Reviews (page 3 of 16)
Deilig plate. Var en favoritt når den kom. Har kanskje ikke helt tålt tidens tann.
Begynner bra, men den intime minimalismen fungerer ikke utover på plata. Søvndyssende kjedelig. Dårlige tekster også.
I found this one really boring. It was alright as background music but I wouldn't listen again.
Contemplative without being obnoxiously moody.
This duet has a relaxing quality that works just fine; however, there is not much variation from song to song and, after a while, their sultry/haunting voices start to sound bored.
I hear it used as background music. It’s ok it’s nice
This was…ok. Nothing special and I don’t need to hear it again. I will say that I really preferred the voice of the female vocalist. The male voice got really lazy about holding pitch. 3 boring stars.
er ingen ting
This kind of stuff is normally out of my wheelhouse, but the interplay between the two vocalists managed to keep my attention on this one. Solid 7/10 for that and the songwriting.
Wonderful, wonderful stuff. I only knew intro and Crystalised coming in, so I was hoping for similar stuff, and I got it! This type of music is such a pleasure to listen to. The album itself is more like a 4.5/5 because there were some parts that were way too slow with nothing happening but whatever I haven’t had a 5 star rating in a while.
Was this the dawn of chill indie?? The oversaturation of the genre might be to blame, but to my 2026 ears this sounds like a whole buncha nothin' Standouts: Crystalised • Heart Skipped a Beat • Basic Space
Hard to figure out where to land on this album. I have a long history with it. Been listening to Intro and Crystalised since around the time it came out and I have had multiple false starts where I just wasn't interested enough to finish it. Pushing through now, I felt it had to be listened to at high volume so I could hear everything going on. The front half is strong but the back half kind of fell apart in my opinion. I also can't stand the way they sing but that style was popular at the time so I can't blame them too much either.
One good Song eveybody knows - apart from that pretty boring.
Occasionally captivating, sometimes bad, but primarily boring. Their later output is far more dynamic and gripping. That said, this is a decent study in minimalism and stretching one specific guitar sound as far as it’ll possibly go.
I love the chill, minimalistic stylings of The xx. I much prefer coexist to this album, but still decent. Solid. 3.5/5
VCR Crystalised
Bra artister men gillar inte killens irriterande indieröst
130726 15:25 3
Low-key ass je catch pas le hype
Bien.
5.5/10 - Very much an album reminiscent of the times. Feels like a lot of the albums of this era (Nico and Vinz, Alt-J, etc.) I prefer the songs that the woman sings. I think he delivery is a bit better and less generic. It’s not bad but it never crested to any meaningful climax or excitement.
I don't really like the guy's vocals on this album and the songs border on boring. 4/10
it was bad.
i've tried to get through this record i think three times before? and never actually been able to sit through it completely without getting bored out of my mind by like the 4th track. now tbf this was a long time ago and my taste has changed a lot since them, but this definitely gave me pretty low expectations going into this. and honestly? i guess it wasn't as awful as i thought it would be (i didn't outright hate it or fall asleep listening, though i came close), but it definitely wasn't memorable; the only parts of it that stood out to me and stuck with me at all were the iconic "intro" and the bassline in "fantasy", while the rest all just blended together. it pretty quickly got both boring and a little annoying, though i guess it can make pretty good background noise if i have nothing better to put on. instead of taking time to talk about why i don't think this should be on the list, i'll just say a few names of albums that try to do similar things to this but much more successfully: turn on the bright lights, hurry up we're dreaming, carrie & lowell, in colour (which is by a side project by a member of this band! it even has a song, "loud places", which is just like the songs on this album if they were interesting!), overgrown, untrue. (also, why is this the first indie record i get? couldn't i have gotten something actually good instead?) in short: 2/5 album, very boring, has no right to be here over other stuff that does the same thing much better
5/10
Can’t for the life of me understand why these jokers have more than one album on this list. There are some fun groves, but the vocals sound like they’re asleep at the mic. Like they didn’t even want to be singing their own lyrics, which I get because their lyrics are fucking dull. This shit sucks.
I adore this album. It has a special place in my heart as indicative of a very happy time in my life. This album dropped and was immediately on the playlist. I love its beautiful minimalism, its sexiness, the longing in every song. I’m struck again on relisten after some time away from this by how sparse it is but how complete the songs feel. There’s a million ideas that could have been laid on top of these songs, but they skipped right to the best 10. There’s a remarkable economy of decision making in this recording to tremendous effect.
A good record. Each song has a little something that I like. Great production.
This was a bit more interesting than the one from the other day. Still doesn't really get my juices flowing.
Its first half is stronger than the second, but I think this album deserves a place on this list based on influence alone. This is the album that brought the spotlight to bedroom pop, arguably one of the biggest movements in music of recent years. It’s a lovely album, I love the minimalist arrangement of VCR and the slightly ominous Intro.
Es sind schöne Melodien dabei
I would say that this album is generally unremarkable except for the Intro and the song Night Time which for some reason I was OBSESSED with when I was 14. It was my most played song that year. It scratches an itch in my brain that I cannot find a good reasoning for. Either way the whole album gets an extra point for hosting Night Time and being generally good background music.
Still often on repeat
Imagine getting the opportunity to make an album and you decide to put in minimal effort and create the blandest collection of music possible. They figured out how to make an entire album feel like a disappointed sigh.
The album overall has this kind of uniqueness and simplicity in the instrumental but sometimes the vocals tend to lack a bit on certain songs. Overall it lacks of risks and feels a bit dull
I remember this not really grabbing me when I came out and on relisten I can see why. The intro and the lead single are great but the whole album is the same tone with no real variety. Atmospheric and pretty but ultimately repetitive and without a second gear. A generous 3/5
I think if I'd discovered this album when it came out, I probably would've liked it a lot. Now we're 17 years later, and I still really like it. The more I listen to it, the more I love it. There's a nostalgic quality to it, sure, to a time when you're in your late teens/early twenties and are full of hormones you don't understand. This album makes me feel feelings. This warrants a 5/5.
