Pretzel Logic by Steely Dan

Pretzel Logic

Steely Dan

3.38
Rating
30284
Votes
1
3%
2
13%
3
38%
4
32%
5
13%
Distribution

Reviews (page 6 of 15)

Just GOOD music. Love the flawless infusion of jazz, pop, and rock!! This was a great vibe that made me love music more. I need more Steely Dan in my life.

Pretty good, but it got old and repetitive pretty fast. I liked "Night by Night" a lot.

Yeah, I just don't get Steely Dan.

Contrary to what pre-40s me might've said, Steely Dan is good. Again this app makes a "not their most popular album" choice. Any major dude will tell you.

I’m not willing to reopen the Steely Dan Debate, but I enjoyed this.

oh fuck yes

Classic SD, nothing crazy.

Rock bem legal

Dad on a roadtrip music

To my ears this is mostly uncompelling. Good album cover though.

Rikki don't lose that number is easily ther best track on this album but the rest is mostly quite enjoyable too. maybe i'll listen to it a 2nd time

I have become such a steely dan fan!

OK, not great, not terrible. Pretty boring Dad rock.

Good 70s pianos and drums. Nothing outstanding but still a pleasant listen.

100%for me

I love the Dan. This isn't quite their best, but it's still better than 80% of the random, forgettable Britain-centric garbage on this list.

My 4th album of the challenge and the first one I had not previously listened to. I've always quite liked what I'd heard of from Steely Dan (classics like Reelin' in the Years etc) so was optimistic for this. A bit in two minds on first listen. Musically it's great, like jazzy and funky, and the guitar playing is outstanding. Rikki Don't Lose That Number is the only one I was familiar with from radio play. From a pure song perspective though, there wasn't a huge amount that gripped me, maybe it would take further listens.. Didn't seem to pull together as a coherent piece. Best bit: Track 5 instrumental is ace Worst bit: Can't say the title track did it for me. In fact I found it unintentionally amusing.

A couple of stand out tracks but little else emerged for me, as an album.

Really good. Uplifting.

Rikki and Any Major Dude are excellent. The rest could grow on me - it took a few listens to those two in the past. A bit naff in places.

Too 70s for me.

This was a good listen, I quite liked it as a change of pace to my norms. The production is sumptuous. I'm familiar with a couple of the tracks, but not heard a while album before today. However, I can't see myself hankering for a return. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ❌️ Surprising ★★★☆☆ (6/10)

A sneaky album but in the best intentions. Through with buzz is funny and melodic, any major dude will tell you is snidey but also has a message. As with most steely dan albums it likes itself a little too much. This is a tremendous collection though and their 2nd best album.

Lots of great songs on this album, highlights like Rikki Don’t Lose That Number and Any Major Dude Will Tell You. Didn’t think there were any weak songs or skips.

My go to Steely Dan Album is Aja and this album did nothing to sway that choice. It's.....fine.

It's fine I guess.

There were some highlight (Pretzel Logic as the title song), however the rest was rather average from my perspective.

This feels very 70s. I ended up listening to this a few times because i ended up getting distracted each time, and i think it got a little worse with each listen.

Good but I prefer Can't Buy A Thrill

very strong opening! I really liked Rikki don’t lose that number. And Barry town. It gets a bit boring for the second part of the album, but it’s still ok. Also a very short album. Production wise, amazingly fresh for a 70’s album. Can’t complain. A very low 5 for me. Enjoyable.

Decent listen, fine to have on during work but nothing super special on my book

Always love the smooth stylings of Steely Dan, even if I only knew one of their songs on this album coming into it. Still so hard to believe Chevy Chase was briefly part of this band. Probably could round up to a four but I’ll stick with a three.

A classic band with a classic sound. One big hit and the rest of the album is solid. A 3.5 for me.

I didn’t like this very much. The band is on point and the music sounds good I guess, it’s hard to explain, there is just something annoying about this record. Barrytown was super annoying, just complete nonsense. Title track is pretty solid, it’s not all bad by any means, it’s half bad and I’ll never return to this one. I’ll stick with Aja or Can’t Buy a Thrill. The album cover for Pretzel Logic is absolutely great though, so it’s a shame this isn’t better. I don’t know why this annoyed me so much but it did, it’s 2.5 stars but I’m rounding down. 2 stars

Three stars for the William Burroughs reference. ★★★

Like a bit of Dan

FUCK! I did not want Steely Dan. At this point, I know what I'm getting: impeccably crafted elevator music with lyrics that only make sense when you read the backstory, but aren't really interesting enough to want to read that backstory. I said in my Replacements review that imperfections make human connection to art rewarding. Despite the slavish devotion to studio perfection, I guess this is still imperfect in the sense that connecting to it isn't rewarding for me. How in the fuck was Rikki Don't Lose That Number a SINGLE? Actually, I'm knocking this down from the Coward's 3 due to the inclusion of East St. Louis Toodle-oo. Fuck off.

A steaming turd of an album. Starting with Rikki Don’t Lose That Number this may be the album that tipped the balance and inspired punk rock. This is a snooze fest from beginning to end. There are no edges or angularity in this lifeless anti-music designed to torture people in elevators. Night By Night is the them from a 70s television with a sound oft associated with cheesy detective shows it adds nothing lyrically. An’s that may be the real issue with the record. It is lifeless music by anonymous white people with no soul. This is music for ghouls. If this is the music that starts your day then you are already dead. Any Major Dude Will Tell You takes it down a notch if that is possible. Slow, with insipid lyrics it is representative of the record. I’m sure it is a sign of genius to try to make a record this terrible and lifeless with such precise playing a stellar production. It’s a nice sounding record- full, sonically balanced with each instrument mixed carefully but then you have to pay attention to the whole of the presented music and realize at that point that there is a jazz inflected “Minnie The Moocher” soundalike playing called East St.Louis Toodle-Oo and it’s bewildering coming about halfway through the record. The Temptation to turn it off at that point is strong. Somehow I made it through the record. Parker’s Band has an Elton John Philadelphia Freedom vibe to it. Just an observation. I have no idea what the song is about. Come and take a piece of Mr. Parker’s band? WTF? Through The Buzz. Nope. Getting high? Perhaps that might help but I’m not sure what drug would make it better. Thankfully that song is short. I sincerely tried to like Pretzel Logic when it came out in the 70’s. Some older kids said this was happening. I said “Have you fucking heard of Black Sabbath?” This is shit. It is just as boring as anything from that era. To think they would have a record Aja that would be much more popular than thus blew my mind. I then understood that the majority of Americans and most of Europe have really shitty taste in music. The last couple of songs on the record With A Gun, Charlie Frank and Monkey In Your Soul add nothing to the rest of the record - unremarkable and bland. Nothing could save this record. I guess really old people would have liked this record. Dangerously safe. It’s a 0 star record but the lowest option is 1. This is just not good.

