My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy by Kanye West

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

Kanye West

3.4
Rating
29874
Votes
1
14%
2
12%
3
21%
4
27%
5
26%
Distribution

Reviews (page 9 of 16)

Favorite Track: Devil In A New Dress

Not gonna listen

Devil in a new dress used to be my favorite damn song.

Regardless of how amazing this album is, or any other possible album of his that may show up in here again, out of principle there is really only one score I can give.

Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Don't get me wrong, I hate this guy as much as you do. As an ex-Kanye West fan, ever since he went on that Alex Jones interview in 2022, I knew it was all over for me to continue giving a blind eye on the bullshit he has done. For years I had defended the actions he made before that, but afterwards, it was impossible for me to ignore. He has all the resources in the world to improve mentally and get better with himself, but he's a grown ass man and he's choosing to continue living the lifestyle he has, with the lastest twitter rants proving that point even further. However, this was one of the first albums I ever heard before I loved listening to albums, so this really brings a lot of memories and nostalgia for me. This album not only saved his career (temporarily), but also saved me. Even in my darkest moments, I listened to this album countless of times and became unstoppable, wanted to continue living and ignore the negative bullshit that I was going to, hoping to strive for better things and that's what I did. This album feels massive in any way, feeling as if you were capable to rule over the whole world with this album, and it truly is bigger than life itself. This album is so amazing that it was capable to revive an career that had a lot of backlash back then. It's not the best rap album of the decade because To Pimp A Butterfly exists, but this is definitely one of the best: The intro has to be some of the best intros I heard, not only in a rap album, but in all albums overall, giving an glimpse of how Kanye was feeling after his backlash with Taylor Swift and showing how maximalist and massive this album feels. Then Gorgeous comes in, great Kid Cudi feature there and some iconic and yet funny lines that Kanye says are also there. POWER has to be one of his most iconic songs he's ever made, with the king crimson sample, and the way he builds up to the end, metaphorically jumping down the window on there. All Of The Lights starts with a short yet beautiful piano section, before inevitably you hear a bunch of voices singing, while the song goes hard. Monster has by far the best Nicki Minaj verse she has ever done in her career, better than almost any song she has wrote. Many people would exclude So Appalled as an amazing song, but there were so many rappers rapping on it and somehow it worked greatly in their favour, as if they united the smartest kids in the class for a school project. Devil In A New Dress has the best riff section I heard in awhile, and can't forget the iconic Rick Ross verse. However, Runaway is the best song on this album personally, everything about it is perfect, start to finish. Hell Of A Life is such an underrated song too, the way he builds up the beat to feel grand and huge is so compensating to hear. Then there's Blame Game which to be honest is great, but didn't had to be that long (that Chris Rock skit was great though). Finally there's the last two tracks, Lost In The World and Who Will Survive In America, such an amazing way to end an incredible once-in-a-lifetime album. If I'm being honest, I had already gave up hope for Kanye West to recover for years, he had the chance too, but he's still the same guy he was back in 2022, nothing changed. Kanye West is dead, and now all we have is a clone of him, Ye, someone who represents the exact opposite of what Kanye preached in his songs. It's sad how he went from making songs like these back in 2010 to make Vultures 1 and 2. Eventually one day, Mr. Ye will have to wake up to his beautiful dark twisted fantasy, and return to what made him so impactful and great to hear in the first place. Overall, this album is the epitome of near perfection. I miss the old Kanye. I hate the new Kanye. 1.- Dark Fantasy = 10/10 2.- Gorgeous = 10/10 3.- POWER = 10/10 4.- All Of The Lights (Interlude) = 9/10 5.- All Of The Lights = 10/10 6.- Monster = 10/10 7.- So Appalled = 10/10 8.- Devil In A New Dress = 10/10 9.- Runaway = 10/10 10.- Hell Of A Life = 10/10 11.- Blame Game = 8/10 12.- Lost In The World = 10/10 13.- Who Will Survive In America = 7/10 FINAL SCORE: 9.5/10

Kanye West is a racist, narcissistic, egomaniac, and a terrible person. That being said, I am separating the artist from the art for this review. Especially because the majority of his unforgivable public behavior has taken place after this album came out. Kanye had a string of albums from College Dropout up to MBDTF that are fantastic. Just about every song on this album is a hit. It's crazy because of those albums I mentioned, this is not even his best imo. Kanye's use of sampling is unparalleled in the hip hop industry. Monster is probably my favorite song on this project but truly it's hard to pick because so many stand up to the rest of time even despite his antics in real life.

As crazy as Kanye is, he’s a musical genius and he knows it. Every album just hits. Can’t even put my finger on it-whether it’s the beats, the lyrics, the message of those lyrics, or the shock factor of some of the songs. Something just WORKS! This is an album I played on repeat to try to find a favourite song, but couldn’t narrow any down because they’re all great. Listen again: yes Purchase for my collection: yes Favourite Song: I went with All Of The Lights Interlude, because having an orchestra instrumental on a hip hop album is gold.

Moments of brilliance interspersed between self indulgent, bloated messes. It also has the cringiest title I’ve ever seen.

Many iconic tracks but its only worth the choruses

Too bad he's a psychopath

No to Nazis

I hate that I'm about to do this because KW is such a shithead, but fuck me this is a great album. Musically, he's a unicorn. Everything about the album (songwriting, rapping, singing, producing) is uniquely and unmistakably Kanye.

Starts off with really good beats and sounds. Towards the end it started to loose me, but overall I enjoyed it more than I wanted to

This person with not make one more cent off of me. F Kanye

fuck him. and his music, too.

Kayne is super fucked up. But this album is one of the best ever.

Kanye didn’t just make an album—he made a spectacle, a maximalist odyssey where orchestras, prog-rock samples, and rap bravado collide in glorious excess. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is the sound of an artist at his absolute peak, crafting a larger-than-life masterpiece that somehow justifies its own ego. From Nicki Minaj’s career-defining verse on Monster to the audacity of Runaway’s nine-minute self-indulgence, every moment is deliberate, every choice over-the-top in the best way possible. But greatness is a complicated thing. Once an album I played obsessively, MBDTF now gathers dust on my shelf, overshadowed by Kanye’s self-inflicted fall from grace. Can you separate the art from the artist when the artist won’t let you? That’s the lingering question. For now, the album remains a towering achievement—one that may be harder to love, but impossible to ignore.

Surprisingly interesting

Today's the fated day I have to listen to a Kanye West album in full. I have long rued this day, as Kanye West is an absolute tool who I wish would just go away from the public eye forever for everyone's sake. As terrible as he is his music remains critically acclaimed, with this project often regarded as his best. Never listened to it, and thought, especially after his recent outburst that, I never would. Of course as a result of being alive and concious during the last 15 years since this album came out, I've heard more than a couple of the songs from here. Let's hope I can remain objective during this reaction/review. Obligatory Fuck Kanye. Dark Fantasy Fun intro segment. RZA with a producer credit is usually a good sign. Great beat, the use of the sample works great. Some of the effects sound a bit dated. His delivery is fine. Overstays its welcome, the sample isn't so powerful that it's needed one last time at the end. Solid. 4/5 Gorgeous I love Cudi's part, though it sounds a muddled at certain points. Fantastic beat. The effect on Kanye's voice sucks. Solid verses from Kanye, though I don't always love his line delivery. The black balls line is terrible. Kanye's bravado has always rubbed me the wrong way, even "before" he went insane. Bloated song, beat gets stale. Fine. 3/5 Power Classic. Samples one of the best songs of all time, and implements it well. Produced magnificently. The asshole lines remain corny even after many listens. A great time, nostalgic. Begrugingly a fantastic track. 5/5 Interlude Does what an interlude should. Bridges one song into another. Interlude/5 All of the Lights Iconic horns. Rihanna's chorus kicks off the song marvelously. The cast on this song is extremely impressive. Many of the biggest stars of the early 2010s having features on one track is really fun. Anthemic song which represents the early 2010s well. Nostalgic. 4.5/5 Monster Crazy list of features. Production goes hard. Don't care for Rick Ross's verse. Fantastic performance on Kanye's verse. The hook isn't great. Jay-Z's verse has some fun writing. Charismatic verse from Nicki. Outro is fine. Fun track. 4/5 So Appalled Don't like the intro. Not really a fan of the squeeks on the beat. Flows well on top of the beat. Not much more to say, the performances are good, but nothing is grabbing me personally. Maybe longer than it needs to be. Could be a grower. Fine. 3/5 Devil in a New Dress Delicious sample implemention. There's some charming delivery here. The writing is oddly fantastic. The guitar interlude before the feature is great, when the sample comes in is pure bliss. Rick Ross is fine I guess, his voice is great for this, but I don't care much for the content of the verse. Good. 4/5 Runaway The famous piano intro. Some call this Kanye's peak. I like how the intro takes its time setting up the song. Almost a bit vulnerable in the delivery and lyrics. There might even be a bit of self-awareness here which is something I didn't know Kanye West was even capable of. The purely instrumental parts are for the lack of a better word, interesting. It's bold and refreshing sounding oddly beautiful at times. Great. 4.5/5 Hell of a Life Crunchy beat. Iron Man interpolation is terrible. Ambivalent about the lyrics. The storytelling is decent, but the lyrics veer on cringe territory. I don't like the moans. Kanye isn't very likable on this track. Did not like. 2/5 Blame Game Aphex twin song used as a sample is great. Avril 14th does however sound better without Kanye West and John Legend over it. The chorus is fine. The panning distorted vocals don't sound great, but I do like the idea behind it though. The phone part is extremely corny it's sacriligous to put this on top of Avril 14th, it's not funny or charming. Pure blasphemy. 1/5 Lost in the World Vocoder harmonies are fun. I like how the tempo shifts. Didn't find much to appreaciate outside of the production. Closes the album well. Decent. 3.5 Who Will Survive America Gil-Scott Heron! Preach. Interlude/5 A decent microcosm of the early 2010s. Great features, good performances and amazing production. The sample work is fantastic. And Kanye even manages to be likable on some of the tracks. Had a good time for the most part, though many of the songs strayed into overly long territory, where it felt like they ran out of steam. Also many of the attempts at humour fell flat, felt in bad taste or just straight up went over my head. And while Kanye is likeable on some tracks, he is extremely unlikable on others, getting to the point where I just want to block him out. I do recognize a personal bias which might affect my reaction to this piece, but I think I gave it a fair shot and probably liked it more than I thought I would. Fave track. Power Least fave track. Blame Game Rating. 3.5/5

