Reviews (page 11 of 13)
Muito, mas esse mar de álbuns de "rock clássico" dessa lista começa a fazer parecer que esses álbuns não são a norma e não o ótimo.
I think this is a workmanlike concept album - it may have made more sense had the projected TV play been made. I don't see why critics seem to laud the quality of the lyrics, which seem rather so-so to me.
My first time with this album. They certainly got better quickly.
Prior to listening to this I was only familiar with a couple Kinks songs. Biting social commentary and a complete album concept about modern British working class life in the late 60s, coupled with war and politics. It has that slightly off kilter feel that the Kinks did so well, along with Ray Davies' warbling singing, mixing in serious along with silly. A little Beatles-esque, a little Who thrown in, but all great to listen to. Drivin' and Shangri-La are my favorites.
fun
Brief moments of brilliance, a little too corny around the concept at times
Liked it.
Solid album. I've heard a fair amount of The Kinks before, but not this album, except the track Victoria. A really good listen!
Alright. This is my third attempt to get through this album. Why? It kicks off with "Victoria" which is a total banger. So what's my problem? Well, I think it's that it's a real steep drop off after that. I want to like the Kinks. They're clearly a very important band and, unlike The Kings of Leon, which I just had to grit my teeth through, they have bags of character and personality. This is a concept album, though, apparently, and I think it suffers the problem of some concept albums and musicals have of having the music being less important than the message or story or whatever-the-fuck it's meant to be about. So after "Victoria" you get eleven songs that have a lot to say for them in term of tone, and lyrical content and musicality... but don't quite have any hooks or riffs that you can get hold off. They just meander along quite nicely with a sense of good old British cynicism. I must say, and this isn't the album I expected to say it about but, it's mixed really well! There's a lot of instrumentation and the drums and backing vocals and horns and everything all sound really clear and distinct! So basically, I want to like it more than I do. I'll try some other Kinks stuff, but I have a feeling they might be a "singles band" for me. Interestingly, I just read the two songs I liked ("Brainwashed" was a distant second) were chosen for the A-side and B-side for the American single off of this album. Brainwashed reminds me of "Modern Life is Rubbish" era Blur - so I guess when they were trying to "sound British" they just wanted to sound like The Kinks!
I really tried with this one but not for me….
Like explaining the Custard Cream to anyone outside the UK
Beatles cover band
Wel een geinig album, leuk voor de eenmalige listen
Is this consumer-obsessed society we've built on the blood of soldiers worth it? The fear at the center of all our frenzied consumption hangs like a pall over our white-washed suburban lives, and we stagnate in our gardens as the walls of our empire fall around our ears.
Calité de The Kinks. Review firmada por Alfredo Duro.
Ach nö...
Listened from Auckland. Kazoo! Generally enjoyable. Harmonically interesting.
Fun
If my kink was catchy, not bad but fairly average albums, then this would be an easy 5.
I like The Kinks and I enjoyed this album. I don't believe I've ever owned an album but then and I'm not sure why.
British-Invasion-Light
I didn't like the first 5 songs... too jaded, pure pop sound. Brainwashed was the first hint of what the Kinks were capable of. Good track. That was about it - one song I liked. However, for that era, I like them more than the Beatles. So, a 2 will do
Very vibey. Enjoyed listening to this
I’m pretty sure I’ve liked everything I’ve heard by The Kinks so far, so it’s quite straightforward in saying that I’m hopeful for today’s album. I don’t recognise any song titles here, so everything could feel new to me. Still hard to believe they are a 60s band. Songs I already knew: none Favourites: Yes Sir No Sir, She’s Bought A Hat Like Princess Marina I’m a real sucker for a concept album, seemingly especially ones where things start bright and get sad. This album reminds me a fair bit of one of my favourites: S.F. Sorrow by The Pretty Things. It’s truly hard to fault any of this album. Perhaps some songs might not stand out so much on their own, but listening as a full album is such a delight. It’s so interesting to me that this is the same band that did You Really Got Me - still a very good song in its own right, but so very different to this album.
An interesting concept album. I don't think I'd listen to individual tracks necessarily but at a whole it's very cohesive. Standout track: Yes Sir, No Sir
The kinks are turning into one of my favourite bands due to this site! Every other album seems more greater than the one before. This one is no exception. From the exceptional opener Victoria to Shangri-La to Arthur and everything in between! Fantastic album by an amazing band! 9 out of 10
Not special.
Loved this album! Makes me feel good! 4 stars
Got bored of this album after the first song. Very forgettable music. I had something I was going to say but I forgot. 4/10
Meh. I'm on vacation and don't feel like writing up a large thing but I felt very 50/50 on this album. Nothing new to write home about. 5/10
Never really listened to The Kinks, I know of them and have heard some songs. On the outside they sound Beatlesy but like more psychedelic rockish. “Australia” is a fucking delightful banger, what a weird masterpiece. We have heard some albums that sound kind of similar to this but there was just more in this one than the others. A strange mix of a bunch of different genres and sounds from the 60/70s that make up a fairly satisfying album. 8/10
Political
This was just kinda there noise in the background didn’t care for it but did not hate it either.
