Reviews (page 11 of 16)
Fuck this album
Wow! Glad I came back to this one. I distinctly remember being on itunes for this tidal wave of hits. And even today, Im still surprised at the number of true bangers on here - Holiday being my favorite. I appreciated a few others this time too. Give Me Novacane and Shes A Rebel were stand outs for me
Wake me up when September ends is the best song on this album. That says a lot more about the quality of this album than anything else. I can’t fathom how this album is on this list. No one wants to listen to watered down pop punk from a band that once made actual punk. I was 15 when this album came out and I remember it being lame then, and this is one of the few times I agree with my 15 year old self on music
Love pop punk, but was never a massive Green Day fan and kind of thought their newer stuff was a little lame. After listening to this one, I think my only major gripe is how overplayed so much of this album was growing up, and how everything on this album sounds like it’s trying to be an anthem. But the songs are great and I love the double song, Rock opera thing. Had never heard Are We The Waiting / St Jimmy - liked that one in addition to some of the singles.
Great album for the genre
Most of these songs have been played into oblivion. Jesus of suburbia gives this the additional star
Not really my thing , but the title track and ‘when september ends’ are decent pop punk songs . rest of it is formulaic and dated.
Anytime this record comes up in conversation (with friends, strangers, my husband), I always say, "it was a landmark record for my sixth-grade class." It's true. Released by Green Day in 2004, 'American Idiot' was possibly the first time my peers and I were swept up in an album cycle that attempted to reflect The Times We Are Living In. Radio singles, interviews, a tour, and an overall buzz in the air, the look of the album serving as a signal of identity. As Robert Christgau says, the visual language on this album is probably the most essential factor in understanding it, especially during its release within a context of a burgeoning pop-punk emo scene that rendered style and artifice over any meaningful substance (be honest). A stark red, white, and black album cover (ostensibly an homage to Saul Bass' title sequence for 'The Man With The Golden Arm') and smoky music videos that played around with colour saturation settings. One such music video was basically a short film with a (pointless) prelude featuring scripted dialogue between Hollywood actors. The album was huge. Starting with the title track, it was anthemic, and operatic, with huge aspirations even if the actual message itself was vague and riddled with a few clichés. Still, Green Day was able to harness the genuine rage and despair of the time and make a song that was genuinely upbeat and fun while retaining subversion. As Christgau pointed out, it "makes being called 'f-----' something to aspire to, which in this terrible time it is." I credited Green Day with producing something with huge aspirations, but to me, most of those aspirations do fall flat. "Jesus of Suburbia" is a good example of this. Did you know that he is our main character in the Odyssey that is 'American Idiot?' Do you even care? Well let me tell you: I don't. And so, while I appreciate a punk band experimenting with a multi-movement song in 2004, it ultimately does not stick. "Holiday," on the other hand, is a fine song and certainly my favourite off the record. The opening guitar has such a sweet, crisp tone that reminds you of these guys SoCal punk bona fides. A great lyrical showcase from Billie Joe Armstrong, who I believe is especially powerful when writing about dogs (please see my review of 'Dookie'): "hear the dogs howl out of key/to a hymn called faith and misery" which is then followed by a well-timed and satisfying "hey!" The call-and-response on this song is a wonderful touch. "Can I get another amen? Amen!" Was there even a first one? No, not in the song at least, but you know everything Billie Joe is saying is true. Is so. Un fait accompli. What is meant by the use of the word 'holiday' here? The idea of being on holiday, or out to lunch, or just spiritually not there, particularly resonates in the Bush-era as our politics increasingly became devoid of facts and data. I wonder if the boys in Green Day stopped to consider whether "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" would be a mainstay in the waiting offices of doctors across the globe. The song has powerful soft-loud dynamics that beautifully channel angst and loneliness, even if the lyrics are a bit sophomoric and goofy. The final 40 seconds or so when guitars start to sound like gusts of wind are exceptional. I can't say that my attention remains as close for the rest of the record as it does here. The transition into "She's A Rebel" is a little bit awkward, but I appreciate Billie Joe's Westerbergian approach of creating complicated female characters that serve as a stand-in for the male author. You know, the production of "Wake Me Up When September Ends" is a bit too saccharine for my tastes, but I will concede that the song captures a beautiful idea about time - needing it to slow down, to speed up, mostly to avoid any suffering. But yeah, I don't know about that 12-minute music video, guys. Many flaws on this record for sure, and once I grew tired of Green Day, I then moved on to some of their influences: The Clash, the Sex Pistols, and the Ramones. So I can't hate it for that reason. B+
trop bien
OK album. The album isn't really cohesive, but it has some really good songs. This brings me back to Junior High. ***
Brilliantly made album
I have vague memories of seeing promotions for this album when it was coming out. ( I was really young at the time) I’m definitely aware of the hits this album after hearing them on the radio for years, specifically Wake Me Up When September Ends and Boulevard of Broken Dreams. Gotta say though after hearing the whole album for once, I really dig this one. Punk rock isn’t really my favorite rock genre (though at this point calling Green Day punk rock feels weird. Honestly I feel more inclined to think of Bad Religion or the Dead Kennedys and even that feels surface level) but this album has a great balance between punk and modern rock. I have a soft spot for the hits, but I also really liked some of the lesser know tracks like Give Me Novacaine and Letterbomb. The 9-minute songs were pretty good, not my favorites though. But overall, this was really good. Favorite Song: Wake Me Up When September Ends Other hits: American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novacaine, She’s A Rebel, Letterbomb
Perfect hip hop magic. 5
One of my favorite albums of all time. Basically perfect from start to end.
Been listening for decades. 5/5
I’m not a huge Green Day fan, but I am a sucker for over-the-top pop-punk rock-operas, so this was preettty delightful.
Classic.
An hour of high octane joy
The very first CD I ever purchased was Green Day Dookie, and I was a huge fan on them at the time. However, by 2004 I was listening to so many different and new things I never found the time to put this album on. It is better than I expected, but it is no Dookie.
It's a decent album but this type of pop-punk sound always feels a bit mundane and unrewarding for me.
Ehhh, this was a lot of Green Day for me. The singles from this album are some of my least favorite Green Day singles, and the rest of the album didn't do much to redeem it.
The singles are unfairly maligned, but the whole thing was always more “musical” and less “concept album” and that is grating to me
I love this of course! Most songs on this album sound kind of the same, but I love the sound. I could listen to 2000s punk/pop punk all day.
pros: it bops cons: activated an unskippable cutscene about the bush presidency 3.5
a Hastings employee sold this to me underage and it made me feel extremely cool
I'm a bit torn on this one. On the one hand, I don't like it and I think it's trash, kids playing at punk rock. But then it's Green Day, and they've got their stripes, so I dunno. Musically, it's a bit bland and overplayed, but also fun and listenable. Man I dunno. I'm gonna give it a four.
as a former green day girly who thought the worst in music were people like taylor swift who grew up to be a taylor swift fan this gave me flashbacks to my teenage years and teenage angst. I always thought this one was peak music and I like it very much but I will give this one a bad grade because I cannot bear the embarrasment of being an akward teen and this brought me right back.
Punk Rock
I find a lot of the sentiment of disillusionment from the early 00s is still very much relevant today. Even though Green Day isn't doing as strongly now, American Idiot still holds up enormously well 20 years later.
78% Best: American Idiot, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me up When September Ends Must-Hear? No
Top-tier punk rock, this is some really good stuff. Jesus of Suburbia is a right jam, my pick of the bunch. The rest of the singles from the album are epic, even the non-singles go above and beyond. Green Day at their peak.