He’s a very sick individual who occasinally makes good music. I just never listen to it freely - not only because he’s that person, but also because I really never cared about this type of music - it doesn’t really move me emotionally

Not a feminist masterpiece, but god how great is POWER?

It's alright. I wouldn't be gone on this but it's ok. No stand out song. I don't be listening to it again

I think we are at the time where everyone has more or less forgotten about Kanye's X crash out (since nobody is talking about it) so i don't think it will be too controversial if i say that i think that My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is a great album. I have had a somewhat mixed opinion on a lot of Kanye's lyrics but i will say that they in this album are not nearly as bad as the ones on Yeezus, but not as good as the ones in The College Dropout. However, what i think is better than both albums is the production. It took a massive step up and delivered some major bangers in basically all of the songs. Kanye might not be the greatest person but this album sure is his greatest. Best Song: All Of The Lights Worst Song: Dark Fantasy Side Note: And since this is the last of the Kanye West albums i will be looking at, here are my rankings 1. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy 2. The College Dropout 3. Yeezus

No hace mucho West era el Rey Midas Discos excepcionales uno tras otro hasta The Life of Pablo. Este puede ser su mejor disco y Runnaway con esa introducción de piano su mejor tema. Dark Fantasy, All of the lights, la inquietante Blame Game, Monster... colaboradores de lujo para auténticas gemas musicales Un disco esencial sin duda.

euh..?..? hoeveel kutplaten kan één mens maken?

Pretty good. Monster is a good song and Nikki Minaj is a surprisingly welcome addition. Power is also good, though it leans heavily on the King Crimson sample. However, Ye has clearly leant to far into the album title and his choices now cloud his earlier work (for us).

I do not give racist, Trump loving idiots listens on Spotify.

Wow. This album is crazy across the board. The production is so varied and unique. The features are all used so well. What an inspired album front to back. It sucks that this guy is so good at what he does, cause he really kind of sucks. Standouts: POWER, Monster, Runaway

Overall, this is one of the better albums I’ve heard from Kanye. He’s made tracks that I’ve really enjoyed, but he’s one of those artists I have a hard time taking seriously. He’s always out there rocking the boat, stirring up controversy just to keep the spotlight on himself, to the point where I find it hard to even want to listen to him.

Pre-listen, 3 of these tracks are already on my liked songs list. Solid album. I'm not a Kanye-as-a-person fan, and I wouldn't really consider myself a fan of Kanye-the-artist, but this album is good. Can't deny it. 4/5.

An all time favorite of mine, I’ve probably listened to this album 50 times now. Kanye isn’t a good man but man is this album good.

It's amazing how separated I am culturally from some types of music. Collectively, these songs have had about 4 BILLION listens on spotify, yet I hadn't heard (of) a single one of them. And are they good? Yeah they are fine. Like 2 or 3 stars fine. However, while I usually try to separate the art from the artist, this album does lose 3 stars for Kanye being a literal Nazi.

Ok, I'm no Kanye fan, but the front half of this album slaps. The back half gets real weird, and you can love it I think if you're thinking it's conceptual but with the time thats passed....not shocking that it's turned out this way. However, beside the weirdness, still good. Putting as a 4. Would probably be a 3 in rock, but for not liking a genre or a person...still wild and that counts.

I have listened to this album plenty of times. This album probably one of his best. I am not listening to Kanye these days.

This album is even better considering his situation back than and how he handled things. Sad how he turned out as a person. Music wise he was really on his peak and capturing the best out of people.

Proof a broken clock is correct twice a day, and the poster child for an argument for the separation of art and the artist

Fuck no, not even gonna listen to this N@zi shit

I actually really liked it as much as I hate to admit because Kanye’s an asshole nazi piece of shit

(i liked it sorry sorry sorry sorry)

Couldn’t bring myself to listen to this. One star is the minimum.

I know Kanye is a terrible individual but I really love his music. The production and arrangements are just so great, and I mean what’s better than a rapper sampling King Crimson? This is just so big and cool and interesting. Kanye is at his best here (I also really like 808 and heartbreak album, but that’s different). I’m not a hip hop expert but for me this is top 5-10 hip hop albums ever so easily five stars.

We don’t support Nazi’s. Can’t separate the music from the artist here. 0/5.

Oh Kanye. This will be my second Kanye album to review, and it’s his contribution to the list that I’m most familiar with. I was really blown away by this album when it came out, and it really shattered my ideas of what a hip-hop album could be. I got to see Kanye play at ACL in 2011, and I hate to admit it, but it was one of the best live performances I’ve ever seen in my life. The setlist was heavy on songs from this album, and the show was absolutely epic and grandiose in every way. I haven’t listened to this album in a while, mostly due to… *gestures at the general existence of Kanye in 2025* but I’m still excited to fire this album up today, because I know how much I like listening to this. It should be a crime for someone who’s as big of an asshole as Kanye to make an album this great. Seriously, what a waste of talent to make something like this and choose to be a Nazi scumbag. It’s infuriating. MBDTF is one of the most epic and bombastic albums I’ve ever listened to, and it sadly holds up incredibly well, almost fifteen years later. The production is my favorite aspect of this album. The beats, samples, and over-the-top musical arrangements are just a joy to listen to. I like the lyrics and rapping too, but the music is what hooked me on this album when it came out. “All of the Lights” is still my favorite song off of this album, if not one of my favorite songs of the 2010’s. Whenever that beat drops, I could run through a brick wall. I can’t think of many songs that are as pure of an adrenaline rush as this one. Those horns, the drums, Rihanna’s hook… everything about this song is fantastic. “Runaway” is in a close second to “All of the Lights” for my favorite song on the album. The opening piano riff sets the tone for the song so incredibly well, the beat is great, and the lyrics are fantastic. Granted, the self-reflection that Kanye seemed to exhibit in the lyrics don’t really seem so genuine these days, but at the time that this album came out, they really packed a punch. I still think they’re well written, even if they haven’t aged well. I’ll stop myself from writing more about the songs on this album, and wrap up by reiterating how much I love the music and production. Now I’m pissed off again that Kanye is a waste of talent. Even though I think this album is great, it’s not something I’ll listen to often, given who the artist is. Favorite line: “Too many Urkels, that’s why you’re wins low.”

Ich weiß, dass ich das Album mag, aber ich mag Kanye nicht

Leider gute Musik aber Werk vom Künstler nicht trennbar.

This is definitely an album by someone who lives in a Dark Fantasy…

Again I feel weird and uneasy cause I'm enjoying the music of a self-proclaimed Nazi. I guess I'm just a horrible person, but I kinda liked this album.

used to love this record but FUCK KANYE

Really debated not listening to this (an album I loved over 10 years ago but have rarely revisited) but ultimately too many artists on this list have done terrible, despicable things and I want to approach this as objectively about the actual music as possible so in the interest of completionism I listened. And I have to be honest, it’s still a 5 star album for me. So powerful and original, with such interesting production and some of my all-time favourite collaborations, with Nicki Minaj and Bon Iver. It really is the most definitive and creatively engaging collection in every way. What an awful shame.

To quote another reviewer, 5/5 album but 0/5 human being. Fuck the nazi bullshit.

I don't get it. Whatever message he's trying to give with this album, I can't identify myself with it. Musically is not that bad, but when I read about the production process I feel sick. 24 hours recording sessions for a guy that believes he's a god. I just can't take this kind of art. And besides, Kanye sucks now a days. In this case I can't separate the art from the artist. Fck this and fck him and all his enablers.

The imagery of bruising a woman’s oesophagus is not something I want in my head. It also passes up the chance to rhyme sarcophagus with “Mr Snuffleupagus”.

