My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy by Kanye West

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy

Kanye West

3.4
Rating
29874
Votes
1
14%
2
12%
3
21%
4
27%
5
26%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 16)

fantastic beats. fantastic guest vocals. generally not a fan of his flow and his constant self-aggrandizement is exhausting. only made harder to listen to by his non-stop idiocy in real life. i do actually really like "Power", and not exclusively because of the King Crimson samples. 2 stars.

Liked it. Sad to listen to it now because Kanye is barely a person now.

Splitting the person and their art is always hard. I loved this album when it was released but I guess now I listen to it less. It’s still a great album though.

*miss the old kanye line*

Great album but just not his best album

Could I possibly ever rate this anything other than 5*? Absolutely not

Kanye is mid and so is this album.

Not a Ye fan per se, but I found this album very listenable. I’ll have to get over my dislike of him and open up to more of his music.

I think I understand it, but it's not my cup of tea. I understand that it is a very influencial/already classic record from Kanye, a lot of bangers and recognizable bits. It did not impact me as much as it did others, especially at the time, but that is due to my taste. People rave about the production of this album, but I just don't get it. I feel other albums, in hip hop as well, have done such a better job at it, and I feel this gets that praise because it is Kanye, and an easy compliment to the guy, "he is a great producer". Yeah, he is, but I just don't feel it here. An easy listen, and a harder one if you delve into the lyrics and features, but it did not blow me away like it did to a lot of people.

Every song is so powerful, so composed. The features are all deliberate, and the album's flow from song to song thoughtfully presented (although "Christian Dior Denim Flow" should have replaced "Blame Game" 100%). A reasonable contender for greatest hip hop album of all time. "Runaway" is my all-time favorite, but this re-listen solidified that "Monster" is one of his greatest songs across his career

It’s a great album and there’s some classics on there. I’m a Kanye fan even now when everyone seems to hate him, he’s been one of the best producers of all time and continues to do so! This album starts so strong, songs like Power and all of the lights are iconic! Monster is a great collaboration with some great verses. Runaway is amazing with its simple piano melody creating an emotional and full beat with the lyrics to match. Blame game is another amazing sample (although I heard its use was a bit controversial!) but to take that Avril 14th and turn it into blame game is special. Only reason it’s not 5 stars is that I feel the last 2 tracks are a bit filler for me personally, but still a great album

one of my least favorite humans/musicians don't like or appreciate his music, and nothing makes you less of a genius than declaring that you're a genius. Such a clown. It'd be lovely if he retired. Lost in the World only decent song on here.

I hated this. I don’t care how creative Kanye is I despise the vulgarity, the misogynism, and the immature boastful arrogance. Just foul.

I've never listened to one of his albums and was surprised by the range. While I'm not a fan of the person, the album was great.

IDK. Songs are chock full of sonic ideas and collaborators galore and a result they go on and on and on...and on. Is this prog rap? Wild maximalist arrangements. Overly long songs (not side long orchestral dirges but several approaching 7 minutes) full of twists and turns. Definitely indulgent. Call convoluted album title. And of course this includes a prominent sample from ground zero for actual prog rock...My Dark Twisted Tales from the Topographic Ocean.

I like Kanye's flow and he's obviously a Pro Tools wizard. However, he may have gone too far in a few places on My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. I dig "Monster" and "Hell of a Life."

well, i expected to like this album more than i did: on paper, a maximalist art pop / hip hop album (viewed with millennial nostalgia colored glasses) should be a slam dunk, but this wound up being a really mixed listening experience for me. i tend to like bombastic / rock opera stuff, but the big, sweeping movements on this album were disorienting because sometimes, i loved them, and sometimes, i was left sitting and twiddling my thumbs. i think they hit more than they miss, but i had multiple instances where i would favorite a song in the first minute or so, and then contemplate un-favoriting it at minute three or five. some high highs, some meh lows. a lot of the parts that i did like were the features, because of kanye's rapping... well, i like parts of it. for me, the hard-hitting features point to the genius production that, at times, i would say is immaculate. the production is the highlight of this listen for me, and i can absolutely hear the influences - from what it takes previously to what it gives going forward - that this album brings. highlights - POWER, monster, so appalled, lost in the world

Considering the Generator gave me The College Dropout less than a week ago and Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... (an album by Raekwon that was produced by RZA) just yesterday, getting Kanye West's My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy today has me beginning to wonder if it truly is randomized. I'm catching on, Generator – you better watch your back! In all seriousness... MBDTF is one of the few albums on this list that I actually have heard, but it's been quite some time (probably around six years since I last spun it). Since then, he's released five new albums (haven't bothered to check out the most recent three, as I've heard nothing but bad things about them) and I've been properly educated on all his pre-2010 albums. That said, I feel pretty much exactly the same way about this LP as I did back in 2019 – these are some of Kanye's most iconic tracks, bundled together in a pretty odd way, with some baffling mixing decisions. If you don't think about it too hard, it FEELS like near-perfect album... However, for someone like me, who actually cares about an album telling a story through its direction and sequencing, it does fall flat. Don't get me wrong, MBDTF is a pretty strong album – it just plays more like a greatest hits reel than a bona fide concept album (which it's clearly trying to be). My biggest takeaway from revisiting the LP after finally hearing Kanye's first four albums is that there's a little bit of each project here – you'll find the chopped-up soul of The College Dropout, the infectious beats of Graduation, the emotional auto-tune of 808s & Heartbreak and even a little bit of Late Registration's conscious lyrics here. If someone were looking to get into Kanye West (no idea why they would in 2025) and knew basically nothing about his music, MBDTF would be a great place to start because there are so many potential avenues to explore depending on which style they're feeling. Kanye may not be a very good person, but My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is a pretty notable and enjoyable piece of his storied career! Highlights: Dark Fantasy, POWER, All of the Lights, Devil in a New Dress, Runaway, Hell of a Life, Lost in the World

Fuck Kanye Favorite Track: Runaway

Principle

Hate how much I was liking this! Not letting myself go above a 3 for any Kanye album because I'm not giving good scores to any self-proclaimed admirer of Hitler, but I totally see why people loved this one so much.

Runaway is awesome

I want to preface this by saying I completely understand why this is here - really did influence a lot of the sounds of the decade. But I do think it’s overproduced and overrated. Was neutral about this album in high school - dont really like it now. Absolutely hate his voice, flow is mediocre at best, and while some of the lyrics were fine, there was always at least one or two downright stupid lines that ruined the whole song. No amount of great guest features and interesting samples will make me like this, sorry. :( Favs: None

Separate the art from the artist

This one’s for lamp

Shame about what happened after, but an undisputed classic. 5.

Hell of a life is one that i havent' heard and really like. the classics are classic for a reason runaway is genius monster is monster all of the lights is hype.

I just don't want to

I don’t listen to Rap/Hip hop, I’m out of my depth. Some of the music was cool but was very repetitive and the rapping gets overwhelming quick

070925 18:43 3

Lotta good stuff here. Also, a lotta marginal stuff. For all the overflowing and overweening creativity, one finds one's patience tested by some of the lamer joke, by the sheer volume of ideas, hooks, samples, etc., and the faux intensity (not to mention the misogyny). Ye does suck all the air out of the room, doesn't he, and by design, too. Best standalone tracks are "Devil in a New Dress" and "Runaway." Rounding up because of boldness of including King Crimson samples and Michael Jackson references. Great to hear Gil-Scott Heron, but Ye is no G-SH, let's be clear. Kids this record – and Ye himself – don't matter nearly as much as he – or you – might think and no one should take oneself this seriously. One wonders if he woulda been better records had he not indulged himself – would the music be improved if he improved himself as a, you know, human being? And will this age well? One thinks not.

He was awesome before the psychosis induced nazism

Tenho tanta pena que o Kanye seja um psycho nos dias de hoje! Não sou nem ninguém cá fui fã de Hip Hop, mas este álbum é um “clássico” para os millenials. Runway é a minha favorita (basic, mas não quero saber).

