Reviews (page 10 of 16)
Do you like Hip hop? if you do then this album is for you. Turn off the lights is fireeeeeeeeeeee, I like the beat, the lyrics, and I like Kanye voice. Monster suck to be honest that´s the only song I don´t like from this album. Run away tho is fireee to everthing about it is great. This alum is 9/10 its the good I recommend this album.
This was a ok album. Its lyrics didnt stand out in my opinion. The music didnt stand out. This album kinda didnt stand out at all. Overall a ok album
All the lights by Kanye West has some sounds that kinda sound like wooden drums like the ones you would use in elementary school. Or it could be digital but either way its very interesting. It adds a nice complement to the other instruments and it sounds up-beat. Nice back-up vocals also. I would say I would recommend this album.
the album runaway is pretty good because I like the beginning it sounds like the theme for Michael Myers but then it changes and its kinda like a mysterious feeling the reasons I think it good is because of the lyrics they just sounded good and fit the instrument and the instruments are also good cause of how they fit perfectly with the lyrics I think this album was good and I would recommend listening to this album
Do you like pop songs? If so, then this is the album for you! The songs have a really good beat, and all of the music components together sound amazing! The singer (s) voice (s) are amazing, and they hit the pitches so well! The instruments are amazing too! So that is why I recommend that you listen to this album.
Do you like Hip-Hop/Rap? If so, this album is definitely for you. In my opinion, I REALLY like this album. I love all of the other singers added to this album. Nice diversity. I also like this album because I like the beat and all of the music in the background. It has good beats too. I highly recommend that you listen to this album.
Here's another artist where I break from the pack. I do not like Kanye on the whole. I think he's an extremely overrated, egotistical, pampered artist that's been told he's a genius so long that he thinks he's a god. And all of that comes across in his work. His rhymes are decent (if self-indulgent) and his delivery has that lazy "I'ma get to it when I get to it" cadence which isn't my favorite. The production is, of course, off the charts good because it's a Kanye record. It's telling that the best moments on this record are the ones where the guest artists bring heat. The production really IS phenominal, though. And, when I stop and listen to THAT instead of trying to evaluate this record on Ye's bars (like I would any other rap artist), I like this album a lot more. I just can't with these lyrics though. So much shit. Giving it three stars because the production is huge.
Perfect album! I like the reference to King Crimson's 21st Century Schizoid Man
Ok disregarding the individual who made this (who unlike Phil Spector or Gary Glitter has not actually been convicted of a crime) it's strong three. Enough.
Hasn't aged well I'm afraid! I think the hits on this still stand out, and the album has bangers in it's locker. I don't really think the themes of redemption and forgiveness work at all anymore. I think we've all culturally moved on from this kind of autotune too. The hyperpop era has not been kind to 2010s pop-rap. Best Track: Devil in a New Dress Worst Track: Blame Game
Best Song: POWER Worst Song: Ball Game
better than i thought itd be at the start? i started to enjoy it with whoever was on those female vocals, seccond song with what i assume is kanyes vocals seems less fun, but its fine. song 3 - kinda hard to listen to, i tend to like hip hop but this is a bit rough, way less good than i expected seeing the reviews.. 5? really? i dont see that yet. song 5 - its fine, i feel like it gets better whenever kanye isnt singing but when he comes back it gets mid again, bit of an issue that is. wtf is monster this intro is ass - this album is so shit lmfao i undestand the beats are fun, but this is really not for me wtf this is so uncanny - AGAIN kanye shuts the fuck up and the music gets better - get it niki fucking get it HAHA maybe i just hate men idk these vocals are just not hitting it for me im so appalled by song 7 look at me im funny PLEASE this album is shitty intro to song 8 is fun okay okay icu runaway is a bit of a banger, heard it before, but its nothing like the rest of the album and its sill a bit mid its fine i guess, nothing ill listen to again.
The Donald Trump of music. One star, I wish I could erase you from my life, and all the sheep following too. All I hear is ego. Only stuck with it to see what Bon Iver contributed.
I can respect and appreciate how intricate and complex this album is. There are a lot of things going on and it's very interesting. However, at its core, it is still a hip-hop album, and I am just not a fan of the genre, so I don't see myself coming back to it.
One of the best rap albums, does fall off a bit at the end.
Thanks Taylor for the inspiration. You helped produce an album Kanye will probably never top. Got this on CD at an Oxfam in Paris for €3, and was reminded about just how damn good the album is. The first Kanye album I can remember listening to as a kid. I've since put on this CD with friends over and we all agree - it's just hit after damn hit. 5* for me, no bad songs on the album. All of the Lights (interlude) as my absolute favourite for sheer beauty. Well played, Mr West!
More pop than hip-hop and more diversified and therefore more listenable than other hip-hop/rap albums. But still not my prefered gengre and way too long.
Not a fan of him as a person but this was a visionary album
One of the best Ye
Monstrous
This is Kanye's masterpiece and it includes his magnum opus and the greatest rap song ever made, Runaway. This album is the peak of Hip Hop and changed my life. Not perfect, but so so so close.
Is er een muziekfiguur in de 21e eeuw die aan de ene kant zoveel verbindt, maar ook zoveel verdeelt? Kanye West is de spil in het voortstuwen van het Hip Hop genre, in een tijdperk dat het internet en de computer hoogtij vieren. Het brengt zoveel elementen samen die voorheen niet met elkaar leken te rijmen, en zoveel popartiesten die vloeken met het originele format 'Hip Hop'. Zijn voortstuwende werking van het genre bedoel ik dan ook vooral op gebied van modernisering, of het nou echt beter is voor het OG rap-genre is de vraag. Daarnaast is hij zo vaak onderdeel geweest van een cultureel momentum, waarin z'n stijl, doen en laten, en 'professionele' aanpak altijd het middelpunt leken te zijn van een rage. Maar juist daarin verdeelt hij ook ontzettend, en is Ye ondanks een 'stralend' brandpunt ook een man die van controverse zijn middelnaam maakt. Dit moest even vermeld worden, want dit is ook de context waarin ik veel van zijn muziek beoordeel. Het eerste deel, waarin zijn pioniersfunctie in de moderne Hip Hop niet onderschat mag worden, doet mij hinken op twee gedachten. Aan de ene kant vind ik veel van zijn werk echt extreem dapper, en is hij een soort 'art pop artiest der hip hop', door de gangbare popmuziek telkens een beetje op zijn kant te draaien. Daarnaast moet ik toegeven dat veel artiesten waar ik normaal niet echt wakker van lig, opeens wel stralen op zijn albums. Hij heeft een fantastisch oor voor wat wél en wat niét werkt, ook al brengt hij dat laatste dan ook gewoon doodleuk uit (zie zijn laatste albums, in het speciaal). Die eclectische mix aan artistieke invloeden overschaduwen dan wel vaak weer het rap-deel van Hip Hop, wat mij een liefhebber maakt van het originele genre. Zijn lyrics zijn vaak cringey, de vocalen missen enige vorm van passie, en zijn rijmschema's brengen zelden de muzikaliteit van zijn nummers tot een hoger niveau. Goed dat hij nog hier en daar wat goede rappers uitnodigt om dat enigszins te verbloemen. Het zijn de sublieme orkestraties die zijn albums vaak redden, en de muzikale plot-twists, en niet het menselijke aspect. Wat wat mij betreft wel vitaal is voor een goed Hip Hop album. Er mist een bepaalde flow. Het tweede deel, over zijn controversiële imago, is ook belangrijk mee te nemen. Want wat ik ontbreek aan rauwe persoonlijkheid op een album van Kanye, wordt voor een groot deel goedgemaakt door hoe hij zich presenteert rond een release. Hij heeft waanzinnig veel karakter. Tuurlijk, hij is een sociopaat en een ontzettende hondenlul, maar hij heeft wel karakter. Dus een album leeft altijd wel in de psyche van de mens die hem een klein beetje kent, zonder het muziekstek zelf heel veel 'soul' bevat. Dit album heeft denk ik de grote hoogtes bereikt wat het heeft bereikt door zijn uitgesproken identiteit, en niet perse omdat het een waanzinnig Hip Hop album is, in ieder geval niet in my books. Het is een sleutelstuk uit een unieke muziekcarrièr, getekend door net zoveel hoogte- als dieptepunten. En ik denk dat dit de plaat is die zijn gevoel voor wat de trends waren van de tijd, om die te presenteren in een Hip Hop context, het beste tentoonstelt. Het duurt mij net iets te lang, om alle prikkels die het verzend een plekje te geven, maar het is wel een ervaring. Een 'Hip Hop opera' werd het al ergens genoemd, en die theatraliteit, inclusief robotstemmetjes, James Blunt-pianootjes, en Nicki Minaj, hoort nou eenmaal bij 2010. Of, Kanye West heeft gezorgd dat het er vanaf dat moment bij hoort, want die invloed heeft hij. Ik vind het een moeilijk album om goed te beoordelen, en moet het echt los zien van veel andere, reguliere, rapgenres waar ik van hou. Daarom 4 sterren, voor het artistieke lef, maar niet perse voor de Hip Hop. 8/10 Highlights: Gorgeous POWER Runaway Lost In The World