Very atmospheric, one of those albums that rides the border of consistency and repetition though. Gotta be in the right mood
XX
This is the profoundly depressive indie rock that my ex was into right before she left me. Let's try to conduct a somewhat unbiased listening, shall we? There's no drummer, so while it's rhythmically interesting, the credit goes to their sampler guy, Jamie xx. The bass playing is competent but not particularly distinctive. Romy Madley Croft's guitar playing is distinctive: fairly clean, mostly single-note loopy hooks with just enough reverb to add atmosphere. The dual vocals alternate and weave in and out a little bit but never harmonize. I'd describe the overall feel as anhedonic -- these folks seem to be experiencing a clinical emotional numbness while writing and singing kind of mopily. If you're not feeling anything, how are you writing music? Or why? Especially: why must I listen to this? Songs like 'Islands' do develop sort of a groove but it's not deep, doesn't last long and is totally undermined by the flat delivery. Indie often did this roundabout 2009 and it's a hill I'll die on: the cultivated affect of listlessness that a lot of bands played with at the time is anti-musical. It should be fought, tooth and nail, both in music specifically and in culture more generally. It's true that anhedonia is a very real affliction of depression and other disorders of mental health but expressing it and wearing it as a badge are very different things. Mostly, this sounds like two musicians and a DJ got to jamming in the wee hours after a party and had had too much booze and Xanax. 'Stars' starts out OK but just because the bassline sounds like Tina Weymouth for a hot second. Then the singing starts. This might be for you. If it is, I recommend speaking to a mental health professional. Otherwise, 1/5; marginally better than listening to Morrissey. I'd rather listen to the Smiths or even Kid Rock.
It's a good album
It kills me that I don’t like this more because it sounds so good – this kind of empty, nocturnal, bleak, yet somehow at the same time positive and romantic sound is striking enough that even the weaker tracks are lifted up by it. Except that’s the problem – there are a lot of weak tracks that seem kind of barely written, as though the band was rushed into the studio without enough material. This isn’t so bad for a first album with promise as long as the band pulls it together subsequently, but unfortunately, this time they didn’t: Coexist, the follow-up, was a disaster, the group took five whole years to put out yet another weak record, and they’ve been on hiatus since that, with the members all releasing yet more forgettable solo albums. A real tragedy, because if we’d had more tracks like “Shelter” and “Infinity” this would have been a straight-up classic. As it is, it’s more like a beautiful promise that went unfulfilled. Best track: “Infinity”
It’s not massively exciting but I enjoyed the chill vibe. I think an album of it was too much for me though. It needs a change of pace somewhere. It definitely grew on me on a second listen, I think minimalist albums normally do. Still, I’m not sure I liked it enough to come back to it. It did make for nice background music while I was working though. Fav song: VCR – or Intro but that might just be because I’m already familiar with it. Least fav: Shelter
Perfect album for having a nap on the train. Can see why it might be boring if you’re trying to do something else (but I wasn’t) Favourite song: Basic Space Least: Heart Skipped A Beat
It’s okay.
Альбом слишком попсовый, но Intro я где-то слышал!
Soulless, programatic music with a muddy and uneven mix. The lyrics are all but indeciperable. "Fantasy" sounds like they accidentally hit record while they were testing out a software update. "Infinity" is aptly named as it goes on forever yet goes nowhere. This album supports the idea that maybe there aren't 1001 that you must hear before you die.
Perfect. Listening to this while bike riding at midnight and distant from everyone around you.
this reminds of that Big Black album, Songs About Fuc*ing. Not the music, just the title. This album is inoffensive but not super original. chill vibes tho!
it's ok, but not something i would want to listen to again
Bandinha preguiçosa mas o som é confortável, ouvirei mais.
Very chill album, reminds me of the Tumblr era (rip). I've never listened to all the songs, so it created a nice Friday soundtrack today. I have a feeling that I have to go back to it in Fall. No fun facts today I'm afraid :c
What a disgusting voices and lyrics. I vomited and got a headache from disgust. Have absolutely no shame publishing this crap
Nah
Solid album.
The simple and low-key feel of this album makes it feel like it could've come out in the early 80s, which is definitely a positive in my book. A very enjoyable record.
This was a pleasure. The overall tone and vibe of the album is extremely calming and soothing, making it perfect for peaceful background music.
Very pretty. I can’t decide if it’s 3 am music or mid morning music but manages to be quiet but not boring.
A really impressive debut album. The sound even 17 years later feels fresh and innovative, with an indie rock and pop sound made to sound grand whilst not overcomplicating the recipe as so many trying-too-hard indie bands did in the 2000s. Intro is a spectacularly atmospheric opener, and the rest has a great vocal interplay between Romy Madley Croft and Oliver Sim, largely on young relationships and emotions. VCR and Basic Space probably my highlights, but pretty much any track has an argument for it. Erred between 4 and 5 (a lack of variety is probably the only flaw), but it’s so well crafted that it deserves full marks.
If you were in the UK in the early to mid 2010s you will recognise half of these tracks solely from them being used in seemingly every other BBC trailer or ident. They won the Mercury Prize in 2009, with their sparse, understated style providing a contrast with a lot of the other music being released around that time. While their sound has been incorporated by a lot of other bands since, the album still sounds fresh, and the quality of songwriting is great, making for an enjoyable and somewhat nostalgic listen.
This is one of those bands/albums I’d heard of without being able to name a single song, but actually recognised quite a few. It’s a solid indie pop/rock album, with very moody, minimalistic (sometimes almost ambient) electronic-based arrangements, focused on the vocal interplay between Romy Madley Croft and Oliver Sim, with melancholy lyrics focusing on various aspects of young relationships. I preferred the tracks with a bit more energy (e.g. ‘Intro’, ‘Crystalised’) and wanted more of them, as I found it got quite samey, and my attention started to wander later on. Still a strong 3 stars.
fine
Vocals felt too pop for me. Instrumentation felt minimal (in a bad way).
