Reviews (page 4 of 15)
Enjoyable album
Solid 3 or maybe 4? Let’s make it 4
Many spots of absolute brilliance, with some streaks of cheese mixed in
The distinctive bass and piano on Rikki Don't Lose That Number form a nice backbone, with a memorable chorus and good solo. I like Night By Night even more, a similar stop-start rhythm to the riffing and nice backing melodies and effects. Any Major Dude has a breezy guitar lick that makes the song. Barrytown is another highlight - melodic in what I think of as a 60s way. Then we get a quirky ragtime-inspired instrumental. This is starting to be a trip through different times and places, but it all comes together in a cohesive way. I like the strings on Through With Buzz, and the title track is excellent, pure blues rock with driving melodic bass and maybe the best solos on the album. Charlie Freak is kind of brilliant also. There's something effortlessly cool about this. I like the clear, clean production too. I'm between **** and ***** but rounding up because I keep wanting to go back and listen to this.
Great start to the record with Rikki Don’t Lose That Number and Night by Night. Everyone after that sort of sounds the same and I got a little bored. Nothing special but certainly not the worst thing I’ve heard
I don't like Steely Dan, there I said it. Part of it is their name, too clever by half. Who the f*** has actually read Naked Lunch? However, the main reason I don't like them is because their music is boring. This album is only 34 minutes long, but it seemed like 3 hours. Except for maybe Peg, which is not on this album, I'd rather listen to almost anything else but Steely Dan. Obviously they are talented guys. I just wish they would have used their powers for good.
nie mogłam się zmusić żeby przesłuchać ten album a jak już to zrobiłam to akurat w dzień migreny, więc będę bardzo surowa!!!!! wokal nieprzyjemny, w barrytown i charlie freak robi dziwne akrobacje głosowe. muzyka typu prank, instrumenty to: - pianino zabawkowe z kiosku -dzwonki sań mikołaja -kazoo zamiast saksofonu -klaskanie
5/10
Rikki Don’t Lose That Number // Barrytown //
i just listened to all the music thats ever been. my favorite was a song a little girl sang to her cat in greece in 1286. my second favorite was from a ceremonial performance in modern day ethiopia, from 22000 bc. i also liked STEELY DAN.
The last album Steely Dan made whilst still a touring band is a collection of concise tunes with a greater pop sensibility than their two previous efforts. It contains their biggest billboard hit (Ricky don't lose that number), their first album title track and their first and only cover and instrumental (East St. Louis doodle-oo). It is an eclectic and quirky mix, and a number of the songs are from Walter and Donald's writing before the band was formed. Not my favourite album of theirs but still totally magnificent stuff - 'every major dude will tell you' is a phenomenal piece of work.
Four Steely Dan albums is at least 2 too many. This is just dull
average steely dan epic moment but not as good as a few of their other albums
Meh - dad rock, to my ears. It's almost offensively inoffensive. Not my taste.
I disliked this album from track 1, It's not that I don't like Steely Dan, it's more that I really hate Ricki don't lose that number. I saw the track list, and that song earwormed it's way right into my brain before I listened to it. The rest of the album was alright.
This list actually makes me look forward to listening to a Steely Dan album. Is this what being old feels like? If that wasn’t enough, this album art would be enough to make me want to listen to this album. I find Steely Dan to be very odd because I don’t know how to categorize them. It’s like “elevator dad rock” but I love it because it’s so unique.
the punk part of my brain says i should hate steely dan. but a band named after a sexual torture device from a william burroughs novel has some pretty punk notes. and i do love me some steely dan
Awesome. Steely Dan's first great album.
I have not started listening to this at all but the name and album cover make me want to learn more. Inter-rest-ing. Also what is it with every music head saying that every masterpiece of an album is just a bunch of sweaty white dudes who probably got bullied in middle school(also known as a band). Pretty chill but also did not finish the entire thing
Nöd so uf passt aber glaubs nöd so schlecht gsi
Raro.pasable, por ahí yo no lo entendí del todo
👌🏻 choice
I guess you can only resist Steely Dan for so long
I think Claude could write this in 2030. Very apple-cheeked.
I may have a new-found appreciation for this band.
I want to like Steely Dan more, but Fagen’s voice is so fucking annoying.
🤓
I liked rikki dont lose that number and any major dude will tell you
Solid listen. Not my favorite by Steely Dan, but very good.
A 2 that became a begrudging 3. I’ve always been kind of irritated by Steely Dan even if I know the hits. The overall sound is just too smooth to me while I also find the vocals grating. But they can clearly write some good songs… and like some others, I actually found more to appreciate on the second side with songs like “With a Gun.” I read more about them and some of their gnarlier lyrics… and I find it hard to hate a band that lets their freak flag fly. Not for me, but I feel like I get what makes people fans of them a little bit better than I did before.
sure!
A nice little album. Kind of short and sweet. Plain vocals, with some great harmonies tossed in. Some nice variety between tracks. And the instrumentation on a couple songs was really cool. All in all, an inoffensive classic light rock experience.
Blah blah blah ... don't get the love for Steely Dan. Forgettable 70s soft dad rock jazz pop, very hard to love it or loathe it. 3 stars
Steely Dan sounds like a parody of Steely Dan. It’s nice, solid music, but rarely does it excite me. I know “audiophiles” go gaga over them, but I don’t listen to music to bask in the fidelity of it.
Nice harmonics
I liked this more than I expected to - there's jazzy elements, and it's got a 70s feel but isn't repetitive. Enjoyed it.
