Reviews (page 6 of 14)
7/10
Classic
I’ve come to learn I really can’t stand The Who from doing this list. They’re a decent singles band, but Jesus this album fucking sucks. I love a long overwrought concept album but this was bloody awful. I can’t believe it’s held in such high regard.
waste of time for me
Its The Who. Classic Rock. Solid.
Impressive and sometimes disturbing I’ve listened to this many times, but never this closely.
I already like a concept album and I like this one especially, having seen the musical revival bring the absolute batshit plot to life.
A camp counselor of mine was obsessed with this album when I was 9 and I remember really wanting to like it then, but I never really got it...and still don't get it (or really care to...oops!). Too long, too all over the place. Sort of became like background music after the first hour.
Good jams. Bizarre story.
What an unhinged premise. I don’t know how to feel but Pinball Wizard is a great song.
as much as I want to love The Who, i still feel like you had to be there with most of their output.
I am really sorry to say this but I just didn’t enjoy it too much and found myself wanting it to be over. There are some cool tracks and I really like ‘pinball wizard’, but stuff like ‘fiddle about’ and ‘there’s a doctor’ just help to fill out the rest of the album with fodder. There is literally zero need to have 24 tracks on one album.
I hear the beginnings of the 80s power ballads. could use a little more variety?
fun story telling and great sound
A bit conceptual, even for me, but all great music.
Just not a fan of concept albums. Some great songs but a lot of nonsense as well
I have a hot take on The Who, which is that they really only have one great album. I think Who’s Next is one of the greatest rock albums of all time, and The Who have a handful of great songs, but Tommy and Quadrophenia have never captured my attention in many attempts. I will say this spin highlighted a few more interesting moments on Tommy, particularly Overture and Underture. Tommy the song is always fun, but overall a record that doesn’t hit in its classic status for me.
Such a strange band, the Who. In my opinion this album deserves its place in the list. And there are fantastic passages, riffs etc. But then sections that are creepy, outdated, too long.
This is my favorite. Who album ever I've spent so much time in the car listening to this album front to back all of it is great
If you're going to have a Who rock opera on this list it needs to be Quadrophenia which is light years ahead of Tommy. I know this is a concept album, but there are really only 3 good songs: - Acid Queen, I'm Free and Pinball Wizard, which is still a belter. A poor album, a poor movie and an average stage show.
this was a really good concept album that went through themes of struggle, transformation and growth, some bangers too
The concept album seems to have a lot of filler. Unfortunately not feeling this even though I like The Who and it’s supposed to be one of their best albums.
So long, each song is a separate narrative which is fun
Tidlig rockopera, respekt og alt det der, fortjener helt sikkert en plads på listen. Vi ville helt sikker ikke have The Wall eller The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway uden den. Stadig kedelig i længden. Pinball Wizard er en banger
Ingen anelse om hvad den handlede om men jeg synese altså det var ret fed!
This is just bad... Thin sounding. His voice doesn't fit this style at all. Instruments are boring. Most songs are boring as well. Tommy.. dude.. Just give up..
Enjoyable. Crisp vocals and enjoyable riffs. I also got a bit more into the lyrics of this and found a new Christmas song. I don't think I've ever listened to an album all the way through that it a story about a character - so an interesting first for me.
Great production. Wanted to go with 3 first but 4 it is.
Little overstuffed, but obviously some classic tracks and they really paved the way for other rock operas that I just musically enjoy more.
This might be the biggest swing in opinion from expectation to reality. I used to really like this album, but it's just really weird and creepy as I listen now. Just not really something I would want to hear again - Used to like this one, but do I still? - More annoying than I remember. I think the whole 'concept album' thing used to really wow me... - Music is fine, but the content is weird and creepy now. Maybe that's on purpose but it doesn't make me want to listen again
On a preliminary listen, Tommy is about a nonverbal autistic kid who loves pinball who grows up to be a cult leader. It's some kind of story I guess, but I honestly think the album is overrated. I can't overstate it's importance to pop and rock, but I don't think it's an objectively amazing project. I'm bumping it up mainly for it's influence. Best Songs: Pinball Wizard Worst Songs: Tommy's Holiday Camp
Great
Their first rock opera has some great songs like pinball wizard but does get dragged down by guitar *anking.
Better than Coldplay
People love this album. I don't. It's got its moments of greatness, but it's not Quadrophenia.
Yeah this one is really damn good. They have so many offerings on this list and I got two in a row (in a 5 day span where I had two Pere Ubu albums and two The Who albums with one random in-between). This one was much better than The Who Sell Out. Still doesn't quite reach a 5 for me, but it's close.
The quintessential (and, I believe, first) rock opera. Tommy is the story of a boy who witnesses a murder and loses his senses as a result. His life is filled with abuse and torture before miraculously regaining his senses and becoming a cult leader. It’s a twisty turvy story that will break your heart. The Who’s style may not be for everyone, and this album is firmly placed in the psychedelic rock era of the late 60s/70s, but the story is something everyone should hear at least once. And, for an added bonus, go watch the old movie that brought the album to the screen. It’s a trip!
Ah yes, the "rock opera". Cute idea. Pretty good album
Quite a cohesive concept album. Pinball Wizard is famous and was the best song on the album. The song before was unpleasant. Leaning to Four, but maybe too generous.
Good but blended together
I can die without listening to this album, but not bad "Im Jesty Acid Queen"
This was an absolute slog to get through, that's hitting skip partway through a few tracks. Gotta respect the rock opera concept album thing as a... concept, but nothing about the listening experience was enjoyable. Going in, I would have told you I liked "Pinball Wizard," but now I feel like I never want to hear it again—it's just going to make me relive the rest of this album and I'd rather not. Best: "Pinball Wizard" Worst: "Fiddle About"
When I first saw the song count, I groaned. I typically don’t like long albums so this had a high bar to reach. After getting into it a lot of the songs are shorter so while still a longer album not as much as the song list might imply. Before going into this, I knew the song Pinball Wizard. I also vaguely knew that they had made a play about the kid in Pinball Wizard. I didn’t know that the entire album basically is the self contained story of Tommy. Which is all really cool. However, this album is the first time so far in these listens that I have wanted to stop listening to the album. I dislike this album immensely. The lyrics do nothing for me and no much of it seems like a teenager wrote it and talented musicians performed it. I really liked the song Pinball Wizard before this and it did give me a brief respite in the middle of the album but ignorance was bliss because I like that song less after a full listen. This album has very few redeeming qualities to me, I do appreciate the concept album style of this but the story feels shallow at best. I fully understand why it is on the list but I never want to listen to these songs again.