It's a good album
Super iconic intro, really incredible. Unfortunately used so much for youtube shorts and whatnot that it kind of lost its novelty. VCR was a cute song and very relatable but the hook was not strong enough for me personally. Crystalised is a cool song, love the riff at the start, but is also missing something for me personally. Honestly this seems like the type of band that kind of leaned into a indie edm vibe that is chill. Never really messed around with it. Islands sounds nice too. But overall the takeaway is that the music is too slow or under stimulating. I do like the melancholy of Heart Skipped a Beat. Fantasy is awesome and surreal. Shelter by porter robinson is better. Still Shelter is prob my fav song so far beside intro. Still all that buildup for nothing? I need a scream or like a crazy guitar riff. Basic Space sounds like Human Music from that one rick and morty episode at the start lol. Infinity sounds fine. Hate how it swells just to deflate rather than pop or climax. 'There's a fine line between music that's "atmospheric" and "monotonous." ' and personally im in the latter camp. Night time is a bit more fun. I actually quite like this one and perhaps this is when the album clicked for me. It sounds sort of like Molchat Doma or even some Kino. I'm a fan. Let's see if the rest of the album ever makes me feel like that again. Nope, not that big a fan of Stars. Okay so prob like a 5/10 for me. I understand how this is an iconic album. The blend of minimalist sound with indie rock + electronic and dream pop elements are great. It's an incredibly intimate album and the guitars are artfully picked. The dual lead vocals of Romy and Oliver creates a fun push-and-pull.
I was listening to this a lot when it came out so that probably colors my perception, but it just feels beautiful and ethereal to me. I love it.
I absolutely adore this album. I've been listening to it since I was a teenager and I remember how in awe I was then. Incredibly zen, chill, sparse album. Well crafted pop music, dreamy but not overproduced. The whole Baria Qureshi situaution is just weird though, did they seriously just screw her out the money and fire her?!? WTFFF I feel the whole magic was there when she was in the band, they captured magic on this album
This one is just ok. I understood why isn’t caused such a splash when it came out, because it didn’t sound like anything else and they did seem original, but it just hasn’t stood the test of time- it’s not very interesting.
*Sigh* More bland 2000s indie rock? Are we serious? As expected, there is absolutely nothing even remotely interesting about this album. It's just basic modern pop with whispery vocals and basic beats. The lyrics are as basic as everything else on this album. So, yeah, this shit is not good. It's not anywhere near worthy of being on the list, so why is it here? I've asked this far too many times, and I'll ask it far too many more if this damn list keeps throwing random boring bullshit at me! Just give me good albums! This album is ranked #2 of 8 albums for 2009. Other 2009 albums rated by me: It's Blitz!(1/8)-4 Veckatimest(3/8)-2
Definitely not for me...
xx keeps teasing you with it's stellar atmosphere, lovely production and clearly solid performances, but that's never enough to hide the fact this band can't write an actual hook into these tracks, most of which are at least 3 minutes long and yet still feel like they get cut off before they can actually develop into something. The only geniunely catchy moment in this is in the goddamn intro track, and even that one ends before you can get attached to it. It's honestly just sad, like watching a kid with talent deciding to give up too early into something.
I actually quite dug the quiet simplistic sound
I didn't hate it, but it was just more background music (my third such album this week!) come on generator give me an album to love or at least hate. This is getting old!
first time hearing of The xx or "XX". defined not bad but it feels like background music, not in a good way.
Interesting
chill
kinda felt like 'that's it?' after it was over.
It was ok. Kinda slow
another album the tumblr teens owe their lives to
Una po ron ga
A masterpiece!
It’s minimalist but I was expecting some mood changes. Didn’t really grab me at any point and repetitive.
This came out in my early teenage years so I feel that I am disposed to like this one. I wanted more energy, the primary emotion from this album is malaise. I expected to love it but felt like it was pretty middle of the road. I really liked Intro and Fantasy
One of my all time favorite live albums.
boring
is oké.. gwn echt heel saai maar niet per se slecht
k vind haar stem niet echt chill.. maar de muziek erachter s wel goed
Acceptable and enjoyable
Great
A few more listens and this will probably be 4, super chill
best track: fantasy
Am I deaf or what??????? I tried turning up my volume and the instruments are very loud and clear but I still barely hear what they’re saying. Why are they whispering and singing in cursive?????? Cool instrumentals but like I can’t hear the singing it’s so confusing!!!
Half of this is all-timer, the rest is extremely pleasant. Such a specific sexy vibe!
One of the best albums of the 00’s. Fantastic album and nostalgic
Xx and chill. Ultimate shag album 😂😂 not quite sure it fits the morning commute but a classic anyways.
Big big nostalgia trip for me, The XX always seemed out on their own, a bit weird, doing their own gothic electric chill indie thing. I have a lot of time for this album, it’s atmospheric and you know you’re listening to the xx. I don’t think it’s my favourite of theirs but it’s a fantastic debut. 4/5 Best Song: Islands
It is OK, it's very listenable and chilled i get why people like it so much, but most of it lands a bit flat for me
Ok
There are definitely a few really good tracks on this album that I enjoyed and added to my playlist. The minimalist, atmospheric vibe is cool at first. However, my main issue is that almost all the songs sound exactly the same. The lack of variety makes it feel a bit monotonous over the full runtime. It’s a cool signature sound, but just too repetitive for me to rate it any higher. A solid 3/5.
music is love
3 stars - v chill. V of it's time! ------- My ratings: 1 star - actively disliked 2 stars - boring / not me, wouldn't listen again 3 stars - it's ok, would listen again, but no strong reaction 4 stars - liked it, will seek it out to relisten 5 stars - earworm, would listen and smile any time!