I liked this. Old school rock and kinda punk-ish. 3.5/5
Fine, but not anything I'd relisten to.
surprising album
Catchy songs with a good political message.
Top ten for me I have this one on vinyl and I treasure it
As if 70 Beatles albums weren't enough.
I wish I was one of those people who felt done with an album 3 songs deep, alas I am struck by an affliction that forces me to finish albums no matter how bad and boring they are I am currently halfway through but I need to vent by submitting my review now. No, the remaining half will not change my mind
Great album
An immediate and effective concept album. Beginning with Victoria, the juxtapose the Victorian British Empire ideals with the reality of day to day life in modern (for the time) Britain, in a funny anecdotal style that epitomises The Kinks. Maybe my favourite Rock Opera Album that I have listened to. The story and lyrics are as evocative today as they were in the 60's.
They are trying so hard to make their point heard, and it gets a bit tired being hit over the head with it on every track. The chorus of Shangri-La is the best on the album so far Did you know this is a protest album? The Kinks would like to remind you once again that this is a protest album.
I liked the instrumentals on this album well enough, but I think the draw is certainly the thematic elements. As opposed to the contemporaries that I have listened to plenty (e.g., The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, etc.), the Kinks "Arthur" is the first album I've heard from the 60's that is so dang...British. Plenty of the themes are applicable to the states, sadly; however, I can only imagine that I'd appreciate this album a whole lot more over tea. Fav Tracks: Australia, Shangri-La, & She's Bought a Hat Like Princess Marina
altogether decent. classic rock.
Listened in Madison at work
5/5
Decent effort by the Kinks bit not their best. A bit repetitive and the storytelling is better on other albums
It's fine.
I thought it was going to be more of a punk album with the name like the kinks but it was really nice guitars and melodies. I enjoyed it
A British Invasion concept album about a very British everyman. Our protagonist loves being British, goes to war for a bit, thinks about moving to Australia, opines on home ownership and the empire, and copies a princess's style. Do you get that it's all very British? This is the rare album where I actually liked the back half better than the front half. "Victoria" is a good start, but I struggled a bit with the war songs at the beginning. "Drivin'" is one of the singles from the album and it's a bit chaotic musically. Once we get to "Australia" though things start to turn a bit and it gets pretty fun. The juxtaposition of "She's Bought a Hat Like Princess Marina" and "Young and Innocent Days" is really striking. The former playing up these goofy horns and then it launches right into a beautiful song reflecting on time passed. I can't quite decide how I feel about this. It's a bit all over the place (and almost painfully British), but the narrative is tight and the varied sound works as a metaphor for what a life is like. "Arthur" finishes strong too; "Somebody loves you, don't ya know it". Favorite song: Shangri-La Other: Victoria, Drivin', Australia, She's Bought a Hat Like Princess Marina, Young and Innocent Days, Nothing to Say, Arthur 12/1/23
solid record. few very cool songs and the others were alright. solid
I like the Kinks a lot and have flitted between a 3 and a 4 here, they have better albums. They have an uncanny ability to have sections of almost comical, upbeat music that then turns into a lovely, melancholy melody. Like being at a village fair but everyone suddenly starts crying.
Decent. Can see why people would love it but not my cup of tea.
This ripped. The first song (Victoria) was far and away my favorite, so I thought this might be one of my favorite albums ever. The songs after that first one didn't hit the same highs, but I enjoyed all of them. I'd give this 4.5 if I could. I really want this to crack my long-term listening rotation, but I'm not sure if it'll get all the way there.
Easy to listen to, but the songs all blurred together into sameness after a while. I knew there was some social commentary in there, but it was a bit difficult to relate to. Victoria is pretty catchy.
I can definitely see how they influenced so many bands. It's an amazing album.
In the past few days, there weren't albums that drew my attention that much, but this album was pretty great. I like the "Drivin’" and "Shangri-La". I was surprised that there ain't many listeners of this album. Thank god that I could encounter this album.
A lot of war themes. Focused on the stories it tells with the lyrics. Nice musical aspect as well. Less popular than I expected an album on this list to be, but I enjoyed it. Will listen more to form a better opinion, but first impressions are pretty good. Has just enough Britishness for it not to be too overwhelming, much better than Blur. From seeing their discography this one doesn't seem to be one of their most successful so I'll give a try with the other ones sometime as well. Feel a bit overwhelmed though with all the music to listen to rn lol. In general pretty good, didn't completely blow away as of now, but good :) 7/10
I liked it. It was nice. My brain needs breathing room to process the amount of music I intake daily, so this album is mostly a pleasant blur of sounds rn.
The album starts off with the great song Victoria and doesnt let up from there.
not my thing
Didn't connect with me as much as other music from The Kinks
Two and a half, I guess. I respect this Britrock thing, but it doesn't really move me much. Feels like a period piece. Would listen to other Kinks, though.
This is a lot more poppy than I thought it would be. Some of the vocals were pitchy but it's still a good album.
I know a bit of the Kinks, but with the exception of Drivin', all tracks on this album are new to me. Victoria is good, Drivin' is good, though a bit bouncy, and I really like Shangri-La. Cover reminds me of Monty Python's opening montage. But on the whole the album is not that exciting. My true score falls somewhere between a 2 and a 3, but I'll record a 3 since it's better than the albums I've scored as 2.
