American Idiot by Green Day

American Idiot

Green Day

3.77
Rating
31357
Votes
1
4%
2
9%
3
24%
4
34%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 10 of 16)

I always thought it was too cheesy, and I still do, but just on great singles it deserves stars

Mainstream Punk at its best.

This album singlehandedly changed my music taste thank you for your service

green day... altijd een twijfelgeval... vond ze altijd een bende posers met hier en daar een goeie song... dit album verandert mijn mening niet... rock operas zijn zo al een genre dat rap kan veranderen in een brij van middelmatige songs met te hoog gegrepen verbanden, laat staan lyrics... dit is zeker geen uitzondering op die regel

I'm really not a fan of the era and genre of popular music that this album belongs to - it's the most manufactured and commercial that a countercultural movement has ever been. All of the kinks that would be on an album like this have been completely smoothed out, and everything else is shined to the point of having nothing to latch onto. It's admittedly pleasing, though only superficially. On a positive, this album definitely belongs on the list. I can't think of a more popular album that I've skimped out on listening to.

Fun, hot and reminds me of teenage times

Such a good album. Was good in 2004 and is still good in 2025.

Somehow, I never understood the hype about Green Day or the specific sub genre. Not bad though, this one. Easy listening Punk Pop if you ask me. Catchy with some pretty good lyrics, but nothing for my island

Catchy! Many bangers 💥

As good as you can expect from a middle aged punk band.

Not really my choice.

Brilliant

im the son of rage and love!!!

I remember when this came out. Dookie was definitely in my top 5 albums at the time, and I very much remember being disappointed in this album. Green Day had grown up, but I hadn't. I have heard some of the singles a number of times as they had significant radio play, and maybe listened to the entire album once when it came out. It wasn't ever something I purposely went back to, let alone listened to with intention. Listening today, in the first days of 2025, I regret all the time that went by that I wasn't listening to this album. I am glad I have been able to mature enough to appreciate this album for what it is: a fucking masterpiece of pop punk, and opera, perfect commentary on the time it was released, and an unfortunately accurate prediction on the time I'm listening in 2025. I listen to music a lot, and have always had a feeling that I couldn't name about certain songs or bands. Sometimes, a song just feels...BIG. An epic. Led Zeppelin and My Chemical Romance are two bands that stick out to me as making songs like this that I couldn't describe well. Reading the Wikipedia article, Green Day said they wanted to abandon the verse-chorus-verse-chorus-bridge structure and go big. That's it. That's the thing I haven't ever been able to put my finger. Also, Tré's toms sound so big on this album. The bass and guitars sound huge and so good together. This was masterfully produced and recorded. 5 stars

the album starting off with two hits is crazy. i kinda checked out towards the end but this is still a good album!

Classic turn of the century punk rock.

Classic album that helped push punk rock into the mainstream, green day is not perfect, but they are a fantastic band with so much influence. 8/10

Great album

an emo essential

Δυνατό

Gott popp rokk. Solid lagasmíði og var miklu betra en annað sem var í gangi 2004. Flest lögin þarna eru auðvitað ofspiluð í drasl en kemur svosem ekki að sök við yfirferðina.

I love the angst and the story Billy Joe is a great songwriter and tre cool carries with his drumming

I can’t say there is anything wrong with this, but by this point Greenday had a “formula”. Listening now after getting back into all the 50s rock, that’s what I hear. I hear the same sensibility that the Ramones were drawing from. I want to hate this but I can’t. I love the melodies and song structure. It has punk energy and elements of gentle 50s pop. I’m over the “hits”. I will probably skip those. Although, again I like the approach to the sounds. It’s very produced. And that’s not bad. It’s just from a time where there formed a sound template and everything after sounded the same. I really hate that I like this album. 🤣 “we are the waiting” is an amazing anthem and I would love to experience this live. “Homecoming” is a great song. I hate that I really like this album. 🤣

As one of the few fans of Warning I had dropped off the Green Day train in the interim and never really listened to this one. I need to spend some time with the lyric sheet, I’m not sure what makes it an “opera” just yet. But I dug it.

not my fav green day album

More complex than albums like Dookie or Insomniac, but still catchy and fun with no bad songs.

Super nostalgic. I remember hearing Holiday on a Tony Hawk game and falling completely in love. The album holds up pretty well and Billy Armstong’s voice remains one of the more distinct voices in music. 4/5

Fitting that I’m listening to this on Trumps Inauguration Day. We really are a bunch of idiots putting that clown back in office. Great album!

Focused and meaningful. Successfully conveys its story and message.

I remember this album's release quite well, despite being young at the time. Green Day hadn't done anything super noteworthy in the few years leading up to this album's release (for what it's worth, I think their prior album "Warning" is pretty underrated). Then boom, the singles were all over the radio during the mid-2000's. Listening to this album all the way through as an adult gives me a better appreciation for it for sure. Being a kid and not fully understanding the socio-political goings-on at the time, the punk rock/pop-punk rage and disillusionment from this era seeps through now. Interesting that the group went the "punk rock opera" route too. As a result, some tracks are very involved and even contain their own "chapters" ("Jesus of Suburbia", which introduces our "main character", and "Homecoming"). It all feels very grand compared to their previous releases, thanks to the overarching narrative. While I still prefer "Dookie", that was much more playful and almost elementary compared to "American Idiot". Both are pop-punk at their respective cores, yet on differing sides of that spectrum. Best tracks: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams (gotta love that transition)

I am a different human without this album. Good songs on it too

This is a classic punk album that really captured a generation.

I have never been too fussed by green Day but I was wrong. My son loves a couple of their songs. This is a brilliant album, all of it.

No album better embodies post-9/11 American in the mid-00s. At a time when public enemy number one was our own President and the constant fear of terrorism still burned in our skulls, Green Day put pen to paper and wrote our collective American experience. 3.9/5

Masterpiece

I enjoyed much more while I was younger, still worth a listen, it's aged better than I have.

Very nostalgic, Bonnie danced to American idiot lol

Super Album!

Solid song craft and power pop. They are no longer punk as far at this point. Sellouts.

Had I been 12 when this came out I might have considered this "deep" and "edgy" and then I might have something positive to say in this review. However even in 2004 I was a lot older then 12 and also I don't think I ever heard it before now since I don't recognize any of it. From my review for Dookie "Loud but only slightly obnoxious". This album however is more than slightly obnoxious as reflected in the 1 star rating.

American Idiot is the seventh studio album by Green Day, originally released in 2004. Like another user commented, it's important to place this album in its context. Green Day were pretty irrelevant prior to this album's release. Their previous record came out 4 years prior to a disappointing reception. This album blew up and I mean BLEW UP. These singles are still getting heavy airplay to this day. And every song on here is so damn catchy. The lyrics haven't aged as well, and I was originally going to give this a 3, but I found myself vibing with every song. It's really the perfect pop punk album. The production is polished but it really fits the music oddly enough. Many people consider Green Day to be sellouts but I think they were just doing what they did best.

Grøn dag får en instant fucking 10/5

I really liked whatshername

First listen. Not bad, just not my cup of tea.

The difficult 7th album. I would have preferred a decent punk rock album to this ‘punk rock opera’

I had no idea that Green Day had sold so many of this album, nor that they'd sold nearly twice as many of Dookie. They are both way up there in the best selling albums of all time. In some ways it's not surprising with this one: it's such middle of the road inoffensive pop rock. Personally, I struggled to get through it. There was a bit of Homecoming that I enjoyed, but that was about it. I struggle to understand how I can find this so uninspiring, but Dookie can be one of my favourite albums of all time. It's either (1) I heard Dookie at a formative time and listened to it so much that it became a part of me, and every subsequent listen reminds me of how i felt and who i was when i first discovered it but actually if I heard it for the first time now I wouldn't think it had value; or (2) Dookie and American Idiot are on two sides of a change in the band that involved them adapting their sound to fill stadiums with modern audiences, rather like what happened to Kings of Leon after Aha Shake Heartbreak, and I don't like music produced after a band makes that change. If it is (1) then I feel the difference would be so intrinsically a part of my personality that objectively assessing it would be like trying to look at the back of my own head. However, I'm pretty sure it's (2), that Dookie is actually great and this is actually shit. I mean: at times it actually sounds like someone is taking the piss out of bad quality W-era protest songs. It belongs in the same bin as NOFX's War on Errorism, when just saying President=Moron was something insightful, amusing, rebellious. But then again, I think Dookie is firmly "pop punk", and is there any pop punk album I would listen to for the first time now and enjoy? Perhaps not. But I listened to Warning around the same time as Dookie and I'm pretty sure I would consider that shit even though I liked it at the time. Maybe I should just stop trying to look for any objectivity in valuing these albums and embrace that two albums that probably have similar musical value can be at opposite ends of the scale for me. Dookie IS a 5 star album, this definitely a 1.