Love runaway, musically really good but some of the lyrics got lazy. "I'm gonna put your pussy in a sarcophagus". Prefer college dropout

Didn’t listen cuz I don’t want any of my money going to Kanye, but this album is an absolute banger

Moro moro :D Kanye West on kyl yks suosikeista ja tällä albumilla oli kyl paljon hyviä kappaleita joita oon ennenki kuunnellu. Kanye on lyrical genius jonka neroutta ei monet ymmärrä. Mahtava levy mut ei täydellinen omaan korvaan.

Alkuun oli ihan jeppis, mut puolessa välissä jotain tapahtu ja loppu albumi oli semi tylsää kuunneltavaa. Alulle ois voinu antaa jopa 4/5 mutta loppu oli 2/5 elikkäs arvioisin kokonaisuuden 3/5.

Kaikin puolin toimiva platta siltä ajalta kun Kanye oli vielä edes jotenkin järjissään. Paljon hyviä featteja mukana ja löytyy levyltä muutama "megahitti". Tykkään tällä levyllä monen biisin rakenteesta miten biisi kasvaa alusta eteenpäin. Hyviä introja yms. Mutta ei kuitenkaan kipua omalla asteikolla ihan neljään tähteen. Vahva 3

I miss the old Kanye

I was a big fan of Kanye's first couple of records but this is when he started getting weird. Too many bars about balls. It makes me sad. Great features from Kid Cudi and Rihanna. Jay Z always sucks.

Tämä oli ihan jees albumi, tasapainottelee kolmen ja neljän tähden välillä. Muutama kova bängeri löytyy levyltä, mutta löytyy kyllä tylsempiäkin biisejä. Lopputulemana pienen pohdinnan jälkeen kolme tähteä tuntuu sopivalta arvosanalta.

Tää onkin helppo lätty arvostella, kun tullut kuunneltua jo ennestään suhteellisen paljon. Ja jumalauta että on laatu Kanyeta + legenda nimiä tuottajina, minkä kuulee kyllä soundista. Ei oo yhtään biisiä, minkä aikana tulisi mieleenkään skipata. Omat top pickit levyltä ehdottomasti Monster ja Gorgeous. Ja pakko nostaa Monsterista Minajin verse aina esille. Ihan helvetin kova vaikka en muuten kyseistä artistia kuuntele. Levy täynnä rentoilua, nostalgista tunnelmaa, poppia ja asennetta.

kinda of a brilliant album

Good poetry. Reprehensible human.

Tää oli melkein raskaampi kokemus ku Napalm Death. Alkuun oli pari kivaa taustabiittiä, mutta kaiken pilas Kanyen ja kavereiden lässytys. En tiedä onko tää jotenkin vallankumouksellista kamaa aikanaan, mutta näin maallikon korvin tuntuu että tätä samaa geneeristä menoa on tehty jo vähintään kolmatta vuosikymmentä. Nykyinen ulkomusiikillinen Kanye huomattavasti viihdyttävämpi. Hämmentävintä on kuitenkin se, että miten ihmeessä kaveri on miljoonansa (miljardinsa?) tehnyt. 1 xtra tähti hyvästä yrityksestä.

Good up there with other great rap albums probably outstanding for its time. Good mix between rap and melody.

I like some songs, not really my type

Was this pre-madness? It's pretty cool

good album, awful person.

Melkosen junnaavaa

Oikein hyvän kuuloisia biisejä, mut tapa jolla Kanye on kohdellut Taylor Swiftiä ei ansaitse minkäänlaista tunnustusta.

Mid 3/low 3? Chris Rock was the best part of this album. A lot of these songs just feel too long and south park really got Kanye

terrible album from a terrible person

5 stars I have a history with this album. It transitioned me from close-minded about contemporary (at the time) hip hop to a fan. This album is huge, with production, guest verses, Kanye’s own flow, and no skippable tracks. This was the culmination of a near perfect first 5 albums (plus Watch the Throne a year later). This album is as close to perfect as Kanye ever got, and the things that fall short of perfect (the excesses of “Runaway” and “Blame Game”) are forgivable in the scheme of things. Obligatory comments about Kanye being a troubled and troubling person who has only gotten worse with time.

I like classic hip-hop, I don't like this. I can't says its bad but it feels like one of those modern remakes of a classic car where it does the things its meant to do much better but without any of the charm.

Tää taitaa olla ajalta, kun kaniksen trollausvaihe oli viel maltillisemmalla tasolla. Hyviä biisejä, vaikkei tässä kyl mitään syväluotausta johonkin läbändeeruspuoleen ehtinyt tekemään ja en tiiä jaksaako kiinnostaakaan. Ehkä liian pitkä kokonaisuus, että jaksais kertaistumalta kuunnella.

Yritetty lähestyä avoimin mielin, mutta ei vaan iske omaan korvaan. Laadukkaasti tuotettu kuitenkin, ja yritetty "kaikkee jännää" joten ei kehtaa antaa ihan 1 tähteä

Kayen hippiduhop ei oikein iske. Tylsää. Toisaalta tavallaan ehkä ymmärrän miksi levy on listalla. Samalla kova huoli Biancasta.

Jotain ok sampleja käytetty ja ei ehkä hirveintä genressä, mut ei tää kyl yhtään sytytä. 1/5

Vihdoin sain tietää mistä yksi hyvä spinningtunnin biisi on, siitä lisäpiste. Pari hyvää biisiä, jos tietoisesti unohtaa itse Kanyen sekoilut vuosien varrella. Vähän outo levy.

Täytyy varmaan yrittää erottaa taiteilija taiteestaan, ja olla välittämättä Kanyen mielipiteistä. Levyllä on huikean nerokkaita melodiakoukkuja ja tarttuvaa musiikkia muutenkin. Vastapainona kyllä sitten myös vähän tylsempiä biisejä. Ehkä vartin lyhyempänä olisi ollut neljän tähden levy, nyt vahva 3/5

Vahinkoarvio :)

He was a lot better when he was openly dissing the Orange Monster.

Fish Sticks 🐠🐟

(95/100)

Kanye's last great album before his descent into insanity. Some outstanding tracks. Very raw in places.

Kanye moment. It has POWER so that's why it's here. It's fine, but nothing particularly standout otherwise. I just don't like rap I guess.

Separating art from artist, this is one of the greatest albums of all time, and certainly one of the best of the 10s, if not the best. Incredible production, lyrics that serve as a strong summation of the artist, massive choruses, great guest spots, multiple iconic songs that would define soundtracks for the next decade. There's a reason Kanye's ego spiralled so out of control, because for a brief moment, he was one of the greatest in the world.

Too bad some people will instantly disregard cause the artist or the genre. Long before he was whack job he was a seriously talented artist. First half of this album is a 5 then is trails off near the end. Will revisit for shre

Hip hop is not music. And from Kanye West to boot. I have no desire to listen to shit from a black Nazi. Adidas was right to finally part ways with him. I won't even enter into a liaison with him. That may be prejudiced. But sometimes I don't feel like sniffing at every pile, only to realize that it's shit after all. There's only one mandatory star in the drawer where Kanye West is. 1/5

8/10 - terrible human but great album

Used to think this was #1 but there’s a bunch of bad songs here

- é estranho voltar a ouvir esse álbum depois de tanto tempo - eu gostava muito, mas hoje vejo que ele terceirizou o trabalho de muita gente - ele ser insuportável prejudica minha vontade de ouvir o que ele tem pra dizer

Except for Runaway, wasn't feeling it. 2.5/5

Interesting. Vulgar but not gratuitous.

If we could rate his music only we would give it a 5. But he is about the worst person alive, which is really saying something. I often wonder would his music be so good if he weren't so crazy?

I'm not a Kanye fan and I can't even understand the slang just because of how I grew up. He has good songs, but this album only has one song I can be okay with just because I heard it before in the past in the car.

A really interesting, genre-blending hip hop album that predates the dull mumble rap of the late 2010s and Kanye becoming a more controversial figure. POWER and it's use of King Crimson stands out to me but there's a lot of good here.

Amazing album.

At best, there were some zinger lines. Some auto-tuned basic lyrics, unoriginal melodies, and nothing that I see deserves to be on this list. The "best" song was only my favorite because it had more talented artists included.