An unforgettable album certain to ruin anyone's day. Tales of misplaced sexual energy and misuse of power jump perspective nearly every song through an impressively choked gamut of sinister characters. I am reminded that evil can come from anyone, and especially those we collectively most trust and idolize. Difficult to stomach but relentless messaging that I choose to interpret as an important reminder to stay aware. Being welcome is not the same as being safe, and though I was more comfortable learning that from Little Red Riding Hood the lesson here is more visceral. There are no allies here, not even Sally's parents. The musical themes are repeated beautifully and carefully, and I appreciate the placement of Tommy's Holiday Camp with its mustache twirling fanfare and We're Not Gonna Take It with its recursion of the cast bringing the story full circle by taking a step back from the overindulgence of the earlier tracks to remind us of Uncle Ernie & crew's unsalvageability, not that we needed it. The only thing more chilling than Uncle Ernie is his possible ubiquity. Were I to hear this album again, it would be too soon.
oodness that was a dark experience. This might be only album where I actively hate every song but one, and I still want to give it 5/5 stars. This is not a musical album, this is dark musical theater you can listen to instead of watch. I was ready to write this album off as a 1/5 stars, this music sucks, about 7 songs in. But I started getting invested by "Christmas" immediately followed by "Cousin Kevin". Towards the latter part of the album, I couldn't focus on the other stuff I was doing, I was just sitting there listening to this musical. I'm still not convinced a good way to write a musical is via a feature length album, but I have to give it to The Who for how innovative that is in 1969. Each song by itself was awful though with the sole exception of Pinball Wizard (which has a much darker twist to it now that I've heard its full album). However, I really don't think The Who cared about making the music all that good. I'm hard pressed to believe there's a single person on the planet that thinks "Fiddle About" is a good song for its music as opposed to its importance to the albums story. The numerous 20-30 second songs spread throughout the album seem to cleanly separate the "acts" of this "show", and summarize the next steps in the story for people not paying close attention, a really nice touch (even though the songs suck).
Ive always thought of The Who as boring. This listen didn't change my mind at all. D'Angelo died yesterday. I'm gonna listen to Voodoo now.
Hey, another Who. It's been a good while since the last one - nearly two hundred albums since I listened to My Generation, which I gave a scandalous 1/5 rating to. Why? I've no clue. I musta been off my gourd when I listened to it, I guess. The title track of that album occasionally pops into my head, so it's probably not a 1/5 by my current standards. I'm curious to see what this middle point in their included discography will sound like. It's another hour-tenner. Right after Kanye's The College Dropout, no less. I need a break. Timeskip because we do those now. I am redefining the review medium through my exploration of abstract, avant-garde storytelling techniques. This truly holds a mirror to our own society or however the bloviating goes. Anyways, this was pretty alright. Maybe I shouldn't have sat out on this one yesterday. This style of pop rock is generally within my ballpark - the acoustic and electric guitars have a nice sound to 'em. Some pretty good percussion, too. Obviously, this thing is much too long and it kind of completely comes apart as it nears the end, though the avarice that this album has for my time and attention could lessen overtime as I come to appreciate this music more. I'm open to giving it a relisten sometime down the line. "Overture" is a solid opener - I love me a good instrumental track. The guitars go a long way in giving the track a satisfying sense of forward momentum, and the piano/horns are a nice touch. "Underture" is another good tune, no surprises there. I had to do a double take when I read the track name. Truth be told, none of the other songs really stuck out to me, though the album is an admirable kind of listenable from start to finish. I'm too laaaaazyyyy to check the book for this entry, so I'm gonna shirk my gatekeeping duties and let this one mosey on through. I cosign this inclusion.
Tämä levy löytyy omasta hyllystä ja on tullut kuunneltua tätä jo 40 vuotta. Tämä on yksi The Who:n parhaista levyistä. Osaan tämän etu- ja takaperin ulkoa.
Totally different vibe vs my generation
nuts
ADOREI! É um álbum muito bom, bem construído, bem completo, várias nuances.
Notevole
2/5
Liked the concept and cohesiveness, liked the music more than my generation, but it's still the who, who i am moderately lukewarm on, still
Really did not like this. Frustrating having never properly listened to The Who before. Felt like music you'd hear at the theatre.
Ik snap dat deze plaat een behoorlijke staat van dienst heeft met het populariseren van het fenomeen 'rock-opera'. Maar los van dat ik überhaupt ver weg wil blijven van opera's, heb ik nooit de pull-factor gezien van het rock aspect. Het sleept mij in ieder geval niet mee. Wel een paar geinige songs, maar net als dat ik met het jaar minder ga hebben met de band, is 'Tommy' ook geen naslagwerk waar ik vaak op terug ga vallen. 5/10 Highlights: Pinball Wizard We're Not Gonna Take It
Ik denk dat Tommy mijn favoriete plaat van the Who is. Ik vind dit één van de weinige écht geslaagde concept albums met een overkoepelend verhaal. De nummertjes zijn kort, pittig en hebben ook wel iets theatraals zonder in een progrock straatje te belanden. Melodieën en riffs komen terug over de plaat en je gaat als luisteraar langs verschillende moods. Er zitten wat prikkelende dingen in, maar vooral zijn er ook gewoon heel wat sterke liedjes - opzichzelfstaand. Dus, vet om weer eens helemaal van start tot finish te hebben geluisterd. 8/10 Highlights 1921 Pinball Wizard Go to the Mirror! We're Not Gonna Take It
Wow--this is a lot to get through. I saw Tommy in London in the 90s. As a musical theater experience, it's fine. The album that inspired it all? Ugh. Not something I would ever listen to again. The best I can say is that it's interesting. It's certainly a concept. I'm just not invested and nothing about the music is making me care. Some songs are too short; others are too long. I know this is important, but I just don't connect with it.
Classic rock, realized that it's a concept album which tells a story
Good. Does not sound like anybody else.
super
3/10
It was better than Who's Next but not as good as Live at Leeds. It's surprising how much I prefer a live album of a certain artist over studio albums - it never happens besides The Who, interesting. I am sure Tommy was a great inspiration for The Wall for example, which is a great thing. Anywho, this is a GREAT album, but it's not as perfect as many people say.
Great to relisten to after may years. Still slays.
Having heard about the album, but not having heard the album, I was very enthusiastic about this album. I really like rock operas in general, and so I was looking forward to finally listening to it in its entirety. However, it was very underwhelming to me. It felt very samey throughout the entire album, and I found myself bored with it quite quickly. The music is still good, and the songs can be enjoyable separately. Therefore this album cannot score any higher for me than it does. Was expecting at least a 4/5, but it falls short of that. 3/5
I already knew this album, but I was glad to give it a refresh. I enjoyed it far more this time than the last, partly thanks to this list and the new perspective it gave me. I don’t care much for "rock operas" in general. It’s a nice concept on paper, but I think it’s almost inherently doomed to fail - mainly because it’s usually too long, which dramatically increases the chances of having a ton of filler or weak songs. You also need a lot of time on your hands to appreciate them : it's meant to be listened as a whole, it makes little sense to just play a couple of tracks ; but not everyone has the the time or the mental space to sit through 75-90 minutes of music. Very few bands can pull it off – even the masterpiece that is The Wall is a weak link in the otherwise perfect discography of Pink Floyd. However, The Who kind of did it right. They obviously drew a lot from The Pretty Thing’s S.F. Sorrow (Pete Townshend denied it, but I don’t believe it for a second), another contender for the "reasonnably well-done rock operas" hall of fame. The Who added a layer of professionalism to the more dilettante approach of SF Sorrow, but also lost a bit of the crazyness in the process. Tommy is better structured (less LSD, probably) but also less spontaneous. I couldn’t care less about the "story", to be honest ; but I really loved the construction and the overall mood of the album. It’s musically very competent and well-balanced, alternating quiet, psychedelic and dynamic moments with gusto. The long psychedelic tracks like Underture are my favorites, and the short instrumental intermissions are very well done, giving the listener time to breath between the songs. There are a lot of awesome tracks, especially towards the end, and almost no bad song, which is remarkable. And I love the cover art ! I probably won’t listen to this record very often despite its obvious qualities, mainly because it's too long and convoluted (even a bit chaotic at times) for a casual listen. But it is indeed a landmark album. 8/10
Quite long and unaven which makes it difficult to grasp. It's a rock opera and I ddn't even lokked at the lyrics... can't really find really good songs or tracks . How ibfluencial this was? not sure, my first impression after Two listenings : overrated.
