still slaps. So there's that.
Not my favorite green day album, but this album is undeniably great.
Punkki ei ole hyvä jalassa eikä korvassa, mielestäni. Hitaammat hittibiisit on ihan okei mutta muuten vähän meh
Hittibiisit on kovinkin nostalgisia jo nykysellään, vaikkei paljoa oo tullu kuunneltua muuta. En oo juurikaan tän emobändin suurin fani ollut koskaan, eikä vieläkään täysin iskenyt.
Ongelofelijke knallers zitten er tussen en ondanks dat ik pas later met Green Day bekend werd heb ik er toch altijd wat mee gehad
7.5/10, zeker als je bedenkt dat ze van bijna een decennium langzame neerwaartse spiraal gingen, naar een killer van een album. Niet het beste in losse genres, maar toch wel de beste punk-pop rock opera (weinig competitie). Laatste halve puntje krijgen ze voor hoe Billie Joe Armstrong als een verdwaalde worm op het podium lag soms
271/1089 Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams is such a great track and such a classic the whole album is pretty decent imo, i think the middle section of Are We Waiting to Letterbomb is a bit of dip below the rest though 74/100
An iconic first half let down by a meandering second act. Still, it’s a hell of a record. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Fairly listenable, but not my thing
This album is way overhated in certain music circles, but I think it is Green Day's best. Over-the-top in the best way, the band abandoned the usual Pop Punk mold in favor of something grander and more mature. The Punk ethos isn't lost, particularly in the protest-riddled lyrics which criticised the Bush administration, but very well still apply to current times, over 20 years later. Which is a bit sad, but I digress. I remember seeing the band perform "Jesus of Suburbia" at some MTV award show and thinking they were playing for a long time. Cool song, cool album, and when was the last time a mainstream artist came out with a honest-to-god Rock Opera and pulled it off? I can't think of many. Key tracks: American Idiot Jesus of Suburbia Holiday Boulevard of Broken Dreams St. Jimmy She's a Rebel Wake Me Up When September Ends
I LOOHOOHOOOVE THIS ALBUM
okay, legalzinho
no es mi favorito de green day ni de cerca, pero algo que siempre he valorado del american idiot es que se siente la esencia del origen de la banda. un poco más romantico, pero con esa vibra punk-rock a flor de piel. lo que destáco particularmente son las letras y las temáticas que se abordan en este disco. aguante green day siempre
This is the album of the 2000s kid! Amazing!
While it's not as instantly catchy as most of Dookie was, it's still an enjoyable listen. Favorite track: Holiday
reminds me of middle school but nothing mind blowing
The perfect adult angst album!
A really good and loyal to-go since I was young!!! L O V E.
based nostalgic BANGER after BANGER
Somehow this album has only gotten more relevant over time, also ‘when September ends’ makes me go wah wah :(
album #30 LET'S FUCKING GO!!!!!!!!!!!! this is such a fantastic album, solid from start to finish! it's fun and i am a huge fan of concept albums, so the story throughout is really appealing. extraordinary girl and she's a rebel are probably the weakest of the album, mostly because it feels more in line with their kerplunk! era. it's hugely nostalgic for me. i was 6 when this album was released; i remember listening to the cd in the car with my mum and watching the music videos on kerrang. great memories! fuck facism and, whilst we can always push this message further, i think green day's sincere (and ambitious) approach to their message is commendable, especially for 2004. 100% deserves it's place on the list, whether it's your scene or not. ꩜ average track rating: 4.2/5 ꩜ favourite track(s): jesus of suburbia, holiday, letterbomb ꩜ least favourite track(s): extraordinary girl ꩜ album rating: ★★★★★ ꩜ number of albums left to review: 1,059 ꩜ number of albums from the list that i agree with being on the list: 16 (+1 American Idiot) ꩜ albums from the list that I would consider on my list: 7 (+1 American Idiot) ꩜ albums from the list I won't include on my list: 23
First lap on this one in a while. This was on the very first iPod I ever had, so I know it's in my top 10 most listened to albums ever. Embarrassing "fun" fact: I used to think Wake Me Up When September Ends was about having to go back to school. And I remember crying listening to it at Sheep Pond the last weekend before 8th grade. Now, let's get into it. The hits here are hits. They were inescapable in the radio/trl era of 2004. And, I didn't mind. I loved these songs. I always liked the 9 minute montage of St Jimmy. Loved Holiday. I forgot how much I liked Letterbomb. The things I didn't enoy are these: Extraordinary Girl stinks. Homecoming didn't need to be that long. And the whole record feels a little two shiny and overproduced. It feels like the beginning of the over-produced rock records from bands like Twenty One Pilots. 4/5
I listened to this repeatedly when it released -- big time moment for my middle school tastes releasing a career highlight to kick off high school. at the same time, this was probably the last "punk" or "punk pop" album that I paid attention to before my tastes shifted pretty hard in other directions. it's been nearly 20 years since I've listened to this front-to-back. some of these tracks I had completely forgotten about ("Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb" and "Whatsername") and others I would be fine if I never heard again ("Boulevard of Broken Dreams" -- not cause it's bad but cause I've heard it enough times). they took some risks on this album and they paid off. loaded with hooks, makes statements without feeling ham-fisted, multi-suite song structures that are crucial to the song, and mostly stellar production/engineering (it's interesting listening now how many songs have guitar parts where it's difficult to distinguish individual downstrokes). also interesting that the version I listened to on Tidal (and that was released on CD) had many of these songs combined into single tracks. after listening, I found another version on Tidal that splits each song into distinct tracks. not sure which I prefer, though it would be cool to stream "Holiday" without having to commit to "Blvd of Broken Dreams" ultimately Green Day knocked this one out of the park and created a highlight of the genre in the process.
