Reviews (page 11 of 15)
Weird music that I wasn’t a fan of
incredible
it was fine
Didn’t make it past the first track.
Hipsters unite! A band named after a steam-powered dildo from the quintessential hipster book ... Steely Dan is basically the 70s' version of LCD Soundsystem. It's a band that all the cool people are into. It's a name-drop in some bar conversation. People who have cassette tape collections and teeny weenie beanies and drink ethically-sourced $8 espressos fucking love Steely Dan. Doesn't mean I don't like them, too.
Solid, a little bit unexciting.
Wunderschöne Musik, Donald Fagans unverwechselbare Stimme, ein abwechslungsreiches Album auf dem Weg vom Roch zum Jazzrock.
nice
Pretzel logic is a bangin track. Rest was ok
5/10 Great opening track. I officially like one Steely Dan song. Mercifully this album is short. so smooth my brain shut off and I found myself drooling. meh. 4-1-2024
Usually like Steely Dan but this album is repetitive and somewhat drones on. Nothing really stuck out.
What a unique and interesting album! Not everything lands, but there is so much neat experimentation and instrumentation on this album, and I absolutely love the vocal harmonies and lead. Nothing overstays it's welcome. This album really makes me want to check out more Steely Dan, which I think is ultimately the point. Fav tracks: Rikki Don't Lose That Number, Charlie Freak, Pretzel Logic, East St. Louis Toodle-Oo
Good album, very steely dan like
This should be an EP -- great songs but also a lot of filler. Great either way. Favorite Track: Pretzel Logic
Seems dull
Un peu en-deça de mes attentes, car j'ai bien aimé les autres albums de leur part. Belle vibe jazz-rock tout le long de l'album.
FUCK, such a cool project. It's got this big blues focus but still retains the jazzy elements they normally bring. It feels front loaded but the second half explores more styles which I loved. I wasn't gonna go 5 but it's just clawed into me.
I love Steely Dan, but this isn’t one of my favorite albums of theirs. It’s still Dan though.
A few solid tunes, but mostly sounds like SD was feeling out what they’d like to to be as a band.
Not bad but not good enough for 4 stars.
3.8 - This was just good solid music in my opinion. Any Major Dude was a great tune and has been in my playlist. I hoping Can't Buy a Thrill is on this list.
Enjoy Steely Dan so enjoyed having it on in the background, but didn't catch my attention in a big way. Wouldn't say it was a stand out album, a few mild boos only. Probably enjoyed the first couple of tracks more than the rest. Not going to go out of my way to listen to it again.
I've got into Steely Dan in a big way the last couple of years, and I've got this record on vinyl, but that being said, its not close to my favourite album of theirs. There are some catchy hooks, and to me its also the point where they are really starting to hone their polished studio sound. But there are also some rather corny moments, and the attempts to experiment with arrangements or styles outside of their typical wheelhouse mostly just fall flat to me. Though I still think its a pretty decent record I don't think its very necessary for the 1001 list. Fave Tracks: Rikki Don't Lose That Number, Night by Night, Any Major Dude Will Tell You, Pretzel Logic 3.7/5
Now we got the bees knees baby! Technical mastery combined with top notch production quality and complex, catchy songwriting just for good measure. This album is perhaps the best and most appropriate example of a certified classic album. Sure, it’s dad rock, but every song here is an ear worm. And every time you come back to it, you’re hearing new layers and discovering something new to love about the music.
A soft baked pretzel is a lot like Steely Dan when you think about it: both pair well with a dad beer, neither ever truly disappoints, and when done just right, they can really hit the spot.
There is not a note out of place. If you like that, then this is the album for you. I'm neutral on it. I find "Pretzel Logic" to be the most accessible Steely Dan album, even if it doesn't have most of the major hits on it. It's a very good listen and I would probably suggest a person who has not heard Steely Day give it a shot. If you hate how perfect Steely Dan is in the studio, then this won't change your mind. I do find this to be as non-grating as Steely Dan can be. They tone down their kitschy and overly-clever (at times) lyrical content and the songs are also shorter. Next is "Katy Lied," which is not a Steely Dan album I would recommend.
Oh yeah, now we're getting into my world. A high school/college classic for me. Not the best Steely Dan album, but definitely an old favorite. 4 stars.
For some reason I’ve avoided Steely Dan, but I really like this. The groove on “night by night” is very nice.
Steely Dan is one of those groups that I know are masterful artists and extremely musically gifted, etc., but that I just don't ever seek out to listen to in favor of other bands. I liked this album well enough, there were a few tracks that stood out as really good, but again nothing I'm probably going to think to come back to later.
Surprised
Super chill with a few classic songs. Still struggle a bit with steely dan's vocals but you can see the detail and precision in their songs.
