Reviews (page 3 of 15)
I am not a huge David Bowie fan but this album wasn't too bad. His songs are usually alright, but not really my style of music. It was okay having it in the background though.
I am used to either loving or hating his music, and this album confused me by not eliciting either reaction.
It’s Bowie!
It was fine. David Bowie is fine.
A little disco/easy listening for my tastes
I would have been SOOO annoying if I was young during this album. Even now, I recognized and enjoyed half the songs without even realizing they were on this album. Highlights: Young Americans, Across the Universe, Can You Hear Me, Fame
I dig all the horns and Fame is funky.
Super high highs, drags from time to time 3.5/5
I know David Bowie named this style "plastic soul" but - I really enjoy it. "Young Americans" (the song) is incredibly catchy. I was singing it all day. The rest of the tracks are either fun or interesting, with the exception of "Across the Universe," which falls apart for me due to Bowie's incredibly phony delivery. Not the best Bowie record but a really strong one all the same. FOUR STARS
It’s Bowie, so it’s great. Just not my favorite of his. It’s in one of those weird transitional phases he had, where there are glimmers of what was and what will be, but it doesn’t feel as cohesive yet.
Eins og mér hefur alltaf fundist titillagið æðislegt, þá var það þessi plata ásamt MWSTW sem síst heillaði mig fram að Let's dance. En það hefur breyst og mér finnst hún nú jafn æðisleg og hinar. Þetta remix frá 2016 er líka mikil framför.
I was today year's old when I learned that Fame didn't come from the 80s. This album was a surprise. I really respect Bowie...some of the albums that have been on here I've liked more than others. It start's off great and the first songs have bounce, shuffle, groove, awesome outros...until we hit Across the Universe. And Across the Universe isn't ALL bad. The band still works and does some good things, but Bowie's voice just doesn't do well here, it's almost like he's trying too hard. But if you're gonna pick an iconic song...and an iconic BEATLES song, you better deliver something immaculate. And this isn't that. Can You Hear Me? drags a little, too. But then Fame comes on and...goddamn, what a song. Bounce for days. Giving this a 4 because I really liked it. Overall a pretty tight album and I might come back to it.
me gusta mucho el recurso de los coros, las trompetas y todo lo traido del jazz mas q nada. muy bueno el cover de across the universe. Y la colaboracion con John Lennon en Fame
Langweilig; nichts besonderes
Man how I love David Bowie :,)
This is one of those Bowie albums that's on the outside looking in when I consider my favorites. I love the singles, Fame and Young Americans... though I prefer the single version of the album's title track. I haven't played the rest of the album very much, but there's a lot to like here. I find Win, Fascination, and Right to be the best section of the album, where Bowie's "plastic soul" is really firing on all cylinders. Somebody Up There Likes Me goes on a little too long without doing much... and the Across the Universe cover just doesn't work for me. All in all, this is still a very good record, but I still don't consider it one of Bowie's true essentials.
love me some bowie. didn't love his across the universe cover.. but this is funky, well produced and top tie bowie
RATING: 9/10 HIGHLIGHT: Win LOWLIGHT: Fame
125 in and I finally get one of the mythical Too Many Bowies. Maybe I'll finally get an Excess Costello tomorrow? Maybe even a Very Justified Beatles. And yeah, there aren't many Bowies that both check off the Unnecessary Addition and also the Likely Addition. I don't think we're getting Black Tie White Noise or even Diamond Dogs (though sure, that has Rebel Rebel, so maybe). And as that goes, this is probably the second I'd cut out besides The Last Day, which was very good but only essential in that it was truly added for the same reason Hackney Diamonds is being added, but is worlds more respectable. It's always impressive how Bowie can work a throwback. Young Americans does what so many America songs do… it takes something that feels nostalgic and upbeat and, well, American, and makes the dumbest Americans think it's pro-America. It's supremely catchy despite being almost impossible to follow lyrically past the chorus. On the other hand is Fame, which slinks and sleazes in a way that feels ahead of its time. In the middle, we get a lot of what Bowie would call “Plastic Soul.” This was the start of an era marked by too much cocaine and bad decisions. It was also a period of Bowie breaking into the US Mainstream (again, Americans can not be trusted to interpret songs about America), of experimenting with funk and proto-disco and embracing other black musical styles, of recording with John Lennon (he shows up on a reasonable Across the Universe cover and on “Fame” itself) and Luther Vandross before he was a name. So it's a weird moment where Bowie the musician and songwriter is not at his peak, but the album is still racking up reasons for inclusion. I suppose the idea of soulless Soul is interesting. Certainly he pulls that off (his backing vocalists are certainly acquitted, but Bowie himself often sounds listless and rambly). Side B makes a much better argument for the album than Side A, even with the Title track being the best on the album. Side A really leans into particularly banal work (what would make anyone write and record “win”?). For my money this is probably the least successful original album Bowie put out to this point, at least from a quality perspective. A very thin ⭐️⭐️⭐️
A pretty interesting album, especially since my last Bowie was Ziggy Stardust. The range of genres Bowie can cover is fascinating, and he kind of pulls it off here, even if it's not entirely my taste of music.
Bowie’s disco record? Not my favorite of his. But you could do worse than having Young Americans stuck in your head all day.
i think this guy might like john lennon
Bowie dabbling with blue-eyed soul, or as he apparently called it, "plastic soul", is interesting. Starts pretty strong, gets a little bit repetitive. Solid overall though. The cover of "Across the Universe" is pretty solid, I like the guitar flourishes they added. Other standouts: "Young Americans", "Somebody Up There Likes Me", "Fame".
Underwhelmed. Bowie knocks it out of the park with Young Americans, but nothing else rises back up to that level.
not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue
Kind of an entry level Bowie album...good, but nothing too far out. "Fame" and "Right" are probably my faves off this one.
Not his best but it's still excellent.
Always think I like Bowie less than I actually do
Perfect loved every note
meh
Being hyper-critical there's a couple of songs that could be swapped out of John, I'm Only Dancing (Again), but difficult not to give it a 5.