A great modern take on punk. It's almost too clean, too polished, to fit the image of punk I'm familiar with – but I think this works to its advantage (mostly). It's hard to find any actual flaws with the sound. The guitar melodies are very loud; I wish I'd have heard Green Day on their American Idiot tour back in the day, because I would've gone crazy over the lead guitar/bass synchrony and how the riffs dig straight into your chest. I do think those two instruments could be played a little more liberally, just to give then a bit more of a human element. Armstrong's vocal is great, though. It complements the instruments perfectly, and retains that great punky youthfulness. The record's concept is a little loose and messy, perhaps counterbalancing the incredibly tight rock sound. I keep hearing mentions of this Jesus of Suburbia guy, but it's hard to really connect the lyrics together, especially when bands of the punk genre don't usually commit to big operatic concept albums. But the lyrics are meaningful, probably. (I was able to work out the title track's meaning!) 4/5 Key tracks: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me up When September Ends
One of my absolut favorit albums ! Hart to pin out favorit numbers - but Boulevard of broken dreams, When september ends and Holiday always gets to me :)
Album shows up, kicks in the door and throws 'American Idiot' in your face and then we are off. American Idiot is my favorite Green Day album. I also really like Dookie, but for me American Idiot just hit different. I understand that those two are switched for a lot of people, but I find that Dookie deal a lot more with the personal, where American Idiot really hits it home with the heavy overtones of critique of the system, the government and society as a whole and really voices the feelings of a generation of disillusionment in the wake of 9/11. The punk-rock/punk-pop sound that Green Day had previously developed on celebrated albums like Dookie just hits extra on the spot when used to approach this subject from this angle. And while the album did serve as a voice of a generation it is still as relevant and applicable today as it was when it was released - just for slightly different reasons Standouts American Idiot Holiday Boulevard of Broken Dreams 5/5
Great album. The hits are unbelievably high and the album tracks are all solid and interesting
Not listened to it in years but still a very enjoyable album. Probably not as many great tracks as I remember but 4 stars for nostalgic purposes!
One of the best albums of the 21st century
Disappointed this wasn’t my 100th milestone album but nevertheless, always happy to get an easy, instant 5-star one on the list. Top notch, even with the overplayed title track
I prefer Green Day's earlier, punky stuff, but no denying there are some very catchy songs here and it was certainly huge at the time. Also one of my favourite music genres: "mocking-right-wingers-without-them-realising"
This album will always be a 5/5 for me :)
2.5☆/5 08.03.2024
I think this album was absolutely observant as to the trajectory things have since headed in the last 20 years. I also think it has a strong collection of tracks. However, it also seems a bit lacking in the raw emotion contained in a lot of more political/angry music which seems a bit at odds with the subject, and it did feel samey when I wasn't paying attention - Billie Joe doesn't deviate a lot in the way he sings. I liked the use of double songs. Green Day just don't hit quite right for me so I had to give this a high 3. Fave Track: Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams Rating: 3
Solid album with a very distinctive and enduring sound. Wasn't my favorite growing up but respect the staying power.
Har ingen koll på Green Day fast jag typ tror det. Hur som, första låten är riktigt bra. Punk och pop. Trummor och gitarr i Jesus of Suburbia älskar jag och att den helt plötsligt blir en annan låt. Vad hände? Skit samma det är bra. Holiday en 5a. Hela skivan är riktigt bra. Drar till med en 5a.
Det är lättlyssnat. Men inte på ett dåligt sätt! Långa låtar. Gillar andra halvan av jesus of sub. mycket mer än början (känns som en annan låt). Ok, har googlat, det är flera låtar egentligen. Jesus of sub består av 5 delar. Samma med flera andra låtar. Hur som helst. Bra rakt igenom. Tycker inte det sticker iväg till en femma dock, det finns inte tillräckligt med låtar som når den nivån. Många bra låtar dock!
Visst, det är rätt enkelt, förutsägbart och publikfriande, men ändå rakt igenom jävligt bra. Några riktiga hits och i övrigt hög nivå från start till mål. 57 minuter totalt och ett par onödigt långa låtar blir förvisso lite utmattande till slut, men tycker ändå fyran är solid.
Impressive. Good songwriting, good sound.
A return to form for Green Day
Trying not to be bias, but this is a fucking incredible album, just so so good. All the double songs. UGH
i never really got into green day, i always thought the sound was corny, but this album was nice to listen to, i really enjoyed the tracks, especially the more popular ones like american idiot, boulevard of broken dreams and when september ends, lot of songs were pretty long on it but as the album went, it was really good overall
I don’t know why I’ve largely ignored Green Day. Maybe it’s because they got so much airplay that I didn’t feel the need to listen to the whole album. My loss.
St. Jimmy is the best pop punk song since The Buzzcocks "Ever Fallen In Love." Fight me. Big anthemic songs. Flawless execution, hard guitars, Green Day made a big rock album in an era when that just wasn't happening. A great sounding recording. A favorite and still meaningful. Somewhat sad and cynical - is all hope gone in modern America? How do we feel about it?
love it. used to listen to it when it came out so have fond memories and enjoy relistening to it.
Classic, has all the bangers
Album is better than I remember
So many good ones. Double song is a cool 4.5.
3.25
Top notch …. Big fan all around
So I always liked Green Day – not loved, as I’m not really a punk guy, but have appreciated their work over the years… Was looking forward to listening to “American Idiot” from start-to-finish, and it did NOT disappoint… For me, there were 3 really outstanding tracks – with most of the rest being a nice collection of solid songs… My favs in order were – #1 – “Holiday” – 5-stars of out 7… #2 – “Boulevard Of Broken Dreams” – 4-stars out of 7… #3 – “Wake Me Up When September Ends” – 4-stars out of 7… I know a lot has been made of the lyrics, though nothing really stood out as exceptional – though again, really pretty solid… Not sure as to the accuracy of their protests in hindsight, but the fact that they were thinking about content like this, was at least interesting… The musicianship is top notch, and always liked Billie Joe’s vocals, so all-in-all, a pretty well put together album… I know there is massive love for the album from the younger generation – which I get, and would probably give it a 3.50 if I could – but when I look at the albums I’ve rated a 4, I just can’t get there… A strong 3 for me…
Elég volt egy életre a green dayből. 1.5/5
I want to hate this with all my heart but it’s actually good :(
An album that helped define my childhood.
Preferred their older stuff
Stupid emo sounds with good production.
Pretty much the only thing I like by Green Day is the song Basketcase and on first full listen, this did nothing to change that.
Kind of embarrassing, in hindsight.
Their best record, and one that defined the new generation of pop-punk. Anyway, the length of some songs on it is unjustified, but in rest this is a good protest album.
Heerlijk album van een band waarvan ik altijd zeg dat ik er weinig mee heb. Maar aangezien ik ze voor de 2e keer een 5 geef moet ik dat misschien even herzien. Dit soort pop-punk is gewoon een soort crack waar ik geen nee tegen kan zeggen.
Such a lovely nostalgic experience to my days of listening to it almost daily.
honestly i probably haven't listened to this one since it came out. it was huge then, at least at school and so i heard most of it from my friends. it's a pretty solid album! a lot of fun, some dated lyrics, not just a straight punk album which i wasn't totally expecting. it's still green day and it still sounds like green day, but it sounds like an evolution of where they were in the 90s - or perhaps a de-evolution (it does feel a bit more 'classic rock' at points than punk). either way, it's a fun enough time and i enjoyed it.
Solid
Enjoyed. Surprised to find I knew virtually every song on it.
I love this album. very nostalgic. I remember listening to jesus of suburbia on repeated and going nuts when they drop into the quiet acoustic part of the song
This is one of the defining albums of a generation.
It's hard to take Greenday seriously, even though I really have fun with them and a protest album is a serious album. There were much stronger protest albums around this time (including punk ones, check Rock Against Bush vol 1 & 2) but none got as much mainstream attention. So while this is good it's definitely not my fav album of it's genre/time or nor my favorite Greenday album. It feels like an odd choice for inclusion personally.
Not my favorite Green Day Album.
A solid album
I forgot how good Jesus of Suburbia is
Lesson learnt, don't judge a band based on its hits alone.
I quite liked it! I think this could benefit from closer listening. Some really brilliant singles here. Songs drag a bit sometimes but I generally found it interesting and enjoyable. 4/4.5
an ugly, obsolete cultural artifact...weirdly enough made me appreciate the importance of more poignant, specific lyrics (especially to evoke that melancholic vibe i crave) because this has virtually nothing genuine to say...endless filler over a repetitive, tinny mush of compressed power chords 2/10
this album has a lot of bangers doesn't it? billie joe armstrong looks like if you caught a human in the middle of their transformation into robert smith.
Horrible. Sanitized pop punk with a forced message trying to be edgy.
