Reviews (page 7 of 14)
Pinball wizard and a bunch of b-sides
I hate it… The opening track Overture sets the scene on this overly bloated concept album. Described by the band as a spiritual opera, it feels more like a self indulgent drug fuelled wank fest. Underture stands at an outrageous 9 minutes and offers nothing, other than making me want this album to end. I appreciate the musicianship, however it offers little to no enjoyment to my ears. The song Fiddle About, is grim, I didn’t need a song about molesting a deaf, dumb and blind boy… The album has Pinball Wizard, which itself is a 5* tune, but can’t save the album.
I just can't with The Who- either it's some of the best music I have ever heard, or the worst dreck ever to befoul my ears.
Sorry folks, I don’t give a shit about some rock opera. This was absolute trash for me, and I couldn’t even get to song 4. I’m glad I bailed too, considering this slop is over an hour long. I really don’t get the love these classic rock groups get, especially when the singing is as bad as this.
A little long
There are a couple of good songs but not enough to keep my interest. Boy, does it drag. Favorite: Pinball Wizard Would I listen to it again: No
El concepto me ha parecido interesante. Por desgracia, no lo son la mayoría de las canciones.
I don't think it holds up as well as other who albums
Seen the film Heard the hits Not bought the t-shirt Now for the album... It would have made a great album if all the bits cut out
Classic. But I’ve heard it toooooo much in my life. I tire of it.
Too weird and demented for me…
Not a Who fan, and that goes double for this cheesy, boring rock opera. Way too long, dull songs, completely uninteresting story, strange mixing choices. Just not at all a fun listen.
This is such a drawn out album. Genuinely hope I never have to listen to it again.
The Who? When? Okay album, none of the big hits
Way better than I anticipated. Enjoyed this.
While feeling disjointed and meandering at times, the fact that Pete wrote this in his early 20s is pretty mindblowing, and overall the first 'real' rock opera comes off as a triumph (IMO). Not entirely my cup of tea, but maybe that's just because I listened while not on drugs. Adding an additional star solely for Keith Moon's drumming.. RIP you legend.
Oh super! 37.5 hours of The Who
Listened Jan 2021. Some undeniable classics and more fun than your usual rock opera. It's not one I would revisit it often but at its best, it's peak Who.
Overall I enjoyed it, kinda strange in parts.
An incredible journey
Un álbum conceptual de ópera rock pionero que narra la historia de un chaval que es maltratado y abusado por su familia y se acaba convirtiendo en figura mesiánica. Un proyecto ambicioso y muy bien ejecutado que, al menos según el libro, acabaría siendo de gran influencia en el prog rock que estaría por venir, incluyendo The Dark Side of the Moon. Como concepto, el álbum en sí es interesante, imaginativo y muy entretenido; escucharlo es casi como ver una película, y la historia no puede ser más sesentera. Pero ahí está precisamente el principal punto flaco del álbum: el estar demasiado enfocado en las letras, y poco en la música. Los temas son muy constantes, con una instrumentación bastante genérica que la mayor parte del tiempo solo acompaña a la voz, que a su vez tampoco es nada del otro mundo. Aunque a veces las armonías vocales molan. Por otro lado, los temas son de una gran calidad técnica (especialmente la percusión), y hay la suficiente variedad entre ellos como para que, sorprendentemente, el álbum no se haga pesado a pesar de durar más de una hora. La verdad es que lo he disfrutado bastante. El tema Underture, con sus pequeños toques prog/psicodélicos, me ha parecido especialmente interesante. Y el resto de temas, pues eso, se disfrutan como el que va a ver un musical más que como un LP al uso. Un álbum para escuchar en su totalidad y prestarle atención. Algo flojo a ratos y demasiado largo, pero me alegro mucho de haberlo descubierto.
I love the Who but have never loved Tommy. It’s similar to Pink Floyd’s The Wall in that it’s a rock opera that could benefit from dropping a few songs (both are too long) but it’s not as well though out as The Wall so it suffers from consistency issues as well.
The Who! Ja gewoon heerlijk ablum. Zal niet helemaal objectief zijn, maar ik luister hier erg graag naar. Om dan toch een kanttekening te plaatsen; het is weinig varierend. 4 reten. FAV: Pinball Wizard
I loved this album. Listened to it 3 times through one time being 2017 live version. I’ve always loved Pink Floyd and Rush both of whom frequently authored rock opera like albums with a story - I really slept on the Who, admittedly in part because of the east county San Diego dirtbag culture that surrounded KBG101 classic rock station growing up - the station constantly blasting “who are you” out of tailgating stereos before and after padres games. Anyway - this was great. 4/5
my goodwill for this reeeeally was stretched thin by the last track
6/10 You have to hand it to them, this was ambitious as hell and was entertaining in several places. 7-13-2025
only decent when accompanying the film
Loses its impact without watching the film at the same time
Classic album. I grew up listening to this. Great from beginning to end though I can see how a couple of tracks might not be loved by all due to their quirkiness given that it is basically a soundtrack.
Cet album s’écoute bien! J’ai du gros love pour Sally pauvre elle 😢
The Acid Queen, Pinball Wizard, I'm Free.
J'avais vu le film passer il y a quelques années à artv ou à télé Québecm la naissance de l'opéra rock qui culminera à mon avis 10 ans plus tard avec the wall.
Bon mais je ne sais pas ce que je pense des opera rock. Trop de symbolismes pour moi? Trop besoin d’écouter les paroles? Anyway en tout confidence, l’album dure 1h14 et je n’ai pas vu le finir hier.
This...simply was not for me.
I get how influential this album is. Prog rock is not my favourite genre...its theatrical with the drama. That said there are some good tracks. Its not an album i will look to listen regularly and not really background music either. There are better who songs and albums. Its not a 3, but its not quite a 4 either. 3.5 stars
Can't say enough about this album
kind of boring
thoughts: you could’ve played this without telling me the musical act and i would’ve known it was the who, easily. this is a fantastic storytelling concept album. also i’m just a fan of those sub-1-minute interludes they love to throw into their albums to bridge between songs. overall, this is an absolute production and it flows extremely well songs: “overture”, “christmas”, “go to the mirror!” rating: 9.0/10
The Who are a top tier band, so of course the standard of performance is going to be good. But seriously? What the fuck. This is the reference point for when people parody concept albums right? There's some good moments but a double album? It's incredibly indulgent, repetitive and just not as interesting or high art as Pete Townsend was aiming for. They could've just recorded the intro and Pinball Wizard and saved us the rest.
There are some good songs on here, I am just not much into the album.
Ehhh...rock operas are boring
Rock opera some good some bad played to death to be honest
на любителя. бенгеров не обнаружено.
Why are there so many songs? Not a big who fan
i unevitably compared it to Who's Next, and it kept me from really enjoying it as i think it's definetly worse, but it isn't a bad record by any means
Had never listened to the whole album before…. What a kickass story tied to these songs. Loved it.
it gets plus points for being one of the first, if not the first? well known rock operas. it's long, and i only really truly love one song, pinball wizard. but in general i like this, it's an easy listen in the background. gonna give it a 4 still.
