Wow, it’s hard to believe this is his first, and not a greatest hits album. Lots of really good tunes, and “Alison” just gets better and better with age. “Watching the Detectives” still has an incredible base line and punchey drums, “Less than Zero”, and “Blame it on Cain” still hold up 45 years.

Very repetitive

This is an example of a relatively unheard of recording, that rocks. I loved it the first time I heard it and have loved it ever since.

Still an outstanding piece of work

Wasn’t really excited to listen to another Reggae album, but a number of these tunes we quite good.

Wow, it’s hard to believe this is his first, and not a greatest hits album. Lots of really good tunes, and “Alison” just gets better and better with age. “Watching the Detectives” still has an incredible base line and punchey drums, “Less than Zero”, and “Blame it on Cain” still hold up 45 years.

A few good ones, still as depressing as when I first heard it.

Solid!

Still sounds a fresh and new as my first listen 58 years ago. Even the covers are new and alive.

A lot of great live performances, really took me back

Very good writing and production

Ground breaking, these guys started synchro-tech.

Lots of raw energy, but it all sounds the same after awhile

Not exactly my kind of music, but a very good album

4 or so solid tunes that still hold up, not into the stuff

Lots of good stuff, and energy

Two timeless classics Marianne & Suzanne, but the rest is hard to listen to.

Lots of noise

This is a waist of vinyl/CD/memory on any device. What a piece of crap,

This is torture

Eh

Wow haven’t heard this before (but have heard other “Queens” recordings), and I like it. A lot! For a first recording, it’s a keeper.

Very enjoyable

Very repetitive

Never have been a big BG fan, and after listening to this, know I will never be one. A lot of the same old thing

I am not a fan of hip-hop and never will be

Very aggressive, and it all sounds the same to me. If this is on the 1001 best, I can’t imagine what’s on the 1001 worst

Very solid recording that stands up well over time

Well everyone has their opinion, I reviewed a few for this recording. The individuals that rated this anything over 2, I wonder what they think of Dark side of the moon? This was another me 2 hip hop piece of turd, with very little originality. The only saving moment was the string arrangement

Still sounds great

Wow this is still really great music, time has only made this recording better. Marc Bolan was a brilliant composer and musician that unfortunately passed way before his time. David Bowie had it right.

Still not a big hip hop fan (is it not possible to write lyrics without explicit language?)

Eh

Still great

Still holds up, lots of great tunes

Excellent writing and recording of happy catchy tunes. This has held up well over time.

Not the best example of ELP’s work, but still much better than many of the 1001

This one made it to my 1001 mediocre albums picked out of a 2nd hand store. To classify this as any sort of “Rock” is blasphemy.

Great tunes, these guys rock

Lots of good numbers

Lots of good memories

Kill me now, I can’t believe so many people bought this crap

A classic

Sad to think he knew he was dying when he recorded it

This is truly a recording that deserves to be on the 1001 list of greatness

A lot of great rocking tunes

Wow, I haven’t heard this for a long time, but “Rip it up” and “I can’t help myself” still sound good

American Pie is still a great song, most of the rest of this album is so so at best

The was the worst recorded music? Yet!

Ya I could set up a sequencer and record an album of 💩 like this, but I have mercy.

Ehh, perhaps it was ok when released, but I have no space or time for this

Still great

Still rocking

This is very dark music! Not advised for people who like to be positive or happy. Not foe me

Ehh, I guess if you’re into head-banding stuff, you can knock yourself out in this one. Not for me thanks

An incredible Blues artist with a great collection of his work

Wow a lot of people must have bee wry stoned (or out of their minds) to have actually paid for this audio recording. I still can’t understand how or why so much of this garbage makes it into this list (perhaps people related to the artist). Save your money for Radiohead