The timing of this appearing on my list is incredible. A day after the assassination attempt on Trump it's here. Not a more appropriate song than the title track for the way things are, and this was a 20 year old song. It has happened with Rage and now again here. A song comes and clearly points out a wrong in the world and it gains relevancy even more later on. Can we not fix this stuff?! We need honesty and settled facts in our information streams. Not agendas and propaganda. Rant over. The rest of the album is also really good. A mix of story telling and emotions that show Green Day's roots and evolution. Several mainstay radio tracks that have stood the rest of time, and that makes me feel ancient.... In some ways it really helped deal with the absurdity of this weekend. It sucks a song like this can be relevant still 20 years later, but that also may give some hope that if it was bad then, we can hopefully make it another 20? Copium? Anyways, wake me up when November ends... Favorite track "American Idiot" just because of the timing. 5/5
Favs: "Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams", "Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb", "Wake Me up When September Ends", "Homecoming", "Whatsername" + Nostalgia Bonus
Not necessarily my favorite album, but I enjoyed listening.
The high points are truly high, and are certainly a mainstay in the cultural zeitgeist, but the rest of the album drags and is forgettable.
Classic and solid start to finish.
It’s non offensive
I can say without doubt or hesitation that this is one of the greatest rock albums of the 21st century. Their best album.
This was the first album I ever bought, and I was obsessed with it as an 11 year old. I could still sing every word of it. If I heard it for the first time today I probably wouldn't score it like this but nostalgia is a hell of a drug.
Not my cup of tea but some good tracks
I wonder how many albums on this list are less the artist's best work VS their most commercially successful work. I appreciate that this album has some depth but for my money they peaked at Dookie. Squarely in the #earlypeak category for me
Don’t know why I put off listening to this for 20 years, it’s actually pretty good
I really hate this album. It feels like they set out to make something "profound" and emotional, but it just comes off like a theatre kid's version of a pop punk record.
Love the wall of guitars.
Surprisingly rich for these guys.
the best part about this album was when NOFX came on after it'd finished. there was a time when i really liked these guys, but between their change in overall tone and it appearing more and more that billie joe is a dink, it's really hard for me to enjoy them like i used to. i don't want to be that guy, but i really did enjoy their older stuff more, even if they essentially wrote the same song over & over. see also: https://open.spotify.com/album/5xlutZ0sYfJQjVIBOkkeW8
one of green days greatest albums
It certainly has a pop charm, dated somewhat now I feel. If you like Green Day then this is one of the better ones otherwise 3*
American Idiot aged better than expected. I thought it would be hopelessly naive, but actually it was unfortunately prescient. The rest of the album I can take or leave, so I will leave it.
Very anthemic, a classic
I did not get into this album when it originally came out. I was past my love for Green Day that had bloomed in the 90's. I think it was because of the uninspired albums since Dookie. So I got into this album more towards 2010 and it's really a great one. You can tell there was a lot of thought and motivation put into these songs with more regard for song structure and breaking out of the Green Day framework they had made for themselves over the previous decade. It is interesting Green Day chose to put songs together (like Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams) that would be considered individual singles. I think it's important to include this album on a listing of albums during the 2000's. Green Day hasn't hit these heights again, though I think they may have tried with the trilogy of albums they put out in the early 2010's.
Probably one of the best albums of the 2000s. I've heard a lot during my life about how a true Punk should behave. I heard a lot about how a real Punk should act, what kind of sound he should play, how to play and where to play. But for me, the true identity of Punk is just one: Not to fear! And Green Day is a band that never feared the kind of evil that said Punk shouldn't be pop or conceptual. Because Punk was never afraid of being pop. Punk was never afraid of anything!
This album is massively overrated, but it's still good.
Holy shit I fucking love this album. It’s a powerhouse from start to finish. Incredibly insightful, unique, and original writing. Not a single skip or weak track on the whole record. Green Days best work. 5/5
its a good record with a good sound, suprising. i didnt care for the lyrics cuz i was like 4 when this came out, and the soundscape wasnt that interesting for another listen
This is one of those albums that's wormed its way so deeply into my heart and soul that I can't even think of anything to say about it. I mean, is it mixed like a brick? Sure, but I hardly even notice. I just throw on "Jesus Of Suburbia" and I'm, like... Still in awe of it. Top three Green Day album, for damn sure. Goodness me.
One of the best damn albums of the 2000s, with a message that still resonates with our modern climate. Happy 4th of July, everyone.
It’s like a 10, probably. I’ve never heard this album in full until today. I’m an idiot. Perhaps the titular American idiot. I never knew there was a big running story and plotline and thread here; I’ve only ever heard the big tracks – American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, and Wake Me Up When September Ends. I always knew there was a Broadway musical, but I never made the connection somehow. This was fucking awesome. There’s not a single missed beat here – from those opening guitar riffs on American Idiot, through the entire running plot of “home sucks, I’m leaving, let’s party, I’m in love, oh shit, never mind, this sucks, I’m going back home” that’s portrayed brilliantly throughout the lyrics and instrumentation of every single track until the sort of epilogue that is “Whatsername,” and the peace that Jesus has finally come to after all his St. Jimmy escapades. It’s a very malleable plot, but what really drives it are these damn songs; every single one of them is fantastic, from the compositions, the guitar riffs, the extremely high energy, and especially in the lyrics. I now understand why all of these are paired so specifically on streaming. You cannot hear one of them without the other, and you really can’t listen to some of these songs by themselves, unless you remember the sort of context of the album. It really is a damn play. One small thing about the plot itself… I dunno, it’s a little weird in the end, given how often people find success outside of their hometown in my experience, but in terms of this hellish post-9/11 suburbia that Jesus finds himself in, maybe he really is just more comfortable at home. Regardless of that, I thought this was fucking spectacular. Absolutely worthy of the hype. Really dumb of me to never listen before now, but I now feel as cleansed as Jesus did at the end of this album. One of the easiest 5s yet.
Great classic!! Brings back memories!
Had Rock Opera, so why not a Punk Rock Opera. Simultaneously too short and yet some songs feel too long. 20 years later and I'm still surprised Green Day had this in them
Decent rock.
Álbum of my teenage years
When I was in 4th grade I really wanted my parents to let me buy this album. Unfortunately, there is a giant "Parental Advisory" label on the cover, so my mom didn't let that happen. I was pissed. I'm not sure why 4th grade me wanted this, but I had great taste, this thing is still awesome 20 years later. What I missed at the time was the context. Green Day was very big at this time (Dookie came out a decade earlier), but their popularity had been declining throughout the '90s and they had a bit of a flop album in 2000 before this one came out in 2004. So in many ways this was a bit of a surprise comeback for them. They call this a "punk rock opera", and it's centered around a lower-middle-class suburban teen that's disillusioned about the state of the US at the time (9/11, Iraq War, Bush elections, etc.). Very few of the songs are explicitly political, but the story comes across regardless. This one has a bunch of their hits, "American Idiot" to kick it off, "Holiday", "Boulevard of Broken Dreams", and "Wake Me up When September Ends". I enjoyed a lot of the songs that I was less familiar with too, so it stays pretty consistently strong throughout. I tend to like punk that's pretty well-polished, and this meets the criteria. Great energy throughout, strong lyrics, multiple classic songs, a bit of nostalgia for my childhood, what more could I want? A great album overall. 5 stars. Take that mom. Favorite song: Wake Me up When September Ends Other: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novocain / She's a Rebel, Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb, Whatsername 6/30/24
Good for what it was
American Idiot is, ultimately, listenable. I definitely found myself bobbing along and enjoying so tracks. The album goes on too long. But it's too important of an album for 90s to ignore. I think the thing that leaves a bitter taste in my mouth is calling it punk. Maybe they bought a mode of punk into popular consciousness that I just don't like very much. I wonder if it was called something else, I'd be left without that bitter taste.
Music is ok, but the lyrics really make this one
Nice one Green Day!
Not a big fan of "commercial" Green Day compared to their early work. But this album is still entertaining.
I have to be honest, I love the singles and have strong emotional connections to them but I find the album as a whole to only be average
Never was a Green Day fan growing up and I'm not one now. There are a few good ones on this album, but there are also certainly some tunes that have aged *distinctly* poorly. Just not super my vibe!