‘American Idiot’ came out when I was in sixth grade, probably the prime age to absolutely love it. And I did. And I still do. This album produced a few major hits and was producing minor ones like a year after it came out. After the initial singles “American Idiot” and “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” had slightly faded from the airwaves, “Holiday” and “Wake Me Up When September Ends” were there to maintain Green Day’s stranglehold on the radio. Hell, I even remember “St. Jimmy” had its time in the sun. Has there been a bigger rock release, in terms of radio play, since this? Was this the swan song for rock as the dominant popular music force? It’s perfect pop-punk musically, and Billie Joe kills it on the lyrics and melodies too. There are so many good lines on “Jesus of Suburbia” alone. Even the ones that aren’t hits have big hooks. The sequencing on this album is perfect, you really do get a sense of a narrative arc. The version that they have on streaming services now makes it so that a lot of the songs are combined with another one, whereas on the initial release they were separated. It’s much better the way it was, it’s kind of a baffling move. This was one of my top three favorite albums for a long, long time, along with two others that aren’t on this list: ‘I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning’ by Bright Eyes and ‘East Nashville Skyline’ by Todd Snider.
Hay temazos. Me termina cansando un toque el punk, pero disco de culto
It's a fun album with some recognizable hits. It's not all my favorite, but in general I had a good time listening to this. 4/5
The hits are hits, the rest mostly filler
Iconic, recognizable and had a lasting impact on the 00s culture. Yeah, it fits on this list. ironic hearing it in 2026 when American idiot seems very fitting. It's easy to listen to and uses effective but predictable progressions. so it might not be a technical masterpiece. I liked Green day since I was young so I'm biased
easily one of the more complete albums i've encountered on this list - wall to wall classics, fun transitions, coherent concept. at times armstrong's voice is just a little annoying, and there's definitely something corporate/sanitized about this punk, but for some reason that's working in their favor here. at the end of the day it's just a great listen. (sentiments absolutely colored by the fact i saw them live while high as tits on molly. this album just exploded off the stage - straight air guitar and headbang fuel. won't ever forget it.)
It’s still strange to think that Green Day did a concept album. It works and feels less annoying than it did when it came out.
What a banger
I've never really listened to any of the albums post Dookie, maybe because by like, my 20s, I felt too old for Green Day, and their music, at least the singles, seemed mostly worse. That being said, on relistening to this years later, the singles are pretty good here--American Idiot, Boulevard and Holiday. Overall the songs just aren't quite as good as Dookie--many sound a little more general. 3/5
Ok
Blah. Boring mainstream punk-ish sound.
I HATE GREEN DAY
Probably their best album. The energy keeps going till the end. Lyrics are a bit naive but still a decent listen
Knew the singles, but not the album. Protest music for 12 year olds, and that's not a bad thing. Was doing well until they did a nine minute track. The Who is not punk.
Halt DAS Album mit all ne Radio Hits.
"It’s late at night. your parents think that you’re sleeping. you’ve listened to this one before, but can’t really remember all of it, so you decide to listen again. and every song, there is a different “holy shit this is so good” moment. lyrics that revel against the Iraq war, media polarization, and the bush administration. The band really matured with this one, too. They haven’t really gone back to their old sound. 11/10 the best album of the millennium"
Góð fløga, gloymi hvussu nógvar evergreens eru á henni.
10/10
Love Green Day. As a teen I binged their entire discography and when this album dropped it was thrown right into the mix. Back then we used to listen to the radio all the time and I'd love when "American Idiot" was playing. I remember walking to the mall after school to pick up the album when it came out. All that to say I really like American Idiot. Every track is unique and cool (but, but, but it's all just power chordzz hurrr durrr!!). Drums and guitar are tight as always, and BJAs vocals are iconic. I tried to pay closer attention to the drumming this listen, and it can't be overstated how good and fitting for the album Tre's drumming is. Best tracks are literally all of them. It's a front to back listen. You can't go wrong. It's all non-stop energy and spite and rock and roll. Definitely a 5. Maybe the last Green Day 5 banger. Gonna go back and listen to everything else up through this album again. Nobody likes you, everyone left you, they're all out without you having fun. Peace.