I like steely dan, but pretzel logic is pretty middle of the road for me.
That clean Steely Dan sound. Lots of unfamiliar tunes for me but enjoyed getting to hear more of the catakog
Great musicians that make music that feels like less than the sum of their parts
Wel nice, vind steely dan wel chill, maar vgm hebben ze betere albums gemaakt wel
Ja goed album, goeie vibe, paar dikke platen
Steely Dan <3 had wel al een keer van dit album gehoord, kende ook al paar nummers maar het hele album in een keer is erg nice
More of the last album, perfectly produced rock, but it lacks the things that make their earlier or later albums masterpieces. B
some classics on there. decent
Jazz stylings over rock without ever approaching prog is a clever sound that really works for the band. 4.0/5.0: Great
very cool musical ideas
mr. pretzel
In my top 15 of all time.
always nice to hear that album...
Enjoyable.
Definitely not my thing and some if the tracks are outright annoying.
Chill! Goede muziek
Drummer killed his mom. Listening to Steely Dan on headphones and trying to hear all the instruments is always rewarding. They fit together like a Swiss clock.
Dumb
Sehr funky, man hörte sich schnell ein. Abwechslungsreiche Instrumentals, vielleicht leicht unscheinbare Vocals aber sie fügen sich gut ein.
Not my absolute favorite but good Dan nonetheless
Like CSN, it's fine/tolerable when it's on. But my god it's bland.
Twisted.
Good, chill album. A little rocky. I added “With A Gun” to the Regulators playlist
Pass
Not knowing what to expect beyond the first track I was already familiar with this was a pleasant surprise. Had the album on repeat all day.
Yikes, 2 Steely Dan albums within 6 days of each other! I was going to give this 2 stars, but I'm warding an additional star for making this album short and sweet. (just 34 minutes) I didn't hate it, probably just a little to close to the previous one. Don't mind bit of the 70's cheese rock.
When I saw this was another Steely Dan album I rolled my eyes so hard I nearly toppled over, but how pleasantly surprised I was by Preztel Logic (terrible name!) I loved this! It put me in such a great mood and although it was a bit cheesy in parts I really got into it! It’s not quite a 5, but I’m making it 5 stars because it’s close and I’ll want to come back to this one later! Or I’m high on paint fumes? Regardless, it was heaps better than the last Steely Dan!
Love Steeley Dan. Band of my misspent youth!
Another fantastic Steely Dan record. I really love the classic rock focused sound on this one, and every tune is a fun to listen to.
Woot! Steely Dan!
A really accomplished version of ‘this sort of thing’ so great if you love that. I liked it.
I didn't enjoy this at all. I think this is what 80yrolds want to hear when they put something groovy on. It's very polished and professional, checks all the music qa boxes. But I don't like his voice or the harmonized voices, and it feels formulaic albiet technically very impressive. It gives me the boredom of slow jazz that gets wild with like 10 8th notes even though it's like sped up it doesn't quicken me. With a gun had sort of rockabilly vibe that almost worked for me except the vocals and lyrics were dumb and contrived. I may especially dislike this bc mom and step-dad played it in my early childhood and it played over a loveless violent household leading me to feel this is the music of deeply broken and dysfunctional people which I'm sure is not at all fair.
2.5
uneventful
my preferred yacht rock. fuck the eagles, this is the music to listen to while wanting to pretend that you're rich in the 70's.
Steely Dan is classic, and always has perfect production. This album has some great tunes but I feel Aja and Countdown To Ecstacy are stronger showings than this one
Ok 3/5
not terrible but it doesnt grab me
Pretty good
takie 3/5
I only recognized two tracks from this album. I always thought of it /them as 70’s easy listening/ soft rock thing. In the deeper tracks the jazz elements are more pronounced. I never owned any Steely Dan but didn’t mind the occasional “hits” if they showed up in a background mix depending on the setting. While the lyrics are dark, I kind of liked the pace / keys of “Charlie Freak”. That said, im glad it was brief. Probably getting an artificial bump due to Simply Dread, I’ll give it a 2 by a hair.
An aptly titled album given the twisted logic it would take to convince me to like this. Better than the Aja album, but still lingers in the WTF category for me.
FUCK THIS BAND. Why do they hate everyone? Hey, at least if you’re having a bad day, you could always make it worse by listening to this shit sandwich.
I can’t decide what’s worse. Smooth Jazz or soft rock. Tempted to rate this higher because it’s better than Aja and the previous album we were forced to listen to. But out of principle…a GFY 1 star.
