Reviews (page 8 of 14)
It took me a long time to decide, but I'm giving this 7 out of 10 and rounding down. I like it a lot, but it's a little slow in the middle. I believe Quadrophenia is better, and Who's Next is an easy 5 star. This is quality Who, but they've got better.
Jag gillar the Whos sound. Det är musikaliskt ofta väldigt bra. Det är dock lite speciellt med en rock opera. Det är mer "filmmusik"-känsla. Lite svårare att greppa. Pinball Wizard är en en klassiker dock som jag lyssnat på mycket när jag var yngre. Grym låt. Mycket annat är helt ok, men som sagt, pga formatet lite svårsmält. Det blir en trea pga bra sound, men lägre än om det av allt detta plockats ut 10 "riktiga" låtar.
Hade svårt att hålla mig engagerad genom hela denna - det är för långt och för mycket utfyllnad, även om det är ett behjärtansvärt försök med en rockopera. Det är dock aldrig dåligt (förutom Tommy’s holiday camp), men det är alldeles för sällan också riktigt bra.
This wasn't my favorite. It wasn't bad by any means, but I just couldn't recall a single song once the album was over. And I genuinely like the Who so this review makes me sad. It's truly just a middle of the road record for me.
The Who's hits are amazing. Once you get into the deeper stuff, I'm not always a huge fan. This is a cool album. I like the hits, and I'm familiar with most of the songs. I don't think, as an album, I'm super into it.
Super excited to get this record! I'm a big fan of progressive rock - my favorite band of all time is Coheed and Cambria but also love bands like Pink Floyd, Rush, Dream Theater, and so many others. A lot of bands I love are heavily influenced by The Who and this record has the only song I know by them on it - "Pinball Wizard". The album has a fair bit of downtime songs that are meant to be used as intermission-type songs and there's several songs that are less than a minute long, so the album looks a lot longer than it actually is. I felt like a sped through this one! Standout tracks are "Eyesight to the Blind (The Hawker)", "The Acid Queen", "Pinball Wizard", "Smash the Mirror", and "Sally Simpson". Side note: Keith Moon is an amazing drummer and I think him and Entwistle hard carry this record. This was a fun one and I have to thank The Who and this album for being so influential on a lot of my favorite music.
Didn’t love this as much as I thought I would! Maybe I don’t even really know who the who is.
la ópera rock y sus consecuencias han sido un desastre para la raza humana. La historia me da un cringe terrible además y es como una mierda new age super turbia tengo entendido. NO OBSTANTE pinball wizard es un temazo
I'm familiar with The Who as a band, but have never given them a listen. I went in with no expectations. It's so theatrical! Am I listening to a musical?! Yes, apparently I am...a "rock opera," in fact. I actually dig it, but it was a tad long. So many songs felt like an intro, or like it was building up to something that never quite got there. Are there choruses in these songs, or is it just verse, verse, verse, next song? Also, the story of Tommy is actually quite dark.
Не перегруженный, выразительный, бодрый и могучий.
кайф
One of the great concept albums. A little biased since the Who was one of my favorite bands back in high school.
i like the whomst but i can’t with this one
Álbum muito interessante. Ótimas notas e melodias. Depois de descobrir o histórico do álbum, ele ganha mais significado. Favoritas : go to the mirror, im free e tommy can you hear me?
Has some ok bits but is generally pretty dull
Heard various Who songs here and there. I will be honest with you, after just 6 songs it felt as if I've been listening to the album for an hour. I'm just not interested in the concept of this concept album. 2/5
The good tracks are great. The others, not so much!
it is calming me. I remember times there's not exist me, and they was good. Good times. Which was never exist.
I'm like 70% sure that this album is mainly meandering instrumental, 20% meandering story, and then, like, 10% solid songwriting. The Who had assuredly come into their own musically at this point, but this weird middle-ground between what the Rolling Stones were doing and what the Beatles were doing just leads the album to feeling wholly unoriginal, not helped by its constant credits with inventing the rock opera, which is just not the case. Sure, there are hits from this, but does Pinball Wizard truly stand against the other 1969 powerhouse hits every other band was releasing at the time, let alone a whole album? No, not really. Would be entirely forgotten were it not for the fact that somehow the Who managed to squirm into the upper echelons of the British Invasion, and for that I'll forever be just confused.
Funny. Ive heard so many cuts from this but never the whole rock opera. Really good!
I didn’t make it all the way through but yay for rock operas
"you've phoned me so we can listen to and comment on 'Tommy' together but MY CD PLAYER IS FUCKING BROKEN." Keith shouted from the other side of the phone. (for the back story of Keith, please see my review for other albums by The Who.) "You better move it to somewhere else. i've done that once and it functions as usual." "well... OK." it finally works, "And-- Here we fucking go!!" "the overture is so fucking long." i muttered. Keith responded with unsatisfaction: "Just pretend that you are listening to the soundtrack for a musical. then it won't feel that long." "erm, Keith? can you come to my home so we can watch the movie version? it's better with a bunch of stars singing it." "You need to accept the original version, cause it's the original version." "You literally said nothing useful!" "Seems the classic motif is coming up. the 'See me, feel me' part always send shivers down my spine when I was watching the movie. and similarly, in their concert videos." "Well, who the fuck doesn't get shivers because of Pete's songwriting?" "can I say that for 'The Acid Queen', Tina Turner's version is better?" "well, i have to admit that her voice is more powerful and suitable for the song. And the arrangement is better!" "Dude why the Underture is ten minutes long?" "it's meant to be like that. i can't do anything with it. i actually skipped that track on first listen. And sometime I still do that too. and well? the CD player still works but the remote is broken. I guess that we should spend the 10 minutes wisely." "It's finally building up. and, three minutes to go." "it's always building up and then going down. like the tide." "can we listen to 'Love, Reign O'er Me' in the last 3 minutes?" "well, it's only 3 minutes. You can tolerate it, can't you." "i... hope so." "And maybe there's a reason why your name is Sally, as in 'So, Sally can wait'. and why do you fail to wait for a song to end?" "oh yeah we are finally through this... two more tracks to go and it's THE song!" (two more tracks later. Keith began to play air guitar to "Pinball Wizard".) "YEAHHHHHHH! although i am not a who fan I absolutely LOVE the song!" "WOOOOO HOOOOO!" "The motif is returning and the 'listening to you' part is adding in... Tommy is ready to regain his senses. Don't you remember the part in the movie, when during 'I'm Free', Roger runs on the beach like that gamer youtuber that is pretty famous for being single for a long time?" "Yeah, I remember that in a vlog, he was running alongside the beach shouting 'I long for freedom! I want to fall in love!'. I love his videos and he is finally married recently..." "yeah, FINALLY." "Wait a minute, the plot of the movie is THAT different from the album? and 'i'm Free' don't come in until two songs later?" "wait a sec you dont know that? you should check out the wikipedia page for that before you listen!" "Why I am laughing sooooo hard when 'I'm Free' begin playing?" "cause you are just fully in the 'I long for freedom! I want to fall in love!' mode." "Shut up." "'Tommy's Holiday Camp' is the cheesiest minute of music that i ever heard." "Cant disagree." "Well, I don't like the first half of 'We're Not Gonna Take It', cause it's pretty political." "erm... but it's still a good song, isn't it?" "you... are pretty right." "And it just fades out at the end? I always thought that there would be a grand finale!" "Yeah! Post-listening reflection time!" "Can I say that although this is an influential album for one of the first rock operas, Quadrophenia is still better?" "of course! So, what's your score? I don't think that it deserves a 5 solely judging by musicality but i'm still giving it a 5." "A 4. there's weak points but the whole album is still strong." "Well... OK. A 4. So, we've agreed on each other!" 4/5
Dog shit
Absolute bobbins, deserves zero stars
All who albums are getting a 1 star for noncing.