Technically impressive but kinda boring?

Surprisingly great, a cosy, happy, tuneful time. The other SD/SD-adjacent records we’ve had so far have lived up to a reputation for favouring slickness over fun, but here even the tangible self-satisfaction is a laugh. The yacht rock more than jazz rock, better for it.

They sure have a characteristic sound, don't they - not one I particularly love nor hate. Jeff "Skunk" Baxter is a legend; I much prefer his era SD albums and am quite jealous of his career and moustache.

Great jams

Any major dude will tell you that I’m a Stan for the Dan. Get out your house coats, brandy, and stogies for this one.

I was surprised by this album, was good

I didn’t hate this. Decent songs. Great recorded sounds

Ofattbart många SD-skivor. För mig känns det helt oförtjänt. Jag måste missa något. Men det är inte svinbra, långt ifrån att få in fyra album på denna lista. Nej, det här är mest irriterande (kan bero på min egen okunskap etc. Men nu dömer jag i huvudsak på känsla).

Fjärde Steely Dan-skivan nu. Denna sticker ut lite pga de många jazziga inslagen, vilket var lite kul. Som vanligt är det tekniskt oklanderligt, men denna lyfter ändå inte riktigt för mig. Samtidigt är det behaglig lyssning. Får konstatera att Can’t buy the thrill verkar vara deras bästa skiva och att denna är en genomsnittlig trea.

It's pretty good despite not being my genre exactly. It's some pretty good jazzy rock, but I don't think I can pick out a song as particularly great.

Not really a huge fan of yacht rock, but this album has a ton of good songs. Maybe it’s growing on me.

Troisième album de Steely Dan généré, le premier étant le très jazzy 'Aja' (plus récent) que j'avais plutôt apprécié (3/5) et le second le plus pop/rock 'Can't Buy A Thrill' qui m'avait moins intéressé (2/5). Ce nouvel album est aussi très pop/rock, il ne m'intéresse pas plus que 'Can't Buy A Thrill' : il m'a paru interminable malgré ses 34 mn ... même note donc. =>2/5

Enjoyed this much more than Aja

2 stars. I'm sure they've done better than this. Any major dude will tell you this album is boring.

5 stars!

Sure it's the kind of music your Dad listens to and you probably hated it growing up because everything they listened to sounded the same, but becoming an adult is recognising that you might also like Dad rock because this is pretty damn good.

Bit boring

My exploration of the 1001 Albums list is currently being guided by artists like Steely Dan, those I've somehow managed to skip over until now. The question with "Pretzel Logic" is whether it qualifies as a five-star omission from my album collection. My conclusion: no! It just earns a rating of four stars. While the opening track, "Rikki Don't Lose That Number", is a familiar radio staple from my youth, at that time it didn't resonate as strongly with me as other acts of the day such as Bowie, Elton John, or the UK Glam Rock scene. The album truly shines on two tracks: the irresistible groove of "Night by Night" and the title track, both highlighted by exceptional lead guitar. Outside of those moments, "Pretzel Logic" remains firmly in the realm of pleasant, safe soft rock, characterized by crisp production, subtle jazz influences, and capable vocals, but ultimately too reserved to leave a lasting mark. Side one 1 "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" (3/5) 2 "Night by Night" (5/5) 3 "Any Major Dude Will Tell You" (3/5) 4 "Barrytown" (4/5) 5 "East St. Louis Toodle-Oo" (3/5) Side two 6 "Parker's Band" (3/5) 7 "Through with Buzz" (3/5) 8 "Pretzel Logic" (5/5) 9 "With a Gun" (4/5) 10 "Charlie Freak" (3/5) 11 "Monkey in Your Soul" (4/5) Total - 40 Average - 3.64 151/1001 81/151 albums reviewed were new to me.

I used to dislike Steely Dan because of the people who liked it. Then I actually listened to it, and I started liking it. Now I'm starting to go back the other way. Steely Dan is music made by people with a really strong understanding of music theory and composition, but have the mentality of 19 year old fraternity bros (who used to be marching band dorks). I have to appreciate songs like Rikki Don't Lose That Number for the musical masterpiece it is, but when I dig into the lyrics...it's just a bunch of guys who are trying to impress women with their masters in liberal arts and job in finance in an attempt to sleep with them. Plus hard liquor and cocaine. It just seems like such a waste of talent and musical aptitude. ...and that's basically yacht rock. Musically interesting and completely vapid at the same time.

A few solid hits and a bunch of less memorable stuff.

mostly smooth and groovey tracks with some unmemorable fillers inbetween. solid.

5/5 Steely Dan

Not this one. 1.7

It was fine background music

Some iconic songs, but I did not even notice the album ended, so maybe a little too much in the background

One of my all time favorites and the one that made me a Steely Dan convert.

Fantastic album. Top notch technical playing. Certainly underrated drumming and time signatures. The first three songs are undoubtedly the highlight then starts to tail off a bit after that. Love his voice. Love the lyrics. Great album. I agree should be in the top 1001.

Smooth listening. Too many sound the same. Enjoyed Night by Night most for its funk and Monkey in Your Soul for their change in style.

Excellent album but not great. I would definitely download the record but wouldn't classify it as a must have or classic. However, there are classic songs on it.

