Reviews (page 9 of 16)
I don't think this is my favorite Green Day album, but it is very good. At the time it came out I was pretty annoyed the hits got so much radio play. Now with a little time (and a little less repetition on the radio) I think I can be a little more objective about it. 4/5
Aah, from a more innocent age when we thought the US electing George W. Bush was hitting rock bottom. Has anyone else noticed that the second half of Jesus of Suburbia sounds like a mash up of All the Young Dudes and Summer of 69?
Great album, listened many times
Ble positivt overrasket. Har ikke tidligere lyttet til et helt album Green Day, kun fått med meg enkelte låter på radioen eller musikk videoer på TV. Flere veldig gode melodier og gode arrangementer. Vokalen er god, og det er ordentlig trøkk i musikken. Min vurdering er gjort etter å ha lyttet på Delux edition. 👍🏻
Green Day has always been a bit of a cringe band for me, going back to their Dookie days when my neighbor blasted it for what felt like 23 hours a day. Beyond that, they’ve long been the poster child for everything I dislike about commercial pop punk, especially their aggressive, punk driven tracks that just don’t click with me. Take American Idiot, the title track is so annoying I can hardly stand it. But once you get past that song, a lot of the other tracks on this album aren’t actually that bad. Over the years, I’ve found their more melodic songs, like some on this record, to be pretty catchy, and I think Green Day would’ve been much better as an alternative rock band than a punk band. On a side note, I’ll give them credit for their influences, particularly Devo, who inspired them so much that some members formed a synth-pop, new wave side project called The Network, which was a fun little venture for what it was. All that said, Green Day has always been, and probably always will be, a bittersweet band for me. Some moments I enjoy, but others I just can’t get behind.
why are you making me listen to Green Day in the year of our Lord 2025... on the day a new pope was chosen too..... i saw the number of tracks and was so excited, but what do you mean they're all 15 minutes long i didn't know they said the f-word in the title track oh wow yeah the song american idiot is good, i knew of it obviously, but i don't have that many thoughts about it, it's one of those songs that's been in my life for too long for me to listen to it critically. but hey, love anything that criticizes the US so go off jesus of suburbia sure is an interesting title. i gotta say though, i know it's still only the second track, but i'm already getting kinda tired of the guitars just... being there sounding the same the whole way through. and yes, i know, it's a punk record. the lyrics are interesting, but very straight-foward. nothing necessarily wrong about that, and this is a punk record after all, but still. ok the song just started going the fuck off at around the three minute mark, this is great. this feels like a transition to a completely different track, interesting that they decided to keep them together. not them say the r-word haha ok this really is the 2000's. ok, I liked this, but i do wish this song was like three or four different songs, because i liked certain parts more than others. and no, this isn't my first case of multiple tracks in one, and yes, i do always hate it. i knew green day was very political, and i am sort of familiar with their recent controversies. that being said, i am liking the themes here (not that we've had anything that hard to disagree with yet). see why is boulevard of broken dreams in the same track as holiday. i know there's a version of it alone, but still. but yeah, that's a classic. are we the waiting is the first song that i don't really enjoy. let's see the second half though. sidebar real quick, i think some of the problems that i have with this album so far really boil down to the vocal performance. it's not bad, but that's kind of the problem. his voice is too ""good"" for a punk record? and that's not at all an insult to the genre. but i do associate it with raw, imperfect vocals. shouting around words. but maybe that's just me being ignorant and close-minded. maybe i shouldn't base all my expectations for punk music on the clash and the sex pistols. oh well, i still think that i would enjoy these tracks more if the voice was different. yeah st. jimmy is much better that the first half. why is it joined together, that's so damn annoying. i actually like when they go for a softer rock sound like the start of give me novacaine (also present in boulevard). yeah this song's nice! i also like that it gets progressively louder. and yet again, i hate the fact that these two tracks are joined together. because while i don't dislike she's a rebel, i like give me novacaine so much more the first 40 seconds of extraordinary girl are the most intrigued i've been this whole album, but then the song does a 180 and it's just another song with the same sound (getting kindaaa tired of that). again, this isn't bad, but it doesn't stand out from the rest of the album at all. it's less impressive. i don't know, maybe the lyrics could be seen as appealing. sorry i paused this to listen to a shitty stand-up clip my friend sent me, my god, that made me more excited to get back to this. ok a self-hatred anthem, wasn't expecting that. i like letterbomb better than extraordinary girl but neither one blows me away oh another classic, i gotta respect them for this, wake me up when september ends was my childhood. but again, i'm incapable of thinking critically about it. i'll be honest, i don't think i was made to listen to a punk record that's this long. i'm getting pretty tired of the loudddd guitars. homecoming isn't really an exciting track either, so yeah, kinda waiting it ends. and my opinion didn't change much throughout the track, even though it did change a lot over the 9 minutes. whasername is an interesting closing track. one of the quietest (or better said, not-as-loud) tracks, at least at the start, more reflective, less political, but it still feels like it belongs here. like it. this is another album that was historical for its time, and green day's heyday is definitelly deserved, but some of the themes here are just not as revolutionary today. and i guess that's inevitable. when you make a piece of art that is as political as this album, it's only natural that, when more and more time passes, audiences relate to it less and less. however, it is also true that we can relate to political pieces of different times by learning more about their context. and maybe i'm just not that informed on all the specific contexts that inspired this release. and i'll own that that's my fault. so, to make an actual in-depth review, i'd have to do some research about that. but for now, as a first listen review, this will do. a lot of songs here are good. none are bad. some blend together and are less memorable than others. but overall, i'd say this is a good project! this is another case where the rating system here bothers me, as this album feels too good to be a 3 but maybe not good enough to be a 4? i'll probably end up giving it a 4 but yeah, not the strongest one. my biggest complaints here aren't really about the album specifically, but more directed towards the genre as a whole, which i do enjoy, but in small doses. however, i do think the album could use some more variety in sound. not much here surprised me, as my hears were always getting assaulted by the loud loud loud guitars (the drums too, to a lesser extent). another thing i disliked, as i've mentioned plenty of times at this point, is the joining together of different songs. i'm sure the band had a reason for it, but it's just annoying. there are also a lot of positives, but sometimes it's easier to write about things you don't like. my favourite parts of the album were the ones where the band went off script a bit, like the second part of jesus of suburbia or some of the singles. so, as it stands, there are some stand-outs, and some forgettable moments. but it's good. worth a listen. bye
Better than I gave it credit for when I was a teenager.
Bedre enn jeg husket det som
Green Day's "American Idiot" is an energetic album with powerful lyrics and catchy tunes that make it an enjoyable listen. The band's performance is solid, and the album has a cohesive feel that kept me engaged from start to finish.
Legendary album. Grew up on these songs. Love all of them.
punk meet pop. pop meet punk.
Faktiskt oväntat bra!
So called classic from American rock band. Some classic tunes.
I liked this album a lot more than I expected too. So many popular songs on here. The tracks in the second half felt weaker than the first half but still pretty good and overall enjoyable listen. Favourite Tracks: American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novacaine
Busy yesterday. Do not feel I gave this album the attention it deserved. I did like a couple of songs however
Green day
Great Album.
5/10 Listen, we all like the hits - boulevard of broken dreams & american idiot are iconic, I can't deny that. But i had higher hopes, they use a very samey structure to a lot of songs and it started to feel like a chore. Long live Dookie. Songs added to playlist: - American idiot - Boulevard of broken dreams
I only came about 20 years too late to this but it rocks
solid punk, pretty long songs but cool instrumentals,
Never has been my favourite Green Day album. They were probably quite progressive with their messaging at the time though, which feels more pertinent now
An absolute favourite of mine, and has been for the past 21 years. This album influenced my life in a sense, and it has shaped who I am today. Got me through those tough late-teens. The messags feels more relevant than ever in 2025. The highlight for me is Homecoming: clearly inspired by The Who's A Quick One.
Based
Uma surpresa! Green Day é outra banda que sempre tive preconceito, e mesmo eu tendo a idade pra ter crescido ouvindo eles, não foi o caso. Não esperava nada desse álbum, comecei a ouvi-lo bem despretensioso, e acho que isso me ajudou muito. Fui surpreendido totalmente. Claro, já conhecia os singles mais famosos, a faixa titular e blvd. of broken dreams, mas também, quem não conhece essas canções? Não tenho nada de negativo com esse disco. Muito bom do começo ao fim. Não inovou em nada, mas nem todo álbum precisa ser um Revolver (Beatles). Um disco básico, mas extremamente bem executado. Todo instrumento aqui é tocado deliciosamente. O vocal do Billy é muito bom, ele tem um alcance bom até. Gostei demais das músicas mais épicas, tipo Jesus of Suburbia. Liricamente ele é bem superficial, mas você esperava o que de uma banda de pop-punk? É musica pra voce colocar e bater o pé e mexer a cabeça. Quer profundidade vai ler Tolstoy... Um album classico, e de certa maneira, até superestimado, que eu nunca teria ouvido e dado uma chance se não fosse por esse site. Curti ! 4/5
This was pretty good. I listened to it twice because I enjoyed it so much, but by the end the modern Green Day flavor was a little old. Four stars.