Awful
So incredibly bad
The creator really likes the who.
wow just like go to school by the lemon twigs
This gets credit for being the first rock Opera but other than that, this is pretty okay. The story they tell is SOOOO dumb and pointless. You are lying if you say you understood some of the plot points. "Pinball Wizard" and "Sally Simpson" obv score points here and the concept of "Overture" was so cool and well done. I do enjoy the vocals a lot. Actual review...2.5 Liked Songs: "Overture" , "1921" , "Sparks" , "Eyesight To The Blind (The Hawker)" , "Pinball Wizard" , "Go To The Mirror!" , "Tommy Can You Hear Me?" , "Sally Simpson"
liked songs: Overture, Eyesight To The Blind (The Hawker), Pinball Wizard First off, I disagree with calling this album a rock opera. It's just a concept album. And yes, it tells a long, extended story over many different songs, but it doesn't have the sense of scale or pomp needed to call it an opera. Second, I broke this album into two listens and I was still bored. There's some standout tracks (which include their huge hit single and a cover), but I can't say I loved most of them. Overall: meh 2.5
Yay!! An excellent album. Was pleased to get to listen to this to kick off the weekend
I'm sure this was pretty ground breaking back then, but when i heard the live album kick off after listening to the whole double album, I panicked and closed spotify.
*To the tune of "Rock Lobster by The B-52s* ROCK OPERAAAAAAA
This was an Amazing Journey. The Sparks were flying. You’ll want to listen to this. You’re Welcome.
Classic.
Really cool album, pioneering the Rock opera and delivering the goods is no small feat. Really enjoyable.
not bad, interesting songs
All right lads, next album is gonna be a fucking rock opera. Ok. What’s it gonna be about? A deaf, dumb, and blind kid. I don’t know, mate. Seems a bit odd for a rock & roll album. But wait, he also crushes at pinball. Fucking brilliant. Let’s make it a double.
The first rock opera? The story is kind of out there but the songs tell the story well.....and the songs are good. I enjoyed this one and would gladly spin it again.
Don’t get me wrong, The Who is a legacy band. However, this record doesn’t really move the needle for me…
Pinball Wizard must be one of the finest songs with a story, just beaten by The Killing of Georgie and In The Ghetto. Alrite?
No one needs to tell you that listening to this album is worth is for the rhythm section alone, but I'd like to shout out Townshend's guitar tone; an often overlooked aspect of this band. Townshend was always an idol of mine because he proved you didn't need to be a virtuoso to write compelling riffs and arrangements. Anyway, this is a rock opera, and if there's one thing all rock operas have in common, it's that they're divisive. You're here, you're taking on this list as an experiment, so take the 75 minutes and listen. Maybe you won't like it, but at least you can say with certainty that you don't like it. Personally I have a lot of issues with this album. I don't think many of the instrumentals do much to enhance the experience, and the story is pretty surface level when compared to similar albums like The Wall. But god damn, there's no other band in the world that could've made this. Hell, there's just no other band like The Who.
While neither the first nor definitively the best rock opera, Tommy stands as the first truly great one—a pivotal moment when The Who leapt forward to cement their legacy among rock's most essential bands.
easy listening
Unnecessarily long, but I'm surprised by the hatred of this album. I think it's an interesting concept to depart from other similar musicians.
I've never really liked The Who, but I've always enjoyed Tommy. I don't know what that means to be honest. Saw Tommy rather than heard it, as a child, and basically since then was disappointed to find that besides the odd song they never came close to matching it. I like all the musical themes that appear frequently, the climbing minor chords piece which first appears in Overture in particular. Obviously Pinball Wizard and We're Not Gonna Take It. Christmas is also great. Cousin Kevin is horrific in its casual and nonplussed cruelty. Same goes for Fiddle About. Bits of Underture are very good, it is a bit on the long side though. I mean I'm not going to make an argument that it's all brilliant. I don't think anyone who does should be taken seriously. But it is the ultimate concept album for good and for ill. And I just enjoy the ride.
I remember my parents having a VHS copy of the rock opera of Tommy and always being like what a weird looking movie haha but little did I know that it was such a cool thing! I really enjoy The Who and this was a cool concept album and had some really good songs! Would definitely listen again!
In general, I really like the Who. And in general, I really like concept albums. This one, while decent, just doesn't..."click" for me.
Maybe you had to be there back then to know how great this is. I love this album - one of my all time favorites.
Interesting - but too long
No fue la primera Ópera Rock (S.F. Sorrow de The Pretty Things,) ni su mejor álbum pero es una gran disco, y sobre todo marcó una época. Compuesto con una base autobiográfica y con canciones que son básicas en su repertorio. La película contó con una magistral Tina Turner, Clapton, Jack Nicholson etc.
The concept is good but not something I would listen to again
Tosi vahvaa Who:ta! Elementeissään.. Toki haluatko elementtejä syödä... Vai kompleksempia hiiliatomijuttuja... Typpeä mukana..m protein...
I rate Pinball wizard a 5 star because the guitar is good and the beat is good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. I rate smash the mirror 5 star because the guitar is good and the beat is good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. I rate were not going to take it 5 star because the guitar is good and the beat is good ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐.
Song:pinball i like this song it is actually good because the guitar sounds so different in other songs. Song: smash the mirror this song is okay not my favorite, but i kind of like it Song: where not going to take it I don ´ t really like this song and this lyrics is good though it is saying don ´ t take drugs so that's good but the beat and stuff is wonky
I like this song because I like the beat. I would recommend this song I like this song because of the weird sounds. I would recommend this song I like this song because it has cool beats. I would recommend this song
I think this album is pretty nice because I like the way his voice sounds with the beat and background music. I like how the album talks about being blind dead and dumb. I think its really cool and would reccomnend this.
Do you want to listen to some music that has a lot of guitar? Well in Pinball Wizard you can! I rate it a ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I recommend this song. Do you want to listen to some music that has a lot of drums? Well in Smash The Mirror you can! I rate this song a ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I recommend this song. Do you want to listen to some music that has a lot of guitar? well in Were not going to take it you can! I rate it ⭐⭐⭐. I kind of recommend this song.
I like this song because i like the beat and the electric guitar and the drums . the second song was good to but i like the first song better the third song was my favorite i like what i says .
Have you ever wanted to listen to music? Then this album is perfect for you. In my opinion, I personally do not really like this album. The first reason why I don't really like this is because I just don't really like the type of music that there is. Another reason why I don't really like this music is because of the instruments that are used in it. I would not recommend this album to someone else because I feel like someone else would not really like it. I would probably give this album a solid 3 stars.