Sigh, Kanye does some wonderful work. Too bad he's turned into a controversial king of sorts. I'm giving this album 5 stars because of the artistry. If I were to include the artists' proclivities of Nazi worship, it would be one star.

I like Kanye West or Ye and a rapper I like his tone. I have his first 2 albums and Yeezus but lost interest in his later stuff. This album passed me by has some great songs on there however tails a bit off at the end and over long. A pleasant suprize.

This album raises the Leni Riefenstahl problem. She was a gifted German filmmaker in the 1930s. Her most significant work was "Triumph of the Will," a mesmerizing depiction of Nazi rallies in Nurnberg that was, above all things, a propaganda triumph for Hitler. She never repented of her work. Comparing people to Nazis is usually a pointless way to end reasonable discussion of an issue. But here, West is now a self-confessed Nazi. So the comparison seems apt. How does one assess his work in light of the fact that he is a thoroughly odious stain of a human being? Musically, it's got a lot going for it. But I can't get over the artist's moral depravity. Maybe this would be a harder call for me if it involved a morally problematic artist from my own youth such as Michael Jackson.

I don't like Nazis, so I didn't listen to this album beyond the Spotify-given clips. It sounded fine, I guess.

am afang hanis wükli no recht kuul gfunde, abem foifte song wirds aber teils lärmig und vor allem werded d songs eintönig (ussert de afang vo runaway aber denn passiert au nüt grosses meh). bi durs ganze album sochli hin und her gumpt zwüsched no kuul und laaangwiilig

I very much hate that this man makes (or made) really good music. Personal enjoyment: 4/5 Relevance to this list: 4/5 Kanye as a person: -100000000/5

Ugh Kanye. But I enjoyed this listen and the album art.

Production is really wild, opulent and experimental, no doubt Kanye is top tier musician, that said it feels like every song is 8 minutes long and they don’t all hit

It was alright. Honestly better than I wanted it to be given who the artist is but I can't deny that he has talent.

In his current mental health system, he's a terrible human being, I really hope he can get the help he needs. This album is objectively amazing and it's sad he's fallen so hard since.

I miss the old Kanye

5/5 production, what can I say

Yeah I know…in fiction it’s a lot of fun and entertainment when a genius goes mad, in real life it’s just sad

I don’t like Kanye as a person. He’s a douchebag. And it’s hard to listen to his music without picturing his stupid face and thinking about how much I dislike him. But I gave this two hard listens. I like his collab songs with others more than I like him by himself. In the end, though, there are only two or three songs on this album I’d gladly listen to again.

Killer beats, snap-wit lyrics, confidence on wax. Points off for being a Nazi fuckhead.

This guy is a piece of shit. The music is alright. I wasn’t much interested it back in 2010- sure am not now.

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is a milestone for Hip-Hop and one of the best albums ever made. It is an artistic, gorgeous look into Kanye’s mind as a person. The production, and alongside it, the samples, lyrics, and features, all come together in a perfect way to create this masterpiece of an album. Not to mention, Kanye managed to get Rick Ross to pour his soul into his feature on the track “Devil In a New Dress” and he still hasn’t topped it since even on his solo work, and this album also kickstarted Nicki Minaj’s career by featuring her on “Monster” despite the fact her verse surpassed everyone else. To say this album had a cultural impact is an understatement. If someone doesn’t understand what makes Kanye so loved as an artist even after everything he has done, show them this album. I’ll admit I have a bit of a bias because this album is the one that make me love hip-hop as a genre as someone who listened to mainly rock before, but now I’m a diehard fan of it. If any album deserves to be called a magnum opus I think it’s this one. Favorite Tracks: Dark Fantasy, Devil In a New Dress, Lost In The World, So Appalled, Power, Runaway, and Hell of a Life.

M'eh, standard rap, nothing at all to reoemmend it

I’m a casual hip hop consumer at best. Enjoyed this album but the first half was just ok. Standard fair guest artist featured w Kanye on fair/good tracks. Second half of the album saw styles expand, get more creative and move away from standard hip hop tropes. Second half was preferred.

Say what you want, but it's a surprisingly good album.

Of all artists to feel conflicted about, Kanye West might win the Most Conflicted About award. I really used to be a huge fan, and this album was my favorite. I haven’t listened to it in a long time, because he is way past “off the deep end,” and I really don’t fuck with Nazis. But most of the things I used to love about this album, particularly its production and certain verses and samples, I still love. It just feels tainted now; it used to be a victory and now it’s a tragedy. The fact that Kanye used to be self-aware to such an extent just hurts to witness. He could have responded to the feelings that created this album in a better way. Oh well. He enjoyed being a douchebag, an asshole, a scumbag, too much and disappeared into that persona. RIP. Anyway, despite no longer feeling like it’s a five-star album, I do think it’s still a must-listen, if nothing else than as a cautionary tale. #81.

Separating art from artist, 5 star album, 1 star person. Dude needs help, desperately. My favorite of his albums.

Better that i expected

I love this album. Reminds me of when I was first getting into music and figuring out what I liked. I was so enamored by the sound of this album. The production is next level. The features are perfect - love Kid Cudi's vocals. Nicki eats. What a collection of songs. My personal favorite being Lost In The World, such a pretty melody and love Bon Iver's feature.

Kanye is one of those artists where I really have to separate the art from the artist. He was never a humble or well adjusted guy, but he has completely gone over the edge in recent years. This may be his greatest album, and possibly the last great album he will release. Kanye’s roots are in production and he puts those skills to great use here. Kanye is an ok rapper, but his ear for finding samples is among the best to ever do it.

It’s ok, there is way better rap out there. Not a must listen album

Masterpiece.

more rap, but not terrible - includes King Crimson sample

Non fa per me, non mi piace

The "21st Century Schizoid Man" sample is perfect, it's exactly what he has devolved to right now. Standout: All Of The Lights

the best rap album of all time, nothing will ever sound as arrogant or rich as this. the chris rock skit is a bit long but who cares, this album is great.

nope - too much swearing.

Too bad he doesn't care about anything other than seeking attention nowadays. "Name one genius that ain't crazy" I guess.

Ikkje mitt favorittalbum av Ye

i hope he takes his medication and says wholesome not-bad things

I enjoyed it, not sure it's something I'd listen to all the way through again, some good songs though

I have never listened to a Kanye album and I am 100% not going to start now. This is a real bummer because I was really looking forward to listening to something new today. At least there is only one more certified nazi album I have to skip on this list (that I know of). It is kind of strange that both Kanye albums I have gotten have been pretty soon after one of his major meltdowns. I can't wait to see what happens right before I get Yeezus. Lowest 1 imaginable.

"He made Graduation, he made MBDTF..." It's sad and pathetic what he's become, but the album is unimpeachable. Kanye's sexual and emotional pathologies are on display here, and in hindsight it's clear he was doomed. "21st Century Schizoid Man" is perfectly apt, Kanye is finely attuned to the spirit of the age, sadly we live in degraded and stupid times. Great craftsmanship endures, idiots like Trump and Musk will die. His regrettable later output and antics don't matter, this album rocks.

Because I can’t give zero stars

HELLLL YEAHHHHH Hadn’t listened through it all in a long time and I forgot how good it is No bad songs

very good. POWER is so fucking good. Def would listen to some songs on a daily basis

wildly good, i just wish when he said 'no one man should have all that power' he wasnt talking about jews. everyone wanted to be on a kanye track until ... they didnt. 5/5, and also 1/5

Unfortunately, it bangs. Absolutely undeniable. Every time I hear a familiar voice and I’m like, “is that - ?”, it is. Rihanna, Chris Rock, Fergie, John Legend. The features are insane. The songs are catchy. The whole album sounds so goddamn good. Idk what’s going on in this man’s head but there was beauty there once.

Too bad Kanye was and continues to be crazy cuz he clearly knows how to make an album. Chris Rick’s bit goes on a bit too long tho.

Not for me at all. No thanks.

Was good until he started rapping.

I can separate the man from the art. Or I think I can. I usually find his stuff ‘ok’ but this was tiresome

Loved this. Never had it on before. Bonus King Crimson sample on Power

Wow I love this album

love the album, sad for the artist

A reluctant five stars. This is a great album by a very complicated protagonist. I'm going to put it in the sarcophagus.

First time listening, pleasantly surprised. Lyrics are questionable at times, but the production is top notch.

Absolute garbage

KW's best. What happened?

Difficult to listen to someone who has become a Nazi.

I don't think I've ever heard the P-word on an album as much as I have on this one. The production sounded good, but I'm not into this.

First one on here that I have listened to previously and still sounds as good as when I first listened to it. Yeah he sucks as a person, but this one has no skips and I’m only judging the music. Lost in the world a favorite

Just couldn’t bring myself to listen

Very sick. I knew some of these before but I'd never listened to the album outright. I definitely found some new bangers. And loved all the bon iver and other features!!

Never heard this album before, probably won’t listen to it again. Scratch that, I’m sure some trainer on Peleton will mix this into the next cycle class. Ho hum.