Know it. Love it
It’s got some hits. Holiday is and will always be my fav. Didnt realize allllll their big singles were this album. Doesn’t age all that well for me but not offensive in any way and generally glad I revisited.
I'm absolutely biased as this album came out when I was in high school, but I still think it's great. Super tight musically and consistent with Green Day's signature sound. At the time I found the political slant kind of cringey, and maybe it still is, but it was also prescient, and brave in a way that main stream bands were not being at the time. The double-song format is interesting, and works most of the time. Ultimately I think this deserves it's spot, though it's at best Green Day's third best album.
Really good album, truly made me a fan of the band not just a handful of prior singles. They have had a pretty remarkable career from "Dookie" on. I saw this tour and realized they're legit and not a one trick pony. This album spoke to the frustration people were feeling at the time, very relevant, not just a new set of songs. The title track kicks all kinds of ass and is in your face from start to finish. It was a huge hit and was followed by "Holiday" which is good high energy pop rock, then another absolute early 2000's classic, "Boulevard Of Broken Dreams". "Give Me Novocaine" & "Wake Me Up When September Comes" were both radio friendly hits that boosted this album to insane sales levels. The glue tracks like "Jesus of Suburbia", "Are We The Waiting/St. Jimmy" & "She's A Rebel" are solid and speak to the creative high they were on at the time. The least popular track on the album has over 40M listens, that's telling you about the relevance, hits and popularity of this concept album. For the impact, longevity, hits & relevance this gets 4.5 stars. Definitely T1001 worthy.
Great album. Not as good as when Eli sings it though
Duh. An all time fave even before watching them play it live front to back with Jane and then performing it live essentially front to back. Whatsername is one of my favorite songs ever and it’s not even the best song on the album (although it is probably the best complete song).
fucking love this, no notes, one of my favourite albums of all time
This one has been in my library for a while. To me this was Green Day at their most ambitious. This is an album that needs to be played through front to back. Not that there aren’t killer tracks (American Idiot, Holiday etc) but the whole thing is punk rock opera. I could see both John Lydon (Sex Pistols) and Roger Waters (Pink Floyd) both appreciating this one.
My preferred 2004 pop punk protest album is Shake the Sheets by Ted Leo and the Pharmacists, but honestly 2 decades later I'm just glad an album like this was so insanely popular. Where is this energy at right now?!?!
Since middle school, I've been aware that the album existed - but, I didn't give it a chance until I'm at the end of 25. I'm glad I've finally listened to it.
It was alright.
Haven’t listened to it since high school, time for nostalgia. Holiday and boulevard of broken dreams are 🔥
All down hill since dookie
It shouldn't work. Over the top, cheesy and politics that nowadays feels dated (Bush era protest just feels so funny when I look at the world around me rn). That being said it kinda does work. The tunes are undeniably catchy and it's enjoyable in a sophmoric, high school coded possibly nostalgia biased way. 8/10
Two Green Day albums in a row… I have nothing useful to say about them; it's not bad, just not something that I'd care to actually revisit, or even inspect more closely.
Great punk rock album from the 2000s
Big fan
Weiss nüd rächt - hät scho gueti Lieder debii. Chami trotzdäm nüd rächt aafründe
ufe und abe und ufe glost als chind. papi het gliebt ich lieb uff american idiot isch suuuper pop punk mit politik und JO FIGG BUSH. THIS IS HOW IM SUPPOSED TO BEEE jesus of suburbia isch en 9 minütige punksong wer macht das. de song het sooo viel teil und ich kenn no alli vo vor 20 johr. fr fr. i do t care if you dont haha jaaa und denn de flat 6 abe und denn de megafon JAAA. holiday au riese banger es het mega chords für en "punk" song. schluss vom refrain isch e sekundärdominante? s riff ide bridge slappt extrem? "the representstive from california has the floor" isch i mis hirn tätowiert kei ahnig wiso. boulevard of broken dreams overplayed und so aber guete song. übergang vo holiday i de super. overplayed. MY SHAAADOOOW. ich wird schwach bi dem album hobla. green day gsehnd halt us wie idiote und gebed sich au chli so. s machts denn nochli erstunlicher dass vo ihne öpis chli "hochstehenders" chunt als nume 3 akkörd. are we the waiting isch biiitz seicht. chamer sege. und ha de titel noniiie checkt. st. jimmy stone cold banger geile pop punk. ah wie de mike dirnt mitschreit. und de schluuuusss sie hend riiiffss. wie hets no en tempowechsel mit backgroundchörli i dem song?? so packed. give me novacaine cuute. stimmt nocher mega aggro wieder. ich lieb wie er fiin singt über mega luuti gitarre. haha nocher pedal steel giti jöö. de kickdrum sound isch sooo geil. huere luftig. shes a rebel macht afoch wiiter. BANGER. extraordinary girl macht tabla stuff? isch das en orientalism? edward said seg du. de song nocher selber isch suuuper. da git e herts füfi i calls etz scho. fuck de chindergsang am afang vo letterbombed hetmi gad zruggworfe. rieeeeeeese song FICK. wake me up when september ends au komplett overplayed aber er funktioniert soo guet d bridge isch saauguet. homecoming au afoch wieder 9 minute. aber null langwilig s passiert huuere viel mann und s isch immer catchy. das album het kei schlechti songs? boulevard isch fast de schwächst und de isch halt de popsong. es isch alles poppig aber jo. hammer hammer hammer. rieeeese füfi ha so spass. aaaah stimmt de glöggli teil wow.
AMERICAN IDIOT leider findi s lied selber chli müehsam bzw. au die art vo strophe vo riff --> gsang mit ¼ drum bass --> riff etc. ES ISCH SO NERVIG de refrain hani aber sehr gern omg da isch jesus of suburbia druff?? hmm iwie hanis besser im chopf gha? also s isch guet aber iwie hanis besser im chopf gha holiday findi glaub mit basket case ihres beste lied, ich lieeeb de chorus iwie ischs en funny move, dass holiday und boulevard zemme sind aber es passt schono boulevard isch halt insaaaaaane overplayed aber find es git au en grund, au wenn ich jz rig nie lust han, zums aktiv lose, sehrsehr es guets lied de fill nachem erste refrain isch ih mis hirn BRENNT hahahaha oke ich kenn würkli alli lieder, au wenn ich glaub nonie das album am stuck glost han ok nvm jz tönt langsam alles chli glich DAMN DAS ALBUM GAHT LANG sorry wake me up when septber ends isch doch en banger? han mier e ziit lang ihgredt, dass es ass isch aber ich hans eifach gern und es isch so sanft okii jaaa es chratzt amene 5i aber für das ischmer s züg chli z glich und z lang, sorro
So many bangers!
What. An. Album....A concept album that actually successfully tells a story. I am not sure if I would agree with rock "opera" but it is fantastic. I have never seen the musical, but I'm sure it is also fantastic. Super political and just overall so entertaining. A story about growing up, maturity, and "coming of age." From "Jesus of Suburbia" to "American Idiot" , to "Holiday" and "St. Jimmy" , this album is FILLED with hits and great tracks. I think "Letterbomb" is the climax as they make references to every song and it is SO fun. HOWEVER, "Whatshername" is probably my most underrated track on the album. Finally, every bonus track is SOOOO good (although "Governator" is kinda weak. "Too Much Too Soon" is a top tier song.) The solos are fun, the message is great, riffs are basic (it's punk) but solid, and if you don't like Billie Joe Armstrong's vocals...I don't get it. The ballads ("Wake Me Up When September Ends" and "Boulevard of Broken Dreams") are probably my least favorites on the album, but still so good! Liked Songs: The whole album
liked songs: American Idiot, Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel, Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb, Wake Me up When September Ends Am I crazy for saying this is Green Day's best album? It has plenty of their punk roots but with just enough variety in the songwriting that it doesn't get boring and same-y. 4
There are only a handful of Green Day songs that were released after Kerplunk, this album does not have any of them.
It makes total sense that this became a successful Broadway show.
Ik vond de nummers die ik kende wel leuk natuurlijk, maar de rest deed me niet heel veel. Was er ook naar aan het luisteren tijdens het werken aan mijn scriptie, dus dat zal ook niet geholpen hebben.
Very important & powerful political album, enjoyed it!
Timeless. Love it!
This album was pretty fun. It drags a little by the end but overall it's solid. I forget how much I really like Green Day.
I mean its a classic. One of the most formative albums of my generation. Fantastic hooks, dynamic performance. Green Day just knows how to make fun music that explores something deep and important
Hard rock classique, 4 pour la nostalgie
Surprised to like this more than when it came out originally.