1 i dislike it its just not my type of music i dont like the vibe its just not my style. the second one i dont really like either its just not my stlyle the third one i dont really like it just not my style of music i dont really like the chorus
the first song is okay i don't really like it because the voice is lowkey weird but like the background music is good ig the lyrics I hear are ight but I can barely understand wha its saying oms oh wait nvm there's lyrics on da screen but without the screen I don't know what there saying bru. the second song started off alr its not that good but I can understand the lyrics kinda but I like the background music like I said in the first song the last song is the most clearest like I can hear the lyrics and understand them oms its igh
The cover is strange looking because of the weird shape. I thought "Pinball Wizard" was good. I thought the lyrics were interesting but in a good way. The music and singing was great. "Smash the mirror" was good but it was short. I liked the smashing mirror at the end. I liked "We're Not Gonna Take It" because it had a good message. The harmonies were good and so was the music. I would definitely recommend this album.
the first song is good. the next is good. and so is the third. i recommend
Why is the cover like that? "Pinball Wizard" I did not like. It was too slow for me and it just sounded a little weird but it wasn't terrible. "Smash the Mirror" I didn't like. It sounded super weird with the "rise rise rise" part and also the smashing mirror sound. "We're Not Gonna Take It" is the best out of all of them but I still didn't like it. The soft voices sound super weird. Overall I didn't like this album and would give it 1.5 stars and I wouldn't reccomend this album to anyone because all of the songs are just to soft and don't match the tempo.
I'm sure there is some musical genius going on here that I can't understand...but I can't understand it. I love Pinball Wizard, but the whole Opera Rock Tommy story going on here is hard to follow and at times not that fun to listen along to. Would give it a 2 were it not for the enjoyable aspects of Keith, Pete, and Roger that demonstrate their musical showmanship. Perhaps the live performance is better, perhaps you need to actually be locked in and paying attention to the lyrics, but overall not an album I'd request to be spun.
I appreciate a good concept album and rock opera but this was too drawn out and some parts aged very poorly
Amazing soundtrack
Good concept album
The "story" was a bit weird and contrived, but the music was good. Very nice how they used the overture theme through different songs, really tied the album together. I can imagine this was a revelation in 69
Good fun, got a bit lost as the version I listened to was 3 discs!
What a treat of an album. Stand outs: Eyesight to the Blind - "You talk about your woman...you should see mine." - so good. Great song in general. Christmas - Great concept (on a CONCEPT album, no less?!). Great lyrics. Textbook Who key changes. Gorgeous harmonies in Cousin Kevin. Love the quintessential 60s ones on "You won't be much fun Being blind, deaf and dumb But I've no-one to play with today". The lyrics might render it a one-time listen, though. Go To The Mirror! - just epic. Classic Who key changes too. I'm Free - so good as we KNOW. Love that they brought the 60s whimsy with Tommy's Holiday Camp. End of We're Not Gonna Take it (See Me, Feel Me / Listening to You) is INCREDIBLE AS WE KNOW.
That deaf, dumb and blind kid sure plays a mean pinball!
I can appreciate this album as the work of art it is, even through I think this is my least fav of The Who albums I’ve listened to so far. The Acid Queen and Pinball Wizard are the standout tracks.
Enjoyed this much more than “Who’s Next”, despite being less refined. Cool vocal harmonization and a more psychedelic experience. I was blown away by “1921” and is the standout track here by far.
This hasn’t held up over the years - there are some great song but others are just ok. I would give it a 3 1/2 if I could but. It’s get the extra 1/2 stars because I keep thinking about some of the songs hrs later. Highlights are Overture, Can You Hear Me, I’m Free and We’re Not Going to Take it Anymore.
A concept album from the 60s is not exactly my wheelhouse. Has some pretty decent tunes though. Just scrapes in for a three.
10/10. What an epic rock opera!!! The story is really interesting, and the music is awesome!!! ;)
Mhmm had high expectations from pinball wizard, the rest of the album is less great
I am not getting this at all. It's like listening to the songs from some grimy musical, but without the sparkly costumes and choreography to distract you.
some of the songs are ok, but the story is a little out there. this was ok but i don’t know if i would ever listen again.
Just not into The Who. Always liked the title track, though.
I’d probably rate it higher if I gave it more time. I like a lot of what it is trying to do, but there isn’t a CRAZY amount that stood out to me aside from the hits. I did like Christmas though.
Classic band Classic album
Super ambitious. Not as intense as the wall but I can imagine Pink Floyd taking some inspiration from this. I found the earlier songs quite troubling to listen to given the story, but it's told well. I got a bit bored towards the end and do think this is too long. Solid 4, with extra props for ambition.
Great music. Too long.
до слез
Speaking of old school, oof. NGL, although I listened to the whole album it was a total slog. In particular there was a little too much talk of r**e and soforth in what is basically a fancy pop song. 2 stars, sorry buds.
Sorry, dad! No album should have this many songs that exist solely for plot exposition.
I really quite enjoyed this. Heard about it so many times, but this was listen #1. Unexpectedly orchestral and cohesive. The Who seem to have been lost to the mainstream of oldies, but they had something gear for awhile and ‘Tommy’ was in their pocket.
I was a long haired early 20s idealist during one of final teaching practicums in Halifax. One of my grade 11s found out I was a fan of the who and made me the greatest who mix of all time. I listened to it for years. I remember playing it on repeat when I visited Windsor castle one May weekend when I moved to London. Many of these songs were from Tommy and I forgot how much I love the who. This album is ambitious and messy but overall is a great listen.
This happens a lot: I wish the link would go straight to the original album (which is on Spotify just fine) rather than the bloated super deluxe edition. Anyway. I can take or leave the concept album/rock opera here, but they manage to wrangle a couple great tracks along the way. Important at the time, sure, but hasn't aged as well as others.
Ok. Ish. In places.
Gne insomma
Tommy cazzo fai
Had to listen over a couple of sittings but this was quite interesting and different. An ambitious idea that probably gets better with each relisten. Favourite tracks: The Acid Queen & Go to the Mirror! Worth a relisten. 3/5
5 for the historical significance, and 4 for my personal appreciation. Tommy is a classic, the first Rock opera ever. Plus listening to the music The Who made is just unspeakably satisfying.
2nd disc is not available on Spotify. Songs without sense of less of a minute (including some of just 12 seconds), the rest is a good album but nothing exceptional.
Respect the effort. Except for Entwistle the who were always meh for me. At one time the loudest band in the world though. Gotta respect that, I guess. Also with album titles like Meaty, Beaty, Big and Bouncy..
I like the album cover. But it is not my taste of music. Despite that, there are 2-3 songs I liked. For example: "We're Not Gonna Take It" (which I liked the most).
I would listen to maybe 1 of these on its own ever
Track 11: "Do You Think It's Alright?". Spoiler for the next track: it was not alright 💀 Quite the unique story album Edit Apr 22 2026: 4 --> 3
tommmyyyyyyy
70s rock is always a good listen
I was already familiar with The Who, of course, but hadn't ever listened to this album in full. I enjoyed how the album flows together. It started to get a little too long for me towards the end. It has some impressive 100% instrumental songs mixed in, though, which I wasn't expecting.