It's okay
Tommy always felt like one of those albums that get passed around circles as one of the greatest ever made…in terms of rock operas. At least that’s what everyone tells me. That’s what Wikipedia told me. It also told me the plot synopsis, since I couldn’t understand it for my life. Yeah, that’s my problem with concept albums or rock operas. I try to get a grasp on the “plot”, like a movie, and end up sacrificing all my listening power trying to understand what the hell is going on. So what I think I’m trying to say is that I kind of think Tommy is a little overrated. Yeah, there are good songs here and there, but the whole thing feels over-indulgent and a little full of itself. I think it lost me somewhere in the 10-minute underture, which felt like padding in an already unnecessarily long album. The only things I grasped were that Tommy’s very good at pinball and the less I know about Uncle Ernie, the better. I hope I don’t feel the same when I eventually get The Wall by Pink Floyd. Favorite track: Pinball Wizard Other hits: Christmas, Fiddle About, Go To The Mirror!
Somehow made it to 30 without hearing most of this album. But I love The Who and I am an absolute sucker for goofy rock operas, so this should have been a home run. Alas, uncharacteristic of The Who and of goofy rock operas, I found this is be very boring musically. And far too many songs about rape. If only the makers of this list had the courage to replace this entry with a far superior rock opera of a similar era about a religious superstar figure and his followers.
I appreciate that the Who took this impressive of a swing even if it resulted in as violent a miss as peak Prince Fielder trying to plant the ball in the right field seats. If there's one redeeming factor to this album it's that Keith Moon's drumming is epic enough to almost carry the opera piece of this. Unfortunately, the lyrics and story are about as awful and terrible as you’ll hear on an album. As a serious album it’s self-parody, and if it’s deliberately a parody the Who do not possess the lyrical prowess of a Randy Newman to properly deal with their chosen subject matter. If you’re going to be offensive you better be funny. The Who made great songs and great albums, and I appreciate their ambition here, but this album is a fucking atrocity.
This was a staple of road trips with my family for some reason that I have no regrets about because the music is phenomenal (also all the fucked up stuff went over my head). And the story is incredible.
Keith Moon! Solid Who material but very long.
Sounds dated and a bit long winded.
Probably should have payed attention to the story, but I don't think its too easy to follow, or maybe its not too overarching, and just an extra thing to dive into if you want. Its ok but maybe a bit too long, I think this rock opera stuff hasn't aged well at all, but this isn't really as theatrical as the bad Queen stuff. I guess I can't really judge it properly, because I didn't really listen to the story, but musically and instrumentally its quite mediocre. Favourite songs: sparks, eyesight to the blind (the hawker), underture, pinball wizard, smash the mirror. Overall around 5/10
Classic
Not listened to this. I found it surprisingly good. Some tracks are obviously well known, and it was good to hear them in context.
Kad znam šta inače rade ovo je dosta razočaravajuće. Predugo, s bespotrebno brutalnim tekstovima, a bez nekih naročitih dobrih muzičkih odluka.
A true concept album and "story". Kudos for that. However I'm just not too fond of it. As a "rock" album, it all sounds a bit plain. Not bad, but just "meh".
3/5
-5 minute song with 2 sentences of lyrics at the last minute -"Songs" that are only seconds long, while others go up to 10 minutes overall it's has decent songs, but as an album it's a bit of a mess.
Хороший альбом, но прошлый понравился больше
perhaps the best thing i can say about tommy is that im genuinely curious about why exactly it was so meaningful to pete townshend. surely all of its famously completely demented narrative choices have intuitive emotional roots in something a very real and probably very weird human being cared deeply about, like this was pete's Baby. but i just cant comprehend it at all. at best i can see some anxieties about reality falling apart and the fruitless search for some kind of universally satisfying truth, certainly still applicable to the present but obviously pronounced in the 60s. at worst, it feels like a never-ending first draft that uses disability and child abuse as (sometimes kinda comedic??????) window dressing on the most sterile and stilted performances/production u will find on a who album. i rly feel like i cant ignore the whole narrative framework because its the only way this record functions at All...if taken just as a regular rock album with arty framing, as i kinda saw it as as a teenager, its just a complete disaster. pete writes a handful of solid (even great) themes, and almost no good Songs, theyre so jaggedy and graceless, as if random pieces have been glued together. the larger context and structure is completely load-bearing in a way i dont think is nearly as true of many other somewhat contentious rock operas...The Wall is sometimes in song mode and sometimes in fragment mode in a way that makes total sense to me, but tommy feels stuck halfway between the two at all times in a deeply unflattering way. and so the most positive way i can think of this record is as a fascinating but kind of bad rock opera, rather than an extremely bad regular rock album. in the interest of fairness, i should point out it improves a lot live, as it fixes the sterility of the studio presentation...hope leeds is on here at the very least!
Expected so much more. Pinball Wizard an island in this sea of mediocrity.
Seems pretty great, but couldn't get into it
Pick your cliché - a masterpiece, ahead of its time; say what you will about this as long as you say it’s fantastic and I’ll agree with you. That it exists as a musical creation, a cinematic creation (albeit, a bizarre one), and a theatrical creation makes me think Townsend accomplished exactly what he wanted with this story.
What a slog. Most of the double record is over before you get to the best songs. Pinball Wizard is a classic.
Recalling the music along with the film at a younger age I’d throw out a 4, but just listening through the album today there are plenty of songs I just found meh.
Even though The Who are pretty much my favorite classic rock band, I've always passed this record over. Not that I don't like it, and I've definitely listened to it before, just it never really grabbed me like their later records. Regardless, this is still a massive record from The Who, the one that I feel basically cemented the sound they'd be known for with Keith Moon absolutely destroying the drums and Townsend coming into his own as a writer. It's not quite them at their full power (Their next record, Who's Next, would be them achieving that, with Quadrophenia after being their magnum opus), but Tommy is them coming damn close. Definitely as a rock opera, I feel this album has some of the same issues that The Wall by Pink Floyd has, mainly that as a listening experience by itself it isn't 100% satisfying as some of the tracks do feel like they need a visual component (It's A Boy, There's A Doctor). I will say though, The Who being more straightforward rock helps to make a lot of these songs listenable on their own, whereas The Wall's prog rock sound kinda forced it into a stage play sound that requires a visual component. But this album has great tracks like Pinball Wizard, Go To The Mirror, I'm Free, etc. Overall, an extremely strong record that barely misses the 5 for me, but they'll get there with their next record (also, I'll mention this in every The Who review, but whoever decided Quadrophenia didn't belong on this list needs to be shot).
Super fedt koncept, men den bliver lidt for “konceptet” og ikke så meget ren rock og rul som jeg kender The Who for 6/10
listened to this album many times before although i dont really listen to the who its a masterpiece concept album that i go back to on special occasions
Gets good at cousin kevin.
This isn't just a rock opera, this is THE rock opera. A true classic with incredible storytelling, catchy melodies, great riffs and vocal performances (all other instruments are incredible too, it's The Who). It's mindblowing that a 20-something young man wrote all of this. It's a film in your mind, if you close your eyes. Just incredible! 5/5
What even is this? I thought this was going to rock, but it was so sing-songy. No offense to people who like it, but this was stupid. It wasn’t unlistenable, so no dreaded one star, but I didn’t enjoy my time here at all.
Good stuff.
Not the strongest concept album but sure does have a pretty dark and harrowing story of Tommy Walker. Poor dude watched his assumed dad get clapped, copes and develops psychosymatic symptoms. Then gets dosed early in life, then molested. Tries to heal a nation the best he can and is rejected, yet doesn't give up. Just sings his song. 4 star album on precedent. Great album and allowed the who to transcend mod pop songs and create a cohesive universe.
bit weird but the guitar music was good
See my Who Sell Out review! Go to the mirror boy, and see what an overrated piece of shit you are. Okay, Pinball Wizard isn’t bad. But then again…pinball? Was this something that people were super into in ‘69? Really? Blech.