I am biased, I love The XX. Used to listen them and Jamie XX (the producer) a ton in my 20's. The minimalist sound is intentional. Listen to Jamie XX's album "In Color" if your interested in understand the range of talent he has. One of the best intros to an album. The duets, the music, and the lyrics are simply beautiful. I used to blast "Fantasy" in my CRV to feel that bass. No other band sounds like them, and this album was an amazing launching point for the XX and Jamie XX.
A fun listen but not enough to make it to 4 stars for me.
Just fine. I have a few songs I like, but it really all blends together into snoringly boring early 2010s alt pop
I forgot how good this album is. Would happily listen to it back to front any time
Really enjoy it, good travel music for when you want to nod off after a few songs. But it I'm trying to stay awake and listen to it, then I think the second half of the album needs a little lift towards the end.
Not usually my thing but I've always been a big fan of this album. Calming and minimalistic. Opened the door for 'In Colour' as well which was sick.
You know, it’s fine? I dunno if it’s aged that well? It’s a little bland.
First 3 songs are all timers. Falls off a bit after then though
Completely forgettable. The most generic 2000s electronic indie BS.
After the album finished I allowed the similar artist’s feature to continue playing. It was not able only because immediately I enjoyed and in some cases recognized those songs. I cannot really articulate why that matters but it seems to me that says something about whether this one was a must hear.
Ok
Hilarious meme song
So simple, very depressing, but goddammit I love this record. I will love this record for the rest of my life.
Quite dull. There's a moment near the back end where there's some oomph but it's quickly replaced with the quiet sound from the rest of the album. I didn't hear much emotion in their voices either. For emotional, ambient music, I prefer someone like Blanco White.
i thought it was pretty decent actually and was compelled to listen again
Dreamy quality. No complaints, but it didn’t really grab me.
Drifted by without leaving much of an impression
For what it is it's pretty good and well made. Personally I like my instrumentals to be a little more complex and not half empty.
Fun fact- this was the first album I got when I tried this website before joining our family listening group and restarting the same day or next day whenever it was. I’ve been waiting for it to reappear and I’m really happy it did today. This was my go to in college biking around isla vista at night. It soundtracked my undergrad and I love it so much. Extremely nostalgic
It was good but a little goes a long way for me on dream pop. Maybe a little too chill for me to actively seek it out to listen again.
It advertised being ambient and I really didn't hear anything from it. Like, no memories of this.
This is some hipster BS...
Gostoso de ouvir
Haven't listened to this album in full for a long time — wonderful work. The sound production is top-notch, the arrangements, the vocal duet — top-tier work within indie rock
This shit was so boring
A quiet and moody album that was one of the pioneers for the tumblr days of taking pictures of colorful oils spills on the asphalt and black converse. Besides the intro, I couldnt find myself getting into it.
2009. Debut studio album. Beats made from a members laptop, mixed with instrumental parts recorded by the other members. Lyrics about love, intimacy, loss and desire. Qureshi left the band after the release of the album.
I have not head of this band before. When I first started listening, I muttered my prelude to high praise – im not hating this. And that fuzzy feeling continued when the vocals started. Nice tunes, great vocals, some of the guitar sounded like Chris Isaak but all in all 3 stars is sufficient for me.
I liked the minimalist aspect of The xx. Most songs are just a drum set, a guitar, a bass, maybe some piano. They don't overplay, so it makes it a little more intimate. Having one male and one female vocalist gives the tracks a fun vibe, but it sounds more like two friends having a chat than a couple (which they obviously aren't). The lyrics are a little young, but they were 20 (or 'xx" if you will) so that's hardly an indictment.
not really into this one tbh
How boring was this? The shy vocal style is interesting I guess but not something I liked. I had high hopes the first two songs but they were quickly dashed. I see how it’s influential, sounds like all the twee/stomp clap pop that was on the radio when I was in middle school.
Weinerlich, langweilig, trostlos! Das nächste Machwerk von Leuten, die einfach den ganzen Tag heulen. So klingt das für mich.
I was aware of some of the songs because they were heavily played on 6 Music when they came out, bit this is my first proper listen. Turns out I like it a lot. The two voices working together are great, and I like the mix of electronicavand rock.
Very solid record, I feel like I would listen to it more if Jeep ads hadn't made it overplayed to me
Great!
I always get The xx confused with other bands from this time. I keep thinking they're going to be a bit bluesy, a bit rocky. Essentially, I get them confused with The Black Keys. They're not Royal Blood either. Nor are they The 1975. So what are they? Indie electro dream pop probably works as a description.
Removed, why, who can say
The intro gave a false hope of energy, as this was very low key and mostly boring. It faded into the background so much that I was surprised to find I was on the 7th track of 11 before I noticed. The final two songs, Night Time and Stars, were OK.
Opens with an 'oh this is them?!' classic - the catchy guitar line and idm drum machine creating a spacey ambiguous atmosphere, instantly recognizable but doomed to play on loop behind annoying short form videos forever. The rest adds a pair of singers trading whispered lines to the sparse reverby synth+guitars indie dance pop arrangement, dark and moody, light tension/release dynamics, easy listening - pleasant enough but pretty dull. The guitar leads are a huge Modest Mouse rip off: sad slow melodic messing with major 3rds/4ths and reverb. It's the epitome of post-hipster millenial retail music.
This was a pleasant record. Super relaxing, really enjoyed the vibe. Thought the instrumentation and vocals were extremely tasteful. The artists stayed perfectly on their lane. This is like English primordial Khruangbin. Lost some steam throughout the record and didn’t break any barriers, but I would absolutely put this on again. This is going in the rotation. 3.5/5.
