Can we stop pretending every shit from a Beatle is gold? #freeRingo

Wow. This one was easy to rate.

Yuk. An uneven and overrated album and that’s before bringing in the singer’s history.

What a fucking slog. Third Springsteen album that I ‘Had to hear’ smh.

4.5 stars but a weird grade because Alive 2007 is my favorite live album and there needs to be some differentiation. If that album didn’t exist then this would be 5 stars.

Pleasant listen. There's nothing wrong with this music but doesn't move me.

Maybe the greatest album artwork. If only the songs matched. I’ve wanted to like this album for years but just can’t get there. Perhaps the context of the release is essential to understanding why this is such a standout.

Pretty fun album. Only knew the single and there’s more to this band than that one song from all the indie comedies.

Didn’t finish. Snooze fest

Rockstar shit.

Fine early punk. Doesn’t really break out or transcend the normal chord progressions.

Not a fan. Ambien music.

No Sympathy is a standout but overall just an okay album. Sort of feels like you had to be there.

Pretty cool album. Feels like a Wolf Parade precursor.

Good for Springsteen, probably one of his best but still feels pretty one dimensional.

The Kinks rock and this is no exception. Can’t wait for Village Green

Kinda good but just off putting and not for me

Fun listen, lots of jams.

Nope, not for me

Lol. Who gives a shit

Like the other Roots album. Technically good but the rap music equivalent of eating a large pile of steamed broccoli.

A little slow but very enjoyable

A fine album.

First album to feel actively annoying

A cool precursor to Dropkick Murphy’s and Flogging Molly

What a blast. So ahead of it’s time. Even if the rhymes are simple, the production just sounds completely unique.

Meh

Not great, pretty repetitive, no Rumors

What a legend.

A bit boring compared to my memory

This was a fun album.

Quick, great flow.

Stone cold classic.

Old hip hop is generally bad. This is very old hip hop.

A little long but a great album.

Pretty fun, very 80s

Very good album. A couple songs feel like outliers but a clear precursor to many modern indie stars.

It’s fine, good instrumentation.

More innovative than enjoyable. More tedious than her other albums. A great artist but and overhyped work.

A good album but it blends together. The first song is very exciting and feels like a throwback to early aughts indie’s best impulses, but by the end it has become mush.

5 stars for the atmosphere, minus 2 for everything else.

A shrug.

Super funky base lines, lots of fun and doesn’t get too jammy or long winded

Not that good, not that bad.

Feels very 90s. Maybe too many world music albums this week to give this its proper consideration.

Who are these early nineties albums for? All the expression of a stale saltine.

Yuk. An uneven and overrated album and that’s before bringing in the singer’s history.

An album that you have to let flow over you. Took a few tries with Spiritualized but really liked this.

The best songs are just so good. Some half baked shit bogs it down in the middle.

Objectively a good album but feels like lab grown indie rock. Jesus etc. being the exception.

Good god, nope.

Pyramid brings this thing up to at least 3, Thinking bout you pulls it even higher, but then Pink Matter, White, and basically the rest of the album pulls it back down.

Didn’t know what to expect, loved this.

Serious Prince is the worst

Pretty tonally similar throughout. Dark gospel starts cool, gets boring.

Fine music, nothing special.

It’s Blitz is better. This is still good.

Idk about this one. Doesn’t feel like I HAD to hear this.

Didn’t finish.

Not really for me but some beautiful vocals.

No more early 90s rap, pleeaassseee

Idk I guess this is something. The riffs are tight but this just isn’t a genre I care about.

Is this a joke?

Okay voice, massively over produced.

Whatever. This list is getting sus.

Not their best but not bad

This is a fun album. Thank god cause it’s been a rough two weeks. A bit long for 5 stars but an extremely solid 4 stars. Some of the base playing just makes you say whoa

Absolute classic. All hail the duke.

Dumb but v fun.

A beautiful album, wish it had a little bit more grab but there are some great songs here. Precursor to a lot of aughts indie.

Such a strong start but really falls off. 30 minutes would be the right length for this album, a tempo change at any point also wouldn’t have hurt.

Sticking to my theory that the 90s outside of rap were broadly shit.

Can we stop pretending every shit from a Beatle is gold? #freeRingo

A really fun listen. There isn’t much of a concept behind the album but 90% of the songs are classics.

I don’t quite click with Roxy Music. This is their second album that’s come up and both times I’ve felt it’s good not great and while I respect the ideas, the execution feels just alright.