I only know a handful of The Kinks songs. Going into this what I expected was not what i got. Album was a good vibe but it did give my expectations whiplash.
6.5/10 - More politically active than I expected, and it was interesting to hear rock that sounds like the Beatles but is very explicitly criticizing various aspects of Britain. Interesting for this reason, but not my something I would choose to listen to very often. Favorites - 1. Nothing to Say 2. Victoria 3. Drivin’ 4. Shangri-La 5. Yes Sir, No Sir
Really is very good. Best song - Yes sir, no sir
Victoria is from this one hey? never knew that. Works much better than Tommy, all the songs here are pretty good. Not totally fair since writing a rock opera about a middle class English family suits the Kinks more than anyone. Cool messy guitar in the left speaker of the last song. I think for me as a listener 'concept album' type stuff is nearly always going to be worse. I'd like songs like Nothing to Say more if they didn't fit in a narrative sequence. Linear lyrical structure isn't what I come to music for. Rounding up to 4 for Victoria. It is kinda funny that the best song on a nostalgia story is the first track. music: appreciated. (⌐◯_◯)
Coincidentally got this not long after Tommy. I ripped The Who for biting off more than they could chew… only to hear the Kinks do something kinda similar and, I think, do it a lot more artfully.
enjoyable, eclectic to some extent and comfy. really liked that guitars, and Shangri-La
Didn't like at very first listen. But they definitely grew on me. Sort of a lazy Sunday album, nice and relaxing.
I was looking at other people's reviews while listening to this. And one stuck out especially. "Bit twee." Yup. That about sums it up. I'm not British (though I do live in the UK now, but I feel like the vibe of this album doesn't quite hit the right way if you're not a nostalgic brit of a certain age. Very catchy, and Victoria is really good, but I couldn't really move past how quaint the whole album sounds. Bit twee.
great!
This album was awful. Songs were annoying to listen to, and musically beige.
For a band that essentially created punk this was a more art infused album.
Very british rock
This isn't the Kinks album for me and I hope that we see them again.
Good 60s rock...that's about it
First time listen. In background, thought a couple of songs were the Beatles.
This album is anachronistic in all the worst ways. It's not only that it's from a long bygone era, it's that I can't even see the influence. When I listened to Motörhead, it's easy to hear the foundations of music that came after. The same goes for the Donovan album; not my cup of tea, but it's interesting, unique, and one can hear why it was popular in its time. This album is none of those things. It drags, it's boring, and I cannot understand why this band is heralded as influential.
Another Kinks concept album which, like the other ones, is better than all the concept albums by prog rock bands that would come later.
I really liked this one. Stories were fun, music was bouncy.
This was a lot of fun. Like a mashup between the Beatles and Monty python. Very whimsical.
This isn't my favorite Kinks album but they're always underrated.
Very British. Album reminded me and Fran of the beetles.
Gem: Victoria, every song enjoyable
As a compliment, this is basically just a very lively Beatles album.
Verdient nog een luister sessie
3.5
So, this is like the sequel to the village green preservation society? This is good. Funky and witty and mean at points. It's got a flair for the dramatic and it's shaken off the stodgy music hall element that made village green a bit difficult to listen to. It's like Monty Python. It's weird and it changes repeatedly and it's sweet in an odd kind of way. 4.5/5. Strong album.
Starts with an absolute banger. Lots of poking at the comfortable class.
Favourite songs: Victoria, "Yes Sir, No Sir", Some Mother's Son, Shangri-La, Mr. Churchill Says, Arthur Least favourite songs: Australia 4/5
Some really good ones on here i liked it
The album was meh.
Nothing new, not even an interesting twist
De LOIN le meilleur album que j'ai eu de The Kinks à date. Les compositions sont tellement plus attrayantes, musicalement plus développées, généralement beaucoup plus entraînant. J'ai beaucoup plus l'impression d'écouter un album rock entièrement étoffé que ceux du passé. Une très belle découverte, je dirais aussi qu'il y a un très bon potentiel de réécoute. 8/10
"Some Mother's Son"
Enjoyed it, reminded me a lot of the Beatles, which makes sense since they're from a similar same place and time.
Really fun rock opera. Huge fan of the kinks so this was a no brainer.
Average
Victoria is good Austrailia was ok but too long. This might just be the new belle and sebastian album
Seems culturally significant for it's time, lots of war protest messaging. The art reminds me of Monty Python (though not the same artist). It's good.
Always a sucker for concept albums, interesting story that it is inspired by his sister and brother in law. Musically quite good as well
Victooooooooooooria! VICTOOOOOOOOOOORIA! The Kinks vinden de connectie tussen The Beatles en Monty Python's the Holy Grail. Misschien niet mijn favoriete Kinks plaat maar toch 4 voor dit geslaagd huwelijk. Gaat hier nog wel eens opstaan.
Ik kende The Kinks uiteraard maar van enkele nummers en heb het verder nooit een kans gegeven, al was dat niet bewust. Daarom was dit wel een extra leuke "ontdekking". Wel had ik iets te vaak het gevoel naar een minder goeie versie van the Beatles te luisteren.