Suprise to no one pero 5/5. Un concept album lleno de bangers. Loud sound and loud lyrics cement this as nothing short of iconic
Superb. On all levels. 4.5ish stars. So rounded, 5 stars.
3.7 I overplayed this within 6 months of it coming out, such that it's hard to rate it properly. The 4 main singles I now can't really do, though tbh apart from the title track I didn't really dig the rest at the time. The albums gems are the two longer tracks - Jesus and Homecoming. Apart from Tre's (in my opinion) unnecessary segment in the latter, these are some of Green Days finest moments. It's a shame they didn't push on from here, I didn't rate 21st century much and then I stopped listening despite loving the spell from Dookie to this. With the political fodder there now for the taking I would love a Trump update. If the Bush administration is evicerated this bad then surely Trumps is there for the taking...
Maybe their best album quite good
Ok
Green day vind ik heel erg cringe. Het mag van mij in het rijtje: suzan en freek, kane, kensington en macklemore. De Tenenkrommers
Als muziek algoritme in 2005 al had bestaan had ik Green day extreem vaak voorgeschoteld gekregen. Het was iets wat in mijn straatje zou moeten liggen met de muziek die ik toen luisterde. Het stemgeluid is altijd iets wat mij irriteerde. Het klonk altijd als een chronische verkoudheid. Het is dus ook voor het eerst dat ik het hele album luister ipv de singels die op mtv langs kwamen. De openingstrack american idiot is van de de dag relevanter dan ooit. Dit was kritiek op het medialandschap en de bush regering en alles wat america was in die tijd. Helaas is de boodschap niet aangekomen en is het alleen maar erger geworden met de Amerikaanse media en de grootste american idiot ooit op de troon. Ik kwam er nu pas achter dat dit een concept album is wat ik wel kan waarderen. Tegelijk is het ook altijd een beetje stom als "punk" verschuift van anarchistisch naar moraal ridder muziek. Dunne lijn waarbij Green day zich aan de verkeerde kant begeeft. Muziekaal gezien het voor punk rock erg gepolijst met emo ballads. Niet echt leuk. Op elk vlak komen ze een beetje nep over. Ik haat ze ook niet echt want ze bedoelen het wel goed maar het komt niet op mij over.
Ik was 14 toen dit album uitkwam, de perfecte leeftijd om deze muziek te kunnen waarderen, ik zat namelijk al in de hoek van Sum 41 en blink 182. Dit heeft me destijds minder gepakt en het doet me nog steeds vrij weinig. Sowieso ben ik een beetje allergisch voor het woord opera in combinatie met punk of rock. Het is eigenlijk te gelikt en over geproduceerd om het echt punk te laten zijn. Ik vind het voor die tijd ook een beetje outdated, een punkband met kritiek op de overheid, ja oké.. de hits zijn verder wel goed hoor, maar voor mij niet nostalgisch ofzo, de zanger doet me altijd denken aan Dirk Kolkman, ik denk dat hij t wel 5 sterren zou geven.
Just a great album
Just add the heretic is worse than the heathen, (American) pop punk is worse than no punk at all.
This album was popular for a reason. Loud poppy punk.