Never studied this album in depth like I have the other rock operas, I dunno, something about The Who that just never fully clicked on for me.
What a load of rubbish. Soundtracks shouldn’t be allowed on this list.
there was some bits and pieces i liked about this album but the run time was just a bit too long for me (between 2.5 and 3)
Some good, some not so good.
I respect that this is the first if it’s kind so is pretty important, but it kinda sounds like they wrote the song pinball wizard (fucking brilliant song btw) and then for some reason decided to write an entire 75 minute rock opera around it
I dont get these prog rock albums, a dreary 70+ minutes sandwiching a solid single
Are rock operas overblown? Admittedly it's a small sample size, but they were all the rage in the late 60s, along with the concept album and the growth of prog rock. And the answer is yes; they're supposed to be overblown, pompous, and ridiculous. Why else would you even try to make one? This one is one of the better ones, you'll find much to like here.
The Who is just massively overrated. I know its very unpopular opinion. As a big fan of rock, metal and everything alternative that came after that I appreciate their place in history. I can hear that they are great musicians. If I was born in the 50-s I would love the shit out of them. But I am born in the 80-s, grew up with Tool, Radiohead, Mars Volta and all the other stuff so I just don't hear what is so special about The Who.
Like nothing I've listened to before, so unique and high energy
Awesome
Would say this is like 7.5 7.8 out of 10 some of the drum overtures are great.
I lied it
I do quite like Christmas and there were quite a few other enjoyable songs in this album. Good background music for sure, and nowhere near as dated as I thought it would be. 3/5 stars.
Tommy is a very ambitious rock opera. Quite unique for the time and still has some freshness to it. It’s really an album’s album rather than song focused - it has repeating lyrical and musical themes, short songs and long instrumentals that progress the story and set the stage…it really needs to be taken as a whole. The songs are better in context than standing alone. There are sections that are quite gripping, but other sections where I lose some focus. As an album it’s a bit softer than most of The Who’s other music, and showcases some of their range and writing ability. Overall, good music on an ambitious album - something I’ll think of here and there but not go back to all the time.
Epic. The first true peek into Pete's genius. Immortalized not by the movie or play, but by the spoof, 'Happy Jack' by Spinal Tap. Not my personal fave Who album, but so many bangers, so much influence on later bands, and such a precursor to what would become one of the greatest rock bands of all time. Worth a spin once a month or so, fer sher.
Meh… few good songs but can really tell it’s a double album, drags
Have only listened to popular singles by The Who before this. Like the concept of rock operas with a theme.. Favorite track: Pinball wizard other picks: amazing journey, go to the mirror, sally simpson
From my understanding, Pete Townshend believes he was a victim of childhood sexual abuse. That’s terrible, and I’m sorry he experienced that. I think that explains the why behind the upsetting themes on Tommy. But, the way it’s handled on this album… not good. Maybe it works in the context of the movie. I don’t need to find out.
I’m not exaggerating. This might be the worst album I’ve ever heard. I never want to experience it again. And I will never watch the movie. I actually think all copies of it should be burned. And the google data centre floating in the middle of the ocean that holds the digital version of this abomination should be allowed to sink to the bottom of the sea as a mercy killing. I can't fucking believe this album is on the list of 1001 albums you need to listen to before you die. The only possible reason I can think of is that it’s the last album in the book and it’s accompanied by the following disclaimer: Save this album for the day of your demise. Once you have finished listening, you will no longer fear death. In comparison to the 74 minutes of Tommy (AKA the 7 circles of hell), death will be a breeze. You will look forward to it, because it will mean no longer living on the same plain of existence as this abhorrent piece of “music.” You’re welcome. It goes without saying that this is a strong 0 out 5 for me. I don’t think this system allows you to give a 0. I believe a 1 is the lowest you can give, which is total bullshit. Before this album, if someone asked me if I was a fan of The Who, I’d have said “sure, I like the big songs.” And now my answer is hell fucking no. I can’t support any artist willing to put their fanbase through an atrocity like this (and make a movie of it). It’s boring, self indulgent, offensive, never-ending, gaudy, unmemorable, pathetic, pretentious and more. I’m torn between continuing to rant about what I hate about this thing or just ending the review now because it doesn’t deserve another millisecond of my time. I think I could write a thesis on how awful this thing is. This album deserves to be the star on the Christmas tree of reasons why we shouldn’t worship 20 year old boys like they’re gods just for making a few catchy songs. 20 year old boys who are treated like gods may start to believe they are in fact gods. And when people believe they are gods, they start to think that every stupid little idea that pops into their under-developed brains is brilliant and worth being invested in financially and shared with the world. Or in the case of Tommy unleashed on this world like a plague that has humanity questioning whether or not we should allow humans to make art at all if there’s a chance of something like this being created. Things I hate about it: I was driving while listening to it. It made the idea of sitting in silence for 2 hours in stand still traffic on the 401 seem alluring, heavenly even. “Tommy can you hear me” in Christmas made me laugh out loud in a bad way. So fucking stupid. Underture being 10 minutes long??? At first I was like, “o, without the lyrics, maybe this album is tolerable.” And then it went on and on and on and on. Holy shit. I thought it would never end. I felt physical relief when it was over. Cheesy/shit songs: It’s a boy, 1921, Cousin Kevin, The Acid Queen, Sally Simpson, Tommy’s Holiday Camp. The rest are either disturbing or dull or some combination of the two. The theatrical delivery of some of the lyrics on this album was goofy and awful. I want to un-hear it. So many short, unsatisfying songs that probably make more sense when accompanied by the film but also… fuck that. The sequence of Do you think it’s alright?, Fiddle about and Pinball Wizard might be the worst 3 song run in the history of music. The first 2 are about Tommy being molested by his Uncle Ernie and then it’s a hard cut to a song about how great Tommy is at Pinball. I guess they cut the song where Tommy deals with the trauma of this very upsetting experience. Probably for the best. I don’t think I could have endured a 25th track. I used to think Pinball Wizard was “fine.” Of the big Who songs, it was not my favourite, but it was inoffensive to me. Now hearing it in the context of the album, it’s horrific. I think that radio stations should have to play the other two songs first before playing Pinball Wizard to give the audience the true Tommy experience. I don’t think it’d be the classic rock radio staple it is today and that would be a gift to society. I can’t unhear this now. I will dodge Pinball Wizard like the plague from now on. Using the phrase “deaf, dumb and blind kid” as a refrain throughout the album just feels offensive the more I hear it. Just because Tommy is the first rock opera, doesn’t automatically make it good. Lots of things that were “first” were bad. Would you want to use the first cell phone or computer? Watch the first movie? I doubt it. I’d even argue rock operas in general aren’t great. There are definitely more bad ones than good ones. 74 minutes is long for any album. For Tommy, it felt more like 5 hours. Musical purgatory if you will. The final song on this album brings back lyrics and musical elements from several songs in the tracklist as if this is a stage musical. But on Tommy it feels a bit like someone vomited, ate the vomit and then threw it up again. What specifically bothered me was a refrain that references the molestation sequence on the record. The refrain was: We foresake you, gonna rape you. I will not explain why I was bothered by this. I think the quote speaks for itself. I don’t think they wrote lyrics for this album. Instead they just wrote a long rambling story and put it to music. They didn’t tweak that story so it fit that music or feel like song lyrics, they just left it as is, first draft. I kept waiting for a song on this album to be good. It has 24 tracks. They can’t all be bad right? It’s statistically unlikely. And yet… they did it. It’s an accomplishment really. The closest thing to a “good” track was probably Pinball Wizard but again due to sequencing it is now unforgivable. There is not a single track on this album that stuck with me in a good way. Normally when I encounter a double album, I come up with a single album track list that cuts the filler, but that’s not really possible here. I guess my cutdown would just be Overture. It’s an instrumental, so none of the nonsense bullshit, cheesy lyrics. And since it’s the first song on the album, you aren’t yet bored or disturbed by the musical motifs being introduced. Things I like about it: It’s over and I never have to experience it again I guess John Entwistle’s bass playing was solid. That’s all I got.