Leuk!
no
Highlights: Australia. In a nutshell: a concept album that doesn't hit the target. I'd say skip Arthur and go to "The Kinks Are The Village Green Preservation Society" (a better album that pokes fun at British culture). Overall: 4/10
At first it sounded like a bag of hipster feed but eventually I was boppin along and it was aight
This is like a worse version of the Beatles but that’s still kinda good
While the sound was likely revolutionary at the time, it has since been replicated so often by other bands as to unfairly seem a bit generic now. But for what it is, it’s still classic.
1. Victoria - weird singing style for me. The music is ok. 2. Yes Sir, No Sir - interesting concept for a song. 3. Some Mother’s Son - not that memorable. 4. Drivin’ - this one was ok, very 60s pop to me. 5. Brainwashed - I like the instrumental of this one and it’s sound, esp guitar. 6. Australia - did not love this one, 7. Shangri-La - the second half is kinda boppy. Interesting lyrics 8. Mr. Churchill Says - this one had bits I liked. 9. She’s Bought a Hat Like Princess Marina - this one is weird to me. 10. Young and Innocent Days - not that memorable 11. Nothing to Say - I liked this one 12. Arthur - good closer Overall didn’t live the style of singing, but I always like a concept album. Sometimes I really liked the music and how it changed but other times it wasn’t that memorable
Starts off with promise but fades. Similar to Beatles with some goofy pop. Some individual songs are good.
Ehh not my favorite... 5/10
Liked it, didn't know any songs beforehand but do like The Kinks songs that I've heard. Would consider listening to again
I'm really fucking with the Kinks. They're like the beatles if the beatles didn't take so much LSD lmao
Excellent
Meh
While I wasn't a fan of the overall production of the album, I appreciated the energy, the chunky guitar rhythms, and depth and subject matter of them lyrics. Not something I could find myself listening to regularly.
Sort of like the The Who
Love the Kinks. Not my favorite album though.
Ja fun maar very british idk of ik dit echt op zou zetten
i had never really listened to the kinks, i didn’t realize they were from the beatles era. i assumed they were from the punk times. easy listening!!
1. Concept and Themes: The album revolves around the story of Arthur Morgan, a fictional character created by the band's lead singer and songwriter, Ray Davies. The narrative explores the life of an average Englishman, Arthur, and his experiences in post-World War II Britain. It serves as a poignant commentary on the changing social, political, and cultural landscape of the country. The concept allows for a deep exploration of themes like class struggle, nostalgia, and the evolving British identity. 2. Musical Style: "Arthur" features the distinctive sound that The Kinks are known for, a blend of rock, pop, and folk. Ray Davies' songwriting prowess is at the forefront, and his ability to craft catchy melodies with sharp, observational lyrics shines throughout the album. The Kinks' signature guitar work, vocal harmonies, and Davies' storytelling abilities make the music both accessible and thought-provoking. 3. Standout Tracks: "Victoria": This opening track is an upbeat, catchy ode to the British monarchy and sets the tone for the album. "Shangri-La": A highlight of the album, this song explores the concept of the perfect life and satirizes the pursuit of the suburban dream. "Some Mother's Son": A moving and powerful anti-war ballad, it reflects on the sacrifices of young soldiers and the impact of war on families. "Australia": A bittersweet and heartfelt song about emigration and the longing for home. "Arthur": The titular track beautifully encapsulates the character's life and the album's central theme. 4. Social Commentary: Ray Davies' songwriting on "Arthur" is a sharp critique of British society. He paints a vivid picture of the working-class struggle, societal expectations, and the pursuit of the British dream. The album serves as a poignant reflection on the post-war era and the changing national identity. 5. Legacy and Impact: "Arthur" didn't achieve immediate commercial success upon its release, but it has gained recognition over the years as a classic concept album. Its influence can be heard in subsequent works by artists exploring similar themes and storytelling in their music. The album also highlights The Kinks' unique place in the British Invasion of the 1960s, distinct from other bands like The Beatles and The Rolling Stones. In conclusion, "Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire)" is a significant achievement in The Kinks' career. It's a brilliant concept album that offers a thoughtful and often satirical exploration of British society in the 1960s. Its enduring quality and insightful lyrics have solidified its place in the pantheon of classic rock albums, making it a must-listen for any fan of the genre or those interested in the history and culture of post-war Britain.
J’ai parfois l’impression d’entendre un jeune Paul McCartney. Un album cohérent dans ses thématiques et textes mutins. J’aime quand le versant rock se fait plus prononcé.
the kinks can be so fucking predictable
Mid
Topical
went back to listen to some of it again idk why i liked it but i certainly did
Wow, wasn't expecting to enjoy this album this as much as I did. Haven't really heard much of the Kinks, but they sound like a more punk Beatles. Thought the concept album was cool, based on a working class life in post war England. Gonna have to listen to more of The Kinks. 4.5/5
For it’s time this was an excellent album. A much underrated band
It was okay. Not the best work the kinks have done. Victoria was the high point. 3/5
Great Value Beatles, but Shangri-La is excellent. I was leaning towards a 2 but the second half won me over.