This ok. Got old toward the end. 3
It's fine. That's all. 2.9/5
Not bad, pretty different stuff. 4/5
Not bad, but I couldn't sustain my interest. The male/female vocals got annoying after a while.
erg chill, lekker voor uit het raam staren en niks doen
I remember listening to this when it first came out and giving it a few tries but it never really stuck with me. I no longer have the album in my collection so I clearly decided that it was not for me. it is not bad, but at the same time, it is not grabbing me. It is like milky coffee. There is something there but it has been watered down and the impact is lost. I feel like Lorde was influenced by this album, because the song Basic space sounds exactly like something you might hear on Melodrama. I got a little bit bored by the end. The album did not really go anywhere. Again, one of those albums that is ok, but I really cannot see what makes it stand out to be on this list. Intro or VCR was probably the standout. Average 3 stars
Intro led me to believe that this album is more than what is actually is: boring indie pop.
Good album, lots of recognizable songs starting right with their Intro which is their best of the album ha!
To my ear is so similar to Daughter
It’s okay, y’know? No real highlights, no emotion or anything like that. Decent tracks right through, so dont get any hate but it starts like a new massive attack record so its a disappointment that its not. 3/5.
The way that the two singers pronounce words annoys the crap out of me. They don't pronounce their Ts or Ds enough and they end up coming out as this annoying "ts" or "dz" sound every time in words like "daytime," which they say more like "dzaytsime." Having to hear that for the length of an album is incredibly distracting. Outside of the way they pronounce words with Ds in them, their singing isn't much to write home about either. It feels like the kind of music I'd hear in a Burlington. Anyways, I appreciate them throwing Fantasy right in the middle of the album. Only took like 20 minutes to get something vaguely interesting. That song brings me to the other guy in the group, Jamie xx. Not to dismiss the secondary guitarist, but I actually knew who this guy was before this album because of his solo stuff. Somehow I never made the connection between that and this band, despite the name. His work as a producer here is mediocre, but I feel like it's more him being held back by the other people in the band than something in his control. It's all boring and low-energy to the point of making me feel tired by the end of it. In a word, yawn.
Very front loaded. Found myself losing interest come the end
cursi cursi cursi ay que cursi
Ok
It’s pretty bland. Only a few bits are enjoyable but most of it sounds the same
I used to want to like this record. It has components that I like. Seventeen Seconds The Cure guitars, simple beats and understated vocals but I find it pretty dull.
I like intro and vcr but the rest kind of falls flat.
No idea who this is. The “X” thing is over used. I like this first track so far. This album feels more 90s than 2009. I’m enjoying this. On track two now. This is a really good album. It didn’t make me want to jot notes, but I would listen again. I would also be interested to see this band live.
Gran ambiente
На фон поставить мне нравится, некоторые песни были уже добавлены
I see a lot of people are calling this boring, and I understand that some may think that. But to me, this is a fantastic minimalistic album, very relaxing and chill. Favorite track(s) Intro Islands Shelter Night Time
Good brittle atmospheric electronica.
Pretty satisfying minimal production, with very interesting instrumentals here and there. Overall not the most interesting songwriting melodies though - it gets a bit mechanical after a while. Faves: Intro, Crystalised, Islands
The opening bars set the tone for one of the most intimate electronic albums of the late '00s. Jamie's production along with Romy and Oliver...chef's kiss! VCR is so pretty. The diverging vocals that eventually coalesce in Crystalised is beautiful. This album is a full vibe of love and longing. I mean if you like echo-y sparse guitar and solid but subtle bass, this is certainly for you.
Quite low key and vanilla. It's ok and I'll give it another go again in the future as I think the songs would grow on me as I listened more
6/10 banger album that aged a little bit badly Will i add this album to my library: already is
4/7
Boring
Great energy
Little too electronic but otherwise pretty fye
Dull. Inoffensive but incredibly dull
Overall Rating - 2.95/5 (5.91/10). Overall a decent album. Nothing great, but nothing bad, either. Not really my preferred style, but, again, no reason not to give this a middle-of-the-road rating.
After listening to this record I'm filled with both nostalgia for my teenage years and also a real warmth. The music produced here is simultaneous atmospheric, chilled and comforting - the songs feeling lke a hug from a friend. The vocals and minimalist instrumental work combine beautifully to produce the iconic xx sound. This is a brilliant album from start to finish!
Smooth Sensory
It wasn’t really my style, but I did enjoy “Islands”
First album out of 21 that I’d literally never heard of. But this was *awesome*. I love how they don’t feel a need to fill in the white space. Pensive, tight album. Very 2009. Loved it.
tumblr era throwback
A great album that came out of the blue. Again as a guitar teacher a lot of my students, Simple melodys but cleverly done.
Mellow ambient. Liked it.
Second album from The xx on the list and it’s another two star. Much like I See You there’s nothing necessarily bad about this. I just don’t find it interesting. With no more albums on the list I would pretty much guarantee I’ll never listen to them again.
Could be good but I don’t think the music ever gets going. There’s a lot of intro through the album
Very chill, good music to work to.
Intro is great but then it’s kinda like why am I still listening… wish there were no vocals
Beats, fine. Vocals, bad
overall rating: 7/10! there's a completely different vibe with each song & i wasn't expecting to like this album given the fact that it came out in 09 and it's a trio band... idk 2000s band vibe yk? i was expecting paramore but corny and cringe but it was actually pretty decent!
Lovely, low-fi electronic mood music. Almost sounds like it was recorded next to your ear.
I like their sound, but overall a bit boring.
I listened to this a lot when it came out. Lots of nice Melodies and catchy bits, well produced. Its only fault is that it’s kinda boring? But makes for a pleasant listen.