Not their top album
𝘛𝘰𝘮𝘮𝘺 is ambitious, theatrical, and undeniably groundbreaking — but also, let’s be honest, a bit too long. Still, when it hits (like 𝘗𝘪𝘯𝘣𝘢𝘭𝘭 𝘞𝘪𝘻𝘢𝘳𝘥 or 𝘐’𝘮 𝘍𝘳𝘦𝘦), it delivers pure rock opera magic. A flawed epic, but an epic nonetheless.
This isn't an album; it's a story. One I thoroughly enjoyed, and one I recommend listening to if you're wondering how Tommy turned out. Favorite Track: "Pinball Wizard".
Klassisk rockopera/musikal. Men är det så jävla bra egentligen?
As some have said, the concept is interesting, but I just can't get behind it. It's a rock west end musical that I don't want to go and see. Pinball Wizard is a colossal track, the rest is just uneventful. It's very 60s/70s and as such isn't for me, it just doesn't stand the test of time. Couldn't listen to it all, I'm not a fan of The Who anyway.
It’s really good and really bad at the same time in the same songs
Pinball Wizard Go to the mirror
Ah, a beautiful album by The Who. Not only that but one of the first rock opera albums. Fittingly, Tommy is a truly beautiful journey, a delight on every musical front from start to end. It's an album you can get emotionally invested in.
Very diverse and long album.
A classic I've heard many times over the years, happy to return to now and then
some good songs, not my favorite The Who Songs though. For me the Album would be better without these short "songs" in between
Wasn't sure how I was going to feel, but I enjoyed it overall. Also, didn't realize Pinball Wizard came from this.
it’s good, but i don’t really have an opinion of it. felt very long and pretty repetitive
As a musical, it's not good. As an album, it's really bad.
I remember the first time I heard Tommy I was expecting Baba O’Riley or My Generation. I was confused because I got neither. Though there is some debate about who wrote the first Rock Opera. Tommy was in the Top Five originates, and the first successful one. Period. It is a concept album like no other, which makes to hard to find singles when taken out of context. It really was the Who proving their musical chops (hear the break about 3 min I to Amazing Journey, which it was). Knowing the size of those four personalities I am surprised this album exists at all. Once you get to Pinball Wizard there is a powerful climax to the album. But some other songs I appreciated more were Go to The Mirror! and Tommy, Can You Hear Me! Overall, this was a masterpiece! However, it does run into the problem of accessibility.
Random thoughts: * I own this on CD and have watched the movie at least once. * I vaguely remember this being a slog to get through but on this listening I realized it is way more catchy than I realized. The instrumental tracks are super solid. * Pinball Wizard might be one of my top 10 all-time tracks! I absolutely love this song. I can't get enough. * I'm Free and Overture are great tracks and really caught my ear. * I'm not sure I really understand what Pete Townsend is trying to say through this art. But it is a fun time capsule. * This inspired one of my all-time favorite pinball machines. Seriously, drop some quarters in if you ever encounter it. Such a cool machine.
Few good songs but bloody weird.
Pinball Wizard and I’m Free
Rigtig fin rock opera omkring en dreng som ser sin mor blive dræbt og så bliver han blind. Der er en masse metafor og symbolik som jeg ikke helt fanger, men lyder er rigtig godt og minder mig om tenacious D nogle gange.
A lame attempt at a grandiose, inventive record.
This album doesn't really have any musical issues but it's so long and frankly overwrought and boring. I tried but I knew in my heart- The Who stinks
Considering when it was released, it was somewhat groundbreaking as a rock opera. While there are some good songs, the storyline is a little weak and some of the songs to support the storyline feel campy and silly…particularly considering later albums like The Wall.
ive listened to this album while i was studying and, overall, it was a good album. the funny thing is that while there were some ABSOLUTE bangers (The Acid Queen, Go To The Mirror!, We're Not Gonna Take It...), there were others that i had to force myself to listen to the whole thing because either they were super annoying or super boring. also, at some points i felt like they were trying to "copy" Queen??? i dont know, man, but i was like, "damn, this is a rhythm Queen would use". to summarize, i liked it and could see myself listening to it again. ps: thank god this website heard me and didnt give me YET ANOTHER country-ass album :D !!
fine I DONT KNOW
Not really a fan of the story on this one, especially repeatedly using the word "rape" at the end of the album.
I didn’t really dig this one.
I enjoyed Keith Moon's drumming throughout, and quite enjoyed Pete Townshend's acoustic guitar. Overall though a little long and self-indulgent for me, but I feel that way about musicals in general. Pinball Wizard is still one of the all-time great rock songs.
The idea of a rock opera is interesting, but it just resulted in a lot of random songs on the album, like some that were less than a minute long just to describe something like a plot point. I love The Who as a band and Pinball Wizard is a classic, but this album just lacks good songs to jam out to.
Great album
I never cared for The Who.
Ok
pretty weird, not gonna lie
Not my favorite "the Who" album.
To be honest, I have always found The Who to be quite average. This didn’t exactly change my mind on that front, but I do appreciate them a bit more. Pinball Wizard was no doubt the best song on the album. I appreciated the theming of the album, all centered around the character of Tommy. Rock opera just really isn’t my thing.
A little rough around the edges sometimes. Otherwise pretty neat, I guess...
Very long like my penits
i found this hugely disappointing. oh well!
Very unique and interesting concept album
3.5* 85%
Crisp and clean. I loved the movie and I love this album. I could listen to Keith Moon for hours.
was ok, then it started to annoy me, and it just kept going. 2.5
Influential concept album.
I expected to like this more, as I liked the film when I saw it years ago and am generally a fan of concept albums and rock operas. It is just so notable that Pinball Wizard is the standout track here, with most of the rest being quite musically forgettable. Maybe not a popular opinion, but for my money the original Jesus Christ Superstar album with Ian Gillan and Murray Head, which came out around the same time as Tommy, is so much more interesting and sophisticated as far as rock operas go.
I have never taken drugs but were I to take drugs I would want to take the drugs that Pete Townsend was on when he came up with this one.
not for me
"Tommy" by The Who... i was a very young boy, when i heard the strains of "Pinball Wizard" on WLCY here in Tampa... it was a few years later, when a friend who was older than me, had a brother who was even older... and we were Beatles fanatics, but the guy's brother told us... The Beatles were good, but they could never touch The Who... and he loaned me his copy of this Album... in another lifetime, i was a tennis coach... and on a few different occasions... my students, in a rain delay or something, would listen, mouths agape, at thier coach singing every word of every song, in order to this album... at first they would laugh... then they would listen... then they would ask me, Derek what is that you are singing? and i would say... "Tommy' by The Who... something you need to hear in your lifetime... They made a movie out of it... and the Soundtrack, while pretty decent, is nothing like the original record... Pete Townshend... card carrying GENIUS songwriter, performer.... The Ox, John Entwistle playing like the virtuoso he is... Roger Daltrey... in peak mode... and Keith Moon... the driving force... listen to it beginning to end... straight through... and the scale only goes up to five stars.... but if any record deserves six... this is the one... listening to YOU, i get the music... gazing at YOU, i get the heat... Following YOU, i climb the mountain... i get excitement at YOUR feet... Amen brother, Pete
First off, I am not a big fan of the Who. I find a lot of their work pretty boring as Pete Townsend was not much for guitar solos or really anything other than chords. This album does not sway my opinion. I'm sure it was grand for it's time. Now it's just a lot of jangly, directionless guitars with an occasional hook from Roger Daltry. I could not make it through "Underture", so boring. I don't think this rock "opera" would even be much more interesting if it was actually performed on broadway. The premise of the tale of a dumb, deaf, and blind boy's life is just not interesting, at least to me.