Tracks to go back to: Right Somebody Up There Likes Me Across the Universe Can You Hear Me Fame Go back to at some point 07/7/26
classic
God, I love short LPs. Both Young Americans and Fame are in this. Those two songs got this album 4/5 stars.
Huh - not really sure if I like this white boy funk era Bowie. Enjoyed the music but I’d need more time with this album I think.
Out of all of the different David Bowie eras -- this is the one I forget about the most! Nothing terrible here but nothing FANTASTIC like some other Bowie stuff.
Obviously a classic and a well-rounded album
ngl sounded a musical soundtrack
Te amo david bowie, espectacular como siempre
favorite song: young americans & fame
The first half of the album really didn't do it for me but the second half certainly shined. Don't think it's a must listen but nonetheless it was a fun listen
Not one off david bowie's best works
Probably his weakest of the 70s run for me. Not sure his voice suits the material, and so many tracks have the hallmarks of cocaine-fueled jams at the end.
How could John Lennon let him slaughter "Across the Universe"? Bowie warbles like a doorstop.
Thought I would like this more than I did.
Another album chosen because of one single. But I guess that's how your average dumbass listens to music anyway.
why does every song have a fade out like LET ME HEAR THE END OF THE SONG
It's good!
a good time until we hit a cover of one of the worst Beatles songs out there. at least the guitar licks are better than butchering the pronunciation of "jai guru deva". anyway Fame is my favorite song here by a mile but i think that's more to do with the quality of that song than the quality of this album
Lowkey metamorphic.
enjoyable music lyrics barely hearable but the whole product is solid id rate it a 7 out of 10 and i bet it can be heard anytime unlike trend songs
Mid. Very American I guess...I like the tunes though.
has a lot of interesting moments but not as cohesive as other projects Would I listen again: I did to get a better idea of this album Deserves to be on this list: nah 3.2
This always felt like a strange direction for him to take, considering what had come previously but he was never straightforward obviously. Although there are some classics here that join his diverse greatest hits, this isn’t one of his that I would reach for as often.
I’m so ambivalent about this that it hurts. As much as I love Bowie, this album is just a wee bit below his usual greatness. On the other hand, what a huge risk as n artist to just shift into an entirely different genre, and not only that, but pull off this perfectly executed album. Definitely the primordial soup for the later and more brilliant life forms. Even so, Young Americans is primordial. It feels like Bowie and company are sort of playing with a style rather than feeling it. On the other hand, there’s a very heartfelt appreciation for that style. But in this case, Bowie isn’t creating anything new or using the R&B he emulates as a jumping off point to something better. It’s more of a tribute. Which is respectable. It just doesn’t feel genuine. With a few exceptions, the title track and Fame among them, of course. An important transitional work.
Has the classic bowie sound, a few songs are bangers, the others fine
Great album, even if it's not my favourite from Bowie. I've never been able to understand the need to cover "Across the Universe", though.
Really enjoyed this ! Need to listen to more Bowie
Bowie got pretty funky there. A nice change.
I'm very surprised at how much I enjoyed this album. Different then a lot of other Bowie albums. Probably because he was hanging out with John Lennon a lot during this time in his career.
Almost every song is a hit but what is this Across the Universe cover?
I expected to hate this, but this was the best Bowie album yet
Bowie was simply amazing and beyond creative...
I like Bowie, but this album was kind of boring for me today, even with the couple of radio hits. Fame is an incredible song, but not quite enough for me to boost the album up to 4...
Another day, another Bowie album. Boy this Dimery guy has got it bad for Bowie. Onto the album. Definitely a different sound from prior albums. Half way in, I thought, huh when was this made? It feels later than 1974, which I guess is what folks think he was a bit ahead of his time. The two big hits on the album, Young Americans, and Fame, are clearly interesting and unique. Other than that, nothing stuck me as particularly fantastic. Right has a funky thing that he stole from somewhere I'm sure. There was no reason to remake Across the Universe and he just did it worse than the Beatles.
Amazing Bowie!
Philly Plastic Soul...and the Debut of Luthor Vandross!!!
Didn’t like, amateur karaoke music
646/1001 2026.06.29 🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑
Not really much to bop to in here but nothing bad either.
This was pretty fun. Except the cover of Across the Universe; that was odd.
The title and final tracks are the standouts of course. I hadn't realized Lennon played on this, and so the repeated, strident denials that "Nothing's gonna change my world" in his cover of Across the Universe seems poignantly prescient. Don't know though, would we call the rest cultural appropriation today?
It was okay bit dated
I liked the radio songs, Young Americans and Fame, but the rest of the songs just fell short for me.
Bowed
With rock I came before to this site, it came to me with soul, and now it presents in front of me with an album combining this new match made in heaven for me, all from a legendary artist I have yet not listened to the rightfully way and amount. Now I saw that this is a little more different than the other albums of his, and I can't wait to have them waiting on this list.
David Bowie never disappoints. Absolute Bowienema
Bowie is a musical genius. Always happy when him albums pop up on this list. This album is a solid album, not my favorite and not his worse.
I love rock'n'roll Bowie. Jazz/funk Bowie, not so much. There are some good moments but honestly not one song that I feel compelled to take with me on my way. I also found his cover of Across The Universe both pointless and painfully bad, so there's also that.
A good sample of what was to come
Young Americans was always one of my least favorite of the Bowie singles. (Fame is a favorite! Though there’s a later mix I like - Freedom 90 Gass Mix) Since I don’t like the song all that much, I assumed I wouldn’t like the album. I was wrong.
David Borie
Yes!!! This man is amazing. How good? This album is stellar, but not in the top five of Bowies. 4.5 star but I’ll round up to 5.
Bowie is altijd tof en afwisselend
Super leuk
What a killer Bowie album, a departure from the glam and into the funky rock soul and R&B. Love when an artist opens and closes an album with great tunes. Really sets the tone to start and ends leaving the listener wanting more. Love his experimentation with all the different instruments and he has a great blue eyed soul voice.
7/10
Favourite Songs: Fame
Album très court période où il en sortait un par an très cool style jazz rock Mention honorable pour l'enchainement Right / SUTLM / Across the universe / Can you hear me / Fame (pour bien finir)
An early Bowie album, not my usual listening appetite but still similar enough to not be jarring. 3/5.
Bookended by absolute classics, the rest of the record is a bit empty. The Beatles cover is fine, but doesn’t quite fulfill the hopes of Bowie covering Lennon.
I don't know why but, even though I've heard Fame a million times, I never expect David Bowie to be so funky. Going in, I didn't really know any other songs in this album, but Young Americans, Fascination, and Somebody Up There Likes Me are all super enjoyable and fantastic songs. Bowie is, simply, a cool dude.
kIND OF MID WITH SOME HITS.
Fantastic album
Blah
It hurts to dislike this one, because Bowie was really going for something interesting here, but it doesn’t work. He was trying, I can see now, to marry two emotional states that at first seem to be contradictory – emotionless dance music, robotic funk. And he doesn’t succeed (with one major exception). What he wanted was one thing, what happened was just R&B with all the excitement, all the juice, sucked out of it. The aforementioned exception is, of course, “Fame” – the combination of skeletal funk with Bowie’s consciously shouted, ugly vocals is so striking that the song is memorable almost in spite of itself – it’s one of the strangest pop tracks to ever become a classic. And, yeah, the title track has a good chorus, too. But this is best seen as an ambitious failure, a stepping stone to superior later albums. Best track: “Fame”
Yayyyy David Bowie made an album about ✨️me✨️
In the titular song I appreciate the approach to criticize the "American dream" especially from within by a citizen who was able to all the good and bad cause it's not solely pessimistic but rather it acts as a grounding force for the country at the time through the lense of David Bowie the album is clearly influenced by the soul genre very clearly and it is used tastefully but I don't fully know if it should be spread into nearly all the songs as much as it is, there is so much fun being had. 0 skips in the album, not everything is perfect but nothing is below a 6 and that is enough.
Over a quarter of the way through the 1001 and I’m only getting my first Bowie now. As a huge fan (he might just be my GOAT) and aware he has 8 albums in the book, this is actually the one I was least looking forward to reviewing. It’s pretty low in my total Bowie ranking, and certainly the one of the 8 I’ll be awarding the fewest stars to. It’s always been so, and I think it’s because the concept should totally work for me (I’m a big fan of 70s soul music too) and because I want so much to be blown away by it. But I’m just not. Today as I listened again, this time trying harder to figure out why it doesn’t grasp me, I probably enjoyed each song a little bit more individually than I ever have done before, but I still came away from the album as a whole dissatisfied. There are some exceptions of course. I couldn’t truly call myself a Bowie fan if I didn’t enjoy the title track. But while I can get off on the vibe of “Fame” I’ve never really been sold on its central songwriting. “Someone Up there Likes Me” is the moment here the idea of the album gels for me; I just believe it more than elsewhere, the moment where Bowie’s self-proclaimed “plastic soul” is least plastic. The sophistication of songwriting is more recognisably Bowie. I straight up don’t enjoy the Beatles cover. I didn’t like much of Pinups either, though I know incredibly well how capable he is of a quality cover (Fill Your Heart, Wild Is the Wind, Cactus, Pablo Picasso). My unpopular take has never had “Across the Universe” as a favourite Beatles song anyway, but on top of that it seems to have little in common with what’s going on elsewhere here. I think the bottom line is that when I’m listening to ‘Young Americans’ I’m hearing Bowie adjusting his writing to what he thinks will suit the surroundings and the outcome comes across as a group of shit-hot musicians doing excellent work but without the quality of material to merit their skills. There’s a good vibe and Bowie’s vocal performances are, by and large, up to his usual spectacular standards, but despite all the positives flying around, I can’t get on board as much as I’d like to. I’ve been glad to give it this much attention today though. Maybe next time I pull it from the shelf, I’ll be finally loving it.
Title track was good, but was a bit bored by the end of the album
Some good songs. Title track and Fame are very good, the rest pretty average.
You know what, this Bowie chap is alright
This was an underwhelming album from Bowie.
ok
Fame and last song are great, rest of album is listenable but feels like many albums do similar
Oh yeah, this is hitting today.
https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/21488-young-americans/
3 star A proper 3 star Bowie album. Good enough that I own it on vinyl but mid enough that I probably haven’t played the record in the decade since I bought it. This is an album I wouldn’t say anything if it wasn’t on this list, but it’s not bad. The singles are good and the rest of the album is passable as “blue eyed soul.” Except the cover of “Across the Universe” is not great. Can’t believe he got John Lennon to play on that cover.
4/5
Not as good as expected
"Ultimately just terribly boring to me. The ""plastic"" part of plastic soul really shines through. It feels very disingenuous. Love Bowie, love his voice, style, etc., hate this. The butchering of Across the Universe feels like the defining moment. Just flippant, a sorta cocaine fueled shrug. Fame is the best song for me, and I've got really big issues with it. Terrible ending, some studio tricks that feel heartless to me. David Bowie plays best when he's got an edge. I think the edge he's going for here is that he's friends with black people, which I know in 1975 means something more but to me right now it feels just very shallow. I would much rather listen to the music he's pulling from. I will say I appreciate that it's a collaboration, especially with relatively unknown musicians, given the history of white artists showing up and wholesale stealing black music. It still does very very little for me."
This reminds me how much I don't really enjoy David Bowie's voice. I do like the switch from his usual glam rock to the more soulful rock sound. I do like most songs with horns. I do not like the "Across the Universe" cover. That's one of my favorite Beatles songs, and nothing is done to really differentiate the song or improve it from the original. Bowie's voice isn't so bad that I dislike this album, but it does curb my enjoyment of the album. There's a couple of fun songs, but in terms of listening there really isn't a whole lot going on here. The style of the album is really the important thing here, and in terms of music history there's some importance to it, but it doesn't sound all that impressive. Favorite Song(s): Fascination, Fame
That’s a great one!
Great, great album. Still not my favourite work of his though.
This cool. a little too poppy for me but it's still great.
Hard to give this one more than a 3. Bowie is great but this one didn't need to make the cut. Love Fame though.
groovy
David Bowie is really great at doing blue eyed soul. Not his strongest or most challenging work of songwriting, but it's really groovy and enjoyable to listen to. The funky side of this album is noticable in his follow up, Station to Station as well. It's a good thing he didn't go in this direction for the rest of his career, like a proto Robin Palmer. For a one album sidestep it's amazing though.
Is this wasn't by Bowie it would just be another forgotten mid 70s album
Bowie no es para mí, lo intenté y no se me dio
It's commonly called his "blue-eyed soul" or "plastic soul" period. I think it's closer to disco-tinged... either way, it's quite a departure from the glam and glitter rock that he made it with. I'm not a huge fan of his experimental side but I enjoyed this just fine.
oki was not big emotions
Rating: 4.7/5 Short Review: Bowie dives headfirst into American soul, R&B, and funk and somehow makes it sound completely natural. This is one of his warmest records. Less alien prophet, more fascinated observer wandering through mid-70s America. Favorite Track: “Young Americans.” That saxophone, that groove, that chorus. One of Bowie’s greatest singles.
had er meer van verwacht. prima maar niet heel leuk.
It was quite a relaxing album. It encouraged me to clean my room.
Smooth and enjoyable but not fully holding my attention. 7.5/10
Goated
Ziggy goes funky soul.
Bowie does soul. Pretty good and an example of his extraordinary versatility.
Fantastic jazzy rnb from Bowie crazy how he changed styles
Young Americans impressed me with how naturally David Bowie could move into soul and funk while still sounding unmistakably like himself. At times, the album barely felt British at all, which made Bowie’s ability to constantly reinvent his sound even more remarkable. Fame was easily my favorite track for its sharp, stylish funk groove and restless energy.
There was a young American i guess
Album was pretty good. 80's hotel lobby vibes (in a good way), would listen to again. Leah - 6/7 Leprechauns - Favourite - Fascination Austin - 6/7 Leprechauns - Favourite - Young Americans
It's a fun Bowie album, but I think it's inaccurate to call it a "soul" album.
No me gusta como vamos Bowie. No me gusta su voz. Tuve que pasar la versión de Across the Universe
I love David Bowie so much. I never listen the hole album before. My favourite album from David Bowie is ‘Diamond Dogs’ but I feel like this suits me better.
Not quite 5*, my favourite Bowie albums are probably the previous glam rock ones, but this is still very enjoyable and marks a turn towards more genre diversity in his music. There are some good tunes here but I thought others were a little forgettable
Переслушай
Ok. Glad I listened, but not likely to listen ag6
so far rly cool, v dif from bowie's more well known sound. track 1 good, wanna listen in the car on a roadtrip w windows down. win was so fire to listen to high w the sun coming thru the window, lyrically rly interesting i gotta relisten. NEED to have sex listening to fascination omg this song is so hot. right was just okay tbh. somebody up there likes me was shockingly christian. across the universe kept going from really interesting to boring over n over idk it was weird. can ypu hear me was a rly cool song i liked it. i wanna see fame in a movie. idk what the context would be but it'd b fire in a movie.
Ahhhh, my 6th Bowie album so far. C'mon. I'm not going to listen to this but I will give it a middle of the road 3
Ich wusste nicht das Bowie auch soul kann. Megaalbum. das besorg ich mir auf Platte.
After the massive success of Hunky, Ziggy and Aladdin, Bowie had the confidence to keep trying his Chameleon act, and it always produced something on interest. Young Americans was one of the lesser reinventions - There's still good stuff, but it doesn't reach the heights of previous LPs. 3.5 stars
I'm struck by how some of Bowie's songs sound out-of-time. While much of this album has a cool soul feel, like "Right", which I really liked, "Win" is almost easy listening. Unlike Station to Station, which I listened to recently, there are songs that I've never heard before, including an over-the-top cover of the Beatles' Across the Universe. Each song is interesting in its own right, but there's a reason why I didn't hear them regularly growing up. The title track, and the last track, "Fame" are spectacular, but besides "Right", I don't think I'd return to other songs on this album. 3 stars?
★★★½
Excellent blend of funk, R&B and glam rock. Some of the most infectious bass lines I've heard, and Bowie is at his most electric. Lot of hidden gems on the album as well, no real weak spots or low points. Top tracks: Win, Fascination, Fame
It’s a good album. It doesn’t really come anywhere close to some of the other albums Bowie was dishing out during this decade, like the Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars, Station to Station and Low, though. I can see why they would put this album on the list but at the same time I feel like there could have been more exclusivity to Bowie’s absolute, irrefutable best albums. Bowie is a great artist but I can’t really say there’d be much of a loss of leaving out this Bowie album to free up space for other artists (who might not even have a singular album on the list). Also, some tracks were pretty filler (namely ‘Right’ and Somebody Up There Likes Me’) in comparison to other Bowie albums where the tracklists are solid throughout (especially the Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars). However, with all the bad stuff out of the way, this is still a great album. ‘Young Americans’ is one of Bowie’s most lighthearted, fun songs; I absolutely love it. Bowie’s cover of ‘Across the Universe,’ whilst not being better than the original in my opinion, was very charming and unique and did justice to the original. ‘Fame’ is also just an amazing song, definitely amongst Bowie’s most underrated songs and the history of that song originating from a jam with John Lennon simply makes it even cooler. Also, Bowie being the first white artist on the show ‘Soul Train’ in which he performed ‘Fame’ one of the countless examples of Bowie being a pioneer, and ahead of his time, and simply iconic. Great album.
There's been a lot written about David Bowie - and justifiably so - but I feel like some people don't realize that for a white British bisexual, the man could get FUNKY. This album is a prime example of that. "Fame" is the most obvious example, but there are others scattered across the album. This is the first appearance of what would become his "DAM trio" rhythm section, consisting of drummer Dennis Davis, guitarist Carlos Alomar, and bassist George Murray, who recorded together on seven of Bowie's classic albums in the '70s. "Can You Hear Me" feels almost shockingly modern, like a contemporary gospel track. All in all, this is a great album by a master musician in his prime.
7/10
It was good. Nothing special and writing this review a few days later, I don’t remember what I listened to, but the beat and music was fun
This is the coke album. Young Americans and Fame are great tracks but too many tracks drag on too long. Also, not a good Beatles cover on here.
i didn't make much of it. Some groovy tunes.
Dark and funky -
After so many glam rock Bowie albums, this was a refreshing change of pace. I really enjoy the funk influences throughout the album, and honestly, this style suits him better than a lot of his earlier work. The songs feel looser, warmer, and more natural than some of the characters and concepts he was leaning on during the glam years. That said, his cover of “Across the Universe” is absolute garbage. I have no idea why it made the album other than the fact that John Lennon was around the studio at the time. It sticks out for all the wrong reasons and feels completely unnecessary on an otherwise enjoyable record. Thankfully, the rest of the album is strong enough that one bad decision doesn’t sink it.
2nd David Bowie out of 9. I understand he was ahead of his time, but not my favorite. 6/10 Top song Fame
It’s Bowie but not my type of Bowie.
So, so, although Fame and Young Americans comfortably take this into 3 star territory
Hard to believe that this was 1975 given how modern the sound is.
So here we go again. 3 Bowie albums in (none of them Ziggy era) and I'm generally unmoved. Fame is the standout track. The title track and Somebody Up There Likes Me are ok. But what the hell is he doing with Across The Universe? Beck's Debra shows how much the musical ideas in Win (and maybe the entire album?) could have been improved. Another disappointment from the legend that is Bowie. And without Fame it would have been worse.3*
It's great because it's Bowie. Less of the groundbreaking energy that his glam stuff had, but his range and enthusiasm for new approaches was amazing.
Nice groove
Mostly great, opener track is a little tacky. But there’s some damn jams in this album and the band can play. Who’s on the rhythm section? There great. I do love how Bowie went with a soul-influenced theme, most of the sax could go though…
Not the greatest Bowie album.
Really cool soul album! You could really tell Bowie didn’t hold back with this album and was really himself. I don’t know if it’s just me, but I thought his voice in certain songs was very Hendrix. The beginning of the album was pretty weak, minus the title track. That might have put some people off but atleast it actually got really good by the end! I think this is definitely a big landmark for soul, as this acted like Elvis for soul music; not that he was the greatest soul performer of all time, even though he was great. It’s more that it acted as a door for white people to soul music like Elvis was to rock ‘n’ roll music. Although the black community that started it off is definitely better. I’d recommend Young Americans, Right, Somebody up there likes me, Across the universe, Fame and Who can I be now?
Bowie taking a stab at soul- but couldn't quite make up his mind whether he wanted to be Ziggy Stardust or James Brown. Still quintessentially Bowie but with some good stabs at soul It’s funny if this was done by Clapton I’d hate it but Bowie pulls it off with out feeling like a safari in the ghetto
Bowie und Funky – das ist wie zwei Planeten, die sich höflich zunicken, aber nie wirklich in dieselbe Umlaufbahn finden. Die Grooves wollen tanzen, Bowies Stimme will erzählen, und am Ende bleibt ein seltsamer Schwebezustand: interessant gedacht, aber ohne echten Funkenflug.
Mystic singer... but an overall boring album for me. Slow and uninteresting despite the cover looks. 4/10
David Arquilo lo hace nuevamente. Groovy, sabroso. Por momentos me pierde
Funky and still pretty mellow.
Great album. Sounds like the precursor to New Wave.
I enjoyed this
One of the best!!!
This is a really nicely executed genre-album. Two of the hit songs, Young Americans and Fame, are five-star songs.
Not my favourite Bowie. Not sonically or lyrically interesting to me. But even the worst Bowie is kind of good, no?
Really outstanding from beginning to end. Each song is a journey. The attention to detail and amount of layering is phenomenal. Bowie was in a league of his own.
Great record. Not my favorite Bowie record, but the hits absolute rip on this record.
another first timer for me. this album is like one long comedown. on other Bowie records I've listened to, you get at least a track or two that's fiery and maybe uplifting. Young Americans gives me the feeling of that emotional drain after the fun has worn off. lots of soul here. lots of saxophone to push the music forward. the only part of this that I could do without is the "Across the Universe" cover, but it was fine -- just felt inessential. also, I didn't realize how Beck seemingly lifted "Win" for his song "Debra"
I love the general sound Bowie works with on this album. The title track is especially exciting. “Fame” is a song I’ve heard enough and I find kinda annoying, but in the context of the album it really works.
cool ig
hallucinant à quel point il voulait les nachos des beatles oh fraudvid bowie
I felt like an American teen from the 70s. Cool.
Not my favorite Bowie album but his butterlike voice is always a privilige to listen to. Although, it might not be the best match for this particular music. The songs are great tho!
What I like about this album has more to do with the non-Bowie contributions. I love the backup singers. I don't love Bowie's voice. Also I just generally love funk and groove. Thanks to the Black artists who made funk and groove possible!
meh
This album has an amazing sound. The saxofone is brillant. It gets better in the second part. Some songs are monotonous but has one of the best 70s song "Somebody up Theres like me"
Funky Bowie with gospel backup singers? Yes please. Favorite track: Fame
Decent album, though not as high on the pantheon for me. High 2s. Opening track is a banger
Love it but not a Everyday listen so probably a 4 or 5
There are 2-3 excellent songs, and the genre experiment of “Plastic Soul” is an interesting premise, but the album overall is Bowie’s most uneven since the early folk/ hippie records (prob at least partially due to the miles of coke lines the glittered one was doing at this time, according to the legends).
This is probably my favorite Bowie that I've heard on this. He was clearly a talented guy and able to work in different genres. I think this is pretty decent soul, but it sounds like someone pretending to be a soul artist. I think it works pretty well for what it is.
Fascination - I really like the intro groove here Somebody Up There Likes Me - Nice Sax Can you Here Me - Amazing Fame - Very Funky
Love this album, but whoever said this is blue eyed soul is the whitest person ever.
FAAAAAMEe! 7/10
Love Bowie 100/10
Classic Bowie, great mix of songs, incredible voice, young Americans is a great way to open an album with a few lovely ballad types thrown in.
This was fine. It was definitely not my favorite David Bowie album. I knew Young Americans and Fame. I didn’t like his cover of Across the Universe.
Very nice, suprised by the funk sonority.
Eines der schlechtesten bowie alben
Really solid, quite different to anything else he's done. Fame is such a good closer. The version of Across the Universe is interesting, not bad
Pretty decent but not his best
funky!
Need to revisit this album more fully, but every song so far has been a banger
this is a relatively middling bowie album, which by basically all known standards still means it's like an 8/10. carlos alomar is on it, which, like... you know, say no more. there's a lot of fun trivia about this album that i think is more interesting than the record itself. for example: a then-unknown luther vandross is on this, and you could argue that it's the session/album that got him his big break! also: john lennon plays guitar on this record's cover of "across the universe", which unfortunately does not redeem it from being a total embarrassment, the worst song on the album, and a complete mood-killer coming off of "somebody up there likes me". the hits on this one are SERIOUS hits, though, to a degree that almost overwhelms the sense of self-consciousness in bowie's blue-eyed soul. "can you hear me", "fascination", and especially "fame", which is such a masterpiece that george clinton and james brown ripped it off basically wholesale for two of their own singles. i like to think that bowie was woke enough back then to feel kind of weird about being a white guy taking up all that airtime on soul train, but maybe i'm writing fanfiction there.
As a huge fan of Bowie, one who would give many of his other albums a full five stars, I feel I have both the freedom and an obligation to be a little harsher on this record. I don't think the soul thing he's attempting to do here really works all that well. Bowie's strength is in driving, catchy hits, I think, and this album feels like a whole lot of him noodling without getting anywhere. Somebody Up There Likes Me is very good, certainly (and also one of my Grand Theft Auto childhood songs, I now realize) but it feels more like a happy accident in the surrounding context. Still, it's Bowie... his sound /is/ still in there. And it does seem like whatever he was doing here did have a positive influence on his later works. I'm certainly not going to go as low as two stars. Favorite tracks: Win, Somebody Up There Likes Me
pretty good innit
bastante normalitas todas, fame la unica que lo salva 2/5
Great album!
bangin
Creo la primera canción es la peor y siempre me había alejado de escucharlo por eso, solo conociendo 1 o 2, pero la mayoría del disco fue muy bueno. Sinceramente es otro mood para ponerlo, se nota la época mucho, lo cual no es malo pero si muy notorio
Сара 4 Марко 4
Sounds like it got a three on it though, to me. I heard some funk like David Bowie. It was cool, but can you imagine Bowie in your funk? Ho! W-E-F-U-N-K
Pretty damn great
It seemed to me like this was easily the weakest Bowie included on the list, but it turns out... I really love this one too, even if it IS probably the weakest one on here.
Its goooddddd
Meh
Ehhhhhh. After 2-3 albums I still don't quite understand Bowie's genre.
Not my favorite Bowie album (Diamond Dogs): but even so, it's still a pretty great album. Of his late 70s albums, I prefer Low. 4 "disco-balled" stars.
Like Bowie still only a 3 starer for me.
The Beatles' cover sucks, the rest is pretty fantastic.
Really really good. Gospel Bowie was unexpected but really great. Bookends of iconic Bowie singles but everything in the middle was great too.
embarrassing asf i havent got into bowie up until this point. yeah i get it.
Nice blast from the past listen, enjoyed it.
love an artist that's versatile. some incredible stuff but also weak boring stuff. cool album but like you're better off checking out bowies other stuff
the first and last tracks? impeccable. maybe some of my favorite "Bowie in America" songs. the title track, with its irresistible soul pocket and that Beatles interpolation, is an especially high point in this transitional phase of Bowie's career between the glam years and the Berlin era. as far as the rest, it's unfortunately kind of a flatline. most of these songs just make me want to run "Young Americans" back again. Bowie and his "plastic soul" band make their way through the whole middle of the LP with just enough energy to not sound completely dead. that is, except for David Sanborn going absolutely apeshit on alto saxophone in the right stereo channel. it's a juxtaposition that's hilarious in a way I don't think was intentional. proving my personal maxim that Bowie's covers are either impeccable or disastrous is the rocky rendition of the Beatles' "Across the Universe". it's somewhat made up for by the John Lennon collaboration "Fame", a modal funk jam stacked with vocal and instrumental earworms. decent 5/10.
Never had an Bowie ecxperience. It's wildly different.
Meh
Jazzy sax but nothing too inspiring in the album
It's fine
Godd but not my style
4.5 Didn't quite enjoy it as much as the first two Bowie albums I got but it's still really good
Sure, there are two outstanding tracks here, but this is not one of Bowie’s best albums.
Good listen overall, but it’s really a two‑or‑three‑song album, and they were smart enough to save the best track for the finish..
Good music, not my type of music.
el álbum perfecto para una banda sonora de una BUENA película. Sin duda la primera mi favorita, te hace sentir el main character sin duda
It's a good album, I'm not gonna give it a relisten tho, maybe Fame. great overall sounds, there's up and down but still
Mildly groovy though not my favorite sound for Bowie. I like title track and the "Nothing's Gonna Change My World" outro of the Across the Universe cover and Fame.
A wonderful transition album where Bowie learned a new idiom. The funk and RnB jams are super satisfying, even if they sometimes feel that they are missing a little songwriting at their core. The backing vocals are rich and voluptuous (shout out Luther Vandross) and the band is on fire throughout. Bowie more than holds his own vocally despite not completely meshing with the musicians (the ‘plastic’ in ‘plastic soul). The additions of the tracks with Lennon somehow give the album an unfinished feel, but this record was a necessary piece of education for Bowie that paved the way to Station To Station, where he would make the sounds, rhythms and feels more his own, integrating them with his personal coke-fueled weirdness.
Bit surprised to see this Bowie album on the list as it's probably his worst of the 70's. Still, it's Bowie and got some really good songs on it!
Weak album compared to many Bowie albums and rather mediocre performance overall.
#393 / 1089 Heard before? ✅ Revisit? ❌ Not the biggest fan of Mr. Bowies music, while I appreciate his skill, the music doesn't do much for me. I wouldn't change the radio station or leave the room if this played, but if this whole album is the main event, I'd get quite bored real soon. Weak 3, strong 2/5
mais um caso de uma faixa de abertura e uma de encerramento sensacionais com músicas razoáveis entre elas, com exceção de somebody up there likes me. ps: que cover horroroso esse de across the universe pqp
Good album!
Really liked
Not always a Bowie fan but this has a jazz meets country style that really works.
Another average Bowie album with a couple of great tracks and some very competent (but less thrilling) others. He certainly churned them out.....
Really funky. Young Americans and Fame are the highlights here, fame might actually be my favourite Bowie song. Great
Brilliant
Bowie ends his glam era with a pivot to soul. It almost feels like a pastiche at time, with a plastic sound, tacky saxophones, and tons of background vocals. But calling it a pastiche ignores the fact that it often sounds very good. The title track and "Fascination" are lively, flowing jams with great vocals. "Fame" is irresistibly funky even if it feels a bit skeletal. Most of the other tracks feel inessential though, without enough going on. The Beatles cover is too similar to the original while also being just different enough to sound off. On his next album Bowie expanded on these sounds and turned them into something new. For an artist of Bowie's caliber, this one sounds a little tame.
Bu adamın yaptığı işleri beğenmemek elde değil
Obviously there are really big hits on this album and I love David Bowie, but this record just grated on me idk??? I feel like the songs were endless and his voice was more abrasive and the cover of Across the Universe wasn't good? Idk am I on something? Wouldn't listen again no offence, there's better Bowie.
Not like my faaaavourite Bowie but listening in the context of this as a lead in to the pure genius of what came a year later makes it kinda fun. And the title track and Fame are some big old bangers
My late father was a big big David Bowie fan. So big he named me after him. So my name is David. If I wasn't named after him, my name would be Jens. That was my mother her chose. Before you think Jens? You must be German. No i'm Belgian. Anyway enough talk about my little little little self. I really enjoyed this album. For me personally it doesn't have a bad track on it. And no I don't say this because I was named after him. 4/5
Good album, but maybe not DB’s best
Great album….Bowie changing his style yet again . A couple standouts ..really enjoyed it
Funky sounds . Enjoyed listening to this.
It’s ok actually. Nice music.
Not at all a bad album, but also not what I expected of David Bowie. Won't come back to this.
Fine, don't care much for Bowie
And lo, I have completed the David albums upon the Project. From the only quite highs of Heroes to the insurmountable highs of Hunky Dory, this falls...about in the middle. It's a tiny weeny bit pastiche-y, and not as powerful as his early 70s pomp, but it's still absolutely tremendous in places. Lennon's lovely little fingers are in David's pies across the board here - most notably in Fame, but also with the really glorious bit towards the end of the title track when the opening line of A Day In The Life is belted out by the backing singers.
2/5 Pretty short album but not my vibe, didn't really mesh with any song. Favorite Song: Fame
The Best
Glad I listened to it for the bangers
I dont like him
Young Americans is one of my fave songs ever but this album isn’t really doing it for me. Still enjoyed, still a classic
Starts and ends strong but this is at it's best when Bowie's to the side and the backing vocalists are doing their thing
Not bad, actually kind of fun. Pretty solid.
Good album.
Really enjoyed. Very laid back and soulful.
I get why this is here -- it's Bowie. But the whole thing just feels undercooked somehow. He sounds great and there are some forever bangers on here. But he was still trying to find what would eventually become the wonders of the Berlin trilogy and it just...doesn't...quite...click. But if you want to know the origins of all that sax in popular music through the early 80's, this is probably the place to start.
A nice listen, bit funky. Good stuff. Didn't finish it yet but got the gist
Songs were mostly good, some vocal performances were stronger than others, but mostly good!
I think the instrumentation on this album is very fun. I see the appeal and I was grooving a little but I think I am not a fan of his voice too much. No shade to David Bowie or his fans, just not my personal style. 6/10
8/10 - The more I listen to Bowie, the more I am impressed by his ability to be influenced by other styles and meld them into his own sound. Big fan of this album and its Funk/Soul underpinning.
An under appreciated album in his discography, I only knew Young Americans and Fame (and Across the Universe via The Beatles). This is a super solid album, but at 8 songs, I would want a little more. 8/10
prima
I love David Bowie, a masterpiece of course
No idea I could be elevated via a music album.
First very good album
muy bueno, me acompañó en mi mañana yendo a la facu, y no decepcionó. fue una linda sorpresa encontrar la inspiración de love me de the 1975 en fame (y de no ser así, es un choreo cósmico de los muchachos). tengo que escuchar más bowie.
Sadly, this is one of Bowie's albums that's fallen off a bit for me, especially considering how great the albums surrounding it are. That said, it still has some all-time bangers on it, like the title track, Fascination, and ESPECIALLY Fame.
Once again, I don’t understand how Bowie attained the godlike status needed to have 9 albums on this list
Bowie gets….. soulful & funky??? what! I’m truly predisposed to like it off the genre influences alone; if there’s any white dude who can be creatively trusted to pull off a genre switch like this, it’s him. Could see this becoming a 4 if it stays in the rotation! Standouts: Young Americans • Fascination • Right • Fame
Mildly disappointing but perfectly acceptable Bowie album. It definitely starts to sag a little at the end. I was completely buying what he was laying down but a little more variety would have helped a LOT, in my opinion.
trying a bit too hard to be wacky
Very good album, the musicality is off the charts, soulful songs and great rythm all the way through, and a Beatles cover to complete. No notes, very good.
One of my favorite Bowie albums!
Good stuff
This album was so ahead of its' time. Namely: the overuse of saxamaphones that occurred in the 80s. :-).... Honestly pretty low on the Bowie list to my ears.
Ufattelig tamt til å bli blåst opp så voldsomt av så mange. Er nok ikke gammel nok.
Too much bloody saxophone for my liking, but Fame is funky. Not sure why we should celebrate the descent of something amazing into something trying to be soul and funk but mostly failing apart from one interesting edgy song
The middle period of a fairly incredible 10 album or so run in the 70s for Bowie. Probably one of my less played ones, I prefer the Ziggy era or the Berlin era, but this is still fairly excellent. Shit hot session musicians, lots of backing vocals and sax make it more slick than anything that came before it, which was intentional, but also puts me off it a tad.
Por ahora el más flojo del David. Me gusta Fame nomas. Nota: 3.2
Bowie was a curious shapeshifter, always reinventing himself and creating a solid body of work in the process. When you change the formula of your success you'll eventually create something lesser. But creating the lesser work is often a step in creating much better work. This record does not reach the heights of Ziggy Stardust, Aladdin Sane, Low, or his final gift Black Star. There are some good songs on here: the title track and "Fame." The cover of "Accross the Universe" is ill-considered and Bowie's voice is not up to turning that song into overwrought soul.
This was great, it felt combative almost though i couldn’t tell you why. Just feels a bit like he’s in on something you’re not and you have to keep listening to try and get in on the bit.
For those of you who can remember anything of the Miss Peaches trivia night, the title track featured in the music round (theme: song titles with America/n in the title). At the time it was my first exposure to the song and these days it’s one of my all-time fave Bowie tracks, so I was very happy to listen to it (over and over, if I’m really honest). The Across the Universe cover was a nice touch too, there’s just not a whole lot else that grabbed me here.
Saw the title and foolishly thought Afraid of Americans would be on here. Then I read the little wikipedia intro and didn’t think that really sounded like my interests. I think I probably liked this less than the last Bowie album we did because I didn’t feel like it was as adventurous, but I really liked the title track!
This isn’t Bowie at his strongest. It’s fine and has moments of brilliance (Young Americans is incredible) but it is a trial run for the excellent Station to Station and doesn’t quite hold the same weight.
I was never a big fan of Bowie, even if there are certain songs that I just love by him (e.g., Let's Dance, China Girl, Suffragette City). And when I had his first record from this list, Low, I didn't think it was all that special, only reaffirming my position. Since then, surprisingly, I've really changed my tune. It started with the Ziggy Stardust album, which had incredible songwriting. Earlier this week, I had Blackstar, a fascinating album with heavy electronic and jazz bents. That he was able to recreate himself that late in his career was astounding to me. This album is only further entrenching my new position and that recreation theme could really apply to this album as well, as he moved away from glam rock and towards more of a R&B / soul inspired rock sound. The title track has a great sound to it, including from some of the support players (Luther and David Sanborn, most notably). I liked the way his vocals offset vs. the soaring background singers. Nice toss to A Day In The Life by The Beatles too. Win answers the question, what if George Michael was around in the 70s. The breathy points of this make it for me. A cool, sultry track. Fascination is a great song. This starts with a strange combination of early 70s funk and some early disco types of sounds. It's bass heavy approach reminds me of Shaft a bit. You can just picture him getting into singing this. This song is the best find I've had in the last week on this countdown. 3 for 3 and an amazing start to this record. Right wasn't quite as good for me, but it was a solid track with continued good base work and more David Sanborn, neither of which are ever bad things. Somebody Up There Likes Me had some of Bowie's best impassioned vocals on it, along with a series of gorgeous harmonies throughout. Totally dug this tune. Listening to Across the Universe, I can't believe a song like this wasn't part of any of the Guardians of the Galaxy movies, as it would have fit perfectly. Cool, sweeping track. I was wondering why it sounded like a Beatles song and then I read that it was a Lennon-McCartney tune, which made total sense. I'm just ignorant to many things Beatles, as I am not a big fan of them. Can You Hear Me was a somewhat subdued track compared to some of the rest of the album. Liked the soul bent to this and I have mentioned that I am fan of the David Sanborn work on this record yet? Yeah, more of that is a good thing. Also, the a cappella ending of this was great. The closer, Fame, is a track that we have all heard a bunch before, but admittedly I've generally just let it sit there when it's on the radio, not really paying too much attention to it. Upon actually listening, the funk, the syncopation, the movement between various vocal parts, all of it is great. A really well constructed track. Blown away by how excellent this album ended up being. Even the couple that I didn't think were excellent songs are still good listens. Basically a complete album. 5-stars.
A first listen for me and besides the opener and closer, it's all new to me. Bowie's first sojourn into soul music is a positive one. His chameleon like tendencies allow him to switch quite dramatically at times and still it sounds like a Bowie album. Not my personal fave but there's a level of quality you tend to get with Bowie and this falls well within that range.
It’s funky, groovie Bowie - complete with a warm 70s production, saxophone, and soulful background vocals. The record starts strong with the stellar “Young Americans”, but for the most part the album works more on vibe than on the strength of its songs, which simply don’t meet the bar set by the preceding and subsequent albums of the period. But, it’s still Bowie. And its still fun and worth listening to.