Reviews (page 7 of 8)
A fascinating little slice of history. Weird to think that this album was released closer to when Marco Polo discovered America than today.
Not available
Cowboy sounds
It is 2023. Bob Dylan is referred to as this guy’s musical “son”. Dude knew Woody Guthrie and taught Woody Guthrie’s songs to his son Arlo. Johnny Carson thought that this guy knew everyone and had a song for everything. And he’s still alive! It’s 2023. This dude is a living musical history treasure trove.
This is my preferred type of country. Folk based and sung with a passion not often seen in the genres modern equivalent. Jack might be rambling’ but it’s choice ramblin’. Simple guitar and vocal folk/country. Really easy to like.
i guess it’s culturally significant and jack looks super-cool in the cover photo but there’s no way i’m ever putting this on just to hear it
Not my style of music, really. Sounds a lot like Hank Williams. Production is bad, even for 1958. But it was OK. I'll be generous and give it a 3/5.
I listen to a good bit of folk music but I’ve never really listened to any this old before besides covers. Really interesting comparison. No particular favourite song but I liked the album.
An important figure in the early folk scene, connecting the dots between Woody Gutherie and Bob Dylan. Much of the music doesn't hold up as well against those heavyweight names but there's some impressive performances on here. It's certainly noteworthy as a document of that era.
Cool so for anyone in the world, you must listen to an album that was only released in the UK where the list was made. Very inclusive. This one isn’t on Apple Music so didn’t listen.
Hard to track this one down, couldn't find it on Apple Music in the US. But there's a sort of rerelease album called "Muleskinner" with all the same tracks, so I listened to that. I like this style, it's like archival blues/folk music, definitely appreciate an album like this. Makes me think of Lead Belly, an even earlier blues musician responsible for some of the earliest recorded music in the genre. Lead Belly recorded albums as early as 1939! Lord knows the British bastard who made this list doesn't know about American blues like that, but I would absolutely add one of those in a redo of this list. This one's pretty good though, too. Favorite tracks: East Texas Talking Blues, Old Blue, Salty Dog. Album art: This one on the website is just a picture of the guy, it's pretty low-res, nothing much at all to it. The Muleskinner repackage album has a cool scribble-drawn portrait, I do like that one quite a bit. 3.5/5
Solid
It’s not my scene but i enjoyed it
I like it. Reminded me of Saturday mornings at my dad's house. He'd get up and make coffee and it'd be cowboy music hour on public radio.
Maybe it was C's reaction but I expected this to be horrendous, and it was surprisingly good. Not anything I'd choose to listen to regularly, but not unpleasant. Liked New York Time, Muleskinner Blues, disliked Grey Goose.
no.
Not my style, couldn’t finish. Classic for somebody I’m sure.
Niet mijn ding, en niet zo boeiend
man with guitar and some singing - i prefer this over frank sinitra, but it is still very average compared to other 50s music. my predicted score in 1958: 1 my real score in 2023: 1.
Too much chatting, too many whoohoos amidst some decent folk.
This was so wonderful!! Salty Dog was a fun highlight and also the tracks with what I think was a woman's vocals? Really nice vintage country vibes. Never heard of Jack Elliott before but all of the Spotify suggestions after the album were corkers too so that's always a great sign!
At first couldn't connect with this music but it got better as it went on I thought salty dog was fun -kinda kinky Liked 'brother won't you join in the line' the best
Some lovely cowboy music that! I do enjoy the speaking over the top of acoustic guitar styley, the recently deceased Rodriguez did this in a few of his songs and I find it very impactful.
Loved this. Didn't know this guy but read about him. Good mates with Woody Guthrie, as we know from that one song, and certainly sounds like him. Very good stuff.
I recognize the significance of this guy. Without him I guess there could be no Dylan. The music didn’t do it for me, but I do like his sense of humor.
Yep, that's some mid-century folk music alright.
Could be nice to have live in a bar.
Oh fuck yeah. Jack outdylans dylan all over the place. Muy autentico.
If they ever trap me inside a metal crate I want this album to be playing in the sped-up montage of me slowly losing my mind. Is this a real album or was poor old Ramblin' Jack Elliott recorded without consent by his next-door neighbor? I feel like I'm in a college dorm having to listen to a guy practice guitar at 3AM. Wanna throw canned beans at him. 2/5
Pretty good classic country, nothing too special but Jack’s lyrics can be pretty funny sometimes
That was a weird one, not to my taste but good on you jack, you do you.
Country. Ni fu ni fa.
It's nice to hear something new... or rather old on this list. Taken at face value, the album isn't incredibly special but I suspect it's included on this list as a bridge between Woody Guthrie and Bob Dylan. Overall a collection of nice folk tunes. It's clear Jack walked so Bob could run.
Nice!
Folksy rambling... Good, just not what I was looking for. 2/5
Some of the songs are more folky than others. But overwhelmingly, it is very country and that is not for me. Spotify does not have the complete album on there but there is a playlist was created to mimic it.
Not my pick for listening to someone pick pickers.
