Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd

Wish You Were Here

Pink Floyd

4.3
Rating
31898
Votes
1
1%
2
4%
3
13%
4
27%
5
55%
Distribution

Reviews (page 12 of 16)

10/10 no notes absolutely flawless

A favourite of mine, the 5 track playlist always put me off when I was a teenager but I wanted it so badly for Wish You Were Here and Shine on. Welcome to the Machine and Have a Cigar are equally as good. It's as mesmerising as ever. An album everyone should own.

The big 2 on here(wish and shine on) are some of the best songs ever, the rest are not that interesting

Cool man!!!

Pretty damn awesome from the first twang to the last chord but didn’t overly enjoy.

Didn't listen. Hate Pink Floyd.

Better than The Wall, mainly because its a more appropriate length. Again, the musicianship is excellent, but it's still a bit highly strung. A low 4.

Have to admit that I'm jealous of people who enjoy this. There's a bunch of musical phrases here and there I halfway like. Some bits that are a little like Richard Thompson but without any punch. I find this album so dull and the countless things that try to sound like it so so dull. My brother once said about a terrible novel recommended to him that it gave him the unsettling feeling that he didn't enjoy fiction anymore, but it turned out to be the book. That's what I feel like here. I bet I would be happier if this sound did anything for me at all. we are who we are I s'pose. music: hated. (⌐■_■)

My Pink Floyd curve on this list started with a 3 for Dark Side. I’m very familiar with the band, and I know Dark Side is not my favourite, and I know they are simply not a five star band to me. I believe this one is my favourite, and according to the curve, it would likely land on a 4. Upon listening, it turned out the question was not “can Pink Floyd be a four star band?” but “Can Gilmour at his best elevate a 3 star record to a 4?” and to my surprise, despite liking Gilmour quite a bit, the answer was no. Good, not great.

Last song was a banger. Loving the exposure to guitar from all these albums.

What to say? Top ten for me. Known it and loved it for 30 plus years, still blows me away. Better structured and more cohesive than most prog. The most amazing soaring lyrical guitar parts you could ever hope for. Dense studio soundscapes with ground breaking efffects. It's in a league of it's own. Does sound very 1970s and the lyrics are a bit schoolboy-ish. Deal with it, make this one your friend for life.

This is probably their best album outside of DSOTM. It may even be better once you've become a fan of the ban and understand that it was written based on some of the turmoil the band felt with Syd Barret leaving. It is also a perfect middle between Animals and DSTOM in terms of their more experimental prog roots and their acclaimed single fame (this album having at least one single with "Wish You Were Here" over Animals having none IMO). The wild group choruses, saxophone and tension all throughout "Shine on you Crazy Diamond." The darker/grittier tones of "Welcome to the Machine." The excellent chorus end on "Have a Cigar." The beauty/sorrow of "Wish You Were Here." And ending with the final parts of the opening song (with equal length) is a good capstone.

Stone cold classic

Beautifully orchestrated. Sonically pleasing. Compared to what else I’ve been listening to from that time they were pushing the boundaries by creating their own style and unique storytelling. This listening session I learned that your environment, mood and what you’re doing at the moment can dictate how you will perceive and also appreciate music.

This is pink Floyd doing what they do best I think

Always loved <3

Pretty good time jamming out.

The only Pink Floyd album that all members of Pink Floyd could agree was kind of okay. Roger Waters might have been the creative force behind Wish You Were Here, but David Gilmour's guitar tone steals the show while Rick Wright's work behind the keys makes this one of the greatest, most cohesive, albums of all time.

I love reading old reviews of Wish You Were Here, as everyone seemed out of their minds and found it uninspiring, dull and insincere - only for them to later realize the magnitude of the record and praise it as one of the greatest album ever released.

It takes stones to lead your album with an 11 minute song (and then continue it on subsequent tracks).

# 209 : Hmmm, sooo looong, I don't know why this is ranked as a classic. There is so much better PF out there than this!

Phenomenal. 4.6

This was fine. The titular song is the highlight, the rest seems fillery at parts but goes down smoothly.

This was really good! It is very rare that I will listen to 25 minutes of the same song (split into two parts at the beginning and end of the album) and never get sick of it. I think conceptually, “The Wall” is definitely better than this album, but I liked the sound of this one better.

If this were an album consisting only of the title track, the song "Wish You Were Here", I would give it five stars. I've been shouting "TWO LOST SOULS SWIMMING IN A FISH BOWL" since I was a child. Unfortunately, this album contains four other songs that are, to me, profoundly uninteresting.

Pink Floyd raised the greatest question in rock music (B-F-G-E?). Noone asnswered yet.

A really great album that I have heard before. I'm sure I will listen to it again, it's a classic.

Some parts of “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” will have you looking at your watch but everything else is pure prog-rock bliss.

Incroyable, Masterpiece, ça m'a retourné le cerveau.

Do yourself a favor and get an waterproof/submersible speaker, take it into a swimming pool, and play this album.

Reeeeallllyyyyy good

Radical. Psychedelic. Original. Emotional.

One of the best ever.

Great, but doesn't match the heights of Dark Side of the Moon.

Previously rated: The Dark Side of the Moon (3/5) The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn (2/5) **************************************** Can't say this is bad. I just like my rock music with a bit more energy and excitement. Just a preference.

Masterpiece. Favorite tracks: All of them

Totally perfect Fav songs: Have a cigar Wish you were here ^=^

Great album

this one was not as good as dark side of the moon. very atmospheric which is not necessarily a bad thing, just not hugely gripping.

Very cool!

Sing are too long

Pink Floyd never ceases to be amazing!