Kan je Kanye haten, en dit toch een episch album vinden? Dezelfde twisted fantasy maakt Ye die knurft die hij nu is, maar maakt dit album legendarisch... Ik ben geen rasechte hip-hopper en heb zeker geen intrinsieke voorliefde voor mainstream hip-hop, dus het is vast een stukje nostalgie dat My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy altijd wel goed is aangeslagen. Volgens mij is de reden daarvoor best simpel... de tracks op deze plaat zijn uniek. Dat vind ik er vet aan. Het is geen klassieke hiphop-beat. Mede door de vele samenwerkingen bevatten de nummers ook veel rock en horen we (gelukkig) niet alleen maar Kanye rappen. West is volgens mij (daarvoor rijkt mijn kennis niet ver genoeg) niet perse een hele goede MC. De teksten heb ik -heel eerlijk- nooit echt goed naar geluisterd. Dan blijven met name de lekker harde en opzwepende tracks over. En die vind ik altijd weer verrassend voor een hiphop plaat. En godsamme, hoe vet dat Bon Iver hier op vier nummers mee doet. Zijn verdraaide stem past eigenlijk bizar goed bij deze muziek. En godsamme, gelukkig staat die samenwerking met Chris Martin hier niet op. Dat scheelt weer een ster. 8/10 Highlights POWER Monster (het rapstukje van Jay-Z is vet) Runaway Lost in the World
Super solid
Kanye may be a garbage person but boy can he make a music
Bubblegum pop with f bombs
For all that Kanye West is such a powerful cultural force, I’m not really acquainted with his music. So I wasn’t sure what to expect when I turned this on. I won’t say I’m a fan of all of it (ugh, Blame Game), but I couldn’t turn away from any of it. The album has a real pull. Monster in particular really blew me away.
Power is a great track, and its a showcase of the great production shown elsewhere on the album really shining. That said, the whole album is bloated, has some distasteful pieces and is a problematic listen only 14 years later (I could have written the same thing 5 years ago).
A little better than the previous one I listened to. Two Kanye albums in the same week is torture...
Wanted to hate this as Kanye is a massive cunt, but this a good album. The production is top notch, with great guest performances. Favourite track is Runaway 4/5
Kanye has said some heinous shit over the last few years, but he also said "Too many Urkels on your team, that's why your wins low", and we do have to respect that.
Kanye's strength is as a producer. As an MC...sigh...well, he's a really good, interesting producer... Highlights: "Dark Fantasy" (weirdly majestic leadoff track despite Kanye-isms (corny lyrics, "hah"), interesting use of choir and sparse piano chords, almost "orchestral hip hop"), "So Appalled" (martial beat with strings, Jay Z and Pusha T have nice flows), "Devil in a New Dress" (old school Kanye production (chipmunk soul sample), surprising guitar solo. Rick Ross sounds better over this music than Kanye does) Notable: "Runaway" (sigh...bad lyrics ruin really interesting good music. Ok, the last 2 minutes of noise and vocoder is kind of annoying...), "Hell of a Life" (fuzzy feedback, auto tuned vocals, and highly sexualized lyrics. Part of the chorus is "p-ssy and religion is all I need". Lord help me...), "Lost in the World" (starts with vocoder and Bon Iver, then more standard dance music sound, then African rhythms and chanting. It's...a lot.. Ironically, this features some of Kanye's best rapping, go figure...)
Wish Kanye wasn’t a scumbag
Not for me. 1/5
The greatest album all time….Kanye West woke up one day and decided to create the greatest rap album of the 21th century which will influence rap music for ever. Thank you YE
Honestly thought it was way too "pop" on the first listen, but this has been in my rotation for well over a year atp and honestly the production is super impressive and fairly uncommon at the time. Amazing samples and guitar instrumentals from Mike Dean, some of the best features from the 2010's (namely Pusha T and Rick Ross) and generally great performances from Kanye. Blame game is annoying as fuck but I mean I guess it's sorta funny? Also Dark Fantasy unfortunately got ruined from the memes.
Some of the best songs in this album are some of the best songs in modern rap music, but overall it's super overproduced to the point of being annoying. I do not like
Boo
I tried to come at this one objectively putting aside how I feel about the man. Putting aside biases towards the artist, I still didn't love this one. Some Kanye admittedly slaps. This album just didn't do it for me.
This one didn’t do anything for me.
The star of the show is the production. Impressively immersive, huge sound. I've sometimes been a hip-hop hater, but I can appreciate why this album is talked about highly.
The random album generator said, "So, you've enjoyed that swinging jazz? Let's see how adventurous you are." Attempting to assess Kanye West's cultural impact is a fraught endeavor, but we are just dealing with 2010's epic release, My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. This 2010 release is maximalist hip hop from a figure who truly believes he is larger than life. On the heels of his Taylor Swift controversy, West released a monumental album that is packed full of grandiosity and anxiety. It is equal parts self-aggrandizing and self-deprecating. West feels deeply the rush of cultural power and simultaneously fears it. For a moment, you believe he could hold the balance. But we know better at this point. Sonically, this album is stunning and bold, a creative amalgamation of sounds, guests, samples, and themes. This is not for everyone. It is at many junctures raw and vulgar. As an artistic achievement, it is a reminder within the noise of current headlines of the occasional genius of Kanye West.
If I’m being honest, I’m not really a fan of rap music but I’ve always believed that any genre of music can produce something worthy of listening to. Sadly this isn’t one of those occasions. Perhaps my judgement is a little coloured by negativity surrounded by this artist, although I don’t know much about West apart from allegations of misogyny and violence. To its credit the production is slick and many of the tracks tuneful but then he starts rapping. I can appreciate that this is a form of poetry and there’s certain skill attached to its composition and performance, but as an ageing white man I can find no cultural connection to this apart froma sample of 21st Century Schizoid Man.
Not his best work, felt like he was trying to be way too artistic. My favorite was “Power”
I didn’t hate it as much as I thought I would.
i mean it's kanye... like... the albums pretty great. good tunes. i sort of dislike this era bc of the amount of producers on a track, everything has this weird shine to it. other than that, fun re-listen
no pienso escuchar una canción de este hombre en mi vida por muy influyente que crean que es
I dont like hiphop, but all these melodies were cool, the voices too. I never heard this guys music, only the memes
Hard separate the musician from the music. This has a lot of my favourite songs I put lights, monster, runaway power, dark fantasy, and gorgeous. It’s too bad what Kanye has become.
Perfect album. Ten out of ten
Yeezy got my pussy reupholstered
aphex twin sample is nice but it also matters what you DO with the aphex twin sample
This stinks.
I expected it to be awful but it was more just sad, especially the song with Nicky Minaj and the one after. Some people really can’t handle getting famous.