Just a nice chill old bag of blues. Bonus points for two tracks in a row being about bugs and a track about the borax mines. It sounds more timeless than a lot of tosh from the 50's and I like how it sounded like just him, his guitar and a mike. Woodie Guthrie has a very strange speaking voice
Again, another album that is pleasant enough, but doesn't really seem to warrant inclusion on its own merit. Sure, maybe it did influence a lot of other albums that are included in the list - Dylan et al - but in it's own right..........? Hard to see why personally.
Country 50's
ramblin man with a guitar and what seems like an unusual interest in household insects
No me gustó, no soy fan del country y menos cuando parece que agarraron un banjo y se pusieron a entonar lo primero que se le vino a la mente
The country girl in me loves this. Makes me think of 4th of July on the lake with my family. San Francisco Bay makes me want to learn how to line or swing dance. Honestly love the yodel/folk/bluegrass vibes. So fun. Obsessed with the harmonica. We need more harmonicas in music.
Welp this things has finally taken me to the other side of the tracks where I've never wandered before. Apparently Muleskinner is the same album plus two songs. San Francisco Bay Blues starts off the album with a sparse arrangement of plucked guitar melody with some spoken word overlay. Opens up about halfway through into a pretty traditional sounding Blues song. I'm into it -- seems like the sort of stuff that the Dead inspired a lot of their Workingman's Dead era songs from. The Boll Weevil and Bed Bug Blues are both super folky. Feels like a natural precursor to Dylan (side note: apparently they were friends). I kind of tuned out after this point and let the album fall into the background. This is fine, but not great folk music. I can see where it was ahead of its time in some respects, but its not something I would come back for repeated listens to. Soft 3/5.
I think I expected to like this album more than I did. I generally like older American music from a history standpoint. While I enjoyed listening to the album from that perspective, I was never too invested in the music itself.
The Boll Weevil song is a jam. Oh hell yeah 2 songs about bugs in a row I had no idea what to expect with this album and what I really didn't expect was a song about woof to end it
Already showing age here by not appearing on Apple Music. What up Youtube! Bed Bugs Blues is giving me flashbacks. Wow Clapton way to steal Ramblin' Jack Elliott's song about cocaine. Another knock on Clapton. Using this more to shit on Clapton. What's the difference between a bag of cocaine and a baby? Eric Clapton wouldn't let a bag of cocaine fall out of a window. 2/5
The human version of Uncle Pecos, Jerry's country music singing uncle from the Tom and Jerry cartoon 'Pecos Pest'. It genuinely wouldn't surprise me if Ramblin' Jack Elliott was the inspiration behind Uncle Pecos. Several tracks on the album are reminiscent of 'Froggy went a-courtin' and one song even has a yodel part that's a little to high for him. Whilst it's tempting to give this a pass as a museum piece, songs about the types of insects that annoy Elliott most don't really resonate in 2023, and the pre-song chat that precedes many of the tracks just seems like a parody today. Rating: 1.5/5 Playlist track: Salty Dog Date listened: 06/07/23
Inspired by Woody Guthrie, traditional folk country, good story telling. Simple music with just guitar and voice and the occasional harmonica.
Not for me.
So happy to listen to this. I did need to find this on vinyl preferably a little scratched up, get a heavy pour of cheap bourbon and sit back and enjoy.
I love stripped down folk country. This sounded like it was recorded at open mic night with the song intros and the live, “first take” quality of the music. Sounds like this was a pretty heavy influence on Arlo Guthrie (East Texas Talking Blues v. Alice’s Restaurant). And I had no idea Jackson Browne didn’t write Cocaine! Neither did Elliott, but at least he credits Rev. Gary Davis introducing the song. I will absolutely listen to this again.
This didn't work for me.
This wasn't for me. A little too much Ramblin I guess. I can see how he would go on to influnce artists that I do like, so that's good. But I can never see putting this one on again.
Boring
I liken this to the Robert Johnson recordings. It's a very simple recording: the man and his guitar. That doesn't mean the recording themselves are simple. There's not much to add to what Elliott puts into it. The sparseness of the songs really doesn't matter. The album is only 30 minutes long, which I think was probably the sufficient length. Anything longer would start to be a bit much. I liked the album for what it was, a simple blues album. Once I realized what it was going to be I was not expecting it to be more than that.
Yeah Jack Elliott rambles alright. Each song has a meandering and possibly unnecessary intro from Elliott (and Woody Guthrie to boot). Then again, it's kind of the charm, giving the album a feel of a live performance and letting him put his own twist on the songs, which are rarely his. I don't mind his simple plucking and playing but I'm not rushing out to find more of it either. Next.
A pleasant fireside guitar-pickin peach of a recording.
I listened to this like Mr. Rogers was cosplaying as a cowboy, which made this more enjoyable.
The man did what he came to do I guess but it’s not for me and not original enough for me to rate it higher
He be ramblin'
Serves as an interesting document of early American country/folk, but not particularly accessible.
Like the songs better than the singer, but after listening to the Cars and TLC and the Hives finally one I could enjoy.