Loved this album in high school but found it deeply boring upon relistening. Sample at the start is an amazingly arrogant way to start off and you really need to come with bangers after. This just didn’t do that. More influential than good.

What a fucking slog. Third Springsteen album that I ‘Had to hear’ smh.

Never a great sign when you’re relieved that an album ended and the Spotify algorithm took over.

Just couldn’t get into this one.

Too twee for me.

Classic for a reason, but a couple clunkers. Looking at you Man Needs a Maid

Basically perfect. One of my five favorite albums.

Probably was in the wrong headspace for this one. It’s obviously good but wasn’t feeling it.

Really enjoyed this and will listen to their other albums.

Good moment but clearly of an era.

Good tunes.

Wow, never heard anything quite like this. Might never listen again, but glad I’ve heard it.

Great flow and production. Probably the first good rap album on the list.

Extremely prog so take that either way.

A good album with great moments but loses momentum in the back third.

This album rocked. Great grunge vibe throughout, coherent sound. Big ups.

5 stars. Easy. Done.

So ahead

I mean I guess it was better than I expected?

Just beats you over the head.

Nope, no thank you.

Just comically horny and not very good.

About 10% of the way through this list and there’s a clear bucket of albums that are influential but not for me. This is another one of these.

Enjoyed the composition but didn’t really pop.

Hahahahahaha fuck out of here.

I just don’t understand why this band has at least two albums on the list.

Pretty but also pretty boring

Way cornier than I remembered but three stars for What’s Golden.

Yup, still really great.

Some fantastic moments, Parklife alone brings this thing up by a star. However, I don’t quite see the impact of this album beyond leading to more interesting products in the aughts.

Wow. Nope. Very boring and indulgent.

Probably a band that’s best of is one of the best out but this is a lot of Led.

Didn’t make it all the way through. The wailing on track two really got to me.

One of the few rap albums that’s really held up. These beats are just dope.

Classic for a lot of reasons. Still lovely to come back to this one.

Well that was better and more musically interesting than I expected.

Loved this. So much range. So much piano.

A really enjoyable listen. More funky swing than I was expecting.

The dude was right.

This was really fun. It’s a bit long at an hour and seventeen minutes but basically every song rips.

I really wanted to dunk on this album. Arcade Fire's latest albums have lost what made this band so special but hot damn The Suburbs absolutely brings it. No skips, great album apparently 19 year old me wasn't totally off base.

Wow. Imagine if Sufjan had done this 50 times.

I just don’t understand why the list author included so much early 90s rap.

Some good jamming moments but I’ll most likely never come back to this record.

Such a good and weird album. Not my favorite albums by the lips but definitely has some of my favorite songs. I’ll always associate this album with my college freshman year and driving around. Nice to bring that sense back.

Damn I love this album but fuck it’s long.

Not my favorite Smiths album but some great songs and more consistent end to end than The Queen is Dead. I get it Morissey is an asshole etc but he knows how to make indie rock music like few others.

Loved every track besides Phoenix.

Idk not really for me. A bit too much twang and twee

Some jams but gets old

Absolutely love this album and this band.

Cool production but no thank you.

Abba just isn’t for me. Kind of like Fleetwood without the edge.

Yup - so good. What a strong debut album.

Best of the three Stevie Wonder albums but just not really my style.

It’s just variants of the same song, but a damn good song.

I bet this felt so progressive when it came out but feels extremely dated.

Nice musicality but not for me. Just kind of drags on and on and on and… On

I fucking hate Frank Sinatra.

Yup, trash.

Probably the best of the early rap albums.

What an off putting album. Did not enjoy it at all. 2 stars because the atmosphere was BIG but overall not one for me.

Some interesting moments but mostly a blaze snooze of an album

There’s a large bucket of albums on this list where I respect but do not like the music. This plops firmly into that pool.

Really enjoyed this one. Pretty singular song writing without being overly eclectic.

Yup - that’s that good stuff. 40 minutes, no skips just pure butter baby.

More metal than I was expecting. Honestly, surprisingly annoying, very guitar forward and doesn’t really highlight Freddy’s incredible vocal range.

Not my favorite Beatles album but fuck, you just have to tip your hat.

Idk man. Mediocre country adjacent twang. No thanks.

More interesting than good? Feels like Bowie is finding his way into something new that doesn’t get fully realized until Toy.