Elements of this were OK. The overall music was good, the supporting vocals were good, production good. Then the rapping began! Tolerated it for a bit but had to turn off. I am no fan of hip hop. I don't like it, I don't get it. Because Elements of it were OK it gets 2 stars

Kanye West is complicated artist and person. He's created some of the most influential, inspiring and divisive music in the 00's. That being said this is an amazing album. You absolutely have to separate the artist from the art.

Απιστευτες παραγωγες με ροκ στοιχεια. Δεν μπορω να πιστεψω οτι τοσο καιρο αγνοουσα τα 3 4 κομματια που δεν ειχα ακουσει. Σγρα 5, κλασσικ

Not my normal genre of choice. My son loves him and has tried to get me to listen so I was always dreading the day a Kanye West album came up. But you know it wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be. Haha The Chris Rock bit at the end of Blame Game made me laugh out loud and some of the language I found a bit harsh.

Kanye is nuts, but I remember enjoying this 💿 in 2010. Upon relisten… it holds up really well. Surprised.

Production on this album is insane, as everyone before me has already said. Everything sounds very intentionally crafted, and it really pays off. It's incredible how many iconic songs from the early 2010s all come from this album. Rating this is hard, because while the production is insane and the songs are very iconic, he's a trash human being, and I think that slips out into his lyrics every once in a while. I don't think it's a 10/10 because of that. But God damn is this a really good album. It's also just incredibly high quality from beginning to end. Even the non-hits are just really good songs. Favorite Song(s): POWER, All of the Lights, Devil in a New Dress, Runaway

Time reveals strange things.

Not a nice dude but what an epic journey

Reiferes Rap Album. Weniger N-Worte und mehr Musik und mehr Melodie verbunden mit netten Experimenten. Diese Mischung macht es, trotz des schwierigen Genres teilweise hörbar. „All of The Lights“, „Runaway“ und „Blame Game” versprühen einen Hauch von Musik.

I can't name a best song, so the worst song was Lost in the world.

“This week has been a bad massage, I need a happy ending.” “Head of the class and she just won a swallowship” I mean, it’s a shame that Kanye is a straight up Nazi.

“Greatest ever” gets thrown around a little too easily sometimes, but greatest rap album ever? Definitely on the Mt. Rushmore. Fuck this dude on every level as a human, but this is a no skips album. Monster” has lived rent free in my subconscious for a decade and a half.

I always thought this guy was weird and outside of a handy recapping of all the kinds of lights that there are, I sure got no use for him now. There's some good beats here and there, such as the Afromerica on Power, Mike Oldfield on Dark Fantasy, which really showcase his strengths as a producer. He's got strengths on the microphone as well, but this dude is clearly not a genius. This kind of hip hop album is aspirational that serves to hype people up but Kanye is not a smart, calculated, thoughtful person, so the accomplishments don't feel earned. Look, if Kanye got on the mic and acknowledged that he was a menace, and nothing more, like he does on the track Monster, this would land hard. Instead he goes off about how he's a complicated Godly man, full of misunderstood purity and none of his identities hold water anymore. Fast forward to now, this guy is still contradicting himself. Bottom line is that when I heard this the first time in 2010 I heard a talented man with a cringey god-complex. 15 years later tell me I'm wrong. This album works best when there are extended instrumental sections that remind you of the artist within, the problem is that Kanye never shuts the fuck up for long enough for those moments to last.

4.5★. No longer my favorite album, as it once was, nor even my favorite Kanye (College Dropout and Yeezus share that honor), and although there are some bathetic blotches throughout (black balls lines in Gorgeous, "picture of my dick" line in Runaway, that entire Chris Rock voice message on Blame Game, even though it's hilarious) this is still 13 tracks with not a single miss as far as I'm concerned. It's like Outkast's Stankonia in that sense, and while Kanye's rapping - outside of Gorgeous - isn't anywhere as impressive, the maximalist production is incredible.

Shame he’s a dick because this is excellent.

Good stuff but cant stand the guy

Not for me

You know, I don't like Kanye as a person, which is annoying because he's actually really good at this.

Ugh I like this but hate Kanye

kenya dear i like you as a concept but your music is giving me migranes

Not my taste

I already love this album so this is easy. This is the album where Kanye finally figured it out. There's no skits thank god, but almost everything else you love from Kanye is here. Hard-hitting, sample-heavy beats? Check. Decadent verses that paint perfect pictures of the highs and lows of fame? Check. Tounge-in-cheek humor interspaced throughout? Super check. Not only does Kanye do some of his best rapping on this one, but the features all understand that we are here to make some of the best raps ever. Except Hov, I don't know why his verse on "Monster" is bad, but it's just lackluster to me. Other than that, everyone else kills it. My favorite track is probably, "Devil In A New Dress." The Smokey sample, the bassline, the breakdown with the strings losing their minds, how Rozay comes in after that insane Mike Dean guitar solo. Just everything. Is this Ye's best? No, but this is his purest album. I used to say this album was too perfect. Everything you'd want from a rap album is here, you don't need much else.

Can you separate an artist from their art? Hard to say. Some amazing tracks here, masterfully produced. Runaway, Monster, Power. Lots of self-aggrandizing, getting high on money and fame, at first glance doesn't seem to be one of Kanye's more vulnerable albums. On a closer listen, he's talking about negotiating mental illness when his sickness and his creativity go hand in hand; getting rich on being outrageous, provocative, leaning into psychosis. Why tone things down when mania feels so good (and makes him so successful)? Great collaborations in this album as well. Hard to fully enjoy knowing that Kanye is a racist, antisemitic, sexist, narcissistic asshole.

Interesting. Music quite good. Lyrics interesting but not usually my thing - but also not a put-off

4/5 last good Kanye album before he went crazy? (Or was he all along)

Back half is awful. Disrespected Aphex Twin. Groaner lines from ye all around. Classic.

Neću uopće trošiti riječi. 1/5, 1/10.

Meh. Not necessarily my thing.

Don’t care for this genre of music.

I can sum up what makes me hate this record in one lyric: "'Cause the same people that tried to black ball me/ Forgot about two things, my black balls" (from "Gorgeous"). I don't care. Congratulations... and people ate this shit up like he was a god-like rapper and lyricist. Look, this isn't my favorite genre, it wasn't fed to me along with my fentanyl-laced fruit loops. I don't know who the guest spots are by, I just listened based on pure sonics and lyrics. It's funny to think a few albums ago in my list people were complaining about the lyrics to a Motorhead album. These are a thousand times worse. The lyricist here comes off like a horrible, juvenile, misogynistic, paranoid, narcissistic, sociopathic person, there's just no way around it. And a lot of the lyrics are obviously references to little petty squabbles. That shit just isn't going to stand the test of time. The backing tracks are varied and interesting, at least. I was actually interested to dive into this partly because I'd always heard Yeezy was such an innovator back in the day. Man. Actual innovators need to take note of "Lookin' at my bitch, I bet she give your ass a bone", "I sent this bitch a picture of my dick", and other golden aphorisms. I guess it took big balls to stretch a 3 minute song ("Runaway") out to 9 minutes, or use a Black Sabbath melody to spruce up a hypnotic throwaway x-rated jam ("Hell of a Life"). "Lost in the World" ended up being the only tolerable, fully-formed track for me. Maybe because Gil Scott Heron was invoked? ... but then the last track just straight-up lifts GSH's message, perhaps trying to bring some gravitas to a record that doesn't have any. This record makes no sense and has no merit outside of the time, place and context in which it was made. Will they be teaching it in 400 years like Chaucer is taught today? I doubt it.

still a classic but my god. he sounds soooo pathetic

Not every song is a classic (no, I'm not that hot on "Devil in a New Dress") and reminiscing about it makes harder to swallow the fact that Kanye is less than a shadow of who he used to be now... but it's still packed with bangers and one of the albums that introduced me to the endless possibilities offered by sampling. So... yeah, classic album.

I don't know... this just isn't my cup of tea. Just from a production standpoint I feel like it's all too over produced. And I don't think I can separate what I know about what kind of person Kanye is from his music. Not sure he can be separated though because who he is really comes through in his lyrics. Sexist, megalomaniac. I enjoyed "Runaway" because I once used it in a Bud Light spot and the Bon Iver track was ok.

Didn't think it was good. Rhymes were so-so. Production was nice. First Kanye album I've ever listened to but I do trend towards JARV and Aesop Rock and Blackalicious more.

Канье типа крутой, много видимо значимых личностей на фите, но чёт не мое

enjoyed much more than i thought i would. 4/5

With the benefit of hindsight: was the King Crimson sample a plea for help?

Went in thinking this had one star written all over it. If my rating took account of my view of the artist as a person, it would be. However, taking the album on its own, there really are some great tracks.