Me gustó algunos son muy nostálgicos , bonitas letras
me gusta que sus letras son tan reales, me encantó la instrumental
AMOOOOO, green day è fd demais fazendo musica. emocionante e atual — adoro as críticas q esse álbum faz ao mesmo tempo que traz reflexões pra nós mesmos sabe
And here we are 22years later and America is still full of idiots, dangerous and deranged idiots. Not Green Day’s best album but still enjoyable
It’s fine. Felt a little longer than it actually was for some reason? 2.5/5
I once befriended a kid who grew up in a strict Christian Apostolic community. I’m talking women could only wear skirts type of community. We rode the bus together and I introduced him to A LOT of non biblical music on bus rides to and from school. He was my first kind of real friend in Kentucky so I overlooked a lot of red flags on a weirdo I probably otherwise should have seen. ANYWAY… His parents wouldn’t let him do normal stuff play call of duty or listen to music like Green Day (particularly this album). Sadly, I introduced him and his younger brother to both. I got to witness what a first person shooter tailor made for a PlayStation console and irate rock does to a guy. He went from like a silent/rebellious honor student who invited me to church to like full-on hanging out with D level students and bragging about getting into fights in the span of two months type of kid. I’m not kidding… His introduction to this album coincided with our grade reading The Outsiders. This kid LOVED American idiot. When we shared my iPod buds on the bus he’d always be like “Play that one American song man.” I also started noticing him bragging about going to fights against ‘socs’ to kids three levels younger on the bus. It was then I knew that maybe I had introduced this kid to too much. This guy reminded me a lot of Icarus and Green Day was his sun. After like two straight weeks of riding the bus together he kept requesting Green Day. That “play that American song man” request was starting to piss me off. Like, friends introduce each other to different music genres - they don’t make you constantly play Green Day 24/7. I started getting pissed and playing Don McLean and Bruce Springsteen when he made the “American song” request. But this album and particularly American Idiot had a weird withdrawal effect on him. It’s all he could crave. One day I silently deleted Green Day from my iPod and he couldn’t take it. I told him we could listen to other stuff. But after like a week of no Green Day (and particularly this album) he started sitting with other kids on the bus and our friendship never really recovered. Green Day was little more than a subtle paste that held us sitting together on a bus ride that lasted 20-25 minutes. Flash forward 15 years… I looked him up while listening to this album. He now has a couple of kids, didn’t maintain the apostolic lifestyle, and may or may not work. Wild to believe Green Day, this album, and maybe what American Idiot can do to a guy. Idk, maybe those weird republicans from the 90/00s railing against modern rock had a point. Was that all those republicans were trying to protect us from? Hell of an album though. I can still see this guy slapping his leg when American Idiot comes on. 4/5 stars, wouldn’t change a thing.
oh fuck yeah
Haven’t listened to this one all the way through in some time, but I loved it. 4-4.5
I was never a big Green Day fan growing up. My exposure was mostly limited through their radio hits, but I remember my cousin was a huge fan. We'd play Battlefront II on his PS2 and listen to this album. Listening to it today brought made me wistful for innocence. This album also makes me think of the guy who threw a shoe at George Bush. I hope he's having a good day.
I bought this CD at Hot Topic in 2009, along with the then-new 21st Century Breakdown (which is basically just American Idiot but worse) and I thought the cashier was hot and she talked me into buying a deluxe edition of Let the Dominoes Fall by Rancid (an okay enough album) that came with a bunch of posters and guitar picks and a DVD and a second acoustic CD and then she wrote down a list of bands I should listen to and like half of them were ska bands that I don’t remember. Anyway, my grandma let me play American Idiot in the car on the way home and her review was “I guess it does have kind of a nice beat.” My grandma was the best.
Muy diferente de lo que estaba esperando, grandes temas!!
Probably going a little lower than most people on this one. The first 5 or so songs are all recognizable bangers. This one just felt a little soft & lower level than what I like to listen to. I kept thinking it reminded me of other, better music and went Beatles to Bowie to Clash to Ramones back to Beatles back to Clash, etc. Half of the album sounded like it was made by the That Thing You Do band, the Wonders (O-needers).
V good
Best of whatever it is
Why weren't you paying attention? Yes, I'm talking to you fuckwits that saw Donald Trump as a better option because he 'gets things done'. Green Day, not part of your MAGA agenda, turn up on my 1001 at just the right time and earn themselves 5 stars. This album is a bit of a blast, notwithstanding the current bout of lunacy we are witnessing. Why, just yesterday Donald Trump posted a picture of himself as Jesus (not of Suburbia) bringing someone back from the dead!! The album, a story of disillusionment from the Bush Jr presidency, has a narrative of someone wanting to go off and 'find themself' but all they do is become a bit of a caricature before they eventually realise they could be true to themself at home! Or something like that. And the songs are great. Outside of the 4 singles that were huge and received lots of airplay and chart action, Are We The Waiting, Extraordinary Girl and Whatshername also stand out, while Jesus of Suburbia hops from act to act, unsettled and constantly shifting focus like our main protagonist. It's a fascinating, entertaining album, doesnt feature in the Epstein Files and hasn't bombed Iran! 5 stars.
OK, I'm maybe a bit biased in my score, as Green Day come from my hometown, Oakland. You have to realize how big it was for them to win a Grammy, considering where they started. The same band that would typically write in-your-face, snotty, ironic pop-punk was now experimenting with song structures and socially contentious themes and lyrics? Seriously? Yes, indeed—and they did it in true form. This book has one of the biggest omissions in rock music: Hüsker Dü's Zen Arcade. THAT album showed us all what rock and punk music could be: a vehicle for experimentation, thematic sociopolitical concepts, filled with noise and emotion that people would find appealing—not just a way of writing simple songs. So, I'll take American Idiot as a replacement, as much as it hurts. It's what Green Day managed to do here, while still breaking into the mainstream like never before. "Jesus of Suburbia" is far from a radio-friendly format, yet it's as perfect a pop song as anything made before it. The other singles are, of course, good (ESPECIALLY "Holiday"), but this album works best as a concept and should be listened to in a single sitting. It sometimes gets a bit repetitive, but I still love it to this day and have massive respect for the band for becoming successful while continuing to do their own thing.