An album with an interesting concept, but not that musically engaging of a listen for me. I appreciate the unique idea, though
Holds up after all these years. Epic end to the album as well
Pinball
I remember going to see a very community theater rendition of Tommy the musical with the whole family in maybe Merriam or Roeland Park. I think it was for your birthday, Dad? I didn’t really know what to expect but enjoyed it! This isn’t my favorite Who album, but definitely a solid 4.
Only my 4th favorite Who album after Who’s Next, Quadrophenia, and The Who Sell Out, but still a great album. Probably didn’t get into it when it first came out, but certainly a couple of years later. A true rock opera, and even if the whole concept and story is arguably a bit hokey, the songs are bangers from start to finish. Amazing what the band can do with just 3 musicians and a singer. Fave track is Underture, an instrumental showcase that’s 10 minutes long, but wish it had been 20 or 30. A masterpiece.
For the entire first half, I was debating how long I’d have to listen to give this a fair shake. I decided I’d go through “pinball wizard,” the one song I knew I knew. I did that. Then, I had to run a quick errand and while doing that, I got through “go to the mirror,” which I actually liked. That was one of those “I’ve heard this song before but didn’t know it” songs. From there, it felt like I was pretty close to the end, so I decided to finish it. Oof. What a mistake. Each of the final three songs had me itching for the stop button. But I did it. Bravery. A 1.5 rounded up.
Second time listening to this and can’t believe how many decent tracks I missed the first time I listened. Don’t have anything new to add, fantastic concept. Christmas is probably my favorite. Rating: 4.5
J’ai quasiment donné un 5 étoile sans l’avoir réécouter depuis 2 ans, démontrant mon indéniable passion concernant cet album phare du band… qui déjà? Pour être fair avec les autres albums, je lui ai redonné une go, pis ça ne fait que confirmer le statut de Banger éternel de Tommy. J’ai même head bang sur Pinball Wizard, c’est peu dire
I am not a fan of prog rock. I can hear why it's good, sonically, but it does nothing for me. There are some good tracks, definitely.
This is genre defining Rock Opera. And it is more or less probably in the top group of all time at that. The Who is amaze. This album... Amaze. The Who, whom I often simply "forget to mention" are literally right up there with the best of the best and I am not sure why I often forget to bring them into those conversations, I remember the music well enough! maybe because I kind of put them in the "classic rock" genre and honestly, I more often than not do overlook that style. But I am glad I was reminded of this!
Never seen the movie. This is definitely a soundtrack, the moods and stories are there. You can see the picture unfolding. Need to watch that movie.
A perfect Concept album..
Rock opera! Nobody does rock operas anymore. Cowards! Umber never seen it performed; it would hold up today as a tale of abuse, cults, pseudoscience and so on. It’s a comprehensive tale told through great music and probably could only have been made in the 60s. Listen for more than “Pinball Wizard”. It’s a masterpiece.
Good Album. 3.8/5
This album (and the Who in general) are a major blind spot for me. They've sort of gotten grouped (maybe incorrectly) with the Rolling Stones in my mind and I just don't care for the Stones. So I was happy to get this album to be "forced" to listen to it. And it was more enjoyable than I would have expected. Don't see myself listening to it again any time soon, but it was a pleasant experience.
Dull
Ég elska mörg lögin í þessari rokkóperu en ég hef aldrei gert heiðarlega tilraun til þess að hlusta og pæla í henni og söguþræðinum. Ég verð að segja að það eiginlega stútaði plötunni. Mér fannst ekki það spunnið í söguna sem er sorglegt en samt sem tónlistarafrek toga ég hana úr 3.5 upp í 4
Concept album about a severely abused child shutting down his senses to cope, regaining his composure by becoming a pinball god, gets a cult following, and then has his cult kill him. Sort of art pop sort of rock (vaguely alt-rockish). It lacks much relistenability (albeit a few songs like 1921, Pinball Wizard, and Sally Simpson are great tracks on their own). Honestly, I very much suggest giving this one a listen if you enjoy concept albums as it is a fun listen in the musical sort of sense.
Interesting concept album with some solid tracks. I liked this one.
Not for me.
This album certainly has some creative stuff, but for some reason, not enough punch. A lot of the songs feel like they're constantly building up towards something, and then just nothing happens. The hard rock tracks here have significantly more energy, but most of this album is not hard rock. These some very fun songs here (Overture, Christmas, The Acid Queen, Underture, Pinball Wizard, Go to the Mirror!), but others are just fine. Still enjoyed this album, but it definitely could've been better. 7/10
Solid concept album. Tina Turner's version of The Acid Queen from the movie is so much better than Roger Daltry's. Also, who can't love Elton John in massive Doc Martin's as the Pinball Wizard who Tommy beats! Favorite songs: Pinball Wizard, Overture, Christmas, Go to the Mirror! Least favorite songs: Underture 4/5
The sheer magnitude of what Townshend is trying for here is quite amazing. This could be one of the greatest achievements of all time--without this album, do we have JCS? The Wall? The album is a surprisingly good listen and I remember Pinball Wizard as a kid who loved arcades being my Who introduction. The movie and musical are not bad either.
Brilliant.
Genial!
No interest whatsoever.
Inessential
Tommy walked so that The Wall could soar, an experience, 4.5 stars
okay cool vibes - nothing more
I saw Roger Daltrey perform the whole of Tommy live when I was 16. Pinball Wizard is still very much the highlight.
Rock opera
Tommy can you hear me?!👂🏻🪞🇬🇧
Outstanding. Loved it.
An interesting story with cool instrumentals
This album flows from song to song very well. A strong album. This album is worth a listen, even if you aren't a big Who fan.
Most concept albums share the traits of dragging in moments and playing too long, and this one does check those boxes to some degree. I did enjoy it playing in the background working around the house. There are a few tracks that have stood the test of time and stand on their own. Couple that with Pete’s age at the time of writing and this is a unique and impactful work. While I think arguably their strongest album shows up “Next” in their timeline, I give this one the round up. 3.5/5
350 albums in and we finally get our first Who record. And on the same day they announce their farewell tour. Hmmm. I’ve always dug the Who. And what I do like about Tommy was it was written and recorded to be played live. Other mammoth amazing records around that time like Sgt Pepper’s or Pet Sounds stand out for other obvious reasons. But Tommy stands out for its live performance factor. And while forming a storyline centered around a deaf mute and blind man playing championship pinball seems thinly plausible and pretty silly, the quality of many of the songs survives due to the unique ability to stand out on their own while always serving as a connecting thread into the main storyline.
I love the Who, but not Tommy. I think this is a good example of a band getting over their skis with an idea and not pulling it off at all. Pinball Wizard is maybe the only song reminiscent of the band, the rest does very little to take advantage of the bands vast skill set. Like most concept albums, this one is forced and too long.