Solid

A lot of these songs still hold up

Lots of great songs

Great to be depressed with

One hit wonder not the most creative band

Still holds up

Absolutely fantastic after 50+ years

Lil’ Rich rocks

Wow surprising good

Oh I have only one wish when it comes to Bob Dylan: keep writing music, stop singing! I have seen him live (as an opening act) 3 times and walked out every time. He is a brilliant writer, but can’t sing (or perform) for shit

Quite interesting

Solid, great writing that has held up extremely well

Brilliant! Well written, great production, very enjoyable

Eh, very 1980’s

It’s no Avlon

Still quite enjoyable

Many of these tunes have held up well

Nothing new, same old

The bonus tracks were an added treat

A classic

Wow! I was thinking typical gross lyrics but this was so good, it blew my mind! So jazzy and progressive. May you be smiling in Heaven, cause this is brilliant (and unexpected) I listened to it twice and then found “The Hot Rat Sessions” for a mind blowing set of studio cuts

This is an example of a relatively unheard of recording, that rocks. I loved it the first time I heard it and have loved it ever since.

Over played, almost every track has the same drum beat

Unfortunately this has not aged well, but I enjoyed it back in the day

Really great to listen to

There is nothing to say except, this is one of the finest recordings of all time

Outstanding!

If Chrissy Hind and Lou Reed had a baby

There are so many great Blur recordings, and this is definitely one of them

Many solid tunes

Same old, nothing ground breaking

We bought this when it was released, and were blown away with so many amazing songs. 55 years later it is still so solid! Yes there are a few so-so efforts (like Honey Pie, Rev #9), however when you consider how many incredible songs are on this double LP: -Well my Guitar gently weeps -Helter Skelter - Obla de - Back in the USSR - I’m so tired - Dear Prudence - Sexy Sadie - Rocky Raccoon - Piggies - Julia - I will - Birthday - Revolution 1 - Mother Nature’s son Above all my favorite is Yer Blues “The eagle picks my eye The worm he licks my bone I feel so suicidal Just like Dylan's Mr. Jones Lonely Want to die If I ain't dead already Oh, girl, you know the reason why Black cloud crossed my mind Blue mist round my soul Feel so suicidal Even hate my rock and roll” This is truly one of my top 10!

A true master, but a lot of it sounds the same

Rod had one good LP, Every Picture tells a story. He has only written a handful of songs, and without Ron Wood he probably wouldn’t have made it. No wonder he had to switch to M.O.R. (Sap crap)

Not a big rap fan, but “The message “ and “White lines” are excellent.

Still sounds fresh

A fine recording with lots of great tunes

What a waste of recording time

Wow totally unexpected, absolutely brilliant. This is classic jazz at it’s height

Gag me with a cheesy spoon, this could be used as torture.

Noise

Not the best Who recording, but lots of good stuff

I’m not a fan of Country, I find it backwards and depressing

It’s been a while since I heard this, but it holds up amazingly well

This still is an amazing recording with so many classic Hendrix greats

Not Neil’s best, but still it’s Neil!

Still an exceptional recording, with so many great (now classic) tunes.

Save me from this crap

Outstanding!!! The 2nd disk has many great songs, my favorite: Dead Flowers

Vintage Stones, love it all

Like a fine wine (nod to Gary/Geddy), this fine piece of craftsmanship only improves with time. All 3 musicians continue to improve and expand, it’s hard to believe 3 guys can create and replicate this live! The writing is solid, incredible bass lines, amazing guitar, and unimaginably sophisticated drums. Neil’s lyrics just keep getting better, how do they do it? Highlights for me have always been: Red Barchetta, Tom Sawyer, and YYZ (Toronto’ airport call letters) just blow me away.

Very interesting, never heard of this before, but listened to it twice

Words can’t express the joy of listening to this historical recording. The “Duke” is simply incredible and had assembled an amazing group of musicians.

Nothing new here

I got this when it came out and have loved it ever since. Of course Michelle and Norgian Wood are classics, but there are so many other great tunes that still hold up.