A masterpiece
"I miss the old Kanye"
Ye the producer 10/10 Ye the artist 2/10
5/5
It is a weaker Kanye album. Thats why it is just 4
Kanye might be a terrible human but the music’s good. 4.16
Oh god, the day has come to delve into Kanye West. Rap/hip-hop is not my favorite genre, so my knowledge of Kanye’s music is almost non-existent. I saw this as a blessing considering how Kanye (or Ye, whatever the fuck he wants to be called) is nowadays, or just plain any point of his career with his 1001 controversies. But I was told that this album is a landmark achievement, and it’s from 2010, so it’s easy to look at this as a reflection of a high point of Ye’s career before the wires in his head became fried. And this project is meant to challenge my tastes in music, so I’ll be fair… to an extant. Let’s start with the good: the production’s great. Surface level complement, I know, but anything that makes a hour of Kanye bearable to me is a miracle. The songs sound really good, as it’s the type of hip-hop that’s more groovy than annoying, which is usually my vice for the genre. I couldn’t help but get lost in the likes of beats of Devil in a New Dress and All of the Lights. And the guest artists all add their weight to the album. (Though I agree Chris Rock greatly overstays his welcome in Blame Game) In a rare instance, I actually think Nicki Minaj is my favorite, as her part in Monster might be a contender for highlight of the album. As for Kanye himself… he’s fine. It’s Kanye. There’s good lyrics mixed with some self-indulgence. It’s tolerable. But here’s the weird thing: I have no desire to heard these songs again. I don’t really have it in me to listen to anything from this album. Most of the songs feel bloated to me and don’t have replayability to me. The closest song I can think of is Runaway, but that’s it. This album does nothing to sway my opinion of Kanye West: I can still care less. It’s the production and talent not nicknamed Ye that made this album not feel like a slog. I hope that if there is another Kanye West album in this project, it’s several hundred albums from now. Favorite track: Runaway Other hits that I thought were neat: Monster, All of the Lights, Devil in A New Dress, Dark Fantasy, POWER
Felt like I should be doing a power hour in Kerst. Could have been 5 stars but I felt like just couldn’t connect with the material…
Duh
Each song flows to the next. Such a great listen as a complete album.
Listen to before Highlights: all of it
Sasquatch Godzilla King Kong Loch Ness Goblin Ghoul A zombie with no conscience Dracula Moth man Dragon Basilisk Leprechaun Mummy Minotaur Werewolf Mermaid Frankenstein Troll Invisible man Ghost Xenomorph Abominable snowman Gremlin Chupacabra Manticore Cyclops Swamp man Cthulhu Giant snake Cerberus The monster from Cloverfield Hydra Balrog The creature from the black lagoon Pennywise the clown Mechagodzilla Tyrannosaurus-rex Giant squid Sirens Boogie Man Gargoyle Goat man Sand worm Medusa Skinwalker Skeleton Bowser Pumpkin man Scarecrow Chimaera Sphynx Centaur Candyman Pyramid head Bride of Frankenstein The Münsters The Rancor The Sarlacc Freddie Kruger The Babadook
5 stars for carley rae!
BOOOOOOOOOOO shamelessly boycotted this one! Not a completionist and idc!
Great album, I forgot how solid it was. Not really something I like to listen to much but it's really good for it's style.
I have major problems with this artist as a human being. His treatment of woman seems to be incredibly misogynistic. There is overwhelming evidence to me that he is mentally ill, but I still don’t give him a pass for how he treats people poorly. In spite of all that, I cannot deny that this is a gorgeous piece of work. Some credit goes to Bon Iver, whose influence is evident.
Kanye entering a new era, you can argue between this, 808s, and Yeezus, over which one marked the death of "old Kanye." Regardless, banging album. Put RZA on everything. Favorite Track: So Appalled Least Favorite: Blame Game
Fantastic album - production is immaculate and so many epic tracks. Thought it did have a couple of skips, and thematically was a bit much for me at times though. 7.75 / 10
miss the old Kanye, straight from the 'Go Kanye Chop up the soul Kanye, set on his goals Kanye I hate the new Kanye, the bad mood Kanye The always rude Kanye, spaz in the news Kanye I miss the sweet Kanye, chop up the beats Kanye I gotta to say at that time I'd like to meet Kanye Jokes aside, pretty decent album. Solid 3/5.
En pitänyt musiikista mutta rakastan artistia
It was good and some great songs but i wouldn’t choose to listen to it on my own
such a shame kanye’s brain is swiss cheese bc this album is incredible. go listen to lost in the world and maybe you’ll feel better
Not my usual jam but I actually enjoyed that
I liked this slightly more than College Dropout. There's a lot of strength in the features and production on this one.
Decent hip hop album but not world changing
Massively overproduced but some quality there.
It's hard to really separate Kanye West's sad mental health journey (and public persona) from his music, but taking this album out of this context is probably the best one can do. It's definitely more interesting and expansive than "The College Dropout" (listened to previously), and it has a few entertaining highlights -- "Dark Fantasy", "POWER", and "Hell of a life" (in part from the "Iron man" riff). The video/singles are also well-produced and entertaining ("Runaway" especially (didn't watch the whole 30-minute film, though) and also "Lost in the world", although "All of the lights" not so much). Much like "The College Droupout", it's waaay too long, with a number of very forgettable songs (and the latter half of "Blame game" is just downright unpleasant and tedious and offensive), but still a very solid album, if you can separate the person from the music (which I personally find tough, given how toxic he's been). The Wikipedia entry for this album feels like it might have been written by a very devoted Kanye West fan, as it rarely makes a lot of sense. Many of the sentences seem to start with one thought and end in the midst of another, with very little coherent in between. ("He elaborated that a minimum of 80 percent was genuine, with the remainder 'fulfilling a perception' for the public. West also insisted that he was not criticizing My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and instead failed to reach satisfaction, then openly revealed his idea of the truth." Or whatever.) But reading between the non-linear lines, it sounds like the production process was fairly tortured and excessive and expensive, which sounds about right. Kanye West put an entire fridge's worth into a blender, and I'm impressed with the strange, rich stew emerged.
Enjoyed "Dark Fantasy" and "Monster." Other tracks not so much--just as douchy as the dude.
Love it
Not my bag.. I’m out in this guy
I've already said my piece back on Common's "Be" about how Kanye once cared about creating and producing music, unlike these days putting the music second to repping fascism. I wanted to give this album the benefit of the doubt from when and where Kanye was. The problem is this was when Kanye started to spiral. Back at the 2009 VMA Awards, Kanye stole the microphone from a then up-and-coming Taylor Swift to instead say Beyoncé had the greatest music video. I can understand to an extent that he was still deeply affected by his mother’s passing, and had overworked himself to the point of making such a public stunt without common sense. It’s not a perfect excuse and doesn’t detract from how he was perceived as an asshole, but it is a reason. After that botch, Kanye proceeded to isolate himself to Hawaii to work on this album alongside those he felt close with, exploring what he perceived as the dark underside of fame alongside the id of his ego. In essence, Kanye wanted to show the monster he became, for better and worse. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy was a frustrating listen for me. There are elements to each of the songs that I like, but there are also enough glaring missteps and a general lack of focus to keep this album from coalescing into a meaningful theme or driving mechanism in the dissection of Kanye’s insanity. We start and end with two excerpts in Road Dahl’s rework of the Cinderella folk tale as read by Nicki Minaj with a fake British accent and the sampled Gil Scott-Heron’s “Comment #1”, without much in the way of connecting the two pieces. In between, Kanye does his best to come off as hedonistic, such as the sexual advances in “Devil in a Dress” and “Hell of a Life” along with more general musings on “Power” and “Monster”, but at best these explorations come off as hollow and token. There isn’t much in the way for someone to connect with Kanye’s purported dark side as he can’t fully embrace it. Not helping matters is that Kanye’s flow and lyrics can get choppy and distracting from what’s being conveyed. Nowhere is this more evident than “Runaway”, the song that many a Kanye fan has claimed to be his best song and the centerpiece of this album. In a way, it almost works - the spare piano motif coinciding with the industrial drum pattern and Rick James sample, the light and elegant strings that add contrast, Pusha T’s verse, and even the chorus and lead-up to Pusha T are well done. The problem with that track and by extension this album is what Kanye chooses to say and sing that can’t match the tone of his production and the general themes he tries to communicate. I understand from the chorus that the idea of “Runaway” is that he is a broken man who can’t change and that it would be better for the loved one in the relationship to keep their distance from him. Unfortunately, that message is not received well by Kanye’s verses, particularly in his enunciation of “She find pictures in my email/I sent this bitch a picture of my dick” that’s flat-out embarrassing and takes me out of my focus. Not even a three-minute piss-poor vocoder solo at the end can save that shit. That is the crux of My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, where Kanye’s flow and awkward lines get in the way of his messaging. Whether it’s taking cheap shots at the writers of South Park and Saturday Night Live, or the thin connection between getting “blackballed” to his “black balls”, his words distract from and hamper what could have been otherwise decent tracks with top-notch production, potent choruses from guests, and eclectic sample choices. Kanye’s lyrical pitfalls also led to some of the rapper guests like the aforementioned Pusha T, Jay-Z, and Rick Ross outshining the man in their respective verses. Granted, not every guest was good as I once again bring up Nicki Minaj for the intro to “Dark Fantasy” and her over-the-top verse on “Monster”, as well as Cyhi the Pyrnce’s lazily written verse on “So Appalled”, but they are noticeable cracks in the frame. I’ll freely admit I haven’t felt this infuriated by an album on this journey since the Sex Pistols’ “Never Mind the Bollocks”. In no way do I see myself revisiting this anytime soon, as I await the other two albums on the list from this man. In a way, Kanye somewhat accomplished what he set out to do by showing off his inner demons. Unfortunately, I don’t think that’s paid off well if history is a good indicator.