A bit annoying, nothing particular, not bad either
I’ve never felt so much like I only skimmed through an album. I’m biased by the only two Who songs I really know (I’m Free and Pinball Wizard) which share that same riff reminding you it’s part of a concept. My single listen was clearly not enough to take it all in. I often get the awkward feeling that the music is just there to serve the lyrics, rather than the other way around, whereas what I usually love about The Who is their musical energy. It’s still fairly easy to listen to and must have been pretty revolutionary back in 69, but in 2025, I struggled to make it to the end but I could come back to it.
This is alright! Not a favorite, but not at all bad.
It's a cool album with a great concept, it's just too long. There are some great songs on here. From the standpoint of a whole album, it's a little challenging for me.
It felt a little longer than the 75 minutes it was. I followed along with the story as best as I could, but the overall vibe of the album wasn't necessarily for me. Keith Moon is a hell of a good drummer though. The only real standout song was Pinball Wizard
I like The Who. I did not like this album. I feel like this took away from The WHO that I know and love. It’s an interesting album, and something I’m sure was an artistic venture for someone in the group. But I miss The Who.
The closest my dad has ever come to disowning me was when I told him I prefer Elton John’s version of Pinball Wizard to the original. Sorry dad, but I’m now doubling down and saying that Tina Turner’s version of Acid Queen is better too. Essentially, my ideal version of Tommy would combine the best tracks from this album with the highlights from the soundtrack to the (completely bonkers) movie - and it would be a single disc.
Sparks est pas pire je déteste pas, mais cet album est victime du classique de la musique des années 60: il manque quelque chose
First of all… Fiddle… about…? You know what, I have to be honest. I don’t like it. There. I said it. I don’t know what they were going for but they did not succeed in my ears. I kind of liked Sally Simpson and Welcome. Kind of. I really wanted to like The Who but this was overall shite.
Probably a good album if you have the time to listen to it. Unfortunately I didn't finish it and while I did enjoy what I did hear of it, it's just a bit too long.
Idk if Tommy can hear but I can 😊
This one was a nice surprise. Didn't expect much as my previous experience with The Who was mostly My Generation so this album felt like a Christmas present.
Hmm no big feelings, quite liked it
Tinny and empty. Not for me.
Album 24/1001 You know a band must be taking themselves too seriously when they think producing a rock opera about a deaf, dumb and blind kid is a good idea. 🤦 1 ½ / 5
Eh
I didn’t know this is where pinball wizard originated- great song! Rest of the album was not my favorite
Couple of bangers but not their best
I haven't listened to this since high school. I always knew this was a rock opera but I never knew the story it was trying to tell. I read the Wikipedia synopsis and I seriously didn't realize how INSANE this album is. Tommy gets tortured by his cousin and sexually abused by his uncle and then the next song is about how good he is at pinball?!? Wtf?? Honestly makes me enjoy this album much more than I thought I would after writing it off for so many years. Easily the most interesting album released by the Who. Favorite track: Pinball Wizard 3.5/5
My brother had this album so i knew it very well. I enjoyed listening to it again. It always amused me the 10second songs to keep you updated on the story line. I bought the soundtrack track album from a 2nd hand record store recently but definitely prefer the original album.
Can someone send me a link to the acid The Who were on when they made this?
Are you kidding? This is a masterpiece.
Interesting concept for a rock opera that was enjoyable nearly all the way through. 8/10
Classic, the inspiration of so much art 30 years later...
Now this is an album you should not die before hearing. The theme is strong and the sounds are varied.
Great album!
Still the standard by which all rock operas are judged. Only Pink Floyd has come close with The Wall.
I was gifted the newly released Deluxe Edition version of Tommy for being a groomsman at my Dad's wedding when I was 14. I'd really gotten into The Who after listening to the early stuff (The Kids are Alright and I Can See For Miles being my favourite tunes). I thought they were just a jangly bluesy typical mod band until I properly listened to this record and realised they had been destined for different things outside of that mods/rockers bubble. There's been loads of records from the 60s labelled the 'first concept album', but this is the first mainstream release with a full 'rock opera' narrative and it builds on dribs and drabs you could hear on 'The Who Sell Out' (arguably another concept album, as the whole record plays out like a 40 minute radio show). The concept itself is a bit offit - a boy who becomes voluntarily deaf dumb and blind cos he walked in on his mam shagging someone after his dad didn't come back from the war. He goes through all sorts of fucking ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE (proper American) and general abuse before he ends up looking in a mirror, sorting himself out and gaining a messianic complex before being brayed by everyone and finding peace. This isn't a record with standouts (I suppose Pinball Wizard remains a popular tune but it's just another piece of narrative in the context of Tommy). It's the use of motifs and musical plot devices throughout that inspired me as a teen. Through the frankly fucking weird narrative (battered by his cousin, fiddled by his uncle, drugged by a prossie) there are beautiful progressions and fun riffs built upon throughout the story (Overture, Christmas, Underture, Go To The Mirror and eventually into the 'Listening to You' ending to We're Not Gonna Take It). While not the Who's best work, it inspired a young Jay enough to learn the entire thing on guitar as a teenager which gave me a massive appreciation for rhythm guitar and chords progressions while everyone I knew was trying to bust out Slash shit in the music rooms in school. An important record for me and an important one for music. It became a weird Ken Russell film and also led to Quadrophenia (which mods love but it's about how fucking silly all that was). Take Cousin Kevin and Uncle Ernie out of this and you have one of the best records of the 60s. Without it, as Gilmour and Waters will tell you, you don't have Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall. A proper transition from the 60s into proper hard rock with spiritual brothers Led Zeppelin in the 70s. 4.3/5 JF -
eh
Думал, что задушусь от британской рок-оперы почти что на полтора часа хрона, но нет... это было весьма весело, а лучшими треками так вовсе оказались 10-минутные проговые бэнгеры.
A big endeavor at the time. Unfortunately too long to keep anyone’s attention these days.
Such a long album for two hits. If you include "I'm Free". Pinball Wizard is a classic but doesn't hold the whole album up.
4 out of 5. Very possibly my favorite album by The Who. It feels like a real journey. Good way to end another week of this challenge.
Hell yes!!!!
What is happening in his heeeaaaad? UIuuuuuh...I wish I kneeeeeew
this right here is the who's crowning jewel, a big musical work of fiction about the life and times of tommy, an enigmatic, truth-seeking and possibly disabled child, trying to get through the world with traumatic events and people who idolize him. it's one of the earliest examples of a rock opera, and it's very good at what it does, from the dramatic rock instrumentals to the sometimes abstract or subjective meanings to the tales being told. it's a must listen for anyone who likes rock music and compelling drama.