pretty good
Rebellious ahh music 🥀🥀💀💀
its alright "nobody likes you everyone loves you" is homo asf
Fucking awesome!!!
muito bom ouviria sempre
Still don't love the nasally twang, but the album lived up to the memory. Excellent album.
a banger, as always
So much better than I expected, and so much better than "Dookie"--what a difference a decade makes, apparently. I'm really impressed that (a) they decided they wanted to pursue a concept album, especially a punk/rock opera concept focusing on alienation and disillusionment, and (b) this trio of misfits largely succeeded in this audacious project (although I'm not sure I would have wanted to see the 2010 musical on Broadway). It's still a very Green-Day-sounding album (not my favorite band, I'll admit), but there are only a few tracks on this overly long album that seemed weak/Dookie-era songs; mainly just the pair "St. Jimmy" and "Give me novacaine", although I can see how each at least serves as a vehicle for their storyline. I'm also really impressed at how well their videos (all directed by Samuel Bayer, apparently) for a number of the tracks extended the opera theme quite well, especially the first three tracks and the remarkably long "Jesus of suburbia". (Such a shame that Green Day chose to change up some of the lyrics to "American idiot" for their recent Super Bowl performance, although I'm sure that wasn't their choice.) Add in the justifiably hit singles "Holiday", "Boulevard of broken dreams", and "Wake me up when September ends" (the latter with an impressively bleak video) and this is a winner of an album, much to my surprise.
I liked this more than I thought I would but they're still annoying. I want to see them playing in a garage and then to stand outside and slowly close the door with an automatic garage door opener.
The second I saw this album pop up, I knew it was going to be a 5 star for me. I just adore the vibes on this album. Pretty much every hit from the band is on here, and it doesn't lose momentum for even a second. I really appreciate Green Day's ability to make a political statement in a way that is entertaining and meaningful. The riffs on this album are awesome, every song is memorable, and it ages incredibly well. I just adore this album.
Green Day no es de Mis bandasfavoritas Pero este álbum es un 10
I really liked it! It sounds like music from the movies and so nostalgic! Loved it!
Pas mon style
I love this album. A fun rock opera.
Punk pop for the youth. Heard it 50 years ago.
Terrible álbum, me hace acordar a mi infancia
First time listening to Green Day, always heard about it but never actually interested in them tell now 5/5, will listen to them again. Also thank you for Ikoxun's Corner for introducing me to this awesome website. XD
American Idiot is the first Rock album i was introduced to when i was 11 years old and completely hooked by it and after relistening it 9 years later, it still gave the nostalgia, sadness and abit rebel but some of it doesnt give the same energy or vibes that i once felt before. So, the rating is a 4 star
I hate this band. Nothing they have done or will ever do will warrant being included in this list.
Punk/power pop with ballads. Some great songs and others not so much. Just learned that Boulevard of Broken Dreams, the one sing that's different than their others, has the same chord progression as Wonderwall. 😕
Only heard blvd of broken dreams (and *heard of* American Idiot) which is a song I enjoy mostly because of nostalgia, but never bothered to branch into their stuff. Found myself pleasantly surprised with some of the material here. Much of the tracks are split into different segments and the transitions often feel well-timed and smooth. Of course there is a lot here that I find utterly uninteresting and I came away from this record pretty confident I wouldn’t have the urge to listen to it in full for a while. However, I enjoyed multiple tracks and feel as if there is the potential for it to further grow on me. Wake Me Up When September Ends is great. Don’t see myself coming back much but came away happily here. 3/5.
American Idiot is an album I listened to a lot when I was younger, and revisiting it now hit me much harder than I expected. Songs like Holiday, Wake Me Up When September Ends, and Whatsername feel deeply tied to my own memories, to the point where it’s difficult to separate the music from my past. It’s not something I can evaluate objectively, it’s more like confronting a part of my life I can’t fully detach from.
Primeras impresiones: Mid pero me algunos arreglos me sorprendieron. De todas maneras no es el tipo de música que pondría a voluntad, pero no disgusta y, a la vez, no me emociona tanto.
An absolute classic and part of the soundtrack of my youth. I listened to this religiously when I was in my teens and it hasn't aged a day in 22 years. I love every song on this album, but Jesus of Suburbia is special. A song I will never get tired of listening to, and an album I will always adore. The fact my least favourite song of the lot is the title track, says it all. A work of art and the easiest 5/5 so far.
It has some great songs but overall it’s not great. Not my favourite
This is an ok album, with a few really good songs. But I won’t listen to it again.
You know, it's a really good album. I get why it got so freaking popular.
This was much better than I thought it would be. I remember hearing a couple songs too much and I dreading this listen. Not bad.