Fuck this shit.

Got caught with 30 rocks, the cop look like Alec Baldwin They rewrite history, I don't believe in yesterday And what's a Black Beatle anyway, a fuckin' roach? I don't really give a fuck about it at all 'Cause the same people that tried to blackball me Forgot about two things, my Black balls

muy bueno el negro

Some bangers, some not (monsters). Pretty damn good as far as rap

One of my all time favourites! Monster sounds dated now, though it was one of my favourites when it first came out. So Appalled and Devil in a new Dress are also weaker than the rest. Runaway 10/10 Hell of a Life 10/10 Gorgeous 10/10 All of the lights 10/10

Kanye West is a genius. But geniuses have been know the flirt with insanity. There is no song on this album that won’t get your foot tapping or your head nodding. And the list of collaborators is a who’s who in music.

I've never been a huge fan of Kanye, like a unpredictable toddler that sometimes shows promise. He's good but not amazing and the same goes for this album. Also modern day albums always seem to go on longer, sometimes twice as long. Is this because of ego or do the artists just have a lot of mid rated songs and they can't decide what to put on the album.

You pretend you're going beyond the rap genre because you're a new renaissance genius and you act like that (yes we all know you're crazy, we don't fucking care). The truth is that your music is pretentious AND lame. You're not ELP nor Yes, but a boring individual. Your version of Iron Man is stupid and worst of all, pretend to be clever. Music is so stupid nowadays.

Kanye sucks = 1. Album great = 5 Therefore 3

I can completely compartmentalise my personal feelings about an artist away from how I feel about their music. So with that in mind, while he may be an absolute dick, I really am loving this. In fact, more than other rap albums I have heard. It actually feels very retro 90s rap and I think the vocals in the background in every track lift it to a new glorious dimension.

- Verassend goed, veel herkenbare dingen - 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM

Ambitious album with several iconic tracks and a seemingly endless amount of collaborators.

Forgot how much I LOVE this album

I am not the target audience for this, and I'm not convinced there is a target audience for this. I think the dude just did his own thing and doesn't care what others think, so props for that. But also, yeah, I won't be listening to this again.

It's almost impossible to like Kanye the person at this point, but the music ain't bad. That said, I was glad when it was over. It was interesting in parts but more than I needed.

Kanye zanim oszalał :)

great production, stands up well after a long time

Can't stand the person, can't deny the talent.

Power is good. Didnt like much more than that.

Fuck Kanye forever.

i genuinely think you are either racist or stupid if you don't like this album

Peak Kanye West. This albums music was ahead of its time (2010). A masterpiece. Powerful.

God help me, I think I need to turn in my progressive card because I legitimately enjoyed the hell out of this. Really loved the composition but found some of the lyrics a bit cringe. I understand now why they called him the GOAT, too bad he had to throw it all away

He’s insane but the album is good 7/10 points docked for his personality

5 stars no question. One of the best albums of all time. Gives me shivers and emotion of nostalgia. I admittedly didn't really listen to it much when it came out but have grown to love it. Fuck Kanye West now smh.

this is unfortunately a perfect album. wish it was made by anyone else.

Silloin ei kanye ollut näin hullu, köpö kuitenkin. Kyllä tämän kerran kuuuntelee. Narsistinen paska se silti on.

Fantano was lowkey right on his scoring. This album's quality drops off a cliff after All Of The Light and it doesnt really bounce back despite trying on some tracks. Given how Ye's obssession with porn and delusions of grandeurs have gotten worse, it almos feels like he was foreshadowing his own current demise, but if anything, it doesn't make the album any better, moreso it servers as merely the cutting off point from his peak to his fall from grace. Important record, but nevertheless inconsistent.

Didn’t listen because he’s the worst and I don’t want him getting any of my money

listening to this reminded me of rihanna's titties in the all of the lights video 🚬

omfg.... i really was a huge kanye stan when he came into the scene and each album was getting better and better before gestures at how he is now.......... so i haven't went back to his music in like... a year plus? so revisiting this i can't get over how fucking talented he is 😭 it's still so good............. can't believe i remember all the words too LMAO. wow take me back 🚬

Fuck Kanye but I'm afraid this album is quite fantastic.

Man, this album is so hard to rate because on one hand, it used to be one of my favorite albums that got very regular playtime but on the other hand, Kanye is a racist Nazi now and I generally boycott music from Nazis. It's been years since I've listened to this album at this point and while I enjoyed hearing some of my old favorites from prime, non-Nazi Kanye, it doesn't have the same charm as it used to no knowing what Kanye turns into years later. 3/5. Easy 5 if he wasn't a Nazi, straight up 0/1 if it wasn't such a good album, objectively, so I'll split the difference.

Rating:9.8/10 best kanye album complaints: the skit on blame game is corny af other than that everything is perfect it's one of the best albums ever made

I have to separate the art from the artist. Kanye’s a horrible and mentally ill person but this album is fantastic.

I really liked this one. It reminded me of albums like Igor and Because the Internet that are full of lush production that pull from different inspirations. Some of the songs were a bit too self aggrandizing for my taste but overall well made album

Some people may like it. Better than other recommendations I’ve received here.

Okay what I like most about this album is all the nasty lyrics about pussy and fucking and stuff. :P 4 stars

so extra, so maximalist, so grand, so all over the place. 4.5/5

most overrated album of all time probably dark fantasy, devil in a new dress and runaway are the only good songs the rest is the type of shit drake would get clowned on if hed written it

Hahahaha hahahaha! Nope. Get in the bin you freak. Annual leave request from this monolithic undertaking has been put in.

Second Kanye album from the generator and I'm starting to realize all the music dudes online lied about this album being one of the best albums of all time. It's not even one of the best rap albums of all time. The samples on some songs were really cool but the rest was meh. If it wasn't Kanye, the album would've been cooler but sadly it is him 2/5

Fuck Kanye West, but this is his last good album, and it's brilliant. Brilliant enough that Kanye's worst ramblings (at the time) were able to be excused by his talent. But this was before he became an actual Nazi. The albums of Kanye's chosen for the list are largely not his best in my opinion, except for this one. But this album makes me sad because it's so good, and he'll never get back there again. He's too hate-filled and believes his own hype too much. This album does fall off a little near the end with some of the epically long songs, but the first few songs are possibly the best he's ever done. I have to separate the art from the artist to rate it properly, and in that case it truly deserves 5 stars.

Not the masterpiece everyone makes it, but enjoyable. It's too over-produced and too long. Also, fuck Ye.

It is fine... The production is very solid obviously but each song drags on a bit too long considering the fact that there is little of substance to be extending by the time Ye is done pontificating on how people dislike him and how lowly he views women. I am not a fan of the lyrics either beyond the Monster Mash going on about 20 minutes in. That being said I did laugh out loud when the 21st Century Schizoid Man sampling began. Music For Assholes

I think the beginning of this album is fantastic; I really dig pretty much everything up to and including "Monster". After that, it's a bit shakier for me, and I certainly start to feel the length. I suppose my only hot take is that, while I love the outro of "Runaway", I'm not a huge fan otherwise. I respect some of the sincerity of the verses, but the chorus totally takes me out of it. I certainly don't see myself rushing to listen to it again any time soon, but in time, I think it could potentially rise in my estimations. 3.5/5

Hard to listen to with his current public persona. Impossible to seperate art from the artist with songs like runaway ☠️

Standouts Power All of the Lights

15 years ago I would have rated this 5 stars. Truly is a work of art. However, being unable to separate the art from the artist, MBDTF gets two stars. A star was added to the rating to take into account the artistry of the album, but Ye’s past work doesn’t get a pass from me for his hurtful and idiotic comments today.

I liked this album at some point, but Ew Kanye

It‘s like mbdtf

I've never knowingly listened to Kanye before, so I was going into this completely blind. It was much better than I had expected, but it still is not my thing. Monster was a lot of fun, especially the Nicki Minaj section.