When Prague goes wrong

Song to song this is cool and a fun listen but an hour and a half is too much.

Fun listen and a good revisit. Can’t say it blew my mind but it’s fun.

I really wanted to like this.

Fuck this bangs (pun intended)

God nope no thank you

Yup yup yup

Absolutely a classic

Truly didn’t expect to like this so much. The composition is just fucking tight so much for yacht rock this things a speed boat!

This was a good album! But samey throughout but an enjoyable listen

Loved this album.

Two stars for Visions of Johanna but a ton of skips

I love QOTSA but this is the wrong album. Hopefully a precursor to either Lullabies or Songs for the Deaf. Hell even Villains or Like Clockwork.

Fine indie stuff. Nothing stood out but also inoffensive.

Like watching a child throw spaghetti at a refrigerator.

Not just hornier Beatles. These guys might have some staying power.

Pretty boring, tbh.

Just so boring

Fine but doesn’t move me.

Surprisingly not bad. I went in with low expectations but sometimes that’s okay!

Not their best but still has some very strong songs.

Yeah this is fun. It’s not perfect and a few songs drag but overall I get the appeal.

Ughhhhhh not for me thanks. So slow, didn’t have pop.

Kind of a best of band.

This fucking slaps. Can see the influence on modern indie especially groups like Destroyer.

Lovely voice, probably a classic. Not my jam.

Standard smiths fair

Beautiful album, esp Coat of Many Colors

Yeah that was pretty good!

Not nearly as interesting as The Slider.

One of my all time favorite albums. Always great to revisit.

It’s hard to rate something like this as have heard most of these songs for decades. I like it but not totally convinced.

Really like the sound but should have been 30 minutes in and out.

Not my favorite Radiohead but damn if it isn’t five stars, I don’t know what is.

Liked it but 90 minutes is a lot.

Hated this album since I first heard it in like 2007. Nice to see some things haven’t changed.

My personal favorite Led Zep joint. Bit more musicality and nerd shit than the earlier albums and that’s kinda fun.

Definitely fun and ahead of it’s time

Oofa

I do not care about the sounds of CCR

Enjoyed more than expected but was ready for it to end. First song really bangs and the voice is distinctive.

Sure. Why not?

What a voice.

Yes! What an insane album.

Like listening to a pubescent boy trying to fuck a brown crayon.

Shoulder shrug. Not sure if bad or not for me so generic three stars.

Some good tunes on here but nothing to really write home about.

Pretty generic indie rock stuff

What a joy to come back to this album. Absolutely holds up and brings me right back to eating Jianbing in Tianjin on cold mornings.

So CCR is like bad Kings of Leon?

A hard album to review. I think it’s probably good for the genre and the time but not the genre for me.

This album is definitely a lot and there’s nothing wrong with that but it really felt a bit pummeling for my taste.

Lots of albums on this list seem to be arguments that 1 hit wonder bands deserve more attention. Not sure this album really makes the case.

Such a rush. Some good good punk sound.

Obviously cool. At times annoying. Makes Aerial Pink less impressive.

Certainly one of the most listenable Tom Waits adventures.

An eminently listenable album.

My personal favorite Beatles album. The B-side is just astounding.

Not offensively bad but also not good.

Good but uneven. I guess I’m happy because if this album made the list then some other great OutKast albums are on the way.

Some of the better Metallica but they really just beat you over the head with it.

Kind of the same as the last Dusty album.

Some great moments but overall more impressive in hindsight that the Beatles took it so far from this to the White Album etc.

Some amazing production - the base line on Be is always a joy and the energy on The Food is so good. At the same time, there are some clunkers here that make me cringe. For example - I used to love Testify but it just doesn’t do it anymore. A solid 4 stars and holds up better than a lot of the rap I’ve listened to on this list.

Lots of Bowie influence (he may have produced) but doesn’t have that same infectious pop. Good not great.

Listened to this when it came out and thought it was fine. Really enjoyed it upon revisiting.

Nice to end the week strong. Easy 5 stars.

Oasis has one good album and this isn’t it. Personally, I’ve just always preferred Drive Shaft so maybe biased.

Good album, very interesting sound but kinda long. The Police are absolutely one of one though and that counts too.

K-Mart Offspring?

A much kinder album than I would have expected.

Sorta expected this to be weirder and bigger.

Good moments but not exceptional.

Great atmosphere but felt like it really found it’s feet in the back half.