Wish You Were Here, the follow up to Pink Floyd's earth-shattering Dark Side of the Moon, is often treated like a sophomore album. In some ways it is. Dark Side of the Moon represented a major break from Pink Floyd's psychedelia of the 1960s. It was, in the post Syd Barret relaunch of the band, something like a first album. Unlike many sophmore albums, Wish You Were here was not a bunch of outtakes. Instead, it leaned heavily into the prog rock of Dark Side of the Moon. At the same time, it was not just a continuation of its predecessor. The tone is very different with a melancholy feel to the album driven by themes of lost youth, alienation, and disappointment. This is especially true with the epic Shine on You Crazy Diamond. Broken into two parts, it talks to the feeling of the loss of youth and yearning for previous times. The two halves of the piece are interrupted by three songs - Welcome to the Machine, Have a Cigar, and the amazing title track, Wish You Were Here. All three share the theme of youth being ruined and consumed by society and its expectations. That last of the triptych, it heartachingly sad both musically and lyrically. History has declared Dark Side of the Moon Pink Floyd's greatest work. Perhaps, but if it's possible to have two greatest works, then Wish You Were Here is the other.

Some undeniably well written stuff but also moments of what sounded like someone wobbling keys aimlessly on their cool new synthesiser thinking they're the second coming of christ.

The opening of Shine On you Crazy Diamond , using wineglass rims, then those notes…. Epic….

very close to a 10/10

This being one of the highest rated albums on here, I really had high hopes for this. I’m honestly struggling between a 3 and a 4. The guitar playing is exceptional. A 5 song album is kinda whack Arnold’s though. The hits on here are so good though. I think my final ruling is a 3.505.

Never listened to this album all the way through, but enjoyed it.

This was my first time listening, but definitely not my last. There are only a few songs, but the first and last songs each have several parts (collectively called "Shine On You Crazy Diamond"). The tunes on here are not necessarily catchy earworms in the way pop songs may be, but they're very pleasant and interesting. I appreciated the instrumental focus of much of the album. Depending on how you choose to listen, "Wish You Were Here" can be relaxing, or it can leave you with a lot to think about, or both.

One of my favourite albums of all time, i love it so much. not much has to be said honestly pink floyd pretty self explanatory STAND OUT: Shine on You crazy diamond (ALL OF THEM)

Perfect, and yet somehow still not as good as their previous album!

Perfection. One of my favourite albums for just vibing. The opener Shine On You Crazy Diamond is the prefect execution of building music to a climax.

good album - forgot to write down notes but i think i really liked it.

This is an interesting concept album by Pink Floyd. This progressive rock album is fluid, building up, ungulates and lives, and slowly releases. This is a great album that must be listened to whole in order to gain a fuller appreciation of the writing and musicianship.

NOOOOOOOO WISH YOU WERE HERE🙁🙁🙁🙁🙁. I love this album so much💔💔 the vocals and the background are very painful for me. This is a beautiful album that has a of meaning behijf it!!

Sooo relaxing, great album but prefer Dark Side of the Moon. Would recommend it to everyone as it’s a really good listen 😃

One of my boyfriends in college went on spring break in California and brought this back for me (along with the Funky Cold Medina cassette single, both of which he had opened and listened to) as a gift. I liked him a lot, so I put this on at bedtime every night religiously. Wish You Were Here is not at all a souvenir of California for me, but of the thoughts and dreams of my 19 year-old self lying in bed at night trying to figure everything out. That the opening lyrics are, “Remember when you were young/ You shone like the sun”…sigh.

Oh darn I had to listen to this again

oh girl i love this album

Although some disagree, I genuinely believe "Wish You Were Here" is Pink Floyd's best album. It was written and performed at the height of their creative power, as well as David / Roger / Rick's penmanship. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part I - IX) is possibly the most beautiful Pink Floyd song. Cloaking at 25-minutes-long, every second of it is worthwhile. The song ending with Rick's organ on "See Emily Play" is an especially charming touch — bittersweet acceptance. "Welcome To The Machine" comfortably sits among my favourite Pink Floyd songs. It is a fantastic exposure of unforgiving underbelly of the music industry ("What did you dream? It's alright we told you what to dream".) In addition, there is a fantastic use of synth (unlike when synth is later reintroduced in "A Momentary Lapse Of Reason", 𝘤𝘰𝘶𝘨𝘩 𝘤𝘰𝘶𝘨𝘩.) "Have A Cigar" has among the most iconic Pink Floyd guitar riffs. Hats off to Roy Harper — one of Pink Floyd's only guest vocalists. I particularly love his delivery of the line: "We call it riding the gravy train-nnn-nnn!" Addictive stuff. The title track, while not as ambitious nor daring as its predecessors, servers as a stirring ode to Syd Barrett. It also makes a great introduction to the band and those who're intimidated by Pink Floyd's complex arrangements (it was actually my introduction to Pink Floyd.) Overall, I think everyone, regardless of music taste, should listen to Wish You Were Here at least once in their lifetime. It is an experience that has changed my — and not just mine — outlook on the world.

Skipped. Cannot with this album. Maybe never again.

One of my big problems with Prog is that, while I find the bad stuff soulless and insipid, an attempt to impress rather than to create true art, I’m also not particularly impressed by the good stuff, finding that it never really rises above the level of pleasant sounding distraction. I’ve been assured by multiple people who like this genre that that is what they enjoy. Turning their brain off and just letting the music was over them. But that isn’t what floats my boat musically. I like hooks and emotion, rather than chops. Pink Floyd’s run between DSOTM and The Wall is probably the best of the classic Prog, and it’s firmly within my parameters for ‘good’ Prog. I can happily put any of the albums on and essentially just nap for 40-80 minutes. And of all of these nap albums, I probably like Wish You Were Here the most. It’s got the title track, which has the emotion that I find lacking in other Prog projects, and is otherwise a pleasant bit of music to listen to. It’s still nowhere close to my favourite music ever, but it’s passable. And for this overrated slog of a genre, passable is the best that it can hope for

I love this record. I love the prog and the synth and the psych elements to it. It's a journey that doesn't get boring. All the subtle sounds effects are great. It's an album I've revisited many times over the last decade and will continue to revisit. It might be my favorite Pink Floyd album.

This album is a masterpiece. I'm not super into prog, and frankly, I don't revisit this one often. However, its impossible to deny how cohesive this whole album. Every song is exactly where it should flows so perfectly into the next. It really does arch like a traditional story. "Wish You Were Here" is right in the middle and always blows my mind. I love how Shine On is on both sides of the record and serves and a book end. It's absolutely brilliant.