Low-key and downcast to a fault. The songs are already background fodder as they are but the instant the rhythm section takes a backseat the songs become downright anemic. There's still some highlights here and there but they're mostly in the first half of the album. One thing is that the group definitely understands its sound and its niche right from the get-go, though they would only ever improve it on later outings. Key Tracks: Intro, Islands
Day868 - this is 2009 music in a nutshell. terrible
A beautifully dreamy, extremely well produced album. I was Taken to a place of tranquility from the ‘intro’ into ‘vcr’ and beyond. The album flowed superbly and gave goosebumps throughout. A very well deserved 9.5/10 for me! Fave track- ‘VCR’ Worst track- ‘stars’ maybe a weaker ending to the album. But only due to the consistently high standard the rest of the album set.
The xx - x Pleasantly surprised that I quite enjoyed this one. I always moan about modern music having so little space, but here we have nothing but sparse, echoey arrangenments where every note and beat is there for purpose. Shades of UK post punk, and bedroom indie - all the stuff I like. Amongst the tracks I went back to was the perfectly formed Intro, the Roy Orbison in a dark alley sounding VCR, the brooding duet Islands, and the build up and release of Infinity. Least fave were the slightly messy Crystalised and the close Stars which never really amounted to anything. Dabbled with the bonus tracks of the deluxe version and would quite happily never hear their version of Teardrops again 🤦 Do You Mind is a beauty though. A really lovely surprise 8.5/10
As weird as it is accessible…
Yes!!!!!!!!!
Everyone’s heard the intro to this album. If you’re wondering whether the rest of the record sounds like that, the answer is: almost. Musically, it stays in the same lane — the electronica touches are tasteful, the guitar work is clean and minimal, and the whole thing feels like it’s drifting through a dimly lit room. The real highlight is the vocals. Romy and Oliver harmonize and blend like a friendship bracelet — simple threads woven into something quietly beautiful. Their voices never overpower the music; they just glide through it. The album is shorter than I expected, and the songs tend to blur together. It’s not always easy to tell where one track ends and the next begins, but that’s part of its charm and part of its limitation. It’s calming, floaty, and pleasant, but it didn’t grab me especially hard. My rating: 4/5
esse álbum é para todas as pessoas que viveram a era Tumblr em 2009 !!!
Hard to separate the nostalgia from my relisten of this.
Not a huge fan of the make lead singers voice. Music is ok.
Sin interés, pero no es terrible.
Intro is the best song on this album. But it doesn't totally drop off after and is a vibe. 3/5
Incredibly 2012 Tumblr feeling. Really shockingly bland. Felt like it belonged in a short Hulu series about young millennials.
I remember this being massive when it came out and it is a good album. It's a lovely melancholy vibe and nicely atmospheric. The dual vocals are quite cool as is the guitar playing. The strongest tracks are front-loaded which makes the second half a little bit of a comedown, though, so capping my rating at 4*
when the guy started singing i said "fuck you" out loud
Grave sympa, pop rock un peu indie qui change
Je connaissais déjà; j’avais déjà l’album dans mes favoris ! Je trouve ça vraiment cool mais je mettrais pas 5/5 car c’est vraiment calme !
Plutôt sympa!
At this point this is a classic of indie music. The intro is iconic in a way few songs ever get to be, which is impressive that it has no words and just repeats simple motif for a few minutes. But simple works wonders when simple is good, which could basically be a slogan for this album. The mix is incredibly clean and the choice of having a producer instead of a more traditional drummer consistently works wonders. The heavy reverb on the guitars and the minimalistic electronic flourishes that pop in and out create a mood that is often replicated and the mix makes the band sound so supremely confident in their abilities. Is prefer a little more dynamic range than what's on offer with this album and the actual songwriting doesn't ever blow me away, but this is a really, really good listen.
so 2010s, intro is so overplayed but not their fault.
Intro is really good - I had heard this before but had no idea who played it (and never heard of XX before). The rest seems almost like easy listening. Background music for a coffeeshop. Interesting sound, but not very daring.
I might claim that this one is perfect - from the first song to the last single one.
gostei!
Wat een verrassend leuke band is dit. Het grappige is dat ik hier op kantoor naar heb geluisterd. Eén collega vond het eentonig, een ander collega vond juist dat er veel variatie in zat. Ik vond het dus vooral verrassend 😃
Wonderful! Listened three times and this album really grew on me!
Another album that I hadn't listened to in a long time. Has somewhat stood the test of time. Relaxing and enjoyable low-fi indie dance rock. Drags a little in the middle but worth a listen. 3 stars
They all sound so bashful. Do they know that music tends to be more enjoyable when it doesn't sound like a middle school class popcorn reading?
Understated, but mostly unexciting. Intro is a great start, but nothing else meets those heights for the rest of the album. Technically competent but sadly The xx seem to be lacking x-factor
imagining this being important to jack and lena
Genuinely did not expect to enjoy this at all given the genre tags, but it kind of fucked? It feels understated, with touches of minimal synth and really emotionally affecting vocals and lyrics. Definitely the kind of album I never would've picked out myself, but I'm really happy I've listened to it!
Good background music but doesn't stand out to me. I feel like it would be in the Winx tv show.
Starting of the late aughts musically, a game changer
Listening to this convinces me that their other album on this list has absolutely no place here. This album feels much more interesting, with more thoughtful production choices overall. I do think it's funny that "Intro" is probably the most recognizable song on the album.
thought id grow out of it but nah Intro still whips ass. it seems like the xx sound is defined by those snappy echoey guitar rhythms and i do enjoy them, but it does feel like most of the vibiness around that isn't as compelling. there's exceptions obviously, Heart Skipped A Beat has this wacky super sick production to it (probably my favorite track). as a whole though the album hits. other favorite is maybe Islands. very strong 3
Rating: 5/10 It's mostly just boring to me. I like pop music that's ambient, atmospheric, dreamy, minimalist, all those things, but the xx specifically doesn't really do it for me. I find it pretty unmemorable and I really don't like their vocals. It's well produced, it's a vibe, especially that damn intro, and it's not explicitly offensive so it gets a middling score
A second remarkably n o t h i n g album from our darlings The xx. I'm not even upset because I knew exactly what was coming for this one and it didn't disappoint. I need to watch a video essay on why people like this artist, because I'm just impressed at how an entire album release can lack any kind of emotion, PIZZAZZ, or even a little bit of any kind of personality. HOWEVER Intro is still pretty cool 2.6/10
Woo, what have we here? Nice. Dark and understated. Can't beat a bit of darkness and understatedness though. New Order-esque obvs but that's no bad thing.