Another album that suffered from over saturation on the radio. In fact american idiot still gets too much radio play. I knew all the words, but this one was a miss for me. I prefer their earlier albums.
Fine album.
The always overrated Green Day finally puts out an album that measures up to their big head reputation. The story of American Idiot is difficult to follow, but a few of the songs are well thought out and have insightful lyrics including; Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Are We the Waiting, and Give Me Novacaine. (3.9*s) Who’d a thunk there could be a successful punk rock opera?
Even though I am a Green Day purest, this album is quite good. A rebranding of the band and one could say a bit of a sell out, but still got the punk roots that made them popular with Dookie. Much like U2 or RHCP, their work has slowly dwindled in quality but they have stayed relevant. I mean they just opened for the super bowl and still sounded pretty good. American Idiot is a solid concept album with themes that will probably always resonate with each generation...certainly do at the present in mid-2026. Lame government, dumb wars, over commercialization and consumerism will always be the US. Amongst the hit tracks are ones that have some deeper meaning and don't suck. The album wraps up perfectly with Jesus returning home and remembering "Whatsername" with a bit of scorn. I certainly liked this record now more than when it came out...ages well. 3.7 stars for these American idiots putting out a decent release mid-career (did they peak?).
I remember when this album dropped and hit the airwaves. It was definitely a tour de force as a handful of the singles were all over the place and it seemingly revitalized Green Day's career after fading a bit over the prior decade. Although I think you could argue they were already superstars in the wake of Dookie, American Idiot definitely re-catapulted them back to the top of the charts and cultural zeitgeist. American Idiot rips out of the gate with a handful of singles, many of which are still enjoyable today. It gets a little thinner as the album continues but the sum of its parts are greater than the individual tracks as you get through the album and all in all it wraps up pretty nicely. American Idiot made a statement in the wake of 9/11 and the political fallout. While I wasn't overly interested in the political message or the opus that was American Idiot back in 2004, it was a welcomed listen when it arrived on the list. I can't say I was surprised how well it held up as the world that it was commenting on has only leaned further into how ridiculous it can get. The overall storyline and message was enjoyable and the pop punk tunes that Green Day assembled remain very accesssible more than 20 years later. I can see why it is heralded as a solid pop punk opera as its appeal seems like it could range from teenager to people over their 50's. The work has taken on a new life as it was adapted into a musical and the title track has been used as an anthem in various ways. Pretty well deserving entry by Green Day. Enjoyed the listen and glad I was able to revisit it. 3.60 stars
I hate most concept albums (efforts from Stevie Wonder and Marvin Gaye aside), but this works even if you aren't paying attention to the narrative. A mix of the band's earlier punk rock with more of a classic rock Who/Kinks element that works (although sounds awful on paper). I like this album more than I love it, but appreciate the band's attempts to break out of the box, something they haven't tried again since.
Bueno, me hace recordar la adolescencia
Album I used to listen a lot when I was a teenager. First Green day album that I heart. Great time listening to it again
Such a nostalgic album for me, I really enjoyed listening to this one since I haven't in a while.
Epitome of that 2000s pop-punk-rock-ish sound to me. Love this album and its politically charged lyrics, sick riffs, and goofy emo voice Billy. Heavy dose of nostalgia as well, soundtrack to a part of my childhood.
The epitome of pop punk. Very angsty, very fun, good album to mysteriously walk through the neighborhood to.
Favorite song: Jesus of Suburbia Least favorite: Are We the Waiting The quintessential pop punk album. It is successful both as cleanly mastered pop perfection and a piece of political media that still holds its weight today. American Idiot manages to avoid the trite, surface-level lyrics that often define others in this genre as extremely far removed from their “punk” roots. The album has something to say, but delivers it in a polished and catchy manner that still resonates 20 years after its release.
heard this tons of times as a kid, and tons more over the years from various sources. guess this was like "baby's first punk album" for me American Idiot - 5/5 Jesus of Suburbia - 4/5 Holiday - 5/5 Boulevard of Broken Dreams - 5/5 Are We the Waiting - 3/5 St. Jimmy - 4/5 Give Me Novacaine - 3/5 She's a Rebel - 4/5 Extraordinary Girl - 4/5 Letterbomb - 4/5 Wake Me Up When September Ends - 5/5 Homecoming - 3/5 Whatsername - 3/5 Average score: 4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ i feel about the same about this album as i did about Dookie. the hit tracks are about as good as i remember. everything else... meh. having finally heard Dookie in full not too long ago, i think that's better than American Idiot by a razor-thin margin
12 year old me owes Mitchell Greer an apology. This album slaps ass. I think that the first half clears the second half, but the second half is still VERY good. The double track format is really interesting, particularly for a pop punk record. I don't really understand the sellout allegations. Is it because of how good the music is? Its still sonically gorgeous and complex. Its literally a concept album/rock opera. I loved this so much. 4.2 (but will likely get higher.)