Enjoyed this one. Not as hard as Led Zeppelin but similar 70s vibe, only softer and more listenable
I enjoyed this album from Steely Dan! This was a great rock album with jazz, blues, and pop influences which added flavor and uniqueness to the album. Overall, I had a good time listening to this album and I would check it out again in the future!
Þeir eru oft fínir, en ég tengi ekkert sérstaklega við þessa plötu. Upphafslagið er kannski þeirra stærsti smellur, en það er ekkert voðalega skemmtilegt. Fer ekki niður fyrir þristinn samt.
Gran para estar depre y viajar
The logic of the pretzel. Mmm yes
A few weeks ago, I wouldn’t have considered myself a Steely Dan fan. Between this and Aja though? It’s tough. They’re good! Still not my personal favorite, but they’ve really grown on me.
Summery vibes - nice listen. Some good riffs
Decent and fun!
No Guitar Hero tunes on thus one
I love the Dan but not their best album bar some highlights like Ricky and Dude
I liked this overall. I enjoyed the first few songs in particular. There were some pretty random ones sprinkled in throughout but I think they are interesting to listen to.
ornate
This was okay, was expecting better, all the songs have a somewhat similar sound/feel.
Had Steely Dan last week, same reaction - at least this time they're not pretending to be freaky shit
Not my fave Steely Dan, but any major dude will tell you that this still rocks
Album #66, Steely Dan, Pretzel Logic, ⭐⭐⭐⭐ The only Steely Dan album I know is Can’t Buy a Thrill, which I like. And, as an Irish man, I have a nostalgic love for Reelin’ in the Years. If you know, you know. So this being my second Steely Dan album, I really like it. It’s a strong four, but I think there’s a lot more to discover here. It feels like one that will really open up on repeat listens. It’s a rare band that can move through so many different styles and still sound completely like themselves. They go through country, soul, blues, funk, rock, all these different styles, but it always sounds like Steely Dan. It actually reminds of Rain Dogs by Tom Waits in that way. The guitar work is phenomenal. The licks, the riffs, the solos, the intricacies, it’s all just so, so good. It’s quite an eccentric album, and maybe a bit too eccentric in places. I think especially in the second half it loses me a little bit. But again, it feels like a repeat listen album. I love how short it is as well. It packs a lot into about 33 minutes, and I really appreciate that. Favourite track is Rikki Don’t Lose That Number. I know it’s their big hit, so may be a bit of a basic choice, but it’s just such a great, catchy song. The chord progressions are brilliant. Final note, having just reviewed Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young, Steely Dans harmonies are better. I think they are an underrated band.
I had never heard this record. I actually like it more than the more popular records
7/10
Pretty good but nothing really stood out. Happily have it on in the background again.
They are all 5 Stars, aren’t they? 😁
THE playlist to draw&dance
Ugh. I don't like Steely Dan. And I recognize a few of the songs on this by title, and already know them to be insidious earworms. I'm not looking forward to this. It's always so frustrating knowing that Steely Dan are notorious for using studio musicians because they felt that the band members weren't good enough to render their parts... meanwhile Donald Fagen is just a _terrible_ singer. The best part of this album is that it's pretty short.
Good album! Smart lyrics that do not make the listener feel stupid if they do not get the meaning. The music is mellow and easy to listen to.
Sorry John
i only remember the hits
This was incredible. Have always loved Steely Dan. Many classics here.
These dudes refuse to make a bad one.
I sincerely doubt I'm going to be able to make myself give any Steely Dan album less than a 5.
First time listen Love Steely Dan. This is a great album but it definitely isn't as great as some of their other stuff like Gaucho and Aja. Production is top notch as always. Favorite Tracks: Night By Night, Parker's Band, Charlie Freak Least favorite: East St. Louis Toodle-ooo 4/5
Nope, still don’t get the hype
Always heared about them, but never actually listened to them beforehand. I don't know what kind of music they play, but this is kind of music that I like.
surprisingly fun and groovy!
An album with good musicianship, easy to listen, but that rewards more attentive listening. The opening track is a bit too pop, but interesting with it's usage of an Horace Silver's base. I like the cover of one of Ellington's most famous compositions. Favourite track: "East St. Louis Toodle-Oo"
muy fab
Smooth and velvety at times jammy
Not sure how to place the style/genre of this album. It had a jazzy/funk feel, but also an edgy indie vibe. I listened to it while running, and I’m not sure when I would listen again on the pure basis that it doesn’t fit into a listening setting. I didn’t love nor dislike any of the songs. I liked the instrumentals but wasn’t a huge fan of the vocals. 7/10
Really enjoyed this, very chill and great vibes overall.
I kinda feel like it is technically insanely good, but still, something misses... Feeling
I went on a Steely binge a few years ago and I knew that this was not one worth coming back to, at all. You can make an excuse for Countdown to Ecstacy I guess, but this was especially bland by their standards. Title track was the best song.
no me encanta. Siento que tiene elementos de los Beatles y algo que me recuerda a Elton John. Creo que hay canciones que fácilmente pueden estar en una película, si es que no lo están ya.
Apparently there are several more Steely Dan albums waiting for me on this list. I never could get into them, mostly for how they seamlessly blended the 2 most irritating tropes of the 70s and early 80s pop scene - languid adult contemporary melodies and cool, smooth jazz. The result is an overly preppy, self-centered sound that reminds me of sleazy businessmen and plain ordinary suburbanites. Of course, the Dan has a couple of songs I like here and there, but they're on Can't Buy a Thrill and Aja. This one, at a crossroads between those 2 albums - one came before and the other after - Steely Dan can't quite seem to consolidate their sound, and though songs like the title track and "Charlie Freak" show some promise, the rest is too middle-of-the-road to be memorable. I think the previous 2 albums could definitely be included on this list (and I have no doubt they will be) but I'm not sure why they would include this one as well and not something with a better critical assessment, like Gaucho or Royal Scam. I'm also not sure why certain artists like these guys, Costello, Dylan or even Bowie need to have this many releases represented... Key Tracks: Night by Night, East St. Louis Toodle-Oo, Charlie Freak
strong 3.5
Overall I like the vibe. A few songs were pretty fun. Liked Barrytown and With a Gun.