Boys! I'm gonna do it! I'm rating a SD album higher than 1*! Listen, this album is still pretty trash, but (i) Rikki Don't Lose That Number is mildly ok, (ii) anything looks good compared to that Simply Red trash album we had yesterday, and (iii) it is better than Aja (oh god I just threw up in my mouth a little bit). I nearly crashed my car in a fit of rage when East St. Louis Doodle-Oo came on. Pretentious AF and no fun. Fuck, am I talking myself into a 1*??? Take a breath... At the end of the day this is a 34 minute album and I made it through ok. 1.75/5
was ok, enjoyed some, zoned out during others
Not bad, actually enjoyed it and was not expecting to
This is a great album. Steely Dan knows how to do it.
I dug this one. None of the songs overstayed their welcome. Barrytown was my new favorite. If there was a 3.5 stars option that's what I'd give this (enjoyed myself, don't really plan to return to it, though).
Steely Dan seems to have developed some sort of cult hipster following in recent years so I thought this might be sneaky good, but it just seems mediocre to me.
3.0 I think for Steely Dan the question is if you personally like them or not. Can't really deny the songwriting and musicianship, they are both really good. I havent listened to enough to say this is better than their other work.
Good album. Not a great album, but enjoyed the listening. Plain and lackluster - but can't really fault it (except for not being special!)
A very plain and lackluster dadrock album. There are some good string bits and I appreciate how short an album in is, but altogether pretty standard. 2.5/5 rounded to 3/5.
Rikki don’t lose that number: Vocals can be a little stronger, I like the group refrain Boring
This album on 1st listen is very close to a 5 for me. Every song is great and the musicianship is always on another level with SD. I wish I had this on vinyl.
I absolutely loved this - it’s reminding me of Chicago and some Simon and Garfunkel as well. I’m a sucker for horn parts, and I seriously love their mixing techniques with minimal reverb. What a fun album! Only song I wasn’t a fan of was probably the instrumental track.
Everything I’ve listened to by Steely Dan has been a pleasure. They have some of the best mixed/mastered albums that I have listened to.
I am married to the world's biggest Steely Dan hater, so I essentially never listen to their music. This album confirms that I'm not really missing much. I loved the instrumental East St. Louis Toodle-Oo. The rest of the album is "fine". The first track (Ricky Don't Lose That Number) was omnipresent through the 2nd half of the 70s and becomes an annoying earworm whenever I hear it. I enjoyed Barrytown. The rest of the album was undistinguished for me.
A fine classic rock album! TIL that Ben Folds Five song Barrytown is a cover of Steely Dan!
I didn’t love it
Wow, I've never really listened to steely Dan before. I'm not sure I'd like any of their other albums as much as this one because it looks like this one has a much higher focus on compact, quick songs and less extended solos/jazz sessions/prog Rock. That being said I found these all tuneful and sonically interesting. I was happy to listen to this one 3 times and had almost half the album make my favorites list!
Idiota
Pretty relaxing, but forgettable
This must not have been one of the Steely Dan albums in as regular of rotation growing up because other than the first track, it wasn’t super familiar. Very enjoyable though!
So great, but still only my 3rd favorite Steely Dan album (after Katy Lied and Countdown to Ecstasy). 11 concise songs, 34 minutes, the last disc with any semblance of being a typical “rock band”. Some admittedly weird tracks for a pop/rock album, but great rhythms, solos, and arrangements throughout. One monster hit (Rikki), one that should’ve done better (title track), and a number of others that would be great to hear on Classic Rock if they’d ever play them. As with most of their LPs it doesn’t seem like a “guitar album” on the surface (only The Royal Scam qualifies), but there is so much tasty guitar work here throughout. Lots of it from original members Jeff Baxter (who joined The Doobie Brothers soon after this was done) and Danny Dias, but Walter Becker, primarily a bass player, has some shining lead guitar moments here. Looking at the track listing before playing it today, my sense was that Side 2 was weaker than Side 1, but nah, it’s all great.
Enjoyable album. I was torn between 3 and 4 stars.
Amazing. So many differing styles of music... but in a steely dan way
Classic Dad rock.
Such a dynamic and versatile album
Great, smooth, lil bit funky. Really enjoyed it
One of my all-time favorite albums, and artist. Great music.
# Playlist track - Any Major Dude # Notes - My first Steely Dan album, and it's a great one. I've been hearing this over and over the entire day. - Super impressive breadth! Overall the album goes steadily on a ballad-like rhythm, but then it throws weird and cool tracks like "East St. Louis Toodle-Oo" at you from outta nowhere. - 5/5 will hear again!
This suburban dad in socks and sandals absolutely wants to discuss grass-layering techniques and then segue into the delicate nuances of Steely Dans’ jazz rock. From funky rhythms to ripping guitar medley. The horns are blaring and the keyboards are squealing. This is musical magic, ladies and gentleman.