Fantastic album and what a great cover

All time classic album

Beautiful, hypnotic music. Great for studying or getting work done.

Fire, probably no skips, 4.5

did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage? greatest album cover ever

Wish You Were Here is the ninth album by English rock band Pink Floyd. This progressive art rock album released to mixed reviews as some felt it was uninspired and inferior to the band's previous work, but it has since received praise as some of their finest work and one of the greatest albums of all time. It was the band's fastest selling album of all time and has been certified gold in Argentina, Greece, & Poland, and platinum or multi-platinum in Australia, Austria, Canada, France (10x aka diamond), Germany, Italy, New Zealand, the UK, & the US. Musically the band again uses synthesizers and acoustic guitars primarily in addition to other instruments occasionally, but intricate everyday sounds were sampled and added to the mix also. The vocals were great and complimented the music well. Most of the run time is taken up by "Shine On You Crazy Diamond," a nine part ballad paying tribute to founding band member Syd Barrett who left seven years earlier due to mental health reasons, but visited the studio during the production of this album. It's interesting history, how the concept of this album became wrapped around Syd, since he is a victim of how the music industry can turn people crazy and then extended absences are the only way they can cope with their sadness. Overall, Wish You Were Here is one of the best Pink Floyd's albums, and on the list of the greatest progressive rock albums. It's a stellar piece of simple, yet attractive music that is carried by its "soul". I highly recommend this album, although it may leave you wanting more.

Shine on you crazy diamon pt 1-5 i don’t remember being this bluesy AS FUCK The through like is but hazier than I remembered. It’s fantastic music but it doesn’t feel life changing? I don’t know how to explain it Maybe it’s cause I’ve listen to it before and it’s the first album that I’ve heard all the songs before Gonna give it the benefit of the doubt and go with 4 over 3

This album is a masterpiece by a band that does nothing but produce masterpieces. For me, this album is second only to Dark Side. With an album this good I find it hard to say anything of substance - some of these speak for themselves and enough said is enough said.

Enjoyed the album. 6/10

As an unabashed Pink Floyd fan, this is One Of The Great Ones.

One of the amazing albums

A timeless classic.

You know, the fact that this album only has 5 songs but lasts 45 minutes already makes me not want to listen to it. Okay so I liked that way more than I thought I would. 4/5

Beautiful album. Best enjoyed entirely in one sitting.

I liked the first track the best.

Shine on crazy diamond makes me explode

One of my favorite bands of all time, if not my favorite. (At least right now, it changes) and this is a great album there is no doubt. I don’t often criticize the judgement of the author but adding this and not including Animals is an error.

Pink Floyd is the perfect example of music as an art form. Besides being great music, this record carries so much weight, emotion, and darkness. It's artsy and a little bit self-indulgent, but never in a manner that's off putting. At the same time it also wears its heart on its sleeve, without ever being corny. Not as good as The Dark Side of the Moon, but very close. Standouts are Wish You Were Here and the entire 25-minute run of Shine On You Crazy Diamond.

Their finest moment

My favorite album of all time.

One of my favorites

Top 10 all time, all genre

Pile on many more layers, and I'll be joining you there.

I’m not sure I’m musically gifted enough to understand how good pink Floyd were. Atmospheric but not sure if it’s my thing 3.2

About as good as rock record can be. Title cut is music for the deathbed itself, not just before dying. To think this was their follow-up to Dark Side more than cements their place in the pantheon.

Sheer masterpiece.

A classic. A true album.

Pink Floyd have some sketchy albums, and some incredibly good ones. This is one of the better ones. Really solid album where actually all songs are really good, harmonize well, and are coherent. Cool album cover too. I guess this might not fit someone who dislikes guitar centric music, otherwise I think this is an album most people are familiar with and can enjoy. I also like that every song is quite different from one another, even though the also work well together. 'Welcome To The Machine' is for example a quite synthetic song, as opposed to 'Have A Cigar' which is more rocky. Solid 5/5, would recommend to everybody.

I mean it's just hands down a great album. I tried to find things wrong with it and the only thing I can come up with is that maybe "Welcome to the machine" is not quite as strong as the other songs. Other than that is pretty much as close to a perfect album I think you can come. Everything is just really good, from the solos, the lyrics, the subject matter, even the artwork is iconic. Everybody should listen to this and see if it is their jam.

No pink Floyd

In my view this is the last great mid-period Pink Floyd album, and one that ranks up there with Dark Side of the Moon, before the more misanthropic tendencies crept in. From Animals onwards I think there was something of a downward creep. High point for me is Shine On You Crazy Diamond, but really the whole album is great. And I can still remember guying the vinyl version and loving the sleeve and packaging.

If Dark Side was their Sgt Pepper's, then this must be their Abbey Road. With the masterful song suite that is "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", the band pays ode to a former member of the Floyd in glorious style. The songs between SOYCD also rule. "Have a Cigar" was, for a while there, my favorite track of theirs. This whole record is a masterpiece, and it was one of the first albums I added to my vinyl collection. It simply belongs among the 5 star albums.

Classic rock. One of my favorite albums -- I've listened to Wish You Were Here more times than I can count and I'm sure I'll listen to it many more times to come. One of the greatest rock bands ever at the height of their powers. Fantastic from start to finish -- lyrics alternating between cutting sarcasm and melancholy remembrance as they explore the business of being a rock star and what it does to their bandmates. The musicianship is outstanding, as are the production values with different tones and sound effects amplifying the moods of the different tracks.

I’d probably give it 3.5. Not really my type of music but I do like the song Wish You Were Here and the album has a relaxing vibe. I probably won’t listen again by choice. I appreciate how each song seamlessly transitions into the next - I feel like people don’t do that so much anymore.

Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here Pink Floyd is a group that requires you to sit and listen to the entire album. Picking and choosing specific songs/singles means you are not getting the full picture of what they created. Wish You Were Here is an example of this. You can pick Shine On You Crazy Diamond, pts 1-5 to listen to, but you would miss the transition into Welcome to the Machine. While Shine On is a great song you lose the full impact of listening to the entire album in one sitting. Albums like this won't work in today's music climate. Everyone wants the one song and to not be tied down into listening to the entire album from start to finish. But Pink Floyd created something special with their albums and they should be listened to on vinyl. Not because of quality or sound, but because their albums were made for that medium. And the title song is amazing. The way it sounds like the sound has dropped and you barely hear the music on the right channel and then it kicks in with full sound! So fucking good. Plus the song is just top tier. 5/5

pretty good, kinda boring

miren the wall amigos la primera ta bastante piola la segunda ta normal en general suena bien pero es medio lento pa mi gusto

a classic for a reason

Pink Floyd might have greater, more ambitious albums, but this one cuts like a knife. Painfully cynical while at the same time elegantly haunting and mournful. Every song on here is a classic. Fave Songs (All songs, from most to least favorite): Wish You Were Here, Have a Cigar, Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I–V), Welcome to the Machine, Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI–IX)

Really good

Ratings: 5: I will happily play this album anytime 4: I may occasionally play this album of my own free will 3: I will happily listen to this if someone plays it in the background 2: I will tolerate this if it is playing in the background 1: I will leave the room if someone plays this in the background The atmosphere and build of Shine On, and the longing on Wish You Were Here made this my favorite Pink Floyd album back in high school (along with the Wall). Very high on the nostalgia factor for me. 5 stars.

Exceptional

Masterpiece

His voice is so annoying.

Haunting, churning, visceral, timeless album. Can have this playing in many settings. In the backdrop at home, during a party, or as a listening event, at the foci of guests’ attention to mesmerize and captivate. Released nearly 50 years ago, true art is unfazed by the test of time. Will listen to this again on a roadtrip, while camping, I could go on. Could teach a music history course on this album and Pink Floyd’s impact on music. 💎🎸🧿

One of my all time favs , it’s all about letting the vibe simmer …. Floyd does it best. They definitely had a message of how shitty the music industry is, but they still made it entertaining as heck. Timeless album 💿 ⭐️

This is a delightful album to listen to for me. I love two of the songs especially: Have a Cigar and Wish You Were Here. The crazy diamond parts in the beginning and end are nice cornerstones.

Personally, I think this album is better than Dark Side of the Moon. The opening track is David Gilmour at his absolute best.

What a start to an incredible journey. This is my first Pink Floyd album I'm hearing in full and it did not disappoint. The title track will always hold a special place in my heart thanks to covering it multiple times in dedication to someone important that passed. Shine On You Crazy Diamond and all its parts are monumental especially the buildup in the first parts to the chorus are magnificent. The other two songs equally hold their weight in grandiosity, and flourish this incredible album. Very much deserved to be so high in the all-time list on AOTY. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 1-5 - 95 Welcome to the Machine - 100 Have a Cigar - 90 Wish You Were Here - 100 Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 6-9 - 95 Final score: 96

3- Stars (7/15)

Perfect. Masterpiece.

One of my absolute favorite albums of all time. Just incredible start to finish. David Gilmour's guitar on Shine on You Crazy Diamond are emotional and moving. Not fast or flashy, but he makes that guitar sing.

Probably their best, right alongside 'Dark Side...'. Sometimes I feel like the middle 3 songs are just fillers between the epic 'Crazy Diamond' pieces, which I think is really the heart and soul of the whole album. But those 3 tracks standalone on their own feet, and I love how seemlessly they blend into each other and back into the final track. Pink Floyd really knew how to create a real album experience, not just a collection of songs.

For me this album is second only to Animals in the Pink Floyd canon. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is heartbreaking and beautiful. Never will I tire of listening to David Gilmour’s soaring guitar and understated haunting voice. I can say the same for this album.

A great album that fits into their odd year 70s must listen /purchase set Sometimes gets overlooked surrounded by the heavyweight albums before and after but stands alone as a tribute to Syd and kept the band going despite some fractures. Watching any iteration of Floyd live and feeling the anticipation of the riff at the beginning of “Shine on….” Is something to behold Can’t say enough about it but still in my rotation 50 years later

Which One’s Pink? Good stuff…Part of the Canon.

One of the best albums ever written. Pink Floyd are incredible sound appreciators. Such patience and thought put into each transition. I love the reoccurring themes. A tribute to a dear friend.

4.9/5 Best Track: Welcome to the Machine

Absolutely amazing album!

Do yourself a favor and get some headphones and find a place to relax and just take all this in. Especially for first tine listeners. To be fair, I am a fan boy, but there is truly not a lot if anything to hate on here.

Classic. Easy 5 stars

The title track is memorable beyond its years (even now), but I really just wanted to skip ahead to parts VI–IX of "Shine on You Crazy Diamond" while listening. I think Syd would too.

I like Wish You Were Here but the rest is only okay. It's not bad, just not as interesting as other Pink Floyd.

My favorite of the later Pink Floyd albums. The cover is amazing, and to me the tunes feel more personal and emotionally compelling than most of their other work. Beautifully recorded, understated performances from the band at the top of their game. Also, 500 points to Ravenclaw for David Gilmour's elegantly expressive guitar throughout. Highly recommend listening with headphones if you can!

It almost felt like cheating to listen to this album (for what must be the umpteenth time). Despite my undying fandom, I've never read any liner notes or anything about this album, so I was surprised to read that Roy Harper was responsible for the lead vocals on "Have a Cigar" (although since I never quite could reconcile Roger Waters' voice to that song, I guess I just implicitly assumed it was another band member singing it?). I think what's always stuck with me most with this album is David Gilmour's distinctive guitar style, which feels as perfected on this album as it could probably be. I'm sorry that contemporary critics didn't feel all that enthusiastic about this album, but I have the feeling that the (to me, at least) unique sound and composition of the album must have seemed out of left field, even for Pink Floyd. When I was a kid, I would play my favorite records continuously while reading books. As a result, It's almost impossible for me to separate "Wish you were here" from a couple of fantasy book series, mainly "The Once and Future King" series (T.H. White), and I think also the "Chronicles of Thomas Covenant" series (Stephen Donaldson). Probably not what Waters and crew had in mind, I know....

shine on you crazy diamond indeed.

2024-02-27...

Music that has depth is more timeless. Rhis style of music has depth. Gilmour's guitar tones are a plus.