i don't get "Tommy". not for lack of trying, really; i understand the spiritual connection the music has and the connection it shares with Pete Townshend's experiences, but the unfortunate fact is that none of this actually helps me understand the "opera" part of the world's first self-billed "Rock Opera". like, maybe the narrative of The Wall falls apart by the end with "The Trial", but things happen for reasons in that album, there is a legitimate cause for the actions and progression of the album's story. Pink is a rock star whose father died in the war, his mother smothered him as a child, and worst of all, he attended British school in the mid 20th century. as a result, he does copious amounts of drugs in order to return to any sort of comfort and lashes out at the world by becoming a rock star. this leads to him overinflating his own ego by imagining himself as the person who took his father's life and led him down this path -- his very own Adolf Hitler. there are reasons as to why Pink does these things. i actually don't know why Tommy does anything in this album. he becomes deaf blind and dumb because he witnesses his dad murder his mom's lover (which isn't really made clear in the lyrics, it's probably clearer in the liner notes); then his parents just kind of turn into Timmy's mom and dad in "the Fairly Odd Parents" and leave him to get tortured by his cousin and molested by his uncle. then he gets into pinball because uh, he got it for Christmas? he then starts a new religious movement when looking in a mirror cures his symptoms. it suffers from being both way too unclear in many parts but also way too on the nose in many other parts. said evil uncle and cousin, his first doctor's acid casualty wife, and the doctor who actually cures him get introductory songs, but Tommy's rise to fame is almost incidental compared to his time as a 12 year old new religious leader. it's confusing. i could overlook this if i was enchanted by the Who's musical capabilities, but unfortunately i find the performances here weak. i can hardly reconcile this being the same band behind "I Can See for Miles" or "Baba O'Riley", because everything here feels way too light for what should be a freaky, challenging record. the guitars should roar; instead, they buzz under the radar compared to the lyrics, which both center stage and struggle to be understood. it's so easy to trace all of the rock opera genre's sins to "Tommy", taking the musical and the concept album and merging the worst parts of both instead of focusing on the possibilities that both offer. it's not awful, but god, i'd rather just watch the episode of Clone High that riffs on this and The Wall.
It wasn't great to listen to. 2/5
Hampered by connective tissue rather than a solid body of music telling a story. Judged by the hits, it’s a great album with a good ratio of stuff I’d listen to again versus filler material. Compare “Tommy’s Holiday Camp” to Les Miserables’ “Master of the House.” If you don’t think that’s a fair comparison, don’t call it an opera.
👍🏼
Very boring compared to Who's next
Nja, det er jo fett... Men de er liksom ikke like musikalsk begavede i andre sjangere som the Beatles. Det føles som om de prøver å lage et mesterverk, og da blir det litt try-hard. Prog rock på tidlig tidspunkt. Med det sagt er det mye bra låter her.
3.5 - cool concept album but it didn’t hit the mark a lot
This is one of the greatest rock albums, a quintessential rock opera. It’s still fun to listen to but you can definitely throw out half the songs and end up with something even better.
I guess you had to be there?
Great album!
OK, better as a soundtrack to a movie. pinball wizard still very good though
Classic (and as a theatre nerd, I was already familiar with), but definitely absurd and overly-long at times.
Today I learned that Pinball Wizard was part of a really boring rock opera… and that the preceding song is about the kid getting fiddled by his uncle. Cool.
I realized as I listened to this that I probably hadn't ever heard the whole thing before or that much of it wasn't that memorable. Sure, there are the big songs we all know from the radio, but there sure are a lot of less consequential songs here. I know this is a legendary album, but I found as much I wasn't impressed with alongside those overplayed hits from our Gen X childhood classic rock stations. Combine that with the kiddy porn charges agains Townshend and I gotta be honest it's probably my last listen.
'Who' gives a shit? See what I did there... Now stop reading this review and go listen to something enjoyable.
I’ve never seen any stage or film production of this “rock opera.” Would I feel differently about it if I had that connection? Without it, you can still pick up on the story and themes, but something is lacking. Being forced to stick to the narrative does perhaps keep The Who more focused on the message they constantly pursued about the state of their generation, and which felt underdeveloped on “My Generation” and “The Who Sell Out.” Ultimately, though, the music is better on those aforementioned albums. Maybe the full experience of “Tommy” would make me feel otherwise, but it certainly seems like The Who’s best songs are found elsewhere.
I can see where the idea of a concept album or theatre show could seem like a cool playground for a rock band to mess around in. And any one of the social issues that Pete brought with his Tommy (murder, bullying, pedophilia, drug use, cult of celebrity, etc) could be the basis of an interesting inquiry. But Tommy throws way too much into the mix to make any of it seem important. And on top of that, the music just isn’t that good - in fact, it’s boring, with long stretches of nothing compelling in either the music or the lyrics. Daltry’s voice is not in good form and he’s not given much by the score to show off his strengths. When Pete takes the mic, it’s only too clear that he should stick to the guitar. Some of these songs fare better on the movie soundtrack, but the whole outing was really just a big miss on The Who’s part.
I’ll keep Pinball Wizard as a great classic song on its own, but a rock opera just doesn’t belong on this list any more than a soundtrack does. It’s meant to be consumed in a different delivery system.
This is probably blasphemy to some, but while I love Tommy, I don’t love listening to the Who sing the entire thing. Give me the cast recording. 😬
Another double album that is too long. There are good songs buried amongst the extended atonal-ish instrumental passages. It’s too much and I lose interest.
This album is such a mess. It’s not very consistent or good. It should absolutely be on here though. There are some highlights here and there.
2.5*
I love this band's music, and Tommy. Was super psyched when I recognized Pinball Wizard and it came on. I also liked how the album felt like it had a progression, like I was at a concert or something
Cool but long
Brilliant rock opera/concept album I had the film soundtrack LP (cheap remaindered cut-out from Debenhams) I saw them perform this at the Royal Albert Hall in 2017, it was fantastic
I have some friends who adore this album, but it left me absolutely cold and actually quite unsettled. I get the idea of it as an opera, and the need for short interludes, but it was missing something. I couldn't easily follow what was happening, it was just a disjointed sequence of sketches and ideas. When it did settle on an idea, it was images of child abuse set to fairground melodies. I started off wanting to give it a chance, and just got more and more disappointed as it went on. I know Pinball Wizard is a classic, but the album as a whole doesn't deserve it.
BEST SHIT EVER LES GOOO
2 stars. Fine, will be never listen to again.
This album is so long. I kinda get it, like, it’s an album from 1969 so why not do anything else haha, but this album just DRAAGGGSSSS ONNNNN. It feels like an elongated jam session, though honestly I prefer listening to alor of these tracks over like the Beatles LMAOOO. Fav song: Underture (even if some of the notes are so jwysuwokwhsua off key)
Concept of the album is cool, it really does feel like a story with a through line which is cool. I also find it funny that with all these tracks about Tommy's struggles, the most popular one is about him being good at Pinball. Biggest gripe is that this album is SO. GOD. DAMN. LOOOOOONG! Like I swear this should have been under an hour! Anyways, Tommy's Holiday Camp is the best song ever made, end of review.
Very experimental for the time, some real quality in drums solos, lyrics and composition however just doesn’t hit the exact spot for me Favourite song - Underture
Out of all The Who albums, I've probably listened to this one the most. It is definitely the most unique and I love the story-telling aspect of this, following Tommy's life journey as a deaf/dumb/blind boy to adulthood. A tad ridiculous concept, admittedly, but I enjoyed it as a kid and still do as an adult. Songs like Cousin Kevin, Acid Queen, Pinball Wizard, Go To The Mirror, and I'm Free can stand out on their own in any album. I always loved the instrumental Overture/Underture that set the stage for each Act. When I listened to this, it felt like watching a stage show or musical. I can understand why this might be a polarizing album. It is pretty long, filled with arguably too many "skits", and can get a little repetitive. I know all of this and still really enjoy the album anyway. My heart says this belongs in the 5 category, but I feel like my bias might be pushing that score up. This album has some flaws and I found it difficult giving this a 5 while overlooking those flaws on re-listening to this with a different perspective (and this being my first listen in maybe like 5 years or whatever). I'll put this as a High 4.
