Rust Never Sleeps by Neil Young & Crazy Horse

Rust Never Sleeps

Neil Young & Crazy Horse

3.5
Rating
29666
Votes
1
3%
2
11%
3
34%
4
33%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 14)

Nice guitars. Fav tracks: “My my, hey hey” and “Powderfinger”

I really liked this. Great raw energy. The production is a bit muffled though, presumably due to the weird semi live recording technique. I've never come across anything recorded like that before.

One of the Neil Young albums that stands out.

Definitely the best I heard from Neil Young on this list so far, bit still a tiny bit from being "good".

0 if I could. .5

jedna nutka spoko

This album really suited me, it was really musical, a lot of instruments and it made my day i thunk happier. This album is really god for rideing a bike at evening

Uninspiring

Apart from the opening and closing songs, nothing on this grabs me. The whole album feels both less personal and less willing to experiment than his earlier albums.

I'm reasonably certain I've listened to this before, but it's definitely been a long time since the last listen. I'm a fan of Neil Young, and I'm looking forward to this listen. While this isn't my favorite Neil Young album, this one is quite solid. I'm adding it to my list of albums to listen to again.

Neil young albums always feel like a cursed monkeys paw. You get such incredible song writing but you have to hear Neil young sing it.

I will never get over the name “Crazy horse”, it might be the stupidest band name I’ve ever heard. And yes, I’ve listened to Butthole Surfers. Might be the least bad album I’ve heard from Neil Young so far.

Number: 272 Familiarity: Moderate (3) Rating: 3 Before: ======= Nooooo. Neil Young, again. This is number 3 for me. I guess it will be a decent follow up to The Kinks though. After : ======= A few 4's, a few 3's, and a couple of 2's: average comes to 3.3. Favorite discovery: Sedan Delivery. I do have to say that I have a little more appreciation for NY's music than I did before starting this challenge.

Decent but a little boring

If I have to listen to a live album I'd like it to be this kind of music. However there was no banter, or behind the music chat.

I came to Rust Never Sleeps with fairly high expectations. I remember people talking about it when I was involved in the bedroom-production scene, and it had acquired the slightly dangerous aura of one of those records I ought probably to have heard properly years ago. What I found was an album I admired a great deal, thought about constantly while it was playing, and never quite loved. The title gave me the route in almost immediately. “Rust never sleeps” is about stasis, but not inactivity. You can work constantly, produce constantly, tour constantly and still stand still. Movement is not the same thing as progress. Progress involves displacement: ending up somewhere you were not before. Rust, in that sense, is what happens when activity simply reproduces the same position over and over again. “My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)” puts that question down at the start. I was immediately taken by the major-seventh colour in the opening, which makes the song sound much more reflective than the famous line about burning out rather than fading away might suggest. That line has acquired a life of its own, but “rust never sleeps” is more interesting. Burning out and fading away are endpoints. Rust is a process. It is what happens while you are still there. “Thrasher” then develops the thought almost perfectly. Young is looking back at people who “had the best selection”, who were “poisoned with protection”, with nothing they needed and therefore nothing left to find. That is a brutal description of what success can do to an artist. Protection ought to be benign, but here it removes necessity, and necessity is part of what forces discovery. Nothing needed, nothing sought, nothing found. His answer is departure: a one-way ticket, suitcase in hand. Not movement for the sake of looking adventurous, but the refusal to stay inside an arrangement that has ceased to produce anything new. The thresher separates what can still be used from what has to be left behind. That became the central idea of the album for me: Neil Young preserving the right to move. That does not mean rejecting everything old. “Ride My Llama” is slight and peculiar, but “it’s old but it’s good” provides a useful correction. Old is not the same thing as rusty. An old form can remain completely alive if somebody is still finding a live use for it. Progress does not mean throwing away every tool you have already used. “Pocahontas” turned out to be the song that gave me the most to think about. It starts with historical violence and dispossession, but gradually becomes a much stranger meditation on what modern civilisation has actually delivered in exchange. The song keeps setting possession against experience. The line about giving a thousand pelts to sleep with Pocahontas and “find out how she felt” contains the contradiction in miniature. Pelts belong to extraction, accumulation and exchange. But another person’s feeling does not. You cannot discover genuine mutual desire by offering something for it. A transaction may secure access; it cannot secure reciprocity. So the song starts to look like a chain: nature becomes resource, resource becomes commodity, commodity becomes purchasing power, and purchasing power is then expected to obtain intimacy. The narrator wants something authentic while imagining the route to it through the very logic of possession from which he seems to be trying to escape. Then there is “the homeland we’ve never seen”. That is crucial because the homeland is itself a construct. This is not memory. It is modern dissatisfaction inventing a lost place of authenticity and imagining that somewhere behind civilisation there was a world in which experience was more direct and real. You cannot return to something you never knew. Marlon Brando appearing beside the fire makes the whole thing stranger still. Brando carries Hollywood with him, including his very public association with Sacheen Littlefeather and Native American representation, and now he is sitting there talking about Hollywood and “the good things there for hire”. By then the song seems to be full of things modern life can own, hire, reproduce or package without recovering whatever experience originally gave them meaning. The juxtaposition of teepee and Astrodome is extraordinary. They are both structures, both enclosed spaces, yet they seem to represent opposite ends of an entire history: one portable and relatively simple, the other enormous, engineered, climate-controlled and commercial. “Sail Away” picks up almost directly from there. “I could live inside a teepee / I could die in penthouse 35.” The penthouse ought to represent arrival. Instead it may be the place where life congeals. Material success is not necessarily progress if it leaves you unable to move. The song scrambles winners and losers as well: losers in the best bars, winners in dives, people becoming “real stars” for the rest of their lives. Young seems much less interested in where somebody sits inside that hierarchy than in whether that position becomes permanent. Fine, be successful. Fine, be unsuccessful. Just leave me the option of sailing away. The danger is capture. That is why “the right to move” kept feeling more useful than the usual language about reinvention. Young is not necessarily saying that an artist has to become unrecognisable every few years. He is saying that no previous success should become a contract obliging you to remain that person. Then Crazy Horse arrive and the record changes physically. “Powderfinger” is superb. Its world appears almost instantaneously: a white boat coming up the river, a red beacon, a flag, a man on the rail. The observation that they do not appear to be there to deliver the mail is wonderfully grim because the language is so ordinary compared with the threat. The narrator is twenty-two and has been left responsible when the danger arrives. He stands his ground and pays for it. I initially tried to pull this back into the album’s movement thesis and then realised I was doing the song a disservice. This is not movement. This is precisely the opposite. He stays. That distinction matters. Stasis is remaining fixed because you have ceased to develop. Standing your ground is remaining fixed because something is worth defending. The physical position may be identical, but the ethical meaning is completely different. Crazy Horse are perfect for this. They play simple things simply, but with such conviction that simplicity becomes weight. There is no need to decorate the story. The band just bears down on it. Then comes “Welfare Mothers”, and I cannot manufacture a grand argument for it simply because the rest of the record has given me one. It seems to be a daft smutty joke with a very good band behind it. The riff is effective, the band are enjoying themselves, but after “Powderfinger” it feels particularly coarse and slight. I kept waiting for some extra layer to emerge. It did not. That is where the album started to feel lumpy. “Sedan Delivery” is another odd fish, though much more interesting. It feels like a drifter’s life told through disconnected anecdotes: someone who cannot hold down much of anything except perhaps delivering cars, which is itself a job built around taking something somewhere and moving on. The lack of narrative coherence suits the character because the life itself does not settle into coherence. Musically, Young has embraced the abrasive permission of the late seventies. He does not sound as though he is trying to become a punk. Crazy Horse already knew how to play primitively. What punk seems to have offered is permission to make that primitiveness abrasive, abrupt, ugly and insufficiently polished. Then the opening song returns as “Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)”, and the album’s construction finally pays off in full. It is the same song repackaged with all its guts hanging out. The important thing is that the reprise cannot simply take us back to the beginning. That would contradict everything the album has argued. You can return to the same stream, but it is different water and you are a different man. “Out of the blue” suggests arrival, the point at which something appears before expectations have solidified around it. “Into the black” is what happens afterwards: exposure, success, history, identity. Once that has happened you cannot restore the original conditions. Success comes at a price because every successful movement creates another position from which you may subsequently have to move. That is where “rock and roll can never die” finally made sense to me. Not as a boast that a particular genre is eternally guaranteed survival, but as an argument that a form remains alive if people continue to find living uses for it. Crazy Horse’s ragged playing matters because nobody is trying to preserve rock behind glass. They are using it. The irony is that all of this left me with a very rich argument and only a moderately strong attachment to the album carrying it. There is an enormous amount here. “Thrasher” is a wonderful statement about the danger of protection. “Pocahontas” kept opening into more difficult questions about possession, authenticity, civilisation and experience. “Powderfinger” complicates the album’s apparent philosophy rather than merely illustrating it. The transformation between the opening and closing tracks is beautifully conceived. But “Ride My Llama” remains a small oddity, “Sedan Delivery” is deliberately scrappy, and “Welfare Mothers” genuinely leaves me wondering why it is there. The record moves between terrific songs and material that feels much less substantial. So the odd thing about Rust Never Sleeps is that the album’s argument landed harder than the album itself. It asked me to engage with it, and I did. My head had an excellent time. But my heart was never quite lifted in the way it has been by other Neil Young records. That does not make the argument any less convincing. If anything, the record’s best insight survives my reservations about the record itself. Artistic life depends not upon perpetual novelty but upon refusing to become fixed. Old things can remain alive. Familiar forms can still produce discovery. What matters is retaining the freedom to become something other than what worked yesterday. You can revisit where you started. You cannot go back there.