Good band but pretty average from them
solid
Album starts on a heater! Super sleazy 70's funk thru those first 3 tracks, kinda cools in the middle and then picks it back up towards the end. Not a fan of the song they choose to end with either, not bad I just prefer to be left wanting more and this song didn't do that. They didn't seem to "jam" these out as much as the previous albums, overall it is a fun album worthy of your time.
Cute. Fun. I liked it
Major heat. Pleasantly suprised
fun! not my fave of theirs, but a solid album
8,50/10 Muy buen album, me gustó. Alegre y movedizo, me hizo acordar bastante a Bee, siento que varios temas pegarían muy bien con la película. Buena instrumental que acompaña la voz sin opacarla
Caveat: I grew up listening to Steely Dan and I still love 'em. Pretzel Logic is fab, a precursor to the sound that would emerge as Aja. The musicianship and arrangements are top notch. I could listen to this almost daily without tiring of it.
Wonderful, beautiful, easy listening album. It definitely deserves its spot on this list. It's an album everyone should hear at least once and pairs great with the smells of pines on the summer air and campfire smoke, the feel of cold water and the heat of UV rays reflecting off sunscreened skin, and the taste of watermelon and cheap light beer. 9/10, it's Steely Dan.
I like a bit of Steely Dan - as a child, these were the songs that played in the background on the radio so they instantly transport me to simpler times. I like their rich, smooth sound, it’s just… nice. Is this an essential album? Not sure. To be honest, I’d be happy with a best of.
While the name resonates with me I genuinely think this is the first time I have listened to a Steely Dan record, perhaps even any song? It's pretty dated sounding, I am sure (just becuase I know the name well) it had some profound influence on something, just not on me.
Very good rock album. Nothing really stands out too much about it, but I enjoyed it and it was very well put together.
Cool Jazz dads unite!
Incredibly strong out of the gate with the first four tracks (plus pretzel logic later). Too much mid to be five stars.
Nope. Not a Steely Dan fan.
I’ve got this album at home! :-) Lovely music...
Love steely dan so. What else then 5
Immaculate but way too tied to Baby Boomer culture
Second Steely Dan album on the list. First one underwhelmed me — overproduced and musically uninteresting. This one shines with diversity. Every track has a unique spin. 'East St. Louis' completely blew my mind on first listen. What's remarkable: from 1974 but sounds like 80s — must have been quite revolutionary for its time. However, on second listen it already wore off. The 'great' factor isn't as captivating anymore. Not quite the heavy rotation material I thought after first listen. Still solid, but loses impact on replay.
Steely Dan always lands in the good not great territory for me. It’s obviously competently executed, and the production is top notch, but the songs lack something I’ve never been able to define.
Enjoyed this! Better than Countdown to Ecstasy, although it got me listening to that again and I might have to adjust my score for that… Very interesting songs, enjoyable vocals, not too long. Good stuff.
Classic. Short and sweet. Every song is great 5/5 pretzels 🥨🥨🥨🥨🥨
It’s just all a bit twee. ‘East St. Louis Toodle-Oo’ had promise but quickly descended into meh. I di enjoy the piano bit though.
Not my favourite Steely Dan album, but this is a solid effort that starts strongly with both the classic “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” and a great follow up with “Night By Night”. The middle section (basically from the bizarre “East St Louis Toodle-Oo”, which feels like it’s out of place on this album) has the wheels off a bit, but by the time you hit the title track you feel back on the right path. Overall, the album isn’t as interesting as what they’d do with Aja a couple of years later, and falls a little flat at times. This is very much a 3 and a half star album for me, but I don’t feel it is strong enough overall for 4*.
Another band plucked from my parent's record collection. I like the stacked backing vocals. I like the brass. I like the piano. In places the vocals made me think of Rod Stewart for some reason. East St. Louis Toodle-Oo feels like a completely out of place cover (although I liked it). I think as a whole I enjoyed it, but it didn't set my world alight. Another 2.5/5 if I could half star it, but as I can't: 3/5
Pretzel monies
its steely dan, cant go wrong
Fun
Yacht rock boredom beyond belief. Never not never!
obviously bangers, ni super mega speciaal ma gwn goeie vibey 3.5
pure vibes maar wel geen 5 sterren album
Meh
I realy enjoyed listening to this album ! Great Find ✌️
i love this album!! definitely one of my favorites now!! wonderful listen
I tried but couldn't muster up the desire to finish this album. It's... fine just not for me
8.5/10
This was absolutely what I needed today. I don't remember rating this album as anything special on my previous listen through of Steely Dan, but it really hit for me this time. Yacht Rock is great Favorite Songs: Rikki Don't Lose that Number, With a Gun
3.5
I listened to this and forgot to write a review straight away. Now a few hours later I can’t really recall a thing about it. That speaks volumes.
Pretty good. Fun to listen to but not very exciting or super interesting, kinda dragged towards the end.
A Steely Jam. Enjoyed it.
Didn’t blow me away, but it’s smooth enough that I didn’t mind the ride.
There's not such thing as bad steely Dan. But there is better steely Dan than this album.
A bit dated, but I liked it.