Excellent for relaxing
I was not expecting to like this as much as I did, but I loved it. A win for this project.
It's cool to learn about how the Kinks helped to popularize concept albums and their interesting approach to music during a "slump" before Lola. It's whimsical, serious, emotional... a very worthwhile listen. 3.5/5
I love it. Found myself singing along Standout tracks: Victoria, Mr Churchill Says, Nothing to Say
Kinks are really growing on me!
Boring and it sounds uninspired.
не мое гнусавый голос, не всегда чистый вокал, который попадает в свою же гармонию.
pretty catchy
Very fun! Bouncy great music but by the third listen I was skipping g songs to not hear em again.
Great album
Did not like it at all
Decent Kinks album, but none of the hits I know. I'm not quite getting why they chose this one for the 1001 albums list.
The Kinks are really great. I’ve never listened to this album before, bar Victoria (a bop), but I thoroughly thoroughly enjoyed it. Will definitely be listening again. Might make it to 5 stars in the future.
Never actually listened to this as an album before. It's great!
The Kinks are a 'hit or miss' band for me and this is a mega HIT. This has everything in every track. Blues psych brit pop with the goofiest darkest lyrics
Started off strong, but fell apart as it went on. Victoria is a smash though
Nice listen. If in the mood for Kinks, no reason to pick any other album.
Australian Beatles!
The kinks are great. Never heard this album. Before but I very much enjoyed it. Felt reminiscent of listening to the oldies radio station
Really clean vocals and a classic rock sound. A must listen and a very enjoyable album. (81%)
Pretty solid!
I don't quite understand why this album was picked. Kinks contributed a lot to musical development at the time, but perhaps not this one?
No thanks. For me, this was the least enjoyable Kinks record I've heard. Borderline unlistenable.
first listen it's good
The opening to this album rocked. Lots of great tracks on here, particularly the high energy tracks were great. Easy listening all the way through.
Boo
I like this one. Lots of hooks and melody. There’s a pervasive Englishness that might turn some people off but I think it creates a distinct mood and style (and, obviously, it fits the concept). Good songwriting. Best song: Australia
一般般，已经没有什么印象了
I hadn't heard the Kinks before today. Gotta say, it's really meh. A lot of bands tried to sound like the Beatles. This was not a good attempt.
I don’t think this genre is really for me, but I really loved the tracks that stood out to me (Victoria, Some Mother’s Son, Shangri-La, Arthur). Some Mother’s Son in particular made me have to stop what I was doing and sit still while I listened to it, it was incredibly powerful. Driving and Australia felt really dire though.
Pretty great.
I'm not quite sure why The Kinks are often overlooked in classic rock. This album is better than anything I've ever heard from the Stones, and yet I'd never heard a single song before.
Another rock album from the 60s... It's fine, but not my vibe. I did like Brainwashed though. 2.5/5
Jangly
Not my type of rock, too many beatle's like songs but it was good from start to end at least
My favorite album by The Kinks yet. Fun listen with goofy lyrics. Added to playlist: Victoria
Great classic rock music.
Väldigt välskrivet. The Kinks fångar klassiskt brittiskt låtskrivande bättre än någon annan. Vid sina tillfällen tar albumet lite skeva vändningar som jag inte älskar. Jävligt bra album ändå.
Eh. Some good songs, but I found myself bored and struggling to listen to the end. I think The Kinks are a greatest hits band for me, I don't need to listen to whole albums.
no
weird and happy
Album 18 I am familiar with some of more well-known songs by The Kinks and have wanted to explore their discography as I don’t know them as well as The Beatles or the Rolling Stones. I did not know any songs from this album, nor had I ever heard of it. By the second or third song, I picked up on the fact that it was a concept album about someone looking back on their life, often through world events and politics. I enjoyed listening to it, and never found myself looking to skip a song. Concept albums aren’t always winners, but this one was. Admittedly, when it ended, I wasn’t sure how to feel. Sad? Content? Nostalgic? I would have to listen to it again. 4.5* rounded down to 4* - Great album
Teniendo una canción que se llame Arthur, cómo no voy a darle un 5.
9/4/2023
Pretty good, nice tunes.
Another really good album.
Sound very similar to the Beatles, not a knock on them, as their subject matter was a bit different.
This was almost a 4. Good album, some of the more theatrical songs bring it down a bit
Forgettable
Fantastic storytelling
Folksy through and through, really liked the last track (Arthur)
Victoria är skitbra, nothing to say också.
I like the Kinks and this is an enjoyable album while touching providing social and political commentary on the British Empire. Victoria is the standout song.
I respect it, the message was probably stronger then, and the music is a bit two-dimensional.
