Reviews (page 5 of 14)
Just wow. What an amazing voice. I also really love the authenticity of the performance and the crowd. Just a really special album
5.5/10 - She has a great voice. She oozes charm and charisma. She made a fun live album. This was probably awesome in 1957 or if you love jazz.
Sarah Vaughan's voice sounds great live, but the songs don't blow me away. It's nice. 7/10
September in the rain - 4 Willow weep for me - 3 Just one of those things - 3 Be anything but darling be mine - 4 Thou swell - 3 Stairway to the stars - 3 Honeysuckle rose - 4 Just a gigolo - 3 How high the moon - 3
Amazing voice, impressive skills from the players, still just don't like jazz.
I'm sure this was the shit in 1957 but I found it super boring. Beautiful voice but you get the jist of it within a song or two.
not rlly an album but a good experience still. I want to visit this so-called "Famous Mr.Kelly's". First song was my favorite, and I liked that she had a lot of commentary--makes it sound like I'm sitting in the bar listening to her play right in front of me
This is a live album from 1957, and I felt the sound quality was good given the age of the album. Sarah Vaughn always has been considered a jazz singer, but she did all kinds of music. She does have a jazzy way of singing, though. There are some good Sarah Vaughn songs, but none of them are on this album.
Been awhile since one of my classic switcheroos, but here it is... I've been mixing up Sarah Brightman and Sarah Vaughn. This live jazz album from the 50s cleared things right up, though. (Her daughter was in the Buffy movie!) It's fine and pleasant, but not that interesting. All these jazz standards kinda sound the same to me. One of the least objectionable live albums, though. Cool album cover. I enjoyed the meta-ness of 'How High the Moon', clap clap clap, but I can't imagine ever listening to this for funsies.
probably important at its time, but feels incredibly schmalzy/kitsch and outdated now
Great late 50s live jazz recording
No gran cosa, pero canta muy bien
Very pleasant on the first listen
Guter Vibe während der Aufnahmesession, Vaughn hat eine super Stimme, aber mich hat es nicht ganz bekommen. Textlich und musikalisch ist es mir einfach zu seicht und wenn sie im Closer den Text vergisst und etwas darüber fantasiert, finde ich es eher unangenehm als charmant. :D
Very pleasant one to listen to, would like it as some background noise to a party. Vaughan's voice is phenomenal here too. It gets a high 3, since this sort of jazz isn't really my thing, therefore I wouldn't go seek it out again. But with every jazz record I'm getting on this list, I can feel my appreciation and enjoyment for jazz ever so slowly l, but surely, increase.
Hmm. Yes, the singing and musical performance are surely top-notch. But am I into Jazz-Singing? Absolutely not. So can I rate this? I can, but whatever I say will be biased by my taste. No, I would not listen to this again, I would not take it to an island, but I can surely appreciate the execution and the postential historical relevance of this. But as soon as someone starts singing "shabadoobedoo" or similar, I get mood implosion - I never could relate to the human voice as an "instrumental" instrument. I hate coloratura arias, I hate Jazz coloraturas. Three stars for the obvious musicianship and value, only three stars because I actually hate listening to it.
Great voice. Loved Stairway to the Stars.
This was fine, and I enjoyed the live element of it. But even for this genre I wouldn’t say this was a must listen so it didn’t do much for me.
A beautiful voice. So clear and bright, so smooth. Ah it was a delight to listen to.
I’m sure it’s fine, just not a huge live music guy
Eurgh jazz
Really nice, one of my favorite jazz singers I've heard. Her voice is incredible, and this being live is ridiculous.
Really nice jazz. I liked some of the little off-script-moments. Very intimate recording.
Not my favorite style of vocal jazz - too detached, operatic, polished
was absolutely amazing and for the vibes
Absolutely wonderful listen!
standard jazz, good vocals.
Nice but not for me
Amazing vocals
I enjoyed listening to this old school jazz. Miss Vaughn has a remarkable voice and is very much overlooked.
Very pleasant voice from someone I've not heard of. Considering how much Fallout music I've listened to I'm genuinely surprised I've not come across her before. Did not like the scatting at the end.
sounds good, classic
Great live vocals, but not the most interesting songs
The album was good, but I just couldn’t get into it. I listened to BB King’s Live at the Regal recently and thought that was much more entertaining. But I still enjoyed this album.
Just some chill vibes, very nice
Classic jazz vocal and live to boot. Really good stuff.
Live albums are always a funny one. Is it the recording itself, the string songs or significance of that performance.. and on a personal level, how much do you resonate with the songs and how does it differ to the studio cut. I’m not sure this has any of those things specifically, yet there’s definitely some magic here and beautiful vocals. A very relaxing morning listen.
A very relaxing album, I will make an exception to my distaste of live performances on this list for this one. Fave track: Just a gigolo
Comforting. 3.5/5
Really lovely. I'd associated Sarah Vaughen with scatty be boppy ddo bop type meanderings but here she sings the songs with swing and lyrics. Beautiful. Interestingly, when she does go off book, she refers to Ella. I'd always thought Ella sang the songs and Sarah went off book! Will ivestigate further.
It was OK, nothing special but a good vibe bumps up the score. This is the oldest album I’ve ever listened to. Rating: 62/100
6 Silkyyy
Nice. Great voice, decent songs, fine.
really jazzy, really lovey dovey, really great voice
4/10
Album 31 Top 3 favorites off the album: Willow Weep For Me, How High The Moon, Be Anything But Darling Be Mine I'm sorry I haven't heard of Sarah Vaughan before. What a warm voice! I don't often listen to live albums, so the background noise and stage commentary were fun. I particularly love the end of Willow Weep For Me. They're musicians and people who knock things over and make mistakes and laugh about it with each other and the audience. I love jazz!