Oh mama, le ptit Steely Dan surprise qui arrive clutch à la fin, j’adore
I honestly thought I didn't enjoy music like this, but it's so good.
Another band I know and heard but never listened to a whole album. This was a great listen! Very interesting songs written with some jazz influences. Makes for a very harmonically rich listen. Each piece is well written in a concise fashion. Leaves me wanting to hear the album again at the end and I did put this on twice. Definitely want to hear their other albums as well.
such annoying vocals. The instrumental track was great.
Steely Dan is fun as always, a true uncgem.
Their sound is pretty fabulous - the right amount of jazz and pop and rock blended into irresistible confections. I added a couple songs to my playlist, though pretty much the hits I already knew. I enjoyed the whimsical forays into a jazz age tune (“St. Louis Toodle-Oo”) and a hard-boiled western number (“With a Gun.”) in just over 30 minutes they were able to display a lot of range and talent in a tight package. 4/4.5
Love some steely
Pretty good stuff, just getting kind of dated
Wasn’t keen on this the 1st time round, still not changed my mind, listening again
Love this album, already reviewed and this was as enjoyable to listen to again
Reminds me of Matt & Sarah, though I have no idea if they listen to Steely Dan. Great tunes.
Not annoying but not something i would seek out again
Slightly better than the last album, but it had a couple of songs that brought it down.
Dad rock to dig. Real WAH-WAH-WAH kinda stuff.
I had trouble forming an opinion on this, so I looked back at my reviews of previous Steely Dan albums, and they were no help, I described them both as "bland". And it's a bland triple-bill from Steely Dan with this too. It's a bit Simon and Garfunkel, slightly funkier, but my overwhleming impression is no impression. The best things I can say about this album are that it didn't actually offend me and it was short.
Maybe a little more loungey than their other stuff, but they still don't miss
Sympatoche poprock qui passe bien mais sans relief.
I love Steely Dan so much
Class. Pop-y in comparison to Can't Buy a Thrill, still great.
Good vocals and really strong lyrics, one of those albums to just vibe to when doing homework or doing some other chore, not MY favorite type of rock that Beatles esque sound, but not bad
steely dan doesn't do it for me Would I listen again: No Deserves to be on this list: Doesn't he have more popular albums? 2.5
2nd Steely album on this list for me! I like all of their albums, but I would really have put Gaucho or Royal Scam here instead of Pretzel Logic, for this goody I will be going for 4 stars I reckon.
Great album, this band always delivers and this one is solid throughout. Not quite five stars but very good
Listened previously. Expectations: High - Verdict: Great - Brilliant album from start to finish. I couldn't pick a favourite Steely Dan album but this would definitely be up there.
Interesting harmonies and funky grooves. Not bad at all!
Want it to be over. I can't put my finger on it but there is something just unsettling and awful about it all. Starting to remind me of Frank Zappa and maybe I don't like Frank Zappa now. Little bits of funk, country come through but it's like it's taking the piss. I know it's an acquired taste but I can't contemplate how people like this.
Loved night by night
Way better than I thought. Steely Dan still has a hokey sound sometimes, to Me. But this songwriting is great and I LOVE the gratuitous solos
I went in expecting not to like it but it's not bad. It is dad-rocky pero that doesn't have to always mean boring and generic. It was chill and nice to have in the background.
I have never heard a Steely Dan song that I enjoy. In that regard, this album did not disappoint. I do not understand working that hard to sound so bland.
This album was solidly good. Nothing stuck out to me as a masterpiece, but none of the songs were bad either. I could see the songs growing on me more with repeat listens. Favorite Track - Parker's Band Least Favorite Track - Charlie Freak ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Risch geil
Starker Einstieg und mit dem zweiten Song erstmal klassischer 70er Funk. Mag ich. Der Rest war mittelmäßig unterhaltsam.
Eigentlich ganz geil am Anfang, finde es allerdings mit Dauer immer langweiliger. Kann aber auch mit dieser seltsamen Mischung aus Funk und Trucker-Musik nicht wirklich etwas anfangen. Das ist wohl dann diese Brezellogic...
Soft rock can get boring quick, luckily this was only 33 minutes. Definition of OK.
I love Steely Dan but this isn’t my fave of theirs. Still more solid than 90% of this list
Pretty eh for steelys standards
3.5
A single hit amongst a variety of bearable and pleasent sending tunes
This album was okay, but it felt unremarkable to me. You can definitely tell it's a 70s piece because of the groovy elements mixed in with the rock music, but there's also some blues mixed in as well. There were a couple of standout tunes to me: "Barrytown" and "Charlie Freak". These songs were perfectly melodic and the storytelling was amazing. Not to say the other songs weren't melodic or told stories, but these two had the best combination of both. The last song, "Monkey In Your Soul", did not feel like a closer to me, more just another filler song. Overall, I see a couple of shining moments in an otherwise sort of bland album.
Not their best work
Biased because I genuinely like steely dan
Album sounds like something my dad would make me listen to as a joke and we're both just mutually suffering to this.
Some gems and some questions. When it works, brilliantly played pop/jazz infused with lurking blues runs through Hooksville, and when it doesn't (have you actually finished this song or is this an idea you are still working out?) it makes you wonder who organized the whole project.
I do love ‘Rikki I don’t lose that number’ but I don’t really care for the rest. It’s accomplished but not my thing.
Always enjoy a Steely Dan record. Ended before I was ready.
Not my bag, but it's well done.