Like, not love.
night by night lyrics are nice.. barrytown is nice "I'm not one to look behind I know that times must change". gay-ish but also hater ass song like,,,,i guess im from barrytown then too lol. whimsical fellow... the guitar on parkers band is NICE wait omg i know Pretzel logic??? the song. omg? or at least the MELODY
I cannot deny that the music absolutely jams at times. I even enjoy a few of these songs, usually. However, the songs often come across as infuriating/annoying, mostly because of the vocals. Overall, I think it's good in moderation. Unfortunately, Spotify does not understand this at the moment, and Steely Dan is my most skipped artist.
one of the dan's best. close in quality to the royal scam.
I know its cool to like Steely Dan now but my ears aren’t agreeing.
Nothing Notable.
this is a compromise because it’s fine. could i write poetry to this? n
Not my favorite Steely Dan album, but it's pretty good. Nothing surprising here. Three and one-half-ish stars, I guess.
Doug is wrong. Steely Dan is great.
I just don't care for lots of 70s style male harmonizing. There were a couple songs that I enjoyed, and I appreciated the short run time. Torn between a 2 and a 3, because it is technically good, just not my thing.
Classic for a reason.
Rikki Don't Lose That Number Any Major Dude Will Tell You
Loving the eclectic sound.
Rock Jazz is better than expected. Barely missed out on a 5 star
Not my favorite steely stuff
Great duo with excellent words & music in various ways. Always a listening treat.
Steely Dan's jazzy and soft tones sound as good today as they did in the 70s. The group is both commercially and technically successful but I think their claim to fame is their sound is not duplicated by other bands. They are simply pleasant and easy to listen to without sounding redundant. Thank goodness for their music instead of the electronic and punk rock pretenders out there who just jam and scream making noise rather than making music.
-surprisingly jazzy -initial 4-track run is fantastic -back-end a lil lacking imo Fav tracks: Rikki Don't Lose That Number Night By Night Any Major Dude Will Tell You Barrytown Parker's Band Pretzel Logic Least fav: East st. Louis Toodle-Oo
goddam: 09,10 cool: 01, 03, 04, 06, 07, 08 good: 02, 11 meh: 05 ass: really good, kind of lowkey like a 8-9/10
There's some short and rather forgettable tracks on here, but otherwise it's a chill and enjoyable listen. Favorite tracks: Rikki Don't Lose the Number, Any Major Dude Will Tell You, Barrytown Least favorite tracks: Monkey In Your Soul
On my first run of this it went completely over my head, and I had to re-listen to it for this review. Having done so I feel quite comfortable just putting it in the middle, potentially a candidate for strong 2 as well. The start of the album is pretty decent with some funky jams like 'Night by Night', 'Any Major Dude Will Tell You', but then it turned fairly bland for the rest of the album, with 'East St. Louis Toodle-Oo' being a low-point that I don't feel belong on this album. Not sure why this is included on the list at all. Like I said it's pretty bland and I don't see many game-changing songs here.
I mean it's nice in a milk toast kind of way. I'm just not a great fan of soft rock. Listened to it once and it didn't leave any real impression so i figured I needed to listen a second time. "Any Major Dude Will Tell You" stood out the second time around. After that song I turned the volume up and I found it quite groovy. I can finally see why people like it.
More of a 4.75 star album than 5 - not as front to back perfect as Aja- but still a masterpiece… love the wackiness of East St. Louis tootaloo
Decent
2.64 per track. Not sure why this is on the list, pretty unremarkable.
Classic
Now I am an old bastard I am of course moving into Steely Dan territory. Like many reviews I see here, when I was younger I thought the soul and charm of the music and lyrics if there was any was eclipsed by the obsession with surgically clean production and endlessly winnowing session takes down to the "ultimate" studio performance. I found the music smug, superficial and overly shiny and produced. It had no grit. Yeah, then I got older. Now I appreciate the dedication and thoughfulness, and also now I like the snarky, self-depricating and doom laden lyrics. This isn't happy-go-lucky cocktail lounge music at all. That said this album is new to me, previously I have got into 'Aja' and 'The Royal Scam' on which Becker and Fagen had reached the apex of Steely Dan-ness. It's OK, it's not grown on me like the others yet, I'm familiar with 'Any Major Dude'. 'Rikki' and the title track and those aren't my favourite SD numbers. The other tracks will need a bit of time. I'll circle back, the good stuff always takes a while to appreciate. At least this one has a half-decent photo on the cover.
Superb production. Any Major Dude is a highlight; only a few moments where this album drags.
Pretty good. Really jazzy
Gewoon cutie steely, always
Good album. I’m not a huge Steely fan but there is a good variety of sounds on this. And a number of recognizable hits.
4.1/5
Bangers
Ouvi só uma vez ontem, não prestei Mt atenção, mas achei gostoso, bom, escutaria de novo e provavelmente teria que fazer outra review. 5/10
Not bad
Steely Dan had such a great sound. Love this album.