Some nice melodies, but also some very cheesy lyrics. It's hard to take seriously at times.

Pretty fun and not at all annoying which is a massive plus

Crappy pop

One of my favorite albums to listen to from start to finish. The broadway musical is great as well!

246/1001

Absolutely incredible. One of my favorite albums of all time. St. Jimmy!!!!

Loved this album - had just moved to Guernsey and listened to it on my 30 min walk in/ back from work. Still rocks.

Was Green Day a bonafide rock band and I didn't really notice it?! "American Idiot" still holds and is relevant as ever. I didn't remember that "Holiday" and "Boulevard of broken dreams" flowed right into each other. Cool.

I wanted to hate it - because Alternative Rock sucks usually, and these guys are from Berkley which I instinctively dislike; but truth is I couldn’t help but like it. I laughed at American Idiot, aimed at GW Bush but in truth so much more applicable to more recent administrations and current culture in America, and I found I really liked Boulevard and Wake Me Up. All in all a solid album.

This one's definitely influenced by nostalgia but I don't even care. Soundtrack to my high school years! I've always really liked Green Day, so even without the nostalgia factor this probably would have gotten a high rating. Solid sound and instrumentals throughout, and the songs are thoroughly entertaining. There isn't really a dud in the bunch.

Just there really, out there, doesn't care whether you like it or not. I can make it all the way through, but it's not pressing any pleasure buttons.

I'll parrot Mic the Snare by saying that this album has lost a bit of its lustre with overplay, and personally it gets a bit sonically repetitive, but its lyrical ambitions are evident and still hit hard nowadays. I really need to listen to it more than once to fully get into it, but for now, it's a very well put-together pop punk album.

Powerful ambitious. Love me a rock opera, and this delivers more so than tommy with discrete, yet part of the whole songs. If dirnt had done more harmonies rather than multitracking BJ (at least on my ear read) and there had been a bit more variety would have been a 5, but its close regardless.

Don’t really like Green Day but this is a good album

I love the transitions. It sounds like they're having so much fun

Absolute banger, no weak songs. There's probably some component of bias due to nostalgia, but I think if I hadn't heard this and listened for the first time I would still think it rocks. Favorite songs were: 2. Jesus of Suburbia 3. Holiday 13. Whatsername 10/10

The song American Idiot was one of the first songs I bought on iTunes (I think the very first was Goodies by Ciara). I listened to it non-stop but never bought the album, so I actually don't know any of the other songs besides Boulevard/Holiday and Wake Me Up When September Ends. I had the compilation CD International Superhits, so all the Green Day nostalgia I have is wrapped up in those songs, not American Idiot. In middle school I went on a very purist/pretentious streak and got deeply into 70s/80s punk (Clash, Ramones, Dead Kennedys etc...). At that time Green Day were huge, and the face of punk/alternative being big in the mainstream. I viewed them as sellout and I wrongly shunned them (sorry Billy Joe). Later in life I realized that they do in fact rule, and started appreciating them as an adult. The end result however, is that I didn't listen to them in those formative years that everyone else did. They were there at the beginning of those times but were absent for the bulk of them, so I have definite nostalgia for them, but it’s not the deepest. From that perspective, American Idiot is quite good but not an all timer for me. The song American Idiot doesn’t do it for me anymore. Boulevard/Holiday are all time greats and will 100% be on my next trip to a Karaoke bar. The rest I alternated between enjoying or thinking “Hey that’s pretty good”. Without the nostalgia bias, this definitely rocks, but it’s not 5 stars. Album cover: (C+) Not trying to be mean here, but it’s not a great graphic. Also a little on the nose.

The day has finally come! When Stijn and I started this project I said that if this album wasn't on here then the entire list was junk. I am happy to report that the list has now been validated! The first concert I ever went to was Green Day on the American Idiot tour in Mullins Arena at UMass. Thinking back, it was cool as hell that Green Day went out to Western Mass to play a show because almost nobody does that. I think I was in the 4th grade. I remember that I had to actually save up to pay for the ticket myself. My friend's dad got us the tickets and when I went to pay him back with literal rolls of quarters I had saved, he told me he didn't want to carry those around and therefore I got the ticket for free, which was super rad. My pants were falling down all night with the rolls of quarters in my pockets and I was on cloud 9. That was a peak childhood experience and everything about that and this album made me the person I am today. Needless to say I fucking LOVE this album. I have listened to it actual hundreds of times. I can still picture my friend's mom's handwriting on the burned CD she gave me of it. I stream it now, but the feeling never changes. It is quite literally perfect. The songs are all amazing and flow together perfectly. If I was being sent to a desert island for the rest of my life and could only take one album, it would be this. No hesitation. I might even take just half of this album over any other album. I still listen to it all the way through probably once a month, minimum. I hope that never changes. Green Day, thank you for existing and creating this masterful work of art.

This is an instant 10/10 for me. "American Idiot" and "The Black Parade" are the two defining albums of my childhood. It was the first CD I ever owned and I listened to it constantly. I could go ten years without listening to it and still know every word. This album was an on-ramp not only to Green Day's older and punkier albums, but the entire world of punk music in general. My parent's friend, Kevin Meeten, heard that I was obsessed with Green Day and showed up at my house with their entire discography burned onto CDs, album covers printed out in low resolution and put inside cheap plastic CD cases. I'm not sure I even knew they had other albums prior to that moment, but they quickly became valuable currency among my friends. I would bring them around to the many houses and we'd listen to them, our minds being blown by "Dookie" and "Nimrod". This was my first introduction to music snobbery, and I was the culprit. Oh, you've only listened to American Idiot? I love basically every song on this album. I went through phases with it, each section of the album becoming my favorite for a few months at a time. I'd listen to just the first four songs on repeat, then get bored of them and realize the next four were just as good. At this point in time, I think "Homecoming" and "Whatshername" are my favorite songs. The live album of the American Idiot Tour, "Bullet In A Bible", came with a concert DVD that shared equal time inside my DVD Player with "Return of the King". I watched it on repeat and put so much pressure on my parents that I went to Green Day as my first concert a year later. It rocked. This isn't Green Day's best album, but it is definitely their most important album for me. The political angles of the album may have influenced me a lot, and unfortunately ring just as true twenty years later. I have no complaints about this album whatsoever. It fucking rocks, it changed music for me. 10/10

A scathing indictment of suburban America and its culture/belief system under the Bush administration. Also at times a beautiful display of the different ways those suburban kids/families struggle to reckon with personal tragedy. A great juxtaposition of power chords and sad but catchy melodies. It’s undeniably a 5, a good snapshot in time for a subset of Americans

Not bad, some classics

Green Day again. Kings of pop punk, I guess. If Green Day is good at anything it’s bringing people with bad music taste together. Is this really what the people want? A pop punk band full of mediocre musicians making political statements? One bright spot is “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” with the cool guitar.

For some reason I've always felt like Green Day was over-hyped. Perhaps it was influence from friends in the 90s who thought that they were "fake punk" or "sold out" or whatever. I've enjoyed their songs throughout the years. The mainstream success of American Idiot made it something that I avoided checking out. Listening to it today, I was struck by how many of these songs I've heard before. They go well together. I'm not really sure about the story of this concept album, but I enjoy the theme and feeling. This really is a great album.