I really didn't want to like this album. As a rule i want very little to do with Nazi sympathisers. I liked the album but i won't be listening to it again

Honestly better than I expected

To cite my prologue from Eric Clapton, Kid Rock, and many more - bad people can make good music. Kanye West is an amazing producer, a good rapper and an okay writer. That's fine, he brings in a ton of features and cowriters to fill the gaps and puts together a good album that even though personally, I'm not a fan of his style I did enjoy. 4/5

Can't stand the bloke, his views, his ego, and his shitty tunes.

There are some underrated bangers on this one, like POWER and Lost In The World. His production and samples are on point - I especially liked the King Crimson one. It doesn't get a 5 because the quality isn't really consistent through out. Couple of duds in there

Get fucked, Kanye

Nah fuck Kanye

Not my kinda music but I can recognize peak

kannski ekki elst vel. en mjög metnaðarfull. synfónískar útsetningar. fíflið er frekar slakur rappari og auðvitað ömurleg persóna. fílaði mjög á sínum. kann ekki við að lækka mikið vegna fyrri áhrifa.

Not a fan. No real value there.

yeah it was good

Not your typical Hip-Hop album, but then Kanye West isn't your typical Hip-Hop artist. Wikipedia also gives the genre as Progressive Rap, which for an an album that samples Mike Oldfield's "In High Places" and King Crimson's "21st Century Schizoid Man", as well as using the tune from Black Sabbath's "Iron Man" is probably a fair description. Highly experimental in places. Apart from the misogynistic lyrics in places, (e.g. "Blame Game"), I quite liked the album.

Kanye West-My Dark Twisted Fantasy Incredibly underwhelming album. Wonderful production and technical aspects but the lyrics are trite and often insipid and Kanye is an incredibly monotonous rapper.

My first instinct was to give this a hard pass but I'm committed to giving every album a chance. Made it halfway through. There's no denying the talent and the production; it's just not for me. And I don't need to listen to a jerk boast about how great he is. There's enough of that in the news these days.

In parts truly beautiful, dark, twisted, and fantastic. However, for my personal taste, it's a little too commercial/geared towards mainstream tastes and the tracks are too long. Probably deservedly Kanye's most successful work, but I also find it the least experimental. Maybe I'm wrong, though, because these songs and the sound in general have been played to death. 3.5/5

As I always say. Rap crap. Not a fan.

Since he’s a self-proclaimed Nazi, this only gets 1 star. To briefly separate artist from the art, I’d say this album is at a 3 for me. I liked Dark Fantasy and All of the Lights, plus some of the samples and featuring artists in other songs. Kanye was probably the worst part about all of the songs and his ego and misogyny are a major turn off.

A hard one to review. Partly because he sucks so much in real-life but also because any negative reviews will probably be looked at as reviews of Kanye as a person (again, he sucks). But I can say that I have listened to this album several times before he went fully off the deep end and I have never understood the hype. And after this listen, I still don't. It isn't bad and there are things I enjoyed. But it is too long and feels lacking because of how hyped it is.

Some of it is fine but there's just so much garbage. And then there's the album itself.

I really don't like Kanye West as a person but this was a very good album.

You can't deny the production quality, the smooth seamless vocals, the excellent beats that support the message and the cutting edge lyrics. What I didn't realise is how "Trumpian" this album was. If you want to understand Trump listen to this. It isn't pro trump, it's if he was channeling trump. "I'm a monster, you knew it you wanted me anyway so stop crying". It's excellent but disturbing and while it doesn't align with my political views you can't deny it. Monster hits it on the head. A must have.

I don't know if it's because it didn't age well or that it's just my disgust for the guy that is having an impact on my appreciation of this album, but this is way more boring than what I remembered. There are some inventive beats and all, but for the most part it failed to impress me and it takes a lot of time for the album to pick up steam.

The guy's a fucking idiot, but he still could make a decent record back then.

The first 6 tracks feel like an intro for the album to finally starts at the 7th song. By chance, everything from then to the end is really good. Moody and creative beat + heartfelt delivery from Kanye. It would be a strong 4 if it wasn't of the 6 first tracks.

Kanye is Lord

Good but not my fav album

just so unfortunate man

Overraskede egentligt positivt ved at være mere melodisk end forventet. Men albummet var for langt.

Not my thing really but appreciate the craft and the production quality. However, Kanye is a dick, to say the least.

Kanye West might not be a crazy lyricist or necessarily that good of a rapper, but he's a fantastic producer and absolutely knows how to make a catchy song (well, at least used to know). This album is full of extremely memorable bangers. The fact that the rapping here is not that special is compensated by this lush, maximalist production, which I absolutely love. Since hip hop is mostly focused on vocals, a lot of rap albums have very simple, rudimentary production (or at least used; I don’t really follow hip hop that closely, so I’m not entirely sure; most recent albums from the genre I’ve heard put a lot more effort into production), which is kind of boring to me. This album focuses more on the instrumentals, which I prefer. The only problem with this album is that it falls of a bit in the second half and becomes too slow and dark for my taste. It really is a shame what happened to Kanye. He used to be such an amazing artist…

Corny at times but still good. Kanye is a really, really good producer. But the lyrics are corny porn addict shit and it's kind of embarassing. There's a reason 14 year old boys love him so much. But it still sounds pretty modern 15 years later and that's impressive.

This was a good album listen and the early inception of Kanye's thought processes. I miss these early album years Kanye.

I am a bit disappointed because I really hoped I would like this. I did about half of the time. Monster and Blame Game were my least favourite. Best song on here, of course, is Runaway. It was however, fun to recognise the samples throughout the album.

Love him or hate him, the dude can turn a phrase. The problem is that the songs are covering the same ole boring hip hop stories we've all heard countless times. While I personally get no enjoyment out of hearing people drop bars, no matter how good they are at it, I do respect that he has a good ear for catchy instrumentals and song structures. I would never choose to listen to this album, but I can easily understand why those who love this genre would. So, it makes sense that this would be included. As an aside, the thing I find the funniest about him is that people seem surprised by his behaviors. Particularly recent hijinks but he always seemed to be that kind of trail mix where you never knew what you were going to get. In his early years, I think that people just kept looking past his extreme behavior because they assumed they were just calculated publicity and marketing stunts to generate awareness and interest in his music. On the other hand maybe they always were?

This has some good songs on it, but the second half is just kinda boring. And apart from the obvious hits, there wasn't much to look forward to. This definitely isn't Kanye's best.

Fuck this guy.

Fuck this guy

Really well written and produced album. Not my favorite style, but I understand the art and it’s well done. I get why it’s a top 20-25 album ever.

It's OK. I mean it's fine. Some of the songs are genuinely good, but this album is overrated. And he's a Nazi, so there's that.

Tried to separate the music from the artist. Great in it’s time, no different now if I’m being honest

Innehåller ju flera av hitsen, men av princip så blir det lägre rating

What can I say

Maaaaaan, idk. Maybe I could get into an earlier album more. A lot of other artists featured on here and they were great. Rick Ross was INCREDIBLE. Had some standout lines that will definitely make it into my regular usage. “I wear my pride on my sleeve like a bracelet If God had an iPod, I'd be on his playlist” “Cause you haters got PhDs Y'all just some major haters and some math minors“ “I call you bitch for short”— “you call me asshole for long”

Имба нахуй

I really thought about skipping this one but I haven't missed a day yet so I just went ahead with it. I really enjoyed the 10 or so seconds of "21st Century Schizoid Man" that was sampled at one point. The rest, well, not so much - or not at all really.

This is now the second of this style of hip-hop on this journey I've gone through. It seems to be very similar in that it's "triumphant" with some hints of soul. Reminds me of that late 2000s/early 2010 sound. It isn't for me especially how cocky Kanye is.