Brilliant rock and roll album
mmm voy a escuchar la versión normal. Lo de la Super Deluxe me parece demasiado. He oído canciones sueltas y Pinball wizard es una de mis canciones favoritas. Pues el resto me ha resultado aburrido, algunas canciones me ha gustado la guitarra, pero poco más. Entiendo que hay que oirlo alguna vez y que fue un hito musical, pero le voy a poner 3 estrellas solo por Pinball Wizard.
A great concept album that’s well executed. The music is good, but many of the pieces are there simply to move the plot along. Undeniably influential on rock operas and concept albums that followed (eg, the Wall). But overall this is pretty simple musically and more of a “musical” (with lots of exposition) than “rock opera”. A 3.
I didn’t love this, but I think a big part of it was that feeling of listening to the soundtrack to a musical or movie that I haven’t seen, which tends to really frustrate me because I’m constantly wondering, “what’s happening in this part? What are they doing?” I get that this was a really cool thing when it came out in 1969, but it does not work for me. If I ever actually see it performed I might have a better appreciation for it? But for now, it’s a no thank you.
How was this a popular as it was?
Megavet album, is soms wel iets te lang om weg te luisteren maar het concept van het album is echt geweldig
Niet echt mijn ding, maar zit wel goed in elkaar.
Beukertje hoor, al moet je er wel voor in the mood zijn. Ik vind Quadrophenia beter. 3,5/5
In it's time it's a pretty decent concept album. You can just about follow the story. Musically it's hit and miss - there's something about the Who's sound that just doesn't quite sit right with me
Impactful, and a lot of people hardcore love this album, but I’ve always felt it was overrated. Bits and pieces are catchy, but I’m just not into the concept
Didn’t like this at all. Songs are not memorable, musicianship was very average
I like concept/story albums
Not bad. English Rock.
A double album I don't like by a band I don't like to start the week. 1001 Albums Generator, you do treat me.
My god it's too long There are moments...the outro to we're not going to take it, pinball wizard...few and far between Much much better live but after more than an hour I don't have the will to go all the way through the live discs too Studio 2 live 3+
For a transgressive, genre pushing work it's just rather boring.
I saw this as a musical in the 90s, but never listened to the actual album. I enjoyed the back half, and the concept is cool.
Chef's kiss
So I like the album telling the story, but it was at the expense of lyrics that had any personal feelings.. it felt a bit gimmicky, a bit try hard.
Pinball wizard is a good song, but other than that this album doesn't really grab me. It feels like there might be a story going on that I'm missing. I should probably come back and actually pay full attention to the lyrics, but I doubt it will make my view of the album change much
lol
The first “successful” rock opera is a story of a boy who retreats within himself as the result of trauma. It’s a trope that we’ll see again and again, whether in “The Wall” – where our hero builds a literal wall around himself, substantially achieving the same thing as Tommy does here – or the later biographies of many youthful, rebellious rock and rollers (a genre that’s perhaps always thought of itself as safe harbour for misunderstood or under appreciated artistic genius). Anyway, Tommy. To put it gently, by the time “Fiddle About” had finished its first chorus of “fiddle, fiddle, fiddle, fiddle” you too may want to achieve a dissociative state of semi-torpor. The rock opera, it turns out, walks a fine line. Done well it’s expansive, a rousing appeal to what can be achieved with fairly limited means. Done poorly, as here, it’s almost an indictment on the whole genre – an incoherently rambling, serially uninteresting solipsism that dares to reveal the superficiality of all that pretends to rock. I feel sorry for Tommy, I really do.
This Rock Opera album is a classic. It is a heartbreaking story of Tommy growing up to be a community leader. The story telling, music, and overall package is genius and entertaining.
J'ai découvert cet album dans les années 80. Je l'ai écouté plusieurs fois à l'époque, il contient des morceaux vraiment excellents. Mais j'ai fini par le laisser de côté : je préfère les Who en live (bien plus d'energie et de folie). Dans le 'live at leeds' le groupe joue un medley des meilleures parties de l'album, c'est bien suffisant pour moi (évite les inévitables morceaux de remplissage pour les 74 mn) ! =>3/5
Favorite Track: Pinball Wizard
Some of this is really good but some of it just has me questioning who it was for. Tracks like The Acid Queen and Go To The Mirror! are great, but Fiddle About and is just odd, at least Cousin Kevin felt like it was thought out and added to the album. This could probably be half as long, but the highs are high enough to drag this up to a 4.
Legendary!
I had listened to this before and enjoyed it, I also got told to watch the movie and honestly....I dont remember a thing about it
Not really a fan of The Who. Especially Rock Opera Who.
Slightly better than expected for a double album rock opera. Riff-tastic in parts.
Firstly, really surprised this was a 60’s album. Thought it was early/mid 70’s. Started quite brightly and could see the idea behind it, but soon descended into self indulgent mediocrity. Didn’t make it past the end of disc2. It was that much of an uninspiring grind.
Crazy musical vibes. Mehr kann ich nicht sagen, über drei Stunden sind echt zu viel und hab schon mitbekommen, dass the who hier jetzt nicht so hoch angesehen ist...
Mir sind zrug mit The Who cares und The Who has time for a 2 hours deluxe album? (liebi Grüess an Basil) Ich ufjedefall ned. (und de Basil au ned) Sorry The Who aber nebed ganz vielne anderne "The ..."-Bands um die gliich ziit sinder mir eifach z wenig speziell und chli z langwiilig. vereinzelti biz spassigeri lieder hender gha, gibi zue. Aber bi 2 Stunde album wird da hald me uf quantität wie qualität gsetzt. Zwei ahkauti und zemekratzti Pünkt, defür super deluxe.
Whohoo, tommy, Who freut sich nöd über who? Hoffes de basil chan sis trauma überwinde oder isch zumindest nöd ernsthaft langfristig mitgnah. Also extended edition mit gfühlt 50 tracks hed mi biz abgschreckt, aber han driglosst. Und sisch nöd schlecht gsi. Eich fast chli unfair, mini vorherig ihstellig gege ihne über. Has gfühl das chan guet es 3 sternli album si. Es nervt eich null. Drüü senf tube für who
chalt de rugge abegloffe isch‘s mer woni d‘albumlängi gseh han... «Etwa 3 Std. 30 Min.» – wenn sogar spotify z‘fuul isch zum die gnaui duur ahgäh und sich defür entscheidet eifach mal en schätzig ab z‘gäh hört de spass wüki uf aber bold move, da chani nur min the whoet devor zieh dank es paar musikalische liechtblick ischs aber no the whoman gsi aber woni nach 30 minute uf mini the whor gluegt hani denn doch en the whoch langwiligkeit verspürt, mit de ziit hani denn au no es liechts the whongergfühl entwicklet, drum hani en the whommer gässe und dezue en the whompe bier vernichtet es drüüfachs the whorra für the whoeresöhn (han lang überleid öbi de letscht söll bringe aber the whomor-faktor isch isch mer denn doch zu wichtig gsi)
Yeah, I don't get it
i like the who but its a bit weird unless you've seen the musical i guess. still. pinball wizard
Brilliant. It has its lower points now and then but overall a fantastic rock opera
i love the concept of the album, the way it tells a story through the songs the music is fine, there were some standouts, but overall i just wanted to find out what's gonna happen to tommy 3,5
honestly goes hard considering it was released in 1969 (!!!) and I think they were attempting something quite empathetic and progressive for themes of abuse of power and disability rights, even though it probably isn't handled in as nuanced of a way as I hope it would now. Idk. Haven't honestly thought hard about it for a very long time. Keith moon truly was such a legend though, those fills are to die for and pinball wizard is even better than I remember. 3.5 but have to round up because you cannot deny how good some of those motifs are
I really appreciate the impact on music that this album had, but it's not something I necessarily need to listen to over and over. It was enjoyable, and I liked it. Four stars.
first listen historically significant but not very interesting
Epic!