Crazy that I thought this was boring on first listen and now it’s pretty handily my favorite Neil.

Another Neil Young album? At least this one is pretty good so thank you for that.

Ok this was way better than I was expecting and I was listening to it during a tough time and lemme tell you this soothed my nerves perfectly. Not a Neil Young fan at all. In fact I find his music to be quite grating. But this was fine.

Sorry it is Neil Young… Not Neil Diamond I only confused the Name… Pocahontas is saved and maybe One other song 2.5* finally

Started well, but than turned into a generic album.

Neil Young and Crazy Horse, my friend

Not sure what I expected but really enjoyed this. Loved loved loved the opening track in particular. Nice surprise

Solid album. I liked the little gimmick with the first and last song. The lyrics seem a little insipid.

Repeat listen

Great! Love me some Neil.

#107 I like Neil Young, but this album feels weak compared to a lot of his earlier work. Most of these songs are decent enough, maybe just a bit forgettable. Welfare Mothers and Sedan Delivery are not good, bordering on annoying. Highlights: My My, Hey Hey, Sail Away 3.5 / 5

Neil Young at his best. No weaknesses with this one. It’s all amazing.

#264/1001 🇨🇦 Neil Young is probably my favourite artist of all time and here he sings about remaining staying not fading away. I wonder if he knew that he would still be releasing relevant music nearly 50 yrs later. This record is recorded live, i assume with studio overdubs added later. The first side is largely acoustic, then gets electric and heavier on side 2. Whilst i prefer the electric version of Hey Hey, My My, its tracks like Thrasher and Pocahontas on side 1 that really stand out to me. Best Tracks: Hey Hey, My My, Thrasher, Powderfinger, Pocahontas, My My, Hey Hey.

Would have given it a 2 and a half to be fair, I am NOT a Neil young fan but this was OK

I thought post "After the Gold Rush" I had had my Neil Young epiphany and that I would like all his albums going fwd. Not quite. I love My My Hey Hey (both versions) but everything else inbetween is just a bit meh. Whats going on Neil?

This rounds off one of the greatest periods of any discography, the Neil Young 69-79 period. Even more notable because his output fell off a cliff for ten years after this (with a couple of exceptions to prove the rule, such as Hawks and Doves). The opening tracks here are sublime - the haunting 'My My, Hey Hey' built around that superb A minor riff, and coupled with iconic lyrics; and the cryptic 'Thrasher', some of the most poetic lyrics he ever wrote and beautiful melody. And 'Pocahontas' rounds off the triplet of acoustic excellence. It's one of his key albums and a continuing part of his tide of 70s creativity - a go to for any newbie. I prefer the acoustic side but the rocky stuff is intriguingly concise for Crazy Horse which really works to the album's benefit.

Classic Americana sound. This would have been such a fun show to see live. The songwriting and production are so easy to get along with. Very thoughtful and passionate record.

extraño

Friday, 25 September, 2026 Not as great as I remember. It was solid, but I was expecting to give this five stars. My My Hey Hey (both versions) and Powderfinger are great. The rest is fine.

I liked this more than I had expected.

Neither good nor bad… as far as I’m concerned. Two stars…

First time listening to Neil Young. As I went through the list, I noticed he has a LOT of albums here. I think about seven. So I hope I like this, or this is gonna be rough. 01. My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue) Really enjoyed. Not much to say about it, was good. 02. Thrasher Honestly really boring. Wasn't impressive. I didn't dislike it, it just left me bored. 03. Ride My Llama Favorite so far. This is definitely going to be a slower album, and I'm fine with that. Just a weird song. 04. Pocahontas I didn't care for the lyrics, but the best instrumentation so far. Still just sort of alright. 05. Sail Away Was fine. Inoffensive. 06. Powderfinger Took a while for me to be into it, but I eventually came around. Still don't love it, but I appreciate it. 07. Welfare Mothers I can't tell if this is suppose to be bashing or uplifting mothers on welfare. I like the instrumentation, but the lyrics are really wack to me. 08. Sedan Delivery There's enough slow here, just keep it fast paced the whole time! I didn't mind this, actually quite liked it. Just found it a bit boring. 09. Hey Hey, My My (Into The Black) A better version of the opener. Overall, I preferred the first half, a lot more. Although it was close, as I didn't much care for this. Like it was fine, but stuff before this is much better than this, in my opinion.

oh wow this album is boring. it picks up a bit near the end but i didn't really care for most of it. neil young's voice is realllly grating to me

Yeah it's a nice album, Neil Young is pretty good

I've always been ambivalent about Neil Young. Some of his music I like a lot. Some I find boorish. This is about half and half.

i feel like im going to love this and make it my personality for the whole autumn season

Started kinda slow and samey, but gradually built up energy and made the total experience feel like a cohesive story, with some nice guitar and catchy songs near the end

Really enjoyed this album. The history of Young was also very interesting to read about.

not sure why i like dylan, but can't really handle neil young's voice

Have never been a Neil Young superfan, but I appreciate his legacy and he has some great songs. I think this album maybe only has 1-2 of them (the bookend tracks). I kind of liked the acoustic interplay and chord voicings on Ride My Llama, and the half acoustic-half electric idea was interesting. Just overall not enough here to sustain my interest - like Dylan, probably another example of needing to really get into the lyrics to get the full appreciation.