sometimes i dont really understand how this album works, simply because it opens with nicki minaj doing a poor british accent but has some of the best hip hop of my generation, so idk. fuck kanye, but damn this album has some highs (including i sent this bitch a picture of my diccckkkkkk) 1.) runaway 2.) devil in a new dress 3.) blame game
I’ve listened to this album more times than I can count. It’s what first got me into Kanye. Not a bad song on here, most are amazing.
Maybe my favourite Kanye, but still is Kanye
Pretty good, some legendary songs. Didnt like the latter ones as much but still enjoyable listen
Highlight: Lost In The World In a nutshell: maximalist hip-hop. There is a lot of copy-paste song format here: find a sample or beat you like- even if it sounds similar to another track you've laid- and loop it. Add anything that sounds shit hot- synth horn, hand drums, vocoder, a Gospel choir, piano. Get your mates involved. Go apeshit. Make it regal, big, unapologetic. Keep shaping it til it sounds perfect. Repeat. I sense a mania in the music- in production and execution- that I didn't hear in The College Dropout. It's definitely bloated, half the songs are over 5 minutes. One has an (unfunny) skit outro featuring Chris Rock. This sounds like one of those albums an artist needed to make to redefine and refine themselves. Kanye is an expert at shaking up shit. I appreciate the ambition, it's not my thing. But it's worth a listen. It's unique and a product of its time. Overall: 4/10
Nothing to say. A masterpiece
So as usual with Kanye the production is great but sine of his rhymes are just too cringe. This doesn't seem as impactful as College Dropout though
Not really sure about this. Hard to reconcile what was actually quite an interesting and artistically meritorious album with the route that Kanye has gone. Feels like sipping tea while watching the mushroom cloud grow.
Kanye started off strong in my opinion, but this is where he started to go off the rails musically. The first half of the album is strong and memorable, but it deviates into something unrecognizable.
It’s a shame Kanye went off the rails, becase his old music are all really good. This is one of the few albums where I think every song is great.
Annoyingly I enjoyed the album, he might be one of the biggest tools alive but back in the day he could craft a tune
I mean there will literally never be an album like this again. I will say after runaway the album is just ok but like ima ignore it
Unfortunately this is a modern classic.
Might be a lil nutty but he is a genius
Pass
How do you go from that last song to supporting DT. Removing the artist from the music because I still liked him back in 2009-2010. It’s got some bangers!
A lot of drama with Kanye, which makes it hard to rate this just based on the music - he's become such an imbalanced Trumpy mess. The backing tracks are pretty awesome throughout - I think Kanye's strength is as a producer. The lyrics don't really speak to me. And this is not an album I heard at all when it was released, so no nostalgia.
Viewed in a vacuum this album would be an easy 5-stars. So good. Like give me chills at points good. But, unfortunately, Kanye has disappeared down a conspiratorial, MAGA rabbit hole. So, sticking to my guns, I have to knock it a star.
I mean, you can't say it better than him: No one man should have all that power The clock’s ticking, I just count the hours Stop tripping, I'm tripping off the power (21st-century schizoid man) I suppose some of Kanye's genius is that he's so self-aware, but he's taken such a nose-dive in his madness (the journey from 'George Bush doesn't care about black people,' which was utterly wild and out of left field at the time but CORRECT -- to MAGA anti-Semite is certainly one for the psychologists to figure out) ...that it's hard to appreciate even the multiple great tracks on this album without remembering what an abusive tool he's become.
not a kanye fan, all the beats sounded the same. sounds to me like he relyed on having other artists come in and do the heavy lifting on half of the track. most of the songs just sound like some sort of mantra for him
Can we get much higher? Iconic opener and the whole record goes incredibly hard. In his peak years — and people forget there were many good records, over a long period of time — Kanye was truly a master at work.
Top 3 hip hop album for me
Yup, heard it a bunch. It's good, but not his best
No sabia que tenia tantas BANGERS hasta las que no conocia estaban muy buenas. La escuche en el gym
Not my type of music at all but that was a damn good album.
as always, great production, horrendous vocals.
# Album Name: My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy # Artist: Kanye West # Rating: 5/5 # Comments: Not my kind of music normally but i have to say this was a very good album. Best of the genre ive heard. Back to back good music. I'd give it a low 5. # Top Tunes: Dark fantasy / Gorgeous / Power / All of the lights / Monster / So appalled / Devil in a new dress / Runaway # Would I listen to it again? Yes
🙅
R&B, Rap, 2010 -> 1
You take your 4 stars and get out, Nazi.
Not as good as I expected. Somewhere between Kanye's old soul sample style and the minimalism of 808s etc and I am not sure if this works. I think I prefer either approaches on their own. Don't think I will play this ever again. Also, with 2024 ears, it is hard not to hear the nastier tone than Kayne has in voice (and lyrics) these days, already kind of being in there.
Keeping the fact Kanye is a problematic character aside... This isn't a great album. It's fine but not even one of Kanye's best let alone one of the greatest albums of all time.
Oh baby, I knew this day was coming. Kanye established himself as a top voice in hip hop in the 2000s with the college trilogy, but his reputation began to precede him at this point. 808s was not a commercial success, despite some critical acclaim and there were questions about what his next album would be. He went to the studio and assembled a team of talented writers and producers larger than he ever had before or would have again. Track by Track, this album starts stronger than possibly any other. Dark Fantasy: Incredible, great feature. This was the first track back, and already this was different than 808s. Gorgeous: Epic, Cudi kills it great verses from everyone. Power: Immediate standout. The first of many climaxes of this album. The Schizoid man sample is just phenomenal. The way KanYe is able to blend such a unique musical pallet to create stadium hip hop was unparalleled. All of the Lights: Interlude and track keep the music high energy. Instrumental is great, Rihanna is fantastic. Monster: Great hook, great beat. Great Ye verse, decent Jay-Z verse and then Nicki Minaj comes in and basically introduces herself to the world with one of the greatest verses of all time and foretelling the prophecy that she would fulfill of becoming one of the greatest female rappers ever. How sick is that. So Appalled: Not that great. Feels like it goes on a bit too long and I'm not a big fan. Mostly forgettable. Devil in a New Dress: Fantastic beats, kind of carried. Doesn't hold up super well but was seen as one of the best songs on the album. Runaway: The grand epic of the album. The minute of slow introduction on keys is awesome. It's so subtle, and stripped back. Moments like this KanYe has been chasing ever since. The song is great, I think the lyrics are fine and as a whole but the instrumentals are all fantastic and the usage of the electric guitar is brilliant. Hell of a Life: Kind of a reprive, falls into a lot of 2000s pop music traps and isn't great. Blame game: Great hook great instrumental, I like the Chris Rock skit and I like John Legends vocal performance. Fits well in the album Lost in the World: A good track, not much to say, Bon Iver on it is cool. Who will survive in America: I think this closing track is pretty weak. It doesn't offer much and I think it allows the album to fall to a close rather than end with a big dramatic piece. This album starts off with great track after great track climbing to Monster. Then the album moves and abandons typical song structure and begins blurring and mystifying with runaway. The album closes by slowing down, perhaps reflecting on the heights of the first half. Like the end of Evangelion, after the chaos and as the world is disintegrating, it quiets and there is space to breathe. Maybe it's KanYe's way of saying, you can't fly so high forever. Rome will crumble and what has been made can never be made again. This world we live in is mortal and as close as we can get to the gods, we will still fall back down to the earth with cracked bones and torn flesh. Regardless the moments we spent touching the sun were the closest we could come to being free of our world, and a part of something bigger. It's only human to want this. KanYe's been trying to find it again ever since.