It's a little bit cheesy at times, and I totally don't understand why there are so many double songs that are quite clearly distinct entities. But this hit all the right nostalgia buttons for me, and it still holds up well for the most part. Shockingly good for me. Came very, very close to five stars.

Love this album It’s almost a five It’s really a 9/10 but in this case I’m rounding UP TO 5.

This was THE album that got me into rock music about 20 years ago now (Christ that makes me feel old) so I’m hardly going to be objective here, but I’ll try There are a few songs in the middle that drag slightly - Are We The Waiting, She’s a Rebel and Extraordinary Girl are all a bit bland, and Homecoming towards the end is very unfocused and feels like a load of unfinished songs slapped together rather than a larger conceptual piece. American Idiot is a concept album and is kind of political but the lyrics are often very vague and it’s difficult to tell exactly what the political stance is, especially when it gets watered down by the central doomed lovers storyline Criticism out of the way - I absolutely love it. The title track is a pure injection of energy and fire with one of the most iconic and pounding drum parts of all time. Jesus of Suburbia is even greater than the sum of its parts, a rock opera epic with so many memorable motifs. Holiday and St Jimmy are both incredibly fun, Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Give Me Novocaine are massive and gorgeous ballads, and Letterbomb is a blast of pop punk greatness with one of Green Day’s most underrated choruses. Wake Me Up is probably their most personal song and (while a bit overplayed) is so emotional and powerful when it hits, and Whatsername is a beautifully nostalgic closer with a heartstopping bridge. It’s a stunning project that blends stadium rock songwriting with pop-punk spirit and musical theatre ambition, and a complete reinvention of Green Day’s sound that led to them one of the biggest bands in the world, and my favourite band for a very very long time. I loved music for as long as I can remember but this in particular captured my heart when I was about 9 years old and opened my eyes as to what music could achieve, sonically and narratively, and what an album could be rather than just a collection of songs, and I immediately began devouring album after album until my brain melted and I signed up to listen to 1001 of the stupid things. No word of a lie, I don’t think I would have studied music at university without American Idiot, I don’t think I would have been friends with a lot of my closest pals growing up without American Idiot, and I would absolutely not be the person I am today without American Idiot. 3 stars.

Simply a really good emo band. Sure, Green Day's overplayed, but "Wake Me Up When September Ends" is loads better than whatever-the-hell My Chemical Romance came up with around that time. The tone shift b/w "Holiday" and "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" is f**king epic. I need to listen to the band more.

I do enjoy some Green Day and this is no exception. Credit for having a punk rock album where 4 songs are 7:30+ minutes long. Huge hits in American Idiot, Holiday, Wake Me up When September Ends. 6.5/10 (3.25/5)

I've always given Green Day a hard time. I love punk, but compared to the likes of the Dead Kennedy's and Fugazi, GD we're always too bubblegum instead of broken glass. That said, this is a dead good record. Saying that punk is bad because it's accessible is obviously misguided - especially when the message is still pretty consistent. I liked this a lot, and will definitely give it another spin.

Still holds true today

- Ich finde (wenn vielleicht auch an der ein oder anderen Stelle etwas überhört) ehrlich gesagt ein perfektes Album - Konzeptalbum, das von vorne bis Hinten eine coole Geschichte erzählt - Fast jeder Song ein Hit, mehrere Welthits - Tolle Lyrics - Super Songwriting - Ich liebe nahezu jeden Track und mein Lieblingstrack auf dem Album "Holiday" war der erste Song, den ich je auf E-Gitarre gelernt habe - "Jesus Of Suburbia" ist einfach Green Days "Bohemian Rhapsody". Eine fucking Rock-Oper im besten Sinne mit großen epischen Parts, mit kleinen ruhigen Momenten, mit Leitmotiv und allem Drum und Dran. Ich sehe es immer wieder als Musical vor meinen Augen. Einfach großartig. - Dazu mit "Boulevard Of Broken Dreams" und "Wake Me Up When September Ends" zwei der schönsten Rockballaden, die je geschrieben wurden. - Allein einfach mit einem Track wie „American Idiot" zu eröffnen, ist auch schon ein Statement. - Auch abseits der großen Hits einfach soo gute Songs - Live einer der geilsten Auftritte, die ich je auf einem Festival erlebt habe, weil die einfach fast 2,5 Std. so krank Gas gegeben haben - Diese Band hat in meinen Augen mit diesem Album Legendenstatus erreicht und von immer schon auch politischem aber auch teils quatschigem Poppunk ein ernstzunehmendes Alternative Rock / Mainstream Punk Album für die Ewigkeit geschaffen. - Artwork eine 10/10 und eines der ikonischsten ever - Ich könnte wohl zu jedem Song irgendwas schreiben aber ich belasse es jetzt bei einer für mich klaren 5/5 und das obwohl ich nie so drüber nachgedacht habe Rating: 5/5

- Mein erstes, selbstgekauftes Rock-Album, Muddi wollte damals erstmal die Texte lesen, um sicherzugehen, dass das für mich hörbar ist (als ob ich damals irgendein Wort davon verstanden hätte, ich war glaube ich 9) - Was ein Banger von einem Album! Hat mich einfach in Richtung Rock, später Metal und schließlich zum Metalcore geführt. War schon derbe prägend - Neben den ganzen Hits auf der Platte, feiere ich auch viele von den nicht ganz so abgegangen Tracks extrem -> "Give Me Novacaine", "She's a Rebel", "Extraordinary Girl", "Letterbomb" und "Jesus of Suburbia" sind für mich auch so krasse Banger - Kehre immer mal wieder zu Green Day zurück und die Jungs stehen auch immer noch auf meiner Live-Bucketlist

I tried. 2

One of the better 21st century albums

Super nostalgic for me and I think that's why I'm rating it higher. This was a really important album in my adolescence and listening to it today transported me right back.

Some commentary here is still relevant. It’s still iconic. One of the classics when it comes to pop-punk. The album feels rather 1 dimensional at times, however.

When it comes to pop punk-operas, you could do worse. You could certainly do a lot better too.

amazing album

I'm honestly empathetic to people who can't stand the idea of pop-punk. "pop" and "punk" seem like antonyms in many ways. But I don't think it's inherently bad when ideas of social awareness, consciousness, and empathy are spread to the masses through catchy tunes and polished production - especially during a time as uncertain as the post-9/11, Iraq Operation dominated, and Bush-administration run 2000s. Was Green Day the most effective in doing this? No, not at all. I can name dozens of hip-hop, punk, and even electronic artists who did a much better job of capturing the horrors of this time. But I don't think any were as commercially successful as Green Day with 'American Idiot', I mean just look at those streaming numbers. While I prefer my punk unpolished, dirty, and relentlessly noisy, even I can admit that there's a lot to love here. The opening title track may be one of the best pop-punk songs of all time, topping anything on Green Day's 'Dookie' even. But what follows is a pretty hit-or-miss concept-driven prog pop-punk album following the "Jesus of Suburbia", a man infected with those post-9/11 blues, as he falls into a deep depression and even dabbles with drug usage by the time the songs 'St. Jimmy' and 'Give Me Novacaine' come along. And I guess that's what initially rubbed me the wrong way about this thing, it's an album that focuses on the struggles of the average, seemingly well-off, American as opposed to the struggles of the ones in the direct line of fire of the American military for example. I don't see it that way now though, or maybe I do, but it doesn't bother me as much, at least not during the first half. But by the time JOS meets that rebel girl, and the cheesy-as-all-hell 'Extraordinary Girl' comes along, I roll my eyes. Maybe I don't get the whole thing, maybe it's all meant to be subtly ironic - the name "Jesus of Suburbia" and even "American Idiot" certainly hint at some level of irony. But if that's the case, why waste so much time building the protagonist up to be this tragic figure? Maybe I'm looking into it too deeply and trying to turn this album's concept into something it's not. Green Day's audience is predominantly young white Americans I'd assume, so targeting this concept toward their struggles and feelings of emptiness in an oppressive world only makes sense. And it's always a good sign when you can feel sadness at the ideas of oppression, even when they don't affect you directly, and Green Day captures those feelings quite well here, so for that, I'll still praise the concept of this thing, at least a tiny bit. So yeah, I'm a bit iffy on the concept. And even the playing here I'm very indifferent towards - it's standard. I do like the song 'Letterbomb' from an instrumental standpoint, with all its Husker Du'isms (20 years after the fact...god that band is good...). I'm maybe less partial towards the slower-ballad type tracks, or momentum-killers as I like to call them, especially the overplayed 'Boulevard of Broken Dreams'. I used to feel this way about the song 'Wake Me Up When September Ends' as well, but after learning about the pretty sad backstory of this song, I've started to appreciate its softer approach. The thing I love the most about this album though, by far, is Billy Joe Armstrong's vocals. I mean I love this vocal style in general but, on this album specifically, every damn song is unbelievably catchy, to the point where it's not even fair. It's fun, and the album's near-hour run time flies by - and a ton of these songs have been in my rotation for as long as I can remember. SO, for as cynical as I am towards the social commentary turned teenage drama concept of a record like this, I still ended up forming an almost guilty pleasure relationship with it. Or maybe "guilty" is not the right word, I do still wholeheartedly believe that the title track, 'American Idiot', is incredibly iconic and even "important(???)". Also, the pop-punk music here, in general, is very influential in this genre. Perhaps the best way to describe this album is 'interesting.' It's certainly a period piece, but how well it has aged is entirely up to the listener to decide.