One of the most boring albums you will ever hear
2.5
Calm country music
Difficult to say. Not exactly much depth to be found here. The only thing I could really comment on is it’s excellent lyricism.
Listening to Mountain Stage the other night, I realize how limited my knowledge of traditional American music is (folk, blues, etc). Guess this is a good jumping off point. Very by the basics, but you see where American music gets the jumping off point from recordings like these. While I'm here, how is there no Woody Guthrie album on here? He has recordings. Favorite tracks: "Boll Weevil", "New York Town", "Dink's Song", "Salty Dog"
I get it, like it’s kinda cool but not for too long 3/5
the entire album is just this guy jack elliot doing smothers brothers-esque songs until Dink’s Song which is a slow, big band jazz song with a female singer. i don’t know why
6/10. Good old-timey fun.
I liked some of the guitar but it was pretty boring. 5/10
idk what to say
I have now been indoctrinated into folk. This is all I want now. 5/5 Favorite song: San Francisco Baby Blues
Música country americana de las primeras épocas. Voz un tanto grave y profunda. Para muy entusiastas del género, aunque se escucha bien
I'm giving this a slightly higher mark, because I love folk music. It has a kind of "documentation of the times, representing the underdog," vibe about it. Unfortunately, he feels like a low rent Bob Dylan and the most memorable part about it was that I live an hour away from where on of the songs is set.
Ramblin' all right... This was not my bag, my purse or my cup of tea. I appreciated he kept his rambling brief though, so thank you for that Jack. Low point here was the yodelling, reminded me of my girlfriend's cat asking to be fed every morning only without the tin of tuna to give to him to make him fucking stop. Fun times.
I get what he was going for. I also get that allegedly Bob Dylan patterned his song delivery on Ramblin Jack. But that does not make this a great album.
Un disco que pinta un paisaje y epoca exquisitos. El folk hace que te sientas en casa y ese sonido viejo de mal grabado aportan a la sensación. a pesar de que pinta el paisaje de manera literaria, no es más que eso y el album se queda un poco liso en eso, por es que el disco es un 8/10.
This is one of those cases where I wish the Wikipedia entry had more information about the significance of this album. Jack Elliot, and particularly this album seems to have been highly influential on a number of genres during the decades after its release. The recording quality is pretty poor, but the songs are good. It's not particularly my genre of music, but it's easy to see why people like it 3/5
Well, his voice does not grate my ears, the guitar works are nice, it's not overblown or overproduced. So while it sounds a bit generic, it's pretty good for a standard folk album.
It’s very meh and boring, not really my cup of tea. It’s pretty repetitive and just VERY boring. Favourite tracks: San Francisco Baby Blues and Cocaine were ok, the rest is meh Least favourite: Black Baby and Mule Skinner Blues. Horrible tracks and Mule Skinner Blues was obnoxious
not for me
Extremely average blues/country licks, nothing special about the vocals either.
Nothing special, but easy enough to listen to.
Along with Woody Guthrie and Pete Seeger, this is an obvious jump point, if not actual influence to Dylan, Byrd's et al. Very rootsy blues/folk. Not a fan of the yodel/howl!
Been a good week (musically only)
Have just embarked on the Ken Burns country music documentary in an attempt to resolve my deep seated hatred for the fiddle and banjo. Will report back in 16 hours.
Cowboy/hobo Woody Guthrie. Interesting but a lot of songs about bugs…?
This album is older than me! Historic slice of American folk-blues.
This bugged me for a few songs because it sounded familiar but I couldn't put my finger on it. Then I realised it sounds like Bob Dylan. It pre-dates Bob Dylan, but that's still absolutely no fucking excuse for sounding like Bob Dylan. I thought it was mercifully over at some point because the style changed so dramatically, but no, there's just a fucking show tune halfway through for no reason. It sucked too. Update: just read his wiki, and I'm not American so correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't these tunes a little too southern for a New York jew? haha. I almost gave it an extra point for this, but no. 2/5.
Rambling by name rambling by nature, definitely an acquired taste but not for me
Very important recording in American music. Ollllld school folk from the 50s. This is the stuff that inspired Bob Dylan. Can’t go wrong.
Classic folk/country. Probably won’t listen to this album in the future, but appreciate what it did for folk/country.
I'm just loving this site!
It was cool to listen to it once for historical reasons. It must have been very influential 70 years ago
This was a cool album. Really enjoyed the guitar work and the vibe of it.
4.5 excellent
Lite Woody light, men ok då.
Excellent
Cet homme est tout ce qu'il y a de plus détestable avec son chapeau et sa façon de parler ridicule. Et ça n'a pas loupé, je l'ai détesté dès la première seconde. Plus jamais tu nous remets ces conneries Robert.
Ramblin' Jack Eliott est-il l'ancêtre de Johnny Cash? Je vais tâcher de mener l'enquête de mon côté, je vous tiendrai au courant des avancées de mes recherches.
Redneck country
This is pretty cool old blues and folk.