Well, the album was okay. The constant harmonica and the sometimes unimaginative guitar strumming were kind of annoying. There isn't much else I remember about it. So, for me, this is a somewhat disappointing album by Neil Young. 3/5

First live album (well technically it was a live album, but the guys dubbed it in the studio after), and already 2nd album of Neil Young on that challenge. Just like the previous one, this release is good. Love Neil, his voice, his melodies. It’s a really short album and that’s a plus. Since he published so many songs, some of them are forgettable, but some are anthems. 4/5. Another solid album from the Canadian artist. My, My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue): 5 Trasher: 5 Ride My Llama: 3 Pocahontas: 3 Sail Away: 3 Powderfinger: 5 Welfare Mothers: 4 Sedan Delivery: 3 Hey, Hey, My, My (Into the Black): 3

I like his politics, but never really cared for his music

YA this was great

Neil Young is kinda cheeks This must've hit so hard if you were smoking the weakest joint in history. Sedan delivery is almost a punk song Into the Black is fine I guess. Nice guitar tone.

Was never a big fan.

I could half understand why people may think this is boring or don't like Neil's voice. But I think they are deaf. It's a grungy americana-twinged album made by a Canadian with an American band. And somehow Powderfinger is more relevant in 2026 than it was in 1979

I liked it but Kori had a hot take and I don’t think he was wrong but it also didn’t mean I didn’t like it

Sounds like Niel Young

Neil Young is and always has been that guy

Almost a 5. Hey hey, My my gives it a 4 instantly. One really great song, but there are some others particularly on side 1. Not as big a fan of the side 2 stuff, but still ok. I kind of view Neil Young like Bob Dylan…. Except I really like Neil Young.

I was really hype after the first couple tracks, but then it quickly faded into (decent!) background music. Better than the last album we listened to of his, but I’m still waiting to love Neil Young.

Now this is a Neil Young album that actually deserves to be on the list. "My, My, Hey, Hey" is obviously the headliner here, and for good reason, but solid tracks like "Thrasher" really help fill the rest of the album out. My only complaint is that Neil Young kinda runs out of lyrical steam near the end and just starts saying random stuff, but the lyrics on the first couple tracks are good enough that I am willing to give him a pass.

Strong start with My, My, Hey, Hey. Enjoyed the rest, but have never been a huge Neil Young fan.

Like the switch from the acoustic sound to the heavier guitars. Good album.

A lot of songs I had never heard, nice!

It were reyt enough.

One half was acoustic, the other electric. I probably preferred the electric slightly. A textbook three star album.

Neil gets 5s.

Perfect soundtrack for hanging around in bars and impressing the ladies with magic tricks.

3.7 I’ve never heard this album although I’ve heard some of the songs on it. I can’t stop listening to Thrasher and Sail On, great songs I’ve never heard before.

26. septembar 2026. 00.27h i mean its nice ali im lowkeynuinely bored ali okej nije lose mozda samo nisam neil young head ima fin progression and its sweet

I never cared for Neil Young. Still don't.

I’ve heard this before. This is the album that made me understand why people called him the godfather of grunge in the early 90s, it’s evident the most in the guitar solos which are noisy and melodic and straight to the point without much virtuosity thrown in, but it’s also evident in the chord structure of a lot of songs which are kind of dissonant and not typical for the time. I like how the live parts of the recording focus on the music and make the crowd sounds mostly quiet to keep it more like a studio album. Also every song is a classic banger here without exception.

Can't go wrong with Neil Young

only kinda liked the first song and maybe the last

i like powderfinger's, walfare mothers' and hey hey, my my's instrumental

I wish I enjoyed this more but I could not get my brain to find it satisfying/pleasing. Things I did enjoy: the storytelling/lyrics and the drums + guitar throughout the folky parts but especially the rock parts. I am just not a fan of Neil Young's voice here. :( Favorite Tracks: Powderfinger

It's Better To Burn Out Than Fade Away 1001 Albums Generator 349 (9/14/2026) Similar to Bringing It All Back Home, Rust Never Sleeps is an album with an acoustic, soft first half, and a more explosive second half. It is bookended by My My, Hey Hey, which is a soft folk song with a great harmonica solo and Hey Hey, My My, which is an extremely heavy (for the time) song that reprises some of the same musical and lyrical themes. Other highlights include the beautiful Thrasher and the hard rockin Powderfinger, which features a haunting story of a young man who is killed trying to protect his family. A few bumps in the tracklist aside, Rust Never Sleeps is a fantastic album. 4/5. Favs: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) Powderfinger Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) Least Fav: Ride My Llama

The rock side is better than the folk side. Probably because the vocals aren't the main thing going on. I still don't particularly like Neil Young's voice, but the music is really good. 3.5 with a reluctant rounding up to 4.

Overall, this was a 3 star album, but also… out of the blue and into the black

Neil Diamond. A good singer songwriter. Good album overall.

I like Neil Young, but I've never clicked with this one - I just don't really like the live sound. My My, Hey Hey is a classic, but the rest of it just floats by. It's seemingly revered by everyone who's ever liked anything by him, but I just don't get it.

I have a slightly uneasy relationship with Neil Young, never quite getting the adulation. This album does open with a stonking track in My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) but also contains some real oddities Then it has some clangers like Pocahontas. As an album it is one of his better ones, for sure.

I like it

Not my bag, Hey Hey carried the album for me

The My Heys were both pretty good. I was keen to hear Powderfinger as I know it’s where the Aussie band took their name from, but I didn’t really care for it. The album was ok. There’s been too much Neil Young along this project, I guess this was the final one I’ll be offered, but yeah, he’s a bit overdone.

went into this expecting to hate it and was gripped by the first couple songs. then it fell off. i liked the acoustic vs electric idea but did not enjoy the electric songs - which is weird because i am not a fan of acoustic 70s rock at all. idk i wouldn’t come back to it but im not dreading the other neil young albums now.

a bit boring

Ok, chill vibes

For Niel Young, this wasn't terrible.

Finally i realized the resource of Lana del Rey’s lyrics, out of the blue and into the black

Good album

Good collection of live Neil Young

Not as good as harvest More Neil young but live and it’s not as good 3/5 Nothing crazy I liked hey hey my my opening an closing the album Favorites: hey hey my my, Pocahontas

OK in places, some decent tracks, wouldn't discount listening to it again

Not bad, Harvest Moon is quite better, even though a few songs are very similar in my opinion

Walked with my pikmin and smoked cigarettes it was a pleasant listening experience

My my hey hey is a banger, rest is nice, but overall not my vibe anymore

I didn’t always love the live elements. The vocals were occasionally a little weak, but I like the songs and it was a good record. 3.5/5

El album sugerido no es el ejemplo más representativo de la energía y carrera profesional de Neil Young, Weld (1991) hubiera sido una muestra 5 estrellas.