I'll always have a soft spot in my heart for Green Day, but there's a reason the best punk songs are under 3 minutes (honestly, the BEST punk songs are under a minute thirty, but I'm being inclusive). Like my ex-wife, Green Day and I have matured in different directions. I'm glad they had the space to grow and all that, but it's just not for me. postscript: just got to 'homecoming,' the longest song on the record, and I'm vaguely 'into it'
So much more than Millennial protest music, although it's obviously great at being that ("Holiday" and the title track). It's also perhaps our best chronicle of the experience of being alive in the mid-2000s and becoming aware that there are no grownups in charge (i.e. that the moms and Brads are away) - and that, despite how much you claim you don't care, you really do ("Wake Me Up When September Ends"). The closer "Whatsername" is a genuinely moving emo tune from a band that was never even emo. All in all, this is punk's answer to *The Wall* and a statement of purpose for anyone, from Anaheim to the Middle East, who intends to survive the Anthropocene with their heart intact. America: fuck, yeah.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ Ganska absurt egentligen med en Rock-opera album från ett punkband men alltså det här albumet är så lättillgängligt. Det kanske inte är superavancerat och så punk är det väl inte men ibland vill man bara ha rak och enkel pop-rock. Det här albumet känns som en tidkapsel (fast Dookie är nog ändå mer så). Det är lätt att gilla, det är fullt med lättuggade spår som är svårt att inte gilla. Sista spåren Homecomming och Whatsername hade de kunnat skippa och då hade albumet också fått en lagom längd. Tycker albumet håller för en 4a. Bäst är Jesus of Suburbia, Give me Novacine/She's a rebel,
No notes.
Didn’t like it then. Don’t like it now. (Sorry Elliot)
Absolutely top tier. No doubt it's one of my best 20 of all time. You just don't see a lot of cohesive, full album narratives, let alone ones this well done, with songs that are also capable of standing on their own.
My biggest enemies
I gotta say, I feel like Green Day really finds the sweet spot between commercial Punk Opera for the disaffected suburban crowds and the low key callbacks to their early stuff for the heads and pop punk aficionados on this album. They’ve got the big anthems that everyone will remember while they were first exploring their suburban footprints and still make room for a few hits that will be remembered by the die hard fans.
I don’t know man, I guess it’s fine. I feel like this was a massive hit & kinda launched these guys to another level. And I understand it’s supposedly smart social critique or sthg. I wanted to at least appreciate it for that reason, or understand what the critics seemed to adore. The problem as I see it, is it sounds so much like Green Day. I just have no patience for the pop punk sound. There were a few moments that sounded interesting but I don’t remember which & I don’t care to go back & find out. I’m granting 2.5 stars & I guess we can round up out of deference to its supposed greatness
This record is the most serious one to come out of the pop punk movement, has 4 of the biggest rock songs of all time, and was just performed at the Superbowl. Anything less than a 4 is criminal and above that is personal preference
The first four songs elevate this album tremendously. The rest of the album kinda meanders in places, with some highlights for me (St. Jimmy, Gove Me Novacaine, Wake Me Up” but the others lose me
Really loved listening to this albums very nice 9/10 very great and highly recommend
This was an album I could swear I had already listened to back-to-front many times, but clearly I haven't. It is filled with an optimistic frustration at post 9/11 politics, but with 2026 ears you can't help but hear the naivety in it. Some of the songs are classic bangers, but there is quite a bit of bland filler. As is life!
Who amongst us on the cusp of Gen Z and milennial didn't have a phase where they thought this was the peak of music? If you say you didn't then ur lying! Looking back it's kinda naff, but then that's only because things were only gonna get worse than George Bush later down the line. But then Billie Joe and co couldn't have known that. It's like, enjoyable upbeat pop punk rock, catchy and fun.
Really good, so close to a 5
Great album! Boulevard, Extraordinary girl and Wake me up were the standouts, but a really great flow
A harsh 3 but Dookie is better and that wouldn't get a 5. That's my justification.
4.4/5 Favorite songs: Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams Wake Me Up When September Ends Give Me Novacaine/Shes a Rebel
I was a massive fan of this album when it was released. It’s a no skip album for me.
Anthemic punk rock that defined the 2000s. Some of the songs are still surprisingly relevant today.
It's not Dookie or Insomniac,but not as terrible as I thought it may be
6.5/10
enjoyed some more than others, wake me up when september ends would be fun to play on drums. didn’t realise a lot of the songs were two in one lol? but yeah idk about this one
4.5
8.0/10
They should make this into a musical.
what a classic album filled with BANGERS i didnt realize how much ive actually heard from green day until i sat down and listened to a full album lol
Phenomenal album. Strong, versatile and with so many outstanding songs that are still relevant today. American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends, Holiday and so on. Love it.