..
Listen to this album with a candle burning and you’ll see your future
I'm sure this is supposed to be brilliant, but it's not my thing despite a couple of good songs.
Honestly, while I like a lot of songs by the Who, Tommy baffles me. It has its moments musically, obviously including Pinball Wizard, but thematically it falls flat and ends up just being a tediously overlong and anemic slog of an album to actually listen to due to boring masturbatory stretches like 'Underture'. Initially planned to give it a 2, but fuck grading on a curve and weighting historical significance. For being an unenjoyable plodding mess for most of its ridiculous 74 minute runtime, and for the plotline of Uncle Ernie raping poor Tommy, this gets the 1 it truly deserves.
Interesting to listen to this all the way through & to read about the film it inspired.
I thought this would be a good one since I’ve heard so much about it being a cult classic. Was totally disappointed. The music was terrible. I might have to watch the actual movie to understand. Listen again: no Purchase for my collection: no Favourite Song: none
I know the history and all that, but it’s…. a lot.
Not for me. 1/5
Tanti cori, tanto caos ma godibile 🧐
Lenge siden jeg har hørt denne! Det er noe så deilig magisk med disse gamle rocke-operaene med korte sanger og litt awkward overganger. Liker stemningen veldig godt, og det er litt å bli sugd inn i storyen. Og Underture er fortsatt like hypnotiserende som alltid. Beste sanger: Underture, Pinball Wizard (så klart) og Tommy Can You Hear Me?
I hundrevis av år har operaer hatt overturer, men det var først da rockeoperaen ble oppfunnet at vi fikk den første underturen. Dette er vel selve den originale rockeoperaen, og den første jeg har hørt der jeg klarer å skjønne historien uten å google. Likte det mye mer enn forventet. Historien har noen kule øyeblikk (og noen absurde svært lite PK øyeblikk). Musikken er veldig klassisk rock, men løftes av kul tromming og akustisk gitar. Favoritt: go to the mirror, pinball wizard
This is an ‘interesting’ album, mostly because of its ambition, but also a bit of a slog to get through to me, with the story being hammered in at expense of the overall experience. The story itself does nothing for me, especially the wholly unnecessary sexual assault songs and the drawn out awakening sequence. I think I’m fine with just listening to this just once tbh. 2/5
As a child, my boomer parents excitedly told me “Pinball Wizard” was from a rock opera one time when it came on the radio. I don’t recall them having much else to say, and having once again tried to glean what’s great about this album, I’d be at a loss to praise it further. The story is boring. The thematic refrains aren’t interesting enough to warrant sitting through. This is literally the soundtrack to a movie no one gives a fuck about.
Je trouve toujours ingrat d'écouter des opéras rock ou comédies musicales sans la mise en scène. J'ai quand même été happée par l'histoire de Tommy à un certain point. J'ai trouvé que la plupart des personnages étaient bien incarnés en quelques paroles.
It's called a classic for a reason. Not much else to say.
3.8
interesting to listen to with headphones all the songs sound really similar
Def want to go back to this one - it’s just so long. And most of the songs I wouldn’t listen to by themselves
This is that real rock opera music - the type I can't really stand. All my experiences with 'The Who' have been more or less pleasant as of yet, with each record providing a unique twist on their generally pop-rock-leaning sound. But this was too soft for me - and plagued with these long and largely uninteresting musical passages ('Underture' and 'Overture' for me). Where's the punch? In a time when sounds of rock were changing (including the sounds of The Who in the direction of something more interesting), this seems behind. There were some highlights, I WOULD HAVE liked 'Christmas' if it wasn't for those annoying backing "gasping" vocals - like whose idea was that? The closing was maybe the best song here musically, and it also serves as a nice thematic tie-up to the bizzaro story presented here. From what I gathered in this story, it seems to be about a physically impaired child and his struggles growing up. And I can't lie, I was pretty invested in this Tommy guy. I love the way his desire to keep some grand secret after '1921' gets translated to this non-medical deaf-dumb-and-blind condition. Also apparently this secret is him watching the murder of his mom's new lover at the hands of his WW1 veteran father? I didn't really catch this in the album...maybe it's a 'Tommy' move thing. Either way, a good chunk of this record seems to follow the people around Tommy begging him to snap out of his incommunicado status. And when the mirror he saw this murder through is smashed, he finally gets cured? And is then treated as a messiah? OK. I mean it is a pretty neat story all things considered - and apparently, it's been made into an actual musical. It's the only reason I bothered finishing this thing (that and it'd be bad taste otherwise) - it kept me engaged. If only the music here did the same - oh well.
Ok, so you have to understand that I think The Who are one of the most overrated bands of the 60's and a pretty lame band, and those horns on the Overture are not helping, but I guess here we go. I do appreciate that the songs flow together, but I guess it is easy when most of the songs kind of sound the same. A lot of these songs sound unfinished, they don't really have a hook or anything to really draw the listener in. I guess I spoke too soon because Eyesight To The Blind and Christmas sound different, but they also sound really bad. who thought the "AH AH AH AH AH AH" was a good idea. We also could have done without Fiddle About. PINBALL WIZARD COMES AFTER FIDDLE ABOUT!?!?! WHAT IS THE STORY AGAIN?!?!? HUUH??? This album has a very ambitious idea, but I think the music suffer for the sake of the story, which makes the actual album pretty flawed. In order to tell their story a lot of the songs just end up feeling really bland or unfinished. The Who weren't able to break their accusations of being lame. High 2.
Ok. Not their best
I thought this was boring when my parents used to play it but now I like it a lot. Much more artsy and nerdy than I’d given these guys credit for.
I like a good concept album even if it's not my favorite musically.
It was good. I like The Who a lot. I feel like this album is not the one I would pick that was one of their most influential since it doesn't include the intro to CSI on it, which probably introduced hundreds of thousands to The Who. Pinball Wizard still hits though.
Interesting but not mind blowing
great album but was probably more worth it to just watch the film
What was this?? First time listening all the way through. Poor Tommy. 2.4
I don't think this style of album is my thing but still has some great songs on it
I love some of these songs, but I don't need the whole meal.
I really liked this, only know a little about The Who which is mostly just their big hits including Pinball Wizard which is from this album. I'm a sucker for a good concept album and this album telling the life of Tommy was such a fun listen. Incredible album!
good! However Disc 2 isn't avaliable in my region :/ Disc 1 and 3 are though? (Denmark). It's either a high 4 or a low 5. I might be biased since I generally like music from the 60's and 70's.
Strange. Nice story but sometimes hard to follow. Sounds fine, nothing spectacular. Weird.
First rock opera, in a class all it’s own. I have never stopped spinning this record ❤️💪
Didn’t enjoy
Kein Zugang zur Stimme
I really liked pinball wizard but to be honest nothing else caught my ear much.
This album is just a slog.
The movie is so much more interesting than the album which is so disappointing.
interessant, teilweise nahe an den beatles, alles in allem aber kein bleibendes highlight für mich.