Flöt lite förbi tbh, men det var bra

That’s an hour and two minutes too much of Kanye. Lots of F’-ing and N’-ering throughout, no surprise there. Significantly better than The College Dropout, but he’s still a jackass, no surprise there either, and a little further up his own ass than earlier in his career. Best track is All Of The Lights. Highest I can go is (2.3*s) His rhymin’ is still ridiculous, but maybe now he realizes that…

Kanye steps it up on this release compared to his debut. The man got beats and the package did sellll, but delivery be weaker than the US Maillll...huuuuh? At least this DB got somewhat real and is "So Appalled" with his ridiculous (dickless, dickless, dickless) lifestyle after the fortune/fame and tells women to "Runaway" cause he is a "Monster" (Top Track). Glad the skits were cut from this record and having Chris Rock cameo was a highlight. Need to be careful of artists with album titles such as this one. They are coming out of the woodworks with twisted, dark secret lives. I expect to see Mr. West on this list again amongst others (Epstein). "Who Will Survive America?" These days, I really don't know but be careful what Yeezy teaches you...2.35 stars.

Not as good as the prior Kanye entry. He's got some clever lyrics sprinkled in here and there, but otherwise MBDTF did little to keep me interested. The highlight of this album was Monster, and specifically Nicki Minaj's segment. Beyond this song nothing really stuck with me. Perhaps his schtick had mostly worn off by this point in his career? 2.04 stars

Das müssen eigentlich 4 Sterne sein. 4 Sterne definitiv!

The production is insane,one of the best albums for the last 20 years

Favorite: All of the lights So far all good and then runaway starts...What's with rappers trying to sing I don't get it and 90% of the time don't like it. That's not where their skill lies. Same problems in hell of a life, I just don't like autotuned singing, I don't mind the rest of it though, it's pretty good. This album has some high highs (All of the lights, Monster, So Appalled) but some low lows too (Runaway,). I think overall I enjoyed this though.

Classic even though it’s Kanye

Largely forgettable

Horrible person, but even though I don't usually listen to this type of music regularly I liked the majority of the album.

Horseshit. 0 stars.

Never listened to Kanye before, all I know of him is it sounds like he’s gone crazy in the last couple of years. For the most part I was surprised how much I enjoyed this. There were a couple of duds but the songs that I did enjoy were brilliant. Top Track - Lost In The World

Good but I wouldn’t go out of my way to listen to again. Plus, he’s a horrible person.

Yeah, it's my favorite genre. Music for ads

I love the album, but don't support the artist. I knew I'd get a Kanye album and considered whether I'd listen to it. I've decided to separate the art from the artist, and I'm glad I did. The production is amazing, the writing is witty, and the features are great! Fav tracks: I loved most of the album, personal favorites are "Blame Game" and "Devil in a New Dress". The latter half of "Power" is great. 5/5

I enjoyed this album, in spite of some hilariously weird lyrics that I think only Kanye could come up with. The man certainly sees the world differently, but it works for a lot of the time.

This was the last album Kanye showed any self awareness. Battling the combination of his ego and the power that comes with fame, it clearly felt like he was on a tipping point. In retrospect, we know he lost that battle. Outstanding album. One the best produced albums I’ve ever heard.

This is my first time listening to Kanye, and gotta admit, this is some fantastic stuff. It sounds great, the lyrics are fun, compositions are complex, I guess other than the crazy he's become, I'd have to say I'm a fan

Hate this dude but my god this album is great.

This is Kanye’s best album, but Kanye has simply ruined Kanye. While not one for cancel culture, Kanye is a clear exception. He’s the worst humans category, making his music dramatically less appealing. Fuck Kanye.

I tried putting off, listening to this album as I could, bit the bullet and listened to to it. It was not as bad as I anticipated it would be; however not my kind of music; I am not asking for a refund today.

I’m conflicted. Definitely like some of the songs but I just can’t get behind Kanye now that he’s a crazy trump supporter

psa for mental health awareness

0 points for Kanye and 0 points for the misogyny…but listening to this just for the music it was almost a 5 for me

Psa for mental health awareness

Svårt att skilja verket från upphovspersonen. Men om jag bortser från vad Kanye hittat på de senaste åren så är det en kompetent skiva. Bombastiskt, domedagsstämning men ändå med hit-potential. Ibland blir det för mycket av allt som i All of the lights. Det är också från och med denna låt som albumet blir mindre intressant. Mer eller mindre misogyna texter. Jag vill helst avfärda det här helt och hållet, men här finns ändå något intressant i Wests begynnande galenskap.

Going into this, I didn't know how to approach reviewing a Kanye album in the present day. His political and social "extracurriculars" as of late are inexcusable and unignorable, and to me his embrace of fascist ideology and imagery casts an *awfully* dark shadow over his discography. I like quite a bit of Kanye's music, but anymore I just don't really want to hear it. That being said, I don't think "art vs artist" conversations are especially helpful, art is shaped by the good and bad of a person, and I think people need to embrace analyzing great art by bad people by confronting how the bad in a person effects the art we love. That being said, I do like this album, and I do plan on reviewing it by its own merits with regards to Kanye as an individual. Besides, my capacity for harm here is pretty limited, anyone still enthusiastically on the Kanye train at this point is pretty much conclusively too far gone, and no one willing to hold him accountable will put that notion aside because I (an individual with no meaningful platform) said that My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is good. And as I said, it *is* good, granted I also think it is sorta overrated, but listening through this, there is a lot to love. The first thing to remember about My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is that it was created with the intent of being good enough and extravagant enough to win back a public that soured on Kanye after the fated Taylor Swift VMAs incident. And, considering this, I think it was really smart for Kanye to take, what I think of as a director's role here. He does appear on pretty much every song here, but to be honest, Kanye's writing and rapping leaves something to be desired at times. He has all the Kanye-isms, but that is a *very* "your mileage may vary" thing, and it hinges a lot on how invested you are in Kanye (personally I'm not *that* invested, and I can't see that really changing any time soon). This feels like the first album where he is really embracing the "asshole who is kind of relatable at the end of the day" thing, and while we have quotables here and unique flows, it isn't a schtick I really buy into. Frankly I'd rather have the Yeezus "I'm just an asshole and I think you should all hate me" thing at this point. In fact, in the presence of features, Kanye is very rarely the best verse on his own songs here. But where Kanye really succeeds on MBDTF is in curation, artistic vision, and production. He pretty much formed a camp of artists, rappers, singers and producers to orchestrate the creation of this thing. Consequently, every song has like 4 features and 15 producers and writers, but the album still very much feels like Kanye's. So in a lot of these songs, Kanye isn't necessarily a strong vocal presence, but he is still felt very strongly. It allows the listener to disconnect the album a little bit from Kanye, while still allowing him to retain all of his creative control. And the results are pretty great, this album really feels like a blockbuster, the sound is rich and maximalistic, and Kanye successfully bridges the pop and rap sound in a way that ended up extremely influential on the development of mainstream pop and rap thoughout the 2010s. We leap straight in, Dark Fantasy is rich and grand and catchy, it is an effective mission statement for the album as a whole. Shortly afterwards, we get a few really incredible "pop" Kanye tracks, POWER and All Of The Lights are pretty much unimpeachable. They are both incredibly detailed, incorporating all kinds of sounds and collaborators from Kanye's pool. POWER seems almost tailor-made to be played in Gatorade commercials, but in a way that isn't obnoxious. All of The Lights is similarly driving in a glitzier way, with big horns and *surprisingly* dense drumwork. We then get, perhaps the most iconic more pure "rap" tracks from the project in Monster and So Appalled. Both songs have incredible production, and strong verses, tons of quotables and great, distinct flows from their many *many* features. After Devil In A New Dress, we get Runaway, which I see frequently cited as the greatest achievement here. Honestly, I do think Runaway is a little overrated. It is a very interesting declaration of self awareness from Kanye, that I think he may not be capable of making at the current point in his career. However, he has some really *obnoxious* Kanye lyrics here, and the autotune solo is kind of self indulgent. On some level, I do at least sort of like every song here (or at least parts of every song), but I so have several complaints across this album. I'm not sure I'm into the vocal processing on Gorgeous, and I am not entirely sold on Devil In A New Dress. I think the verses are whatever, and it I think it's kind of overlong. Hell of A Life has a great Beat, but the lyrics are Kanye in "sex" mode and it is apparent that he just *might* have an unhealthy relationship with sex, anyways, I can see the lyrics being compelling to the right person, but again, it is awfully "your mileage may vary". The song I have the biggest problem with though is Blame Game. If only because it ends in a 2 minute, 31 second long skit that I just hate. It is too long, the implications about how Kanye views women are ugly, and I just don't think its funny. Regardless of all of this, and how I feel about Kanye and his -isms and everything, I do like this album, maybe even more than I want to. A lot of these songs are really great, and the resultant project is very strong as a coherent work, and I can appreciate that. I am officially giving this a *high* 3, it's like a 7/10. Like I said, there's a lot of good here, but realistically, there are a good few songs on here that I'm never tempted to return to, even if they're still pretty good. Besides, the real problems I do have with this album have compounded a little with the fact that I am not feeling especially generous towards Kanye for obvious reasons. But I will say, I can see the importance of this, even if I don't really get the argument that it is one of the best albums of all time.

nasty person, great musician

Qué decir, a mí este disco me encanta. De mis favoritos, lo escucho muchísimo. Tiene temazos pero escucharlo completo suma un montón. Si le saco 2 o 3 temas sería un no-skip de cabeza.