I'm not a Steely Dan guy, but even setting the bar low, I've never gotten the praise for this album. The only songs I find engaging are "Rikki Don't Lose That Number," the Outlaw Country "With A Gun," and the angular, sinister "Charlie Freak." "Any Major Dude Will Tell You" sounds like warm milk but gets points for extremely corny '70s lyrics ("I've never seen you looking so bad my funky one/you tell me your super fine mind has come undone"). "Barrytown" might have been a good song if there was even an ounce of menace the lyrics suggest in the music. "Parker's Band" is the Dorky White Guy tribute to Charlie Parker to the point where it's almost feels like an insult to Bird. "Pretzel Logic" is the dorkiest, whitest, blues song you'll ever hear. Everything else is so forgettable that I can't even bother to make fun of it. I am certainly not one to criticize vocals too much (I just praised a Frank Black album, for chrissakes) but Donald Fagen's warbling straddles the line between "quaintly charming" and "I wonder if I would like this more if they had a better singer." Pretzel Logic is an album very much of it's time. Steely Dan's previous album, Countdown To Ecstasy, was a commercial failure and they needed to get back on the radio. 1974 top 40 wasn't really a neighborhood for challenging music, so yes, compared to Barbra Streisand, Grand Funk Railroad and John Denver, this was practically avant-garde. But a lot of their music was suggestive of better, funkier and (dare I say) Blacker music that was taking place at the time, and nobody should have needed the White Guy filter to enjoy any of it.

Nett. Aber musikalisch kein Meilenstein.

Flew by so quickly. Super smooth. Nearly a 5

Ok storytelling throughout, too folksy for my taste. Best: Parker's Band Worst: Pretzel Logic

Falls kind of flat as an album (and I'm a Steely Dan fan). I'm discovering that there are four Steely Dan albums on this list! All that is needed is "Can't Buy a Thrill", imho. The rest on here is kind of insanity.

This sounds so modern, it’s incredible!

The first side (or the 1st 3 or 4 songs) were great. But I just didn't like anything after Barrytown. The best thing about Steely Dan: I was at one of Levon's Midnight Rambles with a friend (who later passed during the COVID epidemic) in which one of the guest guitarists was Donald Fagan. So many great memories with my friend during this era as we also visited "Big Pink" and the then-present owner allowed us access into the basement. For me, like getting a personal after-hours pass into Graceland for those who love Elvis. Better actually, since I could not give a shite about Elvis/Graceland.

Yes but without prog. That's pretty much 80s Yes though... Nevermind then. It sounds like if 70s Yes didn't have prog.

hmm i love the chourus in the 1st song, rest of the song is dissapointing everything was just so boring i zone out heavily like a 4/10

Reminds me of the kind of music I was deeply obsessed with a few years ago. Still my style, but I’m trying to expand. Interestingly, although I’ve listened to tracks here before, never the full album:

it makes me fall asleep.

Being 55, I’ve certainly heard plenty of Steely Dan songs over the years, but somehow until this pick I never bothered to listen to an entire album and give them a serious listen. I spent my formative years mostly listening to new wave & punk, then the many alternative bands and genres that branched from here. I have subsequently expanded my tastes, but it never included a serious listen of this band until today. Impressive instrumentals by obviously talented musicians. Great guitar work, some outstanding rock riffs. Also, great keys. Cool hand drums. Great horns. All great musicians playing as a cohesive unit. This is sophisticated music. I also really like the blend of different musical genres. Principally a rock album, I heard influences from jazz, blues, rag time, honky tonk, funk and pop. Many of the best bands from the 70s experimented with such genre-mashing and it is done really well on this album. It is easy to dismiss this as boring today, but albums like that combined familiar riffs and hooks in unique ways were important in creating the breadth of music we enjoy today. Yes, I can see how this would be described as dad rock, but I’m a dad and I like rock. I loved this record more than I thought I would while listening at the office and I can’t wait to give it another listen on the hi-fi system by the fire after work. I’ll definitely be checking out more of Steely Dan’s discography. It is pretty rare for the albums on this list to be completely new to me and it is weird to me that a band as lauded as Steely Dan would be among them, but here we are. Better late than never.

I'm just not a Steely Dan person. I don't hate if a song comes on every now and again but don't see myself coming back to listen

This to me sounds like the most accessible Steely Dan has ever been. A more "traditional" pop song structure. Short, Catchy and not as much time devoted to solos. The solo work is always what I appreciated about the band, so maybe this one isn't my favorite, but their skilled musicians and I'll listen to them any way I can get them.

It's a good album, but not even close to one of my favorites from the Dan.

Ihan mukavaa rokkia mutta ei tällekään ihan nelosta voi antaa. Aivan upea levyn kansi ja mukava tuttavuus, mutta tästä huokuu kyllä kovasti jenkkimarkkinat. Joissain biiseissä ehkä torvisoittimet ottaa omaan korvaan liian isoa roolia jota vokaalit ei pysty lunastamaan. Mut kyl meikä tuolta kiskalta pretzelin ostaisi. Rikki dont lose that number jäi jopa soimaan päähän mukavasti

Periaatteessa ihan ok taustamusaa, ei kyllä saanut millään tasolla viisaria värähtämään suuntaan eikä toiseen. Siitä hyvästä nakataan Dania kolkilla

Aika kädenlämpöiseksi jäi tämäkin.

Jee päästiin näiden salaisten paheitteni äärelle. Eli pehmeetä karkkia tarjolla korvakäytäviin. Tää nyt ei oo näistä höyryseksilelustanimensäsaaneen pumpun parhaita levyjä, kun vaan yhdellä biisillä rumpuja soittaa porokaran jehvi. Night by night onkin albuumin paras biisi. Yleisesti ottaen miellyttävää ja harmitonta menoa. Jos itzessä vielä henki pihisee 50v päästä niin todnäk tää ois sillon täyven vitosen setti. Nyt kuitenkin jää vähän vajaaks, joten perusvarmalla mennään.

Parasta Steely Dania mitä itse olen kuullut, mutta mihin se sitten riittää. Tosi puhdasta ja viimeisen päälle hiottua, ei paljon "Oho"-hetkiä ole levyllä. East St. Louis Toodle-Oo oli ihan hauska välipala, kun taas nimibiisin synariffista tuli tosi vahvasti Tom Robinson Band mieleen. Ollaan kyllä varmaan jossain Radio Nova -ystävällisen musan rootseilla tämän kanssa. Eikä siinä siis mitään väärää ole, itsehän olen setämiehistyttyäni uskaltanut ihan antaa luvan itselleni diggailla ihan avoimesti tämmöisestä aor-kamasta. Hyviä biisejä, virheetöntä meininkiä ja sopivan mittainen levy. Helppo nelonen.

Technically sound and probably good but it melted into the background and I forgot I was listening to it.

Just awful, as in mediocre yacht-rock garbage that wasn't unlistenable, but held little merit. Two stars.