Bin etwas gespalten, ist schon ein wichtiges Werk aber am Schluss halt ein Kind seiner Zeit.
This is beyond disappointing. If anyone happens to read this before they have listened to Tommy, I would encourage them to check out the live performance of these songs from the Live 1970 album. The songs themselves are never great but at least on the live album there is a band chemistry that isn’t present on the studio version.
I have a confession… I don’t love The Who. I just don’t care about Tommy, I want songs. I’m sorry. I don’t get it. Great, they made art, sadly the story sucks 4.1/10
is ok
ok
The concept itself of the album was interesting but I'm not sure the music did it justice. The music was decent but nothing really hooked me in Pinball Wizard is a banger tho
I'm so torn between giving this a high 3 or a low 4. It has real moments of genius, the overtures and undertures as well as a leitmotif that shows up every now and again, are brilliant. On the other hand though, there is some inexcusable bloat that are only there to fill in story gaps Think I'll go high 3 on this one
long
This felt like watching a movie. It was quite long for an album, but I really appreciated the story telling as an operic album. Pinball Wizard is a great song and one I'm surprised wasn't more familiar to me despite it's age and reputation. My favorite outside of that is Probably Eyesight To The Blind, or maybe Sally Simpson. This was a fun listen and The Who feel ahead of the game with their rock.
It’s the one with pinball wizard on it
Ok
the only ones that were being deaf, dumb, and blind on this album were the who
It has been a very long time since I heard this. Still a pretty good album, not perfect but definitely good enough.
This rocks. I couldn’t fully follow the story the first listen through, but I will be returning to this one.
Day351 - unarguably genius but i’d argue annoying
5/5
Best: Pinball wizard or Overture Worst: Eyesight to the blind (the hawker) Liked songs: 84%, 16/19 (no songs under a minute) High 4, 90/100 I'm a known sucker for a good concept album/rock opera, and if there ever was one, Tommy is it. I don't always like criticizing concept albums for their length but Tommy does definitely drag at times, and I think a lot of it could've been cut to make it a single album without compromising the story too much. For example, really don't think you need cousin Kevin and uncle ernie in two separate songs; definitely could've combined them. Other than those ocassional drags, the music is really solid. Songs like we're not gonna take it, Pinball wizard, and Overture truly show the highlights of the music, and there aren't really too many lowlights. The story is also fantastic, and really is very detailed and very unique. The concept is also relatively tight, and no song is really wasted (unless you count the repition of some ideas). Overall, love the album, though it falls just below a 5/5 for me because of the length and the dragging of some songs.
fine
This was more interesting than expected, but... I probably won't listen to it again.
I like all of the well-known songs by The Who when heard individual, but for some reason was not expecting much from this. Turns out I loved it! I do have a soft spot for soundtracks and concept albums, especially those that follow a life, Pink Floyd's "The Wall", and W.A.S.P's "The Crimson Idol" being particular favourites. I really enjoyed this.
I've never listened to this full album before, but I of course knew a few of the songs ahead of time. I also knew the story/concept beats, although I was not expecting the lyrics to be as explicit as they were. I was excited going in, but this sort of let me down as an actual listening experience.
PINBALL WIZARD will always satiate the nostalgia urge. CHRISTMAS is such a perfectly weird song. Guitar paces this super cool strange hypnotic harmony. And then later with SALLY SIMPSON and I'M FREE. This album has style changes that don't stray from the story line, but rather direct the listener to ride along with Tommy's journey.
I liked this. Many of the songs had similar motifs which gave everything a sense of continuity and flow. I'd listen to this again. 4/5
Meni je ovaj album dosta kul, iako mi je malo predug bio za slušati u komadu. Generalno mi je druga polovica bolja, a bilo mi je i dosta zanimljivo prepoznati samplove drugih bendova koji su ih koristili. Baš mi je onako Beatles meets Deep Purple meets The Beach Boys 😁 Solidna četvrtka od mene 4/5, 8/10.
2/10 A jesu me udavili s ovim. Inace The Who mi ima super stvari, ali sjecam se da su mi uvijek bili hit or miss sto se tice albuma i/ili perioda. Ovaj mi je potpuni miss i zapravo zalim svake minute potrosene na njega jer mi je bilo gotovo neslusljivo. A i 75 minuta, calm your fuckin' tits sa svojom dosadnom rock operom.
I was told this was THE first major rock opera concept album. Honestly, I was very busy and did not get a change to listen carefully, but what I heard was great! I will definitely try to listen to this again when I have the time to fully appreciate it.
I feel like I should rate this higher than I want to, because of the tremendous influence this album has had. But honestly, with the notable exception of Pinball Wizard, I just don’t like it all that much. My husband loves Tommy, and will sing various snippets of it frequently, but this one isn’t for me.
Not a fan of songs that mention Christmas or has Christmas in the subject. Also songs with the g slur. Nice sounds, but it did feel too long of an album somewhere during the listen. Also, what is the line "gonna rape you" supposed to mean there in the last song,
very good, not my type but good
nothing more to say: masterpiece
instrumentals were cool, lyrics are whack
Pete Townsend is an absolute genius and his Rock-Opera Tommy is proof. A concept album is one thing, but concept album / Rock-Opera was unheard of in 1969. Look no further than this concept album / rock opera / film would wind up as a successful Broadway musical. 5/5
The WHO is a band I have a love hate relationship with. I think they are good but they also have that Rock sound of the 70s that can get on my nerves. However unlike someone like Led Zeppelin I think The Who have a great vocalist and better songwriter. The 60s Who will always be my favourite and Tommy is still a great album among their other albums. “a Quick One”’ and “The Who Sell Out” being favourites of mine Now for a double album this has to be one of the best and has one of the best over arching story. I will say the story may out weigh actual songs but the key moments are here This probably could use some more listens in the future but for what it is and what it accomplished I’ll have to give it a 4/5
Jesus that album is a wild ride! I haven't seen Tommy for 25 years, and kind of forgot you know? 4 stars before I put it away for another couple of years.
For good or ill, "Tommy" has served as the highest example of "Rock Opera." It's flawed, for sure, but will always be one of my favorites.
There's some corniness for sure, but I love The Who and I have a thing for rock operas. I'm not deducting my one point penalty for double albums because I make the rules. Not gonna do it for The Wall when that comes up either.
If you're into rock operas, Tommy should be near the top of the list as one of the best. When I first heard this in it's entirety, I was blown away. The creative genius of Pete Townsend is driven on this double album and musically it's one of my favourite Who records. Listening now, I'm not as keen on this album, it's still a classic, but not perfect. The whole story concept of Tommy, the deaf, dumb, blind boy is creepy and weird at best. I found the story so strange and it made it even worse (almost ruined for me) when I saw the film. I actually heard the soundtrack version, as a young teen, before hearing this album and besides Elton John's version of Pinball Wizard, I hated the songs and the performances. The original album is so much better and turned me around my opinion on Tommy, but I wish this wasn't a concept album. I prefer to listen to the songs as individual tracks and try to block out the story and it is what it is, a great memorable album from the Who.
Ihan ok. Aika pitkä mutta silti mitään ihmeellistä ei oikeen tapahtunut. Kaikki kappaleet olivat keskenään suhteellisen samanlaisia. Eli vaikka sinäänsä ei mitään erityisen huonoa ollut niin mitättömyys jää päälimmäisenä mieleen.