I really respect the ambition of this album and think its a really good effort, but man do I not vibe with most of the songs on here that much
Enjoyed this lots more than I expected, even though it's a bit silly. 4.5
Fun album, loved the variety and strangeness. What a drummer
3.1 To be honest, I in general strongly dislike rock operas. The wall was the downfall of Pink Floyd, despite all it's acclaim, I thought it was pretty shit. Maybe because of that I've had an aversion to them. Credit where it's due to what was arguably the first rock opera, but like all of them it suffers from lots of pointless, boring interludes, songs that are weak but there to continue the story, etc. A few good tracks on here, but used rather sparingly. If this wasn't the first/second it would be heading towards a 2*
01) Overture - 5,5 02) It's A Boy - / 03) 1921 - 6,0 04) Amazing Journey - 6,0 05) Sparks - 5,5 06) The Hawker - 6,0 07) Christmas - 6,0 08) Cousin Kevin - 6,0 09) The Acid Queen - 6,0 10) Underture - 7,0 11) Do You Think It's Alright? - / 12) Fiddle About - 5,5 13) Pinball Wizard - 7,5 14) There's a Doctor - / 15) Go to the Mirror! - 6,0 16) Tommy Can You Hear Me? - 5,5 17) Smash the Mirror - 6,0 18) Sensation - 5,5 19) Miracle Cure - / 20) Sally Simpson - 6,0 21) I'm Free - 6,0 22) Welcome - 5,5 23) Tommy's Holiday Camp - 5,0 24) We're Not Gonna Take It - 6,0 TOTAL: 5,93 (59/100) Current ranking: 545/681 Rock opera? I mean, coome oooon.... I hate musicals, this is boring as hell.
It will take you a while to get to the songs you most recognize - Pinball Wizard, I’m Free, and We’re Not Gonna Take It. Enjoy the journey This entire (double) album sounds so good, is filled with intriguing characters, and some childhood trauma. Keith Moon on drums keeps each song interesting, energetic, and engaging. Favorite deep cut: Christmas
Tommy is an ambitious album, and it is fabulous to see how the entire band leans into Townshend's personal epic to produce this opus. I am not quite sure how well it holds together as a narrative, but I was in on every track! The familiar tracks are awesome, but all of the surrounding tracks work well. I must remember to revisit this album during Christmas because that track is so great. It doesn't sound like the traditional holiday, but it rings true in so many interesting ways. And the backing vocals are indecipherably delightful! And for Christmas, I am asking for a analogue pinball machine... wizard or not.
Starts good, then it gets tiring. Worth it listening to it at least once
The good songs are great. The other songs exist on the album. I can't not think about the Rosie O'Donnell talk show from the 1990s when I hear "Tommy, can you hear me?" For that I give the album extra points.
448/1001 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
All I can say about this one is that he sure plays a mean pinball.
I think I like the movie OST better but still an excellent rock opera.
Not as good as I expected and definitely not as strong as Who’s Next. I’ve never been drawn to The Who based on their hits and this doesn’t change my mind.
I think it would be better if there was some sort of visual media to accompany this. To help convey the story
Cohesive album. Just not my jam
Masterpiece. One of my Dad's faves, Mike and I heard this a billion times as kids - with our Dad blasting it and 'conducting' from his recliner - I love that memory!
Stunning creativity, musically, conceptually, lyrically. Just a masterpiece from Pete’s incredible mind brought to life. Much of his personal past and trauma imbues the story. This is timeless and will endure like all great classical works.
A landmark. Plain and simple. No notes.
Purely epic! The OG rock opera, that is musically and literarily phenomenal!
I rec'd this album on the heels of another high concept album: "They Were Wrong, So We Drowned" by the Liars. While a way easier listen than that, "Tommy" is way so bloated and over-the-top. A concept that should have remained a concept. One of those ideas that stoners come up with, except this time they had the celebrity and the cash to execute the bad idea. 2 stars.
This was decent. Interesting. I don't have much else to say.
I don’t like it.
I appreciate the ambition, I just don't think The Who are a versatile enough band to pull off something like this fully. Lots of bloat. Maybe if they stuck to making it a single lp?
This was a 3.5 but I believe I need to listen to it more times to fully appreciate it :)
Great album.
Brownie points for being the first rock opera, but not as good as Who's Next
I enjoy a bit of The Who, but this is self-indulgent, over-long, toss. It never made me truly angry, except for Tommy's Holiday Camp, which is mercifully less than a minute long, but I was glad when it was over.
I don’t rate this. Bit dull for me
Wow. Hated it. I was looking forward to experiencing this album, assuming that it would be track after track that I knew but didn't recognize from their titles. Nope! Knew 3 songs and didn't like the rest. Boo.
Too weird. One or two good songs but doesn’t hold up as albumn
The mother of all rock operas and concept albums.
I much prefer the Who’s rockier song so as a solely listening experience tjis falls a bit flat. If you ssy Tommy to someone, there’s a good chance Pinball Wizard is what comes to their mind and either good reason the song stands head and shoulders above everything else here.
This album is everything I dislike - it’s by The Who and it’s far too long. I’ve always enjoyed “Pinball Wizard”, so that gets the album an extra star, but that’s all of my positives about this experience used up.
My parents had the London Symphony Orchestra version of Tommy when I was a kid and I used to listen to it all the time. I was too young to really get some of the implications (Fiddle About - *shudder*). It may just be familiarity or nostalgia, but I like that version so much better than the original (or the film version despite Elton and Tina Turner making an appearance). I think the story fairs better with different vocalists doing the various roles and the richness of the fuller orchestral accompaniment. That being said, I still like Tommy. It's probably my favourite individual concept album (as a series, the many albums that make up twenty one pilots Dema storyline, would be my favourite concept overall). The orchestral version would have got a 5 from me, and knowing it exists means this can never score as highly. I would say 3.5, but in a world with no half stars: 4/5
ok - one or two songs that are good and interesting ish instrumentation and progression, but nothing holding it together
I like that there are musical themes that come in and out. But aside from Pinball Wizard and a couple other tracks, it's a lot of filler that outstays its welcome. And some of the lyrics, yeesh. 3/5
How much The Who do you need? I'm telling you, not much. I've never been a fan. I get why My Generation is here, but I really don't feel like it's necessary to have more albums by them.
I do enjoy this but I think I prefer the movie's soundtrack to the studio album
I'll be honest, I don't really care about the story. At some point in my life, concept albums went from "ambitious work and test of creativity and endurance for a band" to "bloated exercise in masturbation". All of the songs were alright with some notable exceptions: - "Pinball Wizard" rules, of course. - "Cousin Kevin" is concerning and "Fiddle About" is FUCKED. I get they needed drama for the plot, but goddamn; Red flag for Pete Townsend. Otherwise, no real thoughts on the album. It's fine.
Much like Deep Purple which I reviewed a few days back, I always considered The Who to be a second tier band. I know it's not fair and there are millions of Who fans that would hit me for saying it. But that's just how they show up in my life. There are some great songs that were (are?) always on classic rock stations, but I didn't go buy these albums or listen to them in their entirety. Obviously, I've heard of Tommy as it's often noted as one of the greatest rock albums and concept albums, and musicals. Outside of the singles, I hadn't heard most of these songs and, as it turns out, that was Ok. Most of them are kind of Roger sing-talking the storylines. There are no classic Daltrey grunts, growls and yells until about halfway through the whole thing. I mostly like Overture and Underture :) but they are both 25% too long and a bit repetitive. It's Ok. The singles were solid, but I think most of their best music is found elsewhere.