Boring
A good representation of country folk
Shocking he’s from Brooklyn. Not a bad sound, but a bit dull when you compare Elvis and Buddy Holly from that time, and the stuff from Bob Dylan to come shortly after.
Enjoyable and barebones early country folk album without any real highlights
For what it is musically, it's fine, but the co-opting of Southern culture by a Dylan compatriot definitely reads as anything other than genuine. Throw in some off-base bonus tracks meant to lengthen the album for re-release (including a near-orchestral track with female vocals?) and it's hard to feel that this is a passion project more so than money grab.
A must have for any road trip
bof
Too He Haw.
Liked the sound of the guitar. Stories were kind of funny too. Woody Guthrie surprised me.
love the commentary between tracks
Wholesome C&W from a man and a guitar. Its a slightly ropey recording but I like the way he introduces each song. The 30 min experience just kinda washed over me but its always good to hear someone new. ( if you know what I mean)
shit
This sounds like early Bob Dylan to me, but Dylan definitely developed more.
This wasn’t as bad as I anticipated but it still wasn’t for me.
som bem das antiga, countryzao
Ugh
Another great country/folk album. Ramblin' Jack Elliot has simple yet earnest style. On this album, we are treated to a feature by Wood Guthrie himself, a mentor of Elliot. Jack Elliot himself went on to have a massive influence on artists such as Bob Dylan, and Woody's son, Arlo Guthrie. Jack Elliot is a living line directly to Woody himself.
Folk is just so painfully bad to listen to
He sure was ramblin'
San Francisco Baby Blues- 6 Ol' Riley- 4 The Boll Weevil- 2 Bed Bug Blues- 2 New York Town- 3 Grey Goose- 1 Mule Skinner Blues- 1.3 Cocaine- 3.2 Dink's Song- 4 Black Baby- 4 Salty Dog- 5.4
I mean... it's a good listen and there's a neat spookiness to these old bad recordings. Something fun in the simplicity of these songs. And Cocaine I have a weird long history with, where I think I heard it first as a young kid because I left a radio playing and woke up to it in the middle of the night once. I don't fell particularly moved by any of it, though.
The bridge between the likes of Lead Belly and Woody Guthrie, and the Sixties folkies like Dylan. Elliott does a fine impersonation of Guthrie on 'New York Town', but is also responsible for some rotten yodelling on 'Mule Skinner Blues'. Strange sounding album for a fella from Brooklyn. I like it well enough, but Elliott isn't as charismatic as Lead Belly, nor as wry as Guthrie, so this evens out around three stars. 'Grey Goose' is fun.
I might be more in the mood for this someday, but today is not that day. I mean... wouldn't it make more sense to just listen to Woody Guthrie instead of this? Maybe that's too harsh, but it's all I can think at the moment. I'll give him credit though. Apparently "Ramblin' Jack" the country boy is actually "Elliott Adnopoz" from Brooklyn. Takes guts to completely reinvent yourself like this and even crazier to think it actually worked out. Good on him?
I may not have loved it, but a good history lesson.
2.7/5
I would probably never listen to this but it's charming in a way.
Auch eher nur musikhistorisch interessant.
Ok, hear me out… Jandek Takes the Floor. A full cover of this record as performed by Jandek. I’m not crazy, right? There’s something there? Like it could definitely work.
Awful Terrible voice, whiney songs, nothing at all good to say about this album
Boring old country
Meh
didn’t like it. he was ramblin too much. lives up his name
Horrible. How or why this is on this list is beyond me
What a painful experience
Bijzonder, deze man kende ik nog niet. Ik ga hier nog eens goed naar luisteren, ook zijn relatie tot Woody Guthrie en Jack kerouac.
'Cocaine all around the brain'! Als dit een straatmuzikant was, zou ik blokje omlopen om deze mafkees te kunnen ontlopen...
Iets te gedateerd voor mij
Nee ik word hier niet heel enthousiast van.
I expected to despise this but something got me to actually listen to it. quite like the cocaine song.
Dogshit on toast
Really enjoyed this
ok
This was interesting in that this influenced a lot of folk music I guess. I enjoyed it for the most part.
Old school folk/country. Kinda fun but a bit too hokey
Yea, this was just too annoying for me. Hoping this is the last time we see Jack take the floor. Tough one to make all the way through. 0 for me.
3 This album is an enigma. Having never heard of the artist, the Wikipedia page only offered me five brief, matter of fact sentences (one of which mentions its inclusion on this list), and even more strangely, while the album is nowhere to be found on Ramblin’ Jack’s Spotify page or through in-app lookup, a Google search reveals the album does in fact exist on Spotify and is fully listenable. What are you hiding, Jack?? Further research into Ramblin’ Jack’s career reveals a deeply rooted Woody Guthrie idolization (his first studio recording was even a Guthrie cover album), and a quick listen to any given track on this album basically confirms that. Yet despite that, and despite me being ready to write him off as a glorified fanboy, I actually really enjoyed my listening. Sure, it’s not the most distinct thing I’ve heard, and no, Ramblin’ Jack doesn’t come off quite as versatile as his hero or contemporaries like Bob Dylan, but I had fun. And you know what? Sometimes that’s what it’s all about. Makes me want to play some Red Dead. Favorite songs: San Francisco Bay Blues, The Boll Weevil, Cocaine, Brother Won’t You Join in the Line
Bed bugs!!!