Beautifully sang but without real melody or direction. No disputing the importance of Sarah Vaughan as a singer but there is a pervading wish that the songs were better.
Another album from 1956, after I got Louis Prima's The Wildest about a month ago. This one isn't quite as good as that one, as Prima's record had a lot more energy to it. Take Just a Gigolo, which is interestingly on both records. Compare the two and it’s not even close, as Prima’s clears easily. That said, it's amazing that this still holds up after 70 years, mainly because Vaughn's voice is really great. That makes it at least worth the listen, though not much more.
You know that feeling you get when you listen to a really great artist, where you just feel safe and secure and like everything is going to go EXACTLY the way they decide it will because they are in absolute, calm, relaxed command of the stage? That's the feeling I get listening to this album. Absolute joy, what a great sound!!
Like a warm embrace
Pretty great with wonderful, lush vocals. Probably not for a regular rotation but I love it.
Not something I'd revisit regularly, but this is a kind of jazz I can appreciate: comfortable and satisfying with a twinge of pleasant nostalgia. Vaughn's vocals are sublime and the warts and all nature of this live recording adds to the charm.
I really enjoyed this. I had never heard of Sarah Vaughan but this was a delightful listen.
This is my eleventh jazz album from the list and by far the best of the lot.
nah
I'm sure this is historically considered a great record, but it is not my vibe at all. It was a challenge to get through the whole thing. I appreciate the talent, just not for me.
Great live album that I will revisit again
Incredible Sunday morning record! No wanky jazz solos. Track 9 has some scatting, which I have a hard time not gigging to. A great “set it and forget it” album… no big standouts, but a lovely vibe throughout.
What a voice! I love an alto voice, and hers is as good as it gets in jazz. I love the intimacy of the live crowd which reminded me in moments of Tom Waits' Nighthawks At The Diner. The album went a little long for me though and it became more background music than a really engaging album by the end of it.
Gorgeous voice but I really don't think I would listen to this ever again except maybe for some pleasant background music.
Classic vocal jazz in the vein of Ella. Very good. Live recorrding. Pitchfork: n/a Rolling Stone: n/a Best Songs Willow Weep For Me Just a Gigalo
Made me feel like I was in a jazz club in the 50s. Wish I was sipping on a cocktail while I listened to this.
Ugh Jazz. I’ve been forgiving on jazz albums before. Not sure I can be so forgiving on this one. Sure I’m listening to a live version and one should be a little more lenient on an album such as this but what am I to do? This is a weak jazz album. A generic band Fall flat vocals. Songs with lyrics that could be replaced by words speaking of Christmas and it wouldn’t skip a beat.
Lovely voice and atmosphere - but failed to move me.
For jazz, that wasn't bad. Actually appreciated the live aspect. Great voice. Cold rainy coffee morning kind of an album.
Love.
Feels like you’re at there - very nice recording. Feels intimate She has an beautiful voice and the arrangements are all nice
Hard no.
One of the best voices. She sounds so contemporary to me. Excellent album, perfect concision.
live albums are rarely good and this one's kinda close to being an exception. it still has all the normal problems most live albums do, but she's working so hard it almost gets past em. i bet it was incredible to be there.
I wasn't really in the mood for this sort of music today, but Vaughan's voice is so smooth and dynamic that I still enjoyed this album. Sometimes jazz vocals can feel screechy to me but this never did and none of the songs meandered so long as to become tiresome.
Excelente álbum! Técnico e emocionalmente belo. QoA Cloudscape.
She is otherworldly as a singer and the music is pretty much perfect to accompany her swooning and melodies.
Really good music and for once a live album where the fact it's live actually adds to the experience. But the way the Spotify version faded the songs to silence between tracks made it a little disjointed.
I believe that jazz is best listened to live. Sure, there are great jazz albums out there but hearing that same album live is unmatched due to the human emotion and feel that comes through. I haven't listened to the music from this live album in its recorded format but based on my listen of this live album, I would bet that's the case here, too. All of that to say, high quality live jazz albums like this (especially when they include crowd noise and the artists' banter between songs) are truly remarkable.
Bas mi je sladak album i zabavan jer je live snimka kao što smo prokomentirali. Super su mi ti opušteni trenutci i reakcije publike a njeno pjevanje je vrhunsko ofc. Pjesma koju sam upamtila jeeee Stairway To The Stars.
Dobar album, jucer padala kisa pa je bila vibe, live album pa je zanimljivo. 7/10 Najbolja pisma: Willow weep for me Najgora pisma: /
The Sarah Vaughan Lovely Lounge Experience. Bloopers, gigolos and skat singing about making whoopie.
Cool jazz swing album
Enjoyed
I really liked this!! Not something I’d usually listen to but she was so silly w the live show interjections
I am not always a fan of live recordings. But this one has so much personality and uniqueness about it. Sarah Vaughn’s vocal performance and ability to improvise makes the album very interesting and fun to listen to.
This was cute - I love hearing the live recording and the chatter between her and the audience. Not something I would actively listen to but I was compelled at points.
Not my favorite in this genre. But a great voice none the less.
honestly quite good! i do love jazz music however i wish there was a version of this album that wasn't recorded live. that being said, definitely one of the better live recordings ive heard, with quite clear vocals and instrumentals. would love to hear this live in a jazz bar with my friends. most likely wont listen to this album start to finish again, but definitely added a few of the songs to my jazz playlist. 6/10
Le jazz c'est pas mon truc je crois, j'ai rien ressenti à l'écoute j'attendais juste que ça se termine
Outstanding
Fine to listen to but nothing really interesting.
oh wow. isn't music amazing? aren't people just great?
Loved it. Definitely see myself throwing it on in the right setting but not regular rotation. Live jazz albums are some of my favorite
Quite enjoyable.
This genre is right in my wheelhouse. I liked the arrangements more than her singing, which I find a bit affected, despite her lovely voice. I also didn’t love her jokey treatment of some of the songs, but all in all it was still a great listening experience.