Banger!
Wow. Now i understand why this one is generational.
Great album
Great album and very pivotal release. This record has aged very well given the current state of the US and the world. The music was innovative at the time and Green Day has always had a distinct sound. This is a solid record.
Had some bangers, but I couldn't get myself to finish the album. i might give it a proper re-listen
Green Day provides timeless enjoyment and relevance to today's events. More likely my children's prime entertainment when it was released. I just get the benefit of sharing with them.
Excellent 👌 this album will always be a great social commentary :)
Definitely one of my favs from Green Day, I love how 4 of the tracks in the middle are actually two songs. Fun album
Maybe my lack of nostalgia hurts me here but this just doesn’t do much for me. Very whiny
The more things change the more they stay the same, yeah?
I was expecting more of a nostalgia bump for this album, but it is pretty weak in between the hits. There's more instrumental/style variety than a typical pop-punk album, but it's still underwhelming.
Although I’m not the biggest Green Day fan, revisiting the album does remind me that it was a pretty good album. But the radio overplayed songs I can live without.
Saved? ✅ Would listen again? ✅ Would recommend to anyone? ✅ Would buy on Vinyl? ✅
Himnos y sin dudas marcas de una época. No es para mi yo actual!
Green Day grows up on this record, eschewing the rude and crude...replaced with political banter and a punk rock opera.
Heard it a million times
Um.....wow...i thought it was noise and noise and noise...but then i used my headphones and 360 flip...it is quite nice. I am not much of a high production music fan but "wake me up when September ends", "are we waiting", 'bvld of broken dreams' are really good. But still it's not my thing or maybe i am just not in the right head space.
Good rock album. It comes across as punk, and the messaging seems to be in line with that. Doesn't quite have the grit that historically punk albums had, but perhaps this was the start of a new evolution of the genre. It was certainly more main stream. Overall, it's a good fare. Due to all enormity of radio play, I knew every word of the hits. But that doesn't take away from their goodness. They are done well and still have some meaning. I did enjoy it and might go back to it someday.
Basic Ramonesy power pop plus trite politics, pretentious frippery and a whiny emo mood. A lot of my friends were into this band in the 1990s but I always found them profoundly meh. This came out in 2004 by which time I wasn’t in this scene at all so this LP was new to me. I found lots of the individual songs were quite good (if overlong) but nobody needs 57 minutes of this.
I already know and love this album so was so happy to listen to it.
Ambitious. I’ve never paid enough attention to follow the narrative, but the standout tunes are great.
I suppose Green Day were an entry point to Punk for Busted and McFly fans. So that’s a positive. But I was already into Punk when they emerged so they seemed a little dull and old fashioned. Some of there singles are undoubtedly fun but there’s nothing fun about this incoherent concept album.
Billy Joe Armstrong has such a good voice. I think the best part about these songs is that I can sing along
really wanted to love this for nostalgia's sake, and for 9 minutes, i totally did - Jesus of Suburbia is a bratty, pathos-laden power-pop epic, incredibly confident and winning. but this doesn't last - the politics, though refreshingly bold today, wear thin really quickly, and then we're left with a lot of overwrought balladry and rock n roll with very little bite. i'm happy that this album once sounded dangerous and important, and you could do so much worse than lots of what's here, but i'm 28! I've moved on and that's fine
Is it me or do these guys feel like industry plants? I swear, it's the same generic "punk" rock as their last hit album. Most of the songs here sound like their were ripped from some eighties tunes, and I don't mean sounds like it I mean literally the same songs. I sound like I hate them, which isn't the case. The music is simple but high energy, they have a good political message, but it is just generic and not great. I can't figure out why they made the list twice now, I know it was popular but what makes this a must hear album?
The longer cuts on this thing I never listened to are actually the best! Suburban Jesus and Homecoming are some great anthems to listen to. Never knew this was a concept album which really helps tying things together not only lyrically but also sonically. Nice surprise
Awesome
My second favorite Green Day album. Nothing tops Dookie for me. This is like Green Day lite, and it's good don't get me wrong, its a bit more pop-y and I still enjoy the majority of the songs on this. I mean 'Jesus of Suburbia' has no business working as a 12 min epic but it does, the first 4 songs on this album are absolute perfection. This album could probably shave 3 songs off and be even tighter and better. Again it's good but can almost feel corny at points. Only further proven by the fact that this album led to a tony award winning musical. It's amazing how these musical responses to the Bush era have only gotten more relevant today.
3.5/5
Great Rock Opera
Great Album. After learning about their precious master tapes being stolen, listening to this album from stary to finish took on a whole new meaning. Great story telling and anthem feel.
it was kinda bland and primitive, but maybe i just hate fun
Good for this genre. Lots of big tracks!
Alarmingly relevant to the times we live in today. America has always been awful, who knew?