I like the ambition of this. And I like the concept. But not sure I loved this. Pinball Wizard is great…such a weird idea…but it works. The rest is very meh. 2.75 Now I’m gonna go smoke some Mother Nature.
Seen the musical once or twice...not sure if it has impacted my thoughts on the album in a positive or negative way. Either way, this is a decent album, not great. Tough for me to get over the silliness factor TBH. 3.25/5
Rock operas have never been a good idea. Never will.
Even at a distance of over 50 years Tommy is such a progression from The Who’s great but largely singles-centric output thus far, it must have blown minds in 1969. It’s an incredible achievement - a concept album but more, a ‘rock opera’ which really works, in which the songs really do carry the storyline. Yet so many of the songs stand alone, many of them comfortably sitting with the band’s greatest singles. “Pinball Wizard”, “Acid Queen”, “I’m Free”, “Amazing Journey”. I have always told myself I preferred Quadrophenia, and I consider Who’s Next one of the best albums of all time but listening to Tommy again with fresh ears, and good earphones, is incredible. I’m astonished not only by the genius of Pete Townsend’s composition and arrangements, by the production and clarity of the mix, but by the amount of acoustic guitar throughout. In the era of Hendrix, Clapton and Beck Townsend may have been forgotten to some extent. He was a different sort of player but astounding in his own right, an incredible rhythm guitarist. The other thing I realised on this listening is what a complete piece of music “Overture” is. It really does serve the same purpose as the great introductions to operas by Verdi or Puccini or Wagner, and deserves to stand alongside them. I have owned this for years but in truth have listened to live performances or the orchestral version more often, so this is the first time in a long time that I have actively listened to the original version. It really is an “Amazing Journey” and one I won’t leave leave so long again.
Yeah i mean its a rock opera by the who
It's alright, I can see why it's a classic. Its definitely something where you have to listen to all tracks in one sitting to get the most out of it. There are moments where it's brilliant but then everything else in between is a bit boring to me. That being said, there's some great musicianship here. You can tell they've put a lot of effort into it. Keith Moon especially does a great job on this. I wish I could rate albums from a scale of 1 to 10 instead 1 to 5 on this site, because then I'd give it a ~7.5 out of 10. I'll have to round it up to a 4/5. I'll be sure to check out Tommy, the movie when I come across it. Fav tracks: Pinball Wizard, Christmas Least fav tracks: Welcome, Fiddle About, most of the short tracks.
Few bands can make a rock opera actually sound cool and organic. The Who can, because they fucking rule. 5/5
Ok. Probably need to listen to the whole album in one sitting to understand properly
Strange….
Among the many pleasures of listening to this album, possibly the greatest is hearing The Who’s legendary drummer Keith Moon giving it absolutely full beans on pretty much every track. Then there’s the fact that the track listing includes an ‘Underture’ as well as an ‘Overture’. And the opening to Pinball Wizard? One of the greatest rock intros of all time…. Ok – all the trigger warnings: Contains murder, physical and sexual abuse of a child, strong drug references, religious extremism and PTSD. But what’s a rock opera without tragedy? This original album lacks the guest performance highlights of the later soundtrack (Elton John, Tina Turner, Eric Clapton, Oliver Reed and Ann Margaret all brought something extra) but for inventiveness, innovation and some banging tunes the ’69 version still bags three stars on its own merits – with a bonus star for ‘Moon the Loon.’ RIP Keith
Boring but fine.
An epic but a great one, with a story weaving through the tracks and a timeless style that keeps you hooked
FFS! Another load of white blokes. Is this a 'history of white male privilege as told through music' list or what? Oh and look whose up next, another old white dude. Jeez. Anyway, I let out a sneer when this Who opus came up and expected to instantly write it off as overblown rock opera shite. Then I got to properly listen to Overture, It's a Boy and 1921 and was mildly interested. Thankfully this blemish on my coolness (you knows it) was soon dispelled - I had no idea that Tommy of pinball wizard fame had endured bullying growing up at the hands of Cousin Kevin and then sex abuse at the hands of some weird uncle. Fiddle About has to be the most ridiculous and excruciating song about a horrific experience I think I've ever heard. Tommy's 'miraculous' rediscovery of his sight left me perplexed - was he kidding all along, or was it PTSD, or was it a miracle? Actually, I don't care. Thanks be to god that we only had to listen to the 1969 version and not the deluxe.
Epic
Excellent!
One of those albums that I've heard the hit songs way too much on the radio, but have rarely listened to the rock opera as intended. Turns out there's a reason for that. Many of the tunes don't amount to much and the story falls flat. I saw the film at the drive-in in the seventies and that version gave the project a little more interest and color.
So cool - I don't think I've ever heard a rock opera before - and it still has killer songs like pinball wizard
Fiddlin Around is hilarious. Fine album. Follows a theme front to back. Usually not a fan of themed albums, but this isn't over the top.
Album No. 5 Never heard a song by The Who but have heard of the artist. This was a long album in terms of number of tracks (though to be fair most of the tracks are rather short) and so I didn't really focus much on any of the songs I wasn't engaged in but I like the energy and sound of the tracks overall. I think if the album was a bit less long and I guess dramatic I would rate it higher. The tracks definitely have an older feel to them but not in a necessarily outdated way. I like the whole concept of the storyline, and I enjoy albums that are very cohesive but I'm not sure if I'm a fan of the whole very like almost musical-theatre style storytelling. Would rate it a 2.5 but I may put it down to a 2. Who knows if my opinion will change in the future. Favourites: - Pinball Wizard - Go To The Mirror! - Smash The Mirror
Som en överklassunges studentspex
A lot of firsts on this listening journey, and this was my first listen to an album by The Who. "Tommy" is an album that tells the story of the remarkable life of Tommy. A fun idea and a story open for interpretation. The album is a good listen and I could see myself listening to it again, but it didn't blow me away on my first listen.
Iconic album, and group. Great music. Sound of the 60’s, 70’s.
Second Who album this week, this one just has to be better. This is also the 2nd or 3rd "opera" I've gotten this week? For an opera, this has way more instrumental tracks than expected. Pinball wizard comes out of nowhere and is a total banger compared to the rest. 3* Highlights: pinball wizard, i'm free
Agree with some of these posts about this hot garbage.
Disjointed with a lot of filler. Just like a real opera! There are moments here and there that are fun or interesting, but it mostly feels like children's music (about child sexual assault). Underture is the highlight, with themes and passages building and twisting on each other. Most of the rest is forgettable.
i like it because the who rock but the concept falls flat for me
no one is writing full length rock operas anymore. this album is insane and has its problems, but what a time for bizarre creativity. and roger daltrey was smokin in the movie so that has to count for something
Twas fine I guess.
Boring review alert! Ok so it's a little theatrical for me, but I feel like thats something I usually like. The music alone I would give a 2.5 rounded to a three. However, with having a story I give it a 3.5 rounded to a 4. I need to explain this for my future self because I think I'll come back and disagree.
No. 313/1001 Overture 4/5 It's A Boy 3/5 1921 3/5 Amazing Journey 4/5 Sparks 3/5 Eyesight to the Blind 4/5 Christmas 3/5 Cousin Kevin 3/5 The Acid Queen 4/5 Underture 3/5 Do You Think It‘s Alright? NR Fiddle About 3/5 Pinball Wizard 4/5 There‘s A Doctor NR Go To The Mirror! 4/5 Tommy Can You Hear Me? 3/5 Smash The Mirror 3/5 Sensation 3/5 Miracle Cure NR Sally Simpson 3/5 I‘m Free 3/5 Welcome 3/5 Tommy‘s Holiday Camp 2/5 We‘re Not Gonna Take It 3/5 Average: 3,24 Really long album. I feel this could have been better, if the made it a bit shorter.