Very impressed by so many things on this recording, you can see why Bowie had such a successful long career. Ya I have heard Changes, Andy Worhal, oh you pretty thing, and Life on Mars many many times and always liked them. However there are so many other great guitar rifts (Eignt line Poem), and lyrics (Quicksand). Unfortunately a few duds held me back from a 5-star

A waste of vinyl

Lots of great tunes

I first bought this when I was 14, and I thought it was great. I have t heard it in 40+ years and it still kicks butt

Not sure if this is a spoof or not, but we’ve heard it all before

Surprisingly tasty

Nothing new, nothing special

Disco sucked then and sucks even more now

How did this guy get a recording contract? Bin dare done dat, same old crap

One of my all time favorites, I just wish Roger Waters wasn’t such a dick

I love this stuff!

An amazing artist, and a very good album

This is pure dynamite, incredible energy

Oh just kill me now, this is the most depressing sh*t. I’m really trying to like it, after Hallelujah, and being a fellow Canadian, but I just can’t handle it

Haven’t heard this for a while, Connected is a great song. The rest is average

A very cool recording to add to my collection

It is so great to hear Neil Young, adding Crazy Horse is the icing on the cake. He has a huge catalog and this one doesn’t disappoint.

This was an unexpected pleasure

Sounds old and tired

A waste of time

It’s no Superfly

A true classic, it still sounds as great as it did the the first time!

Outstanding! I could listen to this for a long long time

Not a rap fan, this sounds just like so many other rap artists

So many great tracks, one can feel his frustration having so many great songs written and rejected by other Beatles. The remastered version uncovers more of George’s backing vocals.

Lot of yelling, musically not my taste

Todd has done better

Still rockin

What a waste of talentless dribble, what record executive got payola for this one?

Very good stuff

This album still rocks, and has some of the greatest rhythm guitar riffs ever.

Nothing new or exciting

Still so powerful and different, I loved it when it came out and have heard it over 100 times.

Nothing special here

Loved Double Bass & Clint

Dylan is an amazing writer, but can’t sing for his life

One of my favorite Rolling Sones LPs

2 good songs and more synth-pop than I can handle

Every track outstanding

Absolutely outstanding

A number of good and a few great tunes

“Connection” is an excellent song, the rest is eh

This has not aged well

Ok, but not much new

One of my favorite versions of Sweet Jane

Shite

Brother brother, this ain’t so good

Boring and blah

Very interesting stuff

I have always loved this album, one of Bowie’s best

Good stuff but the backing vocals are dated

This is one of the worst pieces of crap, I have listen to from this list. Who buys this crap?

Nothing special here

Not bad, but I’m not a fan of any Country music. It all sounds the same winey steel guitar

Not my taste and therefore quite boring

Love Neil

Just shoot me now, this was awful

Still hold up

Absolutely love this

Still an outstanding piece of work

Still outstanding writing and playing

One of the worst things I have had the displeasure of waisting time on. Giving this even 1 star is pushing it

Absolutely fantastic I still love every track! This transcends time and beams me back to the early 70’s. Smoke on the Water is one of the stand out tracks of this period of time, but there are so many other great tracks: Lazy is a great boogie-woogie tune with incredible organ, Highway Star rocks, and who could forget the driving Space Trucking. Definitely 1 of my 10 island picks

How can you compare this to so many of the other albums on the list, TOP of the HEAP! Steely Dan just blows so many other recording artists away. The song Pretzel Logic is so good: “I stand upon the platform The man gave me the news: He said you must be joking son Where did you get those shoes?” The guitar solo rocks, the organ and the piano rhythms blend so well. The horns and guitar licks near the end, are the icing on the cake This is one of my favourite Dan tracks. Charlie Freak, so well written, and Rikki is outstanding. I would have given this a 5 star, but there are a number of weaker tracks

Lost of great tunes too many duds (note to EJ: quality is better than quantity)