I enjoyed this a lot. I always thought Pink Floyd would be for me, maybe this will motivate me to listen to some more

Great album I'm sure, but I'm not a fan.

Four good songs that are mostly too long. This was my first time listening to the entire album since my first year in college, and time hasn't brought any new appreciation. The playing and production are great, just too much space-filling for me. Still, 4 stars for the production alone.

a heartfelt exploration of love and camaraderie accented by dreamy synths and way-too-long guitar solos that speak to your soul. 10/10

I approve

Super pleasant and felt cogesive all the way through. Title track is 10/10, the rest doesnt do too much for me but I enjoyed them.

She shine on my diamond till I'm crazy

Shine On You Crazy Diamond is a very nice journey. The rest is good too, but I understand my dad's frustration about Wish You Were Here outranking Shine On You Crazy Diamond in the annual Top 2000 we listen to. It's just on a different level.

The worst thing about Pink Floyd is the insufferable fans. The music is amazing though.

:( shine on you crazy diamond 1 to 5- music certainly has been playing. the initial instrumentation is ok the guitar solo is psychedelic but nothing particularly interesting and when it gets to the lyrics its ok. 6 or 7. the sax goes crazy tbh though welcome to the machine- "where have you been? its alright we know where youve been" whyd you ask then. fake deep. im sure it was crazy back when it came out but now its whatever. 4 or 5. very boring have a cigar- 5 wish you were here- HOW I WISH HOW I WISH YOU WERE HEREEE WERE JUST TWO LOST SOULS SWIMMIN IN A FISHBOWL YEAR AFTER YEARRR. i feel like you have to like this song. i dont like pink floyd and i like this song. 7. also one time i saw this on a love song playlist and i disagree because i think this song doesnt feel romantic at all. i mean i know its about bandmates so thats why but i feel this song is more about the ache of a long lost friend. shine on you crazy diamond 6 to 9- ayo? ok. 5 divorced uncle type beat. favorite track- wish you were here

The title track “Wish You Were Here” is a beautiful song that I added to my monthly playlist. The others were cool, but not necessarily re-listens for me.

This is probably my second favorite Pink Floyd album. I can hear bits of songs that could have been on Dark Side of the Moon and hints of what was to come with The Wall. There's some pretty tasty David Gilmour guitar and I love how they put this one together. Great stuff!

Shine on you was a bop, wasnt expecting it to be 13 mins but didnt feel long

Masterpiece

Maybe I need to be high to enjoy Pink Floyd, but I’m not, so I just find it boring. 2

I've long lost count of how many times I've listened to this album over the years. From the bookends of Shine On You Crazy Diamond to the three great featured songs it's an all time classic. Earns it's place alongside Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall.

Absolutely perfect. Pink Floyd is like a family member that you always enjoy visiting. Enjoying the stories they share. Brilliant, and emotionally stirring.

I like that this is a tribute to their former singer. I had a copy of this on tape. I really like it. Listens: 2 Fave Track: Have A Cigar Rating: 5

Indulgent prog rock

Love this band. Maybe not quite my favourite album - Dark side of the moon better!

As with all Pink Floyd albums this one too is an experience.

I enjoyed this album while it was on, but not enough to make me want to revisit much from it after it finished

Probably one of if not the greatest album of all time

Not really for me - couple of good tracks.

4 por Wish you were here. Igual un 5 al single, pero al disco entero no. Nada, un 3.

Cool. Pretty good moments. No complaints. Not my favorite proggy album but it’s fine.

I do not think I have listened to this all the through in probably 6 years. And man is it impressive. The synthesizer usage was really awesome. RIP Syd Barrett.

Instrumentally they are insanely good but I find Pink Floyd to be a super boring band. All the songs blend into one giant similar sounding noise.

One of many incredible albums by Pink Floyd. What else is there to even say on this one that hasn't been said already.

Enige minpunt aan dit album is de lengte: het is te kort.

Quite nice. Need to be in the right mood and really listen to it

Interesting structure with long songs. Some good guitar.

My favorite Pink Floyd album, probably in my top ten works of art across all media. Just perfect.

This used to be my 100% favorite album of all time, and while it's title is up for grabs with like 5 other albums likely on this list, I still fucking adore it. Near perfection.

A favorite

Just two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl.

I mean, what can I say about this album that hasn't already been said 1000 times. It's literally perfect. This album is pretty much the absolute pinnacle of psychedelic rock, and I don't even think this is Pink Floyd's best album (my favourite is The Wall if you're curious). This album features some of the best guitars I have ever heard, they are so majestic and airy, yet also so heavy at the same time, truly and amazing sound I have never heard from any other band. Not to mention the absolutely fucking insane vocals, again with so much passion where it's almost aggressive, yet simultaneously dreamy. Until today it's been a while since I have heard this album, so I would love to be able to review it in more detail, but unfortunately I don't want to listen to it too many times in a day. The bottom line is, I fucking love this album.

Yesss! Beautiful album! 12/10.

Icon album cover And more icon music. Influential in so many ways , guitar solos are masterpieces. Shine on you crazy diamond is so immersive, it is my favorite album by them. And the reason why I bought vinyl player in first place

Easy listening but nothing to get too excited over.

I am sure this in an unpopular opinion, but I was never a big Pink Floyd fan.

great, never listened to the whole album cover to cover. Hopefully this is an indication of the 1001 list trending in the right direction.

Thought about a 5 but there are a few bits where it dragged ever so slightly. It's a high 4 though

Never noticed the ending of “Welcome…Machine” before. Social trappings are the machine? Super creative album.

This album feels like running away from home. I love the dystopian feel. Every now and then some hope shines through in the hopeless minor environment. The lyrics are vivid and provoking. If you have nothing to do and no where left to go, put on the best sound quality headphones and listen to this story uninterrupted.

Songs are soooo long and I feel like I should be on psychedelics while listening. Hard for me to appreciate it. My husband loves them.