Good stuff
Good album, not the best of their work. Lacks the overall groove of some of their other albums and doesn’t have as many strong songs. Still good though. 3/5 Might listen again
Groovy, quick, and so easy to listen to.
dad rock
Album? Pretty good. Coming from Barrytown? Less good…??
Mmm pretzels
forgettable
I have nothing positive or negative to say about this album.
average steely dan chad
It was pretty soothing
I can't tell if Steely Dan is less clever than they think they are or if it's me
Another one that I already own and like. This is Steely Dan's 3rd album, and the last one where they were technically a band, rather than a vehicle for Fagen and Becker. I say "technically because there were more than a dozen other players augmenting the 5 members of the band. Regardless, this is a great album, probably my 2nd favorite behind their first (Can't Buy A Thrill). It has all the things that make Steely Dan great: solid pop sensibilities over a slightly Jazzy groove. precise songwriting, solid musicianship, well produced. But it also has the things that can make Steely Dan a little irritating. They's a bit clinical, perhaps too "clean". The lyrics can trend toward obtuse. And there's just a certain feeling that these guys KNOW they're good, and that they're smarter than all us mortals who are lucky enough to listen to them. With a song about Charlie Parker, and a Duke Ellington cover, these guys let you know they understand and appreciate "real" music. With references to The Queen of Spain, Sqonk's tears and and Napoleon... well these guys are beyond the average. All that said, this remains a very good album. Most of the songs are good to great, and none stink. "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" is a prime 1974 single (#4 in US) and at least 1/2 of it got solid AOR radio play. "Any Major Dude..." "Night by Night" and "Pretzel Logic" are outstanding. All my complaining doesn't change the fact that I enjoy this album, and have for years. Easily at least a 4. But not quite good enough to round to 4. I'll save that 5 for their debut, assuming it shows up on this list.
Rikki Don’t Lose That Number was literally my first introduction to Steely Dan as a 12 year old. Listening now, it’s a pretty great album. The songs are of a piece, except for East St. Louis Toodle-oo, which sounds out of place. Otherwise, this is a great exploration of the demimonde, albeit what you get when you’re California hipsters rather than the Velvets.
Enjoyed that album
Pretty good overall.
Mid 70s harmonies and songwriting, and nice grooves.
Nr. 131/1001 Rikki Don't Lose That Number 4/5 Night By Night 4/5 Any Major Dude Will Tell You 4/5 Barrytown 4/5 East St. Louis Toodle-Oo 3/5 Parker's Band 4/5 Through With Buzz 4/5 Pretzel Logic 3/5 With A Gun 4/5 Charlie Freak 3/5 Monkey In Your Soul 3/5 Average: 3,64 This is really good. Liked Aja a bit more. Excited for Can't Buy A Thrill.
Something different
On my second listen and enjoying most of it so far. Night by Night is a fantastically funky tune. 4/5 for now!
Steely Dan’s music is just so slick and smooth at all times, I don’t know how they do it Right on the edge between 4 and 5 I feel like the last song was not as great as most the rest, but I liked the rest a lot
Prima achtergrondmuziek.
3.5/5
I started hating on Steely Dan on other record but some of them from this list have been pretty decent records - always impeccable production - I guess they are the gold standard for sound quality but the songs are actually good - the album not too long and a little tongue in cheek here and there. Enjoyed it.
I used to love Steely Dan, but they really start to annoy me after a while. I don't know what it is ...
Un poco rollo. Pero me ha caído bien Walter Becker. SoftFolk - rock.
Probably the weakest of their 70s material, some solid tunes here and there but nothing approaching the peaks of this era.
I love some prog rock (Pink Floyd and Porcupine Tree are top 10 bands for me), but there's a lot I don't love either (Rush, King Crimson, Yes, and many more). I don't get the love for Steely Dan. Their music isn't bad, but it reminds me a little too much of a cross between prog rock and lounge music if it were done by a rock band. It's got a vibe I can enjoy, but there's no song that I'm going to listen to and say "This is great!" Too "lounge music" for me.
Sort of underwhelming. It has its moments but really just didn’t stand out for me. Occasionally I liked the horns. 1.82
Viel schönes dabei : aber ( fast ) nichts lockt mich aus dem Sessel.
Real chill
it's okay, but does not belong on the list
ta prou bien, muy ir a almorzar en un cadillac el dorado mentre portes pantalons de campana, groovi que diuen algunos, no? ta be ta be
Boring Dadcore
Un poco rollo. Pero me ha caído bien Walter Becker. SoftFolk - rock.
Rikki Don't Lose That Number is a huge tune and the rest had something going for it but I didn't save much!