So much better than I remembered! :) Nice, really creative musically, catchy and exactly what it says on the tin. :) I know it's not "real punk" or whatever, but I don't remember them saying it was :) I like it, and 14 year old me is pleased by this development. :)
Whatever. Boring "pop punk" its sincerely just pop rock with a little punk tinge on some tracks. Could never stand this album
Not on board with everything here but there’s a few bangers
Manchmal bisschen lame Lieblingslied: St.Jimmy Unliebstes Lied: Are we the waiting
7/10
Ugh. The only thing worse than regular dumb-and-proud-of-it punk rock lyrics are dumb-but-trying-to-be-deep/political punk rock lyrics. Musically this is fine, but I got all of it that I wanted from Dookie. Wake me up when this album ends.
Raising awareness about American idiocy. Unfortunately not able to stop the spread. Nice try though.
Like many of my age, American Idiot was my first exposure to punk. The singles from this were *everywhere* for the next year or so, which is an eternity when you're 7 years old! Off the top of my head, I can't think of another time that a punk band has had that level of cultural dominance. It's aged better than I'd have expected it to, too.
That's classic
Already heard.
Eh, not my cup of tea. Good energy but very derivative of better stuff and I don't love the vocals.
Classic
I love that there's finally an album named after me
I don't know what I was listening to in 2004, but it wasn't this album and that makes me an idiot, American or not. Awestruck by Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams.
very fun very silly
This was suprisingly nostalgic! I never listened to the full album, just the popular songs. I thoroughly enjoyed this album, it felt so well done and clean to listen to. Although I didn't listen to the lyrics, I appreciate the storytelling aspect behind it! Using creativity and art to voice what you believe in is beautiful.
We Are The Kids Of War And Peace, From Anaheim To The Middle East 1001 Albums Generator 8 (04/14/2025) Even just looking at the track lengths and cover of American Idiot, it was clear that this was not going to be a return to form for Green Day. Gone were the days 2-3 minute pop punk song, filled with lyrics about masturbation, grouchy old dudes, and blowing up planes. This was a new Green Day, one that, fresh off the heels of 9/11 and the Iraq War, would be leaning into the political edge that punk music was built on originally. This was a new Green Day, one that would focus more on songwriting and dynamics than ever before. This was a new Green Day, one that could write a rock opera full of global hits, still playing on rock radio to this day. I was in diapers when 9/11 happened, so it's an understatement to say that I don't truly understand what it was like at that time. In a time when the population (somewhat) trusted that our government had our best interests in mind, at least more than people do now, it was unimaginable to the average red-blooded American that this terrorist attack could be the work of anything other than Islamic terrorists. Of course, we had to go kill them for what they did to our country, it was almost a no-brainer. The 2004 Presidential election, while relatively close, was nowhere near the nail-biter that 2000 was, indicating that America as a whole was still on board with Bush's hawkish foreign policy. Of course, the world has changed now as much as it has stayed the same. War rages on, pushed by corrupt politicians who fill their pockets with the blood of soldiers. But people, especially the young, on the left and right are beginning to realize the folly of war and some even recognize that some combination of Dick Cheney, Israel, and the CIA were fully or partially responsible for the tragedy that happened on 9/11. An album like this would hardly even register as politically edgy nowadays, besides its use of the words "faggot" and "retarded". Of course, an album must be judged in the context it was released. In 2004, this really was quite brave. Green Day were far from the first group to criticize the Bush administration, but this was a group that was not known for being political. Additionally, they were floundering commercially after their sixth studio album, Warning, so the safe thing to do would have been to release a return to form, agreeable, fun album. This is not that. Singles American Idiot and Holiday are both overtly political, and Wake Me Up When September Ends is a slow rock ballad about the death of Billie Joe Armstrong's father, and in spite of this, they were all massive hits. Why? Well, first of all, these songs are catchy as fuck. I remember so many of these choruses growing up; American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, and Wake Me Up most of all. Some of Green Day's finest melodies are on this album. However, while Green Day albums after this would lose the punk and keep the pop, this album has a great balance between the two. The title track, St. Jimmy, and Letterbomb embody the punkier side of this album and show that in spite of what contemporary critics may have said, these boys can still rock. The centerpieces of this story are the second and second-to-last songs on the album, Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming. The former, named after the main character of the album, and by Armstrong's admission, his attempt at making Bohemian Rhapsody of the future, is a nine minute, five-part punk and progressive rock epic that features styles from pop punk to glammy piano rock to theatrical acoustic rock. Hey, we even get some time signature changes. The titular character is a disillusioned American teen, living on pharmaceuticals since his childhood and growing up in a broken home. This "anti-hero" ends the song by leaving his home city. Amazingly, this song was also a single. The latter, Homecoming, is another 9 minute, 5 section track, and was actually written first. My favorite part of this song has to be the nearly rockabilly Tre Cool-led Rock N Roll Girlfriend. This is one of the coolest things I've heard this band do. This song isn't as good as Jesus of Suburbia, but it's underappreciated for sure. While the singles and some other songs are great, the middle section of this album does drag a bit. The run from Give Me Novacaine to Letterbomb is especially boring. Extraordinary Girl wouldn't be out of place on a modern Green Day album, which is not a compliment. Additionally, I don't like how so many songs here are combined into a single track. This is a nitpick, and is specific to the streaming version that I am listening to, but I don't understand why, for example, St. Jimmy, which is exciting and fun, is attached to the bland, plodding Are We The Waiting. This really isn't a big issue but it has annoyed me since I was a kid. American Idiot is not my favorite Green Day album. However, its level of artistic ambition was never met by the band before or since. The good songs are great, but the bad songs are completely forgettable. Overall, 3.5/5, rounded up to 4/5 Favs: Jesus of Suburbia Holiday St. Jimmy Least Fav: Extraordinary Girl
Probably my favorite of all time. So...5
More sprawling in genre than I realized.
A favorite of mine growing-up. Maybe fed up with a couple songs by overplaying it. Fav Songs : Jesus of Suburbia & Whatsername
Unexpected: - I'm giving a written review even though I don't do that anymore - Everyone describes Green Day as punk but they are actually very derivative and polished - I hate most modern "rock opera" / "concept albums" but I like the structure of this one - The two worst songs on this album are the most popular - I hate Green Day but I'm giving this album 5 stars.
It was an interesting mix of a few hits or near misses. and some stuff that was very forgettable
3.5 rounded up. Never listened to the whole album before and didn't realize that they had created a "concept" album. Personally I prefer Dookie, but the themes in this one seem more mature and sadly relevant.
Lots of recognizeable stuff here, and individually, it's not bad, but its all kinda the same and my ears got tired before the end of the album. High 3.
Really good, though the second half isn't nearly as strong.
Jesus of Suburbia started and I thought “oooh, I really like this” followed by “is this song still going?” That basically encapsulates my experience of this album- some really strong tunes but a shade too long.
This is one of those albums that I know people really love, and I simply cannot get into it. I'm not sure if its the over-strummed guitars, or his voice which just doesn't change emotion at all. Whatever it is, i can respect that it's different and it was a sound of my generation but I just can't tune to it.
I thought I had already rated this (playing catch up ugh!!) cuz I'm sure I listened to it recently but I don't mind listening again
this album is awesome. every damn song was a boom from my books. who doesn’t like some green day. 💪💪💪💪💪
Easy 5 stars. One of the few mainstream albums that I think absolutely deserves the sales. It's unreal how many radio staples are on this one album. They could've trimmed maybe a couple on the backside while still having 45 to 50 mins of a flawless album. American Idiot is THE song for me for the George Bush/War on Terror era. Rating: 4.9
3.5/5
Simply incredible. I've listened to this album probably more than any other from start to finish. First album on the 1001 Album listing that I was able to listen to on Vinyl as well Best Song: Jesus of Suburbia Rating: 10/10 (Perfect) Stars: 5/5
Meh. I did what I do whenever I hear Green Day. Go listen to the bands that did it before, did it better. As I'm pretty sure Billie Joe would. Nothing wrong with it.
I like Green Day. This is a very strong album, especially “Wake Me Up When September Ends”, “Boulevard of Broken Dreams” and “American Idiot”.
+: Holiday, St. Jimmy +-: American Idiot, Are We the Waiting, Give Me Novacaine, Extraordinary Girl, Wake Me Up When September Ends, Homecoming, Whatsername -: Jesus of Suburbia, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, She's a Rebel, Letterbomb 4,0/10
This album just never did it for me. Hot topic punk. That was the genre I loved the most back then too. I don't dislike all Green Day, but never got big into this album. All that being said, I respect the popularity they gained from this and the broadway show. 3/5.
better than I remembered
It's a 2 but I hate GWB so I'll bump it up a star
I am a huge fan of this album!
Pog
Not as bad as you think.
Album art:4
4, 7, 11, 13
Green Day’s attempt at prog. Very front loaded. Some good songs but trails off in the back half. Ambitious but doesn’t 100% work. OK but could’ve been great.