Äkta lande musik 🤠
Nice lo-fi aesthetic and sparse arrangement
Ok
Folkity folky folk. Not much more to it than that.
I like this Folk shit. Sue me.
I get it, but I dont like it
I really enjoyed the first few songs but it quickly got a bit too yodelly for my liking
Fun album, bit twangy
cool
Surprisingly not bad.
Vähän tällästä kahden markan Dylania! Ei oikeen oo samaa potkuu ku WG:llä tai BD:llä kyl. 2/5
Sinänsä lämpenen musalle, mutta on tällaista parempaakin.
Avausraita vahva ja muutenkin ajan hampaan kestänyttä folkia. 3/5.
Jack Elliot sounds like Woodie Guthrie. Bob Dylan sounds like Jack Elliot. He did the whole "pretend to be a country bumpkin though really from a privileged upbringing" before John Fogerty did it. Can definitely see why this album is in the book even though I'm not a huge folk fan. If you like folk, this is a classic. If you don't, it will be grouped w/ Dylan and you'll rate it the same.
This must have been a pretty wild recording back in 1958. I really like the guitar.
Dated country, don't see this as must listen
Dunno, sleep in, good run, really sad, like tearing up at the mems which is frustrating, swann dinner, tired
Stripped down songwriting that bridges the Depression -era folks tradition and the new troubador movement of the 60s and beyond.
Pretty classic folk. Dug it.
This feels old and the mixing is quite complex, I mean it's back from the 50s but still, it's pretty nice as country songs but I'm pretty sure better has been done to this day. I guess that would be fine in the far west but yeah, not astonished overall. 2.25 / 5
The album is not that great.... Overall repetitive and the master sounds old (not point taken out but simply feels bad) some tracks are funny to listen to but I would not recommend as an album... 2/5
Country...
This one caught me off guard. Definitely one of the founding fathers of the folk/protest movement of the 60s along with Dylan. Surprisingly good stuff.
Alright, nothing great, nothing bad. 3/5
Nah
Jack do be Ramblin' Im lying face first in a giant field after a big shootout finale to a western listening to this
Not a high point
2.5
No es lo mío. Me aburrió rápidamente, pero hey, descubrí de dónde viene una canción del Unplugged de Eric Clapton que me gusta mucho.
I didn't look into the details of this album yet, but I'm making general guesses about the era. This is less good honky tonk, some of the songs were outright annoying.
Je suis partagé sur celui-là. C'est de la bonne musique et c'est très viscéral, mais c'est à un niveau trèèès southern folk qui devient lourd à la longue.
Hard album to find cause I guess it's not on any streaming but thanks to illegal YouTube uploads I got it. This album is so very good. It feels like it's like a crowd of 10 or 15 people just sitting around listening to this musical traveler. He's got songs from all over and he's just the voice passing them on. Excellent all around
As cowboy albums go, this one is alright. Just a guy and his guitar, singing repetitive songs. I can tell he puts his whole into each performance though and that's nice.
San Francisco Bay Blues is a banger. Everything else though is unfortunately very bland. I bet it was great fifty years ago but it's very dated now.
I enjoy me some old fashioned country but I feel like I should have enjoyed this a lot more. I agree with a lot of the sentiments done by the other users written here. 2.5/5
Short and sweet and some good fun songs. The beauty of the opener cover though shines a spotlight on how Jacks own songs are a bit plain compared the richness of others of the genre. Doesn’t make it less fun though - just frames the album into the context of others and hence why although I had a good time listening to it it’s simply 3 stars.
Good stuff! Quite the variety of blues, folk, country, and even some jazzy type stuff. Obviously very influential. 3 stars.
A poor version of Woody Guthrie (who appears on one track). What makes this worth appearing in the list is unclear. Most of the songs are written by other people, the performance is not exceptional and at times is rather mediocre. Ramblin' Jack Elliot can have been an influence on some, but surely not a strong one
Not for me.
I can not compare jack with Woody Guthrie, Bob Dylan or Pete Seeger,but just love the ramblin country vibes!this is what i call the digger's delight!
Country blues í anda Johnny Cash en ekki alveg jafn gott.
Was okay, personally not the biggest fan of country music
3.75
Well, not much to say. Kind of country version of Bob Dylan, but not as poetic and maybe subjectively better singer. Songs about hard life in West USA, for sure he had to be some kind of country prototype. As I mentioned couple times already, neither folk, country or bards are my cup of tea, especially that in my opinion Jack Elliott doesn't stand out in any way.
Fun cowboy stuff with plenty of heart.
Buen country
Balls
It's okay, probably a 2.5, but just not enough to my taste to roll it up to 3.