Better than the sum of it's parts. I could go my life without hearing "Wake Me Up When September Ends" or "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" again, but the rest of the album fits together well.

Safe, commercial teenage angst

Good album

Dated, boring, pop punk from Target

18 months ago I gave Dookie a semi-reluctant 5 stars (well, 4.5 stars rounded up) partially because of those classic early singles but partially because I felt it was the Green Day album I *should* rate the highest. Yes, I’d rather listen to American Idiot front-to-back, but that’s just nostalgia for an album than came out when I was 14, right? Surely the debut album, before they starting ‘selling out’, had to be objectively more authentic and better…? Since then I’ve done some reflecting, and also had the pleasure of seeing the band perform both albums live in full, and I can confidently say that American Idiot is, in fact, their masterpiece. For starters, it’s a concept album in a strong sense - it’s musically and thematically linked, with some excellent transitions between tracks, which I always appreciate. Ok, I’ve never been sure *exactly* what the narrative is supposed to be, but that doesn’t matter - the music tells a story on its own. It’s ambitious and cinematic but it never comes across as pretentious to me, as at its core it’s still using the same basic ingredients of punk-rock chords and pop melodies, just served in a different way. 20 years on it still sounds great to me.

Not what I usually listen to, so missed a lot of the lyrics. Recognized a couple of songs.

Green Day really proved they hadn't lost a step when this came out. Sometimes anger and depression can make great art.

I bought this album on CD from a CeX while on a Scout camp years ago. It was a similar time to when I first got The Black Parade, but while I only found out The Black Parade is a concept album in the last half decade this was my first experience with an album which obviously used music as a way to tell a serialised story. The anti-establishment message defiantly effected my teenage mind for the better. The sound keeps changing and everything is iconic. I dream of seeing the musical on stage. Great album. Favourite track: Wake Me Up When September Ends.

I knew right away that I was not going to be a huge fan of green day so I was kind of annoyed. This shockingly wasn’t AS horrible as I had thought it would be, and I recognized a lot more songs than I thought I would. Don’t get me wrong I still hated the voice and everything but it wasn’t as bad as I had expected.

Redundant title, cynically infinitely more-appropriate for 2024. But a pop-punk concept album and from a band I never liked sounds awful...? I absolutely didn't give time to this back in 2004 - let's see how I feel 20 (!) years later... --- yeah every Green Day song sounds so ... Green Day. Every time. Billie Joe's voice is so utterly featureless as to almost seem fake - this was always one big aspect that prevented me from liking Green Day. That and the standard plowing ahead with nothing-beyond-power-chords aspect of the songs .... nitpicking I guess since that IS their thing? But I really don't like it - just not hitting with me at all. There may be some things more complex/interesting than Dookie (the only other album I know from them) and at the risk of sounding like a pompous douche ... it seems like they really tried pushing the limits of their limited songwriting abilities here, so ... good on them! <while patting them gently on the head as they head back to their seats> I shouldn't have read that they listened to "Quadrophenia" a lot to get some concept album ideas because ... this ain't that (nothing is). TL;DR: ... good effort, I guess? This music simply isn't for me: power pop punk with ironically no emotion at all and just one volume (thanks, 2000-era compression?). 5/10 2 stars.

Say what you will about Green Day, the song transitions on the album at perfect.

This album has a lot of things I like: easy to sing along with. Variety of volume and tempo. Multiple voices in chorus or other parts.

Entirely predictable. There were even a few songs where I thought the album had started itself over for some reason because so many of them sound the same. I skipped over Boulevard of Broken Dreams because I don't ever need to hear that again. On the one hand, there is such little evolution in their sound from their Dookie days that this sounds so sophomoric. On the other hand, they tried so hard to create meaning here that just falls flat for me. Maybe if I were at a more impressionable age when this came out...

Good god this brings back memories. I was in high school when this dropped and I remember hearing it everywhere. At the time I wasn't into the pop-punk stuff (wasn't really into music) and never really gave it the proper listen. Amazing how many songs I was familiar with despite never owning the album.

It was amazing

Album is not very musically interesting. I was growing sleepy by the end of it. The political commentary is milquetoast at best. I will grant it a 3 because it has some banger tracks: "Boulevard of Broken Dreams", "Letterbomb", "American Idiot".

No aportan nada nuevo.

Yeah we get you're angsty youths and we live in a sucky country, that doesn't make it a good album. The music is pretty uninspired and the only real selling point is the angst. You know, I'm glad my mom didn't let me listen to this one growing up.

I think this album is great because I grew up in the early 2000s, and this album is just so iconic from that time. Listening to it now, I wouldn't really call this a punk album. It has some of the lyrical qualities of punk, but not a ton, and it's definitely not punk stylistically (more like pop punk if anything). The hits on this album hold up so hard. They're still so good, even if they've been meme-ified a little. The rest of the songs hold their own weight, but the hits are definitely the highlight of any listen through. Favorite Song(s): Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends

I mean, what's to say, one of my favourite albums growing up, and every bit of this holds up.

An album with an overarching storyline? What a concept.

This showed up as my album today, and I immediately went back to my teenage years - so of course I was worried I'd be biased, that nostalgia would play its part in my review. Therefore I tried my best to go into this critically, listening as though for the first time. And you know what? It still rules. When it first came out, I didn't bother listening to it because I though "oh, this is the Wake Me Up When September Ends album, I don't wanna listen to those emos", but I think Green Day have always released maudlin singles off of bangers of albums, which really don't give you an impression of what the rest of the album is like. It's a worrying state of affairs that so much of the societal points that Green Day rally against are no better - or possibly even worse - today, and their lyrics still hit hard now. Also, how is this twenty years old?? Faves: Homecoming, Letterbomb, American Idiot

It’s good. I recognize and remember it’s importance, but just don’t like it that much.

Personally, I'm more of a dookie guy. But c'mon, it's american idiot. 5/5

A punk rock opera, huh? I think I might disagree. I applaud the ambitiousness of this album but, good god I can't stand the way Billie Joe Armstrong sings. Really most of the pop-punk bands from back in the day, the vocals are all trash. This album was huge when it came out. I mean didn't they make a Broadway show off of this? No comment on the irony of that.... As with a lot of the other stuff from Green Day, I actually like the music fairly well. It's interesting, decently recorded, varies from song to song. But the vocals are just tough for me. Lyrically I think it's ok, a little simple and on the nose but not bad I suppose. I appreciate the message at least. Green Day is a band that I wish I liked more, I just don't. Mostly because of the vocals, I just can't get on board. Generous 3/5

Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake me up when September ends carried this for me. Honestly I expected to like it a little more than I did, this one just did not click with me as much as Dookie did. Solid but I wasn't floored

This is a hard album to evaluate. It's definitely not a great punk album. And, I'm not even sure it's a great rock opera. However, it's indisputable that Green Day made a great album. I somehow avoided this album despite living through the early 2000s. I was in my counterculture phase, listening to mostly jam bands, and ironically Green Day was decidedly not counterculture at this point in time. I'm not sure they ever were really, but at least Dookie was a punk album at heart. Of course, I didn't escape the radio hits. They just came and came and came from this album. But, I have to say, listening to the whole thing start to finish, I was really impressed. I knew the popular songs, but I didn't know how it all fit together into the concept album. In fact, I think the songs I enjoyed most were the songs that I hadn't heard before. I liked their composition, I liked their storytelling, and I liked how they incorporated diverse musical styles. This is one of those albums that I didn't love, but I appreciate it. I doubt I'll return to it, maybe a few songs here and there, but I can acknowledge it's greatness. And for that it's a four-star album for me.