Хайп бульвар Брокен Дримс здесь же
Das Album American Idiot der US-amerikanischen Band Green Day wurde 2004 in den Ocean Way Studios in Hollywood sowie in den Studio 880 in Oakland aufgenommen. Die Gruppe, bestehend aus Billie Joe Armstrong, Mike Dirnt und Tré Cool, ist seit den frühen 1990er-Jahren aktiv und bewegt sich musikalisch im Bereich des Punkrocks mit Einflüssen aus Alternative Rock. American Idiot markiert eine konzeptuelle Wendung in der Bandgeschichte. Es handelt sich um ein sogenanntes Konzeptalbum, das eine lose zusammenhängende Erzählung verfolgt. Die Texte greifen gesellschaftskritische Themen auf und spiegeln eine Reaktion auf die politischen Zustände der damaligen Zeit in den Vereinigten Staaten wider. Musikalisch fällt das Album durch eine klar strukturierte Produktion und eingängige Melodien auf. Besonders hervorzuheben sind die Titel „American Idiot“, der als kraftvoller Auftakt dient, sowie die Ballade „Wake Me Up When September Ends“, die sich durch eine ruhigere, persönliche Note auszeichnet. Auch die beiden längeren Tracks „Jesus of Suburbia“ und „Homecoming“ stechen durch ihren Aufbau in mehreren Abschnitten hervor und zeigen eine andere, eher erzählerische Herangehensweise der Band. Das Album bewegt sich stilistisch zwischen treibenden Punk-Rhythmen und melodischem Rock. Die Instrumentierung ist durchgehend klar und energisch, ohne überladen zu wirken. Im Fazit ist American Idiot ein in sich geschlossenes Werk, das sowohl musikalisch als auch thematisch einen klaren Standpunkt vermittelt. Die Kombination aus politischem Unterton, strukturiertem Songwriting und klarem Sound macht es zu einem auffälligen, aber nicht überladenen Eintrag in der Diskografie der Band.
Classic Green Day. While not my absolute favourite style, the punk rock here is very good and pretty much every track is at least solid. Cool concept too.
# Album Name: American Idiot # Artist: Green Day # Rating: 4/5 # Comments: The album starts off well. Dips in the middle. The band is tight as you would expect. Theres four strong singles on the album - american idiot, holiday , BoBD and September ends. The rest of the album isnt bad. Lots of fillers but some decent tracks. Some songs are definitely too long which helps bump the album up to nearly 60 mins runtime. It could have definitely been cut down in areas. But its a good album with a few tracks as good as their early stuff. # Top Tunes: american idiot, holiday , BoBD and September ends # Would I listen to it again? Yes
Balala
Very nostalgic, 15 yo Ninske
Not nearly as fun as their early stuff
I was very familiar with many songs on this album from my youth, but I had never listened start to finish. I was actually impressed- the themes of loss of innocence and dissenchantment with authority are strong and on brand with Green Day. There were also a lot catchy songs (I've always enjoyed Holiday). My only real critique is sometimes they are a little on the nose. Overall- a very good album
I was never terribly interested in the idea of a punk rock concept album, but this works for what it is. 8.9/10 Best Tracks: "Holiday" "Boulevard of Broken Dreams"
One of my all time favorite albums. Green Day does an excellent job portraying the story of the Jesus of Suburbia, St. Jimmy, and Whatshername, along with all of the emotions that go with it.
This album came out when I was in Iraq. My memories of this will always be when I got back listening to it with my friends. I don't know if multi platinum records released by major companies can be political but this tries to be and it is catchy as hell.
Graduation year, who knew this would be the last album my circle of high school friends would be associated with. We hated it, we loved it, we didn’t know how to take it. Good grooves, this was their jump from the cliff. They gained a lot of new fans over this one
This album is truly great. I was a big fan of Green Day when Dookie and Insomniac were current, but I was mostly uninterested in the band by the time American Idiot had come out. This album captivated me when it first came out. It was almost like a new band at that point. The songs on this album are very catchy and satisfying, but the social commentary puts this album over the top. It is timeless at this point.
Huge nostalgia trip. It was fun to revisit an album I bought 20 years ago and gain a new appreciation for it. There were lots of great moments on it that I'd forgotten. I'm not surprised they turned it into a musical.
Formative album for me and still holds up 20 years later. This is Green Day's magnum opus in my eyes. Lots of great commentary but also amazing songwriting. I love the suites in particular.
I remember when this album came out the discourse among my peers was that Green Day "sold out." This was no longer music for losers: Green Day is popular now - time to go back to Bad Religion, The Offspring, NOFX etc. It's funny the lines you draw in your teenage years. This is the first time I've listened through the entire album. I, of course, heard all of the singles. You couldn't avoid them - always clogging up Fuse's music video lineup. The sound aged exactly how I thought it would. It's very much of it's time, and I think that's what makes it an interesting listen. I still prefer Green Day's earlier work.
Harrowing political commentary and highly polished punk feel like such a strange combination to me, which might be part of why this album made such a big splash. It honestly always felt a twinge naïve to me, but maybe I'm even more jaded than most 😅
3 sterne
This may be my favorite album of theirs.
solid. no skips
Great album, front loaded with bangers. Mid section of album a bit aversge. Jesus of suburbia best song on the album
I still remember all the words. Played this record our when it was released
Apt for our current political climate. Haven't heard this album in probably close to 20 years. Rating: 4/5
Några guldkorn
Okay
Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams
This isn't my era of Green Day and I still think of this as "new Green Day" even though we are twice as far removed from this as this was from Dookie. Jesus Christ, I'm gonna die soon. Real solid pop punk record.
All killer, no filler as they say. Great start for my project
This album is an OG!
Green Day went from meandering snot-nosed punks to rock revolutionaries with American Idiot, an album that (eventually) turned suburban disillusionment into a Broadway-sized spectacle. It was loud, furious, and shamelessly ambitious—proof that pop-punk could grow up without losing its bite. Power chords met politics, anthems met angst, and somehow, a nine-minute punk-prog epic (Jesus of Suburbia) made perfect sense. Not every track hit as hard, but when Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, and Wake Me Up When September Ends were on the radio, they were undeniable. Love it or roll your eyes at it, American Idiot was one of the great comeback stories.
Meh
I'm a bit too old to love Green Day. But this album was fun enough.
Iconic. Not, however, good.
I don't like this.
Really good album. Classic Green day.
Objectively great but there's something about the 200s emo rich sound that I just find off-putting. Good to listen to though.
American Idiot Jesus of Suburbia Holiday Boulevard of Broken Dreams Wake Me Up When September Ends
My first selection from the aughts. I think of them as on the better end of radio alternative in the 90s. They are a minor artist. I appreciate them putting in this effort, it's pretty good. (Theme: I appreciate effort.) Another where Must Hear is not quite true. Top marks for the cover art.
Great album. Minus one star because i hate them
5/5 always!
I was discussing this album with a friend, and what it's like to revisit it over 20 years later, and they said "It was very important to me as a young, newly political person" and I agree. I remember listening to some of my peers arguing over whether Green Day were truly a punk band or posers. I hadn't been exposed to any punk music at that point in my life - just conservative politics and Christian music at home. So American Idiot (the song) was truly my first exposure to this type of music, however you choose to define it. It made me start to ask questions I hadn't asked before. And today I'd be able to join the conversation with my peers and say the members of Green Day know better than anyone how the music they set out to make both takes from and breaks from the mold of punk's origins. This is a punk rock opera concept album. And also a pop album. They made something different and true to themselves. Not very poser-like behaviour if you ask me. I'm not even a massive Green Day fan, but this is my second 5 star rating for them, and not just because of the personal significance or because I love a concept album in general. Every song is good if not great, it was a big moment culturally, and the transition from Holiday into Boulevard of Broken Dreams deserves 5 stars on its own.
Feels as relevant, if not more so, now than it did in 2004. Big ups to my dad for buying this back then and being a cool rock dad.
I saw Green Day at Reading Festival about 10 years ago (it was 2013 - ed!) and they played a lot of this album. I knew the 'hits' of course but the whole set was damn good. I thought then I'd seek out some more of their stuff. Of course I didn't, but I wish I had.
Instant 5 star!! 🔥 This is one of the albums that define my teenage years, and I still listen to it. I remember watching the American Idiot music video on MTV and thinking Billie Joe was so cool. What a time to be alive This album was huge. For years I couldn't walk into a HMV without seeing this album plastered all over. Green Day still use American Idiot to make political statements. Wake Me Up When September ends is still a meme. They still play the majority of this album live. You wouldn't think it was over 20 years old This is THE Green Day album. Banger after banger! Hearing those guitar riffs just hit the right part of my brain🤘🏻 Sick album cover. They're also one of the best bands I have ever seen live. Hella Mega tour was insane. They nailed it with this one. Points all round honestly 5 ⭐️
For fucks sake - just give it a 5!