Had a ton of fun revisiting this. I never listened to a ton of Green Day but I always loved this album and I think most of it holds up pretty well. I bet they felt so clever making two songs actually one song
Right off the bat… a MAJOR album for me when I was a kid.. THE album, in fact. The singles actually don’t do a lot for me tbh, but the ambition of this project and a lot of the songs in particular within a pop punk concept totally works on me and kinda opened my eyes when I was young. There’s way more filler than I remember but tracks like Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming have always kinda blown me away There’s also a lot of corny touches, and dated language here and there - honestly it’s more of a mixed bag than I remembered from my relatively recent re-listen, but most everything is catchy and the project as a whole (and a heap of nostalgia) color it positively overall in my eyes. Certainly an influential album and, while in my opinion this does not compare at all to these heights, I can’t deny that it influenced all-time favs of mine like MCR’s Black Parade - I mean the impact this had on steering other pop punk bands towards more “serious” music with emo aesthetics was huge for my personality. blink-182 beat them to it of course, and with much more creative success.
Intensely nostalgic and quite fun but it does feel like it’s tailor-made for 10-year-olds.
Famously my least fav band, I was shocked by how many of these songs I did remember from the last time i listened to this album (i must have been nine years old?) I will at a later date maybe try and do some research about the best art made during the bush era of political activism (there was basically nothing good made tho...) Anyways still think it sucks :)
I found this album to be underwhelming overall. I can understand why it resonates with people but for me this is nowhere near the masterpiece I’ve heard it is. I’ll start by saying I did enjoy a few songs off it, Holiday/Boulevard of broken dreams and Wake Me up When September Ends. While I didn’t enjoy American Idiot (the song) it was anthemic, I just personally felt it was annoying. Jesus of Suburbia is kind of goofy with how long it is but again I won’t deny it has hooks all over it. Unfortunately the album on a whole just dragged on for me, it’s just way too long with way too many songs that sound the same. Every once in a while they will use a motif but I found the story/concept not interesting enough to care when a musical idea was brought back. Idk it feels like more aesthetic than an enjoyable concept album. But hey maybe it’s just not for me, I still think it’s fair to call the album iconic because I know the impact it had but as a listening experience I have no want to every listen front to back again. Wake Me up When September Ends is in my opinion Green Day’s best song.
Dookie is better, but there are some bangers here for sure
Hyfsat rock album ändå. Många av låtarna är överspelade, men de är ju kända av en anledning. Inte riktigt min grej men fattar varför folk gillar dem och kan definitivt lyssna på dem då och då. Hade denna på LP hemma faktiskt så det är inte direkt nytt för mig men kul att få något känner igen.
quite bland musically, quite bland lyrically, couple of nice bangers that are relatively nostalgic, but they are genuinly alright. its not a bad album, but its not good, and its definitely not significant enough to be considered "blabla one of the greatest", its just a generic pop "punk". nothing in the world of music would change if this album didnt exist. In a vacuum id give it a 5-6/10, but in this list its a 4/10
Great production, great songs.
There are so many things I'd like to say about this album. In fact, that its taken me 5 months and 100 other albums to finally sit down and begin typing out my thoughts. As I sat down and began waxing poetic on each song—its instrumentation, lyrics, and place in the album’s overarching narrative—I realized that what I really wanted to convey was how much I absolutely love this album. So while this may not be the ten-thousand-word thesis I initially set out to write, the core message remains the same: this is one of my favorite albums.
Pure nostalgia
This album has it all great song writing great performance and straight in your face rock and roll. Green Day has kept punk alive and well.
Genius album! It’s equally fresh today.
the unwanted soundtrack to my middle school/high school years. nostalgic but not in the best way haha. probably would have been better to me if it wasnt so overplayed during that era.
Album 447 of 1001 Green Day - American Idiot Rating : 5 / 5 A favorite I had almost forgotten about. A good time to pull this out as it is somewhat as relevant today as it was then. Great tunes...great performance. Hopefully, 20 years is enough time for many to separate it from its politics and really appreciate it for the music.
Great sounds throughout
Top Classic punk rock but Not my genre
7/10
Pop punk probably at it's absolute finest. Excellent concept album at that.
It was ok.
The only American Idiots on this album are the political naïve members of this band. This cam out while I was an adult already, so I was able to see through all of their bullshit. About as terribly boring as the other albums on this list from the naughties. It really was the worst decade of Pop Music going all the way back to the 1950s. It seems that the albums that were really worth listening to, that managed breaking new sonic ground in the 2000s were not included at all on this list. For three chords and boredom, "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" is the only song that feels at all like an earworm on this album. I applaud the band for trying a couple of new things, but ultimately this a formulaic mess of a punk rock opera album that is also way too long for a punk rock album. What is more concerning is that are no new fresh ideas for the genre on here. Stormtroopers of Death did this idea better with SPEAK ENGLISH OR DIE way back in 1985 and their concept album character Sergeant D. There are countless other punk rock acts, NOFX is another, who did all of this more interestingly than these guys. About the only positive thing I can say is that Tre Cool, their drummer, is the best thing about this band and he shows it again on this album.
i'm not a part of the redneck agenda
Classic. Mark Knopfler a hero on guitar
An album from my youth 😂
This is a quality album, but I was not feeling it today. Maybe the sound isn’t for me anymore. I loved listening to some of the songs as a kid, and those are still good. Kinda funny to hear the singer ask, “Am I retarded?” Yeah, kinda. Standouts: Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams, and Wake Me Up When September Ends.
Started off really strong, but then faded a bit.
This is the Green Day I like. I am curious as to why there were so many combined songs. A bit outdated- said the r-word. But i actually liked this a lot more than our first album.
pogger and green-pilled
Punk classic
Corny, overproduced shite for angry teens. This list so white.
Way more stadium rock than I remember, and a lot of the tracks work much better within the full context of the album.
Seems all of these guys' hits are in this album. Even the 9 minute songs slapped all the way through (didn't expect it). Second half had a couple mediocre songs which made this drag on a bit, if only it was a bit shorter. 4.5 rounded down cause of the length Stand-out: Holiday, Jesus of Suburbia
Melodically 2-dimensional with some drum hooks lifted from better songs. Blink-182 without the special sauce.
Still a great album, lots of nostalgia. Made me pick up my guitar again.
Great album, just not a huge Green Day fan.
It wasn't a bad album. I'd even say it was a good album.
Very overplayed (I worked at HMV at the time) but nowhere near as bad as I remembered. In hindsight, you can sort of hear that they felt threatened by emo and were trying to do some of the progginess and shape of emo in their music to stay on top.
좋아하는 앨범
Bloody hell, some of these reviews! You'd think Green Day were the Second Coming! In fact, the singles are okay but the rest of it gets pretty dreary.
Thirty albums ago, I had 'Dookie', a nice surprise: how listening to it reminded me of my love with another, older melodic (hardcore) punk album, that it was 30 years old, from 'Cobain's dead' 1994 and how I learned that Green Day's music/musicianship is or was way above their pop punk contemporaries' output. 'American Idiot' does not have that. The last point still stands, but it doesn't work in their favour. In 'Homecoming', there's a "Jeez [exhale]" at 5:24 and that is me at this point when I hear another one of this concept album's breaks, marching drums, toy piano tchotchkes. It's all so weirdly strained and laborious that I can't find the fun I think I'm supposed to have with music like this. Instead, I'm just bored.
Almost every song is a jam.
Some great tunes.
Pure nostalgia
Epitome of music
My favourite album when I was 12, still a great album and easily Green Day's best work.
At least it’s an album of importance and broad critical acclaim even if I don’t like it that much. It’s more of a throwback than a progression. It’s not bad at all. But is it punk? I will concede it belongs on this list.
Propulsive popular punk: We rocked along to it, our mock hero's, and they appeared on the Simpsons: Mindfr*ck America - let's commercialise our satire and rage, that's show the capo Basterds. it's good fun.
Never really been a fan. Title track’s okay, although I prefer the follow-up single, Boulevard Of Broken Dreams. Apart from those, i enjoyed the change of pace with Wake Me Up & I liked the closing track, Whatsername, but the most of the rest of it all sounds the same to me.