A lovely 50s live jazz album by a lesser known by prominent jazz singer. Listened to the longer version of the album, which makes the whole thing more complete rather than a few selected tracks. I enjoy these live selections.
Такую музыку фоном сложно послушать, хочется особой обстановки. Особо не впечатлилась, не дослушала до конца. Редко нравится женский вокал и тут вот тоже не зашло, местами прям неоч когда растягивает.
FUCK THIS SHIT
I was not familiar with Sarah Vaughan before now. Beautiful voice. I enjoyed her ad-libbing and the crowd response in "Willow Weep for Me" and "How High the Moon." The only song title that looks familiar to me is "Just a Gigolo." I was surprised to hear the word "lollapalooza" in "Thou Swell."
Beautiful, beautiful vocal performance — and live too! I could give 5 stars for that alone. But I’m gonna dock a point because the silly-goofy “I forgot the lyrics” ad libs felt forced and cringe.
First thing I noticed is how sweet & smooth her voice is, like a cool breeze on a night. The vibe or sound of the album was light hearted in a way. I enjoyed listening to it, but my type of music if just far from this genre, though Jazz is something I will be up to listen to. Liked songs: September in the Rain, Just One of Those Things Rating: 3/5 JAN 19, 2026 - 5:20 PM
Not usually my fave kind of thing but actually quite enjoyed, and thought the live recording added to it
It’s a live album of jazz standards. It’s from the 50s and sounds like it. I wanted to like it more, because I always say I’d like jazz if it had words and this is jazz with words. I did like it, but I didn’t love it. It had “Just One of Those Things” and that was fun, but I was kinda just wishing it was the Jamie Cullum version
Första kvinnan! Kändes gammalt, inte dåligt, men ablumet var live och lite så raspig röst.
I’d never heard of Sarah Vaughan before. Jazz is a little like rock in that there are so many different styles in the genre it ends up being a fairy wide catch-all name and you’re not sure what you’ll actually end up listening to. I like a lot of “jazz” but more the old classic jazz, noir and the newer doom jazz. I’m not keen on the experimental jazz as a rule. Sarah Vaughan is at the very commercial end of jazz, almost so much that a lot of it doesn’t even really sound all that “jazzy”. I enjoyed her and certainly wouldn’t change songs if she came on - but not sure I’d necessarily go out of my way to listen to her again.
Delightful - I really enjoyed a live album where you hear the band talking between songs
Fantastic album. Not expecting to enjoy this as much as I did. Pure talent and fun.
Nice relaxing Jazz with such a sweet voice!
While I'd call myself a blues rocker at heart, I was introduced to Jazz (alongside several other genres) when I was quite young. My grandfather was something of an aficionado of the genre, and whenever we'd go to visit my grandparents he'd almost always sit me down and play his latest favourites for me, and as a result I developed a bit of a taste for it myself. Sarah Vaughan is one of the vocal artists I remember most clearly from those visits, alongside Billie Holiday, Dinah Washington, and Ella Fitzgerald, and listening to her, or any of the others, always brings back fond memories. This album is quite possibly Vaughan at her absolute best. The original 1957 release only covers the first half an hour of the session at Mister Kelly's, but even in those nine short tracks you can hear just how relaxed she is, how much fun she's having with the songs being played, and how in sync her and the band are. The extended version of the full set released in the early nineties just adds to this, and brings home just how amazing Vaughan's voice was. My rating : a solid 5 out of 5 stars.
Ok average
кароче,я думав це якась хуйня,але ,але не,хароший лайвік,такій спокойний джазік,тьотя прікольно пайот,інстемент клас,кароче заїбісь, було би 10/10 але я не оч люблю лайви так шо 9.5/10
Alsof je zelf achter in een jazz club zit. Goede zangeres die ingetogen liedjes zingt. 7/10
Really fun and playful, especially that last song which is all those things and also cool
this was so nice! i really liked it!!
she got a christmas voice
Gotta be in a certain mood to listen to this but she is undeniable.
Sen ajan mahtavaa äänenkäyttöä, afroamerikkalaisia olisko soul ja sen sellaista, lempeää jazz vaikutteista hidasta rytmiä kuin suoraan Fallout maailmasta. Löytyy pehmeä kohta minulta tällaiselle
4*/5 01.16.2026
Excellent styling. Beautiful voice
I liked this album a lot but wouldn’t listen again
dont know
Very easy to listen to. I liked that that it was a live recording, and there were moments of conversation interjected throughout. Made it feel like I was there enjoying the show. Would definitely listen to this album again.
Wow, what a voice! Unfortunately the live recording elements take it down for me. The applause took me out of it and whatever happened in "Willow Weep for Me" was weird. Man, still what a great performance.
...........
O álbum tá indisponível no yt music e tive de escutar com anúncios no aleatório c anúncios no spotify free
Eu gosto de jazz de negona
Ok
Calma aí Sarah, teve uma música que vc ficou gorgolejando inteira
This bastard is back to not saving my noted properly, reverting to old notes. I had put something about this being back to back to back an album of someone who is a level above and beyond. She has an instrument, not a voice. That said, a little more straight lougne jazzy and not quite as fun as the last album and for that reason, 4 stars.
Actually a little boring I don’t really like live albums. The voice is good but for me is just background music…
It's nice, but if I wanted to go to a live jazz gig I'd go to one. Haven't heard a live album on here that should be on here yet. Though I suppose it's not that live, really. Whatever, I'm tired.
Not something I'll likely revisit, but I will give Ms. Vaughan her due as a landmark in American music.
Guardé September in the rain pero en realidad me gustó mucho todo el album, lo escucharía completo cuando quiera algo lindo.
Beautiful voice. Beautiful album. Classic.