Skits were a bad trend, esp. if they weren't separated into skippable tracks.
This came out as Kanye was transitioning from big time producer and rapper to mentally ill bajillionaire I think? Maybe it was before that was becoming apparent, it's hard to remember when exactly Kanye went from being a real inspirational success story with a ton of talent to this sort of odious and obviously disturbed person he is today. The production on this album is stellar of course, there are some really iconic beats on here (All of the Lights, Power) but I still think it doesn't really get to the level of his early work. College Dropout and Late Registration are such incredible albums that this one seems almost too polished and too full of itself to relate to. I know this is supposed be his opus, but I really don't see it that way. The songs with a ton of features fall flat entirely, the ones with artists that aren't rappers might be even worse. I know that Kanye isn't just a rapper, he's a producer, so it's not weird to be shown up in the rapping department, but it has to be said Pusha T is the best rapper on this album. His verse saves "So Appalled" from being a total throwaway track, and his verse in "Runaway" is great. I've been talking like I dislike this album, but I don't. I still think it's close to being great, I just know Kanye did better before, and probably wont ever do better again. Outside of the big singles, which are all excellent, "Hell of a Life" has a great driving beat, lyrics, and the chorus "sampling" Black Sabbath is great. Real shame he's a piece of shit now.
We've had a few hip hop albums in our adventure here and it made me realize that I almost never listen to hip hop/rap in album form. Notable exclusions: Killa Season, Dipomatic Immunity Vol 1, and all Lil Uzi Vert albums. I don't know what I'm getting at, I just wanted to share. Twisted Dark Fantasy is fine. There's some good stuff in here but this is 100% the start of Kanye's egomaniacal phase. I like that Old Kanye, dropped outta school Kanye. Most of the music here doesn't land for me. That is other than All of the Lights. I fucking love that song. When it was new every DJ had a remix and they all slapped. It's a powerhouse that could end every super bowl show, every fireworks display, every one night stand. The only thing I would change with this otherwise perfect song is fix Kanye's singing or autotune him: "I'm heading home, I'm almost there". God he can't hit a note. It's fine. Most likely influencial on a lot of modern rap but :shrug:
Some brilliance from Kanye West, back before he was a full-on nut job. Just a semi nut job.
Chalk full of legendary hip hop beats.
Qué raro
It was alright Pussy
Nope.
Awesome. Love it
The greatest (and the last great) Kanye album
Arguably good, potential re listen
Kanye is my favorite artist and this is either my favorite or top three Kanye albums. Amazing album.
The self importance permeates this one all the way through. 2.3 stars
Kanye West: 👎 My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy: 👍👍
Eh
Not going to listen to this a-hole. Alrighty I listened to some of this album and I still feel the same…he’s an a-hole. Can I give this zero stars?
not a lot of substance, but its a fun time, highlight is runaway
Hard pass
The first couple of songs are a bit slow but also I’ve probably listened to this album 100 times so hard to say if that’s just me. Despite Kanye’s more recent slippage in quality and abhorrent politics, this is a classic.
Not as good as College Dropout. Better than Yeezus.
All these songs are way too long.
I tried to listen without everything we now know about the person who is Kanye and the album is still a top listen for me. I think I would in all honesty go 4.5 due to perversion that I don't usually like. There is no denying the talent here and looking back, there is another path for this troubled egomaniac where he is beloved instead of reviled. This is a masterpiece.
I get why people like Kanye and put his music on all time lists. I never sought it out before but it is certainly good stuff. I don't think I'm going to add it to my library though.
fuck this guy
Monster was a great track, Power was pretty cool along with So Appalled and Runaway. Otherwise I think this one is a little over hyped.
Best rap album ever
Bring back old Ye
All songs are very enjoyable listens, without a doubt one of Kanye’s best albums. However, some songs were very weak compared to others, like Monster to Runaway or POWER. Overall, great album. 8/10.
Albumi #49, 15.09.2024 Kanye West ei jaksa innostaa.
4 love that there’s actual musical elements to the album rather than the incessant trap beats of current rap
One of my hip hop gateway albums, All of the Lights one of my favourite all time tracks. Make me feel 21 again so has to be 5 ⭐️!
Correct album with a commercial sounding, heavy production. Some song can be very long, overall very good.
Crap
80% Best: Gorgeous; POWER; Devil In A New Dress; Runaway; Hell Of A Life Must-Hear? Sure
Not great
Production, production, PRODUCTION!!! god damn genius… I miss the old kanye 😔
Listened to this while playing Tainted Grail: Kings of Ruin. I intensely dislike Kanye now...but this album honestly is way better than it had any right to be. The guest spots or amazing, the production is so wonderfully lush. I don't even mind Kanye so much on this album. I hate to do this...but this album gets a 5 from me.
I'm not even going to listen to this.
A perfect album and one of the best hip hop albums of all time.
This was a bit sad to listen to know where Kanye went. Great album, very tight throughout. Power has such an incredible vibe and I remember hearing a pull from King Crimson in it and wondering where Kanye was going to keep going musically.
This is an amazing album that almost summarizes the work that came before it. The whole thing just works. He is not the best lyricist but the rest of the tapestry he weaves carries him. From the hits he made for Jay-Z to this he just kept building, but not long after this he flew to close too the sun. The man figured out the formula for producing a pop song for a time. Almost like he made a deal at the crossroads and the bill came due. May he find peace some where that we don't need to hear about him for a long while.
Kanye West is very likely struggling with a diagnosable mental illness. He is not OK and really ought not be in the public spotlight. However, he is also a brilliant musician and it is really necessary to compartmentalize his music from his ... whatever the rest of his life may be. Certain musicians put their POLITICS into their music. I am not even going to imagine Kanye can not automatically feed his emotional states into his music, but that is what makes it what it is. An insane sort of beauty. Just in so long as you don't focus on the man, and just focus on the music, everything will be OK!
First and foremost before I do my review, I would like to acknowledge that Kanye West is not a good person who supports Neo Nazi ideals and refuses to work on his mental health issues as they continue to worsen. Now to the review where I will just be looking at the music, and not the man This might be one of the greatest rap albums ever made, and I am skeptical that we ever get another album with this level of collaboration. Every song is unique, and yet they all work together. All of the features are on point, the production is top level, and the album never drops on quality. Runaway is 9 minutes pure gold. I truly do miss the old Kanye who continually pushed rap in new directions before his ego and mental health couldn't separate from each other.
Honestly wasn't half bad (That is a lot coming from somebody who's "worst" genre is hip-hop.) "Runaway" is a standout for me, featuring a twinkling piano melody and fantastic incorporation of samples. In fact, I would argue that the album was well written. That said, Kanye West is a disillusioned Nazi and antisemite. Whenever I'm listening to his tracks, I remember that Tweet of him wearing a swastika shirt and that instantly ruins the album's appeal to me. I have been called out for turning my nose up to rap music then and again. But why should I breach my own morals just to conform to self-proclaimed music elitists's standards?
Musically it's interesting, but the songs tended to overstay their welcome. Runaway really didn't need to be 9 minutes long for gods sake. It had obviously run out of ideas, passed boring and went into annoying teritory before it finally ended. The biggest issue is Kanye himself, he's just not a good rapper or singer. All the guests mop the floor with him.
fuck this POS. Zero starts if possible. Nicki's verse on Monster is legendary.
no se
Really good. Some of the songs hit harder than others, and some parts really don't work for me, but others really are amazing. 4/4.5
Fuck Kanye
Jotkut kappaleet hyviä, suurin osa ok. Aika pitkiä kappaleita. Monissa kappaleissa loppua venytetty pitkäksi. Keskinkertaista. Parhaat: Dark Fantasy, Power,
01) Dark Fantasy - 7,0 02) Gorgeous - 7,5 03) Power - 8,5 04) All of the Lights (Interlude) - / 05) All of the Lights - 8,5 06) Monster - 7,5 07) So Appalled - 7,0 08) Devil in a New Dress - 6,5 09) Runaway - 8,5 10) Hell of a Life - 7,0 11) Blame Game - 6,5 12) Lost in the World - 8,5 13) Who Will Survive in America - 7,0 TOTAL: 7,50 (75/100) Current ranking: 145/293
Awesome beats, still a mid rapper. I liked it better than TCD.