American Idiot; for American idiots by America idiots. Jeez, this stuff just writes itself... I am a little bit prejudiced against this record on a number of counts. But mostly because of Bloody Matthew (not his real name). In 2004, I recently been promoted to a team leader position, and my most difficult team member was Bloody Matthew, so called because his behavior so frequently prompted people to cry out "Bloody Matthew!". He was a major pain in the arse, exacerbated by the fact that he believed _he_ should have been made team leader. He was a considerable thorn in my side and made life unpleasant for me and other people in the office. Example behaviour; the office manager had OCD, so Matthew would go to the stationery cupboard and mess things up, so that the officer manager would have a fit and spend the rest of the day making sure all the boxes of paper clips were lined up properly. Just being deliberately provocative. One day, Bloody Matthew came into work very excited that there was a new Green Day album coming out. He loved this record; he couldn't believe their 'artistic growth'; it's a concept album! it's political! it's got rockin' tunes aplenty! Just the fact that this was Bloody Matthew's favourite record is an immediate strike against it. This record is a prime example of Steve Albini's dictum that anyone with enough time and budget can make a record that sounds "good". I watched the 'making of' documentary (which contained almost zero insights, except that Billie Joe is secretly obsessed with Broadway musicals and refuses to tune his own guitar, and the band was signed by the same A&R guy who signed the Goo Goo Dolls), and the sheer number of guitar overdubs is astounding. The expensive studio and equipment and the budget meant that this record was always going to sound huge. And there are precedents for punk rock albums that are well produced, like Never Mind the Bollocks or Nevermind, but those are also the subject of controversy about whether they are 'real punk rock'. Bille Joe Whatsit can craft a fair tune and crank out an energetic performance, but I wonder if I would like it better if they had banged the record out in a week at Electrical Recordings. So that's two strikes. And then there is the pretension of the album concept, a punk rock opera. I defer to Robert Christgau: " The emotional travails of two clueless punks--one passive, one aggressive, both projections of the auteur--stand in for the sociopolitical content that the vague references to Bush, Schwarzenegger, and war (not any special war, just war) are thought to indicate. There's no economics, no race, hardly any compassion. Joe name-checks America as if his hometown of Berkeley was in the middle of it, then name-checks Jesus as if he's never met anyone who's attended church. And to lend his maunderings rock grandeur, he ties them together with devices that sunk under their own weight back when the Who invented them." Strike three, dudes. It doesn't surprise me that this ended up on Broadway (winner of two technical Tonys!) I think punk rock was a cheap and accessible musical genre for Billie Joe to get started in, but, in his heart of hearts, he really wants to write musical theatre numbers (in the same way that Billy Joel used rock and roll as a commercial delivery mechanism for his musical theatre aspirations). Not that there is anything wrong with musical theatre, but 'fess up, fellers. Just be open about it. I recently watched a documentary about the Descendents, who really invented the genre of tuneful, apolitical, technically competent punk rock. While I don't necessarily dislike any one of those aspects in themselves, this did become a rabbit hole that bands followed in the 90s into a melodic punk rock style that had the audio trappings of punk rock (fast pace, distorted guitars, lots of down strokes), but also the naked ambition to sell a million records. And I really don't like it. It's the same obnoxious alpha jock blokes in the punk rock outfit, which dilutes the cultural meaning of punk; the willingness to examine social norms from the outsider position. And Green Day were always part of that commercial movement, as far as I could see. This album is where their peak ambition gave them the courage to stop pretending, hire an expensive studio, buy some vintage guitars, and get a stylist in. Pass the lucre, boys! We're cashing in! Summary: I admire the chutzpah of wanting to sell a bajllion punk rock albums. And they did what they needed to do; they wrote a bunch of catchy tunes, spent a fortune recording them to sound awesome, added enough content to seem like a meaningful artistic statement (without being too challenging) and made some rad videos. But the corporate polish just turns me off. I don't believe their Teen Rebellion (tm). It's commodified teenage protest, with almost nothing to say. Sound and fury signifying very little... good tunes, but a tiring listen overall. 2.5 stars.
loved it, one of my fav gd albums
inoffensive rock
Holy shit! It's been a while since I listened to the entire album, and I forgot how good it is. The same guys that sung about masturbation and were known for being able to play 3 chords put together one of the defining albums of the early 2000's. It's poignant and topical. It's also catchy as hell. I was able to sing along to almost every song on the album. I don't think there is a bad song on this entire album.
Was never a big green day fan. Overall pretty bland
I’m not here
Unless you're Taylor Swift, a 9 minute song is not needed, let alone TWO. The double titles on half the album is also unnecessary just pick one title. Music was not super interesting and the album was too long. Favourites: holiday/Boulevard of broken dreams, give me novacaine/she's a rebel. I'm in a hater mood today. 2/5
This is really good actually. I love punk rock and I forgot about how many bangers Green Day has. So classic and a great way to get me back into trying to finish up this generator. I think another 5 star for me, favourites are literally the entire album
Holiday and boulevard of broken dreams 100% best songs but not great for me
First half starts strong then peters out. Double tracks take interesting turns.
Look, anything by Green Day that's not Dookie or Nimrod is a big ol' eye roll for me. It has a couple of good tracks, Jesus of Suburbia and Holiday come to mind, but the title track being the worst song on an album doesn't sit right with me. I could go on a whole rant about how lame that song is, but there's a whole album to write about. It's ok I guess. For me, this does signify Green Day's downfall of quality and relevance.
Good but not my style
Loved it as a kid but hasn't really aged well for me. I think a 7/10 is generous even if there are a couple of great tracks on here.
3 bc I wont listen to it again. Just the 3 songs
I mean, it's not terrible. And I get that they're doing modern punk rock operas. I was well off the Greenday train by this album and not sure I'd heard it full. Like a high 2.
My boyfriend said this album radicalized him when he was 12 so I'd have to give it a four.
Fuck Green Day
Yes, I know it’s not punk like punk should be. But who cares? It’s non-stop energy, great songs and great musicians. Have always liked Billy Jo’s vocal. Whilst I hate rock operas and musicals, this is the exception to the rule.
Big songs on this, some of Green Day's best on my opinion. The first 4 songs are bangers, with 'Boulevard' probably my favourite GD track. ' Are We the Waiting' is the sound of a band embracing their Stadium credentials and coming across life John Farnham bless them. Thank goodness for 'St Jimmy' to bring it back to some sense of normality. I could go on but the essence is that there are so many pace changes, from Punk to ballads going on and to punk purists, it's probably a step too far. Luckily I'm not one and can appreciate a band trying to add a bit of versatility to their sound. It works do a 4 star.
Evidemment !
This was the album that REALLY got me into music in 2004. I was a junior in high school when this was released and I remember it really resonating with me. For years after that, American Idiot was all I would listen to. I became obsessed with learning about what the lyrics meant, which helped awaken me politically as well. This was at a time where 9/11 was still on everyones minds and America's vengeance was being taken out on a country and people who had nothing to do with it. American Idiot (fortunately or unfortunately) helped shatter the illusion of the USA being the moral and just country that we were all told it was growing up. While we still fight for it, in some ways it seems we're further away from that now then we were when this came out. I also remember discovering those tracks that would play on the radio sometimes (Longview, When I Come Around, Basket Case) were also by my new favorite band. This lead me down a rabbit hole, giving me even more music to fall in love with, despite it being very different. While I don't keep up with Green Day's newest music, they'll always have a place in my heart as the band that made me both musically and politically aware. In 2024, this album is still incredible and still 'hits' for me.
I love how theatrical this album is. Even without seeing the musical, I can picture all of the characters painted throughout the album. I’ve been a big fan of this album since middle school, and it is still holding up even at (almost) 30!
8/10 definitely not as annoying as I was expecting, actually pretty well written songs not really my genre, but I can still appreciate it
over rated
Hey, hey, we're The Punkees!
what can I even say. it's American Idiot
Surprise of the year for me. I loved this. Obviously I was obligated to like “American idiot” as a “misunderstood” eighth grader trying to play into a narrative of being cool. In reality, I don’t think I even listened to the whole album when I was a kid pretending to like this to seem cool. But as an adult woman, I was surprised that I actually loved the whole album. Maybe I’m still trying to be cool? Or maybe I just don’t care what people think of me anymore and like what I like because I fucking like it. So Green Day and Taylor swift and Janelle Monet, here I am. I love you all.
Very solid recording that stands up well over time
klasyka, zmora hipsterow i ludzi z czarnego kota, jest monotonnie ale przyjemnie
definitely the most ambitious green day album, and i think it’s pretty great for it even though the execution isn’t perfect. one of the first CD’s i ever picked up too!
I don't really have any comments on this - I'm not the audience. Seems competent
Favorite Track: Bouievard of broken dreams Other picks: Wake me up when september ends, american idiot
Stadium punk.