I want to say something about this album, but I have no idea what. It was better than my rating, but I also found it suffered from the overindulgences of 70s rock operas in general, despite being 4+ stars musically.
Not as Good as I remembered. Bit dark
🗯 I know it’s a classic, I know people who like it. I don’t. The so-called “rock opera” that turned The Who into stadium giants just doesn’t land with me. The production is thin (frankly, shit), and the whole thing hasn’t aged well — very much “of its time.” I haven’t seen the movie, but I know the live versions fare better. Pinball Wizard is a banger, sure, but who’s sitting through all this to get there? I get that it’s a landmark, and I get that you had to be there. But me? The Who just don’t sit right — they’re the only live band I’ve ever walked out on mid-show. Sorry, Pete. Verdict: Overrated (landmark for some, slog for me) For fans of: Rock operas, prog excess, pinball wizards, being there in ’69
Its odd, not my thing persnoally
top
this was 3 discs and hard to listen to all the way through. I like The Who but I don't really like Tommy. there's something scary about it to me and everyone I've said that to kinda looks at me weird but it's true
Live album bylo lepsi
I don't actually like The Who that much. I can appreciate the ambition of this concept album but in practice I don't enjoy it very much. However, Pinball Wizard is the best thing The Who ever did.
It’s good. It’s the who. Not anything special.
Really liked it, had no fucking idea what was going on but what I did pick up was interesting and the sound was really well done. 4 stars
Really disappointed. Very coherent but too long to be built around the one genuinely outstanding track
A lot of experimental dross that didn’t pull you in. Pinball Wizard was great, but one song out of 24, c’mon!
Didn’t like this at all. Repetitive and monotonous. Wouldn’t listen again. Liked the outro on “we’re not gonna take it” Never heard the word Tommy repeated so often on an album.
This would be a 10 if I could! Such a formative record for me on my lifelong WHO fandom! Heading to Philly Wednesday to see their final North American Tour!
Considero que hay bastante trabajo en el desarrollo compositivo y la ejecución musical (aunque tampoco en un grado virtuoso), sin embargo a nivel estético-sonoro no puedo decir que me haya gustado. El álbum está bien grabado, aunque considero que las voces están demasiado al frente en la mezcla. En general las voces están bien ejecutadas, pero cuando cantan en falsetto suenan muy ridículas. En lo personal no me gustan los musicales ni las óperas. Este álbum no me pareció una experiencia horrible como me suele suceder con ese tipo de composiciones, pero aún así, no me gustó. El concepto del álbum podría llegar a considerarse interesante, pero no es suficiente como para ignorar los puntos mencionados anteriormente, y además tener que soportar durante 1 hora 15 minutos le quita valor a la experiencia.
We drank the blood of some pinball people and now I am wizaaard! They really wanted to sing about pinball and schoolyard days. 6/10
Pretentious rock opera ugh
Marching band vibes. Pretty good doesn’t hook well but I don’t hate it. Good just not for me. Interesting instrumentals.it got better I’m liked super hooked now. It’s really interesting. Not going on my playlist tho. Ok I’m tired but this is good so far will finish and rate tomorrow.
Classic album am one of the most ambitious undertakings to bust out a rock opera instead of "just" a concept album. Love several songs and has some bangers. Packed with ideas and originality. Great album but more of an every 5-10 years listen for me.
I listened to as much of this as I could muster. Maybe seven songs? The word pretentious gets thrown around a lot and tends to be conflated with elitism. This album is pretentious in that it takes itself super seriously and it just doesn’t have the depth. The melodies are mediocre, the topics are so painfully boorish - it betrays the Who’s desire to appear as some kind of working class response to their contemporaries. I respect they were trying to do something; it’s just that they aren’t as smart as they think they are.
3 1/2 hours!? What could possibly be so important
The first album that comes to mind when you think of Rock Opera
Classic Who
To be fair, the only way I’d join a cult is if it was led by a blind deaf kid who played pinball
Not what I expected but an amazing storytelling experience
Boring
I love this album. First one to come up that I own on vinyl. That was fun. I love the whole thing. Love the concept album. I like the story. I love the music. It is great.
Cousin Kevin was unpleasant to listen to. The harmony was not harmonizing. Vocals were not great. For 1969, I guess that's not surprising. They have some bangers though.
Bif bof
classic, extraordinaire
One of my top ten.
Compared to later rock operas, it is lacking in both narrative and musical complexity. And because it is trying to tell a cohesive story, it is musically lacking compared to other albums from The Who. Major respect for being one of the first rock operas and there are still good moments.
This album passed me by without me even realizing it happened
pinball wizard
Some cheesy tracks First half decent background music Got good at fiddler very funny Some cheesy songs after Pinball wizard best song on album
5/5 - this was a fun album! Everything flowed so well and I really like that it had a storyline throughout every song, it led to a greater connection to every song and really got me invested in it! I just really liked this album! Really good!!!
Clear 5
Barely halfway through, and so far, it's okay. Exactly what you would expect from the 70s, I guess. Or late 60s, in this case. Kind of like a rock version of The Beatles. Kind of. Okay i didnt want to finish it. 3/10 i jus dont like it.
Listening to this again brought the whole movie flooding back into my mind - tbh the two go perfectly together and the album makes more sense. THE rock opera/musical that sets the standards need to reach - a very enjoyable listen. "Pinball Wizard" is the 'obvious' song from the album but "Go To The Mirror!" was always my fav.
I want to start off by saying as a guy who doesnt care about lyrics this is very digestible and easy to follow even for me dumb ass. It needs some flowers for that alone. But that thing said this is insane. A rock opera is a cool idea and it does it well but the songs aren't that interesting and the story is bonkers. Why is it about a special needs guy who gets good at pinball and then becomes Jesus. What is going on in this guy's head? And why does he 100% have to get diddled? What the fuck dude. Idk dude, pinball wizard is a classic and its still good but it almost makes it not good knowing the rest of the story. At the ends of the day I didn't love this but I do applaud giving such a wild idea a full swing, pulling no punches. But its just not great in the end.
Solid album that is one of a small group of albums that I know of that the group of songs tell a story and each individual song tells a chapter of the story. The album as a whole has a clean clear sound. Recordings quality really seems to have improved around this time when compared to the mid 60s. I will give this album a spin for sure in the future, even though I enjoy a lot of music from this era and style, this was my first time listening to a Who Album front to back.
I disliked this immensely. Poor in concept and execution - long, pretentious and lacking any memorable songs to hang the concept around.
Not if a madcap concept and just seems to meander without going anywhere in particular. Even the more popular songs from are bit meh. Not a particular fan.
Visst imponeras man lite av ambitionen med ett sådant konceptalbum. Sådant görs inte längre? Och musiken är bra. Men det blir liksom FÖR mycket.