Simply Cool
Probably my fault for coming in with expectations based on the very few (but very exceptional) Steely Dan songs I've heard on radio over the years = suspect this album is a creeper that will grow on me over time with repeated listening 3 star with a note to call back from time-to-time
I feel like I could become a Steely Dan guy, but I'm not there yet. I kind of like their attitude and writing, but they're a little too smooth for me. This is probably their most average release. A few good hits at the start, then nice enough but a bit slight throughout the rest
6 / 10 - coole vibes und ziemlich abwechslungsreich (jazz/rock/blues) - interessante Songwriting - Manche Songs besser/einprägsamer als andere - kein befriedigendes Ende zum Album Favs: - Rikki Don't Lose That Number - Night By Night
I feel like Albini because there's something deep inside that renders me incapable of liking Steely Dan. They just sound so *uncool*. They're undoubtedly competent musicians, but this style of anodyne jazz-funk-pop does nothing to my ears or my body or my soul.
Maybe too much Steely Dan.
Yeah.
4.
The instrumentals on this album felt very Beatles-y at times but even that was not enough to save it for me. As someone with the music taste of a boomer dad this should be right up my alley but I just did not vibe with it.
Not noteworthy
Barry town, Through the Buzz, Rikki etc... C'est difficile de doner moins de 4 à un album de Steely Dan, même si je crois qu'un seul serait suffisant dans la liste.
Vous pouvez ben me convaincre que c'est bon mais vous me convaincrez jamais que c'est écoutable. 2.49 étoiles
The kings of easy listening strike again. I don’t have a ton to say about this record. It was a very solid listen, very well produced, and like most things Steely Dan, I enjoyed it immensely. Take out ‘East St. Louis Toodle-Oo’ and this would be a perfect score, but as it stands, it’s a very good 4/5
not my favorite steely dan album
The line up alone requires a standing O. These musicians have consistently put out timeless recordings for YEARS. They are just as good today as the day they were recorded. AND they just got better as they composed and recorded. Steely Dan forever!
Enjoyed, but not as much as later albums.
this album is so fun! the songs blend in together at times but i liked it, it was a nice surprise.
good
Ummm This just reminds me of the boys (they were always boys) who could play their instruments really well, keep a beat and not have a single memorable track. Geeks.
This album felt quite anachronistic. I understand how it paved the way for the development of current pop music, but I probably won't be returning to it.
Steely Dan Man … Steely Dan. Underrated album of there’s, some point criticisms, and a lot of good music
an okay album. it started strong with “rikki doing lose that number” and the next two songs became a bit boring the piano parts are cool, the guitar bits are good too, just a bit too long for my liking, therefore boring it has some jazzy and james-bond-ish vibes sometimes also at some moments really remind me of queen, fleetwod mac, and david bowie saved a few songs a 2.5/5, but i’m rounding up to the bigger
primeiro album curto em muito tempo KKKKK FAVS (top 3): rikki dont lose that number, night by night, pretzel logic mençoes honrosas: barry town, monkey in your soul um bom album, curti o começo, achei a segunda metade meio fraca, mas é bom, pra primeira parte eu tava considerando um 4 mas dps errr uns 3-3.5 entao de media vou dar 3.5 nota final: 3.5/5
Pretty short album, its fine, but nothing catchy really.
this is fun and familiar but would probably not pick it but I like it
Some really good vibes. I really enjoyed the music even if I found the vocals a hit and miss.
Good but what's the logic behind having four damn Steely Dan albums in this challenge?
Good Pop Rock, but I think we got the picture after 4 Steely Dan. Do you know any other band, by chance?
Precise, rich, jazzy, catchy, melodic… Steely Dan are the real deal of having a strong and playful band. I won't hide it to my hipster friends : I love Steel Dan.
A lot of this album sounded like it was going to be fun, interesting, and funky, but proceeded to let me down a little. Most of the songs felt like watered-down Billy Joel to me. Ironically, I really liked “East St. Louis Toodle-Oo,” which is arguably the least Steely-Dan sounding song on the album. I also enjoyed Charlie Freak, but the rest didn’t leave a strong impression on me.
Simple-minded. Artist have better musics in setlist.
A Steely Dan album is like a box of chocolates. I’d heard this album talked about plenty but never listened front to back. Walter Becker and Donald Fagen are clearly virtuosos musically - always some intricate progressions and arrangements. The first 3 tracks had me ready to give this one 5 stars, but I found things getting less interesting by the middle. Glad I discovered that banger “Night by Night” though! 🔥 Any Major Dude rocks as well, and of course Ricky is a certified classic
Beautifully done.
1974. I love Steely Dan and Im glad to have listened to thie album but unfortunately this album doesn't reach the height of the best that Steely Dan has to offer. I still love the sound and style but I know there is better waiting for me.
Tired of all the Steely Dan.
Any more Steely Dan albums and I think I might become a fan. This album flowed so nicely from start to finish and was the perfect accompaniment to my walk along the seafront. Just wonderful vibes, but distinctly different from my memory of Aja. Favourites: Rikki Don't Lose That Number Any Major Dude Will Tell You Pretzel Logic
The good stuff is legendary. But there are a few cuts on here that are just a bit sterile. They haven't quite hit their peak. Excellent guitar throughout, though. Like, REALLY amazing, which was unexpected. "Rickie..." is an all-time favorite.
Great overall album! Smooth, jazzy, catchy, not much filler. Nice listen!
technically, it's good, they make good albums. but nothing called my attention in this one
Favorite Track: Rikki Don't Lose That Number
Phenomenal album and classic Steely Dan sound.
Favorite tracks: Parker's Band, Charlie Freak, Rikki Don't Lose That Number, Barrytown Honestly I'm surprising even myself with this rating. I've always thought of Steely Dan as boring, but it did grow on me as the album went on. Still not my favorite style of music, but I definitely have a new appreciation for the jazz elements and harmonies.