Meh had some hits

Song-by-Song Review: My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy Dark Fantasy The opening track feels like stepping into a grand theater. With its lush strings, booming beats, and Kanye's self-aware lyrics, it’s a triumphant, almost mythic introduction to the album’s world. Gorgeous (ft. Kid Cudi & Raekwon) A gritty, guitar-driven track where Kanye delivers sharp, socially charged lyrics, complemented by Kid Cudi’s hypnotic hook. It’s raw and rebellious, setting a darker tone. Power This is Kanye at his most defiant. The tribal drums and chants amplify the larger-than-life energy, while the lyrics wrestle with fame and self-destruction. It’s electrifying and unforgettable. All of the Lights A chaotic symphony of horns, drums, and over-the-top features, this anthem thrives on maximalism. The lyrics touch on loss and redemption, grounded by Rihanna’s soaring chorus. Monster (ft. Nicki Minaj, Jay-Z, Rick Ross, & Bon Iver) Dark, menacing, and unforgettable. Nicki Minaj steals the show with a jaw-dropping verse, while the eerie production makes it feel like a hip-hop horror movie. So Appalled A moody posse cut dripping with cynicism. Kanye and his collaborators reflect on wealth and excess over a haunting, minimal beat. It’s introspective and deeply layered. Devil in a New Dress (ft. Rick Ross) This smoky, soulful track is a standout. Kanye’s vulnerable storytelling pairs perfectly with the lush production, and Rick Ross delivers one of his career-best verses. Runaway (ft. Pusha T) A stunning centerpiece. The piano intro is iconic, and the track’s theme of self-sabotage is devastatingly honest. Pusha T’s verse adds sharp contrast to Kanye’s raw emotion. Hell of a Life Blending industrial beats with provocative lyrics, this song feels like a twisted daydream about indulgence and excess. It’s chaotic yet captivating. Blame Game (ft. John Legend) Heartbreaking and introspective, Kanye dives into the wreckage of a failed relationship. John Legend’s haunting vocals amplify the track’s emotional weight. The spoken outro is divisive but memorable. Lost in the World (ft. Bon Iver) Ethereal and uplifting, this track merges Bon Iver’s atmospheric sound with Kanye’s introspection, building to a euphoric crescendo. It’s a beautiful exploration of love and identity. Who Will Survive in America A spoken-word outro that critiques societal inequities, it’s a sobering close to an otherwise opulent album. The Gil Scott-Heron sample is poignant and thought-provoking. Each song on My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy feels like its own cinematic moment, contributing to an album that’s as much a personal confession as it is a grand artistic statement.

1/13/25. This one is a classic for me, still remember when it came out and listened over and over again. Peak Kanye and appreciate him pushing the rap genre forward with this.

Well, that was good. I tried getting into Kanye a few years after this came out and I didn't get it. I think I do now

Love the wordplay in this album. Hip hop and rap are really not what I listen to normally but it was cool to spend some time in the thought process of a self proclaimed genius. I do not think I will listen to this album again but it was a nice diversion to what I normally listen to.

Great album

Big sound and impressive production.

Not my style, but I thought it was undeniable in sound and production. Kanye West is a force as a producer, but only adequate as an MC. I think his talents outshine his boringly self-centered lyrics and average mic work to make a very impressive album.

forced to admit once again that this shit head makes good music

Hate filled man has breakdown .mp3

Despite the actions of Kanye this is a great album. Loved nearly everything on here. 5 stars

The hits carry the album

No mal disco de rap, pero se sabe que no es mi género. Y 70 minutos es demasiado rap, pero no la pasé mal. Le ayudan mucho las colaboraciones, le dan bastante variedad.

нормалек. никогда раньше не слушал этого чела, относился предвзято, как и ко всему хип-хопу этих времен. оказалось довольно прикольно. еслть красивые мелодии, местами даже напоминает тейм импалу)

Can’t give 0 but atrocious album and human

Fck Kanye

I really think Kanye is a genius. Some of the songs on here are incredible. I just wish he’d clean it up.

Ok, so this was super surprising because I can't stand Kanye as a man. So I never listened to this album before. There are SO many guests on it. I really liked all the songs except 2. This one was an hour and 8 minutes. Some bangers on here. "All of the Lights"... It was produced by West and features additional vocals from several other recording artists, including John Legend, The-Dream, Drake, Alicia Keys, Fergie, Elton John, Ryan Leslie, Charlie Wilson, Tony Williams, La Roux, Alvin Fields, Ken Lewis, Kid Cudi, and Rihanna; the latter two are credited on the official music ...

Modern masterpiece! So much I could say about this one… a thorough exploration (and critique) of fame and Kanye’s own psyche. Most of the album is him playing a character, but inspired by his past and his thoughts and the pressures of fame. Absolutely titanic rap album that completely changed the game

As despicable of a person I think this guy is not a bad record

Wow. Never been a hip-hop guy, but there's so much to unpack here. And I know that he's kinda problematic, but this is a really good record. I guess it's all about being problematic, in a way, about what it's like to be Kanye, with some thoughts about how he got like that, but how everyone wants to be on his record anyway. Was he forgiveable in 2010?

One of the best hip hop albums of all time. Truly groundbreaking in its style and music. So many exceptional tracks. So many phenomenal guest artists. Kanye is a bit nuts now, but that album will forever stand the test of time.

Lots of noise and beats. Runaway was okay

I don't think it's possible to defend Kanye or his behavior. However, this album would be less interesting if it was a defense, or an apology. I'm sure it's frustrating that he's so arrogant and misogynistic and crazy but that's what makes him a captivating and (not sure how else to describe this) well-written character. Musically this is a delight. I like the over-the-top noise on some tracks, and the haunting minimalist piano on others. He makes good use of samples and guest musicians. Even if Kanye himself hasn't aged well, I think the album has, with its bravado and undertone of mental illness. Or maybe the past fifteen years have just been the rest of the world crashing down to his level.

I'm gonna echo this person's five-star review from Feb. 2021: "Classic. Sadly, he's crazy now" I think this is a perfect album. Kanye's expressiveness is captivating, and his ability to weave in samples, features, and styles is unmatched. There are so many magical moments: the "so exciting/suicide" part in Power, Nicki's verse on Monster, the piano in Runaway... No skips, five stars.

I'm so excited this came up. This is kanyes magnum opus. It is a perfect representation of the music scape of the early 2010s.

Ye comes through again. Hey may be cray but tracks just flow out of that brain.

sags a bit after runaway, but it wouldn't be the best album of whichever decade it belongs to if we lost "yeezy taught me." an incredible album all the more because of its flaws, meanderings, and self-indulgence. he err... reupholstered the game with this one.

I was surprised by this album. I liked it. Maybe its 20mins too long but not bad

It's nigh impossible for me to review this album in a vacuum from where I sit in 2025, for obvious (I'm assuming) reasons. Instead, I'll give the review that I feel like I would have given it back in 2010. Great listen, most for the beats and the features. The flows from Kanye (I don't think he would've been \"Ye\" or \"Yeezus\" yet in 2010) are fine. He's fine! But he's overshadowed on many tracks: by Rick Ross on Devil in a New Dress; by Rihanna on the All of the Lights hook; and by Pusha-T on Runaway and So Appalled. Several skips for sure, but the few great songs are legit great thanks to the supporting cast. (Fun fact: the All of the Lights interlude was my ringtone for several years.)

Not a Kanye fan at all, but Power and All of the Lights are certified stadium bangers, the rest is kinda forgettable for me. Loved the instrumentals for most of the songs but I hate his voice in most of them

I think my primary takeaway was I need to listen to more Rihanna. I perk up every time I hear her voice. I definitely laughed when he referenced his South Park episode, lol. There were other fun pop culture references, but most of them felt shoehorned in. Overall a pretty fun listen with some quality stuff though.

There's some bangers on here, and much to my surprise I have heard some Kanye tracks before (POWER, though I can't recall where I've heard it before). This isn't a listen to the whole album kind of album for me, honestly the best parts were any time Kanye wasn't providing vocals. I'd wager people who heard this when it was new have different feels on it, for me I'm hearing it for the first time in the "Kanye loves Hitler" era which has heavily altered the listening experience for me.

Not an interesting album by Kanye standards. It takes the spirit of Graduation and Dropout (both amazing albums) to push recycled tropes in a directionless manner. The album intro: an airy voice providing a bit of non-sense narration has been done sooo many times. But does he do something inventive? Does she become a character like on ATCQ:Midnight Marauders? No. Does she reappear later to provide insight or relatability? No. Does she provide any value at all besides clicking off the cliche check-box? No. She's included only to say: what follows is semi-clever fully-confused claptrap. This is just the first three seconds, I know. But everything on here is a rehash, and it just gets boring. Unacceptable for anyone calling themselves the GOAT.

Better than I expected.