I can't tell if I'm biased as this was the soundtrack to my teenage years, but I don't think so. I think this is a genuinely great album. Others have imitated, but this is the real deal. The LAYERS on crystallised! Iconic.
A strong 4. This hit the indie scene like a bomb back in the day. They came out of nowhere with such a unique and specific approach and sound. Debuts where the band’s sound is fully formed and you immediately know it couldn’t be anyone else are fascinating. Their minimalist approach, spooky/dreamy/sexy songwriting and production, along with genius use of empty space, evoked so much tension and drama. A true classic.
I remember this. OK. Cant remember what it sounded like already.
Feel like I should have enjoyed this more than I did, but not for me
Always tried to like them but have always found the vocals a bit shit
Excellent start, wee bit of a drop off but still great (3.5)
They're a weird one because they're clearly good. Jamie xx is a good writer and musician. Their songs are inoffensive but the powers at be were trying to make them headliners which they are not. They're a shoulder band made to fill up playlists but a good one.
el intro de este álbum podría ser la intro del universo. lo mejor del album es el intro sin lugar a dudas pero también me ha sorprendido el outro y alguna canción por ahí. En general es un album tranquilo, para escucharlo de fondo o de viaje. El intro todos lo conocemos no hace falta hablar de él pero sí del outro. que sensación de soledad, como los cantantes se les quebrantaba la voz a la vez que la instrumental se acababa, mágico. Muy triste que es obviamente lo que quiere transmitir el outro y lo consigue.
Me gustó la onda tranquila. Me dio romance me dio yearning, definitivamente una banda de la que quiero escuchar más.
Late 2000s indie rock. Debut. Minimalist. Very cool, creative and chill. Banger after banger.
Intro // Crystalised // Heart Skipped a Beat // Infinity // Night Time // 4.5/5
This is the first time that I think that I listened to this record in a concentrated manner, but I have seen them live at least once. This is a really beautiful record. This record has a fairly minimalist sound pallet of voice, bass, guitar, synth, and drum machine. It also has two vocalists, who at times exchange lines in the song. You can hear indie and post punk influences throughout, but those influences cohere into something that is distinctly their own. The Intro sets up the expectation that there is going to be more of a dance influence with this record, but that influence is tamped down once the record starts. The songs are strong and there is also a strong ambiance throughout the record. I'm being presented quite a few records from the aughts recently and its been at this point, pretty uniformly good.
I get it, but not my style, a little too self serious
I listened to this album a lot at the time. I liked it. I liked it on the re-listen. It troubled me that I had completely forgotten it since 2009. Like this band didn't exist in my headspace until this popped up again. So it is lovely, completely forgettable music. I am not sure what that means except it means nothing.
Super impressive debut
Good Album!
- Chill, quiet listening - The album felt quite short and kind of forgettable, apart from the first song
I forgot how good this was. Minimal but very effective. Great vocals
OK
feel like i'm bout to fall asleep to a vague, diluted version of my brother's indie mixtapes from '95.
The vocalists both suck and while there is nothing truly objectionable about the song arrangement and production, there doesn't seem to be anything inspired or inspiring here either. A fairly tedious, boring album. Personally, I was way more blown away by Imogen Heap's 2009 ELLIPSE than this.
I recognized a couple of the tunes from this record, which was interesting, as I thought I had never heard of this band or anything from them. There is some potential here for sure. I'll have to listen further.
Super forgettable. It wasn’t the worst, but I forgot I was listening to music for half of it.
I really wanted this to be better than it was. Intro is obviously a banger, but the rest seemed to be missing something. I'm not knowledgeable enough in music theory to know what was missing, only that it felt like a soup without salt.
Seems like there's probably a much more interesting album in here somewhere. But honestly I just spent most of it wishing I was listening to Interpol or Slow Club.
Don't mind the xx at all but I struggle to get fully into them. That said this album is perfectly fine, want to give 3.5 but downgraded slightly...
Love this album. Less is definitely more here!
Modern indie staple, so much vocal chemistry between Oliver and Romy
fome
This album was like a terrible handjob. Track 1 - Intro promised interest, arousal, perhaps even brilliance. What followed was 35 minutes of musical edging, slow strokes of melodramatic, yet simultaneously entirely emotionless dirge. It's going nowhere, you want it to stop, but out of respect for the other party you stay quiet, allowing your mind to wander to anything but the matter at hand. After 25 minutes the quest for climax intensifies, but the wolf is far from the door. It is only as the final track - Stars comes to a blissful end that anything close to a climax is reached. It's over. Sweet, orgasmic silence.
Superb album. A soft, gentle summer afternoon of an album but also one for a bright cold winters morning. I love it.
I listened to this a lot when it came out, and it's super chill
Their music is cool as hell and it's wild to me this came out almost 20 years ago.
Friday, 8 May, 2026 Low fi in every way. Minimalist to the extreme. Several memorable songs. No real clunkers.
They’re just plain boring! I've heard bands be boring before but they were the boringest bunch of bores that ever bored.
Quite pleasant and easy dream pop. Focuses more on textures than melody I think.
После альбома включилась Лана Дель Рей и я сразу не заметил что что-то изменилось, надеюсь так и задумано
Материал сольный Джейми люблю отдельно, хх банила из-за хайпа в начале десятых. Первый раз слушаю полностью их альбом. Первая половина прикольная, последняя треть нудная. 4,5 точно, но не 5.