Overrated by many, but still a great rap record.
In 2024 - absolutely fuck Kanye West. But there was a large period of time when he was arguably the best hip hop artist out there. His ‘College’ trilogy is damn near perfection; hits upon hits upon hits, with albums that had plenty of commentary layered on some of the best production the world had ever heard. Even when he switched things up with ‘808’s & Heartbreak’, he knocked it out of the park. But this album? This album is by far his magnum opus. He took everything great from the ‘Graduation’ trilogy and ‘808’s’ and mashed them into their final form. Is it self indulgent? 100%. Is it a bit preachy at times? Absolutely. But is it an undeniably great listen. You betcha! The first 5 songs are just a masterclass. The haunting, angry, almost gospel-esque opener ‘Dark Fantasy’, the guitar riff heavy ‘Gorgeous’, the hard hitting ‘Power’ (with a genius sample of King Crimson putting the icing on the cake), the guaranteed hit ‘All Of The Lights’, and the pure hip hop beat driven ‘Monster’. They all paint the overall picture of the album; phenomenal lyrics, masterful rapping, and mindblowing production. Some people claim ‘MBDTF’ is front loaded. But I don’t believe that. ‘Runaway’, ‘Blame Game’, ‘Lost In The World’ are also top tracks. In fact, there isn’t a single bad section to be found here, in my opinion. The collaborations also need to be mentioned, as he works with the likes of Jay-Z, Nicki Manaj, Bon Iver, John Legend, prime Rick Ross, and Pusha T. Rarely do you ever see such a varied and killer list of artists featured on an LP; never mind the fact it’s only 13 tracks, too. Sure, revisiting this album is bittersweet given Kanye’s recent antics. But I think you can often separate the artist from the art. And ‘My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy’ isn’t just a great hip hop record, it’s quite simply one of the greatest albums of all time; and I have held that belief since it was released.
Very close to a 5 but doesn't quite get there 88/100
9/10. While Kanye West is a terrible person, I must admit that this album is a masterpiece. This is coming from a non-rap fan. I would have given this album five stars if it weren't a Kanye West album. Edit: Never mind. Five stars it is.
Enjoyed the song Monster, but still have a hard time getting past who this guy is.
Side A is better storytelling, side B is catchier. All in all, a solid solid album.
Utter shite
Fuck yeah
increíble álbum para tener de fondo cuando querés sentirte poderosa. buena compañia
Good album, and fuck Kanye. ✌️
The first 6 tracks are back to back bangers, but the quality drops off so fast after that. And Blame Game still sucks. If it was just the first 6 tracks it would be a 5/5.
First half is great
I have absolutely not expected this to be so good. Never thought of Kanye as a good artist and not just crazy star
CAN WE GET MUCH HIGHER 🗣️🗣️
One of the greatest hip hop albums of all time but also fuck Kanye
Very good
Beyond Kanye's questionable actions and my deep deep desire to never give him money, this is his least impactful album.
For as much as Kanye has been in the limelight for as long as he has, I really don’t know any of his music. And unfortunately, none of these tracks particularly spoke to me.. much like most of the hiphop genre. 3/5
I don't care if he's a villain
Incredible way to start this off. Bangers piled upon bangers on this album. Every song feels consequential, and I love almost all of them. 4.6/5
Like Kanye himself, this album turned out to be a complete and utter disappointment. The best part about it is Nicki Minaj’s verse on “Monster.”
For someone who slept on Kayne in his early days and avoided him in his latter, I was happily blown away with how awesome this album was and will be fully investing some time into relistens and investigating his earlier albums.
Didn’t think I’d really listen to this album with any sense of enjoyment. I was surprised with the variety, the musicality and the poetry of his lyrics.
What a fascinating listen. There’s so much here, even before you get to the music. Has there ever been an artist, literally worth nearly a billion mostly built on his critically acclaimed discography, who decides to essentially throw most of that away because of becoming enamored with antisemitism and sexual deviance? That alone makes his story memorable, no matter how you feel about Kanye. Classic, “Do you support the art or the artist?” debate. In the end, I land on Kanye being one of the most talented producers and hitmakers of all time (not much of a rapper though; his flow has always been rudimentary to me), so I gotta give him his props for that. And this album is likely one of his early masterpieces; the title literally says it all. One of his best traits about Kanye as an artist is you don’t have to wonder what he’s thinking about; it’s all in the music for better or for worse. In the end, as the debate about Ye continues online where he still has his worshippers as much as those who’ve written him off, I land with the teenager who described him thusly: “Amazing artist, shitty human being.” Either way, his music is too good, too stimulating, too irritating at times, for me to write him off. He’s just too talented and like a car crash, I can’t help but check it out even as I pass it by.
Pop Rap, Hip Hop
Best produced rap album of all time possibly? Their is a sort of epicness that comes with this album, with songs like 'all of the lights' and 'runaway'. It feels bigger than just an album
Alright, some good tunes
Fine. Another situation of the person overshadowing their art.
I hate how good this is. I want to punish Kanye for being the person he is, but I can’t deny this album’s greatness. I can however give props to the many, many guests who elevate this material even more, most of whom are not problematic, I think? I just won’t google it. Problem solved.
I legit think Kanye is a creative genius. I disagree with just about everything about him as a person, though. This album is very good, but I don’t think it’s his peak. I think some of the features in the middle and near the end drug it down for me.
100
Do you like fish sticks?
Waste of my time.
The hits on this album are HITTING, but the rest of the album isn't as amazing as I remember it being. Overall, a good listening experience. I can recognize this as a pretty solid album from Kanye, but it doesn't hold a candle to Graduation, in my opinion.
What to do with this one? I can understand why Kanye has been lauded. There are moments of ambition, even genuis, but I feel like mostly he's mostly getting graded on a curve, merely for stretching the genre. It all feels a tad self-indulgent, which I guess is all part of the rap game, but still. I found Runaway to be the most interesting song, and perhaps mostly because it's a moment of introspection, perhaps clarity, where Kanye can see the cliff he eventually ends up going over. When he tells you to run away, he's not lying. And, as much as I would like, I can't really separate the art from the artist. It colors it all, and I'd prefer not to know anything more about his fantasies, dark or otherwise.
So Kanye’s “Dark Twisted Fantasy” was not as bad as I was dreading, so there’s that… I did find it fascinating that saw a number of rock artists listed in the song writing credits – so Jon Anderson (Yes), Robert Fripp (King Crimson), Tony Iommi & Ozzy (Black Sabbath) – along with Carole King – and I was like WTF, until I realized that Kanye was just sampling portions of their songs on his tracks… I guess that’s part of what bugs me about hip-hop/rap – is the basing of a new rap song, around a musical hook that’s already been created by another artist… I know everyone “borrows” from everyone else in music, and very little is genuinely “created” – but the blatant practice of knowingly taking something, and re-working it, just has never sat well with me… C’est la vie… While nothing earth-shattering here, I did find it at least somewhat interesting, so a solid 2 for Kanye… Still don’t get why he is a thing, but at least he’s better than “Dr. Octogon” – so there’s that…
I acknowledge the popularity of the album and the impact of the artist, though I care for neither. Favorite track: "Lost In The World."
Very good start to this one. I get a little fatigued by the end of it. Will I listen to again: 60%
awful
It took me a bit to figure out that the reason why so many songwriters are listed in the credits - for one song I counted 13 names - is that Kayne was forced to acknowledge the artists he sampled. The album is exceptionally well-produced. I like everything but Kayne's rap.
Not my kind of music at all
I wasn't prepared to like this. I feel like Jack Black's character in High Fidelity when he hears Vince and Justin's demo tape, full of exasperated and disbelieving appreciation. I wouldn't listen to this one in public as he seems to get off on being as crass as his messages will allow, but the music is actually really good. The songs are all well-constructed and interesting. It's just a good listen. If his music kept him from talking publicly, I'd gladly listen to way more Kanye.