This album was great when I was younger. Not so much anymore
Greenday was greated with cheers when they published Dookie,,, 10 years later.... I skipped through most of the songs on this album, as song A sounds like song B sounds like song C... How has this band managed to captivate so many people for so long? This is the first album that I am giving 1 star...
One of my favorite albums of all time! Together this album is amazing and each song can stand so well on its own. This one came out when I was in college and really allowing me to to question and change a lot of world views/stances. I have listened to this album numerous times before but still love it today.
If you love pop punk anthems, these guys are the kings. This is probably their best album. Appropriate to get this one on Memorial Day. 20 year's later the American Idiocy has spiraled into American Insanity.
Awww yeah, love how much Green Day rocks out against the fuckery of society, while being so catchy too. The lyrics are as relevant now as they were then. So many great songs on here, and as a whole, it’s a very complete feeling rock opera. They are so fun live, and this was also a cool show to see on Broadway :)
Sounds like an album Blake would fondle himself to …10/10
At first I was surprised to see this one. Now, I am good with it. Will be my highest rated album thus far because it definitely was a piece of my youth.
Love this album. Many of these songs are still regularly listened to.
Not a fan of Green Day.. but this was probs their best album. Where is Offspring?!
Never been a huge fan of Green Day but this is a pretty decent album.
Simple Enjoyable
Very overplayed when it came out, but it's been long enough that I can enjoy it now. Some very good songs. Bit too much filler towards the end, but still good overall.
always felt this was an overrated generic sounding album
Better than I remember
Very nice album! American Idiot and Wake Me Up When September Ends tracks are the masterpieces! And all other are perfect! Thanks for this album listening, I never heard it before!
Green Day! Really good album, Aged very well.
Absolute staple of an album. I'd overlooked it.
this album is mega and i barely listen to green day wake me up when september ends will never not be a banger
I really don’t like Green Day
behold, the last decent music green day ever made! (dookie still washes this album btw)
Would rather listen to the real punk/new wave rather than this 20 year's too late sanitized rubbish. Not for me
It deserves a higher rating than my other 4s, but is also not Fleetwood Macs Rumours. This is a true 4, I'll be stricter with my ratings moving forward.
Eh
One of the worst things to come out of 9-11.
Wildly dated clown show
Absolutely hated this album when it 1st came out. Still super tired of hearing the main singles from it, but really the rest of the album is pretty great. The rock opera really works out in it's favor.
Are you kidding me???
Correcto pero no demasiado de mi agrado.
When I got this generated, my immedieate thought was "ahh a modern classic". But there is nothing modern about this record anymore. It's 20 fucking years old. It's now a classic. The singles are Green Day's strongest, and so is the rest of the album. Just so consistantly strong, every song an anthem. Truly one of the greatest career resurgances ever seen
Jesus of Suburbia alone can put this up to five stars. Overall though, this record was essential listening as a tween. It's so memorable in my mind, from the rebellion that felt so relatable to me at 10 years old(?!?) to the black shirts and red ties that made up a lot of of the visuals from this era. There's just something about the albums that you grew up with. There's no replacing them.
Good album, but I think dookie is slightly better
Absolutely love it. I miss 2004 and this is full of absolute bangers. More of this sort of thing!
Not for me.
This is the first generated album that I’ve actually listened to before. I really liked the album as a teenager and still do now. Great, solid album. Favorite songs: American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends.
There is something that doesn't fully get me on the side of Green Day. I think it's the timing. I wasn't a greatest listener of rock in 2004. Nevertheless I recognize it's a important album in America.
very good later stage grunge punk.
This was pretty good.
I forgot how epic this album is. True rock opera.
One of my most favorite albums of all time
Long songs - hits mixed in with eh
Good Green Day
Good as Always. Not sure I\"m going to bother re-listening to things I've listened to hundreds of time and own.
One of the few (and I mean *few*) punk albums that could stand the test of time. 20 years later and there's still so much new artists could learn from an album like this.
Gotta say, BJA can write a melody. It’s weird because I listen to her plunk, and Dookie and insomniac so much but I was already pretty much done with them when Nimrod came out and I didn’t think it was a very good album. That was i was probably making fun of Green Day by the time American idiot came out. Some songs are so much a part of the culture now and his voice is really kind of iconic its own way that when I hear it it’s so familiar and hits that nostalgia for the mid teenage years angsty thing but because I don’t know the lyrics to the songs, there’s an eeriness about it. Except Boulevard of broken dreams. I was coming back from NCAAs in Atlanta our fifth year, I just went down to watch with Mooney and Leo Salinas and maybe a couple other guys. I drove Fran’s Crown Vic down there with a couple people, but they stayed or flew back or for some reason I drove home alone. One of Mooney‘s friends, a girl who knew from Jersey, lived down there and we stayed with her and a roommates last night. I was wrecked and made some bad choices and it was embarrassing and I got up early the next morning and fled. Well, I had to rouse Leo from the backseat of the Crown Vic first because that’s where he had slept. Of course. So I’m driving north back to cville and feeling bad, bad, bad—about the things I’d done, but also physically. I was very hungover. It’d been three days of steady drinking and my liver felt like it was flowing backwards and secreting toxins into my bloodstream instead of filtering them out. And it was an ill-fated journey. I had printed Map Quest maps out because this was flip-phone era still, right, and of course I’d lost the printouts but a) assumed I could just reverse engineer the trip and b) could not comprehend trying to find somewhere to look it up and print out another set—imagine searching blindly for an Internet cafe in rural Georgia on a Sunday in 2005–and it was, of course, absolutely impossible to go back into the girls’ house to figure out how to print my getaway plan. ANYWAY, this song was on like three radio stations between Atlanta and the Blue Ridge Mountains—and was the last song I heard before the radio went out so it was stuck in my head the rest of the trip and was already starting to feel like some kind of fateful punishment BEFORE the snowstorm started. Freak late spring storm that dumped and dumped the higher and higher I climbed. By the time I reached the pass (84?) to get to the east side of the mountains, it had reached blizzard conditions AND THE HEATER HAD GONE OUT so there was no more defrosting the sleet Jack Frost piss raining down from the sky and caking the window in a sheet of blurry ice. Luckily there were very few others on the road. None by time I got to a trucker gas station to get some hot water to melt the ice on the windshield so I could see. “Road’s closed,” dude yelled from behind the counter as I walked in. “You must be the last one they let up.” He told me to wait it out there with him but that seemed impossible, too, and after having listening to Blvd. Broken Dreams 9,000,000 times in my head I figured it was really my destiny to either finish this trip alone or die out there, alone and deserving of all the solitude and lonesomeness the world could devise for me. So on I went, after dumping nine styrofoam cups of boiling water on the windshield and filling the wiper fluid reservoir up with antifreeze on the recommendation from the dude from behind the counter. I also got a six pack of PBR, which I started drinking immediately and which, though I wouldn’t recommend this to my kids, might have saved my life because I stopped worrying so much and just settled into the curves and slides instead of working every inch of that freeway and every tiniest bump to absolute white-knuckle death. Once I’d gotten back down to sea level or whatever level cville is at, and made my obligatory “thanks for getting me outta that foxhole, bro” appeal to the Lord and thawed out my feet, I asked Coop if I should tell any pertinent people about all the bad decisions I’d made. “Do you want to tell anyone?“ “I do not.” He shrugged. “Then don’t.” Also, is “Jesus of Suburbia” a country song?
3/5. It has high highs and meh lows. Not Green Day's best or worst works.
When I saw this was my album I once again was very curious what my take was going to be. I was 16 when this came out, and I was really not a big fan of the hits. I know in retrospect I just wasn't there for it taste wise, even if I had listened to the whole album. I went in with an open mind and definitely enjoyed more than I expected! I do definitely enjoy the hits more in the context of the album. There is also something about the shift from Holiday to Boulevard of Broken Dreams that is magic and is lost entirely when you just listen to the radio edit of the later. The album starts strong, and finishes strong. That said the middle section kind of loses me entirely. His voice also used to annoy me at 16, and now I like it more but still get a little tired of it after a bit. Overall this is a worthwhile listen. I'll probably return to it again at some point. However, I will probably only listen to the first 4 and last 4 tracks and just skip over the middle entirely.
The World's most Disney "Punk" band are here to complain about something. But don't worry kids they've bought a load of highly polished commercial pop songs that all sound similar apart from the really heartfelt slow one. Still less cringe than Blink 182 and that bloke sure can play the drums... in exactly the same way on every song.