"Pretzel logic" refers to twisted or illogical reasoning. See Example: Steely Dan being on this list. Would I listen to again? Probably on a dare...

Meh. Kinda corny elevator music

Great recording, super groovy with a lot of interesting sounds. Super consistent, every song is equally good

Very easy listening.

Etwas langweilig

Overall I would say it's pretty standard 70's soft rock, which isn't a bad thing, but this album doesn't exactly set the world on fire. There was some really nice guitar work on 'Night By Night' which I enjoyed. 'East St. Louis Toodle-Oo' is a very interesting track. It's sounds as if you're walking through a busy New York street. Very cool sound. 'Charlie Freak' has a very up and down hook which is a proper ear worm. The opener was also one of the better tracks. Technically sound and I'm sure a lot of people love it, but I kind of drifted in and out of this one. It was alright.

All very beautifully arranged and played but the songs themselves are average.

Le premier morceau était excellent mais sinon, le restant de l'album n'était pas mémorable. 2.5/5

It was alright

Laadukasta ja toisaalta aika mitäänsanomatonta aikuisrokkia

⭐️⭐️⭐️

Erittäin onnistunut! Sanat, sovitukset, stemmat kaikki kohdillaan. Tätä tulee kuunneltua jatkossakin!

I could fill a whole essay with the numerous reasons why I dislike Steely Dan, but I don’t have the energy. Let’s just say their music irks me on a very fundamental level, and makes me want to hit someone in the face with a shovel. I have no problem acknowledging they are technically very competent, but that’s irrelevant. Many artists can produce technically perfect music and still be as exciting as a piece of cardboard. I’ll even admit that it’s the least unsufferable Steely Dan album I’ve listened so far. The instrumentals are generally solid ; but I really hate Donald Fagen's soulless singing. The only song I really loved in this album was East St. Louis... which is actually a Duke Ellington cover. All the other songs are just too dull and emotionless for me to care. 4/10

There's something and then it's nothing. I think I particularly dislike the voice. I don't know what to say. But I won't listen again.

Outdated & nice & common album, nothing special for the listening Album almost already forgotten...

Of all the so-called “rock” albums by Steely Dan we’ve talked about so far (including The Nightfly solo project), this is the first one that actually sounds kind of rock. The production is a bit less clean too, without all that slick jazz-rock polish. Still, it mostly ends up sounding like a weak mix between Supertramp and the Eagles and ends up as a generic record. Yet, it is by far more listenable to me than the others Steely Dan on this list with some nice instrumentations, but honestly, I can’t imagine it ever made much of a splash when it came out.

A bit too “easy listening” for my taste

ehh nothing notable, just an album

It wasn't new 50 years ago, now its dull and trite. I prefer a lot of lift music to this.

Standout Tracks: Rikki Don't Lose That Number Any Major Dude Will Tell You Barrytown But it's all good.

Lyrically good, but dated. Think, Inspector Morse drinking tea on a porch with his dressing gown flapping.

Really enjoyed this one

Pretty alright album! Definitely not better than 'Can't Buy A Thrill', but still a good listen. The first track and title track were my two favourites.

I really really like this album it reminded me of David Bowie and had super cool guitar my favorite song was pretzel logic kinda sounded like Led Zeppelin. Such an amazing album!!!

Easy enough to listen to. Not enough standouts to get a 4.

Cool kid's Dad rock

Eff this website, screw them

DNF. not my thing. Not as good as 10CC

Smooth. Sounds impeccable. Musicianship is superb. Regardless, they’re just not my thing. Not a bad listen, though.

It's okay, not as strong as the other albums.

Steely Dan has some excellent music but I really didn't think this was that great an record, especially the back half. It starts out strong with it's first 3 songs, no doubt. I had never heard Night by Night before, but I really dug that track. That's bookended by a couple of songs we've all heard before in Ricky Don't Lose That Number and Every Major Dude Would Tell You, the former of which is superior to the latter, mainly because of the harmonies and offbeat vocal choices that really work. That said, after that it steadily goes downhill. There are some poor tracks on here, especially With a Gun and the title track. Rare to name a record after a song which is clearly inferior to some of the others, but Steely Dan always have been different. Just an average album.

3.5! again this is opinion not like critiquing

Classic. One of my favorites.

Apart from the East Louise toodle....instrumental. This is a flawless album. Really like Charlie Freak and the arrangements involved.

It's good

I quite liked this album

There's a lot to like in this record. It's short and sweet, and there are a couple of standout tracks too. Favourite Track(s): Barrytown, Easy St. Louis Toodle-Oo Least Favourite Track(s): Any Major Dude Will Tell You

Pretty run of the mill

Maybe I’m messed up by listening to aja before this, maybe just not the time for me right now but I’m just not feeling this. Will have to revisit sometime later.

Just not my style

Pretty good easy listening. Very good. But nothing really catches me

Definitely a classic, but a little dated at times

This album is lively and a pleasant enough listen, but it leaves little impression on me and feels slightly bland for my taste. There’s no doubting the album’s “maturity”, and the sprinkle of jazz influence on the soft-rock base is nice to listen to, but it still falls flat and I can’t imagine I’ll remember much of the album in days to come - other than perhaps “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number”.

- Ist mal wieder ein gutes klassisches Rockalbum - Würde ich wahrscheinlich nochmal hören aber fast eher im Hintergrund - Ich kannte sogar einen Song welcher auch der Topsong des Albums für mich ist Topsong: Rikki don’t lose that number

This was another good album from Steely Dan and I know the main single but I hadn't heard anything else from this album and I quite enjoyed it!

Solid 70s guitar.

Better than aja, that’s for sure. Forgettable. THREE!

dosta dobro, između trojke i četvorke, mislio sam da će mi se više svidjeti. naginje ipak trojci

There’s plenty of speculation kicking about at the moment regarding artificial intelligence. The race to be the first to crack artificial general intelligence – and with it, the right to dictate what the future of humanity looks like, I suppose – is on. Consultants and commentators swarm: “will the workforce be ready?”, “should AGI be free for all?”, “what’s the future of the future of ecommerce look like?”. Anyway, if you’re reading this – and you will be – then listen up. We made this. Well, I didn’t, but don’t be obtuse. Steely Fuckin’ Dan, man. Prodigious postmodernist pop perfection fuckin’ Dan. They weave, duck and dive. They make the most ridiculous choices and then hammer them home with such conviction that you sort of just totally forget how lame you thought it was going to be seconds earlier. They start songs as if they’re already halfway through them, putting you on the back foot in a way that ultimately becomes rewarding somehow. They’re fucking jerks, obviously, god can you imagine? But they’re Dan. They’re only human. Anyway, if it’s peace out to all soul owners then this shall exist only to show pixel posterity that I tried. But if it goes like I hope it will, then AGI’s going to go deep and come back up grinning. Success will write “Any major dude will tell you” across the sky.