Ihan ok taustamusiikkia. 2,75/5.
Aww she was really talented <3 I usually hate jazz, and hate live albums but this was oddly comforting.
very nice listen. total whiplash from listening to aerosmith. like this is just infintely better, but thats a low bar. the last song vamping was great too
Ein Jazz-Klassiker
Very nice and clean album. The fact that is live makes it more lively and and fun to listen to. If you are in a bad mood this can definitely help you calm down abit. Would‘ve liked if there was an studio version tho.
It’s nice, but a live album shouldn’t be on this list. Didn’t you hear me before?
Look. It’s not bad by any means, but her voice wasn’t as impressive to me as others with a similar style, and I don’t feel like I’ll remember it. I do think I skipped the last couple but really it was just not standout for me.
Not my typical jazz-influenced listen but the instrumentals on this are detailed and subtle, but the improvisation is noticeable and impressive. Also recorded at Mr Kellys in Chicago - shoutout and RIP to a Chicago legendary club.
Unfortunately, not my favorite. It's also live.
I don't really like the way she sings.
Jazz lovely singer she was great
It hadn't occurred to me that live albums would be on the list, but it's a delight to discover one that captures a moment in time and place like this one does, and feels so cosy and inviting. Sarah Vaughan's voice is very warm and smooth, and I'm definitely interested in hearing more of her.
Solid crooner album. Gets a little monotonous. He personality is infectious.
Masterclass and so entertaining!
What an exceptionally smooth and soothing voice. Her tremelo and pitch are mesmerizing. The songs are standard jazz but carried by her talent. Wild that this was recorded at a place that no longer exists, in fact it’s a steakhouse (a tasty one) now in the old rich white people part of town. Shame as the documentary sounds intriguing and I’m looking forward to watching it.
I like the music here. Folks seem to love Sarah Vaughn's voice, which isn't too bad, but I could do without all the vibrato. All in all, a fine record, though it's not something that really captures my attention. 3/5
Conectar con Sarah Vaughan desde la costumbre de las estructuras compositivas e interpretativas del pop/rock, siempre esperando de una canción que tenga su intro, sus estrofas y su estribillo no es nada fácil. Pero el jazz hay que sentirlo, no comprenderlo, y si te dejas llevar, tienes que reconocer que la voz de Sarah no es de este mundo. Escucharla te obliga a salir de tu zona de confort y admitir que todos hemos sido muy poco educados para apreciar lo que no sigue más presupuestos que la emoción a flor de piel.
The thing about jazz is that I like it in the moment and then barely ever revisit the music. It's a good album, someone said Sarah's voice is extremely warm and this tracks. Classically, as it is with jazz, it's extremely hard to judge for me if it's pushing forward the medium, as the album is also extremely old. But good.
I absolutely loved this. You could tell she was having so much fun doing it and wasn't taking herself seriously. Her voice is like a sexy personification of smoking a cigar and sipping on a martini. I would recommend this to everyone. 5 out of 5
Sarah Vaughn has a great voice and delightful attitude l, and her personality really shines through her performance. This genre of music in general is not for me but I understand why someone believed anyone should listen to this recording. It feels like it is a "big moment" for Jazz music.
Sarah Vaughn is a singer I wish I had heard sooner because her voice is so very pristine and smooth. She has such a suave voice and completes the jazz band perfectly. The songs themselves stood out less, and seemed more to be average jazz standards that weren’t anything special to me.
love jazz
beautiful singing, just not my thing
jazz (schön aber einseitig)
entspannt. gut, aber kein wiederholungsbedarf
Beautiful voice, great haunting jazz tone from the band
72/100
Great singing and piano
This recording was everything I wanted it to be. The Divine Sarah Vaughan indeed.
Es bueno para música de fondo, para estar en un café leyendo o simplemente no hacer nada y solo disfrutar
Enjoyed this one!
Fuck jazz.
nice to passively listen to because of sarah vaughan's voice
Talk about amazing....
Bee boop ah doo dah. I’m sure this is probably good but this type of thing grinds my gears.
Such a unique recording very raw and authentic
im Wohnzimmer nach der NasenOP Samstag, 10.01.2026
Listened to it in the background, very soothing but didn’t stand out to me
4/10
not my typical listening, but some very nice jazzy mood music for when I feel like cosplaying sipping a martini alone at a jazz club. it being a live album definitely enhances that. 3/5⭐️
It's a good album of jazz standards, I prefer others like Etta James but Sarah is good. She forgets the lyrics on more than one song, and I don't like a couple of her adaptations like on honeysuckle rose, but she comes across as charming working around the difficulties which gives the album some life.
Good, but I probably wouldn't listen to this again. All the songs sounded similar.
Wanted to enjoy this more than I did. Jazz is complicated
god this lady can sing. Like crazy can sing like crazy!!
the crispest most beautiful voice i ever did hear
Inoffensively delightful. A nice reminder of what liking music means without forcing liking. Pleasant background. 3/5
I absolutely loved this album! I actually didn’t know about Sarah Vaughan before this and I’m so glad I do now.
Quite calming to be honest
Sarah Vaughan is a legendary jazz vocalist - her smoky tone is fantastic. I'm not sure this album was the best choice, though. It's patchy, under-rehearsed, and stops abruptly. As a historical document it is fascinating, but I would have loved a better example of Vaughan's prowess.