I listened to A LOT of Green Day in my highschool years, but by the time this album came out in my 2nd year of uni, Green Day's sound had become more pop/mainstream and less raw/gritty, and I had become more musically snobby - maybe like many know-it-all artschool kids, or maybe its just me?! This album fell in a gap where I was listening much less mainstream music (even mainstream alt) and thought of myself as very punk/folk so I missed the boat on this album at the time. Its a great album, one I will give a bit more time to now I'm older (but honestly probably not much wiser)! I've always had a real soft spot for protest music - I appreciate bands that can capture the feeling of a moment and tell the government or injustice to fuck right off. Recently watching Green Day play this full album (plus my fave Dookie) on their Survivors tour was a life highlight! It was an incredible concert (wild to get this album and Pearl Jam back to back - both bands I've seen in concert back to back in that order!?!). Bille Joe is an amazing front man and the crowd was heaving, the show was an absolute feast for the senses - I sang and danced my heart out. Loved that they are still political and speak their minds - even changing the words of 'Jesus of Suburbia' and asking if the crowd wanted Elon and Trump to 'shut the fuck up' - nothing quite like hearing 60,000 people roar in agreement! For me this album is about a 4, but the band has been very important to me over the years and I think this album will grown more on me as I give it some more listens, so its bumped to a 5. I ended up getting a bit distracted today with a different album - because at the time this album came out (2004ish) I was listening to another political punk album - also angry at the George W Bush government of the time but I think it holds up pretty well right now given the state of US politics! NOFX doesn't feature on the list, so I want to do a quick shout out because The War on Errorsism is an amazing album well worth a listen. It's ok, allow yourself a little hate Hatred is not so bad when directed at injustice You can turn the other cheek, just don't turn the other way Enemy of the planet we finally have a common hate A reason to forget about our differences And stand as a united front
The first time I've listened to this for many years. I distinctly remember listening to it whilst working in Bristol and having to get the commute by bus... but as everyone else caught on it was so overplayed at the time that even now I will still skip tracks from this album when they come up. It also marked my departure from Green Day really... although I saw the tour show - I've not since bought a Green Day album or seen them live. However, listening to it all the way through for the first time since it came out I thought it was great. Amazed really that the Green Day of 'Dominated Love Slave' went on to create a concept album that got turned into a stage show etc.... excellent.
4/5
Not for me. Something about the vocals.
56/1001 - Some cool melodies here and there but I wish it was played by better musicians.
4.5 I am biased because this was a big deal to 10 year old me. But I think it holds up. Probably the definitive anti-Bush era album. Jesus of Suburbia is still a top tier medly
Iconic album
Really solid album. I think it’s interesting that in the original version so many of the songs were combined with each other. I wonder what the choice was for that because in the 20th anniversary they are all separated and I think that makes more sense overall and it’s easier to digest that way. And even songs that were combined, only half of the song was a single so it’s a weird concept. Great album though.
OMG this album is knock-your-socks off good. Green Day took no prisoners with their hard-hitting lyrics and those damn good beats. The messages behind "American Idiot" or "Jesus of Suburbia" are so great that I forget it's 2025 and not 2004. And American Idiot is a great example of fusing rock and punk together. This project has shown me that it's the rare artist who can make banger political songs. The only less-than-great item I noticed was that the second part of the album drags on some. The excitement of the first half was so high, and it was noticeably absent in the second half. But to be completely fair, that first half is absolutely iconic 21 years later, and it seems cruel to compare the best fruit to the OK fruit.
Wow, it was a trip to revisit this album in full. I was a teenager when this came out, and it was definitely the sound of an era. As the era of "pop punk" was ending, but before the emo craze took off, teenagers were feeling a specific kind of angst, and this album captured that angst. Green Day comes in and does what they do best, with a more polished, more 2000s spin. And it worked. This album was an absolute craze and several songs from the album have persisted in the music space and are still commonly heard. Probably a 3.5 for me personally, but due to the nostalgia it drummed up AND the timeliness of this album as it pertains to current American idiot behavior, I'm rounding up.
I’ve recently gotten really into Green Day so a couple of months ago I listened to this in its entirety for the first time. I didn’t get the hype, the mega hits from it were good but the rest of the album felt kinda meh. I felt Dookie and (perhaps controversially, idk) 21st Century Breakdown were better. Flash forward to Saturday, March 1 2025. I saw Green Day live for the first time ever for their Saviours tour. The set list for this show had both Dookie and American Idiot being played in their entirety for the 30th and 20th anniversaries of each album respectively. I was blown away and suddenly, I got it. Hearing this album, live and in full, changed my perspective. This album fucking rocks and I suddenly found myself enjoying some of the lesser known tracks (I still think Jesus of Suburbia is a bit overrated and too long). Suddenly Whatsername was part of my regular rotation, Homecoming hit different. This album was a 3/5 when I listened to it for the first time a few months ago. Now? It’s a solid 5/5, I fucking love this album. I still think Dookie is better but I view this album much more favourably than I did before!
Incredible wall of sound. Unrelenting angst and emotion.
The lyrics and theme feel kind of detached from me. Tones are good but something is somewhat sterile production-wise.
The world would not be worse of without this record as musically there's nothing here you wouldn't have heard elsewhere beforehand, albeit probably in a less watered down way. Then again every generation shall have their copycat history-repeating acts. Hey, there was a time I believed Sha Na Na were a relevant contribution to music history. Regarding their overal global pop market conquering strategies Green Day certainly proved themselves to be winners. It just doesn't make the music any more original. Well done and of relevance for quite a few people I guess so that#s an extra star from me for that.
It's so hard for me to keep reviews of albums like these objective because they have such a strong place in time and are so nostalgic. That being said, I think it still holds up. Sure some songs are longer than they need to be and there is some meandering in the lyrics but it still hits. Jesus of Suburbia has a nice little breakdown in there, would have been stronger cut at the halfway point after the little I don't care interlude (though the little somewhere over the rainbow interlude shortly after it's nice too). Don't love how there are a lot of split songs as a lot of these are really strong with one and not as strong with the other (looking at you Give Me Novacaine/Rebel Girl) and would be nice to not have to have both.
I dont get how Green Day have held on to such a big place in American culture - Dookie was amazing, Brain Stew was pretty good, but that Good Riddance song gave them a ruinous taste of sincere balladeering and since then it's been a long steep decline. This album was their big return to the spotlight - an Anti-Bush pop punk opera that is just as embarrasing as that sounds. They still have a nice bright overdriven guitar sound and some decent riffs as well as a gift for a catchy vocal melody, but they're totally wasted on this. Turgid slow tempos turn into forced sped up breakdowns, bombastic production, bloated song writing (8 minutes! 8!), corny arena rock climaxes. The lyrics are pure dumb guys making a statement stuff. Honestly, their songs about teenage disaffection, smoking and jacking off offer a more profound insight into suburban American culture and alienation than this overblown grandiose turd. When Sept Ends is truly abysmal - I know I 've heard this before, but it is so much worse than I could possibly have imagined, how was THIS their return to the bigtime? Good lord this whole thing just sucks so bad.
it's good. too bad I'm bad at paying attention to lyrics and their meaning. I'm sick of hearing "Wake Me Up When September Ends"
someone once told me that I remind them of the song Holiday from this album and I don’t know how to feel about that honestly
Trash
Great album! Starts off with the banger American Idiot. Holiday is a ton of fun. Boulevard Of Broken Dreams is awesome. Give Me Novacaine is also nice. And then the incredible Wake Me Up When September Ends, which I've always loved. Only duds are Jesus Of Suburbia and Homecoming, both of which start off nicely, then kinda drag on. Overall, love this album, rock on! Best song: Wake Me Up When September Ends
I'm really interested in what everyone thinks of this album. I listened to it a LOT when it came out and I was interested to see how it holds up. I have to say, I think the answer is "pretty well", I genuinely like the songs and am enjoying listening to the album. Also, remember when the biggest thing we had to worry about was Bush the Younger? How quaint.
I’m not going to pretend I’m a longtime Green Day hater, Dookie was one of the first CDs I bought. That said I don’t love this album, but it’s not that bad either. Classic 3 stars, I think Green Day’s best songs are their snotty punky stuff and there just isn’t enough of that on this album for me.
My wife loves this album. I’m lukewarm on it. But I’ve always been fairly lukewarm on Green Day in general. Y’all ever heard of Rancid? If not, go give them a listen…
I mean, I kinda hate to say this -- this is a pretty good album in my eyes.
10/10 no notes perfect album
Good new punk! :)
This is a perfect album. I love that Green Day has been fighting the fight against our fascist government for as long as they have, and they haven't switched up, not even once. Every song on this album is dripping in nostalgia, amazing instrumentation, cool lyrics, and just pure talent. I absolutely love this album. 5/5, no notes.
Great Album
BJA is a douchebag USA hater. I love the band, but cannot give a great review to them.
07/03/25 I didn't ever think I would give this album 5 star, but most of the songs hit differently. I guess it helps having a bad run of albums too.
3.5 - Good
clasicazo adolescente
Great album I think this is their best!
I have a bias against this album and band. So my reviews won't be very objective. To me. This is just fraudulent punk rock. It lacks sincerity. But again I'm biased.
If this is the last punk album to break through into the cultural mainstream, at least it goes out on an unbelievable high.
Liked this a looott more than their last album I heard! A ton of iconic tracks on this album, most of which still feel very relevant today.