4/10 I must be as soft as lily white marshmallow, ready to melt in the salty rain of my liberal tears, but the lyrics are horrendous! It's porn, not art. What on earth do they say that is of any value? I mean, not everything has to be Dylan, but hell, this stuff is just filthy. Musically I was pleasantly surprised. Ok, so it is kind of 1 idea, tweak it once and that'll be another song done, but it was alright. But jeez, those lyrics are disgusting.

Horrid. Wish I could give it 0.

Good tracks

Helt ok. Men återigen inget jag återvänder till.

I don’t like the man. That said, there were parts of the album I enjoyed.

I did not listen. I will not support a Nazi even with minimal add or streaming revenue

Really really good. A lot of bangers on here and has a lot of relistening value. I was not the biggest fan of the latter half of the album, so I give it a 4 instead of a 5.

Would have been a 4.4 if he had Kurt cobained it in like 2013. Unfortunately not. Specific rating - 0.0 Fav song- devil in a new dress Least fav- so appalled

Didn’t listen

On Yeezus Kanye told us “he’ll give us what we need, it may not be what we want” Well this is what the people want. HITS and dramaaaaa. Fans: (Get mad that Kanye made fun of T Swift) Kanye: I’m gonna fucking kill myself!!!!! Amazing achievement. Will be listening to a lot of the “Dissect” season on this. That may sway me, but right now I can’t get over how dumb the catalyst to this was. Making a scene at an award show over a MUSIC VIDEO! For that to be his rock bottom is just plain dumb. We now know that would not be his rock bottom, but hearing about how he triumphs over making fun of Taylor Swift is hard to get past. I’m sure I’m glossing over the nuance and how he’s a complicated person etc. Still dumb. Been listening to “Power” a lot after my friend Alex mentioned the King Crimson sample. Very cool. Echo what everyone else has said, bravo you crazy bastard. Letting the T Swift thing slide because I also think she’s overrated.

"Found bravery in my bravado" - this line from the first song on this album announces what Kanye is up to, and the rest of the album backs it up. The first half is stronger than the second half, but no one was doing the kind of stuff Kanye did at the time, and not since either. The beats are all interesting in their own right, and varied from each other. Mixing the sacred (gospel music, harmonies) and profane (grinding beats, autotune, references to his dick) is a classic formula that Kanye mastered here. I don't know if he is a particularly cogent storyteller, documentarian of the human condition or even lyricist, but that's not really what he is about. He is more of an aesthetic innovator than anything - and still, he does that so well that I don't think it's too much of an exaggeration to say this album transcends its genre on its way to being damn near a masterpiece.

An all timer. This came out my sophomore year in high school and half of these songs defined a significant chunk of the soundtrack of my life for the next few years. Its a 5/5 rap album The ensemble of collaborators really pushes it to new heights. The maximalist approach is so much more pleasing to my ear than the Yeezus album was. The album art is so damn provocative. I did a deep dive on George Condo and the way he details human teeth is disturbing, but I cant keep my eyes off it My big gripe: I wonder who is responsible for what on this. Kanye gets credited with the genius but with so many collaborators (?) and producers (7), I wonder where exactly Kanye fits here.. who came up with the core ideas? Is Kanye playing George Martin here with all the strings and horns? The wiki doesn’t describe it enough 🤷‍♂️

This album aged SO WELL. Holy fuck. Got better with time. The production on this is absolutely mammoth. Favorites are Runaway (Pusha T is a gawd), Dark Fantasy, Monster (other than Jay-Z's verse - one of the worst guest verses you'll ever hear). Even Nicki Minaj is great on this album (shout out to whoever her ghostwriters were). As always with Kanye, he left some breadcrumbs of mental illness that are more obvious in retrospect (looking at you, Who Will Survive in America). But hey gotta take the bad with the good

Absolutely insane how many of these songs went on to be huge huge hits. Reminds me of listening to Californication - like, oh shit this song too? And somehow even after hearing most of these songs a ton over the years, none of them feel stale or overplayed. I’ve had POWER on lots of running playlists over the years - that song can make a fat dad feel like Prefontaine. Couple of tracks toward the end that are a little more filler, but this album might find its way into my top 10-20 of all time when it all shakes out.

He may be evil but damnit this album is amazing. 9/10 (leaning down)

Do I hate Kanye West? Yes. Do I think My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is a masterpiece? Absolutely! It is one of the most impressive outings in pop rap, and songs like "Dark Fantasy" and "Runaway" are some of my favorite songs of all time. So, say what you will about how Kanye is a piece of shit, but... Actually, Idk if I can convince any naysayers that this album is amazing at this point. Oh well.

Great album love Kanye he is massively underrated

Ég vissi auðvitað að ég væri að fara að hlusta á rappplötu og bjóst við að þurfa að þrauka þessa en hún var bara allt í lagi og vann á alveg þar til Kanye tók Iron Man söngstefið í lagi un klámstjörnuást. Þá hrundi allt álitið sem var búið að byggjast upp.

6/10 less impressive than I remember it I recognized a large number of the samples used in this album which made me doubt how much talent Kanye actually has? like any idiot can take an already good song and throw some drums and an 808 bass over it granted, I am a sucker for good wordplay and one-liners which this album offers an endless amount of, but I’m not as impressed with the production as I’d like to be :/

Fuck Nazis. (shame as it is an amazing album)

This is so good. Why is this so good? Why didn't I listen to this 15 years ago? I recommend finding fan uploads of this on YouTube so you don't give this Nazi royalties, but this is well worth repeated listens. This is listed as progressive rap and rap opera on Wikipedia, which makes me feel like of COURSE I would be into this. I'm so annoyed I didn't hear this back when it was new and before he alienated close friends and collaborators like John Legend. I was like 8 years late to 808s & Heartbreak and now I'm 15 years late to My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, which I remember being released and I remember friends being excited about it.

Great album. Not what I listen to day to day, but every song on here is incredible.

Heck yes. There's a lot of lot of terrible people in showbusiness but this album is great.

Well we can all agree Kanye West is a terrible human, making this one of the few albums maybe it makes sense to not listen to on official channels so he gets no money. But that being said he sure as hell knows how to write a great album, its got massive beats from start to finish with varied style and tempos keeping you hooked the whole way through and the co labs he has bring some lovely changes to the voices involved in the sound mix. If you listen to his lyrics as well you can start to see the signs of what is his decent into madness and it is hilarious to me to catch the south park fish sticks reference, that really got in his head.

Was never a huge fan of this one, and his last few years have really soured the listening experience over all. Probably would have been 2 without that.

Nazi chumps fuck off

Canciones un poco largas pero guay

One of my favorite Kanye West albums.

Who can listen to Kanye anymore?

This album was like a reflection on who he was after becoming a success. Some of my favourite Kanye songs are on this album, but listening to them back after how much of a terrible person he's become, it's like he knew everything was fucked for him. I wish he learned from his own warning. Going to dock a point because he's a Nazi.