Not bad, especially instrumentally, but god dang some of this is pretty corny
A good album that works together very well, especially towards the beginning. I think it does get bogged down a bit in the concept, but it's still a very impressive achievement. A few tracks were misses for me, but it is generally a great sound with a few standouts. Favorite tracks: "Underture," "The Acid Queen," "Pinball Wizard"
Meu primeiro contato com a obra foi a trilha sonora para o filme de Ken Russel (1975) e ao ouvir o disco original depois, me causou certa estranheza. Mas fui me familiarizando e me encantando a cada audição e hoje prefiro esta. Um disco que continua soando muito bem. Uma maneira fluida de contar uma história com a competência de um gênio criativo - Townshend - que sabe muito bem usar a banda, a seu serviço e da obra. Excelente álbum!
Ah, the rock opera. There is no denying the singular ambition of this record. Unlike other concept albums that preceded it - SF Sorrow and Sgt Peppers as noteworthy examples - “Tommy” has a plot that (sort of) holds together via a narrative flow throughout the whole album, though it is an oddly bizarre story. There are also some great musical moments spread across the record - including “Pinball Wizard”, “The Acid Queen”, and “Go To The Mirror.” The problem lies in reconciling the plot with the music. It sometimes feels like songs are inserted for plot purposes, which weakens the record as they can come across as filler musically. Because of that, the albums doesn’t quite reach the heights it aspires to, particularly when compared to the much tighter “Who’s Next” which was relieved of the narrative constraints when the Lifehouse project was flushed. But Tommy is still both a unique artistic achievement and a (mostly) solid collection of songs, even if it doesn’t quite reach the heights it sought to.
I respect the rock opera or whatever format you consider this album as much as the next guy. It's just not something I'd listen to every day. Pinball Wizard is a cool song, I'll listen to that, but not this whole album. 3 / 5 stars.
hay un par de canciones chulas pero aburrido, no me gusta la voz del cantante:/
Por tener un nombre que alcance a recordar, pero seguro me será difícil la próxima vez
Good music but separate instruments play in different ears and it ruins it, has to quit listening. 2 stars
Omg why is it so long. I got to Tommy’s holiday camp before deciding I’d had enough. But still 3 stars because the who is an objectively good band.
So I decided to listen to the non deluxe version, it was already long enough. Very glad I knew it was a concept album before I listen -- I can actually focus on it now. Amazing cover by the way, it looks like a statue. I think this appealed to me because my family listens to music like this a lot (including the Who) but I've never really listened to it on my own. So I'm not too surprised I liked it. Wait. This was '69? No way. This sounds like 80s, so much better than all the other stuff from the 60s and 70s. I did not like the 10 minute long instrumental song. I had trouble following the plot, but it was cool how they talked to Tommy sometimes and it felt like they were talking to you. I wonder how they picked the name Tommy. Fun, interesting, but a little confusing and felt kind of long. Why is the last song 7 minutes it's dragging like crazy. 3.5/10
Loved it.
My first Rock Opera experience. I really enjoyed the whole album. It looked quite daunting at first when I saw the album was 3.5 hours long but half that time is repeats recorded live. I enjoyed the story of the album. It had good early rock vibes
This was clearly a very ambitious project, and pretty ahead of its time when it was released. A little lengthy, but otherwise a good album. Pinball Wizard is obviously a standout.
I don't think I would add most of these songs to my playlist, but I think they are well produced.
Awesome
Too close to musical theatre for me
What I like about Tommy is the sound. The Who sound great, of course they do. What I don't like about Tommy is that it never settles. Overture, underture, minute long ditties trying to tell a story that I can't follow. Tommy needs more songs, more focus.
Wow this fucking sucked. Still not as unlistenable as some of the ones I’ve rated.
Temporary
A rock opera with a story I really couldn’t follow or get into, and not too many great tracks. Gains a point for the attempt and influence.
Sat through waiting for pinball wizard, then sat through the rest of the original. I was not going to sit through the rest of the 2+ hours of bonus content in the platinum edition
The Poo
I wish more bands went wild with musical concept albums while retaining their sound. Doesn’t make me want to watch the movie but was a fun listen.
Good album, some of the songs were quite strange though. Better listened to in one go, rather than listening to the songs separately.
I don’t much like the who
This is really, really poor. Pinball Wizard is still a great track, but the rest is just crap. The Beach Boys-esque "Tommy Can You Hear Me?" is the best of a bad lot apart from that, and it's pretty poor itself!
saight
Not for me, didn't really enjoy it.
Nah
Concept album
Tommy's holiday camp is a weird song. The whole rock opera is interesting. Go To The Mirror is excellent.
Its clear that all the bets were on the album concept. However, the execution was not great. It wasn't even decent. Too much abuse in the story, especially one of a sexual nature. What's the point? What does it contribute to the story, to Tommy's development? The narrative feels wonky and distasteful, the theme of sexual assault was not handled well. Musically, it was not too hard of a listen. Not enjoyable either. No song in particular stood out to me – they all seemed pretty dull. Will not listen again
Listened in the truck via YouTube music. This was a slog to get through. Repetitive motifs throughout and some long jams that seemed over the top. Glad it’s done.
I know this is supposed to be concept album, which is cool. But jesus it's much too long. And fairly self-indulgent. I do enjoy it though! It's a rock opera. It's catchy and fun and theatrical at times. I like the harmonies and the singing. I like the journey of the story.
An interesting concept album. Very classic rock in stereo. All about about a deaf, dumb, blind kid named Tommy. It’s a really long record—overstayed its welcome, in my opinion. But the musical ideas throughout are varied and interesting. Timbre and tone of the record doesn’t change or have big swings in variance throughout the really long runtime, which make the experience remarkably linear, but on the whole a little bland(?). There are exceptions towards the end of the record where it gets a little weird. But getting there was a slog. I like the record but the “same-sy” sounds played with a bloated runtime keeps me from getting more from it. 5.5-6/10 Standout(s): Overture Pinball Wizard Sally Simpson I’m Free
Cool but didn't really pull me in
It’s been so long since I’ve listened to this album. My dad owned it back in the ’90s and would always play it in his truck. I even remember seeing the movie a few times, but my memory of it is pretty vague. What I’ve always loved, though, is the premise of this concept album, I mean, a deaf, dumb, and blind kid who grows up to be a pinball wizard, and then becomes a spiritual leader? Who, in their right sober mind, could have ever come up with a story like that?!
You know, I think as time goes on and more albums are generated from this era, the more I cannot stand albums that go over the 45 min mark. I get that Tommy's whole deal is the fact that its a Rock Opera and that it is telling a story, which is all well and good, plus The Who are one of the better bands of this era and it isn't an unlistenable album... But I really cannot begin to care about what this album is doing or where it's going. It's just a miss for me
This should have been a single record rather than a double set. The ambition is larger than the result. Exceeding borders doesn't necessarily to great music.
Almost a 4 for me.
Double albums must have been a popular gimmick back in the day. I’m not a big fan of them. I demoted a star based on that fact. This album is good, better than most of the drivel on this list but it still lacks something. I feel like that should have gone bigger with the guitars like they did in pinball wizard.
I think I’m just not a fan of the who… it was fine, rounding up to 3 but it was probably more of a 2.5 for me
Sounds good but yeah not very good. It's too long, I got bored tbh.