Cordial.
Not quite as good as their first, but still damn good. Fun from beginning to end. The only thing stopping me from giving it a 5 straight away is "multiple 5s from the same artist" for the first time being a really high bar, but I thought about it.
I enjoyed it an average amount
Still a very good album. Steely Dan just kills in their ability to write
Definitely not at Can’t Buy a Thrill levels of good, but it’s still Steely Dan which means it’s still really good. I’ll be listening to it again soon to potentially form a second opinion.
Surprisingly fun
solid all around, would listen again. unfortunately i’m no closer to understanding the logic behind pretzels.
Good harmonies
Good tunes! I really liked all the instruments
Best album so far 💯💯💯 I've found a new love
This is a chore to me
кайфово
как же я проорал с East St. Louis Toodle-Oo алкоальбом: красное полусухое
Notable track: Through With Buzz
3.5*
Boredom in perfect craftsmanship
I like Steely Dan, just not a whole album.
Very good, enjoyed very much.
I enjoyed this album. I had already known “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” and the rest were enjoyable as well.
It's alright, the opening track was great but nothing else really stood out to me.
Icónico
loved the harmonies
Fun music! Not something I'd probably think to listen to most of the time but I can see why it's popular
Steely Dan is not one of my favourite bands from the era, something about the sound is just not quite there.
Good unoffensive 70's rock. Felt like a palate cleanser for some bad music I've gotten from the list lately.
Some forgettable 70s rock album. Again. It has earned some sympathy points from me for not being as generic as others, though.
AMAZING ALBUM AND BAND
Cool vibe. Sort of CSNY combined with a little bit of the Grateful Dead/funky blues sound.
Started off strong with the first three songs, but it got a bit boring as the album went on. Guitar tone is fucking sick though
I liked this a lot. Dad rock-ish but also just a tad goofy. Good vibes all around
first song and pretzel song were pretty good. other than that it’s kind of resident sleeper
not my type again, some cool instrument sounds so 2 stars
The mighty Dan of Steel's initial demographic seems to have been future Dentists and fathers who were too smart for their own good. But damn could they groove-- which is why their demographic is so small. The intellectual prog rockers weren't concerned with groove and the funk/ soul crowd wasn't concerned with intellectual lyricism that was chalk full of clever references, inside jokes, and subtle snark. Fagen/ Becker were 2 guys who unapologetically pushed their technical proficiency in the studio while capturing some real smooth grooves that, listening to this album, one just can't turn their back on. This Dan album only has 2 tracks that are overplayed (Rikki & Major Dude) and revisiting, really lets me sink my teeth into lesser known tracks like Barrytown, the tone on East St. Louis, and the visual imagery in the lyrics of With A Gun. Take East St. Louis Toodle-do for example, this should come off hokey as hell, but I just can't skip this track. Until the final second when you hear the gong strike (??) you're pulled into their bizarre nerd-universe where Duke Ellington covers live organically alongside the fusion of future dentists grooving to the obsessive music perfection of 2 men that have definitely read more books than any of us.
Liked the album a lot, but sounded a little over produced to me.
Classic
Okay. I'm not a Steely Dan fan.
Rikki please lose my number
This was an easy listen, I love Steely Dan! This album has eleven songs packed into 34 minutes and there is nothing here that is padding or filler. It was over before I knew it and I was left wanting more.
Second of four Steely Dan albums reviewed. In a nutshell: more of the same formula of jazz rock arrangements and strange lyrics. But it works. Steely Dan released an album a year between 1972 and 1977. Four of those five are on the list (Can't Buy A Thrill, Countdown to Ecstasy, Pretzel Logic and Aja). Pretzel Logic seemed like a last roll of the dice for Steely Dan as Ecstasy did not get traction on the charts. Logic's first single 'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' was a hit. Any artist with three or more albums on the list will face this conundrum: is there charted growth and/or change in sound between albums? You can see the progress made between Thrill and Aja. I *kinda* see some evidence of growth between Thrill and Logic. It's not the Steely Dan album I'd recommend to a new listener (my pick is Katy Lied, which isn't on the list. Maybe Aja depending on the person). Not terrible, but not as memorable as Aja. Overall: 4/10
Nicht begeisternder Jazz Rock.
The sun came out for the first time yesterday in about 20 days. And at the same time I got to listen to this classic masterpiece.
Steely Dan are dreadful.
I have not heard this since 1975 or so. I didn’t think much of it then. Upon relistening, my opinion holds. One of SD’s worst. Certainly behind Aja, Countdown, Thrill, Scam. Charlie Freak was my favorite then. Still is. I detected the different nods to jazz throughout that I wasn’t familiar with at age 18. Two stars.