September In The Rain - 7/10: I like the instruments/beat (idk what to call it) a lot. I also like the higher notes she hits. Willow Weep for Me - 6/10: I like her vocals, the only thing that threw me off a bit was the crashing sound? toward the end, but that's what happens with live albums I suppose. Just One of Those Things - 6/10: Not terrible, but I don't love her volume. I like the instruments/beat though. Be Anything But Darling Be Mine - 6/10: I like her vocals in this song. The song isn't bad at all, it's just kind of bleh. Thou Swell - 7/10: Again, I really like her vocals in this song. I also like the instruments/beat. Stairway to the Stars - 6/10: I like her vocals and the instruments/beat. The song is just a little bleh and forgettable. Honeysuckle Rose - 7/10: I like the higher notes she hits, along with the instruments/beat. Just a Gigolo - 6/10: The song isn't bad, it's just that nothing stood out to me. I like the piano though. How High the Moon - 4/10: I like the instruments/beat, but she's kind of just hooting and hollering, she's not really saying anything. This is my first time hearing this song so I don't know if that's how it's supposed to go, but I don't really like it. Overall Score: 55/90 Overall Rating: 6/10 - I have never really explored the jazz genre, and this is probably the first jazz album I've listened to front to back. It's not a bad album, I'm just not a huge fan of jazz. I really like her voice though, and the instruments/beat or whatever you call if was also nice. It's just not my favorite album, but I could see myself possibly listening to it again in the future.
When this album came on I started sweating, my blood pressure went up, one of my legs started twitching, my eyes were unable to focus on my computer and I felt a slight but palpable sense of dread. It took me a moment, but then I realized it was a physiological reaction to the similarity between this album and that monstrosity, Ellla Fitzgerald Sings the George and Ira Gershwin Song Book (even the title of that album is bloated...how about Ella Fitzgerald sings Gershwin?). This album is way better than that. The lyrics are way better, it is much shorter, and if the singing isn't on par I can't tell. I even like the bloopers that were included.
Great vocal performance but I have a hard time wrapping my head around music that predates the Beatles. Just not really my vibe
Very chill Sunday morning jazz vibe. All the songs essentially sound the same, so it is difficult to pick my favorites. I enjoyed listening to this though!
Favourites: 1. Just A Gigolo
I don’t really like jazz or jazz type music
Genre: Vocal Jazz This was a sweet, very raw-feeling live show from one the bigger voices of the 50s, Sarah Vaughan. It's a sultry vibe at Mister Kelly's, the songs are slow, the music is smooth, and I'm sure it smelled of cigarettes in there. Overall, the music is just fine, but I almost enjoyed it more for the fly-on-the-wall moments. A mic falling (audience laughs), her not knowing the words of the last song and doing her best Ella Fitzgerald impression, things like that. But, probably won't revisit. 3/5
This album is thrilling precisely because it refuses to hide behind perfection. Sarah Vaughan’s voice is astonishing on a purely technical level, but what really elevates this record is the confidence and musical authority on display. Missed cues, forgotten lyrics, even a bumped mic don’t derail anything. They become part of the performance, handled with such ease that they actually deepen the experience rather than diminish it. When Vaughan realizes she doesn’t have the words to “How High the Moon” and simply scats her way through the entire tune, it’s not a workaround. It’s a statement. She shapes melody and harmony in real time, swings effortlessly, and never sounds anything less than in command. The trio matches her every move, covering transitions, extending sections, and responding with total trust and musical awareness. What I love most about this record is the decision to release it exactly as it is. There’s real badassery in letting the flubs stand, because they reveal just how good these musicians are. This isn’t jazz as museum piece or polished showcase. It’s jazz as a living conversation, full of risk, humor, and control. An easy five stars. Incredible musicianship, genuine spontaneity, and a live record that feels alive in every sense of the word.
solidno ali nije me oborilo s nogu :/ također zvuk nije najbolji... jebiga
Groovy jazz singing. Would listen to again.
What a gem wow. Absolutely delicious and beautiful. I could float in all the melodies and Sarah's voice. Amazing.
It was good, but not really something i would come back to often.
Transported to a jazz club instantly. Very charming, funny, and oh so beautiful.
This is awesome
I like it, I like the little funny conversations as well. 4/5
what do you mean you hate jazz?
Never really listened to jazz this much before. Love this album. I especially love live albums.
Cool sound, awesome vocals. I love the sound of old live recordings.
She has a great voice. Some of it is lowkirkenuinely just her going shoo-be-doo. Good background music. Last song kinda ruined it but not quite.
Ignore what Saul said and read this Instead For its time its genuinely quite good, would never choose to listen it but if i was out at dinner and they had this playing i would be quite content.
September In The rain - Long boring ass start (given its live i can look past it)(just about) Vocals are very good but the instrumentals are a bit tame and somewhat dull. Willow weep for me - Again a nice song with the same flaws as previous I am also concerned with the economic climate of the collapse of taiwan, see that bullshit was much more interesting than this song. Just one of those things - bit more upbeat than the previous, I appreciate hwo the instruments are more hearable, Thank you for listening to my critisism mr Sarash vaughan Be Anything But Darling Be Mine - Could very easliy be confused With the first two songs, if you were to merge one song and link it into the other I doubt anyone other than a fanatic would really notice the difference. Thou Swell - More involved instrument which I am a fan of Stairway To The Stars - I will not be repeating previous notes How high the Moon - Definitely my favourite of the bunch, upbeat and interesting. Overall this album is listenable as background noise, maybe in a bar but any other ways to listen to it would be utterly mundane, 2/5
Really pleasant and enjoyable listen, Sarah Vaughan has an incredible voice, very clear and soulful that goes excellent with the lovely piano. I like the live recording atmosphere, the laughter from the patrons and ad libs on the songs make for a very immersive album and it's not difficult to imagine being in the jazz club in Chicago when this was recorded. September in the rain and Willow weep for me were particularly good with the latter perhaps being my favourite although they were all very good with How high the moon being perhaps the only slight dip in quality. A part of me feels this could be five stars but for now it's a high four. 79/100
Quite nice. Relaxing. Lovely jazz piano. A very good 3. I don't think I'd ever choose to put it on but a very nice atmosphere.