Para muchos críticos estamos ante la gran obra del rapero y productor Kanye West. Un conjunto de 13 canciones de 70 minutos complejo y laborioso de digerir. Su primer sencillo, "Power", es una mezcla confusa de rock progresivo y hip-hop en el que sobresalen los samples de la canción "21st Century Schizoid Man" de King Crimson. Su letra sobrevuela la actualidad política de Estados Unidos, y se refiere a su propia salud mental y a sus críticos. Más me gusta "All of the Lights", un tema grandioso, con abundantes metales, maderas y cuerdas, en el que participan 42 artistas para celebrar la fama y, al mismo tiempo, lamentar sus consecuencias. También destacaría "Blame Game", taciturna y melancólica como el tema de Aphex Twin que samplea. Cuenta con la colaboración de John Legend, y en ella West reflexiona sobre rupturas emocionales, amor no correspondido e incluso maltrato conyugal.
One point bonus for iron man sampling
Start to finish, great album.
Didn't finish, got bored halfway through. It's also hard to listen to Kanye now lmao
What happened to my goat :( Genuinely depressing listening back to this one, its like a completely different person made it. Hit after hit after hit. Legendary run of tracks. But it does have to be said the back half falls off pretty significantly after Hell of a Life, drags a bit after that. Such a fun listen but now I'm sad. Separate the art from the artist I guess. Dude was the soundtrack to my life for years. Fav Tracks : Dark Fantasy, Power, All of the Lights, Monster, So Appaled, Runaway, Hell of a Life
One of the best albums of all time
This is the best Kanye West album. It bumps. Just a good presentation and doesn't overstay too much. Lots of guests. He really captured the popular sounds of the time by sampling Bon Ivor.
The best Kanye album.
There is some really good stuff on here but I find it a bit long and some of the songs could have been cut
La produzione è davvero bella secondo me oggettivamente, per il resto vado abbastanza a sentimento. Non tornerò attivamente ad ascoltarlo ma non mi lancerei dal finestrino se qualcuno lo mettesse sull'AUX. Non essendo il mio genere pensavo mi sarebbe piaciuto meno.
Didn’t like this album. Don’t like Rap Music. 1/5
4 Runaway was too long
“Ain’t no question if I want it, I need it” and by “it” I mean the old Kanye
This didn’t jolt me like “Yeezus”, but it’s still bizarre, bold and word-nimble enough to rise above West’s nastiness. Tip: the un-pixelated cover should be seen.
Picked this up on the strength of "Runaway" and a Pitchfork 10/10 (hey, it was the Obama days). Overcome by a braggadocious wall of noise, I didn't give it a second listen. But today, with hindsight: wow, this is absolutely *too much* in just the right way, and I finally understand why pre-Nazi Kanye was so highly feted. Incredible production, witty and funny lyrics (if frequently reflecting obvious insecurities), populated by a wealth of talent all throwing high quality shit at the wall. Only low point is the piss-weak warbling of Justin Vernon (dreading "For Emma..." if it shows up here). Strongest parts have their roots deep in prog (goddam, "Dark Fantasy": where did he hear the original?!), potentially inspiring me to dig into the Gentle Giant back catalog and make my fortune. Watch this space.. I really didn't want to give this top marks, but I've been impulsively listening to it all weekend, and even sat through some of the rest of his output (Yeezus is the closest, the earlier stuff is awful). Uneasy 5*
I know it’s iconic, but it’s not my favourite genre of music
4.50
Not my genre
This genuinely feels like Kanye at the top of his game. I've always treated this album as the precursor to his downfall, and going back to it now feels like opening a time capsule of his music. I think this acts as the apex of his ideas on Graduation, while also going all in on the bravado. Favorites are Power, All Of The Lights, Runaway, and Lost In The World.
These songs are maximalism taken to the extreme. The entire music industry is on this thing. It’s like a room full of gold trim and crystal chandeliers with velvet furniture. Just fantastic front to back.
Great beats for a beast
This started really strong, so I was considering 5, but it sagged a bit in the middle for me. It's borderline 3/4, so I marked down for Kanye being a little Nazi cunt.
Over rated probs a 4 but nazi so its a 3
Not bad but still not my favourite music. But west Damocles some cool bands for this.
Competent, but not something I will ever return to. Favourite track: Devil In A New Dress.
I wonder if i would have liked this if i didn't have some inkling about kanye.
Great album, seriously twisted dude.
I’m not seeing the genius of this album
I think the music itself is a bit better than a lot of the verses, but a powerful album altogether. The vocals are very front and centre in a nice way. Would give it 5 stars if it wasn't for Devil in a new dress and Blame game.
Kanye West's first 5 albums were legendary. An amazing 5 album run. Is this the best album overall of his from those 5? Very hard to say. Basically, every one of his albums up until this one is great, almost perfect but not quite. This one is no exception, I LOVE the first half of the album but it just loses its way towards the end unfortunately. It's not a perfect album but it is very close, the highs are very high.
I am not a Kanye fan, that said there are some great songs on this album. Dark Fantasy, all of the lights and Power are paticularly good. I liked this and will listen to it again. Favourite song: Power Least favourite: all of the lights interlude Album artwork: Basic cover
Undeniably fantastic
It was all over the place, and the subject matter didn't click with me. I just didn't get it.
One of the best Hip Hop album of all time...
nice
Got into a car accident with this playing. Never again :)
There is 0 doubt that "Runaway" is a true masterpeace. Also "power" kinda slaps. And right now i am having a huge dilemma, i know that the album is great, but i also know that Ye is not that great. Also hating on every corrupt musician's music would really reduce my listening options. That is why I am leaving this to math. "Runaway" - 6/5 Album - 4.5/5 Ye - 0/5 Total 10.5/15 === 3.5/5
Honestly think this album is overrated
One of the greatest albums ever made. A perfect 10
This album was the end of the good stuff. I didn't like it when it came out, for some reason, i think the hype was too much and it just didn't live up to it. Only one song is worth relistening to, and it's only good due to the background vocals.
3.3/5 listened 1x, could use a relisten
I always thought 808s was the best Kanye album, but this one has stood the test of time better. Sad, dark, angry, and desolate.
Shocked that I enjoyed this album as much as I did. Never heard a single one of these songs until today. Probably helped that there are so many cool people collaborating on it. Go figure.
Modern masterpiece, hate the man but will always remember his incredible output during his prime.
Kayne’s masterpiece, the one album I can forgive how much of a dickhead he is and just enjoy. I honestly believe this is Hip Hop’s equivalent of Dark Side of the Moon, just a shame Kayne is a bigger twat than Roger Waters.
Almost every track overstays it's welcome a bit, how are they all 5+ minutes sitting on the same beat. Even the best beat gets boring after that long. Didn't like the sampling of 21st century schizoid man, don't think it meshes well and just makes me wish I was listening to the better song. I like the use of the electric guitar on the album, not used to hearing that in hip hop. The album goes out on a high, perhaps the tightest tracks on the album. I don't know, the highs are really high but it feels pretty bloated. There's not a lot to keep me coming back to it tbh, other than a couple of tracks. 4/5
I don’t like Kanye but there were some good songs (run away, and all of the lights)
If I could I would do 2.5 but this album has some good songs but so not so good too
Ce n'est pas un album qui m'a totallement, mais je peux un peu mieux comprendre comment tellement de monde le mette sur un pied d'estalle. Selon moi c'est imparfait et ne mérite pas un score parfait, mais je l'ai trouvé beaucoup plus intéressant que College Dropout ou Yeezus. 7/10
No.
I really can’t explain why, but My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy has the same effect on me that Punk has. It’s so effortlessly perfect, so beautifully constructed, and so brilliant a self-portrait of a highly, highly flawed man that it feels… inspirational? I’m not a rapper. I have a bit of a history playing Jazz and R&B, but musically I’m mostly a Rock guy. And yet, listening to this album makes me want to bust out a drum machine and a synthesiser and bare my soul over some beats. I think that the confessional nature of the lyrics plays a major part, 2010 Kanye is flawed but relatable because of his flaws, and as someone who is also flawed and actively struggling with how to deal with them, the whole album is worryingly relatable. But ignoring that, it just slaps as music. Power, All Of The Lights, the Guitar/Vocal solo that takes up the last few minutes of Runaway, all perfection. Todd In The Shadows talked recently about how difficult it would be to cut controversial artists out of your life, and he name-checked Kanye as one of the hard ones. Listening to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy all the way through, I finally get it
I will never get the whole Kanye is a Genius thing. It's all boring as heck to me. Ah, well, not everything is made for everyone.