I like The Who, I've watched Tommy, it's trucking bizarre, has such a loose storyline some of it is just absolute crap. With one or two good songs. Far from their best work and quite frankly probably their most drug inspired idea. 😅
Much vaunted but I never took to this rambling show of self-indulgence. Redeemed only partially by the magnificent Pinball Wizard, which stands better on its own anyway 😐
Tommy by The Who? More like Who would recommend this album to me? Because it was bad. (Pinball Wizard is of course still a great song, but a deluxe album should have at least two?)
Obnoxiously long. I understand it's telling a story but a lot of it was instrumental and many tracks added nothing narratively. Meaning, however good, this is an auto DNF. It's not a flex to have an album that long, quality must be sacrificed to quantity. Learn to curate! Also, the narrative was weird...
I must think that ‘hard rock’ means something completely different than what it actually does, because if this is a hard rock album, I’m a little confused. This sounds more like a normal rock album to me. But I may be mistaken. Nevertheless, I did enjoy listening to this album, though it was better for background music than actually vibing to music. The instrumentals were pretty good, as well as the lyrics, but it just wasn’t that groundbreaking to me.
This one is hard to rank, as I did listen to it but not with the attention a story album really needs. I thought the music itself was decent and the set up in the first few songs very good but I didn’t pay it enough mind to fully get what was being communicated. But I guess not really wanting to come back to this … very long album is a ranking in itself.
way too long
Confesión: jamás había escuchado Tommy. Por supuesto conocía y amaba Pinball Wizard desde antes, incluso fui al concierto de The Who la última vez que estuvieron en México, pero jamás había escuchado esta, una de sus más emblemáticas obras. Y me pareció increíble. Creo, como también lo creo de The Wall, que no es un disco para escucharse una vez. Tiene muchas capas que pelarle y secretos aguardando ser descubiertos. Así que hoy inicio mi era Tommy, lo escucharé varias veces y veré la película.
Tommy is an ambitious rock album with big musical gestures and classics like “Pinball Wizard” and “See Me, Feel Me.” The Who play tightly, and there’s no doubt it’s an important work in rock history. But for me, it leans too much toward musical theatre. I miss more raw energy and less drama. 3/5
a groundbreaking concept album with several notable songs that made it onto the radio. I have seen the movie "Tommy" several times but had never listened to the entire soundtrack. Quite good!
It’s very ambitious and certainly a timeless piece of art. Gets a little self indulgent at times. It’s more of a show than a record in that sense. Great performances though. Moon is way calm down in this.
Solid album. Classic tale of Tommy. The Who are a set apart from other bands.
Bland, overlong and boring…apart from Pinball Wizard. Might have to stick to the greatest hits.
John Surgery.
Not a huge fan of the baroque rock opera type albums of the 60s/70s, this had some decent songs on it though, and I liked the culmination at the end with "We're not going to take it" 2.5 stars.
Rock Oper
Idk fine
It's absolutely mad from start to finish and fair play for them for doing it, it helped created a fun sub-genre. Pinball Wizard is iconic, yeah take my 5*
For the most part, the playing on this is great, especially Keith Moon's drumming. But it suffers from the lengths to which it goes to tell its story. The choruses on so many of these songs are simple and lame, presumably to make sure you know what's happening. The pacing suffers from multiple minute-long interludes and a 10 minute one that seems to only exist for the "Underture" wordplay. The story ranges from goofy to hard to take seriously. The worst moment is when we hear about abuse by Tommy's uncle in the painfully annoying "Fiddle About" chorus, which is quickly followed by a song about how Tommy is super good at pinball. Talk about tonal whiplash; there are themes here that are worth exploring, but they aren't treated with any care. The biggest problem is simpler though: none of the songs, even "Pinball Wizard," are really all that good.
Enjoyed it, liked the sort of story it told throughout the album.
I never really got into The Who, they never really clicked with me. “Tommy” continues that theme. It has bright moments, and “Christmas” is an unexpected hit for me, but overall aside from the excellent “Pinball Wizard” it’s just not for me. 3 stars for the skill.
The concept never quite took off for me. It's at its best on tracks that don't depend on the album to work, the obvious peak being Pinball Wizard which is great. But then what the fuck was going in with Do You Think it's Alright and Fiddle About? I've never heard anyone get such a bang out of describing their childhood sexual abuse. By this point on the album, Tommy has already been struck dumb by earlier misfortunes - which I guess is preferable to the implication that Tommy got molested into becoming an all pro pinball player, but then why bother with this detour at all? It's weird in a way I don't think was totally intended and sours me on the whole idea of this record. The poorly recorded live stuff at the end of the 2013 Super Deluxe might be my favorite part of the whole thing. Tepid 3.
How to love a terrible album. Tommy is a complete mess. Full of narrative catastrophe and over ambitious musical experimentation. It’s utterly disjointed and often deeply problematic. I also happen to love this album a great deal. There’s a strangeness to this work from start to finish that has always kept me coming back. The band’s sound is consistently good - even occasionally great with tracks like Pinball Wizard and See Me, Feel Me. But I think that it’s the ridiculousness of it all that stops me from hating on its clunky execution. I don’t think any of this is supposed to be taken seriously, and there’s some fun to be had in that. My mind calls back to ‘A quick one, while he’s away’. The Who’s tongue in cheek mini-rock opera. In kind, that story’s tale of the hero’s girl falling into the clutches of Iver the evil engine driver has that same sense of humour as Tommy’s deaf, dumb, and blind kid enlisting the services of a sex worker named “the Acid Queen” to cure his condition. “Watch his body rise” indeed! A flawed work. But perhaps the most deserving of a place on this list out of all of The Who’s albums. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
very solid
I liked this, but I can't finish the last 25 minutes of it. I mean, I had time, but it just wasn't calling me back after I needed to stop for work. ⭐⭐⭐
Great concept album but not as great as Meatloaf’s BAT OUT OF HELL concept album
Is Quadrophenia better? Maybe. Is this ludicrously overblown, a bit crass, and too long? Definitely! Do I really like it? Absolutely!
I don't know how I feel about this album. definitely seems revolutionary for its time, but not really my style. If I listened to it a bunch more, maybe I'd give it a 4 or 4.5, but just not my kind of music. Pinball wizard was good though. Thanks for reading!!
Classic album, but I really struggled with how to rate it. It’s not my favorite Who album, or even my favorite rock opera by The Who, but in the end it’s hard to deny how important this album became in pop culture and to the development of the band. Not all the tracks are bangers but they all hold together as an album flawlessly. The success of the weird concept album in and of itself warrants 5 stars.
I’m gonna be honest I highkey fell asleep while listening to this… whoops
I didn’t anticipate it being this good honestly.
Crazy concept for an album I didn't know they had hands like this in the 60s
Me gustan las trompetas del principio parece la intro de una peli de princesas. Vibras de musical de brodway, me transporta totalmente a estar sentada en la butaca de un teatro viendo a musicos y actores bailando, buena historia, no es mi estilo pero reconozco el esfuerzo y si algo me gusta mucho al escuchar un album es que me cuente una historia sin caer en la monotinia melodica. Me he enterado de todo? No os voy a mentir, estaba haciendo camisetas y no le he dado mi plena atencion :)
I listened to this a lot when I was a teenager. Watched the movie a bunch. Saw a college stage version (long before the Broadway show). Even with all of that, I still don’t really like it all that much. I think “Who’s Next” is one of the greatest albums ever, so I don’t dislike the band at all. I just can’t appreciate this the way I’m supposed to, I suppose. Clearly I’ve tried over the years. I hoped this listen would impress me differently but it didn’t. In fact, I was skipping ahead some just to get through it. There is a lot of talent here, lyrically and musically. So I don’t think I can give it a 2 or less. It’s a 2.5 that’s going to raise to a 3.