This was great for the first half but then lost it
Different, not my style of music
She has a good voice but its not really for me. 2.5
Damn, some serious pipes here. Never heard of Sarah Vaughan in my impoverished musical education, but this is like, flawless? Even the part that has flaws? Really smooth lounge music here, but too long, the live element isn't super present (though it sounds like it was recorded in a studio, incredibel) and I don't really vibe with it so I give it a coward's 4.
Excelente!
Listened on a gloomy, rainy autumn day and this was the perfect antidote. Nocturnal, warm album. Manages to place you right there, in the room, at a 50s Chicago jazz club (great👌). The mistakes and forgotten lyrics adding the human element of live music (really great👌). Amazing voice and, ashamedly, I had not heard of Sarah Vaughan before this - I will definitely be checking out more though. Niiiiice. 3.5/5 Standout tracks: September in the Rain Willow Weep for Me Honeysuckle Rose
Very relaxing. The live setup really works for this
Loved it!
Brilliant beautiful rich soulful fun, she has an incredible voice and in a way it's a smoother sister to Billie Holidays "Songs for Distingue Lovers" (not sure if that is on here yet). I have only heard Sarah Vaughan on a compilation of hers before, this is a far more enjoyable experience. One of those albums where you truly feel you are present at the gig
I love how warm the upright bass sounds, and how that warmth blends with Sarah Vaughan’s deep, rich vocals.
It just passed me by a little, to be honest. She has a very lovely voice and I didn't mind it being there, but it was very much existing in the background.
That voice…..
Gee, mister. Thanks.
I loved her voice and the live album was fun.
Sarah Vaughan war eine US-amerikanische Jazzsängerin, die mit Sarah Vaughan At Mister Kelly’s ein frühes, konzentriertes Live-Dokument ihrer Bühnenpräsenz vorlegte. Die Aufnahmen entstanden im Club Mister Kelly’s in Chicago und fangen eine intime Atmosphäre ein, die ihren kontrollierten, zugleich flexiblen Umgang mit Timing und Phrasierung deutlich macht. Begleitet von einem kleinen Ensemble bewegt sich Vaughan souverän durch das Repertoire zwischen Ballade und Swing. Besonders prägnant sind ihre Interpretationen von „My Funny Valentine“, „Willow Weep for Me“ und „Honeysuckle Rose“, in denen sie melodische Linien frei variiert, ohne den Songkern aus dem Blick zu verlieren. Stilistisch ist das Album klar im Vocal Jazz verankert. In der Gesamtschau wirkt die Platte weniger spektakulär als einige spätere Studioarbeiten, überzeugt aber durch Nähe, Ruhe und stimmliche Autorität.
this was very amazing because of the live aspect and it genuinely felt like you were in the room, but other than that i felt like it was quite bland.
I love Sarah Vaughan in small chunks but a whole album was a lot.
Felt warm yet chill at the same time. Love Vaughan's voice, yet none of the songs truly standout for me, except Willow Weep for Me and Honeysuckle Rose. Helped me read a book, though.
Pretty good
Simpelweg heel Nice, losse sfeer en heel puur!
just smiling!
Amazing vocals, improvisation that just flows, really an amazing performance. However that sort of 1950’s skiddlybop jazzy lounge music is not really my favorite thing.
- 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM - 0 nummers al toegevoegd aan MMMM
"Act normally" when listening to this one. Heart-warming and cozy, this quick look into Sarah Vaughan live sounds wonderful...in the background.
First time listening to Sarah Vaughan, just a beautiful voice. Soothing, relaxing and the perfect soundtrack for a hungover Sunday morning
Sultry and lovely!
Started at 10:06 was recorded live at a performance pretty cool This is the first Jazz album I have listened too and it was great. The first thing the caught me off guard was the fact that it was all recorded live and on the spot which just highlights the talents of Sarah Vaughn. A really great introduction to jazz and the crackling and voices in the background gave the music a very atmospheric feel that current music doesn't have because of the background silence of studios. Having slight background noise elevates the music especially when hearing audiences clap and laugh in the background. Other artists have incorporated slight background noise in their music an example would be Playboi Carti on Rockstar Made where you can hear his chains swinging in the background. This was a great listen, the personality and soul of the music created a calming atmosphere definitely something I would go back to listen too.
I enjoyed this! I’ve never dedicated time to properly listening to jazz I’ve always thought I should try but never really have and i’m so happy I liked it. Sarah Vaughan is SO charming I loved all her unpolished unserious moments. It doesn’t lose anything from being a live album, it adds to it, the vibe is relaxed and warm. Really appreciate getting this one as my first real listen to jazz.
LOVE!!! This album genuinely feels like a 50s time capsule, basically like you’re in the audience at the time. How I LOVEEE live albums! Vaughan really was so talented and knew how to keep an audience rolling throughout a show and it’s evident in this album! So much can be learned about 50s jazz just from 9 songs. This is how it’s done. Favorites: Willow Weep For Me, Just One Of Those Things, Stairway To The Stars, Just A Gigolo, How High The Moon
This is sublime work. Her voice, the lyrics, the instruments.
Wonderful artist. Sublime. Sadly the recording is a bit wobbly.
Now I feel the jolly.
Almost choked on the cigarette smoke by lounging in a 1950's club.
"Sassy is so good now that when I listen to her I want to cut my wrists with a dull razor." – Frank Sinatra Pour a scotch, light a cigarette or two as insence, put on this album and then close your eyes and imagine yourself in a 1950s Chicago nightclub. Okay, I didn't have the cigs, but it would have been perfect. In most of Vaughn’s studio recordings she is accompanied by a full orchestra, but this recording consists of a relatively simple trio. with just bass (Rihard Davis), piano (Jimmy Jones) and drums (Roy Hayes). This puts sharp focus on her voice and oh what a voice it is! Fun fact, in live performances Vaughn used the placement of the microphone to adjust the volume of her voice while singing. You can hear the results throughout this recording. This is among the oldest albums on this list and for someone who is here, in part, due to an interest in music history this is appreciated. I think this is also the first of many iconic albums (Ella Fitzgerald, Muddy Waters, Billie Holiday) recorded at Mister Kelly's. For those with an interest in music history or Jazz, I recommend the documentary "Live at Mister Kelly's". Vaughn (AKA Sassy) is rightfully considered one of the greatest jazz vocalists of all time. It is hard for me to believe that anyone would not relish this performance, but I’ve been doing this project long enough to know that such people exist.