Great album. Love it. My favorite Steely Dan, but not their best. Has some "meh" songs (Garrytown, and Through with Buzz). Not their finest work

Classic 5/5

3.5 stars

It’s Steely Dan. I’m a middle aged man. It’s fine.

I’ve always had an irrational hatred for Steely Dan; it’s bad lounge rock. This album did nothing to change my mind. There aren’t enough Harvey Wallbangers in the world to make me like this.

I’ve never been a real fan of Steely Dan and listening to this album did nothing to improve that. I kept thinking these songs sounded like ithey were created on Christmas morning with a kids newly unwrapped 32-key Casio keyboard. If this album had been 11 tracks of Rikki Don’t Lose That Number I might have been able to give it a better score, but mediocrity begets mediocrity.

The compositions and instrumentals are amazing. But these guys can’t write lyrics or sing. They are band geeks who never got past that. Care to disagree? “East St. Louis Toodle-Oo”. Now, shut the fuck up. Hey Steely Dan, me and Geddy Lee, Thomas Dolby, Ben Folds and the guys from Weezer are gonna steal a case of Miller Lites from Cumberland Farms and go to the football game later. Wanna skip band practice and come? Nah, I didn’t think so.

I like Steely Dan. Smooth jazz mixed with prog rock, very enjoyable. They are the kind of band I never really liked well enough to delve into the catolouge, but always enjoyed on the radio. For that reason I was happy to give this album a listen. Strong start Rikki Don't Lose That Number, great song, and the only song on the album I'd heard before. Night by Night, I liked alot, feels like I'm in for a banger of an album. Then it drops off into the realm of "meh". Very talented players, but feels like they are trying too hard to be hip and cool. Part of that is their white guy groove, they try so hard to sneak a funky groove into their songs, but they are so damn white. It's fine, doesn't ruin the songs, but gives them a musak feel. Only other songs on the album worth note are the title track Pretzel Logic, which is very good, and East St Louis Toodle which is awful. Sounds like something they had fun with in the studio and decided to share with the world, should have stayed on the cutting room floor. Overall the album was dissappointing but not bad. This is a very strong 2.

Love the complexity of this album. They slide between jazz, wah guitar solos, gongs, strings and 80s pop rock. I think what I like about Steely Dan is just the absurdity of what they do but somehow wrapping up into a package that's super accessible to a huge range of people. When I eventually get a boat and spend my sunny Sundays cruising the coast and drinking red wine it will be Steely Dan I listen to.

I realized while listening to this album that if CSNY played jazz rock instead of folk rock, they'd sound a lot like Steely Dan. To make a more modern comparison, some of the singing and composition on this album remind me of Geordie Greep on the New Sound (which better be on the user list by the time I make it there!). Anyways, as a suburban dad in his 30s, I approve.

Not as good as Ajr, but def a solid rock album with jazz influence. It makes me happy when bands push the boundaries in instrument use.

Talented musicians, good jazz influences and chill music. How could you possibly not make the greatest album of all time, yet it steps into mediocrity. Aja is objectively better, but I'm always disappointed with Steely Dan. Like, they have the potential to be great, but never did act on it.

Interesting mix of rock and blues, always soft and light. Catchy hooks.

I always liked Steely Dan. Music you can put on for chilling by the pool

Easy listening Top tier production. Nothing really stands out as spectacular but definitely not disappointed at any point. 3.5 outta 5

The better end of stuff from “classic rock” radio stations. Very consistent in quality, and enjoyed the jazzy instrumental. Solid but not nothing that stands out too much.

15 cent pretzels? That's a deal and a half

Boring and repetitive every song sounds exactly the same and the dude is annoying

i didnt think id like it but its actually pretty good. jeff porcaro gives these tracks a lot of energy and really pushes through.

Didn’t mind this one while it was on but nothing very memorable

Started off good but then just got boring

Alright, this is going to be a fun challenge - afraid that I agree with the turbo-paedo Steve Albini about Steely Dan being dull studio wank, so actually listening to a whole album could hopefully be a voyage of discovery! ---- It's very clean. It really can't shake that "manufactured" feeling, and the end result is an impeccably-produced splodge of tightly white jazz/funk rock. It's all the self-knowing Yankee bollocks that I don't like from Zappa, but with little of his balls to redeem it - there are a few decent tunes, and they're the most "natural" sounding! Better than I feared, worse than I hoped. Favourite tracks: Night By Night, Barrytown, With A Gun

Too intellectual.

The harmonies- the organ- the chill, jammy guitar solos. the HITS. Cheers to Steely Dan!

The best thing about this album was that it was only 33 minutes long although it felt a lot longer. Tedious, middle-of-the-road dad rock. The penultimate track, Charlie Freak, was the only one worth listening to. My second Steely Dan album in the first 55 days. Can't Buy A Thrill was bad - this was even worse.

Positively surprised, the album sounds very nice, touches of blues, wind music, it sounds so 70s. It deserves another listen.

Good but unremarkable in my opinion.

Pas trop mon style J'en ai quand même liké quelques unes Ça ressemble à Supertramp en moins bien

1st track is a classic but it's downhill fast from there.

Super soft 10-ply. Nah man, I can lose this number

Different styles that are nice to listen to.

Decent album with one song that's for the ages.

It’s just a great rock album. More bluesy and soft than anything to be honest, but fantastic song craft throughout. A great entry and exit song in this album too. Said it before and I’ll say it again, but it’s one of the things that makes a great album. Maybe I’m biased but this album is just a great listen. Doesn’t have enough hits to justify a perfect score, but a great listen nonetheless

Love this album. gives billy joel vibes

okay, but not great. A bit too cool for me.