Such a classic. I also had never noticed this before but this album has some freaking long songs! Punk hardly ever has songs this long. I really respect that.
American Idiot, the first album I immediately loved and then was taught to immediately hate. There’s no question that Green Day “sold out” and went completely mainstream. Delivered punk music to the masses while simultaneously ruining the genre. Punk didn’t plateau after this record, it pretty much died, became emo, pop, hardcore or indie. Blink-182 broke up and Green Day filed the void with this record. Despite all the bullshit about selling out, it’s hard to not see and understand the vision of this record. It’s kind of genius and really well executed. There hasn’t really been anything like this since or before. So avoiding pre-conceived notions about how I feel about this album personally and culturally, I think there are some really awesome songs. -American Idiot is such a rad way to start an album. -Jesus of Suburbia is brilliant. Full on punk rock opera. Maybe the sneaky best song on the record. -Holiday is so fun. Such a good anthem. -Boulevard of Broken Dreams is the most important song for 7th grade Blake. -Are We Waiting / St. Jimmy were always my favorite 2 though. I always felt like it was a perfect break mid-record before taking off with St. Jimmy. No idea what it’s about, but it makes you feel things. -Give Me Novocaine is maybe the most unique song on the record. It’s different but it’s a good pace change before She’s a Rebel, which rocks my socks off. -Wake Me Up When September Ends was a sad song that soon became a summer song, which I always thought was hilarious. Also everyone learned the intro of this song on acoustic guitars. The biggest knock on the record musically is that it’s a bit front loaded. The back half isn’t nearly as strong as the front half. Ultimately, this record is always going to be a stamp for a moment in time. Bush Administration / War in Iraq / the peak and crash of mainstream punk rock. And it deserves it. It was important when it came out and it still holds up.
It feels very Nostalgic when I hear Green Days. It is a classic Album. The music brings me back to the 2000s.
I wrote a whole thing out but forgot to save it. C'est la vie. Mostly good.
This isso insanelynostalgic for me like i am so fucking tapped into this. paolo and i used to bond over this album so much i love the vibes and i think that this is their best album by a long shot. I am going to revisit this again so soon
green day type album
The quintessential cultural text from the 2004 Bush/Kerry election, probably the coolest rock and roll album of all time if you were between the ages 10-12 when it came out. Really it's a bombastic, grandiose, kind of milquetoast record that is quite long in the tooth. "Jesus of Suburbia" is by far the best thing here, an epic, anthemic song chock full of amazing earworm melodies and interesting ideas--it is dated and partially ruined by a regrettable use of an ableist slur that was [i]way[/i] too prevalent in the lexicon around this time--but it is what it is. The singles from this are rightfully seen as pop rock classics, even if in the case of like "Holiday" they're definitely a little cringe. This definitely overstays its welcome and despite how good of a songwriter Billie Joe Armstrong is I have no time or interest for most of the back half of this album, but when this hits its peaks though it's still pretty great.
MEU PUNK ROCK FAVORITO
A massive pop punk hit that spawned a Broadway show. There are undeniably studio crafted hits on here but the rest are more by the numbers. Not for me.
Not bad, I still remember when this album came out. Can’t believe it’s 20 years now! Wow.
A couple of stand-out tracks, a lot of energy and pretty emblematic of the 00s soundscape
Very nice album from back in the day, but half of the songs sounds like it is from a American Pie movie. That is not a bad thing, but it throws you back to what all songs sounded back then. I was a fan of slightly more "classical" type of rock at the time, but you can't deny the number of hits in this album. Although American Idiot has the most listens, I like Boulevard of Broken Dreams more.
Oh yesss!!!! Made me really happy!!! Great album!
Tolles Album von einer Band die Vollgas gibt vom ersten bis zum letzten Ton!
Eine super Platte, vom ersten bis letztem Song!
There's nothing worse than bands spouting political opinions held by the retarded class
Fun, topical rock
5/5. This is another one of those albums where although some might call it punk, there are definitely some punk elements but this is more of a rock opera, especially with songs like Jesus and Homecoming. This is a façade and on purpose. You see on the surface, those only listening to the first song and Holiday that is a rebellious album. This is a story about the American Dream. The songs are full of sadness and hope and the need to create polished rock is the only way to tell this story to match the fakeness of radio rock and try to get your message out there while appealing to the masses, counteracting yourself. It's beautiful and wonderful. Also all the songs are so good. Best Song: Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday / Boulevard, Wake Me Up, Whatshername
Green Day has always made me want to shut Green Day off. If I'm gonna listen to poppy-punk, I'll choose a band that does it well (Operation Ivy, NOFX) I wanted to shut this off several times too. I do commend them on stretching out a bit for this album. I'm sure if you like GD then this album works for you, it just doesn't for me. I almost long for the days off Kerplunk or Dookie. Almost
I know my rating is mostly due to nostalgia. I own that. Because nowadays this type of artistic activism drives me nuts. It’s performative and makes it feel like you’re doing something when you’re actually doing nothing. But the songs slap and I enjoy listening to it. 4/5
When I was a pop punk obsessed preteen in 2005, you were either a fan of American Idiot or From Under the Cork Tree. I stood staunchly in the latter camp, and even deep into my teens, defended my stance against this era of Green Day. Listening to it now as an adult, I admit my wrongs! I still replay a lot of the emo classics, as any Elder Emo does, but very few actually hold up beyond nostalgia, and even then, “hold up” is a loose term. American Idiot, on the other hand, really does hold up! The production is incredibly tight, and sounds excellent and fresh to this day. The musicianship is top-notch, and it’s even more evident now how their elder-statesmanship helped them stand out at that time. And for a lofty concept album, it’s rarely a boring or pretentious listen, where 8 minute songs rarely feel longer than 4 minutes, and the energy is also there, even during the somber moments. And now, with maturity and the hindsight of time, the political critique feels especially on point, and maybe even works better today. I’d say there’s a handful of critiques to throw at this. The amount of slurs is a bit of a dicey minefield, and even looking beyond the short-sighted Conservative BS of Political Correctness blah blah blah, it does feel counterintuitive to the point being made; at the same time, punk has a history of white men saying slurs to be subversive and then realizing in retrospect that that was a dumb move and distracted from the message, and I think that’s the case here too. I would also say the fact that tracks are glued together as single tracks is dumb, but that’s a very specific streaming-era critique that feels almost ahistorical; sure, it annoys me today, but during the CD era, it would’ve only annoyed me when/if I was trying to make a mixed CD. Finally, I think Tré Cool should never sing ever again, but it *is* only for a moment and during a medley, so it’s forgivable. These critiques are not enough to bring this album down from its height. The only reason I hated this in 2005 was because I thought calling something pretentious and hating it made me smarter. I’m now an adult and know that’s an equally pretentious move. I have ears. I love pop punk. I always have, and I always will. And while my favorite pop punk/emo albums were solidified a decade ago, from a critical perspective, this is a high-water mark for pop punk and a crucial listen, especially today.
I have this on CD. Sailed close to the wind ripping off Ring of Fire and Wonderwall but overall it's good. 3.5
Objectively, this is probably not a five. Having said that, this is subjective, so, YEEHAW.
One of the last great rock bands and this was one of their best.
HELL YEAH 5/5
kinda fun album, already had listened to it so didn´t pay much attention
I know it's just not my jam
This isn't really my kind of thing and it started losing me by the end but it was OK.
A bit late but I listened to it. Took me back to being 13 and discovering rock music. Very good stuff
Pretty prettty pretty pretty good
I enjoyed a couple of tracks, but it was all a bit the same. Like the other punk albums, I also find the lead singer a tad monotonous.
3.7 - Couldn't help sing a long. Not listened to it in like 10 years but some song still bang.
Nostalgic, but not my vibe.
I had a really good time listening to this. I thought perhaps it would have aged terribly or come across as corny, but I think it holds up well. The album is really well produced and there are some absolute pop-punk bangers. It captures a moment in time and I think is a vital inclusion on the list. Fave Tracks: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Are We The Waiting, Give Me Novacaine, Wake Me Up When September Ends, 4.6/5
This album inspired me to move to America and become an idiot. Thank you, Green Day.