Пресная музыка, хотя пара хитов есть
хороший альбом, просто, красиво, ничего лишнего, приятный вокал, 4 или 4.5 не могу определиться
I remember back in 2010ish, when Pandora was a popular music streaming option, the xx would pop up somewhat frequently. At the time, I didn't really care for them. I think I found the music boring to my then musical tastes (which were not particularly into indie). Listening now, though... I really liked this album. It felt super intimate, like I was in the room with them as they were performing/recording. And that room was someone's own living room, or bedroom. The sparse instrument arrangements and space felt purposeful rather than incomplete. The vocals were more of a conversation, two people stating their views on things with each other, than people belting out for the audience. The melodies were engaging and pleasant even if not complex. And, while melancholy for the most part, the album felt like something the makers were proud of. I think I was really drawn to the simplicity and honesty they captured. Of course, it still has some issues. There really aren't many parts that do anything different, so it all feels a bit the same. And, despite everything I liked, it was still a little boring. An intentional boring, I guess. It's weird how tastes and preferences can change. Where before I would've overlooked this album, today I enjoyed being immersed in it. The flaws keep me from saying it's something great, but it was still very good. Overall: 3.6/5
sigma podcast intro, gotta respect that
i guess it aint that bad i kinda like it but its not too crazy
Made me fall asleep
Все чет мурчали, чет пукали, грустили. Вроде норм, а вроде вообще ничего что зацепило. Спасибо что не прогрессив рок.
Another album I never would have listened to if not for this collection. Also another album that is perfect for an early morning drive. Outside of that I don't know if I will ever return to this album after today. But I didn't hate that I had to listen to it. 3/5
If the early 2010s had a sound, this would be it. In my opinion, this is well-made millennial indie pop. 6/10
Generic mediocrity
Fifa pack opening music
Probabily they made a lot of money selling music rights for netflix dramas and amazon commercials. 1.5 / 5
Meh. Nothing special.
00’s Indie ⭐️Infinity
Wasn't expecting to have recognized a couple of these songs. In total it's nice to know that there are some decent recent entrants in the Alt genre. Sure the subgenre is decently popular and getting new music all the time but this was at least fairly fresh from a new artist. Was good through and through, lull at times but nothing bothersome
Was big into this when it first came out, such an immaculate sounding album, great reverb and sparse arrangements. I think it suffers from the fact that the intro is probably the best piece of music on the album, and even though the singles are very strong it doesn't quite live up to what the first track promises. A really great and unique sounding album though, shame the follow up was a step backwards.
Meh, not a big fan of indie pop
It is a 5er for me. Lots of memories flooding in while I listened to this on my run yesterday morning.
daft punk, khruanghbin vibes
Pretty great, really listenable, light electro-synth harmonies
Videl som ich naživo na jednom festivale a tam im to vôbec nepasovalo. Lepší by boli v malom priestore. Inak sú príjemní.
🙄
This an amazing piece of work. Euphoric, rhythmic and simplicity an audible pillow to rest on, or a companion to travel with. If you can find it, look for the cross over project with Biggie Smalls, it proves the versatility of this album and the talent of the XX.
Yes I’d like to order a scoop of vanilla ice cream on a slice of white bread with a marshmallow on top.
favs: intro heart skipped a beat shelter infinity night time rating 2.3/5
Een album wat ik op lp heb en goed ken. Toch ben ik iets minder fan van het album dan toen het uitkwam. Ik weet niet precies waarom. Het is minimalistisch en atmosferisch en ik hou van de afwisseling tussen de twee stemmen. Het is misschien afhankelijk van uit welke muzikale periode jezelf komt of dit aanslaat of wat meer langs je heen glijdt. Als ik het nu voor het eerst zou horen zou ik het een drie geven maar als ik het luister word ik op veel momenten toch teruggebracht naar die periode en zit ik er goed in. Het pakt mij nog steeds maar het verveeld ook iets meer dan toen, Het maakt ook zeker uit hoe je dit luistert. Het moet op speakers. Je hebt de bas nodig om de productie te horen.
Ik weet dat dit album erg veel impact heeft gemaakt, maar ik moet zeggen dat ik het toch wel tegen vind vallen. Het begint met Intro, en dat is natuurlijk wel een episch, anthem-achtige song. De rest van het album is wel een beetje veel hetzelfde recept. Bij het tweede nummer was ik terecht een beetje bang dat de zangeres de rest van het album om dezelfde lome manier zou zingen, ik vind haar stem al snel een beetje saai worden. De jongen doet dat ook een beetje op dezelfde manier. T’ gitaarspel vind ik wel goed, de dingen die ze speelt, maar vooral ook de sound die ze heeft. Ze maakt de Les Paul weer relevant. Ik snap verder de vibe wel, maar ik vind het niet per se een superleuke vibe.
Disco sobrevalorado
Intro is excellent. Sadly, the rest doesn’t quite live up to it. It’s fine, but only that. I prefer Jamie XX’s music to that of The xx.
Lo recordaba genial y me pareció muy repetitivo
La verdad ni fu ni fa. No diría que es exactamente el estereotipo de música de la época, se parece pero tiene un distintivo. No queda guardado.
better than i expected
Two straight albums, fire opening track, followed by muzak
Understated but cool.
I see this get compared to Colossal Youth, one of my favorite albums, a lot. And while they're superficially similar in their minimalism, I think this comparison misses the mark. See, the minimalism of Colossal Youth underscores the beaten-down anger of that album, whereas here the minimalism is in service of a hazy, dreamlike atmosphere. That latter is something that I hear *a lot* in music that followed, and while I recognize that this is the originator, I'm just so tired of that type of thing, I prefer for there to be more substance in my music, personally.
Phenomenal ...