I once saw Kanye's magnum opus, My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, described as the first and maybe only prog rap album. It's an apt description for this perfect maximalist extravaganza. The production is lush, orchestral, and operatic. Ye has perfected using the human voice as the greatest of all instruments. 15 years after it's release, Fantasy remains so fresh it still sounds futuristic. It is now 2025, and in my view this is the best album recorded in the 21st century. That's not to say there are no weak points. Jay Z's verse on Monster and the skit on Blame Game are glaring misses. But these miscues stick out in part because they are surrounded by a sea of brilliance. Lyrically, Ye preaches his devotion to hedonism, and also explores the effects of his fame and notoriety. Kanye is in peak form, and delivers some of the most quotable bars ever written. He is more boastful than ever, which is saying a lot for a guy whose pride has pride. Ye also consistently manages to capture incredible work from his features. Nicki Minaj, almost everybody on So Appalled, and especially Rick Ross all arguably deliver career best verses. Fantasy proved to be the apex of a nearly perfect stretch of records for Ye. I guess you can be this unapologetic and arrogant if you make nothing but masterpieces. This pimp truly was on Mount Olympus. Favorites: POWER, Runaway, Devil in a New Dress Least Favorites: Monster

Prefer Kanye when the production is more out there but damn this shit hits.

Kanye is, as we know, is problematic, racist, sexist etc. He was also one of the most fun shows I ever went to and it was right after yeezus so we was still repping this songs on his concert. Equally grand, over indulgent, really personal, and insane, this is a hip hop album I'd recommend to anyone. A true stadium experience from a very troubled person. Dark Fantasy is an unforgettable intro. Power and all of the lights are fantastic singles with ridiculous samples and instrumentation (elton john??). Monster is one of his best rap songs with also problematic Jay-Z but a killer verse from Nicki Minaj. The Blame Game is beautiful. Devil in a Red Dress is cool. Gorgeous has a cool Turtles sample. Lost in the World and Who will Survive in America are great closers.

Fuck Kanye but I can see why his fans are so annoying about him

monumental produziertes rap-album. gefällig, aber irgendwie dann doch nicht meins.

Mir ist dieser Rap etwas zu funky.

You had to be there to fully get it, I think. And I mean that literally. Not that you aren’t able to get it if you weren’t there, but I can’t really describe the impact of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy to anyone who wasn’t a hip-hop fan in 2010. At the time, I didn’t know this was the beginning of the end. This was the last CD I ever pre-ordered. The day it came out, I took the day off from my after-school barista job, took the back exit to the senior parking lot so I could leave campus first, and drove down to the FYE at the strip mall by the grocery store where my mom worked. After admiring the packaging for what felt like forever, I put it into the CD changer, reclined the driver’s seat, and listened. It was a very 17 year old way to listen to an album, especially one you anticipated to be an instant classic, but I couldn’t have asked for a better first listen. I remember the weather being unusually warm for New England in the November (at least at the time) and the sky was a gorgeous shade of pink as the sun sank and I listened to Kayne rap about his biggest insecurities, which were also his biggest accomplishments. I listened a second time as soon as it finished, and got half way through a third listen before my Mom came out from her shift, and I took her home, since I split the car with my parents, and thus has to turn off that “noise” while we drove. Once I was home, though, I immediately switched to watching the ✨film✨ that came with my pre-order. To say My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy was brilliant is one thing, and to say it was an instant classic is another. But to say I was obsessed would’ve been the understatement of the century. As an album, as music, I’ve heard this 1,000,001 times between its release in 2010 through 2016, which is around the time when I first realized his antics and ethos no longer aligned with mine. I returned to his other albums from time to time, but MBDTF was like a bug in amber. I’d heard it so many times, I knew every note. I was obsessed– why would I need to revisit it any more? MBDTF prayed on that very obsession. If you liked music in the late 2000s, you were obsessed with Kanye, obsessed with his media spirals. Sure, Kanye’s debacle of 2009 feels decidedly tame 15 years later, when he’s a fascist addicted to nitrous who poses “girlfriends” as pornographic props and makes mind-bogglingly atrocious music that is completely– for lack of a better way of saying it– ideologically conservative, but for the time, the Kanye of 2008-2010 felt just as insane, just as encompassing, and certainly demanded and commanded more attention from the general public. If you were up on pop culture, you were up on Kanye West, and if you were up on Kanye West, you were up on the minuscule details about the situation, which meant you knew that he was a “jackass,” to quote Obama, but also, a generational talent in the music world, and if you liked music, you had your fingers crossed that his tortured genius would produce great art. That great art– this album– literally depends on you knowing the pop culture context of Kanye, to know the details and gravitas as it was happening in real time. It expected you to have an opinion, to know where both defenders and detractors stood, and to have chosen a side– and it didn’t even necessarily ask you to choose Ye’s side, either. It wasn’t going to go over those details, you had to do the homework before class started, but that homework was required to understand a goddamn thing we were going to talk about on this album. And that’s what I mean when I say you had to be there to get it. Literally, you had to be alive, reading the tabloids and the blogs and watching MTV. It was a time before Rap Genius, before you could look up the fish sticks line, when the weight of “MJ gone” was just the attitude du jour, when Kayne’s bars could be schizophrenically celebratory and suicidal and you knew why based on everything you knew from the tabloids, the blogs, and MTV. You also had to know about the hype around Kid Cudi at the time, the renewed chart success of Jay, the Datpiff buzz around Nicki, the hipster kid buzz around Bon Iver, the importance of Pusha T showing up solo from the Clipse, etc etc. I’m sure when people listen to MBDTF today, once they’re able to separate the horrible artist from the art when it was still good and he wasn’t so obviously terrible but rather broken, it still sounds good, as music, as hip-hop. It is lush, with immaculate production and engaging beats. It’s been almost a solid decade since I revisited MBDTF in earnest, and yet I still remember all the nerdy, behind-the-scenes studio breakdowns that made this the album it is, all the liner notes and samples and references, and they’re all still impressive to me. That said, I’m shocked how muddy I found the mix by today’s standards, but there’s still a clear level of maximalist glory that washes over you. As music, it still sounds ornate and overpowering. But today, does the content – the fascination with Kanye West as a tragic hero – hold any cultural value or have any actual impact on the listener, who might not know the Kaynetothe forum chatter? I don’t fucking know. I’m physically incapable of listening to MBDTF in a vacuum and rating it fairly. It’s not even my favorite Kanye album, and it’s still a perfect listen to me. But I say all this to say, I don’t know if it deserves the acclaim it’s achieved over the years, and that I also understand why someone would hate this album, not only on ethos and principles about listening to an antisemitic dirtbag, but for not giving a fuck about the context or the content. I, however, am incredibly biased, because I was there to fully get it when it first dropped.

My favorite of his albums.

Potentially a perfect project

in my opinion, the most overrated ye album. it's too long (see: runaway second half (sorry!), hell of a life, blame game), and the entire thing has this low-fidelity, grainy rock sound on it in service of the maximalist theming. that being said, it's still pretty damn fantastic, and absolutely deserves its spot on this list. also, see me know is one of ye's best bonus tracks - that asphalt line kills me every time.

Some highlights (runaway and power) otherwise pretty standard stuff. listenable but not engageable

Slightly annoying that some of the tracks on this are really quite good (e.g. POWER) because the guy is clearly an absolute bell.

how did this garbage even end up on this list

I'm pleasantly surprised. For me the name Kanye West was let's say controversial. Now I understand why he is so famous (for his work). Previously, I was not particularly thrilled about Rap/Hip Hop. 5 stars for making me reevaluate a whole genre. Just to stress this: Given how negative I view his behavior, it was an uphill battle. It's a complex album. Every song sounds unique. I will listen again.

Dark Fantasy 7/10 - A bit repetitive, nice production, good lyrics. Gorgeous 7/10 - Enjoyed the beat... Power 7/10 - Was not expecting King Crimson... Not sure if I like the song because of that although I like the synths. A tad bit pretentious... All of the lights 8/10 - Enjoyed the Rihanna part. Monster 6/10 - It's alright, not a fan of the Nicki Minaj part So Appalled 6/10 - A bit long Devil in a new dress 6/10 - Don't remember this song Runaway 9/10 - Banger, but was it necessary to draw out the outro though with auto tune voiced synths ? Hell of a life 8/10 - Blame game 6/10 - Liked the first half... Lost in the world 7/10 - Enjoyable first half, drags on. Who will survive in America 6/10 - Overall : 3 stars (70%) It's got it's own charm, although a bit ostentatious and over the top at times but the production is nice, some songs drag out for a bit too long. It might grow on me in the future, but for now there's only All of the lights and Runaway that I would consider listening to.

all opinions of the man aside, this is a great album. i still think either Yeesus or 808's is his best but i think im in the minority there...

Not too proud to say this but My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is the album that got me into hip hop. I was but a teenager, born and raised on the most milquetoast metal and rock bands imaginable, hand-waving rap as an extension of top 40 radio. How naive! The deep complexity of the genre holds incredible value, which some may view as unconventional or undeserving, but this is what made me open my eyes. A masterclass in sample-flipping, MBDTF finds the perfect pace, perfect energy, perfect placement for each song and beat incorporated into the tracklist. Features and guest verses are wide and varied, fleshing out each song and giving the spotlight to some excellent artists along the way. Even comedian Chris Rock delivers an incredible outro skit near the end of the album, providing some relief before the incredibly hard-hitting closing tracks. You really don't get an album with this level of quality from that many features, but here we are. Building on a number of themes revolving around fame, hedonism, and intimacy makes this a potent listen from top to bottom. It's hard to comprehend how thorough MBDTF is in almost every aspect. Is this the distilled essence of music as an artform in the 21st century? West makes a compelling case. Yes, there's an elephant in my room. Kanye West has since made this a difficult listen for me because of his actions in recent years. I did not stream this, but I still listened from a group of mp3s I had readily available. Hard not to recognize a man who was so great in his artistic vision and ability, but could not make himself into a better man otherwise. I hold this album in high regard, even to this day, but I also recognize that there's some tough realities that needs to be reckoned with alongside such an album.