It was all over the screen

I loved Dookie, but then sort looked down on Green Day as "sellouts" (due mostly to the success of "Good Riddance") until this album came out. It really softened my perception of the band. It's a fantastic rock opera, and is enjoyable from end to end.

5 Stars. And so appropriate. The fascist circus is back in town. God Bless Green Day!

American Idiot 3.2 Jesus of Suburbia 3 Holiday 3.3 Boulevard of Broken Dreams 3.1 Are We the Waiting 3 St. Jimmy 2.8 Give Me Novacaine 3 She's a Rebel 3 Extraordinary Girl 3.1 Letterbomb 3.3 Wake Me Up When September Ends 3.3 Homecoming 3.4 Whatsername 3.1 Score: 3.123076923

My first listen to the whole album. I didn’t realize it was a rock opera. And it’s a good one.

Nostalgic as hell. 4/5

Probably would be a 5 star to high school freshman me, but this album does hold up. Even more so with the current political climate

I Don't Care What Any RYM Using Fantano Loving /Mu/ Denizen Says

it's fine. not into punk.

Played REPEATEDLY EVERYWHERE when it was released. Nevertheless, it’s a polished album full of relevance even sadly 20 years after release. Like it.

Yo what a fantastic piece of art this is. I can't believe I never listened to the whole thing until now. Teenage me would have loved it.

Rating: 7.5/10 The highlights are fantastic, some of the other songs not so much.

I love the familiarity

This was a seminal album for me in my teenage years and brought back a lot of good memories. It still holds up well in my opinion, with a great mix of high energy punk tracks and slower ballads. I love how ambitious it is with the rock opera meta-story but most tracks hold up well on their own as well. St Jimmy and Holiday were my favorite tracks as a kid and upon revisiting the album I've learned that I had great taste.

Pretty good. Felt a bit repetitive at times though. Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams is an all-timer

I think for nostalgia’s sake I will rate this higher This slapped when i was 15

Iconic riffs and lyrics. Topical when it came out, but unfortunately remains culturally relevant 20 years later. Extremely ambitious, but is everything it should be. I'm a sucker for a good concept album anyway. Not to mention six songs over 5min is pretty amazing for a "punk" band.

I professed to hate this album when it came out, because I believed the rhetoric that Green Day had sold out. I took me revisiting Green Day's discog in my 30's to realize that the rhetoric was wrong and so was I. This album is excellent, there's not a bad song on it, and it represents the authentic growth (that perhaps took my own growth as a person to fully realize) of a band that is among my favorites, if not my favorite.

The production is too shiny for my taste. The songs too poppy, too earnest. BUT. This has heart and spirit. It has ambition. Will I listen to the whole thing again? No. Do I respect it for its heart, spirit and ambition. Yes.

A great album made weary by overplaying, but nevertheless it desrves it's spot in the 1001

Yesssss. I forgot just how good this album is. A timely listen for me (getting Green Day tickets and Trump’s re-election) and one that I enjoyed all the way through.

How can I rate this down? :D It's impossible for me to be objective about it as it brings me back to my teenage years haha. It opens with American Idiot which is such an energy blast! The whole album has a great punchy, light punky vibe that I feel is a crowd pleaser in general, not just for me.

Quite nostalgic for me. I wasn't super into Green Day when this was current but I like the singles from this album. The whole thing has good energy to it and is varied enough to stay interesting. Not enough of my cup of tea to play repeatedly but this was a very enjoyable listen

This is easily a classic and a must-listen. Green Day fans and punk rock fans, you got your rock opera, this is it. This is so good.

I sometimes forget about or give a hard time to Green Day, but they’re a very solid trio. I think this album is a bit long for what it is, but thems some catchy ass tunes!

Whatever, list generator. No way this was random. Anyway…this album is really good.

I can see why this is a cultural touchstone for so many people, but it was not original in its commentary then, especially now. The songs are annoying at times, and the catchy hooks lose their pazazz after the constant repeating of them. the strongest point of this album is the start where all the big singles are and a couple more near the end.

For nostalgia alone this is a great record. Has aged both amazingly and poorly. To some level, felt like a curtain call for that era of pop punk.

This is a timely album, because Trump was re-elected 2 days ago and I also don’t want to be an American Idiot or a part of the “redneck agenda”. The pace is fun and the long pop-punk songs with movements have a soft spot in my heart. Unltimately, it doesn’t fit my taste these days, but I respect it.

Kind of better than I expected, but also just kind of OK. I did like how Spotify combined the tracks, I guess? It made things flow well.

A great album. I had forgotten what's on it. The starter alone is great. Holiday/Boulevard of brolen Dreams is one of my favorites. And I always enjoy listening to 'Wake me up, when September ends'. Full marks. 5/5

Haha this can’t be a coincidence. Americans are great at self implosion, fuck Trump.

It’s rock, it’s punk, but it’s some of the most eclectic rock music.

I think of they leaned more into the St Jimmy rock opera bit and less of the generic fuck bush stuff it would have been much better

Incredible album and so nostalgic. Jesus of Duburbia is one of my favourite songs of all time along with Give Me Novocaine. One of the best albums, one of my most loved.

I didn't need to listen to rate this as I've played this album a thousand times! I'm a Green Day fan anyway and saw them live at the Emirates Stadium London a few years ago. Billy Joe Armstrong has such a great and distinctive voice and the superb material and brilliant production all together make this one of the greatest albums you will ever hear. In their own words this is a Punk Rock Opera mainly telling the story of Jesus of Suburbia an adolescent anti hero. This album gets a 5 from me