I've never really paid attention to Steely Dan before, so this will be good. It's mostly fine/decent rock. Nothing here really blows me away but it is fun and I'm encouraged to listen to more from them. 3/5
Nice music; overall!
Nothing much to say. I think that if the list is to be rewritten today this wouldn’t be counted in.
Whereas the Stones stole their music from uncredited black musicians and culture…. This shit is so white I terrible I wish they would have done some stealing! Yuck
Nope
Really liked !!
I’m a little surprised at how much I enjoyed this. It’s kinda corny - which I just panned The Beach Boys and Dire Straits for being. Cheesy, but the sense of humor in it feels more authentic. But it’s also smart and a little funky. Ricky is clearly a classic. Listening on my commute, I had a hard time not thinking of that scene in Say Anything when John Mahoney is singing along in his car. I liked it, not loved it. But didn’t expect to like anything beyond the singles. Pleasantly surprised.
Easy listening.
- Steely Dan is peak vibes - Would love to drink a beer in the backyard on a warm summer evening listening to this - 3.5
- yeah this is the good stuff - I love yacht rock vibes - so fun to listen to
I was familiar with Rikki don't lose that number. The album was relatively short. It was not really objectionable, although I do question why there are four Steely Dan albums on this list.
A fun listen, I really liked it.
1- itching my brain in a good way 2- instant like 3- im confused, not in a completely bad way 4- okayy, but not my fav so far 5- i feel like the mc in a black and white movie and i love it (i love wtv happened after 2:20) 6- YES. i am def clapping my hands 7- idk the flow is just wrong in my ears 8- its okay (2 min mark is amazing) i like second half a lot better 9- i like this one too, the lyrics are intEresting and the beat just sounds so good 10- "FIVE NIGHTS WITHOUT A BITE"? evil fnaf lore, also the jingles made this feel sinister 11- the name goes hard, i cant tell if this is bass or not but it sounds so good wtf is it and w the drums its so good
listened to first track while peeing i like this SAVED AFTER hearing beginning of night by night this is so groovy i love my god i love this album so bad already I LOVE EASY ST LOUIS i loved this albnum so much i saved most songs
Duh. 5 Stars. Is there any music this good and this weird? No, there isn't.
Five stars. 'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' and 'Any Major Dude Will Tell You' are great pop songs without sacrificing subtlety. 'Parker's Band' is probably the most joyful track Steely Dan ever did, culminating in a blast of Bird-like horn lines spinning into the air. 'Night By Night' contains one of the Dan's coldest lyrics - "If the dawn patrol gotta tell you twice, they're gonna do it with a shotgun." I often feel that Pretzel Logic is one of Steely Dan's flintier and more unyielding albums. Perhaps so. Still a remarkable blend of rock, jazz and pop sensibilities.
Rikki Don't Lose That Number - Truly a classic for very good reasons, the piano and voices are pure magic, and the guitar adds a plus to everything. Night By Night - It truly sounds like a fun night in the city, it feels like bigger things are yet to come. Any Major Dude Will Tell You - The guitar is the more noticeable thing, I just love how is it used, love this song. Barrytown - Harmony can't get any better than this. East St. Louis Toodle-Oo - I was more than ready to say "OH GOD IT DID GET BETTER", but still an amazing song. Parker's Band - Sounds like The Who. Through With Buzz - Groovy :D. Pretzel Logic - OH GOD IT DID GET BETTER. With A Gun - Western cowboys but rock jazz (I think is rock jazz). Charlie Freak - The only bad thing of this song, is that is too short, 2 and a half minutes weren't enough, I NEED MORE. Monkey In Your Soul - Tha saxophone is just amazing, I want more saxo, MORE. We don't need music to be to progressive, or conciuse, sometimes is just about the mood and happiness, and this album gets it. Top 3 Rikki Don't Lose That Number Any Major Dude Will Tell You Pretzel Logic
Pleasant and mildly electronic
I had no idea what they sounded like before today. It was good! 4.
I had no idea how intricate their music is.
Musically very good. But a bit up their own arse.
Thank you for this one. I have always been haunted by “Every Major Dude Will Tell You” so it was a happy moment to revisit it. Had it on a playlist but must have been deleted or removed.
That was an easy listen
Not the worst but did not enjoy
rigtig hyggeligt album! Jeg kan egentlig godt lide Crosby Stills & Nash og den slags, det er bare ikke altid det jeg får sat på. Kunne lide alle numrene
Har aldrig hørt en Steely Dan plade før, nød det en del mere end jeg havde regnet med. Meget groovy, pissegod lyd.
Fin plade, noget fornuftig tråd.. men meget gammelt og det lød ret gammelt
chill as hell my favorite
Fun jammy album
I don't know much Steely Dan but this album covers so much ground across genres, from classic rock, to jam bands a la doobie brothers. East St-Louis Toodle Oo is the weirdest song and yet I am drawn to it.