Good album, easy listen! 7.1/10
8/10 Great start but dips towards the middle.
Wasn't sure what to expect, listened a few extra times before succumbing to a 4. Good stuff, wide variety.
Fire up the steam powered dildo and prepare to set sail for another helping of baffling 70s yacht rock. This one opens with Rikki Don’t Lose That Number, which puzzled me at the time - why didn’t Rikki just call directory enquiries or look up the number in the phone book? It’s only now that I realise that she was trying to ghost this dork by pretending to write his number down on the back of a napkin or something. The rest of the album is mostly easy listening, smooth jazz/rock which is ok, but the lyrics are just bizarre in places. Does he mean Barry in Wales? Is he going to meet Napoleon in a secure hospital? What has he got against Buzz Aldrin? I genuinely don’t want to look up the stories behind any of these for fear of spoiling them.
Cool stuff
Don't tell my dad, but I could listen to any Steely Dan for weeks
Besides the first song nothing really stood out.
Favorite Track: Pretzel Logic
The older I get the more I like Steely Dan. Pretty good but definitely not my favorite.
take it or leave it
Call it sophistipop, soft prog, complex pop. Call it what you want. It is a work of refined arrangements and complex compositions. Do I like this? Oh fuck no. I hate Steely Dan. But it is undeniably well made, it made its mark in time. Brilliant album. It deserves to be here. I just hope I don't have to listen to it again.
Any major dude will tell you this is crap
Mu ameno y con autenticos temardos. Me ha gustado mucho Barrytown por la clara influencia de Dylan
This album made very little impression on me. All the songs sounded the same. I don't like it but I don't hate it. I think I was expecting better.
Instantly recognisable vocals and guitar - instantly forgettable 70s easy listening Radio 2 music .
The definition of boring middle of the road dad rock.
This guy Dan really has some steely music. Sorry, I saw a review of this that included a line like, "I really like his music" with a 5 rating and thought it funny. Steely Dan may have acclaimed music, but it is too soft for me. I'd prefer more jazz and less pop effort.
I didn't dislike it, but nothing stood out to me. Kinda blah.
I gave it an extra point because the production is excellent, and the musicians played amazing, but god what a bloody boring album!
Thought Countdown to Ecstasy was a little better, but this is a damn good album in its own regard. 4.5 bumped up to 5.
I’m at a 5. I mean, it’s Steely Dan, what am I supposed to say? If you like “Can’t Buy A Thrill” & “Countdown to Ecstasy” (or if you’ve gotten “Aja” by now, unlike us), you’ll enjoy this. All my same praises apply here, with Donald Fagen’s vocals especially sounding even more refined here, and the band’s technical skill being showcased a bit more. I don’t think it’s got the same consistent stream of hit after hit like “Can’t Buy A Thrill” does, but this is still a super fun album in its own right. As with “Can’t Buy A Thrill”, I really have no complaints, and only nitpicks; I think the lyricism isn’t quite as tight as I remember from the band (though still pretty good), and I think it could’ve had a more definitive closing track than “Monkey in Your Soul”, which doesn’t really feel like it wraps up the album satisfyingly. It’s a good track, but it feels like it’s building to something more. The length is surprising here; at just 34 minutes, it’s the shortest one on the list, and I do think that makes the quality / pace of the album suffer just a little bit, in a way that’s almost too fast to appreciate the variety the album is going for. I’m not saying they had to pad to make it 40-ish minutes, but I think just a little bit more room to explore some solos & soundscapes further would give each track a little more weight to appreciate them with. All in all though, I’m splitting hairs – this is another great Steely Dan album, and I think it’s about on par with “Countdown to Ecstasy”. I’m glad it’s on the list, and I really, REALLY cannot wait to get Aja at some point over the final 310 albums. Hopefully that comes sooner than later, but as far as this album goes, it’s a very nice 5.
Bro complete now
Steely Dan is a very polarizing band, you either love them or hate them. I would say I'm closer to the former, particularly because my dad played us a lot of Steely Dan when I was young. I liked the first half of this album a bit more, or maybe I just didn't listen as closely to the latter half. Rikki Don't Lose that Number is of course a classic but I also quite enjoyed Barrytown and Night by Night; this is an album I'd come back to.
Mildly better than one before.
I’ve heard of them. I listened to one of their songs Aja. They're like a jazz fusion band. Rikki Don’t lose that number: 6.5/10 Soft rock really isn’t my thing, this song isn’t too bad. Night by Night: 6/10 The song isn’t bad, the musicians aren’t bad. I just don’t like this style of music. Any major dude will tell you: 6/10 I just don’t like this genre. Barry town: 5/10 Easy St Louis Toodle-Oo: 3/10 Parker’s band: 6/10 Through with Buzz: 5/10 Pretzel Logic: 5/10 With a Gun: 5/10 Charlie Freak: 6/10 Monkey in your soul: 6/10
8 - GOOD
There is no doubting the skill but this is just so lifeless The worst track is a vapid cover of East St Louis Toodle-oo. It was so weak I ended up listening to Duke Ellington to see if the original song is really that bad. It isn't - it is quite playful and kind of fun, with a bit of moodiness in the background. The way Steely Dan play it is just so damned careful. What is the point of that? I am not a big jazz fan but one thing I definitely don't want from jazz is predictability
É um álbum bem legal. Não tem enrolação e músicas bem elaboradas. QoA Vesper.
Technically proficient, but very much of it's time. It kind of bores me. It is odd to me that they are getting some some of reevauluation these days. Shrug.