Yesterday was the first time I actually didn't have time to write down my thoughts on an album - so my streak is broken! At least I still listened and rated it. Nothing to do with this particularly album, I just wanted to let that out. 'American Idiot', huh? The album that totally revitalised Green Day and gave their longevity a huge jolt after a decline in general interest and sales - despite solid albums like 'Insomniac', 'Nimrod', and the brilliant compilation 'International Superhits!'. Hell, even 'Warning:' is a bit of an underrated discography entry for the band, featuring some good deep cuts and genuine hits on its own. But there's no denying that most of their, albeit falling, commercial success was riding the success of their breakout LP 'Dookie' (a pop punk masterpiece). 'American Idiot' was a result of the lost tapes for an album that was going to be titled 'Cigarettes and Valentines'. And instead of just re-recording what they lost, they started from scratch. Commercially, it was by far the best thing that could have happened to them. But is this album as balls-to-the-wall amazing as its reputation would lead you to believe? Let's break that down. 'American Idiot' is one of the most ambitious pop punk albums you are ever likely to hear - released at a time where you could say the genre had hit its mainstream peak; as a few years later My Chemical Romance would almost rival it in this department with 'The Black Parade'; and I feel like the genre hasn’t seen that kind of success since. ‘American Idiot’, a concept album driven by the narrative of a character who eventually goes by the name of St. Jimmy. Who despises conformity and is stuck in a suburban life being exposed to media saturation. He leaves his home town and goes on a self destructive journey framed around rebellion and freedom. But through the events he goes through and decisions he makes, he ends up struggling with addiction, heartbreak, and the ultimate hollowness of his newfound lifestyle. Eventually he lets go of all that - and comes to the realisation that he must find purpose, not through lashing out at society, but rather searching within himself for the answers. The narrative arc is but a mere backdrop and a means for Green Day to step out of the off-the-wall observational based pop punk they had become comfortable doing and run right into protest anthems that, in all honesty, completely stand the test of time given the political and societal climate we seem to live in now. Songs like ‘American Idiot’ and ‘Holiday’, that directly call out government control and the negative effects of the almost brainwashing nature of the media. The epic 9+ minute suites ‘Jesus of Suburbia’ and ‘Homecoming’ that walk a fine line between pushing the narrative of the storyline forward while also making plenty of critiques on society at large. The tracklist also has its fair share of introspective songs, like the massive hits ‘Boulevard Of Broken Dreams’ and ‘Wake Me Up When September Ends’. It’s quite a a mixture that’s all layered on top of a Green Day sound that is comfortably familiar with its catchy riffs, fun drumming, and hard bass lines. But they’ve somehow added so much gravitas to it. They sound louder, deeper, and so much more confident than on their previous LP’s. They knew, once a rock opera was the direction, what they needed to do and in that regard they pass with flying colours. The problem is that for all the mighty highs Green Day achieve on ‘American Idiot’, there is a certain level of forgettable tracks in between them. ‘St. Jimmy’, ‘Give Me Novacaine’, ‘Extraordinary Girl’, ‘Letterbomb’, and ‘Whatshername’ - all fine tracks. But sees them fall backwards a little in confidence and they seem like entries to merely fill up the tracklist, moreso than major contributors despite the lyrical content. It’s honestly hard to really give this a proper rating because it truly is a 3.5/5 album, in my opinion. The high points are good enough to gravitate it to a 4, but the lower points stand out enough to keep it grounded at a 3. But I ultimately decided on giving this a 4 because this site doesn’t like .5’s, and also because the impact ‘American Idiot’ had cannot be overstated; not just for Green Day’s career, but also its effect on the pop punk scene in general. The fact is most of it stands the test of time for a reason - and you’re guaranteed to find at least some appreciation in it if you’re in any way a fan of pop punk. If you’re a hardcore fan of Green Day, on the other hand, chances are ‘American Idiot’ is probably on your Mount Rushmore. As a huge fan of the genre myself, I think it’s solid and worth listening to for the high points alone. 4/5

I really think that this is Green Day's best. Songs are WAY too long, like to the point that it's basically the antithesis of punk music, but damn if this whole album isn't good. This was Green Day's peak, and they have only gotten worse.

Oh man. This album brings back memories. Of my gr 9 best friend, obsessed with Billy Joe, hanging out in her room fully decked out in Green Day posters, playing the Sims 2 with this on repeat in the background. For better or worse, this was probably the album of my generation. And you know what, coming back to it 20 years later, it's not bad.

Man, 4th grade James would’ve given this a 5 in a grenade heart beat. This is my first time listening straight through since probably 2006. Holiday is still a banger and I had completely forgotten about whatsername which I liked a lot. As a whole it’s hard to separate this from the now quaint seeming anti-Bush politics that sparked it. As a rock opera it is useless. But, it is a classic with some fun songs and I have a soft spot for it.

Great punk-pop all the way through

Easy 5. Iconic album that I have not heard in a while! It's political without being annoying, it rocks hard and it's an ambitious concept. I can't say I was able to follow the story. Amazingly it was also full of hits I remember being played at middle school dances! Not sure that will ever happen again.

Very well made. The production is top notch and the lead vocalist has very impressive vocal control, but its almost a little too clean. Best Song: Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams Worst Song: Whatsername

A lot of bangers, it was a fun listen and the themes explored are interesting and engaging. The problem is that it gets too one dimentional and therefore bluring the line between many of the songs when the tempo and riffs are so similar. Best song: Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams Worst song: Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb

There wasn’t much like it in 2004. They filled a gap and it landed. I like the earlier albums better but this one is excellent

Cannot be objective, pure nostalgia for me. Pop punk brilliance.

Expectations were so low after the last Green Day album but after the reaffirmation that they're a pop band (this is not punk), it began to make a bit of sense. Nothing great, but way better than Dookie, at least.

Not my favorite green day album, and I really went to listen to it with a lot of prejudice, this was the album they turned emo and I reaaaaally disliked that move, but I was sidetracked today with how good it was, it was quite enjoyable

ya'll already KNOW how this makes me feel

I still love it. Particularly like Boulevard and Wake Me Up, they always give me that sort of introspective, bittersweet feeling where you think about how time is passing so quickly and you dwell on mistakes you have made.

This album is one of my favorites. Its title track got me into rock music. But that’s only part of the reason I’m giving it a high rating. It’s also because I love the story and the style. 5/5

Got this just 2 days after the 20 year anniversary edition was released, which I was planning to listen to anyway. I was 21 when this album came out and I didn’t care for it. I discovered it properly this year, and now I think it’s one of my favorite albums ever. One hour that flows so well is quite rare. And I got to hear it played live in its entirety just a few months ago!

I don't normally consider myself a Green Day fan, but this album was quite good!

Favorite tracks: American Idiot, Holiday, Give me Novacaine. Angsty. Nostalgic. Not entirely my thing anymore.

I loved earlier green day but this seemed too commercialized for my taste when it came out.

Un tour de force: chaque pièce est un hit. Rarement le punk rock et le pop ont fait aussi bon ménage, et la revendication sociale ne boude pas son plaisir musical

este disco quedó de lado porque en esos años American Idiot era suficiente para mí, pero ahora, 20 años después, me doy cuenta de lo que me perdí. Me gusta cómo las canciones se siguen unas con otras y entiendo todo el contexto político también. Igual podría ser un poco más conciso.

Title track fucking rocks. Holiday/Boulevard Of Broken Dreams is imo their best song in their entire discography, let alone on this album Starts off really good but after Extraordinary Girl/Letterbomb it tails off a bit WMUWSE is a bit overrated - it's good but not that good

Dookie will always be my favorite, but they really took their careers to the next level am with this album.

Fucking fuego. As good as I remember

This a strong three. I admire the ambition I just don't think it sticks the landing

I'm quite familiar this record and was a big part of my early 20s. Still holds up. 4 stars.

Quite enjoyed this to be honest 7/10

Shite, pointless

Green Day’s American Idiot is an outstanding album, blending fast-paced punk, anthemic rock, and multi-part tracks that venture into almost progressive territory. Although I’ve typically found Green Day to be “okay” at best, this album stands out as one of my favorites. The instrument mix is solid, with guitars and bass doing their job well, but Trè Cool’s drumming is on a whole other level. While there’s a slight dip in quality between Give Me Novacaine and Letterbomb, the album still holds up as a classic. The hardest part of reviewing this album is resisting the urge to sing along. I wish I could have experienced one of the concerts where they played it in full. Standout track: Homecoming. Score: 5/5.

Flirts with pop punk line Banging out radio hits While still protesting

Much better than expected. Did they influence Arctic Monkeys?

Pop-punk goodness, hard contest if this or Dookie is their best album

Better than I remembered

1) много слёров, хм, 2) он на удивление правильно интонирует, 3) панк и совсем не для меня, 4) но когда медляки начинаются это ещё ничего

I really enjoyed this! Lots of angry energy, I remember the frustration everybody was feeling when it first came out, it easily summed up how the world was feeling at the time. And it has some absolute bangers on it!

Good vibes of rebellion. Enjoyed it a lot. Lots of popular unforgettable songs. Shifted my mood for the day!

It's another great album from Green Day, with their usual catchy songs, power pop guitar, some acoustic numbers and a likeable singer. This time around they've got a political concept and a couple of long song suites. Enjoyable stuff.

Whilst I don’t think this is their best album, it is still a great album. Like a lot of people I’d imagine, wake me up when September ends is one of my favourite Green Day songs.

Same issues I have with all their albums, one (maybe 2) engaging or interesting tracks, then a lot of filler. This is a band who dont know what they are, feels like a pop band trying to be a punk band, the tracks are too polished and satire is not the same as subversion. Fails more than it hits. Grumble grumble

Green Day never quite seemed to work for me, this was just another in a long list of US pop-punk bands with a well intentioned but somewhat simplistic message delivered in an overly polished and formulaic way. Fun enough in its.way, but too poppy and not quite punk enough for.me.