Es no bueno
I've always enjoyed the Kinks. They've always had that sarcastic, tongue-in-cheek tone in their songs, like there's something more there than they're letting on. But honestly, I'm more into the later Kinks: 1976 or so to the late 80s. The early stuff, when the band were doing more concept albums, I never fully got into. Part of the problem is that I should have read about the concept album beforehand. I did not fully realize the story here and the album itself didn't really make it clear either. Part of it also might be because I'm not British, so some of the stuff I wasn't getting. The songs themselves? I liked most of the songs, probably my favorite was "Victoria" and "Australia." I liked how "Australia" went off in different directions. "Drivin' " kinda... yeah, I was not fond of that one in particular. So the songs separately I liked, but as a cohesive whole I did not see the story and the connections. And that's a problem for an album if you don't "get" it. Maybe I need to listen to it again. The songs were decent, and I liked them, just not enough to go "wow!"
Clearly a 3, is it a 4? I'm always a big fan of concept albums, though I have to get the concept. I think this one was fairly evident after a listen or two. On first listen I was trying to figure out what Victoria was all about - fun song (maybe the best on the album) and cheeky lyrics but what was the point? And it became more obvious as I kept listening. It kind of reminded me of the SF Sorrow album in that certain characters were of to war, but the songs are punchier (Yes Sir, No Sir) or deeper (Some Mother's Son). Overall this album is more energetic and cohesive than SF Sorrow. I didn't love everything but I dug a bunch of tracks, some more uptempo (Brainwashed, Australia, Mr. Churchill says, Nothing to Say) and some a little more sombre (Young and Innocent Days). I quite liked Arthur too and wondered why it wasn't the first songs, so as to set the stage. But realizing this was supposed to be a tv soundtrack, I can also see how this is a recap/closing credits kind of song. I've always thought the Kinks had qualities in the Beatles in them and I think you hear that on this album - different styles, solid lyrics, solid playing, and a thoughtful attempt at putting together an album that is connected from song to song. A solid rock opera/musical.
This album has been compared to The Who's Tommy (which came out earlier in the year). I hear it, but it definitely lacks something in comparison. Part of it could just be that there's an element of goofiness to the Kinks' music. The Who are hard hitting, the Kinks are goofy. That said, this is a fun album. The Kinks are a pre-cursor to punk and even though the album doesn't sound all that much like punk (it has a pretty dated 60s sound), it has the punk spirit (a good example is "Yes Sir, No Sir"). Overall, this is a fun album that I might revisit, but definitely not a 5, mainly because I think it lacks depth. Favorite tracks: Victoria (catchy), Australia (the lyrical section is tongue-in-cheek, but it's the instrumental second half that I think is great - awesome, funky, rocking section), Mr. Churchill Says (good rocker), Drivin' (fun music, somewhat dark lyrics - speaking of dark lyrics, Some Mother's Son was pretty powerful, but the song itself was kinda meh), and Brainwashed (another "fun" sounding song with somewhat dark lyrics). I had mixed feelings about Shangri-La. I liked the acoustic guitar part at the beginning, but by the end the song seemed all over the place (and at one point sounded like a rip-off of Tales of Brave Ulysses).
This album has a niche. I think it needs more than one listen to appreciate.
Mmh.....
Alright
Very Beatles-esque which was the style at the time. Unique in it's own way for sure though. Probably requires a second listen through to fully vet.
What the fuck are these guys saying? This sounds like the elevator music on the way to purgatory.
Fun album!
Fun, not a bad album. 3/5
Solid
нормас, приятные 60ые
Чуваки продолжали пилить концептуальщину. Здесь она более прямая, более понятная, оттого мне кажется, она проиграла по наполнению и вариативности. Но выиграла по качеству звука, прям прогресс заметен, бЕшЕнЫй. Стерео всё равно осталось, но ладно...
Копипейст прошлого ревью, но то будто даже лучше было
Victoria & Shangri-La were decent, just couldn't get into the album
Favourite tracks: victoria; Arthur
каждый раз удивляюсь что кинкс намного приятнее звучат чем в моей голове. но нарратив не успела осознать, поэтому не прониклась
liked it. concept was interesting throughout and the 4 song stretch in the middle was fantastic, brainwashed is a personal favorite. didn't blow my mind, but might come back once or twice. Favs - Brainwashed - Shangri La - Victoria
ya des bon bangers, victoria, shangri-la ya aussi des daubes
I am really enjoying being exposed to the bands from around this time that arent the Beatles. They're all I knew for so long, its great to hear their contemporaries. This album was good, but the guys voice would go from good to goofy too much. The song about the Mother's Sons was very sad :(
Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire) by The Kinks is a brilliant and ambitious concept album that showcases the band's storytelling genius. Released in 1969, it tells the compelling tale of Arthur Morgan, a character navigating the complexities of post-war England. The album features a mix of rock, folk, and music hall influences, with tracks like "Victoria" and "Shangri-La" standing out as masterpieces. Ray Davies' songwriting and vocals are exceptional, creating a vivid and nostalgic picture of British life. The album's production is warm and rich, adding to its immersive experience. While not as widely known as some of their other works, Arthur is a captivating and underrated gem in The Kinks' discography.
So then, the search for the definitive Kinks album recommences. Could Arthur be the one? I’d never heard of it before, but it makes a compelling case. Victoria maintains the apparent one-classic-per-record quota that led me to believe they were primarily just a very strong singles band. But no - this is a consistent, cohesive collection, more so than Face to Face. The Britishness they portray so well is at its most explicit here, treading the fine lines between biting and humorous, rocky and twee. I think the comparisons with The Who’s Tommy are fair, as is the observation that, while Tommy is slightly bigger in scope and ambition, Arthur is bigger on good tunes and fun. I’d rather hang out with Arthur.