Fantastic record. Lots of great collaborations on this record, and also a lot of well-produced and hype tracks. It's sad that someone so awful could produce something so amazing. Favourite Track(s): POWER, All Of The Lights, Blame Game Least Favourite Track(s): Runaway

Didn’t listen bc I can’t stand Kanye as a human

What Kanye needs is for Harley Pasternak and the Mossad to leave him alone. He's not insane, he was made insane. This is truly a masterpiece. "Well gather around children, zip it, listen... Can we get much higher?" 5/5

You can't deny Kanye is talented. Shitty human being - yes. But also makes great music. Both things can be true at once I really really enjoyed this album. Lots of huge songs on here. All Of The Lights is one of my favourite Kanye songs. Loved the interlude with the strings! I wish he'd get rid of Nicki Minaj's terrible British accent at the start though, that was dreadful 5 ⭐️

My favorite album of all time

Glad I was never into Kanye before he went nuts. Don't have to deal with trying to separate the artist from their shitty opinions. Always disliked him for his big ego. Tried going into this album with an open mind, but still didn't really enjoy it. DNF. 1/5

Initially wasn't sure about this record when it came out after 808 & Heartbreak which I liked but was quite divisive too, but came to view MBDTF ultimately as a classic of the last two decades. Last great Yeezy record with amazing production and a who's who of collaborators, and a far cry from his projects now which are not just weaker but beyond the pale and borderline unlistenable.

Great album

Yeah wheb Kanye was good

I was actually pleasantly surprised by this album . In fact I was actually expecting a far more mid reaction to it which is my usual Kanye ratings. I do like some of the stuff but as a whole I'm not a fan, even when he wasn't controversial. First thing I think this album starts off and ends absolutely spectacularly "Dark Fantasy" and "Lost in the World"/"Who Will Survive in America", are above and beyond what I expected. I also really enjoyed the first four tracks on the album up to "All the Lights". This album to me works really well when it's pretty much crossing over the hip hop and pop landscapes. Starting with "Monster" through "Devil In A New Dress", along with "Hell of A Life" however it kind of gets into the typical rap that I'm not really drawn to, though I did like the guitar work on "Devil". "Runaway" I also enjoyed quite a bit, especially the last four minutes goes into musical textures I honestly think is brilliant. If it wasn't for the stretch of songs, which if I were more into rap in general I'd probably dig it, I could see myself going much higher. (8.4) ★★★★

Wonderful production, good variety. 4.5 stars

Before he turned into an insane person, Kanye West was one of the more innovative hip-hop artists of the 21st century, and this album is really his magnum opus. The production is masterful. There's a super weird collection of artist features including Jay-Z, Raekwon, Rihanna, Nicki Minaj, Justin Vernon, Drake and Elton F**king John. And there's just a ton of great songs here -- "POWER", "All of the Lights", "Monster", "Devil in a New Dress", and "Runaway", which is still one of the best songs of the 21st century. If I had a minor complaint, it's that the album is a bit long, and it would've been killer to just have "Runaway" be the closing track. Still, it's a fantastic album and one of the greatest hip-hop albums of all time. 5 stars.

Nice rare blockbuster album effort for the 2010s. Kanye is at the top of his tormented braggadocio game here and there are loads of great features and samples throughout. King Crimsony-assisted Power and Runaway are the runaway standout productions but All Of The Lights and Aphex Twin derivative Blame Game are also brilliant tracks.

I was always fascinated how “above average” producer and rapper hypnotized so many people to believe he’s genius, and his albums is “monumental”, experimental, etc. And I was like that after 2010, when it wasn’t cool. I saw how in 00s he was just a pop-star and interesting producer, but loved his stupid stunts. Couple of years before him was echoes of 90s, “attitude” era, every year was some crazy celeb, so he was one of them, sometimes cute, sometimes don’t. And his “I’m a genius, I’m glitch, I’m god” was hilarious. But he entertained with his music. No one thinking about him seriously, just pop-music-making-man-with-Ego. I remember how Graduation was Great pop album, I liked it even as an album. 808 was ok, his “experimantation” wasn’t something huge, you’ve got soooo many artist who did that more dramatically, even Outkast was doing bigger moves years before him. And 808 was very “not finished”, a lot of space, very minimalistic, but not in artsy way. And most of the people thought so. But years after everyone thinks it was “Pet Sounds” of 21st century, it was revolution or something. No, it wasn’t. It was interesting, that’s all. But… ok, people were intrigued what can he do next. And MBDTF was interesting indeed. It was full of ideas, great moments, and first half reaaaly close to be something great. But… it wasn’t. It had long outros, that were very tedious. It had interlude, that there just to show of, doesn’t have any weight. Song structures were “not as stupidly simple as you expect” but that doesn’t mean that they have reasons to be that way. Start of the album is interesting, it gets you into energy aaaand… stops it with ending that so unfinished, so uninteresting. And when Gorgeous starts you think “Why you just didn’t skip to the next track? Make some transition, save energy, kick with a bang!” But yeah, he didn’t. And Gorgeous is starting it again, you think, oh, the end must be bonkers but… it crushed flow again. And Power is another example where you can glue this in one piece, THAT would be great opening sequence ona GREAT album. But here… it’s good, but it was made by someone immature and surrounded by “yes-men” too much. And after that everytime it’s is the same: he doesn’t know how to make interesting, throat grabbing progession of ideas. He was touring with U2 before that, he was mesmerized with rock-energy, he make his ressearch and he doesn’t understood correctly. He wanted to mimic, he made some stuff like “they do”, but didn’t quite catch why? After Monster, which maybe the only song that works fully, it’s downhill. Every track has something great, but it’s just not enough work, to make it brilliant, so much shit that makes this journey through the album such a chore. Yeah, every hophead who was a kid at 2010 would forever see this as it’s “Sgt. Pepper” or what ever, but whithout these goggles — it’s just a wasted potential of a great album. He can’t cut things, cause he’s a narcisisst, he “loves” himself too much, so his works always bloated, always undocused, too much of a “tell, don’t show” attitude. He’s a genius in only one way — great overproducer, which works feels very underproduced. His production need another producer, who can make a brilliant album from it. 3+/5 Graduation >>> MBDTF

Despite liking some of these, they're all mostly terrible

Ik ken dit album al goed. Heel vet album!

I really liked this album - more than I expected to. Obviously can't play in the car for kids but will probably listen to it again.

Fuck Kanye.

Musically catchy and some great lyrics.

Kanye’s definitive statement, a colossal and excessive portrait of an egomaniac in crisis. Huge beats, huge hooks, huge stars, huge everything. Full of sin, self-loathing, self-pity, arrogance, violence, and loneliness. Probably a masterpiece. Best song: Runaway

Not for me

Anyone born in the past 15 to 20 years probably only knows Kanye West as a right-wing conspiracy theorist and cultural pariah. But from 2005 to 2011, he wasn’t just a rapper. He was a force. And My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is him at the absolute peak of his powers. This album is loud, dramatic, beautiful, and deeply chaotic. It’s part therapy session, part flex, and part art project. The list of guest features is stacked—Jay-Z, Nicki Minaj, Bon Iver, Kid Cudi, Rihanna—and every one of them brings something solid. Even Chris Rock shows up. And somehow, in the middle of all that star power, Kanye still manages to be the gravitational center. It’s wild that this was his comeback album after the Taylor Swift fallout. Most artists would’ve laid low. Kanye dropped one of the best albums of the decade. Favorite song: Runaway

Great album, have to knock a star off because he’s a bit of a cunt

Listening to this album since my childhood, but big dissapointment of what Kanye West became

There is something compelling about this. It could have been a mess given the amount of people involved but every track works and pulls you in. I have listened multiple times already which says something. Almost loses points for the Chris Rock skit which I absolutely cannot stand. However, 5 stars it is. Didn’t expect that going in to this one

Not my thing. The production is good and it all sounds nice, but all-in-all definitely not my jam.

I wish Kanye never went crazy. Back to back bangers.