Gets a little tiring but Frustration and Tainted Love are absolute bangers. Also had to check to make sure I was hearing sex dwarf correctly.

Respect the musicianship but not my bag.

A bluesy effort from Bowie that works to mixed effects.

Really thought I’d like this album but it’s really just fine.

A slog of cozy songs written by committee. A perfect soundtrack for trying to sneak in and take a nap at your local Restoration Hardware.

Man - this is not my music, but it is fucking impressive.

There’s definitely a formula to Elton John’s music, but it works! A classic if it ain’t broke approach to song writing.

Way better album than I remembered. Synths on this go hard as fuck.

Some absolute all timers but a slightly soft middle.

Just a big nope on this one.

I’ve found African music often hits hard but wears thin. This album was a solid exemption with enough stylistic variation and emotion to more than offset that I can’t understand the words.

I don’t know. I didn’t like it and an hour and a half is a lot of this. I guess it’s musically good in the way a broadway show is good. Begrudging 3 stars?

Honestly I just don’t care that much about Willie Nelson’s music. National treasure etc..

A pretty typical 2Pac experience. Repetitive themes, overly long, bad features, but great production and flow.

Fine singer songwriter type things

I really don’t like CCR. They are an annoying band with a distinctly annoying sound. But this album is kind of good. I don’t like saying it but I have to acknowledge that it jams.

Maybe my favorite Radiohead album… but actually upon relistening that’s wrong. BUT it does have some of their best songs just a lot of cruft in between

Wow The National used to make really exciting music. WTF happened!?

Bounced right off this one.

Always felt a bit mixed about this album and it does take a song to get into the groove but then is very good.

4.5 stars but a weird grade because Alive 2007 is my favorite live album and there needs to be some differentiation. If that album didn’t exist then this would be 5 stars.

The Danger Mouse era is hard to assess. He makes hits but also took the edge off of almost every group he worked with. Brothers certainly feels this way, starting strong but overstaying it’s welcome. It’ll be interesting to see if any other Black Keys albums show up on the list. You could make a case for El Camino as an even tighter Danger Mouse experience or something earlier in the discography when this group was more blues focused.

A fun weird one that kept me on my toes.

I love Hounds of Love but this is a lot of Bush.

Couple good songs. Outstanding production. Committee written.

All preach, no fun.

Good ass rock album.

The king of the mope.

Wow, I hated this. Didn’t like the voice, didn’t like the guitars, vibe sucked. Nope.

Yup.

Strong first and last songs but didn’t do much to convince me the stones aren’t a greatest hits band.

Lovely if a little boring.

Nope, no.

Wow. This one was easy to rate.

After being burned by Moving Pictures, this was much more what I wanted from Rush. Unequivocal rock god shit.

Pretty fun album. Extremely listenable if not necessarily that memorable.

Felt a lot longer than it is. More a series of sketches than an album. Didn’t hate it.

It’s been a long time since I listened to the RHCP. Honestly these boys still have it. Great melodies and hooks, a really fun return to 9th grade.

Better than I expected even if it has a decent amount of schmaltz sprinkled over the tracks.

Rambling but tight. An album I will definitely return to.

Incredible production for absolute cornball lyrics

Arguably Bobby D’s best album front to back and for good reason.

Way ahead of it’s time but still too long and repetitive to hold me. Feels like an album that gets more credit for being prescient than good.

Not my style, couldn’t finish. Classic for somebody I’m sure.

Such a great album.

Enjoyable but feels pretty samey at times.

Fairly ephemeral 60s pop. Added a song to the liked playlist though.

Not my favorite Pink Floyd album but still damn good. Even just an instrumental version of this album would be 5 stars from this guy.

Couldn’t find my footing with this when I was in my Jazz phase. Even less so now. Also my god it’s an hour and forty five minutes.

Some gems, some junk. The experimentation is cool but hardly worth replaying.

Solid throughout with some absolute bangers.

Really fun album. Great base work and vocals to boot.

An easy band to mock given their recent output but the early albums stand strong and remind what indie rock can be. Solid 4.5.

Really liked this. Unique sounds, tight composition, definitely will come back.

Some classics, but soft in the middle which counts for a lot given the run time.

Dude… no. Literally the music that made me get into alt genres. Production is impressive tho.

Fun album. Very 90s but not in a bad way.

Good not mind blowing but fun.

Fun but got old

A good solid beating over the head

Love her voice. Little bit repetitive song structure but overall a very fun listen.