3.5. It has moments of great and turd but mostly solid.

10/10 some of Pink Floyd’s best work I absolutely love every second of this and it is recognized as a prog rock classic for good reason

A classic rock album and an interesting prog album. Packed with synth and a handful of jazz influenced interludes, the album builds a harsh look at the price of stardom in its tribute to the former front man, Syd Barrett. Pink Floyd had fully transformed by this point and we're well on their way to their chaotic falling apart. This album is effortless to listen to in the background and has likely cycled through the backdrop of burnt out bars for years. The title track plays this unique trick in sounding exactly like Pink Floyd but filled with emotion that the band has slowly become disassociated from over the course of its tenure.

I read album reviews and see people talk about being "blown away", and I tend to dismiss it as exaggeration, but I recall putting this album on in my room, as a teenager, and being blown away. Wow.

Very good album that I nonetheless have issues with for reasons that have nothing to do with the quality of the songs.

Maybe not the best Floyd album but still amazing.

Do I really have to say anything? It's an absolute classic. My favorite Pink Floyd record.

This is my favorite Pink Floyd album.

Probably my favorite Floyd album.

One of the greates Pink Floyd albums of all the time. And one of the greatest piece of music ever made <3

always a tough admission to accept that every man in my life is actually correct. this is a phenomenal record.

Typically long songs and lack of vocals make it harder for me to get into a song. Though they do such a wonderful job creating an atmosphere I see why they are still so popular to this day.

Would you look at that? Just 4 days after I asked why I haven't gotten a Pink Floyd album yet in my The Sensual World review, I finally get one! And in the same week as Radiohead too! This has been a great week so far for my album listens. Anyways, Wish You Were Here totally lives up to the hype. This is really good. There's only 5 songs on here, so naturally those songs were made to be longer to compensate for that. However, they don't really feel that long. For as long songs like Welcome to the Machine and both sections of Shine On You Crazy Diamond are, they don't drag on at all. For Shine On, that can be explained by it being split into different sections, but the whole album has really good pacing. The songs are all excellent. I could probably talk about all of them individually, which is something I don't usually do. And I will! Shine On You Crazy Diamond is just such a great idea that gets executed flawlessly. The different sections vary, yet flow into each other without anything being jarring at all. Also it has a saxophone solo that surprisingly works really well! Welcome to the Machine and Have a Cigar are similar songs in concept, but stand out in comparison to each other and other songs. Having a guest singer on the latter definitely aids in that variance. The title track is just a masterpiece. It perfectly encapsulates the feeling of wishing that someone you love was still here with you, even if they may not actually be dead. Finally, closing out with the rest of Shine On is a bold move, but one that definitely pays off. The whole sound of this album is excellent and results in the experience having this great vibe to it all. The singing is quite good. There is so much to say about this album that I unfortunately don't have the time to get into. This is just an excellent album, and I am very excited to get to other albums like Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall later on. 5/5.

Very poignant and meaningful

Felt calming at times, easy to get work done or relax

very gentle , not entirely what i expected but something i wouldnt say no to listening to if asked. probably not something ill listen all the way through very often.

This is a very good album. Probably a 4.5/5 so will decide what to give it. But I've heard only 1 song by pink Floyd before and I enjoyed it but this album was incredibly progressive and chill and just very well performed.

I like the album more now than I did when I was young. Not my favorite type of music. I can understand those who think it is an all time great....I just don't.

Classic pysychadelic rock.

The is one of my favorite albums ever. I've probably listened to it at least 50 times in my life. The first time, it absolutely blew my 15 year old mind. I hadn't heard anything like it before. Thus began my love of all things Pink Floyd.

like i get it but its not for me. i apologize to everyone

It is very good. It's not as good as Dark Side in my opinion. But still very good

When I close my eyes I see Factory workers. It's music that would work well when you want to get things done and keep a pace and go and you could play this on repeat. Although it does make me sort of anxious.

Probably my favorite from one of my all time favorite rock bands. I’ve been listening to it since high school and have a lot of memories listening to it. I love how they went from Animals, an album devoted to class structure and socioeconomic to one about becoming a celebrity and all the pitfalls that go with it on WYWH.

Unexpectedly great

OK, so I have traditionally hated Pink Floyd. But I'm going to listen to this and list my thoughts - good and bad. Shine on You Crazy Diamond 1-5: Four minutes of oscillating tone and the song finally starts. Hooray! Some good guitar solos and drum fills in this section. Eight and a half minutes and we have the first verse. Hooray! Lyrics are solid poetry. They seem cliche, but I think that is me being cynical and viewing them thru the lens of hindsight. Saxophone was unexpected and I don't remember this on previous listens. I can dig it. Time signature change is interesting. Why only one at the end of the song. Welcome to the Machine: More long sections of long tones to start the song. At least this song gets moving quicker. "Where have you been? It's alright, we know where you've been" this line is terrible. What's with the redundant questions in this song. It's a mechanism that I don't think really works well. Have a Cigar: A song that doesn't fuck around in the intro and gets straight to it. Refreshing. A self-referential song about sycophants. Seems self-indulgent (Which one is Pink?). The drop to sound like it was playing on the radio was clever. Wish You Were Here: Nice acoustic solo at the beginning. This is the first song that I think isn't particularly pretentious and has something to say. Shine On You Crazy Diamond 6-9: At least this one starts better than 1-8. Bad part about bookending an album with a song is that it feels like you already listened to the song. This is amplified when the combined length of the two is 25 minutes and is half the album. Outro is too long, but at least not as boring as the intro to 1-8. Overall, I have to say this listen didn't really move the needle much for me. It's an album that relies heavily on it's concept, and it seems like it does so to build a story for the title track which is easily the album's best song. However, the other songs are uneven with the exception of Have a Cigar which suffers from being self-indulgent and lacks subtlety IMO. Shine on You Crazy Diamond is overrated and combines for half the total album runtime, which hurts the album tremendously.

Wish you were here and shine on you crazy diamond are excellet

Old favorite. and still a favorite

This was a really good album

Pink Floyd was never a band I could get into, however this album was the exception. Fantastic cover to cover. 5/5

I love this entire album

I see they like to have extremely long intros on all their songs. I liked Wish You Were Here before listening to this album. After listening, I did not find any additional songs that I liked too much.