When Green Day (not punk rock) was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame (questionable), Fall Out Boy (extremely not punk rock) listed off a list of their punk rock bona fides (a not very punk rock thing to do), including their contribution to a Green Day Broadway musical (I’m not sure there’s anything less punk rock than a Broadway musical). Like their contemporaries The Offspring and Weezer, a band with incredible promise that really plummeted. This album is about as interesting as under seasoned mashed potatoes.
"American Idiot" is a modern rock opera about the disillusionment and hopes of American youth. Although the specific subject matter is vastly different, many themes from this album remain relevant in 2025, such as the disproportionate influence of the wealthy over government and reality television creating superficial fame. Following three underwhelming albums after "Dookie" ("Insomniac," "Nimrod," and "Warning"), along with another album that was abandoned, Green Day's "American Idiot" emerged as a bolder and more lyrically confrontational experience than its recent predecessors, channeling feelings of anger and frustration all wrapped in scathing wit. The evolution of Green Day on this album is evident by their shift in perspective. Instead of focusing on the frustrations of their own personal experiences within society, they leverage those experiences to look at broader societal issues. This approach had them largely set aside their pop sensibilities in favor of embracing more of the spirit and essence of punk. The album structure is also strong, filled with catchy hooks, powerful guitars, smashing beats all enhanced by the dynamic chord progression found in various song chapters, with "Jesus of Suburbia" serving as a prime example. I loved this album when released in 2004. And I still do. Also, it just rocks! Who doesn't love an album that rocks?
listened before, some good songs but not my favorite genre
Iconic, one of the defining albums of the 00s for sure. Easy 5 for me, just a great listen, Billy and crew are in top form here. Also helps that it was produced by the great Rob Cavallo.
I remember when this album came out. It had such a massive impact being one of the first anti-war albums of the early 2000s and speaking out against George W. It’s weird to think it’s been over 20 years at this point. I remember it was also controversial because so many people in the punk world said that Green Day had sold out. But by contrast, they made punk accessible and resurrected it from a burn-hot-&-die-out genre that it had become. Was it more commercial? Yep! But in doing so Green Day allowed bands like Blink-182, Against Me, My Chemical Romance, Sparta and others to find success in the 2000s. This album is truly a classic for so many reasons I think this listen my favorite songs were the one that I didn’t hear is frequently such as Are We the Waiting and Extraordinary Girl every once in a while, it’s fun to pull this one off the shelf and give it a listen.
Random thoughts: * I saw this album performed live this past summer. It wasn't as fulfilling as hearing Dookie in its entirety live. * On this more critical listening I found several songs that were better than I ever remembered: "Are We the Waiting" "Give Me Novacaine" and "She's a Rebel". * Just like when listening to it live, Homecoming is too long. It just doesn't hold me. * This album should be a classic to me but it never really captured me the way it has others. Maybe I need to spend more time with headphones and reading lyrics. I like this album but always feel like I should LOVE it. It's still pretty good.
This came out in my freshman year of high school and greatly shaped my music taste after. Always a no-skip album for me.
I wasn’t sure how I would feel about this album because I’ve always found Punk stuff to be edgy just to be edgy but apparently I was just looking at the wrong people because this was really good, my only critique was for some reason the vocals erked me occasionally, but apart from that I was still impressed by this everything else on this project. Favorite Tracks: Bouevard of Broken Dreams, Extraordinary Girl, Wake Me Up When September Ends, and Homecoming. P.S: The Apple Music Animated Art is awesome and probably one of the best ones I’ve seen lol
This album is a punk/rock/pop tour de force. Bristling with killer punk rock licks and insightful social commentary, yet still somehow manages to be a mostly upbeat, foot-tapping sing along. Something about pop punk scratches an itch for my OCD tendencies where everything in the songs just fits together perfectly. I often rail on albums in this project for unneeded instrumental noodling, and well-written pop punk like this is the absolute antithesis of that type of music. The title track is somehow more relevant today than it was in 2004 and is a straight up banger. The thing that gives the songwriting such depth is that Billy Dee and the boys are writing about the hole that had formed at the center of American life. The party of the late 1980s and 1990s was over, and it was pretty clear even in 2004 that the American Dream had morphed into a race to the bottom to see who could accumulate the most money before the music stopped. And all of this was BEFORE the social media era. American Idiot is a kick ass album from a band at the absolute top of its game. 5 stars.
Mwa, niet denderend
Amazing rock masterpiece. One of the greatest records ever made.
Not my cuppa tea but I can definitely see the appeal
Don't love punk, but wake me up when september ends - amazing. As a whole I just feel like this album was made for weird teenagers in the 2000s.
Somehow this is another one of those albums I have never listened to in full. I was in a different place in terms of what I was listening to and personal ongoings. So it was cool to remedy this and finally give it a listen. The album is great start to finish, but I think I’ll keep Dookie at the top of my personal Green Day faves.
Great album, lots of great songs.
Naim seems to like it
Liked mostly because of nostalgia but Dookie is better
not a bad album by any means but it's just not for me - it feels very repetitive and I understand the rebellion aspect but it doesn't really dive into what they're rebelling against... I don't know it just feels a but surface level when other artists really dive in and make you think about things instead of just 'north american society = bad'
nope
Awesome!!
The songs here just don’t do as much for me as the ones on Dookie. Certainly more conceptual and daring, but not particularly better.
Pretty good
Took me back to year 7!
12 year old me thought Dookie was the shit (pun intended) for its anger and punk sensibilities, by the time American Idiot appeared, 22 year old me thought this was pop punk at its most anodyne, bland and mainstream and i had nothing but youthful distain for it. Coming back now was a really interesting experience. It still is pop punk with every edge rounded off, its music a left wing politician claims to like when they dont like music and your mum would gladly sing along on Radio 2. However, i cant deny that they can write a jaunty pop tune with a decent hook. Most impressively, this album is littered with lyrics that resonate now (start of Trump 2) more than ever. For that reason im giving it a binus star and hope it gets more play.
Worst album, i`ve ever heard. Loved it - 10/10
Overrated
Simple, great songwriting. The last real concept album?
I don’t love the genre, but band is good, and this is a great album
Boulevard of broken dreams and wake me up when September ends are the only two I like, and probably wouldn’t revisit too much in general - good effort lads!
Not bad but a lot of corny pop-punk. Many, much better political pop-punk records that actually have something to say other than Bush bad.
Capitalism, according to various thinkers concerned with the cultural mode of postmodernism, is fantastic at absorbing its critique. So good that it often goes one better – commodifying the terms of its deconstruction, always-already negating its critics … to the extent that if they’re especially charismatic and/or unlucky, they’re turned into t-shirt designs. In the early 00s, Greenday was smarting. “Warning” had represented a doomy portent only to the band themselves: they were in danger of becoming obsolete. Greenday huddled, began tracking a new record … and then the tapes were stolen. It’s a sliding doors moment, as had they released “Cigarettes…” they might have disappeared forever. Instead they scrapped the project and began working on what would become “American Idiot”. And the rest is history; or, as the angel of history might put it (and in more ways than one), “a bad record.” As the angel sees history piling up before her, destructive winds driving her forever backward, this album can boast a mounting body count of better artists and their ideas. Here there’s melodies lifted from Bryan Adams, Joann Jet; riffs and ornamentation seemingly lifted completely (surely Dillinger Four got an out of court settlement?); and then – not content with having “musically quoted” from The Kinks on the abortively boring “Warning” – there’s the one where our Anglophile magpies return to Blighty to the answer the question of “what would happen if ‘How soon is now’ was also ‘Wonderwall’?” I wouldn’t mind it – in fact I might even enjoy it – if it weren’t for the fact that it feels so nakedly cynical. Everything about this album feels like the result of focus group testing: the “emo” uniform, the accusatory anti-government stuff (“this trended great with the NOFX kids, Bill, just consider it”), the “concept” of a “Jesus of Suburbia” – a figure who might be the target persona of this elaborate marketing action brought to musical life. And then there’s the “punk rock opera” element: songs that blend into one another, a creative choice that feels grafted onto the whole thing late in the piece after someone noticed that everything’s in pretty much the same key. It’s enough to have one wondering whether the “American Idiot” being narrated isn’t actually you, the listener, for ever letting yourself think that this meant anything more to Greenday than revivified album sales numbers. So, while I’ve been trying to keep my cool through this review, I also need to be fair to myself: this felt fucking lame in 2004 and it feels fucking lame now. This is not an album of rebellion, these are not songs of resistance or hope. This is a pastiche of punk, the sound of the end of history. There is no alternative. Suburbia’s soundtrack is the only game in town. For 15-year old Matthew’s sake, here are three albums released in or before 2004 that I loved back then, succeed where American Idiot fails, and actually should be on this list: “Sticks and Stones” by New Found Glory (pop-punk that looks for you, finds you, and stays with you; actual magic); “Casually dressed and deep in conversation” by Funeral for a Friend (the ultimate melding of post-hardcore and emo, unapologetically hi-fi and edifyingly anthemic); “Tell all your friends” by Taking Back Sunday (atmospheric, antagonistic, bratty, brash, brilliant – gigged into shape, never knowingly focus-grouped).