The more I listen to Steely Dan the more I just get it. This stuff just rules. It's such a great vibe, the perfect blend of funky rock and jazzy blues. Favorite tracks were East St. Louis Toodle-Oo, Any Major Dude Will Tell You, and Charlie Freak. 8/10, 4 stars.

Essential Steely Dan. Brilliant album with a wide palette of musical ideas executed flawlessly.

Dad rock incarnate. Great album nonetheless.

Omg first rock and roll album i heard, love the sound

Good vibes, a bit dated.

My second attempt at getting into Steely Dan. The musicianship is flawless, and the production is pristine but the songs feel like they’re stuck in neutral. It’s technically impressive yet completely devoid of energy. How something this well-played can sound this dull is kind of fascinating in itself.

“Rikki Don’t Lose That Number”! Great opener to the album that goes in a lot of different directions. What it lacks in cohesiveness it makes up for in songwriting. What a strange release in the heyday of rock n’ roll where money could be made off of album sales alone. I liked it but it’s a little too yacht rock for me. I feel like there’s an inherent lameness that gives me the “ick” as the kids say.

Short and sweet. Night by Night, you just feel cool listening to it. Some of the songs didn’t pull me as much. 3.5 stars (I wish these were rated out of 10 rather than 5)

Sounds better than most things. Fun, jumpy jazz/rock thing with plenty of variance while remaining on theme. Album’s shorter than usual and this is one of those rare times where I wish there was more.

Nothing stood out to me

Rikki don’t looose that numberrr Edit Apr 2 2026: 4 --> 3

Good, not my favorite rock music. Mastering was good but nothing jumped out at me.

Among my least favorite records by a great group.

Американская музыка, поп рок, поп джаз.

🗯 Music for people who iron their jeans and alphabetise their vinyl a bit too closely Steely Dan’s third album, and the last before Becker & Fagen locked themselves away as full-time studio scientists, is basically flawless. They take their jazz fixation and polish it into something radio-friendly without dumbing it down. ‘Rikki Don’t Lose That Number’ is the obvious entry point, but the real magic is all over: the title track’s sly piano sway, harmonies layered like a smug grin, songs so sharp they make you double-check your hi-fi setup. Fifty years on, this still sounds crisp and modern — meticulous without being sterile, nerdy without being dull. It’s like they coded grooves in Fortran but somehow made them funky. That’s the Dan paradox: dad rock that’s somehow still aspirational. Verdict: Essential (for the musos, the hipsters, and the dads ironing their Levi’s on Sunday) For fans of: Doobie Brothers, Toto, Hall & Oates, music that makes you want to buy a better turntable

Wasn't a bad listen but didn't really stand out to me at all.

Meh. They’re talented, but their music is so inert.

And a half

This would be a 3.5

It was nice but ronan said it was a solid 4.4 so I went in with high expectations. IT WAS NOT

This most definitely fucks, absolutely loved this. Never listened to a full Steely Dan album before and this has turned me into a fan. Can't wait to hear more. I ordered this on vinyl, easy 4

Funky yet not defined by the funk. A solid album of songs I have never heard before and probably won’t ever hear again. 8/10

Any major dude will tell you this is great

(4) ok this is awesome

Tonight is a Steely Dan night. Tonight is a Pretzel Logic night. This one’s sneaky—it doesn’t have the sprawling jams of Aja or the polish of Gaucho, but it’s absolutely loaded. “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number” opens with one of their most iconic hooks, “Any Major Dude” sounds like a cosmic pep talk, and the title track is pure Dan wordplay perfection. Then there’s “Parker’s Band,” their little love letter to Charlie Parker, and “Monkey in Your Soul,” where Donald Fagen sounds like he’s trying to sweet-talk you and insult you at the same time. It’s tight, it’s weird, it’s brilliant. Basically, it’s Steely Dan. Tonight’s pretzel is twisted just right.

I'm not sure how Steely Dan has 4 albums on this list. Don't get me wrong, I like them but to say they are iconic to a point where they have about as much albums on this list as Pink Floyd is a bit of a stretch. That being said, this album is pretty meh in my opinion. It's just the same formula that they've used their entire run so I can't say it really stuck out to me. Yeah, I just think it is really bland, not horrible but not great at the same time. Favorite Songs: Rikki Don't Lose That Number, Any Major Dude Will Tell You Rating: 3/5

Two Steely Dan's in just over a week. This is my least favorite of those I've heard in full so far, but it's still solid. A number of shorter tracks which I'm not used to from them.

Enjoyable but not something I'm likely to revisit

Pretty good.

CINQUE MILLE UN MILIONE

il 5 più 5 che ho dato fino ad ora. il modo in cui si sovrappongono i suoni mi fa impazzire lo ascolterei per ore

Bellissimo mi ha gasato un sacco bello bello bello

Steely dan grandi geni. Grande album dall’inizio alla fine, poi ricky don’t lose that number hit assoluta. 9-/10

mi è piaciuto molto

Che fatto incredibile.

Pretty fun album! Has some more variety and/or personally interesting tracks to me than Aja, while still being pretty nicely short.

Another great album from Steely Dan! We got Aja early on in this challenge, and while I don't like this as much as that one, it has been steadily rising my Dan rankings for a while now, so it entered this challenge at the perfect time. Much more grounded in earlier forms of rock than Aja, and much less influenced by jazz fusion, it still captures that breezy, self-loathing spirit of the Dan's best.

Certainly not Steely Dan’s best stuff and not my favorite, but still some good stuff in here! And nothing bad at least. The title track was incredible, and I enjoyed the guitar on Night by Night, but not much else stood out to me.

This is one of those flawed albums I can't help but love. I don't think anything here is as technically impressive as Aja, and it does hit a bit of a slump in the back half. Despite that, the high points more than make for it with how fun they are. East St. Louis Toodle-Oo stood out as a shining highlight, haters be damned -- Steely Dan is based as hell for the Duke Ellington nod there. Standouts: Night By Night • Any Major Dude Will Tell You • Barrytown • East St. Louis Toodle-Oo • Monkey In Your Soul

Was not thrilled on this on my first listen because it seemed a little meandering and pointless, but I spent more time on a second listen enjoying the piano in the background and the song structure. Willing to call this a tentative low 4 because it kept my ear interested.

The album was interesting. Had some strong points, but not my favorite.

This album screams 70s background music.