Nice but so sad

5/5 Amazing prog rock, drop a tab and put this in. Choppy synth, very good beats, and a god damn saxophone solo, this makes you see wonder in just about everything.

Better than Prince. Still not great.

This really brought back memories! Loved it!

This is my first Pink Floyd album! Let me just say that this was longer than I thought. 44 minutes with a 5 song run time? Even though each of the parts of “Shine on You Crazy Diamond” are separated into two different songs, it’s still kind of concerning. This was a nice album, though. 4.2/5 Favorite Song: “Wish You Were Here” Least Favorite: None

Easily one of my top 5 favourite albums of all time.

The opening/closing track is necessarily too long, and my pulse cranked up in anticipation of the four-note motif; I hadn't realised I care. The rest is earnest doodling that passes between the ears with barely a tickle, apart from the hint of air raid siren in a keyboard part near the end of Welcome to the Machine that has me thinking about how most of the British artists on this list were parented by a war-traumatised generation. Most fellow Gen-X'ers I know have at least one set of brutally depressed grandparents who scarred one or both of their parents. Poor Boomers, ey? Gilmore's guitar is one of the final evolutionary forms of the white Brit blues movement, flawless and so non-stick I just slide off. The keyboards make me think of Kubrick's A Clockwork Orange, all sleek and alienatingly modish, beamed from somewhere far above - which I like. The title song disappointed me, partly because I realised I conflated the melody with that of the Phil Collins song with all the rain on him, which also made me realise I'm riddled with that ghastly song. The LP cover is trashy pop art. That's all I have. I am certain that Piper and Dark Side are both on this list, and predict that I will be unmoved by the former, and shall fall into a generous nostalgic reverie around the latter.

Very glad to see I still have this fresh in the collection despite not playing it for nigh-on 30 years (more?). No need, even the less-famous tracks are hammered to death on US radio, and with good reason - "Welcome to the Machine" and "Have a Cigar" are both fantastic heavy prog workouts that are always welcome. Mix in the unimpeachable title track and the psych wigging flankers and you've got yourself a classic, sir. Inspired a much enjoyed all-day Floyd session here

One of the best of all time

It's Pink Floyd. What's not to like?

Classic Pink Floyd.

OK, I get it, it's a masterpiece, but it's also *four songs long*, and one of those songs is split into two to make it a 5 song "long play" album.... Snark aside, its prog rock at its finest as suite of 9 movements encompasses the aforementioned split "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" bookends, then the 3 songs in the middle are just great, title track being the pick of the bunch but don't sleep on "Welcome To The Machine" (an anthem for disaffected youth that resonates way more than "The Wall") and "Have A Cigar". It's truly an album made for listening all the way through as opposed to individual songs. Absolute aside, "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is a great karaoke song as you get 8:45 in before you even need to sing, and it's pretty anthemic when you do...

Creo que el primer álbum de Pink Floyd entero que escucho y la instrumental me parece de las mejores que he escuchado y lo he disfrutado mucho simplemente teniéndolo de fondo y apreciando la paz y calma que me trasmitía.

Definitely a great prog rock album.

Good classic rock with some great guitar solos. A bit too lengthy songs in my opinion.

I appreciate it but not really getting the hype

The soundscape takes me to a post-apocalyptic world very similar to Terminator 2. Wish You Were Here brings the human spirit back to life in this destitute world that Pink Floyd creates sonically. The acoustic guitar juxtaposes the wailing electric and synth from the rest of the album. The final track comes to a beautiful end as if to remind us that the sun will rise once again. All bright, sparkly and life bringing.

Sprawling and conceptual. Never gave Pink Floyd too much of a chance, but this seems like a concept album of the highest degree. Not exactly my cup of tea for an every day listen, but impressive nonetheless. Wish there were half stars.

It's a classic album for a reason. Psychedelic rock at its best!

Different than expected in some ways. Enjoyed the lyrical parts but not as much the instrumental. Some songs sounded familiar (Shine on you crazy diamond - Beatles; Wish you were here - Harry Styles).

Very much like it, ne znam opisat drugacije osim the vibes are THERE and they're IT. Nemam pojma koliko je ovo accurate jer sam needukovana but its giving neki old school rock vibe i mnogo odgovara mojim UŠIMA.

I was expecting more song lyrics, but all the solos were fun to listen to. Can’t go wrong with Pink Floyd

A new appreciation for a band I seldom listen to.

Classic top 20 all time album for me.

Best Pink Floyd album, or at least tied w Dark Side. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is one of the best songs ever written.

I loved this. I never knew I liked Pink Floyd until now. It’s extraordinary. Ephemeral and intergalactic.

In line with DSotM

Just a great listen, easy to drift away to, sounded incredible

Musicalmente es 5/5, pero no es algo que me pondría en mi día a día.

Killer album, mind melting flows!

Muy bueno y tripeadito.

Great album. It's only 5 songs long but each song is a completely different experience. "Welcome to the Machine" is such a great track; hauntingly sad. I knew 2 songs before listening and the other 3 are just as great. The songs are very long and I'm not sure that was necessary.

Cool psychedelic album with amazing guitar work and strong messages.

Jazzy rock. First and last song killed the album

Ethereal

Acid vibes. I liked it better than I thought I would. ✌️

I really have only listened to another brink in the wall and this album was so fantastic. I wonder if daft punk got some of there sounds for RAM from this album

A lot more instrumental than I anticipated. Lots of slow burns in a relatively short album. It was a nice listen!

Fantastic album, not my favorite Floyd but still really incredible. 4/5

Love the guitar, as always a good classic

nicht wirklich aufregend

Listening to Pink Floyd for the first time while being very much aware of their existence and influence was akin to uncovering the roots of beloved memes when discovering a new show. The instrumental opening segments of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" were a welcoming start to the day, though there's still something about the very airy, almost dry timbre of the vocals that comes off as harsh to my ears. As I explored the album further, "Have a Cigar" notably showcased an increase in richness, with the bass adding a much needed counterpart to the vocals. Overall, an enjoyable album but probably not one that'll stay in my rotation for too long.

One of my all time favorite albums. My bad used to play a cover of Wish You Were Here.