Sara Vaughan is a gem. This is a nice live album. Reminds me of Christmas even though it has nothing to do about Christmas. Just has that sound I guess. Either way its nice to here this time of year. I do wish this album is a lot shorter because boy does it drag on. Favorite track: Just A Gigolo 3.5/5
Was not expecting that it was recorded live, which was so cool. A real slice of 1950's. Listening to her be so raw was refreshing. I haven't often listened to the recordings of people addressing the crowd for event recordings. It must have been different then. I had also not heard of Sarah Vaughan, I am glad that it no longer true.
Like the live aspect of it, it is nice but not really something I'd choose to listen to. Highlights: Be Anything But Darling Be Me (Mine?), Honeysuckle Rose
I didn't listen to the full album but of what I listened to I really enjoyed but not In a way that made me want to go back to it. I feel evil saying that 😖. Anyway I love how it was recorded live cos it reminded me of this lovely jazz singer who used to perform at the local pub witch I really enjoyed
Very mellow vibes, definitely made sitting in traffic a little more peaceful. I enjoyed this quite a bit, and normally I don’t care for jazz. Didn’t love whatever scatting number was at the end of the album, though.
A funny and spirited live performance!
I typically dislike live albums in comparison to cleaner (and audience-free) studio albums, but Vaughan has so much character in this, and her obvious errors add to the experience. My favorite track is How High The Moon, of which she doesn't remember a single word, but her scat and riffing has so much life to it. Plus, at only 9 songs of reasonable length, this album is tight in a way that many other similar ones (looking at you, Ella "3.25 Hours" Fitzgerald) are not.
Soulful, jazzy performance, but most of it's charm comes from it being 'old' music.
Jazz and scat are not for me, but that's ok. Sarah has a lovely voice and is funny and engaging with her audience on this recording. It's always interesting to hear music from a much older time when things were different. That said, I wouldn't seek this out for future listens.
Love this kinda music. Will be adding Sarah to the rotation. I don't necessarily think the live album was the best. Would have been cool to have been there I guess.
Nem szoktam sokszor jazzt hallgatni, de ez nagyon tetszett. Az énekesnő hangja gyönyörű. Az album végénél a szöveg nélküli éneklés annyira nem tetszett, de összességében nagyon élveztem hallgatni. A kedvenc dalom az albumról a: Just One of Those Things.
I love the mood that the announcer in the beginning sets. Sarah shows her range in each and every song. Quite a neat and timeless little album.
A very Indy sounding album and if you don’t like Indy this will not change your mind. I do like Indy and found myself really enjoying this album. Both the music and vocals I found entrancing and found myself really enjoying quite a few songs
Wish I was there
That pure voice and vibrato. What a live set. Do yourself a favor and get the extended reissue. Muddy waters at mr kellys is pretty great too. I hope that gets served up.....
Sarah was great. You could feel the emotion as she belted out her jazz in what I could only imagine was a smoky, slightly dingy, intimate room at Mister Kelly's.
10
perfect for christmas season! Rating: 3/5*
Hög mysfaktor. 3.5/5 rundat upp
Great voice, honestly a rare sight that i can listen to an hour of singing and like it. Overall great album and loved the ambience. It has taken me by sutch suprise that i think im going to give it ny first 5
Beautiful. I like instrumental jazz more than jazz with vocals, however Sarahs voice more than makes up for that. Her voice has warm tone akin to a mug of warm cocoa on a cold night. The instrumentals are simple, but tight to accompany Sarahs vocals. Live recordings can be hit or miss, but in this case it's pretty well done. I can imagine myself sitting in a corner booth with a pack of cigarettes and a glass of whisky, both of which a greatly dislike, but it's more about the vibe. They make a few mistakes along the way, but I find them to be charming. They make a joke of it and professionally keep the show running. In my opinion this makes it more real, because mistakes happen. Life is about how you deal with them. It'd give it a strong 8.
A beautiful and cozy jazz session that fits the season amazingly. This album felt like a warm blanket.
I think this is probably a really good album for all kinds of complicated aesthetic reasons, but I listened as I made dinner on a Sunday evening after a generally awful weekend, and it made me feel better.
Kind of boring to be honest.
A very pleasant set of tracks, all of which are just a little too traditional and a little too similar. Sarah's voice is incredible, and I found the more upbeat tracks on this to be a joy (the closer made me laugh out loud). But taken as a whole without being present for the actual performance, it feels a little dry on the whole. Something I see myself returning to when I'm in the mood for something very mellow.
I NEED THIS ON VINYL
Ok, just not a big Jazz fan
A fine jazz album but not really many songs I liked, she has a fine voice but I feel like I've heard a lot of stuff just like this
Nice on the ears
Fun and lovely
i love Sarah Vaughan, she can do no wrong. dulcet tones velvety texture also recorded in CHICAGO???
Jazz isn’t really my thing. This album felt way too mellow for my taste, and for a live recording it came across oddly flat, like the crowd was more into chatting and clinking glasses than actually listening to the band. That said, I really enjoyed her take on “Just a Gigolo”, that one track alone almost made it worth the spin.
Very 1950’s. Was a live studio recording with audience. Had a nice feeling to it. Not music I would choose to listen to, but glad I did.