The guy is a scumbag, but that's more or less all I know from him, I've lost interest/lost track with mainstream hip hop a long time ago. Is it any good? I don't particularly like his flow (there is no particular edge, it's a bit too smooth/dull to my taste), the background music is not too bad but a bit bloated. We can clearly hear that lots of efforts were put in the production, but I'm not really convinced and it's hard to claim that is pure genius. It wasn't really bad overall, but not that good either.
That's not really my type of music, so I didn't really enjoy the album, but I know that people like it. I think that it's pretty mid overall. There are some background rhythms that sounds pretty nice, so it wasn't the worst album that I've been recommended here, for sure.
It's hard to seperate the artist from art and this album is a great example. This is a great album made by a crazy person. It is extremely original with the first song being an incredible opener. Each successive song keeps the pace up and are all really great. I can't rate it higher than a 4 though because I don't agree with many things Ye has said and done.
Great album. Power, Monster and Runaway are the big hits and lots of crafty lyrics.
Helt ait, noen bangers, andre var fillers
One of my favorite hip hop albums of all time. I consider it Kanye’s crowning achievement.
My thoughts on this album clicked on that one song that sampled Avril 14th by Aphex Twin. It was great musically and set a great atmosphere, and then Kanye put just enough self-aggrandizement on top of that to make it not unpalatable. At the end of the song, my takeaway was that the original Avril 14th was better. Granted, I don’t listen to rap, and there might be something to his lyrics that might be more meaningful to someone who does, but it didn’t resonate with me. This might be controversial, but I feel like this album succeeded in spite of Kanye West, not because of him. It struck me as a series of slightly worse versions of great songs that are still very good. I struggled writing this because I did enjoy listening to this album, but at the end of the day, my takeaway is that a rap album was good, but would be better without the rapper, which is pretty damning praise.
West is a piece of shit. Ridiculous, misogynistic, manipulative, controlling, delusional, and quite possibly in need of support with his mental health - which may be the root cause of his flaws. He is also incredibly good at making his music. I have very little experience or knowledge of hip-hop as a genre, but I can spot good when it's presented to me, and this album is good. Very good. It is, of course, overly long and that along with the closing 'comedy' skit stops it being five stars, but it is a really solid four. Even though it is made by such a colossal piece of shit.
Trash.
Justice for Taylor <3
What an incredible album - lyrics were fun, flow was great, production out of this world. couple of songs were misses but overall, a stellar album. I finally get why people love his music.
I think I’ll always have a soft spot for this album, because it’s so closely linked to a specific time and place for me. (Summer 2018, Tokyo) I first listened to it on a total whim on a long bus ride - vaguely recalling that it was considered one of the greatest albums of the last 20 years, and curious as to why - and it grabbed my attention from the first track and I was blown away by how much I enjoyed it. I immediately listened again from the start, and I listened many times over those summer months. It was a transitory period when I was often sad and deeply conflicted, and something about this music in particular seemed to offer an escape. I can’t really rationalize or explain what it is I like so much about this album (although there are definitely objective measures by which it’s great), but despite everything surrounding its artist, it’s one of those that I’ll always appreciate for the role it played in my life. (This time, too, I listened through without stopping and listened a second time.)
I am not finding this terribly compelling, but I'll give it three stars because of the samples of "21st Century Schizoid Man" and the tune that shamelessly rips off Black Sabbath's "Ironman". I'm sorry, I'm just not all that interested in raps and auto tune lyrics about falling in love with porn stars. Actually, with the anti Semitism, I can't give this anything other than one star. "Ye" is an asshole.
I'll admit I was a little surprised that I didn't find this to be the worst thing ever. I was actually enjoying much of the first half all the way through Monster. But then it started to get tedious & the lyrics took a serious nosedive. Apparently Runaway is a standout for a lot of people but that might be my least favorite track as it's just the lazy-ass Four Chords again.
Some of these tracks are true classics and it was a joy to listen to. Other parts of the album drag on a bit and some of the tracks I'm not a huge fan of. The tracks that work really work for me but there are a few skips in there too that bring it down a star.
4☆/5 07.11.2024
Sounds great, I see why people like Ye However, lyrics can be questionable as you'd expect Not horrendous though
I didn’t mind this. I didn’t know any of the songs except for “Lost in the World.” I’m not sure how I evaded ever hearing the other songs from this album. A lot of Kanye West’s stuff sounds the same to me so who knows. Mostly pretty tolerable. Too bad Kanye himself isn’t.
I really liked the first five tracks, but I felt like the quality of the record dipped afterwards, starting from the incredibly annoying 'Runaway'. If I could rate the first half only, it would have gotten a four. 3.5 stars
Would’ve been a 4
Meh
As usual I liked this better than I expected or wanted to. The guy is crazy and an ass but the music is legit.
Bangers throughout.
As someone not that much into modern hip hop (and tired of Ye's controversies), I was very surprised by how much I enjoyed this. Decent production and a couple of hits I didn't even know where his
Think I used to own this album back in the day, has some enjoyable tracks but not as strong as other albums on the list.
For the most part it's very good. But while the highs are high, the lows are very low. I do think the guest vocalists really help elevate this... everyone knows Nicki's verse in "Monster" is fantastic, and Bon Iver was an interesting addition to a few tracks. I think if it had just been an hour of Kanye alone it wouldn't have worked so well, his lyrics are often the weak point here. And the Chris Rock sketch at the end of "Blame Game" felt too long and out of place. The overall production is tight, and the background instrumentals on the tracks are great. I was pleasantly surprised by "All the Lights (Interlude)", which I thought was really lovely. I really liked "Hell of a Life", plus of course "Power", "All of the Lights" and "Monster" are the highlights of the album.
Not my bag.. Creative and artistic - - but.. nah
I didn’t want to rate this a 5 going into it because I don’t think this is the best album we’ve had and, if I rated it a 5, it would surely steal that spot. However, I’ve been swayed. This thing is awesome. Combining the fast beat and rap vocals with really dramatic backing vocals and other instruments worked really well. Runaway is a classic as well obviously
Really liked this album. It was really good
歌真不戳,可惜人疯了
Some good songs, some kind of meh
just such a classic. every song is incredible, from the production to the lyrics to the flow of the thing. truly dumps you right into it and never lets go until the end. where did THIS kanye go
Would be a 5, but Kanye's ego gets in the way. 4/5
It’s just too long. I have a hard time judging Kanye of 2010 with Kanye of 2024. He might be the worst rapper on his own album (that’s still pretty good considering the heavy hitters). He’s definitely the worst singer and the auto tune is not great. Is there a Chris rock interlude that just went on way too long??? Cut out a half hour. I think there’s a great album in there
"Dark Fantasy" Grand, cinematic. Features orchestral elements and introspective lyrics about fame. "Gorgeous" (featuring Kid Cudi and Raekwon) Gritty, raw. Guitar-driven beat with social and political commentary. "Power" Anthemic, intense. Combines tribal drums with bold lyrics about Kanye's influence. "All of the Lights" Energetic, vibrant. Features multiple artists; discusses personal and public struggles. "Monster" (featuring Jay-Z, Rick Ross, Nicki Minaj, and Bon Iver) Dark, fierce. Each artist delivers standout verses, with Nicki Minaj’s being particularly memorable. "So Appalled" (featuring Jay-Z, Pusha T, Cyhi the Prynce, Swizz Beatz, and RZA) Brooding, reflective. Complex verses over a somber beat. "Devil in a New Dress" (featuring Rick Ross) Smooth, soulful. Features a classic soul sample and a standout verse from Rick Ross. "Runaway" (featuring Pusha T) Melancholic, introspective. Famous for its extended piano intro and self-reflective lyrics. "Hell of a Life" Edgy, provocative. Combines rock influences with bold, hedonistic lyrics. "Blame Game" (featuring John Legend) Emotional, layered. Explores the complexities of a failing relationship. "Lost in the World" (featuring Bon Iver) Euphoric, expansive. Blends Bon Iver’s ethereal vocals with a driving beat. "Who Will Survive in America" Poignant, thought-provoking. Uses a spoken word piece to address social issues. This album combines lush production with deep, introspective lyrics, making it a rich listening experience from start to finish.
Long, répétitif. Aucun intérêt pour moi. Je ne suis pas allé au bout.