Well, that was something. Another recording where it felt that not only was it not intended for me but it was explicitly not intended for an audience of people like me. From what I have learned, this album represented a change in direction for Kanye West. Quite an array of contributors. The anger over injustice is intertwined with self importance and sex. Still a lot of talent, but I don't need to hear KW's whole catalog in my life.

jel se treba

Kanye may be crazy, but is music is original and powerful - I very much enjoyed this album. Just NSFW!

one of my favourite rap albums already, listening again is just so fun, 'Power' and 'All of the lights' back to back just makes you feel powerful.

Jeg var ganske spent på det albumet her siden jeg elsker Power, men det her gjorde ikke så mye for meg as. Ikke så overraskende, det er langt ifra min sjanger. Jeg satte pris på skalaen på albumet og generelt hvor mye variasjon det er i ideene, men det blir litt slitsomt og repetetivt i lengden. Hadde sikkert fått en annen mening etter flere lytt, men får se om det blir noe av mer av det. Beste sanger: Power, Dark Fantasy og All of the Lights

Ja, Kanye West er en løk, men dette er dessverre fortsatt et veldig bra album. De første 5 sangene er en helt fantastisk rekke, og det holder seg bra etter det og (med unntak av Chris Rock sketchen, "Yeezy reupholstered my pussy" 🤮) Et rap-album like storslått og dramatisk som en av Eirik sine prog-skiver.

This whole album sounds great. It's his best stuff probably, because it's so rich and interesting, and he is neither of those things. Also he's a twat.

Very good. Kanye is a musical genius

It’s fine. There are individual songs that I find undeniably great. But I’m not convinced this entire album is at the same level.

Incredibly nostalgic album for me, and upon listening again, it holds up remarkably well. It's an eerie and uncomfortable foreshadowing of the special brand of opulence and egotism that defines the 2020s, the artist that engineered this album, and several of its featured musicians. Instrumentally and texturally brilliant, but it's the atmospheric and cultural implications the album imparts that give it its uncanny quality. To those who heard it when it first appeared, listen now - it’s even stranger, and far sadder. It has too little innocence.

First Listen: July 20 2020 OMG PEAK WTF. god-tier album i don't have to say anything. back when kanye glaze was understandable

An album that for some reason is always described as maximalist. Not a perfect album by any means but the highs are so high. The first 3 tracks plus Devil in a New Dress are probably my favorites, mostly because the production is so good. The 30 Rock line on Gorgeous is a highlight. There are a lot of features and almost all are great. Overall an essential rap album.

Idk if y'alls schools did senior assassins but i ended up chasing after this guy through a park to get him out and my partner sent the video and put runaway in the background and it was lowk my social peak and that song holds sentimental value in my heart.

7/10 - One of the lyrics was "And I don't know how I'ma manage, If one day, you just up and leave." And I for sure thought he would say vanish because it is a slant rhyme and sounds so much better. This album was significantly better than I thought it was going to be. I loved the first 4 of the first 5 songs. If the whole album was like this it would have been like an 8. However, it went downhill at Monster. I can 100% see how people think this album is great. I also liked Lost in the World a lot. I did not like blame game very much.

This might be the only time that Rick Ross shows up on 1001, so I just wanna say that his performance on devil in a new dress is actually one of the best rap verses ever. At the very least, it’s his best. Lost in the world is maybe my favorite hip hop (if you can even call it that) song ever. Runaway might be objectively the best hip hop song ever. This album does everything right, from the creativity to the production to the features to Kanye’s crazy performances on like every song. This might just be the greatest hip hop album ever; even my mom likes it. It just sucks that I can’t really listen because of who Kanye is now.

I really wanted to hate this as I dislike Kanye as a person and as a figurehead but... ...well this album is pretty good and I can't deny it. Damn! Eclectic collection of referenced cultural references and sounds- it's a non-stop barrage. This is a masterpiece and I hate that.

fave since it came out fave track: monster, nicki eats

Kanye the rapper and producer at his most self-aware. Its a shame that he turned out to be a REALLY shit person. Kanye went into a self-induced hiatus from the public (the Taylor Swift incident occured the year prior) and after getting all his favorite people to come out to Hawaii and help him with the album...the results are amazing. (He even got Elton John to work on "All of the Lights" with him.) The Production is incredible, the features are amazing (Kanye even said that Nicki's verse in "Monster" is the best one. Which coming from HIS ego is impressive), and the songwriting is fantastic. Kinda ironic that Bon Iver worked with Kanye on this album and would later work with Taylor Swift on "exile" 10 years later. I do believe that Chris Rock's part goes on for too long (it probably could have been cut out.) This album was integral to my music taste in high school. I still believe "All Of The Lights (Interlude)" is one of the most beautiful pieces of work and the intro to "Runaway" always gets me emotional and brings me back to high school. This rating is actually a 4.5. Loved Songs: All of them except for "Blame Game" , "Lost In The World" , and "Who Will Survive In America"

I'm going to (attempt to) ignore the fact that Kanye is kind of a piece of shit for this review. I'm trying to give this a fair shot. Dark Fantasy is a decent album opener - I'll give Kanye credit for surrounding himself with lots of talent. My only note on this one is that Kanye must be absolutely tone deaf. His rapping has always been his talent, but he can't hit a note to save his life. Gorgeous is boring. I'm torn about Power. On one hand, it does a really interesting job taking a classic King Crimson song and transforming a song around it to modernize the sound. On the other hand, King Crimson did all the hard work here. How much of the reason that this is a good song is because of people other than Kanye? All of the Lights is fine until, again, Kanye tries to sing. Fergie is great on this track. It is a good song overall. Monster and So Appalled are fine. Very rap, which isn't really my genre. All the substance of Devil in a New Dress is sampled. I think Runaway is the first genuinely great song on the album. For as long as it is, it's cohesive and impactful. Hell of a Life isn't a huge standout for me, but I do think it's a significantly better use of sampling than some of the other songs on the album. The inspiration/borrowed melodies and sounds are obvious, but the song is still original; it's not just rapping over a backing track of someone else's song. Blame Game is not interesting. The outro spoken word part is gross. Lost in the World is actually pretty good. Thank you to Bon Iver for the melody and sample on this one. Kanye's ego is absolutely fucking ridiculous. Anyone who didn't see his complete psychotic breakdown coming, even back at this point, is deluded. There are moments when I can see what people mean by his "artistry" on this album, but his head is too far up his own ass most of the time to let a song, never mind an album, be completely good. Credit where credit is due; Kanye can put together a solid group of talent. The best songs on this album had some heavy lifting by other artists and sampling. Unfortunately, I don't think this proves that Kanye is a good artist, and I don't know that I can call this a good album. 2.5

The first minute of the first song is good, but it's before Kanye kicks in. The song Power is decently okay. All of the Lights is good. Blame Game has quite the monologue. Not a great album but much better than I was expecting. The middle was slow but started and ended strong. This is on the verge of 4 stars but I can't.

9.7/10. One of the most creative rap albums of all time.

More musically varied and interesting than I was expecting. Found the language in the lyrics difficult and alienating, although it does explore a concept and is a proper album. And it’s too long!

Very good. I know he’s an asshole but his music is great. Loved all the collabs on this album.

One of my favs. Have listened multiple times. Even though he is a total piece of shit anti semite lunatic, one of the greatest rap/hip hop albums ever made. Separate the art from the artist scenario.

Tracks: No matter how creative the programming - robot music leaves me feeling cold. Rhymes: Is the threshold for being considered a genius making 30% of your lyrics meaningful and interesting?

One of the best albums, ever.

I actually really liked this album. Powerful music, with beats and lyrics that land hard. Perhaps I'll add to my rotation.

Not listened before, better than expected but not my thing.

Fire album. Hope he gets off that nitrous

I have a soft spot for this album because when it came out when I was living in another country and my friends and I rocked the shit out of this album. It was nice to revisit it. I forgot how good the hook on Dark Fantasy is and I was totally good with it just going on for the last minute or so on its own. POWER with the King Crimson sample crushes Runaway is almost a classic but the last 4-5 minutes of autotune mumbling the chorus is unnecessary. I feel like this could have been a 5 star album if you cut out the skits tacked onto the ends of a track and beats that just continue to outro for multiple minutes, but alas, Kanye did not. Solid album though

first album okay - can we get much higher??? middle was kinda ehhh i think all of the lights is okay tbh like idk didn’t speak to me monster is kinda gas LMFAO WHAT IS NICKI DOING HERE BYEEE didn't really speak to me unfortunately

Crackin' album that

second half not great tbh

Non stop choons!