I’ve never heard of Sarah Vaughn before, and I’m not the biggest fan of jazz music, but this album sounds like it should be pretty fun to listen to. I haven’t really had that many strong opinions on albums like this that I’ve already reviewed, but I’m hoping that At Mister Kelly’s will be the first album like this to really wow me. Unfortunately, I didn’t care for this album that much. Sarah Vaughn is a good vocalist, but I didn’t find anything particularly interesting or unique about her performance on this album. The music itself wasn’t that interesting to me either, and I didn’t think that they did anything to uplift the vocals either. These songs weren’t the most interesting choices either, so if Sarah Vaughn’s singing had more to offer, this wasn’t the setlist to showcase her talent. I wish I had some more insightful things to say about why I didn’t care for this album, but it simply just wasn’t my speed.
It represents this genre well and it's good. I probably won't be adding this to my heavy rotation but it's nice to know about. Good time capsule of a long, long gone Chicago. Back when Rush Street was swinging and thriving and not just the Viagra Triangle, upscale luxury stores, and yuppies with no clue how to take the L.
An unbelievable talent. Loose, funny amazing
Loveee jazz staple
a fun performance .
My journey through the 1001 Albums has highlighted a distinct preference for Jazz vocal over the purely instrumental Jazz reviewed thus far. While I've always appreciated live recordings, and enjoy them greatly, a truly great live album must offer something transcendent beyond its studio equivalent, be it exceptional performance quality, innovative arrangements, historical significance, or palpable atmosphere. In this respect, "At Mister Kelly's" feels somewhat subdued and one-paced. Ultimately, I found it to be a good, but not great, live recording. Neither Sarah Vaughan's performance, her band's playing, nor the selection of songs provided the crucial spark needed to elevate it above a solid three-star rating. Side one 1 "September In The Rain" (3/5) 2 "Willow Weep for Me" (3/5) 3 "Just One of Those Things" (3/5) 4 "Be Anything But Darling Be Mine" (3/5) Side two 1 "Thou Swell" (3/5) 2 "Stairway to the Stars" (3/5) 3 "Honeysuckle Rose" (3/5) 4 "Just a Gigolo" (3/5) 5 "How High the Moon" (3/5) Total - 27 Average - 3.00 181/1001 99/181 albums reviewed were new to me.
Really captures the sense of time and place. Would love to have witnessed it live. A few glitches make it not the best-ever live album. Someone said they wished this list included a studio album and I agree. Vaughan is fantastic but I’d like to hear her without the imperfections.
It was nice. Thoroughly enjoyed till the end 4/5
Sarah Vaughan on todella taitava laulaja, hänellä on hyvä soundi äänessä. Musa ei hirveästi kolissut tai herättänyt tunteita, ihan hyvää tausta musaa.
I just love the human feel live albums tend to have, even though I've never heard of Sarah Vaughn before but she's managed to make me adore these tunes - that I've been heard before - she (and maybe her backing band) picked. I liked the mistake near the end in "Willow Weep for Me," especially her playing off the mistake, as well as the Ella Fitzgerald shout out in "How High The Moon," where she does some (improvised??) scat singing. All in all I really enjoyed this one. Highlight Song/s: September In The Rain
Best Track - "Honeysuckle Rose"
Wanted to like this more because Vaughan’s game for it and I appreciate her mix of self-deprecating humor, but this felt pretty generic overall. Just One of Those Things only one that felt distinctive to me
Killer voice. Fun and Jazzy. Also amusing that they left in the flubs.... "I don't know the words to this song - doobie doobie doo."
What a stellar album, very cool!
Live-levyt eivät itselle paljoa tee, vaikka hyvin laulaakin hän tällä vanhalta kuulostavalla albumilla.
I'm not familiar with Sarah Vaughan, but this was a nice little vocal jazz album. This type of simple arrangement and quiet club setting works really well for a live album. 3.5/5
Interesting album. I liked Sarah's singing, but it was too forward in the mix. On a few occasions, I totally couldn't hear the backing band at all, and I couldn't track the rhythm. That was off-putting. Also, some of the songs are too slow for me. I liked the peppier numbers though. 2.75/5
Listening to a 70 year-old live record so well-performed in 2025 is weirdly refreshing. This is pretty flawless. It also exhibits a level of showmanship we're lacking nowadays. Amazing voice, great delivery, super musicians. Lyrically poor, obviously, that's why it's not a 5.
Not for me
Jazz antigo
*Beautiful voice and a great live recording *Not my favorite style of jazz or I would given this a 5
Didn't fully listen through
Lovely. I liked her better than Billie Holiday. 3/5
old ass live recordings just have that certain charm yknow
Perfect accompaniment to my rainy train ride home
A beautiful voice over instrumentals which are nothing special
Hon låter precis som Sonya Hedenbratt, och det gillar ju en Lundenpôjk som jag. Lite Café Norrköping jazz, oförargligt men smakfullt och bra. Livekänslan lyckas dom behålla bra. Bandet låter utmärkt sparsmakat och elegant, inga onödiga utsvävningar. Absolut bra
Sara Vaughan är kanske den starkaste rösten i sin generation av jazzvokalister. Det är ju lite standard, men visst skulle man vilja sitta där på Mister Kelly’s den där kvällen och låta sig sköljas över av musikens värme.
Vilket underbart hantverk det här är. Precis så här ska the American somgbook låta. Det är inte revolutionerande men fan så snyggt. Det finns en oerhörd nerv i Vaughans röst och samspelet med bandet. Hon når kanske inte upp till Holiday och Fitzgerald men är inte långt ifrån. Ibland är det enkla det geniala. Stark fyra.
Fin röst och fin leverans. Tight band, riktigt bra piano. Inspelningen låter verkligen live utan att ljudkvaliteten brister. Men texterna är i tråkigaste laget. Det blir snabbt bakgrundsmusik till middagen.