I don't like this much, but I could at least tap my foot and hum along to it pleasantly. I don't want to like it, but it's had so much airplay that I know it. I want to give it one star because it's got the feel of something cynically manufactured for the teen buck, but somewhere there's someone like me for whom this is their Nevermind, London Calling or Appetite For Destruction.

I have a soft spot for a concept albums... and this one is a great pop punk rock album, that also kicks dirt at the GW Bush era, win-win! 🤘

Went into this thinking a definite 3* but as the album went on realised that as a piece of work it is brave, cohesive, well written and played by a band bit willing to rest on previous Dookie laurels. Kicks off strongly and is a journey from start to finish. Like the banding of tracks together. When September Ends is beautiful. A critique of the mainstream bringing Green Day even more into the mainstream

Amazing album. My love of it may be influenced by Beat Saber

Hadn't listened to this for years and had forgotten what a good album it was.

Classic, goated. Monthly rotation?

2004. I was seven. Too young to "think" about this album, but I do remember, somewhere around that age, hearing Boulevard of Broken Dreams and doing this slow, cool walk in time with the opening fade-in. I remember other kids head-banging to American Idiot, and I think, I found it too aggressive. I was seven. To me, what stands out is not the sound, but the message. Disillusionment. Stuck in suburbia (a la Arcade Fire), hopelessness, angst. It's almost like this cynicism has always existed, but just manifested differently over the years. You had "slackers" in the early 90s, then was it power-pop-punk fusion for the next 20, and then I think hip-hop took became the language of the young and jaded. So, at the time, I can understand how this was anthemic. Now, falling on my ears, which have heard so many more sounds, lots of digital sounds, it's not so great. Upon this listen I was pleasantly surprised by extraordinary girl/letterbomb, which I wouldn't have been able to name hitherto, and the hits still hit: boulevard, holiday, idiot, wake me up. Armstrong's voice is 100% generation-defining and full of conviction. Fav track: Boulevard of Broken Dreams

After Dookie, which was quite a success, the next view albums weren't similar hits, but American Idiot remedied that. They kept their roots but broadened their portfolio to include other styles and genres. This is some concept album telling a certain story, A thing that wouldn't be possible if they kept just to their punk rock music. The process of creating this album was much more complex, and it was worth it.

Not taking anything away from the cultural impact of this record (I feel a reluctant nostalgia towards it as a real zeitgeist moment in mid-2000s music), but it just does nothing for me anymore. It's a completely distended, superficial, processed punk (debatable use of the term) album. Its commentary is as laughably thin as a primary school reflective essay, and the rock opera premise irks me immensely. There are still one or two half-decent tracks here, but I couldn't wait for it to be over. Billie Joe Armstrong might not have wanted to be an American idiot, but his decision to pen some of this album communicates a level of idiocy that parallels anything said by Bush (albeit with considerably fewer civilian casualties).

This album has aged so incredibly well. Prescient as hell. As a friend put it: where is all the good political rock these days?

Funny to think that this album has become almost classical in many younger people's minds these days. I listened to it a lot back then, and I still enjoy it today.

It is not often an album can ride the line between fun/catchy and politically coherent this well. Most would eschew one element or the other, but I think this is a pretty good mix without needing to be so focused on the politics that they can’t also flex out for things like Wake Me Up When September Ends which is not quite so relevant to the rest of the album but fits the tone and stands alone as a great track.

I like Holiday, but don't care about the rest

Not as good as it used to sound

hopefully I'll eventually get the hang of sending my reviews to y'all..every day I make a new mistake LOL.. I'd voted 1 for Moby Grape and 4 for Brubeck. Here's my review of Green Day - I was never a fan, but I liked a couple of songs and I appreciated them. Now I can honestly say that I don't like them enough to listen to a whole album. Skillful musicianship, a couple of catchy tracks, but I was done when it all started sounding the same..

Hmmm. He taps into something genuine and vulnerable within the ballads. Overall, it’s in no man’s land…not truly punk, rock, … Thus, the hmmm.

Green day emerged just past the party it where I could really engage with them. I appreciate what they do - they at times display Kinks level simplicity in all the best ways. This album obviously stretches far beyond that in scope and scale but in reality - the 9 minute song suites are just a bunch of two minute songs together. But ultimately - for the most part - it works. A little pedestrian but you can't begrudge the pop chops. They know a good vocal/guitar hook. And I like a lot of 60 minute play albums I never like this got dirgy. The W era seems pretty quaint by 2024 standards.

Low quality "punk" for middle schoolers.

This was a rock album that sold like a pop album. I listened to the CD on repeat back in the day, but I've grown up and it hasn't

Familiarity breeds acceptance. The kids wore me out on this one back in the day. This album was/is big time.

A very, very popular album from my youth. Still holds up really well.

As expected with punk rock. Noisy screaming music. Not my thing.

I am very familiar with this album. My wife, and now my daughter, is slightly obsessed with it. I've always quite liked Dookie. It's my favourite style of music, but I enjoy it. American Idiot never really did anything for me at the time. Especially When September Ends which I've always found annoying. But I've warmed to it. It's 20 years old and I think it stands up pretty well. It moves bewteen what it does very nicely as an album. Overall it makes my wife and daughter very happy. So that's enough for me.

fan of green day, not boulevard of broken dreams. i have trauma w that song also why is my guy moaning in my ear during it pls stop and just play the music bro.

Geest álbum. It reminds me of those 70’s albums like Tommy. A sweet opera-rock concept album.

I don’t really love Green Day a ton, but this album definitely holds up

Nostalgic. Brilliant album, reminds me of year 8

Banger 10/10

Decent band, so unlikable as people

It’s ska

Not a big Green Day guy but this ones pretty alright

Political Punk!?!

It’s more accessible than most punk rock, but still carries that “fuck the establishment” message. Holliday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams alone make the album worth a listen. Wake me up when September ends is a childhood favorite. The remainder of the album represents more than just filler, it is all a very well constructed piece of a whole. A “punk rock opera” as it has been described. It gets a little stale and repetitive for me by the end, but overall a very, very solid album. 8.2/10

DNF. Doesn't belong on this list. I like pop punk as much as the next guy but this is easy boring music.

Interesting as a snap shot of early 2000s history. Give me Dookie any day though. The guys voice annoys me and I found the sound of the album as a whole gave me a headache. The simple power cords over and over became so boring.

Ya estoy despierto

Guess I'll have to wake them up tomorrow.

I don't know if I've ever listened to this album in its entirety. This should be good. Opening track has over a billion listens!

Loved Dookie at the time but I've never actually sat all the way through American Idiot before. It's alright.

I found this to be pretty much just ok across the board. It’s perfectly acceptable, entertaining arena rock.

Yeah, a solid album. Everything you want from a green day album.

Nine minute suites; is this punk or prog rock? Anyway, i like this a bit more than Dookie, but it's still not really for me.

#357. Jesus fuck, this is awful. This is just cheesy middle school teenage angst, as written by a weird dude in his mid 30s. Billie Joe Armstrong truly is cringe personified. Green Day should have just stopped after Dookie, that shit was a masterpiece. Or maybe after Nimrod at the absolute latest. The Warning/American Idiot/21st Century Breakdown era of Green Day was truly some of the worst music being played on the radio in the 00's [and that's saying a lot considering the Nickleback/Breaking Benjamin/Staind/Puddle of Mud butt-rock genre was topping the rock charts then]. Luckily the DJs picked up on that fact 10 years too late, and stopped really playing any of the music they made after that, but we were ear raped on a regular basis with those three shit heaps. There is really no redeeming quality to any of this album. I was fully ready to give this album 2 stars, but the more I type, the more I realize it doesn't deserve that much. Fuck em. 1/5: trash Song added to playlist: Holiday/ Boulevard of Broken Dreams I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link

This album didn’t age well. While the opening and title track is strong, it quickly falls off from there. It’s an important album for sure, but the greatness of it didn’t last.

PEAKKKKKKK 4.5/5

One of my favourite albums in high school and still continues to be. Not a bad song on the entire album. Seeing it played in its entirely live was perfection and one of the best concerts I’ve ever been to. My first rock concert at 14 was in support of this in 04’, this album essentially got me into concerts. What an easy 5 star.