Das Album wurde überwiegend auf Hawaii in den Avex Recording Studios in Honolulu aufgenommen. Kanye West, US-amerikanischer Musiker und Produzent, kehrte für diese Produktion bewusst zu einem abgeschiedenen Arbeitsprozess zurück, nachdem sein vorheriges Werk gemischte Reaktionen erhalten hatte. Das musikalische Genre lässt sich vorrangig dem Hip-Hop zuordnen, wobei Einflüsse aus Progressive Rock, Soul und orchestraler Popmusik ebenfalls deutlich zu erkennen sind. Die Produktion ist vielschichtig, mit komplexen Arrangements, die oft mehrere musikalische Ebenen gleichzeitig bedienen. Bekannte Titel wie „Power“, „Runaway“ oder „All of the Lights“ zählen heute zu den am häufigsten rezipierten Stücken seiner Diskografie und gelten inhaltlich wie stilistisch als prägend für eine Phase, in der Kanye West seine künstlerische Position neu definierte. Das Album vermittelt trotz der aufwändigen Inszenierung eine persönliche Note, da sich West mit gesellschaftlichen Erwartungen, persönlichem Scheitern und öffentlicher Wahrnehmung auseinandersetzt. In der Gesamtschau handelt es sich um ein musikalisch durchdachtes Werk, das sich deutlich von vorangegangenen Veröffentlichungen abhebt, ohne sich vollständig von seiner bisherigen Stilistik zu lösen.

Putting aside the person Kanye has become, this is a great rap album. Not exactly sure how much I'll go back to it, but there's a couple of tracks (Power, for example) that I can't help but put on sometimes.

For one reason or another, hip-hop has never been my genre, and for some very specific reasons Kanye feels hard to get into in 2025. Still, listening to MBDTF it's clear what everybody sees in him & his music

immaculate production. some songs i wish ye fleshed out or gave more

Self indulgent to a fault. Album and songs are not tight. Cutting out some of the fluff would make this a much better listening experience. Gotta give credit to the strong production and guest appearances though. I did think the black balls and fish dicks lines were pretty funny though. 2.5, not a big fan but production was worth listening to. I get why its on the list. I round down. 1=Crap that shouldn't be here 2=I didn't like it but get why it's here 3=I thought it was ok or even like it, get why it's here, but won't revisit 4=I like it, will revisit 5=This is some of the best music I've ever heard and will continue listening to it

Totally unknown to me... Certainly topping the hiphop-albums so far. There considerably more music here. I kinda like 'So appalling' and 'Who will survive in America'. I really don't understand why they open the album with the appalling - pun intended - 'Dark fantasy'. Why, tell me why? Interesting thought: how many of the people responsible for over 1 billion Spotify-streams of 'POWER' have listened to the original '21st century schizoid man' (with 37 million streams)?

Track 1: Wasn't all _that_ offensive. Maybe I even give this a 2 Track 2: This is incredibly grating. Track 3: Somewhat offended by the 21 CSM sample. Track 4: Because this is an albums project, I pledge to listen to the entire thing anyway. Scout's honor. Track all the rest: Hang in there. You can take it. Made it. Now I have to go wash my ears out.

I'm giving it a 5 off principle. Idk if I can listen to it given the current situation and I have songs from 808s being my favourite album.

If I were to separate the art from the artist for a sec, this album is very good. Shame he’s so problematic and controversial, as he is actually a talented rapper.

I've got a lot of love for this album, as many do. I haven't listened to it in a couple of years so it was a pleasure to return to it. The track list is incredibly solid. Witty, arrogant, emotional, angry, each track explores varying aspects of Kanye's psyche, extrapolating them to their limits. Greed on Monster Self awareness and vulnerability on Runaway Lust on Devil In A New Dress etc etc Even without the context surrounding Kanye at the time of this albums release, the songs still hold up as time goes on. The only thing i don't enjoy about this album is the annoying outro on Blame Game by Chris Rock, it's a bit much. Other than that, an incredible album, shame about his disgraced legacy Fav tracks - All except the end of blame game

It's alright, not my music though. Also, fuck Kanye

Booooo Nazis.

I know a lot of King Crimson fans were NOT happy with "POWER", but I thought it was a good way to let people know of the band's influence. For the most part, I think this album was probably Kanye's pinnacle. He has a lot of great guest stars, uses some good riffs and samples, and the production is masterful. I could have done without "Blame Game" and the Chris Rock bit (don't get me wrong, I think Chris Rock is hilarious. It just seemed to not fit in the song for me.). Am I going to listen to this album again? Probably not, just because... you know, Kanye. But I will not deny that it is a good album, and probably his best work. Top tracks: "POWER," "All of the Lights," "Monster," "So Appalled," "Lost in the World," "Who Will Survive In America"

So was this when Kanye fully came out as an ahole? He sure doesn't shy away from the fact that he can be a real ahole - embracing his bad boy role (with some help from Jay-Z and the Dark Knight to make the point). The sexual violence and depravity is a bit much at times though. The start of the album is really well orchestrated, some beautiful melodies and sampling along with some sublime rapping and lyrics. For those reasons, Dark Fantasy might be favorite of all the songs, with Power a close second. Gorgeous and All of the Lights are also really good (great vocals from Rhianna on the latter). I didn't totally love Monster - all the beats and featured vocals didn't come together quite right. From there I was less into the album, it's like he took his foot of the orchestration gas and just through more straight ahead stuff at us, but the layers and complexity in the first few songs was what made this album so good. Runaway and Blame Game were two exceptions - simple piano notes and a subtle drum track in each, with soft vocal styles from Pusha T or John Legend that perfectly complement Kanye's rapping. Lost in the World had potential but was auto-tuned to hell (sorry Bon Iver). Who Will Survive in America was a cool ending. Apt title for this album - Kanye arranges some beautiful songs but the lyrics (despite being very clever) are real dark and twisted. If he hadn't lost his way in the middle of the album I'd probably rate this even higher.

It's time again for everyone's favorite game: Separate the art from the piece of shit artist! This an outstanding album from a horrible person. It even helps get under the veneer of his horrible personality, but unfortunately it wasn't redemption - he only doubles down (and then some) over the ensuing years. Still, let's review only the music. Mostly excellent. I'd basically call Dark Fantasy through Monster a nearly perfect stretch (Gorgeous goes a little long, but the lyrics are powerful). First of all, Ye is a prog fan? Mike Oldfield and Jon Anderson on Dark Fantasy? Power based on 21st Century Schizoid Man? I enjoyed watching a video of Greg Lake starting a concert with Power and segueing to him singing and playing 21st CSM. Power was the first song to really hit me - very powerful (pun not quite intended?). All of the Lights was a super-catchy track and Rihanna sounds great. Monster was a fun, cool track and Nicki Minaj's section made me laugh. The rest of the album has a lot of good moments, but the lyrics got to be a little too much (Devil in a New Dress, settle down Kanye, plus the end of Hell of a Life. Ugh). Blame Game was crude as hell (although Chris Rock is never not funny). Lost in the World was catchy, but I HATE AUTOTUNE. Who Will Survive in America was a powerful closer with some disturbing imagery (all from Gil Scott-Heron's spoken word poem Comment #1 from 1970). I recognize that in the world of rap albums, this should be a clear 5. However, I was less of a fan of the second half (except perhaps Runaway, but it went a little too long), hate autotune, and feel I can't give Kanye a 5 since he's such a piece of shit. Guess I can't fully separate the art from the artist. Favorite tracks: Power, All of the Lights, Monster.

"Nazi" "Nicki" and "Minaj" being some of the top keywords explains everything

Ist nicht meins

It's uncomfortable to listen to Kanye nowadays. Kanye's voice is generally the worst part of each of his songs, and knowing how drug abuse can exacerbate mental health issues, those lyrics are more disturbing than enjoyable. Same goes for lyrics about violence against women. Power and All of the Lights are undeniable hits.

I mean it's fine there are some bangers on there that really hit, a few great lyrics too I know damn well yall feelin this shit

I enjoyed this album. I hate Kanye West as a person, but I enjoyed this album. I already owned two songs from it (Power and Runaway).

He can be hit or miss, but when he hits, he HITS.

I refuse to listen to anything by this creep