Начинается альбом с шикарной My my, hey hey, а все, что после, совершенно не идёт ни в какое сравнение. Ожидания не оправдались

Un álbum creativo por parte de Neil y su grupo, sin embargo Harvest sigue siendo su mejor que he escuchado hasta ahora Hey Hey, My My es el estandarte de este álbum, muy melancólica y profunda se logra percibir el sentimiento con la que se interpreta en su primera versión Las otras canciones no es que estuvieran mal, de hecho es un folk muy bien producido, e incluso tienen protesta política en un par, solo no son las más memorables, pero si es una muestra del talento de Neil y de su pasión por la música esté siendo el undécimo álbum de su carrera Permitase escucharlo, no estoy seguro de si volvería recurrentemente a el, pero si lo disfruté

Listened previously. Expectations: High - Verdict: Near Perfect - My My, Hey Hey is an all time classic and the album just continues at this incredible standard. Thrasher is a stunning song with some of my favourite lyrics ever written. Ride My Llama is very spacey, fitting the sci-fi imagery perfectly. Pocahontas is another very good song that has a bit more energy than most of the first side. I think Sail Away is a very good song but it is slightly less interesting than the others so far. Powderfinger absolutely rips and the contrast from the first side to second is incredible. Despite the wildly different sound you can very clearly tell the songs were written by the same person, or at least they have an intangible quality that is distinctively Neil Young. Welfare Mothers doesn't have the lyrical beauty of some of the other tracks but it makes up for it with a fantastic riff and bouncing energy. Sedan Delivery also rocks out while the closing reprise has a ridiculously fuzzed out guitar sound that is pure filth. A perfect climax to a brilliant, brilliant album.

Second Neil Young album in a short span is a pretty quintessential live + studio span. Bookended between “my my hey hey” and “hey hey my my” reflections on the rise of punk and refreshing ones approach vs sticking to the tried and true, I don’t think this is as good as some of his crazy horse backed studio albums just prior to this era. It’s pretty good but could be better. Fave for me is a killer version of “powderfinger”

Really wish Neil would put his stuff back on Amazon. One, it's ad free for me but second, there's quite a few great tracks here. Solid 4/5

It's fine. It's pretty good.

Average, wouldn't listen again except maybe first song

Me gustó, llevadero, buen sonido y de largo justo

out of the blue into the black

Fav tracks: My My Hey Hey, Powderfinger. Neil Youngs voice is generally not my cup of tea but like the flow from acoustic to the grungy electric songs at the end of the album.

very good

10/10 – Masterpiece

Ну неплохо, учитывая, сколько Нила Янга я уже здесь прослушал.

"I'm gonna ride a Llama, from home to Texicama" Riveting stuff. Despite this I actually like Neil Young. Perhaps over represented in the list with 7+ albums. Not generally a fan of live albums but according to Wikipedia most tracks on this album are actually not quite recorded live. Does have perhaps my favourite Neil Young track. I certainly prefer the acoustic version of Hey Hey over the overly distorted electric version that is the last track on the album. Bonus point for having a band named after one of your tracks: "Powderfinger". Minus half a point for overuse of the blues harp (harmonica) on "Thrasher." Thankfully not repeated.

Farts in a bottle

Incredibly wise move by Neil to hold off on releasing Sedan Delivery for at least four years so he could deliver its opening lines at such a speed that the line "I beat a woman with varicose veins" just sounds like a maniac is thrashing some poor woman & not beating her at pool. Welfare Mothers aside, which I don't hate but is not up to the rest of the album's standards, Rust Never Sleeps is the crown jewel of Neil's 70s output. I like On The Beach more and depending on my mood, maybe even After the Gold Rush and Chrome Dreams but this is such a wild object. Total noise explosion at the end, bookended tracks - first acoustic, then electric and heavy. It's got Powderfinger on it, can't beat that. Powderfinger's one of the best songs period. Do I like Sedan Delivery more? Yeah. Rust Never Sleeps just has two of the best songs. And Thrasher. And My, My, Hey Hey. Neil's the god

3,8 Highlights: My, My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue), Sedan Delivery

Before listening to this Album the song Southern Man is all the Neil Young I know, I do enjoy that song so I'm optimistic for this album. Lots of harmonica, more country vibes then I expected especially from a Canadian artist.

This was nice.

Been too long since I immersed myself in some Neil Young. This album was all over the place in a good way.

Neil Young casually invented a new genre of music — on a live album, no less. The acoustic-to-electric transition is a chef’s kiss, and it gives the album a weighty, almost biblical feel.

This has always been a second-tier Neil album for me despite it having two of my favs in "Powderfinger" and "Thrasher" (one of those rare songs that makes me instantly well up with tears for some mystical reason). "Welfare Mothers" is goofy bordering on bad, and I vastly prefer the heavy "Hey, Hey" (did this song singlehandedly invent grunge? with what demonic force did Neil consort to get that earth-rattling tone?). Otherwise, absolutely singular EG solos, timeless melodies and lyrics, some of Neil's best harmonica playing, and how can you not enjoy a concept album about how he went deaf? I'd listen to this any day of the week.

Brilliant classic

As impossible as it is for me to choose a favorite Neil Young album, this might be my selection for his most definitive work to date. In nine songs, you get not only a conceptually rich and sonically dynamic live album, but a perfect microcosm of his career up that point. Side A is the melancholic, slightly cryptic, slightly sardonic strummer; Side B is proto-grunge, pure Crazy Horse wildness. Some of these songs are beautiful enough to bring a tear to your eye (“Thrasher”), others are silly enough to make you laugh out loud (“Welfare Mothers”), and some do both (“Powderfinger”). Fav Tracks: My My Hey Hey (Out of the Blue), Thrasher, Sail Away, Powderfinger, Welfare Mothers, Sedan Delivery, Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) Least Fav: Pocahontas Score: 9.5

Oh great. Another bore fest! Let’s hope this is better than the other one. Yea, it isn’t.

I like the modified reprise at the end of the set, but not quite enough to motivate me to listen again anytime soon

'Hey, Hey, My, My' siempre será mi canción favorita de Neil Young por la serie de Hijos de la Anarquía. Y el resto del disco es magnífico, no lo conocía.

ihan kiva levy työnteon taustalle. Ei sieltä oikee noussu semmosia ylitse muiden biisejä jossei avausraitaa lasketa

Jaahas, lisää nuorta Neiliä ja hevosiakin saatu mukaan. Se ei tätä kuitenkaan pelasta, vaan samaa paskaa edelleen.

On tääkin kyl.

Noniin. Taas helppoa viiden tähden Niiloa. Tämä sisältää pelkkiä huippubiisejä, Powderfinger erityisesti lähellä omaa sydäntä.

Haven't listened to this in a while, great album

Sweet and class

Good but samey af

This is my shit. Sad to find out that my vinyl copy is warped, but man that "Powderfinger" riff sounds great on streaming too.

Didnt expect any of it xddd

ANOTHER Neil Young Album? I swear there was horrible guy that was always at the bar when I was in college, the jerk thought he was a musician, I bet he is on this stupid album selection committee ... this list seems like something he would do

A lot of Neil young but I’m a fan.

Quien diría que Young Neil de Scott Pilgrim era tan meh

All timer

It's Neil Young. It's good. May not put it on again, but it's cool.

It's good. If I was more of a Neil fan I might even love it. Odd choice.

Ever been a big fan with the exception of the song pearl jam did and he played with them

Turns out the only way to get me to like a live album is to make it not a true live album

Never been a big fan of Neil Young, but this album was a pleasant surprise.

Possibly my favorite Neil Young record, just depends on the day and my mood. The beautiful folkier start slowly eases into a heavy and thrilling rock ending, with both Out of the Blue and Into the Black giving you goosebumps that don't go away. Would have fit right into the grunge movement but predated it by a decade. *Record Collection

Neil Young, with his quavery voice, running wild over Crazy Horse. At least this one feels more like a collaboration instead of Neil Young the taskmaster.