26th July 2022 Listened while prepping sandwiches for the day before going down to the river. Read in the evening while mum, dad and kids went to carrefour. Classic country and blues, always great storytelling and Jack seems to be one of the best. Loved the humour throughout too. 3.5 if I could.
This was a fun story-time romp which had me laughing out loud at times!
Lightweight, kinda cool but mostly corny cowboy jingles.
Nope.
Pretty solid, if mostly straightforward folk/country record. Always a pleasure to hear a new version of Dink’s Song.
Busker...it sounds like a busker.
How can you have this on the list, but not the singing postman? Ha ya ma gor a dickie bor?
I sometimes feel like I succumb to the “authentic therefore good” reasoning with this kind of thing. Is it that great? Is it authentic even, I suppose, this Brooklyn-bred child of a well-to-do professional. On the other hand it’s safe to say running off at 15 to join the rodeo wasn’t some stunt to develop a good backstory for his later music career. I didn’t mind this at all though this kind of deep roots country is not a music I go to as a rule. But I’ll defer to Woody Guthrie and Johnny Cash to tip the scale on this one.
This was an enjoyable listen. Simple, bare bones, good humored folk. I really like Elliott's laid back, slightly sweet vocal style, and his guitar picking is solid. Fave Songs: Salty Dog, Boll Weevil, New York Town, Mule Skinner Blues, San Francisco Bay Blues, Cocaine
Thanks to the kind person who made a playlist of this album on YouTube, as it was not available on Apple Music in the USA. This album was kind of amusing and felt very, very American. I don't know what I was expecting, but it wasn't songs about bed bugs, boll weevils, and cocaine. I felt the same as most other albums on this list: I liked it, but I probably wouldn’t listen again. I had never heard of Ramblin’ Jack Elliott but I can see how and why his music was influential at the time.
Well, it does ramble.
terminé saltandome las ultimas canciones porque me aburrí de escuchar canciones que son prácticamente iguales una de la otra así que con eso les digo todo
Jack Elliott. I don't know how this is among the 1001 best albums, I doubt it was even particularly significant in 1958. It's very plain country music at best.
Started tedious, and got worse. I did laugh when he did an intro spiel about how people often seek solace in sleep, but that it sometimes made it worse, before launching into a song about bed bugs :D then we have what sounds like a hostage situation with Woody Guthrie to start track 5. Now he's quacking at the end of track 6 (which is about geese, who don't quack. They hiss or honk). Next track wasn't offensive until he started yodelling midway through. Back to inoffensive but interesting for the next couple, then whiny, and then a song that is better than the others but still not good. He just really can't sing very well. 1/5, but only because I can't give a 0. Probably the worst thing we've had so far, but at least he had the good manners to stop after half an hour.
A pretty underwhelming album. A consistent album of short country songs in pretty poor quality. I know the album is old but country music then really was pretty dull. 2.7/10
well this was an album! it had a great sense of authenticity and i liked how unrefined it was. however, it is definitely from 1958 and i don't think i liked it. i could not believe i listened to a song about bed bugs. whoever sang dink's song has the loveliest voice, but i don't think it was mr. elliott.
I see now why he is called RAMBLIN' Jack Elliott. He also drawls, howls, yodels, and warbles. Definitely not my thing. It was bearable for 30 minutes, but just barely. I would argue that I could have gone without hearing this one before I die.
3.5 - I'm sitting in my jammies, putzing around before bed and this record is right now a terrific companion. I'd also enjoy hearing this in the background at a used bookstore with a curled up cat dozing in a sunny corner. Standouts: "Mule Skinner Blues", "Cocaine."
Grey Goose!
Ljúf plata með tónlist sem er einhvern vegin i dnainu eftir mjög mikla Bob Dylan hlustun á unglingsaldri.
Mikill áhrifavaldur segja mér menn. En það er bara ekki nóg kallinn minn.
Сижу как-то я у дельты реки где-то в штате Алабама и слышу этот альбом;)
Genre: Contemporary Folk 3/5 Well, I'll give it this: this is folk music, for real. Fuck that phony Bob Dylan shit, fuck any of that goofy UK shit that followed him (except for Donovan, he's cool), this is real down-home cookin', dust bowl whirlin', foot tappin' folk music. Jack Elliott, his guitar, his harmonica, and his roaring voice, which can even be stretched to yodels whenever necessary, make for a pretty darn good little album, albeit quite dated and a bit repetitive. This whole album felt like it was ripped directly out of O Brother, Where Art Thou. Jack Elliott is a goofball, and you feel his sense of humor throughout this album. Some of the songs stray away from your average lost-love, hard-times blues tune (Cocaine, Ol' Riley), and you get goofs like Bed Bug Blues and New York Town, which are sweet little nuggets of music that help cut through the straight folkiness of it all. All in all, really not as bad as I had thought it would be, but only because its authenticity is apparent. Good stuff from Jack.
Rudimentary folk/country music from the late 50's. As a whole, this felt like a mess and even at 30 minutes it was a bit of a drag to get through. Sorry Jack. I do love your 2009 comeback though, so I'm still willing to hear your other albums.