I’ve never understood the fame of The Who. There’s nearly no registration of excitement for me when I listen to Tommy or almost any other who album. I love a few of their individual songs, but after three of them, I’m done. I figured there must be something wrong with me.
Good but difficult to follow.
Not really a fan of concept albums, but there is some great work on this one. The Who is an all-time great band.
Includes some great the Who tracks like Pinball wizard, I'm free etc, but the musical bits are bit heavy. Ambitious project which does deserve some credit and listening to this made me want to see the Tommy movie again, last time seeing it as a teenager.
As a soundtrack / concept album this is really heavy to listen to. Most likely I just don't understand this album without seeing the movie. If I think this just as album, I didn't fancy this at all throughout few really cool tracks.
Too long album to my taste. Few good songs, but that's it.
The musical part of this album is not to my liking, while The Who's music in general is, for the most part. Their Live at Leeds is one of the best live recordings I've ever listened to. While I know this is accompanying a full movie, I can't shake the feeling this has a lot of filler and mood music, which ruins the vibe for me.
3.5. a classic, I listened in my 20s, but I realize I rarely listened to the whole album. It i s a bit long.. some songs are just repetitive (just to move forward the story I guess). As of today, and to respect many 4/5 albums that are more consistent I gave Tommy a 3 (3.49 if you wish). Some very good songs, chords, and emotions, inspirational I guess for many groups to come too.
Simple Jack: The Album. But seriously I didn't enjoy this at all, I get that it's very influential to a certain type of British guy with high-minded ideas about "what rock music can be" or whatever but I just was not impressed. I thought the concept was both pretentious and kind of stupid, and the songs mostly aren't good enough to make up for it
Crap. One good song in a 1 hour and 14 minute long album is a joke.
Still an incredibly strange album, even after hearing it for years…. Enjoy the majority of it though…
Very good album
Oh, this one is boring. What a great start to the year. To me, this has nothing amazing, and only a few real standouts. Tommy is a double LP rock opera with a story about a kid gone blind and his life and challenges he faces. The story is a weird way of getting Pete's thoughts on enlightenment and youthful alienation, and ultimately, like a bad movie, it's full of something that's mostly nothing. The songs are also really inoffensive, which is the Who's studio motto. They're cut from a different cloth than their hard rock colleagues, obviously, but everything here is far from good, other than maybe Pinball Wizard. No song has that oomph or fire that makes me want to return to the album. It also doesn't help that, being a rock opera, having good standalone tracks is a hard task in itself. The instrumental -tures are a showcase of their ability to play, which are good, but what is their ultimate purpose? Overall, anemic and bleak, despite its size. ⭐⭐1/2
Rock opera! So cool, so different from what I knew The Who from
Man, I haven't listened to this album in maybe 15+ years, which is pretty crazy to think about. I'm not sure if Tommy or Who's Next was the first album by The Who I heard, but I did buy this on CD, probably sometime in high school. It was likely one of if not the first concept album I had heard. I definitely did enjoy it and gave it frequent listens, although maybe not quite as much as Who's Next. Not long after I started college I moved on from most of the "classic rock" type stuff I dabbled in, and have hardly looked back on The Who since, as I talked about when reviewing their debut. Still a great listen, and kind of wild to think how I almost completely abandoned this band, not because I didn't like them anymore, but more because I was just overwhelmed with other new stuff that I considered more interesting, or at least different/newer/more exciting. As I said before, I definitely am overdue on a deep dive of The Who. This is yet another understandably classic album, and I definitely enjoyed hearing it again after all these years. While I credit Bowie's Ziggy Stardust with first opening the door to progressive rock concept type stuff for me, this album may have actually preceded Ziggy back in my formative listening years, and it is far more "progressive". Honestly, a bit of a mystery as to why I basically abandoned listening to The Who so many years ago.
Only had heard Pinball Wizard before but I really liked the overall album. Good concept album and good music. Can’t wait to compare it to The Elder when it comes up.
very rock opera- mostly i was waiting for Pinball Wizard to happen, but that's a pretty good song.
Not as good as i expected. Too many weird fuck songs and not enough pinball
good
Great to hear this again but really needs the wonderfully weird film to fully appreciate it as all the component parts can be disjointed if you don’t know the story.
enjoyed but not groundbreaking ??
Ambitious and sprawling and for the most part it works. Pinball Wizard is a classic. Sparks is a great instrumental. Very influential, although sometimes not for the best. Still, this definitely belongs. I still think Who's Next is better.
Ok, but very long
I appreciate how different this is as an album, and a lot of the songs have interesting parts. It does indeed sound like the soundtrack of a musical or opera. On the negative side though, Pinball Wizard is the only real standout and from the perspective of someone listening in 2025 the tone of the songs doesn't always match the story or the seriousness of the topics that it covers.
I appreciate the recurring musical themes, but I’ve always felt like this album was way too long. I’m glad they did it, Tommy created the rock opera after all, but I don’t need to hear a song about a bully or a kiddie fiddler. I don’t care about Tommy as a character in the least bit, so in that way, they really failed. Basically, the Who take us on a journey where this boy becomes a cult leader. We don’t need all of that, or at least I don’t. It’s too much. Show us one thing that’s real and be done with it. Points for the song Pinball Wizard, an absolute classic if not slightly unclimactic. l also liked the Christmas song, beyond all logic. The overture and underture were nice. The rest, meh. This rock opera has very few rock-out moments.
kinda boring
This was a double album of what felt like a Rock Opera. The concept was an extended album regarding Tommy's life. Pinball Wizard is on this one. I liked it overall but it is too long for me for an active listen.
Quite a long one. Mixed feelings here. Sometimes it sounded like they didn't know what to record
Pretty good for a concept album.
Tommy has been on my to-be-played list a long time for now and I love that this app brings me to just do that. The story is what makes this album feel so special to me and of course the way it unfolds in the course of listening to album. I love just losing track of time while listening to it, feeling for Tommy and what he had to go through, and knowing how many later albums we love were inspired by this masterpiece. The story of Tommy seems like a tragic version what people imagine what the 1960s were like when they weren't born to live in this time, but no matter what it feels like there are more than just a couple Tommys out there.
I realized, that sadly I didn't knew too much from them. This changes with this album. From now I will for sure listen more The Who!
Solid album, probably one of the best rock operas.
I love rock opera, so of course I love Tommy! It hits wonderfully in the nostalgia for me as well having grown up hearing it. One of the greatest albums of all time truly!! Music that tells a story is always fun to me. Even when the story is a little strange. I can't really put my love for this into words too well. Let the stars speak for themselves
Every few years I’m reminded how excellent this album is and along comes this reminder. A Classic!
Classic
This felt like something I would have been told to listen to for high school English. I understood the concept and respect its historical significance, but I didn’t really enjoy it for the most part. There are some good tracks though.
Odd…
Two albums of The Who in a row? :D Seriously? The band itself is great, but I don't like it much. The vibes of The Beatles are in place. I like a few popular songs of The Who, but I don't enjoy anything else much.
87/1089 - Eh. Would've benefited from trimming the fat and making the story more concise. Pinball Wizard was cool.
Wanha tuttu! Tätä on opiskeltu ja kuunneltu vuosien aikana niin että ulkoa osaa. Hyvää on että tarina on selkeä. Nautin instrumentaalikappaleista. Nykyään tämä kuitenkin häviää Quadrophenialle joka on se ultimaattinen konseptilevy The Wholta.