This was great! It really does sound like something from much later than it is except for young’s voice which always sounds like 1975.

Familiar with the artist? Yes, I heard a lot of Neil Young growing up, though not this album. Thoughts: I will admit that nostalgia will have an effect on my Neil Young ratings. He's my dad's favorite so I have good memories of Harvest playing throughout the house most weekends. A lot of people can't deal with his voice, which I get, but I don't mind it. On this album specifically though - the bookend tracks are excellent, and the only part of the album I was really familiar with. Enjoyed most of the rest as well, though I do have a couple I'd skip. Favorite track(s): My My, Hey Hey / Hey Hey, My My Least favorite: "Pocahontas" probably seemed progressive at the time, but ...😅

Powderfinger is okay Even welfare mothers 2 star album

Nothing outstanding. 2,8

I found it ok to have on whilst I was driving. Would I play it again? Would I fuck !

Listened to only a few, again Paris, but it was good classic Neil. Nothing too fancy. Just guitar, vocals, and twang.

Such a great album. Loved it so much.

Very good stuff

Groovy, vintage, rock

Another just really solid entry from Neil Young. Contrary to what I thought initially, the more standard heavy country-rock instrumentation provided by "Crazy Horse" works oddly well with Young's more introspective folksy style. Songs like the opener and 'Powderfinger' are prime showcases of that; it never feels like they're drowning out his boyish vocals. Instead, they just add another layer of melancholy to the whole thing; the playing is just so sharp and electric, and has this almost heavy '90s alternative feel to it well before the fact, especially on 'Welfare Mothers' and 'Sedan Delivery'. It feels like the album gets gnarlier and heavier as it goes along, with the closer 'Hey Hey My My' feeling almost clanging and industrial. Think there are heavy themes on this album relating to the changing images and shape of the rock music that Neil Young grew up with (especially in the incredible bookend tracks and the way they mirror one another sonically), so this direction only makes sense. These more in-your-face instrumentals bring out a new side of Young that I quite enjoyed here. Still though, my favorite song here was closer to a traditional Neil Young song with the acoustic guitar and harmonica of 'Thrasher'. Just such a beautiful classic-styled singer-songwriter track that, again, tackles those themes of shifting tides in Young's musical career. It's a bittersweet track that's told through the lens of a man struggling to grow in a strange new world. Yeah, pretty great Neil Young record yet again; the guy can't seem to miss no matter how far he strays from his traditional style.

Classic album

Hey Neil, what the fuck are you talking about? "I wish I was a trapper, I would give a thousand pelts to sleep with Pocahontas and to find out how she felt in the morning on the fields of green, in the homeland we've never seen. And maybe Marlon Brando will be there by the fire. We'll sit and talk of Hollywood and all the good things there for hire. And the Astrodome, and the first teepee. Marlon Brando, Pocahontas, and me." "Welfare mother make better lovers. People, pick up on what I'm puttin' down now. Welfare mothers make better lovers. Down at every laundromat in town. Welfare mothers make better lovers when they're washin you can here this sound now. Welfare mothers make better lovers. Divorcee!" "I met a man from Mars, he picked up all my guitars and played me travelling songs. And when we got on ship, he brough out something for the trip. He said 'it's old but it's good,' like any other primative would. I'm gonna ride my llama from Peru to Texarkana. I wanna ride him good." "Sedan delivery is a job I know I'll keep. It sure was hard to find." Can someone check on ole Neil?

5 Not quite as good as EKTIN but another great album. why did Young do so many solo albums if his work with Crazy Horse could be this good After a second listen I think I like it even more than EKTIN and am bumping to 5

The accoustic side of this album was made for me. The electric side less so but I’ll still give it full marks. I added “My, My, Hey, Hey” to my playlist.

Al parecer esto solo recomienda rock. Me cansé de escuchar lo mismo. Dame algo diferente. En otro orden, estuvieron normalitas las canciones, las siento muy iguales al resto que me ha recomendado la app y eso me cansa.

I enjoyed tho i dont know if i would relisten

Love the evil version of my my hey hey at the end

Despite trying several times, I just can't get into most of Neil Young's catalogue with a few exceptions. "Rust Never Sleeps" is one of those exceptions. Part solo, part full band, part studio, part live - it would seem that this project would come across as unfocused, but Neil makes it work. The rock-solid bookends of "My, My, Hey Hey" and "Hey, Hey, My, My" anchor the album but the best two tracks are "Thrasher" and "Powderfinger". A few weaker songs ("Pocohantes", "Ride My Llama", and "Sedan Delivery") prevent this from being a 4 star album but it is a very solid 3 star or 7 out of 10.

beautiful shit in every sense. this is now the third neil young album my group has had and i think this project has cemented him as a favourite of mine, truly one of the greats

My favorite album of his.

it's really not better to burn out than fade away, Neil

joy. meer neil young.

Nice vibe, men inte så mycket mer

Nice! Damn, the riff off of Powderfingers is just too sick isn't it. Haven't listened to this one properly before but of course spam listened the opening and closing track needless to say. I think this is still a good spot for Young. On the calmer tracks I don't quite think we reach the level from After the Gold Rush and Harvest were less truly is more for him. There is a lot more going on musically in this version of Young and it is not necessarily a bad thing, I just prefere the aforementioned. Anyways, another four today, two in a row. As far as fours go, this is bang in the middle I feel. Not quite peek Young but close.

Amazing album, and I truly believe that My my, Hey hey is his best track out of an impressive catalogue 4.3

I didn't mind this album as much as I disliked the last NY+CH album (Ragged Glory) I had on here, but only marginally. I still don't enjoy Youngs voice, but these songs were decent-ish. It's still a 2 for me though, no desire to listen to any of it again. Standouts were "My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)" and "Sedan Delivery"

It’s aight, not my vibe.

I like this album a lot, but is it a five-star album?

Side 1 is sitting round a campfire. Side 2 is living in Missouri, married to your cousin. I preferred the acoustic which if you knew me, tells you alot about Side 2

I'm a life long Neil Young fan and this album spoke to me and me friends upon its release. A classic indeed. Love it.

I’m tired of this, grandpa (Nah it’s got some good stuff. I like Thrasher and Powderfinger)

Neil seems so sad. It's probably because people are so judgemental about his voice. It's really snobby. I like that he did a punk song though. The album had a nice mix of different ideas. Not 100% my sort of thing or as experimental as I'd want, but it was enjoyable enough. It loses a point because I didn't here this "crazy" horse sing at all. As a big fan of Mr Ed I was sorely disappointed. 3/5

2026.08.23.

Never listened to this album before. Not that I dislike Neil Young but there are so many albums to go at and I always wrongly thought this was one of his many live albums. Fooled by the cover! Having now listened think I’ve missed a treat all these years. Particularly the acoustic side which is so good it rivals ATGR and Harvest. The electric bit was OK but is very typical of his sound and does not stand out. Will buy this album for the acoustic songs alone. 4/5 13/8/26

One of my favorite bands

This is a fine album. I listened to it frequently when it came out. These days, I don't listen to much Neil Young. But it was a nice reminder of this era. My guess (I'm not familiar with everything he's done) is that this is one of his highlight works.