I’ve dropped this ‘dote many a time, but my after school routine for a full year was to get home & sit my ass down infront of the TV to play dynasty warriors and listen to this full album on a loop. For real though this is like time travel to me, instantly I’m at the back of the class with my head in my hands stressed about why Lauren won’t talk to me. It’s the high school waster album. It’s not exactly musically complex, but I do love that since it was written as a rock opera experiment before actually becoming one so much of it is musical theatre coded. songs like extraordinary girl and letterbomb as well as the more long form songs feel like there should be a company with them.
One of the first albums I loved. In spite of corny Bush-era lyrics - which I can quote like a priest from a bible - it still sounds great now. Everything from American Idiot to halfway through Homecoming could be a lead single (and most of them *were* singles). The final 1.5 songs are good, but lack the singable choruses and catchy riffs. American Idiot was my introduction to Green Day, and while I love some of the earlier stuff, every subsequent album never struck a chord with me (¡Tré! anyone?) It's fine though, I found my religion: I'll forever be kneeling at the altar of St Jimmy in the Church of the Jesus of Suburbia. Final note: noticed the songs are doubled up in Spotify, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams for example. I hope Green Day are getting all the pennies that should be coming their way.
I wish I could come into this with fresh eyes but twenty years on I think that's impossible for anyone my age. I've heard this countless times in cars, TV, radios. It's simply impossible for me to not have some strong opinions on at least a third of this album. I can't believe how much I went into this with a dislike for many songs for how much they rip. It's hardly surprising but I cannot believe Boulevard won me over. Are We Waiting is a bit of a weak followup though. I do not remember Extrordinary Girl at all. Contrasting to this I have had the start of Letterbomb stuck in my head for 2 decades and only now have I learned where it has been from. I could do without Wake Me Up When September Ends but I cannot truly hold that against this album. I don't hate it in the context of this album but I'd be okay if I never heard the song again, which isn't even a slight against the song itself! All in all this has been a surprising enjoyable jaunt down memory lane. It has been at least a decade since I've listened to this album and it's been a delight.
Really enjoyed listening to an album for my childhood. Brought a lot of memories back. Was great actually focusing on it and listening to all of it.
Green Day - American Idiot This type of music reminds me of early 2000's The Mars Volta. This is soo good. And from what I heard, Green Day has made better albums than even this. This album is packed with fun moments, great riffs and catchy hooks, overall this is really great! 1.- American Idiot = 7/10 2.- Jesus of Suburbia = 10/10 3.- Holiday = 8/10 4.- Boulevard of Broken Dreams = 9/10 5.- Are We the Waiting = 9/10 6.- St. Jimmy = 8/10 7.- Give Me Novacaine = 9/10 8.- She's a Rebel = 7/10 9.- Extraordinary Girl = 8/10 10.- Letterbomb = 8/10 11.- Wake Me up When September Ends = 10/10 12.- Homecoming = 8/10 13.- Whatsername = 7/10 FINAL SCORE: 8.3/10
This is one of those records that I come back to occasionally, knowing full well that it never fails to bring a smile to my face. I’m not a huge fan of the radio singles off this one, however there are some very bright deep cuts, songs like “whatsername” and “St Jimmy” are some of the best music Green Day ever released. What I really want to talk about is the rock opera contained within this album, “Jesus of Suburbia”. At over nine minutes, it’s a far cry from the minute and a half punk rock songs of yore. It is however, as I believe, the single best work that Billie Joe Armstrong has ever created. I can understand criticisms of this track that I’ve seen, people saying the metaphors are weak, and it’s not real punk rock, but I just don’t care. It’s a product of its time, and it’s really an accurate reflection of how young folk were feeling about the world at the time. The section of this song beginning at “Dearly Beloved are you listening?” Is my personal favourite, the simplicity of it musically combined with the brevity of the lyrics really tickles a specific part of my brain. I really like this whole song and I think it alone is worth five stars. Unfortunately I have to take a star off this album due to the incessant and never ending airplay that “Wake Me Up When September Ends” got when it came out.
Someone got a new kick drum for christmas and wrote a whole album to show it off!!! :) The political/social "commentary" on this album feels really juvenile and there is a lot of it. There's also a couple tracks that just feel like the band decided "hey, it would be fun to have some really long songs" and just slapped together various snippets into 8-9 minutes of half-baked musical ideas. Billy Joe Armstrong's vocal affectations are weird. I don't think this album merits much more serious consideration. I will say that it reminds me that in the early 2000s, we really did feel like our political landscape was as clownish as it could possibly be, which in retrospect is hilarious and sad.
Good
Good album full of energy listened twice
That's just not possible. What kind of albums are they suggesting to me? 'Pippi Pop Punk' by Vorstadt Kids. I hate it. There would probably be more of a punk attitude if they had peed the songs on garbage cans. No, I really can't do anything with that. Apart from that, I can't do anything with any "Green Day" release that I know of. That's something for the garbage can of music history.
i’m not the biggest fan of pop punk, but this certainly has its fair share of nostalgic 2000s tunes and fun deep cuts. solid 3.5
This whole album is a huge nostalgia hit for me. This is truly the first album I ever remember being introduced to and certainly the first time I heard the f-word in a song
This is pretty good, not really for me but there are a few really solid songs on here.
Iconic, I’m biased but really great full album and even more relevant than when it was released
Great album that I haven't listened to all the way through before, will listen again
I’m more of a dookie fan but fun album.
Wasn’t hugely impressed by this, largely blended into one. However, Holiday / BoBD is still stunning, what a transition. For that reason it’s a 3/5
I remember in 2003 listening to this on a Normandy history trip, I stared out the window at war graves with boulevard playing thinking it was the deepest point of my life. Was a sad act but what a way to reminisce. Mostly belters, easy 5/5
Expected to give this a 2 or lower, but it’s a 3. Had only heard the singles back in the day - didn’t even realise Holiday was from American Idiot. Managed to miss Greenday completely in my punk phase, I guess because the narrative was they’d already gone commercial? It’s an ok album, never really boring.
да, такой панк конечно это не совсем моё :) бодрая музыка и можно даже сказать весёленькая песенка holiday прикольная :) бульвар разбитых мечтаний мне нравится, за неё одну уже этот альбом можно оценить хотя бы на 4
First time I’ve actually listened through this album. Was pleasantly surprised how good it was aside from the hits everyone knows. What a delight!
Good pop punk record
Only really enjoyed 2 of the 4 songs I knew. But can’t really deny the success of those 4 smash hits. Curious how I would’ve felt about them if I hadn’t heard them so many times on the radio before today. Dookie was the first album I ever bought with my own money, and will at least get 4 if not 5 stars if it comes up. This just seems way more commercially produced and frankly not as good. Still I can’t say it wasn’t listenable.
Dookie is one of the most influential albums of my life. This is not Dookie. Ambitious, maybe, but that didn't make for good listening for me. Each song I was hoping to be the last and there'd be another. And another.
OK, I'll admit I don't know much of anything from Green Day since they left Lookout records and were a cheap rip off of Ramones and Cheap Trick. This... is... rough. It's wildly overproduced milksop powerpop. While it has its moments, it's for the most part forgettable. I don't feel enough to say I hate it, but I would NEVER think to ever put this on to listen to.
One of my FAVORITE albums as a teenager, and revisiting it today was a blast.
I will die on the hill that this is a near perfect album
american idiots
Great back to basic punk.
Whatever I say, is not enough. Teenage years banger. - 10/10 music - 53098347190/10 feels
The energy is amazing, already liked boulevard of broken dreams, when September ends. Homecoming is my pick of the album, great song!