You know, my track record for punk albums hasn't been the best so far. I mean, there's a reason why, as of me writing this review, punk is listed in the "worst genres" part of my summary. Until now, there was really only one punk album I'd gotten that I felt passionate about (Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables). On top of that, while it's not necessarily a bad thing, every punk album I've gotten until now, with one exception, was from the 70s or 80s. What about the 21st century punk, huh? Well, if you want a punk album from this century, you'd be hard-pressed to find one better and more important than American Idiot by Green Day. Green Day has always been a band that I've liked, but have never really dived deep into. I've gotta say, American Idiot is a modern masterpiece. The sound in this thing is just amazing. The guitar and bass work is practically perfect, with the riffs for each song standing out in their own unique ways. The drumming is really something special. Tré Cool is just an absolute beast. The singing is great. I think Billie Joe Armstrong is a strong contender for the best singer in punk. The way each song stands out is just amazing. You have of the best energetic songs I've ever heard with songs like the title track balanced out by deeply emotional tracks like "Wake Me Up When September Ends." The addition of the Bohemian Rhapsody-esque multi-part suits with "Jesus of Suburbia" and "Homecoming" do a lot to aid in this album's story. Speaking of which, let's talk about the story. This is a concept album through and through. The overarching narrative is quite possibly one of the best I've seen in an album. The sharp song transitions represent the rapidly changing mental state of the main character, and the story actually feels complete. Overall, this album's awesome. It might just be one of my favorite albums of the project so far. 5/5.
Fake punk music. Musicianship is good but message is lacking substance.
I enjoyed the sound of quite a lot of the songs. The guitar throughout all of it was amazing. American Idiot was my favourite song. I think I would’ve enjoyed this album more if there were less swear words so I could share it with my family. 3.5
Only one Green Day is required in the collection, Dookie. Interesting lyrics, same-y songs.
I mean I only liked boulevard of broken dreams, but it was okay all around
Almost every song is fun and catchy. The populist anti-Bush lyrics make me feel nostalgic about hanging with my pseudo-intellectual high school debate team friends.
Flashback to when this album came out: I had a calendar of stupid George W. Bush quotes, wore a thrifted child-size Max Headroom sweatshirt and checkered Vans, and had the lyrics to every Green Day song printed out and organized in a binder. Not nearly the shiniest jewel in Green Day’s crown, but have to give it a high score because of how pure my love is for this band and this album.
didn't listen 1/5
😴
I will preface this by saying that I've never really been the biggest fan of this record. I'll be straight up when I say this is one of the most overhyped and overblown rock records I've ever heard. But even so, I gave it the benefit of the doubt with relisten and here's what I ultimately came away from it thinking: It does start pretty strong with the opening title track. There's a reason it's iconic: it has an instantly recognizable guitar riff and first verse along with a very upbeat and catchy instrumental alongside lyrics that are quite fitting for the album's clear anti-war sentiments: "Don't wanna be an American idiot / Don't want a nation under the new media / And can you hear the sound of hysteria? / The subliminal mindfuck America" Moving on, we have "Jesus of Suburbia," the first of two long cuts on this record. The first two parts of this song demonstrate some of the issues I have with the record: the overblown sound and almost annoying choruses this record has. In particular, in the song's second part, we hear audible *hey!* chants that bog down an otherwise solid chorus. It does pick up with the more up-tempo third part, even if the intro for that part is weak with its repetitive lyrics and guitar riff. The last two parts (four and five) do provide a nice contrast in sound, particularly with the fourth part, where we get a more acoustic backing instrumental and some surprisingly introspective and venerable lyrics within the so-called character of the song (that being the "Jesus of Suburbia) that seems to be reflective of frontman Billie Joe Armstrong's sentiments towards American society. Though with that being said, I will say that the lyric "Am I retarded or am I just overjoyed?" is one that I don't think holds up very well in retrospect (for somewhat obvious reasons). Things pick up again in the fifth and final part of the song, as Billie songs about running from a "hurricane of fucking lies," referring to American propaganda on a rocking instrumental, but transitioning into an admittedly beautiful piano ballad moment that abruptly ends and goes back to the rocking instrumental to end off the song. Overall, it's one of the better tracks on the record, even if I don't think the first half of the song is all that great. Following that is "Holiday," a track that I've never really cared too much for, in part because I find the song to be overly preachy and also annoying, particularly on the bridge where Billie does this screechy voice while acting as a US representative that comes off as forced more than anything else. After that is "Boulevard of Broken Dreams," arguably one of the big highlights on this record. Admittedly, I've never been the biggest fan of these sorts of power ballads, mainly because they come off as sort of cheesy and maybe a little dramatic for their own good, especially with lyrics like "My shadow's the only one that walks beside me My shallow heart's the only thing that's beatin'", but there is a certain sincerity in Billie's vocal performance that helps elevate the track. The song ends on a strong high note with its thunderous instrumental towards the last minute or so. From here on out, I find the middle stretch of the tracklist, specifically from "Are We the Waiting" to "Extraordinary Girl," to have a myriad of problems that each track demonstrates. Either a song is wildly overblown (as is the case with that chorus for "Are We the Waiting"), has some relatively mellow instrumental moments ("Give Me Novacaine"), or contains some rather shallow lyrical content and repetitive song instrumentals ("She's a Rebel" and "Extraordinary Girl"). I will say that "Letterbomb" does manage to sort of avoid the issues mentioned above with its catchy and powerful instrumental, even if it is a bit straightforward overall. However, "Letterbomb" is largely overshadowed by the next track after it: "Wake Me Up When September Ends." I previously mentioned that I'm usually not the biggest fan of these sorts of power ballads. However, this song is an exception as it's executed wonderfully not just from Billie's sincere vocal performance and genuinely heart-wrenching lyrics that not only reflect his feelings about the passing of his father at a young age but can apply to anyone who has mourned the loss of a close one (Here comes the rain again / Falling from the stars / Drenched in my pain again / Becoming who we are / As my memory rests / But never forgets what I lost), but also in the instrumental that contrasts beautifully from acoustic guitar and subtle percussion into powerful guitar chords and drumming while remaining very heartfelt. I can more than see why this track resonated with so many people at the time of its release and how it continues to do so nearly twenty years after its release. After this, we get the second of the long cuts on here: "Homecoming." This track contains many of the same issues I mentioned earlier with other tracks, but all combined into a track that clocks in at just a little over nine minutes. It starts sufficiently with another rocking instrumental that works well enough for the first four minutes or so for the track (even if it feels like it overstays its well by then by just a bit) before transitioning to these vocal parts performed by guitarist Mike Dirnt and drummer Tre Cool that honestly just come off as sort of annoying due to their vocal inflections sounding rather forced more than anything else. This is before we reach the final part of the part, which might as well have the most overblown part in the whole record, with this huge chorus that tries way too hard to feel grandiose above anything else. I will say that the record does close out with another more straightforward rocker in "Whatsername," as the character of Jesus of Suburbia reflects upon his journey throughout this record. In closing, I don't necessarily hate this record, as I've certainly heard worse records (especially coming from this same band in the years following this record). Still, at the same time, I don't think I will ever understand how it was as acclaimed as it was upon its release when it features a tracklist that, frankly speaking, has only three or four tracks that I see myself going back to for sure. The rest feels either overblown, overly preachy, or shallow at many points. I can honestly say that many other rock operas that have come before or after this outdo it not just in terms of overall execution (including a specific record that would come out two years after this one *cough* *cough* The Black Parade *cough* *cough*) but are more worthy of your time than the nearly one-hour length of this album.
Highschool lightning captured in a bottle. Still great to this day despite some of the tracks being VERY worn out / overplayed. Bonus of a great followup playlist in the Spotify recommendations.
crrrriiiiinnnnnggggggeeeeeeee bin genervt dass ich mir das anhören "musste"
“You either die the hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.” By some accounts the last truly big rock album, and it is still an awesome listen with raucous energy and ear worm hooks. This is ‘sold out’ Green Day, but it’s first-line-obituary material as well. kind of wild to hear 2005 anti propaganda lyrics from BJA now given what he’s crystallized into. Lol
Better than I give it credit for.
I’m really glad I listened to this one after I listened to “Dookie”. The evolution of Green Day is insane. They’re still clearly themselves, but there’s no way they were doing a mini rock opera back then, much less two of them. This is an awesome protest album, maybe the last great one of its kind. I really miss this kind of album. Maybe encapsulates its era better than any other album of the 00’s. Nailed the zeitgeist.