Imma try to talk less about the meaning of the song because writing it here distracts me from listening to the song. Soo first song is starting off with a melodic guitar intro, expected this from pink. Oo amazing transition to the electric guitar, and drums(I think). Going the same but enjoyable. I must say this song is about Syd which is basically the song's name Shine on You crazy Diamond. Ends quite jazzy. There was perfect transition between the songs, loved that, also second song is already weirdly good. Also song is basically behind the scenes of music industry. 3rd song has the almost same meaning as I've read, same vibe, almost boring, but fun in a way. Guitar was the main, yet it was satisfactory. 4th one started weird. Going usual with the guitar and the drums, additionally this one's again about Syd but now song grieves his absence. 5th song with only 1 min lyrics is having the same meaning as the last one, but starting off differently. I still think whole album was an intro, a very enjoyable one tho, would rate this 2 because I don't think I'd listen to this again, as it doesn't stand out. Quite unique sounds, but not the vibe I wanted to get. Overall this was the worst I've listened to so far but I still felt heavenly tbh. Lovee Pink Floyd, but I would only listen to this as a background music.

One of the last albums where every member had their own important contributions.

I still don’t like Pink Floyd, it’s just a weird soundscape. I thought I’d like “Wish You Were Here” but only really like the covers.

One of the greatest ever!

Ausgezeichnetes Album. Mit einer schlüssigen Komposition und Anordnung der Stücke. Lyrisch anspruchsvoll und differenziert. Musikalisch mit der Auskopplung “Wish You Were here” einen hohen Wiederkennungswert. Das Intro von „Shine on …Pt. 1“ ist Champions League.

I have been listening to Wish You Were Here for forty plus years. It is a great album! Just in the past few years I have learned that Roy Harper did the vocals for Have A Cigar.

Fantastic

Classic album. So many goodies. Love the instrumentals & the long jams. Will always like this one.

This is perhaps my favorite Pink Floyd album! Loved seeing this as todays recommendation!

Classic album and one of my favorites

Not as intrusive as I expected it to be. How times change.

Meilenstein für die ewigen TOP 100 der Popmusik - zwischen Song und Suite. Und der Titelsong gehört wohl zu den meist gecoverten ... Tipp: Ulita Knaus' Version von Have a cigar ...

Neat. Seems like a snapshot of a live show. Synths and guitar and a sax surprise. Who played that? Happy to listen, unlikely to replay regularly.

I understand why people smoke weed and watch laser shows of Pink Floyd albums. Sandwiching the album between two extended prog-rock suites is a fun way to build to the release of the middle of the album. The title track definitely serves as the high point on the album in terms of a traditional song, but for my money "Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Pts. 6-9" is the most fun, and funky track on the album. An undeniable and jazzy groove that kicks off about six minutes into the track feels like it should be the end point of the album. But this funky denouement turns to a melancholy final three minutes, possibly to show regret over the loss of Syd Barrett as their guitarist.

I enjoyed the guitar work a lot. It isn't something I would listen to normally, but I absolutely get why people dig it. Also some really fun production that I'm sure was groundbreaking at the time.

Großartig!

first one. 7.1.24. darkness in pants. guitarr carried

Good album, but already a well-known classic rock masterpiecez

Love it!!

After their magnum opus The Dark Side of the Moon, Pink Floyd couldn't quite match the quality of that album with its successor. The title track is a classic, and all the parts of Shine On You Crazy Diamond make and epic synth and guitar - driven track for the ages. But Welcome to the Machine and Hava a Cigar, while not bad, leave me shrugging. The spark that was there in all the tracks of Dark Side (and would later resurface for most of The Wall) is just not anywhere to be found on this album. Which is not to say that it's bad by any means. It is a great album, but really not iconic. 4/5

Outstanding, sounds of the seventies another Masterpiece by Pink Floyd!

Great variety, epic length of tracks, one of my favs.

This type of progressive rock feels so self-indulgent to me. We get it, you can play scales on the guitar.

Has one of my favorite songs of all time a high 8

Recommended with headphones. I always thought Pink Floyd was for pot smokers and acid droppers. While that is still true, listening to them cover to cover, I can see why people are big fans. The songs are so long but it works well if you are having to listen to a whole album anyways. The transitions between melodies and beats make a long song feel like a journey. The ominous sounds always seem a little strange but the transitions make it all worthwhile. The ambience created is unlike anything you get from other albums. Uniqueness is a 10/10. The music is just fun to listen to. The guy who makes a weird cough noise at 40 secs in “Wish You Were Here” scared this shit out of me. The strange thing is, there’s no one song that I want to replay over and over like I generally do when I hear a song I like. With that being a said I still want to rate this album high because of how different and great sounding it is. This will be on the top of my list for a road trip. 8/10

One of the best bands with one of the best albums featuring one of the best songs of all time. I am a huge Floyd guy and this album is my 2nd most favorite album from them but I still think it's perfect in it's own way. Machine is the weakest song on here but the others songs are like 11/10 on their own. Listen to this all the time. 10/10

Space, no one can hear you synthesize in space. This is a heavy sci-fi blues jam album. It’s very atmospheric and keeps a very solid theme throughout. It also does a great job of leading each song into the next making it a nice front to back album which Floyd is known for. It is a bit slow at times and some songs drag a bit with all the solos. I got really confused when the first song played at the end of the album again only to find out that it is a 9 part song spread through the entire album. Kind of took me out of it as I wanted to hear more varied tracks and instead just listened to the second half of a nearly thirty minute song (the album is 45min…) 7/10.

bring back 10 minutes long songs

unbelievable good, simply great!!!

needed to be high

Not a bad listen, lot of instrumental on first and last tracks. Wish you were here is obviously the big song. Might be a fun listen while high.

The title song is an unbelievable masterpiece. Unfortunately, the rest of the album is so much more depressing in its sound. I mean, unbelievable work, but I really don’t understand the fascination of recording 11-15 minute songs for the general public. Experimentation is great, but those recordings can stay behind closed doors (or made available to those who really are interested) it really shouldn’t be on a mainstream album. Amazing musicians give this a 5, but “replayability” gives it a high 2. I’ll split the difference… solid 3