Before I discovered music of my own, my conduit to music was, like many, my parents. I learned, mostly through my musician of a father, to love The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Deep Purple, and Led Zeppelin. Especially Led Zeppelin. I grew such a fondness for the certain songs that I knew of those bands, and would later grow to love their greater discographies. But that only came after I found music of my own. Music my dad didn't know and didn't introduce me to. Music that I made my own and that I learned everything there was to know about. In 2004, that happened. But even still I needed some help. I was 11 in September that year, having just started sixth grade. My older sister, who was 14 at the time, was much more hip to modern music than I was (in that she was at all) and one day brought home this album from a band I'd only vaguely heard of - Green Day. She told me it was big, and that it was causing some kind of controversy. I think I saw the music video for the title track soon after. I had no idea that there were still rock bands out there, doing rock band things. Everything I'd heard to that point was old stuff. But here was something new. Something that felt like it was for me. I took off from there. Green Day was, as they were for many, my gateway band. My musical taste quickly expanded beyond the bounds of my parents' generation, and became this sprawling landscape of various genres and artists. It's still expanding today (helped in the last year or so by this project, thank you very much). I give you my life story because I feel it important to give you context. I hold this album in such high regard that it's impossible for me to be objective. I have heard this album hundreds of times. I have seen Green Day in concert five times (most recently on the anniversary tour of this album, where they played it in full). This album is as familiar to me as an old leather jacket is. It fits like a glove. It is so familiar that I can start it, zone out, and then zone back in and I haven't really missed anything because I know it front to back. I can't hear anything new in it anymore. I love the band and this album with all my musical heart and this was never going to be anything but a five star review. I tried to write one, but I don't think I can really, properly do it. That requires some objectivity, Which, like I said, I don't and simply could never have. And I'm ok with that. This being the first album I truly loved that was my own, it has always been the way it is. To analyze it or criticize it is so difficult for me, and honestly doing so would probably dampen my feelings toward it. So I'll stop trying and just tell you that I fucking love this album. I tried to write one before giving up, and that's below if you have any interest. Standout Tracks: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday, Are We the Waiting, St. Jimmy, Give Me Novacaine, Letterbomb, Wake Me Up When September Ends, Homecoming Green Day has never done anything better than this, before or since. They've produced great music, don't get me wrong. But this is the pinnacle for them. And what a high it is. Let's start with what is, for me, the two highlights of the album "Jesus of Suburbia" and "Homecoming." The two 9+ minute songs. I have criticized bands like Yes and Emerson, Lake, and Palmer for having these crazy long songs that feel like the stringing together of ideas for the sake of salvaging a few half-baked concepts. The 9+ minute tracks on this album do not strike me that. Each tells different parts of a story (pretty key parts, honestly), and the different sections help to differentiate those parts. I love them and think they're the band's best work, period. The rest is just such a diverse set of tracks that tell a story. What that story is up to interpretation and honestly, I'm not sure the band quite knew what it was when they finished it. But it's secondary to the music, in my opinion. The music takes precedence here. Except of course for the anti-war, anti-government messages of the title track and "Holiday."
4.5
the music is very entertaining. Head banging punk rage, with a unifying operatic theme. Plenty of creative innovations.
I’m just glad Billie Joe and Dick Cheney made up and are now on the same team! Music - 3.75 How punk are they - 0.00
I think this album is just ok but wouldn’t list as a top album to hear before I die
Newer Green Day sucks nuts
One of the few examples of a "concept album" in my lifetime that doesn't come off as forced. Green Say reinvented themselves with social commentary that is still relevant today. The way the songs tie together was really well done, and I respect that even on the streaming version, they lumped songs together to avoid the interruption of a track change.
An extraordinarily solid album and also my introduction to Green Day. I saw "American Idiot" when it was premiering at Berkeley Rep and LOVED it, so this album has a fond place in my heart. That being said, I still think that "Dookie" is their best album.
One of the more formative albums of my lifetime. A perfect blend of punk with a more mature sound that makes for an incredibly satisfying listen. Lyrically somehow even more relevant than when it was released 20 years ago. Quality songs throughout, and a pretty decent story as well; the songs work perfectly together and as standalone tracks. Such a joy to kick back and listen to, and no real low points or skippable songs.
A classic. Glad to finally listen to more than just the singles. The rest of the album is just as good or better. Love the final track
I don’t care about the concept or any of that nonsense, this is just a decent listen. Slightly uneven quality but there are some classics in there. Not punk though but whatever
4.5
I’m not the biggest Green Day fan but this album was a favourite when it originally came out. Been forever since I’ve listened to it in full but it still holds up to this day.
Masterpiece. Nothing more to be said.
I like the record and obviously have added one song to my repeat list. But it doesn't register as a fantastic record to me.
The timing of this could not be a coincidence (Trump - Week 1)
Ahahahaha I don’t need to listen to this again. This album altered my brain chemistry when I was 13 years old. It can have the 5 stars. 😂
Never really my thing, but I think Green Day might be a great band.
Surprisingly good
American Idiot, a quasi topical political issue in the year 2025! In other words, at least for some typical American ideas.
Free skip.
I like this album. I’ve never listened to the whole thing before but am familiar with almost all the songs. Less energy than their first album but right up there with that one because of the more complex transitions and concepts. Didn’t realize that it was a concept album
Oh hey it's Green Day. Wow they are very popular. For me, this album is ok, I do enjoy a concept American Idiot is a great opener and I did enjoy Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams. Wake Me up When September Ends has a nice vide but the rest of it is pretty mediocre.
I have no strong relationship with this album - I think my media bubble had started to crystallize around this time so I didn't find the singles too omnipresent. Yeah, it's alright I suppose. Nothing too horrible, but not a lot of it really sparks my interest either. Probably rates a 3, but I'm gonna bump it up to 4 as the title track is pretty zeitgeisty now that Trump's second term is underway... 🤦 Fave track - "American Idiot" by a mile...
Solid. Dependable, consistent enough.
Just raw fucking awesome album. I forgot how much I love this album. The stuff I didn't recall is how they just break from the hard shit into piano and shit and slow it down and mix it up. Jesus of Suburbia is just awesome. I forgot all about that song. I know a lot of this album but was psyched to listen to the shit i've never heard a lot like Jesus of Suburbia, Are We the Waiting (awesome song). Jimmy. Jimmy - jesus my hand got tired listening to it with all those downstrokes lmao - reminded me of some older Ramones stuff - awesome. Incredible chord changes - just awesome. Enjoyed almost every song on this album. I think Novacaine was probably the only one that was a bit meh - but even that was fine. Letterbomb is awesome, never heard that. Favorites are probably Jesus and September but honestly, this is another one of the very few albums I can listen to start to finish without any issues. Awesome album!
I loved this album so much! I’ve listened to Green Day a lot growing up, but for some reason never listened to this entire album. So many new songs have been added to my liked songs. This was an easy listen through and through and honestly just a classic.
Incredible album with a somewhat relevant theme again. Love the pissed off undertones towards a government controlled by propaganda (regardless of what side you align with). The music is incredible, the lyrics are incredible, just a perfect punk rock album. I saw that this was their sixth album which was a big surprise to me and I’m not sure much of their earlier stuff was popular but this broke through and is rightfully regarded as one of the best rock albums from the 2000s. Favorite songs were AI, Jesus of Suburbia, and When September Ends, but there is no skips on this album.
imagine being 17 in 2004 and hearing holiday into boulevard for the first time, calling your parents American Idiots, deciding to be a rebel and be dangerous, and rocking out. What an album.
Fun to listen to
First? 4/5 Again?4/5
One of the first albums I ever loved, and I therefore must give it a 5
Classe one at this point. Not as good as Dookie, but it’s still a good album 3 stars
7/10. Some classics.
I did not use a private session in Spotify for this one. Good solid rock album, couple of classics.
This album came out when I was eight years old. I wasn't really paying much attention to...what was going on in the world at the time. Sure, I had a basic idea, but my main focus (as a child) was, you know, on making it through elementary school! Now, though? I'm nearing 30. I'm in the US. This album is so damn relevant it's ridiculous. On a musical note, I prefer this over Dookie - I'm a big fan of long-ass rock songs, so I get the complaints from some people, but for me, this is a solid record and still one of my favorites in Green Day's discography.
Literally magnum opus
Fast, loud and boring. Did nothing for me.
Erstes Album dass ich jemals ganz gehört und gehabt habe
Nostalgic. Bangers. I liked the songs that weren’t hits too.
This was a pretty album for me in 2005. I still enjoy it to this day. 4.5
Clasic, iconic. Nothing can be said that has not been said before.
Nostalgia! I was way too young to see the musical on Broadway for my birthday in 2010
Would listen again; have always loved Green Day’s sound and this album came out right as i started college so the nostalgia is high; plus i just like it anyway! Favorites: Holiday, boulevard of broken dreams, st. Jimmy, American idiot.
A few slurs in this eh? I appreciate that I got this right before Trump’s 2nd inauguration and the launch of his shitty meme coin. Fuck Trump and the Oligarchy including his billionaire puppet masters. 3.23
Is now a good time to mention how Johnny Test stole American Idiot for its theme song?
For my money, American Idiot stands as one of the major rock-as-art achievements of all time. https://open.substack.com/pub/richcain/p/project-1001-american-idiot-by-green?r=4ztyq&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
Great album. I remember when it came out. Still holds up
Very good
This was an album that i knew about. Truly awesome
This is one of those albums where I've heard most of the songs, but never listened to it as a cohesive album. I can relate pretty well to the disillusionment of growing up in suburbia around the time this came out and after. It captured the way the world was headed.
Fantastic
This is like meeting a friend you haven't seen since kindergarden in the first week in college where everyone is super pretentious and you finally see a familiar face. Even though I haven't listened to this Album for a long time, I had a good time with it then and now.
While being very of the time, it still feels fresh. A nostalgic and solid concept album
Perfect encapsulation of early aughts atomization & disillusionment. Somewhat translatable to the current political environment. Ended Neoconservatism. Stand Out attacks are “Holiday” and “Give Me Novacaine”.
Absolutely killer punk rock/alt rock blended album. I couldn't even come up with what my favorite song. Killer album.