Very rudimentary stuff, I almost died of boredom
Basic stuff, but still enjoyable.
A man, a guitar and that's it. With all the modern means of production that we hear on today's albums, a return to basics is often very pleasant. Ramblin' Jack Elliott not particularly hooked me, but I'm happy to know him better now!
Very basic
Barn síns tíma, for sure. Áhugaverð hlustun.
Very quaint and intimate.
Like the background story on Ramblin' Jack. Had never heard of him before. Not my typical music but I did find it enjoyable. I like the folksy sound. 3/5
never heard of this guy before, don't have to listen again
Didn’t mind the guitar. Singing and songs were shite.
Not great
It was fine I guess. Guitar was nice. Boring album overall
Pretty minimal
Jag gillar
Banger
Orrefors hade fel jag tycker detta var bra.
Not for me but I can see where Boring Dyling got his inspiration from.
It was good. Ain’t Dylan or other famous folk, but solid.
This folk album is from Ramblin' Jack Elliott and was released in 1958. It's so old that there is little information on it. The music is alright if you enjoy a single, folksy singer songwriter. I thought this album was forgettable.
Some rather simple, rambling songs, nothing I will revisit.
A notably critter-centric album. Critters include the human kind and reinforce the humanity of the music. Ups, downs, echoes make me happy I listened.
Quite boring tbh. Only 1 or 2 songs worth coming back to and one of them was a Sarah Vaughan song (cover?). 3/10
Somewhere between Guthrie and Dylan but not as good as either.
Solid twanging.
Uff ps supongo que fue bueno en los 50s
Not my thing at all - they all sound remarkably similar
A nice bluesy album with a little country/folk twang thrown in for good measure. However, listening to this album straight through has it all sounding like the same song.
Kind of no-politic Guthrie
Yep. It's an interesting song. And when you have songs about the boll weevil, bed bugs, and cocaine, it's a recipe for high bugs? I do like the simple tones accompanied by a guitar. I wonder if these are the songs Walker sings in Yellowstone. Either that or Walker doesn't have the copyright to sing anything else. As I ramble I'm reminded that I'd probably listen to this again, given that this is the very first time that I've listened to it.
An interesting flashback to a more traveling folk singer vibe... particularly with interesting perspective songs like Boll Weevil and Mule Skinner Blues. Was cool to listen to.
listenable, but you know, o.l.d.a.s.f.u.c.k.
mehhhhhh
Enjoyed the start of the album but some songs were questionable towards the end.
Possibly a fine example of C&W music, and fine if you like that sort of thing. Sounds like whining to me.
I've never heard of this man before, but I'm glad to see he's still alive. There's yodelling and songs about weevils - it's hard not to be at least a little charmed. Plus, the recording is *so* primitive and the chat *so* typically old-timey, it has to be the real deal, right? 2.5
This is the kind of album I'm doing this for. Not much chance I'd have given this a listen if it didn't pop up in this list. The more sober / serious songs were great, and I really liked this rendition of Cocain Blues. However, I could be doing with less of the comical tunes. Grey Goose is truly awful
Gently rolling country folky fun
This was good, but it didn't leave much of an impression on me.
Meh. Although I can recognize its importance and understand why it would be included on a list like this, I ultimately found this album unimpressive and pretty average. It is hard to even call it an album as it is more of a collection of random songs Jack Elliott recorded at the time (it doesn't even show up as an album on Spotify; it shows up as a playlist). I'm sure what he was doing at the time could be considered groundbreaking in the folk scene, but I didn't feel the same impact that I do when I hear a rock or blues album from the 1950's in that the songs here are pretty simple and somewhat forgettable. One track that stood out to me was 'Grey Goose', and that is only because it sounds straight up like an Adam Sandler song. Another track, 'Cocaine', I remember for its unique reference to a drug that I'm sure wasn't being done very often, but I cannot tell you anything about the song other than that. Overall, there just wasn't enough depth or emotion here that would make it stand out when compared to other folk artists who came afterwards that were most likely influenced by Elliott. I didn't hate it, but I ultimately found it perfectly mediocre. 2.5/5.
Not my favorite classic western album of all time, but some tracks were pretty fun.
very stripped back and bare but what can you expect from a 50s country rock album. very easy listening
I liked a couple of songs, but the album on the whole was pretty average.
1/12/22
Surprisingly fun to listen to. None of the songs seemed too high caliber in terms of skill or talent, but I could see myself singing along around a campfire or something. Folksy and catchy, but nothing stood out as very great.
Well this was a fun album. Folk music as it was meant to be presented, simple, unencumbered, great stories told simply and succinctly. I enjoyed this album very much. 4 🌟
Zupełnie nie trafił w mój gust
5/10
Marty Robbins doc Watson esque. Pretty decent story telling
probably would have enjoyed it more then
Never heard of him before but his music sounds familiar. Either he is doing someone else's style or they are all doing his. Good for what it is. 2/5
This reminds me of some of the stuff grandpa Kenny used to sing/strum, but his voice was WAY better. For me, this has only historical value.