It's Steely Dan, like come on
Good albim
I love Steely Dan so this was automatically gonna be a high rating. Probably my second favorite album i have heard by this band. The jazzy pianos are what caught my attention the most. Also I really like the album cover
I was excited but the album isn't as great as their other stuff. Still good ofc Favorites: -Rikki don't lose that number -Night by night -Pretzel logic
A great album however I'm not sure I can psychologically endure entering a Steely Dan phase at this stage of my life. I'm also realising I thought Steely Dan and Dave Matthews Band were the same (??) so clearly I have some unpacking to do.
All the elements of a great Steely Dan record appear to be here, but this doesn’t really click for me. Other than “Any Major Dude Will Tell You” and “Barrytown,” this strikes me as below average Steely Dan, which makes it above average for music generally, but still. I would probably not include this on a list of albums to hear before you die, even given my enjoyment of Steely Dan generally.
got 100% absolutely jumpscared by the piano riff in 'rikki don't lose that number'. genuinely thought I had put 'song for my father' on queue somehow. ON THAT NOTE 'rikki don't lose that number' is a BOP AND A HALF. steely dan is??? really good????????? I love it when popular things are good! Barrytown is also excellent. Very catchy. And East St. Louis Toodle-Oo is also great I love a good piano saxophone moment. I think...guys I think I really like Steely Dan.
It's a 4.3.
Never listened to Steely Dan before. This wasn’t bad.
Was very cool and had some bangers. Interesting to see how they teetered between country/soul on this album a little more than they did their debut. Favorite Songs: Parker's Band, Through with a Buzz
Rikki Don't Lose That Number - Es el unico que quieres y que nesesitas usalo cuando llegues a casa y te sientas mejr, nunca lo pierdas por eres todo tú, anotalo para cuando te sientas perdido sepas a quien compartir tu felicidad. Night By Night - Vivire mi vida sin tener que preocuparme de que mañana vendra a corregirme pr vivr. Any Mayor Dude Will Tell You - Aunque te lo diga tienes que vivirlo por ti mismo para sentirlo. Barrytown - puede ver que tu eres de BARRYTOWN !!!! me gusta mucho mos cambios que utilizan para hablar de Barrytown, como si nesesitaras manos de jazz para comprenderlo. East St Louis Toodle-Oo - jejeje me gusta la trompeta y los platillos, la manera en que el teclado te pasea alrededor y puedes sentir como el aire cambia, EN ESPECIAL EL PLATO DEL FINAL. Parker's Band - Tu y yo podemos disfrutar el nuevo aire que te trae la banda de parker !!!! Through With Buzz - AHH ESCUCHEN ESA ARPA, esto lo hago por ti, no me gustaia sufrir de esta forma si no es por ti. Pretzel Logic - jejeje el mismo nombre de su album, sera q les gustan los pretzel?, ¡¡¡ todo cambia tan rápido que que lo que haga hoy o importara para el siguiente abril !!! With A Gun - CON UNA PISTOLAAAA, todo esto va a acabar con una pistola, cuanto más corras, mas digas, más te escondas terminaras con una pistola entre los dos, ¿la lluvia nunca detuvo estos pensamientos tuyos? Charlie Freak - Charlie era más que los errores que cometió . Monkey In Your Soul - Un gran cierre de album con la huida de nuetro protagonista, tal vez no debimos interrumpir su canción.
This album is fire. Sonically it is amazing and you can hear influences from rock, country, folk, and country. The singing is soulful and smooth and there is this cool vocal stacking that makes some parts of some of the songs sound autotune esque while not feeling robotic or over the top.
It sounded very old. I liked it okay
I don’t hate the Dan as much as I did in the 90s, but I’ll never be a fan of this era.
Like a lot of Steely Dan, it's fine. Sometimes they write beautiful melodies and hire people to write catchy hooks. Sometimes you get Pretzel Logic, which is competent and completely forgettable. It's an album and it hurt much less than Kid Rock. It had no effect on my view of music or even Steely Dan, though. It sort of reminds me of listening to a click track, except those weren't used in 1974. So I guess you could set your watch to it, if not derive pleasure from listening to it. 3/5; perfectly middle-of-the-road for The List. At least it didn't involve Morrissey.
Vibes
Very good
Solid jams in a small package, but the weak bits on this album aren't covered by any generational hits. More of a 3.5, but average Steely Dan still has to be considered somewhat average.
Great jams. Only a 4 because I know they have better albums
it's fine. the songs all sound the same to me, but that's just me.
My god everybody smoked far too much pot in the early 70's if they liked this
A good album, with a nice blend of jazz and rock that comes together in a catchy sound throughout. The only major criticism would be that that sound becomes fairly repetitive- there are little quirks on each song that keep it interesting, but broadly the album is one style done very well.
In which Steely Dan brilliantly marry their jazz-rock stylings to really catchy short songs with a great pop sensibility. I’d give this 4.5 if I could; it’s seriously good, but because I’m not as familiar with it as some definite 5 star albums I’d feel slightly uncomfortable giving it the maximum score. My other shortcoming is that there are some relatively weaker tracks (although still really good) in the back half, and the album ends rather abruptly, which was slightly jarring. Still, this is about as close to 5 without getting it as any album is likely to be.
Honestly found this kinda meh. I love some Steely Dan, but this isn't a patch on Aja. 3 Stars.
Sets the stage well for what’s to come in later albums.
Great album title. Terrible earworm starts off proceedings and it then continues... Just fine.
Kinda boring
ah, a banda dos audiófilos™. Tenho nada a dizer sobre esse álbum.
Bog standard. Ok.
Kind of a mash up of different moods and styles. A lot of the songs didn’t really appeal to me.