Just not a fan I guess.

almost painfully nostalgic for me, listened to this a lot at a very formative period of my life (discovered wanking)

Very good album. 10/10

This is a classic. Too many banging tunes. Stadium anthems mixed with songs that Green Day is not just straight up punk-rock. I could scream the lyrics to the title track while playing it on the guitar until I die. Truly flawless album. Extraordinary.

A lot of cool Punk Rock songs

Better than I remembered, or maybe I'm less snobby than I used to be. Probably a bit of both

This album slaps. Time has not left this behind

Too many timeless bangers and too much nostalgia to be anything but a 5

Good, solid songs from that punk base without too much of a polished, sell-out vibe.

A little overplayed but it was a real statement when it was released.

Has some bangers, but I’m just not a greenday girl

I seriously don't know if it's a 3 or a 4 for me. This is obviously an iconic album, but it doesn't really grab me. I've never liked their pretend punk attitude and sound, but this album has some real classics that everyone should know for a reason.

5/5 zeer enjoyable

it’s green day duhhh my teenage childhood!

I kind of get it, didn't do much for me.I did like american idiot when it came out but it's wild it inspired so many people.

They make me cringe so much Saying that, some rammers I really enjoyed: American idiot Jesus of suburbia Holiday Wake me up when September ends Will not be listening again but objectively good album !

Just two days shy of its 20th anniversary, this album’s release is fondly remembered by so many of us - myself included (even if I was getting sick of seeing the music video for American Idiot playing virtually on repeat on Kerrang! This album has so many hits on it, such a milestone album. I never fully committed to this one as a kid, but its singles are still great. Standout tracks: - Jesus of Suburbia 4/5 - Holiday 4/5 - Boulevard of Broken Dreams 5/5

Definitely biased with growing up with this album but it still rocks. Jesus of suburbia’s a top 10 song for me, the rest of the album is full of classics

By the time this album came out I had already soured on Green Day and the pop-punk/Gilbert and Sullivan hybrid was a big turn off for me. It’s still not my thing, but there is some strong songwriting on this.

I had this sitting in the queue for a week because I dreaded listening. I absolutely loved Dookie and Nimrod, and I was so disappointed with American Idiot that it still strings 20 years later. I'm not sure I was wrong to be disappointed, but I have to admit it's a good album. This is the best they've ever sounded, and the easiest to listen to, but that's not really what I want from Green Day. It's a well played, well produced album, but it's just less interesting than their earlier work.

A perfect pop punk rock opera inspired by the who and the jam that's still relevant in the trump era.

This album reminds me of winter in Cannes when it came out it. Coincidentally I was in Cannes when it came up in the list. Some Jungian synchronicity shit going on there.... The music is alright like. The way the songs seamlessly meld into one another is a bit weird.... At the time it was a bit weird hearing Americans show any anti American sentiment, so that was cool.

💖 jesus of suburbia 🗣️ 8️⃣

Good album :) very very cool

Some great songs on this, but always found "When September Ends" to be a bit of a drag.

I'd have given em a 5 It's a modern classic But I've still never forgiven them for cancelling the glasgow date on the dookie tour and not coming back for fucking ages The waiting/st jimmy is still fucking excellent though

The high water mark for Green Day and another album I’ve listened to constantly since its release.

I can't stand Green Day. Even when listening to it objectively for good points. I just cannot do it.

This is one of my favorite albums of all time and was probably the most excited I’ve been for an album listen thus far in our project. In my third year of college, something happened to my computer and my iTunes library got wiped. I borrowed this CD and uploaded it to my iTunes and for longer than I’d like to admit, it was the only music on my computer. I’d love to see the iTunes stats for how many times I listened to it… I added all but the last track to my 1001 albums faves playlist (even more than Taylor Swift - I left two tracks from 1989 off!). Easy 5.

This was wonderful. It seems like the type of album where if it had come out when I was in high school I would have known every lick and every word. They’re kinda like the Foo Fighters, both hard rock bands with great melodic songs. Hard to believe this is 20 years old. Was familiar with it from back then, but it was great to listen to again, and I’m excited for the 20th anniversary deluxe edition next month. Elizabeth liked it as well.

For once the shoe is on the other foot here, because I know this is an album Maggie knows well, and I’m not entirely sure I’ve ever listened to the whole thing. I owned Dookie, as was required of all junior high boys in the mid 90s, and I like the singles off Warning (2000) more than most people do, but I was out on GD after maybe 2002. So, after listening, I knew the singles. It was basically impossible to miss them as a 20-year-old in 2004. Didn’t know the rest. And I know this is supposed to be a political album, but I didn’t pay enough attention to lyrics to catch a ton of that, after the title track. Definitely liked the album, though.

cringey but good hits, only here bc libtard politicz

Modern classic.

i dont like pop punk, sorry

So much fun, so underrated, drums for days, Armstrong doesn’t have the my favourite voice going but it’s solid

wanted to give this five stars but it falls just short with a few songs I don't care much for. But when it hits, it hits hard. Are We the Waiting is my favourite. Grew up with this, never really knew what it represented. Nor that Green Day had another album ready to go and the master tapes were stolen, then they went back to the drawing board. Also annoying that on Spotify they merge most of the songs together (apparently because the original digital release was on iTunes and they wanted to retain gapless playback between those songs). Anyway, a high four stars from me!

You wouldn’t expect it to be as phenomenal as it is. There isn’t really a bad song on it or anything I’d skip over. The hits are good and so are the deep cuts, especially Give Me Novacaine. I think anyone who thinks Green Day are hacks should at least give this a try.

One of the songs was a bit long but these were highly enjoyable. A few iconic ones but the others are easily forgettable. I like the callbacks of some of the songs & also not a fan of “American idiot” the single

There comes a time in every band’s career when someone mentions the C word - the concept album. For a punk band known for three minute pop bangers this is a risky move. However the opening salvo of American Idiot still hits home, relevant today just by changing one word. The album looks American society at the turn of the millennium but not much has changed. Jesus of Suburbia sends shivers down my spine with the final ‘Are you leaving home?’. A punk classic.

I guess it's supposed to be something like their most mature album to date when it was released? All I can hear is that irritating crisp/bright guitar sound so typical of pop punk of that era and these dull melodies. Oh and now they're grown up so they even use accoustic guitars and have freakin' ballads. And of course pseudo-political lyrics. I hated it when it came out, I still hate it.

Punkowa petarda.

Rock. Pop punk, but lots of classics on this album. A little repetitive in parts and some songs were a bit too long for their own good, but a good one overall.

Would be better without the expletives

Classic. Can't help but think of Michael and David when I listen to green day ha

12 year old me would’ve gone wild at the opening of this album.

I liked it

Other than the foul language, I pretty much enjoyed this album. Made me nostalgic for the early 2000’s, and I didn’t even listen to this album then. The lead singer’s voice just took me back.

Die overgang van holiday naar boulevard of broken dreams was ziek episch Uhh ja man

Boulevard of Broken Dreams brought this from a 1 to a 2 for me, but I'm not a green day fan.

very good, reminds me of teenage years

Always been a fan of Green Day and heard many of these songs, but think that was my first full listen thru the album

I’m willing to bet this album was deeply felt by people born around 1990. The lyrics would resonate hard with antsy teens. I was already adulting when this came out, so it doesn't have a nostalgic emotional attachment with me. The length of this album with the sameness of the music started bothering me about 2/3 of the way in. I bet that the Broadway musical based on this was enjoyable. The lyrics tap into some universal teen emotions. But this music needs some visual performance accompaniment to break up the monotony. It’s just not that enjoyable as an adult to sit and listen to.

Ok, I know several hits of this album and I like them, but listening to the whole album is to much, mainly because many of the other songs sound a bit the same to me. I listened the punk rock of the 70's, so most of the songs on this album don't sound 'new' to me.

When i was 16 this was the bible

As a life long Green Day hater I’d love to give this a 1/5 but some of these surprised me. Not enough to go back but more respect for them now.