Having the first and last songs as inverses of one another is simply genius, not to mention they are both wonderful songs

I am staggered I’m giving Neil Young another 4. I thought I’d heard all of his good ones, but no this one comes along with a My My Hey Hey double header and once again I’m forced to admit it’s excellent. Old LPs having two sides really benefit albums like this where Young intentionally kept the first side quite acoustic and melodic, before amping things up for a much rockier and livelier second. Will definitely be playing this again

Déjà écouté avant. Un album étrange dans sa conception (enregistré en live mais massivement retravaillé en studio, au point d'effacer presque intégralement les sons du publics ; une structure en deux parties, acoustique en solo puis électrique avec Crazy Horse, qui rappelle le formidable "Royal Albert Hall" de Dylan, encadrée par deux variations autour de "Hey Hey, My My") mais fascinant dans son exécution, tant le songwriting de Neil Young est brillant, et le Crazy Horse dans une forme rare. Mention spéciale à la partie électrique, qui va chercher des distorsions absolument démentes pour l'époque, à la limite du grunge avec près de quinze ans d'avance (le live Weld en 1991, ira encore plus loin dans le crade avec beaucoup des mêmes chansons). Une œuvre majeure, malgré son statut un peu particulier, à cheval entre live et studio, et la qualité sonore inégale qui en découle. Top : Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black) Flop : Ride My Llama

This is an album I own but haven't listened to for some time, so it's nice to come back to it. The things I really like: the 2 or 3 genuinely great songs on here; My My, Hey Hey, Thrasher and Powderfinger all feel timeless and evocative pieces of songwriting. Also the way the album moves into grittier and more intense music as it progresses, likewise some of the overdriven guitar tones are epic. At the same time, I struggle a bit with the narrative, the overall consistency (it's all 'good' but not all 'great' - at least to me) and, obviously Neil's voice is somewhat divisive. Decent, but it wouldn't make my top shelf of records.

Not too bad

Neil Young, he warrants a commentary. Neil, like Bob Dylan, was an artist I didn’t much care for early in my college years, though it was for a completely differently, set of arbitrary reasons. I grew out of that dislike, FAST! The only artist for which I now have a bigger music catalogue than Neil, is Eric Clapton. That gives you a sense of for how I now revere Neil’s work. This is not my favorite Neil Young album, but it is damn close!

I like some of these songs but probably wouldn't listen to this regularly.

This was a peaceful album. I liked it.

Neil absolutely ripping and fucking

so much greatness on this record. also some pretty heavy mediocrity at times. I'm drawn to the acoustic stuff + sail away. my my hey hey was never my fav neil track -- though it's clearly a great song (and the return is so heavy it's undeniablly moving). 'welfare mothers' sucks favs: sail away, ride my llama, thrasher

my my hey hey that’s a great song man these acoustic guitars sound like shit acoustic DI on a recording is a cardinal sin doesn’t live in the same realm as On the Beach or Harvest or Gold Rush but my hot take is that he is a great songwriter!

Good, I remember it more epically -

Opening track was gorgeous of course, rest a little meh.

My my hey hey, sen resten fillers

Just a bloody good songwriter isn't he?? Really enjoyed this, but have to take a star off because there's not enough of the awesome vocal harmonies that you get on his solo stuff!

Wanted to like this more than I actually did

im canadian so i feel like i have to love neil young. its really good but there's more than enough neil young albums on this list, this one can be skipped

Bem mais a minha cara que os outros mas sei la

Hinner inte skriva så mycket, men jag gillar Neil Young och albumet i sin helhet är helt ok medans några spår (typ hey hey my my) är riktigt bra.

Great album from Neil Young, definitely in the zone of my favorite albums for him.

I'm a Neil Young fan and his stuff with Crazy Horse is my favorite.

C’était chouette

Extra point for My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue) / Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)

Not a style I enjoy.

Why do they all have harmonicas

Not for me

Classic Neil young one of his best albums , a 70s classic.

I don't even really like the harmonica but this was enjoyable (except for track 7-9) also my my, hey hey (out of the blue) was already in my playlist powderfinger was also kinda nice so this gets 3 stars from me bc I would totally listen to track 1-6 on a boat trip and I will maybe listen again

El primero que escucho de Neil Young, No me encantó.

I don’t have much to say about it tbh

didn't really listen that hard

I was not expecting my first 5 star to be a Neil Young and Crazy Horse album. Young is an incredible guitarist and song writer and was one of the many artists my dad would have playing in the house while I was growing up. This album feels like sitting at a crossroads after long day’s walk. Night has fallen and the wind has an autumn chill to it but is kept at bay by a small campfire. You are sheltered beneath a sky of stars, tired but ready for tomorrow. The narratives and prose of the songs are beautiful and poignant. I also like how tongue and cheek Young can be. I love the little clicks and plucks of the guitar strings and anytime a harmonica is playing. Favourite song: Thrasher Least favourite song: None

Neil is a top-5 artist for me, and he pretty much does no wrong here, although it’s lacking the unhinged edge that, while probably not healthy, takes some earlier albums to the next level. The medium matters with this one: man was not meant to go from “Sail Away” to “Powderfinger” without flipping a record over. The closing track is Ditch-era Neil taken in a blisteringly resolute direction, a proclamation of rock’s immortality splattered on an instrumental that sounds like a train about to go over a cliff. Is that panic in his voice? My personal favorite might be “Pocahontas”, which features some of his crunchiest percussive strumming plus an off-kilter lyric which might only be bested in Neil’s oeuvre by the later “Crime in the City”. Plus, I’ll take those gorgeous harmonies over CSN kumbayah crap any day.

Not my current vibe

Classic album with Neil Young, showcasing both his acoustic style and the harder 'proto'-grunge style. A strong 4. ★★★★½

What a time. Crosby yesterday and young today. Very cohesive.

Dammit, stop making me actively dislike Neil Young. Not terrible. Bonus half a point for that guitar tone on the final track.

Two Neil Young albums in a short timeframe is no reason to complain, especially when the two albums in question are my favourite in his discography. Rust Never Sleeps has a great atmosphere, it just brings me comfort any time I play it. I love the split between the acoustic and electric tracks, it feels very organic and raises the level of the whole record. Some songs were recorded live, some in the studio (well, only two), but they never feel too different from each other to create a distraction. Only three Neil Young albums left to generate in the next two years of the challenge. I will definitely expand on that in my spare time. Favourite track: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)

Best song about Marlon Brando and Pocahontas I've ever heard.

мне кажется его нужно ещё немного послушать. будто бы это слегка не моё но чем-то зацепило.

Hard rockin' Neil Young is so much better than folk singer Neil Young. 'Sedan Delivery' was almost punk rock or grunge in nature, it was wild to hear a song like that from him. If you couldn't tell, I enjoyed the majority of this album, some good hard rock with a couple of slower ballads in there. 'My My, Hey Hey' is always a good listen, too. Strong 4/5, really well-structured album that goes places you wouldn't expect for a Neil Young album.

𝘙𝘶𝘴𝘵 𝘕𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘚𝘭𝘦𝘦𝘱 feels like two albums seamlessly woven into one. The first half is built around intimate acoustic folk songs, while the second bursts into loud, distorted rock, creating a contrast that gives the album much of its character. Listening to 𝗛𝗲𝘆 𝗛𝗲𝘆, 𝗠𝘆 𝗠𝘆 (𝗜𝗻𝘁𝗼 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗕𝗹𝗮𝗰𝗸), it’s easy to hear why Neil Young would later earn the nickname “Godfather of Grunge.” The genre was still years away, but the raw guitars, heavy sound, and uncompromising spirit of the song clearly point towards what many grunge bands would embrace a decade later. 𝘙𝘶𝘴𝘵 𝘕𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘚𝘭𝘦𝘦𝘱 is a compelling reminder of Neil Young’s versatility. Few artists could move so naturally between quiet introspection and explosive rock while sounding unmistakably like themselves.