It was a simpler time, I suppose.
Un altre dels discos històrics que ha perdut ja gran part de la seva rellevància. Acòlit de Woody Guthrie i per tant un dels primers mestres de Dylan, els temes sonen ja prehistòrics i cal tenir una gran conciència històrica del folk i la música en general per poder acceptar la seva importància
Im trying to take it for what it is. The point of doing this for all genres is to give it a chance. Its old country blues with a single guy singing and playing guitar. topics include whatever and i mean whatever. a song about bed bugs… still better than the twang but wont relisten … 1 to 2
Ja fint nok. Men lidt ligegyldigt
sygt at det er lavet i 58
God gammel folk, meget simpelt, men også hyggeligt nok
Like a time capsule - interesting, but dusty.
A goofier Guthrie. A cowboy Woody. I can dig it. No doubt Bob D took a page from Jack's book on how to sing through your nose. Compared to those two folk titans Jack seems like a lightweight. Woody had a way of making simple things universal, and Bob is untouchable Bob. Do I need more Oakie Folk in my cereal? Probably not, but Jack's a goofy marshmallow. C. P.S. did Sarah Vaughan randomly drop in the middle of this album for you too?
Proto Dylan, Townes Van Zandt, etc. Good for what it is. Ahead of its time. Succinct. The Sarah Vaughn thing threw me off. But yet another album that is so old I’m not going to rate it a 5 but in its time it was probably due a 5.
they gave me the wrong song at one point
Rating: 5/10
Old school folk/country album met prachtige stem
This was fun. You gotta love an album where the singer tells you it's yet another one of them East Texas prison songs. I love his introductions to these very earthy songs about insects, dogs, prison, hunting, and, naturally, cocaine. He obviously has a love for this music and a desire to share it. He finds interesting connections between American folk subcultures jumping from Texas to Harlem, all sounding raw and soulful.
With no previous knowledge of Ramblin' Jack, when the first tune started, my first reaction was that this was pretty fun. As the album progressed, it did not hold my attention, however. There were a few other upbeat moments of interested that grabbed me, including the last tune, but overall I was not all that into it.
Oh, I like this. I like the style of music, the quality of his voice, and his ramblings. His folksy country-boy persona comes across as kind, gentle, and authentic. This despite his being raised in Brooklyn, his first exposure to rodeo being in Madison Square Garden of all places (according to Wikipedia). He sounds to my Wyoming-raised ears just like a genuine cowboy. I enjoyed this a lot.
This isn't exactly my type of music and not the kind of thing I'll play often, but I'm very glad to have listened to it. At times the recording were a bit muddy, but the simplicity of the arrangements - a guitar and a voice - made this less of an issue. The album is under "Compilations" in Apple Music and this certainly feels like a compilation rather than a cohesive album to me. The songs deal with lots of subjects – old dogs, boll weevils, bed bugs, dogs, cocaine, 20 mule team borax, love, prison... My favorite songs: The Boll Weevil, Old Blue (from the reissue) Not adding this to my library but a pleasant listen!
Recognized a lot of these songs. Enjoyable, but not something I’m going to seek out again to listen to on my own.
Easy to hear the influence on Dylan's early records. Bob invited him to take part in his Rolling Thunder Revue tour in the mid 70's and he's pretty hilarious whenever he's on camera (in the Scorsese documentary)
Pretty samey but Mule Skinner's Blues is a great little ditty.
Not super interesting.
obviously it isn’t my favourite but i didn’t hate it. the talking was a little awkward and there were some like screeching noises? but it’s was funny
This is kind of hilarious. Definitely not my standard kind of music at all but I .... weirdly enjoyed it? Not just a little reminiscent of Stompin' Tom Conners. The "Ramblin'" part is what makes it for me - it's totally silly listened through a modern lens...his low-key folksy chatting to the audience before each song as he's strumming a few chords... but I think that's what draws me in. Probably wouldn't like much more of this and definitely not a repeat spin but for a quick half-hour it's worth the simple and fun look back at raw mid-20th century country-folk. 7/10 3 stars
This was a welcome change, didn't expect to like any folk that is pre-Dylan but I enjoyed it
Brilliant. Raw, "real" and Woody Guthrie!
Jack Takes the Floor by Ramblin’ Jack Elliot (1958) Ramblin’ Jack Elliot is the phony that folks accused Bob Dylan of bein’. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot is the young Bob Dylan without the brains. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot sounds like he came from Missouri, ‘cept he don’t sound like that to people who been there. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot knows how to tune a guitar, but he don’t. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot learnt everythin’ from a Madison Square Garden rodeo clown except how to avoid the bull. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot shares the politics of Woody Guthrie in there somewhere, but it’s kinda hard to find. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot is important for the history of somethin’ that really ain’t that important. Ramblin’ Jack Elliot has fans who know exactly what I’m talkin’’bout. 1/5
Especially i don't like man vocal in a country music
Interesting 50s honky tonk with some interesting bug blues