Decent album. Favorite track was Victoria and it was a good upbeat tune. All around a good album.
Nope
Yea, it was good. Nothing crazy, good right band. Yea, fine. 3 stars
Awesome
Burn the monarchy
I like the Kinks but I’ve never heard these songs. The album starts really well and Brainwashed is a real high. The production and arrangements are really satisfying and the drums really pack a punch. The album keeps you hooked throughout with unexpected movements in the songs. Considering how it was really fresh and enjoyable for me having not heard it before, it’s earned a 5/5.
Coole titel, toffe muziek en goede lengte maar er mist nog iets ofzo idk
Another 4 that is very close to a 3. The only song that I really like is “Shangri-La”, which I do really like, but usually 4s have more songs I like. This is also sort of because I gave Village Green 3 stars and now I would probably give it 5. I think this might be my last Kinks album on this list as well.
It was OK, nothing stood out as exceptional. Beatles inspired classic rock but not as good as the Beatles. They sound more like the poppy earlier Beatles albums but do have some moments inspired by Sgt Pepper.
Tired of all this Brit rock, god damn
Kinks can do no wrong in my eyes!
All hail King Arthur! One of the more underrated albums by one of the more underrated bands of all time. I think the debate should be, “Kinks or Beatles?” Not, “Stones or Beatles?” This one does get a bit weighty at times, but even the slower tracks have redeeming qualities to them. It’s weird and poppy with vocals that keep you hanging on every word.
Leaders of the British Invasion look within, setting sail on a new, conceptual conquest against foes of their own making.
Dare I say it? I think this may be The Kinks’ best work. Hadn’t listened to it in years and loved rediscovering this masterpiece. So good!
Another fantastic album by The Kinks after their brilliant their Village Green...LP. They were at the peak of their careers at this time. This rock musical has great storytelling, music, production. It really has it all.
Classic Kinks. Victoria and Shangri-La stand outs.
I found this album both fascinating and fun. I would have never come across it if not for 1001. This is a Kinks' concept album, a score to a movie that never saw a projector's light. Likely because of that, these songs didn't get much radio play. The tracks are quite varied, with nice changes in melody, key, and rhythm, helping to maintain a lighthearted, playful quality. The Kinks introduce new instruments and sounds throughout the album, sometimes in the middle of songs. "Arthur" shows the Kinks at their quirkiest and most charming.
Some good tracks. Some not great
I was disappointed by the last Kinks album I listened to, so didn’t have high expectations for this one. But it was a masterpiece.
christ these guys leveled up since Something Else
A pleasant 60s rock album from a band that sat closely next to the Beatles during their time. This one will sit closely to the rest of the concept albums from the summer of love: near the top with its brethren.
It's clever and funny,conceptually cohesive with good messages but I still don't fully love it. Occasionally a bit too kitsch, but with some decent tracks here and there. The concept speaks for itself tbh. 19/06/23
2.5/5. This was fine. I like some albums from The Kinks, but this was one a little off for me.
i liked it a lot actually
A great album. Nothing unexpected here and a few lovely songs.
Very Beatles like
ahhhh
v cool
Better than I thought it would be.
Fun and easy to enjoy. 4/5
Pretty darn good. Reminds me of a certain other british band from the 60s. First half is filled with bangers, then they get a little silly with it. Enjoyable and sounds great for the 60s Score: 80 Art: 80
These kinky British boys are pretty talented. This had some great lyrics and melodies. 3.5
I would like to be one of those guys that says they prefer The Kinks over The Beatles or whatever, I actually tried to be that guy, but I can't get myself to fully commit with that band. When they it the right spot, they're absolutely magical. Take Victoria, Yes Sir No Sir and Shangri-La from that particular album, this is some of the best rock music you'll ever get to hear in your life. But sadly I don't think they have an album that keeps that magic from beginning to end, and some of their songs sounds kind of generic to me, like I can't even remember after repeated listens. But yeah, there are some outstanding moments on this and it's worth listening to it for those songs alone.
The Beatles for people who can't afford The Beatles.
Very surprising and pleasant. A flourishing album of great and various arrangements and beautiful melodies. The interpretation of the songs is done with so much enthusiasm, it shows in the recording. I smile all the way through.
Cuando arrancó pensé que la iba a romper, pero me terminó decpcionando. Me quedó un sabor amargo con este disco.
it's alright but i didn't really enjoy it that much
Never listened to a kinks album before! Really good! A punk Beatles?!?
The best album of the last 5.
So fine
This had an extended Day in the Life vibe for me. Good narrative. Good music.
Hadn't realised 'Victoria' was a Kinks song. Enjoyed listening to this despite not being a big Kinks fan.
Just look at the lyrics. Brilliant!!! What do they write for a standard album? Need to check them definetely. Need more drive for 5 stars.
No
fun beatles type
Kinks got way better stuff out there, this one isn't it. Still a big Kinks fan though.