It was kinda good, did not suck as bad as I thought it would.
Better than I expected to be honest, loved the instrumentals more than vocals
Muy tipo The Band, guay de fondo
Can't go wrong with some dad rock. The band was obviously influenced by a lot of the 70s singer-songwriter music floating around at the time. A lot of the songs on here remind me of Crosby, Stills & Nash. Side 1 is definitely the stronger side IMO. However, the instrumental at the end of side 1 feels a bit out of place compared to the rest of the record.
Easy listening
Not my Steely Dan favourite.
great one!!!
was en vibe omg i loved it
very much the 70ies
Meh
Disfruté de escuchar el album y seguro investigue un poco más sobre la banda y sus otros discos.
Not bad music. Some catchy tunes. But not really my cup of tea.
I’m not much of a Steely Dan fan.
What genre is this even? I can see why it is included in the list, but not my speed.
It's giving cosy, Supertramp energy. I loved it!
A few decent songs and I wouldn’t confuse it with anything else, but it’s not the best part of jazz and don’t get me started on the r and/or b.
Little all over the place for me.
Some good groovy tunes. But overall just didn't do it for me.
sorry, but I do not like Steely Dan.
No thanks
There is a reason 'Rikki Don't Lose That Number' got all the radio play. The funk riffs on 'Night by Night' were cool. Overall there are some cool sounds on this album with some jazz, blues, groove/funk influences and blending vocals that push it from background music to interesting for me. Yacht Rock doesn't always have to be a pejorative. There aren't a lot of standout tracks here for me, but there also weren't any I disliked.
Seemed alright but didn't blow me away like so many people have told me it would. Kind of a neat storyteller vibe and it sounded clean and crisp, and I appreciate the piano and orchestral feel to a lot of it.
not terrible I can see why people like it. early rock and roll turned electric vibes
Very solid - power energy than the mood I was in (busy at work) but still a nice listen.
It’s ok I guess, nothing inspiring but quality boomer music.
This wasn't something I'd typically listen to or will probably listen to much going forward but I didn't dislike it. It was enjoyable enough.
It made me want to dance! But all in all I’m probably not adding it to my rotation.
3.5
This is in my top 5 1970s Steely Dan albums. Squeaky clean production, masterful execution. 4.5/5
I only know of Steely Dan from John Mulaney stand up specials. I'm glad to have finally listened to it, really good stuff! need to listen more. Gave me some CKNY vibes 1st listen 3.5
Soulless easy listening, great musicianship and production but boring as.
I liked it.
A couple classics that of course I've listened to, a few new ones I hadn't heard, and even some Steely Dan with strings as well. This is a fantastic album.
Overall upbeat experience where almost all tracks feel like perfect easy-listening road trip songs. The instrumentation was pretty robust, with a light piano cabaret-type jazzy feel at times and some nice layered harmonies. Didn't do much for me lyrically, but I enjoyed the positive happy vibes of the album.
Soo good. This is why I wanted to do this challenge. Never heard of Steely Dan, but it was very good. It sounded like some of the songs were from different decades, the 1950's especially. A good variety of styles. Awesome solos, good instruments, good vocals. Proper chill out vibes. Hope there's another on of their albums in this list.
First listen seemed like a for sure 5 star rating. Second listen confirmed it. 5 stars. fantastic. East St. Louis Toodle-oo was so great
Pretzel logic is a nice enough listen but nothing stands out to keep me coming back.
I wore out this album when new.
The safe and familiar piano and guitar found on "Can't Buy A Thrill" interwoven with jazz brass yields an absolute hoot of an album. Strongest songs: Rikki don't lose that number, Night by Night, Barrytown, Parker Band Weakest songs: Monkey in your soul
Good record, not my style, but pleasantly surprised.
Really enjoyed it! The music is something that I would choose to listen to on my own. I felt that the album as a whole was cohesive but blended together into a blur aside from a few standouts(Rikki, With a Gun, Charlie Freak) 3.5
Good album as all Steely Dan albums are. Rikki is probably my favorite of all their songs, and I really, really like the East St Louis Toodle-oo for a change of pace. That said, not my favorite of their albums, but still a very likeable one that I had not listened to in quite a while.
Loved it
It was a good listen again but not one of my favorite bands.
Great album, lol
A fun album, very groovy instrumentals and interesting vocal harmonies. None of the songs resonated with me personally though and I don’t feel a strong emotional connection to the album.
Second Steely Dan album - another classic. They remain a leader in album rock history. Enjoy!
Not my favorite of theirs, but excellent compared to what else was out there
👎🏽
Loved the variety and great to re- listen to it.
Love the unique voice of Fagen
3.8