Before starting this challenge, I had only heard A Royal Scam. The songs here are shorter and surprisingly commercial, albeit with a zany funk and jazz fusion. I imagine this could get up to four stars for me with repeated listens, but based on first impressions it's a three.

not bad, pretty groovy

Pretty cool.

Good if you're into that kind of thing

Задорный и чрезвычайно мелодичный альбом. Особенно начало понравилось, потом немножко поостыло впечатление (может ещё потому, что слушал после великолепного альбома Стиви Уандера). 7 из 10.

Not suprised that its another really good album like pretty much all killer no filler. Not as good as other steely dan albums but still great. 8/10 Favourite: Rikki Don't Lose That Number Least Favourite: East St. Louis Toodle-Oo

Day 31 A new one for me and I was really impressed. Looking forward to listening to the other Steely Dan albums 8/10 Highlights Night by Night Pretzel Logic With a Gun

I have never met Napoleon, but I plan to find the time

Not the Dan's best, some 5/5 songs, some lacking

Pretty boring

good background music, couple of familiar hits on this album

🤙🏾

Hard to believe this album is over 50 years old. It still sounds pretty fresh today and has some beautiful melodies and harmonies. Not entirely to my taste but a pleasant listen when relaxing.

Listens: 3 Standout Tracks: East St. Louis Toodle-Oo, With A Gun Second Steely Dan album on the List. Still largely average with a few standout tracks. I like the instrumental Toodle-Oo ditty, and With A Gun. Nothing I recognize from radio play and I was not super impressed by the single Rikki Don't Lose That Number.

Rikki Don't Lose That Number and that's about it

Standout Songs: Rikki Don't Lose That Number Any Major Dude Will Tell You Barrytown Parker's Band With A Gun Charlie Freak Really solid album that was fun to listen to. Even the slower songs still had a cheerful vibe. Very pleasant

You can call it tight harmonies if you like, I guess, but to me the vocals just sound blurry. In fact, the whole sound feels like you're listening to them behind glass at a supper club. There's wood paneling on the walls and everything looks like it was filmed directly onto VHS.

One of my least favorite internet tropes is when people share a medium-hot take that is ostensibly uncontroversial and then add on ‘There, I said it’ as if they've made peace with their god about confessing the white hot rage they've kept locked away for years, morality and social norms be damned. Anyway, Steely Dan sucks. There, I said it.

I am a Dan-head, and had a blast buzzing through this record. Jazzy pop rock that is as tight as can be and chock full of hooks and grooves. They dip into some country, blues, dixieland, etc. but firmly sound like Steely Dan; unique lyrics and pristine sound.

Its good. 82/100

I’ve commented about the size of this project before and how ranking 1000 albums is going to inherently result in many mediocre choices being ranked. I’m a middle aged white guy, so I have plenty of time for Steely Dan. But this is obviously not their best work, and not even a fan’s choice of underappreciated album (I like “Coubtdown to Ecstasy” personally. It’s fine, and again as a middle aged white man, who doesn’t like to be reminded of that scene in Say Anything when John Mahoney is cruising around to “Rikki Don’t Lose That Number”?

pretty chill vibe

I know this is total dad music but I’ve always loved these guys. They’re not sweating the small stuff.

It's fine I guess.

I should have liked this more. No doubt they were influential though.

Never been a fan of these guys. They are obviously super talented but not my get down. And Donald Fagen’s voice is not my cup of tea.

3 out of 5 Quintessential yet background classic rock. I know their music well but would not seek it out.

Very focused album that while the production level is high and musicianship is strong the overall range of songs seems scattered.

Rikki Dont Lose that number. Marimba at the beginning? Id forgottwn about it. What is it. Like an album overture - hey everyone come in and sit down, the album is about to start. Mariba over i love the intro to this. Bam bum bum. Bam bum bum. Simple, clean, bit most of all beautiful tone then into the melody. Love the drums over all on this song. The overall groove is so laid back, deceptively casual, but the the drum fills crack and so precise. I bet they ALWAYS use a click track. Such a nice mix if constraint (guitar, drums) and passion (piano) to bring texture. Night by night. Synchopation (?) of the organ gives this such a funk feel. A few wackachicka guitars over this wouldnt be out of place. But there’s a real rock feel to the lead. Can imagine a Dread Zep cover of this. Any major dude will tell. How do they get that close your in the recording booth with them, but back of the hall feel to this? Drums different feel in this song. Very sparse on the fills, toms not as prominent in the mix. Feels less driven, more relaxed. Barrytown. These lyrics make a song whose time has come again! Can imagine this as a song in a musical. Something odd about the notes in thw guitar at the outro bit. Slightly flat maybe (almost a beep boop computer type feel) leading into a country vibe riff (which fits the song). East St Louise. Intermission? Off you go. Have a toilet break. The record will recommence shortly. Its fine an all but id like my ragtime(?new orleans jazz?) with a little less click track. A bit dirtier. Parkers band. Lovely guitar in the early part, around and playing. It gave me the bit of dirty i was missing the previous track. Through with buzz. Orchestral! Theres quite a mix of styles on this album but it remains very much a Dan sound. Pretzel Logic. Another sweet groove to this song, almost a blues groove to the bass in this. I like the Dan songs with a funk or swing or groove to them like this the best i think. I think it is the balance against the metronome feel and shows their craft well. Guitar bit at end sounded like they didnt know how to end it. With a gun. Great track. I could never sing this (yes cant sing at the beat of times, but the key changes, slides up and down - it rarely seems to rest on a note long before hitting another). Charlie Freak. Another favorite om this album. Love the kind of walking bass lines through this, the tick tock feel, the layering of violin??? Bringing in the intensity. Dark lyrics. Beautifully crafted. Monkey in your soul. The dirty bass!!! Such a good sound. Another great groove, bright horns, the guitar solo - reminds me of aomwthing but cant think what. Quick listen - as in not a drag to listen to. They dont fuck around (apart from that intro and intermission. Not much out of olace or wasted anywhere on this album.

Meh I forgot I listened to this tbh and had it unrated for ages. Oops That's how bland it was. Funnily enough I said something similar for another album of theirs 3 ⭐️

Frank Zappa for stuffy folks. 2/ 5

Ok. Pretty good. I liked barrytown and monkey in your soul.