Truly dreadful.
I respect the endeavour, but not something I would return to.
ommy is a bold, messy, often brilliant attempt to turn rock music into something theatrical, spiritual, and mythic. It’s a rock opera in the truest sense — full of recurring motifs, strange characters, and a central figure who somehow becomes both a messiah and a pinball wizard. Pete Townshend swung big with this one, and even when it stumbles, the sheer ambition is hard not to admire. Songs like “Amazing Journey,” “Sparks,” and “I’m Free” still carry a real sense of lift and momentum, with Keith Moon and John Entwistle holding everything together like a manic rhythm section with divine purpose. That said, Tommy is far from perfect. The storyline is fragmented, sometimes uncomfortable, and often barely makes sense unless you’ve got a lyric sheet and plenty of patience. Some of the songs feel like narrative filler rather than inspired writing, and there’s a theatrical awkwardness to parts of it that can be hard to ignore. But taken as a whole, it works
Cool for what it is. For the deaf dumb and blind.
Not a fan of this album at all and it's not only because Heidi stood me up at the College Twin and I had to process that while suffering the searing experience of staring at a twenty foot closeup of Roger Daltrey imploring me to feel him and touch him.
Aside from the three singles from this album, which I recognize immediately from years of radio play, I doubt I've ever heard anything else before from this ambitious rock opera. And so I'm glad I've finally listened to the album and finally understand the context for Tommy the pinball wizard. And I have a much bigger respect for Pete Townsend, knowing now that he largely wrote the entire opera (lyrics, at least), but I'll admit that the Wikipedia entry is incredibly helpful at filling in the blanks between the songs and forming a more complete picture of Tommy's past and later role as (somewhat rejected) guru. (Apparently Townsend gave an incredibly long interview with Rolling Stone that described the storyline and the connection to Meher Baba's teachings in excruciating detail, and while I'm not sure I need that much backstory, perhaps the "1001 Albums" reviewer should have read this first before writing a strangely misinformed and misleading review in the book.) I'm not sure I can say I really enjoyed the album, but I'm impressed at how much better this concept album works than anything else like it in this collection (so far, at least). I also admired that they created this album so it could be played live, in contrast to how the Beatles and Beach Boys were focusing on studio-only productions, and then that they resuscitated the band (and eliminated their debt) by touring the whole album live. And it was fun to hear the big singles from the album, although the album versions aren't the same as what I've heard over the years on the radio, I'll admit. I was also struck with how much "Christmas" sounded more like the Beatles than anything else. And it was fun to read about all the weird and often-celebrity-filled opera/symphony/film/theater "incarnations" of Tommy.
I was never a fan of The Who or of Tommy, and over the years, I've grown more appreciative of their impact and the sound itself, but at the end of the day, I'm still giving it a 3.
As far as rock operas go, this is one of them.
I love The Who. Who's Next is one of my favourite albums. But, somehow Tommy just leaves me cold. I don't know if it's because I have to listen to it in full to get the full experience, and 75 minutes is too much to give it undivded attention, but I just never 'get' it. To me, Pete Townshend, is one of the all-time greats for songwriting and guitar playing. I've read about how technically difficult it is to correctly play the chords on Pinball Wizard, and this goes to show how much went in to creating this album, yet I still find myself longing for a 'Won't Get Fooled Again' track. Perhaps I need to sit in a darkened room, consume some illicit substance and be totally mesmerised by it, then I will eventually understand it fully, but until then, it gets a middle-of-the-road three stars. Standout track - Pinball Wizard (obviously)
Absolutely love.
I thought I didn't know any of the songs (but familiar with the concept), but some of the tunes I have absorbed through osmosis sometime. I quite liked it, I think.
Lots of meandering and forgettable chord progressions with few memorable melodies or hooks. Bloated and repetitive. Maybe it was culturally exciting for being a new way to present rock and roll music, but it doesn’t make it something I’d want to put on my turntable.
Given that I like a lot of songs by The Who, I am speechless at how utter dog doodoo that was. Awful.
Wouldn’t listen to it again, but a few good songs
Alguna canción suelta notable pero no me ha despertado demasiado interés.
Keine Ahnung mehr
The original rock opera
I expected to like this more.
Interesting narrative, kept my interest despite the length. My only complaint is I felt some of the songs barely fit into the story.
It was entertaining. I lost the plot a little in the middle. I knew Pinball Wizard going in. I wouldn’t listen to the whole album again, but I’m glad I heard it.
Yeah, I just wasn’t really into this one.
I hated it. Like it actually had potential. I feel like it might be good music? But gosh I hated it. This had to be heavily drug influenced right?
Honestly, this one felt tedious. I will give them their props for musical talent but other than the ones I knew, I didn’t love any of it. In fact, some of the lyrics were just weird af.
This album has some classic Who songs, like Pinball Wizard ofc. The narrative of the album is interesting, following Tommy with his relationship and eventually moving the narrative back into playing pinball. The feel of the album is like classic dad rock, not something I would've thought to listen to but something that is super easy and nice to listen to.
Is this a rock opera? I have no idea! The songs are great. The album is fantastic, I listen to it over and over again. The film is outstanding; I've seen it more than once. Okay, you who don't like it, I give the album four stars.
Could not finish bleh
Good
69/1001. We all love how the Who brought art and rock together as so called "rock operas" in concept albums. We all hate how the Who brought art and rock together as so called "rock operas" in concept albums. For me this one leans a bit more on the love side, it is 69 (year and my 69th generated album) after all. And I remember Tina Turner kick ass as the acid queen in the film version, plus they are calling my name. I might imagine buying this LP.
Прослушала только один диск. Ну альбом на тот часа это конечно мощно
I have never listened to this entire thing in order, which was quite the experience and now I must grab some kind of mind altering substance and watch this movie.
rated 30 on aoty july 18th 2025 i hate this
Wasn't as good as I hoped
Dit is een interessante. Voor het eerste (grote) rock opera krijgt het al een 5, en het is ook gewoon heel goed, maar ik heb toch steeds de neiging om het te vergelijken met The Wall en daardoor voelt het gewoon minder bijzonder. Wat er gebeurt wordt vrijwel woord voor woord verteld en dat haalt wat magie weg. Ook is het muzikaal niet heel geweldig en is het het verhaal dat dit album echt bijzonder maakt. Al met al nog steeds een 5, maar Pink Floyd heeft dit deels geruïneerd
Didn't like it. Disturbing and also just lacking in good tunes.
Long album , I did not enjoy it so much, it has some good moments though, and the concept of it find it original.
A rock musical in album form. Following the story of Tommy- and I must say; for a deaf dumb and blind kid. He sure does play a mean pin ball. An interesting and enjoyable listen. But also quite long. Sally Simpson a new song which was good