I listened to this on the plane and I forgot to write down what I thought. I think there were a few songs I didn’t like but also others I think I’ll listen to again.
7.5/10 - I thought were not gonna take it was the other song. I absolutely love Pinball Wizard it is just such a good song. The other songs were not as good but go to the mirror and we're not gonna take it were pretty good. I enjoyed the whole album and I enjoyed reading the story as it went on.
Jojah reacted on airbuds while I was listening to this, so if you're reading this Jojah, I'm sorry. I just don't get The Who. I was bored listening to this. It was boring.
This is the first time I ever listened to the whole album, and it's really good. I enjoyed the story arc.
#425. This is definitely the kind of thing where you could only like it if you already like it. I doubt anyone could be convinced into liking The Who or the concept of a rock opera by listening to this album, probably the opposite would occur. That being said, I already liked it, so I like it. 4/5: silly, but it somehow works. *this is the eleventh album from this list I already owned Song added to playlist: Pinball Wizard I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link
That was quite enjoyable.
What a trailblazer of an album. The first side starts of with some less memorable cuts but it does build up hype really well. Side 2 and 3 have some really memorable songs like the Acid Queen and Pinball Wizard. That is also when the amazing 'See me, feel me' chorus starts popping up. The story might be a bit wacky but the album is filled to the brim with amazing energised playing and tons of memorable riffs. 60s bloat and excess at its best, a sign of what was to come in the 70s.
This album is mind-bending, mostly in a good way. It's fun to follow the storyline along until you realise that it's a little devoid of substance, but even after that it's goofy enough that I could see myself being entertained upon repeat listens. Townshend must've had a right time of it explaining the album's meaning to the press. A boy becomes psychosomatically deaf, dumb, and blind after childhood trauma? Sure. He's prescribed psychedelics by an alt-doctor and picks up the pinball machine? Of course. He develops a cult following and dislikes it so much that his character development goes out the window? Superb. I'm not sure that it's particularly relatable, but it's certainly one of the plots of all time. (To give Tommy some credit: it's a ballsy idea for a 60s album, and it turned the world of music – particularly rock artistry – on its head.) A heavily acoustic and vocally-harmonised atmosphere is presented in the Overture, and this sound remains more or less consistent throughout the album. There isn't much electric guitar compared to some of the Who's earlier and later works. The drumming is perhaps a little tamer than fans might have expected, but I enjoy it. The melodies are a little difficult to follow, and they're by no means simple, but that does provide plenty of room for relistening and working out what the heck is going on melodically and harmonically. And the main single, Pinball Wizard, is excellent. 4/5 Key tracks: Pinball Wizard, Go To The Mirror!, I'm Free
Didn’t realise this was a rock opera until and asked who the f Tommy was and then googled it. Overall, it’s a nice concept with distinctive sound and understand why it’s in this list. Personally, couldn’t really follow along; feel like you need to know what this album is to really understand it.
Not terrifically grabby....
This is one of my favorite albums by The Who. It is a classic that holds up well and is always fun to listen to. Moony and The Ox are amazing here and on, "Live at Leeds" if you get the full concert version which features this album. They were an incredible rhythm section. and Townshend's writing is excellent.
Amazing
Long rock opera, like albums
Very long but good album
I kept waiting for the song where Tommy kills Uncle Ernie
This is probably quite good and I was happy to discover the "See me, feel me, touch me, heal me" bit first in Christmas, which is a lovely bit of music, that I know weirdly well, but my urge to type i ain't reading all that. im happy for you tho or sorry that happened was so great that I just did that.
I wrote a whole thing and it got deleted. Missing narration for this to make any sense. Long and meandering.
Fav: Pinball Wizard Least Fav: Overture Ngl I expected a lot more from this album, was hoping for more songs on the same level as Pinball Wizard. Interesting concept though
It’s a little long, it doesn’t always work, but I love it.
Like this if you gaf about Tommy
I know this is a big rock opera that some people love but it doesn’t do much for me. Kind of boring and long
Não fui capaz de entender a história da ópera. Só tem a obra-prima Pinball Wizard
Not bad, way too much filler though
Pretty fun. I remember watching the movie a few times when I was younger
Enjoyed that a lot, way more proggier than I tought they were. Ill try and find a copy one of these days.
That's a damn good theme album. I know it's rock opera, but it's very good. The guitar play is exceptional.
How do you think Pete Townshend does it? What makes him so good?
Listened to this so much in high school and college.
давно слушал, щас точно не скажу почему мне не оч зашел, простите
I've heard "Tommy" three times in its entirety and I'll state my case once again that it is a hot, steaming pile of crap. No matter how much Pete Townshend has denied (and denies) it, "Tommy" is a direct copy of "S.F. Sorrow" by The Pretty Things (non-believers, listen to the riff in "Old Man Going"), which is superior.
Nunca consigo terminar esse disco...
I love it! This is by far my most-played album of the past year, it’s a joy to hear it yet again. My wife adores this album to the point that it now holds great nostalgic value to me. A month or two ago I had lunch in a restaurant at Jay Peak, VT, and the song Tommy Can You Hear Me? played over the radio. I took a video of it to send to her, we joked that I’d been Tommied in the wild. It’s getting the coveted 5 stars, first & foremost for sentimental reasons, but as well as that, it’s such a great jam.
It’s a classic, it’s probably been decades since I listed to the whole thing. Excellent
What a terrible album. It goes nowhere and has one catchy tune. This is played on a loop in the dentist's office in Hell.
Quintessential rock opera; Quadrophenia is superior, in my opinion, but the band had more time to grow before that came out. I'm a big fan of the Who so this is an easy 5/5 for me.
Appreciate it? Yes. Like it? Meh
Lo disfruté mucho. Especialmente las canciones Amazing Journey y Sparks.
It may be the OG "The Wall" but one of the things I learned in this 1000+ list is that the OG aren't always the best, especially when it comes to music.
This was okay. Instrumentals were good, but vocal work was alright. Felt like it was a bit all over the place as an album. 'Pinball Wizard' hard carries here.
General impression: pretty awesome for being the “first rock opera”…but needs trimming Detailed review: I was pretty excited to listen to this, and was a little surprised upon research that this came out before Who’s Next. I thought it would’ve been later in their discography. But whatever. Anyway, I wanted to take it seriously so I read up on its general storyline and then read lyrics along with listening. I think it’s a pretty great and clever story, to be honest, and doesn’t rest on cliches like it could’ve as a “hero’s journey.” I definitely felt like there were a lot of unnecessary filler tracks to move the story along, and I would personally cut 8 of the 23 tracks. I’m going to do that in my music library and listen again, and I bet I’ll love it more as a 15-track album. That doesn’t count for rating it though, so I’ll just give it a 4. Side note: the casual fun of “Fiddle Around” and the “We forsake you / Gonna rape you” bit of the last song is truly horrifying. Maybe I’m a pearl clutcher but dayum! Deeper thoughts (context): Apparently there are 5 Who albums on this list, so I guess I’ll have a good sense of their discog by the end of this. Score: 4 Number of albums left to review: 953 Number of albums from the list I’d consider “must-listens”: 28 (including this one) Albums from the list I won't include in mine: 20
overture- 5 its a boy- 5 1921- 5 amazing journey- 5 sparks- 5 eyesight to the blind- 5 christmas- 6 because the lyrics are funny to me cousin kevin- 5 the acid queen- 5 underture- oh good lord. 4 no more it was fine but i just dgaf
Better than Goldfrapp