Solid album, love the vibe and some songs to come back to 4.7

I've had Aja from Steely Dan already from this list, and any major dude would tell you it's nearly impossible to top Aja. This album does have a few more classic Steely Dan tracks on it, but it's not quite on Aja's level in both a production and creative level. But that just shows what a juggernaut the band truly is. This album is still very good. 4 stars Hard to pick between "Rikki Don't Lose That Number" or "Any Major Dude Will Tell You" for the playlist... I might add both, just because some albums on here have had no good songs to add.

Steely Dan is weird.

Definitely not what I expected. The mixing is superb and the harmonies sound great. A lot of variety but the sound is pretty consistent somehow. Some great guitar licks and the bass is particularly the driving force behind a lot of these tunes.

Rikki Don't Lose That Number earns this a full extra point, but ultimately this didn't impress me much.

Best Steely Dan albums are yet to come, but this too has great songs and those familiar Steely Dan chord voicings, strange arrangements and great story telling are already here. My favourite song of the album is Night by night. Donald Fagen's singing needs acquired taste.

IDK maybe this isn't their best album or I'm not in the right mood, but I just don't get this. I think the overproduction really lacks personality, and feels overcrowded, which I don't think you can really say for other production perfectionists like Brian Wilson. I don't really like the vocals either, probably preferred his solo album, pretty much everything is double tracked, so it just feels quite fake and tacky after a while. I think people call this jazz rock and I can't really see it, I think it would benefit from some heavier jazz influences, maybe that's what their other albums lean into. The blues Eagles esque guitar stuff is also really tacky imo. Favourite songs: Any major dude will tell you, Monkey in your soul. Overall around 5/10

It’s ok. Nothing here to get too excited about.

I still find them boring... But it's a bit better than the last album by then I suppose.

I feel like every day I alternate between loving and hating steely Dan. Tbh only their really popular songs usually resonate with me. My favorite on this was ESLTO which is odd considering it’s the only instrumental song, but it scratched itches that the other songs didn’t. I totally understand the appeal of steely Dan but a lot of their songs aren’t for me

Rikki Don't Lose That Number and 10 more songs you totally won't care about

Can’t go wrong with Steely Dan! The fourth on the list for me, similar to the first album I think this falls short of the 5 but still an easy 4!

I love pretzels. This album was good too.

Makes you feel like you’re in a montage about semi-corrupt cops in a 1976 Brooklyn, NY precinct… and that’s a great feeling. 10/10 recommend.

Loved the variety of instrumental styles even within a single song. Great first album to listen to! 7/10

I’m an absolute sucker for a maestro of the steel guitar. Put this guy in the turnpike troubadours. STRAIGHT GAS

Groovy and overall enjoyable

“Dad rock” before “dad rock.” Just impeccable recording. Everything sounds so clean, clear, precise, punchy. I found myself wanting to push the volume up—just enrapturing production. Musically, there’s a warmth to this record. Inviting, invigorating. Couldn’t stop listening and nodding my head. Something very nostalgic about it but not “old.” It’s been a while since a record just made my heart happy like this. Blues, jazz, rock, pop, bop—varied and inspired, every idea hits and is executed expertly. 9/10 Standouts: Night by Night -immaculate reeds Any Major Dude Will Tell You East St. Louis Toodle-Oo -just made me smile; Main Street, USA With A Gun Charlie Freak -really cool melody Really the whole record is a standout

Funky 70s grooves

grandioso faking album me gusto mucho escucharlo todo junto. No me obsesione con ninguna rola aun pero me encanto

Pretty cool to finally listen to them. I'm surprised I only knew the first song previously, the rest were decent.

I liked this back in the 70's, it dominated a portion of the radio airwaves and was certainly of higher quality than a lot that was being put out. Cool jazzy rock in a radio-friendly pop format. Mellow, brainy and sedate it was the soundtrack of every fern bar and Tupperware party.

It's fine, but given the current time I'd prefer more silk in my songs

With a gun, with a gun I will blot out the sun

I just don’t think I “get” Steely Dan. Occasionally there’s a song I like. But mostly it’s just good music on a telephone call I don’t want to be on. 2.5/5

1.5/5 I didn’t think this album was great at all. I thought the lead singer‘s voice was quirky, but not fantastic. The instruments were very tame, and the riffs were very flat. I understood from his topics that he was speaking cryptically as it was the 1970s. I won’t be going back to listen to this or any song on it.

How can you compare this to so many of the other albums on the list, TOP of the HEAP! Steely Dan just blows so many other recording artists away. The song Pretzel Logic is so good: “I stand upon the platform The man gave me the news: He said you must be joking son Where did you get those shoes?” The guitar solo rocks, the organ and the piano rhythms blend so well. The horns and guitar licks near the end, are the icing on the cake This is one of my favourite Dan tracks. Charlie Freak, so well written, and Rikki is outstanding. I would have given this a 5 star, but there are a number of weaker tracks

What a great album! I've been really loving Steely Dan lately. It's funky and chill. Just great background stuff and at the same time actually worth sitting down to listen to!

Not a huge S.D. fan

I'm a white man, so this a 4 at least.

listened

I knew Rikki Don't lose that Number already. Night by Night was good. Really liked the horns there. AMDWTY kind of just sounded like every other SD song. East St. Louis has a great first 30 seconds, I like the beat. Not so much when the next phase starts. Parker's Band was good. Again just generic SD sound imo. Through with Buzz was eh Really liked Pretzel Logic (first min kinda slow, guitar was needed). With a gun was a nice change for song 9. Not an amazing song though. Charlie Freak good piano. Eh singing. Monkey in your soul mid. Good horns though.

already heard this frikin great

Possibly the best Steely Dan album I've heard. wonderful jazz, mixed with 70s adult rock. Yeah, this is a good one. 4.5/5

yeah it's good

5/5 The run of albums Steely Dan had in the 70s and early 80s was something else, full of masterpieces... and Pretzel Logic is one of them!

Yeah I thought this was pretty good. Dad rock for sure. Something to listen to in a garage while drinking a bar. Didn’t lost the momentum at any point all the way through. Would enjoy listening to again!

Finally got to listen to some Steely Dan. I liked this album, can't wait to listen more from them.

Yes the performances and production are immaculate, and the songs are well crafted. But holy fucking shit it's so god damn boring. I understand the praise this band gets, but it is not for me. I'll give it a 2 just because the production is genuinely perfect. Trying to view it objectively, I can't say that it's bad, I just strongly dislike it