Helt passe
good
I don't get it. Maybe I lost focus somewhere, but the storytelling aspect of the album was completely lost on me. The tracks are mostly fine, but it's a very long album.
ok i thought i would not feel this way after having listened to this album a few years ago. it didnt seem to hold up well and there are some throwaway songs. But listening now i was blown away by Keith Moon's drumming and percussion throughout this album. Amazing Journey has always been a favorite just for the incredible drum fills he performs and Underture is truly a master class in percussion. Also i was struck by the unique sound of this album- really a big departure drom their earlier work. Songs like Christmas, Go to The Mirror and the amazing Overture into 1921. I like Quadrophenia better overall of we are comparing rock operas, but I have to call it: this is a stone cold classic.
One of my husband's favorites.
Pretty long and boring album. Pretty overrated for me.
Langt dobbelalbum, må lyttes igjennom flere ganger, men setter den pr. nå midt på 3.
The album takes you on a journey, for better or worse. Being a double album, not all the songs are great and very few stand on their own. But put it all together and it’s nearly flawless
Great album!
Turned it off during “fiddle about” WTF? Changed times
Okay
One of the great rock album intros surely. The five minute Overture is over the top, dramatic and wonderful. By the time we get to 1921 I'm already entranced. Really good use of overdubs on the vocals and the backing piano is perfect. The tracks unfold like parts of a suite, at times blending one into the next. Melodies and piercing, layered vocals are the constant, everything supported by relentless drumming. Christmas stands out, an introspective moment enhanced by the pounding drums. The long instrumental Underture closes the second side, tension building throughout. Pinball Wizard is still as good as ever, jangly rhythm guitar and the buzzsaw-like lead. Go To The Mirro is great too. You need a bit of endurance to get through this one but the audacity of it has to earn top marks.
Feels like Keith Moon is auditioning for the lead role in a drumming competition no one else signed up for.
long but it’s good
I spent half of it waiting for one track and it only lasted 3 minutes. This whole Rock Opera thing is a waste fo time.
Yeah I mean all-time classic but am I going to be listening to it repeatedly on CD? Probably not
This has got to be one of the most self indulgent albums I've ever hear. Seriously, nobody cares about your creepy little drunk uncle dude. Yeah there are some hits like Pinball Wizard, but by the time you get there you're already so fucking over these guys.
Good album. Like the Who anyway but this more conceptual album is well worth alisten
Nicht so meins
Ich liebs!
det isch en langer alber liebe who. overture cools waldhorn. oke irgendwie schono cool plötzlch gsang und s isch sochli folky und d gitarre wanderet im stereobild ume ohyeaaah. oke apparently isch da so for real e rock opere. glaub schono innovativ gsi da züg. ischer 1921 gebohrt? okay. gad synopsis überfloge. am townshend isch glaub nöd guet gange. fucked up story. underture isch etz no cute aber eaasy repetitiv. ich möst das glaub viel ufmerksamer lose? jo finds bitz langwilig. ok pinball wizard isch seeeehr geil die beide mirror songs au easy. sensation chli sehr meh. ich finds echt nöd sooo geil? isch glaub afoch no mega guet galteret? im free findi no nice aber s isch alles sehr verhalte irgendwie wells d story will verzelle. naja. we're not gonna take it kenntmer glaaaaub? ich check das album null s gitmer nüt git e zwei sorry who.
konfitüre hahah fuck weiss nöd öbi ready bin d gschicht gaht um dune????? ich lieb dass sie seget 21 will be a good year. es ischs nöd gsi! okeee ich cheggs glaub. gnüsses aber nöd mega es schwankt immer sochli zwüsche cool/spannend und eifach nervig? christmas hani iwie geil gfunde aber iwie halt doch nöd hahahah hahah hä hans gfühl ich kenn underture, es erinneret mi recht ah alan parsons project jaa das isch jz recht ah mier verbiizoge wnl hahaha me chönnt sich sicher mega ih die gschicht/das album vertüfe doch eifach eso isches easy gsi
Killer album, one of my all time favourites. My only qualm is I wish underture was shorter.
There are a number of bands that are automatically just going to get 5 stars, and all of them are absolutely worthy of said rating. The Who is one of them. This is an absolutely epic tale from start to finish. I really could have gone my entire life without knowing why the song "Pinball Wizard" happens though. I greatly look forward to listening to more of The Who and their entire catalogue. This concludes my first "week" on this website, and it's been an incredible experience so far. I look forward to finishing the fight in a few years. Give me more like this and it will be an easy feat.
I really appreciate the lengths that the Who went to with this album, but it just did not click with me. I can see how much effort went into this thing - from the songwriting, to the arrangement, production, and performances. It's a shame that most of the songs feel like snippets of longer, more boring tracks. Any sort of rating I have for this comes entirely from an appreciation for the effort and love that went into this album by the band themselves, and a little appreciation of my own for Pinball Wizard. 6/10
A classic album but it is insanity that this is on here and Quadrophenia isn’t.
Skillful
I was expecting Dayman, fighter of the Nightman, to appear at some point
I just can't get through this album, not interesting enough to be over an hour. There are some good songs still Will I listen to again: 5%
the opera has a nice story to it but what an awful album to listen to. Pinball wizard and go to the mirror are good songs.
So. Much. Padding. Dear Lord this whole album has one song.
Significant. A favorite of mine. I get some not digging it.
It was good - but just wasn't my fav
I can see the vision and appreciate the execution but I’m just not a big enough fan of The Who to enjoy this particular album
I wasn’t expecting to like it but I did!
Muy largo, pero entiendo su status de clásico. No es un disco que pondría en mi rotación diaria, por ejemplo.
bombetta
Bell'album, prog il giusto. Poi un concept album, come piace a me. Purtroppo ascoltato in due tornate che è bello lungo. Dopo aver letto il concept è folle, che scrittura, che follia. In totale approvato, da prendere un giorno magari anche in vinile.
Enjoyed this album 8/10
Not my cup of tea
Damn this was really good. This is a concept album through and through, I really appreciate the ambition throughout this album, it tells the story effectively and makes use of the 24 tracks very nicely, I will be returning to this one in the future later on for sure. To summarize the plot without spoiling much, this is about a boy named Tommy who goes deaf, dumb, and blind from some trauma early in his life, but he finds some fame later in live after becoming a champion in a game as well as a spiritual leader. I know it sounds a little bizarre towards the end, but trust me it works nicely, highly recommend this one. Rating: Incredible (Decent ☆☆☆☆☆) Favorite Tracks: Not really one where I would pick out individual songs.
We love a rock opera! The story is weird to me and that’s why I took off a star. I think it takes a weird left turn. But other than that. I love this album
that's a fucking masterpiece
Meh. I’m bored of saying it, but I’m not a big fan of The Who. They had some great hits, but their albums are mediocre. Pinball Wizard is always a good listen, well written, catchy and covered a few times by other prominent artists. The rest is mostly forgettable.
It's hard to listen to Tommy and not just compare it to Quadrophenia, one of my favorite albums of all time. It's clearly good, but it lacks the actual feel of a rock album, and really just plays like one long play/song. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it only has one major hit (two?) throughout the album, and it can tend to end up starting sort of the same. I think of it as testing for Quadrophenia. Maybe too harsh at a 3 because the achievement is stunning, but I feel ok with it for now.
.. no
I may just be a simp but I do love this album.
Wordless. Not my type of album