Nice album! I know a lot of songs from this album! Classic

Not my usual vibe, but undeniably good. 3 stars probably does it an injustice but it’s just not my taste really

Very interesting

Huuuuh Great album. Quite a few songs were 5/5 but others dragged it down a bit. I'll probably listen to this one again. Also Runaway is always a classic

Kanye brings the heat! They call him the GOAT for a reason. I definitely enjoyed this album, but a few songs fall short for me. A solid feature list with banger songs. The end of Blame Game with Chris Rock was strange tho, but I guess Kanye is a strange man.

9/10 kanye’s best album imo

He's really not the genius he says he is.

8.5/10 Good

Fine album. Not my favorite. But I’ve never been that big of a Kanye fan.

Pretty good. Enjoyed some of the slower songs I hadn’t heard of before 7/10

Incredible album. So well produced. From the first to last track. Every song on this album keeps you entertained and keeps your head bobbing.

I try to listen to it as how a fan of this genre would. I guess it would be great, but it's just not for me. I gave up a few songs in. Make no mistake, I do listen to rap, the Filipino artists like Moro Beats, but Kanye is, well, Kanye. And life is too short to listen to music that doesn't move you.

I really did not like this album. There were moments that were ok, but every song felt two-three minutes too long. It wasn’t like the songs were dynamic enough to warrant how they just went on and on. Also I’m not sure if I’m supposed to sympathize with Kanye’s inability to see women as human beings, but that’s the vibe I got.

What a laste of time.

Love the beats a few songs are catchy.

Surprised myself by enjoying this. Melodic, a bit of fun, really dialled-in. Not especially coherent as an album, but overall it was a good listen. Seems like he hadn't devolved into a complete twat at this stage, or at least it wasn't in your face in the album. 3.5/5

Amazing album fuck kanye tho

Ye at his best.

It was all right, but my cultural background prevented me from really getting into the lyrical content. I have to say that the sampling and his flow was nice

I don't like the man, only sampled the first couple of songs, and rap is not my thing but I can see how this album would be appealing to those who do like it. This would be on the higher end of the over-abundance of rap albums offered up here. 2.5/5

Disgusting, Awful, No, No, No. Can I give negative stars?

not for this piece of shit

I like the Chris Rock part

This is better than Yeezus.

“My presence is a present - kiss my ass” Monster is a baroque masterpiece.

I won’t give listens to this asshole. It may be phenomenal but fuck Kanye

I am not into hip-hop and the ones I liked the most are oldschool rap from the 90s. Despite of this I tried to listen to this with an open mind and ears also because I read how important this album was when it came out. This album is extremely well produced and for this reason it was a joy to listen to. I didn't care for the lyrics or the songs individually but the songs flew together very well and it works well as a hip-hop opera. I enjoyed it more than I thought I would. It's between 3 and 4 personally but I will round it up to 4 because the production is really top notch.

I tried but I can’t get around my dislike for Kayne.

You do not, in fact, gotta have a toast for the assholes.

five star album, knocked mostly because of who kanye is as a person but also because i had to hear the phrase "yeezy reupholstered my pussy"

I think there's some really innovative production stuff in here, and it's unfortunate that there's so much other stuff and the tall shadow of Kanye's behavior.

An absolute must listen in the hip hop canon. Kanye at his most maximal. A star studded list of collaborators makes this an incredibly massive record. Super refined, and and a great listen.

production goes crazy. pretty even split between poetic bars and the stupidest (for better or worse) lines you've ever heard. wish there was less gooner shit but i suppose that's essential to the experience.

Oh my, this is the hardest album to assess. Art (incl. music) is as much about the artist than about the product itself - I personally can't separate them. The product first - the album. I had never listened to a Kanye West album but I must say this is creative and sounds excellent. Beautiful production, and a slew of top guest artists taking part. Not really my thing but I recognise a level of quality when I see it. It doesn't move me emotionally though. Now the artist. I find it really hard to enjoy an album made by a self-proclaimed Nazi and otherwise complete assh*le in his morality and behaviour. I won't listen to Ye unless I have to - similarly I would not hang a painting by Hitler in my living room (even f he was a great painter which he wasn't). So in terms of rating, I'll torture myself and rate the album (I'll give it a 3) rather than how much I like the artist as a person (which would be a zero - yes I know the scale starts at one).

Gear: Abyss DIANA MR Artwork: 🖼️👾🟥 Production: 🤯🙂👌 Music: 🧑‍⚕️🧪🔄😈🏙️🔪🕵️‍♂️😱📜💔 Rating: 🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪/5

idk сначала казалось хайпом, потом гавной

Yes, yes, the man's a lunatic, and now certifiably in the worst way, but that is not the focus of this review. Of course, he was a lunatic back in 2010, too. Megalomaniacal. It's the only kind of person that could make this album. Look at the title. Look at the lyrics. Look at everything that was happening at the time of the album's release. Delusions of grandeur are this album's bedrock. And you know what? There isn't a miss on the whole damn thing. "Dark Fantasy", the overture, mercy me. But it gets higher. The classic psych rock sample on "Gorgeous". We see the the power of a 21st century schizoid man. We see all of the lights, extra bright. We get "Monster", where somehow, in a crowded room, Nicki steals the show. And that's the halfway mark. I could keep going, but I'm not even going to continue. It's just a triumph. The triumph of a fool king, but a triumph nonetheless.

Horrible person.

It was prolly peak i didnt listen

I'm not a fan of Kanye these days, due to politics and him being kinda a psycho... but I have to admit this album is pretty solid. Also a shame this is the most representation Bon Iver gets on the list.

its..Kanye West. Not my genre. The album is ok, it just does not excite me. I am not going to listen to it again. Runaway was ok

Didn't love or hate any of these songs really. Fine enough for a huge commercial rap album. Lots of different features which is interesting I suppose. 6/10 (3/5)

This is one of the albums on the list I knew going in I would probably end up giving a 5 rating to but I still tried to reserve some judgement until this listen through. This listen did not disappoint me. I didn't truly fall in love with this album until I listened to the season of the podcast "Dissect" that went over this album. I really recommend anyone curious to know more about it, or Kanye to give it a listen. It really made me have a lot of respect for him and this album. That said, there are many things I don't like about him, and I think he's truly unwell without the will to or the right support around him to get better. I have to say though after learning of his journey to this album and some of the more intricate music theory behind some of the choices on this album I can't help but still recognize that there is greatness in him too. I've never believed the two things to be mutually exclusive anyway, but I think he's a particular example of extremes. Anyway, Kanye himself aside, almost all the tracks on this album have some kind of genius to them in my eyes. There are a couple weaker tracks, but even they are not all that weak. For a long time "Monster" was the only track I was really all that into from this album, but I also was just starting to dip my toes more into hip-hop at the time so hadn't listened to the full thing. "Runaway" was the next one to catch my attention. There was something very raw and confessional there to me, and it remains one of my favorite hip-hop slow jams. Also, the contrast of that with the sparse piano playing against the dark and dirty excess of "Hell of A Life" is a hell of a combo. That's another favorite of mine. "Dark Fantasy", "All Of The Lights" (including the interlude), " POWER", and the ending combo of "Lost In The World" and "Who Will Survive In America" are also all especially great tracks. All in all I think a lot of clever word play, interesting samples, and a great introspective themes from Kanye's magnum opus.

Admittedly, I will not listen to this. He's a disgusting human and I will not give one cent to him by playing it.

5/5. A classic. It's only gotten better over the years. This was my introduction into rap and it feels like cheating since this is mostly just great songwriting in an epic concept album about the struggles of success instead of rap. It can be jarring at first, very direct and non-apologetic but when you re-listen, you see this man knows he is not a good person. He is having an identity crisis and over compensating, self sabotaging to avoid the attention or to try and match the personality the media has created for him. It is not an excuse and this album is his therapy, not a healthy outlet which is why this one feels so raw and emotional. Regardless of the concept, these are just well-written songs and it's a great front to back listen. I never pick a random point, I have to always start from the beginning. It's unfortunate who he is today but listening to this album feels like you can start seeing that side of him very clearly. This was the first sign of that decline. It's fortunate we get this album but at what cost for him? I guess we found out too late. Best Song: Power, Runaway, Monster

Pre-Kim Kanye, so before he lost his mind and started believing his own hype to such a degree that he made shit music. Although this album is long, it is varied and has enough supporting artists to make each track distinct and memorable. Some elements are self indulgent which drops a star

Surprisingly good songs? Very catchy, havent listened closely to the lyrics but would maybe listen to some of the songs again (im at all of the lights so far) overall ok album, power and monster were my faves

高中時聽過了 大部分的tracks在現今來聽依舊前衛、獨樹一格,經典的kanye風格,很難想像它是2010年發行的作品 現在到了大一再重聽一次 感覺有稍微不一樣了(前幾年養成了聽experimental的美感習慣)不過某些曲目還是有點 underwhelming,不過整體還是很棒,最喜歡的是all of the lights, dark fantasy, 和 runaway

I don't want to like it, but it's great. Dammit!