очень расстраивает, что приходится оценивать на сравнении, потому что кто-то сюда фигню поставил. ну ладно, сам по себе альбом неплохой, даже что-то подпевать хотелось, интересно
Short album with high quality material
Cooles Album, sehr chilliger Sound
Ja, ganz okay chillo
Some proper bangers in this one, like Night By Night and Pretzel Logic. Overall, it's a pretty fun one. Nothing overly remarkable, but better than Countdown To Ecstasy for sure
Need more funk!
I wasn’t super into it.
Donc, l'album du jour, encore du Steely Dan. Le premier que j'avais entendu était plus ou moins sympathique, mais alors celui-ci est tout sauf mémorable. On va être honnête : je comprends pas trop ce qu'il faut dans la liste. Il n'est pas vraiment mauvais, mais c'est pas non plus particulièrement mémorable. Au moins, il était pas trop long.
Doing uni work while this on the background, perfect sort of album for that. Love the vibes and super chill. Definitely will revisit when paying more attention to the music. Never got bored and loved all the songs.
𝘗𝘳𝘦𝘵𝘻𝘦𝘭 𝘓𝘰𝘨𝘪𝘤 strikes me as the strongest Steely Dan album I’ve heard so far: concise, smartly arranged, and full of songs that glide by with an easy, understated charm. The blend of pop structure and jazz-infused detail works better here than anywhere else in their catalog, at least for me. Even so, it’s not a record I feel the need to replay immediately — more something I’ll come back to when the right moment arrives.
not quite my vibe
This was a solid album. A little disappointed in some of the musical choices they made, would’ve made this even better. Feels like they went a kind of generic route. Especially night by night.
Eh
Yacht rockers rejoice! I have a soft spot for Steely Dan, my parents like them a lot so listening to them carries some feelgood nostalgia for me. Any major dude would tell you. For the album itself, not my favorite Dan album but I think there are still some gems in there like the title track Pretzel Logic. I think I would go 3.5 stars if I could but I'm leaning towards rounding down.
Rikki Don't Lose That Number is a perfect song. Reminds me of my Aunt Joan. I found myself vibing along to this one very heavily from the jump. Nodding my head. Generally loving it. So many great tracks. A touch slow in spots. 4.5/5
first time listening to this. been meaning to check out Steely Dan for a while now, if only to more fully appreciate the memes. my reaction upon listening: aight then
A type of music where the brevity of the album elevates my opinion of it. An hour of this would put me to sleep, but 30ish mins is enought to brighten my spirits. Charlie Freak was hella eerie and fantastic story telling. Makes me want to go back and listen more intently to other song lyrics. Classic rock, funk, jazz (cover) - Steely Dan did it all. I think I may be a SD fan now...
It’s such well put together music. So many earworms that are designed to get stuck in your head for days. It’s no Aja, but still fantastic.
Steely Dan is probably my biggest discovery so far doing this. Really enjoyed all the tracks on here but especially track 2 and the title track
Overall Rating - 4.09/5 (8.18/10). I consider this one of the weaker Classic Steely Dan (up to Gaucho) albums. That said, it's exactly the kind of tight, jazzy, slick rock music with nothing out of place that you expect from The Dan.
Some pretty fun tracks but kind of ultimately feels like a mess. I followed up with a couple tracks off Can't Buy a Thrill and liked that more. Maybe this just isn't the Dan for me.
Loved the music but the songs, not for me. They lack any gravitas or conviction
Super super solid, liked it a lot top to bottom.
I expect we'll see a bunch of Steely Dan records in here, and I expect they will have a high floor but a low ceiling. I think my general opinion of them having only dabbled is that they're just a little too slick for a jazz rock band compared to their contemporaries, even those coming from the rock side (thinking about Zappa especially). I guess you could even call this soft rock or my new least favorite term "adult-oriented-rock", but it's way more interesting than most of that stuff is. They compare extremely favorably to other soft-rock contemporaries, but do not hold a candle to other fusion contemporaries, I guess I'm saying. Nonetheless, they make like perfectly cromulent dad chunes that are musically interesting enough to listen to. This certainly is a record of their songs, and is is a perfectly fine record to throw on and either listen intently or just have it linger in the background. I remain curious whether one of their records is going to stand out enough to deserve a 4.
East St. Louis Toodle-Oo is a hilarious encapsulation of Steely Dan is so frustrating. anyways rikki slaps and parker's place is fun but there are so many things that insist on itself that I can't go higher than 3
Like a strong 3.5, good vibes, Ricky is good, but not extraordinary!
This was a tight 33min with fun melodies and harmonade me relisten easily. Steely Dan was a lot more enjoyable than I’d expected and especially after the wall of sound we endured from Springsteen, a cool and smooth reprieve
I think it was an Achewood line (maybe Teodor) — a person was trying to describe Steely Dan and said "Imagine if the greatest band in the world fucking sucked." It's a fun conceit I've enjoyed applying to other concepts*, the main point being there's this extremely technically accomplished group artfully making layered music but the end result is Yacht Rock. Anyhow I might give this a few more listens, but honestly I think 3 is where this belongs -- A good album that I wouldn't describe as being all that trail blazing and if not boring can at least sort of fade into the background. *My favourite: Imagine if the greatest comedian in the world fucking sucked — you'd get Tig Notaro
Love this album. So does my daughter on 1 year. Riktigt Don't Loose That Number have been playing a third time straight, and she's just jamming along. For me the best way to describe this album is; tasty. Tasty compositions, Donald Fagens tasty voice that fits so well with the music, and tasty guitar playing by Walter Becker.