I love thi, classic Neil Young. I like the energy a lot. Could see myself revisiting

The songs tell stories that are very poetic. I liked it.

“It’s better to burn out than fade away” Neil says in my my hey hey. At nearly 80 years old, somehow he’s managed neither. Fortunate for his bank account, unfortunate for those of us who are not hearing impaired because this fucking sucks. All of Neil young’s music sucks. Maybe it was just a ”had to be there” thing from the 70s but I will never appreciate his music, and his voice is like the most wheedling 4 year old whinging in your ear. . This is my second album from him, and I will never listen to another Neil young anything ever again. Irredeemable The lowest one star I can give ⭐️

Thrasher - it's light, it feels so airy especially with the single guitar It's giving harmonica, loves a little harmonica bridge Ride my llama - chords on the guitar are really nice, quite playful, <3 I like the way that it's recorded, it's a good balance between his voice and the instrumentals, neither overpower the other in a way that's pleasant Pocahontas - feels like the type of song they would play in a movie when the main character is moving to the countryside and they are looking out of their window into a landscape or rolling hills Sail away - this one is so sweet, the lyrics are endearing, it's comforting <3 Powderfinger - he's sounding pretty sassy, I LOVE the electric guitar on this one in between the chorus and the verse, it's a lot more powerful, he just turned 22 and is wandering what to do It reminds me of American Pie, which adds up because Don McLean released it in 1971. It's the 70s! Welfare mothers - divorce babes divorce, I know he's smirking whilst singing this song, cheeky guy Sedan delivery - the album is getting more and more chaotic, those power chords and coming through, it picks up and slows down and it's so addictive <3 Hey hey, my my (into the black) - it's so interesting how the album just flips on itself, it's reflective. It just gets more and more chaotic. <3 I liked the latter half of the album more, I was absolutely digging those power chords.

Me gusto para viajar y estar al sol

I‘m not sure what it is, but something about Neil Young and his singing just hooks me. I absolutely loved the first half of this album, though the second half with Crazy Horse is also quite good. I just really got into the vibe with the soft guitar playing and Neil (a bit whiny) singing about a lost past. Not sure what he attempted to do with Pocahontas and I guess you just have to ignore some of the lyrics to enjoy it, but well. I guess he meant good?

First half four out of five. Second, half six out of five.

I prefer acoustic Neil Young over electric (don’t like his overtly saturated distorted sound). This is a fabulous album of the godfather of grunge. Some great songs. Noted his obsession with Pocahontas.

Maybe I'm in a bad mood but honestly how is this so highly rated. The music backing is so unspectacular. Neal sounds like a shaky joke and the leryics are far from special.

Not a huge fan of this.

Best song: Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)

One of the best live albums, especially the first half acoustic.

I'd never listened to a Neil young album before but I really liked this one, it's a beautiful mix of folk and hard rock, I liked that the first half of the album is acoustic and the other half is electric

Boringfest

Wonderful sound, one of the better sounding live Albums I've ever listened to, recording wise. Some great tracks, Thrasher is Incredible. An album of songs of that quality is a 5. Very let down by the second half of the album

Folky and enjoyable. Easy to listen to and reminds me of my grandparents. The opening track "My, my, Hey, Hey" stands out as the best track on the album. "Welfare Mothers" was a big surprise after the gentleness of the first half of the album. I like the weird turn on the B side to a heavier sound.

Good album but I don’t think it plays to Neil Young’s strengths

I really don't like country but I understand those who do.

What a trip. I'd heard the name of Neil Young before, though, I'd never listened to his music. And this was such an interesting slow burn clash for me. At first I wasn't so much attracted by the calm, mature, melancholic, "countryish" acoustic atmosphere, even when I enjoyed the melodies, specially in "My my, Hey hey". But then, After listening the full album, something made sense. Then, by listening carefully, and genuinely appreciating every element, including the lyrics, it hit me hard.

Felt indifferent about this album. Too slow at some points, and the heavy parts didn’t seem to flow with the rest of the album. But I often quote “it’s better to burn out than fade away”, so that definitely earns a few points. Rating: 5/10 Favorite Song: My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)

Hmm, liker jeg kun Harvest?

Har alltid foretrukket skivene med Crazy Horse.

Første og siste spor er gull, alt i midten er mid.

Harmonica is alot in this bas also a guy with a bad voice

Stylistically and performatively better than the other Neil Young albums I've heard. Some quite heartfelt and well-meaning tracks with good motivations (I feel?) behind them. I can't tell whether he's anti-punk or just pro rock n roll? Anti-punk would sadden me, as music should change and be progressive, but if it's about remembering what was great and came before then it feels like a different vibe.

Very good album. All songs are enjoyable, most are very good. You can hear the DS-1 style distortion used hear that would influence grunge music in the late 80’s and early 90’s. 4 stars for me.

Really enjoyable album. Not knowing what I was in for made for an interesting listen - transitioning from folk to … glam? Grunge? Was a ride. Bookending the album with a grunge version of the first was excellent.

I love neil young. do I think this is better than “After the Gold Rush” or “Harvest”? no, but this still has beautiful qualities and quintessential neil young

Another Neil Young album where he's a sloppy rocker but never changes the way the guitar sounds or exactly hits the right notes. Maybe I just don't like live albums. I like Neil Young I promise! They should just cut all the songs that aren't My My Hey Hey and I would love it.

'Hey hey, my my / Rock 'n' roll can never die.' Only, I mean only, Neil Young can turn a line that elementary into a haunting, reverberating, meaningfully American anthem. Like Springsteen's Nebraska, tho perhaps w/ even more art, Rust Never Sleeps is a giving record, one of those albums that feels like it was made just for you & no one else. Its intimacies are complex things - at once rudimentary & obscure (again, think Thelonious) - but it's always, I mean always, rapturous. Addicted to the mythos of America, Young, tho v much a songwriter rather than a poet (I celebrate this), carries on traditions of Whitman thru Hart Crane. 'I would give a thousand pelts / To sleep with Pocahontas / & find out how she felt.' & as per usual, it rocks, rocks, rocks.

not a big fan of this kind of music at all. I'm a 20-year-old boy who has no chance to experience what it was like back in the 60s and 70s. I'm not even saying anything about living in this period of time. The first song didn't hit me. It wasn't supposed to, but I listened to it from the beginning to the end (it's the hardest thing to do when you have ADHD and drink two Red Bulls a day), but I DID. And...you know...kind of got it, didn't I? It's about legacy, remembering, being remembered, memorable things, and so on and so forth.

[3/5] folkish. poetry in phlegm. starts acoustic then lightning strikes; acoustic tracks have aged better but finishes strongly. probably a little nasal for my taste but enjoyed the country vibes. less accessible than e.g., harvest. track notes: 1. nasal haunting reflection 2. nice harmonica 3. intriguing space llama 4. emotional native american time warp 5. sweet nostalgia about a canyon i never knew 6. unexpected sacrifice through the medium of powerful electricity 7. anthemic celebration of section 8 milfs. swamppilled 8. punky running from gingivitis 9. circle back but heavy rusty grunge

This was a headscratcher... how was this the best album of '79, peaks and valleys with this one

not my thing 5/10

noisy and grungy. Live or Studio?

each song is ALMOST good, i really wanted to like a couple of these songs.