This album was a refreshing 60’s surprise. It’s remastered recording on Spotify sounded just about perfect. Excellent drums and acoustics in the studio for this recording. Most of the songs are not radio hits, but the lyrics and song construction seem to be pre-post-modern rock. I couldn’t help but think this was a recent recording in the style of the 60’s. Enjoyed the whole listen. 4.4/5
I absolutely loved this. Lots of anti-war ideas here, which is so relevant today unfortunately. War is truly hell. The only thing I couldn’t get was the concept album portion. It didn’t seem like a concept album to me. Nevertheless, I really enjoyed this.
Theatrical with great melodies. Standouts: Shangri-La; She’s Bought A Hat …; Nothing to Say. 4/5.
Beatles footsteps? Anyway, did king artur came a lot?
Me: I want to listen to some great music to drown out my thoughts. Arthur (Or the Decline and Fall of the British Empire): NOPE! And it’s from 1969! Misleadingly fun instrumentals, gut-wrenching overall.
Haven’t heard this album before, let’s see how it is. Love it, catchy songs
Like the Beatles
Some amazing songs, some throwaway tracks, some annoying lyrics, good production. Could have been 5 stars but struggled to get 4 because it was frustrating at times. Favs: Some Mother's Son, Shangri-La
Lola and You Really Got Me are so over-played there’s no way to critique them: they just are. At some point I heard other Kinks songs and discovered what a great band they are. This album isn’t as good as Village Green…, but it has great songs and is very English to boot. I love how funny and playful they can be, without being silly. They do a great job of writing about small little details and opening them up to be about something bigger.
Oi bruv Classic rock
some great tracks, some that were just decent, but overall some very high highs, mature kinks album
Really enjoyed, sounded like The Beatles at times which was interesting. Going to listen to more of The Kinks now.
Listening to this album is like traveling around the world. Music is pretty avg.
Victoria!
Pretty super, loved the tracks about war
Good, different, nice album overall
Heard it before?: No Enjoy it?: Yeah, very strong vocal performances and classic sound Favourite song: Track 6 - Australia
I probably won't listen to the album again, but I could see going back to make a connection.
The kinks are always solid, and this album is no different. Really good production for 1969. All in all, nothing earth shattering, but nothing to complain about either.
basically the median kinks album — still solid, still impressive, but nothing mindblowing. i liked it, though!
I enjoyed the 60s rock aspect of this album, it was fun
Ninguna canción de este disco está entre las 10 más oídas de Spotify pero empieza bien con "Victoria". Lo siento pero se va a quedar en 2 estrellas, hay mejores discos de ellos que oír.
The contemporary reviews say this is one of the best concept albums ever made. Better than Tommy, released the same year. I may agree with the latter, but I'm not getting the "concept album" part of this. I comprehend the lyrical themes, but the musical sinew that would normally link a concept album together doesn't seem to be there, to my mind. I dunno. Maybe I'm missing something? While it's definitely not a collection of songs like so many albums, it's also not a tight through line. Perhaps I'll listen to it more.
Incrivel!!
Really liked this album.
Rock, with a good mix of instrumentation (horns particularly)
Though the TV special it was intended to soundtrack never materialized, Arthur still stands on its own as a fully formed and beautifully realized story. Exploring the trepidation of moving to a new country, the devastation of war, and the sneaking suspicion that life isn’t as happy as it seems, Ray Davies pens some of his most aching and revealing songs.
Yes!
Good old fashioned 60's British quirky rock. Some hits and odd Beatlesque tracks. A bit dated now.
Pas de kinks shaming
j'ai voulu mettre 4 au début mais ca devient vite un peu kitschos non ?
Another great Kinks album, and not only the hit singles but also tracks like Yes Sir, No Sir. A timeless classic.
My favourite Kinks album so far. Cheered me right up.
Entertaining album, very musical.
The Kinks are maybe my favourite discovery from this site.
Fantastic album! Much better than I expected. Before this, I only knew 4-5 of their songs. Almost every song is great. I especially loved the drum work. "Some Mother's Son" brought the album down a bit with the gruesome subject matter, but the rest more than made up for it. 5/5 Hard to choose a favorite, maybe "Shangri-La"?
I like a lot of the songs by The Kinks but it was difficult for me to get through this album for some reason. I just feel like this album is too "British" for me to get it. It falls flat for me.
så stopper vi
I'll forgive this album for being less than stellar after yesterdays album. I think we just recently got a Kinks album but I'm learning I'm not a huge fan. I know what sound they are going for, I've just heard it better from others.
Few too many Kinks in this 1001 Albums hose. Our third, and it's diminishing returns. They aren't bad, but I don't find them very interesting. The decline and fall of the British domination of popular music is more appropriate. A couple tracks I did take away from here, one of which was maybe entirely instrumental. I'm good on these guys. Favorite tracks: Australia, Nothing to Say. Album art: What do we got here: a mug, a band photo, a swan, a kettle, a hand holding a flag of the band name? What does it all mean? I don't know, but I do enjoy this art style. This is a pretty cool cover. 2.5/5
Unlike some other of the 60s albums, I was able to get into this one. I could listen to the lyrics and I felt that it was effective. 4/5
it's meh