As an overall experience I rate Live Rust over this not its still a great album with some standout tracks among a couple of weaker ones

Heard Before? I had someone's discarded vinyl copy. Listened a couple of times and gave away. Notes: - competent strum-and-hum. I'm sure these lyrics could be good but i can't be bothered to pay attention. - very few live albums justify themselves versus studio albums. this is not one of them. throwing in a random mishmash of overdubs and studio tracks doesn't help either. Verdict: Utterly inessential, undercooked songs that apparently mean something to the balding-but-still-have-long-hair dude set. Listen Again? Heck no.

This isn't my favourite Neil Young Album... Not by a long shot. But, I know every word to every song. They are a part of me so how can I give it anything else but 5 stars

Neil Young has a whiney voice. But his songwriting is without par, his guitar-- whether folk or rock-- is top notch and I can't forget his characters. I want to hate him, but I love him too much. 4/5

Made it up to Sail Away before I started skipping. I see the lyrical prowess in a couple of songs but I couldn't stomach the country man vibes

I wanted to rate this 4 but it just doesn't compare to Harvest or After the Gold Rush... a few of the songs don't resonate with me, I don't really get them. But overall a nice listen, always makes me feel homesick listening to Neil Young

didn't realize appreciate this music so idk how to rate it

Pior que amei a primeira música "My my, Hey hey". Ótimo.

Not a Neil Young fan but I can see why this made the list; I really liked the first (acoustic) half

good live album, neil rules

At this point I can't remember which Neil Young albums I have and haven't heard. I honestly thought I had heard this before. but as the first song contains that now famous (to Nirvana fans) lyric of _"It's better to burn out than to fade away"_, I know that I haven't From just one listen each (except _Harvest_ which I own), I'm finding it hard to measure NY albums against each other but the quality here is high and merits revisits.

It's a Neil Young album. It's got good background music and okay vocals, but also can't seem to decide if it's a country album or a rock album or a folk album.

As I've said many times before, I'm not into Folk Rock and this album is as folky and as rocky as one can get. Being a live performance album doesn't help it either. Maybe I need some nostalgia or something else to fuel any kind of reaction from me. I wasn't raised on this genre of music and don't come from a place *heavy with it either. I don't have any association with it. I do recognize the talent and skill in this type of music but my brain chemistry wasn't built for it. I do want to highlight the history and connection of the opening track which would be my favourite track if I had to choose one. Kurt Cobain is next on my album list and just finding out that the verse "It's better to burn out than to fade away" was on his suicide note is heartbreaking. I lean more into the music instead of the lyrics so it takes some time for me to absorb what story is being told by the lyrics. I am sensing a poetic touch from Young that I appreciate; he really does have THAT folk rock voice that perfect. I'm already dedicating a certain amount of my free time to this project and I don't know if its wise to try and accumulate a taste for music like this (re-listening and examining) if I already know I won't be returning. T3: My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue), Pocahontas, Ride My Llama

The goatskiiiii NEIL YOU GOD. The Grunge Sage

First half of the album typical acoustic Neil Young. Last half I can understand why this album was chosen just wish the whole album was like that. Definitely a precursor to grunge.

I liked Hey Hey My My.

Just a great album and i'm not a really big Neil Young fan. Enjoyed it! 4/5

not my cup of tea, só gostei das últimas

Best Track - "My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue)"

This album has a few glimmers of brilliance (the acoustic version of "Hey Hey...") and weirdo stuff that clicks ("Welfare Mothers") but the bulk of this collection is fairly forgettable stuff.

Solid collection of tracks bookended with hey hey my my. An enjoyable listen with some pre grunge sounds on side 2.

It was fine. It was alright.

Pretty good, ends on a really high note. 3.5 stars.

"It's better to burn out than to fade way" 4/5

Neil Young really has a way of hooking you with his music. He does a great job of just slinking his way into your ears and finding a home. This is the fourth of seven Neil Young albums I have listened to for this project, following Harvest, On The Beach, and Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere. In order, I’ve given 2 3’s, a 5, and I would rate this album a 3 as well. Neil has such a charming voice, and I would never be upset listening to it, but much like the movie Titanic, the second half is when this album/movie starts getting really good. The first 5 songs on the album, while still thoroughly enjoyable, are more of the singer-songwriter kinda Folky sounding songs that I wouldn’t feel terrible about skipping over. While again, still great songs in their own right, aren’t really my cup of tea. Luckily for me, the album is split perfectly down the middle in tone. When you start entering “Powderfinger” territory on song 6, the electric guitar starts shining, and the album gets markedly better. There is no better way of noticing the stark difference between halves than hearing the last song blend into the first one when the album seamlessly replays itself. “My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue)” and “Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)”, naturally, are pretty heavily related to each other. The first opens up quite somberly, and Neil is noticeably contemplative about the state of the music industry of the late 70’s. References to Elvis and Johnny Rotten are made, as well as a solemn oath that Rock and Roll is never going to die. The last song on the album, in contrast, hits the ground running and opens up with a meaty, killer riff, and Neil is practically shouting. Instead of coming off as kinda sad, there’s genuine anger and heart in this one. In the first song, he was essentially lamenting Punk being mainstay and changing Rock and Roll forever, but by the last song, he’s acknowledging that music needs to change over time. That’s just the way it goes. It’s only natural. “Rust Never Sleeps”, after all. I might be over analyzing the song a bit too much, but the line “Is this the story of Johnny Rotten??” comes off as 2 distinct trains of thought to me. The first, is that Neil is saying the old style of Rock and Roll is going to take over again when people get bored of Punk, but I don’t buy that personally. What I think he’s saying, is that Rock is going to evolve AGAIN after Punk has its fun, and another genre/sub genre will emerge. The extreme irony of this duo of songs is that Punk music, at least in the form that Neil is discussing here, was only really truly popular for like, 5 years max, and was already on its way out when this song was released, quickly being replaced in the mainstream by Post-Punk, adding yet another layer of irony. I’ve never been one to personally do deep analysis on the songs I’m listening to for this project, I’ve mostly just been going on whether or not they sound good to me. Evidently, I’m not a music reviewer, I say with a big grain of irony. But this duo of songs were quite good, and fun to analyze. When Neil talks to me, I will listen. To take this review full circle, his friendly cadence just draws you in. He tells you stories that are fun to listen to, sometimes important, other times predictions of the future. I might not have been deeply moved by this album personally, but after listening to now 4 of his works, I deeply respect and appreciate Neil Young, and I’m always happy to check out his music. Naturally, my favorite song on this album was the closer, “Hey Hey, My My (Into the Black)”. For making me think and contemplate myself so much, I want to give this a 4, but I’m going to call it a 3.9 out of 5 for now. Great album, amazing bookends.

It might be a little slow going at first and some of the writing feels OK, but this has a cool feel. I enjoy the blend of live and studio which is a nice concept. This definitely feels like a precursor to a lot of grunge and 90's indie rock.

352/1001 Neil Young & Crazy Horse Heard before? ❎ Revisit? ✅ Enjoyed this a lot. The combination of live tracks and studio feels seemlees together. I like Young when he embraces a darker tone and this certainly has it in abundance.

Folk Rock and a little Punk. This album has some of my favorite Neil Young songs, Out of the Black and into the Blue, Out of the Blue and into the